,i^mmr'.
XX
l^>
Wk
•r
-^^^
,i^<^.
K
f#;
.•^^1
^ '^''
*.^^
?ii^
,c
.«c
'1^
^Sf
^
Jlii^
• v • •
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
INDEX FOR VOLUME XVI, 1903.
Illustrated articlee are marked with an asterisk, thus*
Acceleration Tests on the Great Eastern Rail-
way of England, 314.
Additional Kacts about James Millholland's
Work, lly E. J. Kauch. J98.
*Air Operated Kire-Door Opener, 309.
*Air Valve Setting Machine, An, 273.
Air Brake Department, 25, 81. 127, 175, 223, 265,
317. 365. 415. 464. 507. 553.
'A Clever Design of Gauge. Hy M. H. Shep-
ard, 508.
•Adjustable Device for I^oaded and Empty
Cars, by L. T. Cnnfield, 319.
Air Brake Conditions Reported by the Inter-
state Commerce Commission, 31;.
Air Pump Repairs, 223, 507,
Air Pump Test. 465-
'.\ir Signal on Air Brake Train Pipe, 464.
Arrangement on Engine of High Speed Brake
Parts, 26.
Automatic Oiling Device for Air Cylinder or
Air Pump, 318.
Break-in-Twos Due to Burst Ho=e, 318.
Economical Repairs to gVy-inch Air-Pump. By
Otto Best. 367.
iCngine Truck Brake as a Hindrance to Curv-
ing. 553-
l'"ifty Per Cent. Air Brake Trains, 415.
Graduated Release and Retaining Triple Valve,
507.
Handling the New York Engineers' Brake
Valve, 270.
•Hocking Valley Inspection Car, 553-
"Hurst Automatic Retainer, 416.
•Important Air Brake Experiments Abroad,
318.
Making Air Pump \ alves, 25.
New Release \ alve. By J. Farrar, 319.
•Oil Cup for Air Cylinder, ,1165.
Operating Conditions of High Speed Trains,
36s.
Retardmg Power of Driver Brakes, Shocks on
Long Trains, 320.
Some Competitive High Speed Brake Tests,
465-
"Some English Air Brake Designs, 176.
Some Foundation Brake History, 27.
"Some New Retaining Valves, 175.
Speed of Air Pumps, 175.
Tenth Annual Convention Air Brake Assn.,
266.
"Testing Air Cylinders of N. Y. Duplex Pump,
Irain Pipe Leakage, 306.
1901 Model New Y'ork Pump Governor, 41S.
Alleged Train Order in Slang and Twenty-eight
Dead, 74.
Americ-.n and Foreign Locomotives, 171.
"Another Air-\'alve Setting Machine. By E- M.
Jones. 372.
•Apparatus for Drilling Staybolts, 558.
"Armstrong Cutting Off Machine, The, 290.
*Ascent of Mt. Lowe. By Angus Sinclair. 180.
Asking Something for Nothing, 549.
'Atlantic Type Engines in Germany. By M.
Richter, 541.
Attempts to Improve Locomotive V'alve Mo-
tion, 502.
"Automobile Inspection Car, 552.
B
Balanced Engine, A, 142.
Baldwin Locomotive Works' Unit System of
Production. 45.
i. Battle of the Gauges. The, 170.
Blistered Crown Sheet, A. By Shandy Ma-
guire, 535-
"Block Signals Applied to Turntables, 335.
"Boltless Cylinder and Frame Connection, 119.
Book Reviews, 204. 230, 262, 314, 362, 413. 504, 550.
Boone on Elastic Wheel Centers. 495.
*Box Car with Strong End Construction (Cent.
RR. of N. J.>. 424.
Brackett's Models, 530.
Break-Downs. By Jos. A. Baker. 505, 562.
Brevity is the Soul of Wit, 121.
Broken Siaybolts. By lolin Livingstone, 453.
•Bvrd's Flue Welder.' 286.
♦Caboose Brake Apparatus, 1 29.
"Canadian Pacific Coal Car, 159.
Car Details, 219.
*Care and Handling of the Compound Locomo-
tive, ij79.
Carnegie's Gift to Engineering Societies, 264.
Carnegie, Mr. Andrew, on Libraries, 62.
Castor Oil Prevents Foaming. By J. W. Gray-
bill, 542.
'Caswell Dump Car, The, 285.
Cause of Pound of Piston Valves When Drift-
ing. By J. M. Foster, 12.
Center Plates and Side Bearings, 261.
Changes in M. C. B. Interchange Rules, 457.
Combination of Book and Brain, A. By Shandy
Maguire, 109.
Comparing Unlike Things, 74.
Convention Notes, 388.
Cost of Running High Speed Trains, 23.
Counterbalancing Locomotive Driving Wheels,
458.
*Curious Indicator Diagrams. 71.
D
Defects of Cast Iron Wheels and How to In-
spect Them, 403.
'Development of the Locomotive Spark Ar
Tester. By J. Snowden Bell, 16.
Development of the Railroad Car. By Eugene
Chamberlin, 68.
•Different Effects with Oil Burning, 205.
"Dimpfel Boiler, The. By C. H. Caruthers, 43.
Discipline that Hurts, 22.
Dissolution of the Northern Securities Co., 218.
Distilled Feed Water, 570.
'Double Hook and Steel Sling Used in Lifting
Engines, 250.
*Duplex Main Reservoir Pressure Regulation, 81.
Economy of the Gas Engine, 515.
Effect of Lengthening the Reach Rod, 405.
Effects of Tonnage Ratings on the Cost of
Transportation. 362.
Efficient Boiler Shop Tool for Fitting Crown-
stays, An. 04.
'Efficient Smoke Jack Pittsburgh vV Lake Erie
Roundhouse, 495.
Electric Shock Accidents. 58.
Electrically Driven Shops, 459.
Electricity vs. Steam Power. 220.
Elizabethport Shops of the Cent, RR. of N. L.
183.
Encouraging Inferior W ork, 218.
Engineer's Influence on Train Loads. The. 550.
'English Spark Arrester, An, 531.
'Equipping with Piston Valves. 72.
'European Notes. 65. 134- 20~- 329- 40$, 514.
'Evolution of the Locomotive Boiler. By O. H.
Reynolds. 37.
I"ay & Egan Co., of Cincinnati, 528,
Fellow Servant Iniquity, The, 412.
First Aid to the Injured, 158.
Friction. By E. J. Rauch, 255.
I'rictional Limit, The, 20.
General Correspondence, 11, 67, 115, 166, 211. 253.
306, 353. 403. 451. 495- .S4'
Good Cinder Washer, A, 44.
•Good Paint Shop Scaffolding (Cent. RR. of
N. J.), 190.
Government Rule in Boiler Inspection, 126.
Grades. Profiles and Climbing, 312.
*Grand Chief Engineer Stone, 520.
"Grand Trunk Front End, 300.
Grand Trunk Pacific, 21.
"Growth of the Locomotive. By Angus Sin-
clair, I. 78. 113. 161, 246. 302, 350, 398, 444-
418, 544.
H
Halsey on the Metric System, 20.
'Handy Mandrel for Turning Driving Brasses,
264.
Hints on Break-Downs, 282.
•History of Smoke Stack. By W. De Sanno, 233.
"Hollow Car Axle for Heavy Freight Ser\'ice.
28;^.
Hollow Car Axles, 109, 263.
Honey's Magnetic Traction Increaser, 362.
How the New Superintendent Introduced Him
self. By Shandv Maguire. 8.
•How to Handle Gasoline. By E. W. Roberts.
87.
How to Learn Things. 361.
How Tom Burke Won His Spurs. By Shandy
Maguire, 354.
I
•Improved Locomotive Fire-Door Flange, 396
•Improvement for Sight Feed Lubricator, 50.
•Improvements in the Rogers' Locomotive
Works, 97.
Improvements on the Pittsburgh & Lake Erie
at McKees Rocks. 448.
Inevitable and Preventable Heat Losses, 503.
•Inspection Car for the Rochester & Pittsburgh
Coal & Iron Co., 259.
Interesting Optical Illusion, An. 45.
K
'Kansas City Flood. By E- McAuliffc, 353-
Laboratory Locomotive for Cornell University-
By H. Wade Hibbard, 120.
'Large Patent Universal Woodworker, 145.
Lealo' Fire Boxes and Tubes, 548.
Lecture on Mechanics, A. 272.
Licensing Enginemen. By J. A. B.. 213.
'Lincoln Power Station of Boston Elevated, loi.
•Lining of Shoes and Wedges. By W. D.
Chamberlin, 420.
Liquid Fuel on the Pacific Coast (Editorial
Correspondence"!. 2-^4.
Loading Locomotives to Their Full Capacity,
411.
Locating a Blow. By J. W. Reading, 166.
'Locomotive Classification, 140.
'Locomotive Smokestacks, 210.
12!
126
".;•': .'. .•:r:'RAILW.AY..Al>tD.I,C»COM.OTIVE ENGINEERING
TTTT
Locomotives:
Simple
road, 371.
•Baldwin 2-8-0 for the Mexican International,
563.
•Baldwin Engines for the Norfolk & Western
Ry-. 133-
•Baldwin 2-10-2 for the Santa Fe, 513.
•Baldwin Four-Cylinder Balanced Compound
for the Santa Fe. 383.
'Baldwin Passenger Oil Burner for the
Southern Pacitic, 345-
•Baldwin 4-6-0 Engine tor the L. P., 189.
•Baldwin Engine for the Wabash, 463.
*B. &. O. Articulated Locomotive, 433.
•Compound Oil Burner for the Souchern i a-
cific, 183.
•Consolidation for Inverness Ky. & Coal Co.,
S40.
•Consolidation for the B. & O., 95-
•Consolidation for the B. R. & P. Ky., 1S7.
•Consolidation for the Illinois Central, 349-
•Consolidation for the Rock Island, 245.
•Cross Compound Mogul, Grand Trunk Ry.,
533-
•Electric Locomotive for B. &. O. Tunnel,
423.
•Engine of a Trans-.Mississippi Shop, 501.
•Evansville Sl Terre Haute Fast Passenger
Engine, 425-
•Fast Passenger Power for the Alton, 120.
•Fast Passenger 4-4-2 for the Big Four, 547.
•Fast Passenger Engine, 4-6-2 tor the C. bt.
P. M. & 0., 494.
•Fast Passenger Engine for Illmois Central,
282.
♦Fast Baldwin Pabsciiger Engine for the Nor-
folk & Western, 397.
•Fast 4-4-2 Engine for the Pennsylvania Lines,
301.
"Fast Pass. Engine for the Vandalia Line, 19.
•Grand Trunk lo-Wheel Pass. Engine, 429-
♦Heavy Atlantic Type Engines for the C. B.
vy Co
16.^.
♦Heavy "Consolidation for Pittsburgh & Lake
Erie, 299.
•Heavy 4-6-2 for the Northern Pacihc, 357.
•Heavy 2-8-0 Engines for the Pennsylvania
Lines, 209. r- , c-v v
•Inspection Engine on the Lake Shore iV
IVIich. So., 402.
*.\lcIntoch's io-\Vheelers. S. A. F., 253.
•Mogul for the Lackawanna, 447.
•New Caledonian Engines, 546.
•N. Y. C. Tandem Compound Consolidation,
251.
•Novel Suburban Engine on the Great East-
ern of England, igi.
•Paris, Lyons & Mediterranean Locomoiives,
ISS-
•Rogers Consolidation for the T. & O. C. Ry..
86.
•Suburban P. & R., 500.
♦6-Wheel Switcher for the Great Northern, 567.
*io-Wheel Engines for Central of Georgia, 325.
•lo-Wheeler for the D. & H., 456.
"10-Wheel Engine for the Rutland, 121.
•lo-Wheel Pass, for the Southern. 93.
Long and Short Valve Travel. By C. G. Greis.
IS2.
Longest Tunnel in the World, The, 261.
Loose Cylinders Made Tight, 141.
Lubrication of Piston Valves and Cylinders, 542.
Lubrication of Railroad Rolling Stock, 373.
M
Making Electricity Out of Nothing, 5.
Marvelous Achievements of One Century of
the Locomotive. By Harris Tabor, 30.
M. C. B. Coupler Tests, 447.
M. C. B. Report on Cast Iron Wheels, 432.
M. M. Convention 1904 Meets at Saratoga, 573.
♦McElvaney's Ballast Spreading Scraper, 564.
Meeting of .\mericaii Railway Assn.. 282.
Metric System in the Railroad Mechanical Con-
vention, The, 383.
Milholland, James. By E. .T. Rauch. 275.
•Model of :go2 of New York Engineer's Brake
Valve, 293.
Modern "High Duty" Shaper, 288.
Modern "Jolly Miller," The. 551.
Modern Results from an Old Machine, 86.
•Modern Steel Frame. 311.
•Moran Flexible Joint, The, 46.
More Men Needed on Locomotives, 260.
Motive Power Department Holds Up Its End,
361.
•Motor Coach, 316.
N
•National Malleable- Iron Brake Jaw and Dead
Lever Guide, The, 198.
"Natural Knowledge" of L^se in the Brass
Foundry, 47.
Nerve Tonic, A Good. 10.
•New Canadian Pacific Parlor Car, ^^22.
♦New Planer Tyjie Milling Machine, 474.
New Safety Device for Railways, 93.
Newest Shops of the Canadian Pacific Railway.
New Southern Pacific Shops at Los Angeles.
By O. H. Van Rensselaer, 409.
, «l^«»«StyJe«o{Jt>raw Gear, 430.
No JCt^d 'to ^Javeitigate Locomotive Front
• • Enus, 410. • • ,'
Notes Iron? Au5trjflia— Tyranny of Govt. Ry.
Officials, 234.
o
*Obituary of Grand Chief P. M. Arthur, 378.
Obituary of Pulaski Leeds, 379.
Observations on Inside Admission Piston
Valves, 311.
"Old Seth Wilmarth Locomotive. Ky C. H.
Caruthers, 451.
Old Time Railroad Reminiscences. By S. J.
Kidder, 6g, 118, 211, 322, 498.
*On to California First Section — Over the
Lackawanna. By Angus Sinclair, 228.
Outrages to American Trainmen in Mexico. By
M. J. Schneider, 166.
*Over the Nickel Plate — Second Section. By
Angus Sinclair, 279.
"Over the Santa Fe Trail. By Angus Sinclair,
3i^f 380-
Overloaded Engines are Expensive, 221.
Overloaded Trains Cause Freight Congestion,
125.
Overloading Engines, 67.
•Passenger Coach with Cupola Can. Pac. Ry.,
102.
Patent Right, Nature of the. By Paul Synnest-
vedt, 568.
"^Percy's Shoe and Wedge Holder, 496.
Per Diem and Demurrage, 22.
Personals, 34, 91, 137, 185, 231, 277, 327, 377, 427,
471. 519. 565- , ,
Petroleum Oil vs. Coal as ruel, 173.
Piston Valve of To-Day, The. L'.y W. G. Men-
zel, 116.
Piston vs. Slide Valves. By F. A. Hulbert, 212.
Plugging Broken Staybolts. Jiiy J. A. B., 403.
Pneumatic Hammer for Shop Work. By E. R.
Cole. 306.
*Pratte's Crude Oil Burner, 376.
Proceedings of Traveling Engineer's Conven-
tion (The Brick Arch), 469.
Proper Lubrication of Piston Valves and Cylin-
ders. 473.
Purifying Feed Water, 172.
Questions Answered, 23, 77, 125, 174, 221. 2gi,
3"5. 363. 414- 462, 504. 551-
Quick Welding of Frames. 235.
•Radial Spring Buffer Between Engine and
Tender, 216.
Railroad Equipment, 345.
Railroad Trains that Waste Revenue, 22.
* Railway Building and Scenes in Cuba. 107.
Railway' Ignores a Large Suburb. 144.
"Railway Matters in Australia, 509.
Railway Matters in India, 434-
Railway Mileage of the World, 393.
Reading's New Shops (P. & R. Ry), The, 139.
Reality of a "Practical" Opinion. The. By
A. O. Brookside, 497.
Recent Improvements in Boiler Designs, 358.
Reckless Use of Gasoline. 313.
*Reducing Valve Testing Device, 84.
Requesting Information by Circular. 550.
•Revolving "Bookcase" for Tubes, 98.
"Roller Bearings in Passenger Service (Grand
Trunk), 386.
*Ross Winans. By E. J- Rauch, 304.
"Roundhouse Door Fastener, 208.
"Rushton Drifting Throttle, The, 358.
Safe Transportation, 143.
*Sao Paulo Railway, The »„oflFee Road of the
World. By O. Huber, 11.
Scarcity of Ties, 23.
'Schmidt Steam SuperheatL-. 449-
Science of Chemistry, The, .''i
Scientific Liar, A. By Shandy Maguire, 154.
*Searchlight Principle Applied to Headlights,
48.
Seberholm Boiler. The, 45.
Setting Slipped Eccentrics. By T. W. Readine,
254-
"Sheedy's Circulator for Locomotive Cylinders,
370.
"Shop Door Fastener, 188.
Signaling:
Automatic Electric Signals Introduced in
Great Britain, 422.
Block Signaling in the United States, 170.
Block Signaling on a Single Track Road, 459.
Disregarding Signals, 124.
"Overlap" and the "Chalk-line" Stop. The, 313.
Proper Observance of Signals. 1S8.
Railway Signaling Club Meeting, 325.
•Recent Development of Block and Interlock-
ing Signal System. By W. H. Elliott,
"Signals and Signaling — Historical Retrospect.
By George S. Hodgins, 517. .
"Signals and signaling — The Block System.
By George S. Hodgins, 559.
Significance of Block Signals, 260.
Staff System of Train Control, The. By Will-
iam Leith, 454.
The "Normal Danger" and the "Normal
Clear" Automatic Block Systems, The,
ill.
"Simple Shop Crane, 457.
Simple vs. Compound Lubrication, 117.
Slid Flat Wheels, 81.
Small Shop Delusion, The. By E. P. Watson.
S6.
Smokebox Arrangement for Modern Locomo
tives. By W. A. Buckbee, 168.
South African \'isitor's Views on British and
American Engines, 326.
Spark Arresters. By W. De Sanno, 107.
"Star Improved Indicator, 96.
Staybolts at the Rogers' Works, 96.
"Steam Gauge Service Test Apparatus, 233-
Steam Turbine, The, 374.
Steam Turbines, 363.
"Steel Channel Arch Bar Truck, 99.
"Steel Frame Side Door Passenger Car on the
111. Cent., 524.
Stock Investing by Employees, 503.
"Stop, Look and Listen," 68.
Story of a Mechanical Flagman, 407.
Suburban Car Seating Problem, 333.
Superheaters for Locomotives, 360.
Surveying Instrument Used in Machine Shop,
21.
Tandem Compound Locomotive, The. By F. P.
Roesch, 206.
Terry Bennett's Address. By Shandy Maguire,
273-
Tests to Find Out Power of Engines, 263.
"The Public Demand It," 160.
Third Man on an Engine, The, 204.
Third Man on an Engine, The, By E- J-
Rauch, 212.
"Thou Shalt Not Keep Thy Neighbor's Cars,"
75-
To Make Compound Locomotives Efficient. By
W. A. Buckbee, 215.
To Make Something Out of Nothing, 262.
To Prevent Boiler Explosions, 122.
To Prevent Telescoping, 76.
To Prevent Telescoping. By George E- Dick
son, ]66.
"Tour in Scotland, A. By Angus Sinclair, 59.
Train is Harder to Push than to Pull, 204.
Training an Artist in the Forces of Nature.
By E. H. Mullin, 346.
Trans-Continental Railways of the World, 245.
Transportation in New \ ork, 412.
Transportation Problem in (Greater New York
The, 428.
Traveling Engineer, The, 76.
Traveling Engineers' Convention, 414.
Traveling Engineers on Locomotive Front
Ends, 460.
Trip Over Scenic Short Line. By J. A. Baker,
307.
•fri
u
Unpopularity of the Pooling System, 124.
Unresilient Driving Wheel, The, 461.
"Vanderbilt Steel Hopper Car, 10.
w
"War Monster, A, 15.
Washing a Moving Train. 298.
Waste of Wood, A, 549.
Watch Inspection, 67.
•Water Tube Locomotive Boiler, 53S.
Water Softening in Relation to Washing Out
on Railways, 450.
Water Softening on the Pennsylvania Lines, 501.
Westfield Disaster, The. 123.
What is the Torque of an Electric Motor, 18^.
Why an Engine Pounds Harder on Left Side
than on Right, 221.
Why an Engine Slips Backing Up. By J. A.
B.. iSi.
Why Foreign Locomotives May be More Effi-
cient Than Ours. By W. A. Buckbee,
2S6.
Why Large Engines 'Fail, 360.
Wilmarth Engines. By C. M. Sheafe, 541.
With Brain and Hand, 297.
"Wooden Smoke Jack on the Chicago & North-
western, 573.
Word for the Resident Inspector in Prosperous
Times, A, 122.
Young Engineer, The. By Shandy Maguire,
155-
Railway . .and
lOcomotive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co. -1V03
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
vor. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, January, 1903
No. I
LOCOMOTIVE ANNIVERSARY NUMBER
The Cirowth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
The first locomotive engine designed
to run upon rails was built in the year
1803, consequently this is the looth an-
niversary of the introduction of the rail-
way locomotive. The engine was de-
signed by Richard Ti-evithick, a Cornish
mine captain, and built under his direc-
tion in a blacksmith's shop connected
with iron works at Mcrthyr-Ty'dvil in
South Wales.
WHERE THE FIRST ROAD LOCOMOTIVE WAS
BUILT.
If any student of industrial history pos-
sessed of the poetic instinct of looking
The business resulting made Merthyr-
Ty'dvil an important town at the begin-
ning of last century.
AN IMPORTANT WAGER.
The residents of the district, many of
them the descendants of mighty smiths,
those valiant artisans who took the lead
in developing manual dexterity, appear
to have kept informed on the progress
of engineering, for one of them, Samuel
Homfray, made a wager of 1,000 guineas
($5,250) that he could convey a load of
Evans, of the United States, for years
previous. Trevithick, however, devoted
his attention to using the engine for land
transportation, and he made, in 1803, an
engine, Fig. i, that in February of next
year conveyed ten tons of iron nine miles,
gaining the wager for his employer.
A PRACTICAL LOCOMOTIVE.
Although the engine is fearfully and
wonderfully made with its complication
of gearing, it was a practical locomotive
and contained all the elements of the
Itattufny <f liomtnotitr EnginMryna
TRUVITHICK'S LOCOMOTIVE, 1803. FIRST LOCOMOTIVE BUILT
TO RUN ON RAILS. FIG. I.
HEDLEVS "PUFFING BILLY,
COMMERCIALLY IN
181.3. FIRST LOCOMOTIVE USED
HAULING CARS. FIG. 2.
into the origin of things should happen
to be in the bustling city of Cardiff on
the Bristol Channel, and wishes to see
the place where the locomotive engine
had its birth, a trip of 24 miles up a
beautiful vale will lead him into the heart
of lofty mountains, within whose re-
cesses is built the thriving town of
Merthyr-Ty'dvil, the principal seat of the
iron trade of South Wales.
This is no town of mushroom growth.
The district is rich in argillaceous car-
bonate of iron ore, which led to the in-
troduction of smelting furnaces that
v/ere worked before the Norman Con-
quest of England. As Britain advanced
in manufacturing arts iron became a
prime necessity, and the iron furnaces
of South Wales increased and prospered.
iron a distance of nine miles by the
power of steam alone on a cast iron
tramway.
RICHARD TREVITHICK.
Trevithick had been experimenting for
several years with a steam carriage for
common roads, and there is a working
model of a locomotive made by him pre-
served in the patent department of the
South Kensington Museum, London.
His efforts to make a steam road car-
riage a success were widely known and
he was invited to construct the engine
that was to win Mr. Homfray's wager.
In 1802 Trevithick had been granted a
patent for a high-pressure steam engine,
which contemporary writers say was an
imitation of engines built by Oliver
modern locomotive, except the multi-
tubular boiler. This engine had a return
flue boiler which was fairly efScient As
shown the engine was carried by two
pairs of wheels, which were 52 in. diam-
eter; the boiler was 60 in. long and con-
tained a return flue. There was one cyl-
inder 8 x 54 in. to transmit the power.
.•Kfter being used, the steam was passed
into the smokestack, where it aided in
creating draft upon the fire.
This engine made a few trips over the
rough tramway at a speed of about five
miles an hour; but it broke many of the
cast-iron plates forming the rails and was
withdrawn as a commercial failure.
.Athough his first railroad locomotive
was a commercial failure, it was me-
chanically as successful as anything that
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
followed it in the next 20 years, when the
evolution of the steam locomotive was
being worked out by the ablest mechan-
ics in the world. So Trevithick is en-
titled to be called the father ot the loco-
motive engine.
The developing of every complex ma-
chine has been a labor of years and the
locomotive engine was no exception.
WHEN INVENTIONS ARE BORN.
In the history of the world we see that
•needed inventions come forth when "na-
ture must obey necessity." When the
idea of applying the potential power of
heat to lighten the drudgery of mankind
■was conceived, the hope of its most use-
ful field was in carrying heavy burdens
and in brniging distant places into closer
connection. The need of a-tificial power
for transportation did not, however, pro-
duce the steam engine. Grim necessity
brought it forth when great properties
were falling into ruin,- and the necessities
of civilization were becoming forbidden
luxuries, because animal power was in-
competent to concentrate great effort
in limited space. The steam engine was
invented when horses could no longer
do the work of pumping water out of
deep mines.
It was a foregone conclusion that the
reaching. The fame of his achievement
had gone forth and reached the ears of
men who were staring at the specter of
ruin in the expense of horse power for
hauling heavy loads.
hedley's puffing billy.
For the next 10 years after Trevithick's
experiment there was considerable eflfort
made to produce an engine that would
work satisfactorily. Much attention was
devoted to devising means to prevent the
slipping of driving wheels, which was a
serious trouble with Trevithick's engine
due to the tractive power being much too
great for the weight available for adhe-
sion. A variety of engines were built and
tried, but the first engine made to run on
rails, and which did the work of hauling
of a sort of grasshopper type of engine,
which, under a variety of modifications,
became the fashion and held the field up
to 1829, when the directors of the Liver-
pool & Manchester Railway oi?ered a
prize for the most successful locomotive
and a variety of novel types were pro-
duced. Hedley's engine was not a model
of simplicity, but its complications were
modest compared to many of its success-
ors. The pioneer locomotive builders
did not realize that complicated mech-
anism was objectionable until sad experi-
ence with breakdowns taught them that
the fewer parts used which were liable
to breakage the more successful the en-
gine was likely to be. They were the en-
gineers who first learned about the extra
destructive efltects that result from the
engine jolting over a rough track.
PUFFING BILLY IN SOUTH KENSINGTON
MUSEUM.
During a visit to South Kensington
Museum, London, the writer wrote:
"To me one of the most interesting
relics in the great collection at South
Kensington Museum is Hedley's 'Puffing
Billy,' built in 1813, and which was the
first successful locomotive ever put to
work on a railroad track. It was after
an examination of this engine that
Ruiiwni/ $ tocumofiir Enginterxng
STEPHENSON'S ROCKET, FIRST HIGH-SPEED LOCOMOTIVE.
a=WT^
BURY'S LOCOMOTIVE. 1834. BECAME THE PROTOTYPE
OF THE AMERICAN LOCOMOTIVE.
Steam engine would be applied to trans-
portation purposes as soon as the needs
of mankind exceeded the easy capacity
of the horse.
SLOW PROCESS OF DEVELOPMENT.
After a practical steam engine was in-
vented it took half a century to develop it
into a motor suitable for driving manu-
facturing machinery. Another half cen-
tury passed before inventors began se-
riously attempting to devise a steam en-
gine to drive a vehicle on land. A va-
riety of experimental locomotives had
been built or patented before the iSth
century closed, but nothing of a prom-
ising nature was produced until Trev-
ithick's engine was built. Although
Trevithick abandoned the practice of lo-
comotive building after his first real at-
tempt, the influence of his work was far
■ cars regularly, was built by William Hed-
ley, chief engineer of Wylam colliery on
the River Tyne, near Newcastle, England.
His first engine was not a success, but
his experience with its shortcomings en-
abled Hedley to build a second engine,
which worked fairly well and is now to
be seen in the South Kensington Mu-
seum, London, bearing the name of
"Puffing Billy."
This engine, which was built in 1813,
had a return flue boiler, which pro-
vided all the steam required. This form
of boiler had been used by Trevithick
and Hedley made it a practical success.
It was the best form of boiler used until
Robert Stephenson applied the multi-
tubular boiler to the "Rocket" in 1829.
BEGINNING OF THE GRASSHOPPER TYPE.
The "Puffing Billy" was the beginning
George Stephenson proceeded to build
a locomotive of similar style, but which
was not such a good working engine as
the 'Pufling Billy.'
The 'Puffing Billy' has a furnace ex-
tending about half way into the boiler
and a flue leading to an up-take, from
which the gases of combustion passed
through a return flue to the smokestack.
The fireman did his work at the smoke-
stack end of the boiler and the engineer
sat in front on a wooden seat held by
four upright iron posts. The frames are
of wood, quite substantial in form and
rest upon the axles without the interven-
tion of springs. The four wheels are
connected by inside gearing, and the
motion is transmitted to a gear wheel
upon a separate axle. The tank is an
oblong iron box, set behind the coal
January, KJ03.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
bunker, the water being carried to tlic
pump by an iron pipe with a flexible
leather connection. The engine and ten-
der arc coupled together by means of a
chain similar to wliat is still employed
111 connecting wagons together on Eng-
lish railways.
The cylinders are made of wrought
iron in two sections, riveted together.
The steam chest is a small cavity towards
the top of the cylinders, and there is a
handle for connecting the valve stem
that catches on a vertical plug rod con-
nected with the walking beam.
The engine shows evidence of very
substantial workmanship, although no at-
tempt at finish appears to have been
made. The boiler is lagged with wood,
held in place very much as is the lagging
of modern locomotives.
The cylinders are 9 x 36 inches, grate
area 6 feet, heating surface 77 square feet.
The valve is of the D slide form, worked
presents a record of disasters, failures
And of men's perseverance while within
the grasp of distressing discourage-
ments, and forcibly illustrates the deter-
mined persistence which some men will
devote to the practical working out of
an idea.
The locomotive engine was developed
into a practical motor by hauling coal on
private railways connected with coal
mines in the north of England. In 1825
the Stockton & Darlington Railway, a
public enterprise, 25 miles long, was
opened and operated by locomotives built
by the Stephensons and others. George
Stephenson & Son had established loco-
motive building works at Newcastle, and
many other firms were by this time turn-
ing their attention to making locomo-
tives.
THE LIVERPOOL & MANCHESTER RAILWAY.
The ancient city of Manchester, the
opinion about what form of power was
most suitable ior operating it. The learned
consulting civil engineers favored the
use of stationary engines with rope trac-
tion, George Stephenson, who had been
engineer of construction, with other
practical men, advocated the use of loco-
motiv(;s. After several months of inde-
cision the directors of the company de-
termined to try locomotives and offered a
prize of £500 ($2,500) for an engine that
would fulfil certain requirements.
RAINHILL COMPETITION TESTS.
Three engines were entered to contest
for the prize, all of them decided de-
partures from the prevailing grasshopper
types. The "Rocket," built under the
supervision of Robert Stephenson, won
the prize. A series of very thorough
tests was made at Rainhill, near Liver-
pool, and the "Rocket" was the only en-
gine that went through the trials without
T~r^TO
w
Raylwaj/ i tt^vmotivt Bnginwring
ROBERTS' EXPERIMENT. ONE OF THE FIRST FREAKS.
FIRST LOCOMOTIVE WITH PISTON VALVES
WHICH WERE A FAILURE.
EARLY GREAT WESTERN LOCOMOTIVE WITH DRIVING
WHEELS TEN FEET DIAMETER .AND WIND SPLIT-
TING FRONT END, F.^ILTRE -•VLSO.
by a shaft motion. The engine rests
upon fish belly rails.
Two vertical cylinders are used, which,
by grass-hopper beams, transmit the mo-
tion downwards by vertical connecting
rods to a shaft with overhanging cranks
set at right angles. This shaft carries
a spur wheel, which, with four other
spur wheels, transmits the motion to the
two driving wheels, each 39 inches in
diameter."
Stephenson's first locomotive.
At the time Hedley's locomotives were
built, George Stephenson, an ambitious
mine foreman, was employed at a
neighboring colliery. In 1814 he built
an engine something like Hedley's, but
with a single flue, and it was ne.xt to a
failure, but Stephenson was wonderfully
persistent and was encouraged to try and
try again, until within 20 years, in com-
pany with his son Robert, he become the
principal locomotive builder in the world.
t
DISCOURAGING PERIOD OF EXPERIMENT.
The years from 1803 until 1830 were a
period of experiment in developing the
locomotive. The history of the locomo-
tive from the time of Trevithick's ex-
periment until the Stephensons achieved
their triumphs with the "Rocket" in 1829
headquarters of the Lancashire textile
industries, had long been famous for the
enterprise and public spirit of its citi-
zens. This important mart of manufac-
turing was distant about 30 miles from
Liverpool, the nearest seaport, and Man-
chester's trade languished through the
delays and difficulties encountered in
transporting goods to and from the port
of shipment. Sometimes it took longer
to transport a cargo of cotton from Liv-
erpool to Manchester than it did to bring
it across the Atlantic in a sailing ship.
About the time the Stockton & Darling-
ton Railway was opened 3, few leading
merchants of Liverpool and Manchester
organized a company to construct a rail-
way from Liverpool to Manchester. Per-
mission to build the line had to be ob-
tained from Parliament and stupendous
opposition was offered. After a long
and vigorous fight the promoters of the
enterprise were successful and the rail-
way was constructed.
DOUBT ABOUT WH.^T POWER TO ADOPT.
Although there were about 50 loco-
motive engines at work in different parts
of England when the Liverpool & Man-
chester Railway was approaching com-
pletion in 1828, there was great conflict of
some kind of mishap. In a short test
of speed without any load the engine at-
tained a speed of 29 1-2 miles an hour,
and with a car containing 36 passengers
it made 28 miles an hour.
This extraordinary speed was a start-
ling revelation to the people who had op-
posed the practicability of locomotives,
and did more than all the previous 26
years' experience with locomotives to
convince people that a new era in meth-
ods of land transport had arrived.
FROM COHPLEXITY TO SIMPLICITY.
When an engineer examines the
"Rocket" and compares it with those
previously in use, he seldom fails to ob-
serve that a leap had been made from
complexity to simplicity of design. The
absence of superfluous parts to get out
of order doubtless contributed in no
small measure to the success achieved in
the trials.
The "Rocket" possessed all the ele-
ments of the modern locomotives, and
the work left for succeeding designers to
perform was merely that of enlargement
of parts and adjustment of increased pro-
portions or to the modifying of forms to
suit individual tastes. The three most
important features of the engine were a
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
multi-tubular boiler, forced draft by the_
exhaust steam and direct connection be-
tween the piston rod and the crank pni
secured to the driving wheel. None of
these features was original. Trevithick
and others had employed the exhaust
steam to create draft in the chimney; the
multi-tubular boiler had been previously
used in the United States and in France.
and direct piston and crank-pin connec-
tion had been made on several locomo-
tives. It was the combination of three
highly meritorious features that made
the engine the pioneer of a new type.
"rocket" model to pattern from.
Most of the locomotive builders in
Great Britain readily recognized the
merits of the very simple engine pro-
duced by the Stephenson's, and they pro-
ceeded to develop their engines on sim-
ilar lines; but for a few years after the
"Rocket" appeared there were a super-
abundant variety of freak locomotives
"John Bull," imported by the Camden &
Amboy Railroad, now a part of the
Pennsylvania Railroad.
bury's engine.
The Stephensons were not, however,
the originators of th.e cranked axle en-
gine with cylinders in the smoke box.
That style was designed in 1829 by Ed-
v.'ard Bury, although it was not finished
until 1834. This engine, or others of a
similar pattern, exercised a great in-
fluence on American designs. The Bury
engine had inside cylinders, inside bar
frames and a boilef with hemispherical
or "haystack" topped firebox, as our peo-
ple called it. Our readers will readily
identify the Bury engine as the prototype
of many early American locomotives.
INCRE.'\SING the SIZES.
The line of locomotive development
followed in Great Britain was, first, the
few railways in Great Britain, but they
obtain very little favor.
Continental countries imitated the
British style of locomotive for many
years, with the exception that outside
cylinders were preferred. In minor de-
tails nearly every country adopted forms
that gave the engines national character-
istics.
GROWTH OF locomotive BUILDING
IN THE UNITED .STATES.
The agitation in favor of railroad build-
ing began in the United States about the
same time as it began in Great Britain,
and the machinery for operating them
was developed largely by native engi-
neers. Thanks to ignorant writers for
encyclopedias and to writers of ro-
mancing biography, there is an impres-
sion prevailing that pioneer American
railroad engineers were guided entirely
by English types of machinery and Eng-
lish methods of construction, which is a
most powerful passenger ENGINE EVER BUILT. CYLINDERS, 22x28
HEATING SURFACE OF BOILER 3,533 SQUARE FEET.
produced, that testified more to the in-
genuity than to the good sense of the
inventors.
LINES of DEVELOPMENT.
The "Rocket" was a four-wheel en-
gine, the front pair being the drivers, to
which power was transmitted from out-
side cylinders set diagonally across the
boiler pointing toward the back head.
The first improvement made on the
next engine was to drop the cyl-
inders to a nearly horizontal posi-
tion at the sides of the firebox. That
was followed by placing the driving
wheels behind and locating the cylinders'
in the smoke box, from whence the
power was transmitted to the driving
wheels through a cranked axle. Outside
frames were employed for the first time.
The first of this style of engine was
built by the Stephensons and was called
the "Planet," and led to what was known
as the planet type. Many engines of
this kind were imported into the United
States and had some influence on the de-
signs of early native-made locomotives.
One of the most famous of these was the
single pair of drivers and pair of carry-
ing wheels; then two pairs of wheels
coupled; then two pairs of coupled
wheels and a pair of carrying wheels.
Later for freight service three pairs of
wheels coupled and for passenger trains
a single pair of drivers in the middle and
carrying, in the front and back. There
was considerable diversity of practice in
location of cylinders, some designers put-
ting them inside and others outside. Out-
side frames were for years the favorite
style of construction, but that was grad-
ually changed to inside slab frames and
an outside supplementary frame. The
engine truck, or bogie, as they call it,
was gradually adopted within the last 20
years, and the prevailing passenger en-
gine in Great Britain now has four
wheels connected and a four-wheel lead-
ing truck. For a long time they adhered
to plain six-wheel connected engines for
freight service, but an eight-wheel con-
nected engine for that purpose is now
growing into favor. Inside cylinders are
almost universally used. Compound lo-
comotives have been introduced upon a
INCHES; DRIVING WHEELS, 72 INCHES DLi^METER
TRACTIVE POWER 32,00a POUNDS.
fallacy. Those who have studied the
subject thoroughly believe that railroads
and locomotive building in America
would not have been much delayed had
Watt never worked on improving the
steam engine, and had George Stephen-
son never been born. Oliver Evans, a
native of Delaware, developed the high-
pressure, high-speed engine as an im-
provement on Newcomen's atmospheric
engine, and it was much better adapted
for locomotive purposes than the pon-
derous slow-moving engines that early
British inventors had to work after while
designing locomotives.
Woods, an early writer on railroads,
who was a contemporary of Trevithick,
positively asserts that the latter patented
the high pressure steam engine after ex-
amining drawings of a high pressure
steam engine which 01iiv(?r Evans had
sent to Great Britain in hopes of inter-
esting capitalists in his invention.
GENERAL IGNORANCE ABOUT RAILWAYS
AND LOCOMOTIVES.
Americans, as a rule, knew very little
about what Englishmen had done when
Jaiuiary, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
they began building railroads, and their
first locomotives were purely original.
Very little accurate information had
reached America concerning what had
been done in England before our people
entered earnestly into the building of
railroads. Before the railroad era there
was scarcely any means of spreading
scientific information, and few English-
men knew anything about how railways
were going to be operated when the Liv-
erpool & Manchester Railway was under
construction. Six months before the
railway was ready for opening the di-
rectors were inundated with schemes for
operating tlie road. There were plans
proposed for working the cars by water
power. Some proposed hydrogen, oth-
ers carbonic acid gas. Atmospheric
pressure had its advocates, others fa-
vored greased cog rails. There was a
multitude of counselors who proved
nothing except that even the scientific
men of England had no knowledge of
what had been done by Trevithick, hy
.American engineers and inventors have
done for the locomotive. Meantime, we
finish with two illustrations of what wc
regard to be the highest development of
the locomotive as an engine for earning
revenue.
The Chesapeake & Ohio ten-wheel
passenger ■engine, built by the American
Locomotive Company, has a 32,000
pounds tractive power, and has a boiler
with sufficient heating capacity to keep
up steam when cutting off at half stroke.
The Southern Pacific compound con-
solidation engine, built by the Baldwin
Locomotive Works, has 41,000 pounds
tractive power, and is capable of haul-
ing about 1,500 tons up a grade of 50
feet to the mile.
(To be continued.)
times, and also an electric brake mounted
on the armature shaft which is "on"
when the current is thrown off. The
motors are designed especially for crane
work and are wound for 220 volts, direct
current. Each motor has its reversible
controller and rheostat. This shop is an
excellent example of the best modern
practice in locomotive shop design and
equipment.
100 Ton Niles Crane at the New L. S.
& M. S. Shops.
The 100-ton, s-motor electric traveling
crane which has recently been installed
Making Electricity Out of Nothing.
When writers in ordinary newspapers
make mistakes concerning the laws of
nature in describing inventions, the tech-
nical press seldom fail to cast redicule
on the writers. The technical press,
therefore, ought to be very careful not
to fall into similar mistakes. The fol-
lowing article from the New York Tinus
reads a sensible lesson on this matter:
Our learned friends on the profes-
sional and industrial press never weary
of saying derisive things about what
IDEAI, FREIGHT UN'. INK UlILl IIV li.VLL' WIN LoCu.Mu llVt WDKKS. CYLINUHRS, 17 .\ND -,'5 x !li INCHl^s, DKIV1.K>. 3
DIAMETER; WEIGHT, 204,800 POUNDS; HEATING SURFACE. 3,1)00 SQUARE FEET; TRACTIVE POWER. 40,000
POUNDS. CAN HAUL 1,500 TONS UP GRADE, 50 FEET TO THE MILE.
INCHES
Hedley, Stephenson, Hackworth and
others.
AMERICANS PROCEED TO BUILD R.\ILROADS.
That being the condition of engineer-
ing knowledge in Great Britain, it was
not surprising that Americans had to
fall back upon their own resources when
they proceeded to build railroads and to
put them into operation. The nation
has always been celebrated for self-re-
liance, and the pioneer railroad builders
pushed along without hesitation, cross-
ing the bridges of difficulty when they
were reached. So far were they guiltless
of imitating English methods that they
built and began operating the first rail-
road in the world ever projected for gen-
eral traffic and worked it with motive
power of native design. That was the
Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, which was
chartered in 1827 and part opened for
business in 1830.
■ This article is too long to be com-
pleted in one number, so the greater part
must be held over, when our readers will
be able to read a brief history of what
by the Niles-Bement-Pond Company at
the CoUinwood shops of the Lake Shore
& Michigan Southern Railway, is of par-
ticular interest to mechanical men. In
the illustration on page 8, this crane
is shown in the act of lifting an 80-ton
consolidation type locomotive. The
crane is of the Niles standard design,
fitted with two so-ton trolleys. The main
hoist motors are each of 45 horse power
and are capable of hoisting the full load
at a speed of about 10 ft. per minute.
The bridge motors traverse the bridge
up or down the shop, which is about 530
ft. long, at the rate of 150 ft. per minute
with the full load and 2C0 ft. per minute,
light. The bridge is a Niles standard
box girder. It is fitted with eight truck
wheels running in heavy steel truck
frames, which are securely riveted to the
box girders, and it has a span of 65 ft.
6 in. All gears on this crane are cut
from the solid and run submerged in oil.
Each trolley is equipped with the Niles
improved automatic safety mechanical
brake, which controls the load at all
they call "newspaper science," and it
must be confessed that they do not lack
for frequent opportunities to prove as
well as to assert that "newspaper sci-
ence" i^ fearfully and wonderfully made.
Realizing this fact, we have been accus-
tomed to accept with as close a simula-
tion of humility as we could conveniently
assume the high and mighty criticisms of
our specializing mentors. But we have
not been quite as happy under discipline
as we have looked, and it is with sincere
joy that we note the appearance in Elec-
tricity of some "science" as well calcu-
lated to astonish as any story about a
perpetual motion machine or a frog liv-
ing for years in a human stomach that
ever appeared in the most credulous of
dailj' papers. The article that gives us
this joy concerns the lighting of railway
trains by means of a windmill-like de-
vice fastened in front of the boiler-head
of the locomotive. When the train
moves, of course the windmill turns, and
the power thus obtained charges a stor-
age battery and continuous illumination
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
is secured. There is nothing incredible
in all that, but imagine the feelings of a-
-"newspaper scientist" when he reads:
"No air pressure is massed on the fiat
surface of the boiler head, but the curved
surfaces of the fan blades utilize the
traveling air and thereby generate pow-
er. The fan cutting through the air re-
volves swiftly and does not add to the
resistance of the air nor retard the speed
of the train. No gale of wind is re-
quired to cause the fan to operate; the
ordinary pressure of the train moves it
sufficiently to generate the electrical en-
ergy required to light any train and
leave a large surplus for ventilating fans
and other purposes." Ho, ho! doesn't
"retard the speed of the train," hey?
Just "utilizes the traveling air, and there-
by generates power" — out of nothing, or.
Across the sky, high above all, looms the
lofty trestle of the Homestake Mining
Company, connecting its old and new
shafts, mills and crushers across the
gulch. A train of ore cars, pulled by
a small steam locomotive, is in view, and
beyond it one of the compressed air en-
gines which the Homestake uses, can be
seen.
The Elkhorn, a part of the great
Northwestern system, entered Lead over
the tracks of the Fort Pierre and Black
Hills Railroad, a little narrow gauge line,
which connected with the Elkhorn main
line at Buffalo Gap, while the Burlington
came in over its own tracks. The latter
road one day stole a march on its com-
petitor and bought the Fort Pierre road,
shutting the Elkhorn out of the city.
It was thought impossible to build an-
THREE STORIES OF RAILROADS.
what amounts to the same thing, out of
traveling air that doesn't travel! But
we foresee the hole out of which Elec-
tricity will make its escape — it will de-
clare that what it meant to say was that
the train lights are run with power that
otherwise would be wasted, and it will
hope that before the problem involved
in that statement is solved the whole
matter will be forgotten. We have re-
sorted to worse expedients than that
ourselves, on particularly trying occa-
sions, and we'll do our best not to laugh
at it.
Three Stories of Railroads.
Owing to a fight between the Burling-
ton & Northwestern Railroad systems
for the tremendous freight business of
the great Homestake mines. Lead, S. D.,
has a tier of railroads, the like of which
cannot be seen anywhere else in the
world.
Standing on the surface track is a
train on the Burlington line, while im-
mediately above is an Elkhorn line train.
other line into Lead, since the only two
gulches through which a train could
pass were owned by the Burlington.
But a corps of Northwestern survey-
ors were put to work and the result of
their labors was that the Elkhorn con-
structed a line from Deadwood, which
sweeps around in majestic curves and
easy grades until it is right on top of the
mountain and passes through a cut, the
sides of which are worth hundreds of
dollars per car load, in fact passes right
through part of the great Homestak''
mine.
We are indebted to the New York
Herald for above cut and description.
Humors of Booking Strange Animals.
On European railways there are a great
many small packages sent as parcels. There
is a schedule of charges for various kinds
of goods and it is amusing to witness the
embarrassment of the booking clerk when
any article is offered not mentioned in the
schedule. An English parcels clerk was
once offered for transportation a crate
containing a turtle. He pondered over the
case and remarked: "It is some kind of
a big hinsect, but it is not a crab, or a
lobster. It is not a fish, and it is not a
cat, but I shall book it as a heel," and as
an eel it went.
A humorous chapter might be written
on the following adventures of a monkey,
recounted in a paragraph, entitled, "What
Cannot an Ape Become?" published in
the German Journal of Sport. A German
returning from German East Africa
brought with him as a pet a small mon-
key, weighing about one pound. From
Tanga to Genoa no charge was made.
From Genoa to the Swiss frontier the
railway authorities described the little
creature as a "bird," and charged I 1-2
lire for his fare. When he reached Swit-
zerland the Gothard Railway officials were
persuaded that he was not a "bird," but
a "dog." Accordingly, a dog ticket, cost-
ing 81-2 francs, had to be taken for him.
The next railway company in Switzerland,
not being certain under what category of
animals he should be classed, dismissed
him as "passenger's luggage." taking only
a fee of about 7 pence for him. In Baden
and Wiirtemburg. as far as Stuttgart, the
monkey passed as "hand luggage," and
was permitted to travel as such scot-free ;
but from Stuttgart to his destination he
was again relegated to the canine species,
and as a "dog" a ticket was demanded for
him, value is. 7d.
New Lehigii Valley Dining Cars.
The Lehigh Valley Railroad is to place
in service two new dining cars to sup-
plement its present excellent dining car
system. - The two cars will be exactly
alike, and no care or expense has been
spared in their construction. The ends
will be fitted with wide vestibules, and
on each side will be four oval opalescent
windows and nine large double windows,
mahogany sash. The windows in the
side roof are opalescent glass in metallic
frames. The interior of the cars will be
finished in Cuban mahogany, with finely
figured veneer panels. The ceiling, full
Empire, will be decorated in gold leaf.
Window curtains are to be rose pattern,
green silk-faced pantasote, with acme
fixtures; dining chairs, mahogany, seats
and backs upholstered in leather. The
dining room in the car will seat 30 peo-
ple. A pleasing feature in summer time
will be the cooling of the cars by elec-
tric fans, three of which will be placed
in each car.
To obtain the maximum opening of any
circular valve it is necessary to raise the
valve off its seat a distance equal to one-
quarter of its diameter. A valve five
inches in diameter, for example, has
19635 square inches area, and when raised
lYn inches gives full opening. If lifted
higher than this, no greater opening is
obtained.
Juinuiry, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMO TIVIC ENGINEERING
Erie's Handsome Dining; Cars.
The Passenger Department of the Erii'
Railroad has just placed in commission
between New York and Chicago a new
dining car which for perfection of ap-
pointment in every detail, is probably
without a superior on any railroad in the
world.
The interior trimming throughout is
hand polished mahogany, beautifully in-
island a safe country for every one. Sir
William will be 60 years of age in Feb-
ruary, young enough to build a few more
railways. — Toronto Clobc.
To Prevent Collisions.
The devices so often patented in the
United States for automatically stopping
trains witliout the aid of the engineer
.standing by telephone between locomo-
tives. In to-day's tests two locomotives
afniroached each other. VVhcn they
reached a certain distance of each other
the apparatus gave the signals and the
engineers were able to communicate.
Dixon's "Graphite" for December
contains an interesting article on experi-
Trap Diior to raiM
PLAN OK ERIE RAILROAD DININO CAR.
laid with white box. There is an entire
absence of the ordinary carving, but at
intervals in the walls are niches for
potted plants, and the general effect,
heightened by the generous use of har-
moniously tinted cathedral glass, is rich
in the extreme. The furniture corre-
sponds, of course; the napery is all of the
very best Irish linen, made to order; the
service of heavily plated silver; every
article bearing the well-known insignia
of the Erie. The car is brilliantly light-
ed by electricity, with gas as a reserve.
It has an electric fan at each end, and is,
in every respect, as comfortable to ride
in as a car can be made. The solidity
with which all the parts appear to be
fairly welded together, makes the run-
ning exceptionally free from vibration.
The kitchen, pantry, dry-air closets,
refrigerators, wine-locker, etc., are con-
structed after the latest and most im-
proved ideas, and the combination of
economy of space with convenience and
comfort of operation is simply wonder-
ful. So perfect are the arrangements
that it would almost seem that a dinner
could "get itself," but nothing is left to
chance, and it goes without saying that
car 956 carries a chef whose ability cor-
responds with his surroundings.
The Cuban Railroad.
Sir William Van Home's Cuban Rail-
way is a very sound enterprise commer-
cially, but it probably would • not have
been built had it not appealed to the imag-
ination of this hard-headed railway chief,
who is also an artist, a literary critic and
something of a fairy godfather. To take
hold of the war-racked and desolated is-
land and afford it the first requisite of
civilization was decidedly Van Hornesque.
He has that rare combination, imagination
and the highest executive talent. The
Cuban Railway will afford him as much
satisfaction as a Tenters or a piece of rare
Japanese porcelain, and it will make the
ELECTRIC LIGHTED DI.VER OX THE ERIE.
have evidently found imitators in Ger-
many. The following cable dispatch to
the New York Sun explains itself:
A device for preventing collisions be-
tween railway trains was successfully
tried on a railroad near Frankfort to-
day. It consists of a small apparatus
fitted to a locomotive which will give
visible and audible signals if another lo-
comotive is approaching on the same
track or if a switch is misplaced. It
renders it possible to have an under-
ments made by Professor W. F. M. Goss
of Purdue University in the use of Dix-
on's graphite for air-brake equipment.
The experiments were made upon the
fifty-car train equipment at the Univer-
sity, and covered the use of vaseline
without graphite, graphite without vas-
eline, and finally the use of graphite and
vaseline. The experiments are not only
interesting but of value to all who are
connected or interested in locomotive
engineering.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
How the New Superintendent In-
troduced Himself.
BY SHANDY MAGUIRE.
The bulletin boards of the B. & R.
division of the C, U. & B. had the fol-
lowing notice on them recently:
"Mr. C. H. Mayberry has been ap-
pointed superintendent of the B. & R.
division, vice J. H. Arden, resigned."
A. B. DowLiNG, Gen'l Supt.
"Merely that, and nothing more," but
what a red hot shot it proved! How the
stove committee got down to business!
The all-absorbing question was, "Who
is Mayberry?"
Pugnose Casey said he heard of a chap
of that name whom the boys chased ofi
the Raleigh between two days. Toejamb
Curtiss said he was a cousin to the wife
work the train. The train stopped, as
the rules required, before crossing the
tracks of the B. & R., then went ahead
again. The baggage man was deep in
tlie morning paper, with his two feet
tipped up on the top of a trunk. The
conductor passed from the mirror, nav-
igating dexteroi'sly through the scat-
tered trunks, ti" he got to the stranger.
He was handed a pass, which read:
"Pass one between Darien and Clive,"
signed by the new superintendent.
"You seem to have some travel on this
road," said he to the baggage man, after
the conductor left the car.
"Y-a-a-s," said the trunk-butcher with
a devil-may-care-damn-your-soul sort of
a drawl, without even lifting his eyes
from the paper.
NILES-BEMENT-POND CR.\NE IN COLLIN
{Description
of the president. Crosseyed Crowley
said he was a chap whose mother used
to supply the general freight agent with
milk, butter and eggs. No one had ever
seen him to know him, and the commit-
tee adjourned to await developments.
Mr. Mayberry remained in his office
for several days familiarizing himself
with business and looking over old rec-
ords.
One day, as train 80 was pulling out,
a man about 40 years of age, with a
clean shaven face, somewhat pale, and a
pair of clear, intelligent eyes, dressed
in an unpretentious suit of gray clothes,
got on the ofif side from the station onto
the baggage car platform and entered.
The conductor was putting the finishing
touches to a blond mustache and his
necktie, taking special care to not let
any part of it obscure the big diamond
stud in his shirt front. In fact, he was
grooming himself to the very best ad-
vantage, preparatory to going out to
WOOr! SHOPS OF L. S. & M. S. RAILWAY,
oil page 5).
"It is transient or permanent?"
"I dunno," came out curtly and sneer-
ingly. Just then the train stopped and
the station agent knocked at the car
door. Lord Paramount opened it with
a "What de ye want?"
"Here's a check for this gentleman's
trunk."
He searched the checks of several
trunks before he found the right one.
"See if you have any mail for me,"
said the agent.
A package of letters in a pigeon hole
was searched, and one handed out. The
train must have been detained at least
three minutes before starting again. The
gent in the gray clothes strolled out to
the smoker and sat down in the ne.xt
seat to a dandified-looking dude in uni-
form, with "brakeman" on his cap. He
was reading the morning paper also.
"Please tell me how far it is to Green-
ville?"
"Two stations ahead," said the duke.
"Thanks," said the stranger. He then
passed into the coach. The conductor
was deeply occupied in keeping a young
lady smiling, sitting close up to her in
the same seat. He didn't wish to dis-
turb him, so at the next stop he got onto
the engine and showed a pass to the
engineer, signed by the new superintend-
ent.
"All right," said he, "you can ride."
"Say, Jakey," said he to the fireman,
"here is a pass from the new super., the
first I've seen."
"Let me see it," said Jakey. "He
isn't much of a writer, is he?"
"Naw, nor he doesn't know nauthen
about railroadin'."
"How de ye know?"
"October-eyed Patsey Puddinhead said
so. He heard of him from Snook
Brown." The stranger was standing
in the gangway taking it all in, also the
deck with 6 inches of coal on it, and the
filthy condition of the cab all around.
The fireman would jump down from his
perch, fling in about five shovelfuls of
coal and fly up again and help his pard
to watch the top of the stack, out of
which was belching a dense mass of
black smoke which mustered a big broad
smile on both of their grimy faces, and
this encomium from his royal highness:
"Jakey, old boy, ye hit her that time
right where she wanted it." The next
stop was a meet. The local was on the
siding. The stranger left the passenger
train and got onto the caboose of the
local, showing a pass to the conductor
requesting the stranger to be let ride.
"All right, sir," said the conductor af-
ter reading the pass, "that's as good as
the wheat. Make yerself at home. We
are veof busy on this train and seldom
are trOTbled with passengers." The train
was swinging along gaily. A brakeman
was sitting in the lookout, with his eye
on business, and the conductor examin-
ing bills.
"A flag is out at Ashland, Dan," said
the lookout.
"That's too damned bad," said Dan,
"and we havin' so much to do all the way
in. Some lo-cent passenger wants to go
to Lisbon and make us stop again.
Make a signal to Tom to keep her
movin' and I'll get ofT and make the pas-
senger hustle." The train slowed down
to about a 4-mile-an-hour gait as the ca-
boose was- passing the station, where an
old woman stood, waiting to get on.
Dan shouted out "Hurry up here, ould
woman, give me hoult of yer leg."
He caught her and landed her on the
steps, swung the engineer ahead again,
and as he landed his passenger breath-
less in the car he said to her: "Why
didn't you wait for the express and not
stop us?"
"I got word that my daughter's little
girl wasn't likely to live till night with
the croup, and I couldn't sit nor stand
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
till I'd get to her to see her. I wasn't
able to- walk the 7 miles, so I thought
I'd ride with you to Oakville and walk
back the two miles."
"Ye won't have to walk back, Mrs.
Arthur, I'll stop and let you olT at the
house if I was to be discharged for it.
We all know little sunny-haired Ella.
She wags licr hand at us every day as we
pass."
"May God bless you and never let
your heart experience the grief of mine
this winter," said the old lady.
The train slowed up again^ — the brake-
man having notified the engineer — and
Dan helped the old lady off, with a
"Cheer up, Mrs. Arthur, yc'll find Ella
all right, I'll bet."
The stranger was an interested ob-
server. The train arrived at Easton in
a little while. There was considerable
freight to load and unload. The crew
after the affair got circulated. The con-
ductor, baggageman, brakeman, engineer
and fireman of train 80 were summoned
to the office of the superintendent in
about 10 days after the above occurrence.
"Mr. I'lctchcr," said he to the con-
ductor, "I hold you personally respon-
sible for the lax manner your associates
and yourself do business. Your baggage-
man is not fit for his place, neither are
your trainmen. You never looked out
to see if you had the right signal to
cross the B. & R. No station order
method is employed in baggage or mail
in your car, and your trainmen are impu-
dent. None of you ought to be on a
passenger train. You have the idea in
your heads that you own the road. To
disabuse it, you will all go serve an ap-
prenticeship on local freight until you
can be considered common mortals
again.
brakeman acting as baggageman, and al-
though it is very gratifying to see a
train get from a station quickly, do not
ever again expedite business by saying
to a passenger, 'Gimme hoult of yer
leg,' particularly a lady."
How King Edward Pays for
Transportation.
The London correspondent of the New
York Tribune says: Each leading rail-
way company in Great Britain has con-
structed at its own expense a special
train, which is reserved for the exclusive
use of royalty. One company has two
trains, one for the King, the other for
the Queen. These trains are paid for by
the Kings's treasurer on the following
plan: First-class fare is charged for
every member of the royal party and a
were hustling at it and the stranger
strolled up to the engine. He found a
clean cab, the fireman keeping a lookout
for any signal which might be made, and
the engineer looking around the engine.
"A local freight is a hard train to run,"
said the stranger to the engineer.
"Yes, sir, it is, but if men only work
together they reduce the labor by di-
viding it. Either my fireman or myself
always keeps a lookout behind, so as
not to keep the crew waiting to get the
signal to the engine; and when freight is
very heavy, on an understood sign from
the conductor, we go back and bear a
hand. He is a tiptop man to run with,
we have not much trouble in making
time."
The stranger handed his card to the
engineer and shook his hand as a pas-
senger train dashed into the station,
which he boarded. The card read: "C.
H. Mayberry, Superintendent."
When Dan Dailey heard of it he hung
his head and thought of stopping his
train without orders.
"Me name is Dinnis, instead of Dan,"
was the way he told it to his men. A
few days afterward any one could notice
a decided improvement in the service.
CANON DIABLO BRIDGE, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.
Mr. Ellsworth, you and your fireman
also must go back to a freight train
until you learn something about com-
bustion and how to avoid niggerizing
passengers with a superabundance of
black smoke, by "Jakey hittin' her right
where she wanted it." Mr. Dailey, it is
your heart I credit instead of your head.
You violated an order by stopping your
train between stations to let a passenger
off without any orders. There are ex-
tenuating circumstances, and I, too, have
a heart. You, Mr. Beardsley, used or-
dinary politeness when you addressed
me, a supposed stranger. Yourself and
your fireman are well spoken of by your
master mechanic. You will both take
engine 368 on trains 80 and 81. Mr.
Dailey, your two men and yourself will
be given the same trains, your hind
shilling is added for each mile traveled.
The companies hardly need the royaI_
advertisement, and are not adequately
compensated for the service rendered
and the suspension and disturbance of
traffic.
Two freight engines recently collided
near the Kentucky town of Whitlock.
Both were pretty badly damaged, and
one engineer was discharged for care-
lessness and disobedience of orders. The
funniest thing about the matter was the
answer of the disobedient engineer to
the other, who asked: "Didn't you have
orders to meet me at Whitlock?" "Well,
d — n it, hain't I met you?" said the engi-
neer who caused the head-on collision. —
Argonaut.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
Vanderbilt Steel Hopper Car.
A design for a 40-ton steel hopper car
for the carriage of Hmestone or other
rough material has recently been brought
out by Mr. Cornelius Vanderbilt, of
New York, and it embodies several in-
teresting features.
The center sills of this car with the
two body bolsters form what may be
called the ground plan of structure, and
upon this I-shaped foundation the weight
is carried. The center sills are two 12-
inch channels, which extend out to the
end sills, and taking the draw gear be-
tween them, place the line of pull only
slightly below the sill center line. The
body bolster is composed of two lo-inch
channels which are placed on top of the
center sills and are united above by a
S-8 plate which is extended, up at an
light as it can be made, and as the doors
pass under and across the car from side
to side, one shaft is sufficient for the
operation of each. This flat or horizon-
tally-placed door arrangement gives max-
imum hopper capacity, as the sloping
hood covering the center sills is the only
space in the interior of the car occupied
by structural members.
The end sills are composed of plates
backed by angles and are tied together
from car end to car end by a couple of
through rods. These rod ends support
the draw-bar carrying irons. The outer
corners of the end sills are braced by
two channel struts, which reach the body
bolster beside the center sills and are
there all connected together by a flat
plate. Upright angles connect the cor-
ners of the end sills with the corners of
dess Stultitia was proceeded with in due
form. The railway billed the private line
for a loose wheel, two spring hangers
repaired and two new . couplers, less
scrap. The P. P. L. replied that the
loose wheel was all they could fairly be
asked to pay. for, as the rest was cer-
tainly "consequential damage." The rail-
way pointed out that they had not asked
to be reimbursed for repairs to dam-
aged track or delay to freight, or for the
expense of calling out a miniature
wrecking gang in overtime, but had sim-
ply asked for the actual cost of neces-
sary repairs to P. P. L. cars, due en-
tirely to a failure of which the P. P. L.
was clearly the cause. The P. P. L. did
not dispute the statement of the case,
they even expressed sorrow for the ac-
cident, but said that concerning giving
VANDERBILT STEEL HIGH SIDE HOPPER GONDOL4^
angle sufficient to meet the under side of
the sloping hopper, and so act as a sup-
port to the latter. The weight of the
car is, however, also transmitted to the
ends of the body bolster by two up-
right channels which pass up on the out-
side of the car in the center of the two
end panels. The car has no side sills,
. but the plates of which the hopper are
composed are stiffened by a series of
angles disposed so as to make the car-
side a truss structure like the members
of a bridge or the framing of a box car.
The hoppers terminate in flat doors
on the underside, which are supported,
each by four hangers, two on a side.
These are so placed that each door
moves back, with slight drooping of the
central edge, and takes up a new posi-
tion under the hopper and out of the
way. One hanger is slightly longer than
the other, which has the effect of making
the work of opening these gates an easy
matter. The doors- in action are each
opened separately and do not slide back
at any great angle. The opening and
closing mechanism is strong, and as
the hopper, and behind these are two
angles which connect the end sill cor-
ners with the sides of the hopper further
back. The design has been patented by
Mr. Vanderbilt.
A Qood Nerve Tonic.
Once upon a time the Pros^perous Pri-
vate Line did business with the Good,
Slow & Easy Railway tn the usual way.
One day some P. P. L. cars went off the
track while being delivered by a neigh-
boring road. The strange part of it was
that the cars were clearly on the tracks
of the G., S. & E. Ry., while they were
off, and that caused this railway to put
forth effort. It turned out on examina-
'tion that one of the P. P. L. cars had a
loose wheel which fouled a frog point
on a curve. The car left the rails and
broke and bent two spring hangers in
one truck, and somehow managed to
break a coupler on the car preceding and
the car following it. Both of these were
also P. P. L. cars. When everything
was put right, the worship of the god-
up money to a railway they could not
see it from where they sat, and offered
to arbitrate, with consequential damage
scenery artistically arranged in the fore-
ground, while the G., S. & E. Ry. weak-
ened considerably and let it go at that.
An auditor from the planet Mars, who
looked over the books of both com-
panies without their knowing it, found
that the P. P. L. had got a tight wheel
in place of a loose one, for which they
paid, also two spring hangers repaired
as good as new, for nothing, and two
new couplers for two partly worn ones,
without paying for the difference. The
G., S. & E. Ry. had received only a spec-
ified small portion of the total outlay
for work forced upon them so suddenly
that the most expensive way of doing it
was the only possible way for them.
They had paid out cash on account of
the P. P. L. and had filed away a neatly
worded type-written expression of sor-
row. The auditor, however, believes that
consequential damage, with a very pale-
colored tincture of sorrow added, makes
a most invigorating nerve tonic.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY ANIJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
General Correspondence.
Sao Paulo Railway, the Coffee Road of
the World.
BY O. HUBER.
A brief description of the port of San-
tos, from which is shipped three-quarters
of the cofTee exported from Brazil, will
give the reader a fair conception of the
enormous business done by one railway,
in that product alone. The harbor of
Santos is a well-sheltered one; with fine
docks and large warehouses. Ten years
Portuguese). The serea is 10 kilometers
in length, with a gradient of 8 per cent,
or 422.4 feet per mile. The road is
double-tracked, but in a novel manner.
Three rails are used, instead of four, ex-
cept at passing points, which are half
way up or down in each section. In this
respect, it resembles the Lookout Moun-
tain incline railway, which was illustrated
in our October, 1902, issue. The
"Serea" is divided into five sections.
IS at a ^i.nid-,till. The cable bemg an end-
less one, the trains must necessarily meet
just in the middle of each section. On
this high grade no regular road engine
is attached to the train. Each train on
the incline has coupled to it what is
called a "locomotive-brake." This is a
combination of locomotive and auto-
matic machinery used in connection with
the cable. A rail grip may also be used
in case of an emergency. .Ml these appli-
ances are worked by steam. The loco-
tive-brake weighs about 32 tons. Trains
move up and down in the following man-
ner. The cable being at a standstill,
then at the top and bottom of each sec-
tion a locomotive-brake, with train
coupled in front, is securely gripped on
the cable. After this has been done, the
engineman in the "brake" notifies the
signalman. This is done by electric ap-
paratus. Should trouble occur when the
train is between any section, the engine-
man can use this appliance to call the
signalman, as before. When both en-
ginemen at top and bottom of the same
section have given signals, indicating
that their "brakes" are gripped to the
■ LOCO.MUTIVE BRAKE."
ago the port had no docks. Sinitary
conditions were almost unknown, and
yellow fever had been epidemic many
times. The Santos Dock Company h.ive
changed the port almost into ■\ he.ilth
resort. The docks are now over a mile
in length, equipped with hydraulic cranes
for handling heavy freight In the year
1901, nine million sacks, or 540,000 ton?.
of cofTee were exported from Santos.
Every sack of the nine million was
brought into Santos over the Sao Paulo
Company's line. This road is one of the
model railways of South America; it is
about 86 miles in length, and runs
through a tropical country from Santos
to Jundiahy. where it has several feeders,
viz.: the Paulista Railway and Sora-
cabana y Ituana Ry. The Mogyana Rail-
way is a feeder for the Paulista, and taps
that road at Campinas. Nearly all of the
coflfee is grown in the zone of the above-
named roads. To handle this enormous
traffic in coflfee, besides other freight and
passenger business, of which latter there
is a large amount, the road is equipped
as follows: Double track the entire
length, interlocking switches at all sta-
tions, block signals, 90-Ib. rails, 75 loco-
motives and 16 "locomotive brakes." The
most interesting part of the road is what
is called the "Serea" (meaning "hill" in
each separately operated by an end-
less cable, driven by a pair of
1,000 h.p. Corliss condensing en-
gines. The up and down trains each
use the middle rail until the trains come
to the meeting point. There the road is
double-tracked for a distance sufficient
to allow trains to pass. It is impossible
to miss this passing point, as both the
up and down trains are gripped at cer-
tain definite points on the cable at top
and bottom of the incline, when the cable
cable, the signalman gives notice to the
engineman in the power house, who then
starts the engines connected to the cable
on that section. When a train arrives
at either end of a section, the locomo-
tive-brake drops the cable of that sec-
tion, and, being on level track, easily
pushes the train ahead to the next sec-
tion, and then grips the cable of that sec-
tion. This procedure is repeated on each
of the five sections. The locomotive-
brake does no work when attached to the
cable. It simply holds on. As a loco-
motive-brake is attached to each train.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
one balances the other on the grade. The
load gripped to each cable is about 120
tons. This part of the road can handle
more tonnage in 14 hours than the other
part -delivers at present. During what
is known as the "Coffee Season," as high
as 90 trips are run on each section. The
approximate tonnage handled in these
90 trips, over the incline, is about 20,000
tons. This includes weight of locomo-
tive-brake, cars and freight. An aver-
age of 45 thousand sacks of coffee (2,700
tons) is shipped over the incline daily
during the "coffee season." Each power
station is equipped with an electric light
plant. Express passenger trains make
the run between Santos and Sao Paulo,
a distance of about 49 miles, in 2 hours
and IS minutes. The trains are run in
two sections over the cable, at a speed
of about 123-4 miles per hour. It will
readily be seen that very good time is
made by these trains. After deducting
stops, of which there are five on the
serea, where the train is in two parts,
and has to be made into one again at the
top or bottom of the grade. Three
other stops are made, or 8 in all. The
entire freedom from accident on the
cable section speaks well for the system
and the management. Not a passenger
has been killed since the road has been
in operation, which covers a period of
30 years. Mr. John Harrison is Loco-
motive Superintendent, and Mr. Cecil R.
Hillman Assistant Locomotive Superin-
tendent. The writer is indebted to both
of these gentlemen for information con-
cerning the novel and interesting serea
section.
Forces Moving Slide Valves,
In your September, igo2, issue, page
404, query of E. H. B. — Answer: There
is no tendency to move a locomotive
valve, either slide or piston, caused by
steam in the steam chest, etc.
While the steam pressure in pounds per
square inch is uniform, and the pressure
per square inch on both sides of the valve
exactly the same, yet there is a greater
total force acting on the front end of the
valve in the absence of a front extension
rod. tending to push the valve to the back
end.
As an example, take a slide valve on
which the stem is I 3-4 in. in diameter
and steam chest pressure 150 lbs. per
square inch, the force acting on the front
side of the valve is d" x .7854 x P =
360 lbs. d is the diameter of the yoke
stem, P = steam pressure per square
inch in the steam chest, and .7854 is well
known. The same conditions also apply
to a piston valve without a front extension
rod.
Of course the frictional resistance of
the valve stem packing and of the valve
on the seat is greater than the unbalance
load acting on the sides of the valve, but
the tendency is for the valve to move
back.
Referring to the last paragraph of this
article : If the piston valve has a front
extension rod and is pushed ahead, it is
not quite clear to me why the valve might
be forced back. Why would it be forced
back if the extension rod is of the same
diameter as the yoke stem? I can under-
• stand, however, that these conditions
would exist where an extension rod is not
used. S. J. Dillon, G. F. P. C. I.
Jersey City N. J.
Cause of Pound of Piston Valves When
Drifting.
The question was asked in the Decem-
ber number of a railway magazine,
"What causes piston valve engines to
pound when drifting with lever hooked
up?" The answer given was that this
pounding is caused by compression in
the cylinders, on account of the early
closing of the exhaust when valve is run-
ning in short travel. This is a mistake.
The pounding, which is in the rod
brasses, is caused not by compression,
but by the lack of it, on account of the
valve opening for admission, and thus
permitting the air which is being com-
pressed to escape into the steam ways.
There then being no resistance, the mo-
mentum of piston and connected parts
takes up the lost motion in rod brasses
with a jerk. The pounding can be
stopped either by placing the lever in the
corner or on the center — or. which is
the better, by keeping main rod brasses
filed. J. M. Foster, L. S. & M. S.
Collinwood, December 10, igos.
Almost Acquired a Long Charter.
BY R. R. BUCKH.\M.
There is no pleasure quite equal to
mountain climbing. The stirring exer-
cise in the open air sets the blood run-
ning a merry race, while the extended
prospect, growing broader and grander
with every step, uplifts the mind, and all
that is mean and commonplace in life is
utterly forgotten.
With the eastern tourist Mt. Washing-
ton is undoubtedly the favorite moun-
tain summit to visit. The view which it
affords is unsurpassed, and its top is easy
of access, since one can make the trip
by the footpath, the roadway, or the rail-
way, as he prefers. The great majority
of visitors to the mountain patronize the
latter, as it is safe, convenient and
speedy.
As one is slowly but surely borne up
the steep and frowning mountainside by
this achievement of mechanical skill and
genius, he cannot but be impressed by
the feasibility, the practical simplicity of
this method of accomplishing a moun-
tain ascent. Everything about the rail-
way and its car and puffing engine works
to a charm. There is no hitch or flaw
anywhere from top to bottom. Upon
making the trip up and back by this
means, one would say at once that of
course there was no more sensible, and
ingenious, and commendable mode of
carrying tourists up and down than this.
Little does the average passenger re-
alize, however, what a storm of ridicule
it aroused when it was first proposed.
Sound and experienced railroad men re-
garded its inventor as little less than a
maniac. When application was made to
the New Hampshire Legislature for its
charter, the idea was received with de-
rision. During the debate which fol-
lowed, one member of the House offered
as an amendment that the charter be
granted from the base of the mountain
to the moon. Thus this little railway,
but about two miles in length in all,
came very near having the longest char-
tered line of any railroad in the country.
That Broken Whistle Valve.
On page 388 of your September issue
I notice an article under the heading of
"Broken Whistle Valve Causes Excite-
ment," in which you give an instance of
a broken whistle valve on a locomotive
pulling a train into the peaceful town of
Oyster Bay, causing the whistle to
shriek for twelve miles approaching the
station and for fifteen minutes after arri-
val. Could not the engineer have
stuffed something in the bell of the
whistle to prevent the noise and the con-
sequent annoyance which it appears to
have caused, for I have no doubt that a
noisy noise annoys an Oyster Bayite?
F. G. MULLENGER.
Ongarue, Nnv Zealand.
[The item referred to by our far-away
correspondent was published without
comment. On most railroads in this
country there would be severe discipline
meted out to the engineer who failed to
stop the screaming of a whistle when
the valve was out of order. It is a com-
mon practice to blow steam off the boiler
through the whistle valve. — Ed.]
Says That American Engines Burn
Hore Coal Than Those Built in
Great Britain.
A correspondent in Wellington, New
Zealand, writes: "I have been requested
to write to you for an explanation of
how it is that the Baldwin engines which
we have are much harder on coal than
the British engines. The answer as far
as I can make out is that the tubes are
too short in comparison to the length
of the firebox. I have been pushed to
this belief through the temperature of
the smoke box as found in the Baldwin
engines, and in the engines of Scotch
make. You would faft'or a number of
subscribers if you would give them some
information on the question asked."
[In regard to the letter from our cor-
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
13
respondent we would say that tlie tubes
being too short would cause a great
waste of lieat. Our position, however,
has always been that the difference in
the course of operating the American
locomotives as compared with those of
Great Britain, is that our builders persist
in making enormous steam and exhaust
ports and we believe that heat is wasted
through the increased clearance spaces,
and also through the steam exhaust at
the high velocity which tlie big exhaust
port makes possible. — Ed.]
What Is the Matter With These Valves ?
I am running a ten-wheel Baldwin pas-
senger engine in mixed service. In
leaving here as a helper on a three-en-
gine freight train a few days ago, the
head engine failed at the first station
out (about 3 1-2 miles), and had to re-
turn to terminal, the conductor request-
ing me to return also with my engine in
case the head engine failed altogether,
which I did. We had to flag back and
around several curves, and it being night
did not exceed ten miles an hour either
way, it being up hill going out. About
l-S of a mile without doing any further
damage. Now what caused blade to
break, and in such an unheard of place?
M. M. claims eccentric was hot when I
came in, while I claim it was not, al-
though I did not feel them on looking
engine over, going such a short dis-
tance and so slow. I looked at all
pretty good and none showed the least
indication of being even warm, though
when strap and eccentric were taken
down next day they showed two blue
places and looked very dry and rough,
which I claim was caused by hostler
when he moved engine after breaking
down without disconnecting first the ec-
centric strap catching under firebox and
acting all the same as a brake shoe
would do when strap got bound as en-
gine moved ahead, causing strap to get
hot, for when I got under engine imme-
diately after engine stopped the thick
parts of strap were yet cool, the eccen-
tric was still tight on shaft and strap
was working quite free. After accident,
in taking eccentric down next day, a
piece was found broken where two halves
bolt together. This engine has plain
balanced valves and has troubled every
nothing wrong. After starting up again
engine was all right; stopped at water
tank 4 miles further on and looked en-
gine over again and still found nothing
wrong, and lever did not bother any
more for about 12 miles, then it com-
menced to act about the same, only not
quite so bad, so I slowed down and went
out to front end and gave engine some
oil through release valves when matters
improved somewhat, and I do this now
whenever lever commences to cut up,
though by the way it all starts so sud-
denly. I am looking for it to tear both
sides of engine off some day, but hope
not; have reported condition to R. H.
foreman and had valves examined two or
three times, but each time nothing is
found wrong, with the exception that
both valves have some wrought iron
patches on face of them.
Roth tallow pipes are O. K., lubrica-
tor working first class, and I use about
3 pints over division of 170 miles. When
I left engine at water tank hostler
claims he moved my engine with the
one that was coupled in ahead, even
spotting my engine at oil tank with it
and it was after getting oil and moving
VIADUCT ON HOl.YHEAD DIVISION OF LONDON AND NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY.
a mile from town the reverse lever com-
menced to jerk with engine drifting,
which I judged was on account of wind
blowing on lubricator and it not feeding
good on account of backing up, so I
went on pilot with oil can and gave en-
gine some oil through release valves and
lever was all right when I returned to
cab. Made the stop at switch to round-
house and worked steam to water tank
(about 1-8 mile from switch), spotted en-
gine, dropped reverse lever forward and
then pulled it up on center and left en-
gine with cylinder cocks open. Took
torch and looked engine over and ev-
erything looked in first-class fcondition.
Went with conductor to get orders to
return to train, and while we were wait-
ing for orders, hostler took engine to
give it some more fuel oil. Everything
went O. K. until hostler started to move
engine away from oil tank, when things
did not work just right with the result
that L go-ahead blade broke at first
bolt hole in eccentric strap. After the
blade broke hostler moved engine ahead
without disconnecting anything about
engineman that has run her since she
has been assigned to this division, the
reverse lever jerking and cutting up at
times all out of reason, sometimes when
drifting and again at others when work-
ing steam. Only three days after acci-
dent (had been two days on work train
after engine was repaired) I had to cut
loose from freight train going up hill
and let engine drift and give it a dose
of valve oil through release valves be-
fore I could hardly do anything with her
in regard to handling her share of train,
and even after that it was a continual
jerking for thirty miles up hill, but was
O. K. coming back. Had valves exam-
ined and nothing was found wrong; al-
though this was the first time engine
bucked on me going up hill and work-
ing steam. The previous time was when
after going down hill about 15 miles (in
passenger service and speed about 50
miles an hour), the reverse lever jumped
out of quadrant and went first back and
then ahead, even when engine was about
stopped it was as bad. I looked en-
gine over, top to bottom, and found
away from oil tank with hostler on my
engine that the trouble occurred.
This same eccentric got hot and
cooled oflf on its own account while en-
gine was running in passenger service
about ID days previous to accident and
did not cause any delay to train until
after eccentric had cooled off and then
got loose on shaft and allowed set
screws to work out before I discovered
it. The reason of it getting hot then
was on account of the oil not working
down to eccentric as it should have done
(had it repacked on arrival at terminal).
It being night time and rather chilly
weather, added to this a fast run in the
forenoon previous to this (which made
eccentric kind of dry), and starting out
with a speed of about 50 miles an hour,
the reason seems very plain after think-
ing a little. We made a regular stop
about 9 miles out and the fireman said
he thought he smelled something hot,
and I hurried around engine and felt
everything but eccentrics in the few sec-
onds we stopped there, but as I did not
smell anything hot myself I did not
14
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
worry and went over to next water tank
stop, but it was cold then. The reason
I have stated this all is so that you can
have a general idea of everything, and
still the question is, what broke the
blade? R. M. Watson.
[Our opinion is that one side of the
cylinder lubricator is not working prop-
erly. We should, however, like to have
the views of our readers who have ex-
perienced similar trouble with an en-
gine.]
Curious Heat Phenomenon on Fire-
Box Sheets.
Will you please explain to me why the
sheets in a fire box, exposed to the heat
become cool after the water reaches the
boiling point? I find from experiment-
ing that the sheets are hot until the
water begins to boil, then they become
cool and the higher the steam pressure
the cooler the sheets become. 1 can
take a coal scoop and place it inside the
fire door to shield my hand from the
fire and lay my hand on the sheet and it
is apparently perfectly cool. At the same
time, the stay bolt heads are hot. This
may be an old question, and I may be
on a cold trail. However, I have never
heard it explained. An early reply will
greatly oblige, W. B. Chenowith,
Care Cotton Belt Shops.
We never heard of this phenomenon
before, and cannot advance a theory to
account for it. We should like to hear
from other readers who have found the
sheets cold when steam was in the
boiler. — Ed.
Brake Beam with Natural Camber
Reversed.
The C. & N. W. Ry. make a wooden
brake beam in their shops at Chicago,
111., which has the satisfactory feature of
always keeping the nuts tight on the truss-
rod ends. The stick of thoroughly sea-
soned wood from which the beam is made
is sawed so that the resulting beam is
slightly curved, in fact it has a camber of
3-4 of an inch with the grain of the wood
in its natural position. This beam is
bored for brake heads, truss rods and ful-
crums, and when the truss rods are being
put in place, the beam is bent in an air-
operated press so that the 3-4-in. camber
is reversed. The side which is naturally
concave becomes convex. The fibers of
the beam are therefore always in strain,
and the tendency of the beam to right it-
self keeps the truss rod always in ten-
sion, with the result that neither shrink-
age nor wear can loosen the pressure on
the nuts on the truss rod ends, and every-
thing stays tight. The fulcrums which
in each case act as a strut between beam
and truss rod, are made so as to be used
for either right or left, as required.
Spotter Made a Histalce.
One of the oldest conductors in point
of service on the Big Four was greatly
surprised when he received notice to go
to Cincinnati and explain why he had
not turned in a cash fare. But he was
more surprised to learn that the report
was made against him by a spotter on a
certain date, and the explanation was
made tliat on that date, near the front
The Cape to Cairo Railway.
The railway between Buluwayo and
Salisbury, South Africa, via Gwelo, a
distance of 300 miles, was completed on
the 7th of October, 1902. There is,
therefore, now through rail communica-
tion between Capetown and Beira. The
completion of this new section will greatly
.facilitate the progress of the through
THE NEW WAY.
THE OLD WAY.
THE GALVANIZERS.
The jiien who strive to keep axle boxes running cool. The men ate not ornamental,
but they are very useful.
of a certain car. a woman had paid him
a cash fare, and his report did not show
this fare returned.
The incident was of so recent a date
that he remembered about it. The wo-
man had a ticket between the points
mentioned in the spotter's report. She
wished to buy some fruit from the
news agent on the train, and asked the
conductor to change a $10 bill for her.
This he did, and in doing so came under
the observation of the spotter. The con-
ductor got an affidavit from the woman,
stating the facts, and after 11 days' lay-
off, he was reinstated.
Cape to Cairo line, which was a project
dear to the heart of the late Cecil Rhodes.
It will now be possible to supply railway
material both from the Cape Colony and
Beira ports. The line is laid for a dis-
tance of 80 miles north of" Buluwayo in
the direction of Victoria Falls. It is
expected that the line will reach the
Waukie coal fields early in 1903. — Ex:
Let no man turn aside, ever so slight-
ly, from the broad path of honor, on
the plausible pretense that he is justified
by the goodness of ,his end. — Barnaby
Rudge.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVF. ENGINEERING
15
A War nonster.
The large gun recently made at the
Government shops at Watervlict was
intended to be transported by rail and a
special steel flat car was built by the
Baldwin Locomotive Works from de-
signs by Mr. Alfred Christiansen, the
master mechanic at the arsenal. The rail-
way companies over whose lines it
would have to travel declined to receive
it, probably because the concentration of
so great a load upon a wheel base some-
2 1-4 in. diameter at ihc trunion band.
The outside diameter of the muzzle is
28 inches. The projectile weighs 2,400
pounds, and will be fired with an initial
velocity of 2,300 ft. per second. The
weight of the brcecli mechanism is ap-
pro.Kiniatcly 4,400 pounds and the powder
charge is, roughly speaking, 600 pounds
of smokeless powder, or about 1,100
pounds of black powder, while the com-
puted maximum range is 21 miles. There
are 96 grooves in the rifling.
140-TON GUN ON .STEEI, FLAT C.\K.
earth's surface the pressure, amounting
as it docs to over 30 tons on the square
inch, would very nearly equal the pres-
sure produced on the inside of a 100-ton
gun when the charge of cordite has been
exploded to drive the missile forth."
If it were possible to apply a suitable
indicator and have the pencil draw a
pressure diagram as the shot goes spin-
ning down the rifled bore of the 140-ton
gun, we would probably find that the ex-
pansion curve would sink rapidly and
evenly away from the point of highest
pressure until the base of the projectile
passed out of the muzzle, wh(jn the pro-
pelling pressure would at once sink to
zero. The diminishing pressure in the
gun as the shot passes down the bore is
roughly indicated by its tapering form.
At the muzzle, although the powder-
gas does not exert any further pressure
upon the shot and is thus practically
wasted, the expansive force of the former
is by no means reduced to nothing. The
form assumed by the cloud of heated gas
as it is forcibly blown out, without do-
ing any useful work, proves the exist-
ence of an enormous pressure there,
tending to rip open the mouth of the
thing less than that of an ordinary flat
car would have put an undesirable strain
on their bridges, and in the event of de-
railment would have caused a most se-
rious blocking of traflic. The gun was
taken by water to Sandy Hook by the
Merritt & Chapman Wrecking Com-
pany.
The flat car which is now used for
moving the gun in the Government yards
presents some interesting features, which
we are able to give through the courtesy
of Captain O. C. Horney, U.S.A. It is
26 ft. 9 in. long and weighs 34.270 pounds.
It is made with lo-in. steel channels for
the side and end sills and with 10-in.
I-beams for the center and intermediate
sills. It is trussed with eight rods which
come down 18 in. below the sills. The
truck sides are steel plates flanged over
on top. A steel T, from each of the bev-
eled ends of the truck sides helps to stiff-
en the truck laterally. The axles are
6 1-4 in. in the center, the wheels seats
are 8 in. diameter and the journals 6 1-4 x
10 in. The wheels are 30 in. in diameter,
and the whole car is intended to run on 3.
curve of 150 ft. radius. The gun itself
weighs 285,000 pounds, and with weight
of car, the axle load comes in the neigh-
borhood of 79,000 pounds. There are
over each axle box two coil springs,
which, when the gun was in position,
were compressed to half the amount pro-
vided for. and were therefore effective.
The whole car is unique, and is. of
course, a special vehicle intended for a
special purpose.
Concerning the gun itseif, it is a i6-in.
breech-loading rifle, 49 ft. 3 in. long, 5 ft.
in diameter at its rear portion and S ft.
TESTING IMNCH KRIPP GUN AT MEPI'EX.
An idea of the enormous pressure
generated in the powder chamber of a
gun of this size may be had by quoting
a few words of Sir Robert Ball, the em-
inent English astronomer and mathema-
tician, when speaking of the pressures
exerted on the interior of earth's mass
by weight of the earth's crust. He says:
"The pressure due to the superincum-
bent weight of a mile of rock would be
more than three tons on the square inch.
At the depth of ten miles beneath the
gun. It pours from the muzzle in the
shape of a half sphere, somewhat re-
sembling the bowl of a port-wine glass
where it joins the stem. This interest-
ing cloud formation is admirably shown
in our illustration of the firing of a 12-in.
Krupp cannon on the proving grounds
at Meppen. in Germany, which is repro-
duced from Hantts'ccorth's Magaciite.
The hemispherical or port-wine glass
form of the smoke cloud as it issues
forth shows that the expansive force of
I6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
this gas, like all others in confined
space, was acting in all directions, just
as theory said it must act, though mod-
ified by its enforced flow through a long
hollow cylinder.
It also proves that the gas, due to the
ignition of powder, was very far from
fully expanded at the moment when the
"reeking tube and iron shard" parted
company. The rotating shot, in its long,
swift flight, leaves behind a huge, irreg-
ular, cotton-like pufif of heavy smoke,
while the gun backs against the recoil
mechanism. The explosive missile hav-
ing been urged to high velocity in the
gun by the powerfully expansive force
of the now harmlessly drifting cloud,
bursts in the open sea, 20 miles out from
land. It traverses this distance so swiftly
that the sound of the explosion which
drove it forth will be more than 45 sec-
onds later in passing over the waters
where the fragments of the shell have
sunk.
The Development of the Locomotive
Spark Arrester.
BY J. SNOVVDEN BELL.
So much has been said and written,
both historical and descriptive, relating
to spark arresters, that it is difficult to
avoid needless and tiresome repetition
in another presentation of this important
detail of locomotive construction. The
subject is fully and interestingly treated
by Professor W. F. M. Goss, of Purdue
University, in his recent work, "Loco-
motive Sparks," and as that publication,
together with the prior ones to which
it refers, will enable the reader to study
the spark arrester, both of the past and
of the present, as fully in detail as he
may desire, only the comparatively few
leading and characteristic features of its
development would seem to be of suffi-
cient general interest to be here consid-
ered.
The facts, correctly stated by Profes-
sor Goss in igo2, that "the production of
sparks constitutes one of the necessary
Liquid Air.
In a lecture recently delivered by Prof.
Cox to the students of McGill University
at Montreal, some interesting facts re-
garding the eflect of the low temper-
ature of liquid air upon elasticity of
substances were shown. The process
of making liquid air was something
as follows: A low and a high pres-
sure compressor are connected and set
working by a motor. Air entering the low
pressure compressor is compressed to 16
atmospheres. Under tho high pressure it
is further compressed to about 200 at-
mospheres, or over three thousand pounds
to the square inch. The gas is then dried
first by leading into a cylinder, where by
expansion it cools so as to drop most of
its moisture to the bottom, and then, by
leading through a cylinder of caustic pot-
ash, which, besides removing all remain-
ing moisture, also removes any traces of
carbon dioxide gas. The dried air is then
led into the liquefier, a small cylinder,
about seventeen inches high, in which are
four sets of brass coils, two of which run
down and two run up. The air goes down
the coils, which run downward, and by
sudden expansion at the bottom is cooled
to a low temperature and about five per
cent, of it is liquefied. The remaining gas
then passes up the other two coils, which
are so arranged as to cool the air coming
down and then back to the condensers
again. — Ex.
The people of Schenectady, N. Y., are
beginning to realize the prosperity con-
ferred upon a town by'large manufactur-
ing establishments. A statement was re-
cently made that the American Locomo-
tive Works and the General Electric
Works combined employ 14.800 men,
who receive in weekly wages $182,000,
which is a little over twelve dollars per
person.
1S31
M.W. Baldwin
FIG. 1.
manifestations attending the action of a
modern locomotive," and that "it is not
possible under any circumstances to en-
tirely suppress them," were doubtless
recognized by those who were pioneers
in locomotive building, as we find the
spark arrester, in its crudest form, al-
though embodying what seems to be
considered an essential of the latest
types, to have been applied as early as
1831, by the late M. W. Baldwin, of Phil-
adelphia, who may be fairly termed the
father of locomotive building in the
Unitel States. This, which was pre-
sumably the first appliance of the kind,
consisted of a convex sheet or basket
of wire netting, secured to and covering
the top of a plain cylindrical stack, which
was flared out at its upper end to allow
sufficient discharge area through the
meshes of the netting. An accurate
drawing of the first spark arrester is
not obtainable, but it is illustrated suffi-
ciently for present purposes in Fig. I,
which IS reproduced from a sheet of
drawings prepared by M. W. Baldwin &
Co., in the early sixties, for use in lit-
igation, which showed 57 different de-
signs which had been developed prior to
1858.
As a basis of record date, we may note
the first spark arrester patent ever is-
sued, which was but little later than the
original Baldwin appliance, being that
of James P. Espy, dated June 29, 1833.
As shown in Fig 2, it consisted of a cap
which was fitted to turn on the top of
the stack and was pointed or inclined on
its front side and kept to the wind by
a vane. The opening on the rear side of
the cap was covered by a sheet of fine
wire gauze. It was tested on the old
FIG. 2.
Philadelphia & Germantown Railroad,
now a part of the Reading system, and
also on the steamboat "Convoy," of the
Lehigh Coal and Navigation Company,
and highly commendatory certificates of
its merits were given, but it does not
seem to have made any further record
or to have been continued in service.
Starting with the original Baldwin
spark arrester of 1831, as a basis, the
numerous proposed designs, as well as
those actually put into use, have been
worked out on two general lines; first,
appliances located in the stack, and sec-
ond, those located in the smoke box and
used with an open stack. Of the multi-
tude of these, of both classes, that have
been produced, but few are worth exam-
ination, fewer still have gone into ser-
vice at all, and scarcely any now survive
except the diamond stack and the va-
rious detailed forms of smoke-box de-
flector and netting.
The development of the 1831, or what
we may call the "stack" type of spark
arrester, may be briefly traced, as it em-
bodies only two steps of improvement
which remain to any substantial extent in
present practice; first, the addition of the
January, 1903.
RAILWAY ANIJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
17
ciutral dcllccliiig coiic, and, sfcuml, tin:
change of the casing to the "diamond"
form. The deflecting cone is claimed to
have been designed and used by Isaac
Dripps on the Camden & Amboy Rail-
road in 1833, and is shown in a drawing
presented by him at the 1884 convention
of the American Master Mechanics' Con-
vention (Proceedings p. 41, Plate No.
28 A). This construction, which is rep-
resented on a larger scale in Fig. 3, is
marked on the plate referred to: "This
Spark Arrester was designed, built and
used in June, 1833. Designed by Isaac
Dripps," and the correctness of the date
does not appear to have been ques-
tioned. It will be observed that this de-
sign embodies all the elements of the so-
called "balloon" or "bonnet" stack,
which, at a much later date and for a
considerable period, was generally and
almost universally in use on American
railroads.
The second stage of development and
latest form of spark arrester of this type,
which still continues in service to a con-
siderable extent, is the well-known dia-
readers to know that diamond stacks
without any netting whatever have been,
and probably still are, successfully em-
mond slack, one of the latest applica-
tions of which is shown in Fig. 4, and
which is so familiar that description is
unnecessary. Without entering upon a
discussion of its merits, it may be noted
that it was sufficiently "modern" in 1901
to have been put on large compound
prairie type engines of a C, B. & Q.
R. R. standard pattern (B. & M. R. R.).
as is shown by an illustration furnished
by the builders to the New York Rail-
road Club and appearing on page 50 of
the Proceedings of November, 1901.
It will doubtless be a surprise to some
J. .SNOVVDEN BEI.L.
Engineer and 1'atent Attorney.
[iloyed in regular service on the Mexican
Central Railroad.
The second line of spark arrester de-
sign which has been previously indicated,
i. e., appliances located in the smoke box
and used with an open stack, will now
be briefly considered, and in view of its
indorsement and general adoption in the
most approved recent practice, it would
seem that its originator, who. in the lapse
FIG. 4.
art and the measure of credit to which
he is entitled. So far as record evidence
is available, the "smoke-box" spark ar-
rester was first proposed by J. Mcllvaine,
"i Philadelphia, in 18.33, in an article
contributed by him to the journal of the
IVanklin Institute, Vol. XII, N. S., 1833,
liages 74-77. The wood cut illustration
"i Mcllvaine's design which is there
Kiven is reproduced in Fig. 5, and, after
slating objections to a wire net at the
base of the chimney or a wire basket on
the top of the chimney (1831 pattern),
he thus describes it:
"These objections will. I flatter myself,
be effectually obviated by placing a
screen of wire in the smoke chamber, as
seen in the accompanying figure; the
diagonal position allows a net of ten
times the area of the flues, while almost
all the vapor will come in contact with
it nearly at right angles; if we allow one-
half for retardation, we still require but
one-fifth the velocity of the draught
through the flues, and one-sixth of that
in the chimney, a retardation which
seems to be amply sufficient to allow the
burning coals to fall; if, however, these
are retained on the wires, not having the
steam and condensed water thrown upon
them, they will be consumed."
Mcllvaine never patented his design
and does not appear to have put it into
service, but, as will be readily seen, it is
the basis upon which all spark arresters
of this type have been worked out. and
shows an intelligent appreciation of oper-
of time, has apparently been completely
forgotten, should be recognized and
awarded the place in the history of the
ative conditions existing when he wrote
as they do now.
While Mcllvaine's design provides, in
some measure, the deflecting plate which
appears, in one form or another, in al-
most all the present constructions of this
general type, he did not apparently con-
template its use in this regard, and. con-
sidering his new feature to have been
merely a smoke-box netting, the second
and final stage of development of ruling
features of the type was apparently
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
reached by Isaac Dripps, who, as appears,
from the 18S4 Proceedings of the Master
Mechanics' Association, designed an in-
clined deflecting plate located in front
of the tube sheet, in 1849. Fig. 6, which
is reproduced on a larger scale from
Plate No. 28E of the Proceedings, shows
the Dripps design, which bears the fol-
lowing notation: "Arrangement of De-
flecting Plates in front end of Boilers for
Burning Anthracite Coal, C. & A. R. R.
Designed by Isaac Dripps in 1849." Both
the deflecting plates are marked "Per-
forated."
The differences between the various
forms of smoke-box spark arresters now
in service are practically only in detail,
and all of them are more or less per-
fected embodiments of the rudimentary
Mcllvaine and Dripps designs. It would
/
[
0
X
\
1)
) 1
duced to the smallest possible extent,"
he says:
"A plan which I proposed some time
since for the relief of the draft of en-
gines on a line having low bridges, which
plan I have lately learned was tried with
good results some time since on the Co-
lumbia road [now part of the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad], but for some reason was
not continued in use, was to place a level
sheet of iron across the smoke box just
above the upper row of tubes. This
would reduce the contents of the smoke
box and consequently the amount of air
to be lifted out. It would allow of ex-
tending the chimney downward, and of
thereby increasing the effective length
and also of lowering the blast pipes and
Sailway ^ Locumut ive Enffi'iaenng
FIG. 6.
tioned and disposed as to reduce the
length and volume of the smoke box to,
or nearly to, the minimum, and to make
the front a selt-cleaning one, the useless
cinder hopper being therefore dispensed
with. The fallacy of the claim made by
the advocates of the extension front that
it acts as a spark retainer has been so
generally recognized, and the dwindling
down of its proportions in recent ap-
proved practice is so marked, that a dis-
cussion here of its unmechanical theory
and practical objections would needless-
ly consume space. The Lake Shore de-
sign evidences that all the netting area
that is necessary can be located in a
smoke box whose front is only 28 in.
from the center of the exhaust pipe, and
it will be readily seen that it could be
made even shorter if desired.
The Muhlfeld design is also a self-
cleaning front, and, except as to the sub-
stantially horizontal plate which cuts off
the upper portion of the smoke box from
FIG. 8.
probably be neither useful nor interest-
ing, even if space permitted, to present
many examples, and the two following
instances, both of quite recent practice,
which have been selected as being fairly
representative, and worked out on sound
theory and correct application, will suf-
fice to enable an intelligent conclusion
to be arrived at as to the principles 01
construction which seem best fitted to
answer the present conditions of rail-
road service.
The first of these, illustrated in Fig. 7,
is the design of Mr. J. E. Muhlfeld, re-
cently of the Intercolonial Railway, of
Canada, on which road it is stated to
have been applied with excellent results
to 25 engines. While it was doubtless
original with Mr. Muhlfeld, its merit
will not be at all diminished by the fact
that it is essentially a reproduction of a
plan proposed by Zerah Colburn in 1854.
In an article published by Colburn in
that year, after correctly slating that the
volume of the smoke box should be "re-
substituting blast pressure for blast suc-
tion. I look to this plan as one likely
to become generally applied."
An English-built locomotive having its
smoke-box reduced in dimensions, as
proposed by Colburn, is shown in Plare
XLIII of "Recent Practice in the Loco-
motive Engine," London, i860, and the
successful performance of Mr. Muhl-
feld's design encourages the hope thit
Colburn's prophetic view may, after the
lapse of nearly 50 years, be realized.
The latest, and in the judgment of the
writer, probably the most perfect and
practical development of the smoke-box
type of spark arrester that has been put
into railroad service, is that shown in
Fig. 8, which is used in wide firebox
switch engines recently built by the
American Locomotive Company's
Brooks Works for the Lake Shore &
Michigan Southern Railway.
The appliance is, in this design,
brought to its lowest terms— the deflector
and netting— and these are so proper-
the draft, it accords with the Lake Shore
construction in using only the deflector
and netting. It would, however, seem
that the desirable result of reducing
smoke-box volume could have been
more fully attained by shortening the
front about 10 mches and running the
netting on an incline from the bottom of
the deflector to the upper division plate.
Such a modification, which would retain
all the useful features of the design and
affords ample netting area, would, if used
with a correctly proportioned taper or
choke stack, appear to embody all the
elements which go to make up a practi-
cal and successful front end.
Personal preferences and prejudices,
and, to some extent, the character of
fuel and service, operate to prevent any
organized effort toward the adoption of
a substantially standard spark arresting
locomotive front end, but there is no
good reason why conflicting views can-
not be measurably harmonized and the
principal difficulties in the way of prog-
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
«9
rcss in this direction be removed. Mr.
William Forsyth, who will be recognized
as good authority, very aptly said, in
1899, that "the only remedy for the difii-
culties that we have been trying to over-
come with draft appliances is to enlarge
the grate area," and as the best and al-
most the universal practice since that
date has adopted the wide firebox, the
problem is now of correspondingly
easier solution.
In the present stage of development of
the locomotive spark arrester, and in
the light of generally expressed experi-
ence, the best results can, in the writer's
opinion, be attained upon the following
lines:
Under certain conditions, the diamond
stack will be found most desirable, and,
in some cases, may be indispensable.
For general service a spark arresting
appliance located in the smoke box and
used with an open stack will be found
best adapted to present conditions and
Fast Passenger Engine for the
Vandalia Line.
The Vandalia Line have recently pur-
chased four fast passenger engines from
the American Locomotive Company,
which were built at the Schenectady
shops. As will be seen by our illustra-
tion the engines are of the 4-4-2 type,
simple, with 20 1-2 x 26-in. cylinders, and
driving wheels 78 ins. in diameter. The
total weight is 164,500 lbs., of which 91,-
500 lbs. rest upon the drivers. The ma-
chine is capable of exerting a pull of
about 23,800 lbs., and the ratio of adhe-
sive weight to tractive power is 3.84.
The slide valves are American balance
and are actuated by an extension rod
passing over the forward driving axle,
and the motion is direct. The rocker is
placed in front of the yoke and makes
therefore what may be called a cross-
head connection with the valve rod.
The driving wheel tires, as is usual
with wheels of large diameter, are held
I.c.'id of valves 111 full Ktar. line an-1 line, full for
ward motion, % in. lead at 6 in. cut ofT.
wHKF,i.s. x'.rc.
Dia. of driving wheels outhidc of tire, 7Hin.
Hng. truck, 4 wheel Hwini{ Ixjlstcr, with 3 pt. hgr.
Dia. of engine truck wheels, .V> in.
BOII.KR.
Outside dia. of first rinR, <is in. Work. pros. 200 lb«.
Thickness of plates in barrel and outside firebox,
U. 'A. 'A an'l ' "••
Horizontal seams, butt joint sextuple riveted with
welt strips inside and outside.
Circumferential scams, double riveted*
KIKEBOX.
I.tih., 102 in.; wdh.,65H Jn.; dph.. 75^ in, F.66in. B.
Plates, thickness, sides, /« in.; back, yk in.; crown,
Jh ill.; tube sheet, J4 in. Stay bolts, i in. dia.
Tubes, material, charcoal iron No 11; number of.
33S: dia., 2 in.; length over tube sheets, 16 ft.
Heating surface, tubes, 2,816.87 sq. ft.; firebox,
169.8 sq. ft.; total, 2.986.67; grate area, 46.36 sq. ft.
Smoke stack, inside dia., 16 in.; bottom, 17 in. top;
top above all, 15 ft.
Tender, weight, empty, 55,000 lbs., wheel tiase, 21
ft. ',2 in.; tender frame, 10 in. steel channels.
Total wheel base tii eng. and tend., 58 ft. 5>i in.
Brake, Westiughouse, American on all drivers and
trailer operated by air, with high speed brake
attachment. W. A. A. B. for tender and for
FAST PASSENGER, ATI,A.\TIC TYPE ENGINE FOR THE VANDALIA LINE.
presents the most available basis for a
standard front-end design.
The essential features of such design
should be (o), that the smoke box be
of the minimum volume which vrill con-
tain the spark arrester and draft ap-
pliances, and should, therefore, be as
short as possible; (b), that it should be
of the "self-cleaning" type, with appli-
ances adapted to disintegrate the reduced
quantity of cinders which pass out of a
wide firebo.x; and discharge them with-
out liability to set out fires; (c), that a
deflecting plate, single sheet of netting,
and (perhaps) a petticoat pipe are the
only necessary elements of the spark ar-
rester, and (d), that the plan of parti-
tion between the upper and lower por-
tions of the smoke box and inwardly ex-
tended stack, as proposed by Colburn
and revived by Muhlfeld. appears to be
of such substantial advantage as to rec-
ommend its adoption, or, at least, its
careful and thorough consideration, in
the preparation of a front-end design
■which will satisfactorily meet the require-
ments of railroad service under the ex-
acting conditions of its present opera-
tion.
on the wheel centers by shrinkage, and
as an e.xtra precaution, by retaining
rings. The engine frames are cross-
braced by a fiat bar which is held in
place by the pedestal binder bolt at the
back of each of the main pedestals.
The arrangements in the cab have been
made with an eye to the convenience and
comfort of the enginemen, and among
other things the injectors have been
placed on the boiler head, the delivery
pipes running through, inside the boiler,
to the front, with downwardly pointing
openings. The boiler is of the radial
stayed straight-top type, with wide fire-
box. The heating surface is ample, be-
ing in all 2,986;^ sq. ft., of which about
2,816 ft. are in the tubes.
The tank is made with a water bot-
tom, and the fuel space is of the gravity
hopper type. The coal capacity is about
12 tons, and the water carried amounts
to 7,000 gallons.
Some of the principal dimensions are
subjoined for reference:
Cylinders, x}i x 26 in.
V.\LVES.
Greatest travel'of slide valves, 6 in.
Outside lap, i^g in.; inside, line and line.
train. 2 main reservoirs 16 x 84 in. 954 in.
LH. air pump.
Engine equippe ' with trailing truck back of main
drivers, with 48 in. wheels, journals 7J^ in. dia.
and 12 in. Ig., with outside bearings.
Locomotive Trying Superheated Steam.
The officials of the Prussian State rail-
ways have been experimenting with an
apparatus for superheating steam with
rather unfortunate results. Near Berlin
the engine had to slow down before a
station, when from some cause the fire-
door sprung open as if by an explosion
within, and a sheet of flame issued which
enveloped the whole footboard.
It struck first the fireman and set his
clothes on fire, and he was fatally burned ;
Cordes, head inspector of the Grunewald
shops, jumped and had his right hand
crushed by a passing freight train, so that
it was necessary to amputate his forearm.
Garbe, a member of the Berlin State
Railroad Directory, had one side of his
face burned, but was not seriously in-
jured.
A seasonable study at this season is
our Book of Books. Sent free on appli-
ca'.ion.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
Lo%UEgneerii$
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York,
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "l/oceug," N. Y.
Glasgow, "I^ocauto."
Business Department :
ANGUS SINCI<AIR, President.
FRED M. NEI<I.IS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department :
ANGUS SINCI,AIR, Editor.
F. M. NEI<I<IS, 1
GEO. S. HODGINS, Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department :
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Snmmer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
I204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative :
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBIylSHING
CO., Ltd. 102a Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, London.
Glasgow Representative :
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
S2.ooper year, $1.00 for six months, postage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of tite world, $2.50, or ten shillings.
Single copies, 20 cents. Remit by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Registered
Letter.
Mailing address can be changed as of ten as neces-
sary—always give old ajid tietv address, and if you
subscribed in a club state who got it up.
Please give frotnpt notice when your paper fails
t9 reach you properly.
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., iqo2.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
The Frlctional Limit.
Tractive effort, or tractive power, or
in plainer words, draw-bar pull, may be
calculated for a simple engine by squar-
ing the diameter in inches, of the cylin-
der, and multiplying that quantity by
the stroke, also measured in inches, and
again multiplying this product by the
mean effective pressure in the cylinders
given in pounds, and dividing the whole
by the diameter of the driving wheels,
expressed in inches. After working out
this problem for any particular engine,
we get what school boys call the "an-
swer." This answer is theoretically the
number of pounds which the engine in
question could pull up out of a well, if
a frictionless cable and pulley were prop-
erly arranged behind the tender. That
weight, whatever it is, represents all the
engine can do, at a slow speed, on a
good rail, and without slipping.
Suppose that the engine, having drawn
a certain weight slowly up out of a deep
well was to stand with brakes set
while some slight addition was made to
the weight. Obviously, the weight which
came up represented the engine's maxi-
mum effort, and therefore any addition
to it would cause the whole mass to
descend, and the engine would be slowly
slid backward when brakes were re-
leased as the weight went down.
If, however, steam was used against
this backing-up motion caused by
the weight, the wheels would slip, and
though there might be a slight re-
duction of the speed, the engine would
nevertheless continue to go back with
slipping, or even with locked drivers,
just as a child might drag a toy engine
along the floor, with wheels and axles
bent so as to prevent their rotation. The
utmost resistance which the locomotive
could offer, in this tug-of-war, without
using its tender brake, is the friction of
its locked driving wheels on the rails.
Trautwine's engineer's pocket book
gives the co-eificient of friction for steel
on steel as 0.14. The co-efficient ot fric-
tion is the fraction expressing what pro-
portion of the weight of a moving body
is required to slide it along. A steel
block weighing 1,000 pounds would
therefore require 140 pounds horizontal
pull to slide it along a smooth, clean
steel floor. Now. although locomotive
tires standing on railway rails is a case
of steel on steel, yet Trautwine's figure
would be far too low for use in the ex-
ample before us. Traiutwine's co-ef-
ficient was deduced from experiments,
made in a laboratory, surrounded by
ideal conditions, such as absolutely
smooth and perfectly clean surfaces in
contact, and not a trace of lubricant
anywhere. In everyday life out of doors
on railway track, as we know it, the
conditions are anything but ideal, and
the co-efficient of friction usually taken
for steel tires on steel rails is 0.2. This
is higher than Trautwine's figure for
smooth, flat surfaces, possibly because
the wheels being convex and standing on
flat rails tend to bring the molecules of
steel in each, into somewhat closer con-
tact, even though the surfaces may be
slightly lubricated by grease or mois-
ture, while the presence of dust or grit
always assists the wheels to hold and the
surfaces are never quite smooth. Our
steel block of 1,000 pounds would re-
quire, with 0.2 as the co-efficient of fric-
tion, not 140 pounds to slide it, but 200
pounds under ordinary railroad condi-
tions.
Applying this to our slowly-backing
engine, we see that if it had 100,000
pounds on the drivers, then anything
over 20,000 pounds in the well, would pull
the engine back, and it would do this
without reference to what the tractive
power might be as calculated by the
formula given in the opening paragraph
of this article. The aim of designers is
to have the tractive power of the engine
worked out as close as is necessary to this
limit of friction between wheels and rails.
If the engine is so built that the tractive
power is considerably above this limit,
the engine will be "slippery." To push
the illustration to an extreme case, an
engine as light as a hand-car, with cal-
culated tractive power equal to that
usually possessed by a I7x24-in. cylinder
engine, would only be able to use an
amount of tractive power equal to its
adhesion. If, however, the tractive ef-
fort is much below the friction limit, the
engine could not develop its full power.
The co-efficient of friction between
wheels and rails being taken at 0.2; then,
theoretically, as far as friction is con-
cerned, an engine is supposed to be able
to pull about one-fifth of the weight on
its drivers, or at least this is the limit
which designers keep in view. It is
clear that if the weight on drivers be
divided by the tractive effort, the result
will be some whole number, and this
number is called the ratio of adhesive
weight to tractive power. If the weight
on drivers is 100,000 pounds, and the
tractive effort is 20,000 pounds, then the
ratio of adhesive weight to tractive
power is 5, and when this result is tested
as regards the frictional limit, we find
that the reciprocal fraction 1-5, or 0.2,
expresses the ability of the engine to ex-
ert a pull equal to one-fifth of the weight
carried on the drivers.
As a matter of fact, passenger engines
are often designed so as not to come
exactly to this frictional limit. Good
practice allows the ratio of adhesive
weight to tractive power to be 4. and per-
mits 4.5 for freight service. This arises
from the fact that a passenger engine is
not expected to work up to her theoret-
ical limit, when cutting off short at reg-
ular speed, and the chances of slipping
are, to a certain extent, disregarded. A
freight engine in service approaches
nearer to the limit owing to the aver-
age cut off being later and less chance of
sjpping is taken, while good practice
places a yard engine as nearly as possi-
ble at the limit, i. c, 5, so that the chance
of slipping is reduced to a minimum. The
designer has always two objects in view
— not to seriously over-cylinder the en-
gine, nor to let the adhesive weight pre-
dominate so as to make the engine work
below her legitimate capacity. These are
the two dangers which he wishes to es-
cape. It is sometimes difficult steering,
for in successfully avoiding the rock
Scylla, he runs the chance of being swal-
lowed up in the whirlpool of Charybdis.
Halsey on the Metric System.
People who are on the aggressive in
every fight generally have an advantage
over those who are on the defensive.
This has been very well illustrated by
the vigorous assault long carried on by
theorists and visionaries in favor of the
adoption of the metric system of weights
and measures. These people are making
headway over those who are intereste.i
in letting well enough alone, and there
appears to be no misrepresentation or
subterfuge they will refrain from stoop-
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
ing to in pushing their hobby while
the people whose interests are against a
change, seldom do anything to demon-
strate the weakness, shortcomings or
falseness of their opponents' positions.
The American Society of Mechanical
Engineers have generally been sound in
opposing the compulsory use of the
metric system, but the school theorists
have been forcing their views to the
front recently, and last spring they got
a resolution passed by the society con-
demning the action of a committee
which went to Washington and opposed
the compulsory introduction of the
metric system. At the last meeting oi
the society Mr. Fred- H. Halsey, assist-
ant editor of the American Machinist, read
a paper on the metric system, in which
he told very salutory truths about tlio
misrepresentations and falsehoods in-
dulged in by the advocates of the metric
system. If the manufacturers and others
whose interests will be infringed and
whose business will be imposed upon by
being compelled to adopt the metric sys-
tem, will read Mr. Halsey's paper, we
feel assured that they will be stirred into
active resistance to the proposed change.
In his introduction to the subject Mr.
Halsey says: "The pro metric argu-
ment is substantially an a priori argu-
ment. The metric advocate adopts the
methods of the old philosophers who
laboriously sought to prove what ought
to be. The method is that of modern
science which interrogates nature in or-
der to find out what is. For instance,
they tell us how easily and how quickly
this nation ought to make this change;
I shall show how slowly and laboriously
France and Germany have made the
change. They will say that we ought to
adopt this system to please our foreign
customers; I shall show that our foreign
customers do not care one picayune
whether we adopt it or not, and I shall
prove it by a flood of evidence.
"The evidence is plainly given, and
cannot fail to be convincing to minds
open to conviction."
The society's summary of Mr. Hal-
sey's paper reads:
"The actual use of the metric system
in countries where it has been adopted
is discussed and the confusion of units
is shown to have been increased rather
than diminished. Particular reference 'S
made to the textile industries in France
and Germany, where the old units of the
native systems and the units of the Eng-
lish system are more commonly used
than the metric units. It is argued that
the adoption of the metric system means
the abandonment of mechanical stand-
ards now existing, if the metric system
is to replace the English system in ma-
chine practice. The advantages claimed
for the metric system are called in ques-
tion, and particularly the advantage in
making calculations is discussed. It is
shown that in the machinery for export
to countries now using the metric system
the only dimensions which have been
changed are the pitch of screws, such as
traversing and elevating screws for mill-
ing machines, and lead screws for lathes.
It is claimed that the machine building
industry and particularly the machine
tool industry are the foundation of rrjd-
ern industrial life, and that these will
be seriously affected by any change
which involves the abandonment of pres-
ent mechanical standards. Very full
data and illustrations are presented in
support of the arguments."
The Qrand Trunk Pacific.
The Grand Trunk Railway of Canada
is now definitely in the field with a
transcontinental project which has been
received with great favor by the people
of the Dominion. The press comments
over the border on the undertaking are,
however, various and interesting, and
with few exceptions the government
policy in the matter is expected to be
that of reasonable aid, rather than of
extravagant or over-generous assistance.
A map published by the Montreal Star
shows the route of the proposed line
from Toronto to North Bay (already in
existence), thence the road will run
about 100 miles to the north of Winni-
peg, with a branch to that city, and from
the junction point on to the Rockies it
will average from 100 to 200 miles to the
north of the international boundary. It
will probably pass through Edmonton,
and will reach the tide water of the Pa-
cific at Port Simpson or Bute Inlet, or
perhaps at both these points. In fact,
in a general way it appears to be the in-
tention to follow the survey made by
Sir Sandford Flemming in 1872, for the
Canadian Pacific, which route was after-
wards abandoned for a more southerly
location. In this connection it is inter-
esting to read in the Canadian press that
the riches and variety of resources in
the Canadian West had to be proved be-
fore this "Doubting Thomas" of trans-
portation companies would make any
move. Some papers have dilligently
dug up ancient history and refer to the
fact that when the Canadian Pacific
project was started the Grand Trunk
fought it in Canada and in Great Brit-
ain, and sought to depreciate the coun-
try's credit because of its financial sup-
port of the enterprise. It is humorously
pointed out that the Grand Trunk people
are now prepared to build a second road
through a country in which they pro-
fessed to believe it madness to build
even one. But the construction of the
Grand Trunk Pacific, we are also told,
will not be the task of pure faith and
pioneer difficulty which the building of
the C. P. R. was. It was predicted by
a politician of early days that that line
would never even pay for axle grease.
now the valley of the Saskatchewan is
said to have scarcely as yet been trav-
ersed by the white man, and its illimit-
able possibilities arc only beginning to
be grasped.
The Canadian Pacific was undertaken
partly as a national work, for the pur-
pose of developing the country and of
binding together the provinces of the
Dominion. The ultimate completion of
that railway was one of the conditions
imposed by British Columbia before
joining the federation. The Grand
Trunk, however, will build their line as
a private corporation for profit. That
such profit might reasonably be expect-
ed, may be judged from the recent public
utterance of the Hon. A. G. Blair, the
Canadian Minister of Railways and
Canals, when on his return from the
Northwest he said that four lines of
railway, instead of one, are actually
needed to move the present crop from
Canada's wheat lands.
There seems to be satisfaction felt
that the new line will not be managed
from London, but that the majority of
directors on the board will be Cana-
dians, and that a large part of the capi-
tal required for the work will be obtained
in Canada. The road now being built
in the Northwest, the Canadian North-
ern, is believed by some to be destined
to be absorbed by the Grand Trunk, but
at present, that is, as Lord Dundreary
said, "one of those things no fellow can
find out." At any rate, notwithstanding
the hunt for ancient history and the
twitting of railway magnates with the
attitude of their predecessors, the ex-
tension of the Grand Trunk system to
the Pacific Coast, appears to be a sub-
stantial project which will be pushed
through with the characteristic energy
of our northern neighbors to a success-
ful completion within the next few
years.
Surveying Instruments Used in /lachine
Shop.
People familiar only with the compar-
atively small pieces handled in railway
shops will be surprised to learn about ar-
ticles to be machined being so large that
a surveying instrument was employed
to adjust the work and the machines. An
operation of that kind was described by
C. C. Tyler in a paper presented at the
last meeting of the American Society of
Mechanical Engineers. The society's
summarj' of the paper says:
"The author describes the use of a sur-
veying instrument for laying out work
where the dimensions are so great as to
demand the use of portable machine
tools secured to a large floor surface
plate, the tools being moved rather than
the parts which are being machined. The
survej'ing instrument is of special con-
truction for dividing and leveling, ar-
ranged to be mounted on a center coi-
umn. The application of this method to
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
the machining of a cast-iron ring over 20
ft. outside diameter and made up of six
sections, is described in detail and illus-
trated by photographs of the actual op-
erations. The floor plate used is 48 ft.
wide by 176 ft. long, consisting of 132
sections, each 8 ft. square, keyed and
bolted together. The whole plate is
grouted in place upon brick piers, these
resting in turn upon a bed of concrete,
3 ft. 6 in. in thickness. Chips fall through
into tunnels underneath the floor plate
and are cleaned out through trap doors.
The surveying instrument was used for
setting up portable tools and getting
them exactly in line, and for proving the
accuracy of the finished work on the
cast-iron ring. The special dividing and
leveling instrument is described and illus-
trations shown."
Per Diem and Demurrage.
The per diem method of paying for
freight cars was put into operation for
the purpose of hastening the loading,
forwarding and release of cars, and when
released, the return of foreign cars to
owners. Such in eflect, was Mr. Casey's
definition of the system, given in a paper
recently read before the New York Rail-
road Club. These results are, of course,
brought about through the operation of
the system, but there are other incidental
advantages which greatly enhance the
usefulness of this new departure in rail-
road operation. The money value of the
prompt handling of car equipment h.as
been almost reduced to the clear out-
lines of what Mr. James Skeevers would
call an "object lesson," and the teachings
of the lesson, in a greater or less de-
gree, have reached all departments with
correspondingly good results. The sys-
tem has brought into intimate business
relations, officers who may previously
have had only a nodding acquaintance.
In this way it has developed co-opera-
tion, to the great advantage of the road
so served. In addition to being abso-
lutely honest, this method tends to re-
duce the amount paid out for car rental,
considerably below that which would
have been expended under the mileage
system.
In the five months ending November
30, 1902, the Lackawanna Railroad had
2,775 cars of their own equipment at
home, beyond the number for the cor-
responding period in the previous year,
or equal to a daily average increase of
nearly 15 per cent., and from July to
October, though that road had 16 1-4 per
cent, less cars out on foreign lines, the
earnings were only 7 per cent, less under
per diem.
These figures speak volumes. The in-
crease of cars at home was like money
found in the street, during the rush sea-
son, as it had not been experienced be-
fore. The reduction of the number of
cars abroad was highly satisfactory, be-
cause if 100 cars had earned $100 under
the mileage system of payment, the new
regime enabled 84 cars to earn about
$93. The benefits here shown as due to
per diem afi'ecting borrower and lender
alike, remind one of monetary value of
a general election, as estimated by an
amusing character in one of Hoyt's plays,
Mr. Boyle D'Owl, to wit: who said that
when properly conducted, there should
be "something in it for everybody."
Following closely on the per diem pay-
ment is the demurrage charge; in fact,
they may both be likened to branches on
the same tree — they grow out of the
same idea. The object is to secure the
early release of cars, and the demurrage
charge stimulates the activity of con-
signees, just as per diein is having a
tonic effect on car movement among
railways. Those who oppose the de-
murrage charge at a time when the re-
sults already obtained by per diem are
so unmistakably clear that "he who
runs may read," have certainly chosen
an inopportune time for objection. They
may, indeed, be relegated to the ranks
of the men who still pursue with unflag-
ging zeal, the perpetual motion falacy,
or they may find a place among those
who would still persuade us that the
earth is flat. These "perpetual motioners
and flat-earth men," as the late Prof.
Huxley called them, along with the "de-
murrage-demurrers" fail to observe most
obvious facts, or to discern the signs of
the times. Economic conditions to-day in
the car service world are such that un-
productive equipment is actually very
much in the way, and the per diem prin-
cipal which really includes the demur-
rage idea, has been sought as a most
welcome relief.
Railroad Trains that Waste Revenue.
A railroad president, who once was a
prominent figure in the United States,
followed the policy of pushing the freight
trains over the system he managed in
preference to passenger trains. A vig-
orous protest having been made against
this policy, he justified himself on the
grounds that he favored the trafSc that
brought revenue to the company. The
sentiments of that railroad man were
very unpopular ten years ago, but they
indicated sound business views. Another
prominent railroad president has lately
surprised people by assuming a similar
attitude concerning passenger business.
President Loree, of the Baltimore &
Ohio, referring to the erection of the
proposed new passenger station of that
road in Washington, said: "In my opin-
ion the passenger business is the dress
parade part of the railroad business. We
build fine coaches and throw them
away for finer coaches; we erect mam-
moth sations and tear them down to
erect larger stations. Every business has
its display features and this is ours. I do
not believe the passenger department
of any railroad is self-supporting. More
money is spent in these luxuries than is
ever received in fares. The passenger
business does not pay and never did.
Every substantial enterprise has its frills
and decorations, and the passenger busi-
ness forms ours. I will do all I can to
promote the erection of the station, for
these things are necessary to show what
a great railroad is, and how great it is."
That is a very sensible view, boldly ex-
pressed. The passenger department is
the old man of the sea to many railroad
companies, and wastes not a small part
of the income earned by freight busi-
ness. The sleeping car companies long
ago set the pace of luxurious cars, and
every years sees the ingenuity of design-
ers racked to add something more ex-
pensive than anything produced before,
and many railroad companies weakly fol-
low that lead. This tendency of sleeping
car and railroad companies to reckless-
ness in providing luxurious trains has
spoiled the traveling public, and encour-
aged them to demand unreasonable ac-
commodation for which they will not
pay. For years we have been hearing
demands for faster trains. To meet this
demand the limited expresses between
New York and Chicago were accelerated
from 24 to 20 hours, and it is found that
the service does not pay expenses. It
was expected that the conveniences re-
sulting from the higher speed would
greatly increase the travel by these
trains, but this hope has not been real-
ized. Fortunate is the railroad company
that does not indulge in the luxury of
"flyers," "cannon balls" and other trains
of that ilk to eat up the hard-earned
freight revenues.
Discipline That Hurts.
Railroad officials as a rule wish to
treat their men fairly, but a great deal of
injustice is inflicted on account of rules
of discipline framed to inflict punishment
for offences and delinquencies, without
providing credit for efficient service and
good behavior. If there is to be a debit
account maintained against a man, there
certainly ought in justice be a credit
account as well. The Brown system of
"discipline without suspension," has been
adopted by many roads in a modified
form, and in some quarters it is much
more unpopular than the old style of
punishment, when a man was suspended
for any serious violation of rules with
the understanding that the punishment
condoned the offence.
The system as worked under Mr.
Brown was eminently a just way to man-
age men, as the credits were always liable
to overbalance the debits; but the people
who modified the system have as a rule
modified out nearly all the credits. There
was a time when a petty officer would
go through a division like a roaring lion,
discharging men right and left for of-
fences that were due to his own incap-
ability. The Brown system cuts the teeth
January, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
23
of thi^ kind of tyrant, but it is only half
acting when it permits him to put a debit
against a man without providing a sys-
tem of credits. Where this is done, it is
only a matter of time when suflficient
debits will be recorded against first-class
men to have them discharged. A half
acting system of this kind has depleted
some roads of their best men, many of
them having resigned before their
time was due for discharge. On such
roads the men look back longingly to
the "good old days" when a superinten-
den suffering from a toothache would
discipline with his tongue every man
who came within reach of his voice, and
there the end of the castigation would
be. It is easier to stand a little unjust
abuse than to feel day after day that a
silent record is being built up against
you from trillcs that will soon bring
ignominious discharge.
in this country is something enormous,
about 100,000,000 being used every year
to replace old ties and for new trackage.
Scarcity of Ties.
It was expected that steel as material
for railroad ties would come largely into
use, as the scarcity of wooden ties in-
creased, but no entirely satisfactory steel
tie has been devised, and so railroad com-
panies are compelled to do their best with
wooden ties.
The large amount of new trackage built
in Northern Minnesota this season is said
to have pretty well drained the tie mar-
ket and the railway companies are re-
porting a scarcity. The tie output of last
year was smaller than the preceding
year for the reason that the tie men fig-
ured new railroad operations would be
less expensive the preceding year. While
the contracts for new lines have not been
so large as in the season of 1901, there
were many spur tracks built that brought
the average number of miles of new track
very nearly up to that of the preceding
season.
The outlook is good for a large amount
of new trackage to be built this winter
for logging companies and some spur
tracks remain to be finished to the new
mines on the range, hence the demand
for ties continues practically undiminished.
The agents for the various concerns in-
terested in the new trackage being built
are scouring the northwest for the supply
of tics they will need.
The increased demand for ties is likely
to have the effect of causing heavier op-
erations in the country this fall and win-
ter, where tie timber is available, and it
is predicted that the output of the coming
season will show an increase over last.
It is understood that preparations are be-
ing made on the north shore for particu-
larly large operations in tlie cedar and
tamarack swamps as soon as they freeze
over and tie men claim the greater supply
of the new ties will come from that part
of Northern Minnesota.
The demand for railroad ties annually
Cost of KunninK High Speed Trains.
We believe that the Executive Com-
mittee of the American Railway Master
Mechanics' Association acted wisely in
rclinguishing further investigation of the
question, "What is the cost of running
high-speed trains?" When the subject
was first brought up for investigation the
purpose was to ascertain the additional
cost for power that resulted from the
speed of a train being materially in-
creased. A variety of tests and investi-
gations indicated, closely enough for
practical purposes, that increasing the
train speed from about 30 miles an hour
to 60 miles an hour doubled the expense
for fuel. A variety of other extra ex-
penses are also incurred when train
speed is increased, notably repair bills,
inspection, wear and tear of track, and
the disturbing the movement of other
trains that may be more remunerative
than the fast express train. Members of
the American Railway Master Me-
chanics' Association have found out by
their investigations the extra cost in-
curred by the motive power department
in running extremely fast trains, and that
is all that they have a right to concern
themselves about. The extra expense
due to wear and tear of track, the loss
due to demoralizing the movement of
other trains and all other questions out-
side of the mechanical part belongs to
the American Railway Association,
which is composed of general managers
and other operating and traffic officials.
The subject is fairly well threshed out
and further efforts ought to be left to the
American Railway Association.
Scheming New Car and Locomotive
Works.
The .scarcity of motive power and cars
in the country that cannot be filled up by
the existing builders has induced a great
many people to believe that a very good
investment for capital would be in new
locomotive works and in new car works.
There appears to be a great many schemes
of this kind on foot, and scarcely a week
passes that we do not hear of an arrange-
ment to organize a new car or locomotive
building company.
If the existing prosperity could be as-
sured for ten years there is little doubt
that the building of a few new works
would be paying enterprises ; but this
prosperity of business is like what we
have experienced periodically, and a panic
would be sure to bring disaster on the
new concerns.
An honest man is one of the few great
works that can be seen for nothing. —
— Martin Chuszlewit.
lENGINEERINO QtESTIONS
ANSWERED.
(i) J. C. F., Chicago.
Will a valve travel faster or slower
when links are hooked up with locomo-
tive going at a given rate of speed?
A. — If our correspondent would use his
thinking powers he could answer this
question for himself. When a locomo-
tive is running with the reverse lever in
full gear the valve makes its greatest
travel, say six inches. When the lever
is hooked up to produce an early cut-oflE
the travel of valve will not exceed three
inches. It is obvious that when the valve
travels six inches in a given time it must
move faster than when it travels three
inches in the same time.
(2) R. B., Philadelphia.
In reading engineering papers I some-
times find the expression "single-acting
engine." Some of my friends say that
a two-cylinder locomotive is single act-
ing and that a Vauclain compound is a
double-acting engine. Is that a correct
definition? A. — No. A single-acting en-
gine is one where the steam acts only
on one side of the piston. In all loco-
motives, the compounds included, steam
presses alternately on both ends of the
pistons. The Westinghouse engine is a
well-known single-acting engine.
(3) W. M. B., Baltimore.
When you work out the power of a
locomotive you follow the well-known
formula which taking 85 per cent, of
the boiler pressure gives the tractive
power. This method of figuring is rath-
er deceiving, for you do not allow any-
thing for friction, and that certainly
takes away some part of the power.
What ought the allowance to be? A. —
We have generally allowed 10 per cent.,
but have reason to believe it is too low
for the ordinary run of locomotives. In
good stationary engine practice 7 1-2
per cent, is high for internal friction;
but in making tests of a Schenectady lo-
comotive in the Purdue experimental
plant. Professor Gosg found the friction
to range from 12 to 23 per cent. The
latter figure was found at a speed of 55
miles per hour, which showed that at
that velocity nearly one quarter of the
power was used in driving the motion,
no allowance being made for atmos-
pheric resistance.
(4) H. D. Havelock, Neb.
Will you kindly inform me why loco-
motive cylinders wear more on the top
than on the bottom? A. — The wear on
the top of the cylinder of which you
speak, may have been caused by the
guides being too low. The resultant of
the upward effort of the crosshead and
the horizontal motion of the piston is
upward.
(5) O. B. J.. Hopkins, Minn., asks
24
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
has the Davis counterbalance any ad-
vantage over the ordinary weight made
in one piece? A. — i. As far as the relative
merits of the Davis method of counter-
balancing and that usually followed is
concerned, both systems have strong
supporters, and the question is as yet
not fully determined. 2. Are locomo-
tives ever built with cylinders in
line with driving axles? A. — Yes.
When the cylinders are set at an angle
it is usually to facilitate placing of some
part of the machine, such as engine
truck wheels, in former days. No me-
chanical advantage is gained by placing
cylinders at an angle. 3. Why is
the front end of the parallel rod
on some moguls made with strap, gib
and key, while the rest have only bush-
ings? A. — It is usually done for economy
of space, the bushed ends of the rod re-
quire a plate and nut on the outside of
off, something similar to a safety-valve.
Some claim it is a hole in the fire, which
I know is imtrue, as I have carefully ex-
amined the fire and the engine steams
fine; of course, the fire is light and level.
Now there is certainly some great
change taking place to cause such a
sound, whether there is a hole in the fire
or not. I would like to have some of
my brother railroad men or chemists tell
me what produces this sound. A. — The
sound is produced by a series of rapid
explosions caused by the hydrogen in
the coal combining with the oxygen that
sustains combustion. The roaring oc-
curs only when the mixture of gases is
exactly right to produce it. We hnve
generally found that the mixture was
most likely to be right when an engine
stood on a bridge or trestle, but it some-
times happens on the ordinary track.
quiry, is the pounding and consequent
development of lost motion in the valve
gear. This pounding is peculiar to the
solid inside admission type of piston
valve, and results from the pressure of
the exhaust steam which, passing up
over the ends of the valve exerts a force
sufficiently great to take up the lost mo-
tion in the valve gear with a jerk or
pound, more or less, according to how
the engine is being worked. The exhaust
pressure it will be understood operates
to move the valve in the direction in
which it is traveling at the time. The
lost motion in the valve gear being taken
up by the efifort of moving the valve, it
is consequently free to be forced ahead
the distance which the lost motion in the
connections will allow. In the case of
an engine considerably worn and being
worked slow and in long cut off this
pounding is excessive and results in
v:*n'.i»«iff
MADE WONDERI-'UL RECORD OF POWER AND SPEED.
the pin, and in the case of the front pair
of wheels, these would be likely to inter-
fere with the guides and crosshead.
(6) B. H., Scranton, Pa.
When railroad men talk about curves
they nearly always refer to them as so
many degrees curvature. Can you give
me a rule of how to work out the curva-
ture by degrees? I have been accus-
tomed to thinking of curves as part of
a circle of a certain radius. A. — Survey-
ors measure curves as part of a circle,
whose radius is established by the angle
of deflection. If the angle of deflection
is 1° the radius of the curve will be 5,730
feet; 2° is half as much, and so on. A
10° curve will be part of a circle having
573 feet radius. If you keep in mind that
1° is a section of a circle with 5,730 feet
radius you will always be able to tell
mentally the radius when you hear the
number of degrees mentioned.
(7) B. S. R., Hornellsvillc, N. Y.
I wish to ask what produces that terri-
ble sound in the firebox of the small
type of engines, such as the small foot-
board with a small firebox. It sounds
as if it would take the top of your head
A Fast Run on the M. C. R. R.
A fast run was recently made on the
Canada Southern division of the Mich-
igan Central Railroad which is worthy
of notice. A 4-4-2 type engine similar
to the one shown in our illustration
hauled si.xteen passenger coaches from
Bridgeburg to St. Thomas, Ont., a dis-
tance of 118.22 miles, in 127 minutes.
The weight behind the tender was 605 1-2
tons, while the engiue and tender togeth-
er weighed 125 1-2 tons. A total load of 731
tons was, therefore, moved from one ter-
minal to the other against eight slow-
downs at a steady average rate of 55.8
miles an hour. The machine was built at
the Schenectady shops of the American
Locomotive Company, and has 2i.\-26 in.
cylinders, 79 in. drivers, 503-10 sq. ft.
of grate area and 3,521 sq. ft. of heat-
ing service. This exceptional perform-
ance was, no doubt, rendered possible
by the liberal heating surface provided.
rapi(j|wear and increase of lost motion.
This action soon becomes severe enough
to crystallize and break valve stems and
other parts. It also causes a certain ir-
regularity in the admission of steam,
since the valve jumps and then stops un-
til the lost motion is taken up. This ef-
fect is perhaps not important, but the
pounding is so detrimental to the gear
as to probably preclude the use of solid
piston valves, when the matter comes to
be thoroughly understood.
P. M. Foster.
Collinwood.
Pounding of Piston Valves.
A matter in connection with piston
valve locomotives which is of interest
and which has prompted some in-
In 1890 the railroads in the United
States carried 80,000,000 tons of freight
one mile and were paid a fraction over
nine-tenths of a cent for carrying each
ton one mile; in 1900 they carried 140,-
000,000 tons of freight one mile at a rate
of seven and a half tenths of one cent
per mile. That rate is pretty near cost,
and it is not expected that rates will be
made lower in view of the additional ex-
penses which railroad companies must
now meet through the advancing rates
of wages.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
as
Air=Brake Department.
Air-Brake Instruction Rooms at
Trenton, N. J.
Two views of the handsome air-brake
instruction rooms of the railroad branch
of the Y. M. C. A. at Trenton, N. J., are
ilhistratcd hcrewiUi.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NEI<I<IS.
lliiis doing away with the necessity of
waiting for the engine and consuming
valuable time after the crews have been
called and arc ready to start.
This old-time method, which should be
immediately rcEulnted as exceedingly
A VIKW OF THK PENNA. R.
INSTKrCTION ROOM AT TRENTON. N. J.
As will be noted, the two illustrations
show an excellent arrangement of the
equipment, which was designed and in-
stalled by W. B. Page, master mechanic
of the Lambcrtville shops. Regular
classes are held in these rooms, at regular
intervals during the week, when air-brake
instructions are given. The rooms are
open at any time to any and all of the
railroad men who may wish to visit them
and operate the apparatus with a view of
acquiring fuller knowledge of the air-brake
art.
This is an excellent example set by the
Pennsylvania Railroad, and is worthy of
teing followed by all other railroads that
would have tluir employees profitably en-
tertained and properly instructed in up-
to-date air-brake information.
costly and behind the t'mes, should be re-
placed by a more modern one of yard
testing plant, which will greatly falicitate
the air-brake service.
from each side squeeze the metal into
the form of a cross, as shown by the first
stage, in our illustration. The other end
of the bar is then similarly treated, and
the first operation is completed by the
formation of the wings.
The second stage in the manufacturing
of these valves consists in the formation
of the valve-seat. This is done by push-
ing the bar into an end die, which is cut
out to receive the wings. The operator
does this easily enough, as the cross -
shaped end is held so that two arms arc
vertical and two horizontal. Two side
moving jaws grip the bar. and the end
motion of the forming die upsets that
portion of the bar just beyond the wings.
The wings, being sunk in the cross-
shaped cavity of this die, suffer no al-
teration in form, while perhaps
about I 1-4 in. of metal is upset
to form the collar, which ultimately
makes the valve face. At the same
time, the collar thus formed is
pressed over projections in the die, so
that when withdrawn from the machine,
the cavity between each wing, under
the newly-formed collar, is smoothly and
definitely formed. The bars with these
"rudimentary" valves on the ends are
sheared in the middle, and the valves
then appear as shown in the second evo-
Antiquated Methods of Testing Air
Brakes.
It seems rather pathetic nowadays when
a leading railroad reports that the air
brakes on a- fast freight train must wait
for test until the locomotive is backed
down from the shops and coupled to the
train, and when a full hour is consumed
in the testing. Yet this is the situation
on some of the railroads which otherwise
have a claim to greatness. The time of
testing will be largely reduced if the yards
are equipped with testing plants where an
important train may be tested while it is
being made up, or immediately after.
A VIEW OF THE I'ENNA. K. R. .\1R-BR.\KE INSTRVCTION ROOM .\ T IRENTON, N. J.
riaking Air-Pump Valves.
The Chicago & Northwestern Rail-
way have succeeded in making the
valves used in their Westinghouse
air pumps, and of making them very sat-
isfactorily and very cheaply. A bar of
7-8-machine steel, about 11 in. long,
is heated, and one end is thrust
into the jaws of a forging machine. The
jaws grip the bar, while the dies closing
lutionary stage reproduced in the illus-
tration.
The third stage is completed very
quickly in a turret lathe. The shank
ends are held in the jaws of the chuck,
and the ends of the wings are cut off,
their sides trued up, the bevel valve
face is formed, and the valve is cut off;
the whole thing being done in four suc-
cessive operations conducted very rap-
26
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
idly. The shank which remains is sub-
sequently threaded to make a stud, or
if desired it can be left long enough to
stand heading, and is then turned out as
a well-made bolt. Nothing is lost in the
manufacture of these valves, and it is
needless to say that the cost of produc-
tion has been compresse.l to as desir-
able a form as that of the metal bar
when it leaves the forging machine at
the end of the second stage.
Arrangement on Engine of High=Speed
Brake Parts.
The engine truck brake, which made
its appearance on locomotives shortly
after a very serious accident on one of
the railroads in the New England States
some years ago, and prior to introduc-
tion of high-speed brake, has been used
in train service to a greater or less de-
gree ever since. The arrangement of the
parts has been in several ways, without
much regard to standardization. Fol-
lowing are a number of the arrange-
ments of piping and location of high-
TrahtJPipe
entire auxiliary reservoir capacity into
the truck brake or driver brake, should
either brake become defective or fail.
Fig. 3 illustrates an arrangement of the
parts wherein the driver-brake parts are
separate and distinct from the truck-
brake parts, both brakes being connected
to the main train pipe. In this arrange-
ment, either the truck brake or the
driver brake may be cut out should
either become defective, and the remain-
ing brake would act efliciently and would
not be dependent upon or related to the
other brake in any way. This arrange-
ment, however, calls for the provision
of a triple valve for the truck brake and
one for the driver brake.
Fig. 4 shows an arrangement where
the two auxiliary reservoirs and one
triple valve are used for both the engine
truck brakes and the driver brakes. This
arrangement, however, is also faulty, in-
asmuch that if the driver brake were to
become defective, the truck brake would
also have to be cut out.
Fig. s shows a modification of the ar-
Driver Brake
A.uxlliary Jteservair
Triple Talve
O)) for
Driver SraUe
Tritcli Brake
A-um-iliary Beservoir
Triple Valve
'or Truck
J£
^
XJ
Driver lirake
Cylinders
J>rii'er Srake
Cylinder
Triicli Jirahe
Reilucing I'alve
XJ
Driver Brake
Bettticing
Valve
FIG. 3.
speed brake parts, as used on some of
our leading railroads.
i Fig. I shows an arrangement where
one auxiliary reservoir is employed to
supply the two-driver brake cylinders
and the one-truck brake cylinder. In
this arrangement the truck brake may
be cut out without cutting out the driver-
brake cylinders; but the entire auxiliary
reservoir capacity is retained for the
driver-brake cylinders, thus jeopardiz-
ing the driving-brake wheels by sliding.
If either of the driver-brake cylinders
become defective and must be cut out,
the tender brake must be cut out, and
thereby sacrificed, as well. The cutting
out is done with the cut-out cock in the
branch pipe between the main train pipe
and the triple valve.
Fig. 2 shows a modification of arrange-
ment illustrated in Fig. i, a cut-out
cock being placed in the pipe leading
to the driver-brake cylinders. With this
arrangement either the driver-brake cyl-
inders or truck-brake cylinder may be
cut out; if either becomes defective, thus
evading the necessity for throwing the
Truck
Brake
Cyl.
ny
rangement illustrated in Fig. 4, making
that arrangement entirely satisfactory.
In Fig. 5, as in Fig. 4, the auxiliaries for
the driver brake and tender brake, re-
spectively, are located in tandem fashion
underneath the running board, which
makes a very satisfactory arrangement.
In Fig. 5, the cut-out cocks are so ar-
ranged that either the driver brake or
truck brake may be cut out should they
become defective without disturbing the
other brake. This is considered one of
the best arrangements of parts for the
hi.gh-speed brakes on locomotives.
Fig. 6 shows a general arrangement of
the parts, somewhat similar to Fig. 5,
but in such a way that the auxiliary
reservoirs can be arranged otherwise
than in tandem fashion under the foot
board. In this figure, as in Fig. 5,
the truck brake may be cut out
at will witliont disturbing the other
brake. This arrangement, as does also
Fig. S, permits of results as eflfective as
does Fig. 3, where two triple valves are
employed.
Figs. 1, 2 and 4 may be summed up as
distinctly faulty. Fig. 3, while being cor-
rect and effective, employs necessarily a
second triple valve for the truck brake.
Figs. 5 and 6 may be accepted as illus-
Train Pipe
Auxiliary
Jteservair
^) Triple
V/ Valve
d
Driver Brake
Cylinder
Truck Brake Eeducingl
Cylinder Valve J
Driver Brake
'■~J Cylinder
EaUwajf f L<^trmulive Engineering
trating perfectly satisfactory and good
recommended practice.
MORE DESOE CHARTS.
Beginning with our February number
we shall publish in serial form a color
scheme of showing pressures of the air
brake system under different conditions.
This will include operations of the freight
brake, passenger brake and high speed
brake. These serials will be by E. G.
Desoe, the originator of colored illustra-
tions of the air brake system, and will
doubtless prove the results of his best
efforts. Be sure to get all these numbers.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Emergency Tests of Air Brakes.
I wish to say a few words in reply to-
Mr. Desoe on trains being made up in
the yard and before the engine arrives.
We know it is a fact that we cannot
make up trains fast enough — business is
too good; and to hold a freight train of
so cars in a yard to make a service ap-
prfcation of the brakes, then recharge
and make an emergency application of
the brakes is preposterous.
For illustration, say, we take away the
service application of the brakes entirely
from yard test, and make none other
than the emergency test. Then what
Train Pipe
Dl'iver Brake
• Cylinder
Railtiray ^ Litcomulii'S £ni/interi'ii/
about your leaky packing leathers not be-
ing detected? What about brakes going
into emergency with service application,
broken graduating pins, sticky triples,
excess strain on the brake rigging, etc.?
Again, where freight yards are located
on a grade like the Nashville yards, it is
necessary to have at least from 8 to 10
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
27
hand brakes set to hold the train. We
experience quite a good deal of trouble
when the triples work emergency in
service, and hand brake set that the push
rod will knock a hole through the center
of the brake cylinder piston. It is bad
enough to apply brakes in emergency on
the line of road to avoid accident. The
emergency feature of the air brake was
intended for emergency cases only on
the road, and not to knock things to
pieces in making unnecessary and sense-
less tests.
In reply to his article in December
number, is it not a fact that the emer-
gency test of air brakes at a terminal
point will not altogether say if angle
cock is partly closed or not?
Secondly, I still hold that the founda-
tion brake gear is strong enough for
sei-vice tests, but if we are going into
the high-speed brake let us increase the
be open and let the inspectors know they
are open. Seeing is believing. In making
up our trains in Nashville yards the test
plant hose is attached to the rear end,
and each hose is blown out before being
coupled. Otto Best,
A.-B. Inspector N. C. & St. Louis Ry.
Nashville, Tenn.
Some Foundation Brake History.
During the early and middle '70s, the
Wharton switch was used extensively on
the Pennsylvania Railroad and else-
where.
While possessing many merits, the fact
of its rails rising to a height of several
inches above those of the main track
caused many brake riggings to be caught
and torn from the trucks. Of course, this
trouble only occurred with trucks having
the brakes suspended from the loose
£
Driver
Jirafie
i^r
Truck
Srafce
Cyllntler
=Mi=^
1
Driver
Brake
Cylinder
r^
"Cr
A ittottifitic
liillttriug
lalvt)
u
Urivfv lirttlie
Aujiilinry It^scrvolr
t1
■Truck Brake
A-uaciliury Jivscrvoir
Strength of the foundation brake gear.
But that is another question and is out of
line. The Westinghouse bulletin No. 10
says that the standard brake gear is of
ample strength for the high-speed brake.
This has nothing to do with trying
brakes in emergency at terminal point.
We are not testing brakes in emergency
to see how strong the levers and rods
are. The extra stress is not put on the
brake rigging until train is in motion.
Thirdly, I still maintain that it is not
necessary for an angle cock to be wide
open to get quick action. Now, I would
like to have our brother Desoe explain
if he has a so-car train and goes up to
the engine and tells the engineman to ap-
ply the brake in emergency, how can he
tell if an angle cock is partly closed be-
tween the 20th and 21st car; how can he
tell if the brake worked in emergency on
the 2ist car up to the 50th car. In my
opinion, it would be well to equip
brother Desoe with wings (a very ordi-
nary kind, of course — marked down
from a dollar), or that it would be well
for brother Desoe to equip all inspectors
with an ear trumpet or long-distance tel-
ephones.
Now, of course, all angle cocks should
Railway i Loeomotiv* EnginttHrtg
transom, and then only when the springs
became weak or were unduly depressed
from any cause.
The Pennsylvania Railroad cars, and
those of many other companies passing
over its lines, were equipped with dia-
mond trucks having inside brakes sus-
pended from the loose transoms; and
these transoms were carried either upon
half-elliptic springs, or some type of the
large family of spirals which, after a few
trips, refused to rise from the point to
which the loads had compressed them.
The result was that not only were
many such brakes tarn ofT on the high
switch rails referred to, but derailments
and much damage often followed such
tearing off of brakes.
The P. R. R. Co.'s attention was first
called to it by the frequency of such oc-
currences under engine tenders fitted
with diamond trucks using wheels of 28-
in. and 30-in. diameter.
Mr. Elder, of the Altoona shops, was
the first to attempt a remedy. He de-
signed a brake in which the lower holes
of the levers were attached to the jaws
in the break-beams, and the holes usually
so attached were thus thrown higher up
and were secured to jaws which swung
upon castings bolted rigidly to the spring
plank. These jaws were provided with
a number of holes to permit adjust-
ment. The levers, when the brake was
not applied, stood away from the tran-
som at their top ends, and the lever more
distant from the point where braking
power was applied was provident at its
top with a sheave about 5-in. in diameter
and placed horizontally in a frame or
case forged on the top of the lever.
Around this pulley the chain operating
the brake was carried and connected at
its end to the top of the plain lever.
Thus, when power was applied the two
levers were drawn together and the brake
set.
Upon the adoption of switches having
rails conforming to the rest of the track
in height, this brake passed out of use,
although within a twelvemonth the
writer has seen several yet in service on
P. R. R. cars.
Soon after this type of brake was de-
signed, Messrs. W. C. Allison & Co., of
Philadelphia, Pa., patented a wrought
iron device to be attached to the lower
(rigid) transom of diamond trucks in
such a manner as to permit the brakes
to be hung upon these devices, and thus
enable the standard levers and connect-
Driver Brake
Auxiliary
Reservoir
— f[LL[[ ' '-tryO — AuTlliary
IT ■ jT Reservoir
Truck l-.r-ake
AuTiliary
ing bars to be used without danger of
being torn away, as when suspended
from the loose transom.
This device fully proved its inventors'
claims, and while it was thenceforth
largely used, the Pennsylvania people ap-
peared satisfied with the Elder brake;
and the coal company, of whose large
car equipment the writer had charge, af-
ter applying a number of the Allison sus-
pension stands, adopted a substitute pre-
28
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 190.3.
pared by one of its employees; and as
this substitute was -formed of two ver-
tical pieces placed on opposite sides of
the transom and held together by three
bolts, we thenceforth had no end ol
trouble owing to persistent refusal of
the parts of this "improvement" to re-
main firmly in place for any length of
time.
A competing company used the Alli-
Tb Itrah'e JItist
liuilway ^ Luaimotiv* Engineering
Elder's Brake. {Xo.D
son device with entire satisfaction for
years, but with that odd tendency of
human nature not to "let well enough
afone," superimposed upon this "good
thing" a device originated by an em-
ployee, which had to a marked degree
the merit of simplicity, but was not pro-
ductive of the results usually attributed
to that virtue.
This device consisted of a plain stand-
ard brake lever attached at its lower end
to the usual jaw in the brake-beam, and
at its top to the chain or rod applying
the power; while to a hole a few inches
above the poiint of attachment to the
brake-beam was bolted one end of a
connecting rod, which at once curved
upward and passed over the top of the
lower transom, and then curved down-
JiuUuiag $ LoeoMotiM Engineerinff
N0.3
ward and was secured rigidly to the
other brake-beam and at its lever end
was provided with a number of holes for
adjusting.
Our company next came to the front
with a brake designed by the inventor
■of the "rival" to the Allison stand. This
brake closely followed the lines of the
Elder brake, except that the sheave was
replaced by a short lever placed hori-
zontally and in line with the transoms.
The center of this lever was attached to
the top of the brake lever, most distant
from direction of applied power, one
end to the brake chain, and the other
end, by means of a rod passing over the
top of the loose transom, to the remain-
ing lever.
Another "inventor" was permitted by
our superintendent to apply a brake of
his design to one of our cars. Having
unfortunately preserved no drawing of
this brake, I am not certain as to all its
details; but recall its chief features con-
sisted of two levers of standard type,
but much shorter, attached to the brake-
beams and to the lower transoms after
the manner of the Elder brake. These,
at their tops, were united by a set of ad-
justable connections terminating in a
floating lever placed on the side of truck
nearest to the source of application of
power. The brake chain was attached
< — To Brake Jtasi
Raituag j XoegmutiM Engineering
A'o.g
to this lever and therefore avoided the
use of long chains which were on the
preceding two.
Last (but not least in general worth-
lessness, perhaps), came a device of the
writer, vi-hose youthful ambition did not
for an instant propose that all these
people should "make brakes" and leave
him out in the cold. Modesty ( !) for-
H
Sifle. End.
AXlison*8 Support,
SinifU Pivce.
JS'oM
Jiaiiuiay ^ Locvmvtiie Engineering
Xnd.
Sap2*ori,
bids farther description than to say that
it differed from the Elder brake only in
using standard levers, and placing the
sheave in a semicircular shield, having
upon the outside a clevis attached at
its duplex end to the bolt or pin form-
ing the axle of the sheave; and at its
single end to a chain or rod tmiting it
to the brake lever. The brake chain
then passed around the sheave and was
attached to the other lever; the sheave
standing when in release position, about
in line with the side of the transom op-
posite to the lever to which it was di-
rectly attached.
The refusal of the P. R. R. inspector
to allow the cars fitted with the second
type described, to go upon the road,
and a decided preference of the writer
for the old standard brakes, caused some
warmth of feeling between him and a
high official of our company, and led to a
practical test of their merits. This test
was made upon a lateral track leading
to one of the mines, having a grade
somewhat exceeding 150 feet to the mile,
and being nearly one mile in length.
The test train was composed of six
Jiiid. yo.4
-To Brtihe Mast
Railway ^.Loeamotive Engineering
lfo.4
8-wheel coal cars, having an average
light weight of 20,000 pounds each, and
containing an average load of 24,000
pounds each.
They were arranged in the following
order: First, a car with brakes of stand-
ard type; second, two cars with brakes
of the third type described; third, one
car with brake- of the second type de-
scribed; fourth, a car having brake of
the fourth type, and last the car with
my own design.
Precaution was taken to place a num-
ber of empty cars at the foot of the hill
to act, if necessary, as a "buffer" and
prevent the unexpected advent of the
"Special" upon the main line.
Crew and passengers, to the number
of ten, boarded the cars, and we started,
by releasing the standard brakes. .Al-
though each truck was braked inde-
pendently, we soon found it impossible
to stop the train when all the "im-
proveds" were set, and the momentum
rather increased than diminished. The
standards were then brought into use
and worked effectively until a chain of
one of them gave way.
The speed was then about ten miles
per hour, and the advocates of improve-
ment lost interest in the test, and de-
spite our remonstrance began jumping
off, in their inexperience performing
Acros,t TrftHsom.
Xo.B
liaitu/ag ^ Loeumettve Engineering
yo.5
gyrations as they reached the ground
which would turn a gymnast green with
envy; but fortunately escaping other in-
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
29
jury than somewlial soiled and torn gar-
ments!
Three of lis finished the trip in triumph
with a bump against the empties, our
speed having been considerably reduced
by a judicious use of the remaining ef-
ficient standard brake and the aid of a
sharp curve and easier grade at the bot-
tom; but in the hot summer afternoon
we emerged from tlic cloud of coal dust
resulting from the blow with our faces
and hands as black as Africans.
The officer referred to said we might
restore the standards, but keep the im-
proved parts carefully until called for!
Although I remained -in the service
of that company several years afterward,
the "call" never came.
C. II. C.\RUTHERS.
]'c(uioii. Pit.
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On Alr-Brake Subjects.
(i) B. M. McC, Louisville, Ky., asks:
Isn't the left head in the main valve
bushing of a 9 1-2-in. pump to protect
by cushion the piston 79? Is it for any
other purpose, and can the pump be run
without such cushion? A. — The head re-
ferred to receives the small main valve
piston, is its cylinder, and guides the
main valve in its operation. Its head is
so constructed that the piston is cush-
ioned on its extreme traverse to the left,
and the pump could not be run smoothly
without this cushion. This arrangement
of the parts is made for convenience to
get at the parts for repair work.
(2) B. M. McC, Louisville, Ky., asks:
If a discharge valve in a 9 1-2 pump
broke, would you not get better results
if you put the receiving valve in its place?
A. — You would not get good results in
cither case. If the discharge valve
were broken and the receiving valve
were whole, the main reservoir pressure
would flow back into the pump each time
on the return stroke. If the receiving
valve were broken, the piston would
push the air pressure out through the
broken valve each time on the return
stroke, instead of compressing it past
the receiving valve into the main res-
ervoir.
(3) S. \V. B., BuiTalo, N. Y., asks:
Do you believe that a hose that will not
burst when 150 pounds of air is put on it
is a first-class hose, and if it will stand
this pressure, would you consider it all
right for service? A. — The bursting test
is not the only test required of a good,
high-grade, air-brake hose. The master
car builders' specifications require that a
hose when first manufactured must be able
to withstand a pressure of 500 pounds be-
fore bursting. Each hose must stand, in
addition to this, a shop test of 200 pounds.
One of the greatest essentials in an air-
brake hose is its ability to bend readily
and be flexible. The hose should also
have sufficient good quality of rubber in
its composition, and not too much duck.
It will be seen that several layers of duck
and low grade rubber would make a hose
that would withstand a high bursting
pressure, but would not be flexible enough
to bend and accommodate itself to the
curving that would be necessary in prac-
tice. We would not, therefore, consider
an air-brake hose that stood a pressure of
150 pounds alone to be a high-grade hose.
(4) J. F. McG., Corbin, Ky., writes:
It has been positively stated that it is
utterly impossible for the New York
triple to go into quick action after 5 or
6 pounds has been drawn off the train
pipe in service application, yet in our
instruction car I have seen S, 10 and 15
pounds reduced in service, and the emer-
gency application gotten by placing the
handle in emergency position. How
would you account for this strange ac-
tion? A. — It would seem from your let-
ter that the train pipe in the case men-
tioned has been overcharged after an ap-
plication. In other words, after a train
pipe reduction has been made, the brake
has been released, train pipe recharged
heavily (but not auxiliary), and the brake
applied again. In this event it would be
possible to reduce 5. 10 or 20 pounds in
a service position, and get the emergency
action immediately following such service
reduction.
(5) J. L, E., Hagerstown, Md., writes:
Don't you think quite a lot of the break-
in-twos that are blamed on the air brake
ought to be traced to bad knuckles and
poor draft gear? A great many times a
train breaks in two and the conductor re-
ports that the air brakes broke a train in
two and broke a knuckle or pulled out a
draw-bar. Don't you think the draw-bar
or the knuckle was really to blame and not
the air brake ? A. — Undoubtedly a great
many break-in-twos are wrongly blamed
on the air brake as you mention, and if
properly investigated at the time could be
traced to a defective knuckle or coupler.
However, both knuckles and draft gear on
cars are being improved and less trouble
may be expected on this score. Nearly
all heavy modern 100.000 pound capacity
cars are equipped with friction draft gear
and strong knuckles in the couplers.
(6) J. A. D., Albany, N. Y., writes:
Why is it that slid flat wheels are about
as common in the autumn of the year as
in the winter time? I have noticed that
in the spring of the year there is very lit-
tle trouble experienced from sliding of
wlieels. Why is it that they do not slide
as much in springtime as fall ? A. —
One of the greatest causes for wheels
slinding during the autumn season is on
account of autumn leaves getting on the
rails, therefore causing the wheels to slip
and slide. One instance was recently
called to our attention where a heavy ten-
wheel locomotive was unable to make
time with a train of three coaches on a
road running through a wooded country,
and where large numbers of dead leaves
fell on the tracks. It will be observed In
flat wheel seasons that the locomotive
drivers slip a great deal more than in
other seasons. In the case just mentioned
the dead leaves interfered with the ad-
hesion between driving wheels and rails,
causing the engine to slip, in the same
way that they destroyed the adhesion be-
tween the car wheels and rails, causing the
brake to pick up the wheels and slide
them.
(7) D. L. F., Topeka, Kan., writes:
I have an engine with a 9 1-2-inch
pump and a D-S brake valve. I set the
brakes, then release, place handle in run-
ning position, and the brakes set again
quickly. The feed valve has a leak at its
bottom and a very slight leak out of the
emergency exhaust port. These leaks are
felt in both running and release positions.
There is a pipe leading from the brake cyl-
inder up into the cab to help release
brakes. You can feel- the air accumulat-
ing constantly, and if the pipe is shut off
a while, the pressure is very strong. I Ho
not know what sets the brakes. After re-
leasing the connections are all tight and
there are no leaks in the brake cylinder.
I claim that the air coming from the brake
cylinder is from a leaky triple and that
the brake valve has nothing to do with
this accumulation ; but it's a fact that no
air accumulates in the brake cjdinder until
the valve is placed in running position.
The excess pressure is maintained all
right. The main reservoir pressure is
governed in this valve. Please give me
some light on this subject. A. — You have
probably left your brake valve handle in
release position too long, and thereby
permitted more pressure to pass from the
main reservoir through release position di-
rect into the train pipe than your feed
valve is set for. When you bring your
handle to running position you cut off
your direct communication between the
main reservoir and train line. Your train
line is now higher than the feed valve at-
tachment is set for, and there is a leakage
of train pipe pressure through your feed
valve attachment to the atmosphere, pre-
sumably through a crocked diaphragm or
bad joint in your feed valve attacJiment.
and possibly from other numerous small
leaks elsewhere in the train pipe. The
train pipe pressure will therefore reduce,
and not being reinforced with main res-
ervoir pressure by your feed valve attach-
ment, your brake will set. You can prove
this by pumping up your pressure with
the brake valve handle in running posi-
tion and not placing it at all in full re-
lease. Another proof is to release brakes
in running position, carefully keeping out
of full release. Tr>- this. We think it will
end your trouble.
30
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
Marvelous Achievements of One Cen-
tury of the Locomotive.
BY HARRIS TABOR.
The closing years of the 19th century
will go on record as the most marvelous
in the history of the world. Even the
birth of the steam engine did not exert
so great an influence on the world's in-
dustries as have the improvements of the
past decade. Within that time the most
stupendous aggregations of capital and
combinations of industries have taken
place and developments of a most im-
portant nature have been the rule. Rail-
roads, which ten years ago were handi-
capped for the want of freight, have
since practically renewed their rails,
rolling stock equipment and bridges to
enable them to handle the enormous
traffic now offered. Notwithstanding
all these changes, there is not an im-
portant line of rails in this country that
is not restricted by a scarcity of rolling
equipment that amounts to positive
famine. Locomotives have had their
tractive power doubled and the lo-toii
and 20-ton cars of a few years ago have
given way to the more modern cars ol
30 and so tons capacity. To suit these
conditions heavier rails and bridges have
been called for and supplied.
It is the day of big things. Stationary
steam engines, gas engines, machine
tools and structural work have taken or,
dimensions and tonnage undreamed of
20 years ago. Old methods have been
thrown aside and forgotten, and the new
have been as thoroughly assimilated as
though they were the product and
growth of centuries instead of a few
years.
The majority of your readers will re
member the then mammoth Corliss Cen-
tennial steam engine of about 2$ years
ago, with a maximum of 2,500 horse
power. Probably no exhibit in the Phil-
adelphia Exposition drew the attention
and admiration that was given this ma-
chine. After the exposition was over
Mr. Corliss sold this engine to the Pull-
man Car Company, Chicago— then one
of the largest plants of the kind in this
country — ^to be used as a general power
supply for the shops. As a matter of
fact, this engine was so much too large
for the duty put upon it that, when car-
rying its full load, the steam gages on
the boilers often showed no apparent
pressure; the whole work being done, as
shown by indicator diagrams, with steam
below atmospheric pressure and with a
mean effective pressure in the cylinders
of 8 pounds. It would be interesting
to know just how deficient in power that
this famous engine would be in the Pull-
man plant to-day.
In steamships no less significant
changes have taken place and are still
being made. The fast ship of ten years
ago is a laggard in the ocean race of
to-day, as your editor, who makes an-
nual trips to the heather blossoms.
knows. When the Oceanic and the big
German liners spread their pennants
Froude's ideal length for speed, 700 feet,
was reached, and we supposed the com-
mercial speed limit was also attained.
Now we get the astonishing announce-
ment from the old Cunard Company
that they will build two new ships with
a speed ol 25 knots per hour, a speed
surpassing our best railway passenger
service when we, who have passed the
middle mark in life, were born.
In steam engines improvements and
growth to bigger dimensions have been
no less remarkable. A single shaft in
a modern steamship will often transmit
from its engine to the screw from four
to six times the power developed by the
Centennial Corliss engine; and, more re-
markable still, these ships will keep up
a continuous run for 3,000 miles. In
stationary engine practice units of steam
HARRIS TABOR.
Engineer.
power have been multiplied three and
four times beyond that of the Corliss
mammoth, and we have numerous build-
ers who are ready to supply such ma-
chines. Steam turbines, a product of the
last years of the 19th century, are also
taking on great dimensions and bid fair
to rival the reciprocating engine in econ-
omy. In gas engines we find four units
have increased within ten years, from
50 to 1,000, and makers to-day are as
ready to supply the larger size as they
were formerly the smaller. With all
these improvements in the way of greater
dimensions and tonnage have come bet-
ter designs and workmanship.
This wonderful industrial growth has
been made possible only by the men who
furnish the means to do it with. To un-
derstand this one must go to the machine
tool builders, the foundry, the forge and
the rolling mill, where he will find the
tense energy and determination to meet
all demands that characterizes this na-
tion. These sources of supply have
grown with the industries depending on
them, and to-day are catering to the mar-
kets of the world.
We can imagine nothing that will illus-
trate the recent industrial growth of this
country more briefly and eloquently than
the sky line of New York City. The
modern buildings from 16 to 30 stories
high — monuments to daring and enter-
prise— standing by the side of the
dwarfed products of a few years ago, tell
the story at a glance. All the architec-
ture may not appeal to us and we may
smile at Mark Twain's simile of a "mouth
full of jagged teeth," but we must ad-
mit that this line against a clear sky is
a record of marvelous work.
Conventions Qo to Mackinac Island.
The joint committee of the Master Car
Builders' and the Master Mechanics' as-
sociations met at Buffalo on December
10 and arranged for the meeting place of
the next conventions. Mr. J. W. Mar-
den, Boston & Maine, was chosen chair-
man. A sub-committee appointed some
time ago reported in favor of Manhat-
tan Beach, but when the full committee
met they decided to listen to persons
representing other places before they
made a final decision. Hotel men from
Mackinac, Colorado Springs, Denver,
Atlantic City, Put-in-Bay and Niagara
Falls were permitted to describe the at-
tractions of their various localities and
of the comforts offered by the hotel-
keepers. After the offers made by the
various places had been weighed a vote
was taken, which resulted in favor of
Maakinac. The Master Mechanics' con-
vention will come first and will begin on
June 17. The convention headquarters
will be at the Grand Hotel, Mackinac
Island, and the rates will not differ much
from those usually charged. Applica-
tions for rooms should be made to Mr.
Henry Weaver, Planters' Hotel, St.
Louis, Mo. Applications for space to
exhibit in, should be made to Mr. J. Al-
exander Brown, 24 Park place, New
York.
About 4,5CO miles of railroad are now
in operation in Japan, and of this 35 per
cent, is operated by the government,
while all of it is more or less under gov-
ernment regulation, a special depart-
ment of the government being main-
tained for that purpose. The roads in
Japan are all narrow gauge, the stand-
ard there, being three feet. The building
of locomotives has only been attempted
in the country in a very small way, but
all of the cars, both freight and passen-
ger, are built in their own shops, some
parts, such as the wheels, being im-
ported.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND- LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
31
Recent Development of Block and
Interlocking Sig;nal System.
By \V. II. liLr.IOTT, SIGNAL ENGINEER,
C, M. & ST. P. RY.
In judging of the development of any
signal system, it is necessary to consider
the subject from the standpoint of the
trainmen or operating official and from
the standpoint of the signal engineer
who is charged with the successful
maintenance and working of the signal
apparatus. From an operating stand-
point there has been but little change
or improvement in the older signal sys-
tems and the newer systems conform to
the practice followed in those already in
use. What is of the most value to
operating men is that block signal sys-
tems and interlockings have been very
widely introduced and are in use in one
form or another on almost all the prin-
cipal lines in this country. With a great
increase in the number of trains some-
thing more than dispatchers' orders are
necessary to insure the safe running of
trains, and some kind of a block signal
system is an absolute necessity. With
the increase in the speed of trains, due to
competition and to the demands of the
public, all unnecessary stops must be cut
out, and in order to accomplish this, in-
terlockings have been put in to make the
running of crossings, junction points and
draw bridges safe.
No one improvement in signaling has
been of more importance to trainmen
than that of using green for the all clear
night indication, and while this practice
has been in use on the C. & N.-W. Ry.
for a number of years, it is only of late
that many roads have made the change
from white to green. The perfecting of
a special shade of yellow glass, which
will answer for the cautionary indication,
simplifies the situation very much and it
is expected that many roads will change
to green for the all clear night indication
with red for the stop and yellow for the
cautionary indication. The use of green
has much tn commend it, as with white
meaning "Clear," any light in line with
a signal may be taken for the signal light
and an accident result. That there is
great danger of this happening cannot be
denied, owing to the intensity and in-
crease in the number of arc lights that
are used in cities and small towns. With
white for the all clear indication, a
broken glass will result in the clear in-
dication being given, although the sig-
nal may be in the stop position, and a
derail open. With the glasses in the
semaphore breaking occasionally and
with the many that are broken out ma-
liciously by tramps and boys, it is sur-
prising that so few accidents really hap-
pen from this cause. Perhaps all that do
happen are not reported in the railroad
journals.
The yellow light for the cautionary in-
dication seems to be more satisfactory
than the combination of red and green,
which is in use on many roads. The sin-
gle light is more easily discernible than
are the two lights and is less likely to
be mistaken for two separate lights in
line with each other. Sometimes one
light or the other of the two light com-
bination does not show, and an incor-
rect indication is given. The yellow
light, if seen through fog and steam, will
assume a red tint, and when seen by
itself, may not be of as decided a shade
as is to be desired, but as in either case
the light would be mistaken for colors
that would mean stop, no dangerous con-
dition would exist.
From the trainmen's standpoint the
engineer can obey the indication of a
signal, he must be able to see it, and if
the speed of the train is to be high, the
engineer must cither get a view of the
signal far enough away to enable him to
properly control the train or else a dis-
tant signal must be provided which will
be far enough away to enable him to
bring the train under control in the
space between the distant and the home
signals. So long as the distant signal
had to be mechanically connected and
worked from a lever in a tower, it was
not practicable to properly work the dis-
tant signal as far away as it should be
put, but since power operated signals
have been perfected they are used and
"ELECTRIC MOTOR .\ND MECHANISM OF CNION AUTOMATIC SEMAPHORE SIGNAL.'
use of the continuous light spectacle is a
great improvement over the 60 degree
two-light casting or the single light cast-
ing with a shield, for in one case a light
is shown to the engineer at all times,
whereas with the use of a shield no light
i-; shown when the signal is half way
down and the lamp comes between open-
ings in the two light spectacles.
Of late years signal engineers and su-
perintendents have recognized the ne-
cessity of so locating a signal that it
will be put in the best possible position
to be seen by an approaching train and
while a good view is not always to be
had, the ground is usually very carefully
gone over before a final location is made.
The fact is recognized that before an
put as far from the home signal as may
be desired. Their cost is but little more
than that of the mechanical signal, and
besides being far enough away from the
home signal they are much safer and
more reliable in every way.
From the standpoint of the signal en-
gineer, the science of signaling, or that
part of it which has to do with develop-
ment and construction, has been ad-
vanced very greatly in the last few years.
New inventions and improvements have
been made in all branches.
With the telegraphic block signal sys-
tem the semaphore has, to a great extent,
displaced the use of the revolving disk
as a station signal, owing to the greater
distance that the semaphore can be seen
32
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
and the particular advantage possessed
by the latter in giving the indications by
the position of the arm instead of by
form and color.
The practice first adopted by the C, M.
& St. P. Ry. of pointing the arms of all
block signals in order to distinguish this
signal from a switch or interlocking stop
signal, has been followed by many roads
and undoubtedly has much to commend
it.
The three position signal or the giving
of the stop indication by a horizontal
position of the arm, the cautionary indi-
cation when the arm is at 45 degrees
from the horizontal, and the clear indi-
cation when the arm is vertical, is used
by but few roads, and does not seem to
be gaining in favor. The Mozier three
position signal, which allows the per-
missive indication to be given by inclin-
ing the arm upward, or above the hori-
zontal position, has been adopted by sev-
eral roads, the largest of which is the
Santa Fe.
The controlled manual system has not
come into very extended use and com-
paratively few installations have been
made. Several different instruments
have been perfected and work well, but
the great cost of the system, together
with the absolute character of the block-
ing necessary to insure safe working, are
objectionable, and other systems have
been installed in consequence. The ne-
cessity for a hand release in each oflice.
to enable the signal to be worked in case
of failures of the apparatus, is very ob-
jectionable, as by its use the signalman
may make a mistake and admit a train
under a clear signal when the block is
occupied.
The automatic signal has been much
improved and with the perfecting of the
semaphore type of these signals, the disk
signal, of which there are so many in
use, is being superseded by the later sig-
nal. The disk signal is still preferred by
a few, but the greater distinctness with
which the semaphore can be seen and the
positive manner of giving the indications
are of such importance to trainmen that
this type is regarded as a better signal
and is being more generally used.
There are two prominent types of this
signal now on the market. One is the
motor driven, manufactured by the
Union Switch & Signal Co., and the
other is the electro-gas signal, made by
the Hall Signal Co. The motor signal
requires a battery of 16 cells to operate
it and takes from 6 to 12 seconds to clear
the signal according to the gearing used.
The gas signal is worked by means of
carbonic acid gas stored in liquid form
in the usual iron "bottle" used by soda
water manufacturers. One charge for
the battery or a bottle of gas will operate
the signal about 12,000 times, so that .nt
40 movements a day, recharging will
have to be made only about once each
year.
The differences of opinion in regard to
the normal danger and the normal clear
plan of arranging automatic signals still
exist, and both are being used. A large
road has equipped a division with the
signals arranged on the normal danger
plan, and an adjoining division with sig-
nals arranged to stand normally at clear.
The normally clear arrangement is much
easier of maintenance and inspection
than where the signals stand normally at
stop, and as there is but little difference
in the cost of the battery required, the
normally clear seems to be the more
preferable arrangement of the two.
The Staff system for blocking trains is
being introduced on many single track
roads where there are difficult pieces of
track to operate and where a collision
UNION SWITCH AND SIGN.\I, CD'S MOTOR
DRIVEN AUTOM.iTIC SIGNAL.
is apt to result in serious dam-
age. The use of this system effects a
great saving in the time required to move
trains, as where it is used it is not nec-
essary to give train orders and registers
do not have to be checked. So much do
the trainmen appreciate the saving in
lime effected over the train order method
of dispatching trains, that where a staff
machine was recently PUt out of service
on account of the depot burning down
the signal department was besieged with
inquiries from the dispatcher, operator,
conductor and enginemen to know
when the new machine would be put up
and ready for business.
Among the new systems of signals
which are being tried, but which have not
as yet come into extended use, the Row-
ell-Potter may be said to be the most
promising and possessing the most
merit. This system, although in use on
elevated roads for a number of years,
has been put in on the Chicago, Milwau-
kee & St. Paul Railway for trial and has
been put to some severe tests. The prin-
cipal part of the system is a safety stop
or inclined bar which opens a valve on
the engine and applies the air in case
the signal should be run by, when in the
stop position. An ingenious mechan-
ism stores power in a set of springs by
means of a track treadle worked by the
deflection of the rail under the wheels
of passing trains. The power so ob-
tained is used to work a semiphore sig-
nal and the safety stop, and the cost of
the battery employed to work the motor
signal is saved. The system has not been
in use long enough to demonstrate what
it will do, but it has been inspected by
many railroad officials, who were much
interested in the trial now being made.
The Miller block signal, which is in
use on the Chicago & Eastern Illinois
and which is being tried in the Park ave-
nue tunnel. New York City, gives the in-
dications for clear and for stop by means
of a red and a white light placed in the
engine cab. For places like a tunnel,
where it is almost impossible to see a
signal situated on the side of the track,
putting the lights in the cab may be a
good thing, but as the apparatus will
probably be smashed in case of acci-
dent, there would be no way of telling
whether the apparatus had given a wrong
indication or the engineer had failed to
bserve the stop indication. Engineers
do not always observe the stop indica-
tions given by automatic signals, and
\yould be much less likely to do so when
there is no chance of their being detected
in wrongdoing.
In the interlocking branch of signal
work, improvements have kept up with
that made in other lines, but they are
l(ot such as would be appreciated by
those not interested in the maintenance
or operation of such plants. The power
operated mechanisms have been very fully
developed, as evidenced by the electro-
pneumatic, the pneumatic and the Taylor
electric systems, which are being installed
in many places.
With the mechanical plants, improve-
ment has been made principally in the
line of permanent construction, wood be-
ing done away with as much as possible
and concrete and iron parts being used
instead. The old practice oi overloading
levers is being generally abandoned, and
a lever is now made to work only one
signal or one derail. All switches and
derails are bolt locked with the signal
governing them, wherever practicable, in
order to prevent the clearing of the- sig-
nal in case the switch points are not
properly closed.
The low-pressure pneum.itic system
and the Taylor electric system are the
latest development in power operated in-
terlocking plants. The low-pressure
system is said to be economical in the
use of air and free from the trouble oc-
casioned by water collecting in the vent
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3?
holes and freezing up, preventing the
movements from working. The move-
ment of the switches and signals arc con-
trolled by valves, which are worked by
air admitted to different sides of a dia-
phragm, to which the valves are connect-
ed. The Taylor electric system is a very
ingenious one, and the details have been
well worked out. Electric motors are
used to work the switches and signals
and the interlocked levers in a machine
switch, the current in the wires run-
ning to each motor. By reversing the
connections at the motor, by means of
a pole changer, the motor at the end of
the stroke is changed into a dynamo and
made to generate sufficient current to re-
lease a lock on the lever in the machine
and indicate that the movement of the
switch has been completed. The electric
current necessary for the operation of
the Taylor machine can be taken from
any electric supply station, but in places
where current is not to be bought a gas
engine and dynamo with necessary stor-
age batteries have to be put in. The cur-
rent required to work a switch is about £
amperes at no volts and the time re-
quired about I second. A signal takes
about the same time to clear and requires
.■! amperes of current.
With most interlocking plants where
the tracks are not too complicated to
permit, it is now usual to put in elec-
tric locking of the levers so that a sig-
nalman cannot open a derail and ditch
a train after the home signal has once
been cleared for a train to proceed. This
locking my be called a very necessary
safety device, as some of the worst acci-
dents occurring at interlocking plants
have been caused by taking away the sig-
nals and opening derails when a train
was so close to the derail that it wa5
not able to stop before being ditched.
The Railway Porter's flistake.
As the porter passed through the car
she called him aside. There was a whis-
per and a gleam of silver.
"Now, remember, they are in the yel-
low satchel."
"Cyan't miss dem, ma'am."
"You won't let any one see you?'
"No, ma'am!"
"The Major is sitting in that car."
"He won't see me, ma'am."
"Well, here is the key."
The porter took the key and passed
through to the next car.
"Guess dis am it," he said, slipping the
thin key in the lock of a yellow satchel.
He put his hand in the satchel and pulled
out a bunch of hair. Then he relocked
the satchel.
"Heah's yo' frizzos, ma'am!"
"Don't speak so loud."
"Anything else, ma'am?"
"That's all, I believe. I just have a
minute to put these on before dinner."
The purler reached the platform in
time to meet an irate tragedian.
"Not a step!" he thundered, in tones
that almost lifted the porter's cap. "What
have you done with my whiskers, boy?"
"Your whiskers, sah?"
"Yes, my false beard. The passengers
say you opened my satchel with a skele-
ton key. Where arc those whiskers?"
"Laws!" muttered the porter. "Ah
went in the wrong satchel."
Just then a lady passed toward the din-
ing car.
"Dab's yo' wiskcrs, sah!" grinned the
porter. "Dn lop ob dat lady's head."
— Chicago Daily AVtcs.
The Pedrail, or Steam Morse.
It is well known that Nature's great
pulling machine, the horse, possesses a
hauling power altogether out of propor-
tion to his weight. Mr. B. J. Diplock
ROWELL-rOTTER AUTOMATIC BLOCK
SIGN.\L.
(Ptiotographed by VV. H. Elliott. 1
has recently patented a traction engine
that has something of the horse about
it. This new species of steam ''animal"
is called the Pedrail. On the main axle
is keyed a disk, and mounted on one side
of this disk are 16 spokes capable of mo-
tion to and from the center. The spokes
move round with the disc, but a spring
attached to each keeps them normally
drawn toward the center. On the end of
each spoke is a foot, or. as it might be
called, a circular hoof, pivoted by a ball
and socket joint, so that it can turn
through any reasonable angle. To this
hoof is attached a roller, which comes up
beside the disc on the other side from
the spokes. The projecting spokes,
each shod with a foot or hoof, if one may
say so, causes the vehicle to advance
when the disk is revolved, just as a
wheel made with spokes and no rim
would do.
In order to carry the weight of the
machine, the axle box has attached to its-
underside a lever pivoted in the center,
but capable of a certain amount of up-
and-down movement in a slot. This
lever has two springs at either end
which grasp the ends of a similar levci
which rests on top of the box and which
is also pivoted about the center and this
upper one is attached to the box by
spring and carries the weight. The
lower pivoted lever rests on top of two
or three of the rollers, as tliey are suc-
cessively passed under it. The pedrail,
therefore, really carries a short rail under
its axle box, and it permits the "feet"
to firmly plant themselves on the ground
and by means of rollers and "rail," moves
forward. The system of levers, being
pivoted and connected by springs, per-
mits of inequalities on the road being
passed over. Two guides at each end of
the so-called "rail" keep the rollers from
striking it on the end and always pass
them underneath.
A steam horse, with feet behind push-
ing the wheeled vehicle along, was made
in the early days of locomotive construc-
tion, but the boiler unfortunately burst
with disastrous results, and the "steam
horse" method of locomotion was aban-
doned.
Northern Pacific Tandems.
The confessions which we receive from
trainmen on the Northern Pacific lead lis
to infer that the "battleships," as ihey cal)
the tandem compounds, are far from being
popular. The leading objection to the
engines is that they devour too mucb
coal. The remedy for this would be to
equip the engines with automatic stokers.
The engines appear to be highly efficient
in hauling heavy trains, and their enor-
mous capacity enables them to haul a ton
at less cost than any other class of en-
gines, and all that is necessary to make
them popular is a mechanical stoker.
The great power of these engines was
shown by a head-on collision some time
ago. One of the giants ran into a train
drawn by two smaller engines. The small
locomotives were reduced to scrap, while
the "battleship" escaped with a smashed
pilot. For the convenience of the train
crews, the load to be hauled by these en-
gines has been fixed at 900 tons for the
maximum.
The passenger department of the Rock
Island has received four new cafe-obser-
vation cars for use on the El Paso line.
The cars have six tables, seating 18 peo-
ple, and an observation end that is com-
modious and comfortable. One advan-
tage of this class of cars is that passen-
gers can secure meals at all hours.
31
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. Arthur Hale has been appointed
general superintendent of transportation
on the Baltimore & Ohio, vice Mr. J. C.
Stuart, resigned.
Mr. P. J. Raidy has been appointed
chief train dispatcher of the New Castle
division of the B. & O., to succeed J. R.
Lusk, promoted.
Mr. J. A. Chisholm has been appointed
•chief engineer of the Mexican Great
Eastern Railway, with headquarters in
the City of Mexico.
Mr. E. H. Doherty has been appoint-
ed traveling engineer on the P. & I. and
M. C. division of the Lake Erie and
Western Railroad.
Mr. Bruce W. Duer has been appointed
superintendent of the Pittsburg division
of the Baltimore & Ohio, vice Mr. S. P.
Hutchinson resigned.
Mr. B. F. Flory has been appointed
to the position of mechanical engineer of
the Lehigh Valley Railroad, vice Mr.
F. F. Gaines, promoted.
Mr. John Haines, engineer on the
Ohio Central, has been appointed as-
sistant road foreman of engines on the
same line under Mr. Engler.
Mr. W. C. Loree has been appointed
superintendent of the Chicago division
of the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, vice
Mr. D. D. Carothers, promoted.
Mr. Charles E. Dafoe has been ap-
pointed superintendent of Northwest Di-
vision of the Chicago Great Western
Railway, vice Mr. J. A. Kelly, resigned.
Mr. C. E. Brittingham has been ap-
pointed traveling engineer and train-
master on the St. Louis, Kansas City &
Colorado, with headquarters at Union,
Mo.
Mr. George Reed has been appointed
chief train dispatcher of the Toledo and
Lima Division of the Cincinnati, Hamil-
ton & Dayton, vice Mr. J. H. Louy, re-
signed.
Mr. Charles S. Weston has been ap-
pointed superintendent of Wisconsin,
Minnesota & Pacific division of the Chi-
cago Great Western, vice Mr. C. E. Da-
foe, transferred.
Mr. K. P. Alexander has been ap-
pointed master mechanic of the Fort
Smith & Western Railroad, in charge
of all equipment, with headquarters at
Fort Smith, Ark.
Mr. G. W. Creighton. general superin-
tendent of the Buffalo and Allegheny
Division of the Pennsylvania, has been
appointed general superintendent of the
Altonna Division,
Mr. J. B. Dickson, assistant engineer
maintenance of way on the Baltiinore &
Ohio Railroad, has been appointed en-
gineer maintenance of way, vice Mr. M.
L. Byers, promoted.
Mr. C. P. Chamberlain, assistant en-
gineer on the Chicago Great Western,
has been appointed division engineer at
Des Moines, la., vice Mr. E. P. Mobley,
assigned to other duties.
Mr. C. E. Brown, heretofore foreman
at O'Keene, O. T., on the St. Louis &
San Francisco Railroad, has been trans-
ferred to Neodesha, Kan., vice Mr. W.
E. McEldowney, resigned.
Mr. H. J. Underbill, formerly road
foreman of engines of the P. & E. Divi-
sion of the Big Four, has been appoint-
ed train master of the same division, vice
Mr. M. J. Wilson, resigned.
Mr. W. W. Williams, formerly a loco-
motive engineer on the Chicago &
Northwestern, has been appointed train-
master of the M. & D. division, with
headquarters at Huron, S. D.
Mr. R. H. Briggs, formerly master
mechanic on the Southern Railway, has
been appointed division foreman on the
St. Louis & San Francisco Railroad,
with headquarters at St. Louis.
Mr. J, W. Brown, heretofore gang
foreman at the San Bernardino shops
of the Santa Fe, has been promoted to
the position of general foreman of the
company's shops at Needles, Cal.
Mr. S. C. Long, of the River and
Low Grade Divisions of the Pennsyl-
vania, has been appointed superinten-
dent of the Allegheny Valley Division,
vice Mr. R. L. O'Donnel, transferred.
Mr. G. W. Crownover has been pro-
moted to the position of master me-
chanic on the Illinois Central at Free-
port, 111. He was formerly general fore-
man on the same road at Waterloo, la.
Mr. L. G. Haas, formerly general su-
perintendent of the Pittsburg system of
the Baltimore & Ohio, has been ap-
pointed assistant general manager of the
B. & O., with headquarters at Baltimore,
Md.
Mr. Thomas Anderson, general car
foreman of the Wheeling & Lake Erie
shops at Canton, Ohio, has resigned his
position to undertake the management
of the Youngstown Manufacturing Com-
pany.
Mr. R. L. O'Donnel, superintendent
of the Allegheny Valley Division, was
appointed general superintendent of the
Buffalo and Allegheny Division of the
Pennsylvania, vice Mr. G. W. Creighton,
transferred.
Mr. I. G. Ravvn has been appointed
general superintendent at Pittsburg, on
the Baltimore & Ohio, with jurisdiction
over the Connellsville, Pittsburg, New
Castle, Cleveland and Newark divisions,
vice Mr. L. G. Haas, promoted.
Mr. J. H. Goggin, formerly yard mas-
ter of the Chicago Yards and Terminal
at Chicago, 111., becomes assistant to
Yardmaster Barry, of the New Castle
division of the B. & O., with headquar-
ters at New Castle Junction, Pa.
Mr. E. T. Canfield, formerly master
car builder on the Delaware, Lacka-
wanna & Western, has accepted service
with the American Car & Foundry Com-
pany. His resignation was accepted with
much regret by the Lackawanna.
Mr. Charles Gabriel, who for the past
eight years has been road foreman of
engines on the Hocking Valley, has ac-
cepted the position of superintendent ot
machinery with the Tombstone Consoli-
dated Mining Company of Arizona.
Mr. J. R. Lusk, formerly assistant su-
perintendent of the P. & W., and later
chief train dispatcher of the New Castle
division of the B. & O., has been ap-
pointed assistant train master, with head-
quarters at New Castle Junction, Pa.
Mr. J. H. Burns has succeeded Mr. T.
H. Yorke as division master mechanic
on the Chicago Great Western at Du-
buque, la., and Mr. T. H. Yorke has been
made division master mechanic at Fort
Dodge, vice Mr. Geo. Gregory, resigned.
Mr. L. T. Ford, at present assistant
engineer of the Philadelphia Division of
the Pennsylvania Railroad, has been ap-
pointed superintendent of -the Chautau-
qua Division of the Allegheny Valley
Railroad, vice Mr. C. B. Dabney, trans-
ferred.
Mr. Miles Gibson has been appointed
road foreman of engines on the Big Four
to succeed Mr. H. J. Underbill, pro-
moted. Mr. Gibson has been fifteen years
on the road and has the reputation of
being one of the best enginemen in the
service.
Mr. C. B. Dabney, superintendent of
the Chautauqua Division of the Alle-
gheny Valley Railroad, has been appoint-
ed superintendent of what is known as
the River and Low Grade Division of the
Pennsylvania, vice Mr. S. C. Long,
transferred.
Mr. Lewis t)hlinger, superintendent of
the Richmond Division of the Pennsyl-
vania, will succeed Mr. W. C. Loree as
superintendent of the Indianapolis Divi-
sion. Mr. Otto Schroll, superintendent
of terminals at Wheeling, will succeed
Mr. Ohlinger at Richmond. Mr. A. L.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
35
Morgan, engineer of maintenance of way
on the Pittsburg Division, has been ap-
pointed superintendent of the Wheeling
terminals.
Mr. M. L. Byers, engineer mainten-
ance of Way on the Baltimore & Ohio,
has been appointed assistant to the gen-
eral manager. He will assist his chief
in matters pertaining to the analysis of
operations and the analysis and control
of expenses in all the departments.
Mr. J. A. Middleton, second vice-presi-
dent of the Erie, has been appointed as-
sistant to Mr. E. B. Thomas, the new
president of the Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company. Mr. Middleton will have gen-
eral direction of both the Lehigh Valley
Railroad and the Lehigh Valley coal
companies.
Mr. E. ']'. Horn, late oi tlie Canada
Midland, was appointed assistant to the
general superintendent, with headquar-
ters at Pittsburg, Pa. Part of Mr. Horn's
work will be the planning and straight-
ening out of new and old yards, and
classifying freight, with a view to reduc-
ing delays in yards.
Mr. C. F. McDermott, who has been
in the service of the B. & O. for about
30 years, and who was division master
mechanic of the Chicago division of that
road, witli headquarters at Garrett.
Indiana, has resigned, and his place is
now filled by Mr. J. H. Tinker, master
mechanic of the Pennsylvania lines at
South Amboy, N. J.
Employees of the Pennsylvania Rail-
road about Pittsburg gave a very hand-
some Christmas gift to Mr. R. P. Pit-
cairn, assistant to the President. It was
a grandfather's clock which cost $2,000.
About 1,000 persons witnessed the pres-
entation, many of them having worked
under Mr. Pitcairn, who was a remarka-
bly popular superintendent.
Mr. A. E. Long has been appointed
acting superintendent on the Great
Northern Railway, in place of Mr. B. F.
Egan, whose fate has been uncertain.
Mr. Egan went on a hunting expedition
in the mountains several weeks ago, and
though search has since been carried on
steadily by over 200 men, no trace has
yet been found of the missing man.
Mr. C. A. Moore, of Manning, Max-
well & Moore, is indulging himself in a
well earned holiday, which will last
about six months. He has taken his
family abroad, and will visit many
strange places before he returns. The
party are spending part of the winter in
Egypt, from whence they \\\U go to
India, and perhaps China and Japan.
Mr. J. H. O'Neill, formerly train mas-
•ter of the Great Northern at Great Falls,
has been appointed superintendent of the
Montana division of the road with head-
■quarters at Havre. He succeeds Mr. A.
E. Long, recently appointed superinten-
dent of the Kalispell division. Mr.
O'Neill has been in the employ of the
company for many years, having com-
menced as brakeman, serving as tlirough
train service brakeman and conductor.
Mr. W. H. Marshall, general superin-
tendent of the Lake Shore, will probably
be appointed general manager of that
property, and Mr. H. S. Storrs, assistant
general superintendent of the Lake
Shore, will likely be promoted to the
position of general superintendent. It
is also said that Mr. J. C. Nutt, superin-
tendent of the Burlington's Iowa line,
lias resigned to take service with the
Lake Shore, and is slated to succeed
Mr. Storrs in his present position.
John P. ndntosh.
People who arc acquainted with rail-
way matters in the British Isles are
aware that the subject of the above en-
graving, Mr. John F. Mcintosh, locomo-
Jt)II?; V. ]Mi:I-\TOSH.
tive superintendent of the Caledonian
Railway, took the lead in introducing
heavy locomotives and heavy freight cars
into Scotland. His lead in this work is
now receiving much following by other
railway companies, but Mr. Mcintosh
deserves the credit of taking the initi-
ative in this great reform.
Mr. Mcintosh rose to his present posi-
tion of locomotive superintendent of the
Caledonian Raihvay through the shop
and the footboard. His experience was
much the same as many of our officials
have gone through, who passed through
the grades of traveling engineer, general
foreman, master mechanic, and assistant
superintendent of motive power before
reaching the top. The writer and Mr.
Mcintosh were associated together at
one time on the same division, and we
lodged in the same house. We were
both ambitious to "get on," and no doubt
reflected upon each other the powerful
influence of mutual aspirations.
Mr. S. P. Hutchinson, formerly super-
intendent of the Pittsburg division of
the Baltimore & Ohio at Pitsburg, Pa.,
has been appointed assistant to the gen-
eral superintendent of the Michigan Cen-
tral, with headquarters at Detroit, Mich.
Mr. B. W. Ducrr, recently appointed as-
sistant to Mr. J. C. Stuart, general su-
perintendent of transportation, will have
his headquarters at Pittsburg, Pa. He
succeeds Mr. Hutchinson as superin-
tendent of the Pittsburg division.
We arc pleased to notice that our
friend, Mr. E. W. Pratt, who has been
for some time master mechanic of the
Chicago & Northwestern Railway, at
Mason City, Iowa, has been appointed
successor to Mr. S. A. Teal, for years
head of the mechanical department of
the Fremont, Elkhart and Missouri Val-
ley Railway. Mr. Pratt has been one of
the best friends of Railway and Loco-
.\i0TiVE Engineering, and was for years
a very successful agent for the paper.
The system he now has charge of com-
prises 1400 miles in Nebraska, Wyoming
and South Dakota. We have no doubt
that Mr. Pratt will achieve as much suc-
cess in the wider field which he is called
upon to manage as he met with as divi-
sion master mechanic.
Among the changes recently effected
in the official staff of the Pennsylvania
Railroad, Mr. A. W. Gibbs has been ad-
vanced to be general superintendent of
motor power, succeeding Mr. Atterbury.
made general manager. We do not
mean to disparage any of the men who
have been passed over by the promotion
of Mr. Gibbs, but we think the appoint-
ment a remarkably wise one. The con-
spicuous characteristic of Mr. Gibbs as
a mechanical engineer is sound good
sense, with a conservative tendency that
will prevent the company from paying
expensive tribute to false gods. It was
only a short time ago that Mr. Gibbs
was advanced from assistant mechanical
engineer to be superintendent of motive
power of the Philadelphia, Wilmington
& Baltimore, a position he has been fill-
ing very successfully. Mr. Gibbs has en-
joined considerable experience outside of
the Pennsylvania Railroad, which in-
creases his resources as a designer and
as an executive officer.
In February last, Mr. J. F. Deems left
the position of superintendent of motive
power of the Chicago, Burlington &
Quincy, to become general manager of
the Schenectady Locomotive Works. He
achieved decided success in managing
that great manufacturing establishment,
but he is now leaving it to become gen-
eral superintendent of all the Vanderbilt
lines, a position similar to that held by
Mr. T. N. Ely on the Pennsylvania sys-
tem. Mr. Deems possesses in an emi-
nent degree the qualities which push men
upwards. The success he has attained
has been laboriously worked for. He
36
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 190J.
worked his way through college by
teaching school; then he entered the
B. & O. shops as special machinist ap-
prentice. From there he went to the
C, B, & Q., and began work as a ma-
chinist; but very soon was advanced to
gang boss. Steadily he went upwards,
until he became superintendent of motive
power. The first time the writer heard
Mr. Deems speak, in the Master Me-
chanics' Convention in 1894, the reflec-
tion came — that man will be a leader
some day. The prediction has come true.
run from Clinton to Boone (202 miles),
and from Boone to Omaha (156 miles).
Mr. Chapman has seen all this improve-
ment in his service with the C. & N. W.
Ry. Co. Before going to the North-
Western, he was with the C, B. & Q.
Ry. five years. So we can see he is an
old settler.
W. C. Chapman.
Hosts of railroad men will recognize
the portrait of Mr. W. C. Chapman, who
was for years traveling engineer
on the Fremont, Elkhorn &
Missouri Valley Railroad. Mr.
Chapman is wonderfully well in-
formed on everything pertaining
to railway rolling stock. He has
been the agent for Railway and
Locomotive Engineering for a
a long time and made a great
success of the business.
Mr. Chapman commenced
work for the Chicago & North-
western Ry. Company in Octo-
ber, 1863, working in Clinton
shops, Iowa, and running a loco-
motive until 1865, when he was
put in charge of shops at Wood-
bine. Iowa. He stayed at that
point until August, 1866. when he
was transferred to Dunlap. Iowa,
in charge of the shops, until 1882;
next, he was transferred to Eagle
Grove, Iowa, in charge of the
shops of the Northern Iowa Di-
vision of the C. & N. W. Ry. He %
remained on this division until
February, 1888, when he was
transferred to the Fremont, Elk-
horn & Missouri Valley Ry., a
system of the Chicago & North-
western Ry. He was in charge of
shops atChadron and Fremont for
three years, after which he was
appointed traveling engineer for
the whole system of the F., E. &
M. V. Ry., 1,408 miles of railway.
He held this with an assistant west
of Long Pine, Neb., until April,
1902, when he was retired on a pension,
being with that company for nearly 40
years. During the last ten years he had
e.xamined nearly 1,200 men on I, 2 and
3-years Mechanical and Air Brakes.
When he commenced on that road (C. &
N. W.), the railway was running only to
Marshalltown, Iowa, 150 miles west of
the Mississippi river. Now it is double-
track through to the Missouri river.
The L^nion Pacific was not thought of at
this time (1863). Engineers then ran from
Clinton, Iowa, to Cedar Rapids, Iowa
(82 miles), the first day; to Marshalltown,
the next day, and the third day back to
Clinton (150 miles). Now engineers
To Vanquish the Hudson River.
The Hudson river has long stood like
a wide chasm cutting off the island of
Manhattan on which New York city is
built from the New Jersey shore from
where nearly all railroads running to the
West and South have their termini. A
few months ago the Pennsylvania Rail-
W. C. CHAPMAN.
road Company astonished New Yorkers
by the announcement that they intended
to tunnel under the Hudson and carry
their tracks underground to a great sta-
tion to be built nearly as far north as the
Grand Central Station of the New York
Central.
Various schemes had been proposed for
bridging the Hudson, but they all came
to nothing.
Now that an earnest endeavor is on, to
take trains into New York, other railroad
companies are following the lead of the
Pennsylvania, among them the Erie.
Rumor says others are moving in the
same direction.
Peat-Fuel Briquettes Successful in
Canada.
In view of the grave anxieties which
the fuel problem has recently excited, it
is of more than passing interest to leam
from the U. S. Consul at Toronto that
peat briquettes may be produced in Can-
ada ready for shipment at a maximum
manufacturing cost of $1.50 per ton. He
says: "There is, however, some differ-
ence of opinion as to the length oi time
a given weight of peat briquettes will
burn, as compared with the same weight
of anthracite; theoretically, the heat
units in peat being fewer, it may be ar-
gued, it must burn out faster; but with
effective control of drafts, it is surprising
how nearly its lasting quality ap-
proaches that of hard coal, due
doubtless to the fact that more
perfect combustion is usually had
in the burning of peat under or-
dinary conditions, the waste in
burning coal certainly being
greater than in peat briquettes,
both fuels being fired by meth-
ods in common use."
This peat fuel has been made
at the property of the Peat In-
dustries, Limited, near Welland,.
Ont., and at the Berner bog by
the Stratford Peat Company. It
is expected that next spring will
see considerable activity in peat-
fuel manufacturing in Canada.
If, as Mr. Gunsaulus tells us, it
nearly approaches hard coal irr
lasting qualities, there may be a
future for it as locomotive fuel,
while its price would commend it
everywhere.
Round the World Telegraph.
Sir Sandford Flemming, living,
at Ottawa, Canada, recently sent
a message by the new "All Red''
cable to the Mayor of Ottawa,
who lives a few streets away, witb
the request that the operators
along the line insert the local
time of receiving the cable. The mes-
sage belted the world, passing over
land entirely of British territory, in.
six hours and three minutes, thus
beating former records by four hours.
Supposing the telegram had been
a material object and had traveled round'
the equator, a distance of 25,000 miles, it
would have gone forward at an average
rate of 6S.87 miles per minute, or 4,132.2
miles an hour.
Be diligent, work for a steady inde-
pendence and be happy. — Dombey and
Son.
We understand that Mr. W. P. Apple-
yard, M. C. B. of the N. Y., N. H & H.
Railroad, is putting his patented copper
covering on 150 passenger cars. The
Underground Railroad Company of New
York have arranged to cover 500 of their
cars with copper as a means of making
them fireproof.
January, I'JO^.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
37
Kvolution of the Locomotive Boiler.
IIY O. II. RKVNOLIJS.
It may scciii like a wide stretch of fer-
tile imaginative powers to even try to
•establisli a connection between tlie crude
devices fur generating steam of the time
of Hero, tlie Alexandrian philosopher,
and earlier periods (for the force of
steam was known to remote antiquity)
and the locomotive boiler of tlie present
day, but it will not be denied that the
simple vessels of the ancients were the
germs from which has grown the steam
generators of the world's industries. The
present state of the art has, however,
been attained by the crystallization of
the best thought of only lOO years, for it
was in 1802 that Richard Trevithick pat-
ented the principle of the non-condens-
ing high-pressure engine, the purpose
of which was to haul vohiclos on rail-
flue 20 inches in diameter, passing from
end to end. In the previous year Wil-
liam Hedley, chief engineer of Wylam
colliery, near Newcastle, had built a
locomotive with a return flue boiler, an
improvement on that used by Trevithick.
That boiler was entirely satisfactory as
a steam generator for the slow speed of
MR. O. H. REYNOLDS.
Engineer.
ways by the expansive force of steam;
and while there was little resemblance
between the first boiler built under that
patent to those following — it being of
such insignificant proportions as to be
carried low down and at the back of the
rear axle — yet from this bellows drafted
boiler sprang the monster locomotive
boiler of 1903. In 1803, Trevithick built
an engine for the Merthyr-Tydvil Rail-
way, in Wales, having a cylindrical boiler
with a return flue and furnace inside. In
this boiler was probably made the first
attempt to utilize the exhaust steam to
induce draft, by diverting it into the
stack. There appears to have been little
progress made in boiler design from 1803
to 1814. attention seemingly having been
centered on various methods of propul-
sion, but in the latter year George Ste-
phenson built an engine at the Killing-
worth Colliery having a cylindrical
boiler 34 inches in diameter and 96 inches
in length. This boiler had one internal
combustion by passing the exhaust
through the stack, notwithstanding the
idea was tried 23 years before, and had
been used with varying degrees of suc-
cess, even having been abandoned pre-
vious to 1825, as detrimental to fuel
economy, although it was conceded to be
a great aid to combustion. This event
TKKVITIIICK'S RETURN FI.fR BOII.EK.
coal trains. That Trevithick's boiler had marked the most important step in boiler
little influence on pioneer locomotives construction, being the first real im-
was due to the fact that its designer did provement afTecting the steaming ca-
not follow up the work of locomotive pacity of the locomotive boiler, .Much
building. thought had been given to the subject of
The progress made in boiler improve- •'raft, but most of the experiments
nients was necessarily slow from 1814 to seemed to have been devoted to fans to
SEGtTIN'.S MULTITrnUL.'VR BOILER, 1827.
1827, as the locomotive had simply to
keep pace with the demands of the time
for motive power, and as these demands
contemplated nothing but freight move-
ment, and that at not more than 3 to 8
miles an hour, the boilers then in use
HACKWORTH'S RETURN FLUE BOILER.
Used in " Nonpareil " Engine, that was in com-
petition with Rocket. 182.1. Fie i on Table.
gain the object sought. The passing of
the exhaust steam into the stack for the
purpose of inducing draft on the fire, as
then applied, has not been improved on,
except in minor details, the principle re-
Railway ^ Litemnotivtt Enginttr'mg
STEPHENSON'S ROCKET,
fairly served their purpose. The disposi-
tion of the time, to make no radical de-
parture from existing types of boilers,
is shown in the engine Royal George,
built by Timothy Hackworth, one of the
ablest of the pioneer locomotive design-
ers. This boiler was also cylindrical, 52
ins. in diameter, by 13 ft. in length, with
an internal tube, in which the fire grate
was carried. It was on this engine that ~
the exhaust pipe was first made to pro-
duce satisfactory results in stimulating
-CL_^
1829. Fig. 1 on Table.
BOILER OF ERICSSON'S NOVELTY.
Fig. 3 on Table.
35
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
maining to-day practically the same as heat to the water surrounding it. Crude
perfected by Timothy Hackworth in 1827, as this may appear, such a boiler made
who, at this time, also made some ex- steam rapidly enough for slow work of
periments in feed-water heating, by turn- the time, but could hardly be termed an
ing the exhaust at will from the stack economical device, and the investigators
liURY BOILER, 1S40. Fig. i on Table.
into a reservoir carried at the front of the
boiler. The builders demonstrated their
original ideas in numerous other direc-
tions at this period, among them being
the application of the feed pump, and
spring loaded safety valves to this boiler.
The pump is still in use as a boiler feeder,
set about producing a boiler with more
heating surface, and therefore a higher
evaporation, which from their reasoning
could best be furnished by an increased
tube surface. To M. Seguin, an eminent
French engineer, is due the honor of ap-
plying this system to locomotive boilers,
applying, in 1827, the multi-tubular
idea should, however, be given to
Stevens, of Hoboken, N. J., for
original thought in this direction,
for in 1825 he had ■ built a small
railway, on which to experiment with
his conception of a locomotive. The
boiler brought out was of the vertical
type, having tubes I 1-4 inches in diam-
eter, being no doubt the genesis of our
small stationary boilers, to which it was
quite similar. The problem of rapid
transmission of heat, on which the evap-
orative efficiency of the locomotive
boiler depended, was found in the multi-
tubular principle, which has been the
standard form on succeeding boilers.
Boiler history was rapidly made from
this time on. the greatest incentive to
which, perhaps, was the premium offered
by the Liverpool & Manchester Railway
in 1829, for the best locornotive engine.
-0—0- o — 0-5- o-
0~ O -O — O
I I
n"ri|
0—0— » - O l|
©-
STANDARD iOCOMOTlVH BOILER OF )Kr.5. Fig. 5 on Table.
although nearly displaced by the injec-
tor, but the spring-loaded safety valves
remain in a modified form to remind us
that Hackworth was building wiser than
he knew when perfecting his machine.
Boiler development up to 1827 con-
templated the cylindrical form with a
combustion tube, as touching the limit
of possibilities. This tube, extending
from the grate and being continuous, was
elevated at front so to form a high
stack, receiving the flame and gases
which were supposed to impart their
he, leaving the old traditions and reach-
ing into, to him, an untried field, and
revolutionizing boiler design. This
he did on an engine furnished from
England by Stephenson, which was
of the single flue type. A prac-
tical trial of the idea showed the
accuracy of Seguin's reasoning, when
he gave to us the multi-tubular arrange-
ment, the principle of which is used to-
day on every locomotive. In this con-
nection, it should be said that Seguin used
the fan to urge the fire. Credit of first
The conditions to be met in the trials
were for that time of the most rigorous
character, among which was one that
the boilers should consume their own
smoke. What food for reflection for the
cloud-producers of the twentieth century
to read these lines, and be reminded that
these pioneers were expected to give re-
sults that require expert treatment to
produce to-day. There were three en-
gines entered for this contest, namely,
the Rocket, built by Robert Stephenson,
the boiler of this engine being 40 inches
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
V)
in diameter and "2 inches long, with 25
tubes 3 inches in diameter. The firebox
was 24 inches long by 36 inches wide and
43 inches deep inside. The grate surface
was 6 sq. ft., the firebox heating surface
was 20 sq. ft. and that of the tubes 117.75
sq. ft. This was the first multi-tubular boil-
er built in ICngland. These proportions, it
may be well to say here, were remark-
ably near to correct modern design for
the cylinders of this engine, a result
which was, of course, purely accidental,
as nothing was known at that time about
heating surface requirements, except in
the most vague way.
36 ft. long. The healing surface of this
firebox was 9.5 sq. ft., that of tube was
33 sq. ft., while the grate area was 1.8
sq. ft. Here was as widely a differing
lot of types as could well be imagined,
entered for a trial that was to determine,
not only superiority for that occasion,
but was to settle for the future the gen-
eral design of the locomotive boiler.
The results of the trials show the Rocket
to be the only engine to make the 70
miles constituting the runs. The Rock-
et's average evaporation was 5.34 pounds
of water per pound of coke, against an
average evaporation of 2.2 lbs. of water
pursuing an ignis faluiis, as will be
shown by the evaporation data for these
engines, which had 306 and 283.8 square
feet of flue heating surface, respectively,
as against the 1 17.8 square feet of the
Rocket, and an evaporation of 6.64 lbs.
per pound of coke for the Phoenix, with
9.61 lbs. for the Arrow. In the competi-
tive trials, while the evaporation of the
Rocket was far above the other boilers,
the results as then obtained were im-
proved upon afterward by decreasing the
diameter of exhaust tip for the purpose
of stimulating the draft. The light thus
gained on drafting was no doubt made
Amt'icaii Madtin'itt
NEW YORK CENTR.\I, BOILKR, I'.Wl. Fig. C on Table.
The second engine, the Sanspareil,
built by Timothy Hackworth, had a cyl-
indrical boiler 6 feet long and 50 inches
in diameter, with a single tube 24 inches
in diameter at the grate and 15 inches at
stack, having a return bend. The firebox
heating surface was 15.7 sq. ft., and grate
area was 10 sq. ft., while the tube heating
surface was 74,6 sq. ft. The third engine
in the contest was the Novelty, built by
Braithwaite and Ericsson. The boiler of
this engine was a wonderfully complex
afTair, having a vertical firebox sur-
rounded by water, and one tube 4 inches
in diameter, immersed in a horizontal
section of the boiler, through which it
passed three times by return bends be-
fore entering the stack, the flue being
made by the Sanspareil. There is no
record of the boiler performance of the
Novelty, that engine having suffered
from a number of break-downs. Enough
data was, however, deduced to firmly en-
trench the niulti-tubular type of boiler
in its place as the correct thing for use
with the locomotive. This belief was
confirmed at once by the Stephensons on
two later engines (1829-30), the Phoenix
and Arrow, each of which had a greater
tube heating surface than their predeces-
sor, the Rocket, the grate areas and fire-
box heating surfaces remaining the same.
The beneficial results from the increased
heating surface were at once apparent,
giving all the evidence needed to con-
vince the experimenter that he was not
use of on the Phoenix and Arrow and
other of Stephenson's engines of 1829-30.
The success of Robert Stephenson ir»
these trials indicates fully the depth of
resource of the man — his ability to take-
advantage of means to ends, as was evi-
denced by his adoption of Trevithick's
and Hackworth's scheme of induced
blast from the exhaust, the one essential
necessary to the success of his multi-
tubular boiler.
Hackworth, still loyal to his single
flue idea for a boiler, had his engine
Globe built at Stephenson's in 1829-30.
This boiler was fitted with a series of
small circulating tubes placed in the
single flue, a design which was found to
make an excellent lodging place for sedi-
40
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
merit, but the lioiler deserves mention
only from the fact that it had a copper
dome on the top, the first locomotive
boiler to be fitted with a steam dome,
with the view to a drier steam supply.
The same brain worked out some new
boilers in 1830, which contemplate a sin-
gle flue opening into a combustion cham-
ber, from which the gases of combustion
were conveyed to the smoke box by a se-
ries of small tubes. This boiler was said
to be remarkably long-lived and a free
steamer. TIackworth has left the im-
press of his genius on many locomotive
details, but those applying to the boiler,
as enumerated in the foregoing, have
won a place at the top of the honor scroll
for his name.
Another aspirant for fame in locomo-
tion design appeared in 1830 in the per-
son of Mr. Edward Bury, who proceeded
to embody some original thoughts of his
own, and also of his contemporaries, in
an engine built for the Liverpool & Man-
chester Railway. Bury was not slow to
adopt and use the steam dome on this
and his subsequent engines. The design
and proportions of this dome were such
as mark the inventor's personality, he
having been the first to give any sem-
blance of liberality to this important de-
tail of the boiler. There is not anv doubt
about the purpose of these large Bury
domes — they were designed for a steam
reservoir, and filled that function most
admirably. This type of boiler had an
extensive iollowing for several years, it
having been copied in England in 1838,
and in America by the Norris's in 1840,
and also by Stephenson in 1846. It was
again given a vogue by American build-
ers about 1850, after which the rectangu-
lar firebox and separate domes became
recognized as the standard form of con-
struction.
Among tlie improvements in boiler de-
sign may be cited the abandonment of
the crown bar for radial staying, and the
Amtiiea-i ,tfacftiiMt
A MODERN LOCOMOTIVE BOILER WITH WIDE FIRE-BOX. Fig. 9 on Table.
LOCOMOTIVE BOILERS, FIRST AND LAST.
Eig.
Build.
Cyl.
Pres-
sure
No. of
Tubes
Dia.
Tubes
in.
Length
Tubes, ft.
H S.
Tubes
.sq. It.
H. S. H. S. Grate
Fire box Total area,
sq. ft. Isq. ft.|sq. ft.
1
Stephenson
1829
8xi6>^
50
25
3
6
117.75
20
137-75
A
2
Hackworth
1S29
7x18
50
I
24
4 ft. 2in.
74.6
15.7
90.3
10
3
4
-5
Ericsson
1829
Bury
1840
Standard
IS-T
one cyl.
6x12
17x24
50
90
140
36
96
168
4
2
2
36
9
II ft. 6 in.
33
452
1123
9-5
52
119
42,5
504
1242
1. 8
10
17
■6'
Am. Loco. Co.
21x26
200
396
2
i6
3325
180
3505
50.3
7
Am. Loco. Co.
1902
22x26
200
309
2
14
2272
193
2466
34-5
8
Am. Loco. Co.
1902
21x32
210
396
2
i5ft.2>sin.
3159
188
3347
62.18
9
Am. Loco. Co.
1901
22x30
190
462
2
14 ft. 3 in.
3423
238
3661
.90
close attention given the strength of riv-
eted joints, which are invariably of the
butt joint type with welt strips for the
longitudinal seams, giving an efficiency of
nearly or quite go per cent, of the solid
plate; this care in construction being, of
course, due to the high pressures now
necessary. The boilers herewith illus-
trated tell their mute tale of progress
from the days of 50 pounds pressure of
the early ones, to the 225 pounds of the
latest product of the American Locomo-
tive Company, the latter being selected
to show average modern practice in lo-
comotive boiler construction.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
41
A Chance for Inventors and the Ablest
Chemist.
The following puragraph is from the
■editorial page of one of the largest and
most influential of our metropolitan dail-
ies. It says: "Suicides and accidental
deaths from inhaling gas arc now so
frequent that it may not be fanta;Uic to
suggest to the ablest chemists that they
■may perhaps benefit the race by looking
into the question wlK'thcr nr not it is
variably succumb. Arise, ablest chem-
ist, and do soniclhing!
The Safety Car Healing and Lighting
Company of 160 Broadway, New York,
have issued a neatly printed little
brochure on the Pintsch system of Car
and Buoy lighting. The system is of
German origin, having been promoted
,Tnd developed in order to provide a safe
abounding in interesting facts and fig-
ures, will be given away free by the com-
pany upon application.
The American Brake Shoe and Foun-
ilry Company, of 170 Broadway, New
York, have issued an illustrated pam-
phlet on steel castings made bv the
"Tropenas" process. This process is one
of the many methods of converting pig
lll!>-i Shcef-
Lc'iitfth ov<.-r all
I- - C(i;{ Sheet — j ' '">'/>•' (!>o'«yi'
■ '-1U -309-2 TubM--
' liaiiway ^
L'je'jnt-/(it4 t.tjti.nr\ng
ABOVE FRAMES, IOWA CENTRAL, V.IH. Fig. 7 on Table.
,^^ ^
itaiUrag i iMUtmatvM Emgim^friaf
BROOKS BELP.\IRE. Fig. 8 ou Table.
possible to supply gas for lighting and
heating and cooking not so heavily
charged with deadly poison to human
lungs."
Taken as an example of "Newspaper
Science," this is good. As a matter of
fact, the gas referred to is not poison-
ous, it simply does not contain oxygen,
and free oxygen is necessary to life.
A much wider field would be opened
up for the inventor and for the
ablest chemist, if they would separately
or in conjunction invent and suppiy us
with "non-drowning" water. This harm-
less beverage is not poisonous; it con-
tains oxygen, and yet people who have
their lungs completely filled with it, in-
substitute for oil for the illumination of
railway cars. It is used not only in Eu-
rope, but in India, Africa, South Amer-
ica, and, in fact, in almost every civilizea
country in the world. In the United
States there are no less than 63 Pintsch
gas plants in operation. These stations
have apparatus for the safe storage of
oil, the convcrtion of the oil by fractional
distillation into a fixed gas. and appli-
ances for compressing the gas. The rich-
ness of the gas is such that from 10 to 12
candle-power per cubic foot can be ob-
tained from it, while ordinary city gas,
which has not been subjected to com-
pression, does not give more than :;
candles per cubic foot. This booklet.
iron into refined steel, of which the Bes-
semer process was the original. The
booklet gives information concerning
Tropenas steel, what it is, and what can
be done with it, and details the almost
innumerable variety of small intricate
castings which can be well made of by
the process. The company will cheerful-
ly forward the pamphlet to those who are
anxious for information of this kind, on
application.
Messrs. Dodge & Day, modernizing
engineers, have been commissioned by
their clients, the Heating, Ventilating
and Foundry Co., of Pittsburg, to fully
equip the new plant which is being
erected for that company at Wheeling.
42
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 190J.
Packing.
The word "packing" for the rings of
-pistons originated when braided hemp
or flax was used to make the pistons
steamtight. When the steam engine
first came into use good mechanics were
scarce, and the engineers of that time
had to content themselves with crude
work. Once when James Watt was su-
pervising the fitting up of the cylinder of
a pumping engine, he wrote to Boulton,
his partner, that the cyHnder was so
nearly round he could not put in half a
crown between the gauge and the walls
of the cylinder.
It was cases of this kind which led
to hemp packing. The hemp packing
for the piston was a great improvement
in its day, but it burned out very readily
and the inevitable change was made to
metallic packing. Early engines used
steam pressure ranging from 10 to 5u
pounds. The high steam pressure sorm
drove fibrous packing out of use.
Flax and hemp make fair packing for
piston valve stem and they are still used
on a great many engines. The men who
have engines built with stuffing boxes
made to take in hemp packing are not
wise. It has been demonstrated that
metallic rod packing is cheaper in the
end than fibrous packing. Some kinds
of metallic packing are very unsatisfac-
tory, but all of them are better than
hemp. Engineers employed on heavy
e.xpress train service often have trouble
with leaky glands with the danger and
inconvenience that results therefrom, but
we do not hear of any requests to return
to fibrous packing. Metallic packing is
in harmony with modern ideas and ought
to be preferred to fragile material.
iel Willard, and that they may be also
made part of the printed records of the
Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen as
additional evidence of the appreciation
in which he is held by the Brotherhood.
Thanks to fir. Willard.
Mr. John J. Hannahan, grand master
of the Firemen's Brotherhood, and Mr.
F. N. Gear, a prominent member of
the order, visited New York lately, and
presented to Mr. Daniel Willard, gen-
eral manager of the Erie Railroad, a
beautifully illuminated address, which
reads:
"In the City of Chattanooga, Tennes-
see, in the highest appreciation of the
courtesies extended the delegates and
their families, en route to and from their
convention, adopted the following:
Resolved: That we extend our sin-
cere thanks to Mr. Daniel Willard,
Third Vice-President of the Erie Rail-
road Company, for the courteous treat-
ment accorded the delegates and their
families in furnishing them transporta-
tion to and from their eighth biennial
convention, held at the city of Chat-
tanooga, Tennessee, in September, nine-
teen hundred and two. And be it further
Resolved: That Grand Master Hanna-
han and Grand Secretary and Treasurer
Arnold have these resolutions engrossed
and personally present them to Mr. Dan-
W. W. Atterbury.
The prevailing tendency among the
owners of railroad property to select
managers from men who have passed
through the mechanical department, is
again shown in the appointment of Mr.
William Wallace Atterbury, general su-
perintendent of motive power of the
Pennsylvania Railroad, to be general
manager of that great system, in place
of Mr. J. B. Hutchinson, advanced. Mr.
Atterbury is still a young man, only 36
vears old, and there is a long career of
W. W. ATTERBURY.
usefulness before him with the attendant
honors. He was born at New Albany,
Ind., in 1866, and was educated at Yale.
After graduating he entered the Altoona
shops as a special apprentice, and a few
years later was made assistant road fore-
man of engines, a very instructive line
of advancement. By rapid strides he
went through the rising grades in the
mechanical department, until he rested
for a few years at the head. Now he
moves upward again, and will probably
reach the president's chair.
The newest phase of strike talk is
among the sleeping car porters. They
are resenting the growing practice of
giving ten-cent tips.
Demurrage Charges.
The right of a railway company to-
exact payment for demurrage on cars is.
to be tested in court, and while we have
nothing to say as to the merits of the
particular case in question, it has always
appeared to us inequitable that cars
should be used by consignees as store-
houses, free of rent. The consignee may
or may not be ready for his goods when,
they arrive, but it is generally a matter
of importance for railways to get hold
of their cars promptly, and at this time
when cars are so much in demand, it is
simply imperative that no obstacle be
put in the way of rapid unloading and
freeing of rolling stock. The whole ob-
ject of the "railway car" is transporta-
tion of goods, not storage, and trans-
portation is the thing covered when the
freight rate is paid. Storage is entirely
"Utside and beyond the transportation'
contract, and it is covered by a perfectly
legitimate and well-understood charge
called demurrage, which is a sort of car
rental on the European plan — you pay
for what you get — if you keep the car a
long time you pay in proportion. If you
make a sort of "quick lunch" of it, you.
don't find the European plan much of
a drain on your pocket. The railways
are well within their rights in resisting
the free lunch counter fiend in any guise-
and at all times. Much of the existing
shortage of cars is due to too much of
the free lunch plan.
It must be somewhere written that the
virtues of the mothers shall occasionally
be visited on the children, as well as the
sins of their fathers. — Bleak House.
Sherlock Holmes and Train Speed.
Sherlock Holmes was, on one occa-
sion, able to astonish Dr. Watson with
a remarkably close estimate of the speed-
of a railway train in which both were
traveling. Holmes and his friend were
journeying from London to Tavistock,
tb.e famous English detective having
been engaged on the "Silver Blaze"
case, which involved the mysterious dis-
appearance of the favorite for the Wes-
sex Cup and the death of the trainer.
Dr. Watson, in describing the trip, says:
"We had left Reading far behind when-
Holmes thrust the last of the daily
papers under the seat and offered me
his cigar case. 'We are going well,' he
said looking out of the window and
glancing at his watch, 'our present rate
is 53 1-2 miles an hour.' 'I have not
observed the quarter-mile posts,' I said.
'Nor have I, but the telegraph poles on-
this line are sixty yards apart, and the
calculation is a simple one.' "
In the United States and Canada the
telegraph poles are usually spaced 55,
yards apart, and on the average the num-
ber of rail lengths passed over in 20
seconds gives very nearly the train speed
in miles per hour. The mental calcula-
tion made by Holmes would have been
unnecessary if he had carried one of
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing speed cards.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
43
Ihe Dimpfel Boiler.
1!Y C. 11. CARUTHERS.
The increased use of coal as fuel, be-
tween 1856 and i860, on locomotives
running on the eastern railways of Amer-
ica, led builders and users to seek boil-
ers of types combining large areas of
heating surface with rapid evaporating
qualities.
This naturally resulted in designers
producing a number of different types,
some of which were so obviously im-
practicable that their construction was
limited to the model, others passed
through a brief experimental stage in
actual service, and a few others were
used until the materials required renewal,
when the "special" features were cut out
and the rebuilt boilers were made as far
as possible of the standard types. Al-
though it is very probable that much
valuable information was obtained
through these experiments, and some of
the features are now used in modified
forms, yet not one of the specialized boil-
ers exists in American locomotive prac-
tice.
They are now but a memory, preserved
in drawings, and these drawings are prin-
cipally in old books long out of publica-
tion and hidden in remote shelves of
libraries, from which they occasionally
pass to the ignominious prominence of
a place on the bargain tables of second-
hand bookstores.
One such volume recently came into
my possession under such conditions. It
is entitled. "American and European
Railway Practice," etc., by Alexander L.
Holley.
The boiler illustrated in this article
was known as the Dimpfel boiler. Ex-
ternally, its appearance dilifered only in
two points from other wagon-top boil-'
ers. These points were, the peculiar
pocket under the smoke-box and the
large manhole at the top of the back
boiler head.
Internally, the construction was quite
the reverse of ordinary types.
A curved crown-sheet with its concave
side above was riveted in the usual
manner to a back-sheet and to the side-
sheets. At its forward end. however, it
was riveted to a very slightly curved
sheet with the concave side underneath.
This sheet extended forward to the po-
sition usually occupied by the front tube
sheet. At its sides it was riveted to
sheets curved to a circle described from
the same center as those of the boiler
barrel, but of about 4 inches less radius.
This formed a semi-circular combustion
chamber, which was attached to the outer
shell or barrel by radial stays, and which
was closed at its forward end except in
the center, where an opening about 6
inches wide extended from top to bottom
of the chamber.
The bottom sheet of this combustion
chamber was riveted at its rear end to
the front water leg of the firebox, which,
of course, extended no higher.
The 6-inch opening in the center of the
forward end was riveted to a rectangu-
lar flue which sloped downward at the
bottom, and at a distance of about 8
inches forward of the chamber was at-
tached to a skeleton tube sheet which
was simply a frame containing, besides
this flue, openings for two large plates
covering space opposite the front of
chamber, and for another plate covering
opening into boiler-space above the
chamber. These plates were bolted to
the frame and the upper one contained
the opening for the dry pipe, while the
other two contained handholes fitted
with suitable covers.
The lower sheet of the combustion
chamber was cut out for a short dis-
tance back of the front and connected to
those toward the front amounted to but
lilllc.
l-'roin the front sheets of the combus-
tion chamber 186 tubes, i 1-4 inch outside
diameter, extended backward to the front
of the firebox, where they were curved
upward and entered the crown sheet.
It is said that experiments made by
placing small pieces of metal in the front
of these tubes showed them to have
been drawn backward and upward to the
crown sheet by the intensity of the cir-
culation. This boiler would undoubtedly
steam well, but it was next to impossi-
ble to keep the tubes from leaking, while
the difficulty of access thereto and the
great cost of repairs, combined with
some difficulty in maintaining a working
water level, forbade their renewal in orig-
inal form.
Quite a number were in use at one
ria- s
a sort of sub-passage, which formed an
additional passageway for smoke and
gases from the chamber to the smoke
box.
From the bottom of this sub-chamber
a 6-inch pipe having a trumpet-shaped
opening was carried upward and back-
ward to a point about mid-length of the
combustion chamber, where it entered a
square tube or box standing vertically.
The object of this pipe was evidently
to admit air to the chamber and it is
probable that the vertical pipe or box
marked E contained numerous perfora-
tions, but they are not shown in the
drawing. The part G would appear to
be only a brace or support for the hori-
zontal air inlet, and placed at an angle
probably to prevent injury from expan-
sion.
Four openings were provided as shown
at / / for admission of air to the fire.
These and another opening directly in
the firebox through its front leg, ad-
mitted air in a thin film by means of a
sort of valve, but Mr. Hollev states that
Ra3it>ay f Lvc<»notipt Unffinttring
time on the lines now embraced in the
P. W. & B. R. R. system of the Penn-
sylvania, and I have been informed that
one or two of these exploded. The Penn-
sylvania Railroad Company in 1858 sent
an 18x22 inch Norris engine having
4 drivers of 60 inches and a 4-wheel
truck to M. W. Baldwin & Co., to re-
ceive a Dimpfel boiler. Baldwins gave
it their own construction number of 829.
and it was run on the Philadelphia Di-
vision until the firebox, etc., were worn
out, when its interior was renewed in
the standard style, but the large manhole
in the back-head remained, and became
a puzzle to the j'ounger men who
handled it in later years after its running
gear had been remodeled in Mogul style
and it became a helper on the Alleghany
mountains.
This engine was built in 1856 for the
State R. R.'s of Pennsylvania, and
named "Old Dominion." It came into
possession of the Pennsylvania R. R. Co.
on August I. 1857. and was finally re-
tired from service in 1869.
44
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
Changes in the fl. H. Convention
Programme.
At a meeting of the Executive Com-
mittee of the American Railway Master
Mechanics' Association held at Buffalo
on December 10, several changes were
made in the list of subjects prepared for
discussion at the next convention. The
committee decided that there weie too
many subjects to be reported upon. Pre-
vious experience had shown that when
many reports were submitted it resulted
in stifling the discussions and on that
account the number of subjects was cur-
tailed. One subject, "Cost of Running
High-Speed Trains," was dropped and
several others were consolidated.
The first arrangement called for re-
ports on twelve subjects and two indi-
vidual papers. The objection was made
that members had not time to read so
many reports in advance, with the result
that none of them were read, and most of
the members entered the convention
without having any preparation to dis-
cuss the subjects that had been under in-
vestigation. Even a worse result of
superfluity of reports and papers was
that insufficient time was left for discus-
sion, and through this the valuable con-
tributions of personal knowledge and e.\-
perience bearing upon a subject is fre-
quently lost. For several years past the
noon-hour discussions of topical sub-
jects has been almost entirely cut off for
the sake of saving the time. Any one
who cares to turn back and read the
noon-hour discussions for five years, be-
ginning with 189s, is certain to be con-
vinced that the association and through
it the railway world is losing valuable
information by cutting off the noon-hour
discussions.
The New York Central Lines in
Southern California.
The opening of city ticket offices by
the New York Central Lines has been
the subject of a great deal of favorable
comment on the part of the press and
people. The last city office to be opened
by these lines is one at Los Angeles, Cal.
Mr. F. M. Byron, Southern California
passenger agent for the New York Cen-
tral Lines, wUl have charge of the new
offices, which are situated at 324 South
Broadway, Los Angeles.
Squaring the Exhaust with a Plug
Rod.
One of our subscribers remarked to
me this evening that he saw an article of
yours several months ago where a man
squared an engine in 35 minutes, but
said he beat that. The engine in ques-
tion was a 17x24, and some time ago
broke one of her cylinders in a wreck,
and it was bushed to 16 in. A few days
ago the nozzle tip was cleaned out; the
engine would not steam, and sounded
lower. In order to overcome it he put
his plugging bar down into the nozzle
stand, on the side of the large cylinder
(the stand being of the double kind),
the engine sounded square thereafter,
steamed and he saved himself an en-
gine' failure. J. A. B.
Prizes for Essays on Railroads.
The Secretary of the Pacific Coast
Railway Club announces that the time
for receiving the papers pertaining to the
construction, equipping, maintaining and
management of steam railways for which
four prizes have been offered, has been
extended to February i, 1903, by that
time those who wish to compete should
have their essays in the hands of Mr.
C. C. Borton, 1213 Twelfth street, Oak-
land, Cal. First prize, $100; second, $75;
tliird, $50: fourth, $25.
Railroad Department of the Y. M. C. A.
The railroad department has seven su-
pervising secretaries. It is influencing
the lives of a large percentage of the
1,000,000 railroad men of North America.
Seventy per cent, of the railway mileage
is contributing to the support of 170 rail-
way associations, having 237 employed
officers and 43,000 members. Ninety
buildings, costing $1,300,000, are owned
by or set aside for their use and form a
permanent endowment of this work.
Eighteen buildings were erected in 1902.
An active evangelistic work is carried
on under two railroad leaders, with
marked results, and there has been a
steady growth in Bible study and edu-
cational work. This work cost last year
$417,000, of which railway corporations
contributed $205,000.
Before Soap Was Used.
Imagine the condition engineers and
firemen would be in if they had no soap
to aid water in removing the defilement
of grease mixed with all sorts of black-
ening substances. Yet the use of soap
is a comparatively modern luxury.
Cleanliness is said to be next in merit
to Godliness, and it may be that ancient
races were very godly because their op-
portunities for cleanliness were limited.
The origin of soap dates only from
the i6th century. Mention was made of
soap being brought to London in 1524.
The ancient writers Pliny and Calen
mention it as an invention of the Gauls,
but no trace of it has been found in
records of Greek or Roman life. Pom-
peii's ruins yield many things which
seem quite modern, but no soap has
ever been discovered. As a substitute
the Romans used oil and clay in their
baths. Clay, containing a percentage of
fuller's earth, makes a considerable
lather, and is a very fair makeshift:
therefore they doubtless managed to at-
tain a sufficient degree of cleanliness.
especially as they devoted long hours to
the bath.
It is supposed that soap originated in
Mediterranean Europe, where great
quantities of olive oil were produced.
Oil, in fact, combined with either soda
or potash, makes a passable quality of
crude soap, and it is possible that some
Italian or Spaniard accidentally hit upon
the art of making it by letting his pot of
oil boil over and mix with the wood
ashes of the fire. Ashes contain potash
enough for the purpose, and are still
used in country places for the manufac-
ture of home-made soft soap.
A Qood Cinder Washer.
There is a cinder washing machine in
the C. & N. W. Ry. shops at Chicago
which has gained the nickname of the
"Klondyke," as it is, in a sense, a gold
recoverer for the company, though the
metal it washes out is brass. The ma-
chine which stands in the brass foundry
consists of a pair of cast iron cylinders
each about 40 ins. in diameter by 12 ins.
long. These are rotated by belt and pul-
ley and are fixed on a shaft parallel to
the cylinder axis, so that they revolve
just clear of a large tray which rests on
the floor. The outer head of each cyl-
inder has a circular opening 8 ins. in
diameter, through which a water pipe
discharges. The lower portions of the
cylinder are therefore constantly full of
water which comes out of the large cir-
cular opening as fast as the pipe feeds in.
There is therefore a constant flow of
water kept up all the time. Dust, cinders
and shop-floor debris is periodically
swept up and shoveled into the cylin-
ders. The portion of the mass of rub-
bish which sinks to the bottom, usually
coimins small particles of brass whicli
have been spilled on the floor whenever
the crucibles are lifted or earned. These
small particles generally adhere to bits
of cinders or other light bodies, which
latter, if free, would float on the surface
of water. The mass of brass and cinders
immersed in water is carried back as the
cylinders roll over, and when the angle
of rest is passed it slips down and keeps
on rising and slipping in the revolving
cylinder. In this way the lighter for-
eign matter is freed from the brass, and
floating to the top, it is eventually
washed out into the tray, while the brass
particles remain rolling over and over
until the operation is completed. The
water in the tray is kept drained off,
leaving a shallow deppsit of mud behind.
It is true, as Shakespeare says, that "all
that glisters is not gold," but in this case
the constant collection of the brass-laden
cinders from the shop floor, and the sep-
arating out of the metal day by day is
made to yield the equivalent of gold to
the company. The return, by this method
of saving, is said to be something sub-
stantial in the course of a year.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
45
The Death- Dealinst Street Car.
It is reported that Mr. C. B. Barnes, rail-
road commissioner of New York, has
made the assertion that for the last three
years the street railway lines have av-
eraged an accident for every ten miles
owned by tliem with a ratio of one killed
and six wounded.
If the same proportion of persons were
killed on stoam railroads the annual
slaughter woidd be about 20,000 and the
wounded about 100,000. He showed that
the greatest number of accidents resulted
from rear-end collisions, the rear car neg-
lecting the requirement of safety in keep-
ing a proper distance from the one ahead
of it. The next cause for disaster was
head-on collisions or collisions at inter-
sections. In additir)n to these he enumer-
ated the killings and woundings at grade
crossings, those resulting from the disre-
gard of orders and signals, the want of
adequate brakes and the general lack of
discipline im the part of the working force.
work rate, at the <liscretion of the fore-
man.
In the Baldwin Works there is piece-
work proper, where the workman is paid
according to the quantity produced, and
there is also the contract system, where
sub-foremen, called contractors, execute
a portion of the work on a locomotive.
The contractor is paid for the job, but
the firm pays directly each workman for
his labor on the job. The contractor
cannot, therefore, get more than the
amount due him on any one job by cur-
tailing the wages of his labor. Being
paid by the job, he has an incentive to
see that his men do their best.
The accurate knowledge which this
firm obtains of the actual cost of every
piece of work done by the unit system
enables those in authority to make sta-
ble piecework prices.
walls of the furnace. It is carried on a
steel and iron structure, made up of four
cast columns and two heavy I-beams.
The boiler rests upon appropriately
shaped supports, the back one is fixed
to its girder, while the forward one car-
ries a set of rollers to allow for expan-
sion.
The Allis-Chalmers Company arc the
makers, and they have issued a neat little
pamphlet giving full description and data
concerning the boiler. The compan/will
be happy to send a cof>y to any one suf-
ficiently interested to apply. Twelfth
street and Washtenaw avenue, ChicagOy
111.
The Sederholm Boiler.
The Sederholm boiler is practically a
standard horizontal tubular boiler, modi-
An Interesting Optical Illusion.
We hear that great preparations have
been made for holiday entertainments at
the Proctor theaters in New York, Al-
bany, Newark and Montreal, and our
many railway friends who have to travel
to any of these cities on business and
stay over night may spend a very pleas-
The Baldwin Locomotive Works' Unit
System of Production.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works peo-
ple have an excellent way of getting the
actual cost of each engine they
build, which they speak of as "unit sys-
tem of production." Two sets of books
are kept — a financial and a manufactur-
ing. In the financial department ac-
counts of sales, purchases and expendi-
tures appear. In the manufacturing
books a separate account is opened for
each locomotive, and material and labor
are charged against the engine they be-
long to. At the end of the year these two
sets of books must balance each other.
It is upon this unit system, which pre-
serves the identity of each engine, that
the organization of the labor and the
management of the work is based.
About 13,000 men are on the pay rolls
of the Baldwin Works at present. Wages
are reckoned by the hour. Piecework-
wages for convenience of accounting are
equated to a per-hour rate. A piece-
worker can earn the equivalent of from
18 to 50 cents an hour, the average being
30 cents. The unskilled worker averages
16 cents per hour, and all hands are paid
every Friday. Payment is made in coin
so as to insure accuracy. The shops run
continuously 23 hours a day, with a day
and a night force. Rigid inspection of
work is maintained, and damage for
spoiled work is charged to the workman
unless occurring from a reasonable
cause. A man accepting a piece of work
from a fellow-employee in order to
finish it, is held responsible for any
errors in the work of his predecessor. A
workman whose machine breaks down
through no fault of his own receives a
per-hour rate proportionate to his piece-
i
WESTERN OHIO ELECTRIC OVERHEAD CROS.SING, (J. & E. R.MLW.W.
fied so as to meet the exacting require-
ments of modern practice with high
steam pressure. The tubular part of the
boiler is of large diameter, and is con-
nected on the under side with four hori-
zontal drams, the axes of which run at
right angles to the direction of the longi-
tudinal axis of the main boiler. Each
drum has three connection pipes of
ample size, and these provide for free
circulation of water. The drums are
made out of thinner sheets than those
used above, in order to readily transmit
heat. The ends are made convex, so that
staying is unnecessary. Each drum has
a man-hole in one end to facilitate clean-
ing. These drums stand about three feet
above the grate bars, and are so placed
that a bridge wall is built between the
last two.
The main boiler has two nests of tubes,
with space between them to assist free
circulation. Above the tubes the round
heads are stayed by longitudinal rods,
with nuts on outside and inside of each
end sheet The support of the Sederholm
boiler is entirely independent of the brick
ant evening in the enjoyment of various
forms of dramatic art. Talking of art,
moving pictures form one of the many
features presented at these high-class
I)laces of amusement. A most curious
appearance may once in a while be no-
ticed by the observant spectator. It oc-
casionally happens in these pictures that
the wheels of a hansom or a fire engine
or other vehicle look as if they were
revolving backward, when the vehicle is
advancing rapidly. That this is not a
defect in the wonderful projecting ma-
chine called the Kalatechnoscope, may
be known from the fact that a spoked
car wheel, if viewed by the light of a
series of lightning flashes, would pre-
sent the same appearance. The explana-
tion is that the photographing machine
which takes the negatives for moving
pictures does so at regularly spaced in-
tervals of time, .(^n example will make
the whole matter clear. Suppose the
wheel spokes to stand in the position in-
dicated by the figures on a clock dial,
when No. i picture was taken, and sup-
pose that they all advance a distance ex-
46
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
-actly equal to the five-minute space when
No. 2 picture was taken, and so on, all
around the clock. It is obvious in this
case that the wheel would not appear to
revolve at all. If, however, with same
time intervals, the 12 o'clock spoke
moved over only four minutes' space,
and all the others covered the same dis-
tance, and were photographed in that
position, and if at the next exposure the
12 o'clock spoke stood at 8 minutes past,
with all others having made a similar ad-
vance, we would apparently behold the
strange spectacle of a wheel turning
slowly on a rapidly driven vehicle and
revolving in a direction opposite to that
in which we know it to be moving. The
same appearance may be observed with
the spoked wheels of an electrically driven
Ky., manufacturers of a ball and socket
joint, whose simplicity of construction
goes beyond any device so far invented.
It is made with only three parts,
ball, bell and ring, without gaskets, pack-
ing or springs to make it tight. For
steam, air or pressure work of any kind
it has a certain play between the parts,
and is seated and made tight automati-
cally the instant pressure is applied.
Steam acts both as a cushion and lubri-
cant to ball part, which soon becomes
practically case hardened, and instead of
wearing out. it constantly reseats itself.
It has a full, open passageway, and is so
constructed that when moved or turned
at an extreme angle in any direction,
the passage is of equal size to the pipe.
Fig. I shows a special angle joint
Chicago & Northwestern, Chicago, Mil-
waukee & St. Paul, Northern Pacific,
and also by the Baldwin Locomotive
Works and the American Locomotive
Co.
The application of this joint for air-
brake connections is also worthy of care-
ful consideration. Any desired pressure
may be carried with absolute safety and
reliability in air-brake service.
For high-pressure connections to com-
pressed air locomotives, motors, etc.,
it has become a standard by the largest
inanufacturers of such machinery, which
includes the H. K. Porter Co., Pitts-
burg, and American Locomotive Co..
Dickson Works. Scranton, Pa.
The Moran joint is made with close
bearings for conveying liquids or gases.
street car when a series of regular sparks
flash between rail and wheel. It is a
curious illusion and one which requires
keen observation to detect, though it
does not detract from the general life-
like effect produced by the shifting
scene. It would be worth while for any
one to indulge in a pleasant test of his
powers of observation by attending one
of the Ptoctor entertainments and
closely watching the Kalatechnoscope
pictures.
The Moran Flexible Joint.
The question of flexible metallic con-
nections for conveying steam, air or
liquids is receiving considerable atten-
tion. Pioneers in this line, are the Moran
Flexible Steam Joint Co., Louisville.
MORAN FLE-XIBLE JOINT. FIG. 1.
which is being extensively used as
a steam heat connection between engine
and tender; its application for this ser-
vice is shown by Fig. 2. It has an
automatic drain or drip, to prevent
freezing of connection. It is sold with
a time guarantee, which makes it most
economical in point of long and reliable
service as compared with any other con-
nection on the market.
By its use repairs at inopportune times
and places are eliminated, hence delays
from this source are reduced to a min-
imum, which is a most important feature
in railway equipment of any kind.
The Moran joint has long since passed
the experimental stage for this service,
it having been in daily use on the fol-
lowing railroads: Pennsylvania and
branches. Southern, Baltimore & Ohio,
under little or no pressure, and is a
factor for fuel oil connections between
engine and tender. It can be used with
loading and unloading connection to
tank cars, oil steamers, barges, etc. The
steam joint is also used to advantage for
connections to steam shovels, rapid un-
loaders, pile drivers, pneumatic hoists,
rock drills and similar machinery. It is
made by the Moran Flexible Steam Joint
Co., Louisville, Ky., and is furnished on
approval where practical tests are
wanted.
Duty. Begin it early, and do it well ;
and there is no antecedent to it in any
origin or station, that will tell against
us with the Almighty, or with ourselves.
— Little Dorrit.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
A7
Playin>!: an Air on the Whistle.
Men have maslcrcd tlic clarionet and
tortured the trombone, [retted the flute
and nnirdered the French horn, but a
Kichniond man can play an air on the
whistle of a locomotive.
As the 7:4s pulls out from tlie South-
ern Depot one may hear every night the
air "There's a Land Fairer Than Day."
With his hand on the throttle, as the en-
gine swings into the darkness, the en-
gineer plays, with the skill of a trained
musician, the opening bar of the old
song. It is his parting salute to his
sweetheart. The above was considered
of sufficient importance to be tele-
graphed to the New York World.
"Natural Knowledge" of Use in the
Brass Foundry.
Lead is acknowledged to be an ideal
metal as far as anti-friction is con-
cerned, but it is entirely too soft to be
of any use as a journal-bearing metal
alone. Copper and tin, when alloyed to-
gether, make a bronze capable of sus-
taining weight, but have very poor anti-
friction qualities. A satisfactory combina-
tion of these weight-sustaining and anti-
friction properties, has been achieved in
whn't is called Cyprus Bronze, made by
the Brady Brass Company, of New York
a:nd Jersey City. The island of Cyprus,
by the way, is where the ancients orig-
inally discovered copper, and the Latin
form of the word used to designate this
island in the Mediterranean, is the one
from which the name copper is derived.
Cyprus bronze as made to-day is a cop-
per-tin-lead alloy, which contains as
much as from 15 to 32 per cent, of lead,
according to the kind of service for
which the bronze bearing is adapted.
This is a great deal of lead for any such
alloy to carry, without segregation tak-
ing place, and it is to the successful ac-
complishment of this adjustment that
scientific knowledge has been applied.
In making these bearings, therefore, a
large quantity of anti-friction metal has
been introduced into an alloy which al-
ready has weight-sustaining qualities,
and the lead is so introduced that each
function is, so to speak, evenly dis-
tributed through the resulting mixture.
The proportions of the constituents
undoubtedly play their part; the order
of mi.xing has an important influence in
producing the desired result; but the
makers rely principally upon their own
observation of the fact that the intro-
duction of a particular flux into the mol-
ten mass, at a particular temperature,
produces a bronze which consists of an
exceedingly intimate mixture of very fine
particles of copper, tin and lead, in which
there is absolutely no grouping of ele-
ments. It forms a homogeneous metal,
exhibiting a close grained fracture, with
hardly any perceptable shrinkage in cool-
ing. This Cyprus bronze is, therefore,
nothing more or less than a carefully
compounded alloy, which contains more
lead than is usual in journal bearings,
and holds it most minutely and evenly
distributed in the whole mass. It is
everywhere, and all through the com-
pound, each particle of the anti-friction
lead is surrounded or Supported, if one
may say so, by weight-sustaining copper
and tin, and this product is said to give
excellent results in railway service. It
is a journal bearing made by the appli-
cation of what the late Prof. Huxley
called "natural knowledge," or in other
words, knowledge of the secrets of
nature, which is gained by close observa-
tion, patient experimenting and correct
reasoning. The works of the Brady
Brass Company are at 200-208 Tenth
street, Jersey City.
Do You Want Books?
If you do the Book Department of
Railw.\y and Locomotive Engineer-
ing will furnish you with anything in
print, no matter what department of lit-
MOR.\N FLKXIBI.E JOINTS.— Fig. 2.
erature it belongs to. We can procure
you anything from a family Bible to the
latest novel, but our specialty is railway,
mechanical and engineering books.
A year's subscription to Railway and
Locomotive Engineering costs only
$2.00, and the paper is a welcome visitor,
especially where there are children.
"The World's Railway" is a most in-
teresting history of railways and loco-
motives. It is beautifully illustrated and
the net price used to be $10.00. We now
give it and a year's subscription to Rail-
way and Locomotive Engineering for
$5-00.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management." by Sinclair, is an old and
universal favorite. A well-known gen-
eral manager remarked in a meeting of
railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
(or years." Price, $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. A
very useful book combining instruction
and amusement. It is a particularly use-
ful book to be in the hands of a young
mechanic. Has a stimulating effect in
inducing young men to study their busi-
ness. Price, so cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling en-
gineers in the examination of firemen for
promotion and of engineers liljely to be
hired. It contains a wonderful amount
of information about the locomotive in
small compass. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recommend this book. 75
cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin. A
little study of this book will instruct a
man so that he will understand the con-
struction and operation of a compound
locomotive as well as he understands a
simple engine. Tells all about running,
about breakdowns and repairs. Conve-
nient pocket size, bound in leather. $1.00.
"Standard Examination Questions and
Answers on the Air Brake." Formulated
and adopted by the Air Brake Associa-
tion, being a book of nearly 700 authors.
Brought right up to date. All about air
brakes, both Westinghouse and New
York, their construction, operation, dis-
orders, symptoms and cures. Most com-
plete book on air brakes yet printed. Will
pass you through anybody's air brake ex-
amination. 1,35 pages, 6x9 inches, con-
taining nearly 1,000 questions with their
answers and nearly 100 illustrations.
Postage prepaid, 25 cents.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable one to take out license to run sta-
tionary engine. Tells about boilers, heat-
ing surface, horse power, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a par-
tial list. Question and answer style.
128 pages. Pocket size. 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. A book that ought to be
in the hands of every person who is in
any way interested in keeping boilers in
safe working order. Written by a fore-
man boilermaker. Also contains sev-
eral chapters on oil-burning locomotives.
SO cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language easily under-
stood. $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can afford to do without. Enables any
workman to figrure out all the shop and
4S
■RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of combus-
tion. While treating on the chemistry of
heat and combustion is easily understood
by every intelligent fireman. 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for people trying
to learn all about air brakes. Tells the
whole story. Cloth, 75 cents. Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lessons
which appeared in this paper several
years ago. They are interesting, laugh-
able and best of all are of practical value.
$1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehensive
throws a clear, even beam, which covers
the entire right of way for 1,500 feet, or
more, and the spreading is just sufficient
to enable an engineer to see the track
ahead when rounding curves".
A singular fact about this light is that
it is not blinding. One may look into it
at any distance and see the ties right up
to the engine. This is thought by the
makers to be due to there being no un-
evenly lighted areas in the lens, which
would throw small, intense shafts of
light ahead. A further probable explana-
tion is that the non-blinding property
of the light is simply due to its quality.
The acetylene flame is exceedingly white,
and the approximation to the quality 01
sunlight is very close. This is proved
by the fact that the delicate shades and
tones of color retain their quality and
value under it. as in daylight.
MANGIN LENS REFLECTOR.
treatise on the subject. Ought to be
studied by all trainmen where block sig-
nals are used. $3.00.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
The Searchlight Principle Applied to
Headlights.
The locomotive headlight in general
use to-day appeared to Mr. S. W, Rush-
more, of the Rushmore Dynamo Works,
Jersey City, to be simply a primitive
searchlight, and as such, capable of con-
siderable improvement. With this end
in view, he used what is technically
known as a Mangin lens in the con-
struction of an acetylene gas headlight,
which has met with gratifying success
wherever tried.
The Mangin lens is a mirror as
well, and the principles of refraction and
reflection are made use of in distributing
the rays, which leave the lamp in a pow-
erful beam of intensely white light. A
I ft. burner, rated at 70 candle power.
SECTION OF GENER.4TOR,
In operation water passes to the spray
pipe B, by flowing up the casing C, which
liangs from the roof of the upper cham-
ber and reaches the openings in pipe d.
When gas is given off it rises in pipe e,
and goes to the lamp through a pipe
which opens into the top ot the hanging
casing. If gas accumulates faster than it
is used it depresses the water level
below the perforations shown, and water
ceases to flow to the spray pipe B until
the consumption of gas permits the
water to rise again and spray the cal-
cium carbide. This automatic regulation
of the gas is economical and safe, as it
prevents undue accumulation of press-
ure. In the event of excess accidentally
arising, the water would be simply
backed out of the hanging casing, and
the gas would harmlessly escape in the
atmosphere.
A simple method of keeping the water
from freezing has been borrowed from
the water heater usually attached to the
lumible cookstove of household use. A
IT IS
Significant
It IS significant that the
increasing use of pure tlake
graphite as a lubricant is the
result of demands originating
in the machine shop and en-
gine room. It has come be-
cause men charged with the
responsibility of keeping ma-
chinery moving have found it
beneficial in their work, its
use is not the result of pres-
sure or argument. It is the
result of actual tests andcare-
Lil demonstrations.
It must be observed that for
satisfactory results in lubrica-
tion, the graphite employed
must be free from grit and
other impurities, and it must
be properly graded for the
work it is designed to accom-
plish, and the purchaser
should have assurances that
material of a uniform quality
can at all times be supplied.
it is not to be presumed
that because a material is sold
as graphite, it will for this
reason alone give good results
in lubrication. Always com-
pare any offered with Dixon's
pure flake. Dixon's can safely
be considered as the standard.
Samples free.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.,
JERSEY CITY. N. J.
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGLNEERING
49
The Goods
Will
Please
r —
i
i
1
4
Ml
^M^^nl ^^^Bto^fj^^i
^tm
The Prices
Will
Tease
Q.&C.
Pneumatic
Tools
A SK FOR PRICES
Q. & C. CO.
NEW YORK, 1 16 Liberty Street
CHICAGO, 620 Western Union Bid?.
U-shaped copper pipe, which has its
round end inserted a few inches into the
smoke-box, is attached to the water
holder, but, the upper ends enter, each
at a diflferent level. This insures circula-
tion and keeps the water warm. In
summer the U-shaped pipe can be shut
off. The generator supplies light for 48
hours, and the cost of the "carbide" is
about three-quarters of a cent per hour.
Urand Trunk Wants to Transfer Loco-
motives Into United States.
One of the agents of the Grand Trunk
Railway has applied to the Treasury De-
parlment for permission to import into
this country free of duty eleven foreign-
made engines to be used temporarily be-
tween Island Pond and Portland, Me.,
for the extraordinary traffic caused by
cattle shipments at the season of the year.
After consideration in the customs divi-
sion it has been decided that the law re-
quires a duty of 45 per cent, on all foreign
engines imported to run within the limits
of the United States. This declaration
was based on paragraph 193 of the Re-
vised Statutes, including articles not spe-
cifically provided for in the tariff sched-
ules. It is estimated that the value of
these engines is about $20,000 each, and
the total duty to be required of the Grand
Trunk Railway will be approximately
$100,000. According to ofiicials of the
customs divisions it is permissible to drive
a foreign-made engine across the boun-
dary line to a point in the United States
and return, but it is unlawful to run en-
gines between two points within the
United States.
The American Steam Gauge and Valve
Manufacturing Company, of Jamaica
Plain, Boston, have issued a very artis-
tic calendar for 1903. The picture which,
of course, constitutes the attractive fea-
ture, represents a very interesting and
humorous scene, a little girl and a
Gordon setter from the dramatis persona.
Perhaps a "pointer" would have been a
more appropriate animal for a steam
gauge company to employ, but the selec-
tion is eminently satisfactory as it is. The
picture shows the dog laid out on an im-
provised bed on the lawn with a blanket
thrown over him. A sweet little girl,
watch in hand, is holding his paw and
endeavoring to feel his pulse, while a
tumbler and spoon and a bottle of med-
icine are close at hand. The company
are prepared to send this calendar to
those who, according to ordinary bus-
iness ethics, are entitled to it.
the four colors of Dixon's silica-graphite
paint. This little device enables one to
see the effect of any given color without
the distraction caused by the presence
of another. The paint referred to is
used for the protection of steel bridges,
steel cars, metal roofs, smoke stacks,
boiler fronts, coal pockets, trolley poles
and exposed metal of all kinds. The
Dixon people also publish on a separate
card a letter from an electric light com-
pany regarding a tall smoke stack which
was painted some years ago with silica-
graphite paint. They call this a "stack
reference," but it is quite certain that
they have received a stack of such refer-
ences. Write the Joseph Dixon Crucible
Co. for particulars.
The Chicago Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany have issued a catalogue of the air
compressors manufactured at their works
in Pranklin, Pa. The book contains the
latest types of compressors and lias a
very complete illustrated description of
the chief features of each design. The
half-tones are excellent and the cata-
logue presents a very attractive appear-
ance. ."Ml data pertaining to standard
styles is also included. An article on the
uses of compressed air, and information
relative to the proper installation of
compressed air equipment are to be
found in this publication. The cata-
logue will be sent by the company to
those who are interested enough to ap-
ply for it. The \ew York office is 95
Liberty street.
If the New York Central's Empire
State Express were an official instead of
being rolling stock, she would surely get
the big head — she gets so many honors.
The latest feather in her cap is that her
name is used in playing football, in which
it becomes an adjective. One of the
popular plays in the Yale-Harvard game
was called the Empire State Express
play, a play that is swiftest of all, sure
to get there and right on time. — Miller-
ton Telegram.
We are informed that the United
States Government ordered from F. W.
Bird & Son, East Walpole, Mass. (mak-
ers of "Neponset Papers" and "Paroid
Roofing"), 1,200.000 square feet of the
latter for immediate shipment to Manila,
Philippine Islands. The amount, designed
for army barracks and other Government
uses, is sufficient to cover 27 acres ol
roofs, and is undoubtedly the largest
shipment of roofing ever made.
The Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.. of
Jersey City, have issued a pocket card
with a revolving disc on the back. An
opening in the card shows about one-
quarter of the disc, and on the disc are
The bound volume of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering is now ready
for delivery. It is bound in very sub-
stantial shape and cost three dollars.
Write to 174 Broadway, New York.
50
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January. 1903.
Improvement for Sight Feed
Lubricators.
The annexed engraving shows a device
for improving the sight-feed lubricator
now used for cylinder lubrication on lo-
comotives. The difficulty with the pres-
ent lubricator is that the oil passing
through the sight-feed glass collects into
the long pipe connecting to the steam
chest and stays in this pipe until the
steam is sliut oS. or else the conditions
become moie favorable for a continued
flow. If a current of steam could be
made to flow continuously through oil-
conveying pipe in direction from the lub-
G, takes the nut, I, and nipple, J, which
connects steam supply pipe to boiler.
The device operates in the following
manner: When steam is turned on to
lubricator, the pressure on the ring-
shaped valve, H, will keep this valve
closed, and also the valve E. When
throttle is opened and steam chest filled,
the oil pipe will also be filled to about
the same pressure as may exist in steam
chest, and as the area on valve E ex-
posed to this pressure is larger than the
valve H, on which the live steam acts,
the valve E will leave its seat, allowing
the live steam to pass over the seat B
into the steam space, D, and continue to
steam chest, this current continuin.!; as
long as steam pressure in chest keeps the
valve E open. By giving the areas o'
the two valves, E and H, proportions m
relation to the difference of pressure in
steam chest and boiler, the valve E can
be made to lift at any given pressure in
steam chest and thereby admit live steam
into the oil pipe producing the desired
current and the consequently following
continuous lubrication of slide valves and
cylinders. T. J. Buckley.
— B
Railwav 9 L.«»mo(«w( EnuinMring
December Book of the Royal Blue.
"Annapolis in Colonial Times," an ar-
ticle illustrated by photographs of colo-
nial residences still preserved in the his
toric town, is made a feature of the De
cember number of "Book of the Roya
Blue," published by the passenger de-
partment of the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road.
Pictures of the Jennings place, Har-
wood mansion, Paca residence and the
Chase home appear among the illustra-
tions. A description of the new series
of postage stamps bearing reproductions
of Gilbert Stuart's "Washington" and the
"Stars and Stripes," and an article on the
"Pantheon of America," go to make the
book a colonial number that will doubt-
less be much sought after.
ricator to the steam chest, then the oil
could not accumulate in this pipe, and
the difficulty in regard to this point
would be overcome.
The device shown on enclosed blue
print is intended to be applied to any
lubricator condcnsor for the purpose^ of
supplying live steam from the boiler
through the oil pipe to steam chest, this
current to be automatically regulated by
the steam pressure in steam chest.
The device consists of a cross-shaped
piece, A, provided with an interior an-
nular valve seat (B), the steam space C
and the pipe connection D conveying
the steam to the oil pipe, which re-
ceives the oil from the lubricator. The
upper part of this cross-shaped piece is
bored out to form a chamber for the
valve E, which extends through the part
G, which in its upper end forms the seat
for the ring-shaped valve. H. This piece
"Fortunately this company has never
been able to pay dividends, so its stock-
holders will not be disappointed." That
was the satirical answer made by Presi-
dent Ramsey to a committee of employ-
ees demanding more pay and intimating
the alternative of a strike. That seemed
rather a conclusive dictum, but on the
other hand the employees are not to
blame for the property not paying divi-
dends, and they are entitled to the wages
paid by other companies for similar ser-
vice.
Mr. James C. Clark, president of the
Mobile & Ohio, and one of the most
widely-known railroad men in the United
States, died at the home of his daughter
from Bright's disease. He was 79 years
of age.
>
las
January, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
51
A Wise Kaiser
A wise man in his genera-
tion is William, Kaisei" of
Germany. His great new
navy-yard at Kiel is just
completed, and one of its
greatest features is a com-
plete outfit of
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
The Kaiser was not to be
induced to accept inferior
pneumatic tools, even though
marked with the magic word
"America." Only the best
were good enough for him.
Are you as wise as he ?
Send for our new catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
2ist St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Franci.sco Boston
IE
Canadian Pacific to Adopt the Pension
System.
Ill cstablisliing an old-age pciibion .sys-
ti ni for its employees the Canadian
Pacific Railway Company has given an-
other proof tliat its reputation for busi-
ness wisdom is not undeserved. TIic
president of the C. P. R. says in his cir-
cular, it builds up among the employees
a feeling of permanency in their employ-
ment, an enlarged interest in the com-
pany's welfare, and a desire to remain in
and devote their best efforts and atten-
tion to the company's service. That these
results will be obtained there can be no
doubt, for the plan appeals to the strong-
est human motives, and unites the inter-
ests of all connected with the company
by making every man in its employ feel
that his welfare is part of its system. —
Montreal Daily Witness.
No. 5. Vertical Car Borer.
An improved macliine, especially
adapted for heavy boring in wood in car
shops, shipyards, and other places where
large timbers are worked, is shown here-
with. Tts makers have spared no time
necessary stops, and has a device for
firmly clamping the stock. It has rack
and pinion feed under instant control
of the operator, and has connections for
making fine adjustments. When desired
a stationary table 9 1-4 feet long, with
nine rolls, can be furnished.
A supplemental under boring spindle,
especially useful for boring coal car
sides, can be furnished, boring inde-
pendently or at same time as upper
spindle, and short bits can be used to
advantage. This improvement will prove
very beneficial to all those who make
such cars.
The makers, J. A. Fay & Egan Co.,
of Cincinnati, O., will furnish those in-
terested with further particulars, cuts
and terms, and will send free their new
catalogue to those interested who will
write for it, mentioning Railway and
Locomotive Engineering.
The Protectus Company, of Philadel-
phia, have issued a very well illustrated
catalogue in which the merits of the
preservative paint known as "Protectus"
are duly set forth. The claim made for
NEW five-spindle vertical car borer.
(Pat. Jan. 30. liWO; Feb. 6, 1900.)
or pains to embody in its construction
such new points and improvements as
would enable it to successfully meet the
most particular requirements of those
for whom it was designed, and it is
offered to their consideration with the
feeling that it will prove of interest.
The capacity of the machine for bor-
ing large holes has been greatly in-
creased, and every convenience has been
incorporated to make the boring easily
and quickly done.
The spindles are of improved con-
struction, the outside boring ones have
angular adjustment of 45 degrees inside
and 60 degrees outside. Material 14 inches
square can be bored; the spindles will
travel 13 inches, and the vertical move-
ment of end spindle frames is 8 inches.
The outside spindles can be instantly
placed at any angle desired: there is
no strain, and short bits can be used
with facility.
The table is a steel traveling carriage
of any length desired, is provided with
Protectus is that the vehicle which carries
the pigment is itself preservative. Among
the half-tones with which the pamphlet
is illustrated, we notice the Memorial
Hall in Fairmount Park, Philadelphia,
the '■oof and iron work of which are
painted with Protectus. This building
was the Art Gallery in the famous Cen-
tennial Exhibition of 1876. The trolley
bridge in Fairmount Park is also shown,
and some oil tank cars, to which this
covering has been applied. Protectus
can also be used on the front end of lo-
comotives, and a special kind of this ma-
terial has been prepared for use as an
insulator for electrical connections. The
corrosive effect of salt water and the
drippings from refrigerator cars can be
successfully resisted by this medium.
The catalogue may be obtained upon ap-
plication to the company.
If you want any book, be it poetry or
prose of any kind, this office will sup-
ply it.
5J
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, ipoj^
Enlarging Juniata Shops.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Co. are
doubling the capacity of their locomotive
building shops at Juniata, and a large
number of workmen are already engaged
on the newf building. When the Juniata
shops were first built they were a model
of modern locomotive building shops with
all the latest tools and appliances then on
the market. The new shops under con-
struction will contain the best tools that
can be procured, which will be driven by
electric power.
It will be a very interesting comparison
to go over the old shops and compare
them with the new ones. It will give a
very good idea of the progress made in
manufacturing appliances for locomotive
use in the last ten years.
It was expected that the agreement
made by the Eastern Trunk lines for
last year abolishing exchange passes
would not be renewed for 1903, but at a
meeting of the presidents last month the
agreement was renewed, and it is ex-
pected that it will be further extended
this year. The agreement has excited a
great deal of discontent among certain
classes of railway employees, but there
is no prospect of passes ever being so
freely given as they were before 1902.
The Cincinnati Milling Machine Com-
pany, of Cincinnati, Ohio, have just is-
sued an illustrated catalogue which they
call a "Treatise on Sharpening and
Grinding." Its pages are devoted to the
description of the Cincinnati universal
cutter and tool grinder, which is used
for sharpening and grinding milling cut-
ters, reamers and other tools. After a
general description, some directions and
tables, each subsequent page contains a
well-executed half-tone, clearly showing
the grinder at work on some particular
cutting tool, with description of the op-
eration below. Several pages follow,
showing the great variety of pieces
which the machine will grind, the emery
wheels used in the grinding and the
counter-shaft connections for the
grinder. The company will be happy to
send the "treatise" to any one sufficient-
ly interested to apply to them for it.
A very handy "Index and Abstract of
the Master Car Builders' Rules and De-
cisions" has been issued. It is intended
to be carried in the book of interchange
rules for reference, as it contains a most
useful index and a list of the changes
made in the code, together with a brief
abstract of the decisions of the Arbi-
tration Committee. The cases are cited,
each in a line or two and all the essen-
tial information is given. The work of
indexing and condensing has been done
in a very creditable way by Mr. J. D.
McAlpine, of the L. S. & M. S. Ry.,
Cleveland, Ohio, and the pamphlet is
given away with the compliments of the
McConway and Torley Company, of
Pittsburg, Pa., the makers of the Kelso
coupler.
Stannard & White, the well-known
makers of cab seats, have removed from
Appleton to Racine, Wis., where they
have consolidated with the Gold Medal
Camp Furniture Company. This change
has been made necessary by the increas-
ing business which the firm are enjoying.
Under the new arrangements the cab
seats, which have made Mr. Stannard
known all over the country, will be man-
ufactured as well as his numerous other
railroad inventions.
Several western papers contain adver-
tisements asking trainmen to send 25
cents for an examination blank, with the
pretense that the parties supplying the
blank can provide positions for com-
petent men. We advise our readers to
keep their money. The thing is a hum-
bug.
The Atlas Car and Manufacturing Co.
have issued a couple of catalogues, Nos.
1008 and 1012, which show a partial line
of cars made at their works at Cleve-
land, Ohio. The first of the catalogues
deals with the cars which are made for
use around brick yards and cement
plants. The second exhibits equipment
constructed ' for industrial railways.
Good half-tones show the cars, and each
is described and numbered for reference.
The catalogues will be sent free to those
interested enough to write to the com-
pany for them.
"Hard Water Made Soft" is the, name
of an illustrated catalogue recently pub-
lished by the Industrial Water Com-
pany, 126 Liberty street. New York.
Besides illustrating a variety of appa-
ratus used in removing scale-making
imfiurities from water, the pamphlet
gives some interesting information
about boiler feed waters. People inter-
ested ought to send for the catalogue.
We have been informed that the Q
and C Company shipped from their fac-
tory at Chicago Heights one of their
largest special metal sawing machines
consigned to the United States Govern-
ment, to be used at the Cavite Navy
Yard at Manilla.
Seventy-three all-iron flat cars have
been shipped to Newfoundland. They
were made at Berwick, Pa., the iron for
their manufacture being imported from
Newfoundland in pigs, paying a duty of
$4 a ton. Now that this iron has been
made into cars, the manufacturers are
entitled to an export drawback of $3.9^
a ton. The cars weigh 30,000 pounds
each, and are consigned to the Northum-
berland Railroad Company, Newfound-
land.
ITHE
M. fi| S. Oiler
^'- "•" ■
■'- •~-
Made of^eo gauge steel.
One seam. Valve can
with berfeet vent.
Non-dentable. Cant
^V^alve rod and
borne off with
leak
spring
i.l
the spd^tj No gaskets
or walhers. A ma-
1=1
chine jam Price $2.00.
ft "'■'%
Discounts in lots of a
Rp.B. Denver.
oianuafm on a dozen
roads.! IsiBooklet free.
nr^i
M. & si Oiler Co.
=?i
Equitable Building.
DENVER.
January, 19C13.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
53
LUBRICATING
AIR BRAKE
EQUIPMENT
is an important matter. Neither
oil nor grease is satislactory.
( )il works its way to 1)ottom
of cylindurs, leaving tlie top dry
and improperly lubricated, while
grease forms into balls and im-
pedes the working of the cylinders.
NON-FLUID OILS
are free from both objections, re-
maining on walls of • cylinders,
spreading evenly and smoothly and
keeping packing leather in perfect
condition. Pronounced by the lead-
ing Air Brake Inspectors to greatly
facilitate the most ellicient service
of air brake apparatus. Used by
the leadin.g railways who have
adopted same only after subjecting
to the severest tests. Testing
samples, free of charge, by prepaid
express, on application.
NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY
LUBRICANT COMPANY
14 and 16 Church Street
NEW YORK CITV
Jones & Lainson Machine Co.,
Main Office and Works:
fiPRINQFIBLD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
A. B.C. and Luber^s Code used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
son's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain ; Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary.
M. Koyemann, Charlottenstrasse 112, Dusseldorl,
Germany.
k.s,.o™^ YOUR WORK IS LEVEL
.\N1) IT STAYS LEVEL
f il 1. lovtOo.UMil, ,.tl
ARMSTR0N6
PLANER JACK,
4 sizes.
Srnil for CHlalMC.
Armstrong Bros.
Tool Co.
•■Thp T,.i.l ll.,l,l,'i'
'■"""'"•■■ t
O.t.'i Anslhi A\rin<r. \^
CllirAfiO. I . S. \
Class C. S. C. Air Compressor.
A new type of air compressor, built
by the Chicago Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany, represents the latest product in
this field, and is designed to meet the
growing demand for higher efficiency
in air compression. It is known as the
Class C. S. C. pattern, designed for a de-
livery air pressure of loo lbs. per square
inch, with a steam pressure of loo to 150
lbs. The compressor has L. P. steam
cylinder, 31 ins. diameter, H. P. steam
cylinder 20 ins. diameter, L. P. air cyl-
inder 28 ins. diameter, and H. P. air cyl-
inder 16 1-2 ins. diameter, all cylinders
being 24-in. stroke. The capacity of the
compressor is 1,710 cb. ft. of tree air
per minute when operated at 100 revolu-
tions, or 2,052 cubic feet at 120 revolu-
tions.
In design, the frames follow the most
approved Corliss construction and are of
exceptional strength. The steam and
air cylinders are tied tandem to each
other, with heavy tie rods. Steam and
air pistons are of solid type, cored hol-
low, and are provided with snap rings.
They have no followers or bolts, thus
avoiding liability of accident.
Provision is made for a circulation of
cold water the entire length of the cyl-
inder, the water passing also through
the heads, its cooling effect being espe-
cially concentrated around the discharge
valves, which naturally become very hot.
A novel feature is an outside water con-
nection for conducting the circulation of
water between air cylinder and cylinder
head, precluding the possibility of seri-
ous accident through water entering the
interior of cylinder should the gasket
between cylinder and head become de-
tective.
The air inlet and discharge valves are
placed in the cylinder heads from the
outside and are thus immediately ac-
cessible for adjustment or repair without
the cylinder heads requiring removal. A
feature of more than ordinary impor-
tance embodied in this valve is the fact
that the valve seat is a part entirely sep-
arate from the cylinder proper and may
be removed, replaced or renewed when-
ever occasion requires.
The valve seats are of bronze and the
springs of steel. The proportion of
valve area to cylinder area is exception-
ally liberal, enabling the cylinder to fill
freely at each stroke. The cylinder
flanges are recessed to effectually pre-
vent the valves falling into the cylinders,
thus avoiding the use of a guard plate,
and the consequent clearance loss.
The cranks are of disc pattern, made
from best quality charcoal iron. Con-
necting roads are made from best forged
steel, carefully finished. Boxes are ad-
justable for wear, and accord with the
most approved practice. A combined
speed and pressure regulating governor
is provided, having a connection to the
air receiver.
The inter-cooler furnished with thi»
type of compressor consists of a set of
tubes encircled by a steel shell, into the
heads of which the tubes are fitted, suit-
able provision being made for expansion
and contraction. A constant circulation
of cold water is maintained through the
tubes, and the compressed air from the
initial compression cylinder enters the
inter-cooler on one side and after thor-
ough distribution and contact with the
tubes discharges from the other side,
passing to the next compressing stage.
Adequate provision is made for readily
cleaning the interior of the inter-cooler,
and the tubes, being of composition
metal, do not rust or become foul.
This type of compressor is built in
three sizes, ranging in capacity from 500
to 2,000 cubic feet of free air per minute,
and is also built with simple steam cyl-
inders, for plants where the available
steam pressure does not warrant com-
pounding. Single and duplex compress-
ors in a variety of sizes are also manu-
factured. The compressors here de-
scribed are in use in the shops of some
of the principal railways, locomotive
building plants and in large manufactur-
ing establishments.
The Union Pacific Dining Car Menu
has found its way into our sanctum, and
carries the mind of the editor away from
type and galleys proof so that he even
forgets the insistent call for "copy." The
scene before his mental vision is a table
laid with a snowy cloth and covered
with shining silverware and sparkling
glass, while the warmth and light of the
luxurious dining cars on this road con-
trast strongly and yet pleasantly with the
wintry landscape outside as the train flies
steadily along the "overland route."
There is no bell or gong sounded to
announce when the feast is spread, but
there is the more gently urgent personal
appeal in those musical words, "Dinner
is now ready in the dining car." At the
top of each card is a view of some im-
portant city along the line, with descrip-
tion printed on the back, which the diner
may read in the short interval which
precedes the enjoyment of "a bird, a
bottle and a cigarette."
Wm. C. Baker has obtained an injunc-
tion against the Crane Co., of Chicago,
and an accounting has been ordered on
account of infringing the Baker patent
combination cock and filler funnel.
Extract from case respecting the use
of a steam engine for conveying coal.
August 9, 1814. referring to "Puffing
Billy:"
"If the noise of this engine disturbs
the cattle grazing in the lands adjacent
to the wagon way, so as to injure them
with regard to their feeding. I think it
may be considered as a nuisance."
54
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
In a paper presented to the last meet-
ing of the American Society of Mechan-
ical Engineers Mr. William Kent advo-
cates the use of figures representing re-
sistance instead of conductivity of heat.
A table is given, showing the heat re-
sistance of various substances as com-
puted from the conductivity. It is pro-
posed that the co-efficient of heat resist-
ance shall be equal to units divided by
the number of British thermal heat units
transmitted in one hour, by a slab of one
square foot in area and one inch thick
per degree Fahrenheit of difference of
temperatures betvifeen the two faces of
said slab, both surfaces being exposed to
the still air.
Some trials have recently been made
on the line of the South Western Rail-
way of England, with a petrol-driven
motor car for inspection of permanent
way. A speed of thirty miles per hour
was maintained on the level, the car
carrying eight passengers. The experi-
ment on the grades encountered were
interesting. A rising gradient of I in
100 was climbed with eight passengers
abroad; another I in 50, with five peo-
ple carried, and i in ^y on a curve, was
ascended, with three people on the car.
All the grades were attempted from a
standing start. The car weighed 520
lbs., the motor was a 6 H. P. one, hav-
ing two water-cooled cylinders and con-
necting rods driving direct on the back
axle. The test was considered very sat-
factory.
At the last regular meeting of the New
England Railroad Club at the Pierce
Hall, Boston, a paper on "Electrically
Driven Shops" was presented by Mr.
Robert L. Warner, Boston, sales man-
ager of the Westinghouse Electric and
Manufacturing Company. Mr. Warner's
paper was illustrated by a large selection
of stereopticon vievvs, showing many
examples of the application of direct cur-
rent and induction motors to the driving
of machine-shop tools and other ap-
paratus.
The management of the Michigan Cen-
tral has gone into the catalpa tree cul-
ture, with a view to providing ties and
fence posts for all future time. Experi-
ments in planting catalpa trees was made
by several railroad companies about 30
years ago, but the thing proved a failure.
We do not believe that any ties were
made from thousands of dollars outlay.
The Ashton Valve Company, of 271
Franklin street, Boston, have a very neat
calendar for 1903. The card is a pleas-
ing tone of gray, with the name of the
company, etc., in silver letters. The
picture on the calendar is printed in har-
monious tints and shows a little girl and
her fore-footed companion just hav-
ing a little love passage all by them-
selves. The intelligent Gordon setter
who is being fondled by the child looks,
as he is, a "lucky dog," and surveys the
world with a very contented air. The
Ashton Valve Company are prepared to
send a copy of this calendar to their
friends and patrons, whose addresses
they have, or to any engineer who is in
charge of a steam plant, if he applies,
stating the name of his concern.
Every week brings us news of new
companies being organized to build loco-
motives. If the prosperous times con-
tinue for two or three years longer com-
panies will doubtless put up new works
for the construction of locomotives; but
in the meantime the greater portion of
the new concerns of the character recent-
ly announced are similar to one in New
England which is organized with $2,000,-
000 capital and nothing paid up.
The Pratt & Whitney Company, of
Hartford, Conn., will give to those who
apply an illustrated catalogue of their
Thread Milling Machine. The tool is
shown in half-tones and a line cut gives
the name of each part. The letter press
contains a description and directions for
operating. The form of patented thread
milling cutter is shown, and some sam-
ples of the work done are also given.
The claim made for this machine is that
it possesses practically all of the flexi-
bility and adaptability to miscellaneous
thread cutting that the engine lathe pos-
sesses; and that it does the work within
narrower limits of error than any ordi-
nary engine lathe can and at a fraction
of the cost of engine lathe work.
The Buffalo Forge Company are keep-
ing in touch with the festive season of
Christmas and New Year's by issuing a
mailing card, upon which is reproduced
two old-fashioned prints, one represent-
ing a "Seventeenth Century Foundry in
France," and "The Metallurgists of An-
tiquity." The reverse side of the card
shows the various blowers which this
company makes.
The certificate of the East St. Louis
Locomotive and Machine Shops Com-
pany has been filed. The incorporators
are M. M. Stevens, W. S. Forman and
H. L. Browning. The present capital
stock is $25,000, but that sum will soon
be increased.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
16 AND
Total Locomotives Built in the,U. S.
From reliable information obtained
from the various locomotive building es-
tablishments, we find that the total out-
put in the United States for the year 1902
was 3.606 locomotive engines for use on
steam railroads.
SIZE
17 AND LM KIBY
JEWELS,
SAPPHIRE PALLETS
BALL'S IMPROVED
SAFETY
DOIBLE ROLLEB
Are without question
the finest watches that
AniL'iican talent and
skilltd labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing Buch universal eat-
isfaction that we have
no hesitancy in .claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests severe and numerous have proveu this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
Write us for dfscriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
Arc easier to operate
More Rigid, True and Free from Vibration
Than any other Planing Machine made.
For particulars, write
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
WINCHENDON, MASS.
FOREIGN AGENTS: Henry Kelly* Co ,36 Pall
Mall. Manchester. Eng. Schuchardt >c Schutte,
Berlin, Cologne. Brnssels. Vienna, Stockholm. St^
Petersburg. Sussfeld, Lorsch&Co.. Paris. France,
MODEL LOCOMOTIVES
Better than ever ! Latest N. Y. Cen.
Standard. High Saddles — Big Drivers —
4 sizes. Something extra nice. 4c. in
stamps for catalog.
A.. S. CA.1VIPBEI<I.
P. O. Box 268 MONTICELLO, N. Y.
January, Kjii,;.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGL\EERING
\
FOR SALE
FRIICHT, PASSENCtR AND LOOCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
AND
ALL ^ADC 4UICK
SIZES. ^MnO DELIVERIES
F. M. HICKS,
a<5 DBARBORN ST.
CHICAGO, ILL.
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. <^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
-always fit and give satisfac-
Nothing more conclusively shows the
enormous amount of tonnage that is be-
ing liancllcd by the railroads west of
Pittsburg than the fact that the man-
agers of the Pennsylvania lines west
have decided to abandon the annual in-
spection of the roads and methods of
operating officials. The reason ascribed
for the unusual move on the part of the
general managers is that the railroad
men along the lines to be inspected have
not the time to devote to the inspecting
parties. In case they would take that
time from business the operation of the
freight would sufTer immeasurably, much
more in fact, than the condition, as it is
now apparent, will permit. — Ex.
tion.
Made in one of the best
■hops in the country.
Union of course. >^ <^
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. . .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
We understand that Mr. Frank Iled-
ley, who. has been for ten or twelve years
general superintendent of the Lake Street
lillcvated Railroad, Chicago, has been se-
lected as general manager of the Inlwr-
Urban Railroad, New York, which enl'
braces the new underground railway and
other lines. Mr. Hedlcy learned the ma-
chinist trade in the Manhattan Klevated
Railroad shops. New York, rose there to
be a foreman, and went to the Lake Street
Elevated as master mechanic. He is a
grandncphew of William Hedley, who in
1813 built the first locomotive that did
successful work in hauling trains. Its
name was the "PuflTmg Billy," and it is
now preserved in the South Kensington
Museum, London.
Owing to the high price of steel
charged in this country by the Steel
Trust, the Baldwin Locomotive Works
have begun importing steel blooms from
abroad. Last month a vessel arrived in
Philadelphia which brought 500 tons of
steel for the Baldwin people, and the
firm expects to extend these importa-
tions right along. A ton of steel blooms
costs about $13.00 to make, and the trust
is selling it for $30.00, which can hardly
be considered a moderate profit. In im-
porting these blooms from abroad the
Baldwin Locomotive Works have to pay
$8.00 a ton duty, but yet they can do
better than by buying steei in the United
States.
We are informed that "One side of a
piece of ordinary cotton duck with Pro-
tectus Insulating paint spread on fairly
thick, was allowed to dry, thus making
the duck quite stiflf. The electrodes of
a testing machine, which had a capac-
ity of 10,000 volts, were placed one on
each side of the painted cloth diametri-
cally opposite and the current turned on.
Readings were taken every time the
voltage was increased, until the current
jumped through, which was at 5,200
volts. The resistance of duck alone is so
slight that it is impossible to measure
it."
Steps having been taken to organize
a Union of Austrian Locomotive Engi-
neers, the Minister of the Interior for-
bade the formation of such a union on
the ground that it would be a danger to
the state. The organizers appealed to
the Imperial Court, alleging that such a
prohibition was a violation of their politi-
cal rights. The court has decided that
the prohibition by the ministry was Ieg.^1
.Tnd well founded.
The Southern Car and Foundry Com-
pany at Binghamton is making prepara-
tions to double its output of cars. There
is every prospect that it will be able to
put 20 cars per day on the market, in-
stead of ten, as at present, within the
next 60 davs.
The Court of Appeals decided recently
that, if a man leaves his seat in a rail-
road car, even though he has placed
therein a satchel, coat or umbrella, it
may be lawfully occupied by another
person. It came up on a case where a
man had placed his belongings in a seat,
left it, and when he returned, found the
satchel in the aisle and another man oc-
cupying the seat. They had an alterca-
tion, the intruding party thrashed the
other and threw his things out of the
window. He was arrested, but won the
case in the Court of Appeals. He de-
served the licking and it is a pity that
he won the case.
Some recent changes have been made
by the Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co. in
their representatives in this country. Mr.
Geo. A. Barden, who has been repre-
senting the company at BufTalo, has
been transferred to Philadelphia, and Mr.
C. R. Green, who has been connected
with the Cleveland office, has succeeded
Mr. Barden in Buffalo. Mr. Chas. Par-
sons, who recently became connected
with the company, is now traveling in
the northwest. Mr. J. W. Duntley.
president of the Chicago Pneumatic Tool
Company, who has been spending some
time in Europe, is returning with a large
number of orders for their rapidly in-
creasing trade.
The district office managers of the
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co., rep-
resenting all the principal cities of the
United States, spent a week in their
usual annual visit to the works and of-
fices of that company at East Pittsburg.
K very enjoyable dinner, in honor of the
visitors, was given at the Duquesne
Club, at which the engineers and execu-
tive officers of the company were also
present.
The men who learn endurance are
they who call the whole world brother.
— Barnaby Rudgc.
36
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
1903.
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smoke.
Contains about 800 practical questions and
their answers on the Science of Steam
Making. By Wm. M. Barr. The necessary
conditions for the Economic Firing of a
Locomotive are explained. 85 Illustrations.
349 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By Robert H. Blackall. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Alr-Brake
equipment, containing- over i.ooo questions
and their answers on the Westlnghouse
Air-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Air-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearlv every rail-
road in the United States. 1902 Edition.
264 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By Robert Grimshaw. it asks 1,600
questions and gives 1,600 simple, plain,
practical answers about the Locomotive.
No mathematics, no theories— y«5/ facts.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
pages, over 200 Illustrations, and 12 large
Folding Plates. Bound In Maroon Cloth,
$2.00.
^^^A special Circular of these Books Sent
on Request.
^W^Any of these Books Prepaid to any
Address in the world on Receipt of Price.
AGENTS WANTED i°U^,'^ \\°-
sell at sight, and every Engineer,
Fireman and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books is sent free on application.
Norman A. Henley & Co., Publishers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, N.Y,
FOR S.A.L.E:
Six (6( unbound volumes ot Loco:\iotivic En-
gineering for the years 1895. '96, '97, '9^^, "99 and
1^0. All volumes are in first class condition and
as good as new. Price $1.50 per volume.
Also two (2) unbound volumes ot '•The Kail-
road Car Journal'' for the years 1899 and 1900.
Price 50 cents per volume.
Address FREDERICK S. OWEN.
General Delivery-, Waltham, Mass.
Handling of Locomotives
By W. O. THOMPSON
IS A BOOK OF
Questions and Answers About Every-
thing Concerning Locomotives
COSTS ONLY 50 CENTS AND IS
THE MOST VALUABLE BOOK EVER
OFFERED TO HELP ENGINEMEN.
LEATHER BINDING, 75c.
ANGUS SINCLAIR COMPANY
l74 BROADWAY. NEW YORK
The Small Shop Delusion.
BV EGBERT P. WATSOK.
Richard and Robin were two pretty men
who had worked all their lives in a rail-
way shop — the same shop. Richard was
past jniddle age, but Robin had not yet
reached it; the former was a fair work-
man only, but a most unconscionably slow
one. He was lively enough in his move-
ments, brisk and active in getting about a
job, but for some reason never was able
to get it out of his hands; he would potter
and potter until it made all the other men
in his vicinity nervous to see him fiddling
away at some part of it that he had al-
ready gone over before. Aside from this,
he was a conscientious man and tried to
do the best he could, but his best was not
up to the mark. It was this last trait that
kept him in the shop, for the officials have
the measure of every man who works, but
make allowances for congenital defects.
Robin was a very different sort of man.
He was a better all-round hand, but even
he left much to be desired as an expert
workman. For one thing, his experience
had been within a very limited circle, and
he had a notion that the only methods he
had seen were the best possible to get out
work ; neither was he what could be called
a careful, close workman, being a little too
prone to take a cut by his eye and measure
for the fit afterwards — a proceeding that
leads a man into pitfalls and snares very
suddenly sometimes. He was of the "flip
and flirty" type, snatching work out of the
lathe before it had stopped running, throw-
ing the back gears out and stopping it by
a stick under the cone, jabbing the calipers
into a chucked hole and starting the lathe
up and a new cut, all at the same time-
in short, doing circus feats all day long.
He also whistled in season and out, a
weakness which caused much remon-
strance in the shape of blocks, dirty waste,
and even oil cans, from those in the vicin-
ity who did not care for mouth-organ
music. For all this, Robin was not un-
popular, and a short time before this nar-
rative commences he had been made sub-
foreman, at very good wages. Both
of these men were on terms of intimacy,
and as Robin was the more ambitious, he
had got the idea that a small .shop was, if
not a short road to fortune, a pretty sure
one in a reasonable time. They "cussed
and discussed" this topic for a consider-
able time, and as I had had a much longer
and wider experience than either of them,
and was wholly disinterested, they took
me into their confidence and asked me
what I thought of the scheme — their giv-
ing up their present jobs and investing
their small savings in a machine-shop out-
fit.
"The first thing I want to know is,
where you are going to start j'our shop,"
I said.
"Right here, where we are known," was
the answer.
"What! in this town? You must be
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre. Pa.
RAILROAD STORIES FOR
CHRISTMAS PRESENTS
Stories of the Railroad $1.50
Jim Skeevers' Object Lessons x.oo
Express Messenger x.35
Tales of an Engineer 1.35
THIS OFFICE
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EQUIPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds o£ servic*
CARS, rREIGHT, PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Monadnntk Bids;., Chicago 141 Broadway, New York
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. NEW YORK.
Januaiy, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVK ENGINEERING
57
A. Lesclien &, Sons Rope Co.,
Manufactureis
WIRE ROPE,
Ballast tJnIoaders, Switch
Ropes, Wreckinjf Ropes
MANILA ROPE,
Fittings and Supplies.
HOME OFKICK:
■920-922 North First St., - ST. LOUIS, MO.
( i,\^ Iv Lake St., Chicago. III.
branch (ifTices J92 Centre St.. New York City. N.Y.
f S5 Krt-inont St.. San I^'rancisco, Cal.
»T» A TTT AFI Best Yorkshire
1 A I LUK STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS AND AXLES.
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet'sl"
STEELS
PECIAL "
TITANIC"
These Goods are the Standard of Excellence
Sole Representatives in the
United States* Canada and Hexlco.
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire St., BOSTON.
No. 143 Liberty St., NEW YORK.
WAREHOUSE AT EAST BOSTOA\
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
LOAN » TRUST BUILDING. WASHINGTON, D. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sent.
WANTED.
For service on Panama Railroad, an
engineer experienced in operating pile
driver and other forms of hoisting en-
gines. Salary 8125.00 U. S. gold per
month.
PANAMA RAILROAD COnPANY,
24 state Street, New York.
This muffled
pop valve is the
best you can use
—better specify
it in your next
order.
VALVE COMPANY.
271 FRANKLIN ST. BOSTON tlASSl
crazy; there arc more shops here than
there is work ; what kind of a show do
you stand to take it away from those who
haven't enough now?" The reply was
that they would do work cheaper and
prompter than the other fellows, and, be-
ing "practical men," could see just what
was needed to be done on any job at a
glance, where the other fellows, being
only "proprietors," couldn't tell what a job
would cost or whether it was done right
when it was done.
"Look here, Mr. Richard and Robin," I
said, "you are fooling yourselves on the
start. There is now in this town pretty
nearly a shop for every factory, and they
have been in operation for many years,
with ample capital and tools for any kind
of a job that comes along. You are going
to put them out of business with a couple
of 16-inch lathes, a drill press and a small
sliapcr, a few files, three or four vises and
an emery wheel. How long do you think
it will lake to run one of them out, so
that you can get even his business, to say
nothing about the rest of 'em?" All the
reply to this was that I was trying to dis-
courage them, etc., etc. ; that they didn't
expect to do a big business on the start,
but were willing to go slow until they be-
came known, and so on to the end of the
chapter.
"Well, boys," I said, "that is all very
vague and hopeless to me as regards the
situation. What kind of work do you ex-
pect to get, or be able to do without a
proper outfit? There is no paying work
that can be had in this town anyway, with
what you have ; and how you are going to
get as much money in hand every Satur-
day night as you get now, for months to
come, is past my comprehension, or any-
thing like as much. You don't know what
it costs to run even a small shop like
yours, for coal, oil, all sorts 'of sundries,
broken tools, lost time, bad debts, rent,
and so on. Three dollars a day won't cover
it. Now, can you count upon turning out
at least $8 a day to pay for the shop and
your wages at $2.50 per day? I doubt it
very much, for the first year at least. If
you don't do $10 per day cash in hand
weekly you won't make even the $8."
The reply was that they thought they
could, and upon being asked what kind of
work would return them that amount they
said, with one accord, "job work."
" 'Job work' is very elastic," I said ;
"what sort of job work?"
"Everything that oflFers — sharpening
lawn-mowers, sewing-machine repairs, in-
ventors' models, small break-downs of
printing presses, and so on," they an-
swered.
"Well," I said, "as a rule that sort of
stuff is better out of shop than in it. If
you know anything about that kind of
business you should know that it is a dead
toss from the start. You have to earn a
dollar an hour, let us say, to pay your
wages and the shop ; that is $5 a day. or
50 cents an hour for both of you. It \von't
begin to pan out even if you liad >ob work
all day long and got the cash for it before
the job left the shop. You have forgotten
that there is such a thing as time, which
goes on always without any let-up, aijid
you will lose at least iv/o hours every day
by jobs not failing on to each other. The
job work is a delusion as a means of in-
come. A woman asks you to come and
see what is the matter with her sewing
machine, and you spend half an hour
wa-hing up and going to and coming from
her house. When you get there it takes
you about half an hour, perhaps, to ad-
just the machine. If you charge her 50
cents she feels that she has been robbed —
even if she pays it at all. A man comes
in and wants a set-screw made that he
can't buy in a hardware store. You pull
down the lathe, make his set-screw and
he says, 'How much?' It has spoiled the
best part of an hour, and if you charge
him 25 cents for the set-screw he gets
crazy at once. Where is the money in this
sort of thing? Nowhere. I have seen too
much of it not to know just how it works,"
said I.
"Who does all the job work that is
done," said the boys, "and why is it done
if it doesn't pay, as you say?"
"The big shops do it, and small tinkers
do it who work in their houses, and have
no engines or tools to run and no shop
expenses ; but I never knew a tinker to
make even a decent living. The big shops
have to do it to oblige their customers,
but no shop can live on it alone.
"Well," I continued, "you asked my
views and I have given them, but I don't
think you will profit by them, for, like
lots of other machinists, you think that
because you have worked in a shop you
can carry on a shop, but one does not im-
ply the other. Better stick to the day's
wages you have than the bird-in-the-bush
small shop."
Of course the reader has surmised, or
surmises, that the boys despised instruc-
tion and started the shop, and the reader
is right. They did start about a year ago,
and the shop is still running ; that is to
say they both are still in it, but all the
work they are doing is of little account.
Not only this, but they found that the
shop-gait they had always been used to,
the jog-along, "any old time at all to get
it out" sort of thing wouldn't do in their
own work. But it is very hard to get over
bad habits, and one of them (Richard)
will never get over it. They did get some
good customers, who had a regular line of
work to give out which was profitable, and
I saved them a severe loss on one job that
came in, through their inability to cal-
culate anywhere near the cost of it They
were going to bid $135 for a piece of work
that would have cost $250 at the least, and
this they acknowledged when I showed
them their error; but. as I have said pre-
viously, they are just where they started
as regards position, and do all the work
themselves, except upon occasion when
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
January, 1903.
they hire an extra man or so ; and even
the work they get has come chiefly from a
perijOnal friend, who assuredly will not be
always to the fore. They lack what all
men do who have spent their lives in a
shop, and that is, business experience and
business ways. For instance, a man
wanted some considerable work done and
asked them to come over and make an
estimate of what it would cost. This
stumped them at once; they hadn't the
most remote idea 'of costs and how to get
at them, but they went over and guessed
at it, and didn't get within four miles of
each other's estimate ; one guessed one
price and the other another, and both were
out of the way by 50 per cent. They would
have lost a pretty penny if they had under-
taken the work ; also, they lost about a
day's work in the guesses, and one of them
(Richard) was seriously of the opinion
that a bill should be sent to the man for
the time lost — he made them lose it! I got
wind of a job that was to be done, and
told them of it, adding that if they wanted
it they would have to bid low, as there
was another party — -Mr. Low Bidder by
trade — who was after it. They got the
job, and I was curious to see how they
would get out of it. A few days settled
the question. They slid down hill rapidly;
also, Richard's sand gave out, and he came
to me and said they were going to lose on
the job and asked me to go to the party
and tell him so, and see if he wouldn't
give them a little more ! But this I heart-
lessly declined to do.
Now, this is a round, unvarnished tale
of actual occurrences, suppressing only the
names, which are neither Richard nor
Robin, but it could be duplicated many
times in other places.
Being "a practical man" is no sort of
advantage in business unless it is supple-
mented by other very essential knowledge,
but it leads a good many mechanics to
think that it covers everything needful.
In nine cases out of ten it is utter folly for
men who have life jobs, as these men had,
to leave them in the expectation of mak-
ing something out of nothing. It is a
saying that one cannot make bricks with-
out straw, in which event it is the part of
wisdom to continue making bricks for
other people who have the straw. A small
shop in a growing town, where there is
plenty of work that pays to do, has a
future before it, but it is not difficult to see
the finish of a small shop in a town already
full of shops where the only work to be
done is of a desultory, unprofitable charac-
ter.
Electric Shock Accidents.
A useful insert in the Electrical World
and Engineer, of September 6, appears
as a detached sheet which can be framed
or hung up in a conspicuous place. It re-
lates to the proper procedure to be fol-
lowed in dealing with the victim of an
electric shock. The instructions are com-
piled by Dr. Augustin Goelet ; and two
cuts, showing proper position, are
given. The means for resuscitation in
electric shock accidents are the same as
those for apparent death by drowning.
That is a most important fact. Acci-
dental shocks seldom result in absolute
death unless the victim is left too long
unaided, or efforts at resuscitation are
stopped too early. It is well also to re-
member that the victim seldom receives
the full force of the current in the cir-
cuit, but usually only a shunt current
which may represent a very insignificant
part of the whole. Well directed effort,
persevered in faithfully, will in the great
majority of cases restore those who have
been "struck by lightning" in any form.
As so many of our railroad companies
have electric adjuncts to both shop and
road, the diffusion of this kind of knowl-
edge is most important.
We have received the picture of a
steam engine made so small that a sil-
ver dime is used as a foundation plate;
and the request is made that we illus-
trate it. The thing is a triumph of in-
genuity carried out on a small scale; but
we are not admirers of that species of
industry. The maker's time might have
been employed to a better purpose.
Announcement was made from Phil-
adelphia that the Pennsylvania Railroad
has notified coal shippers that on and
after the ist of June $1 per day de-
murrage will be charged upon cars de-
tained over an average of four
days at Greenwich Point, Perth
Amboy, Harsimus Cove and Bal-
timore. This action will interfere very
seriously with speculators, who, taking
advantage of the anthracite strike and
the consequent increased demand for
bituminous coal, are buying the latter
and using the cars for storage purposes,
pending a market for it at high prices.
The reform is badly needed, and it is a
great pity that it is not now in force, for
it might help to accelerate the delivery
of coal urgently needed. One of the
most absurd moves ever made is that of
an appeal by shippers to the courts to
test the right of railroads to charge de-
murrage.
The Clcncot Mirror says that when the
Santa Fe Railroad was built from Paw-
nee to Ralston the people flocked to the
little town of Skedee to see the first
train go by. The engineer was getting
close to the end of his run, and. think-
ing to have a little fun, climbed down
from the cab and commenced oiling the
engine. This aroused the curiosity of
the people, and they crowded around the
engine to see what he was doing. Having
oiled up, he made two or three jumps for
the cab, pulled the whistle cord, turned
on the steam and opened the cylinder
cocks and yelled: "Look out; I'm going
to turn round." Immediately there was
a scamper for the hills.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
I CAN SELL YOUR BUSINESS
no matter -where it is. Send description, state
price, and learn how. Established '96. Highest
references. Offices in 14 cities.
W. M. Ostraoder, 1550 N. A. Bldg., Philadelphia.
that
INKS
the POINT
■Sha
PARKER
"Lucky Curve'
FOUNTAIN PEN
A Pen that has the 0. K. runninff all the way throueru
9,000 DEALERS SELL THEM
"LfCKT C^KVE"— its easy to remember. KEPT IN
REPAIR FRHE ONE YE.^R. We have a catalogue
wailing for you, as well as the name of a dealer you
know who sells tliem. Both await your request.
THE PARKER PEN 00., 24 Mill St., Janesville, Wis.
WANTED
Assistant Mechanical Superintend-
ent for large works in Canada who
manufacture all kinds of castings,
machinery, pumps, Water Work
supplies, Railway Work and general
forgings.
State experience, age and salary
expected. Apply, giving references,
to Canada Foundry Co., Limited,
Toronto, Canada.
Oil Burning in Locomotives
is described in our new book,
Care of Locomotive Boilers,
50c. - - This Office
Railway ..and
lOcomoiive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co. — I'^OJ
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, Tebruary, 1903
No. 2
A Tour In Scotland.
IIY ANCUS SINCLAIR.
During most of my visits to Europe I
have devoted the greater part of my time
and attention to railway and engineering
interests ; but last summer I paid more
attention to visiting places of scenic and
historical interest, particularly to those of
Scotland, my native country, I made a
variety of short tours, and I venture to
think that brief notes concerning them
may interest the readers of Rmlv/av and
Locomotive Engineering.
The start of one tour was from Perth,
which was once the capital city of Scot-
land, has been the scene of more interest-
ing events in Scot's history than any
the right bank of the Tay through a
beautifully diversified country, enriched
with all the scenic effects of wood, water
and green pastures, backed by aspiring
mountains. A few miles out from Perth
we see at the base of a wooded hill the
Palace of Scone which was long a royal
residence. In an abbey connected with
this palace there once was preserved
with great care and pride what was
known as the "Stone of Destiny." Upon
it the Scots Kings were crowned until it
was carried away to Westminster by Ed-
ward I. when that monarch had Scotland
temporarily under his heel. The stone is
now the base of the coronation chair used
by the British monarchs. The value re-
manded by King Kenneth III. Up to a
late date it was common for farmers
plowing in Luhcarty meadows to turn
up spear heads and pieces of other war-
like weapons. But modern historians
throw doubt upon the whole story. When
I read their expressions of unbelief I feel
like Byron when he wrote :
"I've stood upon Achille's tomb
And heard Tay doubted :
Time will doubt of Rome."
Following the valley of the Tay we
soon reach the mountains with the towns
of Dunkeld and Bimam as the first gate-
way, the carrier point between Lowlands
and Highlands. Above Bimam is a high.
other city outside of Edinburgh; but it
suffered so much from the ravages of war
and of spoilers, lay and clerical, that few
antequarian objects remain within its pfe-
cincts. Its beautiful location on the noble
river Tay and the wooded hills around
it, could not be destroyed by wanton icon-
oclasts, and so the place still deserves its
old loving name of Bonnie St. Johnstown
To merely enumerr.te the historical events
of which Perth was the scene, from 1200,
when it became the seat of the Parlia-
ment, courts of justice and royal residence,
until 1745, when the army of Prmce
Charlie, the last of the Stewart princes,
took possession of the place, would in
itself make a long story. Probably most
of my American readers will associate the
place most familiarly with Scott's "Fair
Maid of Perth."
Pulling out from a remarkably hand-
some station, in a train of cars hauled by
the ten-wheel engine shown, we follow
HIGHI,ANn RAILW.W PASSENGER ENGINE.
posed in the stone came from an old
Scots prophecy :
Except old seers do feign
And wizard wits be blind;
The Scots in place must reign
When they this stone shall find.
-Superstition was a very living force in
the days when this stone was stolen by the
English monarch, and superstition has ex-
erted an amazing inlluence ever since men
looked with apprehension into the uncer-
tain future.
A few miles further north on a "haugh"
of the Tay we pass Luncarty, a place
which years ago inspired awe in the hearts
of history reading Scots. For centuries
the coasts of all the British Isles were
badly harassed by inroads of the sea rob-
bers known as Norsemen. Scotland had
suffered intensely, but in 970 a vast fleet
of the robber Danes ascended the Tay
and were annihilated by an army com-
isolated hiil, from which a magnificent
view is obtained, which seemed to em-
brace all Scotland, when I stood
upon its summit, many years ago.
That was the occasion of my first
holiday tour. On a bright Sunday
morning I was sitting, with two brothers,
on the cairn at the summit of the moun-
tain gazing over the vast expanse of
mountain, field and forest, that a hazeless
and cloudless sky held out in clear relief.
We were joined by three gentlemen, one
of whom knew every spot on the pano-
rama. In telling about the places he told
a humorous anecdote which I have recog-
nized in various forms since that day.
That opening, he said, pointing to the
west, is Glen Brand, through which Prince
Charlie's army passed on its march that
ended on Culloden Moor. Dissensions
had broken out among the clans by this
time, and so many of the Camerons fell out
that the glen is still peopled mostly by
Co
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903,
Cameroiis. It was there that an Enghsh
tourist one day met a shepherd and asked
'him: "Are there any Christians in this
district?" "No," repHed the Highlander,
"they are all Camerons."
Birnam Hill will be familiar to read-
ers of Macbeth through the prophecy
"When Birnam Wood shall come to
Dunsinane." With the fulfilment of
the prophecy the wood must have
been carried away, for there is lit-
tle covering now to the hill except
heather. There are two magnificent trees
near the foot of the hill, an oak and a
sycamore, which are worthy to hold up
ihfiir heads beside the giants of Cali-
fornia. They are the last ot Birnam
Wood.
Dunkeld is a charming town and is said
to have grown up by degrees around a
•church instituted about 570. A cathedral
Jiow in ruins is the principal attraction 10
Grampian Hills, with an old lady highly
versed in Highland lore, and she used to
say that no marriages were so happy as
those that followed when the man went
to the Lowlands or to anotner clan and
forcibly carried away the lass he wanted.
For years there was constant conflict
between the Highlanders and Lowlanders,
each followmg:
"The good rule, the simple plan
That he should take who had the power.
And he should keep who can."
The route is through a series of pic-
turesque glens and passes which have wit-
nessed many hard-fought conflicts in the
days when the Lowlanders and Highland-
ers did not love one another. One of the
most notable fights was the battle of Kil-
iiecrankie. That, however, came from a
piece of political unpleasantness. When
\^'i!liam of Orange and his friends made
system very efficiently. Collisions are
practically unknown, and the few that
have happened were due to the kind of
carelessness that no system can provide
against. It is wonderful to see the ex-
pertness that firemen and signalmen ac-
quire in exchanging the staff or the tick-
ets at the intersection of blocks.
After a time we emerge from the wild
wood, water, crag and towering moun-
tain scenes, to follow courses through
dreary glens with heather-covered hills on
each side. The sheen of the purple heath-
er is attractive these August days, and
the yellow bracken (ferns) and green
grass bordering the mountain torrents,
make some diversity, but the treeless sol-
itudes are not much more attractive than
a journey through a prairie state.
I have used the word solitudes because
that is the character of nearly all the
Scots mountain regions. They are de-
Photo.
SCENE ON HIGHLAND R-filLWAY.
a nyte, i nvetufss.
visitors, but there are many beautiful
places in the neighborhood. Nearly all
the old religious houses in Scotland are
in ruins, most of the destruction having
been effected by the zealous rabble moved
to frenzy by the soul-stirring denuncia-
tions of John Knox, whose jaw was much
more powerful than his judgment, and
ambition stronger than conscience.
In pursuing its northerly direction from
Dunkeld the railway leads us for about
twenty miles through the finest scenery I
have ever looked upon, 'the line follows
the natural pass through the mountains,
which was the route followed by the High-
landers when they made expeditions into
the Lowlands, to take possession of black
cattle, corn or even wives that-were need-
ed for the sustenance, comfort and pleas-
ure of the daring Celts.
There have been curious ways of court-
ing among different people. When I was
a boy I lived for two summers among the
the British crown too hot for King James,
and the last of the Stewart kings fled to
France, a strong party adhered to his
cause and fought for it. A leader among
these was Viscount Dundee, the "Bonnie
Dundee" of song. Dundee fled "to the
hills and the woods and the rocks," as the
song says, and gathered a following of
Highlanders, who were generally spoiling
for a fight.
He was leading his army toward Perth,
when their progress was arrested at the
narrow pass of Killiecrankie by the army
of the king de facto under General
Mackay. A short fierce conflict ensued
and the king's troops badly beaten, but
Bonnie Dundee" was among the slain.
The engine keeps toiling upwards, up-
wards with exhaust of work done seldom
heard in the British Isles, and resembling
more the long pulls on mountain grades
so common in the United States. The
line is single and is operated by the staff
voted to the raising of deer and game
birds, the human animal being kept as far
away as circumstances will permit. Yet
a time was when these glens sustained a
liardy population whose sons fought and
won British battles the world over. But
the time came when game paid better
than the sheep and cattle raised by the
natives, and so the people were driven to
the colonies or into large cities. I can-
not help feeling that Goldsmith's lines
about an Irish village apply very well to
the Highland glens :
"l\\ fares the land, to hastening ills a prey.
When wealth accumulates and men decay.
Princes and lords may flourish or may
fade,
A breath can wake them as a breath has
made :
But a bold peasantry, their country's
pride.
When once destroyed, can never be sup-
plied."
L'l.rii.-iry, Kjo.i
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
6i
111 line mm- we rcac'licd Invt-riuss, a
lK-,-iutifnl liiwn, llif cipilal of llic liiK'i-
laiiils. I he place is well worlliy of a
visit even if a tourist had lo go from
I^dinbiirKli or Glasgow for (lie purpose.
It is on Loch Ness, at the cast end of the
Caledonian Canal, which, by aid of a se-
ries of locks, makes a passage between the
Atlantic and tlie German oceans. I had a
curious encounter here of the kind that
seems to prove tlic world small after all.
I went into a sliop to buy some photo-
graphs and there found Mrs. George Ma-
guire, whose husl)and at one time repre-
sented the Butler Draw-bar Attachment
and other r.iilw.iy supplies. Mrs. Ma-
guire was highly popular at the mechan-
ical conventions during the lifetime of
her husband, and will still be remembered
by many of luy readers.
other side set like a diamond among the
dark green woods. By the aid of a glass
we can distinguish the Stars and Stripes
waving from the highest pinnacle of the
castle. There is no fear that Mrs. Car-
negie's child will ever have to ask, what
Hag is that? as the children of an Amer-
ican lady of high degree living in Europe
are said to have asked on seeing the Amer-
ican flag as they were entering New York
harbor.
A visit to Skibo Castle impresses one
witli the noble simplicity of living followed
by the family and the princely hospitality of
ihe host and hostess toward numerous vis-
itors. Mr. Carnegie is an ideal Highland
laird and is carrying out magnificent im-
provements for the good of the district,
and he is very popular among the natives
who are not in the habit of receiving
and-pin draw bar maimed a greater num-
ber, these figures show that it killed
only 3.68 per cent, of its victims while
the automatic coupler has been fatal in
5.9 per cent, of the fewer cases where in-
jury occurred.
"On the Road to riandelay."
If you want to read an account of an
interesting engineering work in Upper
Burma, get the Pennsylvania Steel
Company, of Steelton, Pa., to send you
a most artistic pamphlet called "From
Steelton to Mandelay," which they have
just issued, detailing the building of the
famous Goktcit viaduct. This steel
bridge is 2,260 feet long and 320 feet
ma.ximum height. It spans the gorge
formed by the Chungzoune river, which
disappears in a natural tunnel 500 feet
Photo.
W/tvU^ Inverness.
STRATHPEFFER ON HIGHLAND RAILWAY.
From Inverness I made a visit to Cul-
loden Moor, where the last of the Stewart
princes fought the last fight to gain the
British crown. It is a dreay spot, this
"field of the dead," and was a fit ending
for a hopeless cause.
There are inany other interesting and
attractive places about Inverness which
will well repay the attention of people
who enjoy seeing places which have been
the theater of valiant human endeavor.
After a few days spent in this neighbor-
hood I resumed my journey northward.
The railway by much twisting follows the
Moray Firth past many thriving towns and
villages that have the air of being fin-
ished and are cleaned up and decorated
in nature's pieasantest garb, making com-
fortable homes for an industrious popu-
lation. At the mouth of the Dornach
Firth, an arm of the sea that stretches
deep inward, we see Skibo Castle on the
strangers with open arms. The only crit-
icism I heard of him was. from a free kirk
Highlander, who said that Mr. Carnegie
might spend his money to better purpose
than putting whistling organs into their
kirks.
Effect of the Coupler Law.
The New York Commercial Advertiser
prints some statistics regarding the car-
coupler law which shows that great im-
provement has taken place. It says : "In
1893, the year the car-coupler law was
passed, the number of casualties caused
by the coupling and uncoupling of cars
by the old link-and-pin arrangement was
11,710. of which 433 were fatal. Last
year, the first year in which the law was
in full effect, the total number of casu-
alties from this caiise was 2,256, of which
133 were fatal."
It is evident that though the old link-
below the viaduct foundations. This
gorge lies 80 miles east of Mandelay,
the capital of Burma, on the railroad to
Kulon. The entire w'ork was done by
this enterprising company, and the ma-
terial, which was made at Steelton, Pa.,
traveled 10,599 miles to the bridge
site. The work was completed and the
bridge opened by Sir Frederic Fryer,
lieutenant governor of Burma in June,
1901. The pamphlet contains numerous
beautifully executed illustrations and ar-
ticles reprinted from the World's Work
and the Engineering Record, oi New
York. The cover shows a sketch of the
Steelton plant with tall black chimneys
belching smoke, and a consolidation en-
gine in the foreground, in strong con-
trast to the golden pagoda at Rangoon,
where, as Kipling says: "We useter
watch the steamers an' the hathis pilin'
teak — on the road to Mandelay."
62
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 190J.
Mr. Andrew Carnegie on Libraries.
The Carnegie Public Library, tlie gift
of Andrew Carnegie to the City of
Washington, was dedicated on January
7. President Roosevelt delivered an ad-
dress and Mr. Carnegie replied. In the
course of the reply Mr. Carnegie said:
"I shall not descant upon the advan-
tages of the free library, but this seems
our young men, in Pittsburg — how many
years ago I need not mention — I told
them to put all their eggs in one basket
and then watch that basket. I have been
a concentrator all my life. I have sel-
dom or never known a great success
made by the jack of all trades, the board
member in twenty companies, the con-
troller of none. I am in the library man-
sap the foundation of manly independ-
ence, because it does not pauperize, be-
cause it stretches a hand to the aspiring
and places a ladder upon which they can
only ascend by doing the climbing them-
selves. You cannot boost a man up a
ladder. This is not charity, this is not
philanthropy, it is the people themselves
helping themselves by taxing themselves.
They owe no man anything of moment."
VIEW OF PERTH FRO.M B.\RNHILL.
an opportune occasion to explain just
what the free library business means
upon which I have embarked. Seven
hundred and thirty library buildings have
been given, chiefly within the last two
years, and most of them are built or
under construction. During July last,
276 applications for library buildings
were received from various parts of the
English-speaking world, all of which
were or are being dealt with. Upon ar-
rival in New York last month we found
over four hundred and fifty additional
applications from the United States and
Canada awaiting inquiry and decision,
in regard to nearly all of which my sec-
retaries are now in correspondence.
"From England, Ireland, Scotland,
New Zealand, Tasmania, Australasia,
Mexico and other parts, the cry is,
'Still they come,' for we have to-day
385 new applications on hand. Thus
there are under way to-day more than
800 applications, the great majority of
which will, no doubt, be given. Some
will not be, for none are passed without
careful investigation and unless we are
satisfied that there is a community trib-
utary to the library which is willing and
an.xious to support it as you were in
Washington, thus making them in the
fullest sense the libraries of the people,
because maintained by the people.
"One reason for mentioning these fig-
ures is that it may relieve us of the
charge of rudeness in not replying to the
thousand and one suggestions which are
made, urging entrance upon other fields
of usefulness, while we are unable to
keep pace with the demands of the work
in hand.
"In my first public address made to
ufacturing business and beg to be al-
lowed to concentrate my time upon it
until it is filled. If ever it is filled I shall,
of course, have to look out for other
employment. That day, however, as you
see, seems somewhat remote. As long
as communities are willing as you are
in Washington, to maintain a library
from the proceeds of taxation, as part of
the city's educational system, thus mak-
ing it the library of
the people and an
adjunct of the public
school system, so
Trutli is Stranger Tiian Fiction.
A "tall talker" was retailing to an
admiring audience the many wonderful
things which he had done, or had seen
done in the course of his non-railroad
but most illustrious career. His state-
ments were full of the "Yes-sir-I-saw-
it-myself" style of doubtful verification,
and he told of things which in sober
truth didn't happen because they
couldn't happen. A railroad man in the
party stood it patiently as long as he
could, and then quietly remarked, "In
my profession I daily see far more really
wonderful things accomplished which
are the result of careful observation and
hard thinking than anything which even
the most gifted 'spellbinder' can im-
agine or narrate — a bluffer is simply
wasting time on a mechanical engineer
nowadavs."
A Cranky Section Hand.
Patrick McCabe, lately a section hand
on the 'Frisco road at Wichita, is suing
that corporation for damages for injuries
received while in its employ. His plea
is that while work-
ing the foreman
spoke to him "in a '.
loud, profane and
UIGlILAXIi RAILWAY
long I intend to labor in that vineyard,
keeping myself free as possible from
hearing of the woes and wants of hu-
manity in general, to which, if I lis-
tened, I would soon become unfit for my
special work, which I think best of all,
for among all the suggestions made —
and they are numberless — not one have
I found which, to my mind, equals the
free library maintained by the people as
a field for the wise distribution of sur-
plus wealth. I think it fruitful in the ex-
treme, because the library gives nothing
for nothing, because it helps only those
that help themselves, because it does not
;iAKlNr,
(lUTFir.
very boisterous manner, thereby causing
this plaintiff to be nervous and excited,
and thereby causing him to place hiinself
in a position of great bodily danger, and
to a greater degree than he otherwise
would have done." The orders were
given "in a very loud and boisterous
manner, backed up by many oaths, such
as 'Be smart,' 'Be quick,' and 'Move
yourself,' etc.". Kansas section hands
seem to be sensitive plants.
"A rolling stone gathers no moss," but
velocity is sometimes worth more than
verdure. — Four-Track Nezvs.
February, igoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
63
Newest Shops of the Canadian Pacific
Railway.
The present shops of the Canadian
Pacific Railway situated at the corner of
Delorimcr avenue and St. Catherine
street, Montreal, are generally called, on
the road, the "New Shops," though they
have been in existence (or more than
eighteen years. At the present time
plans have been prepared and some of
the buildings have been erected for a
thoroughly modern as well as an abso-
lutely new plant.
The Canadian Pacific Railway people
have purchased land in the eastern part
of Montreal and are placing their now-
correctly-stylcd "New Shops" at the
head of Mireau street, on the line to
Quebec, formerly the Q., M. O. & O.
Ry. The grounds will occupy about 350
acres, being about 4,500 ft. long and
2,000 ft. wide, a plan of which was pub-
The capacity of the plant is to be 75
new engines per annum, in addition to
tlie heavy repairs to 400 engines in the
same time. The wheel foundry will have
an output of 250 wheels per day. The
passenger car shops will be able to turn
out 100 new and 900 repaired cars per
year, while the freight car shops are ex-
pected to turn out from 25 to 30 new
cars per day while keeping up heavy re-
pairs on 100 old cars a day. The power
house details are at present under con-
sideration, but electrical power will be
used throughout with individual machine
and group motors in the various shops.
The disposition of the shops on the
ground is such that the almost indefinite
extension of any one shop or depart-
ment has been provided for without dan-
ger of interfering with or cramping any
other.
The tracks leading to and beside the
ing are done. It is claimed for tliis form
of construction that engnics can be very
economically handled inasmuch as there
is only the minimum lift required, every
time an engine is moved. This not only
reduces risk of accident by avoiding a
high lift, but the power expended in the
operation is probably the least required
of any system where lifting is done. En-
trance may be had at one end and de-
parture at the other, so that the parallel
track system does not cause any inter-
ference with incoming or outgoing en-
gines. Boilers enter the shop at one end,
while the products of the foundry and
smithy enter it from the other end.
In connection with the passenger car
shops is a 75-ft. transfer table which is
located much nearer one shop than the
other, thus giving very valuable space
with parallel tracks in the rear of one of
the buildings. The cars are moved upon
Photo.
URQUHART CASTLE. I.OCH NESS, HIGHL.AND RAILWAY.
IV/iyte, Inverness.
lished in our December, 1902, issue. At
present locomotive repairs and building
is done at Delorimer avenue, and the car
work at Hochelaga, a suburb of Mon-
treal, and the object of the new shops
is to concentrate in one plant of ample
proportions and modern equipment and
tinder one head, the work which is now
done in overcrowded workshops and at
separate points.
The total floor space of the buildings
is about 75,000 sq. ft. which amounts to
something over 17 acres. _ The buildings
are to be of pressed brick, on rubble
stone and concrete foundation. The
roof trusses will be steel for the locomo-
tive shop, the smithy and the foundry,
while the car department buildings will
have combination trusses, though the
columns in all the buildings will be made
of structural steel. The hot blast sys-
tem of heating will be used throughout.
various shops all run parallel with the
length of the grounds, and in the center,
an outside overhead traveling crane
crosses these tracks so that material can
be unloaded where convenient, traversed
across and delivered wherever required.
The machine and erecting shops are un-
der one roof with boiler shop slightly
ofifset so as to provide for a separate
through track and entrance at both ends
for the boiler shop as well as the large
opening into the machine shop. The
erecting "pits" in the erecting shop are
three long tracks, if one may say so,
the center one being kept clear for the
movement of material, and also for the
entrance and exit of the locomotives.
Engines which arrive on the center
track are moved where required and are
then lifted sideways by two cranes to
either of the parallel tracks, made with
pits, upon which the striping and erect-
this transfer table, as they are of course
not lifted, and the arrangement of the
tracks leading to and from the transfer
table is such that it is possible to turn
a coach, or for that matter an engine,
end for end without the necessity of in-
stalling a turn-table. There is also a
half-circle track in the yard which may
be used for the same purpose.
It is understood that about $2,000,000
will be expended on this plant which
will put the Canadian Pacific fully
abreast of the times as far as up-to-date
shop facilities and modern practice is
concerned. The buildings at present
erected, or in course of erection, are the
boiler shop, the machine-erecting shop,
the foundry and the smithy. Contracts
for most of the others have been let and
work upon them all will be steadily
pushed to completion.
64
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
Southern Pacific Pension System.
We consider that the pension system
introduced by President Harriman for
the employees of the Southern Pacific
Company is more equitable toward the
people to be benefited than the systems
introduced upon other railroads.
In general the plans is similar to the
system of the Pennsylvania, Illinois
Central and the Chicago & Northwest-
ern roads. Employees who have attained
the age of 70 and who have been in the
service 20 years or more are to receive
pensions on the basis of l per cent, a
year of the average salary received for
10 years previous to pensioning for each
year of service.
Thus an employee whose pay has aver-
aged $1,000 a year for 10 years prior to
outlined was that each tie should have
a special nail driven into it, at some
specified distance from one rail or mid-
way between the two. The nails should
be made of steel, covered with zinc or
tin, and having the year stamped in the
head. Such nails could be had for about
6 cents a pound, each pound containing
about 30 nails. When put in by the sec-
tion gang the extra labor would be
very light considering the accurate rec-
ord which would thereby be secured.
It occurs to us that if this system of
nail-dating was adopted, the month
when any renewal was made could be
recorded by fixing the position of the
nail at a certain definite distance from
a selected rail. For example, the nails
driven in January might all be placed
the use of greases disclosed tlie fact
that they gradually worked their way to
the bottoms of the cylinders and were
rolled up into balls. Realizing the ne-
cessity and value of a lubricant that
would satisfactorily meet with the re-
quirements of air-brake lubrication, the
New York and New Jersey Lubricant
Co., of 14 and 16 Church street. New
York city, after much experimenting,
succeeded in producing a non-fluid oil
air-brake lubricant. E.xhaustive tests
made by many of the leading railways
has demonstrated the fact that non-fluid
oil does not gravitate to the bottoms of
the cylinders, nor roll up into balls, but
remains on the walls of the cylinders,
thus keeping the leathers in excellent
condition. We are informed that several
Phol,'
SCENE ON HIGHLAND RAILWAY.
H'hyte, hiverness.
retirement and who had been in the
service of the company for 30 years
would receive a pension equal to 30 per
cent, of $1,000 or $300 a year. Between
the ages of 61 and 70 years employees in-
capacitated for further work may be re-
tired by a pension board, provided they
shall have been in the service 20 years
or more.
The employees make no contributions
to the fund, pensions being paid by the
company in full and without any condi-
tion, the employees being at liberty to en-
gage in other business after being pen-
sioned, should they see fit.
Dating Ties with Nails.
The marking of ties has been sug-
gested by the committee of the Amer-
ican Railway and Maintenance of Way
Association, which had the matter in
hand, for report at the third annual
convention. The method of marking
two inches from one designated rail
flange. Those driven in February, four
inches; those in March, six inches, and
so on, increasing the distance by two
inches as month succeeded month. The
nails driven in December would be 24
inches from the rail flange, and as that
distance is less than half way between
the rails, no confusion would arise as
to which rail was the rail selected to
measure from.
Fluid Oil.
A few years ago fluid oils were con-
sidered to be best adapted for lubricat-
ing air brake cylinders, triple valves, etc.;
later, greases were used quite largely
for this purpose. Results obtained from
the service of both these products, how-
ever, were not entirely satisfactory.
Fluid oils were found to gravitate to the
bottoms of the cylinders, leaving the tops
dry or improperly lubricated, whereas
of the leading air-brake superintendents
and inspectors after making tests have
decided that this lubricant is more gen-
erally satisfactory than the fluid oils and
greases which were formerly used, and
that it will greatly facilitate the efficient
service of air-brake equipment. The N.
Y. & N. J. Lubricant Co. will be pleased
to submit testing samples free of charge,
by prepaid express, to air-brake inspec-
tors who desire to give their non-fluid
oil air-brake lubricant a test.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works are
so rushed with orders that they have
declined to make contracts for locomo-
tives except with the understanding that
deliveries are not to be made within a
year from date of contract. This condi-
tion of affairs has compelled some of the
.\nierican railroads to follow the ex-
ample of the Canadian Pacific and seek
abroad for their new engines.
February, igo.j.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE EKGINEERINfi
65
• Notes from Europe.
All entirely new type of tank engine
lias been built at tlie Great Lastern Kail-
way shops at Stratford. It has ten
eoupled wheels, 4 ft. 6 in. in diameter,
driven by three high pressure eyliudcrs,
iS i-_>.\24 in. The boiler, which is 5 -ft. ,3
ill. in diameter, has a firebox of large di-
mensions, similar In the Wouteii type.
-A. novel form of cunnectiiig rod f(jr the
inside cylinder is provided to clear the
front axle. Two safety valves, working
at 200 lbs. per square inch, are fitted, one
column containing four "pop" valves, the
other being of the ordinary Ranisbottom
type. It is expected with this engine at
starting to attain a speed of 30 miles per
hour in 30 seconds, with heavy suburban
trains of 15 carriages, seating 792 pass-
engers, and often carrying nearly 1.200.
seven vehicles, the two private saloons
running on six-wheeled trucks. The in-
terior of the cars are beautifully fur-
nished, and electricity has been intro-
duced for many purposes, including the
heating of the various apartments, wav-
ing fans for warm weather and cigar
lighters for the King's smoking com-
partment. In the attendants' compart-
ments at the end of the saloons electrical
appliances for cooking are fittc<l. Al-
together, the train is a perfect luxury,
and nothing can approach it in this or
any other country.
The Metropolitan Underground Rail-
ways of London, after experimenting for
some considerable time with electric
traction, are putting into service their
first regular electric train on the new
Kaling & Harrow section. New trains
trolling gear being lined with sheet iron
and asbestos for protection in case of
fire. As it was intended in the original
idea of this line to run the standard
Great Northern suburban trains by a
physical junction onto the new line, the
tunnels have been constructed 16 ft. in
diameter, as compared with the 12 ft.
tube of the Central London. Now it
has been decided to build the Kinsbury
Park station underground, although the
public will benefit by the increased size
and accommodation of the cars. The
motor cars seat 71 and the trailers yi
passengers each, the total seating ca-
pacity of the train being 505, which is
a record for this type of railway, the
nearest approach being a Central Lon-
don train accommodating 288 passengers.
With a view of decreasing the vibration.
CULI-ODEN MOOR,
NEAR INVERNESS, WHERE THE ROYAL HOL'SH OF STE\V.\KT MET ITS FINAL DEFEAT FIGHTING luR
A CROWN. STONES MARK GRAVES OF HIGHLANDERS.
The Great Central have recentlj' re-
ceived from Messrs. Neilson & Co., Glas-
gow, some engines of two diflferent types;
one a six-coupled passenger, with lead-
ing bogie, and the other an eight-coupled
for mineral traffic. In point of detail,
both classes are to the present locomo-
tive superintendent, Mr. J. G. Robinson's
standard, and are painted black, with red
lining. The principal dimensions are:
six coupled bogie Eicrht coup-
pas.sengers.
Cylinders 19x26 in.
Coupled whee'.s , 72 in.
Boiler dia s6^4 in., 4 ft. 8^ in.
Total heat, surface. . 1,74s sq.ft.
Weight of engine \, ^ ^^
in working order ' •t^,^'^
led goods.
19x26 in.
5S in.
57 in.
1,765 sq.ft.
137, 200 lbs.
The London & Northwestern Railway
have constructed at their Wolverton
carriage shops an elaborate royal train
for the use of King Edward VII and
Queen Alexandra. It is composed of
of seven vestibuled coaches are being
constructed with three motors working
on the "multiple unit" system. These
trains have seating accommodation for
330 passengers. The .cars have sliding
doors at center and on the end platforms
a conductor controls the lattice gates of
the adjacent cars. To the list of the
completed underground electric railways
will shortly have to be added the Great
Northern & City Railway, connecting the
Great Northern Railway at Finsbury
Park with the city. The trains, which
are of an elaborate design, have been
built for the contractors, Messrs. Pear-
son & Sons, from the designs of Sir
Douglas Fox and partners. As in the
Metropolitan Underground trains just
referred to, these trains have a motor
carriage at each end, and one in the cen-
ter, the compartment containing the con-
the tunnel tubes are of novel formation,
the upper half being of cast iron seg-
ments, while the lower are of brick.
.Among British railways that are fit-
ting locomotives with liquid fuel on the
Holden system are the Furness & North
Eastern. The former have recently ap-
plied it to a six-coupled side tank, with
the ordinary arrangement, the oil being
stored in the bunker. The latter com-
pany have had two of their large pass-
enger engines running for some time of
the Scotch expresses with great suc-
cess, especially in the case of the six-
coupled bogie engine of Mr. Wilson
Worsdell's design. No. 2,006. exhibited
at the Paris exhibition in 1900. In these
engines, and also the 6 ft. 8 in. six-coupled
successful coal-firing is very ditticult. as
the trains are heavy and booked on very
fast time. .A compact oil fuel supply
66
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Februarj", 1903.
plant has been laid down at Gateshead
shed, and several engines are to be fitted.
The experimental freight locomotive,
which the Lancashire & Yorkshire Rail-
way have had rinining for some time,
fitted with the Vanderbilt cylindrical
firebox, has, we understand, turned out
very satisfactorily, and twenty more en-
gines are in hand at the Harwich Works,
and the adoption of this type of boiler
and firebo.x will probably follow on
other lines.
The officials of the English and French
railway companies, running the cross
channel services between Dover and
Calais, have been investigating the pos-
1893, will be remembered by many of our
readers. The latest type of engine of Mr.
Webb's design is the four-cylinder g3m-
pound "King Edward VII" class, many of
which have been built at Crewe, and are
working the West Coast Scotch ex-
presses and fast Manchester & Birming-
ham traffic very satisfactorily. In the
electrical work of the company, Mr.
Webb has shown great ingenuity, and
among his many introductions the Webb-
Thompson electrical stafif apparatus for
single line working is a well-known ap-
plance, adopted on all the single-track
lines of the L. & N. W. R. and largely
used in the U. S. A. Mr. Webb has
of the British railw'ays, and it js to be
hoped they will be able to select a sat-
isfactory one, which will be adopted by
all, and not allow the present variety to
be increased in numbers, and so repeat
the errors of the brake question. The
enormous expense of keeping up two
brake systems, air and vacuum, becomes
a serious matter now, when the operat-
ing expenses of the British railways
absorb such a large percentage of the
receipts. While mentioning brakes, the
"either side" wagon hand brake con-
troversy still rages, and practically noth-
ing is settled, although many favor the
idea that the companies are fencing the
question, pending the adoption of some
better coupler and continuous brakes on
freight trains. To show the miscellaneous
variety of connections between carriages
in use in Europe, we annex some photos
taken on various railways.
A de Glehn four-cylindered six-coupled
express locomotive is being constructed
at Belfast in France for one of the Brit-
ish trunk roads.
SKIBO CASTLH, SUMMER RESIDENCE OF THE WORLD'S GREATEST STEEL MAKER.
Sir Hiram and Lady Maxim on one
occasion were s'taying at a southern wa-
tering place. When the time came to pay
the bill the landlord of the hotel looked
askance at the proffered check. He
knew the name, but had no evidence that
the signer was the owner of it. Sir Hiram
had not enough cash in his pocket to
meet the case. Lady Maxim then invited
the proprietor to go down to the pier,
put a penny in a slot machine, and look.
sibility of adopting a ferry to replace the
steamers, and have recently inspected
those in use between the islands of the
Danish Peninsula, where for a long
long period they have worked satisfac-
torily. The Continental gauge is 1.5
meters, or approximately 4 ft. 9 in. be-
tween the rails, while the British standard
is 4 ft. 8 1-2 in. There need be little dif-
ficulty from this fact, but as the maxi-
mum width of the Nord vestibuled cars
running between Calais and Paris is
9 ft. II in., and the outside dimension of
the South Eastern & Chatham stock on
the English side is only 8 ft. 6 in., there is
no possibility of running the French
trains through to London, although the
English cars would reach Paris all right.
Freight cars of large capacity are slow-
ly making their appearance on the va-
rious lines, the latest being a 30-ton cov-
ered goods, wagon and box car for the
Lancashire & Yorkshire Railway, built
to the designs of Mr. H. A. Hay, the
company's mechanical engineer.
After a period of 46 years' service with
the London & North Western Railway,
Mr. Webb, the eminent chief mechanical
engineer, is retiring. The success of his
compound locomotives is world-re-
nowned, and his exhibit of the "Queen
Empress" at the Chicago exhibition of
INVERNESS CASTLE.
brought the Crewe Works up to a very
high standard of efficiency, and every-
thing mechanical connected with the rail-
way is made there, the space occupied
by the various departments being now
116 acres.
The adoption of a standard vestibule
connection for passenger cars is now en-
gaging the attention of the chief officials
He saw a "moving picture" of Sir Hiram
firing a Maxim gun in the presence of
the Shah of Persia. That evidence was
conclusive. — A^. Y- Commercial Adver-
tiser.
A word in earnest is as good as a
speech. — Bleak House.
Fcliruary, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
67
General Correspondence.
Overloading Eng;ines.
Are tlic railway companies S(>l\iiiy ihe
problem of freight transportation suc-
cessfully? Arc they not sacrificing rev-
enue in order to show up a big ton-mile
haul? We know they are destroying the
efficiency of their power by overloading
and sending tlieir engines to the repair
sliops long before they should be there,
all on account of some official of high
degree whose idea of economy got
started on the wrong track.
The superintendent of motive power
must slight his work because of the small
amount allowed for repairs, and the con-
dition of the engines is shown (on paper)
as first-class when really far from it.
The enginemen are cut on valve oil so
that the internal resistance of the ma-
chinery, which under favorable condi-
tions is from 10 to 15 per cent., goes up
to 25 or more. Not only does this mean
a loss of horse power, but also a decided
mcrease of coal consumption. An in-
crease of oil means a decrease of coal
consumption. The additional expense in-
curred for oil to secure the best results
would be more than compensated for by
the saving in coal. Suppose you give an
engine one pint of valve oil valued at
7 cents to make a run of 125 miles, con-
suming 14 tons of coal at $1 per ton, and
you then increase the oil allowance to
one and a half pints, at a cost of 11 cents.
and cut down your coal consumption to
13 tons (which is a fair inference based
on personal experience), does this not
show a net gain of 96 cents on the right
side of the ledger?
Rememljcr, when you cut tlie necessary
supplies below what they should be, you
encourage your employees to be dis
honest.
Give an engine a fair rating, with an
average speed of 20 miles per hour, and
you will move more cars with her over
her district in a week than you can, if
you load her down, allowing no reserve
power and cutting down the speed to 10
miles or less. While it is true that your
ton mile per train will be less with the
former, your revenue will be greater on
account of the reduced time of freight
in transit. For instance, if a car passes
over a district in 10 hours, and returns
to the starting point in another 10 hours,
that car is earning just double as much
as the car that consumes 20 hours going
one way.
The argument may be made that by
mcreasing the load per train, we have
fewer trains on the line, and reduce the
danger of accidents, which looks very
well in print, but let us look at the mat-
ter from another point, and sec if it is
not true that we increase the danger in-
stead of diminishing it. Is an engineer's
brain as clear and safe when he is on
the road 25 or 30 hours, as when he is
out only 10 hours?
The passenger engineer working five
or six hours has the right of track over
the freight men, and the latter have to
keep out of his way. The passenger man
assumes no risk, the freight man all. The
former has regular hours of rest after
each trip, the latter none. The man with
the longest working hours has the short-
est rest.
The majority of railroad accidents are
due to overworked brains, and, likewise,
the overloaded engine is productive of
the most failures. An engineer with an
overworked brain is not only a dangerous
risk to the public, but a financial loss to
his employer.
The capacity of an engine for work
depreciates according to the service she
is put to, and the length of time she is
kept in that service. Her rating ought,
therefore, to be re-established from time
to time.
Don't ask your enginemen to do the
impossible with power that ought to be
ofT the ri«ht of way. Have a pleasant
word for them. Don't censure them for
your mistakes.
Cut down your tonnage so that your
enginemen can get over the road on
schedule time. They would rather have
rest than overtime. The results will
show in increased revenue, and it is the
large revenue a road earns and not big
ton-miles that makes the stock "gilt-
edged" J, A. B.
Watch Inspection.
I am not a shouting Methodist, but
I had to let go a big amen when read-
ing in your December issue the little
item about oppression in watch inspec-
tion service.
The writer has looked on aghast at the
workings of these so-called watch inspec-
tions, having been in a position for many
years to see and to know the true in-
wardness of many of them. The most
general plan seems to be to "farm out"
the watch inspection to the lowest bid-
der, the bidder doing the work without
salary, or at least only enough to pay for
postage stamps, depending for his profits
on "what he can get out of it."
This scheme reminds one of the con-
tracts to bury paupers, as let in most
cities, where the price paid for each in-
terment is not enough to pay for the
lumber in a rough wooden box, yet these
contracts arc eagerly sought after, and
in most cases pay big profits.
Many of these watch inspection rules
are monuments of ingenuity, and look
on their faces as honest as the proverbi-
al mule, but when the poor train man is
forced under the rules of the company
to approach their business end and twist
their tails, the result is the same in both
cases, except the mule lands the blow on
the stomach, while the philanthropic
watch inspector, who is doing the work
for "what he can get out of it," lands a
blow on the pocket book.
The writer has tried a thousand times
to picture to himself the expression that
would come over the face of a general
manager, should he be approached with
the proposition to make the writer su-
perintendent of motive power and ma-
chinery, without salary, but depending on
"what he could make out of it" for re-
muneration. No doubt also that many
of the large railroad supply houses would
jump at the opportunity to furnish a pur-
chasing agent, free of cost, to the rail-
road company, but where is the general
manager who would even discuss such a
proposition? Yet, they are not a whit
more absurd than many watch inspection
schemes, the only difference being that
a different lot of men would have to
"pay the freight."
There is no doubt that general man-
agers are honest in the belief that they
are doing the right thing: indeed many
of the rules submitted for their approval
would almost deceive the elect if they
were not fortified with years of experi-
ence in the watch business, which few of
them are.
As your item referred to in the begin-
ning of this article says, no doubt if the
matter could be brought to their notice,
they would afford relief: in the mean-
time, one who sees the true inwardness
of many of the schemes feels like look-
ing up, and exclaiming, how long, oh
Lord, how long?
A Quiet Observer
Defects of Sanders.
A number of air-operated sand de-
vices have been gotten up, but they all
have some defective parts as well as all
other appliances, but I think they have
never been shown up before. The first
thing to look for is the leaks which may
occur in pipe connection between the
blower valve and the sand box. Second.
if the valve is left wide open it reduces
the pressure below that in the train line.
68
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
and applies tlie brakes. A strainer should
be used in pipe connections to keep scale
out of the nipple. A great many sand
pipes become choked up by water which
is carried from the main drum and
dampens the inside of the sand pipe. Of
course we understand that the round-
house men are very particular about
keeping stones out of the boxes.
The next consideration is the proper
place where the sand should be made to
strike the rail. Where the sand is blown
exactly in angle between wheel and rail the
wheel will reach the sand before it can
blow off the rail. If blown directly down
at right angles to the rail the air pres-
sure will take the sand off the rail, and
when blown against the wheel it will
cause the sand to form a spray. A num-
ber of engines are run with one sand
pipe stopped up, and there is then no
sand on one side. Sand is useful on a
slippery or greasy rail, and consequently
the wheels on the side where the sand
pipe is stopped up, will have no grip on
the rail, and it is safe to say that a great
many axles are sprung on this account.
An engine slipping causes a shock to
the fire and reduces the speed of the
train so that altogether it means an ex-
tra scoop or two of coal. Another thing
to consider is the number of wheels that
may be sanded, and the shorter distance
the train may be stopped in when sand
is used. This latter will have to be con-
sidered later on. J. F. Kurth.
Fargo, N. D.
" Stop, Look and Listen!"
There are certain outward and visible
characteristics about each of tlie great
railway systems which interest both the
locomotive engineer and the observing
traveler in the coach or Pullman car.
Warning signs at grade crossings afford
an instance in point. These vary as
much in what they say as in the material
of which they are constructed and the
forms in which they are erected. Not a
few of them, if traced back to their be-
ginnings, would develop interesting sto-
ries.
Perhaps the best known of these is
the one which is seen along all the lines
of the Reading system. It is the miillum
in parvo of them all, expressing in brief-
est and simplest, yet in the strongest
terms, the duty of the pedestrian or
driver of a road vehicle crossing at
grade to "Stop, Look and Listen." An
additional significance attaches from the
fact that this sign has gradually found
its way over the continent. Nor is its
use confined any longer to the steam
lines, the electric railways of central
New York being the last to adopt it.
Within the past month the Utica & Mo-
hawk Valley (electric) Railway has
erected it at a large number of crossings
in fifteen cities and villages from Her-
kimer to Rome, including the New Hart-
ford-Clinton branch.
Various accounts of the origin and
adoption of this sign have been given,
with no two seeming to agree. Inter-
ested to discover and record the actual
facts in the case, the writer addressed
an inquiry to Judge Campbell, general
solicitor of the road, at the Reading
Terminal, Philadelphia, who took the
matter up in the writer's behalf and re-
ferred it to the two gentlemen acquaint-
ed with the subject and responsible in
some way or other for it. These gen-
tlemen were Colonel J. C. Fuller, vice-
president and manager in charge of con-
struction of the old Gettysburg & Har-
risburg Railroad, now a part of one of
the Reading branches, and Mr. J. A.
Sweigard, then general manager of the
Reading.
Colonel Fuller's reply to Judge Camp-
bell is in part as follows: 'Tn building
the Gettysburg & Harrisburg Railroad
we were obliged to cross many public
roads, and were about to prepare a no-
tice to put up at each crossing, when my
attention was called to a court decision
in a suit brought for injury at a cross-
ing. The judge made use of this lan-
guage, that it is the duty of every one
to 'stop, look and listen before crossing
a railroad.' I at once adopted the words,
'Stop, Look and Listen,' believing it a
legal point in determining the respon-
sibility of both the public and the rail-
road. I distinctly remember the trip of
Mr. McLeod (president), and%Ir. Swei-
gard (general manager), over the road,
and our conversation regarding this
sign. I have always felt that the use of
the phrase originated with me, feeling
considerable pride when Mr. McLeod
and Mr. Sweigard adopted it for your
(the Reading) lines."
Mr. J. A. Sweigard confirms the above
to Judge Campbell as follows: "The cir-
cumstances were that Mr. McLeod and
myself were on an inspection trip over
the old H. & P. line and the Gettysburg
& Harrisburg, frotn Carlisle to Gettys-
burg, and while on the latter road we
noticed signs bearing this wording. I
called Mr, McLeod's attention to the
sign and recommended its adoption, in
which he agreed and directed me to call
his attention to the matter on our re-
turn to this city (Philadelphia), which I
did, and the sign was made standard.
The sign we saw there was a small af-
fair, made of iron, and we, of course,
improved on the size of letters and
style, but the wording was used exactly
as we found it."
A supplementary note by Mr. Wm.
Hunter, chief engineer of the Reading
lines at the present time, adds that the
crossings sign was adopted by the com-
pany for use in the State of Pennsyl-
vania on July 23, 1891. In his letter to
the writer, Judge Campbell states the
fact that it was found to be "especially
adapted to circumstances covering the
rule of the law governing travelers upon
public highways when approaching a
railroad crossing at grade." Ex-Pres-
ident A. A.' McLeod died a short time
ago in New York. Robert Bruce.
Clinton, Oneida Co., N. Y.
Development of the Railroad Car.
BY EUGENE CHAMBERLIN.
The ininimum cost per ton per mile
at which freight can be carried, and
methods to be adopted to attract and re-
tain the patronage of the traveling pub-
lic, are problems constantly confronting
railroad companies, possibly to an em-
phasized degree to-day on account of
keen competition.
Attempts to satisfactorily solve these
problems have had all to do with im-
provements in the past and constantly
going on in railroad equipment.
With possibly rare exceptions, the
principal revenue of a railroad is derived
from its freight trafific, and consequently
the necessity of a freight vehicle which
will most economically perform its func-
tions is not only desirable, but abso-
lutely essential if a satisfactory earning
capacity is to be established and main-
tained.
By a reference to well-established data
and the very able article of Mr. Mc-
Millan, in "One Hundred Years of
American Commerce," we learn that
the English stone car early in 1700,
with flanged wheels and hand brakes.
was really the inception or forerunner
of ^e freight car, and in 1804 cars
made in pairs, coupled together by
iron draw bars, with joints at either
end, cars having no sides, but in the
middle of each car a fixed center pin
upon which worked a bolster was the
origin of the bogie truck cars having a
capacity of ten tons, which capacity re-
mained a standard for more than half a
century.
The development of wheels as to sec-
tion chill and flange was largely due to
the efforts of Knight, Edgar, Winons
arid Davis early in 1800.
The American freight car of 1848 was
practically the same box of to-day, hav-
ing a capacity of ten tons. Roof cov-
ered with duck and painted and sanded.
Draw bars of the link-and-pin type hav-
ing springs operating in both directions.
Coal cars of the four-wheel or "Jimmy"
type, with a capacity of about six tons;
draw bars of hook and link type.
In the early sixties the box freight
car had a maximum length of z8 feet
and capacity of 10 to 12 tons, and
were equipped with hand brakes.
Some years later a disposition to in-
crease the dimensions and consequent
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
69
capacity of freight cars was apparent with
all roads, and after gradually going up
the scale, resulted in a car 01 34 feet
length and capacity of thirty tons.
The Master Car Builders' Association
organized in 1867 was an important fac-
tor in perfecting and causing roads to
adopt certain suggestions in car construc-
tion and maintenance, the value of
which soon became apparent, particular-
ly in the interchange of equipment be-
tween the difTerent roads.
Immediately following, came the air
brake, applied by the Wcstinghouse
Company, experimenting in 1868. Then
the vertical plane coupler, supplanting
the link and pin type. Just at this junc-
ture, in the words of an illustrious states-
man, railroads were confronted with "a
condition, and not a theory." With all
of the lighter equipment in service, hav-
ing hand brakes and link-and-pin coupler,
and a disposition on the part of some
roads to continue the building of cars
for local service having a capacity of
8 or ID tons, and many of the four-wheel
type, it was found that the advent of
the heavier vehicle, equipped with
couplers that were somewhat difficult to
join with the link-and-pin type, and air
brakes that would stop a car suddenly if
applied in emergency — had a tendency
while in train with the lighter vehicles,
to strain the frames, break the draught
gear and otherwise incapacitate the lat-
ter to an extent that only required a rea-
sonable time to place the light equip-
ment out of commission. Still the de-
mand continued for cars of greater carry-
ing capacity, and the limit having appar-
ently been reached in timber construc-
tion, steel was substituted, the steel
car possibly having its inception from the
Fox pressed steel truck and others of
that type now so generally used through-
out this country.
The steel car of to-day. both box, coal
and flat, or the steel under frame, with
wooden box or house, is unquestionably
the latest and most approved type of the
modern freight car, having a capacity of
from 80,000 to 100,000 pounds, with a
satisfactory decrease in dead weight as
compared with an all-wooden structure
of same carrying capacity, were it pos-
sible to construct the latter of requisite
strength.
The development of passenger equip-
ment has been quite as much, if not more
remarkable, and one had but to examine
the Pennsylvania Railroad and other rail-
road exhibits at the Columbian exhibi-
tion, showing the Conestoga wagon,
stage coach, locomotive and train of 1834.
and Camden & Amboy train of 1849, to
form some idea of the early progress in
this line.
By reference again to Mr. McMillan's
article, it is found that in 1814. on the
Kenilworth Colliery Line, a coach was
made by placing the body of a road
coach upon a wooden frame fitted with
flanged wheels. In 1825 the Stockton &
Darlington Railway ran as an experiment
a coach, and the first passenger car to
run regularly for use of the public was
placed on four wheels, the car having
doors at each end and rows of seats on
each side, and while the English were
the first to invent both trucks and long
passenger cars, with doors at ends, and
were almost instantly discarded, it was
left to us to make them the features of
.\nierican car building.
The first passenger coach used in
Pennsylvania in 1832 was a stage coach
slightly enlarged.
The passenger coach of to-day evident-
ly originated with three cars built by
Winans in 1833. The passenger coach of
the early 50s was of the plain box type,
30 to 45 feet in length, without clear
story, having small windows and heated
with stoves. Cars had little or no ven-
tilation.
Improvements were constantly carried
on, and with the advent of the clear
story, or monitor roof, ventilation was
secured. The Miller platform of 1867
removed the slack between cars.
Removal of stoves and heating by hot
water, as utilized with the Baker heater,
followed, which was in turn supplanted
by steam from the engine, carried in con-
tinuous pipes and couplings under cars
and thence inside to radiating pipes.
Hand brakes were supplanted by the
Creamer brakes on some roads, and they
in turn by the Wcstinghouse, first as
straight air, and later by the automatic
or three-way. The vertical plain coupler
and continuous platform and vestibule
replaced the Miller device. Cars were in-
creased in length and a marked improve-
ment made in seats, the reversible back
type being almost invariably used — four-
wheel trucks in many instances replaced
by those having six wheels. Toilets and
lavatories of improved types installed,
ventilation given attention, and to-day
the American passenger coach stands as
a monument to the ability and genius of
the American mechanic and places at
the service of the public a vehicle which
for comfort and convenience meets pres-
ent needs.
The estate of Wm. C. Baker, inventor
of the Baker Hot Water car heater, has
issued a circular letter which quotes a
judgment in the firm's favor, delivered by
the United States Circuit Court for the
northern district of Illinois. It relates
to his filling funnel, which was so closely
copied by a manufacturing concern as
to constitute a case of infringement.
There must have been some few oc-
currences in the past year to which we
can look back with a smile of cheerful
recollection, if not with a feeling of
heartfelt thankfulness. — Charles Dickens.
Old-Time Kallroad Keminiscences—
Lucky No. 13.
BY S. J. KIUIJE.R.
That times have changed since I be-
gan my railroad career in the West will
be apparent to those who chance to read
these recollections of some of my ear-
lier experiences in that then rapidly de-
veloping section of the country. At that
period there were no examinations of
engineers to determine their physical,
mental, moral or mechanical qualifica-
tions, a good word from some brother
engineer on the road or other recom-
mendation interspersed with a few queries
regarding the applicant's railroad expe-
rience being all that was required to
ensure work at once, a regular engine as
a general rule and a steady job. Frac-
tions of a cent were not computed in
figuring one's monthly stipend, as all
engineers were paid by the day, work or
play, with overtime on way freight or if
more than a designated number of trips
were made. Full pay was received by
all regardless of the term of service and
"rights" were an unknown quantity, the
railroad officials determining who should
have such an engine or run while com-
petency or some special act of the indi-
vidual which demonstrated his ability
and interest in his employer's behalf
often advanced him over others longer
in the service.
Early in the spring of 1871 I left the
Manchester Loco. Works with a new en-
gine for the Burl. & Mo. River Railroad,
of Iowa, now a part of the Chicago,
Burlington & Quincy, to be delivered
at Burlington, at that time the head-
quarters of the road. While en route
I overtook an old friend, Charley Cole
by name, also on a similar mission and
we journeyed on in company until our
destination was reached, about noon one
pleasant March morning.
After dinner we called at the general
master mechanic's office, but learning he
was out of town and would not return
until .somewhat late in the afternoon, it
was arranged that my friend Cole
should see that gentleman and obtain
receipts for the two engines, which ar-
rangement would permit me to do the
town. I to meet him at the shops later
in the day.
I covered a goodly portion of the city,
climbing first one bluff then another,
many of the sidewalks being composed
of almost endless flights of steps that
compared, so far as exhausting the phys-
ical resources of the pedestrian, with
Bunker Hill monument and at the des-
ignated hour kept my appointment.
As I approached the master mechan-
ic's oflSce I found standing in front of it
the General M. M. and my friend Cole.
The former was a man of stern mien
considerablv more than six feet in
70
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
height, broad in proportion, with some
300 pounds of avoirdupois concealed
about his massive frame.
It was our intention to debark for the
East that same evening, but what took
place within the next few minutes
changed, no doubt, the entire current of
my life.
As I approached and was introduced,
the first remark after passing the cour-
tesies of the day the Gen. M. M. said to
me, do you want a job? I replied I don't
know, what kind of a job you got, he
meantime sizing me up with critical
eyes. It might be remarked here that I
had been employed in my father's office
for a considerable time, engaged mostly
in reading newspapers, drawing pay, etc.,
was hardly more than a boy in years and
with my bleached hands and face prob-
ably did not bear many of the external
marks of an engineer. He questioned
me as to my past experience, which, to
tell the truth, had been somewhat lim-
ited, and my friend, an old engineer by
the way and long-time acquaintance of
the questioner, at an opportune moment
spoke up, saying: Mr. Chalender, if you
want a man, hire him, I will be respon-
sible for his work. That he did want
engineers was true, as shortly before my
appearance he had asked Cole if he could
send him some good engineers, and who
in reply had said yes, but that he had a
young fellow with him, though could not
say whether he wanted a job or not.
Well, the upshot of it was I replied that
I would take a construction engine and
be ready for work the following morn-
ing.
At that particular period of my life
personal enjoyment, with a good home
where board, washing and shoe bills did
not come floating in with painful regu-
larity, had a stronger attraction to me
than hard work, but after, concluding
preliminaries I resolved to spend a few
months in the West, then with a pocket-
ful of lucre return home and resume the
social side of life. Those few months,
however, lengthened into years and sev-
enteen of them passed before I left the
service of this company.
The following morning at the ap-
pointed hour I reported for duty to the
roundhouse foreman, Pat Riley, then
seated myself on a bench waiting for
something to turn up. Sometime after
Foreman Riley directed that I take
down the main rods of the Gen. Mc-
Pherson and file the main pin brasses,
then turned about and walked away.
As I had already learned such work
was not an engineer's duty, and again,
having no tools to work with, I simply
retained my seat, feeling at the same
time a sort of disgust and wonder at the
proceeding. Perhaps an hour later he
returned and inquired if I had done the
work assigned me, to which I replied
no, that I was not in the habit of doing
such work without tools and did not
wish to get into such habit.
He laughed, went to a cupboard, fur-
nished me an outfit and when he again
came round and inspected my work
found I was far from a novice, for the
brasses had been reduced in a way to
close up on either side face to face in
contrast to the method I had observed
on several engines of having one side
closed and the other gaping open.
At any rate he approved the job, then
gave me instructions to go out on an
extra with Jack Hawksworth, who at
the time was breaking in new and re-
built engines. At the hour designated
we pulled o«t with the Gen. Grant,
reaching Ottumwa in the evening with-
out unusual incident. We made a re-
turn trip the next day and on the Sat-
urday following, with the same engine,
again went West. Reaching Batavia for
a meeting point with passenger train
No. 4, Jack announced his determination
to go home, saying I could take the en-
gine to Ottumwa where it would be
turned over to the Middle Division,
where it belonged.
This I did, and Sunday noon with the
J. M. Forbes, No. 13, and Jack Woods,
conductor. Jack is still agitating a
ticket punch over the same right of way.
I started on my maiden trip. We reached
Burlington, but the 13 proved a terror.
The engine had been used as an extra
for some two years, run by first one
engineer, whose engine happened to be
in the back shop, then another, and
when I got her she was in generally bad
condition, rather from neglect than
wear. She wouldn't steam, her pumps
were erratic, the driving boxes and con-
nections beat a tattoo, in short, she was
emphatically a had-been, and by the
time we reached Burlington the coal
pile and my serenity were both well
nigh exhausted. The delusion, however,
that the engine was billed for the back
shop was my only solace, and my sur-
prise and disappointment may be im-
agined when the master mechanic in-
formed me a day or two later that I
would go to Thayer on the Middle Di-
vision and run a construction train. He
concluded by saying he was aware of the
condition of the 13, but for me to try
and get along with her for two or three
weeks, when he would furnish me an-
other engine.
I was also instructed that Thayer, be-
ing but a few miles from the West Di-
vision shops, I should go there for any
work the engine might require.
Running a construction train in those
days was a most desirable job, as it as-
sured full pay with very liberal over-
time and no work Sundays or inclement
days.
Thayer was a small way station of
some thirty houses, contiguous to a
large gravel pit, and by the time I had
become fairly settled there I had con-
cluded to overhaul the 13, and during
the following three months every mo-
ment available was spent in work on
that engine, no part being overlooked
that could be removed without putting
her on blocks. The tools to work with
consisted of only those usually carried
in an engine box reinforced with several
files obtained from no matter where,
and the point of a split switch rail was
utilized for a vice. One after another
the parts were taken down and repaired.
The guides drawfiled and closed, faces of
crossheads and wrist pins trued up,
pump and check valves overhauled and
ground in, eccentric straps and rod
brasses closed, petticoat pipe revamped,
in fact no part was neglected.
During the process of overhauling
some blacksmith work was necessary
and was done in an abandoned smith-
shop in town after patching and repair-
ing the bellows. In brief, the repairs
were finally completed, the engine was
made a very good steamer, the pumps
supplied plenty of water reliably, the
"pounds" were either eliminated or
largely connected, and my rattletrap had
been converted into a very satisfactory
engine, which from that time on easily
held its own with other_ and nearly new
ones also engaged in hauling gravel
trains over the numerous and heavy
grades abounding on this section of the
line grades, too, that taxed the engines
to their full capacity to handle their rates.
Up to this time I had had occasion to
visit West End shops but once. Desiring
to visit Creston one Sunday, and there be-
ing no other way of getting there I took
the 13 along, and as an excuse had the
rodlsrasses filed; but as will appear later,
my visit so far as the work done was
concerned, did not meet with my ap-
proval, the job being hurriedly and bad-
ly done.
Not long after, one forenoon, the Gen.
M. M. dropped off at Thayer and com-
ing over to my engine began plying me
with questions such as, how does she
steam, how are her pumps, can you
make the time, the construction trains
by the way having long and fast runs,
and numerous other questions to which
I replied in the affirmative, and learning
he was going to Creston I asked him to
ride up with me that he might see for
himself. He did so, the engine handling
the train up the grades in fine style and
quite contrary to what usually might
have been expected at such time.
Upon reaching his destination he re-
paired to the shop office, and long after
I heard what took place there. Said the
G. M. M. to his subordinate, "what have
you been doing to the 13?"
"Nothing."
"Haven't you done any work on the
engine?"
"No; well yes, we did do a little work
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMOTIVI-: ENGINEERING
7i
oil the engine some time ago. One day
tliat chap brought his engine up here
and reported tlie main rod brasses filed,
but I guess the job wasn't done to his
liking, for the last I heard of him was
that he left town d g the whole crowd
and remarking that if that was the sort
of work done in Creston he would do it
himself hereafter, and 1 haven't seen
him since.
Well, said the G. M. M., that young
fellow who I first sized up for a school-
boy is all right, for the 13 is in much
better condition than when he took her.
Some two months later I received a
letter from Mr. Chalender to the efTect
that he would send me another engine,
to which I replied that the 13 was all
right and asked that I might keep her.
To this he answered that he had a
back shop pit unoccupied, and as the
time the 13 had been out of the shop
antidated that of any other engine on
the road he would have to take her in.
A few days later the 13 started for
Burlington, and on that very day a head-
end collision near Skunk river furnished
more than enough material to cover the
pit. and my rebuilt engine replaced one
of those disabled, and it was not until
the following spring, some 9 months
later, that she passed through the portal
of the shop for an overhauling.
Whether the G. M. M. ever knew of
the work I did on the engine and the
drawbacks encountered in accomplishing
it I do not know, but when the cool fall
weather concluded our construction
work I was given a new freight engine
and a year later was assigned to the
best passenger run on the division.
Among the boys my somewhat rapid
advancement was attributed to good
luck, but as to myself I have always en-
tertained the belief that to my work of
overhauling the 13. lucky number you
know, could be attributed the good for-
tune which befell nie on the B. & M.
need of adjustment. It will be noticed
that the release is late, an evil which
cannot be overcome in a single eccentric
engine that is overloaded because the
eccentric must be set well back to give a
late point of cut-off. The remedy is two
eccentrics, one for admission and the
and also the sterling value of the steam
engine indicator.
No. I was taken with no load, and Nos.
2 and 3 with a brake applied to wheel.
Decatur. III. W. R. Runk.
No.t
No.i
SnUioai/ i LoeomotU* £ngint4rino
Raa»ag f Lvcoauitwt £nfriiutHnff
Curious Indicator Diagrams.
Dear Sir: Being a reader of Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering, I
notice, from time to time that you pub-
lish articles on steam engine indicator
work. I saw in the December issue cards
taken from a stationary engine, and being
in that line of work myself a little,
thought I would give a short one along
the same line.
Card marked A was taken from a 20x
42 in. Corliss engine. It can readily be
seen that the engine is much overloaded,
as an engine of this type should cut off
at about 1-4 stroke. The difference in cut-
off of the two ends of cylinders is due
to the fact that the valve did not become
disengaged from the hook on the end
marked C at a late point of cut-off, while
the one on other end did, showing a
Sailioaif i LoM^ictivr Enffinmring
Other for exhaust valves (or a larger en-
gine).
Cards marked i, 2 and 3 were taken by
Mr. J. C. White about two years ago
from a 6x7 in. automatic engine, run-
ning 320 revolutions. Any one familiar
with the subject would not doubt some-
thing being radically wrong in the case
of the first two. Upon examination, it
was found that the engine had been re-
versed at one time by turning the gov-
ernor wheel around on the crank shaft
without changing the parts of governor.
Upon this being done Card No. 3 was
the result, with a much less steam con-
sumption. The engine had been running
in this condition for some time, several
years perhaps, showing how a person can
be deluded without sufficient knowledge.
imprisoned In Boiler.
Merle Enz, an employee of the
C. H. & D., was imprisoned for
several hours one night in the interior
of the boiler of a locomotive which
was being repaired at the company's
shops at Findlay, Ohio. During the night
he and another workman were engaged in
repairing the interior of the boiler. They
entered the boiler through the dome,
which required quite an effort because of
the small diameter of the aperture. When
Enz made an effort to get out he found it
impossible to squeeze through the dome.
The more he tried the less progress he
made, and finally he gave up the job and
waited for more assistance. When sev-
eral workmen arrived it required a great
effort to pull the man out of the dome. In
leaving the interior of the engine Enz
was badly cut and bruised in the breast
and back. His clothing was also nearly
torn from his body.
We once knew of a steamer engaged in
the Atlantic trade being delayed nearly a
day by a workman getting stuck inside a
boiler. The man was frightened nearly to
death by the fear that they would fire up
while he remained inside.
" A Royal Train."
The finest is none too good for the
traveler and tourist of to-day, and in its
Royal Blue Line between New York,
Philadelphia, Baltimore and Washing-
ton, the New Jersey Central have a most
complete and fast service. There are
five trains each way each day, which
make the run from New York to Wash-
ington in 5 hours. The coaches, parlor
cars, buffets, observation, dining and
cafe cars were specially built for these
trains. The route of the Royal Blue is
picturesque and the scenes presented
are of great variety. The New Jersey
Central operates a sleeping car service
to Pittsburg, Cincinnati, St. Louis and
Chicago. The stations in New York are
at the foot of Liberty St., North River,
and South Ferry. If you want to travel,
and travel in style, use the Royal Blue
Line. If you want a book on the Royal
Blue, write to C. M. Burt, G. P. A., New
Jersey Central. N. Y. It's free for the
asking.
It is said that the Great Western
Railway of England intends to try one
of the celebrated four-cylinder com-
pounds in use on the Northern Railway
of France, with a view of obtaining re-
liable data as to performance, etc., under
English conditions.
72
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February. 1903.
Why Are Parts of a Fire=box Cool
When Other Farts Are Hot?
Referring to W. B. Chenowith's state-
ment in the January number of Loco-
motive Engineering, relating to sheets
in firebox of locomotive being cool
when water is above the boiling point,
I would say that I have been aware of
this fact for twenty-five years, and have
asked hundreds of men for an explana-
tion of this phenomenon. But so far
have received no satisfactory solution.
An easy way to demonstrate the truth
of this statement — also to study the
phenomenon — is to place an ordinary
iron tea kettle on a bright fire, fill with
water and let it boil briskly, then lift
kettle off fire and place it on the palm
of your hand. It will neither burn nor
even feel hot. Kindly investigate this
matter. Hoping you may be able to
managing director of Marconi's Eng-
lish company, yesterday told a represen-
tative of The Daily Telegraph that the ar-
rangements had all been completed. The
Marconi company will supply the news.
The printers and machinery necessary to
produce the first ocean newspaper are all
ready to begin work. Cuthbert Hall
hesitated to mention the name of the
ship aboard which the first experiment is
to be made, and only gave it in confi-
dence until the result of the first voyage
is known."
This will probably be a newspaper
pure and simple in which politics will
have no place, without literary supple-
ments or financial statements or any of
the magazine features which have been
gradually incorporated into the make-up
of the modern daily. Life on shipboard
will always furnish plenty of humor and
local color, and the readers of this new
PISTON VALVE AND CASING, CANADIAN PACIFIC.
find a rational solution. I know it will
greatly oblige many like Mr. Chenowith
and myself who have puzzled over it for
years. ' W. S. McCully.
PhUipsburg. Pa.
We should like to hear from other
readers, their views on this strange phe-
nomenon.
publicatiun will not feel as if they were
out of sight of land. When it comes.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing will wish bon voyage to its seagoing
contemporary.
An Ocean Newspaper.
The London correspondent of the
New York Tribune says: "The end of
the present month will see a British
mail steamer sailing from Liverpool
equipped with a complete staff and plant
for the publication on board of a news-
paper every day during the voyage to
New York. There is no doubt or un
certainty about the prospect. The con •
tracts have been made. Cuthbert Hall.
Preserving Railway Ties.
Experiments are being made in Ger-
many with beech as a material for rail-
way ties. It has been found that without
preservative treatment such ties are
apt to rot internally, though they may be
apparently sound on the exterior. On the
Alsace-Lorraine lines favorable results
have been obtained with creosoted beech
ties, which have shown an average life of
nineteen and a half years, while others
preserved with zinc chloride have proved
still more satisfactory, their life being
twenty-one and a half years.
A Steam Railroad Chartered to Reduce
Speed to Five Miles an Hour
at Crossings.
One of the first railroads chartered in
New York State was the Canajoharie &
Catskill. From a business standpoint it
was a case of starting from nowhere to
reach nowhere, a project very common
in pioneer railroad days. It was in-
corporated in 1830 and about 22 miles of
it was built. That portion was operated
for two seasons when a bridge went
down and killed one man. which ruined
the enterprise.
In the charter were some peculiar re-
strictions, says the Merchants' Advocate.
They were not to exceed 20 miles an
hour, and they were to slow down at
crossings to five miles per hour and stop
IS minutes at all stations.
It was no easy matter at that time to
get a railroad charter. In the Legisla-
ture some argued that the road would
injure the Erie Canal; it would destroy
the stage routes and ruin the sale of
horses. One member said the infernal
scheme would in the end depopulate the
State of New York. Who would risk
his life in a car going at the rate of 20
miles an hour, running on a narrow
thread of a rail and a little cast iron
wheel and an engine that is liable to
blow up any hour of the day?
But the arguments in favor of the char-
ter were also interesting. The road was
tc be cut off and shorten the distance
from Canajoharie to New York city, as
travel and freight went mostly by the
Erie Canal. The boats carried only 30
tons and made two miles an hour. The
distance from Canajoharie to Albany is
6g miles by canal, and it took 38 hours
to ewer the distance.
One senator in arguing in favor of the
railroad said: "We may not live to see
it, but the day will come when people
will ride over the iron rails at the rate
of 25 miles an hour, and with compara-
tive safety. Freight will be carried on
these railroads and also the United
States mails."
The Catskill Mountain Railway uses
about four miles of the track of the an-
cient railroad and other portions of the
road are visible, although covered with
brush and trees.
Equipping with Piston Valves.
The Canadian Pacific Railway people
are going in extensively for piston valves
on their engines. As each locomotive
passes through the repair shop at Mon-
treal, she is equipped with an end-ad-
mission piston valve, and this is done
without any alteration to the cylinders
or the valve gear. The mode of proced-
ure is simply to remove the ordinary
steam chest, slide valve and yoke, and
substitute a half-round cage, which is
bolted down in place of the steam chest.
February, 1903.
KMIAVAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
73
The (lid valve-seat is plaiu-il .ill so as to
gain as imicli room as possiljle, and the
cage makes a face joint with the new
surface thus exposed. This cage is bored
out, and heated wlien the valve bushing
is pressed in, thus holding it tightiy.
The piston valve used here has, of
course, its valve-stem considerably ofi'
the center, as the height of the valve-
stem above the old valve-seat is not al-
tered, but the disposition of the metal
surrounding the exhaust cayity in the
valve and also the heavy valve-stem com-
bine to bring the center of gravity of the
whole valve considerably below its own
center line. The liability to uneven wear
of rings, due to any tendency of the
ralve to rock, is thus provided for. The
valve-stem also passes through the front
head of the valve-case in order to se-
cure steadier motion.
The followers are held tightly in place
by the valve-stem, with collar and nut,
and by two studs in the upper half,
tapped into the body of the valve. The
bull rings are dowelled into and hold by
the followers, and the rings are com-
pressed tightly when introduced into the
bnsihing. An outline of the whole ar-
rangement is here illustrated, and we
understand a patent has been applied
for.
The advantages sought are much more
satisfactory balancing of the valve, and
consequently less wear and tear on- the
valve gear all round. Greater port open-
ing for same valve travel, and less re-
pair work to be done, and greater facil-
ities for doing what there is. The valve
cage does not at any time require remov-
al from the cylinders, unless in case of
breakage. If at any time it is desired to
re-equip any engine with slide valves, a
false valve-seat can be put in, and the old
steam chest bolted down again.
Owls and Superstition.
"The superstition about owls is a won-
derful thing," said an old engineer, "and
if I had not been inclined to be supersti-
tious about the birds, the engine I was
riding on one night would have been
knocked into smithereens and the pas-
sengers in the coaches behind might
have fared very badly. I am not always
superstitious, but I am particularly so
about owls. But I like the creatures,
for one certainly saved my life. The in-
cident occurred on a very dark night.
The train was running at full speed.
We were running on a straight line, and
there was nothing for the fireman
and myself to do but to look di-
rectly ahead and let her run. I had been
looking intently for an hour, when some-
thing flew into the cab. It struck the
coal pile and fell back deal It was a
great gray owl. With less time than it
takes to tell it. I began to think that the
owl was a bad omen, and T stopped the
train iuimediatcly. I cannot say what
made me feel so, but I was sure that
death was ahead. I descended and
walked to a switch that was a short dis-
tance in front of us. It was open, and
a long train of empty freight cars was
on it. I had the owl stufifed, and since
ih.i*. liuK he has had a place in the cab
of my engine. I owe my life to the
superstition about owls, and if another
(ine strikes my engine I will close the
throttle at once." — New Orleans Timcs-
Dciiwcyat.
Thought a Fool Might Make a Fireman.
A well-known master mechanic had
lieen for months pursued by Timothy
the paddle-wheeler Duchess of Hamilton,
both of the same class, made by the same
builders and plying on the Clyde, shows
that the turbine boat docs not suffer when
one considers her higher speed. The fig-
ures for the season show that the King
Edward burned 1,429 tons 16 cwt. of coal
and covered a total mileage of 12,116,
meaning 8.47 miles per ton of coal used,
and an average speed of i8^^ miles per
hour. The Duchess of Hamilton con-
sumed 1,758 tons 13 cwt. of coal, cov-
ered 15,604 miles, being 8.87 miles per ton,
and an average speed of 16}^ miles per
hour.
The Union Switch & Signal Company, of
Swissvale, Pa., have just issued section
DETAILS OF VALVE AND RINGS, C. P. R.
Brady, a section boss, to employ his son
Mike as a fireman.
"Why don't you give your son a job on
the section?" asked the M. M. one day.
"Well," replied Brady, "Alike is not
very smart and is hardly fit to work on
the section. In fact, if I say it, Mike is
a born fool who reads books about loco-
motives, but he is good enough for a fire-
man."
Steam Turbine Boats.
Vessels equipped with steam turbines
are coming steadily into favor. Two ves-
sels having that kind of propulsion have
been in use on the Clyde all last summer
as excursion boats, and they worked so
well that several others have been ordered
by other parties.
.\ comparison of the fuel consumption
of the turbine steamer King Edward and
Xo. 2 of their catalogue of interlocking
and signalling devices. 1902. This sec-
tion deals with mechanical ground con-
nections and lead out appliances. The
catalogue is well illustrated and contains
tables of parts for ordering together with
list price. Bulletin No. 9, issued by the
same company, is concerned with the
Kopp solid color glass. The red signal
glass now put upon the market is a homo-
geneous mass commonly called "pot glass,"
and differs from the processes known as
"plating" or "casing," in which a thin
layer of red glass is spread on transpa-
rent glass. Other tints are made in tlie
solid color glass also.
The chemical reaction which takes
place when acetylene gas is generated,
may be stated as follows: Calcium car-
bide (CaCi) plus water (HsO) produces
acetylene (C:H:") and lime (CaO').
74
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Powrer and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, Ne-w York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "Loceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, " locauto."
Business Department :
ANGUS SINCI,AIR, President.
FRED M. NEH,IS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Bdltorial Department :
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NELI.IS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
1204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd. 102a Charing Cross Rd., W.
C., London.
Glasgow Representative :
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
ts.ooter year, Si-oo for six nionihSypostage paid
to (he United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of tlie world, $2-50, or ten shillings.
Single copies, 20 cents. Remit by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Registered
Letter.
Mailing address can be changed as often as neces-
gary— always give old and nezv address, and if you
tubscrided in a club state who got it up.
Please give promft notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly. ■
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., 1Q03,
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
An Alleged Train Order in Slang and
28 Dead.
If the account given in the New York
Sun, of January 2, concerning the cause
of the Wanstead wreck on the Grand
Trunk Railway is true, it furnishes an
example of a certain kind of train dis-
patcliing, which should make the officials
of that road hang their heads with
shame.
The facts as given are, briefly. No. S
express, going west, collided with an
east-bound freight train near Wanstead,
Ontario, and serious loss of life was the
result. The cause of the accident was
said to be a misunderstanding between
train dispatcher and operator. There are
three stations concerned in the affair —
Wanstead, near which the accident hap-
pened, with Wyoming about five miles
to the west, and Watford, situated about
ten miles to the east.
It seems that before the express
reached Watford, the dispatcher in-
structed the Watford operator to display
his signal and hold No. 5 for orders. Im-
mediately afterward the operator at Wy-
oming was told to hold the freight. That
being done, an order was sent simul-
taneously to the express at Watford, and
the freight at Wyoming to pass each
other at Wanstead. A little later, the
operator at Wyoming reported to the
dispatcher that the freight was slow in
getting away, and the Watford operator
said the e.xpress was coming. Thinking
that the freight, if permitted to go on,
might delay the passenger train, the dis-
patcher avers that he said to the Wat-
ford operator, "May bust it," probably
meaning that what he had heard about
the freight being slow, might cause him
later to cancel the crossing order. Al-
most at the same time Wyoming re-
ported, "Freight pulling out." "All
right, let her go," replied the dispatcher.
The Watford operator says he only
heard the words "bust it," and therefore
destroyed the crossing order, and let
No. 5 go on. On learning of the mis-
understanding, the dispatcher did what
little he could to stop the freight, but it
was too late. The passenger engineer,
we are told, believed he had a clear track
to Wyoming, while the engineer of the
freight held orders giving him a clear
track to Wanstead. The single line be-
tween Wanstead and Wyoming was thus
practically covered by a "lap" order.
From the Sun's account it looks as if
the dispatcher had been trying to take
the operator into his confidence regard-
ing a possible change of programme, and
as a result twenty-eight people were
killed and about as many more were in-
jured. We are not concerned as to
whether dispatcher or operator be held to
blame, the point which stands out promi-
nently in the case is that any system of
train dispatching is faulty in the ex-
treme, where probable or possible moves
on the chess-board are even hinted at
over the wires, with the desperately "dan-
gerous possibilities of misconstruction.
There is no more serious business on
earth than the moving of freight trains
against passenger trains on a single
track road, and the only permissible or-
ders in such cases should be clear and
concise, and composed of a prearranged
number of words, so that an operator
can know certainly that he has it fully.
All else is completely out of place.
There are on many railroads, rules and
regulations and every conceivable form
of mandate intended to hedge about en-
gineers and firemen and the mechanical
department in general, while the most
extraordinary laxity may often be per-
mitted in the dispatching office, because
the man in charge is, by some absurd fic-
tion, supposed to be the mouthpiece of
the superintendent. The fact that a bit
of slang language from the despatcher
could be regarded by an operator as con-
stituting a definite train order, or that
such a frivolous and wholly ambiguous
message could have been sent, concern-
ing so serious a business as the moving
of trains, places the method as outlined,
by the Sun, in the most unenviable light
in the eyes of the traveling public.
It ought not to require the uncalled for
and violent death of 28 persons to key
up a railroad department to such a
measure of discipline as will enable it to
even safely carry on the daily work in
which officers and men alike are supposed
to have had years of constant practice.
Nor should such a spur to railroad
officials be needed to cause them to de-
vise some system by which a record of
all that actually passes over the wire,
might be had, and reviewed daily by a
cor»petent .officer, whose business it
would be to see that the despatcher's
vocabulary was free from ambiguous
words or inaccurate phrases, and that it
should be clearly mandatory where train
movement is concerned. The lesson of
this disaster means that some check-
on the everyday work of the despatcher
is urgently required.
The most trivial misunderstanding,
which in mercantile life, might not in-
volve more than the redirecting of a
blotted envelope, when made over the
live wire of a crowded railway system
may have its terrible cost counted out
to the full, in the irreparable loss of
precious human lives.
Comparing Unlike Things.
There are strangely enough two
recognized values for what we call one
ton. There is the "long ton" of 2,240
lbs., principally used by our British
cousins, and there is the 2,000-Ib. ton
used in this country and in Canada. The
latter ton is the more convenient to use
in calculations, and its twentieth part is
exactly a hundredweight, neither more
nor less, which is very satisfactory.
There is, however, another value for the
"ton," when applied to coal handling on
a railway, in loading tenders. This value
is not as definite as either of the others,
in fact this so-called ton has no settled
value at all.
It often happens that a railway com-
pany buys coal by weight and pays for
so many tons, each composed of 2,000
lbs. The engines belonging to this same
company are in all probability supplied
with coal, not weighed at all, but shov-
elled into pockets which are filled up to
a certain level, and these pockets are
then said to contain 2, 3 or 5 tons as the
case may be. As a matter of fact what
the engine gets is not tons of coal, but
a certain measure of volume, of which
the exact weight is unknown.
There is generally a periodic attempt
to make the coal bought by weight, tally
with the coal measured out to the en-
gines, because the latter are called
"tons." As there is no definite ratio
existing between the two, the work of
making both sides of the coal account
balance, may possibly be regarded as
"fudging." by those who are disposed to
look at the process with unfriendly eyes.
It may, however, be argued that defi-
nite volumes of coal, when dealt out to
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
engines, are near enough, as all fare
alike. This would be so if some sub-
stance such as water was being supplied,
for in the case of water there is practi-
cally a constant ratio existing between
weight and volume all the time, which is
not true of coal. Large lumpy coal and
fine small coal when filled to the same
level in a coal pocket, represent two very
difTcrent amounts of fuel, and what the
engine is concerned with, when making
her record, is the amount of carbon
carried on her tender, not the height it
will pile up to, in a certain sort of re-
ceptacle.
If accounts are to be kept with accu-
racy the weighed ton cannot fairly be
made to tally with the uncertain, meas-
ured, so-called ton. It is worse than
using pounds, shillings and pence. There
is a definite known relation between the
three denominations of money, by which
the value of any one can be accurately
expressed in terms of any other. This
connecting ratio does not exist between
the weighed ton and the measured
"ton."
If any one should say that six clocks
equaled ten ink bottles, he would be
asked by mathematicians to show the
ratio connecting them, before he would
be permitted to write the expression
down in the form of an equation. If no
definite ratio existed between them, he
would never be able to establish their
equality, and calling them all by one
name would not alter the essential dif-
ference.
Run-of-mine coal differs sufficiently
in heat producing qualities from carload
to carload, as it is, without adding an
artificial difference, in the way it is re-
ceived and put upon the tenders. The
desire at the present day for accurate
detailed costs in railway operation is
perfectly justifiable, and if this is to be
rightly done, the accurate weighing of
coal, supplied to engines, is as import-
ant as is the careful measuring out of
oil. The accurate method is also fairer
to the men who use the coal.
There are many locomotive coaling
stations where the weighing hopper is
not used, and where coal is supplied in
bulk. At these places due allowance
should be made for the fact, and the
man in charge should not be compared
with another man on whose division the
most modern equipment has been in-
stalled, and in no case should coal rec-
ords be "fudged" in order that a set of
books may be made to look as if they
balanced exactly.
A correspondent of ours recently
pointed out that the monthly perform-
ance sheet was often made the basis for
comparing unlike things. The real han-
dicap of cramped quarters, unequal fa-
cilities or old fashioned methods is gen-
erally ignored when mere figures are set
down. The same tale of bricks is too
75
O'ften expected from the man without
straw, as that delivered by the man who
has it, simply because a whole number
and two decimal places on the sheet do
not and cannot tell the whole story.
'Thou Shalt Not Keep Thy Neighbors'
Cars."
Darwin once humorously connected
the presence of a number of old maids
in a village with the profuse growth of
red clover in the vicinity. The chain of
causation between these apparently un-
related facts was briefly that red clover is
rich in honey, which attracted humble
bees, and in extracting the honey, the bees
helped in the fertilization of the plants.
The old maids according to immemorial
custom kept pet cats, and these cats ex-
terminated field mice which preyed on the
honey and the young of the bees. The cats
incidentally helped the bees in the strug-
gle for existence, with the result that red
clover flourished where the gentle tabby
was cared for.
Equally paradoxical as it may appear
to the casual observer, there is a com-
plete chain of causation between per diem
and the prospe.-ity of car builders at the
present time. The substantially increas-
ing business and bright prospects of the
various car building concerns are
strangely related to the adoption of a
single rule in car service. One would
naturally expect that the adoption of a
regulation which practically increased the
car equipment on most roads, certainly
on all the large ones, would have left
the car builders in very slack water. The
reverse of this is, however, the case. The
volume of business for which the build-
ers of cars are now preparing is larger
than ever, but the individual orders
placed are small, and this fact furnishes
the explanation of the apparent mystery,
just as the cats did in Darwin's example.
The fact that the prompt return of
cars to owners in all cases and from all
places has left some roads short of cars,
and these roads have been compelled to
order new equipment for themselves. It
was just as if a man had filled out his
book shelves with the latest volumes
from a lending library, and had preferred
making a good showing before his
friends, to observing the rules of the in-
stitution. When the day of reckoning at
last came, and the lending library per-
emptorily demanded its own. the shelves
of the apparently literary gentleman
would become suddenly and woefully
short of books, with the result that the
local book seller would receive a small
order, and the multiplication of such or-
ders from others similarly situated would
keep him busy.
The new car service commandment.
"Thou shalt not idly keep thy neigh-
bor's cars," strikes two evils squarely
on the head. The habitual car borrower
feels the blow, and the roads which re-
lied upon filling out the tail end of their
equipment with other people's cars, have
been compelled to go into the market
to make good the shortage. Per diem
has beaten the bush all through, and the
borrower has been compelled to break
cover and make the best run he can for
safety. The prosperity in the country
which this reveals is, however, gratify-
ing to all alike.
The storage-expecting consignee has
felt the blow also, and he appears to have
done most of the weeping and gnashing
of teeth, wherever that greeting has been
given to per diem. There is no more
convenient store house in the world than
a good, clean, rainproof box-car, sealed
by a responsible railroad. When this
most compact store house was available
day after day, entirely free of charge, it
was simply ideal. To ruthlessly take it
away was hard indeed, but the cry of the
consignee is really the how] of the free-
lunch counter fiend when he is compelled
to pay. It is too ludicrous to excite se-
rious consideration.
The Other Ox Was Certainly^Gored.
Among the many improvements which
Per Diem has brought about may be
mentioned a new and improved style of
reasoning, something like that which
Jim Skeevers called, "reasoning of the
general managerial order." Not long
ago an important official of the Rock
Ballast & No Dust Railway, said to a
brother officer of a distant line, "This per
diem system is great. We have 20 per
cent, more of our cars at home now
than under the old plan. Those rascally
roads which formerly turned a deaf ear to
the most urgent appeals for the reutrn
of our cars, are now simply turning
handsprings in their efforts to get our
cars home. But they do so from a sordid
motive. They are forced by the con-
temptible fear of pecuniary loss, to return
equipment which they would otherwise
have selfishly kept idle, or at best dis-
honestly accounted for."
"Yes," said his friend, "I am delighted
to hear that at last the miserable scoun-
drels have been made to squirm, but are
you not also quickly returning foreign
cars to owners?" "Of course we are,"
said he of the R. B. & N. D. Ry.. "but
my dear boy, it's different with us,
we were always pretty good that way.
and besides, as we have most of our cars
at home, we don't require so many for-
eign ones, and moreover we have recent-
ly gone in for greatly enlarged terminal
facilities, so that the release of cars is
necessarily quicker, and latterally our
operating department fellows have quick-
ened the movement of trains, and then, a
short time ago, we reorganized the
method of making up trains and of sort-
ing cars, so that although we had to spend
some money we are right, up-to-date all
76
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
round and per diem can't lay a finger on
us."
To all this his friend made answer,
"Once upon a time, a loaded car which
had traveled 800 miles all right on a trip,
was found derailed at an open switch,
and a gang of men were putting in a pair
of wheels, while a bystander whose rail-
roading had all been done almost exclus-
ively in his mind, examined the car, and
seeing that it had a badly bent axle, ex-
plained to the assistant bystander that
the condition of the axle was the cause
of the derailment." "Well, what's that
got to do with per diem?" "Nothing,
only the man looking at the car was con-
fusing cause with effect — but I'm glad
those other fellows are turning hand-
springs."
To Prevent Telescoping.
The Chicago Chronicle publishes a de-
scription of a recent invention of Mr.
Geo. E. Dickson, of Chicago, which has
for its object the prevention of "telescop-
ing" in railway wrecks. The idea is to
build passenger cars with ends having
an angular or curved form, so that when
the cars are on a straight track the ends
will not be at right angles to the rails
as they are now, but will stand at some
angle, and these beveled car ends will
act as deflectors in case of collision. It
is expected that cars so made will, under
the stress of a heavy collision, have each
its front end thrown to one side and its
rear to the other. Instead, therefore, of
the telescoping action, it is intended that
the cars will really lie together, en
echelon, if we may borrow a military ex-
pression. To put it another way, if the
cars were represented by a line of men
in Indian file, all facing north before the
accident, the position assumed after col-
lision would be approximately repre-
sented by the line of men standing each
three-quarters turn to the right. Details
of the scheme provide for the protection
of the sides of the cars from being
crushed in, and also means to prevent the
cars jumping up on one another.
We have no desire to disparage earn-
est effort to make railway travel more
safe than it is now, the road in that di-
rection is wide, but it is quite possible
in avoiding the danger of direct telescop-
ing by this form of construction, to
court disaster in another form. The
elimination of the car platform and the
introduction of solid end cars, and con-
tinuous vestibules, with strong under-
framing to cars, is apparently the safe
Imes along which the evolution of car
design by expert car builders on our
leading roads, is moving. Mr. Dickson's
plan means the dislocation of one or
more "joints" of the train, and the possi-
bility of pushing cars sideways down a
steep embankment, or over a bridge, or
against the jagged sides of a tunnel or
rock cut, may be as serious a menace to
safe railway operation as is the danger
which he seeks to avoid.
The worst accidents in which telescop-
ing has been the predominantly unfortu-
nate feature, are frequently those in
which old style cars, were concerned —
cars with platforms carried on timbers
bolted to, and projecting from, the car
sills. In some cases there is reason to
believe that the presence of the high
speed brake on the ill-fated train would
have averted dire disaster, or at least
softened it into mere mishap.
The enormous amount of stored-up
energy which must be dissipated before a
moving train can be brought to rest was
recently discussed at a meeting of the
New England Railroad Club, in a paper
read by Mr. Desoe. As an example he
showed that a train weighing 1,500 tons
moving at the rate of 25 miles an hour,
would have 62,688,000 foot-pounds, or
31,344 foot-tons of energy to be de-
stroyed, as far as the train is concerned,
before it could be stopped. This amount
of stored up energy, if suitably applied,
would be capable of lifting the entire
train more than 20 feet up in the air.
Higher speeds with less weights may
give practically the same results. These
figures show the enormous forces which
must be dealt with in solving the prob-
lem which Mr. Dickson has essayed. The
deflecting method, in which the cars will
not only be derailed, but probably shoved
off their trucks, and bunched together,
demands very cautious and conservative
consideration from those best able to
judge.
The Traveling Engineer.
We have before us the letter of a sub-
scriber in which he makes some very
pertinent remarks about the good that
may be done by a thoroughly competent
traveling engineer or road foreman of
engines. He says that appointments to
this office have too often been given to
men who by training are not suitable
for the position. A poor imitation of
the resourceful, efficient traveling engi-
neer, is a most expensive luxury. The
only way is to have the real thing every
time, and such a man earns his pay and
makes money for the company. A trav-
eling engineer who gets over the road in
a Pullman car is as much out of place
on a railway, as a representation of a
knife and fork would be in a painting of
one of Nero's banquets. Moreover, em-
ploying a traveling engineer to carry
the latest unreliable gossip, or fake
news of changes among officials, to the
various round houses has been found to
cost money without bringing an ade-
quate return.
A man qualified to run an engine prop-
erly and economically and capable of
imparting his knowledge to others is a
very useful person as road foreman of
engines. A good man has a large field
to work in. He has the eternal coal
consumption to look after; being con-
stantly out on the road he is sure to
personally see some of the breakdowns
or engine failures which happen. He
can do good work on the grade where
doubling has become part of the pro-
gramme and he can quietly assist many
engineers and firemen in getting over
the road. When he is the right kind of
man he can often smooth over a good
deal of friction between engineer and
despatcher without bringing each case
actually into court, and he is likely to
be asked some questions which perhaps
false pride would keep back from the
Master Mechanic or the S. M. P. An
efficient traveling engineer can well earn
all he is paid, while the company can
put something into the treasury as well.
President Loree Has Nothing Against
Passenger Departments.
In the last issue of Railw.w and Lo-
comotive Engineering we published
some particulars of a story which has
been going the rounds of the news-
papers to the effect that President Loree,
of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad had
been making some disparaging remarks
about the passenger departments of
railways.
A prominent general passenger agent,
intimately acquainted with President
Loree, wrote him on the subject, ex-
pressing his surprise at the sentiments
attributed to him, which brought out the
following reply from President Loree:
"I have your letter of December 11.
The story has been told in so many
forms that I have no doubt that you are
familiar with it, but I perhaps remember
best that version which relates that a
lawyer once in excusing his client for
not appearing in court in answer to a
subpoena, alleged some 39 reasons, of
which the last was that his client was
dead. If I may say that the article re-
ferred to was a pure fabrication, and
that I have never publicly expressed an
opinion on the subject, perhaps the other
38 things I might say need not be said."
Against Nepotism.
An order has been issued by the Mis-
souri Pacific management that no rela-
tive of an official shall be employed in a
position subordinate to that official on
the Missouri Pacific & Iron Mountain
system and it went into operation Janu-
ary I.
The order has resulted in a number of
changes at every divisional point on the
line in southeast Kansas, many men
holding subordinate positions have been
placed under superintendents to whom
they are not related.
The motive of the order is to place all
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
77
•employees on an equal basis in ibe mat-
ter of advancement.
It is an order tbat might very well be
imitated by nearly every railroad com-
pany in the country. A burning griev-
ance to thousands of efKcient railway
men is that by hard intelligent work they
have acquired intimate acquaintance
with railway details which ought to rec-
ommend them for promotion, but that
they are kept back so that ineflicient re-
lations of officials might be advanced.
The evil of nepotism is a growing one
and is killing the esprit de corfs of many
railways.
The Dangerous Water Qauge Glass.
A dispatch from BulTalo reads:
Joseph Lacey, an engineer, while
cleaning his engine on what is known
as the ash track in the railroad yards of
the Buffalo Furnace Company at an
early hour this morning, was badly
scalded about the hands by the break-
ing of a water glass. A hurried call was
sent to the Emergency Hospital where
his injuries were dressed. The cause of
the accident is unknown,
Lacey was in the cab of his engine
when the glass blew out. The interior
was filled with steam and Lacey escaped
by getting out of the window.
The British Parliament passed a law
lately compelling railway companies to
have protectors over the water glasses
•of their locomotives. Safety water
gauges are sold by the Nathan Manu-
facturing Company, New York. The
writer has one on his automobile and it
is entirely safe from breakage.
A neat little Christmas card "wishing
you a new year filled with much joy and
gladness, peace and plenty," has been sent
out by Mr. E. J. McMahon, of L. S. & M.
S., to his many friends. The card shows
the 2Qth Century Limited rounding a curve
just as the shades of night are closing in.
The mail pouch which is the emblem
adopted by the Lake Shore & Michigan
Southern Railway is also shown envel-
oped in holly leaves with bright red ber-
ries. It forms a most appropriate device
for the season, as the Christmas letters
and cards and packages and the unexpect-
ed check from your rich old uncle all
come by mail, and the suggestion is pleas-
ing. In acknowledging the greeting sent
us. we wish Mr. AIcMahon and his road
the best of good luck, all round the clock.
"As I understand it," said Mrs. Green,
"messages by the wireless telegraph sys-
tem go right through the air we breathe."
"Yes, that is correct," assented Mr.
Green. "Then," replied his spouse, "a
person having handed in a message at
the telegraph office may swallow his
own words on his way home."
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(8) C. M. D. writes:
When an engine comes into the round-
house, with fire out, to have boiler washed
out, with 200 pounds pressure of steam,
the hostler fills her up with water before
he blows her off through the whistle. Why
does he fill her up? A. — He fills the hoikr
for two reasons, first, because he wishes
to somewhat reduce the pressure before
blowing off, and, secondly, he does not
wish to uncover the crown sheet until the
plates are sufficiently cool to stand with-
out injury to the temperature of the wash-
out water. The blowing off of a boiler
always brings down the water level, and
for the following reason : Steam at 200
pounds pressure has a temperature of
381.6 degrees F., which is a long way
above the temperature at which water boils
in the open air. As the pressure sinks
a portion of the stored heat is liberated
and it turns more water into steam. At
150 pounds, the temperature is 358.2 de-
grees F., at 100 pounds the temperature is
327.6 degrees F., and all the time the pres-
sure has been sinking, the heat required
to maintain high pressures has been turn-
ing water to steam and blowing out, thus
reducing the water level until the pressure
sinks to zero, and the temperature to 212
degrees F. If plenty of water has been
put in before blowing off, a good water
level will be maintained and cool water
may be introduced, as hot is allowed to
escape through the blow-off cock, and the
temperature of the plates may be reduced
any required amount without undue strain.
(9) W. G. P. asks:
Why is the link saddle-stud usually
placed to one side of the center line or
link arc? A. — This question involves
more than can be answered briefly. Suffice
it to say that what is called the angularity
of the connecting rod produces a not uni-
form travel of the piston. The angularity
of the eccentric rods, and the fact that
the pins connecting link and eccentric-
rods are placed back of the link arc, cause
errors in the valve motion, and the approx-
iin.:!te readjustment of these disturbances
is effected by offsetting the link saddle-
stud. This causes a certain amount of
slip in the link, which allows different
points on the link to act on the link block.
Although this causes variable valve travel,
it practically counteracts the errors intro-
duced, as explained above.
(10) M. R. D. asks:
If a boiler has 200 pounds pressure per
square inch inside it, what is the total
pressure tending to tear it apart? A. —
This depends on the diameter of the boiler.
For example, a boiler 64 in. in diameter
under steam at 200 pounds, would have
a pressure of 12,800 pounds acting on each
semicircular hoop i in. wide. The way
this result is arrived at may be explained
as follows: Draw to scale a circle, the
diameter of which is 64 in. Now suppose
the upper semi-circle to be filled solidly
with wood or some other sul)stance. The
pressure of steam in the lower half would
act on the base of the wood, or on the
diameter of the circle, and this pressure
tends to lift the whole upper arch off
bodily. This upward effort is resisted by
the shell at either end of the diameter.
Suppose this upper semi-circle or hoop
to be just 1 in. wide and the internal pres-
sure 200 pounds per sq. in. The total
pressure on this hoop would be 12,800
pounds, as stated above. If the sheets
were yi in. thick there would then be ex-
actly I sq. in. of steel sustaining a pres-
sure of 12,800 pounds for every imaginary
hoop or band in the barrel of the boiler i
in. wide.
(11) P. R. J. asks:
Has a short valve travel any advantage
over a long-travel, each with same cut off?
A. — To get the same port opening, the lap
on the short-travel valve must be less than
that on the other. If the port opening for
live steam is reduced on account of short
travel, as it will be, the exhaust opening
will also be restricted, therefore more in-
side clearance is necessary with valves of
short travel. For fast engines a good fair
length of travel is preferable to very short
travel.
(12) S. H. G. asks:
What is the difference between temper-
ature and heat? A. — This question can
best be answered by telling you how each
is measured. Temperature is measured
by a thermometer and is spoken of as so
many degrees. It is indicated by the ex-
pansion or contraction of some fluid,
usually mercury or spirit. Temperature
is really the measure of the rapidity of the
vibration of the particles of any body.
Heat is measured in what are called Brit-
ish thermal units. One B.T.U. is the
quantity of heat required to raise one
pound of pure water through one degree
of temperature as measured on a Fahren-
heit thermometer.
The mistakes frequently made by rail-
way station telegraph operators makes us
think that the youths who are appointed
to these positions ought to pass periodical
examinations similar to those required of
enginemen and trainmen. Some railroad
companies on employing a station oper-
ator merely find out that he can take or
send messages. That is far from being
sufficient. They ought all to be examined
on train rules and on the movement of
trains. A failure on the part of an oper-
erator to interpret an order properly often
leads to disastrous results. The safety
of the traveling public demands more effi-
cient training.
One comfort, then, for ourselves, and
another is to have done our duty. —
Christmas Stories.
78
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
The Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
{Continued from page j."!
REQUIREMENTS OF A PROSPEROUS COUNTRY
Lord Bacon truly says there are
three things which make a nation great
and prosperous — a fertile soil, busy
workshops and easy conveyance of men
and commodities from place to place.
The history of the world has proved
Bacon's words to be true, but there have
been nations blessed with a fertile coun-
try and busy workshops which have
tried to get along without easy means
of transportation, because of sectional
differences concerning the defraying of
the expense of constructing artificial ar-
teries of intercommunication. The re-
gions served by water transport were
opposed to building roads for the con-
venience of localities remote from sea,
lake or river, and thus conflicting in-
terests retarded the progress of some
countries for the time being and left
great spaces of fertile regions undevel-
oped.
In the course of two-thirds of a cen-
tury a vast wilderness on the American
continent has been changed from
gloomy, untrodded forests, dismal
swamps and pathless prairies into the
abode of a high civilization. Prosperous
states, teeming with populous towns,
fertile farms, blooming gardens and
comfortable homes have arisen from re-
gions where formerly savage men and
wild animals were the sole tenants. A
powerful factor in effecting this benefi-
cent change has been the locomotive en-
gine.
EARLY PRESSURE OF PRODUCTION UPON
TRANSPORTATION — THE LOCOMOTIVE DUE.
Projects for providing facilities of
transportation by rail originated almost
simultaneously in the British Isles and
the United States. Both countries were
badly supplied with highways on which
wheeled vehicles could convey heavy
loads; both had tried canals and found
them unsatisfactory in some respects.
The increase of production of commod-
ities growing faster than the means of
moving them, led enterprising men in
both countries to look in the same di-
rection for relief.
The conditions of urgent necessity
which led to the inventing of the steam
engine were repeated as the volume of
produce and merchandise to be carried
went beyond the capacity of water car-
riage and inferior roads. The steam en-
gine came when great properties were
deteriorating because horse power was
incompetent to concentrate great effort
in limited space. It was a foregone con-
clusion that the steam engine would be
applied to locomotive purposes as soon
as the horse proved unequal to the work
of supplying the motive power for roads
and canals.
The application of steam to water
transportation delayed for a time the
advent of the locomotive, but thought-
ful men had glimpses of what the
steam engine might do in moving loads
on land almost as early as attempts
were made to use steam in propelling
boats.
THE RAILROAD TRACK.
The railroad structure provided a way
for the wheels of a vehicle to run upon
a smooth, hard surface, where obstacles
to progress, such as sinking of the
wheels into soft places and mounting
over stones or other projecting obstruc-
tions, would not be encountered. Such
roads were to be found in various lo-
REM.IINS OF RAILROAD TO QUINCY
QUARRIES.
calities hundreds of years before the
steam engine was invented. There are
many traces of what were really stone
railroads to be found in parts of Asia
and Africa, where an advanced civiliza-
tion flourished thousands of years ago.
The rows of huge stone blocks, worn
with myriads of wheels, are in many
places the most substantial traces of an
enterprising people long passed away.
The writer has seen in the streets of
Italian cities stone blocks laid down
parallel, with a depression to keep the
wheels of vehicles in place, and these
make as smooth a roadbed as the inside
surface of car-track rails provide for the
truckman of our large cities.
NEED OF THE LOCOMOTIVE.
The nineteenth century had not ad-
vanced many years when people in the
United States began to realize that
something better than canals was neces-
sary as a means of intercommunication
if great parts of the nation's territory
were to be opened up to settlement and
civilization. There were numerous nav-
igable rivers and long reaching lakes ia
this continent, but geographically they
are far apart, and there is no means of
reaching vast regions except by land
transportation. To the ordinary thinker
a system of substantial macadam roads-
would have solved the difficulty as far as-
draft animals could have aided, but these
roads were not tried to any extent, for
the cost of making them was beyond
the means of a thinly populated coun-
try, for in many places stone was very
costly and labor was exceedingly dear.
THE PINCH OF NECESSITY BROUGHT THE
LOCOMOTIVE.
The pinch of necessity wonderfully
quickens the inventive faculties. Long
before a mile of tramway was built in
the United States in connection with
coal mines, engineers and far-seeing
public men were discussing the possibil-
ities of the steam engine as a means of
accelerating land travel, and projects be-
gan to be agitated in different states to-
construct railways, or tramways, on
which the steam engine could do the-
work of hauling the cars.
Those who looked favorably uport
steam engines as motive power on rail-
roads were a small minority, and they
were considered by the majority as
cranks and visionaries. Those regarded
as sensible, progressive men. a little
ahead of their time, favored horses for
motive power.
The problem that public men were in-
terested in was: How are we going to
move our merchandise, and coal, and
ore to the nearest point of water navi-
.gation? The transportation of passen-
gers received little consideration from
the early railroad schemers.
The need for the locomotive was
much more urgent in the United States
than it was in any other country. There
were long stretches between westerr>
rivers and eastern estuaries that needed
to be connected. There were no well-
constructed roads of any consequence,
and such roads, had they existed, could
not have offered rapid transportation, so-
the railway was the chief hope of con-
necting the remote territory with mar-
kets and the seaboard.
FIRST RAILROAD CHARTERED FOR GENERAI,
TRANSPORTATION.
The South Carolina Railroad Com-
pany was the first in the world to decide
that its railroad should be operated by
locomotives. Its construction was be-
gun in 1827, but delays occurred which
prevented it from being opened until
part of the Baltimore and Ohio Rail-
road was in operation. Before the two-
railroads named had a working section
finished there were several short rail-
ways in use, horses being the motive
power. One was the Phillipsburg &
Juniata Railroad in the Allegheny moun-
tains, and .-innthcr was near Mauch
Chunk, Pa., but the best known of the
first experiments in raih'Oad operating
was. at Quincy, Mass. This railroad was
purposely built to convey granite to be
used in building the Bunker liill mon
February. 1903. RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVK ENGINEERING 79
signing the machinery to operate them AMERICANS worked o.n original LINES.
were guided entirely by English types of I am not sure that the American rail-
machinery and by English methods of road builders wasted any time trying to
building the permanent structures which find out what others were doing. What
is a fallacy. Those who have studied they desired most was to be left to their
most thoroughly the development of own resources. The nation has always
nment from the quarries to the Nepon- railroads and of railroad machinery be- been celebrated for self-reliance. To
riv In .8.7 a piece of railroad lieve that our railroads would not have demonstrate that the faith in themselves
1 made bv the Delaware & Hudson been long delayed had Watt never was wel founded, they P'-°"«j;dJo
Canal Company for the purpose of con- worked on the steam engine and had build railroads according to the'r own
ving their coal from the mines to George Stephenson never been born, ideas, crossing the various bridges of
HoncsdaU-, Pa., the junction with the Oliver Evans developed the high pres- difficulty as they were reached.
sure as an improvement on Newcom- the Baltimore & OHio.
cr's atmospheric engine and Watt made q^^^ ^j ^]^^ ^^5[ ambitious projects in
radical improvements on the same en- f^ilroad building first ready for opcrat-
gine by inventing a separate condenser, j^^^ ^^^ jj,g Baltimore & Ohio Railroad,
Evans' high pressure high speed engines ^hjc^ ^as chartered in 1827 and partly
were much better adapted for locomotive opened in 1830. The objective point of
purposes than those of Watt, which were ji^^j railroad was the Ohio river, a very
very ponderous affairs moved very slow- comprehensive scheme, since merchan-
ly with very liglit steam pressure.
AMERICANS NEEDED NO PATTERN OF A
LOCOMOTIVE.
canal.
THE "sTOURnRIDGE LION."
The first locomotive on the American
contincut that was tried to run on rails
Americans as a rule knew very little
about what Englishmen had done in the
same line when they began building
railroads; they had very vague ideas
about foreign locomotives and regarded
the "Stourbridge Lion" as a freak. In
consequence of this the first American-
built locomotives were purely original.
Seventy years ago there was scarcely
any means of spreading information
among communities only a few miles
apart. The few newspapers published de-
voted their columns mostly to polit-
ical news. To attempt spreading sci-
entific information would have appeared
ridiculous. Owing to this obstacle to
was brought from England by the Del- the spreading of information, very few
aware & Hudson Canal Company and Englishmen were aware that peripatetic
was tried near Honesdale. The engine steam engines were hauling cars over
was selected by Horatio Allen, a cele- permanent iron rails fifteen years be-
brated pioneer engineer, and brought to fore the Liverpool & Manchester Rail-
the United States under his supervision. way was opened. Six months before
He acted as engineer in some trials made the opening of that railway the directors
in August, 1829. The engine was of the were inundated with wild schemes for
vertical cylinder type favored by George supplying power to operate the road.
Stephenson for hauling coal. The en- There were plans proposed for hauling
gine weighed 7 tons and was reported the cars by water power. Some pro-
by Mr. Allen to be too heavy for the posed hydrogen, others carbonic acid
trestles. That report closed the useful- gas. Atmospheric pressure had its ad-
stourbridge: lion.
dise or other products of the South
would have the markets of a stupendous
area of country. The route located in-
volved the use of a great many curves
and grades that were considered so for-
midable that few people believed the
road could be operated by steam. But
Peter Cooper, afterwards celebrated as
a great philanthropist, was then a mer-
chant in Baltimore, deeply interested in
the prosperity of the city. He believed
that the road could be successfully op-
erated by steam and proceeded to prove
it. Being a man with some mechanical
ability, he designed and supervised the
building of a small locomotive whose
working presented the very best argu-
ments in favor of a locomotive. Sev-
enty years ago nearly all Americans
were amateur mechanics, so it excited
ness of the "Stourbridge Lion," as the
engine was called, and it was laid away
and gradually dismantlea. The boiler is
now in the Field Museum, Chicago.
DISCOURAGEMENTS.
This failure did not dishearten the men
who were advocating the construction
of railroads. The first thirty years of
the nineteenth century were for Amer-
icans a period of speculation about the
probable success of railroad building
and of the utility of the locomotive. But
before the third decade was ended rail-
road construction was going on in va-
rious parts of the country. An impression
is widespread that American railroad
pioneers in building railroads and in de-
vocates; others favored greased cog
rails; but stationary engines with rope
traction had most advocates. There was
a multitude of counsellors who proved
nothing except that even the scientific
men of England had no knowledge of
what had been done by Trevithick, by
Hedley, Stephenson. Hackworth and
others. No wonder that American rail
COOPERS TOM THUMB-FIG. S.
no surprise that a merchant should de-
sign a locomotive.
cooper's ENGINE.
Cooper's engine was the "Tom
road builders knew practically nothing Thumb," Fig. 8, a remarkably tiny loco-
about what had been done in their line motive with one upright cylinder 3% x
abroad. The only things which our first 13H inches, and an upright boiler hav-
railroad builders borrowed from Eng- ing tubes made from gun barrels. Draft
land was the bar frame for locomotive? for the fire was maintained by a revolv-
and the track gauge of 4 ft. SVz in. The ing fan. It performed the duties for
latter might have been declined with which the engine was buflt,^ most of
much advantage.
them having been of a missionary char-
8o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
acter. It proved that steam power could
be used to operate the Baltimore & Ohio
Railroad, and revived the spirits of the
promoters of the enterprise, who were
becoming despondent about the pros-
pects of the property. The "Tom
Thumb" was little bigger than a modern
hand car and was only about iJ/$ horse
power, but its design seems to have ex-
erted considerable influence on our
early locomotives. Cooper claimed no
originality in using tubes for the boiler,
for Nathan Read, of New England, had
built multitubular boilers years before.
The sentiment in favor of railroad
building developed very rapidly in the
United States after the shortcomings of
canals had been plainly demonstrated.
The men who took the lead in advo-
cating railroads were the most influen-
tial and intelligent men in the country,
having clear views about what they
wanted. When DeWitt Clinton, in 1812,
was urging through the New York
legislature the act for the construc-
tion of the Erie Canal, Colonel Ste-
vens, of Hoboken, insisted that he
could build a railroad on which cars
would be drawn by steam locomo-
tives at a cheaper rate, and at a
much higher speed than canal boats.
He submitted particulars of his
plans, and they did not differ
much from the railroads that
were subsequently built.
B. & O. DIRECTORS OFFER PRIZE
FOR LOCOMOTIVE.
Shortly after the experiments
with Peter Cooper's model loco-
motive, the management of the
Baltimore & Ohio advertised, of-
fering a premium of $500 for a
locomotive, built in the United
States, which would draw fifteen
tons, gross weight, at fifteen miles
an hour. In due time this offer brought
to the company five locomotives, all built
at different places, all different in de-
sign, and none of them imitating British
models. One was a rotary engine. The
preference was given to an engine built
by Davis and Gartner, of York, Pa. The
engine had a vertical boiler of a curious
original pattern, and upright cylinders.
She did not work very satisfactorily.
The experience with this engine led to
the building of the "Atlantic," Fig. 9,
which was designed by Phineas Davis
and Ross Winans, who was assistant
engineer of machinery of the Baltimore
& Ohio. The "Atlantic," which became
known as the beginning of the "Grass-
hopper" type, has a vertical boiler with
a fan for stimulating the fire. The cyl-
inders were vertical, 10 x 12 inches, and
they transmitted the power to a sup-
plementary driving shaft by means of
spur and pinion, which was geared up
to make the wheels revolve twice for
every turn of the crank. By this rneans
wheels three feet in diameter were made
equivalent to driving wheels six feet in
diameter.
About twenty engines of the "Atlan-
tic" type were built, and they worked
very successfully in developing railroad
traffic, and only went out of favor when
engines with a longer wheel base be-
came necessary. Some "Grasshoppers"
were used about Mount Clare shops till
about 1890. These engines filled a gap
in railroad operating, but they exerted
little influence on locomotive develop-
ment more than warning designers
against upright cylinders and upright
boilers. They were, however, an excel-
lent object lesson in difficulties that
could be overcome by intelligence and
perseverance. The United States was, in
1830, almost purely an agricultural coun-
contracts the same as iron, thus keep-
ing the joint tight at all temperatures,
and it will withstand the action of steam,,
water, fire or oil. The 60-page illus-
trated book, which the Smooth-on Man-
ufacturing Company, of Jersey City,
have got out, giving further information
regarding this subject, will be sent free
on application. The cements are packed
in 5, 10 and 2S-pound tins.
The Electric Contract Company, of 55
Jilaiden Lane, New York, has put upon the
market a portable electric lamp, somewhat
resembling a locomotive engineers' torch.
In fact, the lamp can be used for the same
purpose as an engine torch is used, and
it has the advantage that it cannot be
blown out. An ordinary torch will stand
a good deal of wind, but often in its bat-
tle with the elements its light-giving
power is greatly reduced. The electric
torch will glow steadily while the
pressure of the thumb is kept
upon a button in the handle, or
Ijy the use of a small attachment
the torch may t)e made to burn
continuously. The company will
be happy to send catalogue or any
desired information to those suf-
ficiently interested to apply.
.\TL.4NTIC,
ROSS WINANS,
try, yet, with few mechanics skilled in
the working of metals, and very meager
workshop facilities, the people began the
work of locomotive building in a spirit
that guaranteed success.
{To be continued.)
Every inch of railway hne in '
England may be said to have cost
I2S., every mile £39,000, and it is-
interesting to remember that
English railways are three times-
as costly as those of America.
Philip Burtt, general traffic
manager of the North Eastern
Railway, who spent several
months in this country last year
studying American railroad meth-
ods, speaking at the Railway In-
stitute of New York, relative to
his recent investigation of American rail-
way methods, expressed general admira-
tion of them, and said he was of the opm-
ion that British railroad men can learn
much from America. At the same time,
he added, the best American roads will
f^nd much to learn and admire in Eng-
lish railroad management.
It is said that a Smooth-on gasket
connection may take a little longer time
to make than an ordinary steam pack-
ing one would, but when once made it
will be more durable and seems to im-
prove with age. Difficult flanged con-
nections can easily be made with smooth-
on as it is applied in a plastic state and
adapts itself to the flanged faces, wheth-
er strictly parallel or not. For high
temperature and high pressure work the
following fact shows its value. It has
been tested to 1,500 degrees Fahren-
heit, and at the same time withstood 400
lbs. steam pressure without injury.
Smooth-on, when hard, expands and
It is reported that the Schenectady Lo-
comotive Works have supplied Japan with
155 locomotives during the last four years.
There used to be a prejudice in Japan in
favor of British engines, but now the trade
with the United States has been worked
up so well that all the supply of locomo-
tives sent to Japan are made in America.
We are informed that the meeting of
the board of directors of the Allis-
Chalmers company was held on Thurs-
day, January 15. 1903. and declared the
regular quarterly dividend on the pre-
ferred stock.
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
81
Air=Brake Department.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NBI,I,IS.
Duplex riain-Reservoir Pressure Regu-
lation.
A practice Ims been inaugurated on
some of our railways, botli in the East
and the West, wliich has been found
beneficial in long train service of the
present day. 1 his practice is made oper-
ative by the installation of a duplex gov-
ernor instead of the single governor
usually employed, so piped that the pump
will operate against a ccunparatively low
main-reservoir pressure when tiie brakes
are released, and against the established
maximum pressure only during the com-
paratively short time they are applied.
As will be noted by reference to the
accompanying cuts, which clearly illus-
trate the method of piping the duplex
governor to accomplish the purpose in
view, the only parts required besides the
standard apparatus are an additional top
or regulating portion of the pump gov-
ernor, the T-shaped piece, or Siamese
fitting, for connecting up the two gov-
ernor tops, and the necessary pipe and
fittings, as shown by the heavy black
lines in Fig. i. As indicated, one gov-
ernor head is connected directly to the
main-reservoir pressure in the usual
way; the other is connected with feed
port f of the engineer's brake valve at
a point between the rotary valve and the
feed valve, which is marked A in the
two small views at the lower portion of
the illustration. Fig. 2 and Fig. 3. There
are no fixed regulations for the low- and
high-pressure heads, these being made to
suit the local conditions. In general,
for heavy service, they should be adjust-
ed at 85 and 120 pounds, respectively,
where the trainpipe pressure is regulated
at 70 pounds. The 15 pounds excess
pressure thus carried is ample to guard
against any reduction in trainpipe pres-
sure from the use of sanders or other
"air brake parasites," where the amount
of air so used is not more than the pump
will ordinarily supply.
With the brake-valve handle in run-
ning position, main-reservoir -pressure
flows freely into the feed valve and, by
means of the feed port, passes to the
low-pressure head of the governor; the
pump will then stop when the main-
reservoir pressure has reached the limit
at which the low-pressure head is adjust-
ed. When the brake is applied, the po-
sition of the ports in the rotary valve is
such that main-reservoir pressure can-
not reach the feed port; a portion of the
air in the pipe leading from port A to the
low-pressure head then escapes through
the vent port of the governor, allowing
steam to pass to the pump, which oper-
ates until main-reservoir pressure, pass-
ing through the usual connection from
the brake valve to the high-pressure gov-
ernor head, is sufficient to overcome the
tension at which it is set and close the
steam valve in the usual manner.
It will thus be seen that when the
brakes are released, which is the case
during the larger part of the time, the
pump operates against a comparatively
low main-reservoir pressure; but as soon
as the brakes are applied, it rapidly ac-
cumulates a high main-reservoir pres-
sure with which to release the brakes
and recharge the auxiliaries.
When the duplex governor is used, one
of the vent ports should be plugged with
Slid Flat Wheels.
It is quite common with some railroads
at the present time, when an epidemic of
flat wheels strikes them, to pounce upon
the air brake as a general breeder of
trouble and the cause of the damage. So
uncharitable to the air brake is this feel-
ing of some railroad men when the sea-
son of fiat wheels comes, that they look
upon the air brake wholly as an intruder
and mischief maker, forgetting mean-
while what the air brake does in better
service and what it has accomplished in
the way of higher speeds, greater carry-
ing facilities, etc., during the past twenty
years.
These are the persons who forget that
I'lil- t
To Main lieservolr
JIuHtl of Gauge
Gov. JJettd ~
To Veeil Fort in
Kiiffinecrs yalve\
Low I'fr»Mure
Cor. J/*"f/
T»ij> Ittrijr pnri
\f I'ent I'urtt antl
pififf one irifh
iO thttttil "tretr
To Bolter —
■ago
'To rum if
% npr Tap ^
Connect A to
L.r. Got: Jfead
Hailw^'y i Lutv^utitt tnyiKmring
Fig. 3 '■•!/• ^
DUPLEX M.\IX-RESERVOIR PRESSURE REGrLATIOX.
a No. 14, 20-thread screw to prevent the
escape of air through both vent ports
when the governor is in operation, one
vent port being entirely sufficient. All
governors now shipped have provision
made for the use of this screw, but in
many cases it will be necessary to tap
the large end of the vent port for the
purpose indicated.
To facilitate the practice above de-
scribed, all brake valves now sent from
the manufacturer's works have hole A.
drilled into the feed port, properly
tapped and plugged; but in case it is de-
sired to make this installation where
brake valves have not been so drilled and
tapped, the work can be properly done
by following the plan and measurements
indicated in Figs. 2 and 3, which show
the proper location and size of hole A.
Ilat wheels occurred long before the air
brake was invented. Possibly that was
before their time. If it was, and these
persons would learn that part of braking
history which tells of slid flat wheels
caused by hand brakes on non-air-
braked cars, they have but to observe
trains where a number of air brakes are
used on the forward end, and too gen-
erous assistance to these air brakes is
given by the hand brakes on the rear
cars, immediately back ot the air-braked
cars.
Perhaps a more forcible object lesson
in this line would be to observe the flat
wheels which too often occur on the ca-
boose car itself. This is especially true
where but two brakemen are assigned to
a train and the rear brakeman, or flag-
man, is obliged to assist in holding the
82
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
train, which he generally does, if at all
possible, with the caboose brake itself.
One of the greatest recommendations
of the air brake on freight trains is that
it brakes practically uniformly on all
cars; hence the less likelihood of slid
flat wheels. In the olden days, before air
the foot of the grade or the end of the
stop. Of course, there are, sometimes,
slid fiat wheels on air-braked cars; but
it is only just to the air brake to say
that the majority of these slid flat wheels
were not produced by the air brake
which brakes uniformly and to a limit,
but rather to the setting up of the hand
brake in yards and the pulling of the
car by the switch engine while the hand
brake remains set; or, possibly, it may
have been "clubbed" at some time.
These points should be remembered by
those unthinking persons who feel dis-
posed to unqualifiedly condemn the air
brake at those seasons of the year when
the slid flat wheels almost invariably set
in to the great annoyance and expense of
railroad companies.
J
Air Brake Charts.
We are pleased to be able to tell our
many readers that during the present
year a valuable educational adjunct to
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing will appear in several numbers in
AUTOMATIC .sight FEED LUBRICATOR
FOR AIR CYLINDER.
brakes were invented, or in operation on
freight trains, it was the practice of the
brakeman to select two or three cars in
his portion of the train where the hand
brakes were in good order. With these
selected brakes, and the assistance of his
"club," he would do his portion of the
braking on the entire train. Thus half
a dozen cars were often obliged on a trip
to do the whole braking of an entire
train of 25 to 40 cars. The result of this
to an observer at the foot of a heavy
grade, or at the end of any heavy appli-
cation, was the pounding of a new "slid
flat" which could be plainly heard.
Indeed, on mountain grades where this
practice was carried on. wheels were fre-
quently known to crack after cooling off
at the botom of the grade, due to the
heating of the continued and heavy ap-
plication of the brakes by the brakeman
with his "club."
But in those days freight M'ains were
neither so numerous nor so long as they
are at the present time, and the number
of slid flat wheels were therefore below
the number of to-day; but taking into
consideration the greater number of cars
run at the present time, it is fair and
reasonable to say that there are far fewer
slid flat wheels per air-braked car to-
day than there was in the past with the
hand brake.
Even to-day we find non-air-braked
cars with slid flat wheels. This goes to
show that the brakeman is still inclined
to select a good brake and stay by it to
ment. These charts will be issued, be-
ginning in the March number.
Automatic Sight Feed for Air Cylinder.
I send photographs of my recently
patented automatic oiling device for the
air cylinder of an air pump, applied to
an 8 in. and 9 1-2 in. pump, also a cen-
tral vertical section of the mechanism.
This device has been put to a severe
test for the past thirteen months, and has
proven successful in every detail, en-
abling the pump to produce more air and
prolong the life of the pump.
F is the connections of any rod or
guide cup, with a fine adjustable feed.
G is the drop tube for oil. H is the sight
feed tube, consisting of a 3-4 in. by 2 in.
lubricator glass. L is the sight feed port.
Also a certain' amount of air passes
through this on the downward stroke of
the main piston. I is the upper check
valve, seated by the spring J. K are
ports leading from the upper to the lower
check valve chamber. M is the lower
check valve, and is seated by spring N.
S is a 1-4 in. street elbow connection.
It will be noted that the vacuum, or
partial vacuum, from the mam piston
opens the valves and the spring closes
them before they are reached by the
pressure. After thirteen months of ser-
vice, the valves and seats do not show
any perceptible wear. I have had four
of these in service, and no repairs have
been required. About two tablespoon-
Ritituiay .J L-jCi^Qtivt ini/ineerinj Raiiuay S Lotomothe En^netring
AUTOMATIC SIGHT FEED LUBRICATOR.
the form of air brake charts, in which
a unique color scheme will be used. The
charts will consist of graphic color com-
parisons, representing the variations of
pressure during brake operation of the
quick-action brake, the high-speed
brake, the high-pressure control, etc.
The color scheme is the invention of
Mr. E. G. Desoe, air brake instructor on
the Boston & Albany R. R. These charts
will be really a practical application of
the old adage, "Seeing is believing,"
as they will, in telling their story, appeal
to the eye. There is no more easy way
of acquiring information than to have
it shown to one. Just as stereoptican
pictures enhance the value of a lecture,
so will these charts add interest to the
whole subject of air brake operation, and
will be a decided help to all seekers after
information in this important depart-
9;4 INCH PUMP WITH SIGHT FEED
LUBRICATOR.
fuls of valve oil will supply the pump for
ten hours. The top lid is hinged, and
requires filling every three or four days
(or round trips). Opening the feed at
commencement and closing at end of the
run is all the labor or care involved.
The oil reservoir rests against the steam
union nut of the governor, which always
insures oil warm enough to flow freely.
. ^ , G. W. Thurston.
Dunsmiiir, Lai.
February, lyo.i
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
83
CORRESPONDENCE.
Dangerous Position of Angle Cocks.
I send you a drawing I made of a
«liingerou3 position of an angle cock in
relation to the outside drawbar carrier
wire bolt.
The drawing is made from a specific
■case in which the lower nut on this bolt
worked down so that one of its corners
rested directly on the center of the top
of the angle cock plug, and although the
train pipe was tight in its clip, there was
still vibration enough to cause the spring
points on fitting them for service, as I
am a triple fitter and air brake repair
hand at this point.
It is not going very far out of the
road to state that the triple valve is to
each car as the brain is to each individ-
ual, and the actions of either are in
most cases in comparison as to their de-
gree of perfection; hence, a perfect triple
might be termed an educated triple. The
slide valve and seat are the points upon
which I wish to focus my remarks, as the
other parts are easily finished by ma-
chine.
A perfect slide valve seat and an air-
SMx.
-4-r-
-1— r
I I
m
^-^-
I I
WB WU
-MM-
U.INOEROUS POSITION OF ANGLE COCKS.
in the angle cock to compress, and the
•corner of the nut resting on the plug
formed a pivot for it, so that the least
touch would move the angle cock handle
open or shut. This car was the second
one from the locomotive on a long
freight train, and the swinging of the
car when running closed the angle cock
and caused trouble when an application
was required.
This train had made a successful stop
three miles away from the point at
which the trouble occurred, and while
very little damage was done in this case,
it shows, however, what could happen
with the angle cock in such a position.
A very large number of the freight cars
of many different roads have their angle
cocks directly under this bolt in the
same w'ay. and are thus liable to the
same accident. Besides, it simply
shortens up the hose couplings. The
standard distance of 13 in. from the cen-
ter line of one car to the center of angle
cock, should be more closely adhered to,
and thus avoid the trouble mentioned.
W. C. Hunter.
Gen'l \.-'B. Insp'r Intercolonial Railway.
Moncton, N. B.
Triple Valve Fitting and Repairing.
A lot of time is spent answering ques-
tions of persons who have a theory to ped-
dle, so if you will kindly give me space
in your journal I will try to make clear
what should be the requirements of the
triple slide valve and its seat, and a few
tight triple are the cardinal points which
should be insisted on, for reasons which
are obvious. A sand hole in the slide
valve, bushing or leakage under the
bushing, are a few of the defects which
will allow air to escape, and by a lax test
makes it impossible to detect the cause
of the leakage. The above added to a
defective seat limits the efficiency and
service of the triple. An air-tight triple
is no criterion as to the perfection of
the seat, as my experience will prove. I
have tested a number of passenger triples
to be used on local trains, and taking the
tight ones (such cases are becoming
rare) rubbed the slide valve on the seat
and found some of them only bearing on
the vital points, leaving low places ex-
posed to catch the grit and sand, thus re-
ducing the service of these triples to a
minimum; whereas, the seats which had
a bearing the full travel of the valve
would stay in service for years without
any appreciable defect.
What constitutes a good triple valve
seat Js limited to those who are experi-
enced in fitting them, owing to the pe-
culiarity of a brass to brass slide valve
aivd seat. The slot is cut through the
bushing by machine, and the fitter seats
the valve by hand. It requires skill and
patience to make an air-tight plane across
the ports and the full travel of the slide
valve. This part of the work is accom-
plished to-day practically the same way
as in the beginning; i. e., by files and
scraper. The .^lot is first filed and the
bearing found bv a surface strip the
width of the slot, a very light film of oil
being used on the strip to detect the
high places which are' scraped, until the
surface strip bears all over the seat.
Then the slide valve is ground in to
match. The life of the valve and seat
would be longer if they were scraped to
a bearing, but it is not practical on ac-
count of the length of time it would re-
quire.
There has been divers attempts made
to finish this work by machine, but with-
out success. One of the many devices re-
sorted to was on the same principle as
the key scat machine with roughing and
finishing bars, the necessary parts being
made as perfect as possible. A number
of triples were slotted, and to the inex-
perienced fitter seemed good, and af-
forded considerable elation to those con-
cerned in the experiment. The slide
valve was ground to match the seats
and they were tested, a tew passing the
test. The triples were then given to the
fitters to be reseated, and upon examina-
tion the seats were found wavy and very
low across the ports. These conditions
were easily accounted for, as three ports
(I allude to the Westinghouse triple) are
so close together that the most accurate
bar will cut low and gouge at this point
The nature of the metal is another
factor which makes thu valve seat one
of the impossibilities of the machine. If
it were possible to grind the slide valve
to such a seat and make it partially
tight, as stated before, the service of
such triples would be limited, and it
SL.'VCK T.\KE-rP DEVICE.
would be just as practical to take a triple
seat that needed repairing and grind a
newly surfaced slide valve to match it.
McKees Rocks, Pa. H. L. S.
Slack Take=Lp Device.
I send you a sketch of my device,
which is used by air-brake testers and
adjusters in the South Pacific car depart-
ment, Oakland, to take up slack in the
bottom rods when necessary, the dead
levers having been taken up to the last
hole in their stops.
This device saves considerable time
usually lost in going to the shop for
clamps, it being so small that it can be
carried on the brake valve stand; also
allowing one man to do the work of
two, where clamps are used.
To use the device, push the dead lever
to the last hole in the stop and pin, then
hook the hook end of the device to the
center of the brake beam, and the clutch
to the bottom rod, seeing that the chain
is taut. Then pull the pin holding the
dead lever in the stop; this will throw
84
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
the strain from the connection of the
lever and bottom rod, to the device.
Connection may now^ be broken, and
the lever moved up one hole in the bot-
tom rod, the pin replaced, and the job is
done. W. H. Collins.
Air-Brake Inspector Sou. Pac. Ry. Car
Department.
Oakland, Cat.
Air Pump Exhaust Muffler.
It may be of interest to some of your
readers to have me mention an important
change I have made in the air-brake in-
struction car I am in charge of.
We have a 9 1-2-inch Westinghouse
pump to furnish the air for use in the car,
and as it is necessary to use the air pump
exhaust to furnish draft for the boiler,
we have experienced considerable trouble
with the noise the pump exhaust made.
Discharge I'ipe front
~ Ftiinjf to Keservoir
l£jc7i{ttist Pipe from
''lieserroir to Stack
the cages, thus I can show the effect of
oiling through the air inlet and can hold
the valve off the seat and also show the
effect of a stuck valve.
The stem on the discharge valve side
has threads to raise the valve from its
seat to show a broken discharge valve.
This arrangement is very simple and in-
structive, and can be very easily arranged.
Wm. Shriver,
A.-B. Instr. B. & O. R. R. West of
Ohio River.
Allegheny City, Pa.
^
<i:
10 Jr 34
Jiesvi'i'oir
liuUwtij/ ■(■ Lacvmvlivi l^'ij/ineai-ing
AIR PUMP EXHAUST MUFFLER.
We were obliged to muffle the exhaust,
so I had it piped from the pump to a 10
x 24-inch auxiliary reservoir which was
placed underneath the car. From the same
end of the auxiliary reservoir I had the
exhaust continued to the stack.
This device works very satisfactorily.
The only noise in the car now is the
valve seating. Thus we still have the use
of the exhaust steam for the draft on the
fire. I send a rough sketch of the device
herewith for illustration.
Wm. Shriver,
A.-B. Inspr. B. & O. R. R. West ot
Ohio River.
Allegheny City, Pa.
Instruction Car Kink to Illustrate
Brolcen and Stucl< Air Pump Valves.
On the 9 i-2-inch pump I use to furnish
air for our air-brake instruction car, I
have the bottom receiving valve and bot-
tom discharge valve so arranged that I
can unseat the valves to show the effect
of stuck or broken valves.
The device I use to unseat the valves is
a stuffing box and a valve steam of a 1-2-
inch globe valve. I had the valve cages
tapped so as to screw into the bottom of
the brake cylinder and reducing valve
to escape to the atmosphere, and you
may disconnect the filling hose, replace
plug in tee O, and call the job done.
W. H. Collins.
Air Brake Inspector S. P. Car Dept.
Oakland, Cal.
Reversing Engine witli Brakes Set.
My opinion of the subject of drivers
sliding with engine reversed, is that it
is never good policy to reverse an engine
if the brakes are holding at all. for as
soon as an engine is reversed, the driv-
ers start to revolve in the opposite di-
rection, and the brake shoes seize the
wheels and hold them, causing flat spots,
etc., regardless of whether the speed is
high or not. I have seen this take place
under these conditions.
W. G. Stenason.
Hamilton, Out.
Emergency Tests of Air=Brakes.
There appeared in the January number
of this paper an article entitled "Emer-
gency Tests of Air-Brakes." which, I pre-
sume, the writer intended to be a reply
Reducing Valve Testing Device.
I send you a sketch and directions
how to use a simple device which I
employ to test the high-speed reducing
valve of the high-speed brake.
The device consists of one air gauge,
two three-eighth inch cocks, and nipples
and fittings which, when put together,
will conform with the sketch.
The nipple at cock D should have the
female part of union I on it; also the
same at tee B.
The hose G should be long enough to
reach the air plug in the yard, with air
coupling on one end, and male part of
three-eighth union at the other.
Filling hose H is four feet long, with
one-half inch nipple at one end and male
part of three-eighth union at the other.
To use the device, couple the hose G
to the air plug in the yard, and tester to
hose at union I. Close cock D. take
the plug out of tee O in the reducing
valve pipe, and screw the filling hose to
it and the_ other end to the tester at the
union F, and close cock C.
Now see that all air is out of brake
system, and close cock A. Then open
cock D and the air from hose G will
pass to gauge, brake cylinder and reduc-
ing valve. At the same time, there will
be a blow at the triple exhaust, but leave
it alone, and in about one minute open
cock A. This will cause the triple to
go to the full service position and the
blow will stop. Leave cock A open,
and when the gauge shows the required
pressure to cause reducing valve to ex-
haust, set your valve. The valve being
tested and adjusted, close cock D and
open cock C. This will allow the air in
R»iimat i XoMffiotiM Jtnginuring
REDUCING VALVE TESTING DEVICE.
to ay article on this subject in the De-
cember number. Besides that which I
have already covered in what I have writ-
ten on the subject, I find very little of any
importance to answer. However, in re-
gard to the point, which I think the au-
thor intended to bring forth, that there
would be difficulty experienced in ascer-
taining if a serial application took place
on a 50-car train, I will say that on roads
which have a complete code of hand sig-
nals in use to communicate from one end
of the train to the other, when testing the
air-brakes, it would not be difficult to as-
certain this. And as for the time required,
I think it would not be over 30 seconds.
E. G. Desoe,
General A.-B. Inspector B. & A. R. R.
S I'ringHcld, Mass.
Tlie Baldwin Locomotive Works have
made an offer to the Sibley College of an
e-xperiniental locomotive, and the author-
ities of the above universities are making
preparations for the installation of the en-
The Pressed Steel Car Company have
made an announcement that they will
share the profit of the business with their
employees.
February, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On Air Brake Subjects.
(8) D. J. McC, Savannah, Ga., asks:
Will leaking gland nuts on the piston
rods of the New York duplex pump
have any effect on working the head
loose? A. — Yes, and especially so if the
pump is run at a rapid rate. At the end
of the upstroke the pump will lose its
cushion, and the piston head will be per-
mitted to strike against the center piece
of the pump, thus causing the piston
head to work loose from the rod.
(9) M. M. D., Albany, N. Y., asks :
Will we got any better signal on the en-
gine by holding onto the bell cord in the
car and keeping the discharge valve open
a long titne? A. — No better, nor as good
a signal, will be had as if a short, sharp,
quick pull of the cord is made, thereby
venting pressure at the discharge valve
sharply and quickly. Again, the longer
pull of the curd will interfere with the
succeeding signal.
(10) J. B. M., Hempstead, L. I.,
writes:
I. — One of our six-car passenger
trains has been cut down to two cars
since the summer travel is over, and the
ten-wheeler that hauled the six-car train
now hauls two cars only. We have had
trouble in two instances from slid flat
wheels on the two-car train, but none on
the six. Why is it? A. — i. The un-
braked weight of the engine is much
greater than that of the cars. In other
words: the cars are now helping to hold
back the engine in making stops, besides
doing their own work. The work of the
two cars in doing this is much greater
than in the six-car train, thus overtax-
ing the wheels on the two cars and
causing them to slide.
2. Wouldn't a brake on the truck
wheels of the engine help out some? A.
— 2. It certainly would.
(in J. B. C., Port Jervis, N. Y.
asks:
Why does the piston rod on an 8-inch
pump break oflf so often in the air piston?
I have noticed that there are more break-
ages on the rod at this point than at the
upper end. A. — Oftentimes a wide open
pump throttle, when the air pressure is
low, will cause a piston head to strike
against the center piece of the pump, thus
causing an undue strain on the lower end
of the rod where the thread ends. An-
other prime reason is the eflforts of the
repairman to tighten up the nut on the
lower end of the rod with a hammer and
chisel after taking off the lower head when
the pump is still on the engine. In this
case he is unable to get a wrench on the
nut, and the result is that the rod is
weakened at end of the thread and finally
breaks off. It will be observed that where
broken rods occur most frequently that
chisel marks may be found on the nut.
(\2) P. J. F., Oclwein, Iowa, asks:
Can you give a rule by which I can
find the size of air drum to hold a vol-
ume of air at 90 lbs., which is contained
in a drum at no lbs.? A. — The capacity
in inches contained in a given reservoir
multiplied by the pounds pressure in that
reservoir must equal the capacity in
inches multiplied by the pounds pressure
of the other reservoir. If three of the
terms are given, the fourth can be found.
In this case, we have the three terms to
help us find the fourth. We will assume
that the reservoir containing the no lbs.
has 16,000 cubic inches capacity. By mul-
tiplying 16,000 by no, and dividing by
90, wc get the capacity of the reservoir
in which we wish to hold the air at 90
lbs. pressure, which is 19,555 cubic
inches. The general rule, then, is, mul-
tiply the known capacity of one reservoir
by its pressure, and divide by the press-
ure of the other reservoir. The result
will be the cubic capacity of the second
reservoir. Similarly, if the pressure and
capacity of one reservoir and capacity
of the second reservoir is known, and
the pressure of the second reservoir is
desired, we would multiply the capacity
of the known reservoir by its pressure,
and divide by the capacity in inches of
the other reservoir. The result would
be the pressure required.
(13) E. L. R., Jersey City, N. J.,
writes:
Is the automatic brake on a switch en-
gine as good as a straight air-brake?
Doesn't it apply too slow and re-
lease too slow? We have an en-
gine here which "spots" cars on a
float at the dock in North river, and
when we get a signal from one of the yard
crew to stop we find the automatic brake
too slow — unless we throw it into the
emergency. We often make a stop
by reversing the engine, in a case like
this where accurate stopping of the cars
is required, would it not be better to use
the straight air direct? A. — The auto-
matic brake is not as satisfactory a brake
for switching service as a straight air
brake. However, switch engines so fre-
quently couple up and handle air-brake
trains that it has proved impossible to re-
move the automatic brake on engine and
put on the straight air brake. Recently
a combined automatic and straight air
brake for switch engines has been de-
signed by the Westinghouse Air Brake Co.
which answers both kinds of service ad-
mirably. The straight air feature consists
of a few parts which may be quickly added
to the automatic. Thus a switch engine
may be equipped to operate with either
an automatic or straight air brake. See
illustration of this in November issue.
(14) C. W. A., Youngstown, O., asks:
Don't the brake beam springs on brakes
take away a lot of the brake power that
should go to the wheels? Yesterday in
taking up slack on the dead lever I found
the resistance of the beam springs so pow-
erful that I had to get a chain and run it
around the axle and the beam to get a
dead lever pin in. A. — A surprising
amount of the force which should go to
the wheels is absorbed by brake beam
springs. These springs are most com-
mon on outside-hung brakes, and seem
to be growing stiffer and stifTer as the
car grows larger and heavier. A scries of
tests was recently made to determine the
friction in the parts of the foundation gear
and the resistance of brake-beam springs.
A reduction of five pounds in train pipe
showed nine pounds in brake cylinder
and only 200 pounds on brake beam, while
the estimated pressure on the beam was
828 pounds, or a loss of 76 per cent. A
reduction of 10 pounds showed 21 pounds
cylinder, and 950 pounds brake-beam
pressure, against an estimated pressure of
1,931 pounds, or a loss of 50.8 per cent
A 15-pound reduction gave 29 pounds
cylinder and 1,600 pounds brake-beam
pressure, against 2,667 pounds estimated,
or 40 per cent. loss. On the emergency
application this percentage of loss was
reduced to an average of about 31 per
cent., due to the sudden shock when the
brakes were set.
(15) J. B. McD., Buffalo, N. Y.,
writes:
Recently I had the privilege of wit-
nessing a test made with a six-car pass-
enger train, equipped with high pressure
reducing valves, to determine how much
pressure over sixty pounds could be had
in the brake cylinders in a continuous
service application — this being the kind
of service application an engineer makes
when he thinks he is going to overshoot
the station, or run by as some term it.
It was found that the pressure in all
those brake cylinders run up seventy
pounds, and in one case, seventy four
before the reducing valve opened. It
then blew for some seconds and finally
closed off at about sixty pounds, there
being a variation of two or three pounds
in the point of closure among the differ-
ent valves. Will you explain how it is that
with these valves the points of opening
and closing are so wide apart, and why
the valve that closes at sixty pounds,
does not open promptly at sixty? A. —
The difference between the opening and
closing pressure is due to the fact that
the piston seats against an annular lip
on the upper part of the cylinder, thus
leaving less piston area exposed to the
incoming pressure. As soon as the pis-
ton starts to descend, however, the full
area of the face of the piston is exposed,
and the closing of the valve will be at
sixty pounds, or whatever pressure the
closure is adjusted to. The difference in
the opening and closing pressures will
sometimes run as high as eight or ten
pounds, but will gradually reduce to a
minimum as the parts become worn to
their seats.
86
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
Rogers Consolidation for the T. & O.
C. Railway.
The Toledo & Ohio Central Railway re-
cently received 20 heavy consolidation en-
gines from the Rogers Locomotive Works
at Paterson, N. J. These engines are
simple with cylinders 20x26 in. The
driving wheels are 54 in. in diameter and
■there is 133,000 pounds resting upon them.
The total weight of the machine is 150,-
000 pounds. With 180 pounds steam pres-
sure, the calculated tractive force which
can be exerted is about 29,500 pounds, and
the ratio of adhesive weight to tractive
force is 4,5. The leading pair of drivers
are equalized with the pony truck, and
the three rear drivers are equalized to-
gether with coil springs in front and rear
.and semi-elliptic springs placed between
the wheels and between the frame bars.
The second driver is the only one not
.flanged. The valve motion is indirect, the
Heating surface, tiit>es 1760.04 sq ft.
Heating surface, firebox i6,s.74 sq. ft-
Total 1925.78 sq. ft-
Grate area, 30.34 sq. ft.
Tubes, dia., 2 in. o. d ; lengtli. 13 ft. 10 in,; tliick-
ness. No. ir gauge; total number, 243.
BOII,ER.
Dia.. outside front, 60 in.; working press., iSo lbs.
Tfiickness of barrel, /gin.; dome course, H in.;
crown, ^ in.; tube, ^ in.; side, ^% in.
Tender, capacity, s,ooo gals.; fram£, white oak;
tiucks, diamond arch bars
Modern Results from an Old Machine.
That an up-to-date idea and an up-to-
date result may be successfully combined
on a machine, which has looked the scrap
heap seriously in the face at close quar-
ters, may be seen any day in the Rogers
Locomotive Works. The up-to-date idea
is the rapid, accurate and cheap method
of making the "square" on the ends of
stay-bolts so that they may fit the socket
ly tapering in the form of a V. These dies
have each seven notches, Vifith cutting
faces along their edges. The stay bolt, as
it is carried down by the butt-end of the
rib on the ram, is forced past these cut-
ting edges, with the result that they lit-
erally cut off two semicircular cheeks
from the stay-bolt end and at the next
stroke eat off two more half-round cheeks
when the operator has given the bolt a
quarter turn. The depth of the teethed
dies and the pushing rib is about an inch,
so that the end of each stay-bolt, as it is
tossed into a heap, has been cut square
for that distance, and of uniform size and
without taper. Two strokes of the re-
modeled slotter, which is running contin-
uously, does the work on each bolt. The
operator does not hold the bolt itself in
his hands ; he fits it in a socket and tight-
ens a set screw. The socket is in the end of
a long hollow bar, which has its farther
ROGERS CONSOLIDATION FOR TOLEDO & OHIO CENTRAL.
transmission bar here takes the form of an
arched steel casting, with bolt and filler
below the axle of the second driver.
The boiler has a Beipaire firebox and
tapers from dome to smoke box, the small-
est diameter being 60 in. The pop valves
are placed in the top of the dome and the
whistle occupies a somewhat protected po-
sition behind the dome. The frame cross
bracing has been well looked after, there
being a large steel casting back of the
cylinders, and the arrangement below the
. cab is very substantial. The tender frame
is made of white oak, and the tank, which
holds 5,000 gallons of water, is finished
very neatly with a deep coping which
helps to hold coal, and which does not
enclose the manhole. A low railing
around the edge serves as a sort of
guard around the edge of the tank. A
few of the principal dimensions are as
follows:
Cylinders, 20x26 in. Drivers, dia., 54 in.
Driv. journals, Sxio in. Driv. wheel base, i.s ft.
Total wheel base of engine, 23 ft.
Weight on drivers 133.000 lbs-
Weight on truck I7,ooolbs-
Total 130,000 lbs.
of the threading machine or fit a wrench
in the boiler shop. The up-to-date result
is seen in the stay-bolts themselves, and
the machine in question is an ancient slot-
ter, whose declining years are crowned
with such a measure of usefulness as a
modern tool might envy.
The table of the slotter remains per-
manently fixed, as the feed mechanism
has long since "gone in," while bolted to
the table is what may be called a large
cast iron die with a pair of jaws. In this
die there works a ram which is guided or
steadied by the die. The front of the
ram carries a rib so that in section it
would be something like the letter T.
This rib is cut oft' some distance from the
bottom of the ram, and anything pushed
up against the face of the ram would be
forced downward when the cut-off end of
the rib came down on it. That is exactly
what happens to a stay-bolt end when it
"goes up against" the descending ram
with its cut-off rib. On either side of,
and close to, the path of the vertically
moving rib are two dies, with faces slight-
end loosely but permanently held in a rest
while the stay-bolt is in the machine.
When completed, socket and bar are
moved out, and while the far end of the
bar remains in its rest, the socket end is
placed in a temporary rest while one bolt
is removed and another put in.
There is no burned iron by this process
and no expense for the fuel of a furnace.
The cost of the doing the work is that of
operating the machine, keeping it in ser-
vice and paying an unskilled workman,
and the result is decidedly up-to-date,
though the instruments are not at all
modern. That is the kind of thing to
which Captain Cuttle's maxim applies :
"When found, make a note of."
We are informed that the Stannard &
White Co.'s patents will be manufactured
by the Gold Medal Camp Furniture Mfg.
Co., Racine Jet., Wis. Hereafter all let-
ters, orders, etc., intended for the Stan-
nard & White Co. should be addressed
to Racine Jet., Wis., where they will re-
ceive careful and prompt attention.
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
87
How to Handle Gasolene.
IIY K. \v. Konr.RTs
As many of our readers liave to handle
gasolene and kerosene and have very
vague ideas about the dangers of explo-
sion, we reproduce this valuable article
by an excellent anthorily from the pages
of The /lutoinobile Magazine, of New York.
Why is it that a man who will handle
gunpowder with impunity, who would not
hesitate to set fire to a small quantity of
the powder strewn upon a board, will
blanch at a suggestion to do the same
thing with gasolene? This same man will
shoot all manner of fireworks in commem-
oration of the nation's birlhday or upon
other momentous occasions, yet were
some one to touch a lighted match to the
opening of a can filled with gasolene, he
would make a break for tall timber. Even
those who are quite familiar with gaso-
lene and have handled it considerably as
operators of gasolene engines would be
inclined to hesitate before performing the
benzine and the remaining petroleum de-
rivatives, and is known as a hydrocarbon.
It will unite with oxygen to form water
and carbon monoxide, the process of this
union being known as combustion. In
order to start combustion the temperature
of the fuel must be raised to the temper-
ature of ignition, when combustion will
take place at the surface in contact with
the oxygen, usually that contained in the
atmosphere. The heat of combustion of
one portion of the liquid raises an adjoin-
ing portion to the ignition temperature,
and so the combustion continues from one
particle to the next. The rapidity with
which combustion takes place depends
upon the extent of the surface exposed to
the air and also upon the rapidity with
which the products of combustion pass
away and give room for fresh air. When
both the air and the fuel are thoroughly
mixed, the combustion is so rapid as to
become explosive, as in the cylinder of a
gasolene engine. An excess of either air
Fig. 2 shows how the flame may be ex-
tinguished without trouble or danger by
dabbing the mouth of the can with a hand-
kerchief. Even a quick stroke with the
bare hand will often suffice, and such was
the method used to extinguish the flame
after some of the experiments illustrated.
The experiment shown in Fig. .3 makes
one think of that incident famed in the
joke book, "Bridget" lighting the fite with
kerosene. Had Bridget taken the cap oflf
the can she would not now be numbered
with the angels. Since kerosene evap-
orates more slowly than gasolene, the top
of a kerosene can is likely to contain an
explosive mixture of kerosene vapor and
air. If the mouth of the can be open,
there is ample exit for tTie proaucls of
combustion should such a mixture take
fire, although the agitation of the contents
due to pouring will usually cause the for-
mation of enough vapor to drive the air
from the top of the can. In performing
this experiment a small quantity of gaso-
^ . A
experiment illustrated in Fig. 3. It would
seem that this uncalled for fear of gaso-
lene is caused by the fact that a bad rep-
utation is easily acquired but difficult to
shake of?.
Gasolene is that one of the series of
petroleum products which is given oflf, dur-
ing the selective distillation of the crude
material, just between benzine and ker-
osene. Gasolene as employed for gasolene
engines is comprised in that series which
is known to the oil trade as C-petroleum-
naphtha. This series includes those oils
which have specific gravities lying between
.667 and .707, or, as they are more fre-
quently distinguished, between 80° and
68° Baume. The boiling points of the
oils classed as C-petroleum-naphtha lie be-
tween 176° and 212° Fahr. Gasolene,
therefore, is lighter than water, and va-
porizes readily at ordinary temperatures.
For gasolene engines the fuel employed is
usually 72° (Baume). or stove gasolene,
and that used for steamers generally 76°.
Gasolene itself is a chemical compound
of hydrogen and carbon, as are kerosene,
or fuel in a confined space dampens the
explosion, and when the proportion passes
a certain point an explosion will not take
place. It is seen, therefore, that both air
and heat are necessary to produce an ex-
plosion, and that, unless air be present,
gasolene will neither burn nor explode.
Again, the liquid will not explode even in
the presence of air, unless the air and the
combustible are intimately mixed. This
is the reason that in the series of experi-
ments illustrated herewith, no explosion
takes place.
In Fig. I is shown a common oil can
containing about two-thirds of a gallon of
gasolene, to opening of which the writer
is holding a lighted match. No explosion
follows this apparently foolhardy pro-
cedure, since the comparatively rapid evap-
oration of the fuel has driven all air from
the top of the can above the liquid, and
this space contains only gasolene vapor
unmixed with air. The gasolene vapor
takes fire and bums at the mouth of the
can in exactly the same manner as gas
burns at a gas jet.
(lene was poured upon the top of the lower
can to accentuate the flame. This gaso-
lene is ignited and the liquid is poured
from the spout can directly through the
flame into the other can. A moment's
consideration will show that there is not
the slightest danger in the performance of
this experiment. The stream of gasolene
will ignite, but it will be extinguished so
soon as it passes into the lower can, where
it is out of contact with the air. The gas-
olene on top of the can soon bums itself
out, and the flame at the mouth of either
can is readily extinguished by a stroke of
the hand.
This experiment is, in a way, the due
to the cause of many gasolene stove fires.
Filling the stove while the jets are burn-
ing is not to be recommended, but when
it is done and a small quantity of the
liquid is accidentally spilled, the flame is
sure to rush to reservoir, and the fright-
ened individual filling it drops the can
and flees. A conflagration naturally fol-
lows, and the newspapers report it as a
gasolene explosion, when it is very uiIi'Ke-
68
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
ly that an explosion took place. It is a
-gasolene fire due to carelessness and ig-
norance of what to do in an emergency of
this kind.
You have probably heard the oft-quoted
fable of gasolene fires due to the spark
from a lighted cigar or a lighted cigarette.
Try as hard as you will, you cannot ignite
gasolene or its vapor with the spark of
burning tobacco unless a flame be present.
The pan in Fig. 4 is halt full of gasolene,
and I am smoking a cigar as fast as I
can with the end held just over the sur-
face of the liquid, as is shown by the
smoke. In Fig. 5 the e-xperiment is shown
repeated with a cigarette. It is simply
a question of too low a temperature in
ember of the tobacco to ignite the hydro-
carbon.
Fig. 6 shows a lighted cigar being
plunged into the same pan of gasolene,
and in Fig. 7 the same cigar has been
liquid and prevent it from spreading, as
shown in Fig. 10, where a gasolene fire is
being extinguished with flour. Aqua am-
monia is also a good extinguisher for gas-
olene fires, and a large bottle of it dashed
upon the floor of a room will often put out
quite a stubborn blaze. It is scarcely ad-
visable to remain in a room in which any
quantity of ammonia has been set free.
While the foregoing experiments show
that many of the assumptions in regard
to gasolene are unfounded, the writer has
no intention of claiming that gasolene
should not be handled with care. A gaso-
lene can will explode if it contains a few
drops of gasolene and a large quantity of
air, and such an operation as warming an
empty gasolene can before a fire is likely
to result in an explosion. A tightly closed
can containing a quantity of gasolene, if
exposed to heat, will have pressure gen-
erated therein exactly in the same man-
above it, it should be smothered with
cloths, blankets, loose sand or earth, or
with flour. Water should be used only
as a last resort, and with the greatest cau-
tion, so as not to cause the fire to spread.
For storing gasolene the tank should be
placed so that it will be kept compara-
tively cool and on no account exposed to
the direct rays of the sun. This is not so
much to prevent danger from fire as it is
to prevent waste from evaporation. Prob-
ably the most convenient and effective way
of storing gasolene is to bury the tank
about a foot below the surface of the
ground. It then may be piped to a pump
in the stable or garage, and all pipe con-
nections should be carefully made and the
threads lubricated with soap or painted
with shellac or some substance that will
not be attacked by gasolene. Leaks should
be avoided not only to prevent waste, but
hmrifeiah^ ..xscrai^B^a- *t>s»»ii!SS»»»a!««;jrj
lighted and is flaming on account of the
gasolene it has absorbed. If the flame is
blown out, the cigar will smolder, but will
not flame up again;
The cigar in Fig. 8 has first been light-
ed, and when it was burning nicely it was
saturated with gasolene by dabbing the
liquid on with the finger. Being accus-
tomed to the taste of gasolene, the writer
suflfered no inconvenience from the added
flavor. The photographer gracefully de-
clined when I offered to add a similar
bouquet to the cigar he was smoking.
The most effective way to extinguish a
gasolene fire is with a substance that will
stop access of air to the combustible, i. e.,
smother the flame. Since gasolene is
lighter than water, it will float on the sur-
face of the latter, and an attempt to ex-
tinguish it with water usually results in
spreading the flame. In Fig. g is shown
a small quantity ,pf gasolene floating and
burning on top of water. A forcible stream
of water will, however, practically blow
out the flame and prevent, by wetting sur-
rounding substances, the spread of the fire
to them.
Flour, earth or sand will absorb the
ner as steam is raised in a steam boiler,
but at a much lower temperature. If this
pressure exceeds the strength of the ves-
sel, it will burst, but should no flame be
present a conflagration will not follow.
If a large quantity of gasolene escapes
from a leaking vessel into an enclosed
space such as a room its vapor will in
time fill the room with an explosive mix-
ture with the air, and if this mixture be
ignited a disastrous explosion is sure to
follow.
Gasolene fires pure and simple, without
the element of explosion, are most pro-
ductive of the disasters due to gasolene.
Like water, a quantity of gasolene spilled
upon the floor will spread over a large
space, and if accidentally ignited the flame
will cover the entire surface in an exceed-
ingly short space of tiire. It is in this
rapid spread of the flame that lies the
chief danger from a liquid fuel. If it is
spread upon merely an open space where
there is nothing above it for the flame to
ignite, the best way is to leave it alone,
as it will burn itself out and not even
char the board. If there is danger of the
flame coming in contact with anything
also to prevent the escape of any great
quantity of vapor into any enclosed space
where it may form an explosive mixture
with air.
In case any great quantity of gasolene
is to be handled no flame of any kind
should be in close proximity, not that
there is any danger in the simple operation
of pouring gasolene from one can to an-
other in proximity to a flame, but the
danger comes from likelihood of the gas-
olene being spilled and forming a highly
inflammable surface. There is, however,
no necessity of handling gasolene with the
same precautions as one would take with
gunpowder, as the two substances are by
no means analogous. The same precau-
tions that are usually taken with kerosene
are generally sufficient, the only difference
between the two substances being that
gasolene evaporates more rapidly at ordi-
nary temperatures. No one would think
of filling a burning lamp with kerosene,
especially if the vapor were so volatile
as to almost instantly reach the flame of
the lamp and take fire. Again, if a ker-
osene lamp takes fire one does not usually
run from it, but tries to throw it out
Fcbnmi-y, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
89
doors as quickly as possible. It should
be remembered thai, it a vessel contain-
ing gasolene takes fire and there is any
danger of explosion, the explosion will
occur immediately following the ignition,
and not later, and it is foolish to run
away. The proper thing to do is to make
every effort to get the vessel out doors,
and it should be "carried by walking back-
wards so that the flame will not burn the
receives all the effects of any arcing that
there may be and, since it is removable, is
easily replaced.
The tanks are insulated from the cir-
cuit, and, all the live metal parts being im-
mersed in oil, there is no possibility of re-
ceiving a shock from touching the breaker.
The controlling and indicating devices
consist of a controlling switch, an electro-
mechanical tell-tale indicator and a lamp.
These are suitably mounted at the oper-
ating platform.
The controlling switch has three posi-
tions, namely, "closed," "off" and "open."
It will remain of itself in the "off" or the
operator. As, for instance, if the vessel
is a pail that is being carried on a poker.
In conclusion, it may be said that a little
horse-sense in an emergency of this kind
does a great deal more good than a wiiole
lot of fuss.
Electrically=Operated Oil Circuit- Break-
er for Higli Tension Circuits.;
The rapid increase during recent years
in the size of central stations and the cur-
rents and voltages handled therein has
brought about a great development in the
methods and apparatus for controlling and
switching electric currents.
It is to meet the need of a compact,
safe and reliable device for rupturing
high-tension circuits that this oil circuit-
breaker has been brought out.
The circuit-breaker is erected in a ma-
sonry structure with each pole and oil
tank in a separate, fireproof compartment.
The movable contact for each pole con-
sists of a U-shaped piece of copper fas-
tened to the end of a stout wooden rod.
In the closed position of the switch, one
of these U-shaped pieces electrically con-
nects the two stationery contacts of each
pole.
The toggle joint which automatically
locks the system of levers when the cir-
cuit-breaker is closed is released by a blow
from the tripping magnet, whereupon the
cross bar under the influence of gravity,
and a powerful spring, quickly drops,
opening the contacts. The break takes
place first at the main contacts and then
afterward at a removable plug attached to
the stationery contact which enters a hole
on the movable contact. The ping thus
the eyes the "open" or "closed" position
of the oil circuit-breaker.
The apparatus described above, known
as the "Type C Circuit-Breaker," is man-
ufactured by the Westinghouse Electric &
Mfg. Co.
Car Building; Is Brisk.
A good idea of the activity prevailing
in the steel car business is shown by the
fact that Robert W. Hunt & Co., of New
York, have been given the inspection of
350 steel ore cars, to be built by the
Pressed Steel Car Co. for the Duluth,
Missabe & Northern, and 450 similar
pressed steel cars for the Duluth & Iron
Range Railroad. In addition, they have
a small order of 75 flat and box cars, to
be built at Hegewisch, 111., to inspect for
that railroad company. They also have
been instructed to inspect 500 steel under-
frame box cars, to be built at Berwick,
I'a., for the Philadelphia & Reading, and
ROBERTS.
"open" positions only. In the "off" posi-
tion it connects the control circuit so that
if the oil circuit-breaker opens through the
action of any of the automatic devices the
lamp will be lighted on the operating stand
to attract the operator's attention. If the
oil circuit-breaker is opened by the oper-
ator throwing the controlling switch to
the "open" position, the lamp does not
light. The mechanism of the electro-
mechanical tell-tale indicator consiste of
an electro-magnet which attracts a pivoted
armature through an angle of about 90
degrees. Attached to the armature is a
disk with a pointer which indicates to
500 steel hopper coal cars for the same
road, to be built at Butler, Pa. They
have just been given the inspection of
1.600 box and 500 stock cars, with pressed
steel underirames, to be built at Hege-
wisch. 111., for the Southern Pacific Rail-
road, and 1,000 flats, with pressed steel
underframes, to be built for the same
company, by the Pressed Steel Car Co.,
at their McKee's Rocks plant. They are
engaged upon the inspection of 300 gon-
dola cars for the Bellington & Beaver
Creek R. R., at Jeffersonville, Ind., and
no coal cars for the East St. Louis &
Suburban R. R., to be- built at Madison,
111. The firm also report their locomo-
tive inspection department to be very
busy at the various works. They have
just received instructions to inspect 27
locomotives at the Baldwin Locomotive
Works for the Wheeling & Lake Erie
Railway, and they have been given an
additional order by the Hocking V^alley
Railroad Company for the inspection of
12 switching engines, to be built at the
Brooks Works of the American Locomo-
tive Company.
go
RAILWAY AND LOCO^iIOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
The Two=Man Power Railway.
Coolie labor is very cheap in the Far
East, and as men devour less than
horses, probably this fact accounts for
human "beasts of burden" being so very
common. The illustrations which we
give herewith are views of which is prob-
ably one of the smallest and most curi-
boiler pressure is 225 lbs. and tlie en-
gine can e.xert a calculated tractive ef-
fort of about 55,500 lbs. The ratio of
adhesive weight to tractive power is 3.6.
The boiler is 78 3-4 ins. at the smoke
box end and tapers from the dome. The
pops are carried in a small auxiliary
dome and the whistle is laid down flat
radial, and swings on a center 58 l-S ins.
in front of the axle. The main valves
are of the balanced piston type and are
placed between the upper and lower bars
of the frame front.
The tender tank has a sloping fuel
space and a water bottom, and carries
7,000 gallons. The frame is made of
steel channels and the trucks are of the
ordinary diamond pattern. The appear-
ance of the whole machine betokens a
substantial design which shows that the
engines are intended for hard, heavy
work and plenty of it.
TWO-MAN CAR.
ous practical working railways in the
world. The traction is not furnished by
either petrol, steam or electricity, but
by human propulsion; so that it is liter-
ally accurate to describe this little loco-
motive as being of "two-man power."
The line connects the little Japanese
watering place called Atami with the
town of Yoshihama, in the province of
Izu. It is about twenty English miles
in length, and runs through picturesque
and characteristically Japanese scenery.
The guard in the front is furnished with
a horn and brake to warn the passersby
or stop the tiny train when going down
hill. Occasionally the two men in
charge have to push the car, but for the
most part it runs easily down a sort of
natural switchback railway, which is
more or less the handiwork of Dame
Nature herself. One style of car con-
tains first class accommodations, while
another is for second class fares only.
We reproduce the pictures and descrip-
tion from the Car, London.
on its side so as to gain height. Tlie
heating surface is ample, being 210.3 sq.
ft. in the firebox, 5,155.8 sq. ft. in the
tubes, of which there are 463, thus mak-
The Department of Agriculture has been
investigating the hardy catalpa tree and
they have found out enough about its
durability that they are advising farmers
to cultivate it. The timber is wonderfully
durable. The wood is particularly val-
uable for fence posts, telegraph poles and
railroad ties, as it has shown no signs of
decay after being in the ground thirty
years. If farmers in the treeless regions
follow the advice of the U. S. Agricul-
tural Department the places destitute of
timber will soon be covered with growing
trees. This will not only make a profit-
able crop for farmers, it will exert an ex-
cellent climatic effect that will confer
much benefit to the whole country.
"Well, sir," said the railway superin-
tendent to a forlorn-looking man who had
A Mikado Goes to the Santa Fe.
The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe
have recently received from the Bald-
win works some heavy 2-8-2 engines for
freight service which the Baldwin people
call the Mikado type. They are Vau-
clain compounds with 18 and 30x32-in.
cylinders, the low pressure being on top.
The drivers are 57 in. and have an adhe-
sive weight of 200,000 lbs. The total
weight of the engine is 260,000 lbs. The
TWO-MAN CAR.
ing a total of 5,366.1 square feet. The
grate area is 58.5 sq. ft.
All the wheels are flanged and the
connecting rod is of I-section. The two
front driving wheels are equalized with
the pony truck and the two rear drivers,
and the carrying wheels at the back are
equalized together. The rear truck is
gained admittance to his office, "what do
you want?" "I would like a situation on
your line." "There is no place for you, I
am afraid." "There is a place, I want to
be interpreter." "Interpreter?" "Yes,
sir ; to tell the passengers what the train-
men say when they call out the names of
the stations."
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
9'
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. M. McDonough has been ap-
pointed road master on the Texas Pa-
cific, with headquarters at Marshall,
Texas.
Mr. C. N. Moussernt has been ap-
pointed engineer of bridges on the Ca-
nadian Pacific, vice Mr. H. E. Vrutelet,
resigned.
Mr. J. G. Taylor, acting superintend-
ent at Brandon, Man., has been appointed
acting road foreman of engines on the
Rome, Watertown & Ogdensburg, vice
Mr. Geo. Hay, promoted.
Mr. Frederick Bradley has been appoint-
ed superintendent of Sierra Railway of
California, with office at Jamestown, Cal.,
vice Mr. W. C. Potts, resigned.
Mr. V. D. Havens lias been appointed
purchasing agent in charge of ihe material
and supply department of the Louisiana
Mr. W. J. Kuhn has been appointed
roadniaster on the St. Louis & Hannibal
Railway, with beadtiuarlers at Hannibal,
Mo., vice Mr. H. R. Buckwald, resigned.
Mr. C. L. Goodhue has been appointed
foreman of car repairs on the Atlantic
Coast line for the Jacksonville district,
with headquarters at the Sanford shops.
Mr. G. K. Joughins, mechanical super-
iiuendent of the coast lines of the A., T.
ROGERS ERECTING SHOP.— BIG C, B. & Q. ENGINE HANGING IN NILES CRANE.
division superintendent on the same road
at that point.
Mr. M. C. Byers has been appointed
assistant engineer maintenance of way on
the B. & O., succeeding Mr. J. B. Dick-
son, promoted.
Mr. A. E. Long has been appointed su-
perintendent of the Kalispell division
Great Northern Railway, with headquar-
ters at Kalispell, Mont.
Mr. W. A. Brown has been appointed
superintendent of the Canadian North-
ern, with headquarters at Winnipeg, vice
J. F. Arudel, resigned.
Mr. C. P. Estes has been appointed
& .A.rkansas Railway, with office at Tex-
arkana, Ark., vice Mr. J. A. Buchanan, re-
signed.
Mr. E. O. Smith has been appointed
master mechanic on the St. Louis & Han-
nibal Railway at Hannibal, Mo., vice Mr.
M. T. Phillips, resigned.
Mr. Robert Patterson has been ap-
pointed master mechanic at Ridgway,
Colorado, on the Rio Grande Southern,
vice Mr. John Schlacks, resigned.
Mr. G. \V. Berry has been appointed
trainmaster and Mr. W. E. W'heelock as-
sistant trainmaster on the Cincinnati, New
Orleans & Texas Pacific Railway.
& S. F., has had his headquarters moved
from San Bernardino to Los Angeles,
Cal.
Mr. James McNaughton has been ap-
pointed general superintendent of the
Schenectady plant of the American Loco-
motive Company vice Mr. F. J. Deems,
resigned.
Mr. H. Miller has been appointed su-
perintendent of bridges and buildings on
the Cincinnati, Hamilton & Dayton, with
headquarters at Lima, Ohio, vice Mr.
C. M. Overly.
Mr. H. J. Helps has been appointed
master mechanic in charge of Plattstnouth
<)i
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
shops of the BurUngton & Missouri River
Railroad in Nebraska, vice Mr. D. Hawks-
worth, resigned.
Mr. R. L. Doolittle, foreman of the
Chattanooga shops Central of Georgia
Railway, has been appointed assistant
master mechanic, with headquarters at
Chattanooga, Tenn.
Mr. W. H. Starr has been appointed
•superintendent of the Chattanooga division
-of the Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas
Pacific Railway, vice Mr. G. W. Berry,
assigned to other duties.
Mr. E. F. Grable has been appointed
Supervisor of bridges and buildings on
the Yazoo & Mississippi Valley with
headquarters at Memphis, Tenn., vice
Mr. Hubbard, resigned. .
Mr. Geo. H. Emerso-i, general master
mechanic of the Western District of the
Great Northern, has been appointed su-
perintendent of motive power, with head-
quarters at St. Paul, Minn.
Mr. John Brown has been promoted
from the position of master mechanic of
the Autofagasta & Bolivia Railway,
Chili, to that of locomotive and car super-
: intendent of the same road.
i Mr. C. J. Bolinger has been appointed
general foreman on the Atlantic Coast
line of the Jacksonville district, second di-
vision, with office at Sanford shops, vice
Mr. Geo. McDonald, resigned.
Mr. Grant Hall, master mechanic of the
Pacific division of the Canadian Pacific
Railway at Revelstoke, B. C, has been ap-
pointed assistant superintendent of rolling
stock of the lines east of Fort William.
Mr. Thomas J. Clark, heretofore trav-
eling engineer on the Great Northern,
has been appointed master mechanic on
the same road, with headquarters at
Everett, Wash., vice Mr. Kelly, pro-
moted.
Mr. A. C. Hinckley, master mechanic
on the St. Joseph & Grand Island, has
been appointed assistant master mechanic
on the Denver & Rio Grande, vice Mr. E.
Punchon. resigned, headquarters at
Pueblo, Col.
Mr. J. A. Edison, formerly connected
with the Kansas City Southern, has been
appointed manager of the Denver & Rio
Grande system, vice Mr. J. M. Herbert,
who has gone to the Colorado Southern in
a similar position.
Mr. F. McArdle, formerly traveling en-
gineer on the Burlington, Cedar Rapids
& Northern, has been appointed train-
master on the Cedar Rapids division of
■ the Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific, with
headquarters at Cedar Rapids.
Mr. H. J. Simmons, formerly chief
engineer of the EI Paso & Southwest-
ern, has been appointed superintendent
and traffic manager of the same road.
with headquarters at El Paso, Texas,
vice Mr. W. J. Choate. resigned.
Mr. J. T. Wallace, heretofore assistant
engineer of motive power on the Penn-
sylvania Railroad, has been appointed
master mechanic on the Northern Cen-
tral, with headquarters at Baltimore,
Md., vice Mr. J. Milliken, promoted.
Mr. John McGarvey, formerly assist-
ant master mechanic on the West Shore
Railroad at Buffalo, has been appointed
assistant superintendent of the Brooks
works of the American Locomotive
Company, which are situated at- Dunkirk,
N. Y.
Mr. Wm. Kelly, formerly master me-
chanic on the Great Northern at Wash-
ington, has been appointed general mas-
ter mechanic of the Western Division of
the same roa 1, with headquarters at Spo-
kane, Wash., vice Mr. Emerson, pro-
moted.
Mr. Robert P. Schilling, who has been
master mechanic of the Lackawanna shops
at Utica, N. Y., has been appointed mas-
ter car builder of the Syracuse, Oswego
and Utica divisions of the road. Mr. L.
T. Canfield, M.C.B. for the whole road,
has just resigned.
Mr. A. F. Hockenbeamer has been ap-
pointed assistant to the general superin-
tendent of motive power of the Baltimore
& Ohio, having supervision, under the di-
rection of the general superintendent of
motive power, of accounts of the motive
power department.
Mr. William Reed, at one time assistant
superintendent of the Rogers Locomotive
Works, who entered the service of the
American Locomotive Company in a simi-
lar capacity, has recently been promoted
to the position of superintendent of the
Brooks plant at Dunkirk, N. Y.
Mr. D. C. Dickert, road foreman of en-
gines for the second, third and Chatta-
nooga divisions of the Central of Georgia,
has been appointed trainmaster on the
same road for the Chattanooga division,
with headquarters Cedartown, Ga., vice
Mr. J. C. O'Dell, transferred to Macon,
Ga.
Mr. W. H. Dunlop has been appointed
general foreman of the Atlanta, Ga.,
shops of the Southern Railway, vice Mr.
O. H. Attridge. resigned. Mr. Dunlop
was general engine house foreman for a
number of years, and his many friends
wish him every success in his new field
of service.
The following appointments were re-
cently made on the Gulf, Colorado &
Santa Fe ; Mr. F. Merritt to be resident
engineer of the northern division, with
headquarters at Cleburne, Tex. ; Mr. J. C.
Christy, resident engineer of the southern
division, with headquarters at Temple,
Tex., and Mr. M. F. Temple, resident en-
gineer of the Beaumont division, with
headquarters at Beaumont, Tex.
William Perkins Tyler, president of the
Tyler Tube & Pipe Company, died last
month. Mr. Tyler founded the business
of this company in i8go, and has de-
voted the last twelve years of his life to
its development, winning not only the
respect and regard of his business asso-
ciates, but the friendship of the many
employees of the company. Mr. Tyler's
interest in the business will remain un-
disturbed, and his associates, who have
had the benefit of an intimate knowledge
of his methods and purposes, will con-
tinue the business on the same lines as
heretofore.
We believe in readers — perhaps that
seems commonplace when stated in the
columns of a technical journal — but let
us explain. We believe people should
read our paper, but we believe they
should also read books for pleasure and
to gain information. It is often quite
possible to combine these. We give else-
where a list of technical books which we
recommend, but we may add that it
gives us pleasure to fill an order for any
book on the market. If you want a
book of any kind write to us direct and
we will get it and send it to you. Do
not imagine that we refer only to tech-
nical books or those of an educational
character. If you want any book on the
market and ask us for it you will re-
ceive the book. We supply books as
cheaply as any one else. If you only
want information concerning books write
to us and we will be happy to give it to
vou. gratis.
The Bullock Electric Manufacturing
Company, of Cincinnati, have a very
pleasing way of keeping their company
name before their friends and the public
generally. They have issued a very neat
illuminated card with the calendar for
January, 1903, printed upon it and a
small colored portrait of James Prescott
Joule. This famous physicist was the
one who first established the mechanical
equivalent of heat. He found it to be
772 foot pounds, though more recent ex-
periments have raised the figure to 778.
He also established the temperature of
water when at its maximum density, 39.2
degrees F.
President Cassatt, of the Pennsylvania,
has offered to take any locomotives that
locomotive works of the country can build
if any road having orders for 1903 will
turn its contract over to the Pennsylvania,
and President Loree, of the Baltimore &
Ohio, is quoted as saying that no man
can get a locomotive until January, 1904,
unless the orders are now in, and that
money will not buy them previous to that
date.
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
93
Ten-Wheel F'assenger for the
Southern Railway.
The Soutlu-rii Railway Company have
recently bought some simple passenger
engines from the Baldwin works in PhiL
adelphia. The cylinders are 21x28 in. and
the driving wheels measure 72 in. in diam-
eter. The total weight of the engine is
170,920 pounds, of which 128,670 rest upon
the drivers. Willi steam pressure 200
pounds, the calculated tractive effort is
about 29,000 pounds and the ratio of ad-
hesive weight to tractive power is 4.4.
The engine is a substantial machine, and
the general effect of the whole design is
pleasing. The connecting and side rods
are of the fluted type and the cross head
is secured to the piston-rod by collar and
nut. The valves are the usual D-slide
'balanced. The eccentrics are, of course,
on the main driver and the link is placed
some distance in front of the rocker, with
transmission bar carried back to lower
rocker pin, giving indirect motion. In
■this engine the driving wedges are in
New Safety Device for Railways.
'] he United States Consul-Oencral at
Berlin, Mr. F. II. Mason, has recently
given some interesting data regarding a
new safety device for use on railways for
preventing collisions. It was tested with
entire success in presence of experts
on one of the State lines near Frankfort.
The description and operation of this ap-
pliance may be summarized somewhat as
follows. Midway between the rails is
laid an electric conductor in the form of
what is usually called a "third rail." Un-
der the engine is hung an electrical ap-
paratus, enclosed in a square case occupy-
ing about a cubic foot of space, and this
inslrumcnt is connected to the third rail
by a contact shoe. Telephone wires and
the wires of a red incandescent lamp run
from the case under the engine to the cab.
When the third rail becomes charged, in
the sending of a warning signal to the
moving train, the impulse which rings the
alarm bell in the cab also lights the red
lamp. A further improvement, we are
proceeded cautiously, sounding its whistle
at short intervals, the telephone bell in the
drivers' cab ringing continuously until the
curve was rounded, when the ringing
ceased, notifying the engineer that the
semaphore had changed to 'track clear.'
Thereupon 290 resumed full speed.
"In the tests to prevent collision, engine
1420 came up rapidly from behind and
on the same track as 290, which had
slowed down and was proceeding cau-
tiously in consequence of reported danger
in front. The moment that 1420 came
within 1,000 meters (1,093 yards) of 290,
the signal on both engines began to ring
and their red lights to glow. Thereupon
1420 halted, the driver inquired of 290
in front the cause of the alarm, and a
complete understanding between the two
trains was immediately established."
In practice, the warning signal is seen
and heard on every engine equipped with
the apparatus which is on the same track
and within the prescribed limits. If a
train runs past a semaphore falsely set at
SOL I'HliK.S ThN-W Hhhi. K.\i'KE:^'S HNolNE.
front of the axles, and the pedestal binder
•consists of a bolt and filler.
The heating surface in the firebox is
136.33 sq. ft., while the tubes add
■2,533.07 sq. ft., making a total of 2,669.4.
The grate area is 44 sq ft. The engine
truck wheels are 36 in. in diameter and
are spoked. The cab is roomy, well light-
■ed where the engineer sits, but it has a
blind panel in the forward part, as may
be seen in our illustration.
A few of the principal dimensions are
as follows :
■Gauge, 4 ft. 9 in. Cylinder, 21x28 iu.
BOILER.
Type, wagon top. Dia,, 64 in.
Tliiclcuess of sheets, J5. 32* Vein. Fuel, bit. coal.
Firebox, length, 96 in.; width, 66 in.: front, 68^
in.; back, 45% in.
Thickness of sheets, sides, }i in.; back, }i in.;
crown, H in.; tube. 5^ in.
Tubes, number, 328;dia.. 2 in.; length, 14 ft. 9 in.
Driv. jour., 9x12 in.; engine truck jour , 5^x10 in.
Wheel base, rigid, 15 ft.
Weight on driving wheels 128,670 lbs.
On truck, front 42,250 lbs.
Total 170,920 lbs.
Tank, capacity, 5.000 gals.
•j»ender, wheels, dia,, 38 in.; journals, 5x9 in.
told, sets the electric brakes on engine and
train at the same time that the bell rings
and the lamp glows. The apparatus is so
arranged that the man on the engine can
at any moment, by touching a lever, satisfy
himself that it is in efficient working or-
der.
The tests were made with two locomo-
tives equipped with the device. The ex-
periments are described as follows :
"Engine 290, drawing a special train and
approaching Sachsenhausen at full speed,
received the danger signal and came to a
full stop ; the driver of 290 then asked by
telephone the cause of the signal and re-
ceived from the keeper of a grade crossing,
half a mile in front, word that a wagon
had broken down in crossing the track
and obstructed the line. After ten minutes'
wait, the engineer of 290 received word by
telephone that the obstruction had been
cleared away and thereupon resumed his
trip. A mile further on, the signal on 290
again sounded, and the driver was in-
formed, by telephone as before, that the
semaphore round a curve and more than
half a mile distant was set at "halt."
Thereupon engine 290 slowed down and
safety, and thus enters a block where an
engine has halted or is moving along,
warning will be given in ample time to
prevent collision. Conditions of darkness,
storm, fog or mistaken instructions do
not invalidate the certainty of the signal.
In fact, this invention of Messrs. Hubert
Pfirmann and Max Wendorf puts the en-
gineer of every train into instantaneous
touch with other trains, switchmen and
station and crossing keepers who are with-
in the prescribed limit arranged for the
apparatus. An automatic visual and audi-
ble signal is thus made to become active
the moment the locomotive which carries
it, while running either forward or
backward, is even menaced with the dan-
ger of collision. The device as it stands,
as Mr. Mason points out, may not be as
perfect as daily operating conditions may
be found to demand, but in the judgment
of those whose opinions are entitled to re-
spect, the way to safety has been clearly
pointed out.
Byegones shall be byegones, and a new
page turned for you to write your lives
in. — Bleak House.
94
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
An Efficient Boiler Shop Tool, for
Fitting Crown Stays.
A very efficient home-made tool is to
be found in the boiler shop of the R(5gers
Locomotive Works at Paterson, N. J. It
is a tapping and reaming machine, de-
signed by Mr. Ruben Wells, general man-
ager of the works. The machine con-
sists of two structural steel channels
which stand out horizontally from one of
the posts of the shop, perhaps 15 ft. from
the floor. On the upper edge of these
channels are placed four movable spin-
dles, with belt-driven pulleys on each end.
These pulleys are loose on their shafts,
and the ones, over, say the right channel,
revolve in one direction, while those over
the other channel rotate in the opposite
direction. A friction clutch capable of
being moved to the right or the left im-
parts to its sleeve, when engaged with
either pulley, the motion of the pulley it
bears against. Connecting with each hor-
izontal shaft is a vertical spindle, which
on its lower end has two universal joints
and a socket which holds tap or reamer
facing tool or stay-bolt head. A pair of
bevel gears communicate the motion of
the clutch-sleeve to the vertical spindle in
each case, so that stays may be screwed in
or backed out as desired. The vertical
spindles are arranged with counter-
weights bearing against collars so that the
weight of the spindle with joints and tool
are just very slightly more than balanced,
and, therefore, rise up out of the way
when not in use. For r>;aming and facing
for button heads a positive feed is used.
A hanging handle enables the workman
to draw down the spindle and enter tap
or reamer or stay as he may wish. The
spindles have a vertical movement of
about 42 ins.
The method of operation is for the
large shop crane to place a boiler bottom
upward on a low truck beneath this ma-
chine, the holes in crown sheet can then
all be reamed or tapped or stays screwed
in without any further movement, the
four spindles of this tool doing the work
of more than twice that number of men.
Each workman with helper has two spin-
dles to manage and has a hanging handle
with which to lower it while the counter-
weight carries it up when the pressure of
his hand is withdrawn. When free of the
feed as when tapping, the spindles follow
the travel of the tap without any dragging
forces to interfere. A lever which oper-
ates the friction clutch secures a right or
left-hand rotation to the spindle, and the
middle position of the lever stops its mo-
tion at once. The series of pulleys which
cause the reverse or "backing out" rota-
tion, are run at a more rapid rate than
the others, so that tools or work can be
run back and out very quickly. In screw-
ing in button-head crown stays, through
crown and roof sheet, this machine is
used to run down the stay until the head
all but touches the crown sheet, the final
drawing up (about one round) is done
by hand so that no injury to the thread on
bolt or crown-sheet can take place by
screwing the head too tight against the
sheet.
In the boiler shop this tool is regarded
with high favor, as an easy, rapid, ac-
curate, effective and cheap way of doing
this otherwise slow work on firebox
crown-sheet staying.
gines here with the exception of the cyl-
inder on the left-hand side, which works
from the blower when the blower is ap-
plied, and beg to say that the sparking
device for cleaning the smoke box works
nicely, and the engine can be sparked
while rolling along, shut off.
Spark Arrester for Wood and Coal
Burning Locomotives.
In connection with this spark arrester,
designed by Mr. E. J. Smith, Master Me-
chanic of the Plant System at High
Springs, Fla., writes :
I herewith hand you a sketch of a spark
arrester and sparkejector, andbeg to say
that I have got this spark arrester in
about fifteen engines on the 5th district
of the A. C. L. Ry. running out of High
Springs and Palatka. Fla. The device is a
SMITH'S SP.\RK ARRESTER.
perfect success on both wood and coal-
burning engines, and much more econom-
ical with fuel than the present standard
coal-burning spark arrester or the bal-
loon stack, which is in universal use
throughout the country.
This spark arrester is on some of our
engines in the heaviest service that we
have; for instance, we have three engines
with this arrangement in them running
from Palatka to St. Petersburg on a 220-
mile run, burning wood. Last winter we
had these engines burning coal with this
arrangement in the front end and have
made an average of 40 miles to a ton of
coal, during the busiest months in the
winter season, on the heaviest local pas-
senger trains handling from seven to nine
coaches and express cars. We also have
a few of our passenger engines fitted up
on trains 39 and 40 from High Springs to
Lakeland. These are 16-inch engines, han-
dling from five to ten cars and burning
three cords of wood to 140 miles.
I thought that you were on the lookout
for anything new to publish, and beg to
say that this device has been in use now
about 18 months, giving entire satisfaction
to the management. I will state further
that I am putting all the parts on these en-
Fast Railroading.
They had been speaking of fast runs
on railroads. "That reminds me of a
run we made some time ago on a train
which came in from a point on the
coast," said the man who wanted to add
zest to the conversation, "and it was
about the fleetest trip I ever had on a
railroad.
"The train was behind time about an
hour, and I think the engineer made an
effort to catch up between the city and
a point not so very far out on the coast.
At any rate, it looked very much like it
to me. We shot through the air like an
arrow. Sometimes it would seem to me
that we had left the track altogether.
That clicking peculiar to railroad trains
could not be heard. About all we could
hear at times would be the whizzing of
the wind as it split by the windows.
Across bayous and through marshes we
rushed like mad. When we reached the
Rigolets the most remarkable thing I
ever saw took place. The train was
traveling so fast it sucked the water up
behind it as it rushed across the trestle,
and I could hear the fishes groan as we
flew over this neck of the gulf. Most
remarkable thing I ever saw in the way
of fast runs." And he lapsed into si-
lence.
'U'm glad you reminded me of that
run," said another member of the group.
"I had forgotten the incident. I can
vouch for all you say, for I was on the
back end of the last coach, and the
water which was sucked in behind the
train by the vacuum almost washed me
overboard, but I held on all right, and
when we had made the crossing and the
waters had receded I picked up on the
platform of the rear coach the finest
bunch of fish I ever saw. They were no
doubt the fish you heard groaning." —
A'ew Orleans Times-Democrat.
"Firstlings of the Flock."
The first locomotive to run on rails was
built in Wales by Richard Trevithick in
1803. First locomotive built by Stephen-
son was the "Blucher," 1816. First cars
with outside bearings and coned wheels
were built by Ross Winans for the Balti-
more & Ohio R. R., 1829. First locomotive
to run on rails in America was Peter
Cooper's "Tom Thumb," which was tried
on the Baltimore & Ohio R. R., 1830.
First locomotive with six coupled wheels
was the "Middlesborough," by Timothy
Hackworth — English, 1830. ' First Amer-
Fehninry, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
95
icaii tinic-table was published liy the Bal-
timore & Ohio R. R. in the Baltimore
American in 1830. First set of rules for
employees, was issued by the same road
in 1830. First locomotive wilh a bogie
truck was the "Experiment," designed by
Jervis, and built by llic West Point Foun-
dry, 183 1. First sleel springs under a loco-
motive were used on the "York" in 1831.
First issue of Railway and Locomotive
Engineering (then called The Locomo-
tive Engineer), was in January, 1888.
Consolidation for the Baltimore &
Ohio Railroad.
This 2-8-0 type for the B. & O., built
at the Schenectady shops of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company, is a simple
engine with 21 x 30-in. cylinders, 57-in.
driving wheels and a boiler measuring
72 in. at the outside ring. The working
pressure is 190 pounds, and with 162.000
pounds on the drivers, the engine can
before and after, and a scmi-eliptic
spring acting as equalizer between them.
The tender frame is made of steel
channels, and the trucks are of the Fox
pressed steel type.
Some of the more important dimen-
sions are appended lor reference:
GKNKRAL DIMENSIONS.
I'liel, l)itumiiious coal.
Wfiglit in workiiiK order, i86,uoo lbs.
Weiglit on drivers. 162,000 lbs.
VAI.VKS.
Cireatest travel. 5'/^ in.; outside lap, % in.; inside
lap, line and line; lead in full gear, ^ in.
WHF.KI.S, KTC.
I)ia. and length of driving journa's, 9!^ & 9 x 12 in.
Dia. and length of crank pin journals, main, 6J^
X 6 in.; main .side, y% x ^% in.
Dia. and length of side rod crank pin journals,
inter., 5^ x 4% in.; K. & B., 5 i jJi in.
BOII.ER.
Style, straight, wide fire box.
Thickness of plates in barrel and outside of fire
box, •/,. }3, n. U, I in.
I'irebox. length, 91-H in.; width, 75^^ in.; depth. 73
in F, 63 in. B.
can jail and everything is lovely with the
v. nited States representative until another
outrage happens.
A meeting of representative railroad
men, through their brotherhoods, was re-
cently held in Kjinsas Cily, Mo., to pro-
test against recent outrages upon train-
men in Mexico. The present agitation
was started by Harry H. Adams, formerly
a locomotive engineer in Mexico. While
he was employed on the Vensges, Central
& Matuhsullu Railway, on May 21, 1901,
Adams says his engine and seven car*
were wrecked, he being absolutely with-
out fault in causing the wreck. His left
leg was crushed and later had to be am-
putated. Adams says that even before he
received medical attention he was taken
before a Magistrate, was fined and then
thrown into prison, where he remained a
month.
Other Americans are in Mexican pris-
ons, he says, whoi<' trains were in wrecks
through no fault of the prisoners, and
I.ATl-'ST H. tc O. CONSOLIDATION ENGINE.
exert a tractive effort of 37.000 pounds,
making the ratio of tractive force to ad-
hesive weight 4.3. The total weight of
the engine in working order is 186.000
pounds. All the wheels are flanged, but
lateral play has been allowed for by
varying the distance between tires. The
forward and rear pairs of drivers are
53 1-8 in. between tires, while the sec-
ond and main drivers measure 53 1-4 be-
tween tires.
This design shows advanced thought
in locomotive construction, as may be
seen by the liberal grate area — which is
50.32 sq. ft., and the ample heating sur-
face, which amounts to a total of 3.495-82
sq. ft. Cast steel has been used for the
deck, grate-bar bearers, frame braces and
other details, which have heretofore
usually been cast and wrought iron.
The valves are of the piston type
driven by direct-acting gear, and the
transmission rod rises over the second
driving axle with very little curve. The
first and second drivers are equalized
with springs over the boxes, while the
main driver and the trailer are separate-
ly equalized together, with spir.il .springs
Firebox plates, thickness, sides. ,^^3 in. ; back, H
in.; crown, ^gin, ; tube sheet. 14 in.
Tubes, number of, 396; dia., 2 in.; length over
tube sheets, 16 ft.
Fire brick, supported on water tubes.
Heating sur., tubes, 329S.oSsq. ft ; water tubes, 22.34
sq. ft.; fire box, 155.40 sq. ft.;total, 3475.82 sq. ft.
TENDER.
Weight, empty. 44.300 lbs ; wheel base, t8 ft. 9 in.
Tender frame. 10 in steel channels.
Water capacity, 5.900. U. S. gals.; coal, 10 tons.
Total wheel base of engine and tender, 57 ft. 4 in.
Outrages Committed on Trainmen in
nexico.
There is no doubt that railway train-
men are oulrageously treated in Mexico
when any charge can be schemed
against them by representatives of
law and justice. When any particularly
flagrant piece of tyranny is inflicted
upon an American the labor organ-
izations appeal to the American Min-
ister. He pretends to investigate, but
that is done in a half-hearted way, as
the Minister's sympathies are all on the
Mexican side, and the report is made that
no cause for complaint exists. The in-
iquity is covered up and some miserable
American who has committed no offence
ii permitted to languish in a filthy Mexi-
some of them have been in prison seven
or eight years. Adams, while in prison,
met some of these men, who begged him
to appeal to the railroad men in America
to interest themselves in their cases.
After two years' experimentation with
nickeled rails the Pennsylvania Railroad
has decided to place them on the heavy
curves through the Allegheny Mountains.
.An order for 5.000 tons has been given
at a cost of $370,000. The nickeled steel
rails cost nearly three times as much as
rails of standard steel. The tests made
by the Pennsylvani.i Railro.id have shown
the durability of the nickeled rails to be
more than three times that of standard
steel.
The Louisiana Railroad Commission
has a rule that railroads must furnish cars
within ten days from the time they are
ordered. It is a very easy matter for rail-
road commissioners to say that cars must
be supplied, but "must" does not bring
into existence cars that have yet to be
built. It is a pity that Railroad Com-
missioners seldom know anj'thing about
railroad business.
96
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
The Star Improved Indicator.
One of the improvements introduced
in the construction of the steam engine
indicator, made by the Starr Brass Man-
ufacturing Company consists in the at-
tachment of the cap 2 at the top of the
cylinder to the interior shell within
which the piston moves. This "interior"
arrangement secures correct alignment
for the motion of piston and rod. The
interior shell being removable, for re-
pairs, etc., is so placed when in service.
as to provide a jacket space for live
Steam, thus maintaining uniform tem-
perature and securing perfectly equal ex-
pansion. A noticeable feature is the
means for unscrewing and removing
from the cylinder the cap with parts at-
tached. The cap has a milled edge made
of hard rubber which is a non-conductor
of heat, and this allows the operator to
mechanism from the cylinder. A new
form of detent is also used. This is in
the form of a friction clutch. It con-
sists simply of a ball which is thrown
into hard contact with a groove of un-
equal radius, cut in the base of the drum.
Electric operating mechanism can be
used if desired. The indicator is a good
specimen of accurate workmanship, the
thickness of the arm has been increased,
to reduce vibration, and the instrument
is at once strong and as light as it can
be made.
Improvements of the kind outlined
above help to increase the use of indi-
cators by removing some of the trou-
bles and discomforts incident to work
with the high pressures of to-day. The
best and most convenient indicator is
none too good for the difficult and ex-
acting task of taking locomotive dia-
STAR IMPROVED INDICATOR.
handle it with comfort, .\nother ar-
rangement for comfort which will be
appreciated is that the indicator is vent-
ed on the side less likely to be encoun-
tered by the hand of the user when turn-
ing on the indicator cock. A suitable
attachment with hose can be clamped to
the barrel, and this arrangement will
effectually carry the scalding drops a
sufficient distance below the body of the
instrument. "Once burned, twice shy,"
seems to have been the motto of the
designer of the improvements to lessen
the danger from heated cap or hot water
and steam, and never had motto better
application.
The piston rod of the Star Improved
Indicator is provided with an adjustable
swivel nut, so planned that the atmos-
pheric line can be drawn at any desired
distance from the bottom of the card,
without removing the piston and its
grams. A scientific instrument of pre-
cision which entails burned fingers or a
scalded wrist, is often not as popular
with frail humanity as the good work
it can be made to do, fully entitles it to
be. Indicator improvements along these
lines are welcome.
Stay=Bolts at the Rogers Works.
Stay-bolt threading is done very rapidly
and cheaply at the Rogers Locomotive
Works in Paterson, N. J. Solid dies
are used entirely and none of the bolts
are cut in a regular lathe. Short side-
sheet stay-bolts are threaded their entire
length in a machine of ordinary form,
having eight upright spindles, which
cut good, clean screw-threads. The
threading of the long, crown-sheet stay-
bolts, with or without button-heads, is
another matter. These bolts are made.
speaking generally, in two sizes, each has-
a larger diameter where it is screwed
into the crown-sheet than it has in the
roof-sheet. A bolt I in. in diameter in
the roof-sheet will be I 5-32 in. in the
crown-sheet and a bolt i 1-8 in. in the
roof is I g-32 in. in the crown. This ar-
rangement permits the bolt being dropped
in so that the threads engage in the roof-
sheet only a few turns earlier than in the
crown, and this saves time.
In the matter of threading, the first op-
eration is to true up the two ends of the
stay-bolt, which are of unequal diameter,
and face the under side of the button-
head, where there is one, and leave the
central portion of the stay untouched.
The work of cutting the screw threads is
done on an old-fashioned machine which
has defied the scrap heap for many years.
Ihe man in charge, not being a very high-
priced operative, threads first one end and
then the other, with the most perfect in-
difference as to whether the thread at one
end coincides with the thread at the other.
In fact, no effort is made to get them to
come right, and they are sent over to the
boiler shop in this condition.
It is in the boiler shop, however, that
this apparently inaccurate work ceases,
and by a simple and rapid process all error
concerning the thread is eliminated. As
the pitch usually employed is 12 threads
to the inch, the maximum error could only
be half a thread or 1-24 of an inch. The
method of bringing the upper and lower
screws into exact unison, so that the reg-
ular advance of the thread shall be the
same as if the entire length of the stay-bolt
had been threaded in a lathe, is done by
simply lengthening the bolt the required
amount. On a handy shelf there lies a
"mas^Jer" bolt. It has been carefully
threaded in a lathe for its entire length
and hardened to reduce wear. Each stay-
bolt is placed beside it, and the threads
made to engage at the upper end. If they
also engage at the lower end the stay-
bolt is "passed." If the lower end shows
want of coincidence it is put under a
small spring hammer, with semicircular
dies, which is operated by a treadle and
friction clutch. A blow or two from this
hammer, struck in the unthreaded center
of the stay-bolt lengthens it so that the
threads at both ends exactly match the
continuous thread of the master bolt and
the now corrected stay-bolt is "passed"
for use in the boiler. The whole method
is inexpensive, accurate and easy, and
not a single complaint has been received
concerning such "rectified" stay-bolts.
American School of Correspondence.
We have received the catalogue of the
American School of Correspondence
which is at the Armour Institute of
Technology in Chicago. We may be
permitted to quote an apt saying in one
of the opening paragraphs in the cata-
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND I,OCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
97
logue: "Intelligent pe<jplc to-day believe
in the common-sense plan of spending a
portion of their spare lime in self-im-
provement, for they know that by so
doing they can greatly increase the value
and pleasure of life. If a man does not
study and advance, but remains station-
ary and in a rut, excluded from the new
and fresh interests of the world, he
gradually grows to be a mere machine
which is soon thrown out for a new and
up-to-date type." The correspondence
courses which are divided under the
heads of electrical engineering, mechan-
ical engineering, steam engineering,
drawing, mathematics, civil engineering,
architecture, sanitary engineering and
textile manufacture, are all designed to
be thoroughly practical, and to extend
at small cost a valuable technical edu-
cation to the great wage-earning class
everywhere. There are no entrance ex-
amination required, nor is there any age
limit. In each of these departments
there are two or three regular courses
with about twice as many special courses.
The corresponilencc method as here
carried on aims to be a technical school
for wage earners who are limited in
means.
The Armour Institute of Technology
vvas founded by the late Philip D. Ar-
mour, of Chicago. Recent changes and
extensions of equipment, faculty and
scope of work has enabled the institute
and correspondence school to greatly
widen its sphere of usefulness. The old
adage is perhaps especially true of an
establishment of this kind, which says:
"Speaking makes a ready man, reading
makes a full man, and writing makes an
exact man." The two last very desir-
able qualities, at least, may be had
through the correspondence method of
getting knowledge. The catalogue con-
tains a list of graduates alphabetically
arranged according to states, and among
the foreign countries are the names of
graduates from Canada, Mexico, Hol-
land and New Zealand.
The Original Inventor of the Pilot.
There is living at Alto Pass., 111., the
man who claims to have invented the pres-
ent form of locomotive pilot, or "cow
catcher," as the country people call it.
This man's name is Eastman, and he
helped to build the first railroad in Ohio,
which was known as the Mad River and
Erie Railroad, now a part of the Big Four
system.
The first locomotives on that road were
fitted with "cow catchers," consisting of
two long curved iron rods that picked up
a cow or other large object and carried
it along. The first improvement on the
"cow catcher" was the "cow bumper,"
which resembled the pilot now in use, but
it proved unsatisfactory, and one day
while Mr. Eastman was at work in the
shops at Sandusky an engineer entered
and told the master mechanic that unless
an improvement over the "cow bumper"
could be had he would resign.
"Something is needed that will throw
an object to one side," said the engineer.
The master mechanic turned to Eastman
and asked him if he could make something
that would answer the purpose. Eastman
replied in the affirmative, went to work
and the locomotive pilot practically as it
is now was given to the world.
Mr. Eastman received no remuneration
other than his regular wages for his in-
vention of the pilot. He wears a small
silver model of an engine pilot as a watch
charm. Mr. Eastman settled in Union
County fort.vsix years ago on a farm near
Anna, where he still resides. He was
born in New York Slate and comes from
extensive improvements for some time.
The new erecting shop was occupied but
a short time ago. This is a thoroughly
modern building 264 ft. long by about
100 ft. wide, with a clear height of 50 ft.
This shop is served by two Niles cranes.
One of 100 tons capacity and one of 25
tons, with heights respectively, under
hook, of 38 and 25 ft. There are sixteen
pits which run at right angles to the
length of the shop, and there is one ad-
ditional track for scales, etc. The pits
are supplied with exhaust steam heat,
live steam, compressed air, gas and
water. The space back of the pits hav-
ing an average width of 28 ft. is va-
riously apportioned. The far end of the
shop is devoted to pipe cutting and pipe
bending. In the far corner is placed
some blacksmiths' forges. The rest of
Kaitmag f Loeamolin LnginMrVkg
C & E. I. STAND.^RD FRONT END.
one of the oldest eastern families. He has
seven children, thirty grandchildren and
six great-grandchildren.
C. & E. 1. Standard Front End.
The accompanying illustration is fur-
nished through the courtesy of Mr. T.
A. Lawes, Supt. M. P.. of the C. & E. I.
A glance at it will show its good quali-
ties, and the point all railways are aim-
ing at, that of having free steamers.
The lift pipe is so arranged that it can
be raised or lowered to suit conditions.
There is no accumulation of cinders on
top of the plate, to enter the nozzle when
engine is drifting and the front end is
always free from them.
The engine throws no fire, and the
company in the past year has not been
called upon to pay a single case of dam-
age by fire from this source.
Hand plates and spark hoppers are en-
tirely dispensed with, showing a saving
in this direction also.
the space is occupied by small tools, with
areas partitioned off for tool room and
supplies and for bolt storage. The line
of shafting attached to the columns in
the erecting shop and all tools are
driven by water power. The steel col-
umns are of the section shown, and
were so made for the sake of lightness,
while securing the requisite strength.
L L
' — 30 lucbes -
->
Improvements in the Rogers Loco-
motive Worlts.
The Rogers Locomotive Works, at
Paterson, N. J., has been undergoing
The entire surface of each can be
readily coated with paint. The shape is
also very convenient for making attach-
ments to. The shop is well lighted, both
by daylight and artificial means, it is
thoroughly drained and is a bright com-
fortable healthy shop to work in.
The opening of this new shop re-
lieves some of the pressure on space
98
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
which had existed. The old erecting
shop is now used for boring planing
and fitting up cylinders, and the space
heretofore reserved for this kind of
work is now otherwise employed. The
modernizing of the works has consid-
erably increased its capacity. The boil-
er shop was remodelled some time ago,
and the various improvements are stead-
ily being made witliout interference of
the output of the plant. The Rogers
works report a full order book for some
time to come.
A Revolving "Book=Case" for Tubes.
A rack for holding locomotive flues,
constructed on the revolving book-case
principle may be seen in the shops of
the C. & E. I. Railroad at Danville, III.
It consists of a circular table made out
of 1-4-inch plate, 8 feet m diametei,
which is pivoted in the center with a
male and female casting. The pivot
point, however, does not carry any
weight; the load rests on four coned
wheels, which run on a circular track
made of flat iron. From the circular
table rise four plates which in plan are
Northern Co.'s rietallic Packing.
The metallic packing made by the
Northern Manufacturing Company, of
St. Paul, Minn., is said to have given ex-
cellent results on some of the leading
northwestern railroads. The packing is
made by modern methods and the
mechanism used, works very exactly,
thereby insuring a I'erfect ring. 1 ho
mixture of metals in the ring is some-
thing comparatively new, and several
years' use on a leading road in the north-
west has demonstrated it to be most sat-
isfactory for the purpose required. In
this packing the telescoping of number
one ring is impossible until worn out,
and this enhances the wearing capacity of
the packing.
The rings in this style of packing are
jointed together with a sharp V-shaped
projection, the straiglit faces not coming
together until pressure is brought to bear
on them by the follower ring and spring;
this makes a perfectly steam-tight joint,
and any one with a mechanical turn of
mind will appreciate the action of the
V's in the cone when under pressure.
These rings, we are told, have not
been turned in a lathe, though the per-
fect fit of the joints suggests that mode
of finishing. We understand that the
Northern Mfg. Co. will be pleased to
send particulars to any railway official
who is interested enough to apply to
them for it.
ISES OF
GRAPHITE
A number of railroad companies are al-
ready placing orders for locomotives to
be delivered in 1904. and in a number of
instances it is stated the roads, in order
to secure power, are paying as high a
premium as $1,000 per locomotive. The
premium is not paid to the locomotive
builders, but to other railroads which
have secured space with the builders.
Roads finding that they will not require
for some time all the locomotives ordered,
or for which space has been reserved, are
disposing of a portion of their orders to
other roads at a premium. This is made
necessary by the heavy demand for motive
power and the fact that the locomotive
works have orders on hands that will tax
their fullest capacity for 1903. This is
an exceedingly profitable method of sell-
ing "space."
From earlier and rather lim-
ited uses of graphite in lubri-
cation, the field has gradually
widened to include its use with
lighter oils, with water and, in
some cases, unmi.xed with other
materials.
In the cylinders of steam
engines, for example, Dixon's
pure flake graphite serves an
admirable purpose, and en-
gines which previously required
large quantities of cylinder oil
are now reported as giving far
more satisfactory results b)' the
entire omission of the oil, and
the use of graphite alone.
In all classes of service for
which Dixon's flake graphite
has ever been successfully em-
ployed, there are many evi-
dences to show that it is no
longer being regarded merely
as material for an emergency,
but that it now has a place in
the ordinary and usual routine
of the day.
REVOLVING FLUE RACK, C. & E I.
arranged in the form of a cross, so that
the revolving rack has four spaces in
which to carry tubes. The angle irons
joining the upright plates in the center
are carried up and terminate in a pivot
casting which has its bearing in the
roof timber. Angle irons riveted to the
plates about 10 feet up help to stiffen
the rack, while the top is reinforced by
a 1-4-inch circular plate. The whole ar-
rangement is very simple and inexpen-
sive. It has the advantage of economiz-
Joseph Dixon
Crucible
Company
Jersey City, N. J.
Ffbruary, 1Q03,
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
99
The Goods
Will
Please
ing space very effectively in the boiler
shop. The tubes after being welded are
placed in an upright position in one of
the divisions of the rack, the angle madr
by the two upright sheets tends to keep
the tubes together at the top if the
lower ends are somcwiiat spread over
the bottom of the rack. When a num-
ber of tubes have been welded the whole
rack is turned and an empty space is
brought round for the flue-welder to
fill, while the man who tests and cuts
ihe tubes to proper length, has in front
of him the tubes on which he has to
work. With this rack, the tubes are
easy to handle, take up a minimum of
room, and are moved at once from one
man to the other as successive opera-
tions require.
The Prices
Will
Tease
Q.&C.
Pneumatic
Tools
ASK FOR PRICES
Q. & C. CO.
NEW YORK, 1 16 Liberty Street
CHICAGO, 620 Western Union Bldf.
steel Channel Arch Bar Truck.
A truck suitable for a loo.ooo-pound
capacity car has lately been designed and
patented by . Mr. Cornelius Vanderbilt.
The truck is made of commercial shapes
and has comparatively few parts. The
top arch bar is a 5-inch, channel weigh-
also held togetlicr by the column bolts.
The tie-bar below the boxes is lipped up
on the box so as partly to relieve the
axle-box bolts of sheering strain.
The bolster for this truck is made of
heavy channels; the upper one, carrying
the center plate, and the side bearings is
made 12 inches wide and weighs 40
pounds per foot. It is canbercd up I 1-2
inches and is placed with flanges down.
The lower member is also a channel, but
is 10 inches across the face, 35 pounds
per foot, and is placed with flanges up
so as to fit inside the upper channel,
and the interposition of a cast filler
makes the ends perfectly solid when riv-
eted together. Bolted through this
filler piece is a casting which forms a
guide with the column casting, and as it
extends under the bolster ends makes
the bearing surface for three eliptical
rollers or rather rockers, which, while
allowing side swing to the bolster, has
a tendency to keep it constantly in the
center of the truck. Below the center
casting is a filler of cast iron which sep-
arates the two channels, a distance of
13 3-8 inches, making a deep and strong
-J-«J/4-
V.\NDERDII.T .STEEL TRUCK.
ing 9 pounds per foot, while the lower
bar is of the same section but weighs
II 1-2 pounds per foot. These channels are
placed back to back and form the com-
pression and tension members of an or-
dinary diamond pattern truck. The
lower arch bar. however, has its channel
formation changed to that of a flat bar,
just as it passes up over the axle box.
This arrangement has the advantage of
giving a wide bearing on top of the box
without the necessity of using a filling
piece, and at the same time it keeps the
height of the top arch bar much the
same as it would be in the ordinary form
of truck. The flat termination of this
second arch bar on top of the box is
lipped up against the end of the top bar,
thus making the "diamond" form self-
sustaining. The familiar truck transoms
are, in this design, represented by two
5 x 3 X 5-16-inch angles which fit on top
of the lower arch-bar and are united to
column castings by rivets, while angle
transoms, lower arch-bar and tie-bar are
trussed structure. The position of the
channels, one being inverted and one
normal, brings the webs of each into
the most advantageous position to deal
with the stresses which they were de-
signed to withstand. The king pin of the
truck passes through the center plate
and upper channel which is in compres-
sion. The lower channel is sufficiently
below the center casting, as not to re-
quire its web, which is in the tension, to
be pierced or weakened by an opening
for the king pin.
The whole design evinces an endeavor
to gain solidity and strength, with a re-
duction of parts and fixings which will
no doubt commend it to car builders and
the railway world in general.
Coal is so dear in Honolulu that the
people in charge of the railways there are
trj-ing to adapt their locomotives to burn-
ing liquid fuel.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1905,
Expanding Mandrel for Turning
U. S. netallic Packing.
The small machine department at the
C. & N. W. Ry. shops at Chicago, which
is situated in an upper gallery, where air
and light are plentiful, is presided over
by Foreman William Wafer. A very
expeditious appliance for turning up the
rings of U. S. metallic packing, in the
shape of an expanding mandrel, has
been designed by Mr. Wafer, and is
used for doing this class of work. It
circumference of the projection marked
A to slightly increase. On this projec-
tion A, the three rough rings of the me-
tallic packing are slipped, and on the
mandrel being then expanded, they are
held firmly while the outside surface is
turned off to exactly fit the inside sur-
face of the vibrating cup used with this
packing. The tool is of the shape
shown, and turns up a full set in one
operation, and also insures perfect inter-
changeability. The packing rings are
bored out when required, to suit the
particular valve rod upon which they
will be used. The time occupied in turn-
ing these rings has been reduced to a
minimum.
EXPANDING MANDREL FOR U. S.
METALLIC PACKING.
consists of a hollow steel sleeve, shown
in the accompanying sketch, which
screws on to the end of the hollow
spindle of a turret lathe. The sloping
portion of this mandrel has a series of
holes in the fillet, into which divisions
have been cut extending from the outer
end. When screwed on the "nose" of
the lathe an appropriately tapered end
on the "draw-in attachment" is pushed
into this mandrel, and engaging with the
inside taper of the mandrel, causes the
Of Interest to Readers.
Christmas and New Year's have come
and gone with all their pleasant greet-
mgs and jolly doings. The good old
custom of giving presents to friends has
been honored in a very substantial way.
This latter custom has also its humorous
side. A friend of ours got three writ-
ing pads which fold up into nearly
nothing, or had waterproof backs or air-
tight inkwells. Each of his friends
said, in effect, when handing over the
presents: "That will come in handy when
you travel, you know." Our steady,
stay-at-home friend, could not look a
gift horse in the mouth, so he replied as
cheerfully as he could, "Capital, old man;
how did you think of it?" and wondered
why his friends were so obtuse. He
does not expect to travel much this year,
certainly not to the extent that three
folding pads would indicate, and when he
does travel he does not write home.
What the polite victim really wanted
was a good book or two. Books gen-
erally make a very safe present, and they
are just as good to the man who travels
as to the stay-at-home. Another thing
about books is that they are appropriate
gifts all the year round, and a man may
give one to a friend, or he may, with
equal propriety, give one to himself.
The chances are, if he gives one to
himself, both giver and receiver will be
pleased and benefited. Our book de-
partment will supply any book on the
market, but here is a very good bill of
fare of railway, mechanical and en-
gineering works, which we recommend:
A year's subscription to Railway and
Locomotive Engineering costs only
$2.00, and the paper is a welcome visitor,
especially where there are children.
"The World's Railway" is a most in-
teresting history of railways and loco-
motives. It is beautifully illustrated and
the net price used to be $10.00. We now
give it and a year's subscription to Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering for
$5.00.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Sinclair, is an old and
<J3
6'
(0
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
lOI
A Wise Kaiser
A wise man in his genera-
tion is Wii.MAM, Kaiser of
Germany. His great new
navy-yard at Kiel is just
completed, and one of its
greatest features is a com-
plete outfit of
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
The Kaiser was not to be
induced to accept inferior
pneumatic tools, even though
marked with the magic word
"America." Only the best
were good enough for him.
Are you as wise as he ?
Semi for our :ie\v catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
aist St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Francisco Boston
H3
universal favorite. A well-known gen-
eral manager remarked in a meeting of
railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
tliat book. It was my pocket companion
for years." The price is $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. A
very helpful book combining instruction
and amusement. It is a particularly use-
ful book in the hands of a young
mechanic. Has a stimulating effect in
inducing young men to study their busi-
ness. Price, 50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling en-
gineers in the examination of firemen for
promotion and of engineers likely to be
hired. It contains a wonderful amount
of information about the locomotive, in
sinall compass. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recominend this book. 75
cents.
POWER HOUSE— BOSTON ELEVATED.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin. A
little study of this book will instruct a
man so that he will understand the con-
struction and operation of a compound
locomotive as well as he understands a
simple engine. Tells all about running,
about breakdowns and repairs. Conve-
nient pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable one to take out license to run sta-
tionary engine. Tells about boilers, heat-
ing surface, horse power, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a par-
tial list. Question and answer style.
128 pages. Pocket size, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. A book that ought to be
in the hands of every person who is in
any way interested in keeping boilers in
safe working order. Written by a tore-
man boilermaker. Also contains sev-
eral chapters on oil-burning locomotives.
50 cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
.Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language easily under-
stood. $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic" Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book thnt no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can afford to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of combus-
tion. While treating on the chemistry of
heat and combustion is easily understood
by every intelligent fireman. 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for people trying
to learn all about air brakes. Tells the
whole story. Cloth, 75 cents. Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lessons
which appeared in this paper several
years ago. They are interesting, laugh-
able and best of all are of practical value.
$1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehensive
treatise on the subject Ought to be
studied by all trainmen where block sig-
nals are used. $3.00.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
Lincoln Power Station of the Boston
Elevated Railway.
The Lincoln Station of the Boston Ele-
vated Railuny differs in many respects
from the various other power stations on
the same railway system. It is the most
recent addition to Boston's numerous elec-
trical power plants and is located on the
lot known for many years as Lincoln
Wharf. The chimney, 250 ft. high, is
said to be the tallest in the city. The
building is divided into two longitudinal
sections, the boiler room and all appara-
tus pertaining thereto being in one sec-
tion and the engines, generators and con-
densing system in the other. The engine
room is served by a large electric crane
of 40 tons capacity. The walls of this
room are faced with white enamel brick,
adding much to its general appearance and
illumination.
The present station contains three units
aggregating about 13.500 h.p. While it
is now complete in itself, ample ground
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
has been provided for tbe extension of
the building. The boiler installation
consists of eight 648 h.p. and four 490
h.p. Babcock & Wilcox boilers. An
■equipment of Roney mechanical stokers
has been installed by Westinghouse,
Church, Kerr & Co.
Coal will be automatically unloaded
from vessels and stored in large pockets
having a total storage capacity of 8,000
tons. Coal is carried to the boilers by the
Hunt coal and ash conveying system
which conducts the fuel into overhead
conveyors leading to the stokers. The
plant is also equipped with Green econo-
mizers. Feed water is supplied to the boil-
ers by means of two vertical compound
pumps manufactured by the George F.
Blake Mfg. Co. A Star vacuum feed-
water heater of 8,000 h.p. capacity is
placed on the base of the chimney con-
veniently near the feed pumps. As the
smoke flues from the boilers enter the
chimney at a point some thirty feet from
the boiler room floor, the space in the
lower part of stack has been found quite
valuable for the location of such auxilia-
by i2-in. risers to Cochrane receiver sep-
arators and thence to the engines. All
the live steam drips from steam drums,
separators and reheating receivers are
carried back to the boilers by the Steam
Loop and Holly Gravity Return System.
Ingersoll-Sergcant air compressors,
each driven by a 50 h.p. Westinghouse,
500-volt motor, supply compressed air for
the block signal and switching system
used on the road. Early in the concep-
tion of the scheme of running trains at
high speed under the rather complex con-
ditions here existing, the engineers of the
Boston Elevated Railway realized that a
block system was necessary, and the West-
inghouse electro-pneumatic interlocking
system, manufactured by the Union
Switch & Signal Co., of Swissvale, Pa.,
was chosen.
The elevated road includes some 14
miles of track. The switches and signals
are controlled from four switch towers
and the automatic block signals are lo-
cated at distances of about 800 ft. apart.
Each tower is supplied with indicators
showing the approach of trains. The tow-
THE
()BSEKV.\TION C.\R— CANADI.\N.PACIFIC RAILWAY.
ries as feed-water heaters, receiver of
the Holly gravity return system and sun-
dry piping.
The original engine installation con-
sisted of two vertical cross-compound
units of 4,500 h.p. each, built by the Prov-
idence Engineering Co. The generators
and flywheels are carried on the shafts
between the high pressure and low pres-
sure sides. The generators are direct cur-
rent machines, rated at 2,700 k.w. each. A
third unit which has just been completed
consists of a vertical cross-compound en-
gine of about 4,500 h.p., designed and
built by the Westinghouse Machine Co.,
and installed by Westinghouse, Church,
Kerr & Co. The engine, however, differs
considerably in design and construction
from the two engines first installed. The
high pressure cylinder is fitted with pop-
pet valves for use with superheated steam,
which is supplied by superheaters built by
the Babcock & Wilcox Company.
The steam piping represents all that is
modern in this important portion of the
plant. Steam is conveyed from both
sides of the boiler room by 8-in. mains to
a :6-in. drum, from which it is conducted
ers at the junctions of the Atlantic cir-
cuit and main line control some 1,200 ele-
vated trains daily. The largest tower is
located at the Sullivan Square terminal
where some 500 elevated trains and 700
surface cars pass in and out daily, involv-
ing 6,000 switch and signal movements.
A force of only two men on duty is re-
quired to operate the switchboard mechan-
ism, consisting of 35 pneumatic levers.
The terminals are also supplied with lamp
indicators showing the relative location
of approaching trains.
Passenger Coach with Cupola.
A novel passenger car has been put m
service by the Canadian Pacific Railway
which is used for the accommodation of
passengers when traveling through the
Canadian rockies. The car here illus-
trated is 56 ft. long over all, with obser-
vation platforms at each end. The center
of the car is arranged as a parlor, with
revolving chairs, which seat fourteen
passengers. The side windows in this
rightly-called observation car are excep-
tionally large, being about 3 ft. wide by
sOILER
Is made of 22-gage cold-
rolled steel and pressed
to shape.
It has only one seam —
where top and bottom parts
come together — and this is
brazed.
The air chamber is always
in communication with the at-
mosphere through the hollow
shaft of thumb-piece
Air is admitted to can only
when valve is opened.
Valve in spout opens "up "
and rod and spring come off
with spout.
Filled at spout opening and
can be emptied there — to the
last drop.
No packing or gaskets of
any kind.
Turned brass unions, ball
joints.
Can, spout and tip all 22-
gage cold-rolled steel.
Every can guaranteed oil-
tight in any position.
Is a mechanical job, is good,
looks good and will be taken
care of.
Nothing but an accident or
rank abuse can break or wear
one out. Cost more than tin
cans in the start — far cheaper
in the end.
And thev save oil.
M€.S Oiler Co^
E()uitabIeBulIdtng.
Denver. Col.
February, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVP: ENGINEERING
103
r
Mr. Air-Brake
Inspector
As yiiu are interested in
obtaining the most efficient
service from your air-brake
equipment, it will pay you
to lest
NON-FLUID OIL
AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT
especially during winter,
when ordinary oils and
greases freeze and refuse
to afford proper lubrica-
tion, thereby impeding the
operation of the cylindbrs.
Non-fluid oil is also espe-
cially valuable on triple-
valves
FREE SAMPLES FOR TRIAL FUR-
NISHED GRATIS, BV PREPAID EXPRESS
NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY
LUBRICANT COMPANY
MAKERS OK
"THE AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT"
14 and 16 Church Street
NEW YORK CITY
Jones & Lamson Machine Co.,
Main Office and Works:
EPRINQFIELD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
A. B.C. and Litttr's Codt used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephtn-
ton's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain : Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 5, Paris, France. Gennany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlottcnstrassc iiz, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
YOUR WORK IS LEVEL
AND IT STAYS LEVEl,
If It U leveled willi'aii
ARMSTRONG
PLANER JACK.
4 Sizes.
Send Tor Catalog.
Armstrong Bros.
Tool Co.
•'The T.>..l Holder
reople."
Aa5 AoNlIn Ateniie,
rilKAIill, I . S. A.
2 ft. 4 1-4 in. liigli. The upper or fixcrl
portion of the window is composed of
four panes of clear glass, whieli meas-
ure, with sash, about 10 in. deep. There
is therefore a wide, open and unob-
structed view from both sides, for sight-
seers. At each end of the car there is a
platform or dais, raised 4 ft. above the
car floor, whicli is surmounted by a cu-
pola having windows on the four sides
and ri.sing about 3 ft. above the roof.
Tlie Monitor or clearstory type of rooi
is, of course, not used here. As eacli
end of the car is exactly like the other,
it will be necessary only to describe one.
The platform in question is built against
one side of the car and has a passage
along its outer edge. Its floor is about
8 ft. 6 in. above rail level and contains
si.x revolving chairs similar to those in
the body of the car. A small stairway
leads up to the platform, and neat brass
railings placed on either side of the steps
and on the side of the platform next to
the passage, prevent any violent or un-
dignified descent of passengers from
platform to car floor.
The passengers enjoying a view from
the windows of the cupola have the
same opportunity for observation which
usually falls to the lot of the conductor
and rear brakenian when traveling in
the cupola of the "dog house" at the
end of a freight train. In fact this
coach is a very luxurious caboose, and the
idea was probably derived from what is,
on Canadian railways, called the conduc-
tor's van. The passengers in the cupola,
however, enjoy the varied mountain
scenery without the discomforts or re-
sponsibilities of freight trainmen.
The car provides seats for 26 passen-
gers in all and is used principally over the
Selkirk range between Donald and Rev-
elstoke. A little way west of Donald the
line leaves the broad Columbia river
and turns abruptly to the left into the
narrow and rugged canyon of the Beav-
er. It is like turning into an alley out
of a wide street. The ascent through this
gorge is at first made on the right bank
of the stream, but as the valley opens
out, the river is crossed and the ascent
of the eastern slope of the SelKirks is
begun in earnest. Rogers Pass is the
station at the summit of the grade.
With snowcapped Mount Carroll and the
Hermit towering on either side of the
pass, it is hard to realize that the rail-
way line is there 4,300 feet above the
level of the Pacific Ocean. The road
winds on down the west slope, past
Mount Sir Donald, Pyramid Mountain
and the Glacier, through the grandly
picturesque valley of the Illecillewaet
Railway riotor Cars.
British railways are beginning to feel
the competition of the trolleys in local
trafSc, just as some of our own railways
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
16 AND
SIZE.
17 AM> ^1 Itl HV
JKMKI.S,
KAPrillKI': PALLETS
BALL'S IMPBOVKD
KAFKTY
DOriU.K ItOLLKB
.\rti nithont question
r)u; finest watchcfl that
Amf'rican talent and
^•killed labor can pro-
iliire, and they are ^v-
ini^ purh nnlvc-real Hat-
iBfa'tion that we have
no licHitanry In claim-
ing that they arc the
b«'t and eafost railroad
watch on the market.
Teste severe and nnmeroushave proven this fact to
the moat critical ubitb in all Bections of the country, to
which thouHiiiidri of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are re^dy to certify.
We have an authorized agent In nearly every rail-
road center. Call on hlm^ for information and facta.
Write HP for (li-nrriptive matt'-r.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Bali Building:, Cle 'eland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
ARE DESIGNED TO BE FREE FROM
VIBRATION SO AS TO INSURE PER-
FECTLY SMOOTH PLANING.
Send for booklet telling
more about them. , . .
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
WINCHENDO.V, MASS.
|y|ODEL LOCOMOTIVES...
Better than ever! Latest N. Y. Cen.
Standard. High Saddles— Big Drivers^
4 sizes. Something extra nice. 4c. in
stamps for catalog.
A. S. CAMPBELL.,
P. O. Box 286, Monticello, X. Y.
104
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
FOR SALE
FREIGHT, PASSENGER AND LOGGING
LOCOMOTIVES
CARS
4UICK
OELIVERIES
F. M. HICKS,
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. J- Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
•hops in the country.
Union of course. <^ j*
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
;Steam-Heatln§:
Connection, All Metal. . .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENOEit.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville. Ky.
Boston Blower Co
HYDE PARK ^
MASS
make
Blawer*
for
Railroad or
other service.
are. To meet this successfully some are
putting electric trolley cars on their own
roads for short runs._ The North Eastern
Railway has recently' placed an order of
large- four-cylinder petrol engines, each
capable of developing 100 horse power, to
be used in the propulsion of light and fre-
quent trains in local service. The cars
will be S3 feet long, and will provide seat-
ing accommodation for 52 passengers, by
means of reversible-back garden seats. At
one end of the car there will be a Napier
petrol engine of 8s-brake horse power,
with four cylinders ; the engine will drive
a dynamo, generating electricity for two
motors, which will apply the power to the
bogie underneath the engine compart-
ment. The body of the car will be much
lighter than the ordinary carriage, approx-
imating closely to the tram type, with an
engine compartment at one end and a con-
ductor's compartment at the other. It will
be entered from the side by doors at each
end, which will be closed when the cars
are running. The car may be driven
from either end, and as it will carry 30
gallons of petrol it is anticipated it will
work for five hours at a stretch without
replenishing. The full height of the car
from the ground is 13 feet. It will be
fitted with electric brakes and illuminated
by electric light.
Messrs. J. W. Duntley, J. R. McGinley,
Jos. Boyer, VV. O. Duntley and J. D. Mil-
liken, a committee representing the di-
rectors of the Chicago Pneumatic Tool
Company, have returned to Chicago after
a visit of inspection to the various plants
of the company. In speaking of the trip
one of the gentlemen said: "This tour
was one of the most pleasant experiences
I have had for some time. We visited the
air compressor plant of the company at
Franklin, Pa., first, and were highly
pleased with the conditions of affairs
there, the facilities of the factory being
taxed to their utmost capacity to fill the
orders which are steadily flowing in. From
Franklin we visited the plants at Cleve-
land, Detroit and Aurora, 111., and are
very well satisfied with the conditions ev-
erywhere."
The Philadelphia & Reading Railway
Company has just started a watch depart-
ment. Its head is John Miller, an expert
on watches and clocks, and his task that
of maintaining a standard of time among
clocks at the stations throughout the sys-
tem. The company will insist that each
engineman, fireman, conductor, brakeman,
dispatcher and stationmaster in its employ
shall own a watch of a standard grade.
The company will sell these watches to
such employees as do not own them, on
an easy-payment plan. We do not know
what the "standard" is going to be, but
it will be different from the practice of
other roads if the standard is not the
watch which gives the best rake-off to the
inspector.
"Lucky Curve'
FOUNTAIN PEN
A Pen tliat has the 0, K, running all the way throueh.
8,000 DEALERS SELL THEM
"LrCKT CnRVE"—ifs easy to remember. KEPT IN
REPAIR FREE ONE YEAR. We have a catalogue
waiting for you, as well as the name of a dealer you
know who sells them. Both await your request.
THE PARKER PEN CO., 24 Mill St., Janesville, Wis.
Oil Burning in Locomotives
is described in our new book,
Care of Locomotive Boilers,
50c. - - This Office
Exposition
Flyer
Via
64
Big Four"
From
Cincinnati
To
St. Louis
Write for Rales and Folders.
Warren J. Lynch, W. P. Deppe,
Gen'l Pass. &, Tkt. Agt. Ass' t Gen'l P. & T. A.
Cincinnati, Ohio.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEV.
LOAN* TRUST BUILDINS, WASHINGTOR, 0. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sent.
February, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
105
This muffled
pop valve is the
best you can use
—better specify
It in your next
order.
VALVE COMPANY.
271 FRANKLIN ST, BOSTON tlASSi
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OmCES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
I CAN SELL YOUR BUSINESS
no matter where it is. Send description, state
price, and learn how. Established '96. Highest
references. Offices in 14 cities.
W. M. Ostrander. 1550 N. A. Bldg., Philadelphia.
lAYLUR YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's .''H'Sspeed"' steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
The Joker.
A striking little piece of advertising
by a well known railroad is called "Our
Leading Cards No. i — The Joker. It
beats cverytliing." In center of the
"card" is an American eagle, and across
his breast and wings is a representation
of the Empire State Express. The
choice of a bird of strong and swift
flight makes an appropriate background
for the New York Central's famous train.
We always associate a bird with rapid
motion. It recalls the description Kip-
ling gives of the passing of trains near
a country residence in England. He
says: "The trains of the Great Buchon-
ian went by with a bee-like drone in the
day and the rustle of strong wings at
night." Mr. Geo. Daniels has certainly
put his train "up to" the American
Eagle, who will no doubt feel bound to
award the N. Y. C. the laurel of fame
which he holds in one claw and the
three arrows indicating sureness and
swiftness which he holds in the other.
If any one hereafter misses these acces-
sories to the national emblem they will
likely be found in the Grand Central
station, New York. Try the general
passenger agent's office first!
A, Leschen & Sons Rope Co.,
.Manufacture: s
WIRE ROPE,
Ballast TJnIoaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sole Representative:, in the United States,
Canada and ftexico
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
Assistant Superintendent for
Locomotive Sliop.
WANTED — A bright, active man ae
Assistant Superintendent in Canadian
shop; must be a good organizer, able to
manage nien, and experienced in locomo-
"tive building. This is an exceptional op-
portunity for an ambitious, capable man.
Apply, stating age, experience and salary
•expected. Applications will be regarded
as strictly confidential. Address
LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERraG,
174 Broadway, New York.
MANILA ROPE,
Fittings and Supplies.
HOMK OFFICE:
920-922 North First St., - ST. LOUIS, MO.
( [-^s Iv Lake St.. ChicaKO. III.
Branch OfTices '92 Centre St., New York City. N.Y.
(h5 Fremont St., San Francuco,CaI.
S. N. CLARKSON,
Wholesale Jev^eler,
The Falls Hollow Stay-Bolt Company
are telling their friends that the year
1902 has been a banner year for them,
and that the outlook for this year is
even brighter. The hollow stay-bolt is.
they say, increasing in favor, though the
company supplies solid stay-bolt iron
made of the same high grade double re-
fined charcoal iron, as that used in the
hollow bolts. The Republic Railway
Appliance Co., of St. Louis, have been
appointed the southwestern agents for
the Falls Hollow Stay-Bolt Co. Mr.
E. S. Marshall is president of the Re-
public Co. He has been S. M. P. on
several of the leading roads in the West,
and knows all about stay-bolts. Mr.
Marshall is not only a first class busi-
ness man, but one whom it is a personal
pleasure to meet. The Falls Stay-Bolt
Company may be congratulated on their
new connection.
The "Soo" road is making a test of
ignite briquettes on one of its locomo-
tives in Minneapolis. If it proves suc-
cessful the anthracite coal problem for
the railroads in this part of the country,
at least, will be solved.
The briquettes are manufactured by an
entirely new process invented by R. J.
Schimper, of St. Paul. They are pro-
duced by compressing lignite, and accord-
ing to Mr. Schimper, surpass anthracite
in heating power.
As the new fuel can be retailed with a
profit at little over a dollar a ton. a great
saving will result.
103 State St.,
CHICAGO, ILL,
Send a postal to-
day for one of my
new 1903 cata-
logues, free, show-
ing illustiations of
Watches, Dia-
monds, latest So-
ciety E mblems,
Jewelr>'. Silver-
ware and a clock
that runs 400 days
with one winding
—all at Wkolesste
Prices. I will guar-
antee to sitve you
n% to 35', on all
Soois.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. NEW YORK.
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EOIIPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of servlc*
CARS, FREIGHT, PASSLNGER and BUSINESS
Honadnock BIdg., Chicago 141 Bnwdwav, New Tock
io6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
February, 1903.
New Patent Sanding riachine.
The cut reproduced here is of a sand-
ing machine especially designed for
makers of wagon, carriage, furniture
and piano material. It has embodied
in its make-up new points to 'insure it
doing good work to those having this
class of sanding to do.
This machine is invaluable where a
perfectly smooth surface is desired,
either for varnishing or painting. It is
massive and substantial, and saves the
work of several machines for doing this
character of work. The three steel
polishing cylinders upon which the
paper is placed have a vibratory motion
to prevent the formation of lines, and
are equipped with a device for quickly
NEW S.\NDING MACHINE.
applying the sand paper and giving it
the proper tension. Each cylinder
carries a different grade of paper, the
third cylinder giving the final and
smoother finish.
The feed is very powerful and con-
sists of eight feed rolls, four above and
four below, driven by a train of heavy
expansion gearing, and which will open
to receive material eight inches thick.
The machine is made to work material
from 30 to 80 inches wide, and has a
brush attachment which cleans the stock
after it has passed through the machine.
The pressure rolls are so arranged that
the adjustments can be made easily,
quickly and accurately, and the feed
started and stopped instantly.
The makers of this improved Sander,
J. A. Fay & Egan Co., Cincinnati, C,
will be glad to hear from those inter-
ested, to whom they will submit prices,
information and cuts showing it in de-
tail. They will send free their new and
complete catalogue, showing every ma-
chine they make to those interested
who will write for it, mentioning this
paper.
The engineers and other trainmen of
the Santa Fe and the Southern Pacific are
making great efforts to stop the practice
of double heading trains. They talk of
striking as a means of carrying out their
objections to the second engine.
Wonderful Scales.
The grand balance or scale used in the
Bank of England is probably the most
wonderful piece of mechanism to be
seen anywhere. It stands about seven
feet high and weighs probably two tons.
This scale is so perfectly adjusted that
it can weigh a grain of dust or 400
pounds of gold. A postage stamp placed
on one of the two weighing por-
tions will move the inde.x six inches. If
the weight placed upon the scale is be-
yond its capacity an electric bell is set
ringing, the machine declining to execute
a task of which it p incapable. — Ex.
One of the great inventions for a rail-
road, although simple in its appearance,
was made in Utica, N. Y., by a black-
smith. It was the fish-plate, that con-
nects the two rails, and is held by bolts
passing through the rails, taking the
place of the old cast iron shoe. The
blacksmith never made a dollar out of
it. Had he availed himself of the op-
portunity and obtained a patent, he
would have been the richest man in
Utica. The chilled-iron-faced car wheel
was also invented in Utica, by a man
named Peckham. He also neglected to
take out a patent and made nothing out
of it, but a man by the name of Dodd,
Rochester, secured it in some way and
made a fortune. — Merchants' Advocate.
In the Baldwin Locomotive Works rec-
ord of recent construction No. 39 are
shown some typical engines among which
may be mentioned a Prairie-type 2-6-2 for
the El Paso & Northeastern, a Vauclain
compound 2-4-2 for the Southern Pacific,
another of the same class for the Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul, a Prairie-fype en-
gine for the C, B. & Q, a compound
Mogul for the Quebec & Lake St. John
Ry., a 4-4-0 for the T'otomac, Fredericks-
burg & Piedmont Railway, with 3-foot
gauge and an Atlantic type 4-4-2 for the
Washington and Plymouth, also for 3-foot
gauge. There are fourteen half-tones in
all.
Leland Hurd, a ten-year-old schoolboy
of Huntington, Indiana, writes express-
ing great admiration for Railway and
Locomotive Engineering, and tells us
that he intends to be a locomotive en-
gineer. To show his familiarity with en-
gines, he wrote down a list giving the
names of 64 parts of a locomotive. Our
youthful admirer seems to know a good
deal about locomotives, but as he grows
up we have no doubt that his ambition
to be a locomotive engineer will en-
counter chilling influences, as he is not
surrounded by railroad people, but is the
son of a lawyer.
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS-
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smoke.
ContalnsaboutSoopractical questions and
their answers on the Science of Steam
Maklne. By Wm. M. BaRR. The necessary
conditions for the Economic Firing of a
Locomotive are explained. 85 illustrations.
349 pages. Cloth, I1.50.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By Robert H. BlaCKall. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Air-Brake
equipment, containing over 1,000 questions
and their answers on the Westinghoute
Air-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Air-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearly every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
264 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By Robert Grimshaw. It asks 1,600
questions and gives 1,600 simple, plain,
practical answers about the Locomotive.
No mathematics, no theories— ^"«j/ fact$.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
pages, over aoo illustrations, and la large
Folding Plates. Bound in Maroon Cloth,
$2.00.
^T"^ Special Circular oj these Books Sent
on Request.
^T'Any of these Books Prepaid to any
Address in the world on Receipt of Price.
AGENTS WANTED '^^^^^ '^J-
sell at sight, and every Engineer,
Fireman and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books is sent free on application.
Norman A. Henley & Co., Pnbllsliers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, N.Y.
To a contented mind, a closet is a
palace. — Martin Chusdexvit.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
Railway . .and
lOcomotive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.— 190.
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
vor. XVI.
Railway Building and Scenes in Cuba.
The latest feat of expeditious Amer-
ican locomotive railroad construction has
just been accomplished in Cuba.
At the time of tlic suvrciuhT of the
174 Broadway, New York, March, 1903
Santiago and Havana in point of time
being as far apart as San Francisco and
New York, though only separated by a
distance of a few hundred miles.
''The facts gatlu-rcd on tliis subject
No. 3
OLD MAR TIMK ENGINK NOW l)N CONSTRUCTION.
island by Spain to tlic United States in
1898, the greater hall of Cuba — from
Santa Clara down to Santiago de Cuba —
a distance of some 450 miles in length.
and covering an area of about 30,000
square miles — was wholly unprovided
with railway communication and prac-
tically a vast extent of country rich in
mineral and other wealth, remained un-
developed and virtually unexplored.
Immediately upon the cession of the
island to America, the late President Mc-
Kinley, wisely realizing the efficacy of
commercial enterprise in preference to
political influences in the real and suc-
cessful betterment of a newly acquired
country, deputed Mr. Robert P. Porter
to visit the island, to inquire into and
report upon its industrial, commercial
and financial condition.
In the portion of his report, dealing
with railways, Mr. Porter stated:
"The railway system of Cuba, consist-
ing of seven companies — the aggregate
length of whose lines is only 917 miles —
is entirely inadequate in bringing the
extreme ends of the island together —
point to the advisability of immediately
constructing a trunk railway from end
to end of the island, with branches ex-
oiild have existed in Cuba if such a
railroad had been completed by the for-
mer government, and nothing will so
rapidly tend to the revival of commerce
and general business as the facility for
<)uick passage from one end of the island
to the other, and from the trunk lines
over branches to the seaboard cities. All
political turbulence will be quieted there-
by and prevented in the future. The en-
tire country will be open to commerce,
lands now practically of no value and
unproductive will be worked, the sea-
port towns will become active and com-
merce between the island and the United
States will soon be restored to its for-
mer figures. After a careful study of the
situation, it would seem extremely doubt-
ful if such an enterprise could be made a
commercial success for many years to
come."
The concluding words in Mr. Porter's
report were certainly not encouraging
to a national undertaking of a new and
much desired railway system, nor, in fact,
did they in the least stimulate any pri-
vate enterprise in that direction. The
prospect of a reasonably immediate
profit was not sufficiently promising.
Undaunted by the guarded warning.
however, Sir William Van Horn, with
a characteristic spirit of venture and sage
foresight at once seized upon the op-
CONSTRICTION TR.\IN.
tending north and south to the important portunity, and got together a few influ-
cities and ports. From whatever stand- ential kindred enterprising railway mag-
point it may be viewed, no one enter- nates, with British-American interests
prise could do so much to improve the and influence, and formed a corporation
situation on the island. No revolution with the object of carrying out the sug-
loS
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
gestions contained in Mr. Porter's re-
port at all hazards.
Without loss of time. Sir William en-
gaged a competent body of practical men
to go over to Cuba to make a prelimi-
nary survey of tlie country, and in less
than a year afterwards, the whole area
was completely surveyed, the route
mapped out, and the constructional work
actually begun. Sir William Van Horn
Clara, Sancti Spiritus, Puerto Principe
and Santiago de Cuba. Cross and
branch lines are being constructed be-
tween Santiago and the Bay of Nipe;
Ingaro and San Fernando and two small-
er sections will connect the main trunk
line with Sancti Spiritus and Holquin.
The country thus opened out is said to
contain much undeveloped mineral
wealth, large areas of land of the richest
ficult to reach, and which have been rare-
ly visited.
Sir William Van Horn and his col-
leagues are to be congratulated upon
the successful and rapid completion of
their admirable undertaking. Cuba will
now enter upon a new and brighter era.
The possession of railway facilities must
very soon tend to ameliorate the exist-
ing Cuban political and economic con-
ditions and difSculties, enhance the com-
mercial prosperity of the country, and
consequently conduce to the improve-
ment oi the inhabitants far more effect-
ually than the wisest of legislative enact-
ments or the most reasonable of treaties.
J. W. D.wiES.
CLEARING THE JUNGLE.
personally traversed the route, made a
careful inspection of the undeveloped
portion of the island, gathered samples
of the various soils for analysis, and what
is not uninteresting, he utilized an old
Spanish wood-burning armored locomo-
tive (which was used during the war) for
constructional purposes.
In less than three years the entire line
of railway— about 400 miles — running
through the very heart of the eastern
portion of the island, has been finished
without a hitch, and the whole system
has just cen opened for public traiSc.
In preparing for and building the track
considerable difilculty was experienced
in excavation work, clearing the jungle
and spanning over rivers and valleys.
Great care was exercised in executing
the permanent V^ay and the most mod-
ern appliances and materials were
brought into use, and the whole track is
now reported to be in a highly satisfac-
tory condition.
The new railway is of standard gauge,
and its bridges are of steel and masonry;
its equivalent will be similar to that of
the best .Airierican railways, and it is in-
tended to run through sleeping cars be-
tween Havana and Santiago de Cuba.
The main object of the enterprise is
"the development of the easterij and
larger part of the island of Cuba, which
consists of large areas where hitherto no
railway facilities have existed."
The main trunk line establishes a direct
rail connection between Havana, Santa
description, and an ample supply of good
water. The mountainous regions are ex-
tremely picturesque, but sparsely popu-
The Canadian Pacific Again Goes to
Scotland for Engines.
The Canadian Pacific have placed an
order with Nelson Reid & Co., Glasgow,
Scotland, for twenty locomotives. They
are simple, ten-wheel engines, 20x26 in.
cylinders, 60 in. drivers, and weigh in all
164.550 lbs. The tractive force of these
engines is 27,100 lbs., and the ratio of
tractive power to adhesive weight is 4.7.
The engines are practically Canadian Pa-
cific standard, with improvements made
by the designers, Mr. E. A. Williams, su-
perintendent of rolling stock, and Mr.
.A. W. Horsey, chief draughtsman. Pis-
ton valves are used, having inside ad-
mission, thus giving incoming and out-
going .steam as direct a course as pos-
M.\KING A CUTTING.
lated and for the most part little known.
The new line will open up a great extent
of new and attractive country for settle-
ment and cultivation, and will add large-
ly to the attractions Cuba ofifers to tour-
ists, for it will make many important
and interesting places and districts easily
accessible, which have hitherto been dif-
sible. The valve gear has been designed
so as to make it straight, thereby doing
away with the motion connection bar,
which reduces the number of parts to a
minimum. This has been achieved by
placing the center of the piston valves
in line with the center of the frames, and
using a rocker which swings on a pin
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
100
fastened in tlie frame, giving a very di-
rect motion in forward gear. The spring
gear is underliung and is central with
tlic driving boxes, the connection comes
down from the underside of the box.
Tlie tender is C. P. K. standard turtle-
back, hopper tank. 'The tender frame is
made of lo-in. steel channels. The trucks
iire also made of steel and iron, with out-
side carrying springs.
The inability of builders in the United
fitted with solid axles will be put in the
same service and a comparison made of
the efficiency of the two cars in the same
traffic and with equal burden.
A Combination of Book and Brain.
I)V .SII.\NDy MAGUIRE.
In these days of educational schools
and papers devoted to every-day rail-
roading, wherein readers and pupils are
^V
X-
♦■fc.-'ti. -►. --
LABORERS IN SUG.^R CANE FIELD.
States and CaiTida to till the order in
the time required has given the Glasgow
firm an opportunity to build a very ser-
viceable and well designed machine.
taught to do everything from how to
screw on a nut to shooting the planets
as they fly, there is a wonderful improve-
school, as he designated the men of to-
day, who are in the saddles, and, as he
supposed, riding in a hand gallop to
Hades. Time was when he could take
his applicants for any position and "put
them through their facings." If a young
fellow made application to him in the
lamented past for the position of fire-
man, he would send him out on an en-
gine with a regular double-breasted son
of the scoop, as chaperone, and tell him
to find out of what sort of stuff he was
made before he got back.
All that has been changed, and Terry
is glum accordingly. One day a wiry
looking young chap, about 4 and 20 years
of age, came into Bennett's office with a
letter from the division superintendent,
telling him to "put the bearer, George
Raleigh, to work as fireman, on the
line of promotion."
Dear old Terry read the letter careful-
ly, and after its perusal he gave a most
])aternal look at the young fellow who
stood before him with all the self-pos-
session a coming engineer could be en-
dowed with. "Are you George Raleigh,
the man so favorably mentioned in this
letter?" "Yes, sir," he responded, "and
I suppose you are Mr. Bennett?"
"Sometimes I am, particularly when
my wife puts my name down on some
subscription paper in a most generous
manner, so as to impress all hearers with
the weight of my purse; at other times,
and under different circumstances, I am
plain Terry Bennett, and much oftener
I am Old Terry. Well, it is not of much
importance, anyway, what I am called.
It will not disturb our future relation-
Hollow Car Axles.
It is well known that a given amount
of metal arranged in the form of a tube
will possess greater rigidity than as a
solid bar. The principle was long ago
utilized in the formation of the square
columns of steel frame buildings. Lately
it has been applied to the immense
shafts of ocean steamships, which are
subjected to severe bending as well as
twisting strains. A hollow shaft is
stilTer than a solid one of the same
weight. The most recent use of the idea
is in the manufacture of axles for cars.
The Pressed Steel Car Company, of
Pittsburg, are fitting up an expcriinental
car with a new design of hollow axle
made by the Howard Axle Company, at
^^'est Homestead, and w'hich is con-
trolled by the Carnegie Steel Company.
The axle is made under the Mercader
patent and it is claimed for it a greater
efficiency, less weight and one-fifth the
machinery necessary in preparing the
solid axle. The experimental car is to
"be put in the local trade of the Pitts-
burg district, and after being in use six
montlis will be examined to ascertain
the wear on the hollow a.xle. A car
LOADING Sl"G.\R C.\NE.
ment in many directions. Old times, old
methods and old men are relegated to
the back track — or should be there — in
the estimation of the up-to-daters, who
boast superior thinking machines than
their daddies used to own.
Terry Bennett didn't take much stock
in the "poll parroting" of the new
ship. I see you are a graduate of the
Engineering Correspondence School,
well recommended, and have been an apt
scholar; have you any experience?"
"No. sir, but I have a fair knowledge of
combustion."
"That won't hurt you any, if you are
only apt enough to put it into practical
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
effect when you stick your nose in the
firebox. I suppose you are educated
-into the knowledge of the component
parts of coal?"
"Yes, sir; it is composed of gaseous
matter, moisture, fixed carbon, ash and
other elements. I feel that I can master
the position."
"There are others who thought the
same, whose heads are gray, and whose
eyes are dim, trying to master it, look-
ing at the firebox, then at the pointer,
then at the schedule, then at the dial of
the watch. Look at the turkey-tram-
pled phiz of the old grizzled mug of the
chap addressing you."
"What school have you a diploma
from?"
"Oh, listen to that now!" said Terry,
in astonishment, looking toward his
clerk, who pretended to be very busy in
Pug Miller does not do him up the first
trip, and report to me on your return."
Purdy reluctantly drawled out "All
right."
"Now, Tom, you do not take kindly to
my instructions. Why?"
"You send me more than my share of
students. Can't you send this one to
Paddy Ryan?"
"No. Paddy is prejudiced against all
modern methods. He thinks no one can
be an engineer unless he climbs from the
pit up."
Purdy introduced George Raleigh to
Pug as soon as they came around to go
out. Pug snarled "Glad to meet you,"
with a scrutinizing look that contained
the essence of all the disgust of Pug's
nature, which was considerable.
The Quickstep was a soft-coal burner
and a fairly good steamer. Bennett's
TOBACCO FIELD.
a pyramid of figures, and who would
tell broadcast every word of the inter-
view before the sun would set. "From
the school of experience, in which I
have been toiling for a diploma for nigh
upon forty years, and have not received
it yet."
"You deserve credit for doing so well
in life as you have, considering your lack
of knowledge scientifically taught."
"Say, young fellow, I think there is
some good stuff in you, judging you by
the fluency of your gab, and I am going
to find it. Report to Tom Purdy, who
goes out to-day on the Quickstep."
Terry was astonished at the gall of
the applicant, and it did more to get him
immediate work than if he came with a
dozen letters. He wanted to satisfy him-
self if the young fellow had anything in
him besides talk.
He sent for Purdy. "Tom," said he,
"I am going to send you a chap to-day
who comes well recommended. He
wants to be an engineer — some time.
You keep your eye on him. and see that
policy was to have an applicant make
five trips over tlie division with an ex-
perienced fireman, then leave him alone
on the same engine for five more, pro-
vided a good report came into his office
from the new beginner at the end of the
five gratis trips. Pug got down to busi-
ness after the train got out of the yard.
He put in the hook, watched the top of
the stack and was satisfied, as he should
be, if it was black smoke he was after;
then three, four and five scoops of coal
and a flop onto the seat, until time to
go at it again.
After they were out about 20 miles
Purdy said: "Pug, let the young fellow
try his hand."
"Wait till we get to Baily's," said Pug.
"No; let him at it here on the
straight."
Pug had to obey. Baily's was the foot
of a 14-miIe grade, and Pug wanted to
postpone the slaughter of the innocent
till he got there, as he had often done
before, but Purdy wouldn't stand for it
this time, as he said afterward, "because
I liked the looks of the youngster."
Raleigh got into position. He gave a
look at the gauge. The pointer stood
dancing a jiggeree at 160. He proved
an apt pupil. In the 20 miles he rode he
kept his eyes open. He scattered never
more than three scoopfuls of coal all
over the surface and watched for results.
He kept this up for seven or eight miles,
and the pointer was coming down to-
hold a chat with him, for it stood at 130,
Pug's face at a broad grin and Purdy's
at anxiety for the meet ahead. Raleigh
went lively for the rake, and after a
rapid scan of the surface, he raked over
the fire, closed the door, got the tool out
of the way as quickly as an old veteran,
and awaited results. The pointer began
to forsake the 130 mark and go up
again. The young fellow followed up
his advantage and manipulated things so
that he gained all the ground he lost,
and seemed to do it without ever letting
anything darker than a sort of a tawny-
colored smoke belch from the stack at
its most active delivery. One hundred
and sixty on a move! and the apprentice
up smiling, while Pug looked discon-
solate. Baily's was near, and the Quick-
step ready to climb it, with George
Raleigh at the furnace door. "Over the
hills and far away," was the song lilted
up by Purdy to nag Wilson.
There was nothing worthy of special
attention occurred until the day's work
was completed. Raleigh acted like an
old hand. Pug sent word to Bennett he
could not go out next day, and he being
.short of men, went to advise with Purdy.
"I'll go it alone with the young fel-
:ow." said Tom.
"I don't think it safe; but I have con-
fidencd in your judgment. Do you think
him capable?"
"He is the brainiest and wiriest fire-
man you have to-day. There isn't any
question I ask him relating to steam, air,
water and fuel but he can answer with
the speed of a school-car lecturer. You
watch that chap's smoke, Mr. Bennett,
and if he doesn't make his mark in the
railroad world before he sees the first
gray hair in his little blond miistac.c.
you can shoot me for a Dago."
Pug Wilson was oflf sick for about five
weeks — with a fit of the yellow jaunders.
as Paddy Ryan called his ailment — and'
George Raleigh remained on the Quick-
step until his return, then he was put
chain ganging on the extra list.
One night Paddy Ryan's fireman was
off, and Raleigh being first out. was al-
lotted to him. His fame had beerr
abroad over the division for some time
as the "know-all dude," by those who
could about sign their name in a sort of
a text between hieroglyphics and
scrawls. Paddy was tainted with the dis-
ease to a certain extent and Raleigh
knew it. However, he did his work, and
gave no reason for Ryan to find fault.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Just as tlic engine struck the foot of
Baily's Hill a tremendous blow occuri^d
in the cylinders, or steam chests, oblig-
ing Paddy to close the throttle valve.
When the train was stopped the crew
came to the engine to know what was
the trouble. Ryan wanted to locate the
blow by moving the engine, but couldn't
move either ahead or back, with the
train and the enormous loss of steain
blowing away. It was evident that Ryan
was confused when he began to take
suggestions from the train crew, who
knew nothing about what they were
talking. Paddy got up again into the
cab to try and move the engine so as to
put it on an available point for pro-
cedure. He was followed by Raleigh.
"Mr. Ryan, said Raleigh, "please ex-
cuse me for having anything to say to
you. but I know a way to locate the side
the blow is on without moving the en-
gine. I did not want to speak to vou be-
fore others."
"You?" — "Yes, sir." — "How?"
"Open the front end and you can tell
by seeing which exiiaust pipe the steam
roars out of."
"Say, you're right. Why didn't I think
of that before? Who told you?"
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management told it to me nights at
home."
Ryan said no more, but opened the
front end and found the side the trouble
was on. He then' whipped off the steam
chest, and saw a broken valve yoke. The
rest was plain sailing, for Paddy, al-
though a graduate from the pit, was no
fool. He was not able to go up Baily's
Hill on one side with his train, but he
flagged back to the first switch and left
part of it there, and then he went along.
After they got moving again, Paddy
nodded his head to have Raleigh come
over beside him.
"George," said he, "I have been big-
oted all my life against theoretical chaps
coming on locomotives, of whom I sup-
posed you were one, but to-night you've
taught me different. You also acted del-
icately by not showing all hands you
knew more than me. See that fist,
George, it is no baby's; and there is
muscle enough behind it to push it into
a fellow's face for a knockout who'll
ever say a word against you in my hear-
ing any more."
Six months later George Raleigh was
round-house foreman at Baxter. After
14 months he was appointed division
master mechanic; and to-day he is super-
intendent of motive power and equip-
ment on a certain trunk line, giving the
best of satisfaction to all parties con-
cerned, gained by his devotion to study
of the most available authors, after his
trips were made, comparing his own ex-
perience with that of them, and profiting
accordingly, instead of being a promi-
nent member of the Stove Committee
or some other assemblage of kickers,
who think they know it all.
Locomotives for Japan.
Although it is reported tliat the Im-
perial Government railways of Japan in-
tend to experiment with locomotives of
American, British, German and Russian
construction, the independent railroads of
Japan arc inclined to adopt the engines
built in this country.
Joseph W. Crawford, engineer of
branch lines of the Pennsylvania Rail-
road Company, is closer to the Japanese
railroad ollicials than any other man in
this country. He assisted in constructing
the imperial railways of Japan and lived
in that country for several years. Al-
arc turninu out on an average of one
complete locomotive every four hours.
The various branches of our plant are
rushed with work. The demand for mo-
tive power by the railroads does not
seem to slacken, and it reflects the gen-
eral prosperity of the country."
From Monday morning until Saturday
night not a wheel in the Baldwin plant
ceases to turn except by accident, and
13,000 men are kept at work. The order of
the Pennsylvania Railroad Company for
350 locomotives, placed some time ago,
is being rapidly filled. For this road
alone the Baldwin Company is deliver-
ing seven complete locomotives every
six days.
A Pennsylvania official said yesterday
that this meant a great deal to labor in
TYriC.\I, HOUSES IX SANTI.\GO.
though he is in no way officially con-
nected with these railways, no innova-
tion is made by their officials without
consulting Colonel Crawford. It was
through him that .American rails were
purchased.
A few days ago he let an order with
the Schenectady Locomotive Works, of
the American Locomotive Works Com-
pany, for the construction of twelve
]\Iogul locomotives for the independent
railroads, to be delivered early this year.
It is understood that a larger order is to
be placed later. — Philadelphia Press.
general, with the fact that the road's Al-
toona shops were sending out a complete
Pennsylvania locomotive every two days.
— Philadelphia Ledger.
Great Call for Locomotives.
Six complete locomotives are now
turned out daily at the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works, but even \vith this supply
the demand for motive power by the va-
rious great railway systems cannot be
met. John H. Converse, president of the
Baldwin Company, said yesterday that
the present condition of affairs was un-
precedented.
"We are working continuously, night
and day," said Mr. Converse, "and we
George H. Daniels on Railroads.
George H. Daniels, general passenger
agent of the New York Central Rail-
road, was the guest of honor and prin-
cipal speaker at the second reception and
dinner of the Baptist Social Union of
Buffalo, held in parlors in the Niagara
Hotel. He spoke on American Railroads
and Our Commercial Development. In
part, he said:
"In all ages of the world, transporta-
tion has been as it is to-day, associated
directly with the advancement of the
human race. It began with the dawn of
the world with the human burden car-
riers; then in certain countries came the
dog, the burro or pack mule; in others
the horse, the camel and the elephant;
the sailing vessels, the canal-boat; the
steamship; the stage coach, the horse
car and the railroad. The steam railroad
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
is tlie highest type of transportation.
When I tell you that all the money in
the world, gold, silver and paper, would
not buy one-third of its railroads, you
will get some idea of the vastness of this
industry.
"Railroad mileage has grown stead-
ily until now we have 200,000 miles of
steam railway in the United States.
These railroads employ over 1,000,000
men, whose wages amount to over
$600,000,000 annually. Their capital is
over $12,000,000, and their earnings last
year exceeded $1,500,000,000. They car-
ried more than 600,000,000 passengers
last year, and 1,100,000,000 tons of freight.
"In 1851 there were a little over 9,000
miles of railway open for trafic in the
United States. In 1903 there are over
200,000 miles in operation. One hun-
dred years ago the Governor of the
great State of New York advised his
friends not to invest their money or
a day passing over the New York Cen-
tral alone.
"American railroads have always been
aggressive. They do not wait for busi-
ness; they go out after it. The whole
world is their field. They keep in touch
with every change in every country.
Their maps are so accurate and up to
date that they are used by students in
studying geography, and remarkable as
it may seem, in at least one case they
proved of service to capitalists for in-
formation about foreign fields for in-
vestment. Within two months after the
signing of the Paris treaty that ended the
Spanish-American War the New. York
Central Railroad had ordered new maps
from the Matthews-Northrup Works to
show the changes the war had wrought
in the geography of the East.
"It is beyond question that American
railroads to-day furnish the best service
at the lowest rates of fare, at the same
Small particles of cinder and metal are
constantly getting into the eyes of the
drivers and stokers, and sometimes,
when the pain is agonizing and dithcult
signals have to be understood, the dan-
ger and inconvenience are not small.
But these men have only one rhethod
of giving each other relief — a method
that, however unpleasant it may seem tc^
the average reader, is declared by the
most eminent surgeons to be the one
practical, feasible plan, and one that
shows how devoted these co-workers can
be to each other.
And the method in question is this:
Directly the stoker, say, gets some
stinging particle into his eye the driver
will firmly, yet delicately, open the eye-
lids wide and then lick out the unseen
fragment — that is quite capable of pro-
ducing tragic consequences — with his
tongue. The public know little of this
heroic remedy, but on every line in the
world it is being applied daily.
Surgeons, with all their beautiful in-
struments, recognize that the way in
luestion is, when the foreign substance
IS of metal and one that cannot be seen,
the only plan.
BELOW BLOODY BEND, SAN JU.\N HILL.
waste their time in aiding the building
of railroads, expressing the opinion that,
while it was possible that improved
methods of construction and perfect ma-
chinery might in the remote future en-
able the people to move a car upon rail-
roads at the rate of five or six miles an
hour, he did not believe they ever could
be made of material advantage and that
any attempt to transport passengers and
freight by railroad from one part of the
country to another must result in endless
confusion and loss. Less than a quarter
of a century ago upon the average
American railroad the capacity of a
freight car was 20,000 pounds; the ca-
pacity of a freight engine was from 20
to 30 such cars to a train. To-day on the
New York Central the capacity of the
grain cars is from 60.000 to 65,000 pounds
and a locomotive of the latest type will
haul from 75 to 90 such cars loaded to
their full capacity. During the busy sea-
son there are from 75 to 100 such trains
time paying their employees very much
higher wages than are paid for similar
service in any other country on the
globe. The fact that American pas-
senger service attracts the attention of
people of every other country who visit
our shores is demonstrated by the de-
sire of all foreigners to ride on the Em-
pire State Express and the Twentieth
Century Limited— the fastest long-dis-
tance train in the world— and the further
desire to examine the magnificent ma-
chines that haul our great trains. This
i? the age of transportation and the
United States is leading the world."
To Remove Sparks from the Eye.
Most people know of the more appa-
rent dangers to which railway engine
drivers and stokers are exposed, but
few know that the form of accident to
which they are, beyond all others, most
subject is injury to the eyes.
Thirteen O'Clock.
The New York Central Company
track managers are making preparations
to place time clocks along the tracks.
These clocks are to be rung every hour
by the track-walkers and are intended
to prevent the trackmen from sleeping
in shanties.
This is in line with an act of the Duke
of Bridgewater, who built a canal through
Lanc^hire and beyond in England about
a century ago. The workmen's dinner
hour was from 12 to i and His Grace
found that they were far from punctual in
beginning work after the meal hour. On
remonstrating with his foreman about
the loss of time he was informed that
the people interested failed often to hear
the clock strike I. His Grace was equal
to the occasion. He had a clock made
which struck thirteen times at I o'clock,
and it is still ringing these many strokes
in a village near Manchester.
Many people conclude that locomotive
builders are peculiarly fortunate at
present in receiving orders that keep
them filled up for a year or more, but
there is a reverse side to this record of
good fortune. The building companies
say: How are we going to figure on the
cost of the engines a year hence? Ma-
terial, labor and every item that goes
to build up the cost of a locomotive are
rising. We try to strike an estimate of
what the total rise may be, but it is easy
to make a mistake. Prosperous times
have ruined more locomotive companies
than hard times. This sounds like a
paradox, but it is true.
Marcli, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
113
Growth of the Locomotive.
By Angus Sinclair.
(Contiinied from page 80.)
POrUI.AUITY OF VIvHTlCAI. BOILERS. ■
The pioneer railroiid engineers and in-
ventors of locomotives in the United
Slates worked out for themselves what
they considered the best form of boiler,
but much unproductive labor was ex-
pended before the fittest was developed.
Vertical boilers were in highest repute
among American designers evidently ow-
ing to the success of Cooper's small lo-
comotive, but some very expensive
blunders were made before inventors
settled down to the use of tubes in hori-
zontal boilers for transmitting the lieat
from the fire to the water.
THE "cheese" boiler.
The engine built at York, Pa., by Da-
vis & Gartner had a boiler of tli''
form shown in Fiy. 10. In this boiler
a circular water table was used for in-
gross load of 50 long tons from Dalti-
more to Parr's Ridge, a distance of 50
miles, up an average grade of 37 ft. to
the mile, at a speed ranging from 12 to
15 miles an hour. The daily expense of
llie round trip of 80 miles was $16, which
included one ton of anthracite coal at $8
a ton; engineer, fireman and laborer,
$3.50; oil and packing, 50 cents; esti-
mated wear and tear and interest on cost,
$3.00; water station expenses, $1. The
engine did the work of 42 horses, the
daily expense of which was estimated at
$33. The first cost of the engine is not
given, but it was about $4,500.
These figures are interesting as indi-
cating the prevailing rate of wages at
the beginning of the railway era, and
also the price of anthracite coal.
FIRST RAILROAD MACHINE SHOPS.
The first two engines for the Balti-
more & Ohio were built in the machine
shop of Davis & Gartner at York, Pa.,
Piiincas Davis, the lamented individual
who so largely contributed to the results
here indicated. On September 27 (1833)
last he, having completed a new engine,
availed himself of the occasion of trying
it to take his numerous workmen on a
visit to Washington. On his return the
engine, striking the end of a rail, which
the breaking of the iron chair had per-
mitted to get out of alignment, it was
thrown off the track and, being on the
tender, he was dashed forward against
the engine and instantly killed. No oth-
er person was injured.
■Phineas Davis was the first who < on-
structed an engine capable of being used
on the road in which anthracite fuel was
successfully employed. With untiring pa-
tience he bore disappointment after dis-
appointment, and the eminent and splen-
did results which ultimately rewarded his
efforts are ample testimonials of his ge-
nius, and will identify his name most hon-
orably with that great system of inter-
VZ7
\I7
ItnUwiiti ^ LiKi
CHEESE BOILER.
Fig. 10.
creasing the heating surface, but it did
not work well. The water-table was
known among railroad men as "the
cheese." It filled up quickly with mud
and scale and soon burned out, and was
replaced by a boiler of the form shown
in Fig. II. This is a tubular boiler with
a combustion chamber, and was a great
improvement over tlie cheese boiler as
a steam generator. Still a greater im-
provement was effected in the boiler
(Fig. 12) designed for the "Atlantic."
That was a more powerful engine than
any of those previously tried and it
weighed 6j'< long tons, or 14,560 pounds.
The cylinders were lo.xao in. and the
driving wheels were .30 in. diameter. The
steam pressure carried was generally 50
pounds above the atmosphere.
COST OF OPERATING.
In 1832 Jonathan Knight, the chief en-
gineer of the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road, reported that the engine hauled a
VI7
niiiiiimTtirrminiiiiiiiil
IMPROVEMENT ON THE
CHEESE BOILER.
Fig. II.
because the railroad company did not
have facilities of their own for building
locomotives. The shops at Mount
Clare were, however, ready in 1833, and
after that all the engines for the com-
pany were built there, although the
shops were under the charge of Phineas
Davis, who proved himself to be a first-
class mechanic and engine designer. At
the same time George Gillingham was
superintendent of machinery and the in-
genious Ross Winans was his assistant.
Mr. Davis came to an untimely end.
The following extract from the minutes
of the Board of Directors of the Balti-
more & Ohio Railroad Company gives
the sad particulars:
PHINEAS DAVIS.
"When adverting to what has been ac-
complished in the improvement of the lo-
comotives of the company it would ill
become the board to omit paying a trib-
ute of merited respect to the memory of
•■ ATLA.NTA' BOILER.
Fig. 12.
nal improvement which is yet to work
so many and important changes in the
relations of society. Of a quiet and clear
perception in matters relating to his pro-
fession, he possessed a calm, discrimi-
nating judgment. The warmth and en-
erg}' of inventive talent were tempered
by a prudent foresight and great prac-
tical skill. He seldom, therefore, took a
step which was not a secure one, and
the success of his suggestions when put
into practice gave them from the first
almost the same weight as if they had
been the dicta of experience. His pri-
vate worth and unassuming manners
were not less remarkable than his rare
abilities. The board deeply regret his
loss, and hold his memory in sincere
and respectful consideration."
OBJECTIONS TO VERTICAL BOILER AND
CYLINDERS.
.\fter the death of Davis the company's
shops were leased to George Gillingham
i'4
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
and Ross Winans, and tliey built new
grasshopper engines and repaired all the
rolling stock under a contract. Between
1831 and 1837 about 20 grasshopper en-
gines were built, one or two of them for
foreign railroads. By degrees the inher-
ent weakness of that style of locomo-
tive began to assert itself. The vertical
cylinders tended to impart a bobbing
motion and the vertical boiler made the
engine top heavy, a defect which was
aggravated by the short wheel base.
CRAB ENGINES.
The first deviation from the accepted
form of the grasshopper engine was to
apply the cylinders in a horizontal po-
sition while retaining the boiler upright.
The engines of this type were built and
the workmen called them crabs, because
they seemed to run backward. This
name became historical.
Placing the cylinders liorizontal helped
to overcome some of the defects of the
engines, but they were never adapted
to the high speed that other kinds of lo-
comotives attained during the first dec-
power with a cylinder of moderate size
and pressure of steam, such as was used
at that time. The upright boiler was
adopted in view of the advantages al-
ready enumerated, and of its successful
use in the little engine of Mr. Cooper,
which seemed to give the maximum of
steam generating capacity in the small-
est compass, and hence to be especial-
ly favorable to the compactness required
in so short an engine. The boiler, af-
fording readiest and staunchest support
to the cylinders, was naturally resorted
to for that purpose. This gave them
their vertical position, and involved the
lever beam and long connecting rods or
grasshopper legs. The separate shaft
was an accompaniment of the system of
gearing required by the small wheels,
and relieved of its objections.
"The fuel used required a strong blast,
and this was most etifectively obtained
by a fan, and this, again, was most read-
ily driven by the exhaust steam, which
at the same time was made to heat the
water before entering the boiler. The
valve motion might have been elTected
CR-^B Fig. I,v
ade of the railroad era. On the Bal-
timore & Ohio Railroad the capacity lor
hauling freight was of more importance
than speed, and we find the improve-
ments effected by Winans on the loco-
inotive were generally intended to in-
crease the tractive power.
MERITS OF THE GRASSHOPPER ENGINE.
Benjamin R. Lathrobe, who was for
many years chief engineer of the Balti-
more & Ohio Railroad, wrote about the
grasshopper engine:
"The engine was constructed with spe-
cial reference to the weak track and
strong curves of the Baltimore & Ohio
Railroad. It was made, therefore, of
moderate weight and short coupled, so
as to press lightly on the track and
round the curves easily (the swiveling
truck not having been then suggested),
and that it must have done this last is
proved by its being able to work itself
through the quadrant of 60 ft. radius at
the street corners. It was supported
upon wheels of small diameter with the
same views and to keep down the center
of gravity, and also to give tractive
and prejudice against heavy loads, he
built engines that compared fairly in
efficiency with those of modern construc-
tion.
The "crabs" were followed by eight-
wheel engines, which the trainmen
promptly denominated "Mud Diggers."'
They had horizontal cylinders like the
"crabs," and the upright boiler was still
retained. The engines would run stead-
ier than the four-wheelers, but they were
\-ery unpopular and only two were built.
They were practically double truck loco-
motives, a style of construction which
Winans originated in a car which he
built in 1830.
{To be continued.)
MUD DIGGER. Fig. 14-
by the generally employed eccentric, but
the use of properly formed cams cut off
the steain in a more satisfactory man-
ner in this engine, and at a proportion
greater or less according to the power
to be exerted on the different grades
of the road, thus economizing steam. It
must then be admitted that, taking it
as a whole, the' engine was admirably
adapted to the road on which it ran,
and although it had to give place, in
time, to another style of locomotive, it
rendered good service and is fully en-
titled to have its memory perpetuated."
winan's work on the locomotive.
Winans led the world in advocating
powerful locomotives and appeared to
have the clear conception of the economy
that would result from the use of engines
as large as the track would carry. It is
only within the last decade that railroad
managers have indorsed by practice the
wisdom of Winans' policy. The light
track which his engines had to run upon
kept down the weight, but with all the
restrictions imposed by weak structures
Mr. Atterbury Breaks the Car Blockade.
About the beginning of last month the
most important problem confronting the
great Pennsylvania Railnoad Company
was how to overcome the congestion of
freight that had become too great for
the facilities as usually operated. Gen-
eral Manager Atterbury had scarcely got
settled in his new position when the
freight-moving problem reached up to
him. Instead of following the usual
stereotyped plan of staying in his office
and issuing orders Mr. Atterbury closed
up his desk and proceeded to the scene
of conflict, where he could watch every
detail. He had very clear ideas of how
ireight ought to be moved expeditiously,
and put them into practice. Within a few
days business was moving as usual.
.\ method of handling coal cars
which Mr. Atterbury introduced has
greatly accelerated the movement of
these cars. They are classified at tide-
water terminals and the empties sent
baw to the mines in solid trains. All
railroad cars not owned by the party
loading them are regarded as applying
to the pro rata share to each mine and
distributed accordingly.
At present only Pennsylvania cars are
treated in this manner. Under this new
arrangement no big coal company will
be able to farm out its own cars to other
operators. At the same time these com-
panies will, it is said, get more cars and
the smaller shippers fewer than they do
now.
The general salutary effect sought,
however, is a quicker and fuller service.
It is expected to discourage the use of
foreign cars on the Pennsylvania, more
prompt return of equipment, and so tend
to relieve the company's lines of the con-
gestion of empties, and which is one of
the causes of freight blockades.
As the conversation proceeded along
the line of success, a gentleman who was
present made the statement, "Yes, the
man who never fails, never blunders,
never makes a mistake, is the man who
is earning 75 cents or $i a day digging
dirt." — Omaha Bee.
March, 1903.
KAII.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
115
General Correspondence.
Cause of Trouble with Valves.
Mr. K. M. "Watson wants to know
what is the matter with his valves? Well,
lie says tliat every man had trouble with
that engine. The fault is that his lubri-
cator was cross feeding, and as they all
had trouble with that engine the steam
pipes or dry pipe in boiler has a leak in
one of the joints. When he is running
freight and jogging along the boiler gets
full of water and leaks in the joint and
goes to steam chest. When running his
50-mile an hour he does not carry water
so high and the engine runs better; that
is, she don't get so much water in dry
pipe. His valves being dry has got his
left eccentric hot through too much fric-
tion, and oil-hole stopped up in eccentric
made her run hot and that is what broke
the blade of eccentric.
James L. Morris.
Tiburon, Marin Co., Cat.
What Made the Reverse Lever Jerk?
In reading R. M. Watson's article
about his valve gear and reverse lever
jerking so badly, published on pages 13
and 14 of January number, I made up my
mind that it was not caused by his
valves, but was caused by his eccentrics
running too close together, and the bolts
that hold the blades to the straps catch
each other, or interfere and would natur-
ally interfere more when engine is
■drifting than when working iteam. We
had an engine here that tilted some of
her driving box saddles over against the
frame, and when they were leveled up
by putting shims under the low side of
the saddle, then the box ran hot. This
was overcome by taking the roller off
from top of saddle and turning it taper-
ing, one end of the roller being made
as much smaller than the other end as
the thickness of the shim used to level
up the saddle, and the small end of the
roller was put to the side of the saddle
that was shimmed up, thereby keeping
the band of the spring in a level position,
also keeping a uniform pressure or bear-
ing the whole length of the brass which
cured the heating of the journals.
Cherokee, la. C. D. Greig.
readily than the iron sheets do, and the
water will absorb heat that is sufficient
to melt the iron sheet— therefore, a con-
dition takes place that is not unlike a
vacuum.
The reason that the sheets are not
cool before the boiling point is reached
is partly due to the air that is mixed with
the water which hinders the water from
absorbing the heat; as the water be-
comes hotter, the air is driven out of the
water and more heat is absorbed from
the plates, providing there is a sufficient
volume of water in the boiler. Two
inches of water on the crown sheet would
not keep the crown sheet cool, but if the
boiler be filled full "up to the whistle"
the crown bolts would not be any hotter
than the crown sheet, because they
would be almost completely covered
with water.
Notice a patch on a crown sheet, the
rivet head of the patch will not be any
hotter than the crown Sheet, because it's
covered with water. Gary A. Brace.
Saginaw, Mich.
[We are pleased to publish the above
explanation, although it is not altogeth-
er satisfactory. — Ed.l
Why Parts of Firebox Are Cold When
Steam Is Up.
Referring to Mr. Chenworth's state-
ment in the January number of Railway
AND Locomotive Engineering relative
to sheets in firebox of a locomotive be-
ing cool while water is above the boil-
ing point, I would say that it is due to
the fact that water absorbs heat more
Squaring the Exhaust.
I noticed a communication from "J. A.
B." in the January Railway and Loco-
motive Engineering about a quick job
of squaring the exhaust. Now I can beat
his time with odds, or else I had noth-
ing to do with it, for she squared herself
with one exhaust. Engine 109 was sent
to the main shop so lame that one would
think she could not run, but she hauled
her rating all right. The motion man
ran her over and found everything O. K-,
then she was assigned to me in local ser-
vice, and it made me tired to hear her
limp so badly. On the return trip, as we
were ascending a very heavy grade, she
squared herself with one exhaust. Now
this may seem "fishy," but I will explain.
L^nbeknown to the M. M. or any one else,
the boiler-makers had put a bushing or
false stack inside, for a reducer undoubt-
edly to make her steam better, or for an
experiment. The supposition is that the
rivets at the base wore ofif and let the
lining swing over so one exhaust shot in
between it and the stack proper. The
engine was laboring very hard, when there
was an unusual commotion in the firebox,
and at the same instant I saw the stack,
as I supposed, rolling down the hill, but
on looking saw everything was all right,
but my fireman's face showed utter
amazement, for she was cutting off as
square as a die. I called him in time to
see the false stack going down the hill,
and then he also looked forward, but
found everything all serene. We did not
stop, for it was a hard place to start, but
reported it to the M. M. when we got in,
and on the next trip we brought the lining
in. Now it is very strange to me that, if
the exhaust would throw that stack out,
how "J. A. B." could keep his plugging
bar in that nozzle. F. V. B.
Heat Phenomenon.
The heat phenomenon, mentioned in
your January number on page 14, which
was observed by Mr. Chenowith, is
a common one and can be dealt
with in one's own kitchen. One can take
a kettle of boiling water off the stove and
immediately place it on the palm of the
hand without any injury to that member
for the space of 30 seconds or more.
As soon as the boiling ceases the circula-
tion of water is less active; its tempera-
ture is practically uniform; convection
ceases and heat is emitted by conduction.
While the water is boiling evaporation is
in progress, the water has a rapid cir-
culation which causes the heat to be used
up by convection. The principle may be
summed up in these two words, "con-
duction" and "convection" of heat.
J. L. Mery.
Jerome, Ara.
The Piston Valve of To-day.
Having recently noticed an article in
the Pittsburg Post, under the title "Slide
Valves Are the Best," I feel called upon
to offer a few lines in defense of the pis-
ton valve.
The author of the article is certainly
prejudiced against the piston valve, or
ignorant, for, in citing certain work
done by a slide valve engine, which con-
sisted of hauling a train of 21 cars over
a I per cent, grade, four miles long, he
fails to give the tonnage of this train,
and does not so much as offer an opin-
ion as to what a piston valve engine
could do under similar conditions.
There seems to be a few motive power
men who still doubt the efficiency of the
piston valve, due, no doubt, to the im-
pressions received and opinions formed
from the earlier type of piston valve en-
gines.
The idea of piston valves is not new
among locomotive designers, having
been experimented with for the past 25
years, but it was only about three years
ago that it was brought out so as to give
best results.
The piston valve has received many a
Il6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
severe criticism which was not its just
'due. About four years ago when the
Brooks Locomotive Works decided to
use the piston valve on locomotives car-
rying 200 pounds of steam and over,
there seemed to be an epidemic among
all locomotive designers of going to the
extreme on the length of stroke or long
crank, changing from a 24 or 26-in.
stroke to a 30 or 32-:n. stroke.
At this time piston valves were ap-
plied to locomotives with a 28 or 30-in
stroke, the diameter of the driving
wheels remaining the same as the 24-in.
stroke engines had, and in a number of
cases were tested against the 24-in.
stroke engines equipped with slide
valves. When the performance of the
engines regarding .speed and fuel con-
sumption were compared, the results
showed in favor of the engines with the
24-in. stroke, and the failure of the long
stroke engine to meet the results of the
short stroke was charged against the
piston valve, when it should have been
charged to increasing the stroke and in-
creased piston speed resulting from the
drivers remaining the same.
About this time designers became pos-
sessed with the erroneous idea that a
steady blow or blast was the correct
thing, and to bring about this condition
the piston valve cylinder saddles were
designed with large exhaust passages,
which acted as expansion chambers for
the e.xhaust so that it became one con-
tinuous roar, instead of intermittent,
causing a steady blow through th^ noz-
zle, which was very wasteful on fuel,
also a continual pressure in the exhaust
passages, which in turn caused high back
pressure in the cylinders. This was
proven a serious defect in the working
of the engine, and for which the piston
valve was not responsible.
During this time the same valve mo-
tion was being used for the piston valve
as for the slide valve, the former having
internal admission and the latter ex-
ternal, resulting in a poor steam dis-
tribution as a consequence of indirect
movement, the lead increasing fast with
short cut-ofif, causing excessive pre-ad-
mission and high compression, all of
which was a detriment and charged to
the piston valve.
However, with the new four-passage
exhaust-cylinder saddles, where the re-
spective cylinders have a separate ex-
haust passage from each end, we get a
short, sharp exhaust and an exhaust
passage free from pressure when valve
closes, so that the back pressure is re-
duced to a minimum.
With the direct valve motion we get al-
most perfect steam distribution, the lead
increasing slowly with short cut-ofif.
With piston valves there is practically
no friction, and they will run for two
years without renewals or repairs, the
valve itself requiring very little oil for
the hardest service. In this connection
I have never in my four years' experi-
ence with piston valves seen a cut valve
or bushing.
Engines equipped with slide valves
cannot be run successfully any distance
with a full throttle on account of valve
running dry, cutting valve seat and
valve, working hard, springing valve
stem, causing a lame engine, and con-
sequently loss of power. However, with
a piston valve this does not occur. You
may run as long and as far as neces-
sary with a full throttle and the valve
will work as free and easy as with a
light throttle. You never have a cut
valve, and it certainly follows that there
is a gain of power over the engine
equipped with the slide valve, as none is
lost through friction of the valve. Ex-
cessive power used to move valve de-
creases draw-bar pull.
As the piston valve engines are now
designed, building them with reasonable
length of stroke so as to get economical
piston speed, casting cylinders with sep-
arate exhaust passages, properly de-
signed exhaust pipe and front end draft
arrangement, changing the valve motion
to "direct." which gives the best steam
distribution on internal admission
valves, they will do better work and at
less expense than a slide valve engine
of the same dimensions.
In conclusion. I will say that the piston
valve engines as turned out now by the
Brooks Works of the American Loco-
motive Company should no more be
compared with the piston valve engines
of three or four years ago than should
the air-brake of to-day be compared with
that of 20 years ago.
I believe that I have ridden on and
noted the work done by all the modern
large power that has been built in the
last few years, and have given particular
attention to heavy power equipped with
slide valves, also different types of com-
pounds, and I am satisfied that the pis-
ton valve engines, as now constructed,
are more powerful on a slow, hard pull
and have more speed on account of less
back pressure than any other design.
I will call particular attention to the
piston valve engines on the Chicago.
Rock Island & Pacific Railway; C. C.
C. & St. L. Railway and many other
roads, both for freight and passenger
service; also the last Wisconsin Central
passenger engines, the performance of
which will bear me out in every claim
that I have made for the piston valve.
W. G. Menzel,
Supt. M. P. & C, Wis. Cent. Ry.
Fon du Lac. Wis.
m tills, but in your January issue your
comment: "A chance for the inventor
and the ablest chemist," you go a little
too far, and are open to more criticism
than the daily paper you refer to. You
state that common illuminating gas is
not poisonous, but you are decidedly irr
error, as it is well known to be very
poisonous, and that the deleterious ef-
fects of inhaling such gas are only
slightly due to the displacement of free
oxygen.
The "inventor and ablest chemist"
"did something" a long time ago and
produced a gas tliat is not poisonous —
acetylene. That acetylene is not poison-
ous is well known to gas engineers, and
I have several times proved it upon rats.
Hold a large rubber tube close to the
nose of a rat in a trap and turn on the
city gas. Within ten to fifteen seconds-
the rodent will fall over dead. Take
another exactly similar rat and in the
same way turn on actelyene gas, and for
nearly ten minutes he will not "turn a
hair," or make any special effort to get
his nose away from the tube. In about
fifteen minutes he will become uncon-
scious, then turn off the gas and in an-
other fifteen minutes he will have en-
tirely recovered and will appear none the
worst for the experience.
This shows, in a rough way. that city
gas is fully sixty times as poisonous as
acetylene for the same amount inhaled.
Then consider that for the same amount
of light only a twentieth the volume of
acetylene is used, and the burners and
fittings are adapted to pass only that
small proportion, then the danger, as
compared with city gas is as one is to
twelva hundred in favor of acetylene.
No one was ever asphyxiated by acety-
lene, although it is now in quite ex-
tensive use. There are no cases on
record of suicide by acetylene. If any-
one ever tried it he likely gave it up as
a bad job and has kept the details to-
himself.
S. W. RUSHMORE.
Jersey City, N. J.
Acetylene Gas Not Poisonous.
Occasionally in your columns you
poke fun at the daily press when they at-
tempt to describe technical things, and
in the mechanical field you are quite safe
Simple vs. Compound Lubrication.
Assuming that any statement found in
print is matter open for argument, I
venture a few remarks regarding an
article which I find in the proceedings
of the Traveling Engineers' last meet-
ing, under the head of "The Handling
of Compound Engines." On page 259. I
find the following, regarding lubrication
of the same: "For the lubrication of
the cylinders it takes no more oil to
lubricate them than the simple engines
of the same capacity." "Same capacity"
in this instance, I take to mean equal
tractive power.
Now, under all known rules of locomo-
tive lubrication I claim that this state-
ment will not bear itself out, from the
Marcli, 190J,
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
fact that what wmtlil lie cconouiical
lubrication of two friction surfaces, one
foot square, would be wasteful on sur-
faces one-half that size, or insufficient
for twice that era.
Upon the same subject, Railway and
LocoMOTivii Enginkkrinc. of April,
1899, contains the following:
"Set lubricator so as to feed same as
for simple cuKinc of same size and ca-
jiacity." Again I fnul on page 302 of
your journal these words; "Five drops
feed per minute will ordinarily be found
sufficient for the largest engines and
licaviest service." This statement is of
so recent a date that it includes com-
pound as well as simple engines.
Lubrication is the maintaining of a
film of oil sufficient to overcome friction
between two rubbing or rolling surfaces.
Economical lubrication is reached when
enough and no more of the lubricant is
supplied to do the work required, in
ary. Let us now examine a few figures
and see if tliey will sustain the argument,
based upon the friction surface, passed
over by the piston and valve.
In the 16x24 i'l- engine we find a fric-
tion surface in the cylinder of S.37 sq. ft.
In a modern 22x30, we find a friction
surface in cylinder of 14.40 sq. ft., and
among our modern engines we find many
of them equipped with piston valves,
which have all the friction elements
found within a cylinder of same diameter
and in some compound engines with as
many as six bearing surfaces, all de-
manding lubrication from the same
source. We will have occasion to com-
pare these valves later on.
The figures shown for the above-men-
tioned cylinders would indicate great
elasticity of the 5 drops, or an added ex-
pense to the shop account by a badly
worn cylinder.
Let us put a 6i-in. wheel under these
slow time up that last hill. They also
suggest food for thought by the Super-
intendent of M. P. while enjoying the
comforts of a Pullman seat en route to the
mountain division, bent on finding out
why those new tandem compounds arc
not doing better work and why they re-
quire so many days on the roundhouse
pit. I fear that he will find in the end
that the schedule must be modified and
allowance made according to work done
in cylinder at ihc present time, and not
according to work done a number of
years ago.
1 will now show what wc are doing
with the compound as against the
simple engine. I have selected two
engines in actual service, one a simple
engine with 22x30 in. cylinders, piston
valve II in, diameter, 56 in. drivers, 200
pounds pressure on gauge, weight on
drivers 130,000, tractive power 4I,48.'>
pounds; speeding them .30 miles an hour
CHICAGO 8: ALTON "FACIKIC ' TYPE, EXPRliSS ENGINE.
Description on page 120.
diminishing wear and preventing the
heating of surfaces.
If we take an allowance of 5 drops per
minute as sufficient for cylinder lubrica-
tion we must concede that this has been
proved sufficient at some time or other.
It was sufficient in the bygone days,
when the 16x24 in. engines were con-
sidered large enough for the work then
done. From 3 to S drops per minute
was the universal feed since the intro-
duction of the lubricator. Those of us
who have been long enough in the ser-
vice can follow the history of lubricator
feed by the letters of remembrance from
the office of the Superintendent of M. P.
or M. M. calling attention to our oil
record for the past month, generally end-
ing with the expression, "We will expect
improvement in the future."
Then, as row, it was 5 drops per min-
ute. Cylinders have gradually increased,
but the drop feed has remained station-
two engines and speed them up to 30
miles an hour and see what our drops
are doing.
For the 16x24 '"■ cylinder we have
5.53474 sq. ft. of friction surface per
mile. For the 22x30 we have 10,372.60
sq. ft. This gives us 55374 sq.
ft. for one drop to lubricate in
the 16x24. and 1,037.26 sq. ft. in
the 22x30, an increase of 87.4 per cent,
in friction surface and work, expected
of one drop of oil. This is enough to
cause one to pause and ask, Are we
working in the dark, with our limit of
ollowance? If 5 drops is the right feed
for the one, the other is certainly entitled
to better recognition of the work done.
In these figures no account has been
taken of the work done in steam chests.
and these figures as they are, suggest
points for study by the engineer while
side-tracked one station back of the ex-
pected meeting point on account of his
and feeding 5 drops per minute. Here
we have friction surface in cylinder, 14.40
sq. ft. ; in valve, 2.87 sq. ft., a total of 17.27
sq. ft.; in one mile we have 10,372.60 sq.
ft. in cylinders and 2,070.92 sq. ft. in
chests; total, 12,443.52 sq. ft. per mile,
which gives us 1.244.35 sq. ft. for each
drop of oil to lubricate.
For a compound I have taken a 17 and
28x32 in. cylinder engine, 57 in. drivers.
210 pounds steam pressure, weight on
drivers 176,000, tractive power 43,000;
piston values, 11 in.; speed and feed same
as before. Results as follows: 17 in.
cylinder. 11,866 sq. ft. friction surface, 28
in. cylinder, 19.54 sq. It.; valves. 8.635
sq. ft. ; a total of 40.03 sq. ft., as against
17.27 sq. feet, in the simple engine, or an
increase of 22.77 sq. ft. or 1.317 per cent
In one mile run we have in the 17 in.
cylinder 8,396.85 sq. ft.: in the 28 in.
cylinder 13,827.28 sq. ft., and in
valves, 6.1 10.47 sq. ft, a total of 2S.334.61
ii8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
sq. ft., or 2,833.46 sq. ft. per drop of oil.
This amounts to an increase in work ex-
pected of each drop of oil over the 22x30
of 1,589.11 sq. ft., or equal to 1.27 per
cent. The difference in percentages of
increase of 1.317 per cent, and 1.27 per
cent, arises from the variation of the
diameters of drivers, the variation in
both instances equalling .04 per cent. I
have made no allowance for the variation
in dimensions of steam passages, those in
the compound containing much greater
area than those in simple engine, and all
retaining a portion of the oil intended for
lubrication. Valve oil in service, from
the time it leaves the choke plug at lubri-
cator until taken up by the steam is in
the form of an emulsion. The steam at a
temperature of nearly 400, becomes
saturated with this oil in suspension,
we note that as steam is exhausted from
the high pressure cylinder of a com-
pound at a higher pressure and conse-
quently with greater temperature than
in the simple engine. It follows that less
condensation takes place in the high
pressure cylinder, hence less oil is left
on the walls of this cylinder. The greater
part of the oil passes over into the low
pressure cylinder, and a portion of it
passes out at the exhaust. This can be
readily shown by examining the condi-
tions which exist in any power plant
using a condensing engine.
As a help to the fuller consideration
of this comparison let me point out that
in the 22x30 in. engine, at an 8 in. cut-
off, we have 1,260.56 cu. ft. of steam at
boiler pressure used per mile, expanded
to 4,754.11 cu. ft., which gives us 475 cu.
MEETING OF BOARD OI-' ENGLISH RAILW.W DIRECTORS.
only a few degrees below the vaporizin.a;
point of the oil; steam enters the cylinder
and comes in contact with a surface
cooled by the expansion and exhaust of
the previous stroke; condensation takes
place and a portion of the oil thus held
in the steam is deposited upon the walls
of the cylinder. Those portions which
contain the greater thickness of metal
and consequently retain the greater
amount of heat, receive the lesser por-
tion of oil, notably the upper part of
cylinder and the piston head. A portion
of this oil must necessarily pass away in
the drip from cylinder cocks and other
avenues of escaping steam, so that we
have only a portion of our drop for ac-
tual service, how much I know not. I
■cannot see where, according to the
figures shown, we have any to spare.
The temperature of steam is governed
b}' the pressure under which it is used,
and as compounding has been adopted
as a remedy for cylinder condensation.
ft. of steam to be saturated by one drop
of oil, with which to lubricate 1,244.50
sq. ft. of surface.
In the compound we have 927 cu. ft.
of steam at boiler pressure, expanded to
10,946.10 cu. ft., to be saturated by one
drop of oil, and expected to lubricate
2,222.41 sq. ft. of surface.
These are hard, cold facts, and not idle
curiosities. Is it any wonder that we
hear of broken packing rings and cut
cylinders and valves; bushings put in
cylinders less than one year old? Is it
any wonder that valve motion wears out
in a short time, blades and stems buckle
and engines go lame? I say no, it is
not, and until we become educated up to
the fact that increased friction surface
means more oil in proportion, there re-
mains a long array of ills which the mod-
ern locomotive is heir to, v^fhich can only
bo cured by oil in alopathic doses. More
oil on the road means less expense in the
back shop, and more dollars saved with
which to buy new engines. When
railroad companies come fully to realize
this point the expense of maintenance,
and not the thousand mile cost of oil,
will become the ruling fad. Yours,
C. B. SOPPER.
Denver, Col.
An English Railway Board.
Tlie cartoon to which the above cap-
tion belongs is reproduced from Truth.
It is a graphic story that tells about the
braking forces which have kept British
railways untouched by innovations and
apart from all ideas of progress. The
cartoon is accompanied by the following
rhymed prose:
How strange are the ways of the Eng-
lish! A railway, of all things, is that
which requireth the men who control it
to know what it is they are at. Great
energy surely it needeth in those who
its doings direct; youth, ardor, initia-
tive, impulse, are what in its board we
expect. But lo! when I looked at the
table round which its directorate drew,
'twas a posse of fussy old parties that
met my inquisitive view. Most were not
only aged, but feeble; some deaf; and
some not far from blind; and to any-
thing rather than business, so far as 1
noticed, inclined. Some had come in
bath-chairs, some on crutches; whilst
some had ear-trumpets to use before
they could hear their friends' gossip, or
even discuss the day's news. So 'twas
no easy task for the chairman, advised
by ofificials of note, to induce his loqua-
cious directors themselves to their task
to devote. And when they did grapple
with questions, or take at the minutes
a look, it was always, I noted, a sort of
old fogyish view that they took. Did
the public want faster expresses? In a
carping and querulous tone the directors
cried, "Bother the public! Why can't
they just leave well alone?" Did inven-
tors suggest new inventions — new en-
gines, new coaches? "Oh, dear!" sighed
the portly old men round the table.
"Why, why with our line interfere? Our
rate's fast enough for our comfort; it's
the same that we traveled when lads.
What's the "ood, then, of these innova-
tions? We don't want these new fangled
fads!"
Old-Tlme Railroad Reminiscences.
Editors: Many of the locomotive en-
gineers at present employed in that call-
ing are not compelled to strenuously
rack their brain to recall some incident
in their career when at a most unex-
pected moment some real or imaginary
obstruction has loomed up in their im-
mediate front, or something went wrong,
which resulted in their hair assuming a
more or less perpendicular position from
the normal it usually occupies.
During my days as a C., B. & Q. en-
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
119
giiiccr, i occasionally was subjected to
annoyances of this character, though, as
a rule, the scarce did not fully material-
ize until after the incident was closed,
but I well remember an experience which
happened one night quite a number of
years ago, when the terror came upon
me in an unguarded moment, causing
my hat to rest on top of my vertically
standing hirsute adornment as cthcrcaly
as a bandanna handkerchief nn tlie sum-
mit of a briar bush.
At the time the incident occurred, I
was running the "Winona" No. 49, on
the night express, known as the Atlan-
tic and Pacific, and from the fact that
the engine was small, the train heavy and
and the grades steep, in approaching the
latter the highest possible speed was at-
tained, regardless of the time-card rule
"no passenger train must exceed a speed
of one mile in two minutes," to olTset
the time sure to be lost in climbing the
hill.
Now, to digress a little, I would say
that the previous night, on our way west,
the operator at Osceola had related to
us a choice morsel of news, which short-
ly prior to our arrival had passed over
the wire, to the effect that about sunset
the evening before a Chicago, Rock
Island & Pacific train had been held up
at Avoca by the James brothers, who at
the time, were actively engaged in con-
ducting financial collections from the un-
wary in States adjoining the Mississippi
River, the engineer killed and the ex-
press car looted of a considerable sum
of money.
The freebooters, when last seen, had
mounted their horses and started in a
southerly direction, which would indi-
cate their crossing our track, some forty
miles south of the scene of action, about
the same time in the early morning that
we would have occasion to use it. How-
ever, we pulled out and reached our des-
tination without molestation.
On our return trip, it was made known
to me before leaving that a large amount
of money was in the express car, such
notice usually being given to the en-
gineer in those days on our road; also
a number of well-armed guards, the prac-
tice being then, as now, to lock the
stable doors after the other fellow's
horse had been stolen, but this did not
relieve my mind, as the hold-up at Avoca
had been accomplished by removing the
fish plates and spikes and, with a rope
through the bolt holes in the rail, shift-
ing it inwardly immediately ahead of the
pilot, which ditched the engine and for-
ward portion of the train.
The shades of night were falling as we
started on our journey, and in the course
of an hour's run, it had grown intensely
dark and forbidding. No stars peered
through the dense clouds, no lamps
designated the location and position of
switch rails, and few friendly lights
sparkled from depots and houses adjoin-
ing the track to relieve the monotony,
which every engineer experiences at such
time, as we rapidly passed over the rails,
but everything moved along serenely un-
til Tyrone had been left behind.
From this point to the foot of Albia
hill, some six miles, the track slightly
descended, following a narrow, heavily
wooded valley, with no signs of human
habitation or life on cither side.
Passing Tyrone at a good speed, T
let the 49 out for her run at the hill.
As we rapidly passed down the valley,
the time being about midnight, I was
seated with my head out of the cab win-
dow, deeply wrapped in thoughts of the
previous night's robbery and depicting
in my mind the inviting locality we were
tlicn in, for a hold-up, when suddenly,
cautionary signal, but from which, with
my mind engrossed with train robbers,
dismal surroundings and a favorable lo-
cation for gentlemen of the Dick Turpin
stamp to ply their vocation, I received
a mental shaking up that left an impress
from which I did not fully recover for a
considerable time, S. J. Kidder.
Boltless Cylinder and Pramc
Connection.
'I'lie Philadelphia & Reading people
have been using, for some little time,
a cylinder and frame connection, in
which bolts may be said to be "con-
spicuous by their absence." The design
was made and patented by Mr. S. F.
Prince, Jr., superintendent of motive
power of the road. That portion of the
frame to which the cylinder is attached
is made very nearly twice as deep as it
is wide, and it is considerably deeper
than the rest of the frame front.
The portion of the cylinder saddle
which fits over the frame is planed out
parallel and the frame is straight on one
side and tapers at the other, so as to ac-
commodate the large side wedge which
lies beside it, as shown in our illustra-
"BinTti-r'^'
Side lileiiation
BOLTLESS CYLINDER PASTENINC-
Ilnilway i L
Front Elemtion
BY E. G. PRINCE. JR.
as we neared the foot of the grade, two
loud reports, sharp as the crack of a rifle,
resounded, each followed by a blinding
flash, I jumped to my feet, and nearly
simultaneous were the movements to
shut off steam, apply the straight air
brakes and the erection of my hair, the
latter, possibly, leading the other motions
— I, meantime, imagining those woods
full of the James brothers' coterie. By
the time we had slowed down to perhaps
twenty miles per hour, my deserted
senses had again collected, and I re-
leased the brakes, the fireman came
down from the top of the cab, and I
pulled out for the hill.
As the reader may surmise, it was a
false alarm, so far as my suspicions were
concerned, though one which was en-
countered at that particular point not in-
frequently. Freight train No. 12 was
scheduled in Albia, at the summit of the
grade, slightly ahead of us. and it being
nothing unusual for that train to stall
and double, when such occurred two
torpedoes were placed on the track as a
tion. This frame and wedge cavity in
the saddle has an opening on the under
side, so that the cylinder casting may
be passed over the frame set in its nor-
mal position. When this operation has
been accomplished a binder, lipped-up
on each side of the opening and carried
along the full length of the cylinder cast-
ing, is closely fitted up and bolted to
place. The frame is thus practically
loosely enclosed in a box with rigid
walls, of which the binder forms the
bottom and the three other sides are the
frame seat in the cylinder casting. A
hammered iron wedge the full depth of
the frame is then put in place from the
front and driven home. Two small end
wedges are placed in a vertical position
at the front and back of the cylinder
casting and driven home. All the wedges
are secured by bolts. The two small end
ones have each a bolt passing through
a lug forged on the top and these bolts
are tapped into the frame. The main
wedge is held by one bolt with head
countersunk in the frame so that there
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
is no possibility of a slip in any diiec-
iion.
This method has given entire satisfac-
tion and has the advantage of not weak-
ening the frames with bolt holes. All
the work, with the exception of the bolt
hole through frame and main wedge,
can be done on machines before any of
the parts are assembled. A pair of
cylinders can be removed when neces-
sary, in a surprisingly short space of
time. There is no possibility of the cyl-
inders "working" on the frames, if the
fitting up has been properly done, and
this boltless cyHnder and frame connec-
tion is in its way as up-to-date as the
horseless carriage or the wireless tele-
graph.
Laboratory Locomotive for Cornell
University.
You will be glad to learn that the
Baldwin Locomotive Works has recent-
ly offered to present to the Railway
School of Sibley College a laboratory lo-
comotive of the Vauclain de Glehn type,
especially built to plans to be agreed
upon by the Baldwin Works and myself.
The gift will not be consummated until
a building and a testing machine are pro-
vided for. 1 did not intend to have the
matter get to the public until we saw
our way definitely clear for the providing
of the necessary equipment on which to
'mount the locomotive, but the knowl-
edge of the oflfer from the Baldwin
Works leaked out to the daily papers,
and to prevent any misinformation is the
purpose of the present letter.
The locomotive will be a four-cylin-
der balanced compound like the engine
built for the Plant system, but with four
truck wheels and four driving wheels.
The boiler will be designed to carry up
to .300 pounds gauge pressure. When
the locomotive is run at this pressure
the entire weight of the locomotive can
be thrown upon the driving wheels by
means of a pneumatic cylinder at the
rear connected to an anchor in the foun-
dation. When this traction increasor is
not used the engine will run at 200
pounds gauge pressure. It is intended
to be very easily convertible into a per-
fectly balanced two-cylinder simple en-
gine by the removal of the two high
pressure cylinder, bushings and a change
in the valves. The details of the en-
gine have not as yet been worked out,
but are being figured. No work at all
has as yet been done on the designing of
a testing machine, awaiting the devel-
opment of the design of the locomotive,
its weight, power, wheel base, etc.
When the plans of testing machine and
building are completed and estimates
available, we shall call upon the friends
of Cornell for assistance.
I would add that every fall a series of
locomotive tests is regularly carried on
for our railway seniors through the
kindness of the Delaware, Lackawanna
& Western Railroad upon that portion
of the road which comes into Ithaca. I
have named these "Instruction Tests,"
as they are primarily intended to in-
struct our railway students in the meth-
ods of locomotive testing on the road.
Each cylinder has two indicators with
short, straight pipes, the indicator re-
ducing rig is of the pendulum or sim-
ilar triangle type, geometrically perfect,
practically rigid and light and entirely
satisfactory. The coal is weighed into
bags, water is metered between tank and
injector, hydraulic dynamometer draw
bar used, steam chest diagrams taken,
we use steam-dryness calorimeters in
dome and steam chest, smoke box,
vacuum gauge, take the smoke box tem-
perature, use the Boyer speed recorder,
driver stroke counter and recorder, air
pump stroke counter and recorder; and
we make the various calibrations of dy-
namometer, tank, water meter, boiler,
blower, safety valve, air pump, valve set-
ting, cylinder clearances, etc. The stu-
dents themselves do the work of rigging
up the locomotive for test and stripping
it ready for replacing in its regular ser-
vice. It is not intended that these an-
nual instruction tests should be omitted
after we have a laboratory locomotive.
Toward the end of the senior year a
number of our railway seniors and grad-
uates usually make thesis tests of loco-
motives for different railroads in the
East. The students are in full respon-
sible charge without assistance from the
faculty. The coming spring, among
other tests of railway equipment, there
will be one of the Baltimore & Ohio lo-
comotives upon the Royal Blue limited
train between Philadelphia and Wash-
ington. H. Wade Hibbard,
Prof, of Mech'l Eng'g of Railways.
Fast Passenger Power for the Alton.
(Illustrated on page 117.)
The Chicago & Alton have recently
purchased some 4-6-2 fast passenger en-
gines from the Baldwin Works. These
are very powerful machines, having sim-
ple cylinder 22x28 in. On one engine
the drivers are yi in. diameter, and on
two others they are 80 in. The tractive
weight is 141,700 pounds, and the boiler
pressure is 220 pounds. From these
figures it follows that the calculated trac-
tive elTort which can be exerted by the
engine with the 73 in. drivers is about
34.700 pounds, and the weight on drivers
divided by the tractive effort gives 4.0S
as the ratio of tractive power to adhesive
weight.
The first engine with this wheel ar-
rangement built at the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works was in 1897, for the Millars
Karri & Jarrah Forests Co., Ltd. They
were used on a Western Australian road
of 3 ft. 6 in. gauge. A similar engine as
far as wheel arrangement goes was buiit
S. Morris, and which was illustrated in
for the C. & O. from designs by Mr. W.
our October 1902 issue. An engine of
this 4-6-2 type had been built for the
C, M. & St. P. in iSgs by what was then
the Schenectady Locomotive Works.
The heating surface in the boilers of
these engines amounts to 4.078 sq. ft.;
this equals an area represented by about
61 1-2 ft. length of a country road which
measures I chain, of 66 ft. wide. The
grate area is 54 sq. ft. The boiler is of
Uie straight top wide fire-box variety,
measuring 70 in. in diameter. The Vau-
clain butt joint, with double triangular
welt, is used, having 96 per cent, of the
strength of a solid sheet. This form of
boiler seam was illustrated in our
.August 1902 issue. Expansion or flex-
ible stay bolts are used in the throat
sheet, which is short and slopes at a con-
siderable angle.
As stated above, the diameter of the
driving wheels on one engine is 7i in.,
.Tnd on another 80 in. This was done
for the purpose of determining from
actual service test, which size would
prove best adapted to prevailing condi-
tions on the road. The locomotives are
equipped with the Rushton radial swing
side-bearing truck under the overhang-
ing fire-box. This makes it possible to
pass without difficulty round curves of
14 degrees. The Player traction in-
creaser is also a feature of the construc-
tion of the engine with the smaller driv-
ing wheels. This device operates so as
to practically shorten the spring hanger
at the back of the rear drivers and the
front of the leading drivers, thus placing
greater adhesive weight on the six driv-
ing wheels. Two W. A. B. cylinders,
sdcomplish this result. It is estimated
that when the traction increaser is in use
about 15,000 lbs. is added to the weight
on drivers.
Tlie motion of the engine is indirect,
the transmission bar being arched over
(he leading driving axle, with bolt and
filler underneath. Piston valves are used.
The cab is lighted in the ordinary way
with ample window for the engineer, and
above in the slooping roof there is what
may be called a dormer window on each
side. The tender carries 9 tons of coal
and 8,400 gallons of water, and is built
up high after the manner of many of the
.\lton passenger tenders. This locomo-
tive furnishes a good example of a
modern high-speed passenger engine, and
includes many interesting features. To
use the ordinary language of the road,
these engines will "pull passenger" be-
tween Chicago and St. Louis.
Some of the principal dimensions are
given below:
Cylinder, 22 in. x 28 in.
Boiler— Dia., 70 in.; thick, of sheets, J5 in.; j3 in.
and Yi in.; working pres. 220 lbs.; staying,
crown bar, ^y^ x 6 in.
March, 1903.
!<.\1I.\VA^■ .\\\) L0Cf;.\10TIVE ENGINEERING
I'irebox— Length, 108 in.; »idtli. 72K in.; diplli,
front. 75H in.; back, 64!/^ in.; thick, of shetts.
sides. }» in.; back, >i in ; crown, H in.; tube,
5^ ill.; water space, trout 4J4 in.; sides, 3J^ in.;
back, 2,14 in.
Tuljcs— Material, iron, f^auge No. n ; Nuniber J2H;
dia., 2'4 in.; length, 20 ft.
Heating Surface— Firebox, 2112 .sq. ft., tubes, 3,848
sq. ft.; firebrick lubes, 27 sq. ft.; total, 4,078 sq.
ft.; grate area, 54 sq. ft.
f\ng. truck wheels (bck.) —Dia .42 in ; jour..Sxi2 in.
Wheel base — Kigid, 13 ft. gin; total eiig., 32 ft. 8 in.
total eng. and tender, 62 ft.
Weight— On driving wheels. 141 700 lbs.; on truck.
front, .1,6,300 lbs,; on truck, back. 4i,.soo lbs.;
total engine, 21.900 It, s.
'lank— Capacity, cool, 9 tons ; water, 8,400 gals.
Ten-Wheel Engine for the Rutland.
The Mancliester sh(ji),s of the .'\meri-
can Liicomotive Company have recently
supphed some passenger engines to the
Rutland Railroad. These are of the type
designated hy the builders as 460-155,
which, when interpreted as it is on an-
other page of this issue, settles the wheel
arrangement, the total wciRht and fact
that the engine is sinipK-.
IJIMKNSIONS.
Weight in working order, l^^.ooo lbs.
Weight on drivers, iiH.oo^i lbs.
Weight engine and tender in working order.
271,400 lbs.
Wheel base, driving, 14 ft 10 in.; rigid, 14 ft. 10 in.
wheel base, total. 25 ft 10 in.
Wheel base, total, engine and tender, ffi ft. 3 in.
VAT.VKS.
Valves, piston type, in.sidc admission,
(ireatest travel 6 in.; outside lap, 1 in.
Inside lap, 'A in. clearance. Lead in full gear, o in.
WUKKLS, KTC.
Dia. and length of driving journals, gin. x 11 in.
I^ngine truck, journals. 6 in, dia. x ll in.
BOILKR,
Thickness of plates in barrel and outside of fire
box. ^8, \\. }4 and ^ in.
I-'irebox. length, icSin.; wdh.. 41 in.; depth, front,
76H in.; back. 64^4 in.; plates, thickness, sides.
^\ in.; back, j^^ in.; crown, H in.; tube sheet. J^
in,; water si)ace. 4^ and ,s in. front, 3^ and
4 in. sides, ^% and 4J4 in. back.
Tubes, iron. No. n; gauge, number. 312; dia., 2 in.
Length over tube sheets, 168 in.
Heating surface, tubes. 2.273 47 sq. ft.
Heating surface, fire box. 172.85 sq. ft.
Heating surface, total. 2.446.32 sq. in.
;->:noke stack, top above rail, 14 ft. 7K in.
used on a neighboring road. The report
was to describe the make-up and opera-
tion of the device with a statement of
first and operating cost, and two sheets
of the company's stationery were used in
carrying out instructions. The G. S. put
a few words on the turn-down corner of
the correspondence, when it reached him,
and the chief clerk regarded it as simply
perfect. The G. S. had written. "We will
not use this." The foreman was subse-
quently "tackled" by the clerk, about the
great length of his letter, and he replied
som.ething after this manner: "See here,
young man, we all know that you wrote
out that circular for the G. S. to sign,
headed, "Brief and Businesslike Corre-
spondence,' in which such expressions a»
'laconic phraseology' and 'short Anglo-
Saxon words' are used. If I wasn't afraid
of stirring up trouble I'd out-do you and
the G. S. at one go. I could fix the cir-
cular up in one word, just to show how
really brief I could be, and if you could
boil down, distill, wring out or extract
TEN-WHEEL PASSENGER ENGINE FOR THE RUTLAND RAILROAD
The cylinders arc ^0x26 in., the diam-
eter of the drivers are 69 in., they carry
118,000 pounds and the working pressure
is 200 pounds. The theoretical tractive
effort which this machine can e.xert is
about 25,600 pounds. The ratio of ad-
hesive weight to tractive power is 4.6.
The valve motion here is direct, as the
rocker arms are both turned down and
the transmission bar passes up over the
axle of the Icadin.s: driver. The springs
are all undcrhuni;. carried by hangers,
which are hooked over and rest on top
<if the boxes. Safety hangers surround
both equalizers.
The boiler is one of the extension
wagon-top style and carries the dome on
the first circular sheet, which is 72 in. in
diameter: the gusset sheet reduces the
diameter of the boiler to 61 in. at the
front end. The total heating surf:ice is
2,446 sq. ft., and there are 30 sq. ft. of
grate surface. The "Perfection" smoke
consumers are used on these engines.
Some of the more important dimen-
sions are subjoined:
TENDER.
W^eight. empty. 47.000 Uis.
Journals, dia and lenglh. 5 in. dia. x 9 in.
Wheel base. 18 ft, gin ; frame, loin steel channels.
Water capacity. 5,900 U S. gallons.
Coal capacity. 10 tons
Brevity Is the Soul of Wit.
.\ certain chief clerk to a general su-
perintendent regarded his superior as a
model letter-writer, brevity being the
characteristic most admired. The clerk
let it be widely known that many of the
lesser officials might, in his opinion, re-
duce the length of their letters, and fol-
low the lead of the G. S. This stickler
for concise English persuaded his* chiel.
in a moment of weakness brought
on by flattery, to permit the is-
suing of an advisory circular' in
which the value of condensed corre-
spondence was extolled, and it happened
that the general foreman was the first
transgressor. It seems the M. M. had
requested and obtained permission for
his general foreman to examine and re-
port upon the merits of a certain device.
the quintessence of absolute truth about
it, more fully, more concisely, or with
more deadly accuracy. I'd give you my
month's pay. I'd just write 'Bosh' across
the face of that circular, and so express
the universal opinion of your efforts to
reduce correspondence. It's easy enough
to say yes or no to a long statement, but
it isn't easy to make a long statement as
short as ves and no."
The business of the late William C.
Baker, which is now managed by his
daughter, Miss C. A. Baker, has been
unusually prosperous this season. In ad-
dition to supplying a great many heaters
for steam railways, they have worked
into a good business of heating ^.treet
cars, which is rapidly increasing. Miss
Baker is a most generous emploj'er of
labor and is extremely popular with her
people.
It is a poor heart that never rejoices;
and our hearts are not poor — no! — Mr.
Pecksniff.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
U^'&i^^Ei$ineerii$
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "Loceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, "Locauto."
Business Department:
ANGUS SINCI/AIR, President.
FRED M. NELI/IS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Bditorlal Department :
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NEI/I/IS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, Aisoclate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKERJ
I204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative :
THE I<OCOMOTIVE PUBI<1SHING
CO., I,td. 102a Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, I/Ondon.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCI/AIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
Ss,oo per year^ $i.oo for six months^ postage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of the world, $2-50, or ten shillings.
Single copies^ 20 cents. Remit dv Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Registered
Letter.
Mailing address can be changed as often as neces-
$ary — always give old and new address, and if you
lubscribed in a club state who got it up.
Please gtve prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly.
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., 1Q03.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
To Prevent Boiler Explosions.
Within one period of ten days last
month we received mention of seven ex-
plosions of locomotive boilers. Several
of them started with the firebox crown
sheet coming down which indicated
shortness of water, but the others were
reported as mysterious occurrences. It
nearly always happens that when the
business of railroads is particularly ac-
tive, boiler accidents are numerous. Rea-
soning between cause and effect, we con-
clude that the eternal inspection vigi-
lance which keeps boilers free from se-
rious accidents is frequently relaxed at
such times and that men are put in
charge of locomotives who are not prop-
erly impressed with the necessity for
keeping the crown sheet covered with
water.
Only a few years ago the first move
in the line of investigation to find the
probable cause of a boiler explosion was
to make tests of the material. Only too
often the material was found defective,
but that is not the case nowadays. With
modern specifications and modern steel
plate there is always sufficient strength
if deterioration has not been permitted
to break it down or mistakes have not
been made about the high pressure to be
provided for.
Of late years there has been a ten-
dency to increase the boiler pressure
from 140 to 200 pounds or thereabout,
and in very many cases the strength nec-
essary to safely resist the augmented
pressure has not been provided. The in-
crease of pressure has brought increase
of danger, yet the men responsible for
the safety of boilers are often too apa-
thetic to find out the great danger that
exists. Hundreds of men are working all
the time over a volcano in the shape of
a weak boiler pressed beyond the safe
limit, and they acquire the familiarity
which brings contempt of danger. It is
so human to become reckless of danger
that good government ought to step in
and enforce rules of safety, even al-
though the parties whose life and limbs
are most seriously at stake object to
have measures to promote safety carried
out. The Interstate Commerce Commis-
sion has labored persistently with excel-
lent results to reduce the dangers in-
curred by trainmen and others, and we
think it high time that the same board
was given protecting power over dan-
gerous boilers, or, rather, over boilers
that are likely to become dangerous
through natural deterioration that has
been neglected.
When a disastrous explosion of a lo-
comotive boiler happens the blame is
thrown upon the engineer in charge if
possible, and failing in that, upon the
master mechanic or the foreman imme-
diately responsible for the systematic in-
spection of the boiler; but all these per-
sonages are mere buffers to prevent the
shocks of the real responsibility from
flying upward to the real culprits. The
demand to keep the motive power work-
ing at any cost is what induces the un-
derlings to risk the neglect of inspection.
The prevailing sentiment among direc-
tors is "move freight and passengers at
all hazards. Do the work safely if prac-
ticable, but move it."
Laws ought to be established that
would make the systematic inspection of
boilers imperative periodically, and the
head of the mechanical department
should be held responsible for neglect of
the very important work. He, of course,
would pass upward the responsibility for
accidents.
Some railroad companies have made
contracts with boiler insurance com-
panies to assume the responsibility of
keeping their boilers safe. Where that
is done everybody interested may rest
assured that no boiler is at work with
scores of stay bolts broken, which is a
very common condition where system-
atic inspection is neglected. Hiring the
services of an insurance company to
keep the boilers safe is better than de-
pending upon the overworked foreman
boilermaker; but a still better method
could easily be arranged to be carried
out by powers whose actions would be
backed by national authority.
The United States Government holds
supervision 01 marine boilers, and it is
generally conceded that this system of
control is right and proper. On the
same principle it would be a small ex-
tension of government authority to put
the boilers of all locomotives engaged in
interstate commerce under the control of
the Interstate Commerce Commission.
Many people supposed, when Congress
put power in the hands of the Interstate
Commerce Commission, to com.pel rail-
road companies to equip their cars with
safety appliances, that the law would re-
main a dead letter; but it was enforced;
and many people are alive to-day enjoy-
ing the pursuit of happiness who would
be in their graves had the law relating
to the compulsory use of safety appli-
ances been permitted to fall into desue-
tude. The extension of the law to in-
clude locomotive boilers would be one of
the most humane acts that Congress
could possibly put in force.
There is no rational reason why the
boilers of locomotives engaged in inter-
state commerce should be exempted from
government inspection and supervision
when boilers of steamers are subject to
this form of control. The lives of people
traveling on railroads are certainly as
valuable as the lives of those who travel
by water. The practice of requiring ma-
rine boilers to be systematically inspect-
ed by competent boiler experts has
proved one of the best safeguards of hu-
man life ever introduced. An explosion
of a marine boiler is a remarkably rare
occurrence, due directly to proper pe-
riodical inspection. Travelers by land
ought to enjoy similar immunity from
accidents. The same treatment will pro-
duce like results.
A Word for the Resident Inspector in
Prosperous Times.
Macaulay tells us in his magnificent
essay on Warren Hastings that when
tliat statesman was Governor-General of
India the directors of the East India
Company, for whom he was acting as
the highest executive officer, used to send
instructions in which were many just
and humane sentiments, but that the
sum of almost all the instructions that
Hastings ever received from home were
"Govern leniently and send more money;
practice strict justice and moderation
toward neighboring powers and send
more money. Be the father and the op-
pressor of the people; be just and un-
just, moderate and rapacious." We may
in these days hold up our hands in holy
horror or feel surprised and indignant
at what we read, but looked at calmly
and dispassionately, are these instruc-
tions, delivered at various times during
a period of years and skilfully boiled
down by Macaulay to a single sentence
— are they any more impossible of fulfil-
ment than '^ome of tho^e which are given
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMOTIVF. EN'GINEERING
123
at the prosciil time to many an inspector
or even (orcnian in some of our large
manufacturing establishments? Ihe in-
structions when boiled down sometimes
resemble the words, "Detect and stop all
bad work in the shop, but do not restrict
output, lie vigilant above all things to
catch delects, but do not mterfcre witli
output." This impossible line of conduct
is particularly liUcly to be what is
marked out for an nispector belonging
to a large manufacturing concern during
rush times. An inspector sent from the
buying company is, of course, in a very
diflferent situation. We do not say
that instructions arc thus put forth with
all their absurdity stamped upon them.
The directors of the East India Com-
pany had probably no idea of what they
were doing or of how posterity, guided
by the eminent historian, would view
their actions. The fact, however, re-
mains that output generally determines
revenue, and the modern Warren Hast-
ings in the shop is often virtually asked
to "practice strict justice and send more
money."
Wc once heard of a resident inspector
in a large car building establishment who
stopped a certain number of cars one day
for various cases of defective workman-
ship. The man in charge of the shop
said: "Can't you let them go, it will
stick me badly in output if you don't?"
The in.spector replied: "As far as I am
personally concerned — yes, and yes all
the more if the defects pointed out to-
day do not appear to-morrow or the
next day since you have had warning,
but you can't guarantee to reform all
tliose practices without making the de-
linquents do the work over again, and if
they work properly they won't turn out
as much as they are doing now." We
are afraid the output department ulti-
mately triumphed, though we believe
tlie inspector did not cave in.
The late Salmon 1'. Chase once said,
when there were any number of ar-
guments being put forward by pol-
iticians to show liow the govern-
ment might best resume specie pay-
ments after the war — "the way to
resume is to resume!" and applying
that idea now, the way to do good work
is to do good and not to talk to the in-
spector about it. There are some men
who seem to think that by carefully ex-
plaining to an inspector how awkward
it would be, and how much time it would
consume, to cut out, say, a loose rivet
in an out-of-the-way corner, that the ex-
planation somehow makes the rivet
tight, and the inspector ought to be
thoroughly satisfied. If the unreasona-
ble inspector has any sort of hazy idea
that the ability to drive a tight rivet
should reside in a man's arms and not
in his mouth, he will probably remain
unsatisfied, even if the rivet is most awk-
wardly paced. The whole thing boiled
down again amounts to "Insist on ab-
solutely perfect workmanship every time,
but, for goodness' sake, don't hamper
output in any way."
It is just possible thai buyers may be
in some way morally responsible for
part of this output craze with which the
resident inspector has to fight. A great
many railroads renew their equipment
l)y fits and starts, and though they make
maintenance a daily study and insist
upon it being properly carried on by tlie
rank and file. They often seem to lose
sight of the fact that at the very best
only a definite percentage of their equip-
ment can be maintained. Cars and en-
gines are bound eventually to get
beyond the economical repair point,
and on the very best roads in
the land, every year sees some equip-
ment ready for the scrap heap. Those
roads arc wise who know approximately
the yearly percentage of loss and make
it good by the systematic introduction
of new stock. It is the roads which or-
der equipment by fits and starts which
insist most strongly on "time" deliveries,
and the "output" department of the
manufacturing establishments is apt to
feel that the resident inspector is, under
all circumstances, a man who ought met-
aphorically to retire to a very consider-
able distance and assume an easy and
comfortable posture in an armchair.
The resident inspector, if he gets any-
thing like a fair chance, is often very
useful safety appliance, and where he is
efficient he is generally a reputation pre ■
server for his firm.
The Westfield Disaster.
On the evening of January 27 an ex-
press train on the Central Railroad of
New Jersey ran into the rear of a de-
layed local train at Westfield. N. J.,
about 20 miles south of New York. Sev-
eral of the cars were badly smashed and
the wreck took fire, so that between the
collision and the fire 23 persons lost their
lives and many others were injured. That
part of the Central Railroad of New
Jersey is operated under an automatic
block signal system, which was in per-
fect order on the night of the accident.
The engineer, James H. Davis, passed
three danger signals before he struck
the local train. He was having a little
difficulty with the injector, and steam
was escaping from a broken steam chest,
which obscured the view ahead some-
what. The injector and the steam dis-
tracted his attention for the few seconds
that a train running 60 or 70 miles an
hour takes to pass over the distance that
stationary signals are within the scope of
vision, and the trains were almost to-
gether before the danger was perceived.
The engineer, who died of injuries re-
ceived in the collision, is justly held re-
sponsible for the accident: but those
who blame him ought to try and put
themselves in his place for one short
minute, in which the whole of the trag-
edy was prepared by the engineer per-
mitting his mind to be concentrated upon
one duty that for the time seemed of
supreme importance.
As New York is the headquarters of
yellow journalism of the United States,
that class of publication outdid itself in
extravagant accounts of the accident and
of ridiculous recommendations of how
to prevent train collisions. The engine
that caused the accident was of the
Wootten type, which has the cab on top
of the boiler. The yellow journals called
this a camel-back boiler engine, and all
of them demanded that laws be passed
immediately requiring that three meij
must be employed on these engines. An-
other demand made was for laws com-
pelling railroad companies to equip their
lines with automatic appliances that will
shut off steam and apply the brakes with-
out the action of the engineer in case of
impending danger.
Judging from our own experience in
cabs of Wootten locomotives, and from
the views of engineers whose business
it is to handle those engines daily, we do
not think that safety would be increased
by having two men in the cab. Rail-
road companies established a rule pro-
hibiting others except the engineer and
fireman from riding on locomotives,
principally because the visiting dis-
tracted the engineman's attention from
his duties with dangerous consequences.
The same objections hold to putting an
idle man as a regular thing in the cab.
The appliances invented to stop trains
automatically are at present like nearly
all emergency appliances, very liable to
be out of order when the rare emergency
arrives. A railway appliance not in regu-
lar use has been found by experience to
be an extra source of danger.
Railway trains will never be operated
without some danger, and we fail to per-
ceive that anything will ever be in-
vented which will dispense with the care.
intelligence and judgment of the human
direction. The public may wisely de-
mand that railroad companies shall use
the most approved appliances for pro-
moting safety — it is the right and priv-
ilege of the people to demand the em-
ployment of reliable, skilful and efficient
employees, but they have no right to
force upon transportation companies
methods or appliances that do not bear
the stamp of reliable practicability.
When railroad companies employ re-
liable and efficiently trained men, it is
their dutj' to see that their employees arc
kept keyed up to a sound tone of effi-
ciency, a duty which, there is reason to
believe, is lamentably neglected. The
number of rear-end collisions that have
happened lately, in presence of auto-
matic block signals, leads to the infer-
ence that the engineers have fallen into
the habit of taking chances in running
past signals that stand at danger. Men
responsible for making time with heai-j'.
124
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
fast trains are under strong temptation
to violate a rule which will save a few
seconds, but the habitual violation of the
rule to stop before a danger signal will
eventually lead to disaster. When rules
are habitually violated the officials are to
blame.
Having equipped their property with
the most approved safety appliances, and
having employed efficient help, which is
properly discipline'd. a railroad company
has performed its whole duty to the trav-
eling public. Accidents intervening
against those precautions are inevitable
and unavoidable.
Disregarding Signals.
A curious circumstance has often been
observed when a highly civilized nation
is engaged in war with savage tribes.
The curious circumstance is that what
will put a civilized soldier liors de combat
does not necessarily check the onrush of
the savage. In the Zulu war, sable war-
riors were frequently found whose bodies
had been penetrated by bullets, and who,
though mortally wounded, were, never-
theless, able to continue the charge, and
for a certain length of time, to fight with
their enemies at close quarters. It was
to meet such cases that the dumduiri, or
"man-stopping bullet" was produced.
There is abundant evidence that in the
present state of the art of railroad opera-
tion, there is room for some sort of dum-
dum train signal — one that will not only
indicate danger, but one which will
actually prevent a train rushing on when
it should stop. The recent serious rear
collision on the line of Central Railroad
of New Jersey and the accident in the
New York Central tunnel about a year
ago, both of which have, we believe, been
atrributed to the disregard of danger sig-
nals, has focussed public attention on the
feasibility of a train-stopping signal.
Last month we published the substance
of an account of some tests made in
Germany with a new safety device for
railways (page 93), which had been com-
municated to our government by the
United States Consul-General at Berlin.
A "third rail" laid in the center of the
track can, when electrically charged,
be made to audibly and visibly warn the
engineer of danger and apply the brakes.
Another safety device is thus described
by the New York Tribune: "On Swiss
roads tests are being made with the fol-
lowing plan: At points where trouble
is anticipated a stout metal arm is placed
between the rails and arranged so that it
can lie down when no service is required,
but it can be raised on end by block sig-
nal or other apparatus when there is
danger ahead. On the under side of the
locomotive is a swinging lever, which
will pass clear of the arm when the lat-
ter is in the 'safety' position, but will
be hit thereby when the arm has been
thrown up. The motion of the lever au-
tomatically sets the air-brakes and warns
the engineer."
There have been many and various de-
vices brought out in this country for deal-
ing -with a moving train it it runs past a
block signal. The Kinsman method of
train control was designed to close the
throttle and apply brakes, the engineer,
however, being free to reopen the throt-
tle and release brakes, if he saw fit. The
Miller block signal apparatus is a most
ingenious device for reproducing in the
cab the same indications which are
shown on the stationary block signals
along the track. As appropriate electric
lamps glow steadily in the cab in front
of the engineer he cannot pass the signal
so given, without seeing it. The visibility
of the signal is thus virtually prolonged.
This system, as far as we know, does not
apply brakes.
A train signal, which will no doubt
be developed before long for use on
crowded lines where track capacity is
taxed to the utmost, we may venture
to predict, will be competent to deal
with the engineer who "takes chances"
or has missed a signal for any reason,
just as the dumdum bullet deals with
the onrushing savage — it will stop him.
We do not believe that there will be an
expensive or elaborate apparatus evolved,
that is not necessary, but the device
must be always effective and not liable to
derangement. The Boston elevated road
has automatic stop signals installed by
the Union Switch and Signal Company,
Not long ago one of these stopped a
train which was proceeding past a danger
indication, owing to the motorman hav-
ing fainted.
The serious point about the responsi-
bility of an engineer in the matter of
obeying signal indications is that prac-
tically he does not share it with
others. Whatever may be the theory
regarding the fireman's responsibility
in the matter, he does not invariably
look for these signals, and he is usu-
ally not favorably placed to see them,
and his work prevents him from be-
ing always on the lookout, nor does
the conductor personally note the engi-
neer's obedience or the reverse at every
semaphore and in every block, and the
passenger brakeman is in much the same
position as the conductor. While we ad-
mit that all this is the case, we do not
think the "third man" in the cab is the
correct solution of the problem, for rea-
sons which we give elsewhere.
A device that would simply open an
air valve somewhere in the train line, and
apply the brakes in the emergency, vifould
be a most useful and efficient safety de-
vice. Its value in foggy or snowy weather
does not require to be enlarged upon.
The valve should, when once opened,
not be closable by a person on the en-
gine, thus insuring that the stop called
for by the signal be actually made. The
stop having been made, enginemen and
trainmen would all strikingly realize the
situation perhaps without the need of a
second lesson. In any case the ^alve
could be made to register its operation,
which would be an aid in the enforcement
of discipline.
An argument against the use of such
an automatic stop signal is that in time
men would rely solely on it and relax
their vigilance and if the signal got out
of order, it might give no indication of
its derangement and so cause an acci-
dent. Relying upon automatic mechan-
ism, which has to be kept in good order,
is exactly what men do who travel at
high speeds, and expect the air-brake to
stop the train in a given distance. If
they did not have confidence in the brake
they could not maintain the speed up to
the point they now do. The signal, if it
ever comes, would have to be main-
tained in thoroughly good order just as
the brake is now. If such a device
was in successful operation the pos-
sibility of "taking chances" in the
hope that a signal will "clear"
at the last moment, or the hon-
est failure to see a danger indication,
would then be dealt with alike, in the im-
perative demand for absolute safety. An
automatic signal showing "stop" would
then not only silently give warning, but
would actually halt the train before the
menace of danger which it indicates had
developed into death-dealing catastro-
phe. The gradual elimination of that
most uncertain factor, the human ele-
ment, in railroad operation is the only
road to safety, because, while men may
dare to put conjecture in the place of
certainty, or may, with preoccupied
mi#d, pass a danger signal, with all the
terrible possibilities which that act in-
volves; the old French proverb will still
hold true with an added and intensely
sinister significance: "It is the unex-
pected which happens."
Unpopularity of tiie Pooling System.
There has been so little said about
the pooling of locomotives during the
last year that we supposed the system
had been improved so much that engine-
men had become reconciled to it and the
railroad officials were finding that it in-
creased the number of engines available
for hauling trains, thereby increasing
the power available for service. We
supposed that all concerned were en-
joying the advantages claimed for the
pooling system, and the natural infer-
ence was that experience had smoothed
down the disadvantages until they were
out of sight. The advantage claimed
for operating locomotives with different
crews are that it saves a large invest-
ment of capital in power, decreases the
amount of fuel wasted in housing, bank-
ing fires and restarting them, and saves
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
125
round- liousc room and fuel and plant
ior warming them in cold weather.
Where there are an unequal number of
trains in opposite directions the pool
system gives the men equal hours of
rest and equal hours of labor.
We recently had a visit from the su-
perintendent of motive power of a large
railroad system which has for years
operated its locomotives on the pool sys-
tem, and the subject of pooling coming
up in the course of conversation, he
spoke very vigorously against it. In-
stead of increasing the power available
for moving the congestion of freight
cars be expressed the belief that it
tended to reduce the number of loco-
motives ready for work. We published
several years ago a letter from a rail-
toad superintendent enumerating a va-
riety of disadvantages inseparable from
the pooling system which covered the
objections raised by our visitor. He ad-
mitted that it was impossible to change
human nature sufficiently to make an
engineer or fireman working in a pool
take the same interest in an engine that
they handled once a month as they
did when they had the same engine
■every trip they made. The personal
care bestowed upon locomotives has
more money value to railroad com-
panies than it has been the custom to
recognize.
An engineer once asked us the ques-
tion, "Will the pooling system of de-
spatching engines ever be done away
■with?" We answered, "When experience
has proved the system less remunera-
tive, as more expensive to maintain than
where each crew has and keeps its own
individual engine, then will pooling be
abolished." We are now inclined to
modify that opinion. There are rail-
roads now whose officials believe that
the pooling system is more expensive
than the individual system, but the diffi-
culties of making a change are too great
to be carried out during the present
rush of business. Our visitor informed
us that they were working to modify
the pool system and that an entire
change will be effected gradually. He
discussed various phases of the pooling
system, one of his strongest objections
being that pooled engines broke down
on the road frequently and often de-
moralized the train service to an extent
never experienced with engines run on
the individual engine system.
The following are a few of the leading
disadvantages of the pooling system as
described by a railroad official who had
endured the grief and worries which the
system entails: "Engines go over the
road with rods and driving boxes pound-
■ing, injectors that take part of a week
to prime, injector throttles leaking,
lubricators with glasses full of sediment
and the joints leaking, handles broken
oflf gauge cocks and air pump throttle,
an air pump that does more groaning
than pumping, a fire-door that won't
stay open, a shaker-bar that slips off
ihe post and permits the fireman to go
back against the coal gate or else take
a run for the boiler head, and other de-
fects too numerous to mcntiop.
The wear of valves and running gear
is great on account of some men being
careless, and too close attention to oil
records on the part of others. An en-
gineer can make an oil record at some
other's expense, by using just enough
to get over the road. The next man on
the engine must make up for the defi-
ciency or be troubled by squeaky valves,
hot boxes and delay reports. The en-
gine soon gets lame, and as she is in the
pool it is not reported, as one man does
not care to report more work than an-
other, and the crew do not expect to get
the engine again, so do not care.
The steaming qualities of engines are
neglected. A fireman has a new engine
to learn each trip. As a man must
learn to fire an engine before he can be
economical with fuel there is a great
waste of coal, as each trip is an experi-
ment. One man succeeds with a poor
engine and gets over the road, so as
long as anybody can keep her hot there
is no change made, as no two suggest
the same remedy. As a man is prob-
ably on an engine only one trip he does
not have time to locate the trouble, then
somebody else tries it and so the engine
continues a poor steamer."
Overloaded Trains Cause Freight
Congestion.
The freight congestion which all of the
roads West and East are experiencing
at the present time, due in most part to
their inability to furnish sufficient motive
power to move the enormous quantities
of coal which is being daily taken from
the mines is the worst known in the his-
tory of local railroading. The blockade
of freight of all descriptions extends
from Boston and other New England
points all the way into Chicago and
nearly all of the terminals in the South
and Southwest. Every available inch of
track comprising the extensive yards of
the trunk lines between New York and
Chicago is crowded with freight cars
which cannot be moved, and the most
favorable views of those familiar with
the conditions cannot see the immediate
relief of the situation. Instead, the offi-
cials state that the situation will become
still more severe.
In a great many instances those re-
sponsible for the congestion of freight
traffic go the wrong way to relieve it.
A recent dispatch says that general man-
agers of Western railroads have agreed
to effect a great reduction in operating
expenses to offset the increase in price
of all railway supplies and labor. The
plan is to reduce the speed of freight
trains about 20 per cent., so fewer but
longer trains can be hauled. There will
be a small saving in wages, because of
the reduction in the number of trains,
but this is an incidental saving and is
not one of the chief objects aimed at by
the managers.
That is exactly the way to make the
congestion worse and the motive power
less efficient. Correspondents of Rail-
way AND LOCO.MOTIVE ENGINEERING who
have made a special study of train
movements have repeatedly demon-
strated in our pages that an engine
loaded to pull a train at a speed of 18
miles an hour would earn considerably
more revenue than one loaded down to
a speed of 12 miles an hour. If railroad
officials would study the earnings of en-
gines hauling stock trains that have to
be run at moderately high speed, they
would learn something that would pre-
vent them from talking about reducing
the speed of freight trains to reduce ex-
pense.
An excellent analysis of the work done
by two engines was given by a railroad
official who supervised the experiment.
.\ standard engine could make 17 1-2
miles an hour with 700 tons behind the
tender. With 800 tons the average speed
was reduced to 10 miles an hour. In
a test of 24 hours the engine hauling 700
tons made 420,000 ton miles, and the
engine hauling 800 tons made 272,000 ton
miles. The fairly loaded engine worked
54 1-2 per cent, more ton miles than the
other.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(13) W. M. A., Bellefontaine, O.,
writes:
We have a number of Atlantic type
engines that have by-pass valves on the
steam chest, they use piston valves and
we have a number of consolidation en-
gines that have piston valves, but no by-
pass valves. What are the functions of
by-pass valves on passenger engines
alone? Would they be of any advantage
on square steam chests? A. — The func-
tion of by-pass valves is to prevent the
churning of air in cylinders or steam
chests when engine is drifting. When
steam is being used the valves close
tightly, but when running shut off, they
open and permit the air in front of a
piston to pass through them to the back
where it is drawn in behind the piston.
On the return stroke the reverse opera-
tion takes place. They are not used ex-
clusively on passenger engines or ex-
clusively on steam chests, but they are
only useful where a piston acts, as they
do away with the churning of air and
so permit freer movement. On an ordi-
nary square slide valve steam chest they
would not be necessary, as the air in the
chest easily passes beside or over the
valve.
(14) A. R. S. asks:
First — Can you give me a brief answer
126
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
to the question, What is a locomotive?
"A. — A locomotive is a steam engine and
boiler carried on wheels, some of which
receive power from the engine for the pro-
pulsion of the vehicle which carries en-
gine, boiler and their necessary attach-
ments. Second — What is steam? A. —
The vapor produced by boiling water.
Third — How does steam pass from the
boiler to drive the engine? A. — When the
throttle valve in the dome is opened the
steam enters the dry pipe, passes to the
branch pipe in the smoke-box, when part
goes down each steam pipe to the steam
passages in the cylinder saddle, from
whence it flows into the steam chest.
From there it is admitted into the cylin-
ders by the valves. Students of such
questions as these ought to have our
valve motion model as an assistant. The
small model costs only ten dollars, or
it is sent to any one who secures twenty-
four subscribers.
(15) Machinist writes:
We had a dispute the other day in the
shop about the water supply that two
sizes of pipes would carry. I wanted to
use two one-inch pipes instead of one
two-inch pipe, and the foreman said I
was off my nut. What was the matter?
A. — You need badly to study Machine
Shop Arithmetic, which is for sale in
this ofifice. We dislike to answer ele-
mentary questions of this character. The
cross section of a pipe is the amount of
space open to let anylhing pass through.
The cross section of one circular inch
is .7854; the area of a circle two inches
diamater is 3.1416, or four times the area
of one inch. A mechanic ought to be
ashamed of not knowing things of this
kind.
(16) M. L. writes:
I am offered at low cost an interest in
the patent of a reversible steam engine
which has only one eccentric. Do you
think it would be a good investment for
the savings of a workman? A. — Do not
put any money in it. Reversing valve
gears with only one eccentric have been
invented repeatedly. If you can obtain
a copy of the Annual Report of the Rail-
way Master Mechanics' Eighteenth Con-
vention, you will find illustrations of
several valve gears that have only one
■ccentric.
(17) R. M. K. writes:
When a person invents a new and
valuable device and pays the government
a high price for getting out a patent, is
it not the duty of the government to pre-
vent others from making use of the de-
vice without paying royalty? A. — Pro-
tecting patentees ought to be the duty of
the government, but it never has per-
formed that duty. Punishment for in-
fringers of patents is left to the law
courts.
(18) Engineer, New York City, asks:
Can you inform me how I ought to
proceed to obtain a license as a marine
engineer? A. — By applying to the Boiler
Inspector's office, in the Post Office,
New York, and passing the examination.
By the study of Hemenway's "Catechism
of the Steam Plant" you will obtain in-
formation that will help you to pass the
examination.
A Typical Vanderbilt Car.
The Vanderbilt I00,ooo-lb. high-side
steel hopper gondola shown in our half-
tone illustration is a typical example of
this form of construction. There are
two center sills which pass through the
middle of the hopper, but there are ho
side sills, except the short ones which
extend from bolster to end sill. Two
upright channel? riveted to the car sides
and terminating at the bolsters, help to
carry the weight. The sheets which form
the sides of the hopper are stiffened with
angles just as a bridge truss would be
made. The car was built by the Cambria
Steel Company for the West Virginia
manufacturer and place of manufacture
and the number of pounds tensile strain
it will bear to the square inch. Boiler
plate made previous to the passage of
the act are assumed to have a tensile
strength of 50,000 pounds to the square
inch.
The rule prescribes that any boiler
having been in use ten years or more
when inspected thereafter shall be
drilled at points near the water line and
at bottom of shell or in the thinnest
place which the inspector can find. The
least thickness of plate at any point is
taken as the thickness of the whole
boiler, on the principle that a chain is
no stronger than its weakest link. Hav-
ing ascertained the actual thickness of
the sheets, one-sixth of the known ten-
sile strength is taken and the pressure
for the particular boiler under examina-
tion is calculated from that. For exam-
ple, a boiler 36 in. in diameter made out
of ,'4 plate is allowed 104.16 pounds to
m.
^^^^^^^^^^^. x^^^^^^^^HS^HHliHi^^^^^^^^H^^^I
BP^jL I
■
'^^^^^^^^^^T^^^P^-'-H
W^
1
BcHb^^^^^' I JTr"'. ' 'ijij^rSin
A TYPICAI, VANDERBILT CAR
Company for the carriage of ore, etc.
The trucks used were also specially de-
signed by Mr. Vanderbilt and were illus-
trated in detail in a former issue. Al-
together the substantial form of con-
struction of this car is apparent to even
a casual observer.
the ijuare in. A table giving diameter
of boiler, thickness of plate and pressure
allowed, facilitates the work.
Qovernment Rule in Boiler Inspection.
A subscriber asks us to tell him what
rule, if any, is used on railroads for the
reduction of pressure on locomotive
boilers on account of deterioration from
age. He also asks what is the practice
of the U. S. Government.
The overhauling of locomotives is
comparatively so frequent that no defi-
nite rule has been adopted by railways
for reducing the pressure from time to
time. The government practice, how-
ever, is interesting and as set forth in
the general rules and regulations pre-
scribed by the board of supervising in-
spectors of steamboats, is an example of
■scientific and safe practice which should
be known to all steam users.
The boiler plates used in the construc-
tion of steamboat boilers are required
to be stamped with the name of the
Heating Surface Compared with
Familiar Things.
The 2-8-2 engines recently, turned out
for the Santa Fe by the Baldwin Loco-
motive Works had each a total heating
surface of 5,366 sq. ft. To get an idea
of what that looks like when spread out.
we may say that it is not quite as large
as the area of the pits in which two 6o-ft.
turn tables can swing. If you cut out the
area enclosed between the rails of only
one of the tables, you will come very
close to the amount of heat-absorbing
surface presented in these boilers. The
tandem compound Decapods built last
year for this road at the Baldwin Works
had 5.390 sq. ft. of heating surface. A
tennis court measures 36-ft. wide by 78-
ft. long, and encloses 2.808 sq. ft. These
Decapods had each a little less than the
equivalent of two tennis courts tucked
away inside their boilers. A strip 3-ft.
wide cut off one side of one tennis court
leaves the rest of the marked oft lawn
verv nearly equal in area to the heating
surface of these monsters.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
127
Air=Brake Department.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NELLIS.
Air Brake Association Convention.
'1 he first raihuad nu'i-liaiiical cuiivon-
ition of the year will be the Tenth Annu-
.al Convention of the Air Brake Associa-
tion, which will be held in Colorado
Springs, Colo., beginning April 28. The
Hotel Alamo has been selected for con-
vention headquarters, and is easily ac-
•cessiblc by the several street car lines
■ of the city. Members should take re-
■ceipts for- all fares paid in Pullman cars,
and upon presentation to the Pullman
agent in Colorado Springs of said re-
ceipts and 1903 membership cards, a free
return ticket will be issued.
It will be interesting to note the suc-
■cess of this first meeting of the Air Brake
Association in the far West, and it is to
be hoped that the success will be greater
than has been achieved by similar conven-
tions in past years. However, should the
meeting not enjoy an attendance equal to
■previous eastern conventions, no mistake
will have been made, for it is but just
that the persistent efforts of the western
men to secure a convention should be
rewarded. Many eastern members have
recognized and believed this, and given
their votes to the cause. Reward will
■ doubtless be theirs, for the committee on
arrangements, which is composed exclu-
sively of western men is exerting itself
to present to the eastern members a
■schedule of entertainment that savors ex-
clusively of western hospitality.
hcieiit prelimiiuiiy work to forecast a
supplcnunlal report that will be of value
to the Association and a credit to the
committee.
Water in Train Pipes.
One of the most important subjects
coming before the Air Brake Associa-
tion Convention next April, is that of
water in train pipes. This subject was
before last year's convention and a great
■deal of valuable information was present-
ed by the committee reporting on it.
However, the important finding of the
committee that the major part of the
water got into the pipe while held in sus-
pension, as moisture in the warm air, in-
stead of gaining entrance at the leaky
paqking nuts of the piston rod of the
air pump, and at dragging hose couplings,
was insufficient ; hence the committee was
•continued over to this year, with especial
instructions to obtain the proper length
of pump discharge pipe to properly cool
the warm air sent by the air pump to the
main reservoir, there to deposit its mois-
ture.
Although the task imposed is exceed-
ingly difficult and hedged with certain an-
noying and uncertain conditions calcu-
lated to seriously interfere with the
work, yet the committee has done suf-
Outfit for tlie Air Bralce Convention.
One of our subscribers, who is also a
member of the Air Brake Association,
has written us, asking what kind of an
outfit of clothing he should take to the
convention, as he has never been in Colo-
rado. Briefly we would advise a straw
hat, light Hannel suit, low shoes, beaver
cap with carlaps, ulster and arctic over-
shoes. The first outfit for the delightful
weather in and about Colorado Springs,
Garden of the Gods and Manitou, and
the latter for a trip up Pike's Peak, if
the blizzards haven't snowed it under.
Oil Cup for Air Cylinder.
We illustrated in this department,
February issue, cuts and description of a
sight feed oil cup for the air cylinder of
air pump.
The time has undoubtedly arrived
when a better method of lubricating the
air cylinder of the air pump should be
furnished than is now supplied. The
little oil cup now used, and having grown
up with the pump since its first introduc-
tion, is really inadequate for the purpose
of oiling the air cylindtr. It was suf-
ficient in years past, when 6 to 25 air-
braked cars were hauled in the average
train; but in modern times, when trains
frequently reach to 80 and 100 operative
air-braked cars, the supply of air pres-
sure being greatly increased, it is but
reasonable to suppose that a more effi-
cient lubricator be supplied for the air
cylinder of the pump.
There are a number of air cylinder
cups on the market, each having its own
value and experience. Some of these
cups are good enough to recommend,
while others at least deserve a trial.
Altogether a cup which is intended to
meet the needs of the air cylinder of the
modern air pump is entitled to consider-
ation, and careful trial and experiment.
There are one or two important feat-
ures that we would suggest be kept
in sight by inventors of oil cups for air
pump cylinders, and these are the point
on the air cylinder at which the cup is
located and the oil introduced into the
cylinder, and the feed be made sight and
automatic. Most of the cups invented
thus far have occupied the place vacated
by the old cup in the top head near the
upright wall of the center piece. One or
two others supplied the oil to the cylin-
der at mid or half stroke of the piston.
This position seems to be the most ad-
vantageous point at which to introduce
the oil, except (or such cups as depend for
their operation upon the minimum and
maximum pressures of the air cylinder.
Cups of this kind would naturally retain
the position on the top head, but there
seems to be so many advantages possible
from the use of mid stroke position that
inventors and designers would do well to
keep this in mind as a very important
consideration.
The sight feed feature seems to be one
worthy of consideration also. Especially
is this true, as that seems to be the better
way of insuring the constant, regular
feed, so essential to perfect lubrication.
The old cup's prime fault is its flood and
drouth way of sending the lubricant to
the cylinder.
Desoe's Colored Air Brake Charts.
We issue with this number the first of
Mr. Desoe's colored air brake charts.
Others will follow.
Colored graphic charts have long been
considered the plainest and most com-
prehensive method of placing a group of
details for. easy and ready understanding.
Mr. Desoe was the originator of colored
graphics to illustrate air brake pressures,
his first work appearing in Locomotive
Engineering seven or eight years ago.
So great was the success of the colored
graphics that other publishers of air brake
matters quickly adopted the scheme.
The latest work of Mr. Desoe along
this line will appear in several numbers of
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. The different pressures in the sev-
eral parts of the air brake system, under
different conditions, have been carefully
prepared by Mr. Desoe in a manner that
is at once readily seen and understood.
Don't miss any of these charts.
Good News — Our Congratulations.
The following notice, issued by F. B.
Smith, M. M., and approved by Mr. John
Henny, Supt. M. P., New Haven Rail-
road, will be good news of Mr. Oviatt,
who merits and deserves the promotion.
"H. C. Oviatt. at present Air Brake
Inspector, is promoted to Foreman of
Engines, he to have charge of all en-
gines and crews and engine despatchers
now under the jurisdiction of Master
Mechanic Hocking, he reporting to and
receiving instructions from Master Me-
chanic Hocking. Engineer E W. .-MI-
ing is promoted to Air Brake Inspector,
vice H. C. Oviatt. promoted. "
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Odd Work for Air Pump.
I am sending you a photograph of a
deep well pump, designed and built by
Mr. Geo. A. Miller, superintendent mo-
tive power and machinery of tlie Florida
East Coast Railway. The steam en-
gine part of the pump was worked
out by Mr. Miller and myself, and
is made of three steam cylinders of
the 8-inch Westinghouse air pump. It
has a stroke of 29 inches and cylinder
bore of 8 3-8 inches. The three cylinders
are set one on top of the other. The
lower main steam valve bush in the top
cylinder, as also in the middle cylinder,
are reamed large enough to allow the
small piston on the main steam valve to
pass through easily. The upper and lower
main steam valve bush, as in the middle
cylinder, are tinned and replaced, and the
space filled in around them with white
metal, as also is the lower main steam
valve bush in the upper cylinder and
upper bush in the bottom cylinder. The
cylinders are fastened together by turned
rivets. Copper joints are used between
the cylinders which are calked inside and
out.
The cylinders were bored out in the
lathe. The main steam valve was length-
ened to correspond and also the revers-
ing valve stem. The bottom head is made
of an old casting, and the exhaust pass-
age made smaller to restrict the exhaust
from the under side of the piston and to
overcome a quick down stroke, due to
weight, etc. It makes an even, easy work-
ing pump, and runs about :;' strokes per
minute, althougli it has worked as high
as 34 per minute.
The well is 85 feet deep, and the pump
piping is 4 inch. The pump is estimated
to throw 2,700 gallons of water per day.
but has never run over 5 hours at a time
yet. Geo. E. McDoug.^l.
Air Brake Repairman Fla. E. Coast Ry.
St. Augustine, Fla.
by other means than looking at the travel
of the piston, and that it is not necessary
to have an air pump smoke in order to
keep up sufficient air to handle the train ;
that the governor is not a safety valve
to be held open constantly, and that the
proper place for the air pump is not on
the left hand side.
Now, Mr. Editor, there are many other
little points, but as I have said enough to
probably bring the indignation of some
of the more sensitive members on my
head, I will stop, only to say to the
members that can possibly attend, go I !
They will be well paid by the pleasure,
experience and knowledge they will have
Urges to Attend Air Brake Conven =
tion.
Although not a member of the Air
Brake Association, I take (his liberty and
opportunity to urgently advise all mem-
bert to strain every effort to attend the
coming Colorado Springs Convention.
In the past (in my humble opinion) the
side excursions have played a very
prominent part of all conventions, and al-
though the recreation of these little
trips is very pleasant, the actual know-
ledge gained has been of little value.
Any trip taken out of Denver will be a
revelation to perhaps 90 per cent, of the
eastern members.
It will be demonstrated there how far
a train can run on one application, how
hot ordinary cast iron wheels can get
without breaking; how to adjust brakes
WATER PUMP BUILT UP KROM THREE
STEAM CYLINDERS OF EIGHT-
INCH AIR PUMPS.
gained; and I can't help thinking that
some of the theory now being practiced
in the East will be somewhat modified.
John Frost.
Kansas Citv. Mo.
constituting a part of tny invention. Figs.
3 and 4 are views showing a valve made
use of to regulate the air pressure.
The operation of tlie device is as fol-
lows : As in the ordinary automatic train-
pipe system, a reduction in the train-pipe-
pressure causes the application of the
brakes, and to hold the brakes the engi-
neer's brake-valve is placed on lap.
Then to increase the pressure in the train-
pipe the valve 32 is opened to admit the
air from the main reservoir I through
the pipe 23 into the upper end of the
the valve-casing 25 to the lower valve
26 in order to force the latter downward-
ly, so that the air can pass from the mairt
reservoir to the train-pipe through the
pipe 28. As the pressure within the train-
pipe 12 is reduced, the valve 26 is forced
downwardly in its casing, and opens the
pipe 28, normally closed by the lower end
of the valve. This permits the air from
the main reservoir to pass into the groove
between the ends of the valve 26, and the
valve is carried down until its lower endl
assumes a position between the points
at which the pipe 29 opens into the valve-
casing 25.
In this position the upper end of the
valve 26 is above the entrance of the
pipe 28, which adjustment permits the
air from the main reservoir to pass in a
moderate stream through the pipe 28 into-
the valve-casing 25 and out through the
pipes 29 and 30 into the train-pipe 12.
This raises the pressure in the train-pipe,
which reacts on the valve 26 for the rea-
son that its lower end is larger, and be-
ing of greater area than is its upper end.
which results in the valve being forced
upwardly again until it assumes the po-
sition shown in Fig. i, in which the pipe
28 is closed, preventing further passage
of the air there-through.
As the pressure in the train-pipe is in-
creased it will pass through the pipe 13
and raise the valve 19 a sufficient height
to admit the flow of air into the auxil-
iary reservoir 7, until the pressure is-
equalized between it and the train-pipe.
As the air flows from the main reser-
voir, the, pump begins tn work and re-
places the air just drawn out, which op-
eration is repeated for every reductioi*
made to set the brakes. To release the
brakes, the excess pressure in main res-
ervoir is turned into the train-pipe 12,
and it will instantly force the valve it>
against its upper seat 21, thus cutting off
all communication between the train-
pipe 12 and the auxiliaries 7 and forcing
the air to pass through the triple valve
in the usual manner.
Benj. W. Smith.
Princeton, hid.
Recharging Device.
Fig. I is a diagrammatic view show-
ing my complete invention with parts
shown in section. Fig. 2 is a sec-
tional view showing the arrangement
and construction of an improved valve
Air brake men attending the Colorado
Springs Convention should do as follows:
Pay dues. Apply for transportation to
nearest official. Take receipts for fares
paid in Pullman cars. Go prepared to
have a profitable and enjoyable trip.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
129
Caboose Brake Apparatus.
Now that "all air" freight trains are
becoming a not unfamiliar sight on other
than western roads, the time is ripe for
a more than passing consideration being
given to the caboose brake apparatus.
The writer believes all cabooses should
have a train pipe, a conductor's valve,
an air gauge, an air brake, where other
than the liglU four-wheel type, a maxi-
mum air braking power of not less than
55 nor over 60 per cent, of the empty
weight, and a rigging so designed that
the hand and air brakes will work to-
gether.
The need of a train pipe on even the
short, four-wheel caboose is so evident
as to require no argument.
The value of a conductor's valve, lo-
cated in the cupola, lays in the prompt-
ness with which the brakes can be ap-
plied from the caboose in case of a de-
night. Such offers the following advan-
tages:
First. It enables the conductor to de-
termine whether the train pipe is open
to the engine, as if this were not so it
would be followed by a steady fall in
pressure. Manifestly, this is of the ut-
most importance, as some of the most
serious accidents have resulted from
an assumed length of open train pipe
that did not exist.
Second. Excessive leakage is made ap-
parent by the rapid fall in pressure when
the supply is cut off or inability to ob-
tain standard pressure when cut in.
There can be little doubt that more
would be done to remedy leakage if ad-
ditional evidence of its existence and
detrimental results were apparent to train
men.
Third. A shortage in pressure with
the engine cut in would tend strongly
until full pressure was regained if the
exact conditions were so easily deter-
mined by the conductor. It is not be-
lieved that, as a general rule, trainmen
are prone to take, knowingly, great
chances of trouble; therefore, that the
too frequent starting of a partially
charged train through the release of
hand brakes would be materially reduced
by the use of the caboose gauge.
Fifth. With such a gauge there would
be no excuse for an inspection for leak-
age and attempt to test brakes when the
pressure was low, now too frequently
the case. This would apply to in.spectors
as well as to train men, as the former
mAGRAMMATIC VIEW OF SMITHS RECHARGING DEVICE.
railment first observed from the ca-
boose or in any other emergency where
the impending danger is liable to be
more serious than the bad effects liable
to follow the use of the conductor's
valve, such as damage to draft rigging,
wheel sliding and stuck brakes.
Abuse of the conductor's valve is no
good reason for not installing it, as
where the fault has proven serious, seal-
ing it, and requiring an explanation
whenever the seal is broken, has proven
an effectual remedy.
But the most valuable feature of all is
the caboose air gauge, so located in the
cupola as to be easily seen, both dav and
toward greater precautions being taken
by trainmen to prevent trouble. This
applies particularly on descending grades
where full pressure may have been had
at the summit, but which is seriously re-
duced by indifferent work on the part
of the engineer or owing to circum-
stances over which he has no control,
as, for example, a material increase in the
leakage.
Fourth. Where, on a heavy descend-
ing grade, the pressure has been much
reduced during a stop, and due to the
brakes being held on, engine cut off or
a burst hose, there would be less likeli-
hood of the train being allowed to start
could be instructed to determine by this
gauge that a sufficient pressure was lad
before inspecting for leakage or signal-
ing to apply brakes for test. They could
as well determine the amount of the re-
duction made for the test and thus do
their work more intelligently.
Inspection of many caboose gauges in-
dicates that such require far less atten-
tion to keep them accurate than do the
locomotive gauges, this being due to the
far more severe service to which the
latter are subjected. In fact, the only
test necessary would be an occasional
comparison with the locomotive gauge,
and which would naturally be made each
I30
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
trip. This would be simplified and serve
as a counter-check if conductors were
required to note on their defect cards for
each trip the maximum pressure carried,
thus checking both the caboose and en-
gine gauge, and the train pipe regulator
rrjl
FIC. 2
as well. A single pointer gauge is all
that is needed, and such with a fairly
good mechanism in a plain but substan-
tial case, can be obtained at a very rea-
sonable price, with no sacrifice of excel-
lence.
An air brakeman with large experience
and observation, in answer to an inquiry
on this subject said, after stating that on
the Santa Fe lines west of Albuquerque,
N. M., all cabooses were fitted with air
gauges:
'There is nothing connected with air
brakes that, for the cost, will any way
near bring the returns as will a gauge
in the caboose. On the dangerous grades
of the Santa Fe lines it is the practice
for the engineer to hold the train with
the air; however, shold the pressure drop
to a dangerous point, the conductor
holds out his whit« light and the train
men at once assist with the hand brakes,
and this without the engineer calling for
fm
Ilaitwai/ .y Loeomotirt Enifin^eiinff
FIGS. 3 AND 4.
brakes. It is also very valuable when
approaching meeting points if a poor
pump was had on engine and pressure
was low, as it in a measure threw some
of the responsibility on the train crew.
It also will tend to reduce the complaint
of engineers that a "dynamiter" caused
the break-in-two, as the train crew can
tell if such "dynamiting" really occurred
or excessive reductions, due to careless-
ness, are being made by the engineer;
or if second reduction follows before the
slack is bunched. It will reduce the
number of stuck brakes, as train men
soon learn to comment on those engine-
men who make excessive reductions —
below equalization — or that fail to leave
the handle in full release a sufficiently
long time to release all brakes. I can
recall several instances where the gauge
detected the failure to open angle cock
after coupling up crossings and on ac-
count of the hurry would have gone un-
detected perhaps until a stop was at-
tempted."
The average four-wheel truck caboose
is enough heavier than the average
freight car to develop as much holding
power and yet not brake above 60 per
cent, of its light weight. The fact that
serving of much more attention than it
has generally received in the past. In
conclusion, it should be said that some
of the western roads learned the value
of the caboose gauge long ago, and
have profited by it.
St. Paul, Minn. F. B. Farmer.
Slack Take=Up Device.
I send you a drawing of a very handy
device for taking up slack at the top
rod of six-wheel passenger car trucks.
To use the device, the short straight
link is hung over the main connecting
rod, just behind the Hodge lever, and
the adjusting lever coupled into the link
by its end ^ole with the 5-8 bolt. The
handle should point to the ground, and
the grab link, which is coupled to the
second hole in the lever, pointing ahead
toward the truck.
The common hook, shown at the hot-
c=n
m — ^-
ii4"—i
'-{-i M bolt
Eft ^
^ Ji chain 5 0 long^
.HaUtfay j Loeomotivt Entfineering
HANDY DEVICE FOR TAKING UP SLACK IN BRAKE RIGGING.
its brake can easily be kept in good or-
der makes it even more valuable than the
average freight car brake.
In some cases, at least where cabooses
are fitted with air brakes, there is ob-
served a tendency among the trainmen
to keep these brakes cut out. One cause
of this is too high brake force and the
resultant flat wheels. Another is be-
lieved to be the air brake working
against the hand brake, rendering it un-
safe at times to use the latter. Yet an-
other is lack of provision for releasing
the caboose brake while running, desir-
able at times when switching with it, or
at any time when the air brake is ap-
plied and it is desired to set the hand
brake. It could be arranged so the air
brake could be released from either plat-
form.
Tlie caboose brake equipment is de-
tom of the drawing, to which is at-
tached 5 feet of 3-8-inch chain, is then
hooked over the top truck rod, just
ahead of the floating lever, and the chain
passed through the grab link. Then one
man sitting on the ground can push the
adjusting lever ahead until he takes up
enough of the chain to give himself a
good purchase and pull up all the slack in
the brake gear and hold it until a bolt is
removed. He can then pull up a hole or
let one out, as the case may be, to secure
the desired adjustment.
The lever is made from an old Millar
drawbar uncoupling lever, and the whole
device is very cheaply got up. It is a
time and trouble saver.
W. C. Hunter.
.-Kir Brake Inspector, Intercolonial Ry.
Moucton, N. B.
March, 190J.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
131
QIESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On Air Brake Subjects.
(16) K. E. J., Pueblo, Colo., asks:
Is the 3-position retaining valve now
being issued as part of the standard
equipment, or is it only out on trial? A.
— It is a regularly listed part of the
Wcstinghouse standard equipment.
(17) J. L. E., Battle Creek, Mich.,
writes :
1 hear that F-46 triple valve is to be
supplied in the future for all locomotives
with brake cylinders more than 10 inches
an diameter, instead of the special engine
triple; how about it? A. — Your under-
standing is correct.
(18) C. P. McG., BufTalo, N. Y., asks:
What are the inside dimensions of the
Wcstinghouse cast iron au.Kiliary res-
ervoir for the 8-inch freight brake cyl-
inder? I wish to find the cubic contents
or volume. Also, what do they call the
-cubic contents of the 10x33 auxiliary res-
ervoir used with the lo-inch brake cyl-
inder? A. — The cubic capacity of the
cast iron auxiliary reservoir for the
:8-inch freight brake cylinder is 1,620 cubic
inches. The capacity of the I2x33-inch
auxiliary reservoir for lo-inch brake
cylinder is 2,156 cubic inches.
(19) N. R. E., Buffalo, N. Y., writes:
I. How can you distinguish between
the three kinds of Wcstinghouse plain
triple valves, the G24, the F2S, and the
F46? A. — I. The "name" of each triple is
-cast on its body. 2. What is the dif-
ference in these triple valves? A. 2 —
There is a slight difference in size of
the ports and parts to adapt each
to its special work. The G24 triple is
for 8 and lo-inch tender brake cylinders
on freight and switching engines, the
H24 for 8 and lO-inch driver brake cylin-
ders on all kinds of engines, the Fzs for
^2-inch tender-brake cylinders on freight
and switching engines, and the F46, or
"high speed" triple valve, for all 12, 14
and 16-inch driver brake cylinders.
(20) B. B. C, Chicago, 111., asks:
Is the omission of the train pipe from
the cuts of driver and engine truck brakes
in Figs. 4 and 6, on page 27 of January
number a mistake? A.- — Not a mis-
take, but an oversight. They might
as well have been put in; but as
the main object was to show the loca-
tion of the cut-out cocks in the auxiliary
reservoir pipes and brake cylinder pipes,
and as the location of the triple valve
would do this without the aid of th; main
"train pipe, the omission of the train pipe,
although accidental, was not considered
serious.
(21) B. B. C, Scranton., Pa., asks:
Why is a larger brake valve reservoir
being supplied ? What are its outside
dimensions? In what service is it used?
A. — The Westinghouse .\ir Brake Co
has decided to make a change in the size
-of their standard equalizing reservoir for
brake valves. As you know, the present
reservoir is 10x12 inches. The modified
reservoir will be 10x14 i-2 inches. This
change was brought about by the desir>;
of the Pennsylvania R. R. to increase
the size of the equalizing reservoir, to
prevent a possible quick-action applica-
tion of the brakes when making a serv-
ice applicalion on a high-speed train,
when the train contained but a few cars.
Experience in the past on other roads
has not suggested the advisability of such
a change, but it has been thought best to
eliminate all possibility of any tendency
to get quick-action application with the
high speed brake in making a service ap-
plication.
(22) J. B. S., Hamilton, New South
Wales, writes :
I was working an engine the other day,
and when working with light engine only,
in making a service application, the ten-
der brake would go on properly, and re-
main on ; but when connected to a train,
it would not stay on five seconds. It
would just go on and come off again
every time. A. — The trouble is probably
due to leakage in both the train line and
auxiliary reservoir. With the light en-
gine these two leakages will balance each
other, and the brake will remain set.
When the train is coupled on, the train-
pipe volume is greater, and if the train
line of the cars does not leak, the brake
on the tender will bleed itself off by aux-
iliary reservoir leakage. Again, the
triple piston packing ring may be in a
sufficiently bad condition to permit the
train pipe pressure on the light engine
to leak past the ring into the auxiliary
reservoir, keeping the pressures balanced,
regardless of the au.xiliary reservoir
leakage. When the engine is coupled
(0 a train, the train pipe volume would
be increased to a degree that would not
permit the train line and auxiliary reser-
voir pressures to equalize, and tne aux-
iliary reservoir leakage would bleed the
tender brake off.
(23) B. M. McC. Louisville, Ky.,
asks:
If you gradually draw all of the air
out of a train line, will the graduating
spring compress and will the valve move
into emergency position? A. — Yes. To
illustrate: Suppose we charge the train
line and auxiliary reservoir to 70 pounds
pressure. Now draw off 20 pounds from
the train line, setting the brake full. We
will now have 50 pounds pressure in the
brake cylinder, auxiliary reservoir and
train pipe each. Now. again, suppose we
reduce the train pipe pressure 10 pounds
more, thus making the train line pressure
40 pounds. As there has been no outlet
for pressure from the auxiliary reservoir
and brake cylinder, the pressures will re-
main the same therein. Consequently,
the 50 pounds in the auxiliary reservoir
being greater than the 40 pounds in the
train line, and the resistance of the grad-
uating spring, the triple piston and slide
valve will travel to their furthermost
limit, compressing the graduating spring.
Of course, the graduating spring would
also be compressed if all the pressure
were drawn from the train line.
(24) J. B. S., Hamilton, New South
Wales, writes :
On one or two of our engines here (all
triples arc set in slow action in this state)
the tender brake would not operate, and
by cutting the triple into quick action
position, the air brake would go on with
a "bang," even though the brake valve
handle was placed in full release position,
and the brake cylinder "bled." The only
way it could be released waj jy placing
the triple three-way cock in slow active
position again, then the brake would come
off immediately. Leave the brake valve
handle in full release, and by simply pull-
ing the three-way cock down to quick ac-
tion position, the brake, as above stated,
would go on with a regular "bang" every
time. A. — There is something wrong with
the quick action features of the triple
valve. The emergency valve is defective,
or some foreign matter has lodged on its
seat, holding the valve open. In this
event, and with three-way handle in quick
action position, the train-pipe pressure
would have a free and constant passage-
way to the brake cylinder and wculd re-
main on as long as there is pressure in
the train pipe. Possibly the leather
packing in the brake cylinder is faulty.
If this be true, a slow admission of press-
ure to the cylinder, such as service appli-
cation would give, will leak out quickly
and perhaps as rapidly as it enters.
When the triple is cut into quick action
position, the train-pipe pressure would
go into the brake cylinder faster than it
could leak out. Clean the triple valve
parts thoroughly, paymg particular at-
tention to the quick action mechanism,
and note that the brake cylinder packing
is in good condition.
(25) B. J. K., St. Paul, Minn., writes:
I do not understand from the sketch
in February R.\ilway .\nd Locomotive
Engineering how I am to drill the hole
in the brake valve, or to strike the port
for the governor to give the high pres-
sure when the brake is applied, and the
low pressure when the brake is off. A. —
Draw a center line through the rotary
valve seat and the part on the side of the
brake valve to which the feed valve at-
tachment is fastened. Draw a parallel line
three-quarters of an inch to the side of
this line — to that side nearer the main
reservoir connection. Set your dividers
for 2 67-128 inches, and from the center
of the rotary valve seat scribe a circle
through the parallel line. The point
where this circular line intercepts the
parallel line should be the center of your
hole to tap into the port to the brake
valve.
132
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
Mr. Qeorge Westinghouse on
American Methods.
At Claridge's Hotel, in London, on the
night of January 9, Mr. George Westing-
house entertained at dinner a large com-
pany of British railway managers, finan-
ciers and scientists. Two speeches of
unique interest were made. One of these
was by Lord Kelvin, the other, by the
host of the occasion. Lord Kelvin said:
"At this dinner of friends I would like
to express a common sentiment which all
must feel, our appreciation of the quali-
ties of our charming and beloved host,
Mr. Westinghouse. I am sure that Mr.
Westinghouse's coming to England re-
minds us all of the advantages that Eng-
land has derived from his genius and
perseverence and grand skill in bringing
out for public good so many of the re-
sults of science and inventiveness. There
are many railway men present at this
table, and many passengers by railways—
which means that every inhabitant of our
country is represented here. When peo-
ple belonging to these two classes— the
railway men and the traveling public of
Great Britain— are gathered together as
now, we can scarcely see Mr. Westing-
house without feeling how muchwe owe
to him for the Westinghouse brake. (Ap-
plause.)
"But Mr. Westinghouse has not
stopped with his brake; he has gone on
and on and on in America, flashing over
again on this side of the Atlantic, and
bringing his energies here. The present
development of the electric industry in
the United Kingdom owes its growth
largely to him.
" 'Largely' is a small word to express
how much we owe to him. I do not
wish to enter into any comparisons or
superlatives, but I do not think any man
in the world of engineering could be
named to whom more is due than to Mr.
Westinghouse for his work in electric
engineering.
"Other things besides mechanical
engineering and electrical engineering
we owe to Mr. Westinghouse. We owe
to him the bringing to England and
causing to be appreciated in England,
American methods— .\merican methods
in a certain way which I may refer to
without invidious comparison; American
methods of industry, and resolution, and
determination— which are also English
methods, because they have been in-
herited from England. (Applause.) Here
it comes back to us, with compound in-
terest, in the shape of Mr. Westinghouse,
and I am sure that we all feel that we
are largely indebted to him for what he
has done for us, what he is doing for us,
and in advance, for what he is planning
to do for us in the future.
"We appreciate all this, and we appre-
ciate him ab a kind friend, a genial host
and entertainer. I ask you to join me in
drinking the health of Mr. George West-
mghouse."
The toast having been honored with
enthusiasm. Mr. Westinghouse rose to
respond. He said:
"I wish to thank our distinguished
scientific friend, Lord Kelvin, for the
complimentary language he has used
about me. And I would like to say to
all you railway men here present, that
my life has been very much associated
with your calling. I invented the brake,
of which Lord Kelvin has spoken, when
I was scarcely twenty-one years old, and
thus became acquainted with railway men
when the railway industry was rather a
poor one compared with what it is to-
day. Since then I have closely followed
railway operations, becoming acquainted
with almost everything that is being
done in them, and it is particularly my
friendship with railway men which has
prompted me to go forward in my work
with an interest and keenness that prob-
ably would not have resulted from or-
dinary commercial motives.
"Lord Kelvin has been good enough
to refer to my coming to this country.
I came here thirty years ago, and for ten
years or so I was here about half the
time. At that time it was very difficult
to get any new thing done in England.
I often wanted to sit down and cry, be-
cause I could not get any one to believe
in anything. (Laughter.) I wanted in
those early days to try an iron brake
shoe, because, on account of rapid wear
we couldn't keep the wooden one ad-
justed. I had to beg and beg to be per-
mitted to put a set of metal brake shoes
on one tender on the Caledonian Rail-
way. Finally I succeeded. You all know
that now-a-days all the railway shoes or
blocks are made of cast-iron or other
metal and are used upon all the wheels
of the train.
"Lord Kelvin has alluded to 'Ameri-
can methods.' May I say that one of
your English difificulties is inherent, I
think, in an old-world highly-developed
country. After a man (or a nation) has
worked prosperously for a long time, he
opposes improvement or suggestion,
thinking. 'What I have is good enough.
I won't try a new thing.' In America,
however, the necessities have produced
different results. Lord Kelvin speaks
of England having sent many men to
America. It has also sent to us many
ideas. If you take up the American
patent records and follow the cases in
litigation especially, you will find that
among the references cited many are of
English origin, some of them containing
ideas so complete, the wonder is that the
inventions disclosed were not established
fully and completely in your own land.
These records seem to show that Ameri-
cans and Englishmen have invented the
same thing many times.
"In America, however, we have always
been short-handed with regard to labor.
We have been obliged to find methods
whereby one man may accomplish the
work of two or three men as compared
with your practice here. We have had
the best men from Europe — Englishmen,
Germans, French, everybody— skilled
men, highly trained men, as well as
laboring men; we have combined their
experience with our own, coupled it with
cur necessities, and have thus accom-
plished results unattainable in a country
like this where you have more labor
than you can well keep employed.
"As an illustration of what has been
accomplished by the use of electricity in
a great industry, I may cite the Home-
stead mills of the Carnegie Company.
Mr. Schwab, whose name is well known
to you, is a genius in his way, particu-
larly in the management of men. He is
a master in organizing and directing
men. Mr. Carnegie believed in him, and
it Mr. Schwab made a suggestion in re-
gard to the use of new appliances, even
if it involved the tearing down of an
old mill and putting up a new- one, the
new one was ordered. What Mr. Schwab
thought should be done was done. As a
result of such progressiveness we may
see the splendid mills at Homestead,
where they produce with about 4,000 mei>
three times as much steel as the Krupp
works produce with 15,000 men. The
results are simply wonderful. You can
start there to-day, in a building contain-
ing steel-melting furnaces, and you will
there see three men mounted on a car
with the charging apparatus which is
moved and operated by electricity. With
a few movements of this ingenious con-
tri^^ce three men charge twenty fur-
naces, which prior to the use of electric-
ity would have required the labor of over
200 men.
"You may go into the yard of the
Homestead mills where they pile the
metal in stock. This yard is covered by
a system of overhead cranes, and the re-
sult is that not only here, but in the milJ
and in every other place, you may see
great weights lifted and many undertak-
ings going on without a single man
exerting himself a bit — working not
half as hard as I am working now.
(Laughter.)
"I took some English friends to
Homestead. Mr. Schwab, after guiding
us through several departments, said:
T will now show you where we turn out
750 tons of plate girders per day.' The
mill was in the shape of an 'L.' We went
into the short end of the 'L.' where the
furnaces were fed by natural gas, of
course requiring no stokers. The end
at which we entered had a rather low
roof, and there was in sight a contriv-
ance like a battering ram in front of the
furnaces; two workmen were sitting
down eating their dinner near by; no
one else was present. I thought, 'Mr.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
>:?3
Scluv.il) Ii.-is iii.hIc a mistake; lie has
asked us to sec a mill that is not in op-
eration.' But wc went through the mill,
which was about 200 feet long, and sud-
denly we heard a rattle and then saw a
truck approaching loaded with a big
ingot. No one touched the truck or the
ingot. The load came to a platform, the
crane overhead dropped a pair of tongs
and quickly put the ingot on the roller
table, and as it moved along to the great
rolls it was automatically kept in place.
The adjusting screws of the rolls were
turned by little electric motors, and not
a man in that house did a bit of work.
It was just as easy as what you are doing
now — looking on! (Laughter.) Wo
went back to the furnaces. There was
a fifteen-year-old boy seated in a little
place called the 'pulpit.' lie was able,
merely by the movement of levers, to
open at will any of the furnace doors
and move the car along. And we saw
this car come in front of a furnace and
contents dumped into a furnace whence
it returned for another load. They were
running the metal into an immense re-
coi)tacle into which the metal from all
three furnaces was mixed. From this
place the metal was taken as required,
put into a special tank, mounted on a
car and taken to Homestead, two or
three miles away, to be poured into the
furnaces; one heating only was required.
"I refer to all this simply to illus-
trate the immense advantages we have
had in America, and the kind of experi-
ence I have been able to bring to this
country, and to which Lord Kelvin so
generously alluded, and which I hope
will be not only useful and profitable,
but will establish for the company I rep-
resent a name and a position which you
will all regard as most satisfactory. (Ap-
plause.)
"I want to thank you very sincerely
for the kind expressions with which you
have greeted me, and especially for your
Baldwin Engines for the Norfolk &
Western Railway.
The Norfolk & Western have recently
received some passenger engines of the
Atlantic or 4-4-2 type from the Baldwin
Locomotive Works. The engines are
simple, with I9x28-in. cylinders, 79-in.
driving wheels and an estimated adhe-
sive weight of 84.000 pounds, and with
200 pounds pressure in the boiler, the cal-
culated tractive force is about 21,700
pounds.
The frame of this engine is continuous
and the carrying wheels at the rear have
inside journals and are equalized with
the drivers. Semi-eliptic springs are
used all through, and the equalization of
the weight on the carrying wheels is sim-
ilar to that which we illustrated in con-
nection with a 4-4-2 engine on the Cen-
tral Railroad of New Jersey in our De-
cember, 1902, issue. The rear spring
hanger of the driver and the forward
hanger of the carrying wheel on each
FAST PASSENGER LOCOMOTIVE FOR THE NORFOLK & WESTERN.
the charging machine approach and take
out of the open furnace a hot ingot
whith was dropped on the car and moved
off to its work. There was this boy
doing absolutely no hard work, and his
mill was turning out 750 tons of steel
plate each day. My English friends said:
"'England has no chance in competition
with such methods.'
"Now all this sort of thing came about
in America because of our necessities.
We hadn't men enough to do our work.
There was a premium in favor of those
who could invent machines to work and
thus supply the deficiency.
"At the Carnegie mills we went to see
three blast furnaces. They were making
1.800 tons of pig-iron in twenty-four
hours. We saw only two or three men
on a truck which was moved automati-
cally. These men were letting the ore
run from slioots and mixing it in the re-
quired quantity, and when tliey had
filled a truck, it was carried up and its
acceptance of my invitation to inspect
this evening a couple of inventions, one
of which — the Hewitt mercury vapor
lamp — is a complete and accomplished
thing. The rays of this light are not
very pleasant as yet, but the light is
likely, however, to be of great value. The
other invention — the Hewitt Static Con-
verter— is quite new, and its object is to
convert alternating currents into direct
current at so low a cost in comparison
with the suras which have heretofore
been expended for equivalent results, that
it is likely, when fully perfected, to cause
an immense stimulus in regard to the use
of electricity in all parts of England, and
particularly in the agricultural parts pf
the country, for farm work, and for mov-
ing all kinds of vehicles.
"I have taken advantage of these in-
ventions to invite you to see them as
my guests, and I thank you for having
honored me with your presence to-
night."
side are attached to the ends of a trough-
like steel casting. This casting is be-
tween the bars forming the frame, and
contains a spring, the buckle of which,
bearing up against the lower side of the
top from member, acts as the pivot point
of the system. By shifting of the posi-
tion of this spring the weight on drivers
may be altered as desired.
The motion in this engine is indirect,
with transmission bar curved below the
axle of the leading driver and the valves
are of the piston type. The crosshead
is the usual two guide-bar tj'pe keyed
through the rod. The boiler is of the
radial stayed wagon-top type and meas-
ures 62 in. at the smoke-box end. The
total heating surface is 2,883.9 sq. ft. and
the grate area is 45.9 sq. ft. The ash
pan hopper doors are operated by air.
The tender carries 10 tons of coal and
6.000 gallons of water and the frame is
made out of lo-in. steel channels.
Through the courtesy of Mr. W. H.
134
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903,
Lewis, S. M. P. of the Norfolk & West-
ern, we are are able to present the above
facts and figures. Sorne of the principal
dimensions are given below:
Driving wheel base. 6 ft 10 in.
Kiijid wheel base, 14 ft. 10 in.
Total wheel base of engine, 2fi ft. 8J4 in.
Total wheel bise of eng. and tend., 53 ft. 9 ^'a in.
Weight on leading wheels, estimated. 3S,ooo lbs.
Weight on driving wheels, estimated, .S4.C00 lbs
Weight on trailing wheels, estimated, 41,000 lbs.
Total weight of eng. in working order, 163 000 lbs.
Total weight of engine and tender, 273,000.
Diameter of driving wheels, 79 in.
Diameter of carrying wheels, ,=0 in.
Diameter of truck wheels, 36 in.
Height of center of boiler above rail, 9 ft.
Height of top of stack above rail, 15 ft ^^A in.
Greatest width over all, running board, 10 ft. 6 in.
Cylinders, 19 in. x 28 in.; steam port, width, i%'m.;
exhaust port, wdh,, 2,'4 in.; bridge, wdh , i % in.
Valves, diameter, 9^^ ii^; steam lap, iH in.
BOILER
Thickness of sheets, ^s and {4 i".
Firebox, width, 6414 in.; length, 8 ft, 3II in. depth,
73^4 in. front; crown sheet thickness, .>s in.;
tube sheet, }i in.; side sheet , % in. back shtet,
'A in.
Water space, width, 4 in. front and back, jV^ in.
sides.
Tubes, Number, 326. dia., 2 in. O.D., no T. length,
16 ft.
Heating surface, Tubes, 2,7iS.9-sq. ft.
Heating surface. Firebox, 165 sq. It.
Heating surface, Total, 2,883.9 sq. ft.
European Railway Notes.
The construction of larger and more
powerful locomotives for the British
railways promises to continue during
1903. The advantages of working heav-
ier trains has become apparent to man-
■agers and the motive power departments
are consequently receiving instructions
for increased haulage.
The Great Eastern Railway of Eng-
land are building some six-coupled
radial tank locomotives at the Darling-
ton shops with 55-in. coupled drivers and
cylinders i8Hx26-in. stroke.
Larger freight cars are rapidly coining
into use on several lines having consid-
erable mineral traflic and we illustrate
the latest type built for the N. E. R. by
the Leeds Forge Company. In the ex-
perimental test the car was loaded with
40 tons of coal and 60 tons of pig iron,
the deflection of the underfraine at the
center was then less than an eighth of
an inch. Fifty of these cars are on or-
der to be constructed of pressed steel
throughout, the length over buffers is
39 ft. and the width 8 ft. The side doors
are of the hinged type. When the pig
iron, placed on for testing, was removed
the remaining 40 tons of coal was dis-
charged in 37 seconds through the hop-
per doors underneath. These cars show
a saving in tare of 40 per cent, and in
train length of 50 per cent, when com-
pared with the ordinary small cars now
used.
The Great Northern Railway has just
built at the Doncaster shops a ten-wheel
locomotive of the No. 990 class, with a
much larger boiler, the diameter of the
barrel being 66 in. and the length 16 ft.
The center is 8 ft. S'/i in. from the rail
level; the heating surface of the tubes
is 2,359 sq. ft. and of the firebox 141 sq,
ft. The tender is of the standard type
and is provided with a scoop for picking
up water.
On January i the G. N. R. began an
accelerated service of new vestibuled-
car trains between London, Leeds and
Bradford. Four coaches make up the
"breakfast" car trains, accommodating
28 first-class and 99 third-class passen-
gers. The down train leaves King's
Cross terminus at 7.15 A. M. and ar-
rives at Leeds at 11.15 A. M. and Brad-
coniotive depot at Battersea; various
types of engines are being fitted, includ-
ing some of the latest express locomo-
tives. For some time the popular "Pull-
man Limited," from London to Brigh-
ton on Sundays, has been covering the
distance of 51 miles in the hour. On De-
cember 21 a very fast run was made with
this train, the distance being completed
in S3^'i minutes, the engine hauling the
train being one of the latest four-coupled
expresses No. 70 "Holyrood."
The Great Western Railway's new
French tour-cylinder de Glehn com-
pound locomotive, which will not be de-
livered until next June, will be in gen-
tCT
Kt)3;$j=ct)^^^
4-4-2 TYPE ENGINE FOR G. X. R, OF ENGLAND.
e.ii!jint€r\ng
ford 11.28 A. M. The corresponding up
train leaves Bradford at 6.45 A. M.,
Leeds 7.10 A. M. and reaches King's
Cross at 11.45 A. M. The down
"luncheon" car train is heavier and con-
sists of six cars; it leaves King's Cross
at 1.30 P. M. and reaches Leeds at 5.12
P. M. and Bradford 5.28 P. M. These
limes, viz.: 3 hours and 35 minutes, for
the i86;/4 miles, are the shortest between
London and Leeds by any route. Each
car runs on two six-wheel trucks and is
fitted with Pullman vestibules and plat-
forms, automatic couplers. Gold's steam
eral design similar to the lo-wheelers of
the Northern Railway of France, with
fittings and cab after the G. W. R.
standard.
The Midland Railway, having found its
latest non-compounds with Belpaire fire-
boxes very eflicient on the fast Scotch
tratlic. has ordered a further ten at the
Derby shops.
Experiments are being made by the
North British Railway Company with
a view to displace the wire rope working
of U^ains up the Cowlairs incline out of
the Queen street terminus, Glasgow;
EASTERN Ol- I'R.VNCE, ^E GLEHN 4 C VLlN' iJliR COiiiror Nl),
heat and gas light. The new engines
and cars used on the service have been
built at the company's shops to the de-
signs of Mr. H. A. Ivatt, the chief loco-
motive engineer.
The London, Brighton & South Coast
Railway has had running for some time
on local and mixed traffic services sev-
eral new six-coupled radial tank locomo-
tives with 60-in. wheels. This railway is
experimenting largely with Texas oil
fuel and has erected a large store tank
and pumping plant at the West End lo-
some powerful si.x-coupled side tank lo-
comotives known as the 795 class have
been built for the work.
Messrs. Robert Stephenson & Co., the
famous locomotive builders, have recent-
ly turned out the first engines from their
new shops at Darlington. These are
four-coupled express locomotives, with
78-in. drivers, built for the Oudh and
Rnhilkund Railway in India.
The Metropolitan (underground rail-
ways of London) -s^WX, it is anticipated,
have some of its electrified sections
Marcli, 190J.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
'35
working during the present year. 1 lie
new trains consist of seven cars, of
which three have motors working on the
multiple unit system. The total length
of the train is 352 ft. and ihc seating ca-
pacity 3,30 passengers; the central cou-
plers and arrangement of platforms,
gates, etc., are operated in a similar
manner to those of the Central Londim
Railway and Manhattan l''.lc\ atc<l in New
York.
In consequence of electric car compe-
tition several British railways are se-
riously investigating the possibilities oi
motor car services and the North East-
ern Railway Company has decided to in-
troduce in certain districts "autocars"
where the traffic demands a quick and
considering this innovation on a sec-
tion of their line between Tunbriflgc
Wells and Horsham.
In France, the Paris, Lyons & Med-
iterranean Railway has the matter un-
der consideration for branch lines, and
in the event of their adoption the ve-
hicles will be of the Gardner and Serpol-
let type.
The law suit brought by the 'J'aff V'alp
Railway Company against the Amalga-
mated Society of Railway Servants in
connection with the strike on that rail-
way in August, 1900, was concluded after
13 days' hearing on December 19 last.
The jury found that the defendants au-
thorized and assisted in carrying out the
?trike by unlawful means and persuaded
ugal have just received from the Han-
over Works at Linden, some six-coupled
passenger locomotives with trailing
wheels and outside cylinders. The boiler,
which gives a heating surface of 1,488
sq. ft., has a Belpaire firebox, with a
grate area of 21.4 sq. ft., the working
l)rcssure being 160 pounds per sq. in.
Equalizing beams arc nsed for the center
and rear drivers and sand is brought to
the front of leading and center wheels.
Dust shields are bolted on to the frame
to keep the motion clean. The engines
weigh, when empty, 95,956 pounds, and
when ready for the road 107,240 pounds.
Messrs. MafTei & Co., of Munich, Ba-
varia, have recently delivered to the
Eastern Railway of France several new
FIFTV-TON ENGI.ISH STEEL CAR.
frequent service. The experiment is to
be tried between Hartlepool and West
Hartlepool, and an order has been
placed with the Motor Power Company,
of Coventry, for a number of four-cylin-
der petrol engines of 85 brake horse
power, driving a dynamo which will in
turn impart motion through motors to
the car. Each car will be self-contained,
a full complement of passengers being
52. If the efforts proves successful sim-
ilar steps will be taken to meet street
car competition in other areas. It has
already been determined to utilize auto-
cars for special trains in place of steam
locomotives.
The London. Brighton & South Coast
Railway Company are at present also
men whose notices had not expired to
break their contract. The question oi
damages, which is expected will be
heavy, is to be settled at the next sitting.
This result has struck consternation
among the men's leaders, and various
proposals are suggested to counteract
the damaging eflfect on all trades unions.
The Midland Railway Company are
building a large new station at Notting-
ham, six additional tracks have been laid
and the main line platforms increased in
number from three to six, with a total
length of 1,000 ft. The general arrange-
ment of the buildings will be similar to
that of the same company's station at
Leicester.
The Minho Douro Railway of Port-
locomotives oi the ten-wheel type hav-
ing a leading truck and six-coupled
drivers. The locomotives are compounds
on the de Glehn system, with two high-
pressure cylinders outside the framing,
and two low-pressure, inside. In general
design these engines are similar to the
series built by the Eastern Company,
but they also embody several novel fea-
tures. The valve motion is of the
Walschaert type. The principal dimen-
sions are: Cylinders, high-pressure,
13 .3-4 by 32 in.; low-pressure, 21 1-2
by 32 in.; truck wheels. 36 1-4 in.;
coupled drivers, 69 in.; boiler, center
above rails, 99 1-2 in.; mean dia. of bar-
rel. 50 1-2 in.; length between tube
plates. 156 1-2 in.: firebox shell length.
136
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
107 in.; copper firebox length, 97 3-4
in.; width, 3 1-2 in.; total bearing sur-
face, 2,227 sq. ft.; working pressure,
220 lbs. per sq. in.; weight of engine in
working order, 149,757 lbs.
At tlie late Dusseldorf Exhibition
there were exhibited several interesting
locomotives. The Hohenzollern Works
sent a fireless shunting engine which re-
ceives its steam from a stationary boiler,
one charge lasting several hours.
By the same firm was also shown a
Mogul locomotive for the Prussian State
railways used for either goods or passen-
ger traffic, having 20 1-2 by 26-in. cylin-
ders. The engine is provided with a
Schmidt's patent superheater, Schifer's
air-brake and the Langor Narcotty
smoke consumer. The Humboldt Loco-
motive Works at Cologne also exhibited
a Mogul engine for the Prussian State
railways, having 4 ft. 6 in. drivers and
19 1-2 by 26-in. cylinders.
A fine compound tank locomotive was
shown by Mons. Arnold Jung, of Jugen-
enthal, near Kirchen, for a meter gauge
track. Four cylinders are provided, each
driving two pairs of wheels.
The visit of English railway officials
to the United States last year has im-
pressed some persons with the possibil-
ity of modification and improvement in
some methods here, and a recent lecture
by one of the members of the deputation,
Mr. Butt, of the North Eastern Railway,
has proved valuable. While admitting
the possibility of reform in many mat-
ters, the gentleman in question, like his
colleagues, is of opinion that generally
English methods suit England best,
while American ways are essential in
America. The revolt of some of the
stockholders of the London and North-
western Railway is to be attributed to
the very conservative management of
the company and the next meeting in
February is looked forward to with con-
siderable interest. Foremost among the
demands of the reformers is a desire for
more explicit accounts, not an unrea-
sonable one we would think, and an in-
vestigation of better means for handling
traffic.
Yellow Jack Delays Hiring of RaiU
readers.
Our correspondent, Mr. W. D. Hol-
land, who is now superintendent of the
Guayaquil and Quito Railway Company,
at Duran-Ecuador, writes us: "I thank
you for the "ad." to mechanics and
engineers. I received a good many re-
plies and have engaged some to come
here, but just not at present, as yellow
jack is raging, but in a few weeks will
die out. I hope I don't want to get the
men here and have them die on my
hands, so I will wait until cooler weather
shows up. I will write up this road and
country for you one of these days, but
at present I am busy in the shops day
and night, so don't get the time to put
my mind on an interesting article for
you."
This will explain to parties who have
written for positions why it is that they
have not been requested to report them-
selves at Duran-Ecuador.
Recently a loving cup was presented
to Mr. John W. Duntley by the members
of the sales department of the Chicago
Pneumatic Tool Company at a banquet
held in the Union League Club, Chicago.
At the same time Mr. W. O. Duntley,
who is vice-president of the company,
was also presented with a handsome gold
match case set with diamonds. Speeches
were made by Messrs. J. W. and W. O.
Duntley in grateful acknowledgment of-
the gifts, in which they thanked the rep-
resentatives of the company for the
hearty support given them, and the good
showing made in 1902, the company hav-
ing doubled the business of the previous
year. Altogether a very pleasant even-
ing was spent.
The H. K. Porter Co., of Pittsburg,
have been particularly busy during these
rush times and have built a good many
locomotives larger than their general de-
sign. They are working on a contract for
locomotives for a railroad in Costa Rica,
the track gauge being forty-two inches.
Aside from its heavy domestic trade for
locomotives for mining opeartions, nar-
row gauge roads and for their special
services, the production of the Porter
Company has gone to nearly every coun-
try on the globe. In 1902 the coriipany
shipped eight engines to Spain. These
were of the usual European standard, al-
though not nearly so powerful machines
as the standard of American railroads.
Japan, Australia, South Africa, Russia
and practically all the European coun-
tries, various States of South America
and Canadian provinces have received
numbers of the Porter Company's loco-
motives.
One completed locomotive every four
hours is the present product of the Bald-
win works, and as this concern is work-
ing night and day with a double force of
men, it is able to deliver six locomotives
each day to its urgent customers. Presi-
dent Converse says: "The demand for
motive power by the railroads does not
slacken and we are doing the best we
can to meet the needs of our customers
by working continuously throughout the
twenty-four hours." The Baldwin works
now employs 13,000 men. This com-
pany's largest customer is the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad, which placed an order for
350 locomotives a short time ago.
The Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany, of Philadelphia, have issued two
publications relative to their specialties.
One is concerned with the Keller pneu-
matic tampers — the tool that knows
enough to pound sand. These machines,
originally made for foundry purposes,
are now used in smelting plants and in
Bessemer steel works. They are used for
tamping the linings and bottoms of con-
verters of all kinds. The other publica-
tion is on the care and use of pneumatic
tools, in which directions for cleaning,
oiling, repairing and using the Keller
tools are set forth at some length. The
company will be happy to send either or
both these publications to any one inter-
ested enough to apply.
The Philadelphia & Reading people
have a good, quick way of making ec-
centric straps. In the first place, the
straps are cast solid, and it is said that
some amusing speculations have been
indulged in by visitors to the shops when
first shown a solid strap. The holes for
the bolts which will eventually hold the
two half-straps together, are drilled
through the solid lug, that operation
avoids the time and work of setting the
straps true with each other. The solid
strap is then sawed in two, a stamped
liner, the thickness of the saw blade is
inserted, the two parts bolted together .
and the strap is bored out in a lathe.
The P. & R. keep liners of varying
thickness on hand and adjust for wear
by removing the liners already in place
and putting in two thinner ones.
We are informed that the name of the
Standard Traction Brake Co., of 26 Cort-
landt street. New York city, has been
changed to the Westinghouse Traction
Brake Company. This company sells all
the power brakes for street railway serv-
ice manufactured by the Westinghouse
Air Brake Company, including straight
or automatic air-operated brakes, with
axle-driven or motor-driven compress-
ors, the storage system of air brakes,
and the Westinghouse combined mag-
netic brake and electric car-heating ap-
paratus.
The Central Railroad of New Jersey
some time ago had been suffering from
what one of the officials of the mechani-
cal department described as a perfect
epidemic of broken cross-head keys. The
keys which failed were composed of ma-
chine steel, but they constantly sheered
and allowed cross-head and piston-rod
to part company with disastrous results.
A remedy was tried in the use of the best
spring steel, forged at a low heat and al-
lowed to cool in the air. The remedy
proved to be what doctors would call a
specific, and the epidemic disappeared
entirely. Even if the keys should be
given a low degree of temper in the mak-
ing the satisfactory results now obtained
are in no way interfered with.
March, 1903.
KAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
«37
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. S. B. Mason has been appointed
chief clcrli to the general superintendent
of motive power of the Baltiinore & Ohio
Railroad.
Mr. W. D. Hall has been appointed
electrical engineer of tlie Grand Trimk
Railway system, with headquarters at
Montreal, Que.
Mr. G. H. Dryden has been appointed
one of the two signal inspectors on the
Baltimore & Oliio, with headquarters at
Baltimore, Md.
Mr. S. R. Payne has been appointed
trainmaster of the western division of
the New York Central Railroad, with
headquarters at Syracuse.
Mr. VV. J. McGee has been appointed
acting master mechanic on the Atlantic
Coast Line, at Montgomery, Ala., vice
Mr. J. F. Enright, resigned.
Mr. J. H. Middleton, until recently sec-
retary of the Erie Railroad, has been
elected second vice-president of the Le-
high Valley Railroad Company.
Mr. G. Mudd has been appointed divi-
sion master mechanic on the Wabash
Railroad, with headquarters at Moberly,
Md., vice Mr. S. Cooper, resigned.
Mr. R. H. Gihnour. formerly superin-
tendent of the Canada Foundry Com-
pany, of Toronto, Ont.. has been appoint-
ed superintendent of the Brooks plant.
Mr. John R. Gould lias been appointed
master mechanic of the Clifton Forge
division of the Chesapeake & Ohio Rail-
road, with headquarters at Clifton Forge.
Mr. M. Hickey. master mechanic on
the Northern Pacific, at Seattle, Wash.,
has been transferred to Spokane, Wash..
as master mechanic, succeeding Mr. W.
Moir.
Mr. George Geiger has been appointed
trainmaster of the second district. Rio
Grande Western, with headquarters at
Grand Junction, vice Mr. E. H. Williams,
transferred.
Mr. George Hay. formerly traveling en-
gineer on the R., W. & O. division of the
Central-Hudson road, has been appointed
foreman of engines, with headquarters at
Albany. N. Y.
Mr. R. T. Shea, formerly of the Sche-
nectady shops, has been appointed super-
intendent for the Montreal Locomotive
and Machine Company at Longue
Pointe, Canada.
Mr. R. W. Taylor has been made one
of the signal inspectors on the Baltimore
& Ohio Railroad, with office at Balti-
more, Md. There are two signal inspec-
tors on this line.
Mr. G. S. Wiiod has lately been ap-
pointed special traveling representative
for the Boston Belting Company. This
concern has as its Chicago oftice 209
Great Northern Building.
Colonel Prout.
Colonel H. G. Prout has severed his
connection with the Railroad Gazelle, to
become vice-president and general man-
ager of the Union Switch and Signal
Company, of Swisvale, Pa. Colonel
Prout has been for the past sixteen years
editor of that journal, and has been an
able successor of Dunning and of Forney.
In early life Henry Goslee Prout served
in the Army of the Potomac and went
through the Wilderness campaign, the
operations which led to the investment
of Petersburg and the pursuit of Lee.
In 1868 he entered the service of the
COL. H. G. PROUT.
Khedive of Egypt as major of engineers.
He served with distinction in the Egyp-
tion army, and rose to the rank of colonel
on the general staff. He was, at the re-
quest of General Gordon, sent to the
head of the Nile as Governor General of
the Provinces of the Equator, and dur-
ing his administration he retained the
warm friendship and confidence of Gor-
don. On one occasion when marching
with an expeditionary force across the
desert from Suakim to Burber, he was
struck with the commercial value of the
route for a railway, and he made a care-
ful barometric profile and report to the
Egyptian authorities. It is now the in-
tention of the government to build a
line over practically ground indicated
years before by Colonel Prout. We
are only able to give in barest out-
line these few facts concerning a man
who has been successfully, engineer, sol-
dier, governor and editor. He now joins
the service of a company which grew out
of one with which he was formerly con-
nected as signal engineer. The best
wishes of his manv friends go with him.
Mr. C. C. Edwards has been appointed
acting master mechanic of the VV. M. &
P. division of the Chicago Great-West-
ern, with headquarters at Red Wing, in
place of Mr. Gregory, resigned.
Mr. George W. Seidel, for a number of
years master mechanic of the Lehigh
Valley at Buffalo, has been appointed
master mechanic of the Birmingham
division of the Southern system.
Mr. J. A. Johnson has been appointed
signal engineer of the St. Louis Mer-
chants' Bridge Terminal Railroad and
Terminal Association, of St. Louis, vice
Mr. W. K. Wuerpel, Jr., resigned.
Mr. J. J. Bayly, formerly master me-
chanic of the Norfolk division of the
Southern Railway, has been transferred
in a similar position to the Memphis
division, vice Mr. N. W. Elliot, resigned.
Mr. M. B. Cutter has been appointed
general superintendent on the Lehigh
Valley Railroad, with office at South
Bethlehem, Pa. The office of Superin-
tendent of Transportation has been abol-
ished.
Mr. B. P. Myers has been appointed
general foreman on the International &
Great Northern, at Houston, Texas. Mr.
Myers was for the past ten years one of
the foremen at the Erie shops at Hunt-
ington, Ind.
Mr. F. S. Kelly has been appointed
general foreman at Long\-iew Junction
of the Texas & Pacific, vice Mr. G. M.
Lovett. promoted. Mr. Kelly was until ■
promoted foreman of the erecting shop
at that point.
Mr. Charles W. Lee, formerly road
foreman of engines, has been appointed
master mechanic of the Norfolk division
of the Southern Railway, with headquar-
ters at Lawrenceville, Va., \-ice Mr.
Bayly, transferred.
Mr. Harry Oviatt, formerly air brake
inspector on the New York, New Haven
& Hartford Railroad, has been promoted
to the position of road foreman of en-
gines on the same road, with headquar-
ters at New Haven.
Mr. H. H. Warner, formerly shop su-
perintendent of the Northern Pacific, at
Seattle, Wash., has been appointed mas-
ter mechanic of the lines north of
Seattle, with headquarters at that point,
vice Mr. M. Hickey, transferred.
Mr. J. H. Dull has been appointed
trainmaster of the fourth and fifth dis-
tricts of the Eastern division of the
Grand Trunk Railway, with headquar-
ters in Montreal, vice Mr. W. W. Ash-
I3S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
aid, who has been assigned to other
duties.
Mr. A. J. Dunn has resigned the posi-
tion of master mechanic on the Atlanta,
Knoxville & Northern Railway, to ac-
cept a similar position on the Virginia
& South-Western Railway, with head-
quarters at Bristol, Tenn.
rXr. Daniel Willard.
In our January issue we published the
text of a beautifully illuminated address
presented on behalf of the firemen of the
Erie and other railroads to Mr. Daniel
Willard, general manager of the line, as
evidence of their appreciation of cour-
tesies extended to their order. That
was more than a mere formality, for
Mr. Willard is one of the most popular
officials in charge of railroad men. His
many friends will be pleased that he has
taken another step up the official ladder,
having been on January 28 elected first
vice-president of the company. Mr.
MR. DANIEI, WII,I,ARD.
Willard is a Vermonter, a proud boast,
which in any other country would be
equivalent to saying that he is a High-
I;mder. He worked his way upward
through the mechanical department, was
fireman, engineer and traveling engineer,
and always first class of every grade.
There was no accident connected with
his advancement. Every step was earne.l
by hard work and careful preparation.
Mr. E. H. Williams has been appointed
trainmaster of the first district of the
Rio Grande Western Railway, with head-
quarters at Salt Lake City, vice Mr.
George F. Cotter, resigned to accept
service with another line.
Mr. C. H. Terrell, heretofore general
foreman of the machine department of
the Chesapeake & Ohio, at Richmond,
Va., has been appointed master mechanic
on the same road, at Covington, Ky.,
vice G. W. Hepburn, resigned.
Mr. C. D. Vanaman, one of the oldest
engineers on the Florida East Coast
Railway, has recently been appointed to
the position of master mechanic on the
same line, with office at St. Augustine,
Fla., vice Mr. G. A. Miller, promoted.
Mr. E. H. Symington, formerly assist-
ant superintendent and mechanical en-
gineer of the Kilbourne and Jacobs Man-
ufacturing Company, has gone into the
railway supply business with the firm of
T. H. Symington & Co., of Baltimore,
Md.
Mr. G. M. Lovett, formerly general
foreman at Longview Junction, on the
Texas & Pacific Railway, has been ap-
pointed master mechanic of the Trans-
continental division- of that road, with
headquarters at Texarkana, Texas, vice
Mr. William Laing, deceased.
Mr. George A. Miller, formerly master
mechanic on the Florida East Coast
Railway, has been given enlarged powers
and responsibility on the road, with the
change of title from master mechanic to
that of superintendent 01 motive power
and machinery. His headquarters arc
at St. Augustine. Fla.
Mr. Robert Potts, the retiring master
car builder of the Michigan Central Rail-
road, was recently presented with an
address and a few gifts at St. Thomas,
Ont., by the employees of the depart-
ment, with which he had been identified.
Mr. Potts has been an old and valued
official on the M. C. R. R., and retires
retaining the highest regard of both offi-
cers and men.
Mr. John Roach, engineer on the
Columbus division of the Pittsburg. Cin-
cinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railroad,
has been appointed assistant road fore-
man of engines on the same road, with
headquarters at Carnegie, Pa. Mr.
Roach will have jurisdiction over the
Washington, Pa., branch, also the
Bridgeville and McDonald branch, and
the Western Washington Railroad ani
the Carnegie yards.
Mr. Joseph J. Williams, of Dennison.
Ohio, has been appointed assistant gen-
eral foreman of the Dennison shops of
the Pan Handle. Mr. Williams served
his apprenticeship in the shop of which
h^ is now an officer. At one time he
held the position of night round-house
foreman, after which he was appointed
locomotive inspector for the Pennsyl-
vania company's lines, having charge oi
new work done In outside locomotive
building establishments.
Mr. George H. Gibson has resigned
his position with the Westinghouse
Companies' Publishing Department oi
Pittsburg. Pa., to accept a position with
the B. F. Sturtevant Company, of Ja-
maica Plain Station. Boston, Mass., the
well-known manufacturers of blowers,
heating, ventilating and forced-draft ap-
paratus, electrical machinery and steam
engines. Mr. Gibson was formerly a
member of the editorial staff of the Engi-
neering Ne^vs, of New York city, and is
a graduate of the Engineering School of
the L'ni\crsity of Michigan.
Mr. William Reed, formerly of the
Rogers wurks. and more recently ap-
pointed superintendent of the Brooks
works of the .\nierican locomotive com-
pany, at Dunkirk, N. Y., notice of which
appeared in our personal column last
month, has been promoted to be assist-
ant superintendent of the American Lo-
comotive works at Schenectady, N. Y.
Mr. Reed is a Paterson, N. J., boy, a
graduate of the high school, and learned
the locomotive business at the Rogers
works, rising there to the assistant sup-
erintendency.
Mr. yi, K. Barnum.
Mr. M. K. Barnum has been ap-
pointed superintendent of motive power
and equipment of the Chicago, Rock
Island and Pacific, succeeding Mr. G. F.
Wilson, resigned. Mr. Barnum is best
.MR. JI()RG.\N K. BARNUM.
known to the railroad world through his
connection with the Union Pacific as
master mechanic in charge of the shops
at Omaha. He was celebrated as a par-
ticularly efficient shop manager, and co-
operating with Mr. McConnell, intro-
duced so many labor saving appliances
that the shops were examples that were
imitated all over the country. For the
last few months Mr. Barnum has been
assistant superintendent of motive power
nf the Southern Railroad. He possesses
the very useful faculty of getting on well
with men of all grades, which will stand
him in good stead with tlie vast variety of
men who will now be under his charge.
Mr. George Gregory, who it was said
had resigned from the Chicago Great
Western, has not resigned, but holds the
position of master mechanic of the W.
M. & P. division on that road, which
position he has occupied since last No-
vember. At the time of his appointment
he was also made acting master me-
chanic of the Mason City & Fort Dodge
division. The transfer of Mr. T. H.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
139
York from the Eastern division of the
Chicago Great-Western Railway, has
only relieved Mr. Gregory of the extra
duty which had been temporarily as-
signed to him.
Mr. Edward W. Pratt has been ap-
pointed master mechanic on the Tremont,
Elkliorn & Missouri Valley at Missouri
Valley, vice Mr. S. A. Teal, retired.
Mr. E. E. Betts, formerly train master
on the C., R. I. & P.. has been appointed
chief clerk to the division superintendent
at Boon, la., vice Mr. G. H. Stcen, re-
signed.
Mr. Chas. H. Temple has been appoint-
ed acting master mechanic of the Pacific
division of the Canadian Pacific Railway
at Revelstoke. B. C, vice Mr. G. Hall,
promoted. Mr. Temple has been on the
Pacific Division since it was opened in
1886.
Mr. E. W. Ailing, an engineer on the
New York, New Haven & Hartford Rail-
road, has been appointed to the position
of air brake inspector on the same road,
vice Mr. Oviatt, promoted.
Mr. R. J. Gross, second vice-president
of the American Locomotive Comipany,
has gone on a trip around the world.
His purpose is to investigate the Orien-
tal countries as fields for locomotives.
Mr. Gross is an old railroad man, and he
will be quite at home following the in-
vestigation? he is engaged on.
Mr. Alexander Shields, who was re-
cently appointed master mechanic of the
Canadian Northern Railway at Winnipeg,
was presented, on leaving the C. P. R..
with a magnificent onyx clock, mounted
in solid gold by the employees of the
round house, and with a solid silver tea
service by the C. P. R. engineers and fire-
men. Mr. Shields resided for many years
at Toronto Junction, and was one of the
most popular men on the Canadian Pa-
cific.
Mr. J. H. Burns, of Cedar Rapids, la.,
for a number of years master mechanic
of the Burlington, Cedar Rapids &
Northern, and late of the Northern dis-
trict of the C. R. I. & P. Ry., was on
January 18 presented with a diamond
ring as a token of esteem by his former
employees. The resignatioti of Mr.
Burns was something of a surprise to
all concerned, and deep regret was
felt on all sides. He was a loyal offi-
cer of the company, but at the same
time the interests of his men were
never lost sight of by him. The deep
feeling of mutual confidence which ex-
isted was demonstrated at the presenta-
tion and by the universal expression that
he was a "grand old man." All ranks
on the old B. C. R. & N. unite in wish-
ing Mr. Burns every success in his new
position as master mechanic on the Chi-
cago Great-Western, at Dubuque, la.
The Reading's New Shops.
A most interesting object lesson in
modern railway shop equipment may be
had by any one who visits the new repair
plant recently established by the Phila-
delphia & Reading Railway. These
shops, situated at Reading, Pa., are to
the whole system what the power-house
is to the shops. They form the distributing
center, and the farthest outlying portions
of the road are less than 200 miles from
this geographical center.
The power-house is one of the best in-
stallations in the country. Tunnels ra-
diate from it for the conveyance of elec-
tricity, live steam, exhaust steam, hot
and cold water and compressed air. The
pipes are fully protected in the tunnels,
while all the time they are capable of in-
spection. The boilers are upright
Wickes water tubular, with Roney auto-
matic stokers, and the whole of the coal
handling plant was made by the P. & R.
C. & I. Company, and is not subject to
the interference of weather changes. The
Holly system of removing entrained
water in separators is used. Exhaust
steam heats shops and the Warren-Web-
ster system of returning the water of
condensation to the boilers is in opera-
tion.
The machine shop occupies 60 ft. of
center width of a 740 ft. building flanked
by two areas 70x740 ft., in which are ar-
ranged the erecting shop pits, 35 pits
down each side, placed at right angles
to the length of the building. In the
machine shop the electric-group plan has
been adopted for tool driving. The
shafting is in varying lengths, turning
in roller bearings with separate motor
for each section.
The entrance and exit of engines is ef-
fected upon two tracks, one at each end
of the shop, and each track terminates
at 65 ft. turntable outside. Each erect-
ing shop is served by a Niles 120-ton
electric crane of 69 ft. span, with two
trolleys. Each shop has also at a lower
level a 35-ton crane. The boiler shop
has a duplicate 35-ton crane, and as the
track of the west erecting shop crane is a
continuation of that in the boiler shop,
the west side may be said to be served
by tvifo 35-ton cranes. If one of these
cranes traveled from the upper end of
the erecting shop to the lower end of the
boiler shop and back, such an excursion
would cover-nearly half a mile. Over
the central portion where the machines
are placed, two lo-ton cranes of 55 ft.
lo-in. span operate. The tool-rooms are
in the center of the shop. The wheel de-
partment is immediately north of tool-
rooms, the cylinders occupy next place on
east side and on the west side the brake
work is done. South of the tool-rooms
all other machine work is carried on.
The main shafting is high up out of the
way, while the counter-shafts are sup-
ported on cantilevers fastened to the
posts. In addition to the other carrying
facilities in the shops there are what may
be called outriggers from the posts for
trolleys for handling rods, etc., with
pneumatic lioists. Outside the walls of
the shop and covered by lean-tos are lour
wash-rooms, supplied with hot and cold
water. There are also seven Buffalo
Forge Fans for heating this building,
also placed in lean-tos, so the entire floor
space is available for the work of the
shop.
The whole building is a well-lighted
brick structure, with steel posts and roof
trusses, and the clear story is filled in
entirely with glass. Between each pit
there is a stand or rack for rods, pipes,
etc., with broad channels on top to carry
cabs when removed from engines. At one
end of these racks is a box with five
holes for the attachment of the wires of
portable electric lights. These lamps are
kept in the tool-room and may be ob-
tained by cheque. A pipe is run down
each post which supplies gas for the
lighting or the heating of work when re-
quired. Each pit is supplied with hot
and cold water and compressed air. A
longitudinal track of standard gauge
runs down the center of the machine
shop, through the store house and into
the receiving yard beyond. The cross
track at the north end of the shop, pre-
viously referred to as one of the means
of affording entrance and exit to en-
gines, communicates with a small ad-
joining building in which are placed two
cleaning vats 10 ft. x 20 ft. x 7 ft. deep.
A pneumatic crane, 7 1-2 tons capacity,
overhead, lowers or raises smaller parts
in baskets while an engine truck or a
pair of driving wheels may be dipped
into the strong lye and thus thoroughly
cleaned before further work is done.
The boiler shop is 400x70 ft., and is
continuous with the west bay of the
machine shop, as already described. A
lean-to 400x50 ft. contains boiler shop
machinery, flanging shop, sheet iron
shop and flue shop, while the riveting
tower is placed near the center of the
lean-to. An ample hydraulic riveter,
with 17-ft. gap, arranged to give 40, 80
or 120 tons pressure on the rivet, has
been installed below crane with hy-
draulic lift and hand traverse, which is
63 ft. above the floor. The operator
stands on a staging attached to the
riveter, with extension floor which can
be used as desired. Beside the riveter
is a flange press of the latest pattern.
It has a capacity of 560 tons. It is con-
structed with a main ram to raise the
center table, with internal ram for use
as required. There are also four auxil-
iary jack-rams working through the cen-
ter table and there is an auxiliary ram
in the top head which is adjustable from
the center to two feet to one side.
(Water pressure is obtained from a set
of triple double-acting pumps, driven by
a loo-horse power motor, working at
1.500 pounds pressure in the accumu-
140
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903-
lator.) The tank shop occupies the
lower end of the main bay. The tube
rattler is contained in a separate build-
ing outside the shop so that the noise
is not very loud in the main shop. A
large wash-room has also been provided,
and tlie heating arrangement is the same
system as that employed in the erecting
shops.
The storehouse is located between the
boiler shop and the blacksmith's shop,
within convenient distance of the ma-
chine shop, foundry, etc. The floor level
is that of a box-car floor for convenience
in unloading. Outside are large plat-
forms, for the storage of castings, built
up to the same level as a car floor.
The forge and smithy is a long build-
ing, each department occupying a floor
space of 275 ft. X 60 ft. The forge is next
to the machine shop. A lean-to con-
tains six furnaces with waste-heat boiler
for the hammers. The furnaces are
equipped with blower and exhaust fans
to take away smoke with branches from
fire holes and doors. The smiths' fires
use the Sturtevant down-draft system,
and are arranged in three sections, each
of which contains blast and exhaust
fans. At the south end of the smithy
machines, etc., are grouped and oper-
ated by an electric motor. The hammers
and fires for heavy work are served with
jib cranes, while a lO-ton electric trav-
eling crane runs over the entire shop.
A standard wash-room is also appended.
The foundry building is 400 ft. x 130
ft. Over the central bay a lo-ton Niles
crane is operated. Two Whiting cupolas
are placed in front of the blower room
in which two electrically driven blowers
are installed. An electrically operated
elevator for material is in a tower be-
hind, which is accessible from the stock
house or the yard. Four five-ton elec-
tric jib cranes can be moved to and from
any post in the shop, as occasion re-
quires, just as a man might take down
a shutter from a window. The north-
west corner of the shop is devoted to
brass work, machinery for finishing
bearings will be installed in the near fu-
ture. A brass stock room occupies the
northwest corner. In the northeast cor-
ner is a large room for cleaning cast-
ings, in which a pneumatic sand blast
will be used. Each side bay of the main
shop is equipped with four pneumatic
traveling hoists. A wash-room is also
attached, with the unique feature that
shower baths can be had by the lucky
foundry-man employed in the shop, and
this is in addition to the hands and face
washing facilities which this and all the
other Reading shops enjoy.
The stock house for foundry material
has depressed narrow gauge track and
bins communicating with the electric ele-
vator which runs up to the cupola charg-
ing floor.
A building north of the foundry con-
tains lumber storage, carpenter and
paint shops, scale department, in which
the weigh-scales of the entire road are
repaired and adjusted, and the electrical
department, all on the ground floor. The
woodworking and pattern shops are on
the second floor and the third and fourth
stories are devoted to pattern storage.
Two large outside electric elevators
serve this building. Altogether the
Reading plant is the largest and prob-
ably the most modern railway plant in
the country.
To Visit Us.
It is reported that a deputation of
officials belonging to the London &.
North-Western Railway are coming to
the United States to study our methods
of operating railroads. The London &
Northwestern have always insisted that
their appliances and methods are as
nearly perfection as they can be made,
and that they were an example for other
railways to follow with the assurance
that they have safe guidance. We sus-
pect that the deputation will come and
look over our railroads and our machin-
ery, then return home and report that
they found nothing worthy of imitation.
compound it would be 442 C 163. If the
tank was carried on the main frames the
letter T would be placed between the
figures indicating the wheel arrangement
and those indicating the total weight.
The "wheel figures," if we may so call
them, may be separated by hyphens, ac-
cording to "the taste and fancy of the
speller," as the elder Mr. Weller said
when asked if he wrote his name with
a W or a V. Using this modified Whyte
system, a heavy compound consolidation
engine might be written 2-8-0 C 200,
which would mean that the engine
weighed 200,000 pounds and was a com-
pound with the wheel arrangement given.
040 ^00
« WHEEL SWITCHER
060 A 000 _
PRO A nooo
240 ^n O O
260_^Q_QQQ.
4 COUPLED
PRO An 0000 _
Pino An OOOOO
440 Ann 00
4fiO An nOOQ
MOGUL
CONSOLIDATION
DECAPOD
B WHEEL
10 WHEEL
AP.D An nOOOO
History of the Baldwin Locomotive
Worlts.
The Baldwin people have just issued
a history of the works which has been re-
vised and brought up-to-date. It covers
the period from 1831 to 1902, and gives
the names and changes in the personnel
of the firm from that day to this. A map
of the present works with recent exten-
sions and improvements is also to be
found in the opening pages. The book
forms a very satisfactory review of the
advance in locomotive design as exem-
plified by one of the pioneer building
concerns and the largest single estab-
lishment in the world to-day. The out-
put of the works is given as 1 18 locomo-
tives in 1866, and in 1871 it appears to
have almost trebled, as 331 engines were
turned out that year. The present estab-
lishment employs 13,000 men, the prin-
cipal departments run continually 23
hours a day, the works consume 2,150
tons of coal per week, and on the aver-
age turn out an engine every 4 hours
and 36 minutes.
Q4_2 J_Q_Qx!
nfiP A 000 o
OR? A 0000 O
044 A on on —
ni^/\ A nOO n n
046 A 00 onn
_4COUPLEPtTRAlLINC
FORNEY A COUPLED
rifift A OOOnn,-,
?42 An 00 o
?62 An 000 n
28i^a_QQQQ-Q
?44 An 00 no
FORNEY 4 COUPLED _
COLUMBIA
OUPLED DOUBLE ENDER
264 ^n OOP 00
PR4 Ar. noon on
246 An 00 000
?e,fj, An 000 nnn
442^nnOOu
462 An nOOOo
444 An nOO 00
ATI ANTIC
PACIFIC .
dfi4 An oOOO 00
44S ^00 00 000 4 .
466.^0 0 000 onn a
_4 COUPLED DOUBLE ENDER.
Locomotive Classification.
The American Locomotive Company
have adopted a system of locomotive
classification which is a modification that
devised by Mr. F. M. Whyte, of the
New York Central. The idea is to elim-
inate the now almost meaningless type
name. Under the new scheme an engine
of the Atlantic type, such as the Norfolk
& Western passenger, illustrated else-
where in this issue, weighing in all 163,-
000 pounds, would be written down as a
442-163. If the engine in question was a
AMERICAN LOCOMOTIVE COMPANY'S
.SYSTEM OF CLASSIFICATION.
Some sort of system is certainly re-
quired, as in at least three instances
there have been more than one type
name applied to the same kind of engine.
Not every one can describe off hand
what the difference is between a De-
capod and a Mastodon, and to the non-
technical public any large engine is a
Mogul. The system now in use by the
American Locomotive Co. gives one the
wheel arrangement, whether the engine
is simple, or compound, or one of the
tank variety, and it also gives the total
weight of the engine itself. After giving
this much information, the system might
not inappropriately add in the words of
the genial showman: "For further par-
ticulars see small bills."
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
141
Cars for New York Underground
Railway.
An order has been given for five hun-
dred cars for the tunnel hne, by the In-
terborough Rapid Transit Company, of
which two-tliirds are to be motor cars
and one-tliird trailers. Two of these
cars, of the parlor pattern, the "John B.
McDonald," furnished by the Westing-
house Company, and the "August Bel-
mont," furnished by the General Electric,
each equipped with two motors of 200
horse-power, which have been running
over the Ninth avenue line, have fully
come up to all of the conditions required
of them in the various tests to which
they were put. A speed of -forty-live
miles per hour was easily attained in the
final test.
The new cars are 50 feet I inch in
length over platforms and 42 feet 7 inches
over oar body, about 3 feet longer than
the cars of the Manhattan Elevated sys-
tem. Their width over window sills is
8 feet II 5-8 inches, 2 5-8 inches wider
thian the Manhattan cars, and their
height from the top of the rail to the
top of the roof 12 feet or 10 1-2 inches
less than those of the Manhattan.
The cars are constructed with the
greatest possible strength, in order to
insure safety. The longitudinal sills
are of compound construction, with
center cross trussing between the
steel needle-beams. The platform end
sills are of steel, fitted with heavy
steel anti-telescoping plate. The side
framing of the car bodies is of
white ash, doubly braced and very heavily
trussed. The platform posts are of com-
pound construction, with anti-telescop-
ing posts of steel bar sandwiched be-
tween heavy white ash posts at corners
and centers of vestibule platform. These
posts are securely bolted to the steel
longitudinal sills and also to steel anti-
telescoping plate below the floor and to
the hood-bow reinforce, which is of
heavy steel angle in one piece, reach-
ing from plate to plate and extending
back into the car body six feet on each
side.
In case of accident, where one platform
rides over the other, eight square inches
of metal would have to be sheared off in
the posts. The vestibule doors on one
car are of the Gibbs type; the side doors
are sliding doors arranged to slide into
pockets in the side framing, thereby giv-
ing up the entire platform to the passen-
gers. The end vestibule door is so ar-
ranged that it will close up the passage-
way between the center vestibule posts,
in which position the entire platform is
given up to the motorman; in another
position the passageway is left open and
the door closed to end post of car body,
giving the motorman a small compart-
ment of about one-third of the platform;
and in the third position the entire plat-
form is given up to passengers while the
door shuts off the motorman's brake
valve and electrical device.
The floors are double, with asbestos
roll fire-felt sandwiched between, and the
floor sheathing is of white pine com-
pletely covered on the under side with
3-16 inch asbestos "Transite" board. All
parts of the car framing, flooring, sheath-
ing and the like are coated with fireproof
paint.
Loose Cylinders Made Tight.
A very neat piece of repair work was
recently done in the Philadelphia &
Reading shops at Reading, Pa. A pas-
senger engine, whose cylinders had
"worked" sufficiently to break the front
flanges, as shown in our illustration, was
very securely patched in the following
manner. Two knees were bolted on the
front through which flange bolts were
ring stood down 3-4 of an inch into the
center casting which had been counter-
bored to receive it. The base for the ex-
haust pipe, which is part of the saddle,
was chipped off on the outside and a
I 1-4 in. square band was shrunk on it.
An external band of the same section
with a pair of car, truss-rod turn-
buckles was passed round the flange
forming the base of the steam chest, and
this band was heated before the turn-
buckles were screwed up, so that it is
now probable that the cylinders have
permanently given up all idea of working
loose again.
R/iUwa]/ ^iLoconwru* ^ngiWf^ I
METHOI> OF TIGHTENING LOOSE
CYLINDERS.
inserted in the usual way, but the most
reliance was placed in the bands and
straps which were applied elsewhere.
The center casting for the engine truck
bolts up to the underside of the saddle
and is lipped-up on the saddle at both
ends in the usual way. This casting had
its lipped-up ends planed off so as to
make room for two straps which are
fitted to the underside of the saddle
front and back. These straps are like
pedestal binders, and are put in place
and bolted up hot, so that the contrac-
tion which follows draws the cylinSers
close together. A further tightening on
the under side is effected by boring a
circular groove of square section in the
center of the saddle. A turned ring i 1-4
x2 in. in section and 6 in. diameter was
dropped in place hot and allowed to
cool. The groove being i 1-4 deep, the
A Block Signal Calendar.
The Union Switch and Signal Com-
pany, of Swissvale, Pa., have got out a
calendar which is simply unique. The
date-recording part of it is what is
known as a universal calendar which
does not become unserviceable with the
close of this year, and this handy feature
of the calendar is very appropriate, as
the use of block sig^nals will grow with
the years and will not become obsolete
with the termination of any fixed
period of time. The attractive feature
is that on the card upon which the calen-
dar is mounted there are six movable
signals about 3 inches long, made of
celluloid and colored "all proper" as
eng^ravers of crests would say. They
stand out very clearly on the deep maroon
background. On the right is the block
signal, with home and distant sema-
phore blade on the same post with con-
tinuous light 60-degree spectacles. For
night signaling this causes a "stop" or a
"caution" light to be displayed until the
semaphore blade is within 10 degrees of
the "clear" position. This is faithfully
reproduced in the beautiful little model,
which can be adjusted with the greatest
precision in a moment. The models are
arranged with the green color as the
"clear" indication, the yellow as the
"caution," and the red as the well-known
imperative "stop." The semaphore
blades indicate their character not only
by their color, but by their shape. The
"home" signal at the top is a square end
blade with white band across the red
ground. The "distant" fish-tail blade
below is colored green and shows a
white cheveron like the sleeve badge of a
sergeant in the regular army.
Other miniature semaphores use what
are called 90-degree spectacles and clearly
indicate the correct color displayed when
the semaphore blade is in any given po-
sition.
We venture to say that this calendar
will be found very useful for purposes
of instruction, because the arms can be
moved just as the real signals along the
track move, and the position assumed
and the light shown by a possibly defec-
tive signal can be simulated on this card
with perfect fidelity. Another possible
I4Z
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
use the calendar may be put to is in case
of controversy about a particular signal
at a certain time. The investigating ofli-
cial can bring the men concerned sepa-
rately into his office and make each one
of them place the model in exactly the
position in vi'hich he remembers the sig-
nal in question to have been, at the time
he savir it.
Spealcing of semaphores reminds us
that Charles Dickens, in Mugby Junction,
amusingly describes the departure of a
railway train in England and the "clear-
ing" of the block signals by saying:
"Then, prodigious wooden razors set
up on end. began shaving the atmos-
phere." We have only this to add to
the great novelist's humor, that the
railway signal razors made by the
Union Switch and Signal Company are
of the "safety" variety, and any railway
which desires to have "clear cut fea-
tures" in connection with its operation
ought to apply first for a calendar and
then for a complete installment.
Trains to Run 110 Hiles an Hour.
Parties interested in the Mona-Rail
Electric Express Railway report that
they expect to have their system in op-
eration between Liverpool and Man-
chester during the present year. They
also expect to connect London and
Brighton with a sort of lightning train
service. They talk of making the mod-
est speed of no miles an hour, and the
places they propose to serve could stand
a little acceleration, but they will prob-
ably find certain obstacles to that speed
which they had not calculated upon.
Experiments that were made in Ger-
many two years ago with electrically
driven cars indicated that a speed was
soon reached that produced shocks
which ordinary track could not endure.
A large proportion of the weight of an
electric truck has no spring interven-
ing between it and the rail. At moder-
ate speed this unresilient body does not
hurt the point of contact very much, but
a velocity is reached within the power
of electrical traction which hamimers the
best steel ever produced out of shape
very rapidly. We hope the mona-rail
people will go on with their no miles
an hour railway. Its operation will
teach people something.
Drawback for Locomotive riaterial
Imported.
Acting Secretary of the Treasury
Spaulding has extended the Department
regulation of March 31, 1899, establish-
ing a rate for allowance of drawback on
locomotive parts known as bars, wrist-
pins, stay bolts and piston rods manu-
factured wholly from imported Taylor
iron, as far as applicable, so as to cover
the exportation of the same and similar
parts including axles manufactured
wholly from bar iron at the various
works of the American Locomotive
Company.
In order to determine just allowances
for waste in all cases the drawback entry
must show for each part or class of parts
exported the weight and value, at the
works, of the iron used as imported and
of the scrap produced therefrom, the
calculations based on such weights and
values to find the quantity of iron con-
sumed being as prescribed under the
head of "locomotive and railway car
wheels," in Treasury decision No. 17,255.
The Department regulation above men-
tioned is amended so as to be subject to
the foregoing provision with respect to
waste allowance.
Self-Closing Tank nan=Hole.
Some of the fast passenger engines on
the Central Railroad of New Jersey have
now and then occasioned temporary in-
convenience to the baggageman riding
in the car coupled to the tender. The
way in which this worthy was given "a
bad quarter of an hour" was that in
scooping water from the track-trough
the tank of the flyer would sometimes
HttUvfajf ^ Locomot\v« Engineering
SELF-CLOSING MAN-HOLE.
become full to overflowing before the
scoop could be lifted. In such a case
the water would flow out of the man-
hole and pour in great volume against
the door of the baggage car, damaging
it more or less or forcing it open, and
flooding the car floor. The very simple
and effective remedy here illustrated was
speedily applied. It consists of arrang-
ing three light iron brackets behind the
hinged man-hole door, which prevents
it opening all the way back. The man-
hole is 48 in. long and the door or lid is
made to stand, when open, at something
less than a right angle, and so always
automatically drops back and keeps the
man-hole shut. When the lid is forced
up by the sudden surge of water when
the tank overflows, the lid swings back
against the supports and compels the
water to flow toward the sides of the
tank and so to the track without reach-
ing the baggage car door. When the up
rush of water subsides the lid falls back
to place again as if nothing had hap-
pened.
We must fight our way onward. We
must be brave. There are obstacles to
be met, and we must meet, and crush
them. — David Copperfield.
A Balanced Engine.
A patent has recently been granted to
a New England man for a perfectly bal-
anced engine. It is a compound, with
two cylinders between tne frames and
two in the usual position. The pistons
of these cylinders, by means o-f piston-
rods, crossheads and connecting rods,
actuate levers lying in a horizontal plane
whiich are pivoted in the frame. The
right outside cylinder and the right in-
side cylinder operate on the two ends of
the right liorizontal lever, which works
something like the walking-beam of a
steamboat. This short horizontal wa]k-
ing-beam has a connection placed be-
tween its inner end and the pivot, very
much in the same relative position as the
condenser pump rods are attached to a
steamer's walking-beam. This connec-
tion rod operates, that is, rocks, a shaft
in the center of the engine, and out-
side the frame this shaft terminates in
a large double-arm rocker. The same
description holds good for the other side
of the engine, the rocker shaft being
made in two pieces works in one central
bearing. The balancing is accomplished
by making the driving wheels without
counter weights, each crank pin being
balanced by a hub on the wheel similar
to that which contains the crank pin. The
large external rocker arm has from
each end a connecting rod. one reach-
ing the forward wheel's crank pin and
the other reaching the crank pin of the
trailer. The pins are so arranged that
when the forward crank pin is on the
bottom quarter, the pin of the trailer is
on the top quarter, and therein the bal-
ancing idea has been worked out. Some
minor detail for joining the connecting
ro^ with what is called a "yieldable
link" has been introduced to compensate
for inequalities of the track.
The patent oflice illustration shows
the arrangement applicable to a 4-4-0
engine, and as there are no side rods
we do not know how engines of other
wheel arrangements would be equipped.
This may be a perfectly balanced en-
gine, but it has on each side nine pin
connections or pivots which are not
found in the ordinary design of locomo-
tive, so that the ability to run hot or
develop lost motion by wear of pin or
brass with consequent increase of main-
tenance charges, has been allowed to
gain a strong foothold in a design where
the usual want of balance may have been
successfully eliminated. There is a law
of mechanics which says that what is
gained in speed is lost in power, or a
gain in power means a loss of speed at
the business end of any machine. There
seems to be a corresponding law of com-
pensation in machine design which,
though not perhaps impossible to over-
come, is yet exceedingly powerful. The
gain in balance in- the machine before
us is secured at a sacrifice of simplicity
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
143
of coiistiiiction, and tlic lack of simplic-
ity in design may easily place an other-
wise good idea, though carefully worked
out, just beyond the dead line which in-
exorably separates what is nieclianically
feasible from that which is commercially
possible. The car wheel loose on its
axle for the purpose of reducing friction
on curves is an exami)le of the same
kind of thing.
How State nanagement of Railways
Works.
At a moment when some Socialists,
more zealous than enlightened and wise,
are planning an electoral campaign on
the issue of the State purchase of the
railroads, it may be useful to point out
the disastrous results that have come
from the management of the railroads in
a European country, Denmark.
The Danish government manages more
than half of the railroad system of the
country and has no reason to be pleased
with the results of its experience. In
four years, from 1898 to 1901, the surplus
of 4,000,000 francs has fallen to less than
500.000 francs, and that in spite of a
steady increase in receipts. For the pres-
ent year a further diminution is antici-
pated.
Now, the deciding factor in this situa-
tion simply is the introduction ot elec-
toral politics into a domain that should
have been closed to it.
While the length of the system has
continued to be practically the same, the
number of employees has increased by
1,400, while their wages have increased
steadily. This is apart from the guaran-
tee of interest and subventions, granted
at the request of the deputies, to lines
managed by private companies.
It might be supposed, perhaps, that in
the presence of such a state of affairs the
Danish government and deputies are
ready to give up these practices. Not at
all. To make up for the deficit in the
budget of railroads they intend merely
to raise all rates for transportation, for
'passengers, freight, postal packages, even
for letters, which amounts to making
everybody pay, through the increased
rate, for the fancies of a few.
This example should be enough for the
advocates of the state purchase of rail-
roads in France.
Safe Transportation.
-A. recent press dispatch from London
says: "Presiding to-day at a meeting of
the shareholders of the London and
South-Western Railway, H. W. Campbell
remarked that if the company did not
adopt American methods it was simply
because what was termed economy in
one country would be rank extravagance
in the other. The officers had experi-
mented with large freight cars, and they
were found quite unsuitcd for their re-
quirements.
"Regarding the passenger traffic, Mr.
Campbell said that, while the length of
the railroads in the United States was
nine times greater than those of Great
Britain, the latter carried twice as many
passengers, or about 18 times as many
per mile of railroad.
"The returns of accidents, Mr. Camp-
bell further remarked, were considered
unusually instructive. Not a single pas-
senger was killed in Great Britain dur-
ing I90t, while 249 were killed in tlie
United States that year and 476 passen-
gers were injured in Great Britain in
1901, against 4,129 injured in that year
in the United States."
The British Board of Trade figures
given in the above comparison were
quoted in Railway and Locomotive
so far been able to accomplish, but the
methods by which this magnificent result
has been achieved are not the methods
which he is at all likely to be pressed to
reform. The London and South-Western
may not care for cost-reducing sugges-
tions from this side, that is, their bus-
iness, but for ourselves it is the duty
of every railroad man in this country
from president to engine wiper to
work steadily toward such a standard of
excellence in operation, as will make
American transportation not only the
cheapest, but the safest in the world
"The Book of the Royal Blue."
"The Book of the Royal Blue" for
February, which is the magazine pub-
lished by the passenger department of
the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, is
ROTARY SNOW PLOUGH BUSY.
Engineering in the September (1902)
issue. The total number of passengers
carried in the United Kingdom in 1901
was 1.142,277,000. Of these 476 were in-
jured, none were killed.
■'American methods," when spoken of
by well-informed persons in railway cir
cles, are generally held to include finan-
cial matters, account keeping, cost-re-
ducing practices, the economical hand-
ling of bulk freight over long distances
in solid trains, the interchange of cars,
etc. These may or may not meet with
the approval of the chairman of the
London and South-Western Railway, but
he is aware of the fact that no sane per-
son can find fault with the system of
train movement which could transport
more than 25 times the entire population
of the British Isles without the loss of a
single life. Col. Campbell may justly feel
proud of the superb transportation per-
formance of his country, which clearly
surpasses what .\merican railroads have
principally devoted to a description of
Harper's Ferry and of the John Brown
raid, and the events connected there-
with. It is written by the editor, Mr.
William Elliott Lowes, in a most inter-
esting style, thus making this issue one
having historic value. We advise per-
sons interested in the events referred to.
to obtain a copy of this number of "The
Book of the Royal Blue," which they
will find a very good publication to file
for future reference. It is very well il-
lustrated with engravings made from
photographs taken during the war time.
A correspondent in New South Wales
writes : "Other drivers and myself have
often found the Detroit lubricator
blocked, the oil not going up in the
'sight glasses,' and by shutting off the
steam for a lew seconds, they have
worked all right, and continued to do so
throughout the trip."
144
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, igoj.
A Railway Completely Ignores a Large
Suburb.
The "unnecessary-ness" of a great deal
of locomotive whistling becomes appar-
ent from the following incident, which is
a true story: A trunk line entering a
large city passed through a suburb, in
which there stood a full-sized and beau-
tifully painted semaphore. This signal
protected a yard in which considerable
switching was done, and the layout of
the tracks was such that the main line had
occasionally to be used. A pensioner of
the road was put in charge of the sema-
phore, and was given a small shanty, just
large enough to contain himself and the
regulation caboose stove. The method
of operating the semaphore, which soon
came into vogue, was that all trains, even
regular expresses, used to whistle for
this sigsal, and on h'earing the whistle,
if the line was clear, the semaphore man
lowered the red and white arm. He
never looked out for the train, he waited
to be "asked" for a clear track.
There are several ways in which this
"asking" may be done. There is the
long, steady whistle, which seems to say,
"Here we are, let us in!" There is also
the excited blast, which implies the
words, "Now, then, old sleepy, look
alive!!" and there is the sudden, explosive,
ear-piercing shriek, which, if delivered
immediately opposite the signal-light at
night, may put it out. This latter sound
seems to say, "What the blank are you
keeping us here for so blanked long!!!"
Now all this whistling and shrieking
had for its object the arousing of one
man's attention to the need of the train.
By the rules of the road, this semaphore
had to be lowered before any train could
proceed. By the curiously established
custom each train had to whistle for it.
By the laws of nature sound is propa-
gated in all directions at an approximate
velocity of i.ioo feet a second, and by a
combination of all three, about 20,000
law-abiding citizens of the suburb were
let into the secret, unwillingly, not once
or twice, but many times a day. But,
gentle reader, as the ancient Greeks used
to say, "the feet of the avenging gods
are shod with wool." The city passed a
by-law prohibiting all whistling within
its limits, except for "cause" — and the
signalman forgot.
On the day after this ordinance went
into effect, fast express Two Two — Too,
approached, slowed down, crept up to
the semaphore, and halted without a
sound save the "swish" of the air brakes.
The train crew waited; then they "got
together," and incidentally gave their
opinion of the situation in fluent and
forcible English, which, by the way, was
totally unfit for publication. The brake-
man, as a deputation of one, walked reso-
lutely forward over several hundred
yards of excellent permanent way and
surprised the signalman. The brakeman
"used language" and the semaphore was
lowered without the knowledge of the
20,000 law-abiding citizens aforesaid.
On the following day the train mail
brought a letter to the suburban station
which was eagerly read by the side of
the caboose stove in the shanty. The
letter was signed by the superintendent,
and was written in the well-known "I-
do-not-for-a-moment - think - you-could-
possibly-have-helped-it" style, but it
ended with the very familiar, though
ominous words, "please let me have your
explanation." It is needless to say that
the so-called explanation offered was
more than exceedingly lame, and felt
down badly everywhere it could, but af-
ter that, the "regrettable incident," as
diplomats say, was considered closed.
Thereafter, the signalman, though old
and somewhat infirm, was most surpris-
ingly alert. Trains were not stopped
without serious "cause," and 20,000 su-
burbanites were able to pursue the even
Cylinder Boring Bar.
The accompanying drawing shows a
new style cylinder boring bar recently
made by Mr. C. D. Higgins, of Boone
shops of the Chicago and North Western
Railway, for boring out cylinders of
locomotives. The advantages of this
bar over the old style boring bar is that
the cylinders can be bored without re-
moving guides or breast beam. Another
advantage is that the shaft is very rigid,
so that it carries three tools and in most
cases but one cut is all that is necessary
to true up a cylinder. In a practical test
of the tool made here recently a cut was
run through a 20x26 inch cylinder in
I hour and 50 minutes. The inventor
will protect his improvement by patent.
A. B. SlI-LIM.\N.
Boone. la.
rietal Plated Cars for the Interborough.
We have been informed that the presi-
dent of the Interborough Rapid Transit
SaVtBap^ LacomoRfg EnginMring
C. D. HIGGINS CYLINDER BORING BAR. C. & N. W. RY. CO.
tenor of their way in absolute silence as
far as the Loud Whistle & Shriek Rail-
way Company was concerned. Thus were
the inhabitants totally ignored by the
road.
Moral: "Please let me have your ex-
planation" is a powerful formula, even
when an experienced man with a search-
light cannot discover the faintest trace of
so much as the mere outlines of the
thing asked for.
The Rhodes Curry Co. have estab-
lished car building works at Amhurst.
Nova Scotia, and are likely to receive
sufficient patronage to build up prosper-
ous works. They are in a position to
receive a plentiful supply of timber
necessary for car building, which gives
them raw material at low cost. They
have received orders for about 600 box
cars and are expecting an order for ten
first-class passenger cars for the Cana-
dian Pacific.
Company has awarded a contract to the
Metal Plated Car and Lumber Company,
of this city, for the sheathing of 500 In-
terborough Rapid Transit passenger
coaches with copper sheeting in its
natural color. The Interborough Com-
pany has adopted the metal-plated car
system as its standard. The metal-plated
car system was invented in 1899 by W.
P. Appleyard, master car builder of the
N. Y., N. H. & H., and has been suc-
cessfully used for several years by a
number of steam railroa(fs, among which
are the Erie, Fitchburg Division of the
Boston & Maine and the N. Y., N. H.
& H.; but this is the first time that
copper in its natural color has been
adopted. Previously it has always been
oxidized. The advantages of the metal-
plated car system are said to be the pro-
tection of wood against fire, saving by
the elimination of the cost of painting
and varnishing. The saving in mainten-
ance on steam roads is said to be $75
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
145
Graphite
per car per year. The copper sheathing
used by the Intcrborough Company will
be lacquered.
For the
Ip-to-Date
Engineer
Our chief editor has gone to visit the
Pacific Coast and the States about and
beyond the Rocky Mountains. If he
should be slow in answering personal
letters the writers had better possess
their souls in patience, as there are many
opportunities for a letter to miss its
goal when it goes chasing addresses that
are scattered over four or five thousand
miles.
while retaining the individuals hereto-
fore connected with the Q. & C. Com-
pany. Both parties to the agreement are
to be congratulated.
It is a matter of common
knowledge that the addi-
tion of pure ilake graphite
increases the service which
may be obtained from the
lubricant, whether oil or
grease, and, hence, reduces
the total quantity which is
required to be used.
The fact, also, that jour-
nals thus lubricated run
satisfactorily, which when
supplied with other lubri-
cants at once become hot,
is taken as sufficient proof
that the lubricating value of
the mixture is increased by
the presence of Dixon's
flake graphite.
Again, the value of Dix-
on's flake graphite as a
remedy for hot-boxes in
many different classes of
service has long been rec-
ognized. The up-to-date
engineer should have at
hand, for use in an emer-
gency, a suppl)^ of Dixon's
pure flake graphite.
Samples free.
JOSEPH DIXON
CRUCIBLE COMPANY
Jersey City, N. J.
The Cleveland Twist Drill Company
have issued what they call "ready refer-
ence cards," to hang up in the shop.
There are three cards about 9x6 inches,
connected at the top bj a brass ring, from
which the cards hang, but loosely enough
to permit any card being readily re-
ferred to. The first card contains infor-
mation about the speed of drills; the
second gives dimensions of the U. S.
standard system of bolts and nuts and the
drill list for gas taps ; the third presents
the drill list for taps with U. S. standard
threads, and for machine screw taps ; the
fourth shows the drill list for taps with
V-shaped threads, and the fifth illus-
trates the dimensions of taper shanks for
Cleveland twist drills, and closes with a
table of the parts of an inch in decimals,
for use with micrometer calipers. The
Cleveland Twist Drill Company will be
happy to send a set of cards to those
who require them for shop use, and who
apply to the company.
A case which Judge Werner, who
writes the opinion, regards as unique,
was decided by the Court of Appeals of
New York in favor of the New York,
New Haven and Hartford Railroad
against the estate of George Dean, an
engineer of the railroad, who was
killed in a collision. Suit was brought
and a verdict for $5,000 was rendered
against the company. The Court of Ap-
peals reverses the decision on the ground
that the entire estate of Dean, in New
York State, consisted of a wartch and
chain, brought from Connecticut after
Dean's death, for the purpose of giving
the New York courts jurisdiction. Judge
Werner says an estate in such a case
must come into the State "in good faith
and in due course of business."
The Railway Appliances Company. Old
Colony Building. Chicago, makes the
announcement that the business and af-
fairs of the Q. & C. Company have been
consolidated with their own and that
hereafter the Railway Appliances Com-
pany will conduct the business of both
concerns. This consolidation greatly en-
larges the facilities of the new company.
Large Patent Universal Wood Worker.
We invite the attention of car builders
and master mechanics to the machine here
shown, as it has been designed to success-
fully meet most particular requirements.
It will do a large variety of work; it saves
the use of separate machines, as it does
each kind of work advantageously. It is
very powerful and adapted for heavy
work, and is especially useful in car shops
and where large timbers are worked. Spe-
cial consideration is invited to the follow-
ing points, which are embodied in its
make-up: i. — It is made to plane 16 inches
wide, and will to advantage plane out of
wind, surface straight or tapering, rabbet
and tace inside blinds, rabbet door
frames; bevel, joint, chamfer, bore, gain,
bead, rip, cross-cut, tenon, rout, groove,
work circular moldings, and other like
work. 2. — Vibration and wear on all
parts are lessened by new and in?»'n'oii =
NO. 4. PATENT INIVERS.II. WOOD WORKER.
devices, while the different adjustments,
change of knives, etc., can be made
easily, quickly and accurately, as it has
been the aim to make the machine as
labor-saving as possible. 3. — .\n attach-
ment for boring is mounted at back of
column, having a table and necessary
stops to regulate the cuts. A fence is
also provided for angle boring, and a
table is placed on top of the boring table
for rotary mortising. 4.— The tables
are planed true, each has independent
vertical and longitudinal adjustments,
and are easily raised and lowered. The
adjustable fence and bevel rest requires
no separate adjusting, as it raises and
lowers with the tables. Those interested
will be furnished with further details,
cuts and terms by applying to the mak-
ers, J. A. Fay & Egan Co.. of No. 445
West Front street, Cincinnati, Ohio,
who will also send free to those inter-
ested their new and complete catalogue
of wood working machinerj-.
We can see no more to the bottom of
the next few hours than we can see to
the bottom of this river. — Charles Dick-
ens.
145
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
Around the World.
- A revival of the dramatic version of
Jules Verne's famous story, "Around the
World in Eighty Days." was recently
presented at one of the Proctor theaters
in New York. It is now stated on what
is believed to be good authority that a
journey around the world in the course
of the next year may possibly be accom-
plished in 40 days. When the rails of the
Siberian line are all laid it will be pos-
sible on the first through trains to go
from Moscow to Irkutsk in si.x days, and
from Irkutsk to Vladivostok or Port
Arthur in three days. The time table
around the world from Paris will then
be: Paris to Vladivostock, 13 days; to
Nagasaki, two days; to Yokohama, two
days; to San Francisco, 12 days; to New
York, four days; to Cherbourg, six days,
and to Paris in less than half a day. This
may give a new impetus to "globe trot-
ters."
Traveling Engineers' Convention
Report.
We have received the volume con-
taining the Proceedings of the Tenth
Annual Convention of' the Traveling En-
gineers' Association. It contains the re-
ports and discussions at the last conven-
tion and is a valuable and interesting
volume. We have published extracts
from the report and the discussions but
the work calls for an examination as a
whole, to show a reader how much
more valuable the whole is compared
with a part. The volume contains 330
pages of reading matter, nearly every
page being redolent with information
which every man connected with the me-
chanical department of railroads ought
to study. In paper covers the volume
costs 75 cents, and in leather $1.00. The
report can be obtained through this of-
fice.
The Newton Machine Tool Works
(incorporated), of Philadelphia, have
just issued their bulletin No. 35. It con-
tains a description of "a new method of
keyseating." This work is done by a
double-spindle milling machine. The
keyway is milled out the required depth
and width by a cutter of appropriate size,
carried on a horizontal spindle, and the
ends are finished by a cutter carried on a
vertical spindle, which cutter is the ex-
act width of the keyway. The cutters
for this machine go in pairs and are
marked accordingly. The tool is neat
and substantial, and its operation is not
only explained in detail, but is illustrated
by three excellent half-tones. .-X num-
ber of other tools made b}' the same firm
are shown in half-tone pictures, but
without description. The bulletin will be
sent to those who desire it. on applica-
tion to the Newton Works, Philadelphia.
Lunkenheimer fleclianical Oil Cup
Reference to our illustration will show
a very neat mechanically operated oil
cup or lubricator, in which the feed is
positive, as it is in fact a small pump.
The driving mechanism is of the ratchet
type and is operated by the clutches F
and A' that work co-operatively by the
motion of the rod /, which can be at-
tached to the eccentric rod, or other
moving parts of the engine, by the
couplings K and M. The motion thus ob-
tained is transmitted to the piston E by
the crank-pin mechanism H and G. The
ratchet wheel D is provided with a han-
dle whereby it can be rotated by hand
in case it is desirable to force a quantity
of oil at any time, as, for example, when
starting the engine. By moving the part
K up or down the rod, the stroke of the
pump can be lengthened or shortened,
as desired, thus regulating the amount of
oil fed by the pump independent of the
feed from the oil cup. The outlet C is
piped to the steam pipe or chest of the
engine, and the spring check valve X
MECH.4NIC.\L OIL Cri>
should be placed as near the end of the
pipe as possible, preferably into the
steam pipe. The bottom of the pump
body B is tapped l/i-m. pipe thread to re-
ceive a stand so that it can be placed
wherever desired. The pump is substan-
tially constructed, the workmanship be-
ing first-class, and, as the parts are
made to jigs and templets, they can all
be easily renewed, being perfectly inter-
changeable. The ratchet wheel D and
pawls F and N are made of tool steel,
tempered and hardened. All other metal
parts about the pump are made of the
very best hard bronze composition.
The Lunkenheimer Company, of Cin-
cinnati, Ohio, will be happy to supply
catalogue and further information to
any one interested enough to apply to
them. Their New York office is at 26
Cortlandt street.
What a beautiful thing human nature
may be made to be. — Oliver Twist.
Q. &C.
Pneumatic
Tools.
HAMMERS, DRILLS, RIVETERS
HOISTS AND
METAL SAWING MACHINES
PNEUMATIC TOOLS
For Every Possible Use
SIMPLEST AND BEST
FEWINGS' CAR AND ENGINE
REPLACER
Will Stand the Weight of the
Heaviest Locomotive. Strong-
est and surest replacer in the
market.
DROP FORGE KNUCKLE PINS
Q. & C. BRAKE SHOE KEYS
GLOBE VENTIUTORS
Send for Catalogs on Track,
Locomotive and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with the Q. & C. Co.
GENERAL OFFICES, Old Colony Building
...CHICAGO...
New York Office, 114 Liberty Street
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
147
"When Found Hake a Note Of."
That most amusing character in
Dicl<cns' "Dombey and Son" — Captain
Cuttle, had a habit of saying, "When
found, mal<e a note of," about anything
which struck liim as of peculiar interest.
There is much sound advice in the Cap-
tain's saying, because the ability to
quickly refer to a subject and get the in-
formation one wants, accurately and
clearly, without trusting to memory, is
most important. Just here the question
of the ownership of a book one likes
comes up. A borrowed book seems to
lose some of its value because it cannot
be referred to after being read and re-
turned. No one can remember every-
thing in the book he reads, especially if
that book is technical in character, and
the safest way is to carefully select the
book or books which will be of the most
use, and then buy and own them out
and out. When one owns a book it be-
comes to him practically a reference
library, and he can do what Captain
Cuttle recommended with great advan-
tage to himself. Below are a few of the
books which we believe will be found
useful, and we have made notes of.
A year's subscription to Railway and
Locomotive Engineering costs only
$2.00, and the paper is a welcome visitor,
especially where there are children.
"The World's Railway" is a most in-
teresting history of railways and loco-
motives. It is beautifully illustrated and
the net price used to be $10.00. We now
give it and a year's subscription to Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering for
$5.00.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Sinclair, is an old and
universal favorite. A well-known gen-
eral manager remarked in a meeting of
railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." The price is $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. A
very helpful book combining instruction
and amusement. It is a particularly use-
ful book to a young mechanic. It has a
stimulating effect in inducing young men
to study their business. Price, 50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling en-
gineers in the examination of firemen for
promotion and of engineers likely to be
hired. It contains in small compass a
wonderful amount oi information about
the locomotive. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recommend this book. 75
cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin. A
little study of this book will instruct a
man so that he will understand the con-
struction and operation of a compound
locomotive as well as he understands a
simple engine. Tells all about running,
about breakdowns and repairs. Conve-
nient pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable one to take out a license to run a
stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horse power, condens-
ers, feed water heaters, air pumps, en-
gines, strength of boilers, testing boiler
performances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list. Question and answer style.
128 pages. Pocket size, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." ftaps. A book that ought to be
in the hands of every person who is in
any way interested in keeping boilers in
safe working order. Written by a fore-
man boilermaker. Also contains sev-
eral chapters on oil-burning locomotives.
SO cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language easily under-
stood. $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can aflFord to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of combus-
tion. While treating on the chemistry of
heat and combustion is easily understood
by every intelligent fireman. 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for people trying
to learn all about air brakes. Tells the
whole story. Cloth, 75 cents. Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting.
laughable and best of all are of practical
value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehensive
treatise on the subject Ought to be
studied by all trainmen where block sig-
nals are used. $3.00.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
A western air-brake repair company
has been organized in Pittsburg, Pa.
There have been companies organized
repeatedly to carry on a business in re-
pairing cars and locomotives, but they
seldom have succeeded in making the
business remunerative.
I4S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
Cement Machinery.
- Catalogue No. 15 (sixth edition) of the
Allis-Chalmers Company, of Chicago, is
concerned with cement machinery. In
this very handy little publication the
methods of making Portland cement are
briefly outlined, and the plan and eleva-
tion of a modern crushing plant is
given.
The Gates rock and ore breaker is il-
lustrated and explained, and the Gates
elevator, style "A," is similarly treated.
The Gates iron frame revolving screen
for "sorting" the sizes of crushed ma-
terial, is shown in a good half-tone with
suitable explanation accompanying it.
Fine breakers and crushing rolls are also
dealt with. In fact, examples of all
kinds of machinery for pulverizing, grind-
ing, breaking and crushing stone or rock
or any kind of refractory material, may
be found in the Allis-Chalmers' cata-
logue, and those interested in cheap and
expeditious methods of producing rail-
way ballast of any size, will be interested
in this publication.
The second part is devoted to the con-
sideration of machinery for producing
and pulverizing Portland cement clinker,
and among the features presented are the
rotary kiln, the raw material storage bin,
hot clinker-handling appliances, the ball
mill, which is illustrated in half-tone and
line cut, thus showing the simplicity and
efficiency of the machine, the Gates tube
mill, and coal crushing and disintegrat-
ing machinery. The Allis-Chalmers
Company, of Chicago, will be happy to
send a copy to anyone who is sufficiently
interested to apply to them for it. Their
New York office is in the Broad Ex-
change Building.
ard goods, consisting of air compressors,
air jioists, pneumatic riveters and special
railroad tools. The selling office is at
85, 87 and 89 Liberty street, New York
City.
An interesting experiment is about to
be made by M. Noblemaire, director of
the Paris, Lyons and Mediterranean
Railway. He has organized a salon for
railway employees which will be held
next month under the auspices of the
Societe Artistique and Literaire. The
members of the salon are employees who
have a taste for art and literature. Works
of art, paintings and sculpture executed
by the railway men will be placed on
exhibition in the Gare de Lyon.
No railway company buys a horse after
it is seven years old, says the Lon-
don Tid-Bils. The Midland has 1,350
horses, the Great Northern 1,300, the
Great Western 1,100, the South-Western
550, the South-Eastern 275 and the Lon-
don Brighton 225. The London and
North-Western has only 650 horses, but
the firm that does most of the North-
western business has 4,000 horses. The
majority of London railway horses work
seventy hours a week. As a rule the
London railway horse is bought at i6o
and is sold at iio or ii2.
The Pedrick & Ayer Company have
been for a great many years located at
Philadelphia, Pa. They have now re-
moved to Plainfield, New Jersey, and are
now occupying the new works, which
have just been completed. The main
building is four hundred feet long and one
hundred feet wide. Independent power-
house, blacksmith shop, pattern shop and
pattern storage are also provided. This
new shop has been equipped with elec-
tric traveling cranes and modern tools
so as to enable the company to meet the
largely increased demand for their stand-
The Joseph Dixon Crucible Company,
of Jersey City, have issued what they
call a souvenir of an inspection trip
made by the American Society of Civil
Engineers to the new terminal of the
North German Lloyd Steamship Com-
pany, in Hoboken, N. J. The souvenir
contains a full description of the "new
departure in the science of pier construc-
tion." The structure is said to be en-
tirely fireproof. Several excellent half-
tones illustrate the booklet. The entire
structural steel and metal work of bulk-
head building and piers are protected
with Dixon's silica-graphite paint. The
Dixon people will be happy to send a
copy to any one who cares to apply.
The locomotive engineers of New
York State made persistent efforts to
have Governor Odell appoint one of
their number Railroad Commissioner.
Governor Odell is perfectly infatuated in
his affection for locomotive engineers,
and habitually strains the English lan-
guage to select expression of admira-
tion for the men who run locomotives.
But when it comes to appointing a man
to a fat position, that is another matter.
He is then ready to strain the law to
land a back politician in the place. It
is only when they do not want any favor
that practical railroad men are popular
with the smart Governor of New York
State.
The late Spanish-American war seems
to have impressed upon the engineers of
the Spanish Government the need of
adopting the most modern methods in
the manufacture of munitions of war.
They are installing Westinghouse motors
in their gun shops at Trubia, and the
Spanish arsenal at Ferrol is also shortly
to be equipped with a number of motors
and other electrical machinery.
Nature often enshrines gallant and
noble hearts in weak bosoms. — Old
Curiosity Shop.
Competition
It isn't the competitor who
employs cheap labor that wor-
ries yoti.
And it isn't the one who uses
cheap pneinnatic tools.
Why .' Because you know
that cheap labor and cheap
tools make hifrh cost of work.
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
cost more to buy than any
others — but their product is so
large that it puts labor-cost
away down.
Are you using inferior tools ?
What will become of yoti .''
Send for our new catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
2 1 St St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Francisco Boston
.cm
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
149
THE
OILER
Is made of 22-g-a5^e cold-
rolled steel and pressed
to shape.
It has only one seam —
where top and bottom parts
come together — and this is
brazed.
The air chamber is always
in communication with the at-
mosphere through the hollow
shaft of thumb-piece.
Air is admitted to can only
when valve is opened.
Valve in spout opens "up "
and rod and spring come off
with spout.
Filled at spout opening and
can be emptied there — to the
last drop.
No packing or gaskets of
any kind.
Turned brass unions, ball
joints.
Can, spout and tip all 22-
gage cold-rolled steel.
Every can guaranteed oil-
tight in any position.
Is a mechanical job, is good,
looks good and will be taken
care of.
Nothing but an accident or
rank abuse can break or wear
one out. Cost more than tin
cans in the start — far cheaper
in the end.
And thev save oil.
M€.S Oiler Co
E()UitdbIeButIdtng.
^ Denver, Col. a
1 he Pratt & Whitney Company, of
Hartford, Conn., have issued a neat little
catalogue of new model turret lathes, in
which they illustrate and describe these
very useful machines. Concerning the
work that may be done they say that
these tools are not only adapted to repi-
tition work in the production of dupli-
cate pieces in large lots, but their use
is advantageous for the manufacture of
duplicate lots of not more than six
pieces. The catalogue contains 37 pages
and is illustrated with half-tones and
line cuts. The company will be pleased
to forward a copy to any one interested
enough to apply. The main office is in
New York, at 136-138 Liberty street.
The Kennicott Water Softener Com-
pany, of Chicago, state that their patents
have all been taken out in the name of
Cass L. Kennicott, and that they have
not granted any licenses, so that the use
of their inventions, save in their own ap-
paratus, is unwarranted and they intend
to protect their rights in the courts in
all cases of infringement. A suit is now
pending in the United States Circuit
Court for the second Judicial Circuit.
A London dispatch states that the
Scotch locomotive builders have practi-
cally completed a combination of the
trade in Scotland. Hitherto there has
frequently been mutual rivalry among
the builders, which hindered successful
competition with foreign makers. They
believe that by combining they will be
enabled to multiply the recent successes
achieved by them in Canada, Japan and
India against American and German
competitors. The capital of the combina-
tion will be between £2,000,000 and
i3, 000,000. The combination at present.
it is said, embrace three Glasgow firms,
Neilson. Reid & Co., the Hyde Park Lo-
comotive Works and Sharp, Stewart &
Co., employing 7,000 hands.
Lanahan, the division roadmaster on
the High Line, has sound views on the
reward due to responsibility. The old
man sent for him and breaking the news
easily told him he had a job of general
roadmaster for him. "What's the
price?" said Lanahan — he never wastes
the Queen's English. "A hundred and
twenty-five," said the old man, and
while he was looking for a perfecto for
Lanahan the division roadmaster had
wafted himself out. The old man's clerk
was telling me about it the other day.
The old man took the joke gracefully
too; he respects the man who would
rather be a division roadmaster at full
price than figure as a general road-
master on two-thirds pay. Lanahan
wants results. That's cash, not glory.
No "'forty-nine" cent sign for him.
Speed ol Woodworking Tools.
People accustomed to iron or other
metal-working tools have, as a rule, very
erroneous ideas about the cutting speed
of woodworking tools. A properly
driven circular saw has a periphery
speed of 7,000 feet per minute — nearly a
mile and a half per minute, or nearly So
miles an hour. A band saw is driven at
about half the speed of a circular saw.
Planing machine cutters have a speed of
6,000 feet per minute at the edge; and
the cutters of molding machines slice out
material at about 4,000 feet per minute.
Wood-carving drills are run 5,000 revo-
lutions per minute, while augurs i^-in.
diameter are run 900 revolutions per
minute. Those half that diameter are
run 1,200 revolutions per minute. Mor-
tising machine cutters make about 300
strokes a minute.
Dyspeptic Man In a hold-Up.
'About six years ago I was riding
through Southeastern Colorado on a
westbound train. There were about
twenty-five or thirty men in the smoker,
all pretty comfortable-looking chaps. A
dyspeptic-looking little man, about 40
years old, with a Bostonese patois, sal
in a seat ahead of me and an hour or so
after I boarded the train he engaged me
in conversation.
"Belong out this way?" he inquired of
me in his Down East drawl.
" 'Yep,' said I.
" 'Reason I ask you that,' said he, 'is
that I've heard there have been a lot of
robberies on the railroads out this way
lately. That right?'
" 'Pretty close,' said I.
" 'Ever find yourself involved in one
of those affairs?' he asked me.
" 'Couple times,' I told him.
" 'Did you let 'em go through you?'
hr asked me, with a searching look.
" "Don't you think otherwise for a holy
minute,' said I. 'I am my sole remain-
ing support, and. in general, I find life a
pretty good game. It's the best I know
anything about for sure, any^vay.'
" 'Well.' said the dyspeptic-looking lit-
tle man in his piping voice. 'I'd just like
to see the loafers get any of my money,
that's all. I'd just like to catch them
at it!'
" 'Why, what would you do?' I asked
him, grinning right in his teeth; I
couldn't have helped it to save me.
" 'Never you mind, sir, what I'd do!'
said the little man, choppily. 'I'd take
good care that they didn't get any of
my goods, however! I'd fix 'em! Yes,
siree, the train robber doesn't walk im
shoe leather that's ever going to relieve
me of a copper cent, and don't you fail
to remember that, sir!'
"The little man, who. as I afterward
ascertained was on his way to California
for his health, looked so puflt-toady and
fierce while he was getting oft these
I50
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
brave remarks that I couldn't help but
Jaugh in his face. That nettled him a
trifle, but I smoothed it over and madj
a remark or so to him about the general
nature and character of stick-ups.
" 'My friend,' said I in conclusion, 'the
only advice I can give you is this: If
any of these chaps ever comes along
your way and asks you to call heaven to
witness with your two hands pointing to
the zenith, just you do the same, that's
all, and do it in a hurry; do it a-run-
ning; be nice and pleasant about it, and
don't get gay. Don't endeavor to frivol
any with a man who's got the edge on
you with a forty-five lead-spitter.'
'"Well, just let one of 'em try it with
me, that's all!' exclaimed the little man.
and then we changed the subject.
"Well, about 9 o'clock that night we
pulled up at a little station called Tyrone
to give the engine a drink. We only
halted there about four minutes, but it
wES long enough. The train hadn't got
more than five miles out of Tyrone be-
fore we heard a lot of shots up forward —
the smoker was the second car from the
engine— and the train came to a halt.
"The wheels had scarcely ceased to re-
volve when the front door of the smoker
was thrown open with a bang, and the
command rang through the car like the
crack of a whip:
" 'Everybody put 'em up — quick!'
"A tall, raw-boned man, with a strag-
gling red mustache, stood in the door
calmly waving his gun from side to side
with the characteristic movement of an
expert gun-fanner. He looked business
all over.
"I decided instantly — I'd put my hands
up before I'd done any deciding, how-
ever— that he wasn't any amateur and
that he was going to get all that was
coming to him. I couldn't help but
notice that the dyspeptic-looking little
man in front of me threw up his hands
with the rest, although he did a little bit
of fumbling with his right hand before
it went up in the air.
" 'Seein' that my podner's busy keepin'
tab out in front,' said the raw-boned
bandit — he didn't wear any mask, and
there was a certain devilish twinkle in
his eye as he spoke — -'I'll just ask you
gentlemen to spring what you've got on
you with one hand at a time, as I pass
along, and I'll do the rest.'
"He wore a hickory bag suspended by
a string aroung his neck, in front of
him — a bag similar to that worn by car-
penters and lathers for holding nails,
and he just reached out his left hand
and dropped wallets, watches and loose
rolls into the bag as he passed along.
None of the passengers had any chance
to hold out anything on him, for he was
one of the eagle-eyed kind, and he
seemed to see all hands in the car at
once.
"He walked sideways down the .aisle,
so as to be sure that he wouldn't be
plunked from behind after passing along.
He was an artist in his business, all
light, was that raw-boned person, and
he didn't miss a trick. Every man up
forward unquestioningly forked over his
belongings to be dropped into that
roomy bag.
"The dyspeptic-looking little man
amused me, with his arms sticking up
there as rigid as poles, so that I almost
forgot to worry about what I was going
tc lose when it came my turn'. He ha-J
become as white as a sheet, and he
looked even more ghastly as the robber
approached him.
"Finally, it came his turn. The rob-
ber looked him over with a grin.
" 'Sorry, my sawed-oiT chum,' the rob-
ber started to say, when pufT, the right
hand of the dyspeptic-looking little man
opened with cat-like rapidity and the
robber got a fistful of red pepper square
in the eyes. He let out a howl and the
rttle man dropped to the floor like a
flash. So did I. for that matter.
"The robber, yelling like a madman,
lowered his gun hand and groped around
with it, and half a second later he was
butted in the stomach with all the force
the little man from New England had
in his head. That doubled the robber
up, and a minute later we were all on
top of him at once.
" 'You will try to appropriate what
doesn't belong to you, hey, doggone
you!' shrilled the dyspeptic-looking little
man, standing over the blinded bandit,
who was almost insane from pain.
"We bound him securely, did what we
could to alleviate his misery, and put a
guard over him. The robber who was
sticking up the engineer, hearing the
agonized shouts of his pardner, con-
cluded that there was nothing doing,
and, firing a few bluflf shots, scampered
ofT the tender into the darkness.
"We took the raw-boned bandit to
Trinidad, where he was tried and, as I
afterward learned, got twenty years.
And that's one time I got fooled up a
heap in a stickup."— AT. Y. Sun.
Baldwin's people have received an or-
der from the Southern Pacific for forty
locomotives with the Vanderbilt furnace.
These engines will burn oil. The South-
f.rn Pacific Company already have some
locomotives with the Vanderbilt fur-
nace which have given highly satisfac-
tory results as oil burners. The fur-
naces are said to outlast two fire-box
engines burning oil. A curious thing
about experience of railroads with oil-
burning furnaces is that the Santa Fe
people received more service from fire-
boxes than from Vanderbilt furnace.',
while the Southern Pacific was the op-
posite way, although the service in both
cases was about the same.
Mr. Air-Brake
Inspector
As you are interested in
obtaining the most efficient
service from your air-brake
eqttipment, it will pay you
to test
NON-FLUID OIL
AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT
especially during winter,
when ordinary oils and
greases freeze and refuse
to afford proper lubrica-
tion, thereby impeding the
operation of the cylinders.
Non-fluid oil is also espe-
cially valuable on triple-
valves
FREE SAMPLES FOR TRIAL FUR-
NISHED GRATIS, BY PREPAID EXPRESS
NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY
LUBRICANT COMPANY
MAKERS OF
14
"THE AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT,"
and 16 Church Street
NEW YORK CITV
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINQFIBLD. VERMONT, V. S. A.
A . B. C. and Luber^s Code used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
son's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain : Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott^-nstrasse 112, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
Get Better and Cheaper
Lathe and Planer Tools
By adopting
Armstrong
System
uf Tot)] Hold-
tTH using Cutlers
ul Self-Hardening Steel
Send for Catalog.
Armstrong Bros.
Tool Co.
•'Tfae Tool Holder
People,"
G35 Austin Aifniit-,
I'llK'AIJO, I. S. A.
Marcli, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
151
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
AND
SIZE
17 AMI 21 Kl I'V
JEWKI.S,
SAl'PIIIUG I'AliliKTS
J-
ItAM.'S IMPllOVKD
SAKKIY
D()rill;K UOM.KB
Arc without qiu'Btlon
till! fliM-pt wntclirfl that
Amcricmi talent and
BkllU'd labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
InK Buch univereid sat-
isfaction that wc have
no lu'Hltancy in claim-
ing that they are the
bci*t and pafest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests eevero and namerous have proven tliis fact to
the most critical users in all Beotions of the country, to
which thousands of good Itailroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road centiT. Call on him for information and facts.
Write us for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
ARE DESIGNED TO BE FREE FROM
VIBRATION SO AS TO INSURE PER-
FECTLY SMOOTH PLANING.
Send for booklet telling
more about them. ...
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
WINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
CEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
LOAN* TRUST BUiLDINO. WtSHINETON, D. C.
Terms Reaion.blc. Pamphlet Sent.
The Science of Chemistry.
It is woiiilcrfiij ilic familiarity with
practical chemistry acquired by many
of our readers. They begin the study of
elementary chemistry in connection with
studies of combustion, and the subject
proves so attractive that they keep up
the study as an amusement.
What may be called the primary ele-
ments of chemistry were known to the
ancient Egyptians. That race did not
find out very much about the composi-
tion of the various substances found on
the earth, but they had made some
progress concerning matters whereon
the foundation of chemistry rests.
Knowledge of the nature of substances
was developed by the study of medi-
cine, and the manipulating of domestic
arts developed knowledge of combina-
tions that formed part cA the facts from
which the science of chemistry was grad-
ually built up.
The Egyptians preserved dead bodies
by compounds whose composition is not
clearly known to modern science; they
fixed colors in silk by means of mor-
dants; prepared many medicines and pig-
ments; they also made soap, beer, vine-
gar and many other commercial com-
pounds. Of course the Chinese were
familiar with chemistry before western
nations, their principal discoveries hav-
ing been in dyes and in the preparation
of metallic alloys. But they also found
out how to make gun-powder, porcelain
and other things that were not found out
by the savants of Egypt, of Greece, or of
Rome. The Romans added very little
to the world's chemical knowledge.
During the social and political erup-
tions that accomplished the overthrow
of the Roman empire suppression of ac-
. quired knowledge prevailed and many
facts concerning matter discovered by
ancient nations were no doubt lost. After
several centuries of darkness the Arabs
became the chemists of the world. The
useful discoveries they made were con-
nected with alchemy researches.
.Alchemy is believed to have had some
connection with the mysticism of Egypt,
and to have originated in that land, al-
though the Arab philosophers became its
most devoted adherents. Alchemists be-
lieved that by mystic rites certain base
metals could be converted into gold, and
that a certain elixir or mysterious com-
pound could be concocted that would
indefinitely prolong human life. A work
on alchemy compiled by Gebir has the
right to be considered the first work on
chemistry, for although there is much
nonsense in it there are interesting facts
mentioned and experiments described.
With the popular cultivation of ignor-
ance and the wooing of superstition and
bigotry that followed the downfall of
Rome and tlie destruction of the Saracen
power, chemistry made no progress for
manv centuries. A mixture of alchemy
and chemistry lingered among students in
religious houses and in institutions of
learning, but what we might call legiti-
mate knowledge was badly mixed with
beliefs in magic, necromancy and other
delusions. Believers in the gold cure
for the alcohol habit might find that
the principle of this faith originated with
the alchemists. Roger Bacon, born 1214,
was one of the greatest lights of alchemy
and a writer whose works are more
chemical than alchemical. He believed
that "aqua-regia," which is gold dis-
solved in nitro-hydrochloric acid, to be
the elixir of life, and urged its use upon
Pope Nicholas IV.
From the time of Roger Bacon there
were numerous students of the proper-
ties of matter who gave their discoveries
to the world and knowledge was accumu-
lating. By the middle of the century so
many discoveries had been made and re-
corded that Lavoisier, a French investi-
gator, arranged about 1785 a system of
chemical nomenclature which still re-
mains the skeleton of the science. La-
voisier devoted himself zealously to in-
vestigating phenomena connected with
combustion and by use of the balance
proved that the act of combustion was a
combination of carbon with oxygen. This
introduced quantitative chemistry, which
proved that no loss occurred when
chemical changes were effected. This
knowledge brought with it the law of
the indestructibility of matter.
Since Lavoisier organized the science
of chemistry it has exercised more influ-
ence on human affairs than all the other
sciences combined, the great discoveries
in other sciences having nearly always
had the path illuminated by chemistry.
That is true of metallurgy, of steam en-
gineering, of its sister science, elec-
tricity, and of many others. The person
who does not possess a talking acquaint-
ance with chemistry is to-day behind the
times.
The portion of the floor where tires
are shrunk on. in the Reading shops of
the P. & R. is very handily fitted up
with trestles, gas pipes and the various
requisites for that sort of work. The
floor is made of cast iron plates, dished
down at the edges all round, and per-
forated all over like the stay-bolt holes
in a crown sheet, though with wider
spacing. By this arrangement when a
heated tire has been put upon the wheel
center, and the hose turned on. all the
small wooden blocking lying about is
not floated away by the water or the
shop floor made into a sort of marsh as
it often is in other shops. The only
floating is done by the steam which
floats off in the form of a hannless cloud
as the tire cools while the shop floor is
kept dry and the water drops through
the perforations in the iron floor, and
finds its way into the shop drain.
152
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March. 1903.
Long and Short Valve Travel.
- I notice on page ^^ of February
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
that P. R. J. asks if a short valve travel
has any advantage over a long travel with
the same cut-off. This question brings
to my mind a 1 7x24- inch passenger
engine that we had on a three-car
run, time two hours for 61 miles, and
13 stops. This engine had 4 1-4 inches
valve travel, and in some way she got a
pair of new valves with 7-8-inch outside
lap; her steam ports were i 1-4 inches
wide, and when working in full gear her
valves traveled just far enough to give
full port opening. This engine would
start her train as quick as any of the
engines of this class, but could not be
worked closer than the third notch, and
on a windy day the fourth notch was the
running notch and time was frequently
lost, as the engine would not run very
fast. My theory was this: The outside
lap was so great compared with the valve
travel that in the first notch there was
no port opening; in the second notch she
would get 1-8 of an inch port opening,
and in the third notch she would get 1-4
of an inch of port opening and a cut-off
of 6 inches; at the fourth notch she would
cut off at 8 inches, and while she would
work good and strong in these last two
notches, at the same time the lever
would be so far forward that the valves
would not have the required amount of
lead to give the engine the requisite
speed. By planing these valves to S-8
outside lap she would make the time
easily in the first notch, as she then got
the same port opening in the first notch
as she originally had in the third notch,
and her lead in the first notch was in-
creased nearly 1-8 more, making the en-
gine easily ten miles an hour speedier
than she originally was.
C. D. Greig.
Cherokee, la.
five to fifteen minutes each, depending
on the size and shape.
This machine, they say, is a great ad-
vance over any other appliance for doing
this class of work, not alone because of
the saving in time which can be effected,
but in the accuracy of the work produced.
A correspondent in London informs
us that we made a mistake in the Janu-
ary number by saying that the standard
track gauge in Japan is 3 feet, when it is
6 inches wider.
The Norton Grinding Company, ot
Worcester, Mass., say that with one of
their gap grinding machines arranged for
grinding piston rods with the pistons in
place, an operator in a prominent rail-
road shop in this country recently re-
ground a pair of piston rods in eight
minutes each. This represents the grind-
ing time only. The time required for
placing the rod in the machine and tak-
mg it out being the same as though the
rods were turned instead of ground, and
this time would depend entirely on the
facilities for handling the work. If the
latest up-to-date compressed air hoist
were used, the complete time for placing
the rod in the machine, grinding it and
laying it down, would be not over fifteen
minutes each. The time of re-turning as
practiced in most shops is from one and
a half to two hours each. Valve stems
were also ground in from fifteen to
twenty minutes each. Crank pins in from
There is a strong prejudice among
foreign locomotive men against steel for
fire-boxes and tubes, but for the latte.-
steel is slowly forcing its way into favor.
There is some objection to securing a
steel tube in a copper tube-plate, but
when common sense tries for a little
longer to leap over the wall of preju-
dice the steel tube-plate will be found
quite satisfactory.
The Derry-Collard Co., of New York,
are issuing a series of pamphlets illus-
trating certain machine shop operation.
The first one is on turning tapers. The
illustrations are admirably done and the
pamphlet is very finely gotten up. It
costs only 25 cents.
It is reported that American electrical
apparatus is making progress in European
markets. The Societe Anonyme West-
inghouse has found it necessary, on ac-
count of the great number of orders re-
ceived, to make extensive additions to
their plant, which has been in operation
for only five years. This plant is situ-
ated at Havre, France, and supplies the
territory included in Holland, Belgium,
Italy, Switzerland, Spain, France and
their colonies and protectorates.
We are informed that the Texas &
Pacific Railway have placed an order for
fifteen freight engines with the American
Locomotive Company. They will be
built at the Cooke Works of that con-
cern, at Paterson, N. J. Delivery is
booked for May i of this year.
Every car shop in the country and
locomotive works has more orders than
the year will see filled. Lines are strug-
gling with each other to be first served.
So persistent are they in pressing their
orders that manufacturers are oftentimes
paid a large bonus for special attention
in delivery. Every car foundry in the
East wants additional employees, but
labor is difficult to obtain.
FOR SALE
FREIGHT, PASSENGER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
CARS
dUICK
DELIVERIES
a«5 DEARBORN ST.
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. ^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
■hops in the country.
Union of course. Jt j*
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
MORAH FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Ine.
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
The Jenison Iron and Engineering
Company has been organized to manu-
facture certain specialties, among them
an electric headlight. Their works will
be at Jenison, near Grand Rapids, Mich.
March, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
"53
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis : Terminal Station.
lAYLUR YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushers .'"h'Ss;;"- steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THE&E GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
8ol« Representative!, in ttie United States,
Canada and Hexlco
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EQlilPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of servic*
CARS. FREIGHT. PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Manadnock Bldg., Chicago 141 Broadway, New York
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspectloa. Tests and Consultation,
1137 THE ROOKERY, CniCAGO.
91 Broadway, New York. Park BuildiDg, Pittsburgh
31 Norfolk House, Lomion, Eog.
Ineppction of steel R:iils. Splice Bars, Railroad Cars,
"Wheels, AxJes, etc. Chemical Laboratory —Aualygis
of Ores, Iron, Steel. Oils, Water, etc. Physical La Ro-
RAToitY— Test nf Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, Dniw Barp, etc.
Kffioiency Tests of Boilers, En^ines and lioco mot ires.
WANTED
A SECOND-HAND HYDRAVLIC
OR POWER PRESS suitable for
pressing car wKeels on aLnd off
standard gauge axles; mvjst be In
good condition and cheap V V
The BUFFALO UNION FURNACE
COMPANY ^J Buffalo. N. Y.
One result of the Westficid collision
on the Ceniial Railroad of New Jersey
is that the company has decided to use
the standard train rules of the American
Railway Association, to regulate the
movement of trains. Every railroad in
the country ought to do the same thing.
It is fewer than tliirty days since the
Lackawanna contracted with the Pull-
man Company for entirely new equip-
ment in the way of sleeping cars, but
already these have been supplied for the
night lines between New York and Buf-
falo, from the Buffalo plant, and very
snon the through lines will have received
ihcir full quota.
Lord Claud Hamilton, president of
the Great Eastern Railway, of England,
made a public statement lately about
•American locomotives. He said his
company had tried them for a year and
a half and found them a distinct failure.
He expressed himself as being against
American railway methods generally.
A press dispatch from London says
that Messrs. Kerr, Stuart & Co., of
Stoke-on-Trent, have secured a contract
for heavy locomotives, of the American
type, for the Interoceanic Railway of
Mexico. It is stated that many builders
in the United States competed for the
contract, but the English firm guaran-
teed a lower price and speedier delivery.
A compound locomotive which has
been a success on a road where the work
of hauling trains is nearly uniform may
prove a failure where heavy pulls and
long stretches of drifting are common.
Several railroad companies have found
this to be the case.
The heat utilized in doing useful work
by the medium of a steam engine is rare-
ly more than 6 per cent, of the potential
energy of the fuel used. To catch part
of the 94 per cent, of waste has been the
favorite labor of thousands of inventors,
and it led to the invention of the com-
pound engine. The success achieved by
that invention has not been worth much
boasting.
The first railroad ever built in this
country for watermelon traffic is being
constructed in Southeast Missouri by
the Burlington. It will be fifty miles
long, extending from the interior to the
Mississippi River, and goes through a
country which raises enough melons to
keep it very busy during the season.
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smolu.
Cod tains about 800 nract teal questions and
their antwerH on the Science of Steam
MaklnK- By Wm. .M. Barr. The necessary
condltioDi for the Rconomlc Firing of a
Looomotlve are explained. 85 lllaatratlonB.
349 pages. Cloth, li.so.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By ROBKRT H. Bl.ACKALI.. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Alr-Brake
•qulpment, containing: over 1,000 questions
and their answers on the WestlnKbouse
Alr-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Alr-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearlv every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
364 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM,
By ROBERT Grimshaw. It asks i,6«>
questions and e'ves 1,600 simple, plain,
practical answers about the Locomotive.
No mathematics, no theories— /i<j< factt.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
pages, over aoo Illustrations, and lalarre
Folding Plates. Bound In Maroon Clotn,
$3.00.
t^-A Special Circular of these Boehs Sent
on Request.
t^'Any of these Books Prepaid to any
Address tn the world on Receipt of Price.
A6ENTS WANTED ;°;,'^ T^i;
sell at sight, and every Bng^lneer,
FlremaD and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalog:ue of practical
bo okB Is sent free on application.
Norman A. Henley & Co., Pablishers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, H.Y.
Arrangements have been made to give
the Pennsylvania Railroad the entire out-
put of the Pressed Steel Car Company.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything: from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
154
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
March, 1903.
The New Canadian Locomotive Works.
- Work on the new Montreal Locomo-
tive and Machine Company's works at
Longue Pointe will begin in a very short
time.
The estimated output of locomotives
for the first year will be one hundred.
Later it is intended to extend the scope
of the work to take in bridge work and
ship building. From the start, however,
tenders will be put in for foreign work as
well as that originating in Canada. Mr.
G. P. Brophy, of Ottawa, is the manag-
ing director of the company, while Mr.
R. T. Shea, formerly of the Schenectady
Locomotive Works, Schenectady, N. Y.,
has been chosen as superintendent of the
locomotive works. The necessary equip-
ment is now being purchased in New
York, at a coat of from three to four
hundred thousand dollars. The motive
power will be entirely electrical. The
active operations of the works are ex-
pected to begin in August.
Mr. Dudley Walker, of the Chicago &
Alton, Chicago, has got out a neat little
railroad picture, about 7x9 inches, called
"Her First Run." It represents a charm-
ing girl sharing the engineer's seat in the
cab, she holding the notched up reverse
lever, while he has his hand on the
throttle. It may be that a hymeneal
"coupling" will be made later on, but in
the picture the right of way occupies the
attention of both. Mr. Walker will be
happy to dispose of these pictures at 25
cents each.
The Consolidated Railway Electric
Lighting and Equipment Company held
a meeting of directors early in February,
at which Mr. Isaac L. Rice was re-
elected president, and the duties hereto-
fore performed by Mr. J. N. Abbott as
vice-president and general manager were
added to those performed by the presi-
dent, Mr. Abbott having terminated his
connection with the company. Mr. J. L.
Watson was re-elected secretary and
treasurer. All communications to the
company should be addressed as above.
the office being at 100 Broadway, New
York. This company is widely known as
the owners of the Axle Light System.
This system not only includes the light-
ing of trains, but the ventilation of cars
by the use of electric fans. The com-
pany's system is in use on the best trains
of many leading railway lines and on all
private Pullman cars and most of the
private cars of railway officials.
The report of the Massachusetts Rail-
road Commissioners for 1902, just issued,
shows among many other things, that the
heaviest locomotive used in that State
in 1892 weighed about 65 tons. Now
the consolidated railroads send engines
there weighing 78 tons, and the Boston
& Albany has some that weigh 95 tons.
Accommodation at Haclcinac.
Mr. John W. Taylor, secretary of the
M. M. and M. C. B. Association, has
issued a circular to members giving a
report of the joint committee on time
and place, in which it is stated that a
careful inspection of the Grand Hotel and
grounds at Mackinac has been made. The
report says that the location is all that
could be desired, and that the Grand
Hotel can conveniently accommodate
twelve hundred people in the style to
which the associations have been accus-
tomed. Cottages and smaller hotels are
within a few minutes' walk of the Grand
Hotel, and the overflow, if any, can be
accommodated comfortably. The circu-
lar also states that accommodation for
exhibits has never been surpassed.
British Expresses.
The Locomotive Magazine, of Charing
Cross Road, London, has issued a very
handsome volume, containing a series of
railway pictures, some few of which are
in colors: the rest are half-ton»s. The
first series is on British expresses, in
which some of the best-known trains,
such as the Flying Dutchman on the
Great Western, the American Car train
on the South Eastern, and many others
are given. The second series contain
views of the world's famous trains ;
among others appears the Black Diamond
on the Lehigh Valley, the "Sud" express
on the Paris-Orleans line, the Scotch ex-
press on the London and North Western.
and the Imperial Limited on the Canadian
Pacific. The third series comprise Brit-
ish express locomotives during the Vic-
torian era. Twelve types are given, rang-
ing from 1837 to 1899. Locomotives of
1900 forms the next series, in which the
summer trains and engines of various
nations are given. The tandem com-
dem compound, four-cylinder, ten-wheel
engine, 697, on the A. T. & S. F., closes
the series. "Locomotives at Work" fol-
lows next. "Cars of 1900" cover the
British and Continental field, and the
book concludes with a series comprising
the locomotives of all nations, among
which may be mentioned the "Victoria"
on the Great Southern and Western Ry.
of Ireland, the French "wind splitter"
on the P. L. M., and the heavy passen-
ger ten-wheel engines of the Chicago &
Eastern Illinois.
Copies of this very interesting refer-
ence book may be had at the office of
Railway and Locomotive Engineering,
174 Broadway. New Y'ork.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works have
agreed to present a locomotive to Sibley
College, the mechanical engineering de-
partment of Cornell University. The en-
gine will be of the de Glehn type of com-
pound. That class of engine is used
largely in France and bears a high repu-
tation for efficiensy and durability.
A. Leschen &, Sons Rope Co.,
Manufacture! s
WIRE ROPE,
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE,
Fittings and Supplies.
HOME OFFICE:
920-922 North First St., • ST. LOUIS, MO.
( 135 E. Lake St.. Chicago. 111.
Branch Offices j 92 Centre St., New York City, N.Y.
1 85 Fremont St., San Francisco, Cal.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. NEW YORK.
CONTENTS.
PAGE
Air Brake Department 127
A Word for the Resident Inspector 122
Balanced Engine. A 142
Boltless Cylinder and Frame Connection. 119
Cars for the N. Y. Underground 141
Combination of Book and Brain, by Shandy
Maguire 10^
Disregarding Signals 124
European Railway Notes 134
General Correspondence 115
George Daniels on Railroads Ill
George Westinghouse on American Methods 132
Growth of the Locomotive, by Angus Sin-
clair (iii paper) 113
Locomotive Classification 140
Locomotives:
Baldwin 4-4-2 for the Norfolk & Western 133
Express Engine for the Chicago & Alton 117
Laboratory Engine for Cornell University 120
Ten-Wheel Passenger Engine for the
Rutland 121
Loose Cylinder Made Tight 141
Overloaded Trains Cause Freight Conges-
tion 125
Personals 137
Questions Answered 125
Railway Building in Cuba 107
Reading's New Shops 139
Safe Transportation 143
Self Closing Manhole 142-
To Prevent Boiler Explosions 122
The Science of Chemistry 151
The Westfield Disaster 123
Unpopularity of the Pooling System 124
APRIL, 1903.
SERIES No. 1.
PREJJUDE IN PCS 80 85 90 95 lOO
brake
Ir Full R«lease
Position
^ Old itylt
Diocharpf Valve
Handle m
RunrvinO Po5)
prfJBbrf spfmrt
ict for 2o Lbs
cl
emergency
Application
(Tr&>y€l of
p\.5tonoini.h«'U
Pl^
?.*
R Brake Inspector,
& A. R.R., Sprinqfield, Mass.
V
' APRIL, 1903.
Color Air Brake Chart, Issued by Railway and Locomotive Engineering.
SERIES No. 1.
PRE^JJUPE m POUND.? O 5 10 IS 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 7S 80 85 90 95 100
Whn charged
Brake
vklve h&ndle
(« Fyi; R«lcait
Gowtncallih,
pr(ijur< aid
let at 70 Lt]
^"
"^
^"
^*
""
D.ac^arj^V,,lv«
CSifcdil)
^^
1
^^
^^
^"
^^
^^
^™
.
^^
^5
—
tcoMi-o reser-
voir prCJiur«
lOO Lbs
Old ityle.
D.O chary* Valvg
Handle in
Run^no PoiP
pr^isurt sprmO
Wt for 2o Lbs
^artintf pi^mp
Uh^r
When
^
^
^"
^
^"
^*
""
■^
"^
Ennaqyenty
Application
PJBinTnpU'
Valve
^
,^
1^
^
O.'ifKAct.fn
-
1
1^
^
.'
KEY
MAIN REJ.
PREiJUCE IN POUND/ O 5 I O IS 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 aS 90 95 100
1
~
Full rj«a.5<
position
Directly arttfr
attacVi.r/4 Co
Lram. Will
v^ry acconiino
To len^tK of
trd'nSlie of
main neaer-
voir and
Jure carried
On engine
and tender
^^
^^
^*
^"
^m
"^
1™
^"
^^
^"
On tra^itr. *
I"i proved
Zooa\\z\n^
disdiafi'f valve
Handle m
rt^rnir\c' bo
5l^;o.^ 'Feed
valva dttftchf^Pnt
*diwfed for
7c> Ibs.Trdin
line pressure
&nd jtivcroor
fcrlOOlbs
Ma"> resef-
voir Prfiiurc
Soc^ after
starting pump
'^
""
^
^
^
bUr
^^
^"
^''
^"
^*
55
^5
"^
^"
""
^^
^^
^^
^
^
^
^
""
when
charged
"""
^
^
^
^
"
^*
^^
^^
^^
^^
^
"I"
"
""
ifftr »n application
v-ill ^S^ry accordino
To Icn^rK of tr<?in,''
rcducCion mavdc etc
^
^"
^
^^
^
^
^
^
^
.
TR/\\n LINE
BRAKE VALVE
RE.J". PRE.j-
Aux PEU--
BRAKE CVL
PRE J,
DESIGNED 6v E. G. DESOE, Genl. Am Brake Inspector.
B. & A. R.R., SPfllNQFIELD. Mass.
Railway ..and
locomotive
Copyright by(Angus Sinclair Co. — 1903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XYI.
174 Broadway, New York, April, 1903
No. 4
Paris, Lyons and Mediterranean
Locomotives.
The two French locomotives here il-
lustrated arc the latest engines designed
for the Paris, Lyons & Mediterranean,
by the chief mechanical engineer of the
system, M. C. W. Baudry, whose por-
trait is also published. Both of these
engines are compounds, with four cyl-
inders, two inside and two outside the
frames. Particulars of the designs can
be obtained from the line cuts.
The 8-wheel type of engine has pro-
portions adapted to high speed, while
the ten-wheeler is designed to combine
moderate speed with much power.
a marking hammer striking once every
four revolutions indicates speed of train,
shows duration of stops, slow downs, etc.
The Young Engineer.
BY S1I.\NDY MAGUIRE.
May his tribe increase, because it
means that our country shall progress
along present lines from ocean to ocean,
and from lakes to gulf, in the same
thrifty manner in which it is making
time at present; for it means the setting
up of men to meet the necessity, instead
of relegating beginners back to the fur-
that the one poor unfortunate, with a
title to the tail end of his name, and who
is known on the locos by his initials
only, is the round-house foreman. Poor
fellow! A bosom of sympithy is his due,
and unsparingly dealt out to him by
the pen-pusher of this sketch. If the
Good Book is to be relied upon there
is a future reward beyond the heart-
aches and the crosses of this life for the
unfaltering slave who forms the first
link in the connecting chain, binding the
low-downers in officialdom with the
august personage reclining upon the top-
most pedestal of the throne of authority.
The following order came duly auten-
FAST PASSENGER ENGINE FOR PARIS, LYONS AND MEUITERRANEAN SYSTEM.
These locomotives are regarded on the
continent of Europe as the highest de-
velopment of the locomotive designers'
^rt. The parts of the two engines are
practically interchangeable except the
changes made necessary through differ-
ence in size.
Common characteristics of all the en-
gines are steel boilers with Serve tubes,
Belpaire fire boxes, the inside part be-
ing of copper, and extended smoke
boxes, with pointed fronts to reduce
atmospheric resistance.
These engines have revolution counters
and speed-recording mechanism which is
worked by connection with the valve
gear. A tape fed at uniform speed under
nace door, and giving an Irish hoist to
the older ones.
Not a million miles away from where
this sketch is scrawled is a road doing
a trunk line business, subject to its ebb
and flow for about ten months in the
year, and not entirely stagnant during
the other two. It is necessary that if to-
morrow business would expand 50 per
cent, from what it is to-day. that men
would be available. The methods of the
Glacials of this system are to set up and
set back; a very laudable one, yet with
its soul-harrowing tortures to one offi-
cial at least. Without any abnormal flow
of verbiage devoted to beating about the
bush, it is as well to state here and now
ticated to Terrence Bennett, round-house
foreman, on a recent date:
"To-morrow we will begin again to
handle the West End Traffic. Arrange
accordingly.
(Signed) R. L. Jordan, Div. M. M."
That meant six additional crews to be
made up. six wipers to be promoted to
firemen, and six firemen to be again
made lords paramount of the cabs of six
engines to be fired up and put into ser-
vice. The first day passed without any
noticeable change from normal condi-
tions. It was after round trips were
made that the tribulations of Terry be-
gan. He went to examine the round-
house report book, at the usual time, in
156
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
order to be tlie judge of the most im-
portant work to do in the line of run-
ning repairs on the engines, with his
very limited help, so as to keep them
moving until their wash-out day, which
occurred once a month at the company's
shops, located in the middle of the di-
fects, real or imaginary, that the young-
sters could trace. Bennett said nothing
pro or con after he examined the various
tales of woe, which was interpreted by
the round-house man to mean that some
other engines than those on the West
End traffic would not be given the go by.
himself and her, doing in an instant
what it takes the courts of the land quite
a spell to accomplish, outside of Dakota
or Chicago, and began the following con-
versation:
"Say, Mr. Bennett, me right hand
packin' is blowin' so that it is all I am
OUTLINE ELEVATION OF P. L. M. FAST PASSENGER 8-WHEEL ENGINE.
vision. Out of the eleven engines re-
ported defective on the book the three
run by the young runners had more
work reported to be done on them than
the other eight, and they but a few days
out of the shop, from a general overhaul-
ing, before having been laid up.
The next day, which is known through-
out Christendom as the Lord's Day, Ben-
nett, who, "to keep peace in the shanty,"
as he expressed it later on, accompanied
his wife to church. As he was walking
with the air of a liberated slave at her
side, in all the splendor of his Sunday-
able to do to get over the road; me
valves are squealin' also, the left hand in-
jector kicks once in a while, and the
main rod brasses on the right side wants
reducin'; there is a leak in me mud ring
that wants corkiti' "
"Mr. Daley," said Terry, "put it on
nsi — 13 m m cr^
SECTION THROUGH CENTER LINE OF
L. M. FAST PASSENGER ENGINE.
A few hours later the other three
youngsters arrived, and they also took
the post of honor on full pages. The
next day being Saturday, the book got
a greater burden to carry than on the
previous day. Nearly all the old stufif
was repeated, and all the additional de-
go-to-meetin's, and taking pride at the
envious glances he saw sidled at her
stunner of a hat, top-hampered with a
huge portion of the very latest furbe-
lows, he was overtaken by one of the
young fellows he set up running two
days previous, who stepped in between
the report book and we will see to it to-
morrow," trying to break off the conver-
sation and shake the fellow, so he could
drop b^ck a few paces and again walk
with his wife, who fell behind after she
got cut out.
"I did put it on Friday mornin', yes-
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOllVK ENGINEERING
157
terday, and agin this niornin', bill old
Uunpliy pays no atlentinn tu it, so I
want to report it to y(jii."
"I appreciate your tlioughtfnliicss, par
ticularly at this time, and I shall attend
to it." He wanted to cut, the interview
off as abruptly as he could, without los-
ing patience, in consideration of where
he was going. At the crossing of an in-
tersecting street he saw Jim Chamberlin
coming towards him. He wanted to
avoid him, but gave it up as a bad job,
for once Jim got his eye on him he kept
it there till they met. Jim was chair-
man of the local grievance committee,
bloated accordingly, as his method of
address indicated.
"Bennett, why can't I get nic packin'
set out on the left side?"
"Have you reported it?"
"Yes, and I might as well be reportin'
it to the man in the moon, for the work
won't be done."
"To-morrow I'll see to it and find out
the reason."
"See that you do, and have the draw-
bar shortened between the tank and en-
gine, pack the throttle and run me valves
over; I have a headache from the way
I go hoppin' along."
Bennett was an easy going sort of a
church militant man, traveling in a go-
as-you-please way on the heavenly road,
utterly regardless of the rules of ortho-
doxy. He picked up Martha again and
gave her a look she knew right well
how to read, as much as to say: "Do
you suppose going with yon to church
l(j protect the streamers floating from
.Martha's hat from flying under the feet
iif the middle aislers, who were out in
M. C. W. BAUDRY.
force, for a spell upon their knees, he
found himself caught by the coat-tail to
attract his attention, and make him turn
round, which he did.
"Say, Terry, why can't I get the work
done on me engine I report?"
of the main box, left side; it makes her
ride harder than hell."
"May the devil pound you back to the
handles of a wheelbarrow, where you
never should have graduated from, you
shallow-pated mule," exclaimed Bennett,
in the hearing of all, who supposed the
Lord had made him insane for having
the audacity to enter His house on the
same footing with them, the pillars upon
which it rested. Poor Martha felt her
position keenly, and entirely forgot her
new headgear in the tittering going on.
One old, bugle-eyed spinster looked at
her with a glance intended to annihilate
her, then with a lip-twist of hate at the
hat, said audibly: "Oh. my! feathers
are droopin' to-day."
Martha immediately replied: "Miss
O'Grady, my feathers are paid for. My
husband owes no one a dime, although
he is not a church-goer, yet he pays my
bills here and elsewhere, and helps to
maintain a pew to seat such tramps as
you are, who come here to defile the
house of prayer with the vile ravings of
an unchristian heart and vicious tongue,
as you are doing to-day. I approve of
his acts. He should be permitted to
pass into the pew with the same in-
dififcrence as your old nobody of a father
entered, but being a man of superior
standing in the community of worship-
ers here, he had to endure the annoy-
ance his distinction was awarded."
" 'Tis thrue for ye, Mrs. Bennett; put
TEN-WHl-.Kl. lASSENGER LOCOMOTIVE— PARIS, LYONS AND MEDITERRANEAN.
is to redound to my honor and glory up
above?" She soothed him by saying:
"Never mind them. They mean all
right; as they grow older they will gain
more knowledge from experience."
They were now almost at the sacrod
edifice, and Terry supposed his troubles
were all behind him. It was the popular
hour of church going, and a small jam
occurred on the porch. r.s too many met
there for comfort. While he was trying
The poor fellow; he jack-screwed
down again the gorge arising in his
throat, in consideration of where he
stood, and in accordance with the teach-
ings of the meek and lowdy Nazarine,
tT whose honor and glory the temple
was erected he was endeavoring to enter,
he said: "I'll see that it is done here-
after. Mr. Doran."
"Well, take care that you don't forget
it; be sure that the pound is taken out
that in your heart and nourish it. Miss
O'Grady. and I'll take me oath it will
sink deeper than the word of God does
into it to-day." said big Tom Kelly.
Bennett's hostler, who stood near.
Terry went direct to the round-house
from the church and asked Dunphy what
he was doing. "Readin' the report
book," said Tom. "There is more work
put in it by the extras than we could do
in a week of Sundavs. Thev don't know
158
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
what they are blatherin' about. I'll prove
it to, you."
"How?"
"Chump Daley thinks the spring cylin-
der packin' is yet in 43. Ask him in the
mornin' how it acted to-night, or I'll
ask him in your hearin.' "
"Do so, Tom, you have more patience
with such men than I have."
Next morning Daley was in on time,
and Tom said in Terry's hearing:
"Chump, 0I4 boy, I set yer packin'
out on both sides yesterday; how did it
act last night?" All Dunphy did was to
put a wrench mark on the cylinder casing
nut, each side, so as to have it pass
muster should Chump know enough to
notice if it had been off.
"I never saw such improvement, Tom;
I was good for four more cars."
"Then the blow is all taken out?"
"Not a whimper left. Here, smoke on
the head of it," and he handed him one,
three for five.
"How is that for high. Mr. Bennett'"
said Tom. when Chump got out of hear-
ing.
"That's good," said he. "and a first
rate way to find out that what some men
don't know would fill a bigger book than
what they know. Work that racket.
Tom, to your heart's content, and per-
haps holding their ignorance for laugh-
able discussion among the other men
may deter them from filling page after
page of a report book with stuff that is
unnecessary. With some of the artists
manipulating throttle bars the notion
prevails in their heads that it gives them
standing to put down all sorts of jobs,
whether they can be done or not. like
Jim Chamberlin did when he put down
to shorten his draw-bar between tank
and engine, and a company's blacksmith
not within fifty miles of here, and no
chance to send it away to be done, and
it no worse than it has been in the last
year. Tom, the company equips school
cars to ».ducate men how to handle the
air-brake. It would be a good thing to
add to the curriculum of the car some
much-needed instruction for new begin-
ners. What do you say if I get some one
to give a lecture to them some evening
here in the round-house?"
"It would be first rate." said Tom.
"and I beg to suggest, as the chief clerk
says, that you be the lecturer yourself.
for you know a thing or two about how
the old thing works."
".Agreed," said Terry.
In the last year $328,403 was paid as
pensions to retired employees of the
Pennsylvania Railroad. The scheme has
been in operation three years, and in that
time $864,000 has been paid out to 1.851
employees.
To Prevent Railroad Strikes.
A recent despatch from The Hague
says: Premier Kuyper introduced in the
Second Chamber of the Staats General
three bills in connection with the recent
railway strike. He explained that the
government considered it necessary to
oppose any unreasonable attack on so-
ciety, which would sacrifice the well-be-
ing of the people to the desire of a cer-
tain class for influence, and to political
tyranny. The government, therefore, pro-
posed to form a railway brigade, to in-
sure a regular service of trains in case
of need. The just complaints of railroad
employees would be adjusted by a Royal
Commission, which would be entrusted
later with the settlement of the situation
from a legal standpoint, as well as re-
garding the conditions of service of the
employees. It also would have to decide
what constituted criminal acts. The gov-
ernment did not desire to be reaction-
ary. It only aimed at affecting social re-
forms. One of the bills provides for a
modification of the penal code, with the
object of affording a surer guarantee for
the personal freedom of labor and pre-
venting state officials or persons engaged
in occupations affecting public interests
from absenting themselves from their
duties.
There's no situation in life so bad that
it cannot be retrieved. — Pickwick Papers.
First Aid to the Injured.
It may cause a smile to say so. but it
is nevertheless quite true that one of the
important results which training in first
aid to the injured on a railway usually
brings about is that it guarantees pro-
tection to an injured man from the deadly
attacks of his most devoted and faithful
friends. One cannot study the state-
ments constantly made by railway sur-
geons without seeing clearly that it is
of much importance to instruct men
thoroughly in what not to do in case of
accident as it is to prepare them for any
definite line of action in an emergency.
It is therefore without surprise that we
see that Dr. J. D. Milligan, chief surgeon
of the P. & L. E. R. R., said in a paper
recently read before the Railway Club of
Pittsburgh, "that the prayer of the in-
jured is not always 'Oh, Lord, save me
from mine enemies,' but it is 'Oh, Lord,
save me from my friends.' " He had often
found that some uninstructed but over-
zealous person may easily undo what
nature was trying to do, and what nature
would have succeeded in accomplishing
if she had not been interfered with.
Sir Frederick Treves, who success-
fully operated upon King Edward, is re-
ported to have said of his experience in
the South African campaign that he had
learned to let a perfectly clean Mauser
bullet flesh wound heal itself. The rail-
way surgeon to-day has often to deal
with a wound, not clean, as the accident
left it, but packed with tobacco"chews,"
covered with old germ-bearing cobweb*
and soaked with black oil or kerosene.
We remember once seeing a fireman
who had cut the artery in his wrist on
a broken pane of glass in the round-
house one night in the mountains, taken
so miles on a light engine to the nearest
doctor with the wound so badly bound
up that it bled constantly and the injured'
man had been given several "horns" of
whiskey "to keep up his strength," with
the result that the heart action had beeni
stimulated and had so pumped out more
blood through the wound than other-
wise would have been lost. In this case
the surgeon literally saved this man
from his friends.
First aid instruction does not turn
men into amateur surgeons, it very often,
prevents them from simply making bad
worse or restrains them from introduc-
ing needless complications with which
the railway surgeon has to contend or
the railway claims agent subsequently
settle for.
In this connection a few facts pre-
sented by Dr. Milligan to the Pittsburglr
Club are interesting. Among other
things he said: "Consider that on June
30, 1900, there were employed 972,808
men by the railroads in the United
States, that there were 39,643 injured and'
2,550 killed, for the year ending June 30,
1900, and that in that statement we mean
al! who die within 24 hours — are de-
clared killed — and all who are disabled
to the extent of three days, are classed
as injured, it shows at a glance that
there is plenty of room to apply first aid.
and also the grim necessity of prompt
and efficient application of the same."
Railroad Mileage in the U. S.
The total number of miles of track in-
the United States up to June 30, 1901,
as given by the Interstate Commerfce
Commission, is 265.352 miles. This in-
cludes single track, double track, three
track, four track and all yard track and'
sidings. Just here we may say that the
mean distance of the moon from the
earth is about 240,000 miles, so it is
easily seen that we have enough rail-
road track in this country, if laid as a
single line from the top of some lofty
mountain, through the air to reach "her
celestial highness," and when we had'
done that we would have something over
25 000 miles of track to spare. The
moon's diameter is about 2.160 miles, so
that we could lay down a line which
would go round her equator more than
three and one-half times. If the moon
ever thinks of flying off into space. Uncle
Sam's transportation companies know
their duty. A train traveling continu-
ously at the rate of sixty miles an hour
would, if it started on January I, cover
the entire distance and probably strike-
the lunar bumping post about 4th July..
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
159
Canadian Pacific Coal Car.
"Tlic object we had in view in de-
signing tliis car was to construct a vehi-
cle for the carriage of coal which would
retain its status as a coal car to the end,
and not degenerate into a sort of coal
sack by sagging in the middle and bulg-
ing at the sides." So, in effect, spoke
Mr. D. McNicoll, second vice-president
and general manager of the Canadian
Pacific in giving Railway and Loco-
MOTi\ E Engineering the photograph
from which our half-tone illustration is
made. The elimination of the chance of
sagging and bulging which are the two
evils which coal cars are heir to, was not
rendered any easier by the fact that the
car was required to have side doors, but
the form of construction finally adopted,
we are told, has given excellent results
in service.
The outside sills are timber, 14 in. deep
by S in. wide. The intermediate sills are
really composed of two members each
9x5 in., spaced i in. apart, with packing
piece between, and through these sills
the long U-bolts, which pass around the
stake pockets are bolted. In addition to
this, from each stake, a rod runs right
across the car through the floor; a bolt
at the end of the stake passing through
the side sill, secures the stakes very
firmly to the outside sills.
The double intermediate sills are
placed within 5 in. of the center sills and
22 in. from the outside sills, so that the
central portion of the car, which cannot
receive any stiffening from the side walls,
is carried on six timbers and is thus
made quite rigid. The whole car floor
is also supported by six through truss
feet of its height, and is reinforced by a
longitudinal timber of triangular section,
resting on top of the stakes and capped
by an angle iron, the full length of the
car. This coping of wood and iron, to-
gether with the fact that the stakes are
all outside the side planks, makes bulg-
ing a most difficult, if not an impossible
feat for the load of coal inside, to per-
form.
The ends of the car have no stakes,
but the "coal box" is anchored down by
about 1,488 cu. ft. volume, and weighs
light, about 37,000 pounds. The design
shows much careful working out of de-
tails and the clever adaptation of means
to an end, upon which the C. P. R. offi-
cials may reasonably congratulate them-
selves.
Still in
the Rinjc and Younger
Than liver.
The Syracuse Post-Standard of recent
date has followed the fortunes of the
CANADIAN PACIFIC SIDE DOOR CO.\I. CAR.
flat iron straps«which grip the top plank
and are bolted through the end sills. Six
Hat corner plates unite end and side
planks.
The side doors open flush with the
floor, and when in position are held
closed by two bolts in each, which drop
into staples on the side sills and cannot
shake out or let the doors open by ac-
cident. These doors are provided with
permanent rods or latches which hold
famous engine "999" on the N. Y. C. &
H. R. The engine has been thoroughly
overhauled and is in service again. In
a recent issue that paper says: "No.
999 is now rattling off miles in sixty
seconds nearly every day, much to the
glee of her engineers, who declare that
she is 'as good as they make 'em,' old
as she is. Last night No. 999 left the
New York Central station at Syracuse,
N. Y., eastbound at 9:30 o'clock attached
rods, of extra depth below the needle
beams,, so that the chance of sagging is
reduced to what may be called a negli-
gible quantity.
.The bulging propensity which coal
cars evince, is also guarded against. Al-
though the stakes are 4 ft. apart and
contain a side door between each, the
full width of the panel, the door itself
is 3 ft. high, while the total height of the
side is s ft. 1-2 in. Therefore the coal
car side is solid all along the upper two
CAS'ADIAN TACIFIC RAILWAY COAL C.\R.
them open When required. Neither
hinges, latches nor any door attachments
extend beyond the line of the stakes, so
that there is nothing along the sides of
the car to catch on anything or be torn
off.
The car may be considered as a par-
tial automatic side dumper, and if all the
doors were open perhaps about 25 per
cent, of the load would be discharged,
the rest would have to be shoveled out by
hand. The car is 40 tons capacity, having
to train No. 32, the Mail and Express.
The western division had delivered the
mail three-quarters of an hour late in
Syracuse. It is required that the train
be drawn to Utica in an hour and fif-
teen minutes from here, which is just
one minute faster than the celebrated
Lake Shore Limited travels, and the lim-
ited does not carry nearly as many
cars as the twelve heavy ones taken out
by No. 999 last night. It was necessary
to make up time, too, for Uncle Sam
i6o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
watches the schedule of the mail trains
very closely. So what more natural than
that No. 999 should have this job? It
isn't fashionable business nor notorious
business that the old .wonder is doing
to-day. But no piece of motive power
on the New York Central is 'earning
its coal' more worthily."
A beautiful line engraving of this typ-
ical "American" locomotive, printed on
heavy plate paper about 30x12 ins., and
suitable for framing, with every part
numbered and a corresponding tabu-
lated index in the margin, will be mailed
free to any address in the United States,
Canada or Mexico on receipt of 25 cents
in coin or in stamps. Address Railway
AND Locomotive Engineering, 174
Broadway. New York. See advertising
page 3 in this issue.
"The Public Demand It."
The phrase "the public demand it" is
a very familiar one to readers of the
daily press, and the thing which the pub-
lic is always represented as demanding
most strenuously is speed in railway or
steamship travel. If any railroad puts
on a fast train, or if a few knots per
hour are added to the speed of an ocean
greyhound we are at once told that it
is the result of a popular demand in
that direction. In fact, the expression
is used so often that many railway men,
steamship men and even the dear, good,
long-sufTering public itself has at last
come to think that there must be some-
thing in it. If the public go on demand-
ing and demanding and demanding there
is no knowing where it will all end —
provided the phrase is true, which it is
not always, by any means.
We have known the inhabitants of a
large city to do some really good, vig-
orous demanding, and to keep it up, and
yet get little or nothing in return.
Right here it is interesting to note that,
as a rule, in the cases where real de-
manding on the part of the public has
not accomplished anything, one factor
in the problem has almost invariably
been omitted. An incident taken from
life may help to make plain what- this
insignificant factor really is: —
The president, the general manager
and some other high officials of the Rock
Ballast & No Dust Railway met in secret
conclave the other day. After prolonged
consultation it was decided to put on a
splendid, through, night train on their
road. It was to be hauled by fast, pow-
erful engines and it was to be composed
of superbly appointed sleepers. The
train was to leave and arrive, from and
at terminals at most convenient hours
for the traveling public, and altogether
no luxury was to be considered too good
for the patrons of the road. The whole
scheme was worked out quietly within
the four walls of a railroad office, and
the public did not know the first thing
about it. "Do you think we will secure
all the business.""' asked the president.
"I know we shall," replied the general
manager. The train was duly put on,
and extensively advertised as the "Night
blooming Cereus," and it was a great
success — after the public found out
what had been done.
Now it so happened that the Me Too
& We Also Railway discovered that they
had been badly "scooped," as the say-
ing is, when this train began going at
full speed, so they straightway went into
the market and procured a train which
Solomon need not have been ashamed
to show to the Queen of Sheba. They
called it by an even more enticing name
than that of its rival and they let it be
known that their train was hauled by
the latest "Mongoose" type of engine
which was simply a compound of speed
and power, and certain death to snakes.
This railway therefore eventually di-
vided up the business evenly with the
R. B. & N. D road, as it was in the
beginning. When everything was as it
had been before the trains were run,
somebody worth knowing complimented
the general managers of both lines, at
a public banquet, and spoke in glowing
terms of the gold-plated, diamond-
studded service which they had inaugur-
ated between important cities, and the
speaker was told by the managers in re-
ply that though it was very expensive
yet the public had demanded it. In all
this the person, or the insignificant
factor, or whatever you like to call it.
named Competition, who had brought
it all about, and had been the means of
giving the public a really good thing,
wasn't referred to at all in the speeclies
and wasn't mentioned as being "among
those present." In fact, he wasn't even
an "also ran," but he got there just the
same, while the public went home from
the banquet thinking that they had de-
manded the trains and had got them.
Kept His Nerve.
The engineer had been many years in
the service of the road, and it is a well-
known fact in railroad circles that in
time the majority of engineers lose their
nerve. They become too cautious, and
as a result they get their trains in late.
This engineer — and this is a true story
— had lost his nerve. He had a passen-
ger engine, and twice he had been told
that if he could not bring his train in on
time he would have to begin hauling
freight. That is a pretty hard threat to
throw at an engineer, and he meekly
promised to do better.
On the occasion of the third warning
he asserted that he would bring the train
in on time "even if there was a brick
house on the track and a barn in ad-
dition."
He came info the office after his "run"
a day or so later, glancing about the
room, looked up at the ceiling and then
asked:
" Seen any of it?"
" Of what?" asked the official.
"Coal!"
"Coal?" repeated the official. "Why
should we expect to see any coal here?"
" Oh, I guess it hasn't come down
yet," answered the engineer carelessly.
" What do you mean?" demanded the
official.
" Some one left a loaded coal car on
the main track," explained the engineer,
"Switch turned too soon or a coupling
broke, I guess. Anyway, it was there."
" And you "
" Oh, I got in on time. I'm not like
a man who has lost his nerve — not by a
good deal."
" But the car! How did you get
around "
" I didn't get around. I pulled her
wide open and came through. There's
about half a ton of that coal on the top
of the rear coach, and I was expectmg
to find the rest of it here. The last 1
saw of it was high and scattering."
" Great Scott!"
" .A-nd say!"
"Well!"
" The smokestack of the engine is gone,
there's no pilot left, and the windows of
the cab are busted. But, of course, I
was acting under orders, and I got in on
time. And say. again!"
"Well!"
"Just put it down on your books some-
where that an engineer who hasn't lost
his nerve, but is tired of keeping it, re-
signed from the service of the road to-
day, and i? going to look for a job on a
farm."- — Buffalo Enquirer.
Ingenious Belt-Sliifter Carrier.
A. simple and most ingenious belt-
shifter carrier designed by the general
foreman of the P. & R. shops at Read-
ing, Pa., may be seen by the observant
visitor, or will be gladly shown to others
on request. The carrier can be put in
any position or at any angle, and will
work as well standing on its head as it
will in the conventional position. It
consists of two separate arms, each ^<
terminating in a flat disc perhaps 4 in.
in diameter. On one side of eacli disc
is cast a number of radiating V-shaped
ribs. When these two discs are properly
bolted together the V-shaped ribs en-
gage and preserve the angle at which
the two arms may have been placed. To
alter the angle, the slacking of a nut
will allow for new adjustment. One
arm is secured to the post, the other
holds the belt-shifter and the carrier
falls in pleasantly with any angle which
circumstances may demand.
Let us try to be sensible; let us try
to be good-natured; let us try to be
fair. — Little Dorrit.
April 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
161
Growth of the Locomotive.
By Angus Sinclair.
{Continued from page 114.)
AGITATION IN FAVOR OF RAILROAD BUILD
INC.
While the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad
was the first in the United States to have
a section opened for regular traffic, and
the first railroad on which a native-built
locomotive did useful work, the promot-
ers of other railroad enterprises were not
waiting to see if the Baltimore undertak-
ing would be successful. Before 1830
ended the Legislature of nearly every
State in the Union had granted charters
for railroads, and many of them were in
course of construction before the year
was far advanced.
EFFECT OF CANALS ON TRADE.
The tendency of canals was to divert
commerce toward certain centers and
consequently deprive other places of
business which had previously been
theirs. There had been considerable mile-
age of canals constructed before 1830,
and much more was projected and under
way. The towns that could not receive
benefit from cinals naturally looked to
railroads to help them and bring to their
warehouses commerce that the water-
ways were trying to divert. This was
what stirred up the business energy of
Baltimore in favor of a railroad to es-
tablish transportation between the Sus-
quehanna and the Ohio Rivers. The
road in fact from its inception was in-
tended as a rival to the Chesapeake &
Ohio Canal.
NEW YORK CITY AGAINST RAILROADS.
The apathy which the people of New
York, the most important city in the
country, displayed toward railroad build-
ing, was due to the fact that they sup-
posed the Erie Canal, constructed by
other people's money, would bring them
all the business they could handle. The
rich city of New York has always taken
a discreditable position concerning rail-
road property. Its politicians have al-
ways succeeded in ta.xing the State peo-
ple heavily to maintain the Erie Canal
so that it might depress railroad rates;
yet the railroads have at all times moved
passengers and freights cheaper than the
subsidized canal.
CHARLESTON OBTAINS CHARTER FOR A
RAILROAD.
About the time that the good people of
Baltimore were preparing to invest their
capital in the construction of a railway,
the citizens of Charleston. South Caro-
lina, were laboring to establish railroad
communication with Hamburg on the
western border of the State, 136 miles
away. A charter for the road was ob-
tained in 1827 and renewed for some rea-
son in January, 1828.
The projectors of the road appeared to
be very enterprising and sagacious busi-
ness men, for one of their first moves was
to induce the Legislature to pass a bill
exempting the property of the company
from taxation.
The enterprise of building a railroad
to the western part of the State was very
alluring for Charleston. The town is
built in a region of swamps that brought
little local trade, but by reaching out to
the uplands, the city would draw not only
a large shipping trade from good cotton-
raising districts, but would also bring
purchasers for the goods handled by its
enterprising merchants. The ground was
of such a character that a great part of
the road from Charleston to Hamburg
had to be built on trestle work. That
did not -discourage the promoters of the
scheme, however, for pine was plentiful
and cheap and labor cost less than in
any other part of the country.
MANAGEMENT BY LOCAL TALENT.
The company was managed at first by
local talent, and one of the first acts of
the directors was to offer a prize nf $500
talent was necessary for the officers per-
forming scientific duties, the position of
chief engineer was offered to Horatio
Allen, who probably knew more about
railroads than any man in America at
that time. Mr. Allen accepted the place,
?.nd within thirty days made an exhaus-
tive report recommending the kind of
road to be constructed and the kind of
power to be employed in operating it.
Mr. Allen had spent several months
in England the previous year studying
the construction of railways and of the
power employed in operating them. He
had been' commissioned by the Delaware
& Hudson Canal Company to purchase
some locomotive engines for the piece of
railroad they intended to build, so that
he probably enjoyed the best of op-
portunities to study the design and pro-
portion of the engines under construction
in the few shops in the British Isles then
devoting themselves to that kind of
work.
TRACK THAT TKEVITHICKS ENCI.VE KAN ON.
for the best locomotive driven by horse
power. American ingenuity was quite
equal to meet this requiremen:. and the
prize was awarded to C. E. Detmold,
who invented a horse-driven motor
worked on an endless chain platform.
This motor carried twelve passengers
and attained a speed of twelve m;les per
hour. Its performance was regarded as
satisfactory.
A sailing car was also tried on this
road, but its career was even shorter
than that of one tried by the Baltimore
& Ohio Railroad about the same time.
The crew, who engaged to manage it on
the trial trip, were more accustomed to
manage horses than sails. When going
before a fresh breeze at about twelve
miles an hour, and loaded with fifteen
passengers, the mast went by the board
carrying the sail and as many of the
passengers as it could scoop off. That
broke the taste of Charleston citizens for
sailing on land.
HOR-^TIO ALLEN APPOINTED CHIEF
ENGINEER.
The impression having reached the di-
rectors that something better than local
ALLEN RECOMMENDS LOCOMOTIVE POWER.
In reporting to the directors of the
Charleston, South Carolina, Canal and
Railroad Company, as the corporation
was ofificially called, Mr. Allen urged that
a structure sufficiently strong to carry
locomotives should be built, and that lo-
comotives be employed to operate it. The
directors met on January 14, 1830. and
the Chief Engineer's report was fully en-
dorsed. A resolution was adopted which
said that the locomotive alone should
be used upon the road, and in selecting
that power for its application to rail-
roads, the maturity of which will be
reached within the time of constructing
the road, would render the application
of animal power a great abuse of the
gifts of genius and science. This was the
most progressive action hitherto taken
by a board of railroad directors, and the
Charleston Railroad was the first in the
world to decide positively that the road
should be operated by locomotive en-
gines.
When the Erie Railway was completed
to Dunkirk a great celebration was held
and Mr. .Mien was one of the principal
l62
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
speakers. Concerning his connection
with the Charleston Railroad he said:
ALLEN ON THE SOUTH CAROLINA RAIL-
ROAD POWER.
"At the same period, that was, prior
to the great locomotive trial in England,
when the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad
Company were so strongly impressed in
favor of horse power, it became neces-
sary for me as engineer of the South
Carolina Railroad Company to decide for
what power that road should be built.
The road was, one hundred and thirty-
six miles long. From the character of
the country the plan of the road would
be naturally influenced by the kind of
power adopted. Stationary power was
out of the question, but the opinion was
held, by many of great intelligence, that
horse-power should at least be com-
menced with. In the report I read on
this important question, I submitted such
comparative estimate of the results of the
horse-power and locoinotive-power as
the information then to be had appeared
to me to sustain. That estimate was in
favor of locomotive-power, but I rested
the decision of the question on the posi-
tion that,' what the performance of a
horse was and would be, every one
knew; but the man was not living who
would undertake to say what the loco-
motive was yet to do, and I may add
that, after more than thirty years have
elapsed, during every one of which the
soundness of this position has gained
new grounds to sustain it, he would be
a bold man who would say that we had
attained the limit in the performance,
and especially in economy of perform-
ance of this great mechanical blessing to
mankind. In the recommendation of
this report in favor pf locomotive-power.
the Board of the South Carolina Rail-
road Company unanimously concurred.
for the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, was
nearly paralleled on the Charleston Rail-
road. Although the advice of Chief En-
gineer Allen had been followed when he
recommended the use of steam loco-
motives for power, he did not at first
control the designing or selection of the
engines. When the company decided to
purchase a locomotive the duty of select-
ing it was conferred upon E. L. Miller,
an influential citizen of Charleston, who
engaged Mr. Detmold, who had designed
the horse-locomotive, to design one to be
driven by steam. Between them they
produced designs of a locomotive which
they guaranteed to haul a load three
times its own weight at a speed of ten
miles an hour.
Mr. Miller proceeded to West Point
Foundry, New York, and superintended
the construction of the engine which was
wisely named the " Best Friend o
Friend" was built. The salient parts of
Mr. Matthew's letter reads:
" The 'Best Friend' was a four-wheel
engine, all four wheels drivers. Two in-
clined cylinders, at an angle, working
down on a double crank, inside of the
frame, with the wheels outside of the
frame, each wheel connecting together
THE "BEST FRIEND OF CHARLESTON.'
FIG. 16.
Charleston." The reading world is quite
familiar with the appearance of that en-
,gine, here illustrated after the original
drawings which are in the possession of
the American Society of Civil Engineers.
DETAILS OF THE " BEST FRIEND."
A curious thing about the design under
PLAN OF THE "BEST FRIEND.'
and as this decision was the. first on any
railway built for general freight and pas-
senger business in this country or in
England, it has been referred to as one
of the interesting facts in the early his-
tory of railroads."
MERCHANT DESIGNED FIRST AMERICAN
LOCOMOTIVE.
, The spectacle which was witnessed, of
a. merchant unaccustomed to mechanical
pursuits designing the first locomotive
the circumstances of its origin is, that it
shows decided originality and displays a
high order of engineering ability.
Particulars of the engine were given in
a letter written in 1859 to William H.
Brown, author of the " History of the
First Locomotives in America," by
David Matthew, one of the pioneer loco-
motive engineers, who was foreman of
machinists in West Point Foundry, Beach
street. New York city, when the " Best
outside, with outside rods. The wheels
were iron hub, wooden spokes and fel-
loes, with iron tire, and iron web and
pins in the wheels to connect the out-
side rods to.
" The Jboiler was a vertical one, in
form oran old-fashioned porter bottle,
the furnace at the bottom surrounded
with water and all filled inside full of
what we called teats, running out from
the sides and top with alternate stays
to support the crown of the furnace; the
smoke and gas passing out through the
sides at several points, into an outside
jacket, which had the chimney on it.
" The boiler sat on a frame resting
upon the four wheels with the connect-
ing rods by it to come into the crank-
shaft. The cylinders were about 6-inches
bore and i6-inches stroke. Wheels
about 4'^ feet in diameter. The whole
machine weighed about 4V2 tons."
As the tons were long, or 2,240
pounds, the total weight was about
10.000 pounds. Figured by our present
rules, the traction force with 50 pounds
boiler pressure, was about 400 pounds.
Running at a speed of 20 miles an hour
and working steam at three-quarters'
stroke, the engine would develop about
12 horse-power.
The boiler, which was decidedly orig-
inal in design, appears to have been the
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
163
prototype of the Hazleton and other
boilers which have teats as evaporating
surface. It was perfectly cfiicient and
steamed well with rich jjiiie wood, the
fuel used.
The engine was t.ikcn by ship to
Charleston and put to work in Novem-
dcr direction of Julius D. Petsch, who
applied straight axles with outside cyl-
inders and cast-iron wheels. The rebuilt
THE "WKST POINT.'
ber, 1830. The wheels proved too weak
for the lateral strains put upon them in
rounding curves and had to be rebuilt
with wrought iron spokes.
When the "Best Friend" arrived at
Charleston about seven miles of the road
had been finished, and the engine was
put to work hauling material for con-
struction.
" BEST FRIEND " HIGHLY EFFICIENT.
The engine proved highly efficient and
doubled the stipulated power and speed.
The engineer who first ran her wrote
that the engine hauled forty or fifty pas-
sengers on four or five cars at from 16
to 21 miles an hour, and ran at a rate
of thirty-five miles an hour without a
load.
BOILER EXPLODES.
About seven months after the engine
was put to work, the negro fireman, who
was left in charge while the engmeer
superintended the loading of cars, an-
noyed by the noise of the safety valve,
fastened the valve down and sat upon
it with the result that the boiler ex-
engine was christened the "Native" when
she first emerged from the repair shop;
but that name was afterwards changed
box with dome on top. Six or eight
tubes about three inches diameter and
six feet long conveyed the products of
combustion from the fire-box to the
smoke box, which was merely the base
of the smoke stack. The engine was
called the " West Point."
That engine went into service early in
1831, and did the work required quite
satisfactorily. In a public test made
shortly after being received, she hauled
four passenger cars, carrying one hun-
dred and seventeen passengers, nine per-
sons more on the engine, and a barrier
car carrying six bales of cotton, two and
three-quarter miles in eleven minutes.
The "barrier car," which was always
loaded with cotton, was a regular fea-
ture of all passenger trains at that time
and was advertised as being used to pro-
tect passengers when the locomotive boiler
exploded. An explosion seemed to be re-
garded as a regular occurrence.
HORATIO Allen's double-ended freak.
After the "West Point" was received,
Horatio Allen, the chief engineer, under-
THE "SOUTH CAROLINA."
with decided propriety to the " Phoenix."
Mr. Petsch, who had displayed so much
skill in re-designing and rebuilding the
engine, was appointed master machinist
of the road and he was the first man in
the world to hold that title.
THE WEST POINT.
Before the "Best Friend's" boiler ex-
ploded another locomotive was ordered
PLAN OF THE "WEST POINT."
ploded. The excessive pressure frac-
tured the crown sheet and the reaction
threw the boiler in the air.
THE FIRST MASTER MACHINIST.
The engine was afterwards rebuilt in
the shop of Thomas Dotterer, a Charles-
ton mechanic. The work was done un-
from the West Point Foundry. Mr.
Miller again being chief designer. This
time he specified an engine with a hori-
zontal boiler, but otherwise the frames,
wheels and cylinder connections were
very similar to those of the "Best
Friend." The boiler had a square fire-
took to design a locomotive, and one was
built at the West Point Foundry in 1831.
It was a double-ended freak, and vindi-
cated the good sense of the directors in
employing ordinary business men as lo-
comotive designers in preference to a
civil engineer. Mr. Allen was a good
civil engineer, but with things mechanical
he was a failure. The engine he pur-
chased in England was antiquated at the
time it was bought, but a clear-headed
business man would have stiffened the
trestles to carry it safely.
His double-ended locomotive was
called the "South Carolina." The
boilers were ridiculous vagaries. They
had a single fire-box in the middle with
two barrels side by side extending to
?moke boxes at each end. The engine
had eight wheels arranged in two trucks,
one pair of driving wheels located close
to the fire-box and one pair of small
carrying wheels close to the smoke box
forming a truck. Each truck had one
cylinder which was in the middle of the
engine and attached to the smoke box.
The driving axle had a crank in the mid-
dle, to which the connecting rod was
attached by a ball-joint.
The engine was built and put to work,
but, like most other freak locomotives.
1 64
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
most of its time was spent in the repair
shop.
Baldwin's second engine.
When t he railroad company was
ready to order their fourth engine, which
was in 1833, the services of Mr. MiUer
were again sought, and he went to Phila-
delphia and consulted with Mr. M. W.
Baldwin, who had built one locomotive,
and was inclined to engage in the work
as a regular business. Messrs. Miller
and Baldwin consulted together and ex-
amined several locomotives that had
been imported from England. The re-
sult of their deliberations and examina-
tive was worked out and influenced by
the pioneers connected with the Balti-
more & Ohio and South Carolina Rail-
roads. When the "E. L. Miller ' was put
in service, the South Carolina Railroad
was the longest railroad in the world.
(To be continued.)
A "Compound " Street Car.
The term compound locomotive is well
understood, but the expression used as
BALDWIN'S SECOND ENGINE. FIG. 21.
tion of engines was, that Mr.. Baldwin
agreed to build a locomotive for the
South Carolina Railroad.
The engine built was called the " E.
L. Miller." It had outside frames and
a single pair of drivers behind the boiler
and a four-wheel truck under the smoke
box. The cylinders were set on top of
A HORSE LOCOMOTIVE.
the frames at the sides of the smoke
box, and transmitted the power to half-
cranks inside the driving wheels. The
boiler was of the Bury or hemispherical
type, with a dome on top.
This engine was delivered in March,
1834, and became one of the most famous
locomotives of its day. Its form was
standard with the Baldwin until the
necessity for heavier power gradually led
to radical changes of design.
This story as told will give an idea of
how far the development of the locomo-
the heading of this article requires a lit-
tle explanation. The Compania de Tran-
vias de Merida, of Merida Yucatan,
Mexico, is experimenting with street cars
propelled with compound steam engines,
and the "works" are all well out of the
way on the front platform or under the
car. The boiler is of the automobile
type, and is placed on the front platform
at one side so that the door is not
blocked. The fuel is gasoline. Water is
supplied from two tanks at the opposite
end of the car and gasoline is carried in
a similar tank placed between those con-
taining water. The throttle, lever, re-
verse lever, injector, feed pump, brake,
etc., are all within easy reach of the
motorman. The engine drives a shaft
which is connected to one of the axles
with a sprocket and chain, and both the
wheel axles carry sprocket wheels and
are connected by an endless chain.
The engine, which is a very compact
compound, was made by the Reeves En-
gine Company, of Trenton, N. J., and is
light and rigid in design, and intended to
stand a lot of hard usage, and to keep
going day in and day out. The cylinders
are 3 1-2 and 6 1-2 inches by 5 inch
stroke. When running 600 revolutions
per minute, with 200 pounds pressure,
with reverse lever well notched up, it is
said to be able to develop about 25 horse
power, and greater duty can easily be
obtained as circumstances arise. Both
cylinders are made in a single casting
lagged with asbestos. There is a central
valve between the cylinders and steam
passes from high to low pressure cyliiv-
iler as directly as possible.
One feature of these engines is that at
the moment when live steam is entering
the high pressure cylinder it passes into
llie port leading to the low pressure
cylinder, where it is blocked by the head
of the valve, but is permitted to fill an
ample groove all round the valve. When
the valve reaches the cut-off point live
steam is imprisoned in this groove, and
when the opening to the low pressure
cylinder is made by the movement of
the valve this stored-up live steam in
the groove helps to augment pressure and
temperature of steam entering the low
pressure cylinder. It is claimed that by
this means condensation in this cylinder
is very considerably reduced. The cen-
tral valve is actuated by a fixed eccentric
and its cut-off is independent of the posi-
tion of the link. The admission valve
simply permits steam to reach the high
pressure cylinder as the admission and
exhaust ports are separate. The groove
just referred to has another function, it
is made to contain the compression or
cushion steam for the high pressure pis-
ton so that the clearance in this cylinder
is reduced to a minimum.
Altogether the experiment is a novel
and interesting one, and the performance
of the compound steam street car will be
watched with considerable interest.
Mechanical Brains.
Most machines improve upon hand'
labor only by insuring greater uniform-
ity of product and cheapening the latter.
Once in a while, though, a mechanism^
is invented which seems to think also.
Of coijrse, it doesn't, but it will per-
form work which has hitherto been done
only by human brains. A device belong-
ing to this exceedingly twisted class is-
a tabulating machine in use at the Cen-
sus Bureau in Washington. It draws
important lessons from data that are
first recorded by the punching of cards.
All of this preliminary work can be done
by girls and for a time the cards are
filed in convenient cases or drawers.
Subsequently a lot of them are fed into
the machine miscellaneously and cer-
tain ones will be automatically sorted
out. These, on examination, will tell ani
important story; that is, if the proper
adjustments have been made for selec-
tion.
If this system were in use in a big
engine factory the punching would run-
something like this: One hole would in-
dicate, by its place in a possible column,
the year, a second would record the
month, and a third the day. There
would be several more imaginary col-
umns, in each of which at some point
one hole would be punched, the posi-
tion being dictated by circumstances.
These additional holes would tell the
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
165
nuniljcr of the job, the number of a
particular operative who worked on it,
the hours he spent on it, and his wages.
It would also be possible to show
whether this was piece work or not,
whether it was for a customer or for
the house, and other facts that might
be of importance.
Suppose, a year or two after the
punching was done that the manufact-
urer wanted to know why one engine
which he had turned out cost less than
an earlier one. His machine could then
be made to pick out from a large num-
ber of cards the very ones which regis-
tered the facts he wished to learn. In
a few minutes he could get what it might
take a bookkeeper several weeks to find.
— Nezv York Tribune.
Heavy Atlantic Type Engines for the
C, B. & Q.
The Rogers Locomotive Works, Pat-
erson, N. J., have been turning out some
very fine 4-4-2 engines for the Chicago,
Burlington & Quincy Railroad. They
izer for the rear wheels rests upon the
top of the box and terminates in a pair
of spiral springs at the back and con-
nects with a pivoted equalizer bar which
connects with the rear driving spring
hanger. The driving wheels arc equal-
ized in the usual way with overhung
springs.
The valves are of the piston type anl
are placed directly between the top and
bottom bar of the frame front, thus giv-
ing short direct steam passages to the
cylinders. The valves are 12 ins. in
diamotor. and the packing rings are put
in what may be called spoked bull rings,
which are held in place at each end by
the valve-stem with shoulder and nut.
The transmission bar passes over the
axle of the leading driver and is attached
to a rocker with both arms on the same
side of the center, thus securing direct
action for the valve. The cross-head is
of the two guide-bar type and is secured
to tlie piston-rod by a nut.
The boiler is of the wide fire-box type,
with extension wagon top. The inside
to spin round at a good speed. In or-
der not to cut the seat in a scries of
concentric circles, as would likely hap-
pen if continuous motion were kept up,
a neat device simulates the little jump
off the seat which a workman gives to
the valve every little while, wlien grind-
ing by hand. The device is a treadle,
which when pressure is applied by the
foot, raises a small ram which strikes
a temporary throttle stem. In other
words, while being ground in, the throt-
tle valve is opened and closed by the
foot of the operator, just as the engi-
neer opens and closes it with his hand
on the regulator, when the throttle is in
its own legitimate business of steam
choking.
Two Little Tooters.
Two of the little Manhattan Elevated
Railroad engines, which have for years
glided past masses of struggling and
crowding New Yorkers on the "L" plat-
forms, will shortly make a start for
China. The ,\merican-China develop-
nE.4VY ".ATLANTIC" TYPE ENGINE FOR THE C, B. & Q.
are to haul tlie famous "Burlington No.
1" and other trains of that class, so that
work is already cut out for these ma-
chines. The engines are simple, with
20x26-in. cylinders, 84 1-2-in. drivers, the
adhesive weight is 92,000 pounds and the
pressure carried is 210 pounds. The total
weight of the engine is 174.000 pounds.
The rear truck wheels, which are
54 1-4 in. in diameter, have outside jour-
nals which are 12x8 ins., and are en-
closed in a journal-box with dust-guard
brass and wedge on the same general
lines, though larger, as the regular M. C.
B. axle box. The use of this box necessi-
tated a special frame arrangenient. The
main engine frames terminate in a steel
casting -which acts as a very solid filling
piece between the frames, and the cast-
ing extends out far enough to spread the
frames for the rear truck so as to pass
them over the center of the axle box
when in normal position. The bo.x slides
in frame jaws similar to those of the
driving wheels, but considerable side
play has been allowed for. The equal-
diameter at the smoke box end is 64 ins.
The heating surface amounts to 2,990 sq.
ft., and the grate area is 44.2 sq. ft. A
few of the principal dimensions are as
follows:
Cylinders, 20 x 26 in.
Driving wheel base, 7 ft. 3 in.; total wheel base
of engine, 27 ft. 7 in.
Weight on drivers, 92,000 lbs : weight on truck,
42,000 lbs.; weight on trailers, 40,000 lbs.; total,
174.000 lbs.
Heating surface — Tubes, 2,834 sq. ft.; firetx)x, 156
sq ft.; total, 2,990 sq. ft.
Grate area, 44.25.
Tubes, diameter, 2 in.; length, 16 ft. 6 in.; thick-
ness. No. II; number, 330.
Grate, length, 96 in.; width, 66 in.
Wheels— Engine truck, diameter, 375^' in.
Tender— Capacity, 6,000 gals.; frame, wood with
steel center beams; trucks, with cast-steel
bolster; wheels, diameter. 37H in.
Throttle Valves Ground by Air.
At the new Reading shop of the Phil-
adelphia & Reading they grind throttle
valves by the use of compressed air. The
throttle case is clamped against a bench
and a pneumatic boring or reaming ma-
chine operates the valve, which is made
ment Company is about to begin work
on the Canton-Hankow Railroad, which
will eventually be about 900 miles long,
ana these little hard-coal puffers will be
required to do some construction work.
We are afraid that they may not be nearly
as particular or well behaved out there
as they have been here. In the city
they are most careful not to let the
water from their injector overflow pipes
fall upon the street below, nor that
any hot cinders shall get out of their
ash pans. Who can tell what they may
do when away from home for the first
time and working on construction, but
surely a pair of snorters, who can con-
stantly be "out all night" in New York
and yet keep a fairly straight course
frorn the Battery to Harlem, may still,
in a foreign land, do credit to their
American bringing up. They have been
trained here, in making "chalk-line"
stops with the vacuum brake, and they
may "spot" cars in China in a way which
may make even the Celestial Empire look
earthlv.
166
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
General Correspondence.
Locating a Blow.
Reading the article, "Combination of
Book and Brain," written by Bro.
■"Shandy" for the March number of
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing, I find a mixture of conditions; that
■is, there is a mixture of the ancient and
modern that does not blend; this cuts
no figure, however, with the good re-
sults which should come from the ar-
ticles written on the subject that the
'brother has mentioned. In the days of
long ago, and before the advent of cor-
respondence schools, -the old balloon,
sunflower and diamond smokestacks
were in evidence; this long ago was a
full quarter of a century back. In those
days it was a short job to open up the
smoke box and slip a shingle over the
nozzles to locate a valve blow. Begin-
ning fully 20 years ago the mechanical
"heads of various locomotive departments
were taxing their brains to get up some
device to husband the cinders, and the
extension front end was born as the
fruit of their labors, and it did the work,
and the results — well, every old-time
railroad man knows the results. Any-
how, the extension fr6nt was universally
adopted and, with its adoption, it be-
came about as hard a task to get into
a front end as the average railroad man
will find in trying to get into heaven.
After the coming of the extension it
was about as easy to take oflf both
steam chest covers as to get to the noz-
zles, and this condition led me to adopt
-the "Stick telephone" to locate valve
"blows. _ I will describe this method (al-
though if my memory serves me right,
I read an article in Railway and Loco-
motive Engineering on same subject
some time ago): take a piece of wood
about 1-2 inch in diameter, 2 or 3 feet
long, grab it firmly between the teeth (if
you have teeth), close both ears and place
the end of the stick farthest from you
against the steam chest proper, that is,
do not rest stick against the jacket
covering, but against the chest where
release valve is screwed in, or at back
■end, close to stuffing box; place your
engine where blow seems strongest and
use this "phone" first on one side then
the other, and you can easily distinguish
the side that gives forth the greater
volume of sound. I have never failed
in this method of locating valve blows,
and if there is any one thing more than
another that an engineer should know
these days it is how to locate a valve
Wow, and I believe it possible to locate
this trouble in almost every instance if
a little care and patience are exercised.
J. W. Reading.
Manistee, Mich.
To Prevent Telescoping.
My attention has been called to an
article on page 76 of your February
issue in which you discuss the merits of
a certain non-telescoping car patent re-
cently issued to me.
I have read the article with much in-
terest, and the objections mentioned by
you have been mentioned by others. I
have done a vast amount of traveling
and have had the misfortune to be in
several railroad wrecks, but the good
fortune to escape injury myself. One
thing that has impressed itself upon me,
and which, in fact, set me thinking along
the line wjiich developed the non-tele-
scoping idea was the fact that the simple
derailment or even ditching of entire
passenger trains often happens without
the loss of a single life. I have kept track
of railroad wrecks in recent years, and
it is the exception for more than one
or two persons to be killed in derailed
cars, and generally these are the engine
crew or trainmen. On the other hand
telescoping accidents always result in
fearful loss of life. More than one hun-
dred and fifty passengers were killed in
telescoping wrecks within a period of
thirty days this winter. The reason for
this is the crushing or telescoping of
the cars, and there is little chance of
escape. When cars are derailed or rolled
over, passengers are bruised up, but as
long as timbers and other cars do not
enter the car in which the passengers
are riding, the chance of fatal accident
is not very great, and the non-fatal in-
juries that happen are, as a rule, not
serious.
I note your statement that "the elim-
ination of the car platform and the in-
troduction of solid end cars and con-
tinuous vestibules with strong under-
framing to cars, is apparently the safe
lines along which the evolution of car
design by expert car builders on our
leading roads is moving." Of course it
is a fact that the solid end cars do not
prevent telescoping. I know a num-
ber of instances where solid vestibule
cars have telescoped and there is no
reason to believe that they are safer
than any others. The only tendency of
"solid ends and strong underframing"
is to withstand and check the momen-
tum by main force, and if this could
ever be accomplished — that is, if on ac-
count of the strength of the cars it would
be possible to bring the entire train to
an instant stop without telescoping — the
effect would indeed be disastrous.
A train running at 30 miles an hour
is traveling 44 feet a second, and if it
were possible to stop the entire train
as suddenly as the engines stop in a
train would strike the object directly
in front of him with the same force that
a man would strike the sidewalk after
jumping out of a fifth story window, as
his body would be going thrugh space
at about the same rate of speed (44 feet a
second) when he struck the sidewalk
that the passenger is traveling when the
collision occurs.
I maintain that it is a physical impos-
sibility to stop a train in this way, as
the tremendous energy or momentum
must be given a chance to spend itself.
When a collision occurs the forward
cars crush together and the rear cars
on account of this crushing come to a
stop within a car's length or two, and
this is the only thing that saves them
or the passengers in them.
The theory of my invention is that it
is absolutely necessary to provide one
or two hundred feet within which to
bring the cars to a stop so that the mo-
mentum of the train can spend itself.
This is made possible by dislocating one
or more joints of the train and throwing
the cars aside in the way provided by my
invention.
Strong underframing of cars or strong
ends never have and never can prevent
telescoping, and even if they could the
shock would kill everyone irf the train.
Geo. E. Dickson.
Chicago, III.
Outrages to American Trainmen in
Mexico.
I cannot refrain from replying to your
article in the February number regard-
ing outrages to American trainmen in
Mexico.
Among all the articles in print in the
United States there are none from any
trainmen now in prison in Mexico, and
if any were deprived of their liberty here,
surely the organizations of conductors
and engineers would know it. H. H.
Adams, who, by the way, belongs to
neither organization, is well known here.
He was in a position he had no business
to be in, caused the wreck himself, was
well treated, considering the opportuni-
ties that existed in a little mountain
town, and instead of "flagging a train
with a match and being smuggled out of
the country" he rode out on the express
of the National Road with a purse of
money in his pocket. The conductor and
engineer with whom he rode are still
on the same train.
Nor are the agitators against our
Minister and Consuls among the Ameri-
can residents here. I personally know of
cases where our Minister has interceded
for railway men here, and secured their
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
167
release, but you must not forget, it is
not a Minister's business to uphold
those who transgress the laws of a coun-
try. M. J. Schneider,
M. M. Nat. Ry.
Heat Phenomenon in Hire Box.
In answering the question of W. B.
Chenowith, of Cotton Belt shops, in
January number of the Railway and
Locomotive Engineering, regarding
the phenomenon of cold firebox
sheets when the engine is hot, will say
that this is due to the law of convection.
It is a very important study for engine
crews. It cuts no small figure in
cracked sheets, leaky stay-bolts and
flues. When steam is raised in a boiler
and the injector put to work with a good
fire in fire-box, the water in boiler is in
continual motion by currents. The cold
water passing in currents down the side.s
of the fire-box sheets. These sheets be-
ing splendid conductors of heat, the heat
from the fire readily passes through the
sheet in to the cold water, which is con-
verted to steam and passes in currents
through the body of the water to the
surface. The water absorbs the heat so
rapidly that it keeps the sheets compara-
tively cool. If W. B. C. will shut od
the injector long enough for all the
water in boiler to become hot and allow
the fire to cool down he will find the
sheets would be too hot for his hand.
Convection keeps the heating surface of
boilers from being destroyed by heat, by
communicating the heat of the fire-box
to the water, which is carried to the top
of the water in currents, and replaced
by cold currents of water descending
from the top. The practice of some en-
gine crews putting on the injector with
full feed of water for a short time, shut
it off for a short time, and then again on
full, and thus continue over the road is
very hard on the heating surface of a
boiler. The continued expansion and
contraction of the sheets and tubes causes
cracks in sheets, and leaky stay-bolts and
tubes. The boilers should be fed as even-
ly as possible, for the above reasons.
Jno. a. Ross.
East Las Vegas, N. M.
Mr. A. M. Waitt. superintendent of
motive power and rolling stock on the
New York Central Railroad, has a few
days ago issued the following circular
addressed to the employees of the me-
chanical department: "Having decided
to sever my connection with this com-
pany after March 31, I desire to express
my appreciation to the employees of my
department for their good will and co
operation for the past four years. In no
way can your good will for me be better
shown than by giving to whoever is
selected as my successor the same sup-
port and loyalty that you have accorded
me. In retiring from the road I leave
with you each and all my best wishes."
Sparic Arresters.
It was with a great deal of interest
that I read the article on spark arresters,
contributed by Mr. J. Snowden Bell, in
February issue of Railway and Loco-
' MOTivi! Encinekring. The same old
hustle to prevent throwing fire and have
the engine steam obtains to-day, as it
did in my boyhood days. Among the
many devices illustrated in the columns
of your journal from time to time, I
have never seen this old stack men-
tioned, and of which I 'enclose sketch.
Where this stack originated "deponent
saith not." At all events, it was the only
one used for a number of years on the
old Philadelphia & Columbia Railroad
(Pennsylvania State Road). It came
Fia- t
moved in the line indicated by the ar-
rows. The relation of the moving cin-
ders and angle of netting is very much
the same as obtains in modern practice.
These old stacks did not in a general
way throw much fire, considering the
kind of fuel used (wood and coal com-
bined, and the engines were good
steamers. It was the duty of the fire-
man at all water stations to clean out
the front end, and they are doing the
same thing to-day, with extension front
ends. The old engines had boiler-iroii
fronts; to-day they are steel. In Fig. t
you will notice the rod E connected
to the left side of the stack, and near
the top; also at D what appears to be
a small wheel, is a coiled spring and
Fig. 2
OLD PHIL.'iDELPHI.^ & COI.rMBI.\ R. R. SMOKE BOX.
into use on the old single driver engines,
and held its own long after the era of
multiple coupled engines, on the State
Road. Fig. i shows a general outline
of the stack. Fig. 2 shows the front re-
moved, exhibiting the arrangement of
steam and exhaust pipes. A part of the
smokestack casing in Fig. 2 is broken
away to show the netting A in the
lower part of the stack. The netting,
like the bottom part of stack, was an
inverted frustum of a cone.
Between the casing and the netting
was the space B. The exhaust tips en-
tered the bottom of the netting, which
was in reality an iron plate (C) having
holes for the admission of the exhaust
tips. Any cinders carried out of the
front end bv the force of the exhaust
hinge combined. The top section of the
stack is jointed at this point, the rod
E leaning back to the left side of the
engine, it was another duty of the fire-
man to lower the stack when going
through all covered bridges, on account
of the bridge roof being too low. Fire-
men have lost their lives by forgetting
to lower the stack in time, the bridge
striking the stack and driving the rod
through the man's body. Steam and
exhaust pipes were made of copper, and
being directly in front of the flues, they
had to be protected by a sheet-iron
jacket. These sketches are made from
memory and are practically correct. The
motive power consisted of engines built
by Baldwin, Norris. Eastwick & Harri-
son and Campbell, all of Philadelphia;
i68
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
Dotterer & Co., of Reading, Pa.; Pennel,
Leonard & Hume, of Lancaster, Pa.,
and they all used this stack. Who can
tell the readers of R.\ilway and Loco-
motive Engineering more about it?
W. DE San NO.
Srs Van Ness Ave., S. F.
3moke Box Arrangement for Modern
Locomotives.
Much has been said in regard to the
adoption of a standard form of front end,
"but it would seem that the result of ef-
forts in this direction would be sufficient
to demonstrate that such a plan would
not be practicable for all kinds of ser-
vice and conditions existing in different
localities. What we need is efficiency,
economy and simplicity. Free steaming
engines that can be run with a reason-
ably large exhaust opening. By f^impHc-
ity is meant to do away with all adjust-
able parts in the construction of front
end if possible, and when one engine of
a class is found to steam satisfactorily
after thorough trials, and under all pre-
vailing conditions, with a certain size
nozzle and front end adjustment, make
the latter non-adjustable. And all the
other engines of this class should be ar-
ranged like it. Any further changes of
these parts will not improve the steam-
ing qualities of the engine. How often
we see a case where the engineer reports
an engine not steaming, without assign-
ing any cause for it. The engine-house
foreman makes alterations in the front
end without any apparent reason for do-
ing so, which usually consist of moving
everything that is movable, and winds
up with either bridging or bushing the
nozzle, and the real cause of trouble
which is probably a loss of steam ov
something more that interferes with the
proper work of engine is not thought of
at the time. The engine goes out on
the road and with the very strong blast
on fire and increased fuel consumption,
probably a sufficient amount of steam is
generated to overcome the existing de-
fect and the engine makes a very suc-
cessful run. One will only have to talk
with the engine-house foreman on the
subject and he will look wise and teil
you that he made the 796 steam. Mean-
while the engine continues in service
with the original trouble getting worse,
until finally it is unable to do business
and is ordered out of service. The
trouble now must be located and the
cylinder packing, valves, etc.. are exam-
ined. Perhaps the cylinder packing will
be found to be defective or even worse
trouble found, as is often the case with
compound engines. The defective ports
are repaired and the engine again goes
into service, but the mutilated front end
remains as the engine-house foreman left
it. It only takes a few experiences of
this kind and the unsatisfactory perform-
ance of the engine becomes noticeable.
However, it is a fact much to be re-
gretted that we not infrequently find
well proportioned modern locomotives
so choked up at the exhaust opening as
to render their performance unsatisfac-
tory, particularly so as regards fuel con-
sumption. In taking up the diflferent
parts contained in the smoke box for
consideration, let us look at the deflector
and diaphragm plate. We find that it has
taken the place of the draft or petticoat
pipe used in the diamond-stack engine to
regulate the flow of gases through the
iiues, thus distributing the draft evenly
over the grate and utilizing all the
heating surface represented in tube
area for making steam. The question
arises, and I believe is yet to be de-
cided, as to what this plate should be,
and its location. In my opinion the de-
flector and diaphragm plate should be all
in one, non-adjustable and placed back
of exhaust pipe, with sufficient space be-
tween it and flue sheet to equalize the
flow of gases through all the flues. It
should be placed at a long angle reach-
ing to exhaust pipe, the height of thi:
latter being determined by it, and a short
front end should be used that will not
allow sparks to accumulate beyond the
path of the current of gases passing up
to the stack. The height of exhaust
opening can be governed by nozzle tip,
as it can be carried to any height de-
sired. Just what advantage there is in
using a draft pipe with a deflector
plate is not quite clear to the writer,
having been familiar with many excellent
steaming engines without it, and I would
like to see trials made with some of our
modern engines to demonstrate whether
or not it is a necessity. At any rate tho
tion of front end filling up with sparks
is a very troublesome one, and as there
is no advantage in collecting them, the
front, as I have before stated, should be
short. Usually trouble of this kind can
be traced to inexperienced firemen or
small exhaust nozzles. In case of the
former where the fire is being fed too
fast and is being continuously stirred up
with the fire-tools, large quantities of
partly consumed fuel in the shape of
sparks are carried through the flues and
the same can be said of the small ex-
haust nozzle. A moderately coarse net-
ting gives best results. Fine netting
should not be used, as it acts as an ob-
struction to the passage of gases and it
is necessary to use a small nozzle tip
in order to get enough blast on the fire.
In addition to other disadvantages this
produces a sharp, jerky exhaust which
throws more fire than with a coarse net-
ting and larger nozzle. There is no dis-
advantage in throwing out the dead
sparks that find their way into the front
end. With a mild exhaust and free-
steaming engine most of the sparks are
consumed in the firebox and go toward
producing steam. What few do pass
through the flues do not do so with a
rush and are usually out by the time they
reach the stack. W. A. Bucklee.
Rensselaer, N. V.
Planing Cast Steel Frames.
Noticing that the steel fram is coming
thick and fast, also bringing with it hard
work for the planer-man to properly
turn out a good job, sand and lots of it
coming with frames, why don't they re-
duce the surface to machine as per my
HaUieay A Loeomotitv Engineering
PROPOSED STEKL LOCOMOTIVE FRAME.
pipe or pipes should be non-adjustable.
In my opinion the diameter of stack
should be governed by the amount of
grate area, kind or service and quality of
fuel used, and I would not be surprised to
yet see 20-inch stacks used on high-speed
wide firebox engines burning gaseous
fuel. The question of the exhaust filling
the stack does not seem to be of as much
importance under the above conditions
as that of allowing the unconsumed
gases to pass out with it. At very slow
speed and with fuel containing a less
amount of gas it will be found necessary
to use a smaller stack in order to ob-
tain a sufficient amount of vacuum. I
believe it is a well understood fact that
the unconsumed gases in front end must
have room to pass out of stack with the
exhaust. Otherwise they act as an ob-
struction of the draft and the engine
does not steam satisfactor ly. The ques-
sketch, loosing lots of sand holes and
reducing time to plane. F. Rattek.
Manchester, N. H.
LWhat our correspondent is hoping
for, is being put in practice by several
leading roads. The reduction of ma-
chine work on cast steel frames is one of
the objects which modern designers
have constantly before them. — Ed.]
The First Successful Coal Burning
Locomotive.
Though never having been employed
in any branch of railroad work, I have
from a child been interested in railroads,
and have noted the development of loco-
motives from the old woodburners I re-
call in the sixties to the productions of
the present day. Having recently made
somewhat of a study of the origin and
growth of .American engines, I am
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
169
pleased to see the scries of articles by
Mr. Sinclair on this subject now appear-
ing in Railway and Locomotive En-
<;iNEERiNG. I have gathered pictures and
descriptions of historic engines, most of
which are the originals ot the numerous
types that appeared at intervals of from
three to five years, from 1803 to the
seventies. Of the early American en-
gines made at the West Point Foundry,
and by Baldwin, Jervi"s, Campbell, the
Lowell Machine Shop and others, the
first engine to have a cab, at least the
first so far as I have been able to learn,
was the Norris eight-wheeler No. 16, of
the B. & O., in 1838. But after this. date
Norris seems to be about the only
American builder to discard the cab, as
appears by pictures of his ten-wheeler
the "Chesapeake," in 1846, ^nd the
Norris-Phleger of 1855. An explana-
tion has suggested itself for this singu-
lar fact by the possibility that the cab,
which looks modern enough, was put on
some time after the engine was built. I
have two pictures of this engine obtained
from different sources and from differ-
ent sized plates, and they are alike. Per-
haps I am not the only engine crank
who has sought an answer to this con-
undrum. Coming down to a later date
I find there are as many "first success-
ful coal burners" as "oldest Masons" or
articles of Mayflower furniture. In a
series of papers by Mr. S. AI. Vauclain
entitled "Locomotives of a Century,"
which appeared in Popular Mechanics
(Chicago) last spring. I find in the issue
of May 3rd Ross Winans' "Delaware,"
1846. spoken of as "the first locomotive
to burn anthracite coal successfully, and
this enabled the Reading Railroad to
"haul coal to Philadelphia by burning coal
instead of wood." In the next number
of the same paper. May 10, 1902, we read:
"We now come to the first engine to
burn anthracite coal, which marks a dis-
tinctive step in the wonderful evolu-
tion of the locomotive." "It was Mill-
hoUand's 'Illinois,' shown in Fig. 25"
(1852). On reading this I thought of
the entertaining article in Railway and
Locomotive Engineering of last
.August entitled "The First successful
Coal Burner and Modern Successor,"
which gives an account of Mr. Felton's
final success with coal on the "Daniel
Websiter," of the P .W. & B. road, some
time in the sixties. So this matter of
■first successful coal burner seems to be
a case where the doctors disagree.
Jas. M. Kimball, Woburn, Mass.
76 Garfield Avenue.
[Really the first locomotive to burn
anthracite successfully was Peter Coop-
er's "Tom Thumb." There is no ques-
tion about that as a fact. The grasshop-
per engines designed by Phineas Davis
and Ross Winans also burned anthra-
•cite.— Ed]
Boiler Hxplosions.
I not only was pleased with, but
heartily indorse the views expressed in
the March issue relative to boiler ex-
plosions.
I go a step still further. My belief
for years has been that every State
should force on locomotive engineers a
license and examination. Also every
company should be forced to put in the
hand of every man hired as foreman a
short, comprehensive treatise on com-
bustion, steam and boilers.
Every man knows just how far his
particular company expend time and
money in caring for the motive power, so
setting all complaints against the com-
p.inies aside for brevity, let us consider
the chances some men take.
So many possibilities exist wherein a
man can get caught low in water and
touch his sheet that in numerous cases
I can heartily sympathize with the unfor-
tunate one. Firing for a man who warped
the crown and caused a number of stays
{'• let go, I can testify to unpleasant sen-
sations.
There is a limit to the elasticity of
iron and steel, and for years I have been
inclined to believe the mysterious part
you speak of in a number- of cases has
been by some men stretching the limit.
There has been and there are men who
to make a good run, or to overcome a
hard pull or to make a little faster time
than some other fellow, will crowd the
safety line. Then there is another type.
You will see him with a free steaming
engine trying to overcome the last part
of the grade. The engine struggling,
straining, swaying, every fiber in her
seeming to quiver like a thing of life.
Her safety valves up and he closes oflf
his water to force her just a little more.
When I have been ordered to leave a
door shut under such conditions I have
thought: Will she stand the strain of
what she is using if he shuts off sud-
denly. Then there is the fireman who,
against repeated instruction, will not
watch his steam. And there are some
others. Sometimes mufflers does not
relieve. I have seen from 10 to 30
pounds excess of pressure when shut-
ting off. An engineer cannot always
reach the firebox door.
One very foggy night, taking an extra
engine on a passenger run, and while
passing over a section of road where
signals were thick and strict attention to
them requisite, I was leaning out of
side window when the thought came to
me: This is a pretty smart engine for
one allowed only 130 pounds of steam.
Well, when I passed the next "clear" I
pulled the old broken hand lamp a little
nearer the steam gauge. 175 pounds of
steam ! Not a simmer from relief, both
doors shut tight. If I had shut off sud-
denly I wonder if I would have passed
the "clear" except perpendicularly.
Moderation.
Squaring; the Exhaust.
I see that V. V. B., in the March
issue of Railway anu Locomotive
Engineering, fails to sec how I could
keep a plugging bar in the nozzle when
he could not keep his liner in the stack.
One thing he has not taken into consid-
crating is the vast difference in area be-
tween a y^-\n. bar and the liner he men-
tions, which I should judge was about
16 in. in diameter, as he gives no figures.
I have not only once, but dozens o(
times seen the bar used as I described
in the January issue, for the purpose of
making engines steam that were failing
on account of a poor tank of coal. I
have also seen brake-wheels inserted in
a taper stack for this same purpose, but
never yet found that the exhaust would
dislodge and blow them out of the stack.
From the description he gives of the
antics of Engine 109 I should judge that
the exhaust and cinders had worn ofif the
rivets and cocked the false stack, giving
him the results he mentions. Now, the
only fault I can find with him was that
he did not extend his thoughts far
enough, due probably to loss of sleep,
long hours, etc., and put too much re-
liance on the shop force to locate the
difficulty for him.
While traveling engineer for the Ohio
Central Lines I had a case identical with
brother F. V. B., and when the engine
went lame she quit steaming. The en-
gineer wired in for permission to give
up his train and come in with the light
engine. Knowing him to be a very cap-
able man I refused to grant his request
until he had made a thorough examina-
tion of the cause, realizing that if the
shop force should find a cause which
might have been remedied out on the
line with the resultant delays and ex-
penses incurred, it would have reduced
his stock as an able and competent en-
gineer in the estimation of the company
considerably.
I went out on a departing train to
meet him. We opened the smoke-arch
door and found a liner dislodged and
cocked in the stack. After removing the
same the engine steamed free again. I
found upon inspecting our other engines
four others that were about ready to cut
up the same capers. Now. our liners
were not put in to reduce the stack, but
to protect the stack from the wear of
cinders.
We removed them all and experienced
no more trouble from this source. The
engineer also, in the case just cited, not
only brought in his train, but saved the
expense incurred in your case of having
the shop force go over the valve motion
and finding nothing wrong with it.
L A. B.
-All good ends can be worked out by
good means. Those that cannot are bad.
and may be counted so at once and left
alone. — Barnaby Rudgc.
170
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
U^iZt^^Ei^ineeriii^
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Fubllshed monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York,
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, " l/oceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, "l<oca«to."
Business Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NEI<I<IS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATBRSON, Secretary.
BSltorlal Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
T. M. NEI/LIS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
AdTcrtlslng Department :
Eastern Representative, S. 1. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
1204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE LOCOMOTIVE PtrBI<ISHING
CO., I/td. loaa Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, I/ondon.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCI,AIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibroz, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
ta.oofer year^ $1^00 for six months, postage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other Paris of the world, Sl-so, or ten shilling's.
Sing'le copies, 2o cents. Remit by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Re^ttered
Letter.
Mailing address can be changed as ojten as neces-
lary — always give old and new address, and if you
iubicribed in a club state who got it up.
Please gtve prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly.
Entered at Post Office. New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.. igoj.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Block Signaling in the United States.
In the proceedings of the session of
the American Railway Association held
in New York on April 23 and 24, 1902,
some very interesting statistics on block
signaling are given, and from them some
very instructive lessons may be learned.
It appears from the table published that
there is a distance equivalent to 34,i7.t
miles of single track which is equipped
with block signals. The total mileage
represented by the association is given
as 200,154 miles. The report of the In-
terstate Commerce Commission gives the
total mileage, including single, double,
treble and quadruple tracks in the United
States on 30th June, 1901. as being 210.-
437 miles, and this does not take in yard
tracks, which, if included, would bring
the total up to about 265,325 miles. In
this survey of the facts no account has
been taken of the interlocking signals
used in yards, though it may be stated
that 83 roads use them and there are
24,057 such signals in use.
In dealing with the block signal sta-
tistics it seems fair to take the Inter-
state Commerce Commission's figure of
210,437 miles as the total number of op-
erated miles equivalent to single track
to which block signals might be applied.
This means that there are 176,262 miles
of such track without block signals. If
we choose to designate roads using block
signals as protected roads, we find that
there is more than six times as much un-
protected mileage as there is protected.
In other words, about 16 per cent, of the
total operated mileage which we have
considered as equivalent to single track,
is all that this country can boast of in the
way of block signal equipment, and ac-
cording to the Railway Association its
use was confined to 53 roads at the date
given.
The reason why such a small percent-
age of block signals is used, is not far to
seek. In the early days of the develop-
ment of this country the principal thing
was to build and work a railroad, with-
out any of the refinements in operation
which the needs of these latter days are
beginning to force upon us. We have
passed out of the simple developmental
period in which railways of the crudest
type were in advance of the needs of the
people. We are now well into what may
be called the "Can-you-handle-the-busi-
ness-offer d" stage, in which existing
transportation facilities are often severely
taxed to meet the normal and perfectly
reasonable demands of the country.
The motive power departments of our
railway systems seem to have kept more
nearly in touch with the changes time
has wrought. We have to-day large,
high-speed passenger engines, capable of
hauling fast through trains and of main-
taining schedule time. We have also
heavy freight locomotives of modern de-
sign, developing power sufficient to move
cars with maximum load, in long trains.
Not only has adequate power been pro-
vided, but the "large car" has helped to
reduce transportation to a low cost per
mile. Further than this, motive power
departments all over the country have
been rebuilding and modernizing their
repair and maintenance plants. These
excellent results may briefly be summar-
ized by saying that the motive power
department is abreast of the times, but
the fact nevertheless suggests a compari-
son.
We have something over 210,000 miles
of good track in this country, let us say;
we have modern engines and cars and
we have repair plants adequate for
the service required, but in every 100
miles of this track on which these
engines and cars run, there are about
84 miles unprotected by block sig-
nals. This fact is all the more remark-
able when it is remembered that the
steadily increasing business which has
made equipment of engines, cars and re-
pair plants, grow larger and larger, does
not appear to have materially stimulated
the use of block signals, although the
block system and track capacity are very
closely related matters. Just here it is
interesting to quote the l^ew York Even-
ing Post of recent date, where it remarks:
"The preponderance of evidence leads
us to believe that the trade of the coun-
try has actually outrun its means of
transportation, and that the shortage is-
not merely of cars and locomotives, but
of trackage as well." When looked at
side by side, these facts as stated above
seem to indicate that the operating de-
partment on our railways can hardly
have taken block signaling seriously.
As time goes on and as incidents in tht
operation of railways come more and
more under the notice of the government
statistician, deficiencies in equipment
or defects in maintenance and operation
will come more prominently into view
in every published report. As the search-
light is gradually turned on the cause
and relative seriousness of accidents, it
will be found that train movement, not
engine failures, is casting the darkest
shadow.
It has been customary in the past for
technical men and others in this country
to criticise railway management in Eng-
land and to dwell with perfectly justifi-
able satisfaction on American cost-reduc-
ing methods. Perhaps this criticism has
failed to recognize some of the details
of the work which our friends across the
water are doing in the matter of safe,
even if not cheap, transportation. They
hold the record for the successful move-
ment of an enormous number of persons,
with minimum loss of life. They achieve
the desired result in general by a method
of train movement which includes some
form of block signal or train staflf sys-
tem, and the enforcement of such disci-
pline as serves to make these devices
effective.
The Battle of the Qauges.
The origin of what is now called stand-
ard gauge of track, viz. : 4 ft. 8 1-2 ins.,
was not due to the adoption of any scien-
tific standard, nor had that width of road
been determined by any mathematical
process. The original width of ordinary
road wagons and the coal trams in the
north virtually determined the British
track gauge. It was adopted because its
use had already been established.
George Stephenson had all his life been
accustomed to this distance between the
rails of the colliery track where he
worked, and he introduced it on the
Liverpool and Manchester Railway when
acting as engineer for that line. He be-
lieved it to be "the most economical in
construction, not only as regarded the
engines and carriages, but more particu-
larly of the railway itself." In fact, in
the matter of railway gauge. Stephenson
showed himself to be a man of extraor-
dinary foresight. He believed in the
4-ft. 8 l-2-in. gauge as the desirable
standard, and fought for it all through
his life and educated his son Robert to
believe in it most firmly. On one occa-
sion when Stephenson the elder was
consulted as to the gauge of two rail-
ways, the Canterbury and Whitestable
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
171
line, and the Leicester and Svvaniiing-
ton Railway, he said, "Make them tlie
same width, though they may be a long
way apart now they will be joined to-
getlier some day."
History tells us that before the days
of the Stephcnsons and as early as 1776
cast iron flanRed rails very much like
what we call angle-irons, with the ver-
tical faces on the inside, were nailed to
wooden sleepers at the Duke of Nor-
folk's colliery, near Sheffield, in Eng-
land. John Curr designed this primative
track. In 1789 William Jessop built a
railway at Loughborough, Leicester-
shire. On Jessop's line the wheels were
flanged and the rails plain. In 1800 Mr.
Benjamin Outram, of Little Eaton, in
Derbyshire, used stone supports instead
of timber, for carrying the end of the
rails, and some writers have endeavored
to connect his name with the origin of the
word tram-way, or tram, which latter is
used to-day in Great Britain to designate
a street car. Benjamin Outram is prob-
ably more widely known to fame as being
the father of General Outram, who, with
Sir Henry Havelock, was concerned in
the relief of Lucknow during the Indian
Mutiny. In this connection it is inter-
esting to note that the Standard dic-
tionary gives as one of the meanings of
£he fword tram that it is used in Scotland
to indicate a bar or shaft, beam or tliill.
The handles of a plow were from very
early days called trams, north of Tweed,
and the man who held the handles and
walked between them as he guided the
plow was designated as the "in-tram-
man," while the man who walked along-
side driving the animal was naturally
enough the "out-tram-man." The word
out-tram shortened in time to outram,
eventually became a family name just as
Smith and Carpenter have, and the name
Outram was probably, by accident, borne
by the man who introduced stone sup-
ports under the raus instead of the tim-
ber previously used.
When Robert Stephenson beg.in to
take the place so long and honorably
held by his father in the growing rail-
way world of Great Britain, there were
many and fierce contentions as to the
best width to use between the rails.
Robert Stephenson's rival, Brunei, op-
posed what was then known as the nar-
row gauge, upholding most spiritedly the
advantages of the 7-foot track which he
had recommended to the directors of
the Great Western Railway. The
Stephensons, who were inventive, prac-
tical, sagacious and naturally conserva-
tive in the best sense, stood for the 4-ft.
8 l-2-in. gauge as a standard, and a
gauge which possessed the merit of
economy, but they were nevertheless
spurred to greater exertions in fighting
for the maintenance of existing practice
than they would have been without the
powerful opposition of the talented
Brunei. When the Eastern Counties
Railway was built Braithwaite, the en-
gineer of that line, adopted S feet as the
gauge of road, as he thought it best for
the purpose of giving space for the ma-
chinery of his locomotives. When the
northern and eastern extensions of his
line came to be built he adopted the
Stephenson gauge for the purpose of se-
curing uniformity where these lines con-
nected with the narrow gauge of the Mid-
land. Brunei, in championing the broad
gauge Great Western line, sought with
his ingenious, imaginative and daring
mind to secure the best railway which
could be built, while the Stephensons,
adopting a safer course, endeavored to
construct a line which would pay. As a
matter of fact, Brunei's line was not
satisfactory in a monetary point of
view to the shareholders, but as the his-
torian of these early days has pointed
out, Brunei's ambitious designs may
have caused individual loss, but they
nevertheless gave to mechanical inven
tion at the time a powerful stimulus
which resulted in great good to the na-
tion at large.
American and Foreign Locomotives.
For many years it has been a favorite
occupation with friends of foreign loco-
motive design to claim for those ma-
chines an economy in fuel consumption
over those of American build. What
there is in this contention must be left
unrefuted, since we are not in possession
of any records of competitive trials be-
tween the two products— such trials be-
ing the only way to satisfactorily de-
termine a matter of such weighty import.
There is this in these claims, however,
that vibrates harshly on the sensibilities
of the American designer, and that is,
that the foreign machines furnish a horse
power on a heating surface that would
be far too low for use in this country.
The reason why those engines are suc-
cessful with proportions that would fail
to give results here is covered by many
dissimilar factors in the respective con-
ditions, if true, but is it not possible that
the smoke-box arrangement is one vital
factor, since no foreign builder looks
with favor on our scheme of choking up
the front end with a mass of netting and
deflecting plate, and afterwards making
a weak attempt at reparation by reduc-
ing the nozzles enough to overcome the
obstructions so carefully planned. This
practice is ancient history here, but it
never obtained a foothold on the other
side of the Atlantic. It is a fact that the
foreign engineer regards our methods of
drafting locomotives as not entitled to
serious consideration.
Cylinder clearance in the American
engine may also come in for its share of
responsibility in this matter of fuel con-
sumption, our engines being notorious
for excessive clearance in the ports, this
amount being from 7 to 14 per cent, of
the piston displacement for slide valves
and piston valves respectively. This is
certainly a strange practice to perpetu-
ate, when its evil eflfect is so well under-
stood, but it is only just to say that one
late piston-valve design has shown a
radical improvement in this respect,
bringing the clearance down lower than
on the average slide valve. Foreign de-
signers look sharply to this ratio, for
they know as well as anybody that any-
thing that will reduce the water consump-
tion per horse power hour is conducive
to fuel economy. This popularity or fad
of the piston valve may have another
bearing on the fuel question which might
prove of advantage to us to investigate,
namely, the intensity of pressure of the
rings against the steam chest walls, by
which the internal friction of the engine
is increased, for there are few piston
valve rings that do not have a surface on
which the steam pressure cannot be
exerted to force the rings outwardly. All
claim the ideal frictionless piston valve,
but how many attain a realization even
approaching it?
In experiments to determine the con-
ductive efficiency of different metals for
water heating surfaces, according to
Hutton, in "Steam Boiler Construction,"
it is shown that copper has a conductive
value equal to practically twice that of
-Steel — the surfaces of each metal sup-
posed to be clean. This information
may be interesting as afiording a par-
tial solution of the superior capacity of
the foreign boiler, which almost invari-
ably has the copper firebox, and either
copper or brass flues. Steel fire-
boxes were tried and abandoned on
English roads several years ago on the
ground of lack of durability, but it is
probable the transmission of heat had
some bearing on the action taken. There
is yet one other factor to be considered
in the case— that of fuel— a point of
primary importance. It is well known
that the coal used in England has a
higher calorific value than our own
bituminous product. Seven pounds of
water per pound of our coal is rec-
ognized here as a good evaporation,
while the average is five pounds and un-
der. To find coal abroad as low as this
in evaporative value is an exception,
and when it is compared with English
coal, which has as high as 85 per cent.
of fixed carbon, one good reason why
those engines steam economically on a
small heating surface presents itself, al-
though railroads abroad are much like
our own in respect of avoiding high
priced fuel, but there is no doubt that
they use coal of a much higher quality
than is the case here. Results of work-
ing tests on different foreign roads have
shown an average evaporation of from 7.5
to 8.5 pounds of water per pound of ordi-
nary bituminous coal: it is possible that
while there is coal to be had high in car-
bon, that it is not in universal use, just
172
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
as it is understood that our best bitu-
rrtinous coal having 78 per cent, of fixed
carbon is rarely used in our locomotives;
but in any event, the average foreign
coal is no doubt superior to what is
known as good coal in this country.
Particulars of the actual every day per-
formance of some well known foreign en-
gines are given herewith for the purpose
of making clear the fact that their claim
of efficiency for small heating surfaces is
not without some foundation, when com-
pared with some of our machines with
liberal heating surfaces. The Great
Northern of England "single" is selected
as one of these for the reason that it
represents proportions that would not be
considered in this country, yet it has a
record for good work and is called eco-
nomical in fuel consumption. This en-
gine is one of the machines made popu-
lar by the late Patrick Stirling. They have
19 1-2 by 28-inch cylinders and one pair
of driving wheels 96 inches in diameter,
with an adhesive weight of 40,300 pounds
and a tractive effort of 14,600 pounds,
which shows a badly over-cylindered en-
gine. The total heating surface is only
1,032 square feet, and the grate area 20
square feet. With these proportions the
"single" takes 200 tons of train at speeds
of more than 50 miles an hour, which,
assuming a train resistance equal to that
on our roads — as train resistance is
shown by Aspinall in recent exhaustive
tests on an English road to be prac-
tically the same as ours, based on Well-
ington's formula of quarter velocity plus
two — requires an average tractive efifort
of 4,833 pounds, on a level, and this with
the above tonnage means the develop-
ment of 644 horse power. If a horse
power can be furnished on 23 pounds of
water per hour, an evaporation of 14.35
pounds of water per hour will be neces-
sary from each square foot of heating
surface, and a coal consumption of only
92 pounds will be required for each
each square foot of grate per hour. This
is a high evaporation per unit of heating
surface area, but the consumption of
coal is well within the limit.
The second engine is one of the Dun-
alastair class, on the Caledonian Rail-
way, an eight-wheeled engine having
I9x26-inch cylinders and four 78-inch
drives, with 80,000 pounds adhesive
weight. These engines, designed by Mr.
John F. Mcintosh, one of the eminent
motive power officers of Great Britain,
can exert a drawbar pull of 20,450 pounds,
which is seen to give a ratio of cylinder
power to adhesive weight more nearly in
line with what we know as correct prac-
tice, but still under what the best well de-
signed .American engine has for the same
service. The total heating surface is 1,600
square feet, while the grate surface is 23
square feet. A marked increase in boiler
power is found here over the Great
Northern engine, as would be expected
in a machine designed five years later, or
ill 1900, although it should be stated that
the Stirling engine does not represent
a truly modern machine, as little change
is seen in that type in the long years
since they were first brought out. This
Caledonian engine hauls 300 tons of
train over "banks" of no mean rise, at
the rate of 60 miles an hour. Measur-
ing the work done on the same basis
as for the "single" — that is, on an as-
sumed level, and with our resistance in
pounds per ton — we find an average
tractive effort put forth of 7.816 lbs.,
and a horse power of 1,250. At 23
lbs. of water per horse power hour
there is an evaporation demanded of
17.9 lbs. of water per square foot of
heating surface per hour, and 166 lbs.
of coal per square foot of grate per
hour. Here again is a boiler power
away outside of American results; and
while the figures appear high they would
be still higher if account was taken of
grade resistance.
The record recently made on the
Northern Railway of France by a De
Glchn four cylinder balanced compound
engine of our "Atlantic" type is of such
an exceptional character as to be en-
titled to mention in this connection.
This engine handles 175 tons of passen-
ger train cars at an average speed of
74.6 miles an hour, and that on grades
of over 0.5 per cent. The high pressure
cylinders are 13 3-4 inches diameter,
while the low pressure cylinders are
21 1-2 inches, with a stroke of 25 1-4
inches. The four drivers are 80 inches
diameter, and the total heating surface
is 2,275 square feet. Putting the resist-
ance again at our figures, this engine ex-
erts on the above grade a tractive ef-
fort of 9,558 lbs. and develops 1,900 horse
power. If it is assumed that these com-
pound cylinders can do this work on a
water rate 18 lbs. per horse power hour,
the boiler evaporates 15 lbs. of water
per square foot of heating surface per
hour and consumes not less than 145
lbs. of coal per sq. ft. of grate per hour.
These evaporative valves are remarkable
for a comparatively small boiler, and
serve to illustrate what is done with small
heating surfaces on the other side of the
ocean. How much of this result is
due to the valve gear is unknown here
at this time, as the valve motion of the
De Glehn engine is of a new design,
there being one for each set of cylin-
ders, which is equivalent to an indepen-
dent cut-oflf mechanism. In comparison
with the foregoing examples of foreign
engine performance, that recently made
on the Michigan Central stands as the
best record for tonnage and speed in
.America. This engine is also of the
"Atlantic" type, having a four wheeled
engine truck, four drivers and a two
wheeled trailing truck. The cylinders
are 21x26 inches, and drivers 79 inches
diameter, with an adhesive weight of
95,000 lbs., which may be increased to
107,000 lbs. by means of a traction in-
creasing device operated by air, where
necessary to utilize full cylinder power.
The total heating surface is 3.505 square
feet, and grate area is 50 square feet.
This engine hauled 605.57 tons of pas-
senger train cars on a road remarkable
for its lack of grades and curves, at an
average speed of 55.8 miles an hour,
covering a running time of two hours
and seven minutes. With the same re-
sistance as before, there was a tractive
force of 12,600 lbs. e.xerted to keep the
train up to speed, which equals 1,915
horse power. With a water consumption
of 26 lbs. per horse power hour, which
is average American practice for sim-
ple engines, there was 14.2 lbs. of
water evaporated per square foot of
heating surface per hour, and a coal con-
sumption of 142 lbs. per square foot
of grate, in which 7 lbs. of water is
taken as the evaporative value of one
pound of coal. This comparison is
made to illustrate how, when such an
immense horse power is developed, the
rate of combustion falls when the heat-
ing surface and grate area are designed
to give an unlimited reserve of boiler
power with coal of a low califoric value.
It also shows that the small foreign
boilers give a higher efficiency than is
known in the average American boiler,
for those under discussion all evapo-
rated more than 14 lbs. of water per
square foot of heating surface per hour;
that figure being understood to represent
about the limit of evaporation per square
fool in America. It would appear that the
favorable performance of the foreign ma-
chine could be traced to the boiler with
its restricted healing surface as well as
to cylinder efficiency, and it may be pos-
sibl^hat what we are pleased to term
heating surface in our multitude of long
flues is not what we give it credit for.
Purifying Feed Water.
The index of the proceedings of the
.American Railway Master Mechanics'
-Association, compiled two years ago,
has nearly four pages devoted to indi-
cating where there are reports, discus-
sions and papers relating to feed water.
The declared objects of the association
being "the advancement of knowledge
concerning the principles of construc-
tion, repair and service of the rolling
stock of railroads," the members very
soon found out that the investigation of
boiler feed water, was one of the most
important subjects that could engage
their attention, and they labored hard
at it for many years. It would be diffi-
cult to estimate the amount of good
that resulted from the knowledge re-
specting water impurities that the re-
ports, papers and discussions circulated.
That valuable educational work was per-
formed is undoubted, and it has now led
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LUCUMOTIVE ENGINEERIN'G
173
to the use of appliances and methods
that rob bad water of all its destruc-
tive power.
When the Master Mechanics' Asso-
ciation first began to investigate feed
water impurities for the purpose of dis-
covering remedies, hopeless darkness pre-
vailed intensified by a pall of ignorance
that no available light could break
through. A practice arose of sending
specimens of feed water to scientific in-
stitutions for the purpose of being
analyzed. This work was duly per-
formed and a report made of the quan-
tily and nature of the impurities, but
very little effort was made to apply a
remedy. Later on when people began
to apply chemicals that IkkI a softening
tendency, the same ingredients were
generally employed for the treatment of
all kinds of water, and of course failure
resulted. Where the chemicals hap-
pened to be of the proper kind to neu-
tralize the scale forming elements, the
treatment would be followed for a short
time, then neglect would intervene and
finally the good work would be aban-
doned akosether. That was for a long
time the history of attempts to purify
feed water for locomotive boilers.
Novelties such as zinc, potatoes and
mechanical purifiers that had their day
and even season of popularity, received
patronage, but they were soon aban-
doned.
There is always considerable leakage
that causes the operating expenses of
railroads to be higher than they ought
to be, and we think unnecessary ex-
penses incurred by the pernicious effects
of bad feed water are among the worst
to be found. There are now in opera-
tion some good methods of purifying
feed water that leave little to be im-
proved, but really the best method is
an efficient preventative rather than an
efficient cure. Some railroad companies
are compelled to wrestle with bad feed,
water, because nothing but bad is to be
found in the territories they 'traverse,
but there arc others that suf?er from bad
feed water because no care has been ex-
ercised in selecting the water stations.
The practice may be changing now, but
in the past the oiScials in charge of rail-
road construction have followed the prac-
tice of locating the water tanks a certain
distance apart without the least consid-
eration about the character of the water
obtained. In many cases by a little in-
vestigation and the exercise of good
judgment surface water or water from
soft streams could be obtained. Instead
of that a deep -well is dug through lime-
stone and magnesia rocks which supply
water that keeps the boilers loaded with
incrustations that prematurely destroy
the heating surfaces and wastes fuel. If
railroad managers would investigate how
bad water has come to be one of their
burdens they would have serious charges
standing against the construction en-
gineers.
The first railroad company to apply
proper remedies to bad feed water was
the Uhicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul.
They took hold of the business in a sys-
tematic and scientific manner. They
found out the characteristics of the water
at all the supply stations, had a compe-
tent chemist arrange the proper reagents
to remove the impurities, and employed
agents to see that the remedies were
ai)plied and the percipitated sediment
removed from the boilers.
Even with the clearly defined arrange-
ments made for treating the feed water
successfully, strong persistence had to be
exerted by the officials to prevent those
attending the water manipulation from
relaxing their efiforts. Mr. J. N. Barr,
superintendent of motive, speaking at
one of the M. M. conventions, on treat-
ing water, said: "We all agree that
this is an important matter, and we all
have the idea that certain materials can
be used in boilers to advantage with
bad water, while ten or fifteen years
ago we were all agreed that the thing
was no good. I am glad to see the
change. While all the methods recom-
mended are good, it will require con-
siderable discussion and calibrating to
prove which is the best, but none of
them are good unless followed out
properly, and if the necessary attention
is not given to cleaning the boilers."
"None of them are good unless fol-
lowed out properly" is a good text to
start the discussion of almost any sub-
ject connected with railroad operating.
Almost any kind of bad feed water can
be made suitable for boilers if the
.methods of treating it are properly fol-
lowed out. At a discussion heard at a
meeting of railroad men recently the
representatives of several railroads that
traverse lime rock 'regions asserted
that the purifying of their feed water
had almost entirely stopped the trouble
from leaky flues and fire-boxes. The
purifying had been done by companies
making a specialty of treating feed water,
and it evidently was well done. It is an
old story which tells that it pays railroad
companies to hire the work done that re-
quires specialists.
Petroleum Oil vs. Coal as Fuel.
The past year's series of accidents and
destructive wrecks on railroads through-
out this country has suggested a com-
parison of coal and crude petroleum oil
as fuel for locomotives. There seems *o
have grown up a feeling against crude
petroleum as a fuel for locomotives, and
it is believed by some persons that in
such accidents or wrecks petroleum fuel
may cause more serious results than
would coal.
An investigation of crude petroleum
as a fuel does not seem to prove this
to be true. In the far West, on the Pa-
cific slope, where, after careful experi-
ment and consideration, crude petro-
leum has been so generally adopted as
fuel for locomotives, accidents to lo-
comotives so equipped, have occurred,
yet it appears that the results, due
to conflagration taking place, are not
as serious as in other instances in the
East where terrible holocausts have oc-
curred from the igniting of the wreck-
age by the scattering of the hot coals in
the firebox of the locomotive.
With coal as a locomotive fuel there
ever exists the fact that on the train
there is an incandescent mass of fiercely
heated coals in the firebox, which, upon
being scattered, will set fire to the debris
of the wreck, burning everything, in-
cluding the unfortunate passengers or
persons imprisoned in the wreckage.
With crude petroleum as a locomotive
fuel the flames in the firebox may be in-
stantly extinguished and no bad results
will follow. This is particularly true if
the locomotive be equipped with an auto-
matic shutting-oflf device to stop the flo.v
of the crude petroleum at the dangerous
moment. In the absence of such an
automatic device, and should the oil
carrying tank be wrecked, the crude pe-
troleum may be scattered over the
wreckage. But this fact does not sug-
gest positive or immediate danger, as
does hot, burning coals, for crude petro-
leum itself is not an explosive nor a
highly inflammable liquid. If a quantity
of crude petroleum be poured upon a
blazing torch the petroleum will act the
same as water and extinguish the flame.
If a blazing torch be immersed in a vessel
of crude petroleum, the flame will likewise
be extinguished, the same as if the ves-
sel contained water. Of course, if crude
petroleum be scattered over a wreck-
age immediately following the moment
of collision impact, it remains there to
catch fire and hasten the conflagration.
In order to use crude petroleum as a
fuel it is necessary, as our readers know,
to vaporize it and combine it with other
gases supplied by steam or compressed
air to procure the highest efficiency.
Crude petroleum oil is an efficient fuel
when vaporized, but to vaporize it in the
open air is an exceedingly difficult, if not
impossible, operation to perform, it be-
ing possible only to vaporize, when in
such conditions as exist in, the firebox
when the engine is in operative condi-
tion.
The superior advantages of petroleum
fuel over coal fuel is that about 25 per
cent, more heat units can be extracted
from petroleum than from coal. There
are no sparks, no smoke, no clean-
ing of fires, no removal of ashes nor
loading of coal. These items are very
considerable in the maintenance and op-
eration of this end of the fuel account.
174
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
and it has been conservatively judged
that about 50 per cent, of the cost of the
fuel account will go to these items.
Again, the engine is always ready for
service, which is not the case if a coal
fire must be started before steam can
be gotten up.
With these enumerated advantages we
can add the fact that a petroleum fire in
a locomotive can be ignited almost in-
stantly, and such cannot be said of a
coal fire. This would seem to argue very
greatly in favor of crude petroleum oil
as a fuel over either bituminous or an-
thracite coal.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(19) A. M. I. writes:
(l) What is meant by "clearance,"
which I notice often mentioned in writ-
ings about locomotives and other en-
gines? A. — Clearance is a general term,
but in steam engine phraseology it re-
fers to the distance between the piston
and the cylinder heads. In calculations
concerning the efficiency of an engine,
clearance is considered to be thf space be-
tween the piston at the end of the stroke
and the valve covering the admission
port. That of course includes the por-
tion of the cylinder not filled with the
piston and the volume of the steam pas-
sage. (2) What is the difference, if any,
between cylinder back pressure and
cylinder compression? A. — Back pres-
sure is the pressure of air or steam re-
sisting the return of the piston from the
time the latter begins to return; com-
pression is the resistance caused by the
steam or air remaining in the cylinder
being squeezed into small volume after
the valve closes prior to the beginning
of a new stroke. A little study of any
good treatise on the steam engine indi-
cator (Hemenway, for instance) would
make this question clear.
(20) Rustic writes:
I do a jobbing machine business and
I find that the expense for files counts
up. I have heard something about a
method of sharpening files with acid.
Can you give me particulars? A. — Acid
sharpening of files is very unsatisfactory,
but it may help out in an emergency.
Clean the file thoroughly, then dip in .n
mixture eight parts water, three parts
sulphuric acid, and one part nitric acid.
After a few minutes wash the file, dry
and then oil.
(21) Apprentice asks:
Wliat is the difference between physics
and natural philosophy? A. — None.
They are the same thing. Natural phil-
osophy may be regarded as the old name
for the science which treats of the prop-
erties and laws of matter. The Greek
investigator Pythagoras was the first to
use the word "philosophy." From him
it was borrowed by Socrates, who called
himself a philosopher, or lover of wis-
dom, when other scholars of his day
called themselves "sophists," or wise
men.
(22) Fireman writes:
We hear so much said and written
about the saving that could be effected
by skilful firing that I and many others
would like to get an idea of how much
the locomotive fuel bills amount to in
the total expenses of railroad operating.
A. — About 15 per cent.
(23) A. J. W. writes:
Would you kindly answer the follow-
ing questions in your April number of
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing? What are the qualifications and re-
quirements of a young man who wishes
to apply for the position of "special ap-
prentice," which is in vogue on some of
the large railroads? Is it absolutely
necessary that the young man be a tech-
nical graduate? A. — Yes.
(24) F. B. H., Philadelphia, asks:
How does it come about that the ma-
terial used on a railroad to keep the
ties in place is called ballast. Is not
that a nautical terra? A. — Yes, it is,
and the word ballast came to be applied
to the broken stone or dry gravel which
is laid on the permanent way of rail-
roads from the practice of using the
gravel-ballast emptied by ships when
in the river Tyne. This "ballast" was
first used on the various tramways in the
vicinity of Newcastle, England.
(25) Subscriber, Dennistown. O , asks:
asks:
Why does an ^ engine pound harder
on the forward center than the back
one? A. — We do not think it pounds
appreciably harder on one center than
it does on the other. The only thing
which might make a difference is that
the area of the piston rod is taken out of
the area of the piston in one case and
not in another, but if this fact makes
any difference it might cause a slightly
harder pound on the forward center than
on the back center. If the pound clearly
appears to be as stated, some other de-
fect probably exists which may deaden
the noise of one knock and so make
them sound unequal.
(26) A. A. P., Minneapolis, asks:
Does the crosshead move in the
guides? I claim that the crosshead
moves and my friend claims it does not.
Which is right? A.— You are right. The
crosshead moves in the guides. Your
friend of course knows that the cross-
, head reaches first one end of the guides
and then the other, but we suspect he is
thinking of the relative motion of cross-
head with regard to the earth. Some
people think that on the back stroke
the crosshead remains over one particu-
lar spot of earth during the half-revolu-
tion of the wheel, and that it is the en-
gine which goes forward. The backward
movement of the crosshead is two feet,
and with a 5-foot wheel the engine,
carrying guides, crosshead. etc., has
moved forward more than 7H feet in the
same time.
(27) M. A. P. asks:
How do you calculate the horse pow-
er of a locomotive. A. — The formula
generally used is ^' ''^ = horse power.
Where P is the mean effective pres-
sure in pounds per square inch on the
piston during one stroke; L is the
length of the stroke in feet; A is the
area of the piston in inches, and N is
the number of strokes per minute.
This formula gives the horse power for
one cylinder, and multiplying by two
gives the horse power for a locomotive
which is really t\vo engines combined.
(28) T. W. A. asks:
What is the usual way of super-heat-
ing steam in a locomotive and what
good does it do, and what are the dis-
advantages, if any? A. — Superheaters
are generally made by placing in the
smoke box a coil of pipe through
which steam going to the steam-ches-s
must pass. While circulating through
this coil the steam is heated by the
waste gases, and is delivered to the cyl-
inders at a very high temperature. The
advantage claimed is that this very hot
steam gives greater range of expansion
in the cylinders with less loss due to
condensation. The pbjections are, of
course, first cost, cost of maintenance
and the difficiilty of properly lubricating
cylinders and valves constantly kept ;it
very high temperatures.
The stockholders of the London &
Northwestern Railway are reported to
be agitating for reform in the operating
department, and the first battle for re-
form was fought in the board room late-
ly. The directors naturally think that
their policy and management is as
nearly perfect as possible, and they suc-
cessfully opposed any change. We are
inclined to think that change will come
soon. We have repeatedly met a promi-
nent stockholder of the road, who has
been unalterably opposed to Mr. Webb's
management of the mechanical depart-
ment. That gentleman insists that the
compound locomotives will be changed
to simple engines as soon as Mr. Webb's
influence is removed.
Five mogid locomotives have just been
shipped by the Baldwin Locomotive
Works for use on the Hokkaido Govern-
ment Railway of Japan, two consoli-
dation engines for the Hokkaido Coal
Mining and Railway Company, and one
eighteen-wheel engine for the Sany. Rail-
road, Japan. Narrow gauge mogul loco-
motives have been ordered for shipment
to Honolulu and Cuba.
April, 1903.
KAILW.W AXIJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
175
Air= Brake Department.
The Air-Brake Convention.
Members attending the Tenth Annual
Convention of the Air-Brake Association
at Colorado Springs, April 28, should
know and follow these points:
1. Convention headquarters will be at
the Alamo Hotel.
2. Requests for transportation should
Pipe Tap
Loevntittivi Eni/inttrint/
be made to the master mechanic, super-
intendent or other immediate official.
Make request early.
3. Take receipts for fares paid in Pull-
man cars. These, accompanied by mem-
bership card for 1903, will entitle the
bearer to free return Pullman transpor-
tation, which will be issued by the com-
pany's agent at the convention headquar-
ters, Wednesday, April 29.
PipeSap^
FIG. 2.
4. The hour for topical discussion will
be strictly adhered to at this convention.
Members having a subject for discussion
must have it typewritten and in the sec-
retary's hands at the opening hour of
each day's convention. Any member
having a subject which he believes would
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NBI^ItlS.
be of interest to the convention may pre-
sent it under the head of topical subjects.
5. Convention will be called to order
in the convention hall of the hotel at
9 A. M. sharp, Tuesday, April 28.
Speed of Air Pumps.
A correspondent writes us, asking
whether the most economical speed of
the pump is at a slow or high speed. This
is a question which cannot be answered
unconditionally or unqualifiedly.
It was believed at one time that the
faster a pump was run the greater would
be the pressure accumulated. This is true
in point of time only, where the increase
in accumulation of pressure is. due to
the greater number of strokes; although
it is safe to say that the pressure ac-
Some New Retaining Valves.
The gradually changing conditions un-
der which the retaining valve is oper-
ated has led to the manufacture by the
Westinghouse Air-Brake Co. of two new
retaining valves; one being for service
on 12, 14 and 16-inch car cylinders, and
FIG. 3.
cumulated per stroke would be less with
the high speed than with the low speed,
-due to the fact that there would be a loss
of pressure in the former case on ac-
count of the greater heating of the air
and the inability of incoming pressure to
the cylinder to keep up to atmospheric
pressure.
There was a series of tests made by
the Air-Brake Association at one time
for the purpose of determining which
was the most economical speed to run a
pump. These tests proved that at very
high speeds the pump would heat ab-
normally and the incoming pressure
reached considerably below the atmos-
pheric line long before the piston
had reached the end of its stroke. It
seems, therefore, that no hard and fast
rule can be laid down for the speed of a
pump; but it is safe to say that less sat-
isfactory work will be obtained from a
pump run at top speed than one run at
about so or 60 double strokes per min-
ute, a double stroke being one up and
one down.
the other, a special driver brake retain-
ing valve, for use on driver brake cyl-
inders exclusively. In addition to these
two new valves the manufacturers are
prepared to supply the old standard pres-
sure retaining valve, which is now rec-
ommended for use with 6, 8 and lo-inch
car cylinders only, and the new valve
for 12, 14 and 16-inch car cylinders, with
an extended socket piece and handle, so
designed that the valve itself can be
FIG. 5.
located outside the car hood on vesti-
buled cars and operated from within.
By this arrangement the noise of the
escaping air is avoided without aflfecting
the accessibility of the valve.
Fig. I is the old standard valve for
use on freight cars and on passenger
cars, having 6, 8 or lo-inch cylinders.
176
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
Fig. 2 illustrates a valve which has
larger ports and a one-half-inch pipe,
Arrauffeittent with
separate Reservoir
Altogether there are five different re-
taining valves manufactured by the W. A.
A.rrangeitient with
J^illar Keservoir
supportinff the I'alve
portion of the triple performing this
function. The bleeder, instead of being
in the bottom of the auxiliary, as in
.^merica, is located neatly and out of
liarm's way in the end portion of the
reservoir.
Fig. S is a sectional view of the en-
gineer's brake valve, with the rotary valve
portion and the equalizing piston part
designed side by side, instead of the
former above the latter, as is the prac-
tice here.
All of the parts carry the English neat-
ness of design with them. However,
from our viewpoint, there are some old
ideas which might be dropped and new
ones taken up. For example: the three-
way cock in the quick-action triple was
abandoned in America fifteen years ago;
and our English friends do not seem to
have yet caught up with the slide-valve
feed valve attachment for brake valves.
and is for use on 12, 14 and 16-inch car
cylinders.
Fig. 3 is the same valve shown in Fig.
I, modified only in respect to the exten-
sion handle and socket piece, as above
explained.
Fig. 4 is the same valve illustrated in
Fig. 2, differing only by having the ex-
tension handle and socket piece for ves-
tibule location.
Fig. 5 represents a pressure-retaining
valve cspeciilly designed for use on an
engine in connection with the driver
brake. The operating handle of this
valve has three instead of two positions.
As in the older form, one position allows
a free exhaust when brakes are released,
while another retains 15 pounds pressure
in the brake cylinder and causes the air
that escapes after lifting the weighted
valve to pass through a restricted port.
The third, or lap position — the handle
being at right angles to the valve stem
— confines all the air in the brake cyl-
inders and enables the engineer to re-
lease all the brakes in a train of any
length, and at any speed, without un-
pleasant surging or danger of parting.
B. Co., each weighted valve being de-
signed to retain 15 pounds m the brake
cylinder.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Excess Pressure and Main Reservoir
Capacity.
The question of releasing the brake
on long freight trains at low speed, with-
out shock which will cause damage to
tlie draft-gear, is becoming very impor-
tant. The shock is due, principally, as
is well known, to the difference in the
time of release . of the brakes, that is,
could all the brakes be released at the
same instant, no shock of any conse-
quence would occur. Should the slack
of the train be stretched out when an
application is made, the same as it is
when the locomotive is drawing a train,
then the difference in the time of re-
1
Some English Air=Brake Designs.
It is always interesting to note how
somebody else does the same things we
do ourselves, especially when their ways
are quite different from ours. The ac-
companying drawings show how the
English Westinghouse Air-Brake Co. in
London assemble the parts of their sev-
eral devices.
Figs. I and 2 are views of the different
arrangement of the equalizing reservoirs
for the brake valve.
Fig. 3 shows a cut of their quick-action
triple valve, which is essentially the same
as our American design, with the excep-
tion of the three-way cock in the lower
part of the triple and whose positions
are. quick action, automatic, plain auto-
matic and cut out.
Fig. 4 shows this triple valve in place
on a freight auxiliary. As will be noted,
there is no cut-out cock in the crossover
pipe, the three-way cock in the lower
FIG. 3.
lease would not cause a shock. The
slack, however, when an application
is made, generally bunches toward the
engine, the same as it is when the en-
gine is backing the train; then, with
brakes releasing earlier on the head end'
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOI'IVE ENGINEERING
177
than on the rear, the slack is due to the
reaction of the draw bar springs, which
were compressed more or less, due to
the slack bunching, runs out quickly un-
assumc the cord is just strong enough
to stand the shock and permit the larger
weight to pull the smaller one along
with it. Now increase the larger weight
Frotn
Main Jtcsm'oir
To Srake i'lpe
til it is suddenly arrested by those cars
at the rear on which the brakes have not
released, resulting in a shock .of more
or less severity, and, when the draft gear
is not sufficiently strong to withstand
it, the train is parted. When the break
occurs near the middle, or further back,
the application of the brakes on the
head portion, due to the hose couplings
separating, generally results in the head
portion being broken in two at one or
two other places, so that when the train
is finally stopped, it will be separated
into three or four different parts.
The severity of the first shock depends
largely on the make-up of the train; the
weight of the engine in particular. The
greater the weight of the engine, the
greater the shock. The amount of com-
pression of the draw bar springs, at the
time of release, affects the shock; also
the retarding power of the rear brakes.
An illustration of this may be had by
attaching one end of a cord about three
feet long to a two-pound weight, and the
other end to, say, a half-pound weight.
The first to represent the weight of the
engine, and the second the retarding ef-
fect of the brakes on the rear which
have not released. Place them on a
table with the leaf up. the one half-
pound weight on the main part, and the
other on the leaf, so that there is about
a foot of slack cord, and in such a posi-
tion that the large weight can be moved
to take up all the slack without being
moved off the leaf. Then tip the leaf
just enough to cause the large weight
to slide toward the floor. Now we will
to four pounds, and repeat the experi-
ment, and you will find that the cord will
be broken. Repeat the experiment again,
and this time use the same large weight,
as was used in the first experiment when
the cord was not broken, and increase
power, and speed), and the strength of
the draft gear.
The release of brakes is accom-
plished by quickly increasing the train
line prcs.iurc, above that of the auxiliary
reservoir, and air stored in the main
reservoir, or reservoirs, is depended on
to accomplish this. In order for any
of this air to reach the rear car it must
pass through about 2,000 feet of pipe on
a so-car freight train. The frictional re-
sistance which it meets with retards its
flow, resulting in the head brakes re-
leasing earlier than the rear ones.
Tests made by the Westinghouse Air
Brake Company with a SO-car train,
brakes applied by a lo-pound reduction
from 70 pounds, showed that with a main
reservoir capacity of 50,000 cubic inches,
charged to 100 pounds pressure,. the train
line pressure was raised from 60 to 62
pounds, on the fiftieth car in 9.9 seconds
from the time the handle of the brake
valve was placed in full release position,
and at this time the train line pressure
on the head car was 74 pounds. With
main reservoir capacity of 20,000 cubic
inches charged to 125 pounds pressure,
the train line pressure was raised from 60
to 62 pounds on the fiftieth car in 9.5
seconds, and at this time was 76 pounds
on the head car. The main reservoir
pressure in both of these tests was re-
duced to 86 pounds in the time given.
It appears from these tests that large
main reservoir capacity is not of so much
value in releasing brakes as high excess
pressure in reservoirs of small capacity.
On engines with a main reservoir ca-
the small weight to one pound, and you
will find that the cord will now be
broken. The first experiment would
have resulted in the cord being broken
had it not been quite so strong. There-
fore, the result of brakes not releasing
as early on the rear end as on the head
end, depends on the bunching of the
slack, weight of the head end, retard-
ing effect of the rear brakes (wdiich is
determined by the application, braking
pacity of 20,000 cubic inches, and carry-
ing 100 pounds pressure, better results in
releasing the brakes will be obtained by
increasing the main reservoir pressure
25 per cent, than by increasing their ca-
pacity 150 per cent. This, considering
the room available on many engines for
main reservoirs of greater capacity, is
important. There are other reasons,
however, which makes it advisable to
have large main reservoir capacity, at
178
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
least 50,000 cubic inches on freight en-
gines. E. G. Desoe,
General A. B. Inspector B. & A. R. R.
Springfield, Mass.
Retaining and Recharging Device.
An air-brake device has recently been
patented by N. J. Benton, a machinist in
the L. & N, shops at Birmingham, Ala.,
and W. P. Thomas, a locomotive en-
gineer, of Louisville, Ky. This device
has been tested by one of the largest
railroad companies and it is believed will
be adopted by them, as it fills a long-
felt want for trains on hills and switch
engines. In the former case, the en-
gineer can retain his brakes on the train
while recharging the auxiliary reser-
voirs, independent of the assistance of
trainmen. In the latter case, a switch
engineer can apply and release quicker
and, unless pipes are broken off, or the
leather is not entirely gone, you will get
sufficient power to make a short stop.
In the accompanying drawing you can
see all the new features that are neces-
sary for the aforesaid results.
Figs. -2 and 4 in the drawing show
positions of the cut-out cock for apply-
ing and releasing brakes, and is placed
in the pipe running from the engineer's
valve to the triple on the engine.
Fig. 5 shows the new automatic re-
tainer used in connection with the ap-
paratus, and it screws into the triple-
valve exhaust port, so when the handle
of the cut-out cock is turned in posi-
tion shown in Fig. 2, the air would be
admitted to tlie retainer, closing up the
triple exhaust, raising check valve /
(Fig. 6) off its seat, admitting air direct
to brake cylinder.
When the handle is turned to the
leasing right at the brake cylinder, by the
aid of the new retainer and check valve,
assuring a quicker release and a more
positive brake application.
W. P. Thomas,
Loco. Eng'r, L. & N. Ry.
Louisville, Ky.
OlESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On Air-Brake Subjects.
(26) B. R. 0., New York city, asks:
Which is" the best kind of a driver
brake, one which has a horizontal pull
or one which pulls straight up and
down? A. — A push brake is better than
a pull, as the stuffing box is done away
with. The brake which pushes down in
a perpendicular direction is much prefer-
able to the horizontal type, for the rea-
son that the wear of the packing leather
Fitj. a
Fig. 4
Railuiny J Locomotive Enffincering
RETAINING AND RECHARGINC, DEVICE.
than he can with the present automatic
system; but this is only to be used when
in a hurry or when the automatic system
is inoperative either from corrosion or
leaks.
The brakes can be operated, if desired,
by either the automatic or this straight
air feature, independent of each other, or
both can be worked at the same time.
If the automatic brakes fail to work,
the straight air feature can be operated,
position shown in Fig 3, it is on lap,
and, as shown in Fig. 4, it will allow the
pressure in the pipe to escape, which
relieves the retainer, causing an auto-
matic action of same and allowing the
brakes to release.
For switch engines, the device, as
shown in Fig. 7, can be used without
the aid of the triple, auxiliaries and
brake valves, thus' receiving a pressure
direct from the main reservoirs, and re-
is even on all sides, and does not bear on
the bottom merely and wears out that
portion of the leather, as does the hor-
izontal type.
(27) B. G. E., Denver, Col., asks:
Is there only one automatic reducing
valve for the high-speed brake, and is it
used for the 10, 12, 14 and 16-inch brake
cylinders? A. — There is but one type
of automatic reducing valve for the high-
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
«79
speed brake, but it is made in three dif-
ferent sizes to accommodate respectively
the 8-inch cylinder, the 10 and la-inch
cylinders, and the 14 and 16-inch cylin-
ders. This is made necessary by the
great difiference in the capacities of the
largest and smallest cylinders, and per-
mits of a more uniform reduction of
high-speed cylinder pressure to the nor-
mal or ordinary cylinder pressure.
(28) B. R. E., Galesburg, 111., asks:
Why shouldn't a quick action triple
valve be used on tenders? Is it not the
practice of some roads to put quick ac-
tion triples on tenders i is it to give
higher brake power that some roads use
the quick action triple on tenders? A. —
The only objection to quick actio triples
on tenders is the tendency of hostlers to
unduly use the emergency in "spotting"
an engine on the turntable, etc. Some
Toads have been using quick action
triples on tenders for some time. All
tenders equipped with the high speed
brake should have quick action triple
valves, as this gives them the highest
possible brake power in emergency. The
Westinghouse Company has now adopted
the quick action triple valve for all pass-
enger engine tenders, whether they have
the high speed brake or not.
(29) F. J. K., Winona, Minn., writes:
If, in making a stop with a heavy
freight train, the drivers should begin
to slide, and you did not dare to release
the brake for fear of breakmg the train
in two, what would you do? Would it
be advisable to open the engine throttle
and get your wheels revolving? A. — It
would be better to accept a chance of
breaking your train in two than a sure
thing of sliding flat spots in your drivers.
If your driver brake was "holding well
enough to slide the drivers, it would also
hold so tight and hold the drivers locked
that opening the throttle would not jerk
them loose and start them rolling again.
The better thing to do would be to pre-
vent the trouble by having the proper
braking power on the drivers so they
would not slide.
(30) J. L. M., Sioux City, la., writes:
Has anybody ever tried to make the
air-brake signal work on the train pipe
of the air-brake? If so, what has been
their success? What objections are
there to such an arrangement? A. — The
principal objection to such a scheme is
that it would be impossible to get a
signal to the engineer while he is apply-
ing or releasing brakes. This is a seri-
ous fault. Mr. Westinghouse patented
such a device nearly thirty years ago.
(31) T. G. K., Spencer, N. C, asks:
What is the best mode of grinding
triple valve slide valves and what best
and most convenient tool for boring out
the triple bushings? A. — The best
method of grinding the triple valve .^lide
valve is to face it to its seat, either by
machine or hand scraper, leaving as little
grinding to do as possibte. Some good
grinding material, such as ground glass
or Trojan compound, should be used,
which will not stick in the brass after the
job is finished. Modern long train ser-
vice has demonstrated that it is impos-
sible for the railroad shop repairman to
properly fit a triple piston packing ring ,
into its bush in a triple valve, because
of lack of necessary facilities. There-
fore, this delicate, refined work is sent to
the manufacturer by railroads nowadays,
as the manufacturer is equipped with
special machinery for doing this kind of
work. Modern long train service makes
this practice wise and advisable.
(32) W. T. G., Dayton, C, asks:
Will a pj^-inch pump make more air
per stroke running at loo strokes a min-
ute, 150 strokes a minute or 200 strokes
a minute? By stroke I mean a single
stroke, cither up or down, of the piston,
one up and one down being counted as
two strokes. A. — This would largely de-
pend upon the size and lift of both re-
ceiving and discharge valves, the condi-
tion of the packing rings in the piston
and the accuracy of the bore of the cyl-
inder. The ideal conditions for any
number of strokes per minute would be
perfectly tight piston packing rings, ac-
curately bored cylinder, receiving valves
of suflicient size and lift to give full at-
mospheric pressure in the cylinder dur-
ing the whole stroke of the piston and
the discharge valve of sufficient size and
lift to allow the piston to thoroughly
push the pressure out of the air cylinder
into the main reservoir. These con-
ditions could be so made and manip-
ulated in one pump to favor a slower
stroke, while by another condition of the
parts the reverse could be made to be
true. However, the results at a series
of tests held by a committee appointed
by the Air Brake Association proved
that an air pump driven at top speed
would pump less air than one run about
120 single strokes per minute.
(33) J. B. O'D., Freeland, Pa.,
writes:
I am interested in retaining valves and
would like to know if the following de-
vice would be any value in the railroad
world. The device gives the engineer
full control of the retainers after the
train crew turns them up. He can re-
lease part or all of the air from the re-
tainer pipe, holding on as many of them
as will hold the weight of the engine
and prevent the train from parting. A
30-pound retaining valve can be used
with this device on account of having
full control of the retainers at all times.
It is simple and inexpensive, and is op-
erated with the train line pipe and en-
gineer's brake valve. It doesn't inter-
fere with the working of the triple valve.
A. — It might be interesting. Send us
a sketch and description and we will see.
Usually, such devices haven't much
money value.
(34) G. E. C, Moncton, N. B.,
Canada, writes:
A 9-car passenger train broke the
train pipe on the baggage car nc."<t to
engine. The crew coupled the train pipe
on engine to signal pipe on this car, and
used it as a train pipe to connect to the
rest of the train. At the next point where
engines were changed, the car inspectoi
had the baggage car placed on the rear
end of train. This action is condemned
by some. Will you please give your
opinion as to the propriety of the use
of signal line under such circumstances?
A. — Both the practices indulged in with
this train were in accordance with good
practice. In the first place, when the
train pipe' on the first car was discov-
ered to be defective, the train line of the
lender was quickly coupled fby means of
a special coupling, no doubt.) to the
signal line on the iront end of the first
car. The signal line at the rear end of
the car was coupled again to the train
line of the second car. This got around
the difficulty with the least possible de-
lay. In the second place, when a ter-
minal was reached where time was foijnd
to shift the defective car to the rear end,
it was done so by the inspector, who
doubtless coupled up the air brake hose
on the car ahead to this defective car,
keeping the angle cock closed on the
forward end of the last, defective car.
This also was good practice, for it per-
mitted of quick action application of the
brakes through the entire train, which
could not have been had if the signal
line had been used on the car next the
engine. It also brought safety to the
rear car in case it should brake off, by
the coupling up of the air brake hose,
whose separation would set the brakes
on the entire train if the rear car broke
off.
(35) A. M. L., New York city,
writes:
We have the Westinghouse Air-Brake
on the Manhattan elevated. When I put
the handle of the brake valve to the
first notch in service position with a six-
car train, the brakes won't act, and 1
have to go past that notch to get the
brakes on. But with one-car train, if
I put the handle to the first service notch
I get quick action. What is the matter?
A.— Disregard the notch. Don't go quite
so far as to apply brakes on single-car
train, and go further with six cars.
We regret, exceedingly, our failure to
issue the first of the color charts of the
Desoe series in our last number, as in-
tended; but accuracy of detail must be
considered ahead of all features, and this
month will see the belated chart in per-
fect condition.
i8o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1503.
Ascent of Hount Lowe.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
Pasadena, Cal., March 11.
There is a curious fascination in moun-
tain climbing to some people, and I must
confess myself a little touched with the
mountain climbing fever. I seldom look
upon a hill or mountain aspiring away
above the surrounding country without
more tireless than human muscle pro-
vides the elevating power. I have done
some mountain ascents in Switzerland
and other places, in railway cars, and
they suited my taste, which leans rather
toward- comfort than toward physical
triumphs. When I heard that the Mount
Lowe Railway, one of the most cele-
brated scenic mountain railways in the
FIRST SECTION OF CLIMB.
wishing to reach the top. In my callow
years that tendency frequently led to
long, exhausting climbs that left the tor
ture of strained muscles for days after-
wards and paid by pain for the pleasure
enjoyed.
Age has not cured the mountain climb-
ing aspirations, but now-a-days I like to
make the ascents in a comfortable car or
at least on something where a medium
world, was within easy reach of Pasa-
dena, where I was staying, no time was
lost in making the ascent.
Mount Lowe belongs to the Sierra
Madre range of mountains, which with
a lesser range to the south, form the
barriers of the San Gabriel Valley. They
speak of other valleys within the natural
borders named, but it is really one great
valley, in which are found the finest fruit-
raising orchards of California. The
Santa Fe Railway traverses the valley
and forms the chief means of communi-
cation with the outside world.
Pasadena is in the Southern part of
this valley, about ten miles from Los
Angeles. It is situated on a sloping
plateau about 800 feet above Los Angeles,
and is a town of about 10,000 inhabi-
tants, it is the prettiest place I have
ever seen. Handsome houses, with all
the attractive surroundings that tropical
trees, profusion of flowers and beauti-
fully kept lawns can supply. The streets
are finely maintained, cultivated taste
dominates the whole town, and all signs
of filth, penury or sloth's defilement are
absent. It is a dwelling town of wealth
of the kind that carries with it refine-
ment and cultivated taste.
Viewed from the hotel, the Sierra
Madre Mountains appears to be about
a mile away. Such is the deception of
this transparent atmosphere, that on
boarding the street car we find that a
journey of about five miles must be ac-
complished before we reach the base of
the mountain where the first stage of the
scenic railway begins. Speaking of
mountains Campbell says:
"Distance lends enchantment to the vieiv
And bathes the mountains in an azure hue."
That description does not apply well
to the Sierra Madre Mountains. At a
distance their rugged outlines are round-
ed olY, but the visitor must be amidst the
rugged defiles and profound charms, to
witness the rich variety of color and the
softened aspect imparted by the profuse
vegetable undergrowth and the towering
pines and larches and live oaks that
stand up like mere stately bushes in the
deep recesses of the Canons.
Thel'first section of the ascent is by a
substantially built double track cable
road. The starting point is called Rubio
Pavilion, from whence the road rises on
a grade of about 60 per cent, average to
Echo Mountain, a vertical distance of
1,325 feet. That is an uneventful trip,
little more exciting than going up a sky-
scraper elevator, but it introduces the
tourist to a trip which strains the nerves
of all but veteran mountain climbers.
The ascent which follows is made by
a single-track trolley railway which is
five miles long and has an average grade
of 7 1-2 per cent. The route is round a
succession of jutting crags, everywhere
hugging, yawning precipices and span-
ning chasms that are thousands of feet
deep. But the imposing grandeur of tlu-
scenes is sublime. The beautiful valley
below looks like a checker board of what
we know to be the richest orchards in
the world, and away beyond another
range of hills shine the 'blue w-aters of
the Pacific Ocean. We witness scenes
so impressive that they will always cling
to the memory, but the engineer who
understands the possible defects of car
April, 1903.
KAII.WAV AN'IJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
181
building material would rather view the
scenes from a car that had something;
more reliable than friction brakes to Ivild
it in descending a 7 1-2 per cent, grade
on a 4 ft. gauge.
On getting to the end of the track I
discovered that the railway stopped 1,100
vertical feet short of the summit. As I
had started to go to the top of Mount
Lowe, and go there I must, if the re-
mainder should be walked. An easier
means was at hand, and the party fin-
ished the trip on steeds.
I have spoken of the quick transilion
from winter to summer in making a trip
by rail from New York to Florida. The
ascent of Mount Lowe brought a much
quicker change of temperature. In about
three hours we went from the region of
yellow oranges, peach blossoms and
blooming flowers to a region of arctic
snow and ice.
Going around a succession of sharp
curves, on a car with yawning chasms
beneath the track, is not a comtort-in-
spiring ordeal, but it is nothing to round-
ing similar precipices on the back of a
pony following a path no wider than tlie
animal's body. It was bad enough when
the path was solid mud, but when il
came to be covered with six or eight
inches of snow, ice and slush, on which
the animal's feet slipped every few step^^.
the reflection came that a little pleasure
was purchased at a high price.
We had one hero in the party whose
name was "Dewey." He had long ears
and a shaggy grey coat, but he had sa-
gacity, grit, perseverance and courage.
Dewey regulated the pace of the caval-
cade, and no difficulty or danger dis-
turbed his equanimity. When the spirit
moved him Dewey stopped and fell into
profound reflection, mixed with slumber.
When he elected to move he moved, but
not before, and then we all felt satisfied
that he had seen his way to get there
without accident. Thanks to his care
and to good luck we got to the summit,
surveyed the world as from a higher
Mount Pisgah and got down to the com-
mon level to tell the tale.
seen a theory advanced as to why an
engine slips readily backing up. I
know that my solution will bear me
out where the ratio of power to ad-
hesion is nearly i to 4. As an illustra-
tion, let us take an engine with cylinders
17 in. by 24 in.; diameter of driver 57 in.,
weight on drivers 60,000 pounds, boiler
take about S-OOO pounds from the engine
truck and transfer it to the drivers, as
the action from the cross-head to the
driver exerted through the main rod is
downward toward the rail, so that we
now have 65,000 pounds on the drivers
in motion, while we only have the normal
weight when they are at rest. Backing
Why an Engine Slips in Backing Up.
BV J. A. B.
Tractive force we know is the power
which the pistons of a locomotive are
capable of exerting through the driving
wheels to move engine and train. To
prevent slipping of the 'driving wheels
the adhesion must be sufficient to over-
come this, which necessitates a weight
to rest upon them equal to or more than
four times the power exerted upon the
pistons, and where the engines are in-
tended for heavy freight service this
weight is increasetl to 5 or 6 times the
power of the pistons. Most of us have
seen or run slippery engines, particularly
in backing up. but I have never before
WINDINGS OF THE TRACK.
pressure 155 lbs., and mean pressure
about 130 pounds.
This class of engine will give us a trac-
tive force of 16,000 pounds. Allowing 10
per cent, for friction brings it down to
14.400. With the weight mentioned
above on her drivers and 10,000 pounds
on the engine truck, we know that when
she is running forward the power trans-
mitted from the piston to the cross-head
is against the upper guide bars, with the
result (from rough calculations) thit we
up we reverse the conditions. The cros'-
head now throws the strain on the bot-
tom bars, which gives a downward pres-
sure to the truck, an equal amount of up-
ward pressure to the driving wheels aTid
a tendency to raise the drivers from the
rails. In this case we have reduced our
weight on drivers to 55.000 pounds, but
added 5.000 pounds more pressure on the
rail at the truck.
Taking the power exerted upon the
pistons in this case and allowing 10 per
IS2
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
cent, for friction, we have, as stated be-
fore, an efTective pressure of 14,40°
pounds exerted by them as available
tractive force. Four times that force, or
S7,6oo pounds, is the amount necessary
for weight on drivers, but with the en-
gine backing up and 55.000 pounds on tlie
drivers, we are short 2,600 pounds, and
just that much nearer to the slipping
point. Of course this 10 per cent, al-
lowed for friction I have based upon
favorable conditions, and cannot be he'd
accountable for variable conditions of
friction due to want of lubrication. That
is up to the company that wants a big
oil record. They may get the oil record,
but the question of friction or the rev-
enue the engine earns to compensate for
this record is an unknown quantity. In-
creased friction reduces earning power.
Heroes of Imagination.'* ]
The fairy tales on which many repu-
tations rest seem to be vanishing into
thin air in these matter of fact days. We
have been made melancholy by the ser-
mon of. a preacher on last Washington's
birthday, who alleged that the cherry
tree and hatchet story was a myth gotten
up by the first biographer of tlie Father
of his Country, who was a preacher and
considered poetic license fair in working
up the actions of a hero.
The scoffer and the cynic would have
point taken from their stings , if the
statements of other gushy-gushy' biog-
raphers were repudiated by all sane writ-
ers. But we still find that the stale
silliness of Samuel Smiles gravely tells
tliat James Watt had his attention di-
A CAREFUL MOUNTAIN CLIMBER.
rected to the potential power of steam
by seeing the lid of his mothePs tea-
kettle vibrating from the action of the
boiling water. That was a pretty story,
but other men made the preliminary dis-
coveries about the force of steam which
prepared the way for Watt's work on the
steam engine.
All through the history of important
discoveries we find men accorded ro-
mantic triumphs which rightly belonged
to others, and the injustices are made
popular by hero worshippers who have
learned the art of scribbling without fair-
ness or judgment.
Color Ignorance Not Necessarily Color
Blindness.
A good many men can very readily
distinguish between various colors or
even between tones of color who could
not correctly name the shade selected.
Ignorance of the name of a color should
not be confounded with color blindness,
which latter is the inability to tell red
from green or yellow from purple or any
definite color from any other. Color
ignorance may be removed by proper
instruction, but color blindness is a de-
fect of the eye. We knew of a man who
was taken to task by his wife for some
outrageous description of the ribbons
in her hat. He was shaky about when the
word "mauve" should be used, or when
a delicate "ecru" would correctly de-
scribe a shade worn, but he could never-
theless pick out all the colors of the rain-
bow with unerring accuracy.
A LONG CLIMB.
Tourist: When does the next train
start for Cork, porter?
Irish Porter: She's just gone, sorr. —
Judge.
April, 190J.
irMi.vvAY AMI) F.ocoMoTivi': I'.xf.i xi-;i-:ri \<,
183
Compound Oil-Burner for the
Southern I'atiflc.
A very interesting example of an oil-
burning compound consolidation engine
is here presented. It has been turned
out by the Baldwin Locomotive Works
tor the Southern Pacific. The cylinders
are 17 and 28x30 in., the high pressure
being underneath. The driving wheels
are 57 in. diameter, and all are flanged.
The two leading wheels arc equalized
with the front truck, and the two rear
drivers are eiiualiezd by themselves.
The boiler is of the straight top va-
riety and radial stayed. It is 76 in. in
diameter at the smoke-box end. The
heating surface is in all about 3,604
sq. ft., of which 3,390 sq. ft. are in the
tubes. There are 442 tubes, and the
grate area is S4'A sq. ft. The weight of
engine and tender is 210,130 pounds,
and 185,240 pounds rest on tlie drivers.
The striking feature about this ma-
chine is the tender, which is semi-
circular in sections and contains 3,300
gallons of fuel oil and 7,300 gallons of
water. The tender has a running board
The fjli/.abcthport Shops of the Cen-
tral Railroad of New Jersey.
The .shops of the Central Railroad of
New Jersey, situated at Jilizabethport,
N. J., are good examples of modern de-
sign and equipment. The main shop is
a building of red brick standing on a
concrete foundation. It is 700 feet long
by about 150 feet wide, and contains the
erecting shop, machine shop, boiler and
tank shops. One of the features which
strikes a visitor on entering is the design
of the building with reference to securing
the greatest amount of daylight. The
erecting shop is about 80 feet wide and is
about 45 feet high. The south wall is well
lighted with windows, and the roof is,
in the centre, covered with what is called
translucent fabric. This material is ap-
plied somewhat as panes of glass would
be applied, and it allows diffused light to
enter while it prevents the direct glare
of the sun from getting in. What would
be the north wall of this building is rep-
resented by a line of steel columns, and
to them are attached the beams of a
flat-roofed lean-to. The vertical wall
and the other is a lo-ton crane. At the
west end ot this lean-to the wheel and
axle work is done; further down the
frame and cylinder work is handled. The
foreman's office occupies as nearly as
possible a central position, and east of it
the eccentric straps, rocker boxes, tum-
bling shafts, etc., are fitted up, and
further on is the general repair depart-
ment.
In the second or outer lean-to lighter
work is done, for which the services of
overhead travelers and runways are suffi-
cient. In this building are contained the
valves, pistons, guides, etc., department,
driving boxes; links and rods; the tool
room, the air brake department, the pipe
fitting department and the machinery
for doing stock work. The copper
shop and flue departments are also here.
The machine shop tools are operated by
both individual and group drive accord-
ing to the character of the work re-
quired.
The lower or east end of the main
shop and both lean-tos form the boiler
and tank shops, with riveting plant
SOUTHERN r.\CIFIC COMPOUND Oil, BURNER.
and hand rail the full length, with ladder
and steps at the back. The tank is car-
ried on a steel channel frame. The ten-
der is longer than usual, being in the
neighborhood of 24 ft., which is no doubt
the result of the special design which the
Southern Pacific have adopted.
Some of the principal dimensions are
subjoined:
Cylinder, 17 in. and 2S x 30 in.
Valve, balanced piston.
Boiler, thickness of sheets, ^. % and §§; working
pressnre, 200 lbs.; fnel, oil: staying, radial.
Firebox, lenpth. loS in.; width, 72U in.; front, 75^4
in.; back, 66Vi in.; thickness of sheets, sides.
5Mn.; back. Hin.; crown, ^1^ in.; tube. Vs in.;
water space, front, 4 in. to 4^ in.; sides, 3^ in.
to 6 in.; back, 3H in. t0 4'i in.
Tubes, nviniber, 442; diameter, 2 in.; length, 14 ft,
q^g in.; heating surface, firetiox, 182.2 sq ft.;
tubes. 3,390.7 sq. ft.: firebrick tubes, 30.9 sq. ft.;
total, 3,603.8 sq. ft ; grate area. ,S4 .s sq. ft.
Driving wheels, diameter outside, 57 in,; journals.
main. 10 x 12 in.; others, 9 .x 12 in.; engine
truck wheels, front, diameter, 30 J^ in.; jour-
nals, 6 X ID in. ; wheel base, driving, 15 ft. 8 in. ;
total engine, 24 ft. 4 in.
Weight, on driving wheels. 185,240 lbs.; on truck.
front, 24,890 lbs.; total engine. 210.130 lbs
Tank, capacity, oil, 3,300 gal.; water, 7.300 gal.
Tender, wheels, diameter, 2^/2 in.; journals. 5^5 x
above the lean-to is almost entirely
glass, while the center of the roof is com-
posed of translucent fabric. Beyond this
first lean-to is a second lean-to. The
vertical wall above its flat roof is glass,
and the center of the roof is also covered
with translucent fabric. The north wall
of the second lean-to is liberally suppl'ed
with windows. Viewed from the outside
this building is like two or three steps
of a gigantic stairway, in which the
"risers"' have plenty of glass, and the
"treads" or flat roofs of the lean-tos are
covered largely with translucent fabric.
The erecting shop has three tracks
parallel to the length of the shop, and
it will hold about 35 locomotives. Two
50-ton Shaw electric cranes of 80 foot
span cover the entire area. Engines
when being placed or removed are car-
ried up or down the space between the
tracks, the cranes doing the necessary
"side-stepping" at either end of the shop.
In what we have called the first lean-to
there are two electric cranes operating,
having each a span of about 35 feet.
One is a 3'/^-ton crane for light pieces.
served with a 40-ton crane. The riveter
is of the pneumatic-hydraulic type, and
when not in operation the overhead
crane carries a portable pneumatic-hy-
dralic riveter for tank work. There are
three Ferguson oil furnaces in this shop
and one annealing furnace of the Fer-
guson type.
The entire erecting, machine and boiler
shop building is heated by the Buffalo
Forge Company's system. A separate
building containing a well appointed
lavatory is provided for the men and ex-
panded metal lockers are furnished to
each individual worker.
The blacksmith shop is a building male
entirely of concrete, and is about 300 ft.
long by about 83 ft. wide. This shop
is supplied with Sturtevant down-draft
forges. There are four large jib cranes,
two of which serve the large steam ham-
mer: one is placed near a large Acme
bulldozer, and one takes care of material
for frog, crossing and switch work. This
department is also equipped with a drill,
cold saw and planer. The bolt headers,
bolt cutters and nut tappers are also in
1 84
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
this building. There are three Ferguson
oil furnaces for the bolt headers, one for
the hammer and one for the bulldozer.
A track is laid in the center of the shop
which communicates with the storehouse
and also with the main transfer table.
The power house is located in a central
position, and supplies steam, compressed
air and electric power to the various
shops. The equipment at present con-
sists of three Ballwood engines, two air
compressors and two 500 h.p. boiler bat-
teries. There is room for the installa-
tion of three other Ballwood engines,
two additional air compressors and an-
other battery of boilers. It is expected
this plant will be one of the air com-
pressor stations for the electro-pneu-
matic block signal system which is used
its long side, like that of the paint shop,
extending along the transfer table. In
this 'department the wood-working ma-
chinery is placed, though partitioned
ofT from the rest of the shop. The pat-
tern makers occupy a corner of the room.
There are three fire walls in the paint
shop and three in the passenger car re-
pair shop. Back of this shop is a small
transfer table capable of handling trucks,
etc., from one track to another in the
passenger car repair department, and of
conveying material to the upholstery de-
partment, the cleaning and dyeing de-
partment, and the varnishing department.
These three departments are in one
building, 150x30 ft., made of brick, with
concrete foundation, each occupying a
separate room. Further on is an isolated
Upon the arrival of a tank in front of
the platform connection is made with
pipe from bottom of tank car and the oil
runs by gravity from tank-car into large
storage tank. In the oil room is a row
of spigots (connected with storage tanks)
under each of which is a sink to receive
the drip. These sinks have lead pipes
leading each one to its appropriate tank,
so that the loss is reduced to a minimum.
The sinks are also used for the purpose
of filling the small storage tanks in cellar
with the oils that are' purchased in
wood.
An air valve at each spigot controls
the lifting of all oils for distributing or
to fill barrels, which is done entirely by
air pressure. A barrel can be filled with
kerosene in about two minutes at an air
PASSED ON THE WAY TO MOUNT LOWE.
on the C. R. R. of N. J. The feed water
for the boilers is heated by exhaust
steam and is pumped under pressure into
the boilers at a temperature of 230 de-
grees F. The company's ofScials are
contemplating in stalling mechanical stok-
ers, and an ash and coal handling plant
at an early date.
The paint shop is a concrete building
325x150 ft., having its long side fronting
on the transfer table, which also passes
along the ends of the erecting shop and
the blacksmith shop. This shop is well
lighted and contains a good modern
stockroom with storeroom for paints,
oils, varnishes, etc., in what might al-
most be called an air-tight cement cellar,
in the construction of which nothing in-
flammable has been used.
Crossing the transfer table the pas-
senger car repair shop is reached. This
is also a concrete building, 425x100 ft.,
brick and concrete building 70x30 ft.,
used for pattern storage.
A feature worthy of note is the oil
house, which, while not yet finally com-
pleted, is expected to stand as a model for
economical and prompt handling of oils
for the entire road. This is a building
made entirely of concrete and measures
So ft. X 20 ft., with an outside platform II
ft. wide. A cellar or basement 16 ft. deep
extends beneath the entire structure, in-
cluding the platform. In the basement
are located four large tanks with about
11,000 gallons capacity each. These
tanks are for oils most commonly used;
kerosene, engine oil, car oil and signal
oil. There are also seven smaller tanks
which will contain from 400 gallons to
1,600 gallons each, for other kinds of
oil. The four oils first mentioned are
purchased in tank-car lots. The other
kinds in barrels.
pressure of about 30 pounds. Empty
barrels and those filled for shipment are
stored in the basement and will be raised
and lowered on a pneumatic elevator,
which is now being installed.
One-half of the proposed round-house
is at present built and contains 25 pits.
It is composed entirely of concrete. .-V
commodious store and office building
■300x50 ft., made entirely of concrete with
scrap platforms, receiving and shipping
platforms, etc., occupies a convenient
position near the power house, with
tracks placed to facilitate the movement
of material.
"Firing Locomotives" is the name of
a new book by .A.ngus Sinclair, recently
published at this otlice. It is a very read-
able, elementary treatise on combus-
tion, and can be carried in the pocket.
Price. .50 cents.
April. 1903.
RAILWAY AXI) I.OCi )Mi ) ri\l-; l-:.\f;r\F.F.RI\'G
185
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. M. W. Wells ha.s been appointed
gencnil manager of the Illinois Sonlhcrn
Railw.iy, with office at Cliicago, III.
Mr. James H. Manning has been ap-
pointed second assistant superintendent
of rolling stock on the Canadian Pacific
Railway.
Mr. A. Bamseur, superintendent of the
Norfolk division, has been transferred
to the Charlotte division of the same
road.
of the Southern Railway, vice Mr. G. R.
Cone, transferred.
Mr. A. Ramseur has been appointed
superintendent of the Ashe division of
the Southern Railway, vice Mr. G. R.
Loyall, transferred.
Mr. R. J. Johnson, who was trainmas-
ter of the Newcastle division of the Bal-
timore & Ohio, has gone with the Chi-
cago & North-Westcrn as superintendent
of terminals at Chicago.
vision of the Southern Railway, vice Mr.
H. A. Williams, promoted.
Mr. W. G. Choate has been appointed
superintendent of the Washington di-
vision of the Southern Railway, vice Mr.
A. Gordon Jones, transferred.
Mr. Thomas Fieldon has been ap-
pointed general foreman of the Sapulpa
I. T. shops of the St. Louis & San Fran-
cisco Railroad, vice Mr. T. S. Rcilly,
resigned.
Mr. F. A. Gascoigne has been ap-
pointed car accountant Canadian Pacific
Railway, vice Mr. J. P. DriscoU. re-
signed.
Mr. G. R. Loyall has been appointed
superintendent of the Knoxville division
of the Southern Railway, vice Mr. C. L.
Ewing. resigned.
Mr. H. A. Williams has been appointed
superintendent of the Norfolk division of
the Southern Railway, vice Mr. A. Ram-
seur, transferred.
Mr. B. G. Fallis has been appointed
superintendent of the Asheville division
PASSED ON THE W.^Y TO MOUNT LOWE.
Mr. James M. Johnson has been ap-
pointed road foreman of equipment.
Texas division of the St. Louis & San
Francisco Railroad.
Mr. A. P. Cane, trainmaster Norfolk
division of the Southern Railway, has
been transferred to the Charlotte divis-
ion on the same road.
Mr. Alexander HoIIey Rudd has been
appointed assistant signal engineer on
the Pennsylvania Railroad, with head-
quarters at Philadelphia.
Mr. W. F. Anderson has been ap-
pointed trainmaster of the Danville di-
Mr. F. F. Busteed has been appointed
division engineer of the Pacific division
of the Canadian Pacific, vice Mr. H. J.
Cambie, assigned other duties.
Mr. Webb C. Ball has been appointed
chief watch inspector on the Rutland
Railroad. He already holds a similar
position on the Vanderbilt lines.
Mr. A. Brumer. resident engineer of
the Norfolk division of the Southern
Railway, has resigned in order to accept
a position on the Norfolk & Western.
:Mr. B. G. FoUis, late of the Iowa Cen-
tral, has been appointed trainmaster of
1 86
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
the Norfolk division of the Southern
Railway, vice Mr. A. P. Cane, trans-
ferred.
Mr. S. L. Rainey has been appointed
superintendent on the South-Western
division on the St. Louis and San Fran-
cisco, vice Mr. G. H. Schleyer, trans-
ferred to the Tex^s division.
Mr. H. J. Cambie has been appointed
special assistant engineer of the Cana-
dian Pacific Railway, with headquarters
at Vancouver, in connection with the
Pacific division of the service.
Mr. H. J. Cambie has been appointed
with the Railway Appliances Company,
with headquarters at Pittsburg, giving
his time more particularly to the sale of
the Q and C Pneumatic Tools.
Mr. W. E. Dunham has been appointed
mechanical engineer of the Chicago &
North-Western Railway, with headquar-
ters at Chicago shops, Chicago, 111., vice
Mr. E. B. Thompson, promoted.
Mr. J. P. Driscoll, formerly car ac-
countant on the Canadian Pacific Rail-
way, has been appointed superintendent
of car service on the Canadian Northern
Railway, with office at Winnipeg.
Mr. Thomas O. Cole has been ap-
pointed superintendent of car service on
the Lehigh Valley Railroad, with office
at South Bethlehem, Pa. The office of
car accountant has been abolished.
Mr. Robert L. Langtim has been ap-
pointed mechanical engineer of the Den-
ver & Rio Grande Railroad, in place of
Mr. .Muchnic, who has accepted service
with the American Locomotive Com-
pany.
Mr. J. D. Hurley and Mr. A. B.
Holmes, formerly connected with the
Standard Pneumatic Tool Co., are now
associated with the Rand Drill Company
in the "Imperial Pneumatic Tool De-
partment.
Mr. James Reed, formerly car inspec-
tor on the New York Central at Roches-
ter, has been appointed to the position
of chief car inspector at the Grand Cen-
tral Station, New York, vice Mr. James
How, retired.
Mr. J. B. Harden, formerly assistant
foreman of the Boston & Maine car
shops, at East Fitchburg, has been ap-
pointed foreman of that company's shops
at Portland, Me., vice Mr. George L.
Miller, deceased.
Mr. G. W. Seidel has accepted the
position of master mechanic on the Bur-
lingtc.n division of the Southern Rail-
way. He was. previous to this appoint-
ment, master mechanic on the Lehigh
Valley at Buffalo, N. Y.
Mr. Eugene McAulifife, engineer on
the Southern division of the Frisco sys-
tem, was recently appointed road fore-
man of equipment for that division. He
has still more recently been appointed
fuel purchasing agent for the entire sys-
tem.
Mr. J. B. Kilpatrick, who has been
master mechanic of the Kansas division
of the Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific,
with Headquarters at Horton, Kan., has
been transferred to the Northern dis-
trict, with headquarters at Cedar Rapids,
Iowa.
Mr. R. J. E. Scott, chief inspector of
time service on the Canadian Pacific,
has also been appointed chief examiner
for testing the color sense, sight and
hearing of employees engaged in the
movement and handling of engines and
trains.
Mr. Barney Goodwin, better known
among his friends as Buck Goodwin, has
recently been appointed traveling en-
gineer of the Philadelphia division of the
Baltimore & Ohio, to assist Mr. H. S.
Peddicord, who is the road foreman of
engines.
Mr. H. A. Williams, formerly train-
master of the Dansville division of the
Southern Railway, has been promoted
to be superintendent of the Norfolk
division of the same road, with head-
quarters at Laurenceville, Va., vice Mr.
A. Bamseur, transferred.
Mr. Charles M. Muchnie, formerly me-
chanical engineer of the Denver & Rio
Grande, has been made private secretary
to Mr. R. J. Gross, of the American
Locomotive Company. Both these gen-
tlemen will make a tour of the world in
the interest of this locomotive building
concern.
Mr. C. P. Coleman, having resigned,
the position of purchasing agent has
been abolished on the Lehigh Valley
Railroad. The duties of the office will
be performed by the second vice-presi-
dent, to whom all communications rela-
tive thereto should be addressed, 39
Cortlandt street, New York city.
Mr. James How, chief car inspector
at "the Grand Central Station of the New
York Central, has retired. Mr. How
has held this responsible post for twenty-
seven years. He was with the Lake
Shore before be joined the N. Y. C.
Good health and a substantial pension
will enable him to enjoy the rest he has
fully earned.
Mr. Charles Davenport, one of the
pioneer car builders of the United States,
died at the home of his son, in Water-
town, Mass., in February last. He was
the first large builder of cars in this
country, and for thirty-two years his
firm held a prominent position in that
important industry. He died at the ad-
vanced age of 91.
Mr. J. P. McMurry, formerly pas-
senger engineer on the Rio Grande
division of the Atcheson. Topeka &
Santa Fe. has been appointed traveling
engineer on the same road. He will
have jurisdiction over the lines west of
Las Vegas, N. M. Now that he has
started in the line of promotion his
friends expect to see him reach higher
positions as time goes on.
Mr. J. J. Scully, chief clerk in the
office of general superintendent of the
Central division, Canadian Pacific Rail-
way, was recently married to Miss Ce-
cilia Mallon, of Toronto. R.mlway and
Locomotive Engineering extends its
hearty congratulations to the bride and
groom, and hope's that the "home" sig-
nal may always stand at "clear" for them
during a long and happy life.
Mr. Charles S. Powell, who has been
associated with the Westinghouse elec-
tric interests since 1893, and who, for
the past six years, has been manager of
the Cleveland oflSce of the Westinghouse
Electric and Manufacturing Company,
has changed the scene of his activities
from the United States to Europe. He
has been appointed Assistant Manager
of the British Westinghouse Electric and
Manufacturing Company, Limited, and
has already entered upon the duties of
his new position. Mr. Powell, who was
one of the most popular men in the elec-
trical business in the United States, is
bound to be equally well liked in Great
Britain. His headquarters are in the
Westinghouse Building, Norfolk street.
Strand, London, W. C.
Mr. Thomas Tait, manager of trans-
portation of the Canadian Pacific Rail-
way, has been offered a^nd has accepted
the position of Chairman of Government
Railroad Commission for the State of
Victoria, in the Commonwealth of Aus-
tralia. The commission is composed of
three members, appointed for a term of
yeaj*. It is absolutely independent of
party politics. In this body the chairman
has the casting vote, the other two mem-
bers being departmental officers. The
Australian railways are state owned and
managed strictly for the benefit of the
people, so that they pay about 3 per cent,
on the money invested. The offer com-
ing unsolicited, as it did, is considered
a great compliment to Mr. Tait hiinself
and to the road he has so long and ably
served. Mr. Tait's many friends unite
in predicting for him a useful and pros-
perous career in the land of the South-
ern Cross.
Wood or Coal ?
A passenger of an inquiring mind asked
an engineer of an outgoing passenger
train the other day, "Does this coal you
have on the tender give as much heat as
wood would?" The engineer replied,
"This engine would not burn wood be-
cause it depends greatly on the grate."
"Oh, I see," replied the other; "as the
engine stands now you greatly prefer
coal?" "Yes, I would," said he of the
throttle.
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
187
Consolidation for the B. R. & P. Ry.
A very good example of heavy freight
power in the shape of a consolidation
engine has been turned out recently by
the Brooks shops of the American Lo-
comotive Company for the Buffalo,
Rochester & Pittsburgh Railway. The
engines are simple, with 21x28 in. cyl-
inders. The diameter of the driving
wheels is 57 in. and the adhesive weight
is 164,600 lbs. With a steam pressure
of 210 lbs. the calculated tractive force
of this engine is about 38,500 lbs.
The valves are of the piston type and
the old familiar square steam chest is
replaced by the sloping of the valve
chamber, on the outside of which a step
has been placed for the convenience of
those who may have to get from front
foot plate to running board. The pis-
tons drive on the third wheel while the
eccentrics are placed on the second axle,
and a short and nearly straight trans-
mission bar passing over the forward
axle gives direct connection gear.
presents a neat and clear cut appearance.
A few of the principal dimensions are
appended for reference:
Wci^ilit ill wnrkitipr order. iR^.^oo n>s.
Weight on ilrivers, 164,^.00 U>».
Wci^;ht cii^;. and tend, in work'K order, 3oH.6oon>H.
Wheel liasr, drivillK, 1.5 it. 9 in.; total, 24 ft. 6 in,
Wlicel base, total engine and tender, ,<:4 ft. 7 in.
Valves, kind of, piston; gieatest travel. 53', in.
Outside lap, i in.; inside lap, o in.
WHIvKLS, KTC.
I)ia. and Igtll. of driving jmirnals, H'/, and 9(^x1 1 in.
IJia. and Igtli. of main crank pin jour., 6J^x6J4 in.
Uia. and iRtli. of side rod pin jour., T4x4hi in.
HOII.RK.
Thickness of plates in barrel and outside of fire
bo.'c, S3, 38, A. 1°.. 'yi "■•
I'irebox, length, 108 in,; width. 74 in.
I*irc box, depth, front. 72 in.; back, 'HJ^ in.
Hire box plates, thickness, sides. ■}i in.; back. }4
in.; crown, J4 in.; tube sheet, ^ in.
I''irebi).\. water space. 4111. fnt ; 4 in. sides; 4 in. bck.
Tubes, number. 354; dia.. 2 in.
Tubes, length overtube sheets, 14 ft. 6}^ in.
I-'ire brick, supported on tubes.
Heating surface, tubes 2.672.7 sq. ft.
Heating surface, water tubes 28.5 sq. ft.
Healing surface, fire box I7,s.8 sq. ft.
Heating surface, total 2,'*77. sq.ft.
weight. For the sake of example, sup-
pose the scale registered 4,000 pounds
under the circumstances. The torque
of this motor would therefore be 4,000
foot-pounds because the pressure exerted
by the lever had been measured one foot
from the center of the shaft. Continu-
ing the experiment, let us suppose that
the lever has been removed and that a
pulley has been keyed on the end of the
shaft in its place, and further suppose
the radius of this pulley to be 12 inches,
and that it carries a belt which gives ro-
tation to some other pulley. The torque
of the motor remaining the same with
given current it follows that the pull on
the belt, like the weight registered on the
weigh scales, will be 4,000 pounds.
Torque is, however, always expressed as
foot-pounds. The pulley we have been
considering had a radius of 12 inches, or
in other words, its diameter was 2 feet.
Now, if a pulley 4 feet in diameter was
to replace the smaller- one, we would
have this new condition. The torque
SIMPI.E 2-S-O ENGINE FOR THE B. R. & P. RY.
The spring gear is very compact. The
semi-elliptic springs are placed in the
space between top and bottom frame
bars. Two f^at equalizer bars rest on
each axle box, inside and outside the
frame, their ends terminating in the
Brooks webbed hook hanger which
carry the spring ends. The forward driv-
ing spring is, however, carried above this
frame in the usual way. All the driving
wheels are flanged. The tumbling shaft
casting is also utilized as a bracket for
the spectacle plate, and the reach rod is
a piece of 2-in. pipe screwed into pin-
connection castings at each end.
The boiler is of the wide firebox type,
radial stayed and measures 77 in. in the
waist and tapers to 70 in. at the smoke-
box end. There is ample steam space
and the boiler contains 2,877 sq. ft. of
heating surface. The grate area is about
54 sq. ft. The tender has a coal capacity
of 12 tons and the tank holds 6.000 gal-
lons of water. Altogether the machine
Grate surface, 54.4 sq. ft.
Smoke stack, top above rail. 14 ft. 11 in.
Tender, weight, empty. 49,700 lbs.
Wheel base, 16 ft. 5 in-; frame. 13 in. channeLs.
What Is the Torque of an Electric
Motor?
The word torque comes from a latin
word meaning to twist, and it may be
defined as the twisting or turning effort
imparted to a shaft carrying the revolv-
ing armature of an electric motor. The
torque of a motor such as is used to
drive a street car or to run a machine
tool in a railway repair shop may be
found by experiment. A lever tightly
clamped to the shaft is of such length
that its free end may be supported upon
the platform of weigh scales, exactly
one foot from the center of the shaft.
As soon as .the current is turned on the
end of this one-foot lever resting on the
scales will press down a certain amount
and register what is equivalent to a
being constant with constant current,
the pull on the belt would now be 2,oco
pounds.
As the torque is found by multiplying
the radius of the pulley in feet by the
belt pull in pounds, it rests with the de-
signer to make pulley or car wheel, as
the case may be. the size best suited to
the work to be done. Torque is practi-
cally equivalent to the tractive effort of
the motor if mounted on wheels 2 feet
in diameter.
When the speed of the motor is con-
sidered, the horse power may be deter-
mined. As the motor revolves a certain
number of times in a minute it follows
that a definite number of foot-pounds of
work must be delivered in that time. If
the speed be such that the belt pull
would be equivalent to the raising of
33,000 pounds one foot high in a minute,
the motor would, under those circum-
stances, be developing i horse power.
i88
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
"Tunnel Scrapers."
We have often heard the modern high
steel frame buildings in New York and
other cities called "skyscrapers." In
fact the number of them that have of late
years been built on Broadway in the
lower business end of city has given rise
to the curious expression "the canyon
of lower Broadway" as a term descrip-
tive of that thoroughfare toward the enJ
of Manhattan Island. We read now in
the Charlotte Observer that the new en-
gines lately received by the Ashville
division of the Southern Railroad are
called "tunnel scrapers." It is said that
these engines are so high that the tops
of the cabs come close to the roofs of
the tunnels along that line, and when the
water which soaks through the roofs
forms into icicles, these engines break
them off and grind along the ice with
such a noise that makes a new engineer
think the tunnel is on top of him — which
in a certain sense, it certainly is. It oc-
curs to us in this connection that a
chance for a new invention is afforded
by this state of affairs, to some ingenious
individual. If there should be an up-
grade through one or more of these icy-
roofed tunnels a traction increaser might
be devised by which a pair of skates
mounted on top of a suitably braced cab
might be pushed up by compressed air
against the ice, and so add to the ad-
hesive weight on the drivers. Any ice
cut off or knocked down by the skates
should be caught in a suitable receptacle
and shot into the tank, where it could
be melted and eventually used to supply
the boiler. This outline of the possibili-
ties of the "tunnel-scraper traction-in-
creaser" is respectfully submitted to Eli
Gilderfiuke, who in past years has made
public some of his choicest devices for
making things comfortable on engines,
through the columns of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering. If Mr. Gil-
derfiuke succeeds in securing a patent,
he will not have anything more extraor-
dinary than many of the devices which
the United States Government have in
years past been asked to issue patents on.
The latest aspirant for notoriety is a
self-denominated professor of astron-
omy in Indiana who pretends to have
discovered that the sun is inhabited.
When science can demonstrate that a
substance can be formed to sustain life,
which will live in' an atmosphere hotter
than the carborundum making furnaces
at Niagara Falls, which melt like lead
the most refractory substances found on
the earth, then it may be demonstrated
that some kind of salamander life exists
in the sun.
Shop Door Fastener.
The large doors of shops and round-
houses which are hinged to posts in-
variably develop the habit of gaping open
at the top, and these doors usually be-
come warped sufficiently to render the
use of a long bolt at the top imprac-
ticable. In dealing with long doors the
designer must allow for this habit and
endeavor to correct it. He cannot force
the door to adopt so radical a departure
from its own custom as to swing in tight
at the top when it is bolted in place at
the bottom. Assistance is what the door
requires rather than coercion.
A neat method of fastening such doors
as we are describing is in use at the
Elizabethport shops of the Central Rail-
road of New Jersey. At the bottom of
the door a simple and easily made but
effective bolt is used — no coddling of the
door at its lower end is thought of. The
bolt consists of a piece of 7-8-inch round
iron bent over at the top with a 3-8-inch
dowel let in which slides in a slot cut in
a piece of gaspipe which encloses the bolt.
The pipe is clamped in place by two U-
shaped bolts, with nuts screwed up on
the inside. The doors are simply closed,
the rabbit of one holding the edge of
the other, and the bolts are shot without
ceremony. The upper end of the door
where the warping and gaping take place
is out of reach, and a simple piece of
mechanism shown in our illustration is
used. It consists of a lever which oper-
ates a vertical rod, this rod terminating
in a knuckle which works between two
triangular brackets bolted to the door.
From the roof timber of the shop a
piece of 2-inch flat iron stands down
about three inches and has its lower end
bent up so as to form a brace. When
the door is open the lever which operates
the knuckle is placed so that the handle
is in its lowest position, and the business
end of the knuckle, which looks like a
crooked finger, is "wide open" away
from the door as far as it can get. When
the door is closed and bolted at the bot-
tom the tendency to gape at the top is
kindly but firmly repressed by drawing
up the lever handle and sliding it past
the inclined bracket until it rests on the
top of the stop. This pulls the business
end of the knuckle tightly against the
flat iron brace and the top of the door
comes in line with the bottom and is
held securely closed all along its length
as a well made door should be. From
this it almost looks as if the door was
continually up against a thoroughly
braced game.
expressed in the columns both of the
technical and non-technical papers, he
being "right on the ground," so to
speak, and having experience widely dif-
ferent from those in other departments
who quite frequently use these papers
for airing their views and opinions.
While block signals on a railroad are
intended to afford greater safety for the
movement of trains, the fact remains
that these signals are sometimes disre-
garded, either partially or wholly, and
especially by high-speed trains having
few stops and fast time to make. These
Many a gentleman lives well upon a
soft head, who would find a heart of the
same quality a very great drawback. — Old
Curiosity Shop.
Proper Observance of Signals.
A correspondent writes us interestingly
from the view point of an engineer on
the subject of proper observance of block
signals. His letter is all the more inter-
esting from the fact that his views are
somewhat different from those usually
Itailivay ir Laovmolita Enginmring
ROUND HOUSE OR SHOP DOOR FASTENER.
fast trains must make their schedule time
or else the railroad company may be
obliged to pay a forfeit to the passen-
ger at the end of the trip. It is, there-
fore, highly important that such trains
be kept on time, and frequently this is
done by the sacrifice of the proper ob-
servance of signals by the engineer. Our
correspondent writes that an engineer of
such a train approaching a block signal
which is held against him will generally
run much closer than an engineer of an
April, 1903.
RAILWAY ANIJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
189
ordinary train woulil, the former expect-
ing the signal to "clear." Sliould the
signal remain at danger while the track
is apparently clear the engineer believes
he can safely go on, and he will often
pass the signal and enter the next block
in strict opposition to rules. He finds
an excuse for so doing in the fact that
his train is usually given a clear track,
and that other trains are on the lookout
for him and know that they should be
out of his way. Sometimes they clear
him by some minutes less than the rules
call for. He knows this, and in his hard
fight to 'maintain his schedule he will
enter the block or. partially disregard the
signal, believing that when the clearance
point is reached the confiitting train will
be out of the way.
There is a great temptation to the en-
gineer of high speed trains to take ad-
vantage of signals in the manner de-
scribed by our correspondent, for such
an engineer is nearly always successful
and very seldom an accident happens by
his disobeying of the signals, but when
it does happen the accident is usually
currcnccs of this kind, due to block sig-
nals or a flagman, would make the train
from s to IS minutes late at the end of
the run, and the reputation of the road
would suffer. The engineer would be
blamed for inability to make time. He
would be taken ofif the engine and an-
other man put on who will make time
by hook or crook. There is only one
way that the second man can make
faster time than did the first, who drove
the engine to its utmost, and that is by
"squeezing" signals, i. c., totally or par-
tially disregarding them, knowing that
the dispatcher will endeavor to give
high-speed trains the right of way. It is
in this manner that much of the time is
made on some of the fast trains of to-
day. As long as all goes well the en-
gineer will receive a pat on the back,
but if he is unsuccessful in the risks he
takes he gets a kick and the whole
blame."
Our correspondent further asserts that
if passengers knew the peril they are
sometimes in and knew the secrets that
could be told by the signal blocks and
type has been given a wide fire-box over-
hanging the rear driving wheels, and the
tender is of the form designed by Mr.
Cornelius Vanderbilt.
The engine is a Vauclain compound,
with high pressure cylinders on top. The
cylinders are 15^ and 26x28 in. The
driving wheels are 62 in. outside diame-
ter, and the engine is expected to take
her place in passenger as well as freight
service, as occasion demands. The pres-
sure carried is 200 pounds. The tractive
effort is about 29,700 pounds.
The boiler is of the wagon-top type
and measures yy in. in the waste and 66
in. at the smoke-box end. The pops
are situated in an auxiliary dome which
also carries a chime whistle. The heat-
ing surface is 2,993 sq. ft., with 47 1-2
sq. ft. grate area.
The Vanderbilt tank contains 7,000 gal-
lons of water and is provided with a run-
ning board on each side at the back end
for the use of the fireman when taking
water. The total weight of engine and
tender in working order is 319,210
lACUlC J-'i-O TYPE WITH VANDERBILT TENDER.
a very severe one, with fatal results. If
lie is successful in passing signals noth-
ing is said against his action, but if his
venture ends disastrously he is punished
fordisobedihenceby discharge. Too often
superiors are more or less cognizant
of this disobedience, and are often in-
clined to wink at it. Our correspondent
further emphasizes his views by citing a
special case. He says: "A passenger
agent of a road orders a fast train to
compete with a similar train on a neigh-
boring road. The opposition road has
powerful engines, substantial roadway
and engineers can easily make the time
laid out for the fast train. The other
road does not have such equipment or
roadbed and is taxed to its utmost. If
the engineer on the handicapped road
shuts off steam and allows the train to
drift for 10 or 20 seconds it means a
•delay of half a minute, or a minute on the
run. If he slows down by applyin.;?
brakes it means delay of from I to 3
minutes. If he stops he probably loses
from 3 to 8 minutes. Two or three oc-
the dispatcher's office at the terminal,
some of the swift trains would be taken
off and would be found among their
more humble companions which the
present fast trains now bully and beat
to the sacrifice of profitable revenue to
the railway company. The engineer
would be better off. He would be set a
reasonable task, would accomplish much
and would not be usually encouraged by
subordinate railway officials to ignore
certain rules, the successful evasion of
which is open reward, and the unsuccess-
ful disobedience of which entails punish-
ment and disgrace.
Baldwin 4-6=0 Engine for the Union
Pacific.
Our illustration shows a ten-wheel en-
gine with a cylindrical tender, for the
Union Pacific Railroad. This engine is
somewhat similar in general construc-
tion to others of the same class which
have been built for this railroad by the
Baldwin Locomotive Works, but this
pounds. A few of the principal dimen-
sions are as follows:
Cylinders, 15^ and 26 in. x 2S in.; Valve balance
piston.
Boiler, diameter. 66 in. ; thickness of sheets. 4i x ii
in.; working pressure. 200 lbs.; staying, radial,
Firebox, length. ioi}| in.; width. 66^4 in.; depth.
front, 71 V^ in.: back, jSi^ in.; thickness of
sheets, sides, "'-3 in.; back, -^^ in.; crown. *^ in.,
tnbe, \i in.; water space, front, 4 in.; sides. 4
in.; back, 4 in.
Tubes, n-ateriat. iron; wire gauge. Xo. 11; number
550; diameter. 2 in.; length. 15 ft. 6 in.
Heatinf: surface, firebox. 16S.2 sq. ft.; tubes. 2,825:
total, 2,99J.2 sq. ft.; grate area. 47.5 sq. ft.
Driving wheel-«. diameter outside. 62 in.; journals,
main, q x 12 in.; others, gx 12 in.
Engine truck wheels, front, diameter. 50 in.; jour-
nals, 6S in X II in.; wheelbase. driving. 14 ft. 6
in, ; total engine, 26 ft. 9 in.
Weight, on driving wheels. 140.070 lbs.; on truck,
front. 45.140 lbs.; total engine. 1S5.210 lbs.; total
engine and tender. 310.210 lbs.
Tank, capacity, 7.000 gallons.
Tender, journals. 5*3 in. x 10 in.
One person can no more quarrel with-
out an adversary than one person can
play at chess or fight a duel. — Martin
Chuszleu'it.
I go
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
Good Paint Shop Scaffolding.
A very ingenious arrangement for the
scaffolding used in connection with the
painting of passenger cars is to be seen
in the Elizabethport shops of the Cen-
tral Railroad of New Jersey. On each
3-8 in, truss rods, each carried under two
queen posts 7 in. deep, which gives the
unloaded plank a camber which can
hardly be detected by the eye. The ends
of the plank are covered by two small
angle irons, which support the truss rod
great economy of space is secured. The
pegs act as ladders and as they stand
parallel to the passageway they cannot
strike men or material moving past.
" Railways on tlie Ocean."
The Canadian Pacific Railway has
lately acquired possession of fourteen
steamships belonging to the Elder-
Demster Line, the aggregate dead
weight tonnage of which amounts
to about 130,000 tons. It is believed
that about $8,000,000 was the purchase
price. These vessels will be used largely
in the North Atlantic trade. This rail-
way company already has a fleet on the
Pacific ocean, and when things are in
working order it may possibly be able
to lay claim to being the transportation
company covering the largest land and
sea mileage in the world. The Pall Mall
Gazette, of London, thinks that this
"deal" is a serious blow to independent
Canadian shipping, for it says nearly
the whole of the North Atlantic trade
will be dominated by American railway
companies. The Canadian Pacific has
also some fine steamships of the ocean-
going type on the Great Lakes, plying
between Port Arthur and Owen Sound.
Itailway i Locomotive Enginetring
END VIEW OF SCAFFOLDING,
View pnraUel wiih
passage
of the shop posts there is bolted about
ten feet from the ground a 2j^x4 in.
piece of yellow pine, and this crosspiece
extends out about four feet on each side
of the post. From the ends of this cross
bar two uprights are pivoted, their lower
ends resting upon the floor. A bolt
which passes into the concrete prevents
the upright being moved, though when
the bolt is withdrawn this 3x4 in. post
may be swung back out of the way, as
shown in our illustration. In each one
of these upright posts there are ten pegs
made of 3-4 in. round iron spaced a foot
apart, all except the lowest, which is
about half that distance from the floor.
These pegs stand out 4 1-2 in. on each
side of the uprights and are parallel to
the passageway between the cars.
The plank upon which the workmen
stand is made of selected spruce 12 in.
wide, and is supported at each end on a
bracket with a hook at the right angle
of the triangle which it forms, as may be
seen in the accompanying sketch. The
hook is dropped over one of the pegs
in the uprights and the lower point of
the bracket rests against the peg next
lower down, so that when in place the
footboard is really supported by two
cantilevers, one at each end. The ease
with which the board can be raised or
lowered is plain to be seen.
The plank itself is trussed with two
nuts and take the bolts which secure
plank and triangle together. The queen
posts are made by taking lengths of J4
in, pipes, 15 in, long and flattening them
in the middle and shearing them through
in the flattened portion. These pieces
of pipe are then placed in two holes in
cross battons screwed to the under side
We have received an interesting pub-
lication got out by the Lackawanna Rail-
road called "Modernizing a Trunk
Line," which is a story of the perma-
nent improvements on the D., L. & W.
since 1899. A number of neatly executed
half-tones show new stations and bridges.
The work has been very extensive and
thorough. A copy will be sent to any
one interested who applies to the rail-
road company for it.
DETAIL OF TRUSSED PLANK AND SUPPORT.
of the plank, the truss rods being run
through and tightened up, completes the
job.
The whole arrangement is simple,
strong and effective. There is no coun-
terbalance to get out of order, and
We have been informed that the gross
earnings of the Chicago. Great Western
Railway (Maple Leaf Route) for the first
week of March, 1903. show an increase
of $18,202.23 over the corresponding
week of last year.
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
191
Novel Suburban Engine on the Qreat
Eastern of England.
Mr. James lloldtii, locomolivc super-
intendent of the Great Eastern Railway,
has designed a powerful suburban en-
gine, which is intended to haul trains of
about 370 long tons and carrying each
about 1,200 passengers. The traffic is
horizontal, and the eccentrics arc se-
cured to the third axle. There are only
two steam chests, one is lor the left cyl-
inder and one for the right and middle.
A curious arrangement is the connecting
rod for the center cylinder. It is a
forked rod, and the wrist-pin connection
is a separate piece bolted between the
feet II inches long. As the boiler stands
so high, the chimney has been brought
down in consequence, and is flared out
inside the smoke box so as to be practi-
cally an upper petticoat pipe. The ex-
haust has three annular openings. The
pressure carried is 200 lbs., and an esti-
mate of the tractive cflfort places it about
rilKHE-CVLINDER SIMPLE SUBURBAN ENGINE, GREAT EASTERN RY.
such as to require about 15 stops and
starts in a distance of ten and three-
quarter miles, between London and En-
field, and it is proposed to cover the dis-
tance in 30 minutes.
The engine is built up very close to
the loading line of the road and weighs
about 156,800 lbs. A]\ the weight
upper and lower bars of the forked end.
When in place this rod entirely encloses
the forward axle, and as the opening so
made is not long enough to clear the
axle when the piston is at the back end
of the cylinder, the leading driving axle
is oflfset in the center to suit. As the
leading pair of drivers are revolved by
37,500 lbs. The cranks are set at 120
degrees, and in balancing the total of
all the reciprocating weights has been
taken, instead of two-thirds of them, as
is the usual practice. The provision
against slipping in making a start is
accomplished by a sanding device which
uses tompressed air, which latter is sup-
Soiler I'ressurc 200 lbs. per n"
OUTLINE OF HEAVY SUBURBAN ENGINE. GREAT EASTERN OF ENGL-^ND.
rests upon the five pairs of drivers, in-
cluding that of fuel and water. The cyl-
inders are three in number, all simple,
18^x24 inches. The two outside ones
drive on the tliird pair of wheels while
the center cylinder, placed directly below
the smoke box, drives upon a crank axle
in the second pair. All the cylinders are
the side rods the forked rod and the
off-set axle each work in perfect har-
mony.
The boiler has a wide firebox, with
grate area of 42 square feet, and the
total heating surface is 3,005 square feet.
The tubes are 395 in number and they
are l54 inches in diameter and are 15
plied from a separate reservoir. Air is
pumped into the sander's reservoir and
passes through a check valve into the
main reservoir, so that even if air is tem-
porarily used freely in sanding, it can-
not aflfect the main reservoir pressure.
There are 1,300 Imperial gallons of water
carried, and about two tons of coal.
iq2
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
The Britannia Tubular Bridge.
Our illustration shows a view of the
Britannia Tubular Bridge over the
"Menai Strait, which latter separates the
island of Anglesea from North Wales.
The bridge is on the Chester and Holy-
head Railway and was built in 1845 by
Robert Stephenson. It is really two
bridges composed of four tubes each,
the center ones being 460 feet long.
The whole structure stands at a height
of 102 feet above high water mark. The
tower, which is built upon a small rock
near the center of the strearn, is called
the Britannia tower, and the height of
the tube here is 30 feet; it diminishes to
22 ft. 9 in. at the abutments. The bot-
tom of the bridge is straight, while the
top is made in the form of a true para-
bolic curve. The interior width is
13 ft. 8 ins., and the total length is 1,841
feet. The sides of the tubes are wrought
iron plates riveted together, but the top
and bottom are composed of a number
of smaller tubes or cells, which give
additional stififness to the whole tube.
The bed plates in the shore towers and
limit. We need intelligent men to-day
more than ever to make our railways suc-
cessful. No sane man will take up an
engineer's profession, or any other, that
prevents him from making a living at it
after he has reached the age of 35, he
really enters the prime of life then.
What is there about a locomotive en-
gineer's profession that he should hear
a watch tick forty inches from the ear?
Why, 90 per cent, of our male population
can't accomplish that feat, and I doubt
if their friend (?), the originator of the
clause in their rules, could hear one at
that distance.
Has it not a tendency to make the
medical examiner — if he is a man with
lots of ambition but little practice — dis-
honest? I have heard of just such ?
case. No doubt the management wants
to be fair, but certainly the conditions
have been misrepresented to them. Not
a click around an engine escapes the ex-
perienced engineer, and still he may be
unable to hear his watch away from his
ear. If he should conclude to follow
some other business at 35 or later (and
their business, you can find lots of them
every month in Railway and Locomo-
tive Engineering — and the results will
amply repay you in better service and
increased revenue. An ignorant man has
no business on a railway. The public
asks and pays for first-class service, and
you can only accomplish it by employing
intelligent men to man your engines.
Ignorance and a stake road go hand in
hand. You don't want that kind of a
reputation. Don't discourage but en-
courage the coming generation and take
care of the good men of to-day. Be fair
if you want results. J. A. Baker.
A Unique City by=the=Sea.
Atlantic City has no season. It is
perennial. It has broken a tradition
that a seashore resort is necessarily a
summer resort. It took daring and im-
agination on the part of the first man
who decided to spend his winter vacation
at a famed summer place, and even
more of the same quality on the part of
the hotel keeper who decided to keep his
house open to provide lodgings for
BRITANNIA TUBULAR BRIDGE OVER THE MENAI STRAIT.
in the abutments on which the tubes
rest, move freely on cast-iron rollers and
balls. The difTerence between the sum-
mer and winter lengths is fully 12 inches.
The total weight of iron used was nearly
12,000 tons, of which the tubes contain
about 9,360. There are 1,015 tons of cast-
iron used, and 175 tons of permanent rail-
way, and it is said that more than two
millions of rivets were used. The total
cost was about $2,919,700. It was com-
pleted in less than five years. It was in
March, 1850, that the first train passed
through the bridge. In our illustration
the spectator is supposed to be on the
island and is looking toward Caernar-
vonshire, across the strait.
Be Fair and Just.
Are not some of our railways of to-day
making a serious mistake in adopting the
harsh measures accredited to them?
Will it not have a tendency to turn our
bright young men to other pursuits, un-
less these restrictions are removed? I
refer to the hearing test and the age
he invariably makes a failure at any-
thing else), he has lost out entirely be-
cause the pension clause puts tne
limit at 35 at which he could be re-
employed. Did you ever hear of a man
being old at'35 in any other profession?
Grand idea that pension, but put it after
35 instead of 70. Very few men will live
to see 70, and run our battle-ships of
to-day. If the pension must stand, why
not insert a clause, that a man hired after
35 shall not be entitled to one? Don't
ask him to be physically perfect, an ac-
cident on your own line, over which he
had no control, may have made him
otherwise. A much better plan would be
to rid yourself of incompetents, gamblers
and saloon habitues, if you have any,
and hire good men. Again, you can ele-
vate the morals and standing of your
men by starting local clubs, which every
engineman should be expected to join.
Make your master mechanic the official
head, and have him preside over them.
Start topical discussions pertaining to
whoso might follow in the trail blazed by
the daring innovator. The experiment
succeeded a decade ago. The Gulf
Stream made it so. Geographically At-
lantic City is the most favored resort on
the North Atlantic Coast. Its great tem-
perature regulator is the Gulf Stream,
which approaches the land nearer at this
point than at any other place north of
the Carolina coast. Thus the ocean
winds that come breezing out of the east
are tempered to the winter sojourner
and made almost balmy and free from
chill.
There are fun and amusement a-plenty
for the person who is seeking recreation
and not health. The Casino has an e.x-
cellent ballroom, and a commodious
white marble swimming pool of sea
water, warmed to a comfortable tem-
perature for bathing, no matter what the
season. There are bowling alleys and
sun parlors with commanding views of
the ocean and esplanade. Three long
ocean piers are additional places of re-
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
193
What Is
A Lubricant?
Lubricant: Anything that
lubricates ; specifically, a
substance, as graphite, oil,
or grease, used to diminish
the friction of the working
parts of machinery.
—5 TA NDA RD DIC TIONA R Y
Lubricant: That which
lubricates ; specifically, a
substance as oil, grea^se,
plumbago, etc., used for
reducing the friction of the
working parts of machin-
ery.
— WEBSTER'S DICTIONARY
The highest authorities
consider graphite as a lu-
bricant and as the finest
solid lubricant known to
science or practice. Other
solids, such as lead, soap-
stone, mica, etc., may help
to fill up the microscopical
inequalities of bearing sur-
faces, but have no lubrica-
ting value.
Dixon's flake graphite
not only fills up all such
inequalities, but fills them
better and forms a veneer-
like surface on the bearing
parts of marvelous smooth-
ness and freedom from
friction.
Samples and booklet
free to those interested.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.,
Jersey City, N. J.
sort anrl amusement. They are kept
comfortably heated when the tempera-
ture demands. For the large contingent
who devote their time to outdoor sports
there are the golf links. — New York Post.
The New Jersey Central has a double
daily service to Atlantic City from New
York, leaving the latter city from foot
of Liberty street at 9:40 a. m., 3:40 p. m.
Send to C. M. Burt, General Passenger
Agent, New York, for illustrated Book-
let and Time Table. It's free for the
asking.
"She Walks the Waters Like a Thing
of Life."
We are indebted to the master me-
chanic of the Ohio River Division of the
picturesque B. & O. for the photograph
from which our illustration was made.
The high water, which was something
over 10 inches, covered the track, as
shown, on March 3 of this year. The
A Useful Device for Railroads.
The Railway Critic informs us that
"A modern development of the old-fash-
ioned hydraulic ram in the form of a
direct-acting machine, utilizing all the
force of the water feeding is one of the
latest contributions to railroad equip-
ment. The machine, known as the
Niagara hydraulic engine, is rapidly sup-
planting the steam pump and the neces-
sary boiler, and coal supply at tank sta-
tions, and is being utilized to furnish
water for general locomotive work. This
machine needs no engineer and fireman
to run it. An occasional glance from a
section boss is all that is required, and
the greenest hand in the section gang
can regulate it to pump all the water re-
quired for the tank. Railroad tanks are
located where running streams may be
depended upon for a water supply, and
here one of these engines can be installed
for less than the annual pay for a compe-
WADIXG PAST THE ROUND HOUSE, KNEE DEEP.
photograpli was taken in front of the
Parkersburg, W. Va„ shop of the Balti-
more & Ohio, and gives us a passenger
train "passing through the deep." The
wave which flows off from the pilot is
very like the waves which, originate as
the bow of a fast steamer cuts through
the briny. The solitary figure on the
left is that of our friend, the M. M., who
appears to be standing in rubber boots
nearly knee deep, and waiting, not for
the clouds, but for the waves to roll by.
We have not been informed whether the
engineer took advantage of this state of
affairs and scooped up some water
into the tank, for the pumping of which
the company had not been compelled to
pay. It must have been a unique experi-
ence for all concerned.
tent engineer. For electric railways the
supply of water for power-house pur-
poses is satisfactorily accomplished at
little expense by one of these engines,
and for the sprinkling of tracks or toll-
roads the installation of one of these ma- \
chines will save its cost in meter charges
in a single year."
There is nothing innocent or good that
dies and is forgotten. Let us hold to
that faith or none.— Old Curiosity Slwfi.
The Allis-Chalmers Company will on
May I remove their general offices from
the present location in the Home Insur-
ance Buildin-g to the New York Life
Building, corner of Monroe and La
Salle streets, Chicago. The .Allis-Chal-
mers Company has for the past two
years been expending large sums of
money for betterments at their various
plants in Milwaukee, Chicago and Scran-
ton, so as to secure the best possible
ser\-ice in point of economy and quick
delivery. To give a fair idea of the
194
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April. 1903.
scope of the business conducted by the
AHis-Chalmers Company, we are in-
formed that during the past two months
orders for either engines, mining ma-
chinery, rock crushing machinery, saw
mill machinery, or flour mill machinery
were booked from every State in the
Union, besides the following foreign
countries: England. South Africa,
Mexico, Canada, Chili, Central America,
Brazil, West Australia, Turkey, Finland,
Yukon Territory, Belgium, British Col-
umbia, Bolivia, Hawaiian Islands, Peru,
Alaska, China and the Philippine Isl-
ands.
such as Mr. Holden's heavy suburban
engine now running on the Great East-
ern of England. The formula is:
An Irishman was filling barrels with
water from a small river to supply a
village which was not provided with
waterworks. As he halted to give his
horse a rest a gentleman rode up and
asked:
"How long have you been hauling
water, my good man?"
"Tin years or more, sor."
"Ah! And how many loads do you
make a day?"
"From tin to fifteen, accordin' to the
weather, sor."
"Well, Pat," said the gentleman,
laughing, "how much water have you
hauled altogether?"
The Irishman jerked his thumb in the
direction of the river, at the same time
giving his horse the hint to start, and
replied:
"All the wather that yez don't see
there now, sor." — Chums.
Steel Shutters.
The catalogue of the Columbus Steel
Rolling Shutter Company, of Columbus,
Ohio, show the form of construction
mechanism and uses of the steel rolling
doors. The construction of the slats is
very ingenious; on the weather side there
are no pockets or recesses for the ac-
cumulation of water, dirt, snow or sleet.
The rounded cylinder formation which
is necessary at each edge of the slat
does not weaken or crack the metal at
the joint and such slats are also not
liable to spring and thus successfully re-
sist wind pressure and general hard
usage. They can be readily used for
round-house doors, and their vertical
lift does away with the danger of swing-
ing or being blown against a moving
engine. Unlike the ordinary hinged
engine-house door, these steel ones can-
not gape open at the top, and allow an
inrush of cold air. This form of con-
struction can be used as a fireproof
shutter on windows. A copy of the cata-
logue, or other information may be had
by applying to the company.
It may be interesting to some of our
readers to know the formula for calcu-
lating the tractive power of a locomotive
with three simple cylinders of equal size
T = 2 of
d' X s X p
D
where d is the diameter of the cylinder
in inches, s is the stroke, /> is the
mean effective pressure in the cylinder,
and D is the diameter of the driving
wheels in inches.
The Joseph Dixon Crucible Co., of Jer-
sey City, have a set of pencils made spe-
cially for the use of car inspectors. They
are like two Woods who were examined
before a magistrate, both hale and hearty
men about eighty years old. The mag-
istrate found that the first one had never
smoked or used liquor, while the other
brother admitted that since manhood he
had seldom "gone to bed sober."
"Well," exclaimed the judge, "it seems
to me that the best way to preserve a
wood is to keep it very dry or very wet."
Those car inspectors' pencils are de-
signed to work very dry or very wet, and
they are good for it. The advertisement
department sent us a pair of these ver-
satile pencils in mistake, and they are
just the thing for marking copy. They
have the merit of leaving a plain mark
that stays there.
During the scarcity of anthracite a
good many people were compelled to
burn soft coal in their house furnaces,
with the result that enormous quantities
of soot were deposited, because of the
difference in drafting required by each
kind of fuel. A remedy offered in the
daily press at the time was the use of a
little scrap zinc of any kind thrown on
the fire, and those who tried it appeared
to be satisfied. The vapor of zinc has
an affinity for carbon, and in passing
up the chimney causes a chemical reac-
tion to take place, and the soot disap-
pears. Of the resultant compounds one
goes out of the chimney with the smoke
and the other falls back and is eventu-
ally shoveled out with the ashes.
In the sequel to Alice in Wonderland
the White Knight who claimed to be of
an inventive turn of mind said to Alice,
"I heard him then, for I had just com-
pleted my design, to keep the Menai
bridge from rust by boiling it in wine."
This may have been a capital plan when
used amid the marvelous scenes through
which Alice traveled, but in the work-a-
day world as we know it the problem of
preserving steel cars has to be solved by
less expensive and less bibulous means.
The Protectus Company, of Philadel-
phia, have just sent their friends a neat
little card with a half-tone of the high
side steel hopper gondola recently de-
signed by Mr. Cornelius Vanderbilt,
Pneumatic
Tools.
HAMMERS, DRILLS, RIVETERS
HOISTS AND
METAL SAWING MACHINES
PNEUMATIC TOOLS
For Every Possible Use
SIMPLEST AND BEST
FEWINGS' CAR AND ENGINE
REPLACER
Will Stand the Weight of the
Heaviest Locomotive. Strong-
est and surest replacer in the
market.
DROP FORGE KNUCKLE PINS
Q. & C. BRAKE SHOE KEYS
GLOBE VENTILATORS
Send for Catalogs on Track,
Locomotive and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with the Q. & C. Co.
GENERAL OFFICES, Old Colony Building
...CHICAGO...
New York Office, 114 Liberty Street
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
«95
^:^
wliicli has been coated with Protcctus
paint. This material is used on trucks,
bolsters, bridges, and in fact anywhere
where steel is exposed. The trade mark
of this company is a black knight in full
armor, and his presence on the card sug-
gests the comparison between his prac-
tical and modern way of preventing rust,
with that of his amusing prototype in
Lewis Caroll's well known child's story.
Railroad Hospital.
An emergency hospital car has been
put in operation on the Delaware
Division of the Erie Railroad. It is said
that the Westfield accident prompted the
management of the Erie to make trial of
an hospital car. The car itself is equipped
with all the modern appliances of med-
icine and surgery. In the central portion
are six single iron cots, with woven
wire springs and hair mattresses, and
these beds are covered with soft all-wool
blankets, white sheets and each bed has
a rubber sheet and one feather pillow
incased. In an end compartment there
Endless Bed Timber Planer and Jointer.
We arc pleased to show our readers
in general and car builders in particular
a cut of a new machine especially de-
signed to meet the requirements of the
latter class. It is built for heavy surfac-
ing, on either one or both sides, as de-
sired. It works stock on two sides 30
inches wide and 14 inches thick, and will
plane in a very superior way the four
sides of a timber to 28 inches wide and
14 inches thick. It will plane at one op-
eration two sides and one edge of two
pieces up to 12 inches wide and 14 inches
thick. The feeding mechanism consists
of a traveling bed supported on four
steel-faced ways, over which are placed
two divided rollers, and under these two
boards of unequal thickness can be placed
and fed at the same time.
The cylinders, pressure bars and rolls
have easy, quick and accurate adjust-
ments, with a view of making all as
labor-saving as possible, and when
necessary to change the thickness of the
material being worked it can be done
ENDLESS BED TIMBER PLANER AND JOINTER.
is a complete surgical outfit consistmg
of an operating table, towels, basins,
brushes and all necessary appliances.
Another feature of the car is its equip-
ment with tools tor the use of workers
at a wreck. There are saws, axes, chains
and hooks, ropes, shovels, crowbars and
pickaxes. A Babcock fire extinguisher
for hand use has been provided. It is
said that if this car proves its usefulness
another may be put on the Buffalo
Division.
An Optical Illusion.
Box Tunnel between Bath and Bristol
in England is not only perfectly straight,
but the railway track is perfectly flat
also. When you approach the yawning
mouth of the tunnel all is black and dis-
mal-looking; but immediately you enter
the dark portal you see the other end of
the tunnel, some three miles away, and
so near does it appear that you can ap-
parently emerge at the other end in a
few steps. But as you proceed the other
end gradually recedes, and by the time
you are half way through it is quite
small. The illusion is very curious. —
Queensland Railway Times.
from the operating end of the machine
without loss of time. Feeds from 40
feet per minute and up are furnished, as
desired.
The makers of this labor-saving ma-
chine, J. A. Fay & Egan Co., of No. 445
West Front street, Cincinnati, Ohio, will
be glad to hear from those interested, to
whom they will send full details and
terms, together with cuts showing the
machine to advantage. Their new 450-
page catalogue showing and describing
every machine they make, will also be
furnished on application to those writing
for it.
Ancient and Modern Books.
Ecclesiastes, or the Preacher, has said,
"of making many books there is no end;
and much study is a weariness of the
flesh." There are some people who are
inclined to quote this saying in dispar-
agement of books in general and of all
study. The saying no doubt applied in
ancient days, but the "books" were then
very different from what they are to-day.
They were then much more difficult to
write, and it is perfectly fair to suppose
that the authors were not specialists on
the subjects they wrote on in the sense
196
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
that they are to-day, aiid, moreover, it
wasn't everyone who could read the so-
. called books when they were written.
To-day the making of books is without
end just as the Preacher said, but the
study of the wonderful laws of nature
as presented in modern books is by no
means a weariness of the flesh. As a
matter of fact, for a seeker after truth,
it is a downright pleasure to read, and
so drink in accurate knowledge. The air
brake, the distribution of steam, and its
action in the cylinder, and hundreds of
other things which the railroad man en-
counters in his daily life, depend upon
the action of the laws of nature. Look
over the subjoined list of books and see
for yourself if the study of them is likely
to be wearisome. Using, good, accu-
rately written books will be found to be
a healthy, bracing mental exercise by
means of which the mind grows stronger
by the understanding of facts. To read
intelligently now-a-days is to gain knowl-
edge.
A year's subscription to Railway
AND Locomotive Engineering costs
only $2.00, and the paper is a welcome
visitor in every household, especially
where there are children.
"The World's Railway" is a most in-
teresting history of railways and locomo-
tives. It is beautifully illustrated and the
net price used to be $10.00. We now
give it and a year's subscription to the
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
for $5.00.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very lielpful book, combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particu-
larly useful book to the young mechanic.
It has a stimulating effect in inducing
young men to study their business. Price,
50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers likely to
be hired. It contains in small compass a
wonderful amount of information about
the locomotive. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recommend this book.
Price, 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book v ill instruct a man so that he
will understand the construction and
operation of a compound locomotive as
well as he now understands a simple
engine. Tells all about running, about
breakdowns and repairs. Convenient
pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant" Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horsepower, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list of its contents, question and
answer style. 128 pages. Pocket size,
50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a forman boilermaker. Also contains
several chapters on oil-burning locomo-
tives. SO cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. $1.00.
"Macjiine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can aflford to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of com-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily un-
derstood by every intelligent fireman. 50
cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons
trying to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. Cloth, 75 cents. Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehen-
sive treatise on the subject. Ought to
be studied by all trainmen where block
signals are used. $3.00.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
We regret that owing to the vast
amount of detail work connected with
our air brake chart, our engravers were
not able to get it ready to issue with the
March number. The chart accompanies
this paper, and any one who by accident
or otherwise fails to receive a copy is
requested to notify us of the fact.
Good Tools
We don't say that other pneu-
matic tools are not good — we
know they are good. But we
must have a standard for com-
parison.
What we say is that the differ-
ence in cost of work done be-
tween merely "good" pneu-
matic tools and
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
will often make the difference
between success and failure.
There's no easier way to make
a tremendous mistake than by
buying "good" tools.
Are you making it .'
Send for our new catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
2 1 St St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Francisco Boston
lOE
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
"97
Mr. Air-Brake
Inspector
As you are interested in
obtaining the most efficient
service from your air-brake
equipment, it will pay you
to test
NON-FLUID OIL
AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT
especially during winter,
when ordinary oils and
greases freeze and refuse
to afford proper lubrica-
tion, thereby impeding the
operation of the cylinders.
Non-fluid oil is also espe-
cially valuable on triple-
valves
FREE SAMPLES FOR TRIAL FUR-
NISHED GRATIS, BY PREPAID EXPRESS
NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY
LUBRICANT COMPANY
MAKKKS OF
"THE AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT"
14 and 16 Church Street
NEW VORK CITY
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works :
EPRINQFIELD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
A. B.C. and Luber^s Codt uted.
English OfBce : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
ion's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott^nstrassc 112, Dusseldort,
Germany.
LONG JOBS MADE SHORT
Armstrong Gang Planer Tool
IT will suifiice large castiiipa
in 50 to 75 per cent, lessti me than
with an ordinary planer tool.
This tool has done a
VA HOUR JOB
in
23 MINUTES
Write for Catillog
IIR«ISIRONGBROS.IOOlGO.|lia^
'*The Tool HoUier People,'
635 Austin A\enii<\
CHICAGO, U.S.A.
It is occasionally quite possible in rail-
way shop equipment to save money and
buy "something just as good." At the
Elizabetliport shops of the Central Rail-
road of New Jersey there is an example
of this. Instead of buying an expensive
receptacle for the acid used in cleaning
the brass work from the interior of pas-
senger cars, a cheap but satisfactory sub-
stitute has been installed. A plate of
thick common glass such as is used for
lighting rooms beneath the sidewalk was
bedded in concrete, and upon this two
lengths of large vitrified sewer tile were
placed with flare ends uppermost. The
joints were run with sulphur, and a satis-
factory vat for strong acid was thus
secured. The tiles being over and above
after the sewer for which they were in-
tended had been built, were like good
material found upon the scrap pile.
naturalist on II. M.S. Beagle. It was on
the cruise of this ship that Darwin was
brought into close contact with nature,
and his careful and minute observation at
this time laid the foundation for his no-
table works, the "Origin of Species" and
the "Descent of Man." Incidentally it
may be mentioned that Darwin was not
responsible lor the popular view of his
celebrated theory. He did not believe
the human race had sprung from mon-
keys, but that man and the higher apes
had sprung from a common ancestor.
The Bullock Electric Company will be
happy to send any of the cards of their
interesting series to those interested
enough to apply to their office at Cin-
cinnati, Ohio.
The Union Switch & Signal Com-
pany's Bulletin No. 11 deals with con-
tinuous light semaphore spectacles. The
object of these spectacles is briefly to
display the normal night indication
whether it be the "danger" or the "cau-
tion" indication until the semaphore arm
has traveled more than two-thirds of its
arc toward the "clear" position. To pre-
vent the display of a "clear" night indi-
cation under similar conditions, and also
to prevent the total eclipse of the sig-
nal light at any point in the transit of
the signal from one indication to an-
other. These are very important points
in a night signal. In the daytime an
engineman can easily determine by the
angle the arm makes with the post what
signal is intended to be given, but at
night he must depend entirely upon the
light. The company will be happy to
send this bulletin to any inquirer who
will write to them, at Swissvale, Pa.
It is not surprising that more than
twelve thousand out of the one hundred
and sixty-eight thousand men on the pay-
rolls of the United States Steel Corpora-
tion have applied already for stock under
the generous profit sharing plan which
has been laid before them. The recently
published figures of the gross and net
earnings of this colossal organization are
so impressive that the eagerness of the
wage workers for a part of the gains is
natural and commendable. — New York
Tribune.
The Bullock Electric Manufacturing
card calendar for March has been re-
ceived. It is one of a series in which
a few words of biographical history con-
cerning eminent scientific men is given.
The March card is about Charles Dar-
win. He was educated at Edinburgh
and Cambridge, and was only an aver-
age student. His scientific career prac-
tically began when he was appointed
Four large freight locomotives belong-
ing to the Baltimore & Ohio were re-
cently engaged in what was most truly
an errand of mercy. Fire broke out in
the business portion of the town of
Mount Airy, which is described as a
thriving hamlet of about 3.000 inhabit-
ants. The town was without fire pro-
tection, and a strong wind was blowing
at the time of the fire. An appeal for
aid was sent to the town of Frederic,
twenty miles away. The Frederic fire
brigade were dispatched on a special
train and were able to check the spread
of the fire. Water was supplied to the
fire engine by four freight locomotives,
each having a 7,000-ganon tank. The
supply was kept up by these engines, one
or two at a time going for water to near-
by stations, while the others remained on
the spot and allowed the HiO contents
of their tanks to be emptied on the flames
by the busy little "steamer" from Fred-
eric.
We have been informed by the E. J.
Ward Company that they have turned
over to the Railway Appliances Company
their car vestibule diaphragm business
and have withdrawn themselves entirely
from that department of railway sup-
plies. The Railway Appliances Com-
pany have purchased the entire stock
of diaphragms, material and machinery
and removed the manufacture to Chi-
cago Heights, where they have increased
facilities for doing this business. The
E. J. Ward Company, it will be remem-
bered, have been the pioneers in the
canvas diaphragm business, making car
vestibule diaphragms of all varieties.
• They have introduced the riveted dia-
phragm made under their patents,
which, together with other forms, has
been transferred to the Railway Appli-
ances Company.
To Reduce Noise.
Mr. F. W. Everett, acting superin-
tendent of the New York Central, has
issued a circular which is intended to re-
198
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
duce noise at the company's terminal
stations. Among other things the cir-
cular calls attention to the noise caused
by rough handling of cars, men shouting
instead of giving signals by hand or
lamp, car inspectors and oilers letting
journal-box lids close with a bang,
unnecessary bell-ringing, the boisterous
and wasteful pop, and the general all-
round reduction of loud talking is re-
quired. The elimination of noise may
also have a money value, because if no
unnecessary noise-producing violence is
permitted wear and tear will be reduced,
all of which will add to the comfort of
patrons of the road and incidentally tend
in the direction of economy.
National Malleable lron = Brake Jaw and
Dead Lever Quide.
The devices shown in the accompany-
ing illustrations are. Fig. i, the Brake
Jaw, and Fig. 2, the Dead Lever Guide.
The principal feature common to both is
the method of attaching the rod. This is
done without welding, which is necessary
where a forged rod or guide is used. A
connection is thus insured which is ab-
solutely reliable, all welding being dis-
pensed with, the danger of accident from
imperfect welding is thus avoided, the
rod does not require upsetting to form
a head, and it is not necessary to drill
connection pin holes.
The application of the rod to the jaw
is very simple. The jaw is slipped onto
the rod through one of the two parallel
holes in the end of the casting, then the
end of the rod is bent into the form of a
pot hook over a mandrel and slipped
through the other parallel hole. The
end is then slightly bent over to prevent
the jaw slipping back. That the jaw is
sufficiently strong and can absolutely be
relied on will be seen from the following
report of test made at the Rose Poly-
technic Institute:
"The jaw was fitted with a 3-4-inch
iron rod, and with the stub end of a
lever fitted in the end between the jaw.
It was then put in a Rhiele testing ma-
chine and the pulling strain applied. The
iron rod broke at 22,500 pounds. A bar
of crucible steel was then applied in-
stead of the 3-4-inch iron, and the jaw
again submitted to the pulling of the
machine. This crucible steel broke at
35,100 pounds strain, and we were un-
able to find anything sufficiently strong
to hold the jaw to the breaking point of
the casting. At the conclusion of the
test the jaw was apparently in good con-
dition, with the e-xception that the holes
for the pin were slightly elongated, but
not sufficiently so as to cause any diffi-
culty in removing the pin."
These jaws and dead lever guides have
been in service for five years, and a
broken one, it is said, has never been
reported, although there are at the pres-
ent time over one hundred thousand of
them in use. Many railroads and pri-
vate car lines in all sections of the coun-
try are now using these jaws. The jaws
and guides can be furnished for 3-4-inch,
7-8-inch and i-inch rods, and the jaws
with either one or two connection pin
holes. Prices and any further informa-
tion will gladly be furnished on applica-
-^^
/V
-::
::
::::::
^
Bairs Official R. R.
Standard Watches
AND
SIZE,
17 AND 21 BUBY
JEWELS,
SAPPmEE PALLETS
BALLS IMPROVED
SAFETY
DOUBLE ROLLER
Are without question
the finest watches that
American talent and
sliillcd labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing Buch universal sat-
isfaction that we have
no hesitancy in claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests severe and numerous have proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent iu nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
Write us for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
NATIONAL DEAD LEVER GUIDE.
tion by The National Malleable Castings
Company, of Cleveland, Ohio, by whom
these devices are manufactured.
Ensure freedom from vibration — hold
the work firmly— feed steadily past
knives which travel a constant path.
Japanese Description of Train
novements.
The Japanese are said to acquire for-
eign languages very readily, but they
sometimes conclude prematurely that
they understand a language when they
have only learned the meaning of iso-
lated words. The Railroad Gazette has
picked up a Japanese railroad advertise-
ment which reads: "The through train
services between two terminals of Osaca
Send for booklet telling
more about them. . . .
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
VINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGlLL BUILDING, WftSHINGTON, D. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sent.
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
199
FOR SALE
FREIGHT, PASSENGER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
O AND
A>->- ^ADC 4UICK
SIZES. W>^IA0 DELIVERIES
F.-M. HICKS,
315 DIARBORN ST.
CHICASO, ILL.
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
ovcrclothcs. ^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best.
— always fit and
tion.
Easy to wear
give satisfac-
Made in one of the best
■hops in the country.
Union of course. .^ ^
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TEHDEW.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. 140 Third Street. Louisville, Ky.
and Nagoya are operated five times, of
which two being the express train
from either terminus per day, with all
the carriages of bogie system which ac-
company a uniformed attcndcnt and
provision sellars making themselves to
be useful."
The Chicago Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany report that the removal of their
factory at Aurora, 111., to Cleveland, C,
and its consolidation with the Cleveland
plant, has been definitely decided upon,
and tlic alteration will take place in the
near future. This move has been under
contemplation for some time, and will,
when consumated, undoubtedly result in
benefit to both the Chicago Pneumatic
Tool Company and its numerous patrons.
The consolidation not only makes more
economical production possible, but will
also largely increase the output. The
constantly increasing business of the
company has shown conclusively for
some time past that it would be neces-
the Union Pacific, the Oregon Short
Line, and the Oregon Railroad and
Navigation Company's lines. Numerous
illustrations of the principal buildings
of the important cities passed through
on the trip are shown, and many of the
natural wonders of the country arc re-
produced in full page half-tones which
have all the detail of good photographs.
The book is really a reference album of
the country. Two views of the famous
Shoshone Falls, on the Snake River,
Idaho, are worthy of mention. This
river descends 500 feet in four miles in
this vicinity, the actual fall itself being
225 feet in one leap. "All about is vol-
canic-rock, wild lava fields and desola-
tion." The Giant Geyser, in the Yel-
lowstone National Park, closes the in-
teresting series. This book may be had
on application to the company.
The Pressed Steel Car Company, of
Pittsburgh, Pa., have issued a statement
to the stockholders signed liy the audi-
N.\TIONAL BRAKE JAW.
sary to largely increase facilities in order
to adequately fulfil requirements, and
it is hoped that this move will have the
desired eflfect.
tor, from which it appears that the sur-
plus earnings for the year 1902 reached
the extraordinary figure of $3,403,114.
The Pressed Steel Car Company is evi-
dently enjoying prosperous times.
President Roosevelt has signified his
purpose to attend the Eleventh Inter-
national Railroad Conference of the
Young Men's Christian Associations at
Topeka, Kan., April 30-May 3. The
President's well-known interest in
railroad men has undoubtedly influenced
him to accept the invitation to meet this
body of men who represent the vigorous
type of manhood which he admires.
Among the speakers secured in addition
to the President are: Dr. Elmore Harris,
Dr. P. S. Henson. President Ramsey, of
the Wabash: Governor Bailey, of
Kansas; General Manager Mudge. of
the Santa Fe. and Rev. Chas. M. Shel-
don. Col. John J. IMcCook will be the
presiding officer.
The Pratt & Whitney Company, of
Hartford, Conn., have issued a folder
in which they show a picture of the build-
ing which they have just added to their
small tool department. This addition
they say fully doubles their capacity, as
the plant is thoroughly equipped
throughout. They make in this depart-
ment taps, reamers, ratchet drills, mill-
ing cutters, punches and dies, Echols'
patent taps, with interrupted threads,
suitable for tough steel, copper, etc.
They make gauges of all kinds.
The Union Pacific have issued a very
handsome scenic guide book called
".Across the Continent." which illus-
trates an overland trip from the Missouri
River to the North Pacific Coast, via
A favorite pastime of transcontinental
travelers is counting the number of tele-
graph poles in a mile, and then figuring
on how many seconds ought to be con-
sumed between telegraph poles to rep-
resent a given speed. On the Lacka-
wanna and on the Nickel Plate there
are 40 telegraph poles to the mile. Some
of the Western lines use 25.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
Australia's Climbing Frogs.
It is said that one of the great enemies
of the overland telegraph line in Central
Australia is the common green frog. In
order to save the insulators from being
broken by the lightning they are pro-
vided with wire "droppers" leading round
them at a little distance to conduct on to
the iron pole in case of need. The frogs
climb the poles and find the insulators
cool and pleasant to their bodies, and
fancy that the "dropper" is put there to
furnish them with a back seat. After a
nap they yawn and stretch out a leg until
it touches the pole — result, sudden death
to the frog, and as the body continues to
conduct the current to earth, we have a
paragraph in the papers to the effect that
"in consequence of an interruption to the
lines probably caused by a cyclonic dis-
turbance in the interior, we are unable to
present our readers with the usual cables
from England." — Argonaut.
The Stannard & White Company, of
Racine Junction, Wis., make camp cots
for the United States Army, and they
look to be very comfortable. We mean
the cots look comfortable, though as we
wrote it down we certainly said the army
looked comfortable, which they no doubt
are, having these cots. This firm now
makes twenty different styles and sizes
of locomotive cab seats, so that "all sorts
and conditions of men" may be accom-
modated, and all sorts of cabs may be
suited, and we have no doubt that the
users of these seats will not only look
comfortable, but will be comfortable.
The company will be very pleased to
send catalogue and full particulars to any
one who writes them to do so.
It will be remembered that the loco-
motive engineers of the Erie Railroad
built an engine for the exhibition at the
Columbian Exhibition at Chicago, held
in 1893. It was supposed to be the em-
bodiment of practical locomotive design
from the runners' standpoint. This en-
gine was subsequently bought by the
Erie, and it is said, will be put in service
between Jersey City and Nyack hauling
a local train.
"California in a Tourist Sleeper" is
the title of a booklet published by the
Santa Fe. It is quaintly illustrated with
pen sketches printed in dull red and half-
tones showing comforts of the tourist
sleeper. The chapters are only a page
long and there are only eight of them.
A time table and tarifif of berth rates are
given, together with a list of the com-
pany's agents and a map of the road. A
copy will be sent on application to the
company. We may mention that the
New York office is at 377 Broadway.
A press report says that one man was
killed and another severely scalded as
the result of blowing out four plugs in
the cylinder of a freight engine on the
New York, New Haven and Hartford
Railroad. We suspect that instead of
cylinder plugs they were plugs in the
boiler-head that close up the openings
of the tub'is supporting the brick arch.
The Norton patent ball-bearing jacks
and the "sure drop" track jacks, manu-
factured by A. O. Norton, of 286 Con-
gress street, Boston, are listed in the 1903
catalogue, just issued. All sizes and all
kinds of Norton jacks are represented
there. A picture showing four men tug-
ging at the jack bars of two old-fash-
ioned bottle jacks raising a box car is
humorously contrasted with two men
using two of the Norton car jacks to do
the same work. These men are each
only using one hand, and they look
happy, thus is comment rendered su-
perfluous. Among the jacks shown are
those of the traversing kind with steel
base, jacks for general purposes, those
with hook for ground lift and handy lit-
tle car inspectors' or journal jacks, track
jacks, etc. The catalogue will be sent
to those interested if they will apply to
Mr. Norton.
Shakespeare talks of something that
"murders sleep," yet the great dramatist
never heard the discordant noise made
by the porter pushing up the upper berth
of a sleeping car. The sound assassin-
ates every vestige of repose remaining
in the brain of a weary traveler.
Jenkins Brothers' catalogue for 1903
shows that they have establishments in
New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Chi-
cago, and London. The catalogue is
profusely illustrated with engravings
showing every description of valve made.
— Graber water gauge, gauge cocks, in-
jectors, pump valves, Jenkins' standard
'96 packing, gaskets, gasket-tubing,
valve stem packing, union rings, water-
cock washers, steam traps, valve files,
pipe hangers, and, in fact, everything
connected with pipes and pipe work,
boiler attachments, etc. The firm will
be happy to forward copy of the cat-
alogue to anyone who is interested
enough to apply. The address of their
New York establishment is 71 John
Street.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OmCES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis : Terminal Station.
lAYLUR YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's ::H'Ssi':ed--' Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steals
THESE aoODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Bole Representative!* in the United States,
Canada and Hexico
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
iSo. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
FITZ'HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EOlllPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of service
CARS, FREIGHT, PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Monadnock BIdg., Chicago IJl Broadway, New York
The Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany reports that its sales for December
exceeded those of any other month but
one in its history, and a number of large
orders for pneumatic tools which had
, , ,, ^■^ u ^u c „k „c 4.i,» We make 20 different styles end sizes of locomotive Cab
been held over until alter the hrst Ot the seats. Send for Catalogue with full particulars.
year have already been received and STANNARD & WHITE CO.,
executed by this company. A feature of Racine Junction, Wis.
April, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smoke.
ContalnB about 800 practical questions and
their answers on the Science of Steam
MakiDK. By Wm. M. Bakh. The necessary
conditions for the Economic Firing of a
Locomotive are explained. 85 illustrations.
34g pages. Cloth, |i. 50-
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By Robert H. Bi.ackai.i.. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Air-Hrake
•quipment, containing: over 1,000 questions
and their answers on the Westlnghouie
Alr-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Alr-Krake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearlv every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
964 pages. Cloth, $t. 50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By Robert Urimshaw. It asks i,6oo
questions and gives 1.600 simple, plain,
&ractlcal answers about the Locomotive.
o mathematics, no theories— /wi^/ facts.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
paees, over 300 Illustrations, and 12 large
Folding Plates. Bound In Maroon Clotn,
$3.00.
JSWA Special Circular 0/ Ihese Books Sent
on Request.
^^^Aft)f of ihese Books Prepaid to any
Address tn the world on Receipt of Price.
A6ENTS WANTED ^^oks'^ tSI^
sell at sight, and every Engineer,
Fireman and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books Is sent free on application.
Horman A. Henley & Co., Pablishers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, N.Y.
the Philadelphia Company's business,
which they speak of as being very grati-
fying to them, is the large increase in
railroad trade during the last six months
of 1902, not only in the United States,
but in Canada and Mexico.
We arc informed that this company
has arranged to double the size of its
offices in New York by renting addi-
tional room in the Singer Building, cor-
ner of Broadway and Liberty streets.
This is made necessary by the increas-
ing business in and around New York
city. An electrically driven air com-
pressor and a complete plant for testing
and exhibiting pneumatic tools of all
Uinds, in operation, will be installed. The
New York offices will continue under
ihe management of Mr. W. A. Battey,
assisted by Mr. James H. Beaubien. Or-
ders have been recently received by the
I'hiladelphia Pneumatic Tool Company
for complete equipments of pneumatic
tools for the National Railroad of
Mexico and for the Interoceanic Rail-
road of Mexico.
happy to give particulars of this valve
to any one who will write them on the
subject.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't g:ive
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
We are informed that it is the policy
of the United States Steel Corporation
to keep the price of steel rails within
moderate limit. Their sense of modera-
tion was lately displayed in raising the
price from $28 to $28.50 a ton. As it
costs about $14 to produce a ton, the
humor of the Steel Trust's sense of
moderation will be appreciated.
Passengers who travel from Chicago
to California by the magnificent Santa
Fe limited speak enthusiastically about
tlie electric lighting of the cars by the
Consolidated Railway Electric Lighting
and Equipment Company's system. The
difficulties which were encountered when
the system was first introduced have been
entirely overcome, and the lights are
just as reliable as those of an ordinary
dwelling. Quite a number of private
cars belonging to Santa Fe officials have
had this system of lighting installed,
which is an excellent testimony to the
merits of the svstem.
The Crosby Steam G^uge and Valve
Company, of Boston, Mass., have issued
a folder in which the Crosby spring-seat
valve is explained by cut and letter press.
The novelty in this valve is that a section
of the face and seat is conical like the
letter A, which is said to give a double
seating capacity which prevents leaking.
A small groove cut in the apex of the
cone permits of a springing action, but
prevents any jambing when the valve is
closed, and this arrangement is useful
in allowing for any variation of tempera-
ture. The working parts of the valve
having been made by special machinery,
are interchangeable and easily remov-
able. The Crosby Company will be
Explosions of locomotive boilers are
becoming painfully numerous. During
the month of January we were informed
of about five explosions which resulted in
loss of life. The principal cause seems to
be broken staybolts. Broken staybolts
are much more dangerous in a boiler
carrying a pressure of 200 pounds to
the square inch than it is to a boiler
carrying 140 pounds gauge pressure.
Great Britain's Locomotives is the
title of a portfolio which has been issued
by the Locomotive Magazine of London.
There are in this convenient little linen-
covered case, twelve colored plates about
1IX12 inches, showing engines on the
leading English lines. There is also en-
closed a list of F. Moore's railway photo-
graphs and lantern slides. The colored
plates may be had at the office of Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering for
IS cents each or $1.00 for the complete
portfolio.
The world's longest tunnels are the
New York Rapid Transit, 32 miles; Met-
ropolitan, London, 13 miles; Simplon,
Switzerland, 12 miles; St. Gothard's,
Switzerland, 9 1-4 miles; Paris Under-
ground Railway, 8 1-2 miles, and Mount
Cenis, Switzerland, 7 1-2 miles. — Queens-
land Railway Times.
"Hard Water Made Soft" is the title
of a little pamphlet got out by the Indus-
trial Water Company, of 126 Liberty
street. New York. The pamphlet deals
with that company's method of water
softening and purifying apparatus.
Therein it is pointed out that no one
process in the world is exactly suited to
more than one particular kind of water.
The company states that they can ex-
tract oil from the water of condensation,
soften hard water, clean muddy or swamp
water and purify water which contains
acid. There does not appear to be any
hidden process involved, as the company
say they simply supply the machine and
allow the purchaser to buy soda ash and
quicklime in order to carry on the work.
The pamphlet will be sent to those who
ask or write to the company for a copy.
The Bible and the Empire State Express.
A Bible student has recently been fig-
uring on how long it would have taken
the people to make the journey from Dan
to Beersheba if they could have had the
benefit in the olden times of the Empire
State Express. He figured that the train
would have made this journey in less
than three hours, although from a read-
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
April, 1903.
ing of the account in the Bible one
would think it was a long journey, and it
was for those days with their limited
means of transportation. Ezekiel, the
Chaldean prophet, had in his mind's eye
something like the Empire State Express
when he uttered the words recorded in
the first chapter of his prophecy. Look
this up and see if you do not agree with
the idea. — From the Troy Daily Times.
The C. W. Hunt Company, of 45
Broadway, New York, have their works
and office on Staten Island. They have
recently got out a little publication which
they call Pamphlet No. 031. It gives
some applications of "Industrial" Rail-
ways, particularly the use of such a rail-
way in the boiler room. Several half-
tones illustrate the matter and are ac-
companied with explanatory reading
matter. Among other things the views
show the industrial railway in the
Brooklyn water works, the G. W. Wheel-
wright Company's plant, the Stanley
Rule and Level Company boiler room,
etc. The back shows standard track and
all sorts of cars, trucks, buckets, hop-
pers, ladels, etc., made for all sorts of
uses. Write the Hunt Company for
catalogue or full particulars if you are
interested.
The Pullman Palace Car Company
have arranged to reduce the working
hours in their shops from 60 to 54 hours
a week, making a nine-hour day. The
reduction of working hours afifects about
8,000 men.
The Anaconda Copper Mining Com-
pany is about to put in operation a new
S,ooo-ton-per-day reduction plant, which
will be equipped with electrical appar-
atus for power distribution. A recent
contract with the Westinghouse Elec-
tric & Manufacturing Co. embraces
seven motors of an aggregate of 185
horse power, to be added to the present
installation of about 30 Westinghouse
motors of an aggregate of over 1,000
horse power.
The Allis-Chalmers Company, of Chi-
cago, have taken a very appropriate way
of commemorating the opening of their
West Allis foundry, which occurred in
the latter months of igo2. This well-
known concern, which among other spe-
cialties makes the Gates rock crusher,
or what we may call a railway ballast
producer, is distributing among friends
a very handy paper weight in the form
of a little flat, hollow brick. It is com-
posed of bronze poured from the first
heat run in the West Allis shops. There
are two stamped medallions let into the
weight, one showing a perspective view
of the works and the other a likeness
of Mr. Edwin Reynolds, chief engineer,
who designed the plant. The paper
weight is nickel plated and has two con-
venient grooves for finger and thumb,
so that it may be readily picked up. It
will be found a very useful and hand-
some addition to the desk "furniture"
of the company's patrons and may be
had on application.
It is reported that the New York Cen-
tral has arranged for the services of
sixty surgeons who will live along the
line and be easily got at all the time.
Each physician will have charge of a
certain allotted length of line, and trains
will carry emergency cases and some
requisite surgical appliances.
At a recent meeting of the Board or
Directors of the Seamless Steel Tube
Company, of Detroit, Mich., Mr. W. C.
McMillan was re-elected president, Mr.
T. H. Simpson vice-president, Mr.
George M. Black secretary and treas-
urer, Mr. R. H. Phillips assistant secre-
tary, and Mr. C. H. Wood manager.
The Baldwin Record of Recent Con-
struction No. 40 is an illustrated reprint
of the paper read by Mr. W. J. Mc-
Carroll, before the Traveling Engineers'
Association, 1902. It is on the "proper
handling of compound locomotives." Il-
lustrations of the different positions of
valves and pistons of the Vauclain com-
pound are shown, the flow of high and
low pressure steam being represented by
colored engravings. It contains about
13 pages of reading matter and is uni-
form with the series which the Baldwin
people issue from time to time. The
booklet is useful for instruction and ref-
erence. Application to the Baldwin
Works, Philadelphia, is the way to get a
copy.
A. Leschen &, Sons Rope Co.,
Manufacturers
WIRE ROPE,
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE,
Fittings and Supplies.
HOME OFFICE:
920-922 North First St., ■ ST. LOUIS, MO.
( 135 E. Lake St.. Chicago, 111.
Branch Offices ! 92 Centre St., New York City, N.Y.
( S5 Fremont St., San Francisco, Cal.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
The steel mills at Homestead, Pa., by
the employment of 4.000 men and highly
perfected machinery, produce as much
steel as 13,000 men do 'in the Krupp
works, with crude machinery. That is
why steel can be made in America at less
cost than it can be made in any other
country.
It is stated in a press dispatch from
London that the amount awarded to the
Tafif-Vale Railway by the Court of
King's Bench is $115,000. The money
will have to be paid by the Amalgamated
Society of Railway Servants.
The draughting rooms of the engineer-
ing department, Pennsylvania Railroad,
in the Union Station, Pittsburg, have re-
cently been fitter throughout with the
Nernst lamp. The quality of this illumi-
nant is peculiarly suited to the require-
ments of draughtsmen, having a perfect
downward distribution of light, of day-
light quality, with an absence of shadow
or flicker.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. NEW YORK.
S. N. CLARKSON,
WHOLESALE JEWELER,
103 State Street, - Chicago, 111.
Hampden, 23 Jewels, $28.00.
Elgin. 21 " 25.75.
Waltham, 21 " 25.75.
Complete with dust proof silveriae case.
Special price this
month for B. of L. E.
or H. of L. F., iS size,
14 K. gold filled, screw,
dust proof cases, guar-
anteed 25 years, same
design as the cut.
Send a postal to-day
tor my igo3 catalogue
free. All goods at
wholesale prices. See
my newest designs of
jewelry and Brother-
hood pins and lapel
t)attoDs.
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation,
1137 THE ROOKERY. CHICAGO.
91 Broadway, New York. Park Buildins, Pittsburgh
31 Norfolk House, Loudon, Eng.
Inspection of Steel Rails. Splice Bars, Railroad Cars,
Wheels, Axles, etc. Chemical Laboratory— Anal y bis
of Ores, Iron, Steel, Oils, Water, etc. Physical Labo-
ratory—Test of MetiUs, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Ears, etc.
Efficiency Tests of Boilers, Kn^ines and LocomotiTos.
LSaWneerini
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.— J903 ^^^F ^^^
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, May, 1903
No. 5
ON COLORADO SPRINGS AND CRIPPLE CRKKK RAILWAY.
Qold Fields Scenic Railway.
The engraving shown is made from a
photograph of a scene on the Colorado
Springs & Cripple Creek District Rail-
way, which is famous for its magnificent
scenery. The ride of forty-five miles
from Colorado Springs to Cripple Creek
District is one panorama of Nature's
most gorgeous mountain and canon
scenery. The road is worthy of the rich
scenic and mineral attractions to which it
leads. The roadbed is of an ideal char-
acter, the track is made up of 75-pound
steel laid on broad ties as numerous as
could be put in, ballasted with disintegrat-
ed granite. The vice-president. Mr. Will-
iam Lennox, an Iowa man, is exceeding-
ly proud of the road, and he has good
cause for being so. Mr. Lennox left a
farm in Iowa thirty years ago to seek
health in Colorado, and, like many
others with the farmer training, he found
both health and fortune. Few men have
been more deserving of both blessings.
204
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
The "Third Man" on an Engine.
There is at the present time an agita-
tion in favor of seeking legislative en-
actment which will compel railroad com-
panies to place a special loolvout man on
every engine, in addition to the regular
"ngineer and fireman. This agitation is
no doubt the natural result of the recent
terrible railroad accidents, particularly
the one on the tracks of the Central Rail-
road of New Jersey, in which, it is said,
a caution and a stop signal were both
disregarded. . The fact that such a law,
if passed, would entail additional ex-
pense on railroad companies may pos-
sibly make it even more attractive in the
eyes of a certain section of the com-
munity. It is well, however, before any
such regulation receive government sanc-
tion, to consider the question from all
sides.
The public desires to have something
done to prevent danger signals being
passed, but it is by no means certain
that three men on an engine would be
the cure all, which many are disposed to
assert. We believe that the automatic
stop signal will come in time, for use on
crowded roads or where the fullest track
capacity is required, just as the high-
speed brake came in due time for very
fast trains which required maximum
stopping power, but in the meantime
would the "third man" give the security
desired?
In the first place, an engineer and
a lookout man on an engine would divide
responsibihty, and in times of emergency
it is quite conceivable that they might
misunderstand each other. There is also
the question of rank involved. One of
the men would be practically subordinate
to the other, even if the rule which placed
the third man on the engine gave him
equality of rank. The practical result
would be that either the engineer would
be really in charge of the engine or the
lookout man would be in charge, and
whoever was not in charge would occupy
a more or less advisory position. Two
men cannot run one engine satisfactorily
at the same time. There is also the
liability that two men who would have
to sit on the same side of the engine
might discuss the latest shop news. In
fact, the same objection to the "third
man" can be urged as is now assigned
for keeping passengers and others out
of the cab altogether — the presence of
some one else tends to distract the atten-
tion of the man doing responsible work.
Examples aie not wanting in which
accidents have occurred with extra men
on an engine. A collision took place at
Mud River, Pa., in 1888 in which 66 per-
sons lost their lives, and at the time there
was a pilot with the engineer in the cab.
In a collision at Monmouth, III., som.e
years ago, a prissenger train was wrecked
by running over a misplaced switch, with
engineer and road foreman of engines in
the cab at the time. There have been
serious accidents to double-header trains
due to the runner of each engine not act-
ing in unison, or viewing circumstances
differently when there is no time or op-
portunity for consultation or explanation.
It is open to grave question whether in
thus seeking to divide responsibility for
clear definite action in cab, those
favoring the "third man" may not in
reality be increasing the fallible "human
element" in the problem.
A Train is Harder to Push Than to
Pull.
A walking stick on end successfully
balanced on the finger, is a difficult f»at,
for the reason that the base of sup-
port has to be constantly moved in or-
der to keep it approximately under the
shifting center of gravity. This illus-
tration is, in a way, analogous to what
an engines tries to do when it backs a
train of cars along the track. If one
tries to push a cart along the roadway
one will find that it takes a lot of steer-
ing to do it. In the case of railway cars
there can be no such intelligent steering,
as the push is only delivered through the
coupling, and as this cannot be moved
to the right or left, it happens that the
necessary "steering" has to be done by
the rails, with additional flange friction.
If the balancing of one stick on the fin-
ger be a difficult task, the balancing of
a second on top of the first would be
still more diflicult, and when the analogy
is applied to the case of a long train,
it is easy to see that in order to keep
the backing train straight without the
aid of the track and flange friction the
engine would have to do such an amount
of "steering" as would be quite out of
keeping with its dignity as a steady-
going locomotive in good standing. It
is easy to draw a chain straight along
the ground over obstacles if need be,
but it would take a considerable expendi-
ture of power to push even a short chain
between the flanges of a steel channel,
supposing the chain fitted easily in the
steel shape and even if both were
well lubricated. This reason why a
train backs harder than it pulls will
furnish an additional cause for the slip-
ping of an engine while backing, which
has already been explained by J. A. B.
on page 181 of our April issue. The
transfer of weight from drivers to engine
truck and the large increase in flange
friction, both of which come into play
when an engine backs up, combine to
make the work of pushing very much
harder for the engine than the work of
pulling the same train over the same
piece of level track.
genial passenger agent figure, has found
its way into the public prints. The
points are briefly that the vaudeville actor
in question has two performing goats,
who, when before the footlights, enter-
tain the audience by eating what pur-
ports to be some of Uncle Sam's cur-
rency, whereupon the actor feigns dis-
pair at the untimely disappearance of his
hard-earned wealth. The other day one
of these goats gave a full-dress rehearsal
at the railway station iri Detroit. Just
as the actor handed his ticket (good
from that city to New York) to the bag-
gage man at Detroit, the animal made
a grab for it, and before anything could
be done, began to eat the ticket. The
actor's despair was quite real this time,
but the goat naturally regarded it quite
professionally, and chewed up the De-
troit-Buffalo coupon, and was rather dis-
appointed at not receiving a round of
applause. The mutilated ticket having
the marks of Billy's teeth in it, together
with a full explanation, was duly sent
to Mr. O. W. Ruggles, the general pas-
senger agent of the Michigan Central,
who generously issued another, and let
us hope goat-proof, ticket to the vaude-
ville actor. The goat, it appears, in-
tended to have eaten the entire ticket,
but was almost choked by his erstwhile
friend before he got all the mileage in,
and had it controlled by one head. It
is rumored that the goat intends starring
it alone next season in the role of a
"railway merger," if the Northern Secur-
ities decision does not stand in the way.
New Book.
Dies. Their Construction and Use, by
Joseph V. Woodworth. Publishers.
Ndrman W. Henley & Company, New
York, 1903. Price, $3.00.
This book has 384 pages and 505 illus-
trations, and is divided into twelve
chapters. It contains also a good index.
It is a treatise upon the designing, con-
struction and use of tools, fixtures and
devices, also on the manner in which
they should be used in cheap and rapid
production of sheet steel articles and
parts. Dies, press fixtures and sheet-
metal working devices are described by
the author from the simplest form up to
the most complicated, in a clear and prac
tical manner, which is easily understood.
In fact the book was written by a prac-
tical man for practical men, and is one
whicli will be of value to die makers,
machinists, tool-makers, metal-working
mechanics and otliers interested in the
subject.
Devouring nileage.
An amusing story in which a vaudeville
actor, a goat, a railway ticket and a
The exhaust steam from the station-
ary engines driving the machinery in the
Southern Pacific shops at Oakland, Cal.,
is condensed and the water produced, is
used for washing out and filling the loco-
motive boilers. The effect on the boilers
is excellent.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOII VK ENGINEERING
205
Different Effects with Oil Burning.
We hereby publisli two engravings
to illustrate the different appearance that
results from Inirning oil as fuel due to
the skill or otherwise of the fireman.
The first picture shows two antiquated
early in the fifties he, as a boy, often look
trips on the engine run by Mr. Wood.
In describing the occurrence he says:
"My fatlier, the first dealer in coal at
Auburn at that time, was agent for the
Scranton mines.
from my father's cars, wherefore he had
the fireman put a good quantity in the
tender and then being well fired up with
wood, filled up the furnace with Scranton
coal.
"I shall never forget the expression
which passed over his face, as he opened
the fire door when we were running over
to Owasco Bridge. So hot was our fire
tliat the grate bars, which had melted,
dropped out with the fuel and ash pan
into the stream and 'J'™' looked through
the furnace door down to the river be-
low.
"Soon after the 'Providence' received
a new set of grate bars and ash pan, but
for many years no one else knew just
what happened to us."
POWER PLANT litRNINCi Oil.
A novel and interesting way of adver-
tising has been hit upon by the Grand
Trunk Railway. It is the giving of an
exhibition of moving pictures from
scenes along the line. Among those re-
cently shown were a trip over the Vic-
toria Bridge and through the St. Clair
funnel and some trout fishing scenes in
Muskoka.
locomotives whose boilers are used to
generate the steam necessary for driv-
ing the machinery of the Santa Fe shops
at The Needles, Cal. They are working
at their highest capacity, but not a breath
of smoke is to be seen. The fireman
who is seen leaning out of the cab is a
Mojave Indian, from which it may be
inferred that high-class labor is not
necessary to burn oil successfully in a
stationary plant. The men standing
around are mostly officials belonging to
the road, among whom we recognize
Mr. H. Schaefer, master mechanic.
The other is a traction engine also
using oil. It is needless to say that there
is considerable smoke in evidence. They
used to burn straw in the boilers of these
engines, and ideas of fuel economy were
not developed. They are burning the oil
as recklessly as they burned straw. The
country around is so vast that there is
no fear of making a smoke nuisance an-
noying to human beings. Locomotives
burning oil sometimes create great vol-
umes of smoke, but they are generally
quite clean, depending upon the con-
dition of the engine and the skill of the
fireman. We will, however, have a good
deal to say about this in future issues.
"The train I was on being at Cayuga
beside a train of coal cars, of the kind
emptied by tipping to one side. I sug-
In the exhaustless catalogue of
Heaven's mercies to mankind, the power
rielted the Grate Bars.
The death of Mr. James Wood, the
veteran locomotive engineer on the New
York Central, removes a well known and
interesting figure from the railroad
world. Interest in the early days of
locomotive running has been revived by
Mr. F. H. Pulsifer, who has given some
interesting facts to the Rochester Herald
stating that Wood was the first en-
gineer to burn coal, i.e. hard coal, in
the firebox of an engine. He says that
THRESHING ENGINE BURNING OIL.
gested to Mr. Wood that possibly some
of our coal would make a good locomo-
tive fuel, and offered the use of a supply
we have of finding some germs of com-
fort in the hardest trials must ever oc-
cupy the foremost place. — Barnaby Rudgt.
2o6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
The Tandem Compound Locomotive.
F. P. ROESCH.
Among the various types of compound
locomotives in operation in the United
States, there is one type which, where
understood, is rapidly forging to the
front, due to their excellent work, good
riding qualities, low fuel consuinp-
tion, and where men are educated in
locating the few steam blows, these
engines are subject to. to their compara-
tively low cost for repairs and mainte-
nance. We refer to the American Loco-
motive Company's type of tandem com-
pound.
These engines are of the four-cylinder.
continuous-expansion type, but, unlike
most four cylinder locomotives, the cyl-
inders are coupled in tandem, that is,
the high-pressure cylinder is coupled
ahead of the low pressure, both pistons
in each side being mounted on the same
piston rod; the steam chests for each
cylinder are joined together, making one
continuous steam chest in which both
valves — usually of the piston type — oper-
ate, both valves being on the same valve
rod and operated same as a simple en-
gine.
Both pistons being mounted on one-
piston rod, these engines are not subject
to the twisting strains on the cross-head
developed in other four-cylinder com-
pounds, and therefore a lighter cross-
head can be used, and consequently are
easier counter-balanced, thereby improv-
ing their riding qualities, and also
eliminating the piston rod packing blows,
so frequently found in other types. Both
cylinders are also fitted with an excel-
lent system of by-pass valves w-hich ma-
terially aid their drifting qualities, the
writer having maintained a speed of
fifty miles per hour drifting, with a con-
solidation engine of this type, weighing
175,000 pounds on drivers, with 57-inch
wheel.
The starting valve is of very simple
construction, consisting of a plain cast-
ing containing two. ports connecting the
two steam ports of the high-pressure
cylinder, the steam connection being
made by means of a straight plug
mounted on starting valve rod and oper-
ated to admit high pressure steam to
low-pressure cylinder at will There is
nothing about this device to leak or
get out of order, which is quite an ad-
vantage.
In a series of extended road tests con-
ducted by the writer with this type of
locomotive in comparison with simple
engines developing practically the same
tractive power and having the same
weight on drivers, the tandem showed
an economy in fuel, figured on a ton
mile per hour basis, of 34 per cent, on i
per cent, grade and 37 per cent, on ij^i
per cent, grade.
Part of this economy must be at-
tributed, however, to the difference in
grate area in favor of the compounds,
they having the wide fire box, while the
simple engines in comparative tests were
fitted with narrow fire boxes. The dif-
ference due to the increased grate area,
figured on an evaporative basis, was cal-
culated by the writer to be equal to 13
per cent., which leaves the gain due to
compounding 21 and 24 per cent., re-
spectively, according to grade. It hav-
ing been found that with full tonnage, or,
in other words, at slow speeds, the com-
pounds showed a greater efficiency over
the simple engines than with light ton-
nage or at high speeds.
It is not the purpose of this article,
however, to lead anyone to believe
that in the tandem compound locomo-
tive the acme of perfection in compound
locomotives has been reached. The tan-
dem has its faults, the same as any other
locomotive, the jjrincipal one being due
to the vibrating sleeve, packing the
piston between tlie high and low press-
ure cylinders. This sleeve being en-
closed between the two piston heads is
rather hard to get at, and also difficult
to lubricate, consequently where the
lubrication is not well looked after, the
sleeve wears very fast and often seriously
impairs the efficiency of the engine. This
defect and other steam blows, whicl; oc-
casionally develop, seem, to the average
engineer, rather hard to locate unless he
has been carefully instructed in their lo-
cation, and also in the construction of
the valves and cylinders and the manner
in which steam passes from one cylinder
to the other and through the various
ports. We will therefore treat of this
part of the tandem compound locomntive
in a separate article under the head of
Diseases of the Tandem Compound, a
careful study of which article should en-
able any engineer to readily locate any
steam blow which may develop, and so
save quite a little expense to the com-
panies where these locomotives are
operated, by his knowing how to report
all defects correctly.
Woking, a distance of about twenty-four
miles. This line has adopted the low
pressure pneumatic electric system,
which is made by the British Pneumatic
Signaling Company, which has recently
amalgamated with the well-known Eng-
lish firm of Saxby & Farmer. The
Great Eastern is also contemplating a
trial of the automatic block signal.
The Great Central Railway Company
are using the Miller system experiment-
ally on a section near their Woodhead
tunnel. The tunnel is three miles long
and forms one block, which causes much
delay to traffic. This system will enable
the length of blocks to be shortened and
does away with the necessity of signal
men being placed in the tunnel. The
Miller system is expected also by South-
western officials to very successfully
solve the problem of train movement in
foggy weather.
The North-Eastern Railway are ex-
perimenting upon a section of line eleven
miles long between Alue and Thirsk
with the Hall electro-gas system. Elec-
tricity is the controlling agent, but the
motive power is compressed carbonic
acid gas contained in cylinders very like
those which are used in soda water foun-
tains. Each cylinder is capable of giving
about 6,000 signal movements. This
system is now being installed on the
Paris. Lyons and Mediterranean, and
Midi lines in France.
The ^Automatic Block Signal in
England.
One of the reasons why the automatic
block signal, such as is used in the
United States is not universally applic-
able to British railway lines is said to be
that they are not very satisfactory at
junctions, and there are almost innumer-
able junctions on these lines. Since
1902, however, some progress has been
made in the introduction of this kind of
train signal in the British Isles.
The London and South- Western Rail-
way has installed a series of such sig-
nals controlling five blocks between An-
dover and Grately. and have been so
much pleased with the result that they
intend to extend the system to their four-
track road between Basingstoke and
No More Broken Platform Sills.
The Central Railroad of New Jersey
people are now doing away with the
flimsy plate which is usually fastened by
unreliable wood screws to the platform
ej|d sill of passenger cars, where the
shank of the Miller buffer comes
through. The practice adopted at the
Elizabethport Shops is to remove this
plate and replace it by a 7-inch channel
(each of which is supplied in specified
lengths by the steel mills). These chan-
nels have the holes for the buffer shank
punched out in the bull-dozer, and the
bolt holes at the ends punched out in
the usual way. The application of these
steel channels, of about 33 inches in
length, very materially strengthens the
platform-end sills by distributing any
strain which falls upon them to four
platform timbers. The presence of two
substantial bolts in the place of a few
wood screws driven in by a screw-
driver and oftener by a hammer,
is a very great improvement. The life
of the platform-end sill is very materi-
ally lengthened. The riveting over of
the bolt ends prevents the channel from
ever working loose. The material of
which it is composed, and its shape, is a
guarantee against cracking, and not only
is the arrangement more durable, more
easily applied, more in accordance with
correct mechanical principles, but it
May, 1903.
RAILWAY ANIJ LOCOMOIIVE ENGINEERING
207
looks far bcUer lliaii the nld plate, wliiili
invariably came into the repair shop with
screws missing, timber broken and a gen-
eral air of "couldn't stand the racket"
on the road. The new plan is good and
it looks well.
European Notes.
The Mersey Railway, whicli connects
Lixerpool and Birkenhead by means of
a tunnel under the river Mersey, has for
a period of seventeen years been worked
by steam locomotives, but for many rea-
ing with ihiir products generally, a con-
siderable increase in the output is an-
ticipated, tlius enabling them to deal
with many orders now passed to foreign
competitors.
The Austrian State Railways have re-
cently been supplied with a new class
of passenger locomotive of Herr R. von
Golsdorf's design. These engines arc
two cylinder compounds and have four
coupled drivers 2.14 meters diameter,
cylinders H.P. 0.50 meters and L.P. 0.76
meters diameter, with a stroke of 0.68
meters. In general details the engines
GOLSDOKK COMPOUND— .\rSTRIAN ST.^TK RAILWAYS.
sons, not excluding the foul condition of
the tunnel, and the desire to provide a
quicker and more frequent service of
trains, it was decided to electrify the road
and to adopt the new method of hauling
the trains now in operation. The line has
its terminus at the Central Station, Liv-
erpool, on one side of the water, aijd
on the other at Rock Ferry, its total
length being a little over four miles; the
gauge is, of course, standard. The work
of conversion to the new traction was
commenced in January, 1902, and despite
the difficulties due to the heavy and con-
tinuous traffic running through the tun-
nel the work was so rapidly pushed for-
ward that on March i last the line was
ready for electric traction. The British
Westinghouse Co. have carried out the
work and the main generating engines
and plant have been supplied from their
East Pittsburg works. The steam loco-
motives which are now practically use-
less for the Mersey Company are eigh-
teen in number and are of two distinct
types; they were built by Messrs. Beyer
.Peacock & Co., of Manchester, and
Messrs. Kitson & Co., of Leeds.
All the British locomotive builders
will be fully employed on orders for
some considerable time, many foreign
railways having engines being con-
structed for them. The firms of Messrs.
Sharp, Stewart & Co., Nelson Reid &
Co.. Dubs & Co., all of Glasgow, have
amalgamated, the combine being known
as the North British Locomotive Com-
pany. With the thoroughly up to date
machinery possessed by these three
builders and the efTicient means of deal-
conform to recent practice of Herr
Golsdorf and reference to the illus-
tration herewith will show the Wal-
schaert vahe gear with the valves above,
piston tail rods, extended smokebox,
first engine of this class is at present
running on the East Coast expresses be-
tween Doncastcr and Peterboro', and is
giving great satisfaction.
The Great Northern have also in
Ijreparation a powerful new type of tank
engine for the suburban traffic and the
London, Brighton and South Coast
Railway people are premeditating the
building of some very large express lo-
comotives.
The strike that occurred on the Taff
Vale Railway and which resulted in the
Amalgamated Society of Railway Ser-
vants being sued for aiding the com-
pany's employees in breaking their con-
tracts and causing considerable public
inconvenience, has after many legal de-
cisions been settled by agreement and
payment of £23,000 ($115,000) as dam-
ages. It is but fair to state that the
chief officials of the A. S. R. S. were
adverse to the action taken by the local
committee in South Wales in assisting
the strike, and ought to have taken more
drastic measures to have prevented it,
for as might have been expected this
result has been a fatal blow to the so-
ciety.
Al the meeting of the London and
North-Western Railway Company the
question of reform was brought to the
front by some prominent men, sup-
ported by a very large contingent of
stockholders. There can be no doubt
that the management of the company is
very unprogressive, and one item of re-
MIDI.AND ST.\.VD.\RI) SIX COIPLED GOODS ENGINE.
etc., etc. These engines weigh in run-
ning order 54,200 kilogrammes.
The Great Northern Railway Com-
pany have built at the Doncaster shops
an enlarged "990" Atlantic type passen-
ger engine. The most important in-
crease is in the large boiler, the diam-
eter of which is 66 in., being the largest
in the British Isles. The frames, wheels,
cylinders, motion, etc.. remain the same
as the previous ten-wheelers. The fire-
box is constructed after the Wooten type
and has a grate area of 30.9 sq. it.; the
total heating surface is 2.500 sq. ft. The
form suggested was the adoption of
larger cars for mineral traffic. As a se-
quel a deputation of L. & N. W. R. offi-
cials left for the United States on the
25th of February to learn and profit by
the methods adopted there. In this di-
rection it is interesting to note that large
freight cars are being largely adopted
on several roads, the Caledonian Com-
pany among others having just placed an
order with private British firms for 300
cars.
Twelve new locomotives have just been
constructed by Messrs. Sharp. Stewart
2o8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May. igo,5.
& Co. for the Bengal Nagpur Railway
of India. They are powrful machines
with six coupled drivers ys'A in. diam-
eter, and cylinders 21 in. diameter and
26 in. stroke. The boiler has a Belpaire
firebox and total heating surface of 1831
sq. ft., the grate area being 32 sq. ft. As
regards rolling stock the B. N. R. are
probably the most progressive line in
India and the new passenger engines em-
phasize the statement. AH the modern
improvements in locomotive detail have
been introduced and the finish of the
engines reflects great credit on the de-
signer and builders.
The Midland Railway have departed
from their standard six-coupled goods
engines of Mr. Johnston's design, which
have with the exception of a few minor
details been used since 1875, and have re-
cently built at Derby some locomotives
with wheels and frames the same as be-
fore, but having boilers of much larger
dimensions and similar to those of the
latest Belpaire passenger engines. The
safety valves are placed above the fire-
box— quite a novelty for Midland en-
gines.
The Great Western Railway are fitting
their latest type of Mogul goods engine
with taper boilers, thus somewhat in-
creasing the steam space. The new
Do Glehn compound for the G. W. R.
mentioned as being under construction
at Belfort, in France, will, with the ex-
ception of a few details, be precisely sim-
ilar to the "2643" class now running on
the Northern of France Railway be-
tween Calais, Paris and Lille.
Automatic pneumatic signaling appli-
ances are meeting with more attention
just now and several projected installa-
tions are talked of.
A Well rianaged Tool Room.
One of the best-managed machine
shop tool rooms that we have seen is in
the shops of the Southern California Rail-
way at San Bernardino, the details hav-
ing been worked out by Mr. Werst, the
general foreman. The place is run
strictly on the ticket system with mes-
sengers to carry the tools. They have
the tools grouped in kinds to facilitate
selection. For instance, drills, reamers
taps and everything relating to hole mak-
ing are grouped together. The forg-
ings ready to replace at shortest notice
every tool in use. The orderliness of
the place is worth to the company a good
many dollars daily.
A small store department is run in
connection with this tool room, all sorts
of small pieces such as studs, nuts and
bolts of the kinds most in demand. The
time spent in going to a regular store
house for a stud or such small article,
is frequently more costly than the value
of the article. The system of adhering
rigidly to rules about drawing articles
invariably from store rooms is frequently
very costly, especially with the developed
forms concerning orders that call for
several entries of every article drawn
out.
In this tool room they carry packing
rings which rise in diameter by 14 inch
from the smallest to the largest size.
This insures having the size wanted, to
a certainty. They carry about 500 rings
in stock. The use of piston valves has
greatly increased the demand for piston
same distance from the rabbitted edge
of the door, and suitable iron brackets to
receive its ends were bolted on. A few
inches from the pivot points in these two
cross beams two bolts were placed, one
in each, and these were connected by a
vertical rod. When it is desired to open
the door the operator simply swings the
lower cross beam into a nearly vertical
position and the upper cross bar
acts like the walking beam of a
ii^cizxq
ROUND HOUSE OR SHOP DOOR F.'^.STENER.
rmgs, and they are frequently wanted in
a hurry.
I'here are reamers in the room in-
creasing by 1-32 inch from 5-16 inch to
iJ4 inch.
Round House Door Fastener.
A very easily made and very inexpen-
sive door fastener is here illustrated. It is
applicable to the doors of a round house
or shop where engines or cars pass in or
out. This door was originally made with
a pivoted wooden cross beam which,
when in position, engaged with two iron
brackets appropriately placed, and so ef-
fectually braced the door. In order to
prevent the gaping at the top which
round house doors are prone to, a smaller
and similar cross beam was pivoted to
the upper- cross rail of the door, at the
steamer, and swings "out of latch"
and frees the upper part of door.
In closing, the reverse operation is
performed, and to make it always ef-
fective it is well to look to the form of
the bracket which is attached tc hall
door not carrying the cross beams. This
bracket should be slightly bent outward
at the top as shown in the section on the
margin of our illustration, and should be
made long enough to permit the small
cross beam to engage with it even when
the upper part of the door is considerably
warped. This door fastener has been in
use in a round house for many years in
a region where very cold weather is ex-
perience in the winter, and the doors
so secured are always snow-proof as far
as the absence of the eflfects of warping
or gaping are concerned.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY ANIJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
209
Heavy 2-8-0 Enjjines for the Penn-
sylvania Lines.
The Pittsburg shop of tlie American
Locomotive Company has recently de-
livered some heavy 280-193 type engines
to the Pennsylvania lines west of Pitts-
burg. The engines are simple with 22x
28-inch cylinders. The driving wheels
measure 56 inches in diameter outside
the tires. The working pressure is 205
pounds, and the adhesive weight is about
173.000 pounds. The calculated tractive
power is in the neighborhood of 42,000
pounds.
In looking at our illustration if will lie
Mpcralion ni rever.sing. With the double
hanger here used, the introduction of
.my measure of artificial lost motion as
an expedient to prevent binding is not
necessary.
The side rod is made with solid bushed
brasses, and this form of construction is
also followed with the crank pin of the
forward driver, though the brass is se-
cured to the rod with a strap bolted up
'iolid to the rod end.
The boiler is of the wide firebox, ex-
tension wagon-top type, measuring 71
inches at the smoke-box end and 76
inches at the dome course. The firebox
rm] crank pin journalH, M. 7^x6 in. K. IN'T.
&tt 4'A in. Ilia x.^K >".
Holler, worlcinK pressure, 205 IbH.; thickneflB of
platen in barrel and outside of firet)ox. K, H,
&{jin.; firelx}X, Icni^th, lo.SiV in.; width, 66
in. ; depth, front, ys^g in.; back. 61^ in.; plates,
thickness, sides, ,•, in.; back, /, in.; crown, }i
in.; tube sheet. ^A in.; water space, front. 5 in.;
sides, 5 in.; back. *; in.; crown staying, t in.
radial; stay ImjU^, y^ in. dia.
Tubes, material and gauge. No. 11 Charcoal Iron;
number, 373; dia., 2 in.
Heating surface, tuttes, 3,677 s<|. ft.; firebox, 165 sq.
ft.: total. 2,842 sq. ft.; grate surface, 49 sq. ft.
Stuokc tack, top alx)ve rail; r.s ft.
Tender, weight, empty, 57.7WJ 1t>s. ; wheels, dia., 36
'n.; wheel Jjase, 20 fi. 6 in.; trucks, pedestal
type, with steel twister; wMter capacity, 7,000
U. S. gallons : coal capacity, 1354 tons.
HEAVY CONSSOLIDATION FOR THE PENNSYLVANIA LINES WEST OF PITTSBURGH.
seen that the engine has the second and
the main driving tires without flanges.
The rigid wheel base is 16 feet 6^ inches.
The cross-head is of the two-guide bar
type, the connecting rods only are of
fluted section and the big end is of a
design which is cominon enough in loco-
motive practice now-a-days, but which
has something of the marine type about
it. The driving wheels are all equalized
together, the two leading pair have
springs above the top frame bar, and the
two rear drivers are equalized with
springs placed between the upper and
lower frame bars. The pistons drive on
the third axle and the eccentrics, as is
usual, are placed on this axle with a
transmission bar made in two parts,
which completely encloses the second
axle. The valve motion is indirectly
connected, and the valves are of the
ordinary Richardson, balanced. It may
be mentioned that the expansion links
in these engines are suspended by two
hangers, one on each side, there
being two link-saddle pins provided.
This arrangement, while not new, is
a great improvement on the method
of suspension from only . one side,
which while very successful on engines
of smaller and lighter build, when ap-
plied to modern heavy machines, gives
the link an opportunity to bind very
badly and so seriously interfere with the
is of the Belpaire type and the crown
sheet and roof sheet are quite level,
though the back sheet slopes 20j^
inches at the top. The flues are 373 in
number, 13 feet 8V4 inches long, and con-
tain 2,677 square feet out of a total of
2,842 square feet.
The tender has a deep-water bottom
while the fuel space is arranged for the
convenience of firemen. The tank holds
7,000 gallons, and the coal capacity is
13H tons. The front of the water legs
on each side is made in the form
of a cupboard, so that no tool boxes
show above the shallow coping. As the
tender leaves the hands of the builder
each is equipped with a tail rope slung
alongside the steel channel tender
frames. A few of the principal dimen-
sions are as follows:
GENERAL DIMENSIONS.
Weight iu working order. 1(33.500 lbs.: weight on
drivers, 173,000 lbs.; weight engine and tender
in working order. 336,500 lbs.; wheel base.
driWng. 16 ft. 6v; in.; wheel base, total. 24 ft. 9
in.; wheel base total, engine and tender, 58 ft.
iKin.
Cylinders, 22x28 in.; size of steam ports. iJt:X
21 in.; size of exhaust ports, 3x21 in.; size of
bridges, I'i in.
Valves, greatest travel of slide valves, 6 in.; out-
side lap of slide valves, i in.; inside lap of slide
valves. ^ in.; lead of valves in full gear. ,', in.
Wheels, etc.. driving bos material, cast iron:diain.
and length of driving journals, 9 in. diam.xi3
in.; diam. and length of main crank pin jour-
nals, 6 in. dia.x7 in.: diani. and length of side
" Please Shut the Door."
W'e have recently come across a very
ingenious way which a foreman of a
large railroad shop has taken to always
insure the fireproof door of his office
being securely shut at night, which door
is, as a lawyer might say, "for that pur-
pose made and provided." The office
contains records, etc.. which are valuable,
and at night the isolation of this room
is important. There is a swing door
made of wood with an elegant glass
panel which shuts off the office from
the shop, but this door has no lock.
The fireproof door is the only one with
a lock, so that in order to lock up the
office securely the person charged with
that duty is therefore compelled to com-
bine with that operation the duty of
closing the office against fire.
Stalled for Steam.
A train traveling on a small branch
railway in the Highlands suddenly came
to a standstill. One of the passengers
poked his head ou*. of the window to as-
certain the cause, and just caught the
guard as he passed un^er the window on
his way to the engine. "W'hy are we
stopping?" he inquired. "Hoot, mon,
ye maun jus' abide a wee; the water's
gane aff the boil." — Tit-Bits.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
Belt Action and Heart Action.
"New Knowledge on Belt Manage-
ment" is a book got out by the
Cling-Surface Company of Buffalo.
The company say, on page 13: "We
return your money if you consider
Cling-Surface not successful in your
works," and the offer is couched
in language which is refreshing to
read, and, by the way. the book is
free. Cling-Surface is said to cause a
belt to cling so tenaciously to a pulley
that the belt may be run absurdly slack.
The half-tones in the book show loose,
flapping belts transmitting high power.
The company draws 'an analogy between
a slack belt and heart action. We all
know the heart rests between beats.
"The working side of a belt is the beat,
the slack return is the rest between
beats." This rest they think prolongs the
belt's life. They propose to make it very
exceedingly busy when it does work,
but with a pretty slack time for rest,
while returning, between pulleys. The
book itself has a sort of cling-surface,
you can't lay it down until you get the
drift of it, and, moreover, the book is
free. Write for it and read for yourself.
It is very interesting, and some things
in it are new and strange.
Locomotive 5moke Stacks.
At first sight one might not suppose
that the "draughting" of a locomotive
had anything particular to do with the
enjoyment, by the passengers, of the
scenery along the railway line. It seemsi
strange to say that a long or a short
smokestack on an engine should make
any difference to the traveling public,
but some years ago the late locomotive
superintendent of the Highland Railway
in Scotland employed a unique arrange-
ment in connection with the "chimneys"
of his engines, which had for its object
the comfort of passengers. The exhaust
steam was thrown high in air, so that
the beautiful views along the line of this
celebrated railway were not hidden from
the eyes of expectant tourist travelers.
The chimney used for many years on
the Highland Railway is shown in Fig.
I. reproduced from the Locomotive Maga-
zine, and the other cuts are from the same
source. The chimney proper, or, as we
would say, the smokestack, was sur-
rounded by a casing which enclosed an
air space. In the front part of this cas-
ing were a number of "louvre" open-
ings like the sloping wooden slats in a
belfry. These openings permitted the
entrance of air as tlie engine rushed for-
ward, and a strong upward draught of
air between casing and chimney was thus
secured, at the back, which had the ef-
fect of forcing the cloud of exhaust
steam well up, so that it was completely
dissipated before it could fall to the
level of the coach windows.
The gradual increase in the size of
locomotive boilers in Great Britain and
the consequent reduction in the height
of the chimney, as the "loading line" is
approached, has produced a state of
affairs hitherto unknown. The short-
chimiiey engines trail their exhaust
steam very much, along with what little
smoke there may be, and it has the ef-
FIG. 1.
FIG. 3.
feet of handicapping the engine driver
very seriously by obscuring his vision.
On many railways on the Continent
a pointed form of smoke-box has been
introduced where dwarf chimneys are
used, such as is outlined in Fig. 2. This
shows the diagonally upward movement
of air currents caused by the motion of
the engine. The use of this sharpened
front end does not bring about the de-
sired results when used with an exten-
sion smoke-box.
The advent of Mr. Holden's "Deca-
pod" on the Great Eastern, which has a
chimney just high enough to take a
stand-up collar and a cravat, has no
doubt suggested a modification of the
Highland Railway chimney, so as to pre-
vent the trailing of exhaust steam. The
proposed plan is outlined in Fig. 3, and
consists of a casing surrounding the
front and top of the smoke-box, with
"louvre" opening in the front upper half
of the smoke-box casing. Air entering
the space between casing and smoke-
box is conducted to the back of the
chimney, the true smokestack being
placed well forward, somewhat out of
center, and the result would probably
be a powerful uprush of air just at the
point where it would counteract any ten-
dency to trail exhaust steam or smoke,
and thus permit those on the engine to
have a perfectly clear view of the signals
and the track ahead.
Annealing Side Rods.
The Southern Pacific Company having
suffered from an epidemic of broken
side rods, the suggestion was made to
anneal the rods, which has proved to be
an effectual remedy. Mr. D. P. Kellogg,
general foreman of the shops at Oak-
land, devised a furnace for the annealing,
which does the work very effectually.
It is a reverberatory firebrick furnace
made long enough to hold the longest
side rod. It is also used as a case har-
dening furnace, and the heat generated
for that purpose is utilized for the an-
nealing process.
The practice is to heat the furnace to
the highest temperature for case harden-
ing, then it is cleaned out and filled with
side rods. No more heat is applied, the
heat remaining in the brick being suffi-
cient to thoroughly anneal the side rods.
They remain in the furnace forty-eight
hours and are then taken out. All
strains of the original manufactures and
those sustained in service are eliminated,
and the rod is found to be stronger than
it ever was. The epidemic of breakage
has ceased.
An ordinance was introduced into the
Chicago City Council some time ago es-
tablishing rules for the regulation of
the smoke nuisance. Mayor Harrison
was opposed to the ordinance, but it has
been passed without his consent. There
appears to be considerable politics in the
move.
We understand that the Portuguese
State railways, South and Southwestern,
have just placed an order with Mr. A.
Borsig, of Berlin, for four 6-coupled
4-cylinder compound locomotives with
large double bogie tenders. Delivery
has been promised for next autumn.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
General Correspondence.
Old Time Railroad Reminiscences.
BY L. J. KIDDER.
It was about ten o'clock on a sultry
July morning and the "Ananias Club"
was holding an impromptu meeting on
the shady side of the Ottumwa engine
house, the four members present being
seated on a divan, the constituent part
of which was a three-inch plank attached
to the exterior of the circular brick
wall. One of the number had just re-
lated how many loads he had pulled up
White Breast grade with the "Powe-
sheik," drawing on his imagination to
make up the deficiency of power the en-
gines should have possessed to make
good the claim when one of his listen-
ers exclaimed: "Hello! There comes a
chap hunting for a raih'oad job, and I
will bet the old man hires him." We all
looked in the direction indicated and
sure enough the youny man referred
to had all the marks of a successful
aspirant, for we well knew the master
mechanic's predilection for employing
strong, healthy-looking country boys as
•the most promising material from which
to make firemen and engineers.
The chap was plodding down the road,
ycleped Main street, of Blake's addition,
with a swinging, though uncertain gait.
leaving a dense trail of dust behind, as
his cumbersome cowhide boots ploughed
through the deep, soft covering of tliat
thoroughfare. Reaching the well-worn
path leading across an open lot to the
round house, he followed it and a mo-
ment later was in the presence of the
club, one of which, in answer to the in-
quiry where he could find the man who
hired firemen, directed him to the mas-
ter mechanic's office.
The boy was. indeed, a promising
subject for a fireman, being, perhaps.
19 years of age, of ruddy complexion,
large head covered with an abundance
of hair, a sort of cross between brindle
and red. some six feet in height, stocky
build and hands calloused to the extent
that coal shovels and clinker bars would
have little effect on them.
Entering the office he walked up to
the picket fence which served as a di-
viding line between the M. M. and his
caller, and doffing his hat inquired if
they wanted to hire a man. The master
mechanic turned about in his chair,
took a long mental survey of the aspir-
ant, and apparently a satisfactory one,
then inquired his name.
"Tom Hayworth," he replied.
"Where do you live and what can you
do?"
"I live at home over in Wapello town-
ship and have been working on a farm."
"What sort of jub do you want?"
"Fireman."
"Did you ever fire coal any?"
"Well, no; I never worked on one of
your railroad engines, but I fired a saw-
mill boiler with saw dust all last winter
and I s'pose that's about the same
thing?"
"Y-e-s," said the M. M. slowly in re-
ply, causing a smile on the part of the
official as well as the club members
who had followed Tom into the office.
After some further questioning, Tom's
name was ordered placed on the list
and be directed to come round at ~ the
following morning ready for work.
The next day he reported promptly
on time and was assigned to the clinker
pit, where if the initial embarkation into
railroad work was not quite up to his
expectations, it certainly did afford an
opportunity to demonstrate that he was
all wool and a yard wide, so far as mus-
cular activity and ability to weild a coal
scoop was concerned.
Tom, called "Brick Top." for short.
was soon promoted from the pit to the
foot board where he manipulated the
shovel for some two years, during which
time he proved a good worker, though
his ability as a fireman was of a some-
what mediocre character; but as time
went by numerous promotions placed
him at the head of the list of eligibles,
and he was given the "Mahaska."
Long before he attained the right side
of an engine, however, the hayseed had
been eliminated from his hair, and a
striking propensity developed by "Brick
Top" was an insatiate appetite, not unlike
the engine he fired, for fuel, and which,
like the wart on his nose, was always
with him. There was no eating houses
along the road; as a consequence, lunch
buckets had to be depended on, and as
Tom's was not of sufficient capacity to
provide for his demands, he depended
upon those of engineers whom he
chanced to meet along the road.
Every bucket that Tom could reach
was stealthily robbed, did the owners
happen to be oiling or away from his
engine, and oftentimes insult was added
to injury by "Brick Top," afterward
complimenting his victim on the quanti-
ty and quality of the viands he had ap-
propriated.
This state of affairs, like others of fre-
quent repetition, finally became burden-
some, and with a view of succor, an im-
promptu meeting was held by both club
members and other freight engineers on
the division, at which it was decided to
take radical action, but what that should
be was left for time and occasion to de-
termine.
In these early days facilities for lodg-
ing at the West End were not very
satisfactory and often unattainable; as
a consequence, the engineers and fire-
men, all of whom lived in Ottumwa,
slept on their engines when at the end
of the division > the round house, too,
being the only available place to pass
the time while awaiting a return trip.
Several weeks elapsed before the op-
portunity presented itself to get even
with "Brick Top;" but one Sunday
morning, as several of us were passing
the "Mahaska," the coveted occasion
presented itself, and we were not slow
in taking advantage of it. Most of us
had had a full night's sleep, but Tom
liad arrived early in the morning and re-
tired for a forenoon's nap on the seat
box of the cab. For a mattress he had
appropriated both the fireman's and his
own cushion, one of which, as well as
his feet, extended forward through the
front door of the cab.
A fire-box door chain and two pad-
locks were hastily procured, one end
of the chain being encircled about his
ankles, the other round the side rod be-
low, and both secured with the padlocks.
The conspirators then went up town
to breakfast, returning an hour or so
later finding "Brick Top" still wrapped
in the arms of Morpheus, little dream-
ing (that is, we did not suppose
he was dreaming) how long a time
would elapse before he would again see
his way clear to assuage his hunger.
We brought up a bench, placing it near
the driving wheels of an engine stand-
ing on a pit adjoining the "Mahaska;"
and as we passed the forenoon in con-
versation, Tom lay there on his right
side sweetly sleeping, his face in view-
just above the arm rest on the window
sill.
Along toward noon he awoke, rolled
over on his back, rubbed his eyes, then
made a move to sit up. first endeavoring
to draw his feet inside the cab; but they
didn't draw. He then sized up the sit-
uation, and looking at his visitors
laughed at the joke. Directly someone
remarked it was time for dinner: then
Tom endeavored to take a fresh survey
of his attachments, but soon found he
was a prisoner, for beside being chained
to the side rod his corpulent body
would not permit passage through the
limited space aiforded by the cab door.
First he treated his incarceration in a
jocular way, but soon discovered its
import was of a character requiring
more serious consideration.
Next he supplicated, interspersed with
profuse promises to tamper with lunch
buckets no more, and finally found vent
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May. igoj.
in expletives far more forcible than
-elegant, but all to no purpose. His
tormentors went to dinner leaving two
of their number on guard to prevent
possible tampering with the padlocks,
and Tom wrapped in meditation. Poor
old "Brick Top" was kept in confine-
ment until 7 P. M., when he was given
his libertj', but too late for supper, as
the hotels and boarding houses closed
their diningroom doors at that hour.
The lesson proved a most salutary
one, and while Tom threatened all kinds
of vindictive things on the heads of the
conspirators, nothing ever came; but
from that time henceforth unprotected
lunch buckets were as safe from being
despoiled by Tom as he was from get-
ting his meals that Sunday in Creston.
"Brick Top" is gone now, having
passed from this vale several years
ago, and the last time the writer heard
his name brought up in a reminiscent
way was when an old B. & M. engineer,
who left the road during Tom's palmy
days, inquired where he had gone, and
one of the Ananias Club members re-
plied, for once speaking the truth: "No
one knows where Tom has gone; he's
dead."
Piston vs. Slide Valves.
In the March number of RAILVV.^Y and
Locomotive Engineering I read an
article by Mr. Menzel, entitled "The
Piston Valve of To-day," which certainly
is a very good defense of the piston valve.
In regard to being the most perfectly
balanced valve of to-day no one will
deny it. I do not see where it has all the
virtues attributed by your correspondent.
In the first place it is much more diffi-
cult to keep tight than the slide valve is,
on account of the wear of the rings, and
also on account of the wear the rings
cause in the bushing when the engine is
cutting ofl short. This in time leaves a
shoulder in the bushing, which shoulder
helps to shorten the life of the rings.
Mr. Menzel also says that with the piston
valve a direct motion can be used which
gives a better distribution of steam and
that the lead increases much more slowly
when the engine is cutting ofi than it
does with the indirect motion. In my
experience with the valve motion of a
locomotive, I have always found that
the increase in lead from full valve travel
to mid position was great or small ac-
cording to the radius of the link, lead
being increased much more rapidly with
a short link radius than with a long one.
There are, of course, other modifications
that will control the lead increase, but I
am speaking of the link motion as ap-
plied to the American locomotive. It
therefore makes no difference whether
the motion is direct or indirect as far as
the lead is concerned, and as far as the
distribution of steam by the valve is
concerned the principle is the same with
the piston valve as it is with the slide
valve. From my experience with the
piston valve on locomotives, aside from
the fact of it being more perfectly bal-
anced and therefore requiring less power
to operate it, also its freedom from cut-
ting the buildings, I do not see any-
thing to recommend it in preference to
the slide valve.
Frantz a. Hurlbert.
232 Dearborn Avenue, Chicago.
"A Hachinist's Point of View."
Master mechanics and foremen in gen-
eral have considerable fault to find with
the inefficiency of machinists and their
rambling dispositions.
Where there is "effect" there must be
a "cause."
In the past few years there has been
a tendency to run the majority of shops
in a slipshod sort of a method. En-
gines have increased in size, and no ef-
fort has been made to facilitate the doing
of the work. Consequently mechanics
are compelled to do very heavy lifting,
and meet with the disadvantage of
doing the work without special tools
which are necessary on the up-to-date
engines. An effort on the part of the
foremen to overcome these disadvan-
tages would surely have a tendency to
decrease the spirit of discontent and the
number of time checks issued. In the
selection of foremen master mechanics
evince an inexplicable partiality for per-
sons whose character embody little of
the union principle and much that is dis-
gustingly sycophantic. If the time ever
comes when master mechanics and fore-
men receive their positions by the virtue
of their ability as practical men, with a
fair knowledge of the technical, then
mechanics will have the incentive to
reach the zenith of the trade.
A. Royal.
Alamogordo, N. M.
Tlie "Third Man" on an Engine.
Of late there has been much talk of
placing an additional man on locomotive
engines when in service as a precau-
tion against accidents due to the sudden
disabling of one of the two men now on
engines. Many ideas of all kinds have
been suggested as to how to utilize this
third man, and where to put him. These
theorists lose sight of the old saw, "The
child that many parents share, seldom
knows a parent's care." In other words,
divide the responsibility for performing
any duty and it is a rare chance if that
duty is not neglected in part, if not in
whole.
Years ago when ships were 250 to 300
feet long, from taffrail to cutwater, the
position of the wheel, by which the ves-
sel was guided, was on the quarter-deck
just abaft the mizzenmast. From this
point the steersman had a clear view of
the ocean ahead of him, when the foresail
and mainsail were clewed up. When
those sails were in use (set) there were
lookouts in the waist and on cathead
to warn the helmsman of any obstruction
in his path; these men were not close
enough together to hold conversation.
The binnacle compass gave the helms-
man his course. As ships increased in
length the wheel, or bridge, was moved
forward, until now on many ships it is
forward of the foremast. This seems to
be an evidence that nautical men discov-
ered with the evolution of the ship that
the man who controlled her movements
needed, and should have, the best pos-
sible place from which to see how to
do it.
The locomotive engine, after it came
into use and had passed the experimental
stage, was about 10 to 12 feet long
from door of firebox to extreme of
front end, and the engineer stood on a
platform behind and alongside of the fire-
box, and had a clear and unobstructed
view ahead of, and around, him. He
could see over the dome of the boiler,
and there was no forward dome, or big
smokestack and headlamp to block his
range of vision; the sandbox was low
and was really no obstruction. Well, the
locomotive began to increase in size and
length until now many of them — a large
majority^range from 30- to 40 feet
from firedoor to extreme of front end.
(By the way, did any one ever see the
benefit of these "extension front ends,"
except the man who got a royalty for
them?) On the great majority of the
locomotives of the present day the en-
gineer stands where he did sixty years
ago, with to-day on his left side is a
boiler as high as his head and on top of
that boiler are usually two domes, a
sandbox, smokestack and headlamp,
which completely cuts off his view of the
left hand rail for nearly a hundred feet
from the front end. If he wants to see
on a left hand curve he must open a side
window of his cab and stretch out half his
length to do so; this at the risk of being
struck by some mailbag hanger or other
obstruction.
To get back to the original proposition
of an additional man on the locomotive,
where is he to be put? With the present
type of engines if he is put on the left
side he can't see the engineer or com-
municate with him speedily. I believe
some one has suggested electric signals
or telephone. He can't be put on the
engineer's side, for on many engines
there is no room for a 200-tb. man to
turn around. Granted, however, there is
room, how long will it be before the two
men get into an argument or a pleasant
conversation, and then no one will be
looking out? Mr. Editor, there is a
remedy for this dilemma, simple and
easy! Can't some of the inventors of the
day find it? E. J. Rauch.
May, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
213
Licensing Enginemen.
The article in the March issue 01
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
touching upon the responsibility tor
boiler explosions, has brought out a sug-
gestion from Moderation in the April
number, to which I wish to make some
objections. I disagree with him on two
points, licensing of enginemen by State
Board of Examiners and shifting respon-
sibility for explosions on enginemen.
Who makes the time-card and forces
men to make faster time? Is it not
the transportation department? Who
hounds the men to do better with inade-
quate power? Is it not an official? Who
is responsible for the condition of the
boiler and safety valves? Is it not an
official in the mechanical department?
I should not call an engine a free
steamer if I had to shut off the water
to raise the steam to the point where
the valve* relieve themselves unless I
had bad coal or an inexperienced fire-
mule-driving than the management oi
men. He is a demoralizer instead of an
organizer and educator. I know of a
case where an engineer blew his brains
out rather than stand the abuse of his
traveling engineer any longer. The poor
fellow had just completed a 40-hour trip
and was in no condition to stand abuse.
This same traveling engineer does not
approve of his men reading Railway
AND Locomotive Engineering, they
censured him several years ago for ask-
ing men to do the impossible.
Fifth. High steam pressure and bad
water districts where men have to take
chances in order to move traffic at all.
I know of cases where bad water and
225 pounds steam pressure necessitated
the removal of side sheets from engines
only sue months in service, and that road
has been free from explosions ever since
it adopted regular and systematic in-
'ipection of boilers.
With continually added improvements.
theorist without practical experience
is a dangerous investment, particularljr
around a locomotive.
I know of no better medium for the
practical railroader with little time for
study than Railway ajjd Locomotive
Engineering.
It tells you that there i<; a cause for
every explosion.
"Destroy the cause and you will avoid
the effect." J. A. B. '
Pounds, on Forward and Back Centers.
I note in your April number a ques-
tion by "Subscriber" as to why an en-
gine pounds harder on the forward cen-
ter than on back center.
The answer is incorrect. An engine
does pound harder passing the forward
center. That is. if the pound is caused
by a worn journal or box, or by a slack
wedge. Main rod pounds are about
alike on both centers. The reason is
SEEN FROM THE SAXTA FE TR.^XN IX CALIFORNIA.
man. Licensing enginemen would not
relieve that condition of affairs, and it
would establish a dangerous system, sub-
ject to political jobbery, and not likely
to accomplish the desired end.
If there is a limit of elasticity of iron
and steel, there is likewise a limit of
safety to the power of endurance of the
human anatomy. Admitting for the sake
of argument, that some men do take
hazardous chances, would they do so if
discouraged and punished for it?
What are some of the causes that lead
to explosions?
First. Overloading of engines, due to
the selection of officials in general ac-
cording to the strength of "pull' rather
than the strength of brain.
Second. Selecting officials from a de-
partment who are not familiar with the
mechanism of a locomotive.
Third. A theorist somewhere without
practical experience, trjing to make a
reputation for himself as a "hustler."
Fourth. A traveling engineer who
owes his position to a "pull!" That
sort of man generally lacks brains.
He is often a bluffer or a bully,
sometimes both, and better adapted to
to protect life and property, we force
increased responsibility on the engine-
man. Let him be ever so competent or
careful, we are apt to overtax his brain.
Xo license from a State Board of Exam-
iners can remedy that evil.
One of the bad features of such a li-
cense system would be the flooding of
the country with correspondence schools
of the get-an-education-and-promotion-
quick kind. We already have a foretaste
of this in the horde of agents traversing
the countrj- at the present time, distribut-
ing seductive literature, and whose sole
object is to coin money by touching the
enginemen's purses.
Of course, there are some good cor-
respondence schools, deserving of sup-
port, and not to be classed with that
sort
With many of our roads at the pres-
ent time promoting their own men. who
are familiar with the physical condition
of the line, it is an easy matter for the
indi\-idual lines to select an e.xamining
board more competent to judge men's
qualifications for managing and running
a locomotive than some political board.
.\ practical man may theorize, but a
simple. When the crank pin passes the
forward center the movement of the en •
gine and frame is forward and t) e
thrust of piston on main rod is backward,
the wheel is slid backward on the rail
and the loose box comes up against the
advancing pedestal with a slam or the
worn journal meets the back side of the
box in the same manner. On the other
hand, when the crank passes the back
center, the pull on the main rod finds the
engine and frame moving in the same
direction, and the box or journal is
pulled up to its space with the rolling
of the wheel. The result is a much less
perceptible pound. It's about like the
difference between kicking a man coming
toward you and one running away.
Of course an engine backing up
pounds harder passing back centers.
There is another question on these lines
that has bothered the tribe for tnany
years. It is. why does an engine pound
worse on the left side?
One of our engineers says it's on ac-
count of "hard northeast winds." If I
am not mistaken, the real reason for this
has been published. J. M. FosteS-
[In answering the question referred
2t4
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, ignj
to. we dealt with main rod pounds.
The reason why an engine with loose
boxes pounds worse on the left side is
given in another column. — Ed.]
A Southern JPioneer.
I enclose herewith print of the old
engine "Tornado," which, with five
others like it, was built in England dur-
ing the 40's for the Raleigh & Gaston
R. R., now the S. A. L. Railway. I had
hoped to get a picture of old Uncle Rufus
Horton, living near the city, who ran
this engine 55 years ago, to send you
with it, but he rarely comes into town
now. This engine will be appropriate
for use in your "Growth of Locomo-
tive," now in Railway and Locomoiive
Engineering. The picture was kindly
made for me by Prof. W. F. M. Goss, of
with the hand the screen of vapor is
formed from moisture on the hand which
effectually prevents the hand from act-
ually coming in contact with the heated
surface till the vapor has all been burned
away, which will then allow the hand it-
self to bear on the heated surface and
will result in a burn.
It is for this reason that a tea-kettle
of boiling water can be held in the
hand, but it cannot be held there for
more than 30 seconds, for by that time
the vapor caused by the moisture on the
hand will have been burned away and
will allow the hand to come into direct
contact with the hot surface.
For another example of this take a
white-hot iron ball and drop it into a
basin of cold water. For a few moments
it causes very little bubbling, as its great
heat is sufficient to form a screen of
RALEIGH & GAST0N',S PIONEER.
Purdue University, Indiana, where the
old engine now is.
Henry M. Reece,
R. F. S. A. L.
'Raleigh, N. C.
Heat Phenomenon.
I have been much interested in read-
ing the answers to Mr. Chenowith's
article in the January number of your
valuable paper, but the answers seem a
little vague. One can find an excellent
description of this phenomenon and its
causes in Tyndall's "Heat as a Mode
of Motion," lecture V. In one place Mr.
Tyndall says: "I have seen Mr. Bou-
tigug myself pass his wet hand through
a stream of molten iron and toss with
his fingers the fused metal from a cru-
cible; a blacksmith will lick a white-hot
iron without fear of burning his tongue."
Mr. Tyndall explains this as follows:
In touching some intensely hot surface
vapor about it, but soon it is so cool that
it is unable to longer maintain the wall
of vapor and the water comes in direct
contact with its hot surface and violent
ebullition follows for a few moments.
This is a simple experiment; any one can
do it, and it practically explains the
phenomenon.
Mr. Tyndall has gone so far as to
freeze water in a white-hot crucible,
which is fully explained in this lecture,
by chemically forming a screen of vapor
between the water and the side of the
crucible.
From this I think it can easily be seen
that the vapor formed by the moisture
on the hand in coming in contact with
the hot side of a fire-box sheet seems
cold for a few moments, but I think that
if Mr. Chenowith held his hand against
it longer than 30 seconds he would get
burned. Allen S. Weeks.
Boston, Mass.
When a small boy, I had in my pos-
session a little book called "Parlor
Magic," which contained, among other
feats, the trick of holding a boiling tea-
kettle on the bare hand. But. with spe-
cial injunctions that the bottom of said
kettle be well covered with soot, which,
being a complete non-conductor of heat,
protects the hand from injury.
This, I believe is the solution of the
phenomenon in regard to the fire-box
sheets, as described by Mr. W. B. Cheno-
with. E. W. Gregorv.
Hoffmanville. Md.
To Make Compound Locomotives
Efficient.
With the existing difference of opin-
ion in regard to the advisability of using
compound locomotives it would seem
that the question, in some respects at
least, was yet to be decided. If we look
over the experience of the last few
years we will find that many conditions
have been met with, that have interfered
with the proper performance of these en-
gines, and that the results obtained from
them in many instances have not been
all that could be desired. Without doubt
the future will produce new features in
the compound that will increase its effi-
ciency. But it is safe to say that what
is most needed at present is a better
knowledge of the construction and op-
eration of this type of engine by all con-
nected with their maintenance and op-
eration. With a better understanding of
the subject and the engines in the service
to which they are adapted, we can look
for satisfactory results. That the dif-
ferent builds of compounds have their
advantages there is no question. The
cross-compound, with one high and one
low pressure cylinder, such as the Schen-
ectady, the Richmond, and the Rhode Isl-
and, with automatic intercepting valves,
differ but little in their operation, and
judging from my personal observation
will produce the best results from an eco-
nomical standpoint under conditions
favorable to the engine. The Schenec-
tady and the Richmond seem to be the
favorites, and I should say there was but
little difference in the results obtained
from either except that the Richmond
has the advantage in drifting, due to the
by-pass valve used on the low-pressure
cylinder of that make of engine. One fact
in connection with these engines that has
been brought to my notice, particularly
so where they are used on comparatively
level roads, is that the power of the en-
gine covers too wide a range. Of
course this fact is an advantage from the
trainmaster's point of view. We will,
however, find it a disadvantage in
considering the welfare of the engi-
neer and also from an economical stand-
point. It is in regard to the latter that
I wish to speak.
All who are acquainted with the
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
215
two-cylinder compound are aware thai
the best results arc obtained with
tliese engines when loaded pretty
close to their limit — I might say when
engine can be worked with wide open
throttle and lever three or four notches
below half stroke. The power is then
very closely equalized on both sides and
we are getting the benefit of the full ex-
pansion of high pressure steam and have
sufiicient volume of exhaust to make the
engine steam freely. It is under these con-
ditions that the compound produces the
best results and it will be found that with
either the two cylinder br the tandem
type the wear on the machinery will be
no greater than with a simple engine de-
veloping the same power. I have noticed
■on many roads where these engines are
used that the tractive power is such that
it would not only be inadvisable but
would be almost impossible to load
tliem to their full capacity. The result is
the engines are being run with light
throttle and about half stroke cut off.
The engine does not make steam and
ihe results are unsatisfactory all round.
Condensation is increased where we wish
to decrease it, thus wasting the steam, and
the efTect is soon noticed upon the ma-
chinery, for the cylinder packing will not
only have to be renewed often, but
pounds will develop quickly in boxes and
rods. If in many cases the size of cyl-
inders were reduced without making any
further change the engines would be
much more satisfactory.
The Vauclain four-cylinder com-
pound, while we frequently hear it se-
verely criticized, seems to have its ad-
vantages. One is that it is well adapted to
high speed heavy passenger work. With-
out doubt much of the complaint we hear
against these engines is due to the ar-
rangement of cylinders, valves, etc., and
to the same causes which produce un-
satisfactory results with the two-cylinder
compounds. For it is of equal impor-
tance that the power should be equal-
ized in the high and low pressure cylin-
ders. In my opinion it would be advis-
able to have but three working notches
in quadrant and so located that the cut-
off will be such as to about equalize the
power in the high and low pressure cyl-
inders.
I believe all will agree with nie
when I say the high pressure cylinder
should always be located above the low.
The tandem compound being new in the
field is not as well known as the others.
It has already had troubles of its own
that have no doubt influenced opinion
against it to some extent. But I will
not hesitate to say (and I believe I am
well qualified to speak on the subject)
that its troubles do not in any way re-
flect upon the compound feature of the
engine. While in my opinion the tan-
dem will not show the economy of the
two-cylinder compound it has features
that will make it a more desirable en-
gine for most railroads. The one most
noticeable is that it offers a wide range
of service, and can be used either for
light or heavy service with good results.
Under all conditions the power is the
same on both sides of the engine, and
as the power of bolli cylinders is trans-
mitted to the cross-head by one piston
rod it makes no difference how the
power is distributed in the cylinders.
Thus it can readily be seen that while
the full benefit of the compound feature
of the engine will not be realized when
running with light throttle and short
cut off. it has no bad effect upon the
engine, and while it is not advisable to
do so. except at very slow speed, the
engine can be worked simple with the
same result. It does not matter which
compound it is, it is important that it
should be adapted to the service in which
it is working. We should not be sur-
prised to see a great, heavy consolida-
tion, with a 56-in. wheel and weighing
perhaps 200.000 lbs., tear herself to
pieces in a few months' time on
a forty-mile-per-hour fast freight; where,
with a mogul, or ten-wheeler, with
a 60- or 69-in. wheel, and weighing
about 175.000 lbs., the effect would be
hardly noticeable on the lighter engine.
In order to obtain the results that are
expected with the compound locomo-
tive, it must be in good condition. Per-
haps this will explain the remark so
often made that "compounds do well in
the hands of their friends." I do not
mean to say that they must always be
new, for we would not expect to give a
compound general repairs any oftener
than any other engine doing the same
work. But I do say they should not be
expected to pull trains with defects ex-
isting that would put a simple engine
out of business. Defective cylinder
packing, for instance, which is noticed
immediately with a simple engine is
often not detected in a compound until
it is either all gone or begins to affect
the engine in some other way. The fact
that a compound engine will continue to
do business under such adverse condi-
tions is detrimental to its welfare and
is responsible in many instances for the
unsatisfactory results obtained.
I will say that I know of no
greater annoyance or expense to a rail-
road than one of these engines in ser-
vice which, when the engineer opens the
throttle, he is not sure whether the en-
gine will go ahead or back up. I have
had opportunities to observe many such
cases, and even worse. Usually the
damage and trouble that such an engine
will cause on the road is enough to
condemn all the compounds on the di-
vision. In order to have,, and to keep,
these engines in good condition it is
necessary, as before stated, that all con-
cerned should be familiar with the con-
.itruclhjn and operation of the compound
feature. Defects in the operation of the
engine would then be immediately no-
ticed by the engineer, the cause discov-
ered before the trouble became serious,
reported by him in an intelligent way
and repaired without the workman hav-
ing to dissect the whole engine. We
would then find that the increased cost
of repairs over that of the simple en-
gine would be only in proportion to the
increased number of parts contained in
the compound which in the cross-com-
pound are very few. The necessity of
holding the engine out of service would
then be no more than with any other en-
gine.
The writer has seen many cases
that fully illustrated the necessity of a
better knowledge of the subject. For
example, an engineer came in after
making his trip with a cross-compound,
Schenectady built engine, and reported
that he thought there was something
wrong with his engine, as it had acted
strangely during the trip and upon one
occasion had positively refused to move
until another engine came along and
gave it a start. However, he was un-
able to give any definite information as
to what the trouble vras. After a whole
day's work on the part of engine-
house men. when they came to run her
Dut it was necessary to get a switch en-
gine to put her on the table, simply be-
cause they had put the intercepting
valve in upside down. The original
trouble was probably due to the en-
gineer '"washing out the stack" or his
neglect in properly lubricating the in-
tercepting valve. Here was the engine
out of service thirty-six hours, with a
bill of expense charged up to her when
she should have been on the road pull-
ing her train.
As the compound locomotive repre-
sents a higher standard of mechanical
ability, with little complication, we
should consider it not only a duty
but a privilege to become familiar
with it and undeavor to see that it re-
ceives fair and impartial consideration.
Then will the question of its advantages
be fully and fairly decided. The writer
does not wish to create the impression
that he believes the compound suitable
for all kinds of service. His many op-
portunities to study the service on vari-
ous roads throughout the country have
convinced him that there are conditions
under which better results would be ob-
tained with simple engines.
W. A. BUCKBEE.
Rensselaer, N. Y.
The Southern Pacific Company have a
Cooke engine which makes a train mile-
age of 124,000 miles per month. She is
washed out every day and calls for very
light boiler repairs. We expect to il-
lustrate the engine soon.
2l6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903
Radial Spring Buffer between Engine
and Tender.
The Philadelphia, Wilmington and
Baltimore Railroad have designed what
they call a radial spring buffer, for use
between engine and tender. The loco
motives equipped with this new ar-
rangement are intended to run upon
curves of 70-foot radius, and so handle
cars in and out of old-fashioned private
tracks, switches, etc., which were built
in the days when the wheel base of en-
gine and tender were much shorter than
they are now. These tracks have not.
and in many cases now, cannot very
well be altered for the better.
Our illustration shows a flat shackle-
bar between engine and tender which is
pinned at either end in the usual way.
On the front of the tender and on the
lugs which pass down on either side of
the flat shackle-bar, so that as engine
and tender pass through a sharp curve
the lateral motion of the shackle-bar
carries the radial buffer with it, either
to the right or to the left, as the case
may be.
By this arrangement the engine and
tender are able to stand at a consider-
able angle to each other as the curva-
ture of the track demands, and yet the
ilistance between each is always pre-
served intact without lost motion or un-
due strain. In fact, the ordinary slight
wear of pin and shackle-bar holes is
automatically taken up by the spring
buffer. The increased space between
engine and tender necessitated by this
arrangement is covered by an apron of
ample dimensions. It will be noticed
'llklllWm
oJ-4oHoM- "^ °
..J^n
RADIAL SPRING BtJFFER. P. W.
back of the foot-plate two castings are
boited, the outer edges of which are
curved with such a radius as would be
got with the pins for centers in either
case. The casting on the back of the
foot plate has a perfectly plane face and
it is used as a rubbing or chafing cast-
ing. The similar casting on the front of
the tender is horizontally ribbed and
carries a hollow casting which is free to
slide upon the curved face, and which
has grooves which engage with the ribs
of the tender chafing casting. The hol-
low casting contains a spiral spring,
the outer end of which bears upon what
may be called a plunger, which fits eas-
ily into the hollow casting. This plunger
or buffer casting presses directly against
the smooth chafing casting on the engine,
and the compressed spring always keeps
buffer and chafing piece in close contact.
The hollow casting has also two deep
that the safety chains are replaced by
two eye-bars pinned securely in the
foot-plate, but with long slots at the
tender end, through which pass two pins
upon which pulling may be done when
either or both of the safety-bars draw
out to the end of their slots.
When the engine and tender are un-
coupled the buffer casting is prevented
from being thrown out by the spring be-
hind it, by a set screw in the upper part
of the hollow casting. Altogether the
whole arrangement forms a neat and
efficient device which secures the needed
flexibility betwieen engine and tender
when working on the crooked track for
which it has been designed.
Mr. D. P. Kellogg, general foreman
of the Southern Pacific shops at Oak-
land, whose attractive contiibutions to
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing are well known to our readers, also
manages a class for the instruction of
those interested in locomotive mechan-
ism. He has a variety of air-brake
mechanism and several charts which
learners find sufficient when explained
by such a master of the air-brake art as
Mr. Kellogg. He also has a small valve
motion model which he makes the best
of, but he is ambitious to have a full
size model which will show the minute
movements of the mechanism and clearly
demonstrate the effect of small changes.
A general foreman ambitious to have
motion of this kind to use for the in-
struction of the company's employees
ought not to have much difficulty in get-
ting one made. But when the work of
repairing locomotives is chronically
ahead of the facilities, the construction
of a valve motion model must naturally
wait.
Mr. John H. Converse, of the Baldwin
Locomotive Works, Philadelphia, re-
cently said to a newspaper reporter:
"We are working night and day, and we
are turning out on an average one
complete locomotive every four hours.
The various branches of our plant are
rushed. The demand for motive power
by the railroads does not seem to
slacken." At this rate, and assuming
that the total average length of an en-
gine and tender is 50 ft., the Baldwin
works could fill a mile of track in 17 1-2
days with 105 engines. A year's work
would require more than 20 miles of
track to hold the output of the works,
and when filled would contain 2,190 en-
gines if the works were operated every
day in the year, which of course they are
not. Some people have been known tn
describe Philadelphia as a slow town.
"The People You Meet in the Dining
Car," is the title of a neat little bit of
illustrated railroad literature issued by
the Chicago & Alton. The literary man,
alone, silent, observant of details, writes
out his order, mark you, in the Alton's
diner. — The ubiquitous, voluble story-
telling drummer, like Othello recounting
perils "i' the imminent deadly breach."
The pretty girl alone; again soon one
of a family party — the country farmer
with napkin comfortably tucked in at the
collar, with knife and fork in hand, ready
for the feast; mentally appraising the
value of the land he looks out on, from
the car window. Then the people you
don't meet, are shown also — they are the
most important people of all — the chefs
— but the Alton looks out well for them,
it's "the only way" — ask the Alton if you
would like to have a copy.
Half a loaf's better than no bread, and
the same remark holds good with
crumbs. — Captain Cuttle.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
217
Atlantic Type Passenger Power for
the Erie.
The Baklwin Locomotive Works have
recently supplied the Erie with some
very substantial Vauclain compound
4-4-2 passenger engines. The sizes of
the cylinders are 15 and 25x28 inches, and
the high-pressure cyhnders are placed
on top. The driving wheels measure 76
inches outside the tires, and the weight
carried by them amounts to about 88,000
pounds. The total weight of the engine
is about 180,000 pounds. The drivers and
carrying truck wheels are equalized to-
gether, and the valve motion is indirect,
with transmission bar passing below the
leading driving axle. The valves are of
the piston type. The guide bars are
very securely fastened to the spectacle
plate by a heavy steel castmg which
passes completely around ihc ends of the
guides.
The boiler is of the straight-top
variety, with wide fire-box for bitumin-
ous coal, this, however, is not quite as
wide as the ordinary Wooten type, thus
allowing the cab to be placed at the rear
of the engine. The boiler is 64 inches
sheets, sides, yk in.; back, >i in.; crown, }^ in.;
tube, 'A in.; water space, front, 4 in.; sides, 4
in.; t>nck, 4 in.
Tubes, wire gauge No. 12; nnniber, 305; diameter.
2 in.; lengtb. 16 ft. 6 in.
Heating surface, firebox, 172 s<i. ft,; tubes, 2,639 Sf].
ft.;total, 2,811 sq. ft. ; grate area, 46.75 sq. ft.
driving wheels, diameter outside, 76 in.; journals.
9x12 in.
Hngine truck wheels, front, diameter, 3.^ in.; jour-
nals, 6x12 in.
Trailing wlieels, diameter, 50 in.; journals, KJ^x
12 in.
wheel base, driving, 6 ft. 7 in.; rigid, 13 ft. 10 in.;
total engine, 26 ft. 3 In.; total engine and
tender, 52 ft. 2 in.
Weight, on driving wheels, 88,000 lbs.; on truck,
front, 48,000 Ujs. ; on truck, back, 44,000 lbs.;
total engine, 180,000 lbs.; total engine and
tender, about 310,000 lbs.
Tank, capacity, 7,000 gals.
Tender, wheels, 33^ in.; journals, 5x9 in.
variety of signal mechanism cut in sec-
tions to show the operating, and that is
supplemented by sectional drawings of
other parts. The men do their work
much more efficiently since this school
of instruction was formed, and overcome
difficulties that formerly were referred to
headquarters. The prevention of delay
that results can easily be appreciated.
Want to Make Prick President of ttie
Steel Trust.
A rumor is current in Wall street that
H. C. Frick will be elected president of
the United States Steel Trust at the
meeting of the directors next month to
succeed Charles M. Schwab. The talk
is that the Morgan interests have deter-
mined upon the election of Frick, and
Time for Refresliments.
A I'ileshire paper tells an amusing
Story. For unseemly rapidity of locomo-
tion Scottish railway trains have an in-
famous and dangerous repute. It is
probable that the North British Railway
is the hero of this yarn: Golfer (who
has been doing St. Andrews, after un-
usually long stoppage at small station)
— "I say, guard, why aren't we going on?
Anything wrong?" Guard (who is peace-
fully taking his lunch) — "There's iiae-
Ihing wrong. But I canna whustic the
noo; my mouth's fn" o' biscuif;"
The Baldwin Record of Recent Con-
struction, No. 41, is entitled "Some
Ari..\\Tu: Tvi'i-: v.Arci,.\iN coMPorNn for thk Erie.
in diameter at the smoke-box end. The
total heating surface is 2,811 square feet.
The tender has a hood over the front of
the fuel space for the protection of the
fireman, and the tank has a water bot-
tom. The water capacity of the tank is
7.000 gallons, and there is back step, hand
rail and ladder for the fireman, so that
the tank man-hole may be conveniently
reached.
These engines altogether are very
similar to those built last year at the
Baldwin Works for the Erie, except
that the ones here illustrated are ar-
ranged to burn soft coal. Though the
position of the cab differs from that of
the hard-coal burners, these engines
have been made with parts interchange-
able as far as possible, to suit the for-
mer design.
Some of the principal dimensions are
as follows:
Cylinder, 15 and 25x28 in.
Boiler, diameter. 64 in.; thickness of sheets, \^ in.;
working pressure, 200 lbs.
Firebox, length. 102 in.: width, 66 in.; depth,
front, 66Ji in.; back, 57^ in.; thickness of
that they have the votes to carry out
their purpose. Those who regard the
change as certain appear to have over-
looked the influence of Andrew Car-
negie in the Steel Corporation. Mr.
Schwab is Mr. Carnegie's choice, and he
is not likely to be displaced without a
fight, especially as Mr. Carnegie has no
love for Mr. Frick. The Homestead
conflict was due to Mr. Prick's action,
and it brought a great deal of unde-
served obloquy upon Mr. Carnegie
which is not forgotten.
Learning about details of their busi-
ness appears to be particularly popular
among railroad men in the neighbor-
hood of San Francisco. Mr. E. M. Cut-
ting, assistant signal engineer of the
Southern Pacific Co. at Oakland, carries
on an instruction class for the men en-
gaged on repairing and caring for sig-
nals, and the men display a keen inter-
est in acquiring knowledge concerning
the mechanism. Mr. Cutting has a
Notable Trains," comprising the special
train recently run over the Atlantic City
Railroad for the visiting English railway
officials, also the regular Atlantic City
flyer which makes daily trips between
Camden and the famous seaside resort.
The Philadelphia and New York
service is represented by a train
drawn by one of the P. & R.
"bicycle" Vauclain compound engines.
Following these are the Alton Limited,
on the Chicago & Alton Railway; the
Overland Limited, on the Union Pacific ;
a train of the same name on the South-
ern Pacific; the C, B. & Q. "Fast Mail;"
the "Pioneer Limited." on the C, M. &
St. P.; the famous "Prince Henry Spe-
cial." on the same road; the Canada At-
lantic and the Canadian Pacific Limited
trains between Montreal and Ottawa: the
Royal Blue Line on the New York,
Baltimore & Washington; a typical Le-
high Valley train of steel coal cars, and
a train on the "Cog-Wheel Route" via
the Manitou & Pike's Peak Railway.
2l8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May. 1903.
Uati^^Egneerini
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "I<oceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, " l/ocauto."
Business Department :
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NEI/lvIS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NEI/I/IS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, I Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Departtnent :
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
IZ04 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd. loaa Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, London.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
f2.oo per year. Si. 00 for six months, postage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of the world, $2.50, or ten shillings.
Single copies, 20 cents. Remit oy Express Monev
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Regittered
Letter.
Mailing address can be changed as often as neces-
sary— always give old and new address, and if you
tubscribed in a club state who got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly.
Entered at Post Office. New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.. 1Q03.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Encouraging Inferior Work.
There is a great deal of truth told in
few words in the letter "A Machinist's
Point of View," which appears in our
correspondence department. The let-
ters of other correspondents and per-
sonal observation convince us that in
railroad shops generally, practices favor-
ing the production of inferior work are
fearfully on the increase. Railroads as
a rule are very scarce of motive power
at present, and it is natural that all con-
cerned in moving the traffic should strive
to have repairs effected as expeditiously
as possible, but that is no excuse for the
encouraging of the production of in-
ferior work at the hands of individual
mechanics. Yet this is undoubtedly be-
coming a common practice. There is no
excuse for it, and the fact that locomo-
tives are feverishly in demand,, instead
of excusing inferior work being done, is
a weighty reason why the work should
be finished in tlie most durable manner
possible.
The railroad companies are earning so
much money and are so prosperous that
it is simply infamous that a spirit should
be growing which encourages the pro-
duction of inferior work, by the oractical
worship of nasty cheapness, for it is
playing with the lives of men. This is
no exaggerated note of alarm, for we
are writing with personal knowledge of
facts that are almost incredible. We do
not say that the managers deliberately
require their mechanical departments to
put inferior work upon their motive
power, but their policy amounts to the
same thing. They make far-reaching re-
searches of the cost of repairs of mo-
tive power on various railroads, and keep
repeating to the head of the mechanical
department, why is our cost of repairs
so much higher than that of the Skeem
& Falsify road? The superintendent of
motive power explains that the con-
ditions of operating are entirely differ-
ent, but his explanations fall upon un-
sympathetic ears; the merits of his de-
fense are doubted, and he is told that he
must endeavor to do better. Seeing the
coming of an invitation to vacate his
ofifice, he passes his embarrassing posi-
tion upon his master mechanics and
urges them to do better, with the result
that some of them begin encouraging
their men to turn out work quickly, no
matter what its quality may be.
The big railroad combinations have
had the effect of intensifying this evil.
When a new system is absorbed the
officials compare the shop performance
with the best per.'ormance of the par-
ent system; and finding it does not make
a favorable comparison, the men in
charge are informed that they must do
better or get out. It is not taken as any
excuse to be informed that all the shop
tools in use on the newly absorbed sys-
tem are antiquated and away below the
capacity of those used on the divisions
whose efficiency they are expected to
equal. The fiat given out is the savage
notice — improve your output or quit.
Few foremen and master mechanics are
ready to throw up their positions, so
they try to save themselves by pushing
the strenuous condition upon the men.
They can do a job more quickly than
they were accustomed to do it only by
slouching the work. A story is told of
an affectionate father giving advice to
his son who was about to leave home.
"God bless you, my son," exclaimed the
affectionate parent, "may you prosper
and be happy. The leading aim of a
young man should be to make money.
I say, make money honestly, if you can.
but make money."
The mechanic of a combination-ruled
modern railroad shop is not only ad-
vised but forced into the position of
the affectionate parent's son. His covert
instructions are— get the repairs done in
short time, get the work done properly
if possible, but get it done quickly.
This policy deserves the strongest
kind of condemnation for various rea-
sons. It reduces the reliability of rail-
road machinery, which is always too
liable to accident, since the strongest
material, fitted in the most perfect form
known to the cunning hand of the skilled
workman, is liable to fail under the ter-
rific shocks of fast-speed train service.
When perfect work sometimes fails
slouch work is a constant menace to
the people traveling on railway trains,
since it seriously increases the liability
to accident.
The system is the most expensive
policy for a railroad company to pursue,
for they will have to pay for good work
in the end, and may have to add a heavy
premium for expense of accidents, to say
nothing about loss of human life.
If a railroad manager wanted to spread
discontent and bad feeling throughout
the whole system he could not find an
easier way to effect it than by having
locomotive repairs slouched. Bad fit-
ting of rubbing parts will bring annoy-
ance and failures from heating, badly
rolled tubes and other boiler work done
in inferior shape will cause leakage, so
between bad fitting on moving parts and
miserable boiler work, engine failures
become a grievous burden. The blame
cannot be located with exactness, so it
is shifted about, exasperating high and
low.
The practice demoralizes the workmen
and their day of reckoning will come as
sure as the sun rises and sets. The av-
erage run of workmen is conscientious
and honest, and, in addition to that, love
of his calling moves him to take pride in
work well done. It is a woeful condition
of affairs when his employers, or the
conditions of his employment, impel him
to degrade his handiwork. A matter of
pride to Americans has been the inter-
est that mechanics took in their work,
an interest which induced thousands of
theiB to invent appliances for increasing
and perfecting production. A mechanic
who is constantly pursued by the order
to slouch work is not likely to use his
brains up devising labor-saving means
or methods. Under the system the best
of men become time servers and all
esprit de corps, or pride of employment,
slowly but surely gets rooted out.
Dissolution of the Northern Securities
Company.
The United States Circuit Court has
just rendered one of the most moment-
ous decisions ever decided in the United
States. It has declared that the
merger of the securities of the Northern
Pacific and of the Great Northern Rail-
roads, effected by J. Pierpont Morgan
and James J, Hill, is in violation of law,
and an injunction was granted against
the continued operation of the merger.
All the four judges concurred in the de-
cision, which is regarded as against the
probability of the United State Supreme
Court reversing the decision. The most
important point in the decision reads:
"It placed the control of the two roads
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
2ig
in the hands of the securities company,
by virtue of its ownership of a large
majority of tlie stocl< of both companies;
it destroyed every motive for compe-
tition between two roads engaged in in-
ter-state traffic which were natural com-
petitors for business, by pooling the earn-
ings of the two roads for the common
benefit of the stockholders of both com-
panies, and, according to the familiar rule
that everyone is presumed to intend what
is the necessary consequence of his own
acts, when done wilfully and deliber-
ately, we must conclude that those who
conceived and executed the plan afore-
said intended, among other things, to ac-
complish these objects."
The defendant in the suit insisted that
the rates charged by the combination
were reasonable, but the Court held that
the rates charged had no particular bear-
ing upon the merits of the case. The
vice of such a contract or combination
was held to be that it confers the power
to establish unreasonable rates, and di-
rectly restrains commerce by placing ob-
stacles in the way of free and unre-
stricted competition between carriers
who are natural rivals for patronage.
The corporation's contention that the
combination was really in aid of com-
merce is fitly characterized as a "novel,
not to say absurd, interpretation of the
anti-trust act," and the court has no
doubts about the validity of the act and
the constitutional powers of Congress in
the premises.
The issues are so clear that all these
mergers appear simply as examples of
conscious lawbreaking, and the decision
will be hailed as a triumph of law and as
a victory for the people which must
strengthen their confidence in the admin-
istration of the law. It is certainly a
welcome check upon dangerous corpor-
ate aggression.
The practice of combining railroad
control so that enormous properties
came practically under one management,
threatened to go on until all the railroad
property in the country would be under
the control of a few bankers. Several
new huge combinations not frequently
known, were being worked into shape,
but the decision on the Northern Se-
curities merger will frustrate the
schemes.
An impression prevails among business
men that the decision of the Court on
the Northern Securities Company is a
direct blow at all trusts and great com-
binations of capital which have been or-
ganized in such stupendous forms of
late years for the controlling of certain
industries. If the Northern Securities
Company can be dissolved because it
acts in restraint of trade and compe-
tition, there are certainly other huge
trusts that act in the 'iame way and
suppress competition more relentlessly
than the railroad combinations have ever
thought of doing. First among these is
the United States Steel Trust, which is
on a fair way to control every steel mak-
ing industry on this continent.
If the discussions in the daily press
are to be relied ui)on to reflect public
opinion, several railroad combinations
now holding trade by the throat will
soon be prosecuted under the anti-trust
law, particularly the New York, New
Haven & Hartford combination. The
Pennsylvania Railroad Company will, if
the predictions come out true, have to
drop the Baltimore & Ohio and other
lines which were competitors of the
Pennsylvania before they were absorbed.
Future action is a matter of specu-
lation, but we feel certain that the pros-
pects of all railroad officials, except the
large capitalists, will be improved by the
decision that law puts restraints upon the
ambition of capital, and will be en-
forced. The dread and anxiety of many
men who were constantly apprehensive
of changes that would throw them out
of employment, is at an end and many
a household will be made happier by the
Court's decision in the Northern Securi-
ties merger case.
Car Details.
Steel in freight car construction has
become so well established as a standard
that wood for the purpose may be said
to be well out of it, as practically all of
the large recent orders specify steel ex-
cept for box cars, in which it has been the
practice of late to split the difference and
make the sills of steel and the superstruc-
ture of wood. Why this lone exception
stands to mar a fine record of progress
no one is ready to explain — if indeed
such a glaring inconsistency can be satis-
factorily cleared up. The friends of the
steel car can afford to wait, however,
knowing that time in the fullness thereof
will see the change from wood to steel,
full and complete for all rolling stock.
While this consummation will be wel-
come, there are some things about car
details that force themselves on our at-
tention, for the reason that many of them
have been worked out from every view
point but that of the mechanic. Among
these are center plates, in which the
necessity for a low coefficient of friction
has apparently been lost sight of, and
the relation it bears to flange wear ami
curve resistance.
To those who have given the question
proper thought it is plain that influences
that hold the truck tangentially on a
curve, other than those due to centri-
fugal action can be eliminated. The most
serious of these is side bearing contact,
and the next in importance is the re-
sistance of the center plates to prevent
the truck from assuming its correct posi-
tion normal to the curve. Instances are
common where the wheel flanges bear
hard on the outer rail of a curve and
hold to that position for long distances
after reaching a tangent, in many cases
retaining a bearing hard against the rail
until a reverse curve is reached. Sharp
flanges are the logical outcome of this
condition, and broken flanges should ex-
cite no comment when from any cause
a truck can.-'.ot easily enter and leave a
curve. In the agitation for a cast-iron
wheel to meet the requirements of the
100,000 pound car, great stress was laid
on the weakness of the present wheel
flange, and much alarm was expressed
at the difficulties in the way of strength-
ening the flange for safe service under
the heavy equipment. There is every
reason to believe that with good material
in the wheel the original thickness of
flange of ij4 inches will be amply
strong for the heaviest rolling stock, ii
the flange is given a chance to perform
its legitimate function of guiding the
wheel with perfect freedom. As a
means to that end it is of the greatest
importance that the center plates offer
the lowest possible resistance, and that
the side bearings remain apart. Center
plates to fulfil these conditions should
be of the ball-bearing type; if these are
not available a fair substitute can be had
in the plain variety, and they should have
flat bearing surfaces of an area large
enough to prevent abrasive action under
load. The upper plate should have a
flange extending down over the lower,
thus reversing the usual order of con-
struction, and the bearing surfaces
should be machined. Such a center
bearing when lubricated, as it should be.
would pay for its low extra cost in de-
creased train resistance and flange wear
on curves.
The failure of the average center plates
to prevent a free swivelling action be-
tween car body and trucks, is quite often
the result of a deflecting body or truck
bolster — either of these may be so weak
as to cause the load to be carried on
side bearings as well as center plates — it
is therefore plain that when such a weak-
ness is present, a frictionless center plate
would not solve the problem. A fairly
intimate acquaintance with bolster lore
prompts the statement that no other de-
tail of a car has received more atten-
tion— such as it was — and profited less,
than the bolster; the reason for such a
peculiar situation is no doubt the want
of a correct understanding of the tech-
nics of the case. The multiplicity of
weak designs of this detail proves this
proposition. One of the most aggra-
vated examples of this kind is the two-
plate type — a beautiful scheme on paper,
but lamentably bad in metal. A bolster
of this brand is the weakest thing that
could be devised to support a load, with
the possible exception of the wooden ar-
rangement, and yet these "failures" are
still put under cars. One of the two-plate
kind of bolster was noticed recentlv on
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
some drawings for new 60,000 lb. cars,
'where the plates were ^ inch thick by
12 inches wide; this was positively the
worst case among many bad ones, and
it is difficult to conceive an arrangement
better calculated to let the side bearings
come together. It probably never oc-
curred to the designer to dispose his
material with the sides in a vertical
plane and have a bolster with a resisting
moment of some value. This is the
"head and front of offending" in every
instance, that the problem is approached
by any but the man who is conversant
with stresses and how to provide for
them — in other words, the engineer — and
he is not infallible. If liability to spread-
ing rails, broken flanges and excessive
resistance on curves is be avoided, the
bolster must be made to stand up with-
out deflection under the load.
It is not necessary to go on a still
hunt for trouble with car details, they
are ever present in too many tangible
shapes to be forgotten, or ignored when
known. The draft rigging is another
place that gives evidence of the need
of care, more now than ever since
heavy cars are here. In this detail there
are two points to consider in order to
gain the highest efficiency, namely: The
location of the drawbar so that the center
line of draft coincides with the longitud-
inal center line of sills as nearly as pos-
sible, for the purpose of eliminating the
lever arm through which the draft and
buffing forces act. The necessity for a
device that will absorb these buffing
strains is a serious one, and while there
is such a draw gear which uses friction
as the medium for the purpose of ab-
sorbing shocks, we have the old spring
drawbars which absolutely fail under
many conditions, and these are con-
tinued in use with a full knowledge of
their shortcomings, when the limit of im-
provement has not yet been reached for
this kind of a gear.
The arrangement of truss-rods affords
a fine field for the mechanical juggler,
and this can be verified by a random ex-
amination of different car drawings pub-
lished in the technical press, which will
make it evident that the principles of
moments or parallelogram of forces is
as Sanscrit to some who ought to know.
If this were not so, truss-rods would be
made to deposit their loads as near the
center of the bolster as practicable, and
more attention would be given to the
question of depth of truss and also the
spacing of cross ties, all of which exer-
cise the greatest effect in reducing fiber
stresses. These points embrace the need
of improvement in a few car details:
others will be treated later.
Electricity vs. Steam Power.
Some very sensational statements have
recently been cabled out from England
as to what is alleged is about to be done
in the matter of the substitution of elec-
tric traction for that of steam power on
important lines in the United Kingdom.
From what has been said and written
on the subject, one might almost im-
agine that the British engine driver and
fireman would hardly have time to take
their overalls off the discredited locomo-
tive before it was consigned to the scrap
heap as a useless and antiquated ma-
chine. We have repeatedly noticed that
the dear old locomotive of our youth
has been from time to time, joyfully con-
signed to oblivion by sensation-mongers,
and the whole thing is taken as gospel
truth by the thoughtless or the ignorant.
As a matter of fact, what little fire
gave rise to so great a cloud of smoke
was briefly that the representatives of
two British companies, conferred to-
gether for the purpose of arranging that
the electrically propelled trains of the
one should be able to run over the lines
. of the other. The two corporations are
said to have been the Metropolitan and
the District (underground) railways of
London. How it happened that a system
of what we would call car interchange,
and the necessary adoption of similar
electrical standards by two companies,
could have been regarded as in any way
foreshadowing the retirement of the lo-
comotive throughout the British Isles, is
known only to that class of writers, who.
along with the heathen, according to
Holy Scripture, "imagine a vain thing."
This matter is of interest to us inasmuch
as the retirement of the locomotive in one
country would practically mean its
abandonment in others.
With regard to the substitution of
electricity for steam on trunk lines in
England it has been said that one of
the reasons which induced Mr. James
Holden. locomotive superintendent of
the Great Eastern, to design his
suburban "Decapod" (which was illus-
trated on page 191 of our April issue),
was that steam power so applied was
cheaper than the installation and opera-
tion of electricity. It was stated that the
maximum service which electricity could
give with traffic existing on that portion
of the Great Eastern Railway, where
the "Decapod" operates, is a three-min-
ute, service. Mr. Holden's new engine is
expected to give the same service, but
with longer trains. The cost of electri-
fication, according to a foreign technical
journal, would be fully £2,500,000, where-
as the one-hundredth part of that sum
would be sufficient to build 50 engines
of this "decapod" class, and strengthen
any of the bridges which might require
it.
.•\n interesting writer on this subject,
Mr. Alton D. Adams, in a recently pub-
lished article, holds that electric traction
has proved its superiority for distributed
loads. That means that for short trains
frequently run, electric power is better
than that of steam, but that while con-
centrated loads are moved at intervals
of several hours, steam locomotives are
unquestionably the more economical of
the two. In support of this contention
he invites the hypothetical consideration
of a railway 100 miles long, on which
cars requiring 2,000 horse power must
be kept in motion. If 20 cars required
100 horse power each, in order to
move them over the road, the elec-
tric conductors and current-distribut-
ing apparatus would never be re-
quired to deliver more than lOO
horse power at any one point. If, how-
ever, the traffic represented by these 20
cars be concentrated into a single train,
then the conductors and distributing ap-
paratus would have to deliver the full
2,000 horse power at each and every
point along the line. This concentrated
load means multiplying by twenty the
capacity of the distributing apparatus de-
signed for the short trains, and this in-
volves a prohibitive capacity in, and cost
for, distributing apparatus, unless short
trains be run at frequent intervals.
The tendency of modern railroad op-
eration in this country, especially in the
handling of freight traffic, has been to-
ward the employment of the "large car,"
the long train, and the powerful locomo-
tive. These things make for economy
in various ways, among which may be
mentioned greater tonnage moved by
fewer train crews, which offers a sub-
stantial reduction in operating expenses
for wages, and reduces locomotive hand-
ling and some items of maintenance.
The whole question of steam or elec-
tric traction is simply one of dollars and
cents as far as corporatfons are con-
cerned, and the irresponsible predictions
of fl^boyant press correspondents may
indeed produce startling scare heads in
the daily papers, but they do not stand
for anything tangible in the railway
world.
If electricity ever permanently retires
the steam locomotive, it will not do so
in a single night. If the change comes
at all, it will only be by the gradual work-
ing out of the law of evolution, which
has hitherto permitted alterations to be
effected so slowly that the process may
be said to be tardy in the extrertie.
Though the "survival of the fittest" is
no doubt a natural law. yet its very ex-
istence pre-supposes a struggle, for no
type ever suddenly ceased to be. The
introduction of any new form, be it or-
ganic, mechanical, or intellectual, has
always been a slow process, by reason
of the vitality and growing power of
those forms which the newcomer seeks
to displace. Sudden and swift revolu-
tion has no place in natural law, which
always recognizes legitimate com-
petition. This matter of electricity or
steam on railways is as much amenable
to the operation of natural law as is the
relation of supply to demand.
May, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Overloaded Engines are Expensive.
"The overloading of engines is a most
expensive piacticc, occasioning more re-
pairs than ordinarily needed, and excess-
ive fuel consumption, it lessens the
capacity of a railvifay, and is expensive
in overtime and is indirectly the cause
of train accidents," so spoke Mr. G. J.
Bury, general superintendent Lake
Superior Division, Canadian Pacific
Railway, at a leccnt meeting of the
Canadian Railway Club.
The speaker referred to the increase of
101.91 average trainload tons between
the years 1889 and 1901 on his road.
Eased grades and lieavier engines in
part accounted for increase, but greater
loads for engines accounted for the re-
mainder. Transportation officers, he
said, know that to use minimum staff in
moving a given tonnage is the most
economical way to do it. If freight
trains average 15 miles an hour, train
crews can make 5,000 miles a month,
while if the average be reduced to 8
miles an hour, men cannot stand more
than 3,000 miles a month. If they make
2,500 miles during slack times for say
eight or nine months in the year, they
would be able to make, up to perhaps
5,000 miles for the few months of the
rush. The economical plan is, if pos-
sible, to make the regular, trained staff
handle a rush without dangerously over-
taxing them. More men employed with
trains traveling at slower speeds produces
greater risk of accident, first, by intro-
ducing longer service hours, and second,
by the larger employment of new men.
Mr. Bury makes a calculation in which
he shows that a 2-8-0 engine hauling
a . train weighing 1,100 tons (tare and
contents) over 118 miles up and down
several l per cent, grades at an aver-
age rate of 8 miles an hour, would cost
$41.96, or 32.3 cents per thousand miles.
The cost of a train of 1,000 tons (tare
and contents) hauled by the same engine
over the same division, but at 15 miles
an hour, would come to $34.13, or at
the rate of 28.8 cents per thousand miles.
The lighter train also produces less wear
and tear on the engine and so reduces its
maintenance account^ust how much
would have to be decided by actual tests
extending over a given period of time.
The economical load is, of course,
variable, but the speaker held that it was
decidedly uneconomical to overload en-
gines when traffic was dense, because, as
he rightly said, "even one train stagger-
ing and doubling over a district will
demoralize the trains following and
those met, resulting in overtime, extra
consumption of fuel and the risk of
train accident, which increases when
train and enginemen are long hours on
duty."
The conclusions of Mr. Bury agree very
closely with the practice urged by Mr.
Roesch and other correspondents of
Rmlway and Locomotive Engineering,
that a fairly light train lo.ul is the most
economical.
Why an Engine Pounds Harder on Left
5ide Than on the Right.
A correspondent of ours, whose letter
is printed in another column, calls atten-
tion to the fact that an engine loose in
her boxes pounds harder on the left side
than on the right, and he humorously
says this has been attributed to tlic cfTect
of hard northeast winds.
It may be stated that the pound noticed
in an engine having the same amount
of lost motion in her boxes on both
sides, will always be greatest on the side
on which the "following" crank pin hap-
pens to be. In this country the leit is
usually the following side, so the greater
pound is observed to be on the left side.
When the engine stands with right
crank pin on forward quarter, the left
pin is on the top quarter. When the
stroke begins on the right side the ex-
isting lost motion will permit the box
on that side to be driven back against
the rear horn, while at the same lime
the crank pin on the left side is being
pulled forward, and if the left side of the
engine alone was working, this pull
would be competent to keep the driving
box on the right side away from the
back horn and tight against the front.
Therefore the pound caused by the mo-
tion of the piston on the right side be-
ginning its stroke, is always opposed by
the forward pull of the crank on the left
side.
Consider the case where the left-hand
crank is on the forward quarter and the
right is on the bottom. Here the push
on the right side having crowded the
axle back as far as it will go on the right
side, is also tending to drive the left
box back. This is augmented by the
straight, fair and square push back,
which the left piston is able to give when
it begins its stroke.
In the former case the two sides
worked so that the pound was slightly
neutralized every time. In the second
case, the pound was produced by the
joint action of both sides, and the hard
northeast wind before referred to, may
have helped to waft the sound of the left
side pound to ears of the men on the en-
gine.
The passenger engines on the Southern
California lines of the Santa Fe with
Vanderbilt furnaces, use an average of
16.000 gallons of water in five hours.
That is equivalent to 25.600 pounds of
water an hour, or 626.6 pounds per min-
ute. As 20 pounds of water or its
equivalent of steam per hour may be de-
pended upon to produce one horse power,
these engines develop over 1.200 horse
power per hour in ordinary working.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(29) E. R. M., Lafayette, Ind., asks:
What is the difference between a di-
rect and an indirect connected engine?
A. — A direct connected engine is one
which is so arranged that a forward
movement of an eccentric rod will pro-
duce a forward motion of the valve; and
a backward motion of rod causes a back-
ward travel of the valve. An indirect
connected engine is one in which the
opposite effect takes place in each case.
Indirect motion is usually produced by
the interposition of a rocker between
valve and eccentric, the rocker having
one arm above and one arm below its
center, so that when an eccentric rod
moves in one direction the valve will
move in the opposite direction. A good
and full explanation of this, and of how
the eccentrics arc placed on the axle for
direct and indirect motion may be had
by reference to the May, 1902, issue of
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
INO, page 220. The article is called "Set-
ting Piston Valves," and is worth care-
ful perusal.
(30) P. L. K. writes:
With a Vauclain compound, right for-
ward eccentric strap broken and forward
head of valve chamber broken, how would
you block and how much of your train
would you attempt to puU? A. — If the
valve chamber cover was broken so as to
be useless, with the Vauclain outside ad-
mission valve you would be in much
the same plight as the runner of a simple
slide-valve engine would be in if the
steam chest cover was gone. The only
possible thing is to blank flange the
branch steam pipe in the smoke box.
That is a most difficult thing to do effec-
tively on the road with modern, large
engines using high pressure. If you
promptly ask for assistance you are
likely to get it before you could get your
train out of the way of others on a busy
line by attempting to fix up on the road.
(31) J. R. Algiers, La., asks:
How would you handle a standard
8-wheel underhung engine for a broken
tire? Engine in question is a Schenec-
tady make, weighs 75 tons, saddle extends
into driving box and is held in position by
a pin through box. Is it practicable to
handle this engine on the road? A. —
Yes. Suppose the left driving tire had
broken. Run this wheel up on a block and
so get it as high as possible. Put in a
couple of nuts or other convenient pieces
for blocking between the bottom of box
and the pedestal brace. Then block the
end of the equalizer near the left trail-
ing spring hanger by putting in a piece
of wood or other material between
equalizer and bottom bar of frame.
Block this down as far as possible to
somewhat relieve the pedestal brace.
Reverse the process if the trailing tire
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
was broken, but be careful about back-
ing into a siding with one of the trailing
wheels in the air.
(32) H. E. S., Snohomish, Wash.,
asks:
Why does the crown sheet in so many
makes of locomotives slope from the
flue sheet down to the back of the fire-
box? A.— The crown sheet, placed as
you describe, permits the flue sheet to be
made so as to give a large area for the
flues, and sloping back gives more steam
and water space if the roof sheet is hori-
zontal. It also has the advantage that
when the engine is going down grade,
a more uniform water level is maintained
than if the sheet had been perfectly hori-
zontal.
(33) C. H., Philadelphia, asks :
1, What is cylinder oil composed of
and what process does it go through
which makes it so expensive? A.—
Good valve oil, such as that supplied by
the Galena Oil Company, is compounded
of a refined product of petroleum, with
some good animal oils, the selection of
the ingredients and the compounding of
the mixture is done with a view to
eliminate all matter which would tend
to corrode the cylinders, valves, etc.
Moreover, such oil must be able to with-
stand the high temperatures now used
in locomotives and to retain its lubri-
cating qualities under these circum-
stances. The more fully valve oil meets
these conditions the probabilities are
the more expensive it will be to make.
2. What is crude oil composed of?
A,— Galena engine oil is made from
Franklin crude oil, mixed with whale
oil and red lead in certain proportions,
known only to the manufacturers. These
constituents are combined in such a way
that the lead is held in solution in the
oil, and is conveyed by the waste to the
journal and fills up the interstices in the
bearing.
(34) Subscriber, Delphos, O., writes:
We have an 8-wheel 17X24-UI. engine,
Rhode Island make, which, when work-
ing, the water in the glass is full of large
bubbles and has always been that way.
It is impossible to tell where the water
is by it. The water valve is set even
with the crown sheet, and steam valve is
top of boiler head. Engine does not
seem to be priming. Will you please ex-
plain cause? A. — It is possible that the
engine referred to has a very small steam
space in the boiler, and that gentle prim-
ing is going on all the time. Some loco-
motives are built deficient in steam room
from the start. It is always safer to
have the lower gauge glass mounting
three or four inches above the highest
point of the crown sheet, and the open-
ings both top and bottom should not
be too small. In any case, they should
be kept thoroughly clean to allow free
flow of steam and water.
(35) W. J. W. writes:
(1) Considering one side of a loco-
motive only, and considering the total
pressure on the piston the same in
both cases, where does she have most
power or strain on the draw bar, when
the main pin is directly below or di-
rectly above? A. — The maximum effort
is when the crank pin is on the top, or
is on the bottom quarter, the effect in
each case is exactly the same. (2)
Considering everything, at what point
does a locomotive have most power and
why? A.— When both sides are con-
sidered, the maximum power is exerted
when the right crank pin is midway be-
tween the top and the forward quarters,
and the left midway between the back
and the top quarters. Corresponding
positions or the eighth positions below
the axle give equal power. The reason
is that these positions form what may be
called the best average position for both
sides.
(36) A. K., Post Falls, Idaho, writes:
Is it not a fact that a locomotive and
similar engines with link motion and
valves set to give lead, with reverse lever
in the center notch, one of the ports is
open the amount of the lead, no mat-
ter in what position the engine stands?
A.— No, this is not how the valve moves.
With properly designed valve gear, and
no lost motion, placing the reverse lever
in the center of the quadrant, ought to
shut ofif steam from the cylinder alto-
gether. An interesting point is that
with piston at one end of cylinder, the
valve will be open, the amount of the
lead, if the reverse lever is full ahead or
in full back gear. You would be able to
work out many of these problems for
yourself if you had one of our valve mo-
tion models.
values smart looking men, and is pre-
pared to pay something for what they
want. There are said to be calls among
the men for the introduction of this sys-
tem on other parts of the line.
The Susquehanna Iron & Steel Com-
pany, of Columbia, Pa., is about to in-
stall an electric power distribution plant
in its mills. A recent purchase from
the Westinghouse Electric & Manufac-
turing Co. comprises a 400-kilowatt, al-
ternating-current generator, one 200
horse-power induction motor, and 300
to 400 horse power in motors, ranging
in size from 50 horse power to 20 horse
power.
The famous New York Central engine
999, which, after being thoroughly over-
hauled, is now engaged in hauling Uncle
Sam's fast mail on the Central, has been
greatly pleased and very much flattered
at the phenomenal sale of her picture,
since we called attention last month to
our transparent engraving of this typical
"American" engine, shown in section
with the correct mechanical name of
every part given. We have been busy
mailing these charts all over the coun-
try, and the demand keeps up. An idea
of what her picture is like is given on
advertising page 8 of this issue. Engine
999 is as popular as a foot-light favorite,
though she may be more correctly styled
a "headlight favorite."
The railroad companies using oil fuel
in locomotives find that the extension
front end is a disadvantage, and are
shortening it to the length that prevailed
J^efore the extension front mania struck
the country. Many coal burners would
not suffer if their front ends were
shortened by half.
A short time ago, Mr. W. L. Derr,
superintendent of the Erie Railroad at
Jersey City, introduced a novel and most
effective plan for having passenger train-
men present a neat and trim appearance.
At the beginning of every month each
man who is entitled to the privilege is
provided with a ticket which is honored
at certain establishments. The tickets
are "good" for various services, and the
company pays for them. The holder of
one of these tickets is entitled to have
his trousers cleaned and pressed twelve
times in the month, and other articles of
apparel six times in the same time. It
also secures the services of boot-black
twenty-five times. Mr. Derr, in his cir-
cular, requests the men to be very par-
ticular concerning their personal appear-
ance. Now, when you see a well-
groomed conductor with a clearly defined
crease down the center of each leg of his
trousers, his coat and cap well brushed
and his buttons shining, you will
appreciate the fact that the Erie
One of our friends, Mr. J. B. Phillipps,
a gang foreman in the Southern Cali-
fornia shops at San Bernardino, has in-
vented a variety of labor-saving tools
which he has agreed to have illustrated
in Railway and Locomotive En-
gineering.
Compound locomotives are more
popular among enginemen on the Pacific
coast than they are anywhere else where
we had the means of noting unbiased
opinions. It is a common thing for en-
gineers to make requests for compounds
in preference to simple engines.
The Evansville & Terre Haute Rail-
road have recently ordered three con-
solidation engines from the Baldwin
Locomotive Works, in Philadelphia.
This road has received two Atlantic
type passenger engines from the Amer-
ican Locomotive Company.
May, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
223
Air= Brake Department.
Air-Pump Repairs.
The good practice u( assembling all
air pumps for repairs at a central point
is becoming more general witli a larger
number of our railroads.
The centralization of pump repairs
means a great deal to the air-brake ferv-
CONDCCTED BY F. M. NEI<I<IS.
Other repairs, which seem to grow out
of the first repairs.
New Alr-Brake Foundry.
The Westinghouse Air-Brake
Company will at once begin the
erection of a new foundry to
a greater efTiciency in production and
prompt delivery of material, it has be-
come necessary to provide greater
capacity. This addition to the plant will
materially increase the Brake Company's
working force, now numbering about
3,000 men, the majority of whom reside
in VVilmerding and vicinity.
WESTINGHOrSE AIK BR.VRH COMTANY'S WURK.S, HANOVER, GERMANY.
ice. It means that when repairs are
once made on a pump, at a specially
centralized point, it may be taken for
granted that the work is quite well done.
Whereas, if the work be done in the
round house in running repair fashion,
it must be hurriedly done in order to
permit the engine to keep moving, and
the consequence is that the work will be
done by a general utility man and the
work will most probably be slighted. A
few such repairs as this returns the pump
to the round house after a very short
term of service. A repetition of such
loose repairs just mentioned soon places
the pump in a general bad condition, in
which a malrge number of repairs have
been made, and each one quickly and
slightingly done. The pump is a victim of
numerous doses of bad medicine. The
result is that instead of really improv-
ing, the pump grows weaker and weaker
until it finally gives up the ghost in a
bad air-pump failure.
The advantage of back shop repairs,
where air-pump work is centralized,
special and efEcient workmen are em-
ployed, and after repairing the pumps
their work is carefully tested. The lat-
ter system of repairs will do much to-
ward greatly and permanently improv-
ing the air-brake service. It is a notice-
able fact that many pumps repaired on
engines in round house? soon return for
be 320 feet long by 65 feet wide, and
constructed of brick with steel frame.
This foundry will be located just west
of the present air-brake works at
1902 nodal New York Engineers'
Brake Valve.
The accompanying figures illustrate
the improved New York Engineers'
Brake Valve, which is known as the 1902
model. This valve retains in its con-
struction all the essential features of its
predecessor, known as the Vaughn-
McKee brake valve, and it possesses in
addition several modifications of the
working parts, which make it completely
automatic.
It will be observed from the figures
that the valve consists of a main slide
valve 114-A; a handle to move the main
slide valve; a seat for the main slide
valve, shown in Fig. l; a piston 104-A;
a lever 112; a small cut-off valve no, an
excess pressure valve 97, and a cover
IIS-A, and a body lOi-A. to enclose these
parts.
The modifications consist principally
of a change in the shape of port ], in
WESTINGHOUSE AIR BR.\KE COMl'.>\NYS \VORKS, LONDOX, EXGL.^ND.
Wilmerding, and has been made
necessary by the greatly increased de-
mand for castings used in the apparatus
manufactured by this company. Owing
to the development of the traction brake
business, the Air-Brake Company's pres-
ent foundry facilities have been overtaxed
tor some time past, and in order to insure
the main slide valve, and the addition of
a tee-shaped cavity P to the face of this
valve, as shown in Fig. 2; of a port and
passage O, which begins in the center
of the back cap 102-A, Fig. 3. passes
up through the back cap, then through
the valve body ioi-.\. into and along
through the valve cover 115-A, Fig. 4,
224
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
to the point marked 0 in plan of valve
seat, Fig. i ; then it re-enters valve
body loi-A, and ends in the seat of main
slide valve 114-A; of a vent valve 180,
Fig. 3, attached to the stem of piston
104-A, by means of a combined follower
nut and cage, which controls passage
0, when the piston is in the position
6
O
o o
RdOway $ Loixmotiiv Engineering
shown; and of a ball-check valve 1S4 held
in a cage formed in a boss on the front
of piston 104-A. The purpose of these
modifications is to locate automatically
piston 104-A in its proper position re-
gardless of the method employed in
handling the brake valve, and to charge
the supplementary reservoir through the
small port in piston 104-A. controlled by
check valve 184, instead of through pas-
sage H, as is done in the older Vaughn-
McKee brake valve.
At passage H there is a pipe connect-
Face of Slide Valve
Railway f Lvcomutut iT'i^nKrinp
litj. 2
ing a small receptacle, known as the sup-
plementary reservoir, to the brake valve.
The supplementary reservoir may have
any convenient location in the cab, pro-
vided only that it is somewhat higher
than the location of the brake valve it-
self, and its function is to enlarge cham-
ber D, behind piston 104-A, and to liold
sufficient air to expand behind this
piston, and move it the proper distance
forward in service applications. The
positions of the dififerent valves and their
relations to one another when the valve
is being operated, is shown in Figs. 5,
6, 7, 8, 9 and 10. (Six views showing re-
lease, running service, positive lap, au-
tomatic lap and emergency positions.)
In Fig. 5 the handle of the brake valve
is shown in the extreme forward posi-
tion. In this position (release) the rear
edge of main slide valve 114-A, uncovers
port A in the seat. Through port A the
main reservoir air may flow freely into
the train pipe to raise up quickly the
pressure therein, thus releasing che
brakes promptly and quickly recharging
the auxiliary reservoirs.
The running position is shown in Fig.
6. Here the main slide valve 114-A
covers port A in its seat, and the main
reservoir air flows to the train pipe by
way of the excess-pressure valve 97, not
shown in this figure, but shown in Fig.
4. In this position excess pressure is
obtained in the main reservoir, the
amount of excess obtained depending
solely on the tension of the excess press-
ure spring. Referring to Fig. 4, which
is a cross-section through the excess-
pressure valve, it will be observed that
this valve is constructed similar to a
steam pop valve; that is, there is a flange,
(ir projection, on it so that when it lifts
from its seat the air may impinge upon
this flange, and thus raise the valve
higher from its seat, and permit a faster
feeding up of the train pipe.
Positive lap position is shown in Fig.
7, and when the handle is in this position
all communication between the main res-
ervoir and the train pipe, and also be-
tween the train pipe and the atmosphere
is cut ofT, or, in other words, in positive
lap position, the valve prevents the flow
of air in any direction through it.
In the service application. Fig. 8, main
slide valve, 114-A, is moved back until
port F, in its face, is uncovered, and
port 0 in the seat is covered and port
G, which communicates with port F, is
brought over exhaust port C, which leads
to the atmosphere. The service applica-
tion position is shown in Fig. 8, and the
.arrows indicate the course the train pipe
air takes in flowing to the atmosphere.
The air in the supplementary reservoir
and chamber D, on account of port 0
being blanked and the passage through
the piston 104-A being blocked by valve
of it, until the small cut-ofif valve no,
through the medium of the lever 112, is
moved far enough to cover port F again,
and so prevent further reduction in train
IIBA
Fig. 4.
pipe pressure. The valve when lapping
port F in this way is said to lap auto-
matically, and the location of all parts
in this positions is shown in Fig. 9.
In all cases of emergency, the handle
of the brake valve should be moved to
the emergency position as shown in Fig.
10. Train pipe air leaving chamber A
passes out through port /. shown in
^^gg%;'^^--^"^^l^aj^
lOlA
Fig- 3
184. will now expand and push piston
104-A forward as fast as the pressure
falls in chamber A (train pipe) in front
Fig. 10, and port K, wliich coinniunicates
with port / by means of a passage
through the main slide valve connecting
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
225
these two ports, and the exhaust port
C to the atmosphere. These ports arc
made large purposely so that train pipe
air may flow freely to the atmosphere
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On Alr-Brake Subjects.
ii'tiitu'iy >> L^iinulitt L'tufiniMriiij
when the handle is in emergency posi-
tion, in order that a sufficiently quick
and sudden reduction in train pipe press-
ure may be had with which to start the
quick-action parts of the triple valves
into operation.
ISO [ [J) ■'
(39) A. P., Newton, Sydney, New South
Wales.
In the Improved Driver's Brake valve
rotary, there is a small port drilled
(35) J- P- P-. Highbridgc, N. Y., asks:
What brakes are to be used on the
underground cars when that road is com-
pleted in New York city? A.— The
Westinghouse quick-action automatic
air brakes.
(36) E. R. G., Kalispell, Mont., asks:
How much more time will it require
to charge, say a 40-car train of air, at
an altitude of 5,300 feet than at
an altitude of 2,900 feet? This means, of
course, from nothing to 70 pounds. A.
— About 40 seconds.
(37) P- J- F- Oelwein, Iowa, asks :
Why do you not put a cut-out cock in
the driver brake pipe to each cylinder, so
that one cylinder can be used if the
Mr. M. LaQuay, until recently air-
brake inspector on the Chicago & Alton
R. R., has accepted a position with the
New York Air Brake Co.
Fig. 6.
Lovk-est, Most ; Highest, Least.
I send you a sketch of steam pipe
connections to pump testing rack at
Stratford Shops of the Grand Trunk
Railway. The 2-inch steam main is per-
pendicular. Will the lubricator, placed
at A, lubricate all three pumps equally?
Robert L. Stamp.
. Stratford, Canada.
Flg.7 I 1~T'1 ^ )
rig.s
BaUmit 4 Ltievmvtm £i«0U«ibi#
through, and situated about one inch to
the right of the. reserve pressure port,
will you kindly say what the object ol
this port is for and its use? A. — This
port is called the "warning port." Its
object is to warn the engineer that the
brake valve handle has been left in full
release position, and should be returned
to running position. In full release posi-
tion this port permits main reservoir
pressure to escape to the atmosphere,
producing the warning sound.
(40) R. L. E., Elkhart, Ind., asks:
Why will not a retaining valve on the
driver brake hold in the slack of the
train when brakes are being released and
Raitvay ^ LoiMMn/fiK Hjiginocring
other gets out of order? A.— It is not
good practice to attempt to use one
driver-brake cylinder if the other should
become defective or faulty, as this would
throw uneven strains on the side rods of
the engine, and if the wedges were not
set up snugly, it might be the means of
stripping one side.
(38) D. J. L., Burlington, Mo., asks:
How long does it take for the air to
travel from the engine to the rear car
on a 50-car train in releasing brakes?
A.— The time would depend largely on
the difference in pressures in the train
pipe and main reservoir, and the capacity
of the main reservoir. With a reservoir
of about 25,000 cubic inches capacity and
at a pressure of 90 pounds, if opened into
a train pipe whose pressure was about
60 pounds, the time required for the wave
of increased pressure to travel from the
engine to the fiftieth car would be be-
tween 7 and 10 seconds.
Sailmi]/ } £M«M«m<i E
Fig. 9.
keep the train from breaking in two as
well as the combined straight-air and au-
tomatic air brake? A.— Retaining valves
226
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
on locomotives, for holding in the slack
-of a long freight train when brakes are
released, have not proven a success. A
great fault is the fact that the leather
packing in the driver brake cylinders
leaks away the pressure, depriving the
retainer of a chance to do its work,
therefore rendering it inadequate and
Railway .J- Locomotive Enginetring
useless. The combined automatic and
straight-air brake, when set straight air,
to hold in the slack while brakes are
being recharged, connects the main res-
ervoir with the driver-brake cylinders,
thus furnishing a large and constant air
supply to these cylinders, keeping the
brakes set regardless of any leakage in
leather packings. The air pump is virtu-
ally pumping direct into the driving-
brake cylinders.
(41) C. C. A., Scranton, Pa., writes:
I am told that the air-brake pump
used on locomotives is extravagant and
costly in its use of ste^. One engineer
says the air pump uses as much steam as
the engine cylinders do. A. — While the
air-brake pump is extravagant in its use
of steam, especially when based on the
quantity used compared with other
pumps and engines, it is far less extrava-
gant in steam use than is the engineer
above mentioned in his assertions. An
eminent authority states that several
times as much steam is required by the
air-brake pump to compress a given vol-
ume of free air to a certain pressure as
would be used by the most efficient mod-
ern compressor to do the same work. But
then, air-brake pump service is peculiar.
The pump uses steam mostly when the
engine throttle is closed, standing at
stations or drifting down grade, and
when the safety valves would otherwise
be blowing such steam away. Less
steam used by the air pump would not,
generally speaking, mean more steam
for the locomotive cylinders, but more
steam for the safety valves. Again, the
air pump is very simple in its mechan-
ism, and always ready for immediate
service. This is not true of the most
highly efficient air compressors.
(42) D. H. R., Syracuse, N. Y.,
writes:
What is the difference between a high
pressure control system and the system
which has the two governor tops, with
one top connected to the under side of
the brake valve that you illustrated in
the February number? A. — The two
systems are distinct and separate.
The high pressure control is a device in
which, by turning the reversing cock, a
high pressure governor top and high
pressure feed valve attachment may be
cut in, and simultaneously a low pressure
governor head and feed valve attachment
be cut out. Likewise, by a reverse move-
ment of the handle of this cock, the low
pressure parts may be cut in and the
high pressure parts be cut out. The
high pressure parts will give pressures of
90 pounds in the train line and no
pounds in the main reservoir. This high
pressure feature is for trains whose cars
are all loaded. On the other hand, the
low pressure parts give 70 pounds in the
train line and 90 pounds in the main
reservoir, and is used to operate trains
wholly made up of empty cars. The du-
plex high pressure main reservoir con-
trol apparatus is a device which merely
permits the controlling of main reservoir
pressure at about 20 pounds above the
train line pressure (or maintains an ex-
cess of 20 pounds), while the brake valve
handle is either in release or running
position; but when the valve handle is
placed on lap position, the pressure ob-
SII,VENE'S DRIVER BRAKE RELEASE
VALVE.
tainable in the main reservoir is greater,
because the low pressure governor head
is cut out and the high pressure head cut
in. Thus, on lap, the main reservoir may
be pumped up to whatever the high pres-
sure head is set for, and in running or
full release position, the low pressure
head will control. The advantage of this
arrangement is that the pump will labor
against a high main reservoir only while
the brake valve is on lap, and an unusual
high pressure will be thereby obtained
to release and recharge brakes.
J I /"Pipe
RaUvjan ^ Xocomufice £njine6ring
STEAM PIPE CONNECTIONS TO AIR PUMP
TESTING PLANT.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Driver Brake Release Cock.
We arc aware of the fact that brakes
set and engine reversed is a dangerous
practice. We lay ourselves liable to
spot tires and get demerit marks; and,
with wheels skidding, you will run by
the mark or into something.
My solution of the problem is to have
a pipe with a ^ stop cock located in
a conjUnient place in the cab and con-
nected to the brake cylinder pipe, which
we might term a quick release. Then, if
your brake is not in good condition, and
won't hold as much as you can with en-
gine reversed, release your' driving brake
with the J4 cock and reverse the engine.
You will find such a device handy to
switch with where you have a large cyl-
inder and small triple valve. Also, in
conjunction with this have a retaining
valve. The writer has both, and finds
them to be very handy switching and also
handling a train. B. McCloskey.
Louisville, Ky.
Driver Brake Release Valve.
There appears in your paper of No-
\ ember issue, an article on the sliding
of drivers with engine reversed. I am
sending you a blue print of an apparatus
used by myself for the past twelve years
to overcome the sliding of driving
wheels. This device acts as a kind of
retaining valve by plugging up the ex-
haust port of the triple valve. By so
doing, you make the driving brake inde-
pendent from the train. If the engineer
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
227
does not want the air on the drivers he
opens the globe valve and lets the air
off, and still has the air brakes set on
the train. Again, on long grades it be-
comes very handy, for he can let the
an engineer throws his engine over with
the brake set, his drivers will start to
slide, and he lets all the brakes off. I
have seen an engine running at thirty
miles an hour, without the air on her
Jiailwiti/ j L'icmHotilt EngincQring
A I,HVEK.\GK ruOBLEM.
air off his drivers and let the tires cool drivers, and by reversing her, the driv-
down. ing wheels will start to slide if the en-
I think this little device will help a gineer doesn't give her steam,
good many engineers from getting into T. Silvene.
trouble from Hatting or sliding driving Victoria, B. C.
Fig. 1
Early Form of Triple Valve.
One of the first forms of all-metal
triple valve is illustrated' herewith. The
section of this triple valve is also
shown. As will be observed, the triple
valve has no feed port in the bush as
has the present form of triple, the feed
of pressure from the train line side of
the triple piston into the auxiliary reser-
voir being through the center of the
trunk of the piston, in which is a "feed
needle." Tbis type of triple valve is
commonly known as the "center feed,"
or " needle feed."
On the bottom of the triple is a large
drain cup, much larger than seems neces-
sary in common practice. This triple
valve is also supplied with a device for
disposing of train pipe leakage, which
the modern leakage groove in the brake
cylinder now takes care of. This little
bit of air-brake history may be of inter-
est to some readers.
Amos Judd.
Boston, Mass. —
Soiling another will never make one-
self clean. — Tennyson.
OLD CENTER-FEED TRIPLE.
wheels. If he wants to reverse the en-
gine, all he has to do is to open this
valve which lets the air off his drivers,
and still he has the air on his train. If
The Southern Pacific Company have a
remarkably intelligent equipment of en-
ginemen and the younger men ought to
be afforded every facility for keeping
themselves posted about the changes of
mechanism coming into use all the time.
A Levera)j;e Problem.
The sketch accompanying this litter
was handed me by a friend, and I would
like to have your idea as to its value.
You see the idea is a system of levers
for car braking, wherein the fulcrum of
the levers are utilized as braking power,
instead of being solid to the car body.
I would like to have the opinion of
other readers of the Magazine on this
subject. C. P. McGiNNis.
Chicago, III.
Ao. It
OLD CENTER-FEKD TRIPLE VALVE WITH
DRAIN CUP ATTACHMENT.
The Georgia Railway & Electric Com-
pany are building cars to be used in dis-
tributing light freight in and around
.Atlanta. That business is gaining favor
with many street car companies and the
prospects are that in the near future
most of them will be engaged in it.
228
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
On to California. First Section,
the Lackawanna.
Over
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
The doctor said that the raw, damp
winds which circulate around New York
in February and March accentuated the
infirmities of age and enabled rheuma-
tism to twist around its most excruciat-
ing screws. "You must go to a milder
climate," positively asserted the disciple
of Esculapius, and I suggested Florida.
Florida is too near your office was the
next opinion, you would be back every
week. Go to California. The doctor's
advice was seconded by others who
wield influence in my affairs, and that
is how I decided to visit California.
The journey of nearly 3,200 miles from
New York \o Los Angeles does not
give the sudden transformation from
winter to summer that a traveler goes
through in the brief run into Florida, but
the gods cannot take away the pleasure
that memory brings." Those who en-
joy the pleasures of travel too seldom
thoroughly appreciate the privileges com-
ing to them. When a man spends seven
or eight hours a day in a sleeping car play-
ing solitaire, and when a woman keeps
plunged all day long into the recesses
of dime novels, the natural inference is
that the principal advantages they enjoy
from travel is telling friends where they
have been and what lovely scenes they
have seen — in the photographs.
A trip over the Lackawanna is a good
introduction to people starting out with
the expectation of deriving much en-
joyment from what is to be seen in the
Rocky, the Sierra Nevada and other
mountains, with all the varying scenes
of flood and field, that are always strik-
ing as surroundings wherever mountains
rear their heads above the clouds.
PICTURESQUE LACKAWANNA.
the experience is a much more interesting
one and compels the traveler to see a
long stretch of most varied country,
which impresses every observant person
with the vast possibilities of the United
States for the support of an enormously
increased population.
Our entire outward journey took the
party over the Lackawanna, the Nickel
Plate and the Santa Fe lines. They all
have charms all their own, and during
the five days of the journey there were
attractions enough to make every mile
of the way marked with a white stone,
engraving impressions that become a
lifetime heritage.
In ancient lore mention is made of a
great man endowed with the gift 01 en-
joying outward impressions. He had
seen and heard many beautiful things,
and misfortune having come, he ex-
claimed in the midst of disaster, "I have
enjoyed great happiness and seen many
wonderful things, and even the wrath of
We are no sooner away from Hobo-
ken than we begin to see things that
would excite great interest among
strangers, more especially among foreign
travelers. The journey away from the
Hudson seems to be interdicted by
nature in the shape of a high ridge of
basalt rock, which we pass through in
a tunnel from which we emerge upon
the far-famed Jersey meadows. Mea-
dows by courtesy, but marshes in fact,
noted for the quantity of mosquitoes
raised annually, and they in their turn
for their ferocity. I have traveled in
many lands, and I have made the ac-
quaintance of many mosquitoes, but none
had the depths and endurance of sting
possessed by the Jersey breed.
Eight miles out we pass through New-
ark, one of the oldest cities in the
Union, with nearly 250,000 inhabitants,
having the greatest variety of industries
of any city in the United States, and
known by name to less than one per
cent, of the country's inhabitants; i
famous town unknown to fame through,
its proximity to New York city, the
greater overshadowing the less.
We are speeding through the Oranges
on a plateau which, three miles from
tide water, is 200 feet above the sea, and
has homes for 60,000 people suburban to
New York. We are climbing the
Orange "mountains," which would be re-
garded as low hills by people raised out
of Holland; but the Dutch who first
made settlements in this district, and had
never previously seen anything higher
than a windmill, looked with awe upon
the altitude of these hills, rising 500'
feet above the surrounding valleys.
Although the hill scenery here is not
majestic, it is highly picturesque, cov-
ered as it is by beautiful trees and foliage
of every hue.
In the rolling plains near these hills
many minor fights took place during the
War of Independence. We are thinking
of them when Morristown is reached,
where Washington had his army en-
camped during the winter of 1777. The
surrounding country is noted- for the
number of Washington headquarters.
Every tumble-down dwelling is reputed
to have sheltered "the father of his coun-
try" at some time.
We are now in a country that in a
charming manner combines the scenic
and the utilitarian. Attractive scenery
graces fertile farms, handsoifie resi-
dences appear to rush past us every few
rods, and presently we see signs of
manufacturing industry.
Since Mr. Truesdale became president
of the Lackawanna he has pursued the
poliw of encouraging and fostering in-
duswies. This policy was carried out
with intelligent discrimination, for no-
industry was encouraged to settle in a
place unless the conditions were likely
to promote success. A booklet pub-
lished by the company on industrial op-
portunities says:
"The aim of the railroad is not alone
to secure the location of industries, but
to secure locations under the most favor-
able conditions with respect to raw ma-
terials, the most available power, the
class of labor required, tlie market for
the product and the innumerable other
conditions which have their bearing upon
the production of manufactured goods at
a profit."
The first manufacturing town of any
irnportance reached by the Morristown
route is Dover.
When the history of the older indus-
trial centers in the L^nited States is
studied, we often find that the original
nucleus was a mill of some sort, or a
"forge," which people of British birth
would call a smithy. This was altogether
diflferent from the origin of Europeair
towns. Most of them originated with-
the building of a church or a castle.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
329
These were towers of strength, ami
houses gradually grew under their wings
like chickens under their mother's pro-
tecting cover. The origin of European
and of American towns was character-
istic. One needed the protection of re-
ligious grandees or of a powerful baron;
but all that the pioneer American needed
was the proximity to an established
peaceful industry.
I had almost forgotten Dover, N. J.
It originated from a forge, and has a
variety of manufactures, mostly of metal,
and is beautifully situated on the highest
position occupied by any city in New
Jersey.
AH along the line we find at nearly
every station signs of industrial opera-
tions of some kind, most of them in their
infancy, but at other places considerable
progress has been made, and Scranton
is one of the greatest manufacturing
cities in the United States. Other
towns, such as Elmira, Binghamton,
Corning, Stroudsburg, Danville and
Owego, produce a volume of manufac-
tures which provide good business for
the railroad.
The principal carrying business of the
road, however, is anthracite coal, large
quantities of it being mined in the neigh-
borhood of the track. To those who
suflered last winter from want of coal.
the long sidings full of coal cars loaded
over the brim, was a nerve inspiring
sight.
At some of the stopping places where
coal loaded cars appeared to be as nu-
merous as the sands of the sea. I noticed
the eyes of some of the passengers glis-
tened as they looked on with fond long-
ing, and I knew that they were among
the unfortunates who failed to put in
their winter supply last summer.
There is one feature about the Lacka-
wanna route which is unique. The way-
side is perforated with coal pits, and
nearly all the manufacturing towns pro-
duce iron products; yet there is a clear
sky all the way untainted by smoke. To
one who has gone through the "Black
Countries" of England, France and Ger-
many, where the beauties of nature are
blotted out by smoke and its products.
the difference is remarkably striking.
Where ugliness is artificially produced,
it exerts a baneful effect upon the hu-
man beings who are compelled to dwell
amidst such surroundings; and they are
slovenly and dirty, with meager pride
in personal appearance. In all rhy
travels in the Pennsylvania coal and
metallurgical regions, I have never seen
displayed the affinity to filth and squalor
so common in similar regions in Europe.
I do not seem to be making much
progress with our journey, but whilst
I have been thinking of such things, the
train has been speeding along, has
rounded glorious showing-off curves by
the Delaware river, has shot through the
Delaware Water Gap and is now climb-
ing Pocono mountain. 'Ihat meant that
we had been passing through some of
the favorite pleasure, health and pastime
resorts that tired New York uses for re-
cuperating waste of vital energy. Upon
the retina of my mind was printed
masses of gigantic rocks softened by en-
vironments of green foliage and verdure,
standing like a mighty rampart to pro-
tect the waters of a crystal river, rush-
ing with relentless force toward their
peaceful haven, the cold blue ocean;
green peaceful meadows, where sweet-
breathed kine lazily waded through beds
of wild flowers; hillsides where spread-
ing trees seemed to rival each other in
producing its own fairest tint of green,
which seemed to vary from blue to shad-
ed white, making a continued canopy of
greens varied as the trees themselves.
There are pictures of black-watered
twining had to be accomplished before
the city was reached. I have been on the
lops of many mountains, but I have sel-
dom seen such a striking sight as one
beholds from Pocono. Now ye men of
I..ackawanna receive me as a brother.
Although culm heaps arc too much in
evidence about Scranton, the town is
beautifully situated and has a most strik-
ing appearance in the distance. But
Scranton is in itself a stern reality, a
town with hollow coal mines extending
beneath like huge catacombs, while all
sorts of activities reign above the
ground. Whatever can be made from
the ores of iron is be found here under
manipulation, mostly in the rough.
There are steel rail mills, engine build-
ing works that embrace locomotives and
a variety of other industries that give
work of a lighter vein to willing hands,
such as silk making and piano making.
PICTURESQUE LACKAW.^NXA.
canals where long barges were moving
with weary pace, the Past lagging away
behind the Present. And there were
lakes and swamps and brooks with rush-
ing waters that suggested trout, and
buildings for storing ice fruit, and
burned woods and desolated land crying
laudly like the voice in the desert for
the planting of trees, that the nakedness
of its bosom might be hidden, and as we
recover consciousness we are climbing
Pocono mountain, as the toiling engine
plainly proclaims to our ears.
Pocono mountain is not so awfully
high after all, being 1,900 feet above sea
level; but everybody connected with the
Lackawanna system is proud of it, and
swears by it, and I strive to enthuse
through sympathy. But no effort was
needed for enthusiasm, when I rode on
the engine, one time, and suddenly be-
held the vision of a splendid valley be-
neath with Scranton apparently at our
feet, although 31 miles of twisting and
to say nothing of the great establish-
ment which houses the International
Correspondence Schools.
After leaving Scranton the route sel-
dom touches a wild country such as was
encountered in the first part of the
journey. The scenery is never tame, but
the track passes through a great deal of
fine agricultural country with rolling
swells and numerous valleys protected
by aspiring ridges. The traveler who
enjoys looking at nature dressed in its
most attractive robes, will have no in-
clination for reading or for playing cards
while passing over any part of the Lacka-
wanna system.
The company provides everything in
reason for the comfort of passengers.
Since Mr. Truesdale was elected presi-
dent in 1899 the road has been practically
rebuilt. The roadbed apd track have
been improved upon the most modem
lines, new bridges have substituted all
the old ones that were too light for
230
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
-80-ton engines and 50-ton cars. Curves
have been straightened out, grades have
been cut down and a modern system of
automatic block signals has been extend-
ed from New York to Buffalo.
The first-class condition of the rolling
stock is particularly noticeable, locomo-
tives have the appearance of being thor-
oughly cared for and the cars are clean,
airy and ride splendidly. There is no
smoke, no dust, and the cars are so well
ventilated that no request is ever heard
for open windows.
The dining-car service is remarkably
well managed on the restaurant plan, and
gives entire satisfaction to the patrons
of the road. After dinner I retired to
the smoking room for a taste of the
soothing weed and to glean the views
of my fellow travelers. The place was
unusually crowded. If Mr. Lee li^ad
hired a corps of travelers to praise the
Lackawanna management, they could not
matter, and has 312 illustrations. It is
what it claims to be, an up-to-date work
on the subject. It deals with explosive
motors for all purposes, and is complete
in its treatment of theory, practical de-
tails and operation of these types of
engines. Illustrations of parts, together
with tabulated sizes of explosive motors
for stationary, marine or vehicle power,
are given, followed by notes on the care
and management of these machines.
Electric ignition by induction coil and
jump spark are fully explained and illus-
trated with notes on testing for econo-
my and power, and the erection and in-
stallation of power plants.
The book has a comprehensive index
and gives a list of patents issued in the
United States for gas, gasoline and oil
engines and their appliances from 1875
to July I, 1902, inclusive. The book is
intended to afford information to every
one interested in this kind of motive
PICTURESQUK I,ACKAWAXXA.
have talked more enthusiastically about
the attractions of the road and the com-
forts of the train service. On ocean
liners, in hotels and in Pullman cars, I
have always found that the smoking
room habitues have correct knowledge
about the management of steamers,
hotels and railroad trains. The smok-
ing roorn opinion thoroughly endorsed
the management of the -Lackawanna and
their views coincided with my own in
■every particular.
power. It treats of the theory and prac-
tice of these engines as designed and
manufactured in this countrv.
English and American Loading Gauges.
The "Decapod" suburban engine de-
signed by Mr. Holden, locomotive su-
perintendent of the Great Eastern, is
said to be the largest engine ever built
in England, and the first one to have
five pairs of coupled wheels. This en-
gine was illustrated in Railway and
Locomotive Engineering last month.
It is built about as close to the English
load line as can be. British designers,
in gaining greater efficiency by increas-
ing the size of the boilers of their en-
gines, have been compelled to sacrifice
something of the artistic appearance
which has hitherto been one of the strik-
ing features of their machines.
Book Review.
Gas, Gasoline and Oil Engines, by Gard-
ner D. Hiscox, M.E. Publishers,
Norman W. Henley & Company, New
York, 1902. Price, $2.50.
Mr. Hiscox's work on Gas, Gasoline
and Oil Engines is now in its tenth
■edition, it contains 391 pages of reading
Not that Kind of Sand.
A four-year-old boy of the question-
asking breed was visiting San Diego
Mission with his mother. Mamma, re-
marked the boy, this is an awful sandy
place, is that why it's called Sandyago?
Hush, said the mother, don't talk so
much. It's not that kind of sand that's
meant.
Our old friend Mr. Geo. L. Weiss is
one of the incorporators of the Cleve-
land Car Specialty Company, which will
manufacture and deal in devices for
passenger and freight cars. Mr. Weiss
may be depended upon to give vim to the
company.
It is stated that a type of car built
for one of the tube railways of London
will have a novel form of construction.
A trailer car has been built for the City
& South London Railway with the plat-
form at either end attached to the truck.
The object of this is to permit the plat-
forms to swing with the truck, so that in
rounding curves the platforms wil! not
project over one rail, as they otherwise
would. Any one who has noticed an or-
dinary street car going round a curve in
a city like New York must have noticed
that the projecting basket fender, if it
has one, projects out into the roadway
so as to hardly cover the outer rail. A
person in the center of the track would
not be touched by the fender at all.
There will not be any fenders on the
English cars or people crossing the
track of the tube railway, but this illus-
tration serves to show what the designer
has in mind in attaching a platform to a
truck. ^
Boring mills are not generally em-
ployed to cut piston rings out of the
casting, but they can be made to do that
work when the pinch of necessity is the
mother of invention. Mr. C. W. Werst,
general foreman of the Southern Cali-
fornia shops, found that he did not have
enough lathes to turn the piston rings
in demand, so he enlisted the boring
mill. It bores and turns the blank in
one operation and then the work of cut-
ing off the rings takes very little time.
In the Southern California shops at
San Bernardino they forge the piston
head of steam-hammer pistons solid on
the rod. This practice is becoming gen-
eral in railroad shops and it deserves to
be universal for broken steam-hammer
pistons are very common and cause
troublesome delays.
The use of babbitted or brass-lined
eccentric straps is becoming almost uni-
versal with heavy modern locomotives.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND I,OCO.\iO I l\ 1-, KNoINEER!NG
231
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. A. Gordon Jones has been ap-
pointed assistant to the general superin-
tendent of the Southern Railway.
Mr. J. E. Chisholni is appointed gen-
eral shop foreman of the Chicago Great
Western, vice Mr. R. M. Crosby, pro-
moted.
Mr. Charles Hosier has been ap-
pointed foreman of the boiler shop on
the Evansville & Terre Haute Railway
at Evansville, Ind.
Mr. W. W. McCormick has been ap-
pointed trainmaster on the Great North-
ern Railway, vice Mr. C. M. Bryant, as-
signed to other duties.
Mr. W. K. McCoy has been appointed
trainmaster of the Adirondack Division
of the New York Central, with head-
quarters at Utica, N. Y.
Mr. K. V. Brogan, formerly chief dis-
patcher of the L. S. & M. S. R. R., has
been promoted to the office of trainmas-
ter of the Buffalo Division.
Mr. Harry A. Norton, of Boston,
Mass., sailed last month for Russia,
where the Norton Bali-Bearing Jacks
are now being extensively introduced.
Mr. R. M. Crosby has been appointed
master mechanic of the Oelwein Termin-
al, in charge of shops, round house and
car yard of the Chicago Great Western.
Mr. W. A. Vaughan has been ap-
pointed assistant to the general super-
intendent, of the Southern Railway,
with headquarters at Chattanooga, Tenn.
Mr. \Vm. Bennett has been appointed
superintendent of the Wisconsin Division
of the Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis &
Omaha Railway, vice Mr. Winter, pro-
moted.
Mr. Arthur W. Trenholnrhas been ap-
pointed general manager of the Chicago,
St. Paul, Minneapolis & Omaha Rail-
way, in place of Mr. W. A. Scott, de-
ceased.
Mr. W. T. Kuhn, general foreman of
the Lake Shore locomotive shops, has
been promoted to the position of master
mechanic of the Lake Erie & Western
Railroad.
Mr. Wallace C. Winter has been ap-
pointed general superintendent of the
Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis &
Omaha Railway, vice Mr. Trenholm,
promoted.
Mr. Thomas A. Walker has been ap-
pointed round-house foreman on the
Evansville & Terre Haute Railroad at
Evansville, Ind., vice Mr. C. W. Hyde,
transferred.
Mr. Walter M.iloy, formerly train dis-
patcher on the Chicago, St. Paul, Minne-
apolis & Omaha, has been aijpointed as-
sistant chief train dispatcher, vice Mr.
Nicoles, promoted.
Mr. Frank E. Nicoles has been ap-
pointed assistant superintendent of the
Wisconsin Division of the Chicago, St.
Paul, Minneapolis & Omaha Railway,
vice Mr. Bennett, promoted.
Mr. T. J. Foley, heretofore assistant
to the general manager of the Baltimore
& Ohio, has been appointed superin-
tendent of the Chicago Division, vice
Mr. W. C. Loree, promoted.
Mr. Willard Kells has been appointed
assistant master car builder of the Union
Tank Line Company, with office at 26
Broadway, New York. Mr. C. A. Smith,
consulting engineer, has retired.
Mr. C. O. Jenks has been appointed
assistant superintendent of the Eastern
Division, with jurisdiction over Second
District, Great Northern Railway, with
headquarters at West Superior, Wis.
Mr. R. A. McCandless has been ap-
pointed assistant superintendent of the
Dakota Division of the Great Northern
Railway, with headquarters at Larimore,
N. D., vice Mr. C. O. Jenks, transferred.
Mr. Charles W. Hyde, formerly round-
house foreman on the Evansville &
Terre Haute Railroad at Evansville, Ind.,
has been transferred to a similar position
on the same road at Terre Haute, Ind.
Mr. W. C. Loree, superintendent of
the Chicago Division of the Baltimore
& Ohio, has been appointed general su-
perintendent at Pittsburg, Pa., vice I. G.
Rawn resigned, to accept service on the
Illinois Central.
Mr. Owen Owen, master mechanic of
the Colorado Springs & Cripple Creek
District Railway, has been given charge
of the electric as well as the steam lines.
He will have charge of the power plants
and all electric equipment.
Mr. C. W. King, trainmaster of the
Colorado Springs & Cripple Creek Dis-
trict Railway, has had his jurisdiction
extended over the entire system, includ-
ing steam and electric lines. He has
also been appointed car accountant.
Mr. H. B. Hunt has been appointed
assistant to the general manager of the
Erie. Mr. Hunt was formerly a me-
chanical engineer on the Erie, and was
stationed at Meadville. It is understood
that he will have charge of the en-
gineering department in the general man-
ager's office.
Mr. James E. Simons, formerly con-
nected with the Pittsburgh Coal Com-
pany, and more recently with the Hunt
Foundry and Machine Company, has ac-
cepted the position of general manager
of the O. M. Edwards Company, of
Syracuse, N. Y.
Mr. C. A. Beck, formerly of the 'Frisco
system at Cape Girardeau, Mo., has been
appointed chief clerk and secretary to
Mr. T. A. Lawes, superintendent of mo-
tive power of the Chicago & Eastern
Illinois Railroad at Danville, III., vice
Mr. F. L. Davies, resigned.
Mr. Edgar N. Smith, formerly road-
master on the B. & M. R. Railroad, in
Nebraska, and previous to that on the
N. Y., N. H. & H. and the Boston Ele-
vated, has accepted a position with the
Railway Appliances Company, giving his
time particularly to the Q and C-Bonz-
ano Rail Joint.
Mr. C. C. Murray has accepted serv-
ice with the Railway Appliances Com-
pany, with headquarters at Pittsburg,
Pa., giving his time more particularly to
the sale of the Q. & C. pneumatic tools.
Last month the printer made us say it
was some one else. Mr. Murray is the
man, nevertheless.
Mr. A. B. Trenary, employed as pas-
senger engineer, has been promoted to
the position of road foreman of equip-
ment of the Southern Division of the
'Frisco System. We understand that the
superintendent of motive power has or-
ganized a staff of bright capable men
for this branch of railroad work.
Mr. W. Cockfield has resigned his
position with the National Iron & Steel
Works, Mexico City, to become super-
intendent cf machinery on the Inter-
Oceanic Railway of Mexico. He takes
the place of Mr. Louis Greaven, who
has accepted the service with the Tehuan-
tepec Railway as superintendent of ma-
chinery.
Mr. Frank L. Davies, chief clerk, mo-
tive power and machinery department of
the Chicago & Eastern Illinois Railroad,
and secretary to the 'superintendent of
motive power of the road for the past
eight years, at Danville, III., has been
nominated for mayor of Danville. He
has therefore resigned his position with
the C. & E. I.
Mr. William Lauder, who has been
foreman pattern-maker at the Montreal
shops of the Canadian Pacific Railway
for the last twenty years, has been one
of the first to take advantage of the new
pension system which has recently been
put into operation on that road. Mr.
232
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
Lauder was presented on his retirement
with a handsome wicker chair and a
walking cane, by his fellow employees.
Mr. Thomas P. Egan, president of J.
A. Fay & Egan Co., Cincinnati, Ohio,
manufacturers of wood-working machin-
ery, was one of the visitors at New
Orleans at the National Association of
Manufacturers' meeting last April. Mr.
Egan was the organizer and first presi-
dent of the association, and takes great
pride in this distinction, as this body of
'men is most influential in the country.
Mr. J. P. Roesch, formerly traveling
engineer on the Colorado &
Southern Railway, has been
appointed master mechanic
on the Chicago & Alton, with
headquarters at Slater, Mo.
Mr. Roesch is well known to
our readers through his
numerous contributions to the
pages of Railway and Lo-
co motive Engineering.
Those who were associated
associated with Mr. Roesch
in Colorado speak in the
highest terms of his ability
and popularity as a railroad
official and predict that he
will make a decided success
as a master mechanic.
Mr. Archie M. Baird has
been appointed agent to rep-
resent the Falls Hollow Stay-
bolt Co. at Topeka, Kan.,
and that vicinity. Mr. Baird
was formerly foreman boiler
maker of the Santa Fe, at
Topeka, and was the inventor
of several pneumatic tools
that are used in many (-ail-
road shops. He was also the
pantentee of a double crown
fire box. Mr. Baird learned
his business in the Illinois
Central shops at Chicago,
was for a time foreman boil-
er maker of the B. E. R. &
N. shops at Cedar Rapids,
la., and had a wide experi-
ence in ■ charge of boilers.
Mr. Lacey R. Johnson,
assistant superintendent of rolling stock,
Canadian Pacific Railway, Montreal, re-
cently gave a lecture at Toronto Junction,
under the auspices of the C. P. R. Club.
Mr. Johnson described the whole trans-
continental line from Montreal to Van-
couver. Many of his hearers who had
worked for years on one division of the
road and only knew that one. were great-
ly interested in the lime-light views of dis-
tant parts of the Ime, which were shown.
Lime-light views were als.o shown of the
trip from Yokohama in Japan, where
the C. P. R. steamships land passengers
from Vancouver to Hong Kong, the
British Island on the coast of China.
William Warren Card.
When the Westinghouse Air-Brake
Company were pushing their great in-
vention into popularity, one of the most,
active workers belonging to the com-
pany was General Sales Agent W. W.
Card. His genial personality won for
Mr. Card friends wherever he went
pushing the interests of the air brake, and
his capacity for making friends proved a
powerful factor in overcoming the ob-
jections railroad men nearly always offe:
to the introduction of a new device.
Hundreds of railroad men who met him
in those days still remember l\Ir. Card
WILLI.^M w. C.\KD.
with affectionate regard. The numerous
friends he has all over this continent will
be grieved to learn that his life was
taken away on the 4th of last month,
close to his own home, by a street car
accident.
William Warren Card was born in Nel-
son, N. Y., in 1831. His father was a
civil engineer, and the son elected to fol-
low his father's profession and was edu-
cated with that end in view. When only
19 years old, young Card went West and
proceeded to make his way amidst the
activities that were rapidly converting
Ohio into a populous State. He engaged
in whatever engineering work was most
readily obtained, and like all earnest
■workers rapidly puslied to the front. His
first regular railroad employment was on
what was then called the Tuscarawas
Valley & Wheeling Railway, where he
rose to be superintendent and chief en-
gineer. From there he went to the Pan-
handle as superintendent, and on that
road he first met Mr. George Westing-
house, who was then struggling to in-
troduce his air brake. Mr. Card had the
engineering acumen to recognize the
merits of the great invention, and at
once co-operated in having trials made
to demonstrate its value in controlling
trains. It was on his division
from Pittsburgh to Steuben-
ville that the first train equip-
ped with the Westinghouse
.Air Brake was put into reg-
ular service, and Mr. Card's
intelligent interest did much
to overcome the scruples of
railroad men against favoring
a device which was such a
radical departure from any-
thing hitherto tried.
Mr. Westinghouse, a re-
markably good judge of men,
was strongly attracted to Mr.
Card and there seemed to be
powerful mutual affinity be-
tween the two men. The re-
sult of their intercourse was,
that Mr. Card entered the
employ of the Westinghouse
Air-Brake Company as gen-
eral sales agent. It is doubt-
ful if a better man could
have been found in t'ne coun-
try, for he had an influential
standing among railroad of-
ficials, had a powerful per-
sonal magnetism, had the
God-given faculty of making
many friends and no enemies,
and possessed the thorough
knowledge of the brake's
mechanism that enabled him
to overcome all difficulties
and to explain understand-
ingly the details of the me-
chanism. He was not to
Mr. Westinghouse what
Boulton was to Watt, but he
was a pillar of strength to the company
in its struggling years, and an active
zealous official until the day of his death.
Mr. Card was elected Secretary of the
company in 1S81 and held the office till
last year when he was elected Second
Vice-President.
The writer first met Mr. Card at the
Exposition of Railway Appliances in Ch'-
-ago in 1883, and a warm friends'.iip was
formed that never cooled. In the course
of considerable social intercourse, I had
very good opportunities of judging the
man. In gladness and in sorrow he was
ever the same big hearted gentleman, full
of helpful plans for others less fortunate
May, 1903.
RAJLWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
23J
than himself, and ever giving many peo-
ple very good reasons (o be lliankful that
W. W. Card liad prospered in the world's
goods.
Mr. Card was married twice, first in
1862 at Columbus, to Miss Hattie Dins-
more. In 1890 he wedded Miss Mary
Llewellyn, of Pittsburg. He is survived
by the widow and four children. The
latter are W. D. Card, a Chicago busi-
ness m^n, who is now on a tour around
the world, having been last heard from
in Japan; H. S. Card, a business man.
of Zanesville, O.; Mrs. Nellie Card
Moore, widow of D. A. Moore, and Miss
Ruth Card. A. S.
Mr. A. W. Horsey, chief draughtsman
mechanical department, Canadian Pacific
Railway, has gone to England and Ger-
many on business for the company. His
duties will be principally in connection
with, the inspecting of the engines now
being built for the C. P. R. by the
Saxon Engine Works, of Chemnitz, in
Germany. Mr. Horsey will, while
abroad, avail himself of the opportunity
of visiting the diiTerent shops in that
country. He will also incidentally visit
the Hyde Park Locomotive Works in
Glasgow, where the company are also
having some engines built. There is, how-
ever, a regular inspector already there.
Mr. E. E. Clark, assistant secretary
of the Department of Commerce and
Labor, began life as a locomotive fire-
man. He was promoted for merit, and
was head of the Order of Railroad Con-
ductors, and one of the visiting labor
leaders when President Roosevelt at-
tended the convention of the Brother-
hood of Locomotive Firemen at Chatta-
nooga last year. On one occasion Mr.
Clark made a brief but pithy address,
to which the President listened. He was
so much struck with Mr. Clark's ability
that he subsequently appointed the labor
chief as one of the Anthracite Coal Strike
Commission. Mr. Clark justified the
President's choice and has been ap-
pointed to office in the newly-created
government department.
Mr. G. A. Bowers has recently been
appointed master mechanic on the South-
ern Railway, with headquarters at Alex-
andiia, Va. Mr. Bowers was born July
21, 1867, at Martinsburg, W. V.; he
graduated from the high school at Mar-
tinsburg, W. Va., in 1883, and the same
year was taken on in the B. & O. shops
as machinist apprentice, and served the
full term of four years, and in 1887 was
accorded a diploma, ranking first in ma-
chinist examination. In i8g6 he was
appointed night foreman of the Western
Maryland R. R. shops, with headquar-
ters at Hagerstown, Md. ; in 1897 was
appointed general round house fore-
man; in 1898 resigned that appoint-
ment to accept as position as as-
sistant chief engineer at the Maryland
University Hospital, Baltimore, Md., and
.ifler eight months' service resigned to
accept a position as assistant general
foreman of the shops of the B. & O.
R. R., with headquarters at Ilyndman,
Pa. He remained there two years when
he was appointed master mechanic of the
Baltimore & Annapolis Short lines, and
Annapolis, Washington & Baltimore
R. R. Co., at Annapolis, Md., and was
there until January 15, 1903, when he
accepted a position as general engine
inspector of the Southern Railway, and
on March i he was promoted to the
position which he now holds.
History of Smoke Stack Described by
Mr. W. de Sanno.
Supplementing Mr. W. de Sanno's de-
scription and illustrations of the old
Philadelphia & Columbia R. R. stack in
your April issue, I would say that it was
known as the "Shultz" stack, and origi-
nated with William Shultz, who was, I
think, master mechanic of that road in
its early days, and was patented by him
March 31, 1836, as will appear by refer-
ence to a copy of the patent drawing,
which I send you herewith. As this pat-
ent, with many others, was destroyed in
Fig. »
RaVwny ^ Looomiitite Eni/\ne«ring
SHULTZ SMOKE STACK.
the fire at the Patent Office in 1836, the
specification is not of record, but the
following brief description of it, which
may be of interest, appears in the Journal
of the Franklin Institute, vol. 18, New
Series, 1836, pp. 404, 405:
"There is to be a swell in the smoke
pipe, which will give to it the form of
two funnels joined together at their rims;
and across this wide junction there is
to be wire gauze stretched, the enlarge-
ment being intended to prevent any ob-
struction in the draught. The pipe for
waste steam is to perforate the sheet of
wire gauze, which is secured to it by a
flanch. Flues, which may be opened
when the engine is at rest, are to pass
on the outside of the conical enlarge-
ments, allowing a free draught; these are
to be closed by valves, when the engine
is in motion."
Claim. "What I claim is the whole ar-
rangement, as hereinbefore described,
without any connection with any other
machine heretofore constructed for the
same purposes."
I remember, as a boy, seeing many of
these stacks on the Columbia road, but
never saw them anywhere else. It may,
however, have been used on the engmcs
built by Harrison, Winans & Eastwick
for the Russian Government, in 1844 and
thereafter, as a stack of substantially the
same external appearance is shown in
the illustrations of their freight and pas-
senger engines, which appear, facing
pages 52 and 58, respectively, of "The
Locomotive Engine and Philadelphia's
Share in its Early Improvements," by
Joseph Harrison, Jr., Philadelphia, 1872.
J. Snowden Bell.
Pittsburgh, April j, 1903.
It's Not All Qoid That Qlisters.
To those of our readers who are
making microscopical examinations of
steel and to those who contemplate do-
ing so the following incident may be of
interest:
The metallurgical expert of one of the
largest steel companies in this country,
having extensive experience in this line,
was submitted by a friend some micro-
scopic photographs with the request that
he select the one representing the best
quality of steel, stating that after he had
made his selection he would find the
composition of the material marked on
the reverse side of the photograph. After
a careful comparison the expert decided
they all represented good steel and final-
ly selected one as being the best. Upon
examining the reverse side of the photo-
graph he was astonished to find that he
had selected a microscopical photograph
of a "ginger snap" as being the best
grade of steel.
Newspaper items have been for
months telling people that a locomotive
building plant which will cost millions
is about to be built at Port Dover, O..
for the purpose of building the Dodge
patent locomotives. We have been asked
repeatedly, what are the Dodge patents?
As far as we can learn the Dodge loco-
motive is designed to be operated by
power derived from hot water. A great
saving of fuel is of course promised, but
how the saving is to be effected has not
been shown. Capitalists are evident-
ly supporting the scheme which, how-
ever, proves nothing, for capitalists will
generally put up their money more readily
upon a freak than upon a practicable in-
vention, but the powerful support given
to this peculiar locomotive will ensure
that whatever merit it may possess will
be thoroughly demonstrated.
What the tongue is. I suppose the man
is. — Tale of Two Cities.
234
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
Liquid Fuel on the Pacific Coast.
Editorial Correspondence.
We have received so much uncertain
information, and read so many conflict-
ing statements in the last few years
about the use of liquid fuel in locomo-
tives on the Pacific coast, that I was
keenly interested in seeing with my own
eyes the methods of burning oil.
Through the courtesy of Mr. George
R. Henderson, superintendent of motive
power of the Santa Fe, I was granted the
privilege of riding on locomotives. I
have ridden on liquid-fuel burning loco-
motives in England and in Russia, =0 I
was in a good position to make a mental
comparisons.
There is a popular belief that little
skill is required to fire a locomotive suc-
cessfully with oil fuel; but the experi-
ence of the Southern California and the
Southern Pacific is, that it takes much
more skill and judgment to fire an oil
burner properly than it takes to fire
with coal. To do the work properly the
engineer and fireman must co-operate
constantly, as the supply of fuel must be
regulated according to the work the en-
gine is doing. I rode a long way on one
engine that was doing very irregular work
with a heavy passenger train, sometimes
running on the level and at other times
ascending or descending grades, and the
fireman did his work so well that a puff
of smoke was rarely seen. Other en-
gines that I watched appeared to smoke
a little at every change in the intensity
of work, while others again made smoke
all the time. I was informed that when
the tubes or fire box are leaking it is
impossible to fire without considerable
smoke.
The talk I heard both on the Southern
California and on the Southern Pacific,
was that oil fuel is harder on fire boxes
than coal, and that the Vanderbilt fur-
nace gets out of order more rapraly than
other furnaces. This is a significant
commentary on the prevailing methods
of railroad management in this country.
In itself, mineral oil is an ideal fuel, and
contains no element which would injure
the metal of the furnace, in the way that
the sulphur and other impurities in coal
does, but mineral oil provides the means
of maintaining a tremendously high
furnace temperature, and the tendency
on our railroads is to keep the tempera-
ture up to its maximum intensity. That
is done because the officials in charge
are never satisfied to receive anything
less than the very highest performance
within the capacity of a locomotive.
There is reason to believe that the
sheets of a furnace will sustain the
strains due to a certain number
of heat units going through them,
and that they will be worn out when this
volume of work has been done, no mat-
ter what time it takes. If, however, the
fire is forced so that in one furnace the
number of heat units is generated with-
in a year that in another furnace would
be spread over five years, it is not sur-
prising that the hard pressed furnace is
worn out in less than one-fifth the time
that the other one will remain in working
order. In addition to doing the work in a
short time, the hard-worked furnace is
subjected to destructive agencies that do
not affect the other. An intensity of
heat may be generated in a furnace that
will keep the fire surface of the sheets
almost red hot, and convert the water
on the other side into steam so rapidly
that the water is driven away from the
sheets and never presents a dense body
capable of absorbing the heat as it is
generated. From that cause a hard-
worked furnace will not give equal serv-
ice to one moderately worked when the
work is measured by heat units.
The state of the case on the Pacific
coast, as I summed it up, is: A fire
box of the ordinary pattern burning oil
is capable of producing much more heat
than it does when burning coal; a Van-
derbilt furnace burning oil is capable of
producing more heat than a fire box
using the same fuel, and the result is
that the furnace doing the most work
requires the most repairs.
The mechanical officials of both the
Southern California and of the Southern
Pacific strive most persistently to over-
come the difiiculties experienced with the
Vanderbilt furnace, but they do not suc-
ceed to their satisfaction, because the
engines are chronically overworked.
The Southern Pacific uses the Vander-
bilt furnace engines on freight, and they
do not give so much trouble as the
Southern California engines of the same
kind which are kept hauling passenger
trains; but the difference accords with
the difference of service. The engines
on both roads receive about the same
amount of care and of intelligent super-
vision. There is certainly no lack of
care or of intelligent interest on either
road. An official of the operating de-
partment was complaining to me about
the trouble the Vanderbilt furnaces give,
and I said that the engines were worked
too hard, and advised that they be given
lighter trains. That would never do, he
replied. Locomotives are built to haul
trains, and they ought to be worked at
their utmost capacity.
Two ordinary oil-burning locomotives
were engaged hauling certain passenger
trains on a certain division of the Santa
Fe, and they were by no means under-
worked; but it was found that an en-
gine with the Vanderbilt furnace could
do the work alone. The engine was
badly overworked in hauling the trains,
but there was no yielding, and the opera-
tive officials could not understand why an
engine doing double work should need
more repairs than one doing half the
duty.
The locomotives burning liquid fuel on
European railways are rated to do the
same work as those of similar capacity
burning coai or wood. There is no ex-
cessive heating of the evaporating sur-
faces, and the engines are light on re-
pairs. But then, the mechanical depart-
ment has'charge of the engines and regu-
lates the loading of them. If a similar
practice prevailed" in this country, oil
burning would be considered an unmiti-
gated success. It would probably pay
better in the end to work locomotive
furnaces much below their maximum
capacity, but that would not suit the
official who insists on every possible ton
of load being hauled. A. S.
Notes from Australia — Tlie Tyranny
of Qovernment Railway Officials.
During the last six months the railway
men of the State of Victoria have had
many troubles and trials. As the State
owns the railways, the position of the
men, in regard to wages, corresponds
to the position of the finances of the
State, whether good or bad. Just now
Victoria is suffering from a depression,
owing to a severe and prolonged
drought. This drought has made the
wheat harvest a complete failure and the
railway department is being run at a
loss. In order to make the railways pay,
the Government has taken three per
cent, of the men's wages, makes them
work five days a week instead of six,
and in addition all overtime is to be
worked off instead of paid for, and all
their small privileges such as free passes,
privileged tickets have been abolished.
Whilst all the starving stock was being
shifted from the drought stricken parts
crfl'the State to the fertile lands of the
south, the engineers and firemen were
almost worked to death in consequence
of the great rush of traffic. An engineer,
returning to his home depot at Bendigo,
fainted from exhaustion as soon as he
stepped off his engine. He had been on
duty for 36 hours continuously.
An amusing incident occurred at Gee-
long. The roundhouse foreman received
orders to put his men on short time.
That same day, all the engineers put in
abnormally long hours, one being on
duty for 30 hours. Last but not least
of the troubles is the fact that the men
have been deprived of their votes. At
present the outlook is a little brighter,
and we hope that in a very short time
the men will receive their' proper rights.
The Missouri Pacific Railway have de-
cided to do away with the heavy locomo-
tives at present in use on the Colorada
division, and substitute therefor the
smaller ones known as the 300 class,
which are used on the prairie divisions.
It is claimed that they are more economi-
cal to operate and better adapted to rapid
transit.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
JTS-
Of Great Importance
To Steam Users
It is of great importance to
steam users to have all parts work-
ing smoothly. This necessity is
apparent to all and nowhere does
this apply with greater force than
in the vitals of a steam engine,
where lack of smoothness means
trouble and expense.
To reduce friction to its lowest
degree the surfaces must be as
smooth as possible, and that is why
we so strongly recommend Dixon's
pure flake graphite.
Dixon's flake graphite gives a
polish to the friction surfaces which
has hitherto been unknown. Fric-
tion on cylinder walls and piston
is reduced; the surfaces are highly
polished; tighter joints are made,
and all friction therein reduced to
the lowest point.
This means less trouble, less
steam, less coal and greater
economy.
The engine runs smoother and
easier and lasts longer. The pack-
ings are tighter and do not have
to be renewed so often. With
graphite lubrication, repairs and
stoppages are reduced, and the
advantages are unbounded.
For new engines with rough
cylinder, graphite should always
be used. In a short time, through
its use, a polish is produced that
under the old methods would take
weeks and months to accomplish,
and cylinders so treated can be run
at their highest efficiency.
Five per cent, of Dixon's flake
graphite added to the oil will do
the work nicely. It is not recom-
mended to use graphite on locomo-
tives in a regular cab lubricator.
For stationary engines it may
be fed through regular oiler or
through hand oil pump or force
feed lubricator.
We are glad to answer all in-
quiries.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.,
JERSEY CITY, N. J.
Quick Weldinj; of Frames.
In Railway anl> Locomotive Engin-
eering of June, ipcw, Mr. D. P. Kellogg,
general foreman of the Southern Pacific
.shops at Oakland, Cal., had an illustrated
description of the method he employs
to weld locomotive frames without re-
moving them from the engine. During
a visit the writer made recently to the
shops mentioned, Mr. Kellogg very
kindly had the operation of welding a
frame performed for our entertainment.
It was one of the most interesting oper-
ations we have ever been privileged to
witness. A broken pedestal had to be
mended. They first jacked the parts
asunder and inserted a piece of iron
about J^ inch in the break. The parts
were then jamined together while the
welding piece was red hot.
A small furnace was then built of
fire brick and fire clay and an oil flame
j'et applied which gradually raised the
frame to a welding heat. The parts were
then hammered together by an Inger-
soIl-Sargent rock drill converted into
a hammer. The time taken to finish
the weld was about one hour.
Master mechanics or general foremen
who are pushed to do engine repairs
with the least possible delay, would do
well to look into this system of weld-
ing locomotive frames. They will find
enough particulars in the description
written by Mr. Kellogg to enable them
to introduce the system. Mr. W. H.
Russell, master mechanic at West Oak-
land, remarked to the writer that he did
not know what they would have done
for engines during the rush times if this
expeditious method of welding frames
had not been introduced. The frames
50 welded stand the strains of service
as well as those heated in a blacksmith
forge.
To Hake a Raid on Noises.
There is in the United States an acad-
emy of Ophthalmology, Otology and
Laryngology, which has been holding a
convention lately. From the published re-
ports of the meeting, we infer that
one purpose of the ologies is to
oppose the production of noises.
These ologians do not propose to
assail preventative noises which tor-
ture the ears of every dweller of cities.
They want to stop the noise of car wheels.
We suspect that some one with a patent
wheel is working up the ologies for his
own behalf, for a petition was read urging
boards of health throughout the United
States to secure the attention of street
car and steam railway companies for an
early consideration of the sanitary, the-
rapeutical value of noiseless car wheels.
The petition requests the boards of health
in the large cities to investigate the sub-
ject, with a view to bringing about a re-
form in the matter. A resolution adopted
on the same subject says: "Thousands in
our hospitals and homes, who are ill, need
this courtesy, as they are rendered more
ill by the din and clatter of the cars as
they pass along the streets."
We believe that railroad companies
would not wait for pressure from boards
of health to adopt a noiseless car wheel
if anything of the kind could be found, but
it is impracticable. So long as steel tires
run on steel rails there will be noise. Any
number of patent noiseless wheels have
been tried on the New York Elevated
railroads, but they always made as much'
noi.se as the common kind that are not
patented.
The Pressed Steel Car Company has
removed its general offices from the
Tradesmen's Building 10 the Farmers'
Bank Building, Fifth avenue and Wood
street, Pittsburg. This company has
possession of the entire nineteenth floor
and has spared neither money, time nor
effort to make their offices the finest and
best appointed in Pittsburg, and have
new desks, furniture, carpets, typewriters
and. in fact, everything requisite to mak-
ing the offices bright and cheerful. All'
of the new furniture is finished in mahog-
any and presents a very rich and beau-
tiful appearance. This company, there-
fore, entered their new quarters with'
nolliing but their office records. A spe-
cial invitation is extended to the friends
of the Pressed Steel Car Company to
visit these offices and pass judgment
upon their superior qualities and ele-
gance.
The American Steam Gauge & Xalvc
Manufacturing Company and the
Mowry & Phillips Company have be-
come merged under the corporate name
of the American Steam Gauge & Valve
Manufacturing Company. The business
heretofore conducted under the first-
mentioned names will, hereafter, be con-
ducted by the company in which the
others are merged, being a corporatiorr
organized under the laws of the State
of New Jersey. The officers of the new-
concern are as follows: John McCand-
lish. president: M. Briggs Phillips, vice-
president; R. B, Phillips, secretary: and
J. L. Weeks, treasurer and general man-
ager.
The officials of the Brooklyn Rapid
Transit Company tried to work a great
scheme upon the BrookljTi Bridge Com-
missioners, but it did not work. They
wanted to prepare the Elevated railroad
cars to run on the surface street railways
and to effect this they began putting in
wheels with flanges 'f^ inch deep in-
stead of ij^-inch. the M. C. B. stand-
ard depth of flange. The Bridge Commis-
sioners got on to the little scheme and'
compelled the Rapid Transit officials t(y
restore the wheels of standard pattern.
23(>
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIv^E ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
Students' Antics.
The Chicago Trtbutie of April 12 con-
tained the following item:
"Not satisfied with the results of their
attempt at reforming election methods,
University of Chicago students have
turned their attention to industrial prob-
lems and the settlement of strikes. Sev-
eral students shipped as stokers on the
grain. boats leaving for Buffalo yesterday
morning.
"The strength of Prof. Stagg's athletes
attracted the attention of the Lake Car-
riers' Association, and representatives of
the company came to the trainers in
Hitchcock Hall Thursday night and ask-
ed the young men to take the places of
striking firemen. They offered $30 for
the trip and transportation by rail back
to Chicago.
"Seven students at once volunteered
to go and were driven in carriages aboui
midnight to the vessel. Their leader was
Barrett C. Andrews, the freshman who
was chief detective in the Western Pass-
enger Association's case against the
Wisconsin Central."
Though the young man may flatter
himself with the titles of detective and
strike-breaker, he has really earned the
degree of "Spotter" and "Scab" and all
the dishonor pertaining thereto.
Those who have read "The Letters of
,a Self-Made Merchant to His Son" will
be reminded by this occurrence of old
John Graham's opinion of college-bred
men. He says: "College doesn't make
fools; it only develops them. It doesn't
make bright men; it only develops
them. A fool will turn out a fool
whether he goes to college or not,
though he'll probably turn out a different
sort of a fool. Some men are like pigs,
the more you educate them,- the more
amusing little cusses they become, and
the funnier capers they cut when they
show off their tricks. Naturally, the
place to send a boy of that breed is to
the circus, not to college."
The Building Material Trades Council
entered a protest with President Harper
of the University, and there is a pos-
sibility of a strike of all union working-
men employed on the University build-
ings. The University authorities claim
that they have no control over the
students in such a matter, and know
nothing of the affair except from the
newspapers. The working-men. being
in the position of the frog in the fable,
are bound to protest.
Half a dozen scatter-brained students
mistaking notoriety for fame, bravado
for courage, cat's-paws for heroes bring
to mind John Graham's educated pigs,
at whose amusing capers the audience
laughs, knowing well that their day will
be short and the end thereof not pleasant
— for the pigs.
The University of Chicago, which is
educating these particular pigs, is not
to be blamed because it has unfortu-
nately been made the consignee of raw
material which should have been billed
to the circus.
Mr. H. B. Hunt, for several years
mechanical engineer of the Erie at Mead-
ville, has been appointed assistant to Mr.
D. Willard, general manager. Mr. Hunt
is a graduate of the Massachusetts In-
stitute of Technology, Boston, .and re-
ceived all his practical training in the
shops and drawing office ol the Erie.
He is succeeded as mechanical engineer
by Mr. A. G. Trumbull, who has been
chief draftsman. Mr. Trumbull is a
graduate of Sibley College, Cornell Uni-
versity, and has also received his prac-
tical training on the Erie.
The Lake Shore & Michigan Southern
have just ordered fifteen new passenger
coaches that embrace decided ideas of
progress. They will be seventy-two feet
long and will seat eighty-four people,
that is more than any coach now in use,
except those received by the Lake Shore
recently. They will be finished in mahog-
any and the whole interior as well as the
exterior will resemble very closely the
Pullman car. They will probably cost
about $12,000 apiece. They will be used
on regular through trains.
The Southern California Railway
people in the shops at San Bernardino,
Cal., are making material reduction in
the reciprocating parts of their heavy
engines by making the piston heads of
cast steel. The head is solid and cast-
iron rings sprung on. The lightening
operation has enabled them to dispense
with the use of front extension piston
rods which had been found a source of
annoyance without any visible benefit.
Mr. George H. Daniels informs us that
on the Putnam Division of the New
York Central for the month of March,
99 and 73-100 per cent, of the trains
were on schedule time. Out of 3,400
passenger trains handled, only 11 were
late. It is thought that this record has
never been surpassed and seldom if ever
equaled.
The air compressors in the railroad
shops at Oakland, Cal., compress air for
all the yards and station signals besides
providing the supply for pneumatic ham-
mers and other shop tools. It takes
1,000 cubic feet of free air per minute to
keep up the supply. Pneumatic tools are
greatly in evidence in these shops.
Pneumatic
Tools.
HAMMERS, DRILLS, RIVETERS
HOISTS AND
METAL SAWING MACHINES
PNEUMATIC TOOLS
For Every Possible lise
SIMPLEST AND BEST
TEWINGS' CAR AND ENGINE
REPLACER
Will Stand the Weight of the
Heaviest Locomotive. Strong-
est and surest replacer in the
market.
DROP FORGE KNUCKLE PINS
Q. & C. BRAKE SHOE KEYS
GLOBE VENTILATORS
Ride on. Rough-shod if need be,
smooth-shod if that will do, but ride on.
Ride over all obstacles and win the
race. — David CopperHeld.
Send for Catalogs on Track,
Locomotive and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with tiie 0- * C. Co.
GENERAL OFFICES, Old Colony Building
...CHICAGO...
New York OHice, 114 Liberty Street
M;iy, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERLNG
237
0,11^
V)
I'ine Catalogues.
The Nilcs, lieiiient, Pond Company,
136 Liberty slrcel, New York, have is-
sued two very handsome trade cata-
logues. One is concerned with multiple
drilling machines, and the other with
horizontal boring, drilling and milling
machines. In the first of these, machines
of two general types arc shown, viz.,
niulii)ilc drills in which the spindles are
adjustable to any position in a given
line; and adjustable multi-spindle drills,
in which the spindles may be arranged
in a group of any size within the capacity
of l;he machine. The catalogue also con-
tains descriptions of a full line of multi-
ple drilling machines suitable for rail-
road work.
In the latter catalogue such machines
as liorizontal drilling, tapping and bor-
ing machine; double drilling, tapping and
stud inserting machines; horizontal bor-
ing, drilling and milling machines of all
kinds are shown in excellent half-tones,
accompanied with suitable letter press.
The concluding pages show types of
these various machines at work. The
company will gladly send either or both
of these catalogues to those who write
to them for copies.
Ill
The A. Leschen & Sons Rope Com-
pany, manufacturers of wire rope and
aerial rope tramway.',, with headquar-
ters at 920 to 932 North First street,
St. Louis, Mo., have just opened an
ofifice and warehouse at 1717-1723 Arapa-
hoe street, Denver, Col., where they
will carry a full stock of their various
grades of wire rope, manila rope, etc.
This gives that concern four branch
offices and warehouses in addition to
their headquarters at St. Louis. The
offices are at 92 Centre street. New York
city, N. Y.; 137 Kast Lake street, Chi-
cago, 111.; 85 Fremont street, San Fran-
cisco, Cal., and the Denver office just
opened. This company not only manu-
factures all ordinary grades of wire rope.
but they are also sole manufacturers of
the celebrated Hercules Colored Strand
Wire Rope and of Patent Flattened
Strand Wire Rope. They also make
tramways which load and unload auto-
matically, and they make several types
nf friction grip tramways and also single
line and two bucket tramways.
The New York Air Brake Company
are about to enlarge their plant at
Watertovvn, N. Y. They also expect to
arrange for their workmen building
houses for themselves, A dispatch from
Watertown says : A tract of 268 acres,
lying within the city limits toward the
east, has been purchased and along the
main street the factories will extend for
nearly half a mile. In the rear of the
factories a tract of 400 by 1,300 feet has
been laid out for an athletic ground for
the workmen, while the main body of the
tract lying to the north, has been laid
out in streets with 564 building lots,
wliich will be disposed of to the work-
men desiring to locate near the works.
On the rear of the purchase is about
sixty acres covered by handsome trees
and lying nearly level. This has been
laid out with drives and walks and will
be cleaned and beautified and thrown
open to' the city under the name of
Starbuck Park.
The Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool
Company, of Philadelphia, have just is-
sued a neat little poster showing a work-
man engaged in riveting up a sign bear-
ing the words "Keller Pneumatic Tools"
which the company say are modern tools
for modern plants. There is no doubt
that the poster shows a man working on
the sign, but another object he has in
view not so immediately apparent is to
rivet the attention of the beholder. The
workman does both these things very
well. Information concerning the Keller
tools may be easily obtained by apply-
ing to the company.
The Atlanta and West Point has re-
cently purchased some ten-wheel freight
locomotives from the Rogers Locomo-
tive Works, the first have already been
put to work and are giving excellent
service, little trouble being experienced
from hot journals and driving rod boxes.
With the exception of the Central of
Georgia's consolidation engines on the
Columbus and Birmingham division they
are the heaviest in service in the South-
ern States.
The Locomotive and Machine Com-
pany, of Montreal. Limited, has given
the Westinghouse Electric and Manu-
facturing Company. Limited, a contract
for eighty motors, bearing from five to
fifty horse power each. A contract for
heavy machinery, at an expenditure of
$130,000. has been awarded the Niles,
Bement, Pond Company.
Griffith & Winters, a firm in Chicago
which sells books has reproduced our
educational chart No. 2. (the American
Locomotive) and are giving it as a pre-
mium with their books. As the chart
cost us a great deal of money to make
and is protected by a copyright we intend
protecting our rights in the courts if
necessary.
The repair shops belonging to the Santa
Fe at Topeka are so well provided with
facilities for doing new work that the of-
ficers of the company have decided to work
the shops to their full capacity in buildin?;
new locomotives.
The Nashville. Chattanooga & St. Louis
have recently built 503 box cars in their
shops at Nashville. Tenn.. and they now
have commenced working on an orde'- for
.2^0 gondola cars.
238
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, igo.^.
At the las: meet iig of the Board of Di-
rectors of the AUis-Chahners Company
held in New York, April 15, the regular
quarterly dividend of ij4 per cent, was
declared on preferred stock. The volume
of business on the books of the company
to-day far exceeds that of any time since
the organization of the company, notwith-
standing the fact that the output of the
plants has been increased to a large ex-
tent. The company say: We can see no
abatement of prosperity in our various
branches of manufacture. There seems
to be an unlimited deniand for all kinds
of high grade machinery, which is cer-
tainly a good indication that prosperity
is enjoyed in all lines of manufacture.
it comes to excluding one's own kind it
looks to me like a case of 'dog eat dog.'
No exchange passes are issued east of
Buffalo, but from there west all railroads
exchange. I consider that the person who
originated this state of things did not be-
long to the enterprising class that has
made the world's railroad service what it
is. Taken at his par value he would be
dear at $100 per month.''
Siiiooth=On in the Shop.
Many breakdowns to machinery sub-
jected to steam and hydraulic pressure,
it is said, can be successfully repaired by
use of the material known to engineers
as Smooth-On Iron Cement. The fol-
lowing is an extract from a report made
by an engineer in the Department of
Construction and Repairs in the New
York Navy Yard:
"For over four years I have used
Smooth-On Iron Cement No. i, and
have found it to be as good as a new
casting when used in repairing breaks
in castings. I have found it to make
steam joints tight when everything else
failed. I have used it on porous cast-
ings that had to stand 180 pounds steam
pressure. I have used it on steam pipes
that leaked, and will say that I ' have
never had any trouble with anything I
repaired with it. About four years ago
one of our 45-inch centrifugal pumps
split almost in two, due tb a sudden
strain. The crack was over twenty feet
long and in some places opened up three-
quarters of an inch. This fracture was
repaired with Smooth-On Iron Cement
No. I, and the pump was running on the
third day; it ran successfully for thirteen
months, wlien it was replaced by a new
pump."
Smooth-On Iron Cement No. i is a
metal cement which, when properly
mixed with water, "metalizes" and
slightly expands during the process.
This iron cement is made by the Smooth-
On Mfg. Co., Jersey City, N. J., U. S. A.,
who will send their illustrated book free
to anyone who is interested enough to
write them for it.
Luis Jackson, industrial commissioner
of the Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul
Railroad, recently completed a tour oi the
Eastern States, and he appears to have
been disgruntled because he was obliged
to pay his fare on the Eastern lines. He
says: "For the first time I paid fare to
Boston. I can understand the excluding
of everybody outside of the railroad busi-
ness from free transportation, but when
A nodern Booking Office.
In the old stage-coach days in Eng-
land the engaging of seats in the coach,
whether inside the vehicle or out,
was done by passengers at the
stage coach office, and the name
of the person and his position in
the coach were recorded in a book,
hence one might say in olden times he
had "booked" a passage up to London.
As the modern railway was evolved, this
old vehicle was mounted on a frame sup-
ported on wheels capable of running on
rails, and several coaches were coupled
together in a train. We use the word
"coach" at the present time to describe
a passenger car, and the origin of the
word is quite clear. In England they
still use the designation "Booking Of-
fice" in railway stations, to indicate the
place where tickets are sold, though the
old-fashioned book in which passages
were recorded has long since passed
away. There is, however, another sense
in which we are constrained to use the
expression "booking office." We cannot
sell you railway tickets, it is true, but the
office of Railway and Locomotive En-
c.iNEERiNG is a booking office in the
sense that it will supply you with any
book you require. Cast your eye down
the list of what we especially recom-
mend. Do you wish to book a passage
up to the good old town of Knowledge?
A year's subscription to Railway and
I^ocoMOTiVE Engineering costs only
$2.00. It is well worth the money, and,
besides, the paper is a welcome visitor
in every household, especially where
there are children.
"The World's Railway" is a most in-
teresting history of railways and locomo-
tives. It is beautifully illustrated and the
net price used to be $10.00. We now
give it and a year's subscription to
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
for $5.00.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in !'fe to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book, combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particu-
larly useful book to the young mechanic.
A Hard Test
Making steel cars is a good
test of the quality of pneumatic
hammers. They must stand the
hardest use, antl work at high
speed week after week, without
breakins: down.
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
have triumphed over all others
in this great test. The Cambria
Steel Co., that "makes cars by
the mile," has over three hun-
dred Keller hammers in use.
Their speed is marvelous, their
endurance apparently unlimit-
ed, and the cost of their work
far below that of any other tools.
Do you use the best tools .•'
Send for our new catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
2 1 St St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Francisco Boston
.OE
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
239
Mr. Air-Brake
Inspector
As you are interested in
obtaining the most efficient
service from your air-brake
equipment, it will pay you
to test
NON-FLUID OIL
AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT
especially during winter,
when ordinary oils and
greases freeze and refuse
to afford proper lubrica-
tion, thereby impeding the
operation of the cylinders.
Non-fluid oil is also espe-
cially valuable on triple-
valves
FREE SAMPLES FOR TRIAL FUR-
NISHED GRATIS, BY PREPAID EXPRESS
>v
NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY
LUBRICANT COMPANY
V.
MAKKRS OK
"THE AIR-BRAKE LUBRICANT"
14 and 16 Church Street
NEW YORK CITY
iki,=^^^.^-
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
■ PRI.NGFIELD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
Ji . B. C and LUber^s Code used.
EngUsli Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
sons Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary.
M. Koyemann, Charlotfnsirasse 112, Dusseldorl,
Germany.
SAVE ALL FORCING^
aiiil Tempering of
Lathe and Planer Tools
loiitiiis: till
iBy
'Armstrong
System
of Toi^l HoI'U-rs,
usint: Cutters of
Sel l-Hanlenmg
Stfi-l.
Send for Catalog
Armstrong
Bros. Tool Co. ^
"The Tool Holder % r —
People." ^L
635 .\uMiil Avi-., ^J^^
CHic»eo, us A. ^^ L
•^^^S^^S^^^iS^^X
It has a stimulating effect in inducing
liiiii to study liis business. Price, 50
I cuts.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers likely to
\k liirtd. It lontaiiis in small compass
a large amount of information about
the locomotive. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recommend this book.
Price, 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colviii.
Tliis book '• 11 instruct a man so that he
will understand the construction and
operation of a compound locomotive as
well as he now understands a simple
engine. Tells all about running, about
breakdowns and repairs. Convenient
pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
cnway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horsepower, condenser.';,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list of its contents. It is in the
cjucstion and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. Price, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
f^oilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a forman boilermaker. Also contains
several chapters on oil-burning locomo-
tives. 50 cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can afTord to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
tor want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of com-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily un-
derstood by every intelligent fireman. 50
cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons
trying to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. Cloth, 75 cents. Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
liave not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehen-
sive treatise on the subject. Ought to
be studied by all trainmen where block
signals are used. $3.00.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3,00.
We understand that Mr. George E.
Martin, who has been for some time past
superintendent of the Pedrick & Ayer
Company's shops, has tendered his resig-
nation, which has been accepted.
The Shelby Steel Tube Company, of
Pittsburgh, Pa., have sent their friends
a very neat little souvenir in the shape
of a paper knife. Interest in the useful
little article centers in the fact that it
is made out of a Shelby steel tube. A
piece of J^-tube about 9 ins. long is
flanged over at one end just as a Icco-
motive tube is beaded, and the tube, for
a distance of about 3^ ins., is left as
manufactured. The whole tube, how-
ever, is formed so as to have a slight
reverse curve. The blade of the knife
is made by simply compressing or flat-
tening part of the tube and cutting away
a portion of the end so as to give the
knife a sharp point, which is useful in
opening letters. The name of the com-
pany is stamped on the blade. Those
who have letters to open and desire, to
have a neat and handy instrument to do
it with, had better send the Shelby com-
pany a sealed envelope for them to open,
containing a polite request for the sou-
venir,
"Seen From the Car." or travel as a
fine art, is No. 31 of the "Four-track
Series" issued by the passenger depart-
ment of the New York Central Railroad.
It was written by Mr. Charles Barnard
and touches interestingly on the geology,
the geography and the history of that
delightful region which stretches from
tlie palisades of the Hudson to the cata-
ract of Niagara. Of course, there are
many more things in this pleasing little
hand book than can be seen from the
car. and Mr. Geo. H. Daniels, whose
office is in the Grand Central Station,
New York, will be happy to send a copy
to any one who applies for it and who
sends five cents in stamps.
Portfolio of Views.
Thirty-three magnificent reproductions
of photographic views of various scenes
along the Fitchburg Division of the Bos-
ton and Maine Railroad is what this new
portfolio consists of. The delightful
panoramic scenery of the Hoosac country
and Deerfield Valley, the dashing water-
falls and towering mountains are all
240
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
aptly portrayed in tliis new aildition to
the Boston and Maine's Art Library.
This book is entitled "The Charles River
to the Hudson," and will be mailed to
any address upon receipt of 6 cents in
stamps by the General Passenger De-
partment, Boston and Maine Railroad,
Boston. The complete set, consisting of
the other five portfolios, and this new
one, will be mailed upon receipt of 36
cents.
The Latest Locomotive Freak.
We received from Mr. Charles Hop-
good, St. Louis, the blue print from
which the annexed cut was made. Mr.
Hopgood says:
"I enclose a drawing and description
of an improved driving mechanism for a
locomotive engine which I have invented
and for which a patent has been allowed.
"I shall be obliged if you will kindly
publish the same in vour valuable
Chrismas day, that a fire corps has been
organized in the Allegheny and McKee's
Rocks works, and it is largely due to
their effective work that the fire loss ha^
been kept down to a low point. Dur-
ing the year two gas wells were drilled
on the property owned by the company
and a good supply of natural gas was
the result. The number of cars built in
1902 was 27,456, and 4,148 steel undcr-
frames for wooden cars. This is an in-
crease of 1 1.7 per cent, over the num-
ber of cars turned out in 1901, while the
output of truck frames was practically
doubled. The company has orders
booked and business in sight which will
keep all plants busy for some time to
come.
A folder issued by the Chicago Pneu-
matic Tool Company of Chicago has
just come to hand. All sorts of pneu-
matic hammers, long stroke, chipping
RaUleai/ i Lotomntiva EnginMt-i xj
THE L.'^TEST FRE.'\K.
journal, as I am desirous of obtaining
the views of engineers thereon.
"I think that with this mechanism more
power and speed, with smoother run-
ning, can be obtained than with the ordi-
nary method of driving."
Among the orders being filled by the
Hicks Locomotive and Car Works, of
Chicago, it may be mentioned that the
Bessemer & Lake Erie has ordered a
chair car, also a 60 ft. baggage car; the
Rodgers-.'Vllison Lumber Co., Vanderbilt,
Mich., have ordered a locomotive. The
Hicks works have received miscellan-
eous freight car orders from the Gold
Bar Lumber Co.; the Missouri, Arkan-
sas & Western Ry. ; the Union Traction
Co., of Indiana; the Coal Belt Ry. Co.;
Fairbanks, Morse & Co., Central Ari-
zona Ry., Detroit & Mackinac Ry. and
the Santa Fe Centra! Railway have or-
dered two eight-wheel cabooses.
caulking, and beading, are shown to-
gether with piston air drills, Boyer drills,
compressors, painting machines and a
very ingenious pneumatic motor hoist,
in which a little motor turns a small
drum and so winds up a light steel cable.
The whole thing hangs from a hook
in the shop ceiling. The motor is oper-
ated by air but the drum is of course
windless — we mean a windlass. Write
the company if you are interested.
The annual report for 1902 of the
Pressed Steel Car Company, of Pitts-
burgh, has just been issued in very at-
tractive form. In speaking of fire losses,
the report says, concerning a fire which
occurred in the Allegheny shops on
The Stannard & White Company, of
Racine Junction, Wis., who are the
makers of a large variety of locomotive
cab seats, the Atlas railway car mover
(which is really a very powerful pinch
bar), gauge glass cutters and other com-
fortable and useful articles, have recently
issued a book on camping, containing
120 pages and 200 illustrations. It is a
manual of camping, and contains 16
pages of camp-cooking receipts, and it
tells what to do in case of accidents when
campers are out of reach of medical aid.
The Stannard & White Company will
send this book — it is not a catalogue — to
their friends on receipt of ten cents in
stamps or coin.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
16 AND 18 SIZE,
17 AND 21 RlBt
JEWELS,
SAPPHIRE PALLETS
BALL'S IMPROTED
SAFETY
DOIBLE ROLLER
Are without question-
the finest watchea that
American talent and
skilled labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing such universal sat-
isfaction that we have-
no hesitancy in claim*
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the market.
TestB severe and ntunerous hare proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, tO
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts..
"Write us for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
Ensure freedom from vibration — hold
the work firmly — feed steadily past
knives which travel a constant path.
Send for booklet telling
more about them. . . .
Bax'er D. Wtiitney & Son
VINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGILL BUILDING, WASHINGTON. D. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sentr
May, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
241
FOR SALE
FREICHT, PASSINCER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
AND
ALL /^ADC *^"I<^>^
SIZES. ^MRO DELIVERIES
FAii l_ll/^l/e "' OIARBORN ST.
." IVl. mOAOj CHrCACO, ILL.
ai5 DIARBORN ST.
' CHICAGO, ILL.
P
ETERS'
ATENT
OCKET
A Universal Ratchet.
The Armstrong universal ratchet was
formerly known as the Williams univer-
sal ratchet drill, and was invented by
Mr. Harvey D. Williams, who was at
one time connected with Cornell Uni-
versity. The successful application of
the laws of theoretical mechanics to the
making of a highly efficient and thor-
oughly practical tool is not the only in-
teresting feature about this device. The
ratchet is capable of use in very re-
stricted places, and this is one of its most
valuable characteristics. The universal
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. ^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
•hops in the country.
Union of course. >^ >i^
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
^^^
By ANGUS SINCLAIR.
Best book in print for any rail-
road man. New edition is re-
vised and enlarged.
THIS OFFICE.
faster than the common ratchet. The
handle can be rigidly fixed by screwing
up a set screw in one of the three coun-
tersinks in the ball of the tool. This
makes the handle practically equivalent
to that of the ordinary ratchet, and the
possibility of making it thus rigid is pro-
vided (or convenience of operation in
certain cases.
The Armstrong Brothers Tool Com-
pany, or. as they are often called, "the
tool holder people," of 617 Austin ave-
nue. Chicago, will be happy to send cat-
alogue or other information to those
who are interested enough to apply to
them.
A Poser.
.\n amusing story is told of how a
lady tourist "stumped" a railroad super-
intendent in .Al.Tska. The town of Skag-
THE .ARMSTRONG IXIVKRSAl, RATCHET.
motion is secured by placing the axis of
the two trunnions upon which the handle
turns at an acute angle to the axis of
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
EH6INE AND TENDER.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc,
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
Locomotive
Engine
Running and
Management
way was fortunate enough to be served
by a railway in the early days when the
milk used in that far away town was
condensed milk brought there as canned
goods. The locomotive which brought
this lady to Skagway was furnished
with a pilot of the usual form and se-
cured in the correct position. The lady,
meeting the superintendent on the plat-
form expressed a desire for some infor-
mation which the railroad man gallantly
offered to give. She therefore propound-
ed this question: "Why do your loco-
motives wear cow catchers when the
only cows you have in this country are
in sealed cans?" The official was speech-
less.
SECTION OF UNIVERSAL RATCHET.
the ratchet. About two inches of mo-
tion of the end of the handle in any di-
rection whatever, will drive the tool; in
fact, even a vertical motion of the handle
will suffice to do work. The tool can
be operated quite satisfactorily with the
handle between the spokes of a wheel.
In the section here illustrated there are
twelve teeth and four pawls; thus, 48
catches are made in each revolution.
This size. No. 4. drills holes up to
I in. diameter. The only other size made
is No. 6, which drills holes up to 2 in.
diameter. In this latter there are five
pawls, which engage with the 12 teeth.
The pawls, therefore, catch 60 times in
one revolution, and on this account the
tool is said to cut about one-seventh
Not Responsible for Fires from Sparks.
.\ dispatch to St. Louis headed some-
thing new in court rulings reads:
.\ Kansas court has decided that if a
railroad company has good modern ap-
pliances and careful and competend engi-
neers and firemen damages cannot be col-
lected when a locomotive spark burns a
planing mill, a lumber yard, a Methodist
church and several minor buildings. This
is quite important to both railroads and
owners of buildings.
That ruling is by no means novel. It
is a long time since the courts first de-
cided that when a railroad company ap-
plied the most approved spark arresters
on its locomotives a suit would not hold
against it for causing fires by sparks.
The man who knows only one subject
is next tiresome to the man who knows
no subject. — Christmas Stories.
-243
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smoke.
Contains about 800 practical questions and
their answers on tne Science of Steam
Making. By Wm. M. BarR. The necessary
eonditrons for the Economic Firing of a
Locomotive are explained. 85 illustrations.
349 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By Robert H. Blackall. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Air-Brake
•quipment. containing over 1,000 questions
and their answers on the Westlnghouge
Alr-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Alr-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearly every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
S64 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By Robert Grimshaw. It asks 1,600
questions and gives i.boo simple, plain,
aractlcal answers about the Locomotive.
o mathematics, no theories— yw.r/ facts.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
pages, over 200 illustrations, and 12 large
Folding Plates. Bound in Maroon Cloth,
$2.00.
}3^A special Circular of these Books Sent
on Request.
^^^Any of these Books Prepaid to any
Address in the world on Receipt of Pries.
AGENTS WANTED '^U^^ %\°:^
sell at sight, and every Engineer,
Fireman and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books is sent free on application.
Norman &. Henley & Co., Publishers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, N.Y.
Tandem Compounds Gaining Favor.
The American Locomotive works at
Schenectady has been building some
large tandem compound engines lately
of the 280 type. Fifteen of these are
for the New York Central and are the
heaviest engines of this class which that
road has ever purchased, having a total
weight of 225,000 pounds, 200,000 of this
being on the drivers. The cylinder di-
mensions are 16 and 38 by 34 inch
stroke. They have small driving wheels,
which give them a tremendous tractive
power, enabling them to haul 100 light
freight cars. This does not represent the
entire capacity of these engines, which
could haul a larger number of cars
were there no grades, and if the
draw rigging of the cars could stand
the pull. The company is also ful-
filling a contract of twelve engines
for the Kinshiu railroad of Japan. These
are of the 260 type and are designed
for narrow gauge service.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, talie up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Talie up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Mcholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
Block Signal Expansion.
The automatic block signal system on
the New York Central Railroad will be
extended over 434 miles, while 39 pneu-
matic and 54 mechanical interlocking
plants, in addition to those now in use,
are to be installed. Grade crossings to
the number of 44 are to be eliminated.
No less than 469 new steel bridges,
with an aggregate length of 125.000 feet,
single track, are included in the improve-
ment plans. These bridges, containing
about 133,000 tons of steel, will cost over
$5,000,000, apart from the new founda-
tions which will be built in many cases.
— Philadelfhia North American.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
TAYLOR YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushers .'"^Ssi^'d"' Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
h. very neat little illustrated catalogue
concerning Westinghouse Fan Motors
has just been got out by the West-
inghouse Electric & Manufacturing Com-
pany, of Pittsburgh, Pa. The fans are
suitable for desk or wall bracket, as re-
quired, and are made some to be oper-
ated by direct and some by alternating
current. The electric fan is getting more
and more to be one of the indispensable
adjuncts to the modern cafe and smok-
ing car. The company will be happy to
send the catalogue to those interested
enough to apply to them for it.
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sole Representative* in the United States,
Canada and riexlco
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EQlilPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of servlc*
CARS, fRElGHT, PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Monadnock Bldg., Chicago 141 Broadway, New York
The Electric Contract Company of
New York announce that they have
moved their quarters to 202 and 204 Cen-
tre street, in this city, where, with largely
increased facilities, they will be able to
handle their growing business to greater
advantage. This firm makes portable
electric lamps, and electric torches. The
company will be happy to forward copy
of their catalogue to any one who will
write to them for it.
AN OUNCf OF P/9£V£-NTIV£/S SerTFR THAff rCft POUf/DS OF Ci/fl£
ON A
[LOCOMOTIVE
CAB
-SEAT
AT AN
INVESTMENT
FR0MS2°-°UP0R-'
PATENT MEDICINES
MISERY'S? FINALLY
THIS -"'Ipj
RIDING ABONESHAKER
YOU CA/^ nr^D 0(/T ALL ABOUT /T BY A POSTAL
??STANNARD&WHITEGO.
May, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
»43
A. Leschen & Sons Rope Co.,
Manufacturers
WIRE ROPE,
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE,
Fittings and Supplies.
IIOMU OFFICK:
920-922 North First St., - ST. LOUIS, MO.
( 135 E. Lake St.. Chicago, III.
Branch Offices j 92 Centre St., New York City, N. Y.
(85 Fremont St.,San Fraucisco, Cal.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord ft Company,
CHICAGO. HEW YORK.
Over One
Thousand
^. Miles
A DAY
on
"The Colorado Special"
Bre!tkl:ist m uriN.li.i 1 <.ni<>i
Dinner in |itii\. r ioin..iii
rM\x .Mnrn;
:m K\ t-nin
'1^
SPLENDID TRAIN SERVICE
io DENVER via UNION PACIFIC
Fntl information i-hee
lurriished on aiiplirnti
L. ^- P-an.) Tkt, Ac
rfully
Kill t(l
t..
i
THE ROBERT W. HU^T & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation,
1137 THE ROOKERY, CHICAGO.
91 Broadwa> , Xew Vnrk. Park BiiilitiDg, Pittsburgh
ol Xorlulk House, Loudon, Kug.
Inspection of steel Kails, Splice Bars. Railroad Car^,
Wheels, Axles, etc. Chemical L.vdor.\tory— .\nalyei8
of Ores, Iron, Steel. Oils, "Water, etc. Physical L.^BO-
K.\ToRV— Test of Metals, Drop and Pullint' Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Barp, etc.
llfliclenpy Tests of Boilers. Kn£:ines and IiOooniotiT»s.
Nearly all railroads are increasing their
orders for locomotives atid steel rails and
it is hard to find a triffic official who docs
not anticipate a heavy traffic the present
year. 'J'he larger lines now have the
tr.icks about as full of trains as is pos-
sible ; especially is this true of the Penn-
sylvania Railroad. The tracks will not al-
ways stand the heavy strain now brought
to bear upon them and sooner or later
I hey will have to be thoroughly over-
hauled. It is stated that niorc rails will
be l.iid on extensions and connections dur-
ing the year than in many years past. It
is estimated that the unfilled business on
the books of the steel rail plants of the
country is nearly 3,000,000 tons.
Those most familiar with the vast
amount of energy that has to be
tr.insmitted for the moving of heavy
fast trains have very little to say
about electricity monopolizing the
business of moving all trains in the
near future, but fools rush in where angels
fear to tread. Some one connected with
tlie Pennsylvania recently said to a New
York reporter: "In connection with the
entry of our road into your city, of
course, all trains in the tunnel will be pro-
pelled by electricity. This means that all
trains passing from New Jersey to Long
Island will be electric ; which means that
in a short time all through trains to Bos-
ton and New England in general will be
electric ; which means — well, to be plain
and frank, the building of the tunnel and
its electric equipment means that in a
short lime there will not be a locomotive
on the Pennsylvania Railroad between
New York and Philadelphia."
The Youngstown car manufacturing
company directory are considering the
installation of additional machinery to
the plant for the construction of steel
car.*;. It is said the project has ad-
vanced so far that specifications have
been drawn for new buildings and ten-
ders asked from machinery builders for
the equipment of the plant.
The Southern California people, in
their shops at San Bernardino, use a sort
of Bessemer furnace for melting brass.
Tliey blow the inflammable mixture of
oil gas and air througli the mass to be
melted. They say that the process is
decidedly cheaper than melting in cruci-
bles.
We have been informed that the gross
earnings of the Chicago Great Western
Railway (Maple Leaf Route) for the
second week of March, 1903. show an in-
crease of $10,152.50 over the correspond-
ing week of last vear.
The work on the building of new car
shops at Savannah, Ga., was commenced
on April 14. The work will be rushed to
completion as rapidly as possible.
Watering Can Necessary at Times.
(Jn board one of the northern pleasure
steamers, which have to be built with ex-
ceedingly light draught to get over the
frequent shallows of the river, a Yankee
tourist remarked to the captain, a shrewd
old Scotchman :
"I reckon, skipper, that you thinlc noth-
ing of steaming across a meadow when
there's been a heavy fall of dew?"
"That's so," replied the captain, "though
occasionally we hae to send a man ahead
wi' a watering can." — London Tit Bits.
CONTENTS.
.\ir-Brake Department 223
Booking Office, A Modern 238
Car Details 219
Coinpounds to Make Efficient, by
W. A. Buckbee 215
Different Effects with Oil Burn-
ing 205
Dissolution of the Northern Secur-
ities Co. 218
Electricity vs. Steam Power 220
Encouraging Inferior Work 218
European Notes 207
General Correspondence 211
Liquid Fuel on the Pacific Coast,
by Angus Sinclair 234
Locomotives :
Atlantic Type Engine for the
Erie 217
Heavy 2-8-0 for Penna. Lines. .. 209
Obituary— Late W. W. Card 232
Overloaded Engines are Expen-
sive 221
Over the Lackawanna, by Angus
Sinclair 228
Questions Answered 221
Quick Welding of Frames 23S
Personals 231
Radial Spring Buffer, P. W. &
B. Railroad 216
Tandem Compound, The, by F. P.
Roesch 206
Third Man on an Engine 204-212
INDEX^TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
Paok
Acme Machinery Co Front Cover
.A.jax Metal Co 4th Cover
Allis-Chalmers Co 5
American Balance Slide Valve Co 9
American Brake Shoe Co IS
American Loco. Sander Co U
American Locomotive Co 19
American School of Technology IS
American Steam Gauge & Valve Mfg. Co... la
Armstrong Bros. Tool Co 239
Armstrong Mfg. Co 20
Ashcrott Mtg. Co 8
Ashton Valve Co lOT
Audel, Theo., & Co 9
Baker. Wm. C 12
Baldwin Locomotive Works 17
Barnett, G. & H.. Co 2d Cover
Becker-Brainard Miillng Mch. Co 2
Big Four Railroad 10
Books :
Compound Locomotives 9
Firing Locomotives 1th Cover
Handling Locomotives 14
Locomotive Running and Management 3
Machine Shop Arithmetic 10
Miscellaneous 7
Oil Burning in Locomotives 2
The American Locomotive 8
Boston & Albany R. R 10
Boston Blower Co 199
Brady Brass Co la
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
May, 1903.
CHARLES MILLER, Chairman.
J. S. COFFIN, PRESIDtNT.
SAMUEL G. ALL"-N, Vice-President-
C0FFIN-ME6EATH SUPPLY COMPANY
FRANKLIN, PA., U. S. A.
:CIAI-I8TS IN DEVICES THAT IVIAKE FOR
:CONOMY
YMAIL
Every pay day you should save a part of
your earoings.
You can send your money to us safely and
conveniently no matter where you live.
We pay
4% INTEREST
compounded semi-annually, on any amount
from one dollar up. That is better than Rail-
road or Cuvernment Bonds.
Ours is a Big, Strong Savings Bank with
immense capital and strong men back of it.
Write for Booklet "S." "■ Bankir g By Mail,"
for instructions for opening an account.
THE FEDERAL TRUST CO.,
Capital, $1,500,000.
Tfie City of Banks. CLEVELAND, O.
ATLANTIC CITY A PLEASANT FALL
RESORT.
SOCIAL LIFE STILL A FEATURE.
In mauy ways Atlantic City is the most novel
place iti the world. Even thougli it iS| a shore
resort its season is twelve months long a^id at
all seasons there is something doing. The great
hotels, and there are many of them, are open
all the year and ilie f ervice is fine at all times.
Atlantic City is a city in every sense of the
word, and every convenience is afforded, in-
cluding golf, driving, theatres and similar di-
versions.
It is a particularly healthful place and the
autumn months at Atlantic City are always
charming. 'J he famous promenade, the board-
walk, is ever interesting, nnd no better season
can be selected for visiting this famous wati-r-
iiig place. Ihe New Jersey Central operates
3 hour trains to Atlantic City fmin New York
at 9.40 A. M. and 3 40 i'. ^\. Tli« se trains are
models in every respect, and the arrival at At-
lantic City is in time for luncheon and dinner.
The route is by far the shortest from New
Yolk, and the General P'assenfter Agent of the
New Jersey central, New York has prepared an
illustrated booklet on Atlantic City which, upon
application, will be sent to any address.
■Jhe l\merican
Locomotive
Shown in our Locomotive Chart should
be found in every railroad man's home
2S CENTS EACH.
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Under this Cover
is the
OUR IS t
FREE ^
CATALOGUE'
RAi;'
fTER!
N PLAIN SIG[t|]
StantiartI Operators Gan Do
t5"o More Work
on the Williams than on any other Typewriter,
CDCniKI DDIPC to Ajedts in unoccupied terri.
OrLlllHL rnlut tory. Xnal machines sent to
' responsible parties.
WILLIAMS TYPEWRITER CO., Derby. Conn.
LONDON, 104 Newgate St. 310 Broadway, NEW YORK.
INDEX TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
Page
Buffalo Forge Co 4th Cover
Buffalo Union Furnace Co 153
Chapman Jack Co 9
Central R. R. of New Jersey 1
C, H. & D. R. R 11
Chicago & Alton R. R 2
Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co 13
Clarkson, S. N 243
Cleveland City Forge & Iron Co 4th Cover
Cleveland Pneumatic Tool Co 11
Cleveland Twist Drill Co 4th Cover
Coffin Megeath Supply Co 1
Colored Loco. Plates
Commonwealth Steel Co 3d Cover
Consolidated Safety Valve Co 4
Consolidated Railway Electric Lighting &
Equipment Co 20
Crosby Steam Gage & Valve Co 17
Damascus Bronze Co 13
Dart Mfg. Co 12
Davis. John. Co U
Day-Klncaid Stoker Co la
Derry-Collard Co 21
Detroit Lubricator Co 4
Dixon, Joseph, Crucible Co 235
Klectrlc Contract Co 2d Cover
Eyoon-Evans Co la
Falls Hollow Staybolt Co 9
Fay & Egan Co.. J. A 19
Federal Trust Co 1
Fitzhugh & Co 242
Flanders, L. B., Machine Works 14
Flather. Mark, Planer Co 9
Franklin Mfg. Co 12
Galena Signal Oil Co 12
General Electric Co 15
Gold Car Heating Co 237
Gould Coupler Co 3
Gould & Eberhardt 4th Cover
Hammett, H. G 4th Cover
Hancock Inspirator Co 8
Harrington & King Perforating Co.... 2d Cover
Hayden & Derby Mfg. Co
Hendrick Mfg. Co U
Henley, N. A., & Co 243
Hicks, F. M 241
Hoffman, Geo. W V
Hunt, Robert W., & Co 243
Industrial Water 9
International Correspondence Schools 21
Jenkins Bros 4th Cover
Jerome & Elliott 2
Jones, B. M., & Co 242
Jones & Lamson Machine Co 239
Kennicott Water Softener Co 2d Cover
Lake Erie Iron Co 4th Cover
Lake Shore R. R 13
Latrobe Steel Co
Latrobe Steel & Coupler Co 12
Lawson Improved Dumping Boat & Car Co. 22
Leschen & Son's Rope Co 243
Locomotive Chart
Locomotive Publishing Co., Ltd 3
Lunkenheimer Co 14
McConway & Torley Co 4
McCord & Co 243
Manning. Maxwell & Moore
Mason Regulator Co ... '
Moran Flexible Steam Joint Co 241
M. & S. Oiler Co 149
Nathan Mfg. Co 11
National Car Coupler Co 4th Cover
National Malleable Castings Co 4th Cover
National Tube Co 3
N. Y. & N. J. Lubricant Co 239
Nicholson. W. H., & Co 241
Niles-Bement-Pond Co 6
Niles Tool Co
Norton, A. 0 1
Norton Emery Wheel Co
Norton Grinding Co la
Norwalk Iron Works 20
otto Gas Engine Works 12
Parker Pen Co 10
Pedrick & Ayer Co 3
Peters, H. S 241
Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool Co 238
Pond Machine Tool Co., The 14
Porter, H. K., & Co 17
Pratt & Whitney Co 14
Pressed Steel Car Co 2
Prosser, Thos., & Son 3
Protectus Co., The 16
Q. « C. Co 236
Railway Appliances Co 194
Railway Materials Co 2d Covtfr
Raraapo Iron Works 13
Rand Drill Co 15
Rogers Locomotive Works 17
Ross Valve Co 4tli Cover
Rue Mfg. Co 13
Sackmann, F. A 4th Cover
Safety Car Heating & Lighting Co 10
Saunders'. D., Sons 20
Seamless Steel Tube Co 16
Sellers, Wm., & Co., Inc 14
Shaw Electric Crane Co
Smoothon Mfg. Co 11
Standard Car Truck Co 16
Standard Coupler Co 14
Standard Seamless Tube Co 3
Standard Steel Works 13
Stannard & White Co 242
Star Brass Mfg. Co 2
Starre't Co.. L. S IB
Stearnes Steel Range Co 9
Sturtevant, B. F., Co 21
Tabor Mfg. Co 21
Underwood, H. B., & Co
Union Switch & Signal Co 242
United States Me'allic Packing Co 4
Universal Car Bearing Co 12
Utica Steam Gauge Co 2d Cover
Valve Models
Vitrified Wheel Co 4th Cover
Walworth Mfg. Co 2d Cover
Watson-Stillman Co 4th Cover
Webb C. Ball Watch Co 240
Westinghouse Air-Brake Co 18
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co 19
Whitecastle. L. & S., Co 2
Whittlesey, Geo. P 240
Whitney & Son, Baxter D ; 240
Williams Typewriter Co 1
Wood, R. n.. & Co 14
JUNE, 1903.
PREJ5URE IN POUMDS O
1
5
lO
SERIES No. 2.
fc,S 7o 7S 80 6? 90 9S- loo
Service
Cipplication,
piston trdvel
4 inches.
Made with
8" Cylinder
and frcig^'t
au5<.il(ar^
reservoir
10 poundi
reduction
1
HZI
\
-p— II
/4 pounds
reduction
1
t
■Mill
\
i
^^M
t
'"
7o pounds
reduction
^^m
i
Scrv/ice
*pplicz>tion.
Piston travel
6 inches.
Made with
S'cylinder
and freight
duxill&ry
reservoir
lO pounds
reduction
18 pounds
reduction
^^
««>. ■
, J
7o pounds
rexdoction
■^11
,,
Service,
application,
Piston travel
flinches.
Made with
B" cylinder
and freight
ZkUKillivry
reservoir.
lOpounds
reduction
^^ II
1 g
^■H II
' ^
21 pounds
fczduction
""" "
1 1
;;
7o pound*
reduction
■.1
,1
■
70 7S no as 90 9s /oo
fnfsr MAIN RE&ERVOi^ q ^ Brake Inspector.
B. & A. R.R., Springfield, Mass.
JUNE, 1903.
Color Air Brake Chart, Issued by Railway and Locomotive Engineering.
SERIES No. 2.
pRE.SiURE IN P0UMD5 O
15 20 25 30 35 'W- 4S SO 55 60 fcs 70 ."'^ So 85- 90 9S 100
PRE65URE IN POUNOJ O
Service
application
Pislon trdvfl
4 inches.
Made With
8"C>'linder
and frcig^-t
auxijlar^y
reservoir
10 pounds
reduction
^"
^m
Mil
/4 pounds
reduction
^^"
mma
II 1
7o pounds
reduction
— ■
Ml
—
;;
5e^^/lce
application.
Piston tfAvel
6 inches.
fUdewith
8 c/linder
&nd freight
duyill&r^
reservoir
10 pounds
reduction
.HI
Ml
;
i «<
I8p0jnds
reduction
^^
11 11
7o pounds
reduction
^"
^J
Service
application.
Piston tfAvcl
flinches
fi' Cylinder
and freight
^uxili^kry
reservoir.
lOpounds
reduction
■ini
1 1
.
M
2l pounds
reduction
^ ^
III!
,,
'""
7o pounds
reduction
1 1
ill
^
;:;
^
Im
^° =S JO ^S ^ AT so jrs 60 fcS 7o 7S 80 65" 90 5r
tS 2.0 a-S Jr ^i- 'Kj ts
o3 foo fcis ?o
Bo OS- 9o
Service
application
piston havfl
10 inches.
Made with
8"cylinder
and freight
auKtllarx
reservoir
10 pounds
reduction
T
^^
• i<
nil
11 III
^'"
^
^^
^^
"
"
1 II
^"
^^
^^
^^
I
24 pounds
reduction
li 1
11! 1
^^
^"
1
^pounds
reduction
^
.11,
^a
B^
^
^
f«*5i:
^"
Service
application,
piston travel
12 inches.
Made with
8" cylinder
and freight
aLJXlltar.y
reservoir
/O pounds
reduction
^"
^"
""
'""
'^
Ill INI
^^
lUJI
^"
■1^
"^
^
""
^
27pourids
reduction
■MJ
'^^
'
^"
^"
^^
^"
^"'
^"
^"
^"
""
^
^
t
7o pounds
reduction
■ ■_!
^"
^^
"^
^''
^"
^"
^"
1
Service
application,
piston travel
6 inches.witfi
15 pounds re-
10 pounds
reduction
""
^
^
1
^"^
^"
^"
""
"""J
I
^H
"^
^^
t
^
^
:: i:
brake cylin-
der by pres-
sure retaininj
valv« .
Made with
8" cylinder
»nd freight
auxiliary
reservoir
15 pounds
reduction
umi
""
^"
"^
1111111
^^
^^
I""
^"
^^
^^
'
^^
^^
^^
^^
II 11
reduction
^^
^"
^"
""
""
^"
T
c
s
P 1£
2
> 2-
.3c
) JJ
**0
*\5 J-O S5 lt>C
fcS
7C
7i
at
Si" 9o
9£
/ec-
KEY
MAIN RE'.SERVOIR
PREJ5URE.
TRAIM UNE
PRE3SURE
BRAKE VALV/E:
RESERVOIR PREi
AUXdLARr RES
PREAJUAE.
BRAKE CVllNDEJ*
PRESSURE
Designed by E. G. DESOE. Genu Air Brake Inspector,
B. (t A. R.R., SPniNGFiELO. Mass.
Railway . .and
lOcomotive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co. — J 903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
vor. XVI.
Consolidation Engine for the Rock
Island.
The American Locomotive Company
have lately supplied the Chicago, Rock
Island & Pacific with some powerful
2-8-0 engines, built at their Dunkirk
shops. The engines are probably the
heaviest now on the C, R. I. & P., the
machine weighing in all 202.500 lbs. The
engine is simple and has cylinders 22x30
in. The driving wheels are 63 in. in
diameter and carry a weight of 182,000
lbs. With 85 per cent, of the boiler
pressure, which is 200 lbs., assumed to
be the mean effective pressure at slow
speed, the maximum tractive effort is
174 Broadway, New York, June, 1903
cylinder as possible, so that the steam
spaces to be filled and emptied at each
stroke are as small as can be made. The
valve-rod transmission bar is slightly
curved, in order to work freely over the
leading axle, and being a steel casting,
is stifTened latterly with webs.
There are many familiar Brooks de-
tails about this engine, among others, the
band-like spring hanger and the reach
rod of 2 in. extra heavy wrought iron
pipe. The pilot stays are riveted to the
smoke bo.x and pinned to the front foot
plate. The headlight frame is below the
level of the top of the smoke box. The
diameter of the engine-truck wheels is
No. 6
Tubes, number, 3H3; dia., 2 in.; leoRth over lube
sheet, 15 ft, 6 in.
Heating surface, tubes, 3,087 sq. ft.; fire Ijox, 177 sq.
ft.; total, 3,264 sq. ft ; grate surface. 50 sq. It.
Smoke stack, top al)ove rail, 15 ft. 74 in.
TENDER.
Weiglit. empty, 57.220 lbs.; wheel base. iHft.
Ten. frame, 13 in. channel: ten. trucks, Brooks pat.
Water capacity, 7,000 U. S. gals.; coal, 15 tons.
Trans-Continental Railways of the
World.
Nearly every country with any sort of
enterprise, and with any considerable ex-
tent of territory, has one or more trans-
continental railway projects under
way or completed. The United States
39,200 lbs., and the ratio of tractive ef-
fort to adhesive weight is therefore 4.6.
The engine has a large boiler which
is 72% in. at the smoke-box end and a
total of 3,264 sq. ft. of heating surface
has been provided. This, with the am-
ple fire-box, guarantees good steaming
qualities. The boiler is of the extended
wagon-top type, with plenty of steam
room.
The valve gear is direct, and operates
a piston valve having inside admission.
This arrangement reduces the wear and
tear on valve-stem packing at both ends,
as it is only required to stand the com-
paratively light and intermittent press-
ure of the exhaust steam. That pro-
lific steam waster, the clearance, has been
very materially reduced in this design.
The valve chamber is placed in the direct
line of steam passage, and as close to the
ROCK ISLAND CONSOI,ID.\TION ENGINE.
36 in., running in a radial swing truck.
Some of the leading dimensions are as
follows:
GENERAL DIMENSIONS.
Weight in working order, 202.500 lbs.
Weight on drivers. 182,000 lbs.; weight engine and
tender in working order, 347.500 lbs.
Wheel base, driving. 17 ft.; total, 26 ft.
Wheel base, total, engine and tender. 57 ft. 6 in.
CYLINDERS.
Cylinders, 22x30 in. ; size of steam ports. 2x29 in.:
exhaust ports, 65 sq. in.; bridges, 3^ in.
VALVES.
Kind, improved piston: greatest travel, 5i| in.; out-
side lap, I in.; lead in full gear, ^ in.
WHEELS, ETC.
Dia. of driv, wheels outside of tire, 63 in.
BOILER.
Style, radial stayed extended wagon lop.
Outside dia. first ring 72J s in ; work, press . 2co lbs.
Firebox, length, loS in.: width, 6Sin.;depth, front,
75J^ in.; back, 6i'4 in.; plates, thickness, sides,
is in.; back, 3^ in.; crown, ^3 in.; tube sheet, ys
in.; wat. space, 4 in. fnt., 4 in. sides. 4 in. bck.
was the pioneer in this respect and
still remains first in the field. Canada
comes next, and even now has a
second trans-continental railway scheme
on hand. The trans-Siberian Railway,
about which we give some information
in another column, is Russia's most im-
portant railway undertaking, and al-
though this was built originally as a
military line, it cannot help being of the
greatest commercial importance as
time goes on. The Cape to Cairo
road, though not strictly a trans-conti-
nental line, as it runs north and south
in Africa, is nevertheless technically
such a road, and is being pushed forward
by our British cousins as rapidly as
possible. There is also the Chili-Argen-
tine railway project, which will one day
be an important South American line.
Not long ago there was some talk
246
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
of Great Britain joining France and Ger-
many in the construction of what press
dispatches call the Bagdad Railway.
The idea seems to be to run a line prob-
ably from the town opposite Constanti-
nople on the Bosphorus, to some terminus
on the Persian Gulf. This will practi-
cally be a trans-continental line. Part of
this line is already in existence, so that
Kouia will be the point from which con-
struction will now begin.
There is also the Australia trans-
continental railway, which, like the
British road in the "Dark Conti-
nent," will run north and south. The
State of South Australia, as its name
does not imply, occupies the central por-
tion of the continent, and is a belt of
territory, roughly speaking, in the
neighborhood of 800 miles wide, extend-
ing from the north coast to the south.
It so happens this one State is thus able
to span the island by a railway without
calling upon the Commonwealth to assist
in the work. At present the two ends
of this line are in existence. A road
from Port Darwin on the north, extends
in a southerly direction for about 145
miles, and from Adelaide, on St. Vin-
cent Gulf, a line runs about 688 miles
northward. The gap between these,
which has yet to be built, is about 1,063
miles. When completed, the' Australian
"perpendicular" trans-continental rail-
way will be about 1,890 miles long.
Tenders for the work are being asked
for in Great Britain, France, Germany
and the United States, and when com-
pleted the road will be State-owned, as
are the other railways of Australia.
We have on our list at present several
good men looking for positions as gen-
eral foreman or master mechanic. We
do not recommend any but efiicient men,
so superintendents of motive power
looking for help will find it an advan-
tage to correspond with us.
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCL.MR.
{Continued from page 164.)
In my last article I forgot to men-
tion that the interesting illustration of
the track which Trevithick used came
to me through the courtesy of Mr.
Clement E. Stretton, C.E., of Leicester.
England, a well-known engineer and au-
thor.
PROSPERITY PROMOTED R.MLROAD ENTER-
PRISES.
The beneficent administration of John
Quincy Adams, which ended in 1829,
left the country so prosperous that there
was unusual surplus capital to invest in
industrial enterprises. The operation of
railroads promised to be so profitable
that capital was readily secured for the
building of new lines. In some States
nUwaukee Road to Build Locomotives.
The Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul
has determined to build its own locomo-
tives in the future. The high prices de-
manded for locomotives, coupled with
the inability of American locomotive
builders to make deliveries promptly, in-
duced the company to take this step, and
new shops for locomotive building are
now being constructed at Milwaukee,
with a capacity of from 80 to 90 locomo-
tives annually.
J. A. Barr, lately general superinten-
dent, has become assistant to President
Earling, and will have general charge of
this feature of the company's policy. He
is one of the best mechanical engineers
in the country, and was formerly with
the Baltimore & Ohio and Erie. The
change of position for Mr. Barr will
necessitate other changes, which are
noted in our personal department.
Mohawk & Hudson. The purpose of both
inventions was the same, but the means
employed was different, yet a fierce con-'
trover.=y arose about who was the oiigi-
nator of the leading truck, which after-
wards became so popular.
The Baltimore & Susquehanna was
subsequently absorbed by the Northern
Central Railroad, which in its turn was
swallowed by the Pennsylvania Railroad
Company. It is usual to say that the
Camden & Amboy was the first link built
of the Pennsylvania system, but the Bal-
timore & Susquehanna clearly antedates
the other.
Other railroads that had some miles
put into operation during 1831 were the
Camden & Amboy, in New Jersey; the
New Castle & Frenchtown, in Delaware;
the Mine Hill & Schuylkill Haven, the
Mount Carbon in Pennsylvania, and a
few others that began nowhere and
ended in a similar locality. A few miles
of mine tramways were also opened, all
showing that the idea of moving heavy
DeWITT CLINTON. FIG. 82.
excitement in favor of railroad building
became vigorously active about 1830, and
continued till the inevitable panic of a
few years later converted the golden day
dreams of many investors in railroad
securities into hideous nightmares of
ruin.
PIONEER FRNCMENTS.
During 1830 many charters were
granted for the construction of railroads,
and considerable work was done on
short sections that now belong to great
railroad systems and are boasted about
just as families boast about the antiquity
of their ancestors, who often in the flesh
were very inferior creatures.
In 1831 seven miles of the Baltimore
& Susquehanna Railroad were finished,
and an English engine, the "Herald,"
was imported to operate it. This en-
gine has a historical association, since
Ross Winans applied four small leading
wheels to it, about the time that John
B. Jervis applied the four-wheel truck
in front of an engine belonging to the
freight on rails was appealing favorably
to the American people.
THE MOHAWK & HUDSON RAILROAD.
After the South Carolina Railroad, the
next one to come into prominence was
the Mohawk & Hudson Railroad. This
company was chartered in 1826, but con-
struction was not commenced until 1830.
It was opened with ostentatious cere-
monies in 1831.
Readers of railroad development often
wonder, why one of the most celebrated
pioneer railroads in the United States,
should have been built away inland, to
connect two comparatively small towns,
while the great city of New York had
done nothing to promote such enter-
prises. The fact is that in 1830 the city
of Albany, the capital of New York
State, was relatively a much more im-
portant place than it is to-day, and
Schenectady was an ancient growing city
that expected to advance rapidly into
metropolitan dimensions. Albany was at
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
247
that time the seventh city in the Union,
was the seat of the State Legislature, of
the law courts, the principal entrepot
for the farm produce brought in from the
fertile valleys extending to Lake Erie,
and was the immediate landing place for
all the products of the uberous Mohawk
Valley.
INDUCEMENTS TO BUILD THE RAILROAD.
The movement of population toward
the forests and prairies west of Lake
Erie had hardly begun, for there were
less than five thousand people settled
west of the lakes; but farseeing men
perceived that the immense vacant spaces
would be filled before many years passed,
and it was seen that the route of the
Erie Canal would be the channel of
western emigration. Railroads, built
along this route, were certain to take
much of the business of transporting pas-
sengers away from the tedious canal
which was prostrated by frost a con-
siderable part of the year. So the en-
terprise of building the Mohawk & Hud-
son Railroad was a sensible undertaking
and received all the financial support re-
quired.
The line was only about seventeen
miles long, but natural obstacles had to
be overcome of greater magnitude than
those undertaken by most of the pioneer
railroad engineers. John B. Jervis, who
had become celebrated for achievements
in canal construction, and who sent
Horatio Allen to England to study rail-
road problems, was chief engineer, and he
had few equals in the world at the time.
The old city of Albany was built on
river bottoms, that had been washed out
of the adjoining high lands which form
an elevated plateau extending many
miles south and west. This plateau had
to be traversed by a line going to Sche-
nectady. As the pioneer engineers sup-
posed that a locomotive engine could
climb only very light gradients, inclined
planes were employed to raise the cars at
Albany and to lower them to another
low level at Schenectady. The top of the
inclined plane at Albany was near the
point where the imposing State House
now stands.
THE "dE WITT CLINTON."
Early in August, 1831, the Mohawk
& Hudson Railroad was ready for oper-
ating, and a locomotive called the "De
Witt Clinton," built at West Point
Foundry, New York, was ready to haul
the first train of railroad cars moved in
New York State. The appearance of
this engine, shown in Fig. 22, is well
known, owing to the numerous pictures
of it which have been published.
The De Witt Clinton was a four-
wheel engine, all drivers four and a half
feet diameter, with cast-iron hubs,
spokes turned and polished and wrought
iron tires. There were two cylinders,
5V3X16 inches, set at the sides of the
fire-box at an angle of about 30 degrees.
They transmitted the power to inside
cranked axles on the first pair of wheels.
The wheels were connected outside by
side rods in the form of double trusses.
The most conspicuous thing about the
engine was the boiler, which was hori-
zontal, and had a huge dome that over-
shadowed the rest of the engine. The
boiler had thirty copper tubes 2V2 inches
diameter and si.x feet long, and was fed
by pumps operated vertically by a bell
crank. The fire-box had two doors, one
above the other. The steam carried was
50 pounds to the square inch. When the
boiler was filled with water and the fire-
box charged with wood, the whole thing
weighed about four tons. When in good
working order it was found that the en-
[fine would haul five of the small cars
then used on a level at a speed of about
thirty miles an hour.
CEREMONIAL INAUGUR.\TION OF RAIL-
ROADS.
In the year of grace 1831, the Ameri-
can people were beginning to be proud
of the achievements in railroad building
accomplished by native enterprise and
ability, but this feeling had been Httle
FIG. 23.— FIRST TYPE OF PASSENGER CAR
USED ON MOHAWK & HUDSON
RAILROAD.
manifested publicly. There had been
one exception in a public demonstration
made in connection with laying the cor-
nerstone of the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road. That had been attended by one
of the most magnificent processions of
the military and civil associations, trades
and professions ever witnessed in the
United States. The venerable Charles
Carroll, of Carrollton, then over ninety
years of age, the only survivor of those
who signed the Declaration of Independ-
ence, was present, and laid the corner-
stone amidst impressive ceremonies.
Since that day railroad builders had
been contented to begin their work and
to inaugurate the operating of their
properties in a less ostentatious fashion.
But when the opening day of the Mo-
hawk & Hudson was approaching, a
movement was instituted to give the en-
terprise an initiation worthy of the first
railroad connecting the capital of the
Empire State with the outside world.
The year before, the Liverpool & Man-
chester had been opened with impress-
ive ceremonies, in which the Duke of
Wellington, the hero of Waterloo, and
other celebrities took a part. The fes-
tivities of the occasion had been clouded
by a locomotive running over a member
of Parliament with fatal results; but that
did not deter the promotors of the Mo-
hawk & Hudson Railroad from arrang-
ing for an opening excursion in which
the leading celebrities of New York
State were invited to ride.
DEMAND FOR A GALA DAY OPENING.
There were many legislators, judges
and other public officials in Albany at
the time, and they readily accepted the
invitation to take a free ride, a practice
the politicians of all States have faith-
fully adhered to ever since. A formida-
ble array of names of men who took
part in that excursion is preserved, but
time has robbed most of them of the
note they originally possessed.
On August 9, 1831, the De Witt Clin-
ton stood on the newly finished track at
the top of the inclined plane at Albany
with a train of highly picturesque cars
(Fig. 23) behind her. They were large
stage-coaches with doors at the sides, and
to convert them to railroad use the bodies
were secured to oblong wooden frames
to which the axle boxes were fitted. The
ends of the frames acted as bumpers and
the cars were coupled together by loose
chains. They carried passengers inside
and on top.
THE FIRST TRAIN AN EXCURSION.
When the engine was getting up
steam, passengers were crowding into
the cars until they were nearly as well
filled as an elevated railroad car during
the rush hours. David Matthew, the en-
gineer, dropped oil on the frictional sur-
faces, examined carefully every rod and
bearing, then mounted the unprotected
fnot-plate ready to start. John T.
Clark, who was the first conductor.
mounted to the seat at the back of the
tender, tooted upon a tin horn, and this
famous cavalcade started. So did the
horses belonging to a concourse of
farmers who had come in their buggies
and wagons with their wives, families.
cousins and aunts. No resounding au-
tomobile ever spread such consternation
around. When the engine gave forth the
first exhaust the horses started away in
frightful terror.
A gentleman who was in the train
afterward wrote: "A general notice
having been given of the contemplated
trip, e.xcited not only the curiosity of
those living along the line of the road,
but those living remote from it. causing
a large collection of people at all the
intersecting roads along the line of the
route. Everybody, together with his
wife and all his children, came from a
distance with all kinds of conveyances,
being as ignorant of what was coming
as their horses, drove up to the road as
near as they could get. only looking for
the best position to get a view of the
248
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
train. As it approached, the horses took
fright and wheeled, upsetting buggies,
carriages and wagons, and leaving for
parts unknown to the passengers, if not
to their owners, and it is not now posi-
tively known if some of them have yet
stopped."
ON THE TRAIN.
The passengers on the train had their
own share of excitement when the en-
gine started, the loose couplings jerked
the train so violently that the passen-
gers were thrown into contused heaps
clinging desperately to each other to
avoid falling oflf.
The original intention was to burn an-
thracite in the fire-box of the engine,
but a few experimental runs had proven
that anthracite would not generate steam
fast enough, so it was determined to
burn pitch pine. There was no spark
arrester, so the force of the exhaust
threw out a volume of black smoke
freely mixed with sparks, coal, cinders
LOCOMOTIVE ROBERT FULTON.
As the only public locomotive building
works in America at this time was the
West Point Foundry, New York, which
was of very limited capacity, most of the
railroad companies had to order locomo-
tives from England, principally from the
works of Robert Stephenson & Co.,
Newcastle.
Shortly after the Mohawk & Hudson
Railroad was opened for business a loco-
motive called the "Robert Fulton" was
received from England. This engine
was a modification of what was known
as the "Planet" class, the most success-
ful type of engine built by the Stephen-
son's up to this time. The Planet
class proper had inside cylinders placed
under the smoke box, cranked axle, of
course, one pair of drivers set in front
of the fire-box and one pair of small
carrying wheels behind the smoke box.
Instead of the small carrying wheels, the
Robert Fulton had a second pair of
drivers, and the wheels were connected
the same as the De Witt Clinton. The
wheels were four feet diameter, set four
and one-half feet apart from center to
FIG. 34.— JERVIS' "BROTHER JONATHAN."
and lumps of half-burned pine. The
sparks found their way into the eyes and
ears of the passengers, down their necks
and into every crevice in their clothing.
Those who carried umbrellas raised them
to ward ofT the fiery downpour ; but
these soon took fire, and the train held
a frantic crowd, who slapped out the
flames, destroying their own and their
neighbors' garments. People by the
wayside supposed that the train was car-
ryingi'a load of maniacs. Consternation
reigned supreme, and many people
thought of jumping before the engineer
perceived the condition of affairs. By that
time they were near a water tank, where
a stop was made, and the burning gar-
ments were drenched with water. Many
of the pleasure seekers had good reason
to remember their first ride on a railroad
train.
center. The total weight of the engine
in working order was about 15,000
pounds.
DEFECTS OF THE ROBERT FULTON.
The engine steamed well and had all
the tractive power required, but defects
developed which led to the invention of
the engine truck. The frame was twelve
feet long and the axles being four and a
half feet apart, it projected beyond the
bearing on the axles nearly four feet
each way. This produced an unsteady
motion that was very unfavorable to the
track, the machinery and disagreeable to
the enginemen. It teetered like a short
wheel-base horse car. The track of the
Mohawk & Hudson was well constructed
for that time, being of strap iron laid on
southern pine, but the hammering action
of the Robert Fulton was too much for it.
INVENTION OF THE ENGINE TRUCK.
Mr. Jervis admitted that heavy engines
must come into use and he got cogitating
over means to prevent the destructive
effects of the Robert Fulton. This led
him to propose a four-wheel leading
truck. He made drawings for an engine
having this improvement and sent them
to the West Point Foundry. The engine
made from the drawings, which was
called the "Brother Jonathan," was de-
livered in 1832, and worked so well that
the English engine was changed, the
forward pair of drivers being removed
and the four-wheel truck put in front.
David Matthew, who had charge of the
building of the Brother Jonathan, wrote
about the engine: "She had cylinders
9%xi6 inches, two driving wheels five
feet diameter, set aft furnace. Truck
wheels 33 inches diameter. The truck
worked upon friction rollers. The fur-
nace was five feet long and 34 inches
wide, made to turn anthracite coal.
"With this engine I have crossed the
Mohawk & Hudson from plane to plane
fourteen miles in thirteen minutes, mak-
ing one stop for water."
This will show that claims of high
speed began early on the New York
Central.
JERVIS ORDERS STEPHENSON ENGINE WITH
LEADING TRUCK.
That same year Mr. Jervis sent to
Robert Stephenson & Co. drawings and
specifications for a locomotive to be built
for the Saratoga & Schenectady Rail-
road. It had a single pair of driving
wheels and a four-wheel truck, and this
was the first locomotive built in Europe
with a truck which they call a "bogie,"
then the slang name given to small four-
wheel service cars. The word is now
good English, but it was not admitted
into dictionaries in the third decade of
last century.
The weak and fragile condition of the
track of early American railroads made
the leading truck popular wherever it
was tried, and it came rapidly into favor.
Baldwin used it in his second engine and
continued its use, so did the Norris's and
other early locomotive builders. It was
the most valuable improvement whicTi
the New York Central Railroad System
bestowed upon the railroad world.
(To be continued.)
We have received a letter from W. F.
Allen, Argentine, Kansas, in which he
takes issue with Mr. Buckbee's letter in
the May, 1903, issue of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering about the
relative merits of the two cylinder tan-
dem compounds. Our correspondent in-
sists that he has a tandem compound
which is better than any other kind and
very easily kept in piston packing be-
tween the two pistons. He does not,
however, give any figures to sustain the
position he takes.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
249
Trespassers on Railroad Track Have No
Redress,
A decision handed down by the circuit
court at Akron, O., last month, is at-
tracting much attention among raihoad
men, and it is also of considerable inter-
est to the general public, especially that
portion who make a practice of walking
along tlie tracks of the railroad com-
panies. It was in the case of Stein
against the C, A. & C. Railroad Com-
pany. Stein was a student at the high
school, and while walking along the
track of the C, A. & C, just below
Center street, he was run down by a C.
A. & C. switch engine and badly injured.
' He sued for big damages and secured a
judgment for $2,500 in common pleas
court. But last week the circuit court
reversed this judgment and ordered the
case sent back for a new trial in common
pleas court.
Judge Hale, of Cleveland, handed
down the decision. He held that where
anybody trespassed on railroad prop-
erty, except at street crossings, they did
so at their own peril, provided, of course,
they were not run down maliciously, in
which case criminal action as well as
civil action could be brought. The
court held that the engineer need not be
on the lookout for possible trespassers
on the tracks of the company. Of
course an engineer, in case he should
see a man on the track, is not supposed
to run down the man in case it is pos-
sible to stop the train.
This particular case is of special inter-
est in view of the fact that persons for
thirty years have been using the tracks
between Mill and Exchange streets as a
path, and the evidence showed that at
times there are as many as 200 persons on
the tracks between these streets. Not-
withstanding this the persons were tres-
passers, as the company has signs up
warning persons to keep off the prop-
erty, and consequently persons walking
along the tracks do so at their own peril,
and if they are injured or killed they or
their relatives can recover nothing if the
engineers have exercised ordinary fore-
sight, the court held.
Air-Operated Door for Oil Annealing
Furnace.
A very satisfactory arrangement for
raising and lowering the heavy cast-iron
and fire-brick door of a plate-anneal-
ing furnace is to be seen in the Eliza-
bethport Shops of the Central Railroad
of New Jersey. The furnace is heated
by the combustion of oil. Four jets
similar to those used in the well-known
Ferguson oil furnaces supplied by the
Railway Materials Company, have been
applied to this furnace by that concern.
The hearth is 14x9 feet, and is 20 inches
high at the sides, and 26 inches high at
the center of the arch.
The door itself is composed of five
cast sections with two half-sections, one
at each end. The sections are bolted to-
gether through a flange on the outside,
and are filled with fire-brick inside. The
central chain is the one which does the
lifting, being attached to a hook oper-
ated by a 6-inch air cylinder with about
30-inch stroke. The two side chains
pass over pulleys bracketed against the
wall and pass outside the wail of the
building where two counter-weights, each
and at the same time makes the long,
low fire-proof door equivalent to one of
from ten to twelve feet high. Two flat
bar iron diagonals, from the door
proper, are bolted to a flat, iron cross-
brace, as shown at A. With the aid of
a short iron strap at the back the
counter-balance chains are firmly
clamped as shown in plan, at B. There
is no chance for the door to rack or to
swing sideways, though the pull which
PLATE ANNEALING FURNACE DOOR
about 400 pounds, balance the door.
Over this furnace is a shop window, and
the problem was to arrange the raising
and lowering mechanism so that the light
should not be interfered with and yet
that the door should work easily and
promptly without sticking or sagging
down at one end. These two conditions
were met by the construction shown.
The mechanism consists of a braced
skeleton frame which offers no obstruc-
tion to the entrance of light to the shop,
raises it is applied through the center
chain. All three chains are secured by
dove-tail hooks, slid into dove-tail lugs
on the castings. The center chain is
quite independent of the skeleton frame.
The placing of the counter-weights out-
side the building does away with the
possibility of their getting in the way,
and in case of breakage of chain or hook
the risk of injury to any employee is en-
tirely obviated. The whole arrangement
is planned to secure maximum advan-
250
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
tages, with minimum cost, and it gives a
'positive and satisfactory movement to a
door which is otherwise very awkward
to manipulate.
Double Hook and Steel Sling Used in
Lifting; Engines.
The annexed sketch is of a double
crane-hook used, together with the main
hook, on one of the 50-ton cranes em-
ployed in lifting engines at the Elizabeth-
port shops of the Central Railroad of New
Jersey. This hook is used in conjunc-
tion with a steel wire cable sling, good
for 60 tons and about 25 feet long, which
is made with an eye at each end. The
double hook is slipped into main hook
and both the eyes of the wire sling are
then dropped in place on the double
hook and the sling hoisted until it car-
Oil Burners for Boston and Halne.
Among the recent orders received by
the American Locomotive Company at
Schenectady for locomotives to be built
at the local works is one of twelve en-
gines for the Boston & Albany road.
Four simple oil-burning engines of the
Northwestern type are being built for
the San Pedro, Los Angeles and Salt
Lake Railroad. They are for August
delivery. The locomotives are to weigh
157,000 pounds each, with 90,000 pounds
on the drivers, which are to be 70 inches
in diameter; cylinders, 19x26 inches.
The boilers will be of the straight-top
type, 66M, inches in diameter at the
smallest ring, with 326 tubes 16 feet long
and two inches in diameter, to stand a
working pressure of 200 pounds. The
tender will have a water capacity of
Itailway ^ tyc^mofiia EnffinMring
DOUBI^E CRANE HOOK FOR LIFTING ENGINES AT FRONT END.
ries the smoke box of the engine which
it is intended to lift. The back end of
the locomotive is lifted in the usual way
with top equalizing beam, two hangers
and heavy carrying bar which passes
under the foot plate.
The double hook for the cable sling
is made of soft steel, and the whole ar-
rangement is regarded as one of the
handiest and quickest methods for tak-
ing hold of the front end in a lift. The
shop people are not prevented from tack-
ling a hot front-end when necessary, as
the steel sling does not take any harm,
as a hemp rope might, from surrounding
a hot smoke box. The two eyes and
double hook together reduce the time
occupied in "taking hold" of an engine
to its lowest terms, as well as being a
safe method. The whole thing has little
or no wear, and can be readily hung up
out of the way when not in use.
55.000 gallons and an oil capacity of 1,750
gallons.
A Diminutive Locomotive.
There is on exhibition in the waiting-
room of the Lackawanna at Hoboken a
product of the Kingsland shops of the
company, which they call the smallest
working locomotive in the world. It is
not one of the thumb-nail freaks, but a
complete working locomotive of par-
ticularly small dimensions.' It is stand-
ard eight-wheel American type, with
four coupled drivers. It is 5 feet 4 inches
in length, 18 inches wide and 28 inches
from rail to top of smoke-stack. Thi:;
cylinders are two inches in diametc,
with a stroke of 4 inches. The boiler i.^
built of steel and has stood a test of
400 pounds to the square inch. The
engine complete weighs 600 pounds.
It will be taken to Cranberry Lake,
the company's excursion resort, where a
track about 1,000 feet long is being con-
structed, and it will haul a train of ten
cars during the summer months. It at-
tracts considerable attention from the
thousands who pass through the Ho-
boken terminal daily, and is especially
pleasing to the young folks.
Small as it is, this engine is capable
of developing considerable power, and
is nearly as strong as the Cooper en-
gine, illustrated in Railw.w and Loco-
motive Engineering of February last.
Engines for the Pittsburgh and Lake
Erie.
The American Locomotive Works
have received an order from the Pitts-
burgh & Lake Erie for a large number of
Atlantic type engines. The machines
will weigh 167,000 pounds, with 97.000
pounds on drivers. Diameter of cylin-
ders, 20 inches; diameter of drivers, 72
inches; wide fire box; heating surface,
2,800 square feet; working steam pres-
sure, 200 pounds; tank capacity, 7.000
gallons of water and 10 tons of coal. The
special equipment includes Westinghouse
air brakes, steel axles, magnesia boiler
lagging, Gould couplers. Monitor injec-
tors, Dressel headlights, Paxton-
Mitchell piston rod and valve rod pack-
ings, Coale safety valves. Economy
sanding devices and Nathan sight feed
lubricators. This additional power is in-
tended for the increase of passenger busi-
ness expected in connection with the St.
Louis exhibition.
Moundsville, which is a small town in
West Virginia, has succeeded in securing
an inij)ortant industry, being a $3,000,000
pressed steel car plant, to manufacture
cars and other structural shapes on a
large scale. The town has secured the
project by giving a tract of 45 acres
upon which to construct the plant and
making other donations of means, in-
cluding stock and money. The papers
in the matter are being closed up at
Pittsburg, Pittsburg parties will be In
charge of it. The villagers are jubilant
at present concerning the addition to the
place, but in about five years they will
be doing their level best to overburden
the new industry with taxes.
The N. L. Hayden Manufacturing
Company, of Columbus, Ohio, have is-
sued a folder dealing with the Tippett
Compact Safety Valve for Locomo-
tives. In the circular, the form of con-
struction and the method of operatior*
of this ingenious valve is shown and ex-
plained. The sizes, effective area and
price of each valve in the series from
two to four inches, is given, and the
claims made for the compact valve are
duly enumerated. The Hayden company
will mail the circular to those who write
to them for copies.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
251
New York Central Tandem Compound
Consolidation Bn)(ine.
The New York Ccnlral & Hudson
River Railroad have lately received some
heavy tandem compound freight locomo-
tives. They weve built at the Schenec-
tady shops of the American Locomotive
Company and are described according
to their scheme of locomotive classifi-
cation as 280C200. The cylinders arc 15
and 28x34 ins. and the driving wheels,
which are all flanged, are 63 ins. in
diameter. The calculated maximum
tractive effort of this machine when
working compound is about 38.000 lbs.,
and the ratio of tractive effort to ad-
hesive weight is 4.5.
The tandem principle has advantages
and disadvantages like many other
things. The most obvious advantages,
however, are that the thrust upon the
cro.ss-head is delivered by one rod, and
that the variation of pressures upon both
pistons does not produce any injurious
strain on cross-head, guides or rods.
box end, and there is a fifteen-inch mud
drum placed near the throat sheet.
The tender is of the usual water-bot-
tom form under frames of lo-inch steel
channels, carried on Fox trucks with
side bearings on both trucks. The
capacity of the tank is 5,000 gallons, and
the coal carried is 10 tons.
The engines present a compact and
powerful appearance, and are designed
for fast heavy freight. A few of the di-
mensions are given below:
CUNERAI, DIMENSIONS.
WttKht in working order, 200,000 lbs.
Weight on drivers, 172.500 lbs.; weight engine and
tender in working order, 306,400 lbs.
Wheel base, rigid, 17 ft.; total, 26 It. 3 in.
Wheel base, total, engine and tender, 54 ft, 3 in.
Cylinders, 15 and 28 x 34 in.
VALVES.
Greatest travel of valves, 6 in.
Outside lap of slide valves, i in.; inside lap, H. P.
clearance, o in., t,. P. clearance J^ in.
Lead of valves in full gear, line and line full gear
F. & B. '4 in. lead, 'A in. stroke.
WHEELS, ETC.
I)ia. of driving wheels outside of tire. 63 in.
Dia. and length of driving journals, main, 954 in..
passenger engines are equipped with
cylinders 18x26, the switch engines are
18x24 and freights 19x26. The new,
powerful load-pulicrs are beauties and
have a most imposing appearance. A
correspondent says: "The Cotton Belt
IS gradually equipping the system with
a fine lot of rolling stock, and in a few
years will have as fine a roadbed as is
possible to be made in this country.
The system is being personally and care-
fully handled by Mr. E. A. Peck, di-
vision superintendent, and his good gen-
eralship is having a telling cflfect. Mr.
Peck is considered by all who know
him as fine a railroad manager as has
ever been in this section. He sees a
proposition clearly and quickly, and
acts with a natural decision in all mat-
ters."
Purposely nisunderstood.
A lady of our acquaintance in Canada,
to whom we recently showed with pride
a copy of Railway and Locomotive
TANDEM COMPOUND CONSOLIDATION FOR NEW YORK CENTRAL.
One very easily perceived disadvantage is
that economy of space demands that both
cylinders be bolted close together, which
renders the piston rod packing between
cylinders hard to get at or repair, how-
ever, this defect is in part remedied by
placing the packing in a sleeve which is
capable of a certain amount of self-ad-
justment up and down as well as side-
ways.
The valves are of the balanced-piston
type and are driven by indirect con-
nected valve gear. All the driving
wheels are flanged, and the two forward
ones are equalized with the pony truck,
while the two rear wheels are equalized
together. The cross-head is of the two-
guide type, with upper guide cut out to
receive the lip on the upper portion of
the cross-head.
The boiler is of the straight-top
variety, with wide fire-box. and measures
72 -^g ins. outside diameter at the first
ring. There is a four-inch hand hole in
the bottom of the boiler, at the smoke-
I. F. & B. 9x12 in.; dia. and length of main
crank pin journals. 7^3x5^ in,
Dia. and length of side rod crank pin journals,
main, 6J2X6 in., F. & B. s^-jX^'i in.
BOILER.
Working pressure, 210 lbs, ; thickness of plates in
barrel and outside of fire box, J§, H. H' 'i ^'^•
Fire box plates, thickness, sides, ^% in. ; back, ?«
in.; crown, H in.; tube sheet, ^ in.
Fire box water space, 4 and 5 in. front, 3J4 and 55^
in, sides, 3J^ and 4^ in. back.
Tubes, material and gauge, charcoal iron No. 12,
B. W. O,; number. 396; dia., 2 in. O. D.; length
over tube sheets, 16 ft.
Heating surface, tubes. 3,298.08 sq. ft.; water tubes,
27.09 sq. ft,; fire box. 155.40 sq. ft.; total, 3,480.57
sq. ft.; grate surface, 50.32 sq. ft.
TENDER.
Weight, empty, 44.750 lbs.; wheel base, 16 ft, 7J^ in.
Water capacity, 5.000 U. S. gals.; coal. lo tons.
A Boom on the Cotton Belt.
Business must be booming on the
Cotton Belt Line, for they have recently
received thirty new locomotives from
the Rogers Locomotive Works. There
are seven switch engines, three passen-
ger and twenty freight locomotives. The
Engineering, fresh from the press,
turned over the pages with evident pleas-
ure. Although she disclaimed any tech-
nical knowledge of railroad matters she
praised the half-tones and line cuts and
made some complimentary remarks upon
the general appearance of the magazine.
On handing it back to us, her eye caught
the words "Upsetting Machines," which
are printed very conspicuously on the
outside of the cover. "Oh," she said, "I
did not know you required upsetting
machines on railways. Is not that form
of entertainment usually provided for
passengers without the use of elaborate
machinery and generally without much
previous preparation on the part of the
company?" Just let the delicate irony
of the question steal over you. and try
to imagine our reply, for it was very
good, you may be sure, in fact it was the
"acme."
Tears never yet wound up a clock, or
worked a steam ingin'. — Sam IVeller.
252
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Locomotive Sander.
'Mr. W. C. Andrews, assistant round-
house foreman on the Pennsylvania at
Altoona, has taken out a patent for a lo-
comotive Sander which is shown in our
illustration. It consists of a sand-holding
chamber which is surrounded by steam
pockets, and has the sand-discharging
device placed inside the chamber. This
arrangement and its construction is
clearly shown in the central longitudinal
section, being on the left side of the
line cut. The view on the right is a
central transverse view of the sander.
This whole device is connected to the
sand box with one feed pipe, through
which sand enters the apparatus. A
plug at the bottom enables the sand
chamber to be cleaned out when re-
quired. There are only three parts in
the make-up of the sander, the chamber
and the two nipples for forming the
and hold the annual convention at Cleve-
land. A fund of $20,000 has been raised
to entertain the firemen, and the business
men of Cleveland appear to think that
the inducements will be sufficient to
bring them the convention. We hope
that the firemen will not be seduced
by this offer from Cleveland. Expen-
sive entertainments have been given to
several railroad conventions, and they
always left a bad odor behind them.
There is no convention of railroad men
more successful than those which do
their own entertaining, and it leaves no
aftermath which railway officials can
use as a reflection upon the organiza-
tion. We have in mind one railroad as-
sociation which received great induce-
ments in the way of a large entertain-
ment fund to go to a certain city with
their convention, and it almost ruined
the character of the association. Rail-
Railway J- Locumutive Ei>uiiie»ring
ANDREWS' LOCOMOTIVE TRACK SANDER.
blowing jet which drives the sand into
the pipes leading to the rail. We un-
derstand that the device has given every
satisfaction, as the sand does not clog,
as it is always kept dry by the steam
jacket, but it is said that it will work
wet sand or such material as smoke-box
cinders. It has had a six months' trial
on the Pennsylvania and has not failed
in that time. It is a very ingenious and
compact contrivance.
road officials held it against the associa-
tion for years, and it was only by pass-
ing strict rules against entertainments
that the association in question re-
gained the respect and confidence of the
superior officers.
very best information obtainable on the
subject in this country, at least. Con-
cerning the burning of fuel in locomo-
tive furnaces a report says:
"It may be of interest to note the
work done with coal and petroleum as
fuel on these locomotives. In each •
case the engine had its full rated ton-
nage to haul, and a 30 days' run was
taken for the record. On the Florida
East Coast Railway, where the road was
level, 6.}4 gallons of oil was burned per
engine mile; the oil weighted 7 55-100
pounds per gallon. The same work
with Tennessee coal for fuel resulted in
19.6 miles run per ton of coal of 2,000
pounds. Under these conditions 132.3
gallons of oil equaled a ton of coal. The
same engine on freight service, with a
heavier load at lower speed, showed
10.6 gallons per mile run, and on coal
13 miles per ton, or 131. 8 gallons of oil
per ton coal.
"On the Boston & Maine, on the
Hoosac Tunnel helper, running double
head with coal-burning engine, up grade
42 feet per mile, and returning light, the
engine used 11.45 gallons per mile. Oil
weighed 7.75 pounds per gallon. Same
engine burning coal ran 12.25 miles per
ton of 2,240 pounds, and in this service
140.26 gallons of oil equaled i ton of
coal. In this last test the engines were
loaded as nearly equal as could be de-
termined from freight records.
"In conclusion, it may be stated that
on the locomotive it was always pos-
sible to drive the engine to greater
capacity with oil fuel than with coal, and
with a smokeless fire. I see no reason
why this cannot be done as well in the
marine service, and with the work con-
tinued afong lines following the Hohen-
stein boiler tests the proper propor-
tions for furnace and boiler settings will
be found. In a locomotive from 15 to
25 per cent, of the coal is lost in smoke,
unburned gases and cinders, which go '
out of the stack by reason of sharp ex-
haust, and there is also a loss of fuel
through grates."
Cleveland Wants Firemen's Convene
tion.
At the last convention of the Broth-
erhood of Locomotive Firemen, it was
decided to hold the next convention at
Buflfalo, the people of Buffalo having
given all the inducements they could to
have the convention held there. We
now find that a vigorous effort is being
made by the city of Cleveland to induce
the firemen to change the arrangements
Government Tests of Liquid FueL
The Edwards oil fuel board of the
United States Navy has been making
tests of petroleum for fuel under ma-
rine and stationary boilers, and are pre-
paring an elaborate report of the results.
They did not make tests under locomo-
tive boilers, but they obtained data of
oil-burning locomotives from the Bos-
ton & Maine and the Florida East Coast
Railroads. It is strange to us that
they did not obtain data from railroads
in Texas and on the Pacific Coast, where
the burning of liquid fuel is an estab-
lished practice that has been going on
for several years, and could provide the
Members of railroad clubs in general,
and of the New York Railroad Club in
particular, will be glad to learn that a
libel suit against Mr. H. H. Vreeland,
president of the Metropolitan Street
Railroad Co., and of the New York
Railroad Club, has been dismissed. The
evidence brought out in the case shows
that certain speculators were doing their
best to depress the Metropolitan Street
Railway stock, and that Mr. Vreeland
publicly expressed his opinion of what
they were doing. On this account they
brought a libel suit against him, which
did nothing but show the despicable do-
ings of the parties who brought the
suit. A person must get up early in
the morning to get ahead of Mr. Vree-
land.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
253
General Correspondence.
Hclntosh's Ten-Wheelers.
Mr. John Mcintosh, the locomotive
superintendent of the Caledonian Rail-
way, has just designed and completed at
the St. Rollox works of the company two
locomotives intended for the West Coast
express traffic between Carlisle, Glas-
gow and Pertli.
These engines are of a type absolutely
unique and new to the railway world,
being the first lo-wheeled locomotives
for express work which combine inside
cylinders, inside framing, a leading bogie
and 6-coupled wheels of so large a diam-
eter as 6 ft. 6 in. As such, they mark
a step or epoch in locomotive design,
and are worthy of special notice.
The cylinders, 21x26 in,, are placed be-
tween the frames with the valves (ordi-
nary slide) above and actuated by ordi-
formances are giving the greatest satis-
faction, handling with ease the heaviest
trains put behind them, and though not
yet running the fastest trains, promise,
when the "shop stiffness" wears off, to
"run" with anything on wheels.
S. A. F.
Setting Slipped Eccentrics.
It was during my first year's service
firing a locomotive that I got some very
valuable pointers in setting a slipped ec-
centric.
I was firing a "Hinckley" — go-ahead
eccentrics were next to driving boxes.
About noon one hot day in mid-summer
engine suddenly quit doing business.
Engineer of very "stout" build; he was
burdened with about 150 pounds of
superfluous avoirdupois; quarters were
that eccentric to top of shaft, and nearly
in position to fasten at least a dozen
times when my lever would slip out and
that ecentric would glide back to the
place "from whence it came." Talk
about an orthodox hades, I have my
doubts to this day about hell being quite
as warm as I found the atmosphere un-
der that engine. I think I would have
perished in my attempts to corral the
thing were it not for the cheering en-
couragement that was passed in from the
outside. His engineership would say,
"put the bar right in there, Jimmy, now
pry up a little, now be careful, you'll
have her this time," then, by way of
sympathy, he would do a little grunting
for me. I might here add that the
thing was not a bed of roses for his
"boss-ship;" his endeavors to keep in
CALEDONIAN TEN-WHEELER.
nary Howe link motion through a rock-
ing shaft. The boiler barrel is 17
ft., and the fire-box 8 ft. 6 in. in length.
The total heating surface being 2,400
sq. ft., this latter could easily have
been exceeded, but Mr. Mcintosh has
used flues of a large diameter for the
lower rows, where there is a liability of
choking. The working pressure is 200
lbs. per sq, in,, and 4 spring safety valves
are provided, inclosed in the circular cas-
ing above the fire-box. The weight of
the engine in working order, as shown,
is 165,800 pounds, or greater than that of
the average British goods engine and
tender combined. The tender, which
runs on two four-wheeled trucks, carries
6 tons (2,240 lbs. per ton) of coal and
5.000 imp. gallons of water. At present
these are the largest locomotives work-
ing in the British Isles, and their per-
very close under the "Hinckley" for him-
self and his excess, and he said, "Jimmy"
(he always called me Jimmy), "jump
under the 'old gal' and see if you can
put that eccentric back where it be-
longs." Being anxious to learn, and at
the same time please the "boss," I was
soon trying to do business. Unfortu-
nately for me, however, I found the
"ear marks" on eccentrics and axle were
in a position that made it necessary for
me to roll that go-ahead valve crank to
top of axle to get it in position. My
knowledge of valve motion at that time
was very limited, I knew as little about
the functions of an eccentric then as I
do now of Purgatory. It was necessary
for the "plug puller" (inasmuch as he
could not get under) to be where he
could direct my movements from the
outside. Well, I guess I must have got
position to direct my movements, taken
in conjunction with the torrid condition
of the atmosphere, was a combination
that caused him to perspire quite freely,
and even made breathing a task some-
what laborious.
I finally conquered, and, upon my ad-
vent from underneath "the old gal," I
recollect that my mate in distress said,
"I guess we've got her at last, Jimmy,"
and I had just strength enough left to
say, "hope to God we have." I got my
"thinker" to work after I was back on
the engine, and I asked myself ^-hy could
we not have moved the engine one-half
turn of the driving wheels? What was to
prevent engine backing up far enough to
bring marks on axle and back-up eccen-
tric to the mark on its unruly mate?
Then I went out in gangway and
jammed my "dome of thought" up
254
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
times, and wondered who I had ^ ^^^ ^^^^^
ask to kick me. .
In looking over the different authori-
ties on best manner of setting slipped
eccentrics, I find that placing on front
center is advised for setting go-ahead
eccentric, and I cannot believe that
earn shows at ^^^^^'l^Z^^uT'st.rn never dread the exami,.at.on for promo-
Why I adv..se moymg the valve s em ^^^ ^^^ ^^^.^^^ ^^^
m.
,.s „. where live distance is measured
on valve stem is, that the standard used
about the country (or outside lap is
seven-eighths of an inch, and at this writ-
ing the majority of iocomolive builders
advise line and line, or n= lead for full
parties who so instruct ever had my ex- ^^^^^j ^j ^^j^^^ f^r freight t^rvice.
perience with one of those refractory
necessities that could move freely on
the driving shaft.
One of the first things for a locomotive
man to learn is, that in all indirect mo-
tion engines the eccentric follows the
pin nearly one-fourth of a turn back,
and such being the case when mam pin
is on back center, eccentric for the go-
ahead motion on that side will have cam
on lower side of axle, and there is where
you will find it every time should it get
loose while in service, and consequently
the proper place to put an engine for trie
setting of a go-ahead eccentric is on back
center; if you cannot move engine ahead
tion. Time is about all the capital^ the
most of us have, and why not use it to
the best advantage?
If you are not a subscriber to Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering
subscribe at once, and never let your
subscription run out.
Pat the Rounder.
(The writer of the above letter, who
is a general foreman of important shops,
raised himself from the fireman's scoop
to the position he now occupies by the
means which he advises others to adopt.
Railroad men have got a ucuc. v...-..— ^^j^ present position is a rung on the
to read and improve themselves than j^^^^ ^^^^j^ ^^ ^jn ^ge to reach the
any other class of men, and could be the t^p._i7jj j
best educated class of laboring men, if ^
they would try. I have reference to the
men in road service. •
Make the above assertion to some
man and what would be his reply? He
would say that I have not had time to
J. W. Keading.
Manistee, Mieh., April 22, 1903.
Read and Improve Yourselves.
Railroad men have got a better chance
What Is Ue Matter with the Valves ?
I am runr.ng a geared locomotive
equipped with t.,= common D slide valve
with Yi in. steam =,p exhaust line to line
would say tna: i ud.vc n^i. •■"- witn ft, m. =i.tai" =.p exnausi
read the paper for two weeks. He^ will j -^^ j^^jj ^nd '4 n travel. When the
relate he is so many days ahead of the ^j^gjj^g jj standing stil-and not on either
the re-
to get main pin on back center, back ^^^^j^ ^nd has made so many hours
her up. overtime, and ask when have I got any
Every locomotive man should make a ^^^^ jo read a book or magazine,
study of the relative position of the ec- jhen reason his case and see il ne
centrics to the main pin. Were it not ^in ever have any time to read, ine
for lap and lead the back-up and go- ^^iter will use his own methods tnat
ahead eccentrics would stand at exactly he borrowed from a friend in his rounds
right angles to the main pin, that is, when ^hich are as follows: Make an uie
engine was on back center the back-
up cam would point straight up and the
go-ahead cam straight down. With en-
gine on back center and web of eccen-
tric pointing direct towards the earth, the
valve is in the center of its travel, and
eccentric must be moved toward the pin
or fire box far enough to overcome the
outside lap and lead (where lead is used).
The best rule for setting a go-ahead ec-
centric is, put engine on back center and
if web of eccentric is not already point
tim- you can without injury to yourself,
work while your engine is out of shop,
take the necessary rest in preference to
reading; but the time comes to us all
when business will be slack or our en-
gine will be shopped for a few days, then
catch up with your reading.
How do we pass away our time when
our engines are in the shop?
The following is usually the way.
After breakfast go to the shop, stay
until YOU tire of that place, then drop
dead center, by slowlj movin
verse lever I can stop . so steam will
slowly come out of both yiinder cocks.
The valve looks as smooh as it ever
did and the seat is also jus ^g smooth;
can any brother engineer tel j^g why it
is, what harm it will do, a.^ how to
stop it? ■ T. G.
(The valves and seat need facing.—
Ed.)
f web of eccentric is not aireauy p^i.-..- uau.. .,w,. .-- -
ng straight down, place it so it will, put into tl-_ b- -"f P' ' ' ^ .^^.f '^^
reverse lever in forward notch, make a
mark on valve stem Ys in. from stuff-
ing box, then move eccentric toward
main pin until the mark comes flush with
the gland, tighten cam and proceed
and of course, there are other places you
can go to on the sly and while away a
few hours. You go to those places
with practically no intent at all.
That is eenerally the round every day,
Stic. reV„L':::" rpS '" " :"«; b..», « .. ,«. .. .,,.,.. _ , __
:e„„i. .. U wm pcin. s„.i.h. down ,0^ ^Z ^^t «" »n,>. .o. «« «■»-'", J- r:,,'", S I E
Wants to Be an Oil Han.
The oil question and the footbal gjjjjg
are somewhat alike and I think ^hey
started about the same time. I don „„.
derstand all of the technical points t the
ball game. One takes the ball and-ynj
until he falls and all pile on top of ;„,.
That is the way the oil question sta^^j
Some one saw that there was plMtj^f
room for economy on that one pomt,,^,
everybody fell on it. I wish some ^^
would conceive a new game that would ..
cupy their attention until we could get u
figures set back a little on our oil supp.
The writer holds a position in which
becomes one of his fundamental duties I
distribute that precious fluid where fri<
tion exists, and it has caused him a lot c
xtra tnougiiL j^^'- •— ■■ —
nake it go around, but I claim to b
mark on valve stem close to stumng Dox nre....... "^ ,-. . .,^ to read at profited by it. I^ has caused me to stud
and then move cam toward main pin suits y°- -°° ^ fhk Jt.'bJi^uUivate friction and observe what _could be d_on
and then move cam Luwa.u ...c^." t-" -- - ... •
or links until you have moved mark away times you don t fejl
from the gland % in.
Another way would be to place engine
on back center, and if eccentric was not
already on under side of axle, place it
there; then, with lever in front notch
and throttle slightly open, move eccen-
tric towards main pin or fire box until
steam shows at the back cylinder cock.
For back-up motion, place engine on
front center, cam down, lever in back
notch, throttle slightly open, move ec-
d taste for reading.
Doctors, lawyers, merchants and every
other man subscribes for the best
journals and books that will give them
he best insight to their business to meet you
with a given amount of lubricant, pro
vided you don't have a hot pin.
Just imagine what kind of a loot
and answer the M. M. would giv.
if you would go in and brace
valve oil ir
uic ut:,.. ..wo-- - - , , Ljjjj fQ]. a pint of extra
their rivals that are in the same held. presence of the oil man, innocent o'
What other business are there any ^he prese ^^^^ ^^^^^ ^^^.^ ^^^
„.ore rivalry and competition m than the who the lat te ^_^ ^^^^ ^^^^^^ ^^,
railroad business at the present age? you got ' jf. ^ut wouldn't y,
Don't stick to that old conservative idea question tc. you seU ^^.^,^ .^ ^.^^ ^^^^
and wait lor experience.
June, 190,^.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
255
free transportation all over the country
and your expenses paid at the best hotel
just to tell the M. M.'s what en-
gineers should do with the few drops of
oil they get? My goal in life at present
is to be the oil man. I can imagine myself
telling the M. M.'s what I used to do. I
would forget about bad water, engines
foaming and poor lubricators. I would
have my pockets full of tables and data
showing what had been done and would
have my little song to back it up, and
would be able to make the engineer that
had used a few more pints than the* al-
lowance, feel like a criminal. We want a
little more margin, or the writer wants to
be the oil man. Foreman,
of mine from Chicago gave the follow-
ing solution: "You were kicked on the
head by a mule when you were a small
boy, which left you laboring under the
delusion that ice could be frozen on a
red hot stovfe." I would like to hear
from others on the subject.
W. B. Chenoweth-
[We do not care to publish anything
more on this subject. — Ed.]
Temperature of Fire Box Sheets.
I have read with interest the several
answers to my question in the January
number in regard to low temperature
of firebo.x sheets in boilers. Mr. Allen
S. Weeks, of Boston, quotes Tyndall's
"Heat as a Mode of Motion." I fail to
see where this firebox condition is ex-
plained in Tyndall's. I have passed my
hand over intensely hot pieces of iron
and also passed my finger through mol-
ten metal, but in this case the moisture
that is in the hand will create sufficient
pressure to force the metal away from
the flesh. But this will not hold good
in the case of a boiler or firebox, be-
cause you cannot hold your hand on the
outside of a boiler for an instant with-
out being burned. Mr. Weeks seems to
think I would get burned if I should hold
my hand on the sheet long enough. In
this he is correct, because the hand at-
tracts the heat to that spot. I have
taken an air jet and placed it against
the sheet for a few seconds and then re-
moved it and placed my hand on the
spot and found it to be very hot. In
reference to the teakettle problem, yon
can hold the kettle on your hand until
the water stops boiling, then it becomes
hot instantly.
I don't think that the vapor from the
hand is a solution, because the outside of
the firebox will burn one's hand in-
stantly and the inside won't as long as
there is a hot fire in the firebox. When
the fire is knocked out and cold air ad-
mitted the sheets become hot. I am of
the opinion that a large per cent, of the
leaks and cracks in fireboxes are caused
by using the blower strong while knock-
ing the fire out of them.
Mr. E. W. Gregory, of Hofifmanville,
Md., explains it from the soot stand-
point. Soot being a non-conductor of
heat will protect the hand, but I have
also tested that argument by washing
a vessel clean on the bottom. I have
also tested it in the firebox by cleaning
off the sheet before placing my hand on
it. The sheet is cool just the same. I
have had several solutions sent to me
through the mail. A mechanical friend
Friction.
A great many theories are advanced
and received as facts simply on the
strength of the reputation of their ad-
vocates, as the interests of some might
be afTected. Hence, it is often many years
before the character of either is estab-
lished. For instance, at a time long ago,
it was said the moon was made of green
cheese. At this time not many believe
it. Gallileo proclaimed the rotundity and
rotation of the earth. The Church, and
wise men in her interests, denied it. Not
iiviVi
tact, and not by the amount of surface
bearing," and, to this day, notwith-
standing the daily evidence to the con-
trary, scarcely anyone has the hardihood
to contradict the general's theory. And
some there are who yet maintain its cor-
rectness. (Not many, however. — Ed.)
With the pulleys in use on shipboard
previous to 1840, it required the full crew
to hoist a topsail; and the whole watch
to shut home the dew. About the years
mentioned, a "friction pulley" was in-
troduced into the Navy. It had steel
rollers of small size between the pin
and bushing of the sheave. With this
pulley the watch on deck could hoist the
topsails, and the quarter watch could
shut home the topsail clews.
In 1847, Norris, of Philadelphia, built
for the Reading Railroad a lO-wheel en-
gine. She was a slipper, and on a "bad"
rail was of no use with a full train.
When James Millholland became the
master mechanic of the P. & R., he took
CALIFORNIA FARM HOISE. ON SOUTHERN TACIFIC ROITE.
many now in the civilized world have
any doubts of old Gall's theory. One of
the King Georges of England asked his
savants why the addition of a live fish
to a vase of water would not increase
the weight of the whole? One by one,
they took up the question, and gave
scientific reasons for the phenomenon.
One of them. Sir Christopher Wren,
asked if his Majesty was sure such was
a fact. "No!" replied the king, "I know
nothing about it." It was not a fact.
Thus it is, some one of reputed knowl-
edge on certain lines advances an idea,
and it is endorsed without a question;
until, like a soap bubble, it bursts from
its own overgrowth.
.\bout 1830, a French mechanical en-
gineer, named General Morin, made the
assertion that "friction was governed en-
tirely by the weight of the matter in con-
out the leading pair of drivers, hoping,
by having the weight (nearly) of the
three pairs of wheels on the two remam-
ing pairs, the traction of the engine
would be improved by reason of the
wheels biting deeper into the rail, .\fter
the change she would not pull a half
train.
Mr. Millholland, later on, built some
engines to drill around the yards and
wharves. Many of them were alike in
cylinder, size of wheel and weight, but
some had six wheels and some only four
wheels connected (all tank engines.) The
six-wheelers would handle 30 per cent,
more cars than the four-wheelers.
In 1884 I had an ii-ton, narrow-
gauge engine on a branch running from
Timberline, on the Northern Pacific
Railroad, just west of the Bozeman Tun-
nel, to coal mines. The iron was 28 lbs..
256
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
and I could hardly haul ten empties up
the grade on account of slipping. Iron
was changed to 70 lbs., taken out of the
N. P. track, and engine wouldn't slip a
turn with 18 to 20 empties.
The Manhattan Elevated Railroad laid
their middle track on Third avenue with
iron taken out ol main line. It was good
enough to Store cars on. Much of this
iron had been worn out on the curves
of the road, and was cut away to the
"web;" full half the head was gone.
Unfortunately, some of this iron was laid
between 89th and 98th streets. When
the expresses were put on, somewhere
in 1889, they took the middle track at
98th street; as soon as the engine came
on this half-head rail, she flew up and
stalled. This kept up until full-sized
iron was laid, and there was no more
stalling from slipping.
When the Ninth avenue tracks were
relaid in a couple of days with 90-lb.
iron, the engines could not haul their
trains. The tire had worn to fit the
smaller rail taken out, and only touched
the edges of the head of the larger rail.
The weight was then all the same, but
there was not the surface contact as on
the old rail.
I'll close by merely referring to the
ball-bearing axle boxes now in use on
nearly everything on wheels outside of
steam railroads. E. J. Rauch.
EJectricity on Surface Railways.
I see in the current number of your
paper some reference to electrification
of railways in England. In addition to
the cases mentioned, I may say that the
Lancashire & Yorkshire are now elec-
trifying the road between Liverpool and
Southport, a distance of 24 miles (ceica).
The current is to be supplied at 250
volts, and the system is the third rail
center conductor. Experiments were
carried out at the works at Horwich.
The North Eastern are also to electrify
a road of 31 miles near Newcastle.
Trusting this additional information
will prove acceptable, I can guarantee
its accuracy.
H. Stathain.
Stratford, Out.
Why Foreign Locomotives May Be
More Efficient Than Ours.
The article in April number of Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering
comparing the performance of American
and foreign locomotives, suggests some
points that are worthy of attention in
our present locomotives, particularly so
as regards smoke-box arrangement and
lieating surface, represented in long
flues. The former is already receiving
some attention, as the large stacks now
being used on some of the wide fire-bo,x
engines will testify. As we become bet-
ter acquainted with the subject, we find
that it is necessary to allow the un-
consumed gases to escape from the front
end freely, otherwise they act as an ob-
struction to the gases passing from the
fire-box into and through the tubes; and
the result is incomplete combustion in
the fire-box. If we take an ordinary
kerosene lamp that is burning brightly
and giving olif no smoke, and suddenly
place an obstruction over the outlet of
the chimney, in noting the result we
find that the current of air in passing
up through the chimney, which is being
robbed of its oxygen by the process of
combustion, is suddenly stopped, and as
the supply of air is limited, its oxygen is
uniting with the carbon in insufficient
quantities, producing inferior combus-
tion. We will notice the lamp is smok-
ing badly and burning with a dull, red
flame, and it illustrates what is taking
place in the fire-box of a locomotive
whose front end is obstructed by dia-
phragm plates, fine netting, small stack,
etc. It is needless to say that dense
black smoke will be seen issuing from
the stack and that under such conditions
the engine is wasting fuel.
As to the long flues, we might say
that a long boiler presents advantages
such as a better equalization of weight,
etc., and who will say this is not an ad-
vantage with some of the very heavy
engines now being used? While we
know that the heating surface in the for-
ward part of long tubes is heating sur-
face just the same, it is not entitled to
the same consideration as that of the
back part, which is in contact with the
intense. heat being generated in the fire-
bo.K. As the heat in passing through
the thin flues is being rapidly absorbed
by the water in the boiler,- it is very
nearly used up by the time it reaches the
forward end of a 16-foot tube. It would
hardly seem fair to compare the heating
surface of our long boilers with those of
foreign build which are as a rule much
shorter. It would seem that the con-
ditions and requirements in our rail-
road service had placed the American
designer in rather a bad light in this re-
spect. There is one point I wish to
speak of that bears heavily upon the
question of boiler efficiency. It is the
conditions existing at the fire-box end
of the boiler. While I am not familiar
with the methods of the foreign builders
in regard to it, I am inclined to think
they give considerable attention to the
admission of air through and over the
fire. In order to obtain combustion in
the desired form in the locomotive fire-
box, it is just as essential to have the
facilities for admitting the proper amount
of air to the fire as it is to have the
smoke-box free from obstruction.
Again, taking the kerosene lamp for
an illustration, and this time obstructing
the bottom opening of the chimney, we
find about the same conditions as before,
that of the lamp smoking badly, due to
an insufficient supply of oxygen, and il-
lustrates what takes place in the fire-
box when not enough air is admitted
to the fire. We will then also notice as
before that black smoke is issuing from
the stack. Now, let us again return to
our lamp, but this time remove the chim-
ney entirely. We also find combustion
is incomplete, but this time it is of a dif-
ferent nature. Air being admitted to the
flame in such large quantities the proc-
ess of combustion cannot take all the
oxygen offered, with the result that the
gases are cooled down below the igniting
point and pass of unconsumed to a great
extent in an invisible form. Here is an
illustration of what is taking place in
the fire-box when too much air is being
admitted, either through the grates or
above the fire. As when the grate is
only partly covered or the furnace door
is left open long enough to supply large
quantities of fuel at one firing. In this
case the loss does not appear in the form
of dense black smoke issuing from the
stack, but is more like slightly discol-
ored steam, a greater portion of it being
invisible as the unconsumed gases pass
out with the exhaust. While we know
that complete combustion cannot be ex-
pected in the locomotive fire-box, we
also know that a general knowledge of
the process of combustion when properly
applied has much to do with the effi-
ciency of our locomotives.
Possibly our Foreign Brothers have,
in designing their locomotives, given
more attention to this particular subject
than has been the custom with American
locomotives of late. It has been my ex-
perience to observe many modern loco-
motives that were not only deficient in
the means of regulating the supply of air
above and below the grate, but their
grates, shaker-bars, ash-pan, etc., were
such that it was a difficult matter to
maintain a clean fire while on the road.
It is also possible that more attention
is given this important subject by' the
foreign operatives, and I am inclined to
think the latter has much to do with the
excellent performance of foreign locomo-
tives.
There was a time, however, when we
had engines in this country with limited
heating surface and many other disad-
vantages when compared with our en-
gines of to-day. I well remember one
that I fired in 1886. It was part English,
built by Wilson Eddy, with cylinders
19x26 in., and weighed about 35 tons.
What the heating surface was I do not
know, but I do know the fire-box was
so small that a dozen scoops of coal
would fill it about full, and that the en-
gine was over-cylindered. Yet, v/hen
the rail was good, this engine did ex-
cellent work, as did all the others of
its class, and steamed well also. Why
was it? Simply because the men. par-
ticularly the fireman, displayed more
skill in the performance of their duties
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
»57
tliaii at present. While in those days the
fireman was not expected to pass ex-
aminations on combustion, and he knew
but little about the subject, but he made
good use of what he did know. And in
his crude way he knew how much air
was required to make the hottest fire,
and when and how to admit it to the
fire-box to get the best results. If he
did not give close attention to the use
of ash-pan dampers, keep the flues
clean and grate and ash-pan clear of
ashes and feed the fire very deli-
cately, he could not get the steam; and
if he did not get it the engineer would
not have him on the engine. I can just
imagine the result if we wore to place the
average American fireman of to-day on
such an engine as that.
W. A. BUCKBEE.
Rensselaer, N. Y.
Conditions on the Air Line.
BY A. SUP LYMAN.
Fourth Paper.
At 8.30 next morning the local ofTi-
cials of the Air Line, including Thomas
Barker, master mechanic; Tom Williams,
superintendent; Graham, the trainmas-
ter, together with Turner, ex-supply man
once, now grief specialist, met the man-
ager of the road in his car, the 300.
Nine was the hour set by John Stew-
art for this meeting, but the night's hap-
penings, as told by the wires, seemed to
have moved all alike toward the place of
meeting, where the situation, the sub-
ject of discussion the evening before,
was to be gone over more fully.
Two serious wrecks with the loss of
three lives was the cause for the well-
defined look of care and worry that
marked every face except that of John
Stewart. That veteran was rapidly ex-
amining a pile of matter that lay on his
desk, pausing only to dictate a few brief,
terse sentences to his assistant, and in
a moment he rose, closed his desk, and
with a word of dismissal to his clerk,
he offered his hand and a quiet word of
greeting to his subordinates. The look
of mobility that the manager habitually
wore, and which was well described by
Smyser, who ran the 37 on the Meteor,
when he said. "The old man has a face
like a poker player. You can't ever tell
what he is thinking about," gave no in-
dication of concern at the loss of three
engines, twelve cars and, their lading.
This was the outward show. Inwardly
the property loss had no effect, but loss
of life with its resultant effects, widows,
fatherless babes, the pitiless questioning
of the Coroner's inquest, had a numbing
effect, which ef late oft recurring he had
learned to dread. After a serious acci-
dent the "old man" usually took an hour
to himself. With a half consumed cigar
in his mouth, the ashes whitening his
vest, he leaned back in his chair and
thought; perhaps thoughts turned to
dreams.
The old days came back — when his
future was before him — he was running
an engine on the Southern then — his first
trip was with the wrecker, warm-hearted
and sensitive, the sudden screaming of
the shop whistle, that pitiless wail that
shrieked out the wrecking crew's "call to
arms" and brought half a hundred dis-
tracted wives and mothers, red-eyed and
sobbing, down to the little office where
the despatchers worked, cut into John
Stewart's soul. But while his heart bled,
no man ever got engine ready quicker,
and absorbing the contents of a dozen
complicated orders faster than the eye
could read the words he was off.
After thirty years the memory of those
wild rushes was yet fresh. The hasty
summing up of the disaster — the dis-
mantled engines, tangled cars, and then
the quick, sharp word of command from
Hickey, that past grand of wreckers.
Why shouldn't he be? He was at it all
the time. Then came the tiresome slack-
ing, now ahead, now back, the pile of
debris in the cut gradually growing less,
and then the awe inspiring cessation of
work while hands that were rough and
calloused lifted with the tenderness of a
girl the remains of a poor unfortunate,
laying them down where the glare of the
bonfire began to lose itself in the dark-
ness, while the nervous boy operator,
his relay box sheltered by a screen of
car doors, clicked off "Burns, brake-
man, found; body badly mangled;" and
the response "I I, send body on four's
transfer," came back. The "pinks" that
the message boy brought to car 300 at
four that morning had kept the "old
man" smoking and dreaming in his chair
until Sam had called him to breakfast for
the third time. At 8.30 he was the keen
man of business, the manager of the Air
Line, and when the party was settled he
looked over toward the supply man and
said, "Mr. Turner, how do you account
for the mistakes that some of our men
make? Our best men seem daft. They
are daily getting into scrapes that can-
not be reconciled with sanity. They for-
get schedule trains, meeting points, mis-
read time orders, even forget to flag fol-
lowing trains when stopped between sta-
tions, as was the case last night when
Second-Thirty-Two struck the first sec-
tion between Midland and Lawrence —
two stock men and one Hreman killed.
We did not suffer these things a few
years ago."
"Oh! they came in with prosperity,
pooling, per diem battleships and the
other improvements," replied the sup-
ply man. "Accidents they are called —
nice name that. Given on the principle
doctors give a Latin name to death from
plain drunkenness — sounds nicer to the
relatives. Of course we will always
have accidents; the human element will
provide for that; even good families
have had hangings. Men will forget,
but to my way of thinking your numer-
ous accidents of late can be charged to
two causes — that is, the most of them —
overloading the man and lack of educa-
tion. In regard to the first cause, all
men, like a gallon jug, have their limita-
tions; fill it full of tonnage, long hours,
doubles, add a hot driving box, leaky
flues and a couple of asthmatic squirts
for good measure, and the jug overflows.
That's where the Coroner gets in his
fees. Don't fill the jug too full. As to
the second cause, lack of education is
one of the weakest points in our whole
railroad fabric.
"The call boys pick the new material
lor firemen and brakemen, and from the
day he first goes out as a student he i>
left to shift for himself. None too much
capital to start with, and that unde-
veloped, until some day the seniority
list puts him 'first out' on local. Look
at the copies of accident reports men
make. Why their applications in this
day of little red school houses on every
corner should cut them out. But it
don't, and their first lesson is in the line
of shirking.
"There is where a good, wideawake
traveling fireman would win gold for
you. I mean one whose head is not
cramped trying to hold in what he thinks.
Corrigan, who is possibly your best
engineer, 'don't know.' Corrigan can
take care of things alone fairly well,
breaking in a student fireman in the
proper way is less inspiring, perhaps
more perspiring work, but it pays, quick-
ly, too.
"Instead of the traveling fireman tak-
ing the new beginner in tow the 'old
head' who is always looking for a snap
takes him in charge. The 'old head' un-
loads on him and he begins to think thit
the science of railroading lies in unload-
ing, and as they grow older they find
that some of the officials have Bachelor
degrees in the art. Then the sanctity
that should surround train orders and
train movements is never impressed on
them. I tell you, Mr. Stewart, and gen-
tlemen, the man who can see hospital
beds, widows, orphans, tears and pov-
erty back of "chance taking" and care-
lessness, will seldom make a mistake. He
is the kind of man that wants the work
done on his engine, wants good pay and
is outspoken, but he is nearly always
reasonable and he generally delivers the
goods. There's the M. & L., they took
up the Brown system at request of en-
gineers' committee. Their superinten-
dent was an enthusiast, promised to
make it go, would supervise all bulletins
and make every case educative. Well, he
forgot his promises or was too busy to
look into things, and now a fellow who
parts his hair in the middle and buys his
collars in pairs does the act.
258
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 190,3.
"Accidents of all kinds look alike to
him, so do the men. He deals out fit-
teen, twenty or forty-five, just as the
ratchet drops on each case, without
cause or comment. Then he tosses in
a few 'days' for good measure. The
men are beginning to think that their
committee buncoed them. Men, like
engines, must be divided into families,
and the right kind of parents seated at
the head of the table, and then family
talks, yes, even prayers indulged in. li
you will draw the line at each freight
division terminal, give each family their
own engines, their own trainmaster and
traveling engineer, a friendly rivalry be-
tween families will soon spring up, and
u' you have a good man at the head of
each department to hold things even you
will see some changes.
"You have the State officers, good
ones too, but Grayham, Casey and
Smith are the only township heads you
have, and they cannot touch things. One
thing sadly needed is a reorganization
of your examination system. As it is
handled now it is a farce.
"Your examiner is taken from his
regular line and brought face to face
with thirty or forty firemen at one clip,
all of whom you need so badly that he
cannot afford to refuse to pass anything
but the very worst. Men are like chil-
dren on the school question. They pass
up the educational question until they
are 'next,' then they rush around and
find Congor, buy Railway and Locomo-
tive Engineering, glance at a couple of
copies and brace the examiner. They
don't fail, because you can't afTord
to let them, but how they dec-
orate the hard luck sheet for the
first couple of years while learning
the business is a caution. What you
want is a semi-annual progressive ex-
amination covering three years. Lead
them up by stages; in that way men
will learn something every day and
call you blessed for forcing a good thing
on them. Have it understood that on
the first six months' service and study
will depend the matter of the student's
remaining in your employ. Make it a
condition of entering your service that
this period is purely a probationary one;
the brotherhoods will indorse that, it in-
sures them good material. Did it ever
occur to you on that line that the offi-
cials are the men who handle the ballot
box in all the railroad brotherhoods?
Thry have to take what you give them "
The supply man had the floor with a
vengeance. Involuntarily leaving his
chair he had moved forward and was
leaning over the general manager's desk,
the unlit havana littering the old man's
Wilton carpet.
"Unfortunately this organization costs,"
the general manager remarked, "and
we have our limitations. The men
have asked for a revision of their con-
tracts next month, and that means they
want more pay. I suppose we will have
to give them something, too, and if we
were to add an extra official organiza-
tion on top of that I am afraid our Bos-
ton people would kick."
"I have talked to your best men on
that question," replied the supply man.
"What the men on the Air Line want is
a job. Do you know the improper dis-
tribution of men and power is close to
the wage question? Men who are busy
seldom think of a 10 per cent, raise, it is
the fellow with a $140 job who draws $30
or $60 that keeps the pay question up in
the air. Summing this thing up, Mr.
Stewart, an organization is what wc
want. We will always be short until xve
i-et one. It is possible that dividing the
engines on a class basis with the view of
maintaining supplies and making run-
ning repairs is of as much importance to
the company as is that of Casey's putting
a black eye on my friend Grayham's ton-
nage performance — general results should
be kept sight of."
As the supply man took his seat the
general manager rose, saying, "Gentle-
men, I meet the State Board at 11. I
think we will have to organize on the
lines Mr. Turner suggests." Turning to
Mr. Barker he said: "Don't let go of
the young man, Tom; figure out what
place you want him in and we will talk
tilings over later."
As the party left the depot, going
toward the hotel, the supply man turned
to his old friend and said: "Where does
'.he best squirt on earth come in. I came
down here to sell a few, and instead I
find myself the president of a revolu-
tion."
" I'll Save This Train."
"What sad and stormy times we some-
times see when out upon the road." re-
marked the engineer; "and none of us,
not one, knows what moment may be
our last. I myself have been lucky, for
I've never been in but one accident, the
one where Engine No. 1319 went
through Swan Creek bridge. Old John
W. Bruce was engineer the time of the
Swan Creek wreck, and I was firing for
him.
He was a queer old boy, much given
to religion after his little girl died, and
although all the boys thought well of
old John, they often used to chaff him
on this subject. He wasn't much of a
talker when on duty, but the night of
the accident we were running the Sun-
set Limited, and he turned to me, this
side of Swan Creek, and said:
"George, I suppose the boys don't
mean anything when they make re-
marks about my religion, but they hurt
my feelings more than they have any idea
of. I never took much stock or interest
in religion before my little girl died.
"One night." he continued, "at home,
I was sitting by her bedside, looking at
her lying so quiet and still, and some-
how I broke down and began to cry like
a little baby. Well, she just rose straight
up in bed, and putting her arms around
my neck, said, 'Don't cry, papa, . I am
going away, I know, but I'm going up
to Heaven, and some time you'll come
up there to live, too, won't you, papa?'
"I say, George, I made up my mind
then and there that if trying would do
it, I'd try."
Here John blew the whistle for the
curve. As he looked ahead I saw him
give a start, and glancing through the
front window I saw a sight that took
away my breath. The trestle over Swan
Creek, only a few hundred yards away,
was on fire. In an instant I sprang for
the gangway, and reaching it turned to
see if John were following me.
"Jump! jump for your life!" he shouted
as he saw me pause. "And you?" I
asked. "My place is right here in the
cab," he replied. "I'll save this train if
1 lose my life in attempting it!"
I waited for no more, but gave one
good leap that landed me in a swamp
below. I had hardiy come to my senses
and got my footing when I heard a crash
and saw the engine go through the tres-
tle, leaving the tender hanging upon the
edge of the break. John Bruce had
been, true to his word. He had saved
the train, though it cost him his life, for
when we picked him up from the wreck-
age he was dead. It takes courage and
nerve to face death like poor John did,
for the sake of saving the lives of others.
Somehow I can't help thinking that
John Bruce must have met his little girl
in Heaven. If he didn't it wasn't because
he failed to try.
WlLLI.\M F. Eberwein.
A new device to prevent a railroad
wreck is being tested by several of the
big railroad systems. It consists of an
electrical equipment, aoplied to the rails
and locomotives, designed to stop mov-
ing trains in a very short space. It is
claimed on behalf of the invention that it
automatically shuts off steam, releases
the air brake automatically, sounds an
alarm and lights a warning signal in the
locomotive cab, permits telegraphic com-
munication between trains and needs no
third rail. The invention is the work of
Pittsburg men.
The employees of the American Car
& Foundry Co. made trouble for their
employers some time ago because ma-
terial made by non-union men was em-
ployed in building cars. The company
agreed to unionize their shops and re-
duce the working hours to nine hours
a day. reducing the wages in propor-
tion. This has led to another strike, as
the men will not stand for a reduction in
wages.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
259
Inspection Car for the Rochester &
Pittsburg; Coal & Iron Company.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works have
recently supplied the Rochester & Pitts-
burg Coal and Iron Company with an
inspection car with small locomotive in-
side. The engine occupies the forward
part of the car and partitioned off it, is
a handsomely furnished passenger com-
partment, finished in green and gold,
with mahogany trimmings. The fur-
niture includes a mahogany desk with
revolving chair, a leather couch and half
a dozen wicker easy chairs upholstered
in green plush. Closets, washrooms and
lockers are conveniently located.
The cylinders of- the simple little en-
gine are 9x16 in., and the driving
wheels, of which there is only one pair,
are 54 hi. in diameter. 'l"hc leading
truck is of the rndiril type, .nid all ibe
l)artnicnt furnishes electricity for two
head lights, and sixteen incandescent
lamps in the passenger compartment.
Electric signal bells are provided, and a
solid door shuts off passengers from
engineer. The platforms are arranged
for observation purposes, having mov-
able step covers. The whole machine is
an example of a very completely ap-
pointed observation or inspection car.
preparations to build their own engines,
and now we learn th.".t the Chicago,
Rock Island & Pacific Railroad System
propose putting up locomotive building
works at Moline, III. We do not believe
that railroad companies can build their
own locomotives as cheaply as they can
buy them, but it is very likely that the
experiment will again be attempted.
riore Room for the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works are
badly crowded for want of room by
being in the middle of the city of Phila-
delphia. When a large building is put
up it is often necessary to close streets
permanently, and the politicians of the
city find the proposal to close a street
a verv good -^iihieet on which tn ven-
150 niles an Hour.
At Elizabeth, N. J., there is under con-
struction an electric car which, it is
stated, will make 150 miles an hour.
A Mr. Zimmerman, in the interest of
the Aurora, Elgin and Chicago Rail-
road, is now at Elizabeth supervising
the construction of the car, and he pre-
dicts that it is only a short time until
the twenty-hour Chicago train will b?
AN IDEAL INSPECTION CAR.
engine's wheels are equalized together,
with three springs in all, the center one
lying in a sort of box equalizer, com-
posed of two side plates with blocks
bolted in place to take the ends of the
springs. The cylinder is placed at the
fire-box end of the engine, and the dry
pipe therefore comes out of the back
sheet with tee-pipe above the fire door,
and one branch pipe running down in a
curve which just avoids the door. A
cross branch pipe supplies both steam
chests. The valves are the ordinary D
slide, and they are actuated by indirect
connection in the usual way.
The boiler is 40 in. in diameter, and
has 144 tubes, 5 ft. 6^-2 in. long, and the
total heating surface is 360 sq. ft. The
rigid wheel base is 6 ft. 2 in., while the
-wheel base of the whole car is 28 ft. 3 in.
The driving wheels carry a weight of
25,400 lbs., the engine truck carrying
23.200 lbs., while the car truck at the
back sustains 24,000 lbs., making a total
of 72,600 lbs. in all. A water tank hung
under the framing of the car holds 500
.gals.
A small dynamo in the engineer's com-
tilate their patriotic sympathies, and at
the same time reach out for a little
boodle if it can be drawn from the com-
pany to be benefited. Lately there has
been a struggle to close Taney street
in the interests of the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works, and they have at last suc-
ceeded. Mr. S. A. Vauclain, the vig-
orous general superintendent of the
works, says in connection with the clos-
ing of the street:
'We want the land to give .us room to
construct a suitable building in which to
take care of our locomotives preparatory
to shipment. The works this year will
turn out between $9,000,000 and $10,-
000,000 worth of locomotives. We have
35 per cent, of our army of workmen liv-
ing in the Fifteenth Ward, in wdiich the
works are situated, and I think the pro-
posed building will be an improvement
to the ward."
The difficulty in obtaining new loco-
motives on prompt delivery has excited
a feeling among railroad companies that
they ought to build their own engines.
The Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul
Railroad appear to be making genuine
considered commonplace beside these
new space-destroying cars.
The car, now almost finished, will be
equipped with four motors of 126 horse
power each. They are built of steel and
are equipped like Pulman vestibules. The
interior is finished lavishly in quartered
oak and rich hangings.
Atlis-Chalmers Company.
.■Mlis-Chalmers Company, Chicago,
desires to announce that after May
I, 1903, the general offices of the com-
pany will be located in the New York
Life Building, 14th floor, corner of La
Salle and Monroe streets.
A press dispatch to the New York
Times from Milwaukee says: The Allis-
Chalmers Company and the Christensen
Engineering Company have practically
decided to double the size of their great
works. A small estimate of the cost of
this expansion would place the figure
at nearly $300,000. The Allis-Chalmers
new works, which have just been com-
pleted, cost between $2,000,000 and $2.-
500,000. The work of the Christensen
Engineering Company cost $600,000.
j6o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Uati;f^Ei$ineerii$
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "l/ocengr," N. Y.
Glasgow, " Ijocauto."
Bnslness Department:
ANOXTS SINCI,AIR, President.
FRED M. NEI,I^IS, Vice President.
JAMBS R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCI/AIR, Editor.
F. M. NELI.IS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, } Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
■Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
I204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE I,OCOMOTIVE PUBI,ISHING
CO., I,td. 102a Charing Cro»s Rd., W.
C, l/ondon.
Glasgow Representative :
A. F. SINCI<AIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
f2,oofer yeary S1.00 for six months, postag^e paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of the world, fi.jo, or ten shillings.
Single copies, 20 cents. Remit by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Regittered
Utter.
Hailing address can be changed as of ten as neces-
sary— always give old and new address, and if you
suiscribedin a club state who got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly.
Entered at Post Office.New York, as Secosd-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Anffus Sinclair Co.. igo3.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
The Significance of Block Signals.
"During 1902 in Illinois there were
138 derailments at interlocking plants
due to trains running against signals."
These words occur in the printed pro-
ceedings of the Railway Signaling Club,
and were recently spoken by Mr. H. C.
Hope, of the Chicago, St. Paul, Minne-
apolis & Omaha Railway. He pointed
out that this statement gave food for
reflection, for he continued, "if trains
run against signals when derailment is
the penalty, we must infer that a much
larger number is run where there is no
penalty or detection except in case of
disaster." The speaker attempted to ac-
count for this state of affairs by asking
the question "may it not be that the en-
gineer who allows his engine to be de-
railed, does so through a certain care-
I lessness in his nature, developed by con-
tinued disregard of signals where there
is no penalty attached?"
If these statements are true, the in-
dictment lies pretty clearly at the door
of those who are responsible for the dis-
cipline of the road, because it may be
accepted as almost an axiom that on any
road where an important rule is habitu-
ally disregarded by the men, the officials
of the road are to blame. There is, how-
ever, an individual responsibility carried
by every man who passes a signal set at
danger which he cannot evade, and every
such passing of the outstretched danger
arm tends to produce an effect which
may one day recoil upon the head of the
man who is guilty of disobedience.
The block signal is essentially an "in-
formation giver." It conveys certain
definite information without causing any
uncertainty. It tells the enginemen of
the occupation or the non-occupation of
the track immediately in front of him.
If the company employed men at inter-
vals along the line, able to communicate
with each other, and if they furnished in-
formation concerning the road ahead by
word of mouth, in a yes and no form,
it would be in essence the same ihing.
The block signal is information given by
one who knows to one who does not
know. It is the guarantee by the com-
pany to the man on the engine that either
the line ahead is clear or that it is dan-
gerous to proceed.
Men who have run for years on a road
on which there are no block signals,
naturally acquire the belief that as the
track is continuous between stations, so
the right given to them by the time-table
or by train orders is, in a sense, the
right to make a continuous run. An
engineer on such a road, running a pas-
senger train, not timed to stop except at
important stations, expects everyone else
to keep out of his way, the road is his
for long stretches, and to stop him is a
grievous offense.
This general conception disappears
completely with the advent of the block
signal. The road is not his for long dis-
tances, but is his only for the short space
which constitutes the block which he has
legitimately entered. The capacity of
the road has been increased and other
trains are permitted to be closer on his
time with the increased protection now
afforded. His trip is not necessarily
made up of long reaches of unbroken
speed. He is now given surer rights
only over short distances. Formerly he
w^as a wholesale trader, now he is only
permitted to deal in retail bits of the
right of way. With the installation of
the block signal, the rules of the game
have changed.
One result of disregarding a stop sig-
nal is to substitute the "I think" of the
man for the "I know" of the signal. To
do that cheapens the value of the indi-
cation at once and introduces that ele-
ment of ambiguity in train or track
rights which is justly the horror of all
engineers. The reducing of the full
strength of the signal's meaning by suc-
cessfully disregarding it, goes on whether
detected or not or whether followed by
accident or not. The real danger point
about the whole thing lies in the fact that
there are always some men on the road
who will believe that the rule is abso-
lute where they themselves require pro-
tection— men who will assume that the
regulation has been faithfully observed
by others and will act accordingly. In
such cases when the rule has been dis-
obeyed, the man who is protectd by sig-
nal, and who is safe, by all the rules of
the road, may yet stand in very jeopardy
of his life. Nov/here is the power of ex-
ample more surely felt than in the be-
havior of men on railroads. The disre-
gard of signals by even a few men,
though not officially detected, produces
an effect which is wholly evil, and from
which, in time of emergency, there may
be no escape.
A story taken from Greek mythology,
briefly outlined here, telling of Actaeon.
the hunter, may serve to illustrate the
position of a man who having assisted
in developing a certain state of affairs
for his own satisfaction, may at length
fall a victim to the very forces he has
helped to call into being.
.(^ctaeon with his hounds roamed free
and far. He had brushed danger iside
many times. His fifty dogs, selected'
from the best stock, he had trained to
follow, and had hardened to endure by
long practice, and strong, indeed, and
fleet was the quarry that could escape.
One day Actaeon trespassed too far. and'
surprised Dianna and her nymphs bath-
ing in a river. The enraged goddess of
the chase changed him at once into a
stag, and he was pursued and torn to-
pieces by the very pack he had so care-
fully trained and had so successfully led.
The arguments and the pleas for what,
shorn of all specious covering, amounts
10 a desire for more than one meaning
to a danger indication, may be skilfully
put forward, and may be made to look
as if in the interest of the rapid handling
of traffic, however they may appear, or
however seemingly strong they may be,
these arguments are wrong and false in
principle. As Actaeon was pulled down
by his own dogs, so may a man who
has successfully passed danger signals
for years suddenly find himself in the
grip of circumstances where life itself
may depend upon the absolute integrity
of a rule which he has often set at de-
fiance, and which by his example he has
actually taught others to disregard. No
nian can reasonably hope to escape from
the legitimate consequences of his own
deliberate acts.
riore Men Needed on Locomotives.
.^n agitation is kept up in several of
the Eastern States in favor of putting an
extra man on each locomotive for the
purpose of watching signals, and there-
by preventing collisions. We think that
a third man is badly needed on many
locomotives, but his duties ought par-
ticularly to be that of assisting the fire-
man, whose work is becoming too heavy
for one man. On some railroads there
is already great difficulty experienced
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
361
in obtaining firemen lor some of the lo-
comotives now in use. The introduc-
tion of the new heavy engines is respon-
sible for the lack of men. The men are
re(iuired to shovel from twenty-five to
thirty-five tons of coal each way on the
division, so that on a full trip both ways
the average fireman shovels nearly sev-
enty tons of coal. The men come home
completely played out, and probably be-
fore they have had time to secure the
necessary amount of sleep they are
called out on the road again. This con-
tinual wear soon takes the ambition out
of a fireman and he quits. On one of
the roads in this city I know a young
fellow who is only 16, and imagine him
trying to fire one of those large engines.
The evil should be remedied by the
roads placing two firemen on each of
the big engines and that certainly is not
too much. Some of those large en-
gines would keep two men busy enough
to maintain the correct gauge of steam
during the entire run, and then the roads
would not have to suffer so much from
engines "lying down" on the trip. Un-
less the operating departments make
some general changes in this regard
they are likely to experience serious
trouble in replenishing the ranks of the
firemen, who cannot stand the pressure.
The Longest Tunnel in the World.
Readers of history are familiar w-ith the
name of the Simplon pass over the Alps
made famous as the route over which
armies were marched first by Hannibal
and two thousand years later by Napoleon.
It is the natural route between Switzer-
land and Italy, although railways have
chosen two other passes for their routes.
The Simplon will soon enjoy its natural
advantages for they are driving a tunnel
through the mountains under the pass
which will be fourteen miles long.
The United States Consul at Genoa
visited the place lately and writes : 'T
have recently made a visit to the Simplon,
in order to ascertain the character and
progress of this stupendous undertaking,
whose success or failure means so much
for the future of Genoa. Last March,
upon the authority of an American en-
gineer, I stated that such serious ob-
stacles had been encountered in the south
side of the tunnel that no progress was
being made, and that the location of the
line would probably have to be changed.
"My examination, on the spot, removed
all doubts on this score. The work is
progressing rapidly in the tunnel on both
sides of the Alps ; about 4, COD workmen
are employed in the tunnel and not less
than 6.000 on the Italian section of the
mad between Isella. at the mouth of the
tunnel, and Arona. the present terminus
of the railroad running north from IVIilan.
It is now practically certain that the road
will be completed within the estimated
time — that is to say. by July i. 1905 — as
nearly two-thirds of the tunnel was fin-
ished on July I, 1902, and the worst ob-
stacles have already been met and
mastered.
"The greatest of the impediments was
the ever-increasing heat in the tunnel.
1 lie volume of water flowing out of the
south end of the tunnel is over 15,000
gallons per minute, and furnishes motive
power sufficient not only to work the
refrigerating apparatus, but to comjiress
the air by which the drills are operated.
"This tunnel, when completed, will be
the largest in the world — to wit, 14 miles
long, or twice the length of the Mont
Cenis and five miles longer than the St.
Gotthard. The cost of the tunnel alone
will be 70,000,000 francs ($13,510,000), an
average of nearly $1,000,000 per mile."
Center Plates and Side Bearings.
There has been something of a con-
troversy among car men since the ar-
rival of the heavy cars concerning the
advisability of relieving the center plates
of a car of part of their load by trans-
fer of same to side bearings that shall
have a low frictional resistance; this
proposal being made with the view of
giving greater freedom of truck action
on curves, eliminating the danger to
wheel flanges and rail, and reducing train
resistance. The so-called frictionless
side bearing is said by its advocates to
be the correct solution of the weak
bolster question on old equipment, and
is also urged as the proper treatment
for cars yet to be built, making the
bolster problem an easy one for the tyro
to negotiate. From what has been said
and written about this simple solution of
a vexatious situation, it is gathered that
side bearings having rollers, or perchance
balls, are friction annihilators of such a
degree of efficiency as to force their way
into use against a prejudiced opposition.
Such bearings are correct in principle
and would admirably serve their pur-
pose in a side bearing, but there is a
large contingent who cannot be made to
?ee the need of such a device on bolsters,
they arguing that the intimate relation
existing between bolsters and side bear-
ings forbid any consideration of the lat-
ter without first taking proper cog-
nizance of the former. When this is
done it v.ill be noted that tens of thou-
sands of cars are running to-day with
bolsters so weak that side bearings are
in solid contact when car is light, and
tlie frictionless party would appear to
have the best of it. The wheels on those
cars are giving evidence anything but
mute, of the power required to move
them on curves. This result is certainly
ill consonance with a law of mechanics
which provides that a resistance acting
through a long lever arm requires more
force to overcome it than when acting
through a short lever arm, and is well
exemplified in the case under considera-
tion, where with center plates of aver-
age diameter and side bearings of the
usual distance between centers (50 to
60 inches) wc have, when side bearings
of the plain type are in contact, a re-
sistance to curving practically five times
as great as when side bearings arc clear;
since the wheel flange must absorb the
force necessary to overcome that resist-
ance, it is plain that it accomplishes that
function with disaster to itself and rail.
To correct this tendency to flange wear,
the frictionless side bearing is evolved
with its saving grace to the weak
bolsters, which stand as object lessons of
mechanical misfits, and thus bring them
to a condition of renewed usefulness at
a small financial outlay. The accuracy
o! reasoning of the sponsors of the fric-
tionless idea does not, however, appeal
to its opponents, since it is claimed by
them to have the appearance of an at-
tempt to get results with regard to the
prime need of the case, which is clearly
from the bolster man's standpoint, to
keep the side bearings apart, and intro-
duce the frictionless idea at the center
plates. There would be little advantage
in this construction if measures were
not taken to correct the weakness of
the bolster, and this, it is claimed, cannot
be done with cars now in service, for
the reason that sufficient room is not
available without redesigning bolsters
for both body and truck; such a move
would, of course, involve an expenditure
that would be prohibitive, hence the
plausibility of the frictionless side bear-
ing argument.
If it were not within the possibilities
of mechanics to make these old weak
bolsters hold up, then would the above
be accepted as something more than
makeshifts, but it has been slioivn that
any weak bolster may be strengtnened
most efficiently at a nominal cost, by the
use of truss rods, as wis done a few
years ago on the Chicago & Northwest-
ern Railway. When old bolsters are thus
stitfened and new ones properly designed.
the ball-bearing center plates leave little
to be desired in the way of reducing
truck resistance on curves.
The Master Car Builders' committee
on side bearings and center plates re-
ported a series of tests in 1902 that gave
most convincing data on the necessity
of reducing center-plate friction. That
portion of the report furnished by Mr.
L. H. Turner, superintendent of motive
power, of the Pittsburg & Lake Erie,
is given in part as one of the most valu-
able exhibits of the subject on record.
The car tested was equipped with the
Hartman ball-bearing center plates and
side bearings, and had been in service
three years, and was a comparative one
with the flat center plate and side bear-
ings. A dynamometer was used to de-
termine the resistance to overcome in
order to displace the truck two inches
262
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
.at the end or four inches in its length,
corresponding to a 154-degree curve.
FIRST TEST.
That center plate and side bearing,
with ^-inch deflection of body bolster
resting on side bearings:
Required to start truck 800 lbs.
Required to displace truck
two inches 1,100 lbs.
SECOND TEST.
Flat center plate, without side bear-,
ing:
Required to start truck 275 lbs.
Required to displace truck
two inches. 525 'bs.
THIRD TEST.
Hartman ball-bearing center plate and
side bearing, with ^-inch deflection of
body bolster resting on side bearing:
Required to start truck 75 'bs.
Required to displace truck
two inches 45° lt)S.
FOURTH TEST.
Hartman ball-bearing center plate
without side bearings:
Required to start truck 75 'bs.
Required to displace truck
two inches 325 'bs.
The above figures tell an eloquent
story of what may be accomplished by
reducing friction at the truck. The
wheels showed absolutely no flange wear
in three years of service, which fact in
itself would have been convincing evi-
dence that the center plates used met
all claims made for them, and the many
cars since equipped with them is their
endorsement. Mr. Turner advocated the
use of the roller side bearing for curves
of high outside rail elevation, but for
straight and level track the ball-bearing
center plate would meet all requirements
alone. The results of the fourth test
leave no room for doubt as to the advan-
tage to be had by carrying the load free
of side bearings.
To Make Something Out of Nothing.
A company has been organized and
incorporated with a capital of $5,000 for
the purpose of what the promoters call
a hydroilogen engine, which as usual, is
going to revolutionize the methods of
producing motive power. They promise
to greatly reduce the cost of power by
the peculiar way the engine is to use
the fuel. The public announcement de-
clares "that this has been accomplished
in the new engine by the use of low-
grade fuel or crude oil, preferably Texas
oil, water and air; gasifying the oil and
decomposing the water into hydrogen
by mechanically combining and mixing
them with air, heated to an intense de-
gree by
wasted in modern engines, and thereby
increasing the expansive efficiency of
the resultant gases of the elastic body."
That is rather a vague description of
what the promoters of this engine ex-
pect to do, but vagueness is a very good
attribute when they are trying to obtain
subscriptions to a stock company. That
thing of gasifying water to burn hy-
drogen is an old experiment, and has
been used to deceive, not a few times.
The people who advocate economy of
heat by a method of this kind take good
care to conceal the fact that the amount
of heat expended in converting water
into its original elements is more than
equal to the heat which will be repro-
duced from the operation. When the
General Hydroilogen Engine Co., organ-
ized under the laws of New Jersey, be-
gins inviting people to subscribe to the
stock, we advise our friends to keep
severely away from it.
If the principles of natural philosophy
were the popular study they ought to be,
it would be more difficult than it is for
promoters of what are really perpetual
motion schemes, to cheat people by
using senseless gibberage as a descrip-
tion of operations which they allege are
inventions or discoveries. Water is a
combination of oxygen and hydrogen,
and has the same relation to its elements
that the products of combustion have
to fuel. Water is the dead product of
two gases, which have great potential
power when separate. Hydrogen gas
makes, in combination with oxygen, the
hottest flame known to nature, and when
they combine together the product is
water, just as the product of the com-
bustion of carbon by combination with
oxygen is carbon monoxide or carbon
dioxide. The products are inert gases,
good for no useful purpose until worked
back through nature's laboratory into
wood and grass.
To give new vitality to water the
product of oxygen and hydrogen is an ex-
pensive operation. It requires the same
amount of heat to tear the combined
gases asunder that was produced by the
combination, and there is always loss in
carrying out chemical combinations.
When weighed deliberately, the Hydroil-
ogen Company propose to increase tfie
heat value of fuel by wasting part of the
heat produced in an endless chain
process.
Book Reviews.
Hardening, Tempering, Annealing and
Forging of Steel, by Joseph V. Wood-
worth. Publishers, Norman W. Hen-
ley & Company, New York. 1903.
Price, $2.50.
This work from the pen of Mr. J. V.
Woodworth, author of "Dies, Their Con-
ters, taps, dies, reamers, punches, dies,
etc., also shear blades, saws, fine cutlery
and metal-cutting tools of all descrip-
tions.
The important question as to the best
use to which the leading brands of steel
are adapted is concisely set forth, and
the method of working them under dif-
ferent conditions, and also the methods
of tempering and hardening the special
brands. A number of "kinks" and
"practical points" are given in this con-
nection.
Case hardening is taken up and special
reference is made to the adoption of ma-
chinery steel for tools of various kinds.
At the back of the book there is a
comprehensive table of articles made
from crucible steel, with figures indicat-
ing about the percentage of carbon each
shorild contain. The book is intended
for metal-working mechanics in general^
and those interested in the subject.
Modern Machine Shop Tools, by W. H.
Vandervoort, M.E. Publishers, Nor-
man W . Henley & Company, New
York. 1903. Price, $4.00.
This comprehensive work on modern^
machine tools, their construction, opera-
tion and manipulation, includes both
hand and machine tools. It is beauti-
fully illustrated with about 670 cuts and
contains in all 600 pages. It is well
printed on pages about 5V2X9 inches.
The various hand and machine tools
are grouped into classes, and the amount
of space devoted to each is proportional
to its relative importance. Each tool is
considered with reference to its construc-
tion, its operation and maintenance, and
the examples of work which can be done
by it^re given.
It IS intended that the book shall be
really a course of instruction to the ap-
prentice and to the mechanic, a manual
of practice, and for the foreman and the
shop superintendent it contains many
valuable suggestions and much useful in-
formation. The first chapter deals with
the hammer and the cold chisel, the sec-
ond with the file and filing, the third is
on scrapers and surface plates, then fol-
lows the consideration of standards of
measures. Chapter V is on calipers. VI
is on gauges and indicators, VII rules,
squares and other small tools. These
are succeeded by chapters, one each, on'
Drills, Reamers, Screwthreads, Tap and
Dies, Drill and Tapholders and Mandrels.
Four chapters follow on the lathe, the
lathe in modified forms, lathe tools,
chucks and drivers for lathe work, the
subsequent chapters are on lathe work,
boring and turning mills and the various
struction and Use," contains 320 pages
heat that has hitherto been of reading matter and has upwards of machine tools which are to be found in
200 illustrations and like other modern any up-to-date shop. The two last chap-
technical works contains a good index, ters, XXXIII and IV deal with miscel-
It deals with the heating, welding, forg- laneous shop equipment and conveni-
ing, annealing, hardening and tempering ences, and with useful tables and data,
of steel. It goes into the subject of tem- The book also contains a good index for ■
pering steel tools such as milling cut- handy reference.
June, H.03.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOIIVE ENGINEERING
263
"Locomotives: Simple, Compound and
Electric," by H. C. Reagan, Locomo-
tive Engineer. Publishers, John Wiley
& Sons, New York, 1903. Price, $2.50.
The popularity of this book is proved
by the fact that it is now issued in its
fourth edition and new matter has been
added which is intended to put the
reader in touch with the very latest and
highest type of locomotive and with its
details.
The work contains 565 pages of read-
ing matter and is divided into fourteen
chapters, followed by an appendix which
is chiefly concerned with electric loco-
motives and apparatus. The illustra-
tions, both half-tone and line cut, are
good, and there are plenty of them. The
printing, paper and binding are excel-
lent.
One feature which is sure to strike a
seeker after knowledge is that at the
^ end of nearly every chapter there is a
series of questions and answers pertain-
ing to the subject of the chapter itself,
and further, there are also questions and
answers concerning breakdowns and
the best methods of making temporary
repairs on the road. The book has been
written by a practical man for practical
men. and this question and answer feat-
ure of the book is most valuable.
The locomotive boiler is first consid-
ered, then the front end; cylinders;
frames, boxes and springs; rods and
connections; the breaking of rods; valve
motion; valve setting; the compound lo-
comotive. This is a general description
of the compound principle as applied to
locomotives. Then follows a chapter
on indicator cards; and one on the de-
scription of the various systems of com-
pound locomotives. In this chapter all
. the styles of compounds used in this
country are enumerated, and also the
Webb system in Great Britain, and the
various kinds of m'shaps which may be-
fall each particular kind of compound are
taken up, and the best methods of deal-
ing with each emergency are set forth.
Injectors, safety valves and steam
gauges, come next; then brakes, air-
pumps, valves, governors and the West-
inghouse brake; and then locomotive
packings. The appendix which follows
deals with electricity and electrical de-
tails, and a good reference index closes
the book.
The aim of the author has been to in-
struct the reader in engineering, of
whatever branch, to give him modern
examples and a clear and thorough ex-
planation of each point touched upon.
This book is the real locomotive up-to-
date.
Hollow Car Axles.
The success, as far as manufacturing
goes, which has attended the making
axles hollow by a process of punch-
ing, at the Homestead Works of the
Carnegie Steel Company, has made the
hollow car axle not merely a mechanical
achievement of a high order, but has
also made it a commercial possibility.
It remains now for that impartial sifter
of all work, Daily Service, under operat-
ing conditions, to report upon the per-
formance of the hollow axle, and if that
report is favorable then the hollow axle
will be "in our midst," as country news-
papers say.
The hollow axle for any given capacity
of car will have to be somewhat larger
in diameter than the solid axle for the
same capacity, but it will contain less
metal. A contemporary of ours remarks
that if the steel in an axle for a 50-ton
car is of the same strength both for
solid and hollow axles, then the hollow
axle will have to be Va an inch larger
at the journals than the solid one is now.
Some people are puzzled about the
relative strength of a solid and a hollow
column and often attribute some occult
power to the empty space in the center
of hollow pillars. It is needless to say
that the empty space itself has no
strength-giving quality. If a column had
to be made out of exactly 1,000 pounds
of metal the hollow form would be the
stronger of the two, and the diameter of
the hollow one would naturally be
greater than the solid column of exactly
the same weight.
Pursuing this line of reasoning a step
farther it is obvious that if the two
1.000-pound columns are of unequal
strength, the stronger, that is, the hol-
low one. when correctly designed, may
have some metal removed from it in
order to exactly equal the strength of
the solid one. If metal is taken from the
hollow one then it becomes lighter,
while retaining strength equal to the
solid one, and the saving of material has
always a very satisfactory economic
value. What has been said of columns
applies to axles.
The hollow axle as now made at
Homestead is said to save 33 per cent,
of metal, and to have other advantages
as well. The Homestead axle is, how-
ever, only hollow through journal and
wheel-seat, and has a solid center. It
has been made by a most highly skilful
mechanical process devised by a scientific
man of undoubted ability. We are, how-
ever, in this matter, only upon the
threshold, but the door has been opened.
It may be that the hollow axle, with its
weight-saving and its dense metal, made
by what amounts to a flaw-detecting proc-
ess, can be produced by rolling, and be
hollow clear through, and still retain all
the advantages which are now conceded
to it. If so, the cost of manufacture may
be still further reduced, and being en-
tirely hollow, it would contain the mini-
mum amount of metal with maximum
strength. The seamless tube, if we may
so say, used as an axle would have a
large internal oil reservoir, and the
formation of wheel seat and journals
might be accomplished without the
necessity of lathe work, and without
breaking or cutting into the skin of
the dense smooth steel. The hollow
car axle reveals great possibilities in the
matter of cheap production, less liability
to failure, absolute uniformity of pro-
duction, greater service and less wear,
and reduction of dead weight hauled
with the paying load in every car. Such
advantages have a very pleasing and
dividend-paying aspect for railway men.
Tests to Find Out Power of Engines.
The Chicago & Alton people are mak-
ing scientific tests with indicator and
dynamometer car to find gut the exact
tractive power of their various types of
locomotives. That is a very good thing
to do, but it allows for variables which
an actual test eliminates. Badly laid out
curves, low joints, inferior track, mis-
takes in estimating gradients, and a va-
riety of other uncertainties make it very
difticult to ascertain by figures the haul-
ing power of a locomotive, even when
the figures are based on indicator dia-
grams. We are repeatedly informed by
motive lower officials that the ordinary
rules for calculating tractions of loco-
motives are not found correct on various
divisions. We believe that the rules are
all right if the amount of resistance was
what it ought to be according to the
grades and curves. The resistance of
curves is very hard to estimate under
the most favorable conditions, and when
the track is in bad order the best esti-
mates are little better than guesses.
We think the Illinois Central people
who are also experimenting to find out
the tractive power of certain engines,
have adopted the most practical methods.
They load up an engine with trains cal-
culated to be its load over a certain
division, and if it hauls it easily they add
cars until they find out its capacity over
the various grades. This is not an ab-
solutely perfect method, because the
track may be badly out of order some
time after the tests have been made,
and then the engine will not be able to
do the work which was performed by
that making the tests; but on the whrde.
it is the fairest method that railroad
companies could adopt. Tests of the
capacity of locomotives by the use of
the steam engine indicator are of doubt-
ful utility. If the engine is not working
properly the indicator is a good instru-
ment to find out what is the matter, but
it gives very little information about
what trains the engine should haul on
various grades. A mechanical engineer
or expert on indicator practice can tell
the mean effective pressure at the
various points of cut-oflF of any ordinary
264
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
locomotive near enough for practical
purposes without applying the indicator-
If one engine is working difterent from
others of a class then the indicator
ought to be applied to ascertain the
cause of the difference.
Carnegie's Gift to the Engineering
Societies.
On February 14, 1903, Mr. Andrew-
Carnegie, addressing the American So-
ciety Civil Engineers, American Society
Mechanical Engineers, American Insti-
tute Mining Engineers, American Insti-
tute Electrical Engineers, and The En-
gineers' Club, wrote: "It will give me
great pleasure to give, say, one million
dollars to erect a suitable union building
for you as the same may be needed."
Was ever such a magnificent gift given
in such a simple and modest fashion?
The societies which are beneficiaries
of Mr. Carnegie's extraordinary gift,
have been extremely in need of a com-
mon home, the useful work they are
capable of performing having been re-
stricted through inconvenient headcjuar-
ters. The societies lost no time in tak-
the New York Railroad Club and others
of a similar character. The conveniences
and utilities provided will make the
Carnegie Engineering Building the
headquarters of all the engineering ac-
tivities on this continent. It is a fitting
tribute to the great work which the en-
gineering world of America have per-
formed and have vet to be achieved.
Handy Mandrel for Turning Driving
Brasses.
A handy rig for turning up driving
brasses has lately been put in operation
in the shops of the Central Railroad of
New Jersey, situated at Elizabethport.
N. J. Our illustration shows a cast-
iron mandrel for use in a lathe with lugs
at one end for driving. There are two
flanges cast on this mandrel, through
each of which three set screws pass, and
these bear against the edges of the
brass. The two set screws in the body
of the mandrel are adjusted so as to
hold up the crown of the brass inside,
and the two dowels are for the purpose
of having the brass rest on them during
the process of adjustment. A brass held
in place on this mandrel can be quickly
Jiaitu/ai/ ^ LoeoiHstwe £iiffitieering
HANDY MANDREL FOR TURNING DRIVING BRASSES.
ing the action necessary to utilize the
gift. The American Society of Civil En-
gineers displayed decided reluctance to
include themselves in a movement where
less aristocratic people may realize bene-
fit, but their opposition does not count
for much. A joint committee represent-
ing the societies interested has been se-
lected, which have already secured op-
tions on property in Thirty-ninth street.
New York city, that will provide room
for a magnificent building with suf-
ficient vacant grounds to show ofif the
place to the best advantage. The site
is within three blocks of the New Y''ork
city library, under construction, is with-
in easy reach of the Grand Central sta-
tion, and of the Pennsylvania station,
that will be built soon, and is altogether
an ideal location.
It is the intention to erect a hall suit-
able for meetings of the four societies,
to form a combined library from the
existing libraries belonging to the so-
cieties, and to provide accommodations
for other engineering societies, such as
turned ofif and removed by the slacken-
ing of three set screws at one end. If
the lathe hand has a number of the same
kind of brasses to do, it is readily seen
that time occupied in "setting" his work
has been reduced considerably. The
officials at Elizabethport speak very
highly of the handiness of this appliance,
and claim it to be a very good cost-re-
ducing device.
Work Rushing in Baldwin's.
Baldwin Locomotive Works is turn-
ing out locomotives at an average of
more than six every day in the week,
not excepting Sundays. In April no less
than 191 finished locomotives left the
great Philadelphia plant. The average
weight of the locomotives and tenders,
including all types, was 125 tons. They
represented a v:due approximately of
$2,750,000.
Never before has the output reached
those figures in any one month. In
August of last year 167 locomotives were
turned out, but that was not regarded as
a normal output, as the preceding and
succeeding months showed a much lower
number. The total number of locomo-
tives built at Baldwin's last year was
1,533. In 1901 the number was 1,375-
For this year the output has been: Janu-
uary, 142; February, 132; March, 160, and
April, 191 — high-water mark.
There are more than 15,000 workmen
on the payroll of the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works. The amount paid in wages
is $190,000 weekly, or at the rate of nearly
$10,000,000 a year. The materials used in
construction cost considerably more.
Orders in hand and others in prospect
will, it is believed, continue the enor-
mous business for months to come.
Additional Power for Baltimore &
Ohio.
Since April I the Baltimore & Ohio
has added 75 new engines to the mo-
tive power of the Pittsburgh Division.
Of this number 65 were for freight use,
while the remaining 10 are doing switch-
ing service in the yards. This makes the
total number of engines on the Pitts-
burgh Division about 750, of which 450
are freight machines. The addition
nieHns 10 per cent, increase to the entire
service, or 15 per cent, to the freight
service. With the use of 13 miles of<
additional second track between Pitts-
burgh and Cumberland, which goes into
service this week, the Baltimore & Ohio
will be able to greatly increase the ton-
nage of the Pittsburgh district. The
record of May promises to be 20 per cent,
greater than that of April. Of the total
tonnage the coal and coke shipments at
present comprise more than 60 per cent.
New Engines for Buffalo.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works is
building two consolidation locomotives
for the South Buffalo Railway Company.
Tlie locomotives will be equipped with
Vanderbilt boilers, says the Buffalo Ex-
press. The\- are designed for heavy road
service, and will be used exclusively for
hauhng freights over this short but hilly
road. The line is seven miles long and
runs from West Seneca to the tracks of
of the Buffalo Creek Company, and has
connections with the Buffalo. Rochester
c& Pittsburgh, the Lackawanna and the
Lake Shore. The total weight of the lo-
comotive is to be 175.000 pounds, with
159.000 pounds on the drivers, which gives
91 per cent, of the total weight for tractive
adhesion. That is one of the features of
the design. The heating surface will
amount to 2,500 square feet, and the
cylinders will take a pressure of 200
pounds. Recently, the same concern
built a locomotive of the same type for
the BufTalo, Rochester & Pittsburgh, but
the new engine has 92 square feet of heat-
ing surface less than the other one, which
is caused by shortening the tubes about
5M; inches.
Iimt", 1903.
RAH.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
265
Air= Brake Department.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NEI/LIS.
An Interesting Brake Cylinder Chart.
This brake cylinder pressure cliart
was taken from Colorado Midland Pas-
senger Car No. 107, on the Air-Brake
Men's special train, Divide, Col., to Col-
orado Springs. The train consisted of
three cars, handled by engine 201; en-
niarkcd C a full stop was made on ac-
count of being flagged. Between "D"
and "E" retaining valves were in opera-
tion, the grade being 3 per cent. It will
be noticed the retainer did not reduce
brake cylinder pressure to 15 lbs., this
was due to the reapplication of the brake
was on a 4 per cent, grade. Retainers
were again used, the brake cylinder pres-
sure in one instance reaching 35 lbs.
The 3 per cent, grade was practically
straight, while the 4 per cent, had a num-
ber of very sharp curves, one of them
being as high as 16 degrees. For this
reason the retained pressure in the brake
cylinder was allowed to drop lower while
rounding these curves. The reason for
the retained pressure dropping below 15
lbs. was due to a slight leak in the con-
nections to the recording gauge. From
points "G" to "IV the retainers were
turned down, the grade being consider-
ably lighter, the train reaching Colorado
Springs about 5.35 P. M.
itailwai/ ^Xoamotivc Engineering
AN INTERESTING BRAKE CYLINDER CHART.
gineer J. Kissel!. Weight of engine on
drivers. 91 tons. Total weight of engine
and tender, 154 tons. Vauclain compound
cylinder dimensions, 17x28x30 ins; driv-
ing wheels, 60 ins.; steam pressure 200 lbs.
Engine ecjuipped with Westinghouse
combined automatic and straight air-
brake, and the water brake with the
Vauclain compression relief. Cars
braked at 80 per cent, of light weight,
based on 75 lbs. train-pipe pressure; 80
per cent, instead of 90 per cent, of the
weight of the car is used, as the steady
use of the retainers on a 4 per cent.
grade may raise the brake cylinder pres-
sure so high that at the slow speed which
trains come down these grades wheel
sliding may result.
This train was handled by the auto-
matic brake, the straight air or water
brake not being used at any time. The
recorder was adjusted to give a complete
revolution in three hours. Connection was
made from the brake cylinders to the
recorder inside the car by means of a
length of rubber tubing for convenient
observation of the air-brake men.
The train left Divide at about 4.05 P.
M., at the point marked A, test was
made to determine if the recorder was in
operative condition. At the point mark-
ed B it will be noted the brake was ap-
plied by making three reductions, be-
fore release, which is also shown in the
next brake application. At the point
being necessary. The cylinder pressure
ranged between 20 and 30 lbs. for a
period of about ten minutes on the 3 per
Tenacious Work of the Air-Brake
Convention.
The .\ir-Brake .'\s50ciation's motto is
to improve the air-brake service on
.American railroads. It lives up to its
motto in these conventions by working
hard while it works, but can play equally
hard while it plays. While the ' para-
mount intent of the' association is to do
work which will be forcibly felt and
plainly seen by railroad companies, the
air-brake men believe that there may be
work as well as play at these conven-
tions.
TR.\IN PIPE AND BR.^KE CYLINDER PRESSURE CHART T.\KEN FROM CO.\L TRAIN
DOWN JEROME PARK COAL BR.\NCH, COLOR.ADO MIDLAND RY. FOUR PER
CENT. GRADE. NO HAND BRAKES USED. iS LOADED CO.AL CARS.
cent, grade. Practically a uniform speed
of 20 miles per hour was maintained.
Between "E" and "F" retaining valves
were not used on account of lighter
grade. Between ''F" and "G" the train
It is doubtful if any of the railway
mechanical associations show as krge
an attendance as greeted the president
at each of the meetings which he called
to order in the morning at nine o'clock
266
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
iji the convention hall. The first morn-
ing, the meeting consisting of the mem-
bers and their ladies, was what would be
expected in one of the larger mechanical
associations. The second and third
mornings' attendance was greater and
considerably more than is had at the
meetings of the larger associations. The
third morning, nearly seven-eighths of
all visiting delegates were in their seats
at nine o'clock, when called to order by
the president, and this, too, in the face
of a carriage drive given by the asso-
ciation to the ladies of the convention
to the Garden of the Gods, William's
Caiion and Manitou.
This shows that the air-brake men can
work even though there is entertainment
going on coincidently. Truly the air-
brake men are jealously guarding the
.welfare of their association by a refusal
to permit themselves to be drawn from
the convention hall to enticing pleasant-
ries of outside entertainment. This is a
feature that should be recognized by rail-
roads sending delegates to the conven-
tion, and to those interested in the de-
liberations of this young but vigorous
association.
To the Convention Bride and Groom.
Here's to "Patsy," clever and bright.
Who "brakes" the road of Anthracite,
— Brakes it, too, without jar or shock
O'er hundred-pound rail and ballast rock.
With high-speed brake and Schedule U,
The slack adjuster and straight air, too.
He brakes all cars, whether loaded or
light.
Up to date on the road of Anthracite.
And here's to her, "Miss Phoebe Snow,"
The convention bride of a week or so.
Whose ways are modest as the ripple's
lap
On the mossy shores of the Water Gap.
Whose radiant look has the inspiring
glow
Of the twinkling stars above Pocono.
May their life's journey be as smooth and
bright
As a trip o'er the road of Anthracite.
The liberality of the railway officials
of the Colorado Midland & Rio Grande,
in issuing passes to members of the con-
vention, is deserving of special note and
comment. This exceptional generosity
permitted members and their ladies to
take in all the sights around Denver,
Cripple Creek, Summit, Divide 'and Glen-
wood Springs, which some would have
preferred to forego had they been ob-
liged to pay fare. Too hearty thanks
cannot be given to these thoughtful
officials for their generous treatment of
the .\ir-Brake Association.
The splendid entertainment arranged
by the committee on arrangements was
a prominent feature of the convention.
A noticeable and commendable feature
ot this arrangement was that no enter-
tainment was provided during conven-
tion hours, thus placing no enticement to
draw members away from the meetings.
This was a level-headed move, and in
keeping with the substantiability of the
committee.
The trip up Pike's Peak was an especi-
ally enjoyable one. The one and a half
hour journey carried the tourists from a
valley of sunshine and flowers into a
weird land of rocks and ice above the
clouds, where raged a violent snow-
storm. Although the time was but four
Max. i^, =
8000
%0D0
6000
6000
■^
^
■--,
S I 1 i
s, S o^Max. =
-iZ °>
Max. ijfi ^
— s
■"H
:\
^
22s 280 Milea > 210
JProfile. Jerome Pnrk Coal Branch
ROUTE OF AIR-BRAKE ASSOCIATION'.S
TRAIN.
o'clock in the afternoon, the darkness
indicated a twilight hour of seven or
eight in the evening.
Five strenuous members of the con-
vention arose one morning at five o'clock
and took a fifteen-mile horse-back ride
to Glen Eyre and through the Garden
of the Gods before breakfast. Not one
of the party had been in the saddle for
ten years, and all rode like wild Indians
and cowboys. So fatigued did that por-
tion of their anatomy resting on the sad-
dle become, and so unsatisfactory was
the consequent search for a "well spot"
to sit upon, that the whole party pre-
sented a grotesque appearance, hanging
on sidewise and standing up in the stir-
rups, on the way home. These members
absented themselves from the dining-
room meals and stood up against the
wall in the convention room. The unani-
mous verdict with them was "never
again."
The rarified atmosphere at the sum-
mit of the Peak made breathing diffi-
cult, and several persons of the conven-
tion party were visably distressed. One
ambitious member ran the short distance
from the train to the shelter of the sta-
tion and panted for ten minutes after-
wards. At this altitude one must neces-
sarily breathe about twice as much air
to get the same amount of life-giving
carbon into his lungs as at the seashore
level.
Mr. S. J. Kidder's well-known railroad
stories of quaint, droll persons, has
earned for him the deserved name of "the
Chauncey Depew of the Air-Brake Asso-
ciation." Depevv's "Jed Prouty" gives
way to Kidder's "Chris. Guyer," and the
"Peekskill" of the Senator is replaced
by "Galesburg, on the Q Rud," made
famous by Kidder. Mr. Kidder would
coin ducats if he could write stories as
well as he tells them at conventions.
Some of the visiting members heard
for the first time that beans and potatoes
and such things cannot be boiled at high
altitudes such as at Pike's Peak. This
statement is true and apparent upon re-
flection. Water boils at lower degrees
of temperature as we ascend into higher
altitudes, and we find in altitudes of
Pike's Peak height, that water boils
at such low temperature that the heat
of the water is insufficient to cook the
vegetables through.
The consensus of opinion of the ob-
serving members was that the superior
air-brake service of the western moun-
tain roads is principally due to better
condition of brakes. This better con-
dition has been brought about by a bet-
ter appreciation of the existing situation
by western railway officers who have
given air-brake maintenance their sub-
stantial support.
Tenth Annual Convention of the Air-
Bralce Association.
The tenth annual convention of the
Air-Brake Association was called to or-
der in Colorado Springs April 28 by
Second Vice-President E. G. Desoe,
President Goodman and First Vice-Presi-
dent Huntley being absent.
Addresses of Mayor and President.
Mayor Harris, in a few well-chosen
words, welcomed the convention to Col-
orado Springs, assuring the members and
their ladies of the city's sincerest hos-
pitality and well wishes in the conven-
tion work. Mr. Desoe responded to the
Mayor's welcome briefly, and proceeded
to address the convention.
Mr. Desoe dwelt on the air-brake
progress during the past year, making
a special reference to the work which
the association has been engaged in. He
also urged the importance of the appoint-
ment of a high grade and thoroughly
capable general air-brake inspector to
take the whole charge of the air-brake
June, 190.V
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
267
departiiiciit of our modern railroads. He
cited specific cases where such appoint-
ment had resulted in great benefit to the
railroad through intelligent management
of this important department.
Rc(>ort of Secretary and Treasurer.
The secretary's report showed the asso-
ciation to be in a flourishing and pros-
perous condition, a number of members
having been dropped from the roll be-
cause of non-payment of dues, etc.
Eighty-six new members had been added
during the past year, making a total en-
rollment of 700.
The treasurer's report showed the
financial condition of the association to
be sound and good, although the treas-
ury balance this year was nearly $100
below that of last year, being $1,386.54.
The meeting hours for the convention
were voted to be from 9 A. M. until i
P. M. each day until the business of the
association had been transacted.
Water in Train Pif'es.
The first paper presented was that of
the committee reporting on "Water in
Train Pipes and How to Prevent Freez-
ing." In the absence of Chairman Whit-
ney, Mr. Desoe read the paper. Third
Vice-President John Hume, Jr., taking
the chair. The paper dwelt on the ex-
tended experiments made by the com-
mittee during the past year, and gave
considerable additional data to the valu-
able amount which had already been se-
cured. The committee urged the use of
two main reservoirs and a length of dis-
charge pipe from the pump to the main
reservoir not less than 20 or 25 feet in
length, and showed the importance of
avoiding an excessive length of pipe
which would cause freezing.
In the discussion which followed, Mr.
Langan, of the Lackawanna, gave some
interesting and valuable experience ob-
tained during the past year in the line
of this subject. He reported splendid
results from limiting the speed of air
pumps to not more than 140 single
strokes per minute. If the pump could
not supply the train in good condition
with this number of strokes, it was re-
moved from the engine and taken to the
repair shop, being replaced by one in
good order. If the leakage in the train
line was too great to permit the keeping
up of pressure with a good air pump at
140 single strokes per minute, repairs
were made on the train pipe.
Other members believed that Mr.
Langan's practice was exceedingly good.
The entire convention approved of Mr.
Langan's method of requiring the pump
to be in good condition, and the train
to be also in reasonably good condition
to permit the pump to keep up pressure,
instead of requiring a larger pump to
keep up bad leakage, in wdiich event
leakage would naturally grow worse and
more neglected.
Mr. Kelly suggested the use of long
slender reservoirs where practicable in-
stead of the short, stocky reservoirs com-
monly in use.
Mr. Nellis endorsed the committee's
recommendation for a longer length of
discharge pipe to the air pump as a pre-
ventative of water passing back into the
train pipe. He cited a case on an east-
ern road which had trouble from water
in train pipes, and which, after trying a
length of 20-feet discharge pipe, the
trouble entirely disappeared. He en-
dorsed the use of long, slender reservoirs,
where practicable, as such reservoirs af-
forded better opportunity for the heat
to radiate from the air and deposit moist-
ure into main reservoir, thus preventing
it passing back into the train pipe.
Mr. Budig stated that after a winter's
experience, he had succeeded in prevent-
ing water passing into the train pipe by
the use of longer discharge pipe. It was
his practice to blow out the train pipes
at the end of each trip. Mr. Conger en-
dorsed the practice of blowing out train
pipes, and believed if it was followed out
freezing of train pipes would be greatly
reduced. He also endorsed the commit-
tee's views and recommendations.
Mr. Sitterly had experienced the value
of long discharge pipes. He also en-
dorsed the recommendation of long res-
ervoirs where practicable, and also be-
lieved that further advantage may be
obtained by the use of a larger discharge
pipe, as large discharge pipes would
serve in a small degree the purpose of
long, slender main reservoirs.
Mr. Greenwade gave an interesting
talk on main reservoirs and their connec-
tions. He believed that the association
should recommend the use of at least two
main reservoirs where practicable, and
the connecting pipes should be of suffi-
cient length to permit the water to be
deposited in the main reservoirs from
where it could be drained off. IMr. Kelly
suggested that more frequent draining of
main reservoirs would be had it a more
convenient arrangement of draitiage were
supplied.
Mr. C. C. Farmer believed that all
main reservoirs should be so arranged
that a circulation of air could be had
through them, and that no dead ends
should be permitted.
Mr. Fredericks suggested that the pipe
entering the main reservoir should never
be placed opposite the point where the
pipe led out of the main reservoir, as
this gave too direct a current of air
through the main reservoir, which per-
mitted warm air to flow ttirough the
reservoir into the brake valves. He
cited a case where the changing of pipe
of this nature had resulted in greater de-
posit of water in the main reservoir and
less in the train pipe.
Mr. F. B. Farmer deprecated the prac-
tice of having the suction of the air
pump so arranged that steam and vapor
from leaking piston rods, valve stems,
injector, overflow pipe, etc., could be
sucked into the air pump, as many pumps
are not yet supplied with the longer dis-
charge pipe. This moisture would be
carried back into the train pipe more
easily than if dry air were taken in.
Mr. Alexander stated that the Penn-
sylvania had for some time past installed
two main reservoirs to each engine and
that now a discharge pipe of about 20
feet connected the air pump and the
first main reservoir, and a connecting
pipe between the two main reservoirs
had a length also of about 20 feet. He
stated that with such arrangement his
line had experienced no trouble what-
ever on engines so equipped from water
accumulating in the train pipe. He also
stated that his road had been applying
small pet cocks in the main reservoir
instead of the old tap plug to draw out
the drainage. This arrangement was
vastly superior to the old plug, as the
engineer was accustomed to open this
cock frequently in passing around his
engine, where he would not take the
trouble to carry down a monkey wrench
and remove the plug. He believed this
a great improvement, as the reservoir
could be drained without drawing off all
the pressure.
Mr. F. B. Farmer related his experi-
ence with engines in the extreme North-
west which was in line with that of the
committee, and he endorsed their recom-
mendations. He did not believe that the
association could adopt a standard length
of pump discharge pipe for all engines
in all climates, as the tendency for the
discharge pipe to freeze up before enter-
ing the main reservoir increased after a
certain length of pipe was reached. He
believed that from about 20 to 30 feet
gave good service under average con-
ditions.
Mr. Alex. Brown also endorsed the
committee's recommendations and stated
that in the Eastern Canadian country that
little trouble had been experienced with
freezing of the train pipe where rea-
sonable length of pump discharge pipe
had been employed. He cited an in-
stance where an air-brake man had sug-
gested use of the hand rail for delivery
pipe, in cases where the location of the
pump discharge pipe was inconvenient.
One member objected to this arrange-
ment, as he believed one pipe should
not be required to perform too many
functions, especially in this case where
the discharge pipe would be hot and
would be disagreeable to the touch of
engineer or fireman, should they be
required to pass along the running board
and hold to the pipe while the train was
moving.
Trip up Pike's Peak.
The meeting adjourned at 12 o'c'ock
to prepare for a trip to Pike's Peak,
268
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
which had been arranged by the enter-
tainment committee. The members and
their ladies left the base of Pike's Peak
for the summit at 2 o'clock. One train
had been prepared, but as the number
was larger than had been anticipated,
two trains were provided. Both these
trains proceeded to the summit, where
the members and their ladies found
themselves in a heavy snowstorm, being
imable to see more than a few feet away.
After an hour's sojourn at the Peak, the
party returned shivering to the cars to
descend the mountain. Several of the
ladies and gentlemen were considerably
inconvenienced at the high altitude of
14,000 feet, two of the ladies and one
of the gentlemen being in a somewhat
alarming condition when leaving the
summit, although they quickly recovered
as the descent was made. Down at the
timber line (11,000 feet), the party passed
through the clouds and out of the snow-
storm, all parties again feeling in jubilant
spirits and in comfortable condition.
The evening was spent by the mem-
bers and their ladies in the parlors and
lobby of the hotel getting better ac-
quainted. All retired early in order to
begin the next morning's session on time.
IVednesday's Session.
The convention was called to order on
Wednesday, the second day, by Chair-
man Desoe, and discussion of the paper
on "Frozen Train Pipes" was resumed,
several members taking part. After a
general discussion, the subject was
closed, the paper accepted and the com-
mittee discharged.
High-Speed Brakes.
The next paper presented was that on
"High-Speed Brakes." In the absence
of Chairman Roney, Mr. Carlton read
the paper. The paper stated that dur-
ing the past year nothing of material im-
portance had been reported to the com-
mittee or had been added to the informa-
tion already at hand. Several members
reported that their lines had adopted
the use of the high-speed brake on all
of their passenger trains, both through
and local, and with entirely good results,
quite up to those expected, had been se-
cured.
Mr. Kelly stated that during the past
winter some tests had been made without
the automatic reducing valve, but with
higher train-pipe pressure than the ordi-
nary brake, which stopped the train in
a little shorter distance than in com-
peting test made with high-speed brake.
He added that the automatic reducing
valve feature now employed was perhaps
the best that could be obtained at the
time of its invention and was doubtless
giving very good results; that during the
coming year further tests along the lines
he had experienced would produce in-
teresting and valuable information in
high-speed brakes.
Mr. Garrabrant, of the Pennsylvania
road, stated that his line had adopted
the high-speed brake on all its passenger
trains, both through and local, and that
they expected improved results. No flat
wheels had resulted since his line began
this total installation with high-speed
brakes. He was loud in his praises of
the high-speed brake.
Mr. Carlton, of the Chicago & North-
western, stated that the high-speed brake
had been in service on all of their
through trains for some time past. It
had given entire satisfaction and very
much improved results.
In reply to a question from Mr. Con-
ger, Mr. Carlton stated that the ordinary
standard hose had proved sufficient for
high speed brake trains, carrying a pres-
sure of 110 pounds. He had not ob-
served that high speed brake trains were
any diflerent in any sense, so far as hose
were concerned, from trains cairying a
70-pound train line pressure.
Mr. Budig, of the Burlington, stated
that the shoe wear on his road was
greater with high speed brakes, due to
performance of more highly efficient
brakes, than experienced with the 70-
pound brake. Mr. Carton's experience
was coincident with that of Mr. Budig.
'Sir. Kelly believed that an air brake,
based on lower train pipe pressure might
give better satisfaction than one obliged
to carry no pounds pressure, as the heat
generated at such high pressure reduced
the holding power of the shoe — shoe
wear was also more excessive with high
speed brakes.
Mr. Nellis questioned the wisdom of
such a change, believing that the in-
creased advantage of high speed brake
service warranted faster shoe wear,
stronger foundation brake gear, etc. He
stated that a foundation brake gear meet-
ing the M. C. B. requirements was am-
ply strong for high speed brake service.
Mr. Langan expressed the belief that
in changing the foundation brake gear
on cars having light rods, flexible brake
beams, etc., should be supplied with lib-
eral cylinder capacity in the event of a
form of high speed brake, depending on
lower train line pressure than at present
employed with the high speed brake,
should be developed and adopted.
Mr. Culver objected to an unreason-
ably large cylinder, the total leverage, in
his mind, being about 8 or 10 to i. He
reported the cars on the New York Cen-
tral road as being sufficiently strong with
the old brake up to the M. C. B. require-
ments, and that no change was therefore
necessary in any of the foundation gear
in going from 70 pound brakes to high
speed brakes.
A number expressed the belief that
both the low pressure and high pressure
reducing valves should be tagged in or-
der that they might be more readily
recognized by the engineer, who might
possibly get bewildered and turn the re-
versing cock the wrong way.
Mr. Budig reported excellent results
from transferring the leducing valves
and reversing cock from the old position
outside and under the running board to
a place inside the cab where the warmth
would prevent the parts from freezing.
Mr. Libby, of the Lake Shore, stated
that the practice of his road to paint
the high pressure reducing valve and
small cut out cock a red color in order
that they might be more easily recog-
nized and more easily manipulated by the
engineer. The plan, he said, had proved
a good one.
Mr. Desoe believed that the matter of
brake shoes should cut no figure in de-
ciding between the 70 pound brake and
high speed brake, and also believed that
the Master Car Builders would require a
brake shoe for high speed brake service
if a different brake shoe were needed
than is now used in ordinary service. He
believed that the matter of brake shoes
should not retard or check the use ot
high speed brakes on roads, either in fast
passenger or local service.
Mr. Culver believed that more than lO
pounds excess should be carried with the
high speed brake on trains hauling more
than 4 cars. He stated that on the Em-
pire State Express on the New York
Central, no trouble from slid flat wheels
had been experienced, but that on the
20th Century Limited, where the train is
composed of 6 cars, slid flat wheels had
been experienced. This he supposed
was due more to lack of excess pressure
than it was to the high train line pres-
sure carried. Mr. Desoe agreed with
Mr. Culver that at least 20 pounds excess
should .be carried with high speed brake.
Mr. bidder advised that no hard and
fast rule could be made with regard to-
amount of excess pressure carried, but
that each road, having its own local and
peculiar conditions, should adopt the ex-
cess required. He stated that 10 pounds
excess originally adopted by the West-
inghouse Air-Brake Co. had resulted
from the experience then at hand, which
was confined to trains 01 3 and 4 cars
in length.
Mr. Conger endorsed the resolution
making it the sense of the meeting that
20 pounds excess should be carried where
needed in high speed brake service, the
same as at present carried with the 70
pound brake.
Mr. Fredericks stated that some few
slid flat wheels had resulted on his line
with high speed brakes, but that clean-
ing the triple valves had resulted in dis-
appearance of the trouble. Both he and
Mr. Alexander spoke highly of the
change from 10 in.xi2 in. to the 10
in.xl4V2 in. equalizing reservoir, as
the change had resulted in a discontin-
uance of the trouble of brakes going into-
June, 190.?.
RAILWAY AND I.r)COMOTI VK. F.N'GI N'KKRING
269
emergency when service application was
made on the shorter trains.
Mr. Kidder advised tliat tlie 10 in.xi4V2
in. equalizing reservoir was now the
standard of the Westinghouse .\ir-Brakc
Co.
Mr. Jones advised that his past year's
experience with high speed brake had
been of an entirely satisfactory and
pleasant nature. He strongly endorsed
the views of the committee.
Upon vote the paper was accepted, the
committee thanked for its work and dis-
charged.
Topical Discussion.
It now being 12 o'clock, subjects for
topical discussion were taken up, and Mr.
Carlton opened the subject by calling for
the experience of other members in mat-
ter of testing tlic efficiency of the air
pump cylinder. The discussion was car-
vied on at considerable length, and two
good methods were endorsed.
Mr. C. C. Farmer mentioned a test
practiced on some roads and known as
the "oil cup test." This consists of open-
ing the oil cup on the top of the air
cylinder, and noting whether air pressure
escaped past the packing rings. On the
down stroke, at about 25 strokes per
minute, the packing rings, if in leaky
condition, would show up by pressure
passing from the lower side around
the rings into the upper side of the
piston and out through the oil cup. On
the up stroke the tightness of the rings
could be determined by the amount of
pressure escaping at the oil cup. This
test, he believes, was valuable as a quick
and easy test under ordinary conditions.
Mr. Parker, of the Great Northern
road, recommended a test which con-
sisted in the attachment of a pressure
gage in the lower head of the air cylin-
der. On the up stroke at about 54 of
the distance traversed, at about 30
strokes per minute, the ga.ge would show
about 7 or 8 pounds with the pump in
ordinary good condition. The pump in
bad condition would show a great deal
more. Mr. Parker advised that pumps
which had just been overhauled would
sometimes show a gage pressure of this
amount. The discussion on these two
tests brought out a great deal of valuable
and useful information to the convention.
Trif' to Summit.
The convention adjourned at 12:30 to
prepare for a trip via the Colorado Mid-
land Railroad to the Summit. A train
consisting of engine and 3 cars carried
the convention party above the clouds,
and into another snow storm. The won-
derful engineering feat of building a rail-
road line along the abrupt cliffs and bor-
ing through rock tunnels was impressed
upon the members and commented upon
by them. On the descent several of the
convention imen attached a recording
gauge to the train pipe of rear car. from
which was taken readings of the manipu-
lation of the brakes by the engineer. The
descent was made from the 10,000 foot
level, down through the clouds and the
snow storin to the sunshine in the valley
below without any considerable excite-
ment, the party landing at the ."Marm
Hotel about six o'clock.
The Hotel Hop.
:\l 0 o'clock the members and their
ladies proceeded to the ballroom of the
hotel, where the manager had prepared
a dance for llu-m. Everyone seemed to
join in and more than 100 couples tripped
the light fantastic till 12 o'clock to the
excellent music of the orchestra of 12
instruments provided by the hotel man-
agement in honor of the occasion.
Thursday's .Session.
Thursday morning the discussion of ef-
ficiency of air pump cylinders was con-
tinued, but shortly closed by unanimous
vote.
Combined Automatic and Straight Air
Bral;c.
The topical discussion presented by
Mr. F. B. Farmer on combined automatic
and straight air brake was presented.
The paper was full and complete, and
showed careful preparation, containing
valuable experiments and their data. Mr.
Farmer advised that a large number of
straight air brakes were in operation on
roads in the Northwest where they were
giving excellent satisfaction in switching
service, long train service, and mountain
service. He advised that much benefit
had been derived from this device in
long train service on level roads where
break-in-twos had been experienced. He
also advised that it was in successful op-
eration on mountain grades where
straight air could be held on locomotive
and tender while the automatic brakes
were being recharged on the train. For
switching, and in "spotting" the device
had been exceedingly advantageous and
acceptable.
Mr. Strickland advised that the device
had been in exceedingly satisfactory op-
eration on his road, where accurate
"spotting" of cars was required. He
said that several minor changes had been
made in the double check valve and re-
ducing valve which rendered it more
adaptable to the peculiar service of his
line.
Mr. Nellis reported that one of the
large anthracite systems in the East had
adopted the device on all of its heavy
freight engines after a service trial of 2
months on one of its heavy engines. On
this road trouble was experienced in the
heavy grades from skidding of wheels,
due to "clubbing" of the brakes by the
brakeman. The device Iiad proved that
trains could be dropped down heavy
grades with this device and "clubbing"
rendered unnecessary. On long coal
trains, on level portions of the road, the
device had proven an excellent assistant
in taking up slack of trains in applying
brakes and holding in the slack in re-
leasing brakes, thus preventing damage
to draft gear and break-in-twos.
Mr. Kelly reported that the straight
air brake manufactured by the New York
,'\ir Brake Co. had given excellent sat-
isfaction in hill service.
Mr. Hutchins advised that the device
had entirely eliminated the difficulty ex-
perienced on a very heavy grade of the
Louisville & Nashville road, where hand
brakes had been necessary to assist the
air brakes in controlling the speed of
trains down a heavy grade.
Mr. Parker reported excellent results
from the use of the combined automatic
and straight air brakes on his line.
Both Mr. Carlton, of the Chicago &
Northwestern, and Mr. Libbey, of the
Lake Shore, reported equally good re-
sults from the use of this device on their
lines.
.•\fter further discussion on this sub-
ject, it was closed and the convention
proceeded to election of officers which
resulted as follows:
Election of Officers.
President. E. G. Desoe, Boston & Al-
bany: first vice-president, John Hume,
Jr., Houston & Texas Central: second
vice-president. L. M. Carlton. Chicago &
Northwestern; third vice-president, W.
P. Garrabrant. Pennsylvania. Executive
committee, J. H. Hardy, Colorado Mid-
land: P. J. Langan, Delaware & Lacka-
wanna; C. P. Clendennin, Colorado Mid-
land. Secretary, F. N. Nellis, New
Y'ork; assistant secretary, F. W. Gross,
New^ Y'ork; treasurer. Otto Best, Nash-
ville, Chattanooga & St. Louis.
Buffalo Selected.
Buffalo was selected as the next meet-
ing place, the convention to convene the
second Tuesday in April. 1904.
Convention adjourned.
Trip to Divide.
A trip for the members and their ladies
to the Continental Divide had been ar-
ranged by the Colorado Midland, which
furnished a locomotive and three cars for
the occasion. The 3 coaches were well
filled, and the party enjoyed immensely
the trip over the winding road, through
the tunnels and canyons to the summit
of the mountain. Here all passengers
disembarked and gathered wild flowers.
After the attachment at recording
gages to the brake cylinder of the first
car and the train line of the third car re-
spectively, the train started to descend
the mountain. In the evening the mem-
bers began to scatter to their various
homes, quite a considerable number re-
maining to take side trips to Cripple
Creek, Glenwood Springs and Salt Lake
City, transportation having been kindly
270
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June. 1903.
provided by the Colorado Midland and
^e Denver & Rio Grande roads.
Thus ended one of the most success-
ful and best attended conventions of the
Air Brake Association.
Handling the New York Engineers'
Brake Valve.
In the May number we illustrated the
1902 model New York Engineers' brake
valve, and called attention to the modi-
fications and improvements incorporated
in it.
While it is well to understand clearly
the principal features in the construction
of a piece of mechanism, it is also
equally, if not more, important that we
give attention to the proper method of
handling it in order to get the best re-
sults.
At the outset, it should be borne in
mind that the function of the brake valve
in air-brake operation is to regulate the
flow of air into and out of the fain
pipe, in order to charge the air-brake
apparatus, and to enable the engineer to
apply the brakes in the manner and with
the degree of force desired, and to re-
lease them properly.
As shown in Fig. 5, May number, the
handle is in release position, and the
main slide valve 114 A is in the extreme
forward position, uncovering a large por-
tion of port A (shown in Fig. i) in its
seat. As may be easily seen, the main
reservoir air can flow freely into the
train pipe, so long as the handle remains
in this position.
When charging up the train pipe and
auxiliary reservoir, it is desirable that it
be done quickly, and hence while charg-
ing up the air-brake apparatus, the han-
dle should be left in release position.
When the train pipe is charged almost
to the required pressure, move the handle
to running position, shown in Fig. 6
(May number). This is the position in
which it should be carried ordinarily,
after the train is charged, brakes released
and the train standing or running.
It will be observed that in running
position slide valve 114A is moved back
a short distance from the extreme for-
ward position-release, and that port E,
in its seat, comes directly under cavity
M in its face. Port E is shown in Fig.
I, and cavity M is shown in Fig 2.
With port E and cavity M in com-
munication, main reservoir air flows into
the train pipe by way of the passage lead-
ing to the excess pressure valve 97, as
explained in the May number, and shown
in Fig. 4.
As the excess pressure spring has a
tension, sufficient to resist a pressure of
twenty pounds per square inch, tending
to force it upward from its seat, the air
from the main reservoir, flowing to the
excess pressure valve, must overcome
this resistance before the valve can rise
■from its seat, and any of the air pass it;
therefore, it follows that the main reser-
voir pressure must be twenty pounds
greater than the train-pipe pressure be-
fore any air can pass from the main
reservoir into the train pipe with the
handle in running position.
Excess pressure carried in the main
reservoir is necessary to insure a prompt
and a certain release of all the brakes,
and to recharge the auxiliary reservoirs
quickly.
Therefore, after the train pipe and the
auxiliary reservoirs are properly charged,
the handle should be moved to running
position, where the pump will pump up
the "excess," and the ordinary train pipe
and auxiliary leakage will be supplied
through the excess-pressure valve.
About the only exception to this rule is
when recharging auxiliaries on down
grades — a case where it is important that
auxiliaries be recharged as quickly as
possible.
The lap position, shown in Fig 7 (May
26), is used to prevent the flow of air
through the valve in any direction, and
it is used in service application of the
brake whenever the automatic cut-ofT
feature is inoperative, to close the train
pipe exhaust; when a hose bursts, the
train parts, or the conductor applies the
brake from the rear. In all these cases
the handle of the valve should be moved
to lap position to hold the brakes on or
to prevent the loss of main reservoir
air, as the case may demand.
While we say the handle should be
placed on lap, when a hose bursts, etc.,
to save main reservoir air, a little
thought will show that the service or the
emergency application position will an-
swer the purpose equally well, because
communication between the main reser-
voir and the train pipe is cut off in all
positions of the handle, except release
and running.
The service application position is sub-
divided into five graduated positions, and
when the handle is moved to the first of
these positions, a gradual reduction of
five pounds will be made in the train
pipe pressure, and the valve will auto-
matically cut off further escape of air
from the train pipe in that position. To
reduce train pipe pressure further, it will
be necessary to move the handle to the
next graduated service notch, and after
the additional reduction is had in train
pipe pressure, corresponding to that
notch, it will lap itself, and so on down
to the last service graduating notch,
when it will be found that a total reduc-
tion of twenty-three pounds in train pipe
pressure will be had. This is the amount
of reduction required to set the brakes
in full in a service application from a
train pipe pressure of seventy pounds,
and at the same time provide for slight
variation in piston travel.
In Figs. 8 and 9 the operation of the
valve in service application is illustrated.
so that not much explanation is needed.
Fig. 8 shows the handle in the third serv-
ice graduating notch, and the arrows in-
dicate the way which the air takes to
escape from the train pipe to the atmos-
phere.
Fig. 9 shows the automatic cut-off
position of the valve, valve no blanking
port F, in the face of the main slide valve,
and preventing further escape of air from
the train pipe.
It should be remembered then when
making a service application that the
handle of the brake valve should be
placed in the service graduating notch,
that will give the desired reduction in
train pipe pressure, and left there until
an additional reduction is desired, or the
handle is moved to release position to
let off the brakes.
When making a service application,
should the train consist of three cars or
less, the handle should be placed in the
first graduating notch, as port F in the
face of slide valve 114A, in this notch, is
only about half open, ana, therefore, the
escape of air is restricted to a rate that
will obviate the danger of setting the
brakes in quick action. With trains of
ten cars or more the second graduating
notch should be used for the initial train
pipe reduction, as it usually requires a
greater than five-pound initial reduction
in train pipe pressure to move the brake
cylinder pistons on trains of this and
greater length, beyond the leakage
grooves, and also to get a more prompt
movement of all the triple valves.
Should it occur in service applications
that the automatic cut-off feature fails to
work, then when the desired train pipe
pressure reduction is had, move the han-
dle of-the brake valve back toward posi-
tive lap position until the train pipe ex-
haust ceases. When necessary to move
the handle in this way, if the train con-
sists of forty or more cars, move it
slowly, so that there may be no abrupt
closing of the train pipe and consequent
surge of air in the front end of it that
might cause the driver and tender brakes
to release.
When emergencies arise there is but
one thing to do with the train pipe air —
let it escape as quickly as possible.
To do this, place the handle in the
emergency position as shown in Fig. 10,
and leave it there until the train stops or
the danger is passed.
When releasing brakes, it is good
practice to hold the handle of the brake
valve in release position momentarily,
the length of time that it should be held
there depending somewhat upon the
number of air-brake cars coupled and
working, to insure the release of all
brakes; then it should be moved to run-
ning position.
This rule for moving the handle to
running position after releasing br.ikes
June, I'joi-
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
271
holds aiiniirably in all cases where the
main reservoir pressure does not fall be-
low seventy pounds, and equalize with
the train pipe pressure; when the main
reservoir and the train pipe pressures
equalize below the standard train pipe
pressure carried, after the handle is
moved to release position to release the
brakes, then it should be allowed to re-
main in that position until both hands
on the air gauge, moving up together,
nearly indicate the standard train pipe
pressure, then the handle may be moved
to the running position. Handling the
valve in this way prevents the pump from
stopping when standard train pipe pres-
sure has been obtained, and it will con-
tinue to work on until standard main
reservoir pressure has been obtained.
To sum up the matter of handling the
New York Engineers' Brake Valve,
whenever it is required to charge the
train pipe and auxiliaries quickly, as after
coupling on to an empty train pipe at
the terminals, or to recharge auxiliaries
quickly while descending grades, place the
handle in release position and let it re-
main there until the full train pipe pres-
sure has been nearly obtained; then move
the handle to running position, so that
the excess pressure may be obtained in
the main reservoir.
Positive lap position blanks all ports,
and the handle should be placed in this
position when circumstances such as
mentioned above, pertaining to use of
lap position, require that it should be.
The service graduating notches should
be used in making service applications;
and in emergencies, always use the
emergency position, leaving the handle
there until all danger is passed.
(Continued in next number.)
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
On the Air-Brake.
(43) E. J. L.. Wellington, New Zea-
land, writes:
A driver coming into a station with
about 30 wagons makes a 7- or 8-pound
reduction, but before the after blow has
finished, he gets a right-of-way signal
and puts brake handle into full release,
when the jar he gets nearly sends him
through the window. What is the cause?
A. — The answer given to W. J. H. in
question 47 is the answer to this question
also.
(44) R. G. P., St. Paul. Minn., asks:
In the event of double-heading pas-
senger trains, is it customary to cut out
air signal on second engine, and what is
the practice usually followed? A. — On
some roads the practice is followed of
cutting out the whistle-signal apparatus
on the second engine in a double-headed
train. On other roads both engines are
left cut in. The difference is not very
great, as the whistle operates about as
well with both engines as if the second
engine were cut out.
(45) J. U., I'hillipsburg, N. J., writes:
We have three 8-inch air pumps that
have been overhauled, new reverse valves
put in, also new bush, new reverse piston
and bush, new main steam valves and
bushings, and new rings in pistons. They
all make an up stroke, come down and
stop. What is the matter? A.— Y'our
trouble is probably due to either the fail-
ure to properly get steam pressure
through port in upper head gasket, past
reversing valve bush onto top of your
reversing piston to operate the valve
motion, a worn reversing plate, too long
reversing-valve rod or the piston strik-
ing some of its parts against the bottom
head in the air cylinder.
(46) R. M. E., Wellington, New
Zealand, writes:
A driver while standing at the station
with a tidy long train, makes a 7-pound
reduction which sets the brakes. He
then makes a 2-pound reduction, when
the first three brakes come off. What
is the cause? A.— The equalizing piston
may be working stiffly, due to lack of
lubricant or presence of foreign matter,
thus closing abruptly the train pipe be-
fore the pressure in the train pipe has
equalized, thus kicking off the head
brakes. If the train is a short one, the
same trouble might be produced by a
leakage of main reservoir pressure
through a faulty rotary valve or bad gas-
ket into train pipe, thus forcing the triple
valves on head cars to release position.
(47 ) W. J. H., Wellington, New Zea-
land, writes:
A driver coming into station with long
train makes a 7 and 3-pound reduction
and finds he has stopped too short. He
puts handle into release position when
he shortly receives a nasty jar. What is
the cause? A. — This is due to the re-
lease of brakes on head end of train
while those on rear end remain set. If
the brake-valve handle is placed in re-
lease position, admitting main reservoir
pressure to the train line, while the ex-
haust is still blowing at the brake valve,
we will have a strange combination of
reduction of pressure in the rear part
of train pipe and increase pressure in
head end; or, in other words, brakes will
be still applying on the rear end while
they are releasing on the head end. This
condition will cause the slack of the train
to run out, giving the jar referred to,
and generally causing a break-in-two if
the train be a long one.
(48) A. J. B., Columbus. O.. asks:
Should air-brake hose be any stronger
or thicker where the high-speed brake
is used? A. — It was at one time believed
that stronger hose than the standard
form should be used for high-speed brake
service. Several years ago. when the
New York Central equipped its Empire
State Express with high-speed brakes,
it applied to one of the prominent rub-
ber concerns for a stronger hose, believ-
ing that 110 pounds train line pressure
would require a stronger hose than
would a 70-pound brake. The rubber
company somewhat reluctantly consented
to make a 5-pIy hose for this high-speed
service. At the end of the year the hose
was removed regardless of its condition
and placed in ordinary service, new S-ply
hose taking its place. After four or five
years' experience it was decided to aban-
don the 5-ply hose, as it seemed to give
no advantage over the 4-ply, and it was
believed the latter was sufficiently ade-
quate for high-speed service. There is,
therefore, but one class of hose for the
service of both high-speed and ordinary
forms of brakes.
(49) W. J. H., Wellington, New Zea-
land, writes:
A driver, after releasing brakes, lets
his train charge up to 70 pounds, and
then puts his handle smartly into run-
ning position, when the first three or
four brakes will go on, but if he puts
his handle slowly in the running position
they stay off. What is the cause? A. —
No mention is made whether the brake
valve is of the type with the common
excess pressure valve or with the im-
proved feed-valve attachment. If the
former valve is used, the trouble is prob-
ably due to leakage in the train pipe.
The pressure pumped up in the main
reservoir after the handle has been
moved to running position must give 20
pounds more there than is in the train
pipe before any feed is had from the
main reservoir into the train pipe. While
this 20 pounds excess is being pumped,
the brakes may creep on if there is train
pipe leakage. The fast or slow move-
ment of the handle from full release
would have no effect on this, except per-
haps that during a slow movement, the
pressure passing back through full re-
lease position would have better oppor-
tunity to equalize in a train of any con-
siderable length. This may be the cause
of the trouble. On the other hand, if the
brake valve is of the type having a slide-
valve feed valve attachment, the trouble
is probably due to the higher pressure
in the train pipe while the valve is in
full release position, than the feed-valve
attachment is set for. In this case leaks
in the train pipe would have to lower the
train pipe pressure sufficiently to permit
the feed-valve attachment to open and
give a feed from the main reservoir into
the train line.
Note: Most of our general matter has
been crowded out this month by Air
Brake Association convention matter,
but will appear in next month's issue.
Don't fail to get your regular copy of
the Air-Brake Association proceedings of
the Colorado Springs convention.
272
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 19C3.
Southern Railway Improvements.
"- The work of double-tracking the
Washington division of the Southern
Railway between Alexandria and
Orange, begun early in the spring, is
being pushed forward as rapidly as pos-
sible, and those in charge of the work
state it will be completed by September
30. In putting down the second track,
the curves have been abolished as much
as possible, and it is the purpose of the
railroad company to make the old track
conform to the new road as soon as the
latter line is finished.
Plans are. now in preparation in the
office of the chief engineer to double-
track the road from Orange through to
Atlanta. All plans will be finished this
year, and the appropriation for the work
made by the board of finance at its win-
ter meeting. Much money has been
spent this year for the purchase of loco-
motives and rolling stock. An average
of five engines are delivered each week
to the road, and as soon as they are re-
ceived they are broken into service.
The company are preparing to im-
prove a large mileage of the road by
putting stone ballast under the track.
The Sinclair Construction Company, of
Chicago, are erecting a large stone
crusher in North Carolina, and it is ex-
pected that several other plants will be
installed in the near future.
The Delaware. Lackawanna & West-
ern does a large share of the business of
hauling suburbanites out of New York
to the breezy uplands of New Jersey.
The railroad takes the passengers at
Hoboken from the Ferry Company,
which has given rather an indifferent
service. The railroad company have now
purchased all the franchises and prop-
erty belonging to the ferry company,
and the multitude of people who have
. to cross the Hudson River at that point
are anticipating considerable saving of
time on account of the change.
A Lecture on riechanlcs.
Not long ago, Mr. Roger Atkinson,
master mechanic of the Reading shops
of the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad,
delivered a very interesting address to
the employees of the company on the
science of mechanics. The lecture was
delivered under the auspices of the Rail-
road Y. M. C. A., and was so well re-
ceived that it is probable Mr. Atkinson
will be asked to deliver another.
After some preliminary remarks, and
after defining the terms "matter" and
"force," the lecturer proceeded to explain
the method of measuring force; to do this
it is necessary to get a standard which
is easily comprehended, and easily dupli-
cated, we therefore select one of the
forms of force which exist in nature —
the attraction of gravitation. We use
"gravity" in the form commonly called
"weight" for many purposes to measure
force. As every particle of matter at-
tracts every other particle of matter m
the universe, it follows that the apple
which Sir Isaac Newton observed, as it
fell to the earth, caused the earth to
"fall up" to meet it, but the amount of
movement being inversely proportional
to the weight of the body, the earth's
motion would be imperceptible.
This was illustrated graphically by an
oval containing five points and another
oval containing three points. If lines
be drawn from the five-particle body
marked A, to the three-particle body
marked B, so that lines from each of
A's particles reached each of B's par-
ticles, we would have 15 lines of mutual
attraction between the two bodies. As
B consists of only three particles, it is
obvious that the 15 lines of attraction
will have more eflFect upon B than
DIAGRAM ILLUSTRATING ATTRACTION.
upon the 5 particles of A. Tliereiorc
B will move toward A, more than A will
move toward B.
Our standard weight of one pound only
balances one pound of attractive lorce
at the sea level and at a given fatitude or
distance from the equator. It does not
weigh the same in a mine, or the same
on a mountain top, nor at the equator
nor at the poles. A body weighing one
pound at the sea level at the latitude of
Greenwich when hung on a spring bal-
ance, produces a certain extension of that
spring which may be noted. At the pole
it would pull harder and extend the
spring further; with less spring exten-
sion at the equator or on the top of a
high mountain, according as it ap-
proaches or recedes from the center of
gravity of the earth. The speaker very
clearly difTerentiated "mass" from weight
by showing that if one pound weight
were transported to the actual center of
gravity of the earth, the particles of
the earth pulling it in every direction
would simply neutralize each other, and
the "pound" would weigh nothing,
though its mass would remain un-
changed.
The pound weight, this measure of the
force of gravity is a purely arbitrary
standard adopted for convenience. A
piece of platinum which "weighs" ex-
actly one pound at Greenwich is de-
posited in the office of the Exchequer
for reference in England. (A similar
reference standard is kept at Washing-
ton.) In the metric system the unit of
weight is one gramme, and this also is
a purely arbitrary unit, in the same way
that the pound is.
Powerful Electric Locomotives.
The electric motors which the Balti-
more & Ohio put in service several
years ago for haulins- trains through the
Baltimore tunnel proved too weak for
the service and the company are replac-
ing them with electric locomotives de-
signed to give much more efficient ser-
vice. These motors are the heaviest ever
built, and with the three 96-ton motors
now in use will enable the company to
haul all the freight and passenger trains
from Camden Station to the top of the
grade without the steam locomotive ren-
dering any assistance.
The new ele'ctric locomotive fs made
up of two independent duplicate sections
coupled together, each section being
equipped with four 65 horse power
motors, so arranged that either section
can be operated independently, or from
any one section two or more sections
can be controlled. The capacity of the
locomotive can at any time be increased
by adding duplicate sections as desired.
Two sections of the locomotive, weigh-
ing together 150 tons, are designed to
handle a loaded train weighing, complete
with steam locomotive, but exclusive of
electric locomotive, 1,500 tons, over the
Belt 'tine grade from Camden Station
through the tunnel to the summit, a dis-
tance of 3.44 miles, at approximately a
maximum speed of 10 miles per hour on
the .8 per cent, grade and 9 miles per
hour on the 1% per cent, grade when
operating at 62=; volts.
A neat little booklet called "Points on
Packing," has just been issued by Jen-
kins Brothers, whose New York office
is at 71 John street. Information con-
cerning the Jenkins '96 packing is given.
Its strength, flexibility, durability and
its ability to become vulcanized are duly
set forth. The firm supply gaskets of
any size and in any quantity on short no-
tice. They also make gasket tubing,
union rings, water-cock washers, discs
and pump valves. Write Jenkins
Brothers for the "Points," and the little
book will be sent free.
The Richmond Locomotive Works
officials are fighting the granting of
saloon licenses near the works. They
say that the saloon keepers smuggle
liquor into the works and it is subver-
sive of discipline.
June. IQ0,5.
RAH.VVAY AND LOCOMO'IIVR ENGINEERING
273
An Air Valve Setting Hachine.
A very simple and eflicient device for
revolving the main wheels of a locomo-
tive during the operation of valve set-
ting is that shown herewith, which is in
operation at the Carbondale shops of the
Delaware & Hudson. The idea was
worked out by master Uiechanic VV. C.
Innis, who applied an ordinary air motor
found in every shop where compressed
air is used. On the spindle of the motor
is fitted a worm which meshes into a
worm wheel, and the latter being keyed
to the roller shaft, imparts motion to
same when air is turned on. The
sprocket wheels and chain perform a like
office to the second shaft, and transmits
the turning eflfort to the drivers rest-
ing on the four rollers. One of the
beauties of this scheme is that the wheels
can be stopped at a tram center with ab-
solute accuracv. There are some ntlur
liawiuK, but took a header into his sub-
ject.
"Ladies and gentlemen, I have been
requested to entertain the association on
one evening during the present winter;
so here I am. It is not necessary for
me to disclaim being a public speaker in
the sense in which I am here this even-
ing, yet I couldn't deny having a small
habit of outdoor vocalization, as occa-
sion may require — or indoor, either. I
see too many familiar faces before me
to do any hocus pocusing with the
tnuli, or say I am not in the habit of
Kiving punctuated orations about hourly.
I am aware that the proportions of
many a well-developed bust of your
wives and sweethearts do not owe
their bewitching expansion to the affec-
tionate regard in which I am held.
However, ladies, you must remember
tli;it the devil niav not be as black
INNIS AIR VALVE SETTING MACHINE.
kinks devised by Mr. Tunis that we pro-
pose to give our readers from time to
time.
Terry Bennett's Address.
BY SHANDY MAGUIRE.
The bulletin board of the R. R. Y. .M.
C. A. contained the following notice re-
cently; "The last lecture of the course
will be delivered by Mr. Terrence Ben-
nett on the night of the loth inst. Sub-
ject, "A Heart to Heart Talk with the
Boys.' "
On the evening in question Mr. Ben-
nett didn't have to play to a beggarly
array of empty benches. He came in on
time, and found every seat occupied, with
a goodly sprinkling of the fair sex
among them. At the appointed moment
the choir, consisting of seven voices, ar-
rayed themselves around the organ, at
which a young heart-breaker, about de-
parting from her teens, presided. After
the choir sang most musically "Wife,
Children and Friends," the secretary of
the association stepped upon the rostrum
and announced the speaker. When ?iTr.
Bennett came forward he was warmly
greeted. He lost no time hemming and
as he is painted. When your mous-
tached deluders give a free rein to
a prevaricating tongue, and make the
round house foreman the storm center of
their venom, behind his back, you can
rest assured that, in the language of the
craft, 'they deserved a jacking-up and
they got it.' The Lord never had a se-
lection made for that position from the
church-going, sanctimonious souls of the
rail. He, in His wisdom and glory, did
not want to damn some men not all
bad, but who did not carry a very
heavy knapsack full of creed upon
their backs; so sooner than roast them
eternally He had them put where their
expiation of sin would be so thorough,
owing to the trials they were obliged to
undergo, that their through pass, good
on all trains to the New Jerusalem,
would be ready the moment they were
ready for it.
"We will now talk and listen to things
we know more about than discussing the
Kingdom Come. I shall devote my re-
marks to a brief discussion of the ability
of men required to recruit the service of
the Locomotive Department. There is
a glamor of romance for a young man in
looking at a locomotive engineer on
duty; and he aspires to be one. As the
surest way to get there, he applies for a
wiper's job. He gets it, after he replies
to a few questions, the most prominent
one being: 'Are you willing to give
honest service in return for the pay we
give you?' The answer is invariably
'Yes, sir.' Before he is one week in the
service he knows more about the parts
he is to wipe than the man who hired
him. The chances are more than favor-
able, that he has struck up a partnership,
which will have a pernicious effect on his
whole future existence on the road.
What a splendid opportunity a new en-
gineer has to educate himself, if he is
only inclined! He is in what can be
truly called 'the kindergarten of locomo-
tive engineering.' An enquiring mind
can note the machinery attached to the
main driving axle, the eccentric cams,
the straps surrounding the same, the
blades reaching from the straps to the
links, the block within the links, its at-
tachment to the rocker arm, the rocker
arm to the valve rod, then try and fancy
the movement given to the valve within
the steam chest, and why; all impelled
by the motion of the axle, and the axle
moved by them, making an interdepend-
ence harmonious and grand. An am-
bitious young man will, while in the pit,
or wiping the parts available from the
floor, begin to learn the names of them,
and to grow more familiar with them.
Do they all do it? Not on your life!
Seven out of every ten become thorough-
bred "Sogers" before fifteen days
elapse, and by some mysterious method
of acquiring pernicious knowledge, can
tell just the spots to wipe, and give a
lick and a promise to all the others. If
they are reprimanded for not doing work
as it should be done, with a fluency of
gab worthy of a better cause, they can
tell just what they must touch and what
avoid. Circumstances mostly relating
to the labor market may necessitate a
grin-and-bear-it sort of resignation on
the part of the foreman. He may have
been a graduate from the pit himself, and
iKid a very fair knowledge of how work
should be done long years before the
fathers and mothers of the wipers began
throwing sheep's eyes at each other,
strolling within the confines of some
sweet-briar scented boreen in Paddy's
land, or had yet arrived at the dignity
of shoes, to protect their naked feet from
the stone splinters of the roads in Italy,
when cadging for grub.
"We will now suppose that the neces-
sity of the service requires a fireman.
With the elasticity of young manhood he
jumps from the pit onto the deck. He
is allotted his engine and his engineer.
He goes out on his first trip and begins
to find that he cannot sit upon the seat,
gazing at the people and the houses as
he passes. The gauge requires a little
274
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
of his attention, and tlie pointer is his
bane. He learns that if he wishes to
make a return trip he cannot devote so
much of his time to the pantomimic
movements of his idle hands, when he
sees a female form at the doors or the
windows of the adjacent houses. Be-
sides, the lad in chief command, occupy-
ing the seat upon the right, is becoming
a little restive. He manages to get back
to the place of departure, but the illu-
sion of the past, which glamorized his
whole time in the pit, is knocked galley
west. He tells his tale of woe into will-
ing ears, and he is consoled by the
listeners' telling him that the engineer
does not know his business, and is to
blame for all the discomforts he com-
plained of, and assured that it was a
wheelbarrow to which the engineer
should have been assigned, but was
given a locomotive to manipulate
instead. He drinks in the nectared
draught, and it does him good.
Now, ladies and gentlemen, we will go
meandering away from the main track
of my subject to dally a few minutes
upon the siding. How often have we
perused the eloquently written essays of
enthusiasts on how to recruit the ser-
vice? One in particular, which was got-
ten up in the most beautiful style of or-
nate language, by a chap in the General
Manager's office, doing subordinate
duty, attracted my attention. It was
read before one of the prominent rail-
way clubs of the country, and received
marked notice from all exchanges, who
used parts of the same. But for the fact
that I have pocketbook proof that the
pass privilege is annulled, I would not
mention the reason that editors of com-
mendable papers quote it. It was glor-
ious reading. It described the sort of a
biped the applicant tor a wiper's job
should be. His grandfather's and grand-
mother's habits were to receive close at-
tention from the investigator. If their
blood was sufficiently pure to transfuse
into the veins of offspring, it was to be
noted; the adolesence of the father and
mother was to get most important at-
tention; then the offspring must have
positive proof that the union of his father
and mother had been mutual and a fam-
ily-raising certificate was awarded to
them, after a rigid investigation. The
young kid had to prove that he never in-
dulged ill any of the frisky tricks of
youth, which would impair his manly
vigor, or reduce his mental ability; and
if the investigation was up to the stand-
ard of the writer's ideas morally, men-
tally, physically, intellectually and other-
wise, the applicant was to be hired, so as
to put him on probation for a future en-
gineer. I got a little excited when read-
ing the essay, and Martha noticed me —
you all know who Martha is — she knew
by my actions the deep interest I was
taking in the paper stuck under my nose.
and naturally she enquired what inter-
ested me so. I said. Oh, for a celestial
incubator, to raise just such a crop of
recruits for the round house pits, as the
pen-pusher of this essay describes, was
my explanation, and after she heard me
read it, she seconded the motion, for she
had a pretty good idea of the difficulty
almost daily experienced, to get black-
strap, smoke-guzzlers for duty on the
night trick; and she requested me to send
the author a spring-scented bouquet with
her compliments.
"Now is the time for a young fellow to
get down to his work, to acquire a
knowledge of his business, and to edu-
cate himself for the coming fray. Nat-
urally he looks for promotion and the
right side of the engine is his objective
point. If he endeavors to obtain knowl-
edge of his calling, he has a splendid op-
portunity in these days, as compared with
a few years ago. He can secure books
which were written by practical men,
when in the harness. He can store up
in his mind the big nuggets of informa-
tion contained within their pages, for
future need, and can add to them his own
experience; and when the time arrives
for him to go across to the responsible
post of duty, he can have the consolation
of knowing that in any position he may
be placed in when plying the hazardous
vocation, he can do as well as men of
ability who were there before him. But,
if he fudges an examination, so that he
has succeeded in passing only, his skill
as a pilot, navigating schooners of beer
across the bar. will be but poor assist-
ance to him when confronted with the
many perplexities of the engine submit-
ted to his charge. I have my ideas of
what a locomotive engineer should be.
I do not want him a paragon. I am not
difficult to please. I want a sober, think-
ing man: one who is not satisfied with
being able to throttle and keep water on
the top of the crown sheet when making
time; but one who studies out the rela-
tion of one part to the other. One who.
when he goes to the report book, to en-
ter within it the defects of the engine he
came in with, can make his troubles un-
derstood by the repairers. I want a man
cheerful and respectful. One who is
willing to give the company more than
a perfunctory service for the compensa-
tion received. One who is not contin-
ually going around in search of ills to
be given to the Grief Committee to ad-
just. One who does not carry a schedule
of what he is not supposed to do, in his
vest pocket, for hourly reference. One
who will not vaporize the track with
steam blowing out from a piston or valve
stem for many a mile, perhaps frighten-
ing animals while passing, sooner than
make a jump and put in a turn or two at
the first opportunity, because the sched-
ule says it is not his business.
However, ladies and gentlemen, the
percentage of indifferent jaw-workers is
so small upon our locomotives, that I
can take my leave of them, to tes-
tify my unbounded admiration for
the noble army of men upon both
sides of our engines, plying their
calling upon our railroads to-day.
Never from the dawn of history have
nobler deeds of heroism been known
than are done by men in the cabs. Men,
for God or fatherland, go forth to meet
the foe. inspired by either religious zeal
or valor, keeping step to the drum beats
of heroic sounds, side by side with asso-
ciates who follow the flag to do or die,
knowing that the eyes of the world are
on them and ready to reward their ef-
forts; but where are they alongside the
two brave fellows who feel the jar that
indicates leaving the rails at a speed of
SO or 60 miles an hour, who know it is
but a question of seconds until their
mangled remains will be unrecognizable
by their dearest friends, and who, entire-
ly thoughtless of themselves, devote their
latest efforts to bring the train to a
stop as rapidly as possible, and if they
are not totally dead, as they are pinned
under the wreckage, tell the rescuers to
never mind them, but to get out a flag
-ind stop approaching trains from danger.
These are the men who deserve the
medals for heroic deeds, but very seldom,
if ever, receive them. I fervently feel
that when the last trump is sounded, to-
awake the dead for final judgment, as the
procession of the heroes of all ages and
climes is moving by the Grand Reviewer,
that the van of the limitless army will be
led by men of the locomotive cabs, who
upon the railroads of America, laid down
their lives to save the passengers and
prM)erty entrusted to their care; and
shall be saluted by the Reviewer with.
"Well done, thou good and faithful
servant; enter thou into the joy of thy
Lord."
The Long Island Railroad Company
has had a number of powerful passen-
ger locomotives built at the Baldwin
Locomotive Works in Philadelphia, and'
they will soon be added to the equip-
ment of the road. There are eight new
ten-wheelers, which are said to be of
the most powerful type made. They will
be used on the Montauk and main line-
and the north side branches.
The Toledo, Bowling Green & South-
ern Traction Company has recently pur-
chased, from the Westinghouse Electric
& Mfg. Co., a 250-kilowatt rotary con-
verter, which will be used for supplying;
current to its lines. Power will be re-
ceived in the form of alternating current
from the Maumee Valley Electric Com-
pany, which is installing a 250-kilowatt,
inverted, Westinghouse rotary-converter -
for the purpose, together with three 100- -
kilowatt raising transformers.
J line, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
»75
James nillholland.
DY E. J. RAUCH.
The name of James Millhollaiul de-
servedly stands pre-eminent among
those who contributed to the evolution,
success and superiority of the American
type of locomotive; especially those that
successfully used anthracite coal as a fuel.
Of the early life of Mr. Millholland
not much can be said, as it was compara-
tively uneventful until he engaged in
railroad business. He was born in the
city of Baltimore, on the 6th of October,
1812; and when of proper age entered
the shops of a builder of steamboats and
machinery in general, as an apprentice.
The first notice of James Millholland
recorded in books concerning pioneer
locomotive improvers, is that he was an
apprentice under George W. Johnson,
who had a machine shop in Baltimore,
a substitute for the wrought one.
He made the trial, and when he left the
I'altimore & Susquehanna Railroad the
cast-iron cranks were doing good serv-
ice, and there is no record of one of
them breaking.
In the spring of 1848 Mr. Millholland
was called by the Philadelphia & Read-
ing Railroad to take charge of their roll-
ing stock as master mechanic. He found
a very poor shop, with old tools and in-
ferior appliances for getting out work.
Fortunately, in a year or two after his
advent in Reading, the shops burned
down, and he rebuilt them to his liking.
The company had a forge in which were
iicveral steam "helve" hammers (the
"Nasmyth" steam hammer was not then
known). These hammers did good serv-
ice in faggotting scrap iron, and making
car axles and other forgings for the
success as far as he was able to supply
the engines. He then put up a double-
headed lathe and brought a man from
the Baltimore & Susquehanna shops to
run it. This man introduced a side-
cutting tool that took off a shaving 5^
to ^ inch wide, and from ^ to ft
inch thick. This relieved the tire ques-
tion of its most knotty points.
There was a large amount of steel
scrap lying in the yard for which there
was no sale. Millholland had a Berks
county forgeman turn a lot of this scrap
into blooms from which he had a set
of tires made and put on a Baldwin
6-wheel engine, "The United States," and
these were the first steel tires of which
there is any record; this was between
1853 and 1854.
The Philadelphia & Reading's power
was a heterogeneous combination. En-
Sorrin R\ tAI.lMlRNI.\ KNGINE equipped with .SHEEDY cylinder CIRCILATOR. THIS DEVICE ENABLES PISTON V.\LVE
ENGINES TO COAST AS FREELY AS A SLIDE VALVE ENGINE.
and to whom Peter Cooper turned over
the "Tom Thumb'' to be finished. James
Millholland, who was called a remarkably
bright boy, with a natural aptitude for
mechanics, was Mr. Johnson's principal
helper.
A few years after his majority James
Millholland became the master mechanic
of the Baltimore & Susquehanna Rail-
road. While with that company he de-
veloped the Napoleonic character that he
kept through life, and which contributed
so largely to his success. When he be-
came imbued with an idea, he followed it
to the end, whether it led to success or
failure; determined to know what was in
it; and it is not known that any one ever
made a success of any idea that he failed
in.
In those days there were many crank-
axle locomotives in use. Owing to the
imperfect and crude means of forging
these cranks, many of them broke after
short service. Mr. Millholland conceived
the idea of trying a cast-iron crank as
blacksmith shops. Millholland saw
where an improvement could be made in
the forge. He soon learned that jeal-
ousy between the forgemen was a detri-
ment to good results; that each hammer
man felt that he ought to be "it." This
was a condition bequeathed to him by
his predecessor. He solved the problem
by placing the forge under the control
of the foreman blacksmith — Jimmy Mul-
lin — who soon made matters work
smoothly. One of the troubles to con-
tend with was the locomotive tire.
"Low Moor" iron was used exclusively,
and much of it was bad. so that the tires
mashed out in spots, necessitating turn-
ing ofif at frequent intervals. Added to
this there were no double-head lathes in
the shop on which to turn tires, and the
lathe men used a diamond-pointed tool
that took a cut about xJ-'nch deep.
Ten or twelve days were required to turn
off a set of tires for an 8-wheel engine.
Mr. Millholland tried making tries from
scrap in the forge, and it was a grand
gines were from Norris. Baldwin, New
Castle Manufacturing Co.. Eastwick &
Harrison, Braithwaite, Locks & Canales,
Ross Winans, Dotterer & Darling, and
perhaps others. In addition there was
a number of engines built by the com-
pany from designs of Tredgold.
These engines were all under the
control of separate foremen and gangs,
and they were all independent of each
other. When the new master mechanic
came the most of these foremen had a
chip on his shoulder. Suffice it to say
none of these chips were knocked off,
but in a very short time none of them
were in evidence.
About a year before the advent of
Mr. Millholland. the P. & R. had built
an experimental engine to burn anthra-
cite coal, and this was one of the legacies
bequeathed to him. The machinery was
carried on one frame and the boiler
on another. Of course he was ex-
pected to make it go. The thing had
been in service some little time under
276
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
her builders' administration, but was a
-lamentable failure. A few attempts un-
der Mr. M. to get the "Novelty" to make
any showing enabled him to convince her
projectors that the machine had better
be scrapped, and she was.
One of the bad features Mr. M.
had to meet was the drunkenness
among the engineers, not more so per-
haps than on most other railroads, but
too much for good service. He took a
number of steady young men from dif-
ferent departments of the shop — not con-
fining the selection to machinists — and
put them on engines under reliable men
to learn to run an engine and handle a
train. In a short time he had sober men
to replace some of the lushers; and the
effect was salutory.
In those days brass valves in steam
chests and solid brass boxes on loco-
motive axles were in general use. Fil-
ing, scraping and grinding valve seats
was the practice. This was all changed.
Cast-iron valves in steam chest, solid
cast-iron boxes with two brass strips in
quarters and babbit in the crown were
put on axles, and a hand planer faced
the valve seats; and, much to the sur-
prise of many, all the changes were suc-
cesses. The first engine to be rebuilt by
Mr. Millholland was a Norris 6-wheeler.
In those days all engines had hook valve
motion, and only one on the Reading
road had a cut-oflf. The engine rebuilt
was fitted with a cut-ofT — Va stroke — and
was a success, saving at least 25 per cent,
of fuel. He changed one or two Bald-
win engines to cut-offs, out they were
not a success on account of the steam
ports being too limited.
On the first engine rebuilt by Mr.
Millholland, as well as all subsequent
ones, rebuilt or new, he put a dome on
the boiler, forward, and put in a balanced
throttle valve that took steam, by an
arrangement of the dry pipes, from
both domes. With this arrangement the
boilers carried their water nearly at same
level with open or closed throttle.
He made a number of minor experi-
ments to burn anthracite coal in the
wood-burner fire-boxes, and finally re-
built a Baldwin 8-wheeler, the "Warrior."
The fire-box was kept within the frame
line until it reached back to rear of hmd
driver; there it spread to about five
inches outside of the track. There was
a grate door in rear of tire-box resting
on the grates, and two solid doors on
this grate door to put the coal through.
This engine was the greatest success of
any attempt to burn anthracite coal up
to her advent.
In 1852 the company had their charter
amended to enable them to build new
engines, and the work on them com-
menced. It was thought that Millholland
made a grave error in not following the
beaten path that he had so largely helped
to lay out. He attempted to make a suc-
cess of what had been in England a fail-
ure, viz., water table boilers with a com-
bustion chamber in interior of the
boiler and in rear of the flues. There
were seven of these engines built, and
they were all failures. They could not
be made to steam. The machinery of
them could not be excelled. Not profit-
ing by the experience with these en-
gines, he built two passenger engines
with boilers on same principle, i.e., water
tables and combustion chambers. They
were named "Illinois" and "Michigan;"
and were probably the handsomest loco-
motives ever built. The driving wheels
were of wrought iron 7 feet in diameter.
Cylinders, 17V2 by 30 inches — weight,
about 35 tons. The boilers would not
make steam, and the cylinders were
bushed down to 14 inches. Water tables
taken out and replaced by a nest of
3V'2-inch flues; combustion chamber was
left in place. The wrought-iron wheels
proving too weak, were replaced with
cast iron of 6 feet diameter. The en-
gines were finally put into a mixed pas-
senger and freight service, where they
finally wore out.
In the building of engines for the road
Mr. Millholland retained his love for the
combustion chamber between two sets of
flues; but finally gave it up and fell back
to the straight flue, with as much grate
surface as he could get. Then he built
engines for all kinds of service that were
peerless, and it is an open question if
there are any better built now.
In 1865 Mr. Millholland resigned from
his position of master mechanic and as-
sistant superintendent, and went to the
Mt. Savage Railroad as master mechanic.
He remained there only a few years
when he resigned and returned to Read-
ing. After a short time he engaged in
the banking business for several years.
Mr. Millholland amassed a competency
■ — a handsome one; but money never
affected his disposition. Those who
knew him when he came to Reading and
kept in touch with him to the end, never
saw any change. He had no extrava-
gant habits nor the taste for any, and
yet was a jolly good fellow, when jollity
was in order.
As a railroad official he w-as just and
impartial in dealing with the men. No
matter how much he disliked a man per-
sonally, that dislike did not affect the
man's treatment, and vice versa.
If there is such a thing as luck, good
or bad, good luck seemed to hang to
Mr. Millholland's skirts; everything he
took hold of came his way. One instance
will suffice to explain. He bought the
patent of a wooden spring for coal cars
for a few hundred dollars, sold royalty to
the P. & R. for a handsome price. Be-
fore the war he became one of the in-
corporators of the Leesport Iron Co.,
and was to put in the engines and blow-
ing cylinders. He traded the right to
make his wooden car spring for these
engines and cylinders; tnen made a con-
tract with the iron company to take
his pay in pig iron— on call — at the then
market price, about $i8(2,$20 per ton.
The war broke out, pig iron began to
raise in price, and Millholland waited
until his pig iron brought him $60 to
$70 per ton. He once laughingly said
that he had taken his pigs to a good
market.
Mr. Millholland's declining years were
marked by ill-health. His disposition to
think his own way stuck to him to the
end. His physicians — and he . had the
best in the country — all agreed that his
trouble was of the lungs and treated him
accordingly. He claimed his liver was
the source of trouble. An autopsy
proved he was right. He died August
18, 1875, sixty-five years of age.
New York, May 11, 1903.
Watering Can Necessary at Times.
On board one of the northern pleasure
steamers, which have to be built with ex-
ceedingly light draught to get over the
frequent shallows of the river, a Yankee
tourist remarked to the captain, a shrewd
old Scotchman:
"I reckon, skipper, that you think
nothing of steaming across a meadow
when there's been a heavy fall of dew?"
"That's so," replied the captain,
'though occasionally we hae to send a
man ahead wi' a watering can." — London
Tit B-its.
The Southern Pacific Company, vvith
which the public invariably associate the
Sunset, Ogden and Shasta routes, has
just issued through its passenger depart-
ment trbig tree book in which the forest
giants of California are partly repro-
duced in very clear half-tone illustra-
tions. We say partly reproduced, be-
cause the only way one can get a whole
California tree in a photograph is to
snap shot it, end on. The big tree book
is a tastefully executed souvenir of the
Mariposa big tree grove in the Yosem-
ite Valley. The book tells how to see
the big trees, and is most interesting and
instructive as well. Send for a copy to Mr.
E. O. McCormick, passenger traffic man-
ager, San Francisco, or to any of the
passenger agencies of the company if
vou are interested.
The Southern Railroad Company ap-
pears to be adopting the policy of con-
tracting to some extent for repairs on
their locomotives. They have given the
Kelley Locomotive Works a contract
for repairing all their locomotives on
the Mobile and Birmingham division
that lie over at Anniston.
Where's the good of putting things
off? Strike while the iron's hot. —
Barnaby Riidge.
June, I'jo,?.
RAILWAY AND r.OCOMOTIVR ENGINEERING
277
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. I'alrick KcUcy lias been appointeil
shop foreman on the EI Paso & North-
eastern, at Alamogordo, N. M.
Mr. C. S. Lake has been appointed
trainmaster of the main line of the Dan-
ville division on the Southern Railway.
Mr. Neil La Bauni has been appointed
roimd-hoiisc foreman on the El Paso &
Northeastern, at Alamogordo, vice Mr,
R. Ross, resigned.
Mr. G. L. Potter, formerly general
manager of the Baltimore & Ohio, has
been advanced to the position of third
vice-president of that road.
Mr. H. J. L. Roberts has been ap-
pointed general foreman of the Canadian
Pacific Shops at Revelstoke, B. C, vice
Mr. S. J. Hungcrford, promoted.
Mr. H. H. Ma.xtield has been appointed
assistant engineer of motive power on
the U. R. R. of N. J. Division of the
Pennsylvania, vice Mr. John L. Mohun.
resigned.
Mr. H. A. Williams, superintendent of
the Norfolk Division of the Southern
Railway, has had his headquarters
changed from Greensboro to Pinners
Point, Va.
Mr. E. E. Herr, round-house foreman
at Cold Port, N. J., on the Pennsylvania,
has been transferred in the same capacity
to Camden, N. J., vice Mr. F. A. Smock,
promoted.
Mr. J. Cooper, formerly of the draw-
ing office staff, Pennsylvania Railroad,
has been appointed foreman of the
Waldo avenue round house, in Jersey
City, N. J.
Mr. G. B. Williams, formerly chief
clerk for the master mechanic of the
Canadian Pacific, at Toronto Junction.
has been transferred to Winnipeg, in the
same capacity.
Mr. D. L. Bush has been appointed
general superintendent of the Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway, with
headquarters at Chicago, III., vice Mr.
J. N. Barr, promoted.
Mr. F. A. Smock has been promoted
from the position of round-house fore-
man at Camden, N. J., to that of gen-
eral foreman of the Meadow Shops of the
Pennsylvania at Jersey City. N. J.
Mr. F. J. Buchbaum, round-house fore-
man on the Pennsylvania at the Waldo
avenue shop in Jersey City, has been
transferred to Cold Port, in the same
capacity, vice Mr. Herr, transferred.
Mr. Otto E. Walter has been ap-
pointed assistant foreman of the boiler
shop of the Brooks Works of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company, vice Mr. F.
G. Bird, transferred to Schenectadv.
Mr. J. iv. S.iK'ue, mechanical engineer
of the .Xnierioan Locomotive Company,
has gone on a two-months' trip to
Europe to study foreign-built locomo-
tives in the interest of his company.
Mr. J. W. Harkom, formerly mechan-
ical assistant to the manager C. P. R.
lines east of Winnipeg, has been ap-
pointed general superintendent of the
Canada Foundry Company's works at
Tcironto.
Mr. H. B. Brown, formerly on the
B. & O., has been appointed master me-
chanic on the Mahoning Division of the
Erie Railroad at Cleveland. Ohio, vice
-Mr. F. Johnson, assigned to other duties.
Mr. G. H. fledge, formerly locomo-
tive foreman nn the C. P. R. at Brandon,
Man., has been appointed locomotive
foreman on the Canadian Northern at
Port .Arthur, vice Mr. J. W. Blythe, re-
signed.
Mr. W. C. Parsons has been appointed
superintendent of motive power and ma-
chinery of the El Paso & Northeastern
system, with headquarters at ."Ma-
mogordo, N. M., vice Mr. H. Ridgeway,
resigned.
Mr. M. J. Horsey has been appointed
chief draughtsman of Canada .\tlantic
Railway, with headquarters at Ottawa.
Mr. Horsey was formerly with the
Canadian Locomotive Company at
Kingston.
Mr. S. J. Hungerford. rormerly general
foreman of the Revelstoke Shops of the
Canadian Pacific, has been appointed act-
ing master mechanic for line west of
Broadview, with headquarters at Cal-
gary .■\lta.
Mr. W. S. Cooper, formerly train-
master at ^lilwaukee on the Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway, has been
appointed division superintendent of the
river division, vice Mr. J. H. Foster,
promoted.
Mr. J. H. Foster, division superintend-
ent on the Chicago. Milwaukee & St.
Paul, at Minneapolis, has been promoted
to the position of assistant general super-
intendent on the same road, vice Mr. H.
B. Earling, transferred.
Mr. B. C. Gesner, who for some time
has held the positions of air-brake in-
spector and master mechani-c of the east-
ern division of the Intercolonial Railway
of Canada, has resigned his position to
accept service with the Galena Oil Com-
pany.
Mr. Jacob Merle has been appointed
general foreman of the Alamogordo
shop on the El Paso & Northeastern
system. He was formerly connected
with the G. H. & S. A. and the National
railroads. He is a shop manager ol con-
siderable experience.
Mr. C. C. Elwcll, assistant superin-
tendent of the Shore Line Division of
the New York, New Haven & Hartford,
has been appointed superintendent of the
Air Line, Northampton Division, with
olifice at New Haven, Conn., vice Mr.
W. A. Waterbury. resigned.
Mr. J. E. Mulfeld, formerly superin-
tendent of rolling stock of the Inter-
colonial Railway of Canada, has been
appointed superintendent of motive
power on the Baltimore & Ohio for the
Cleveland, Chicago & Newark districts,
with headquarters at Newark, N. J.
Mr. H. E. Earling, formerly assistant
general superintendent on the Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway at
Marion, Iowa, has been appointed assist-
ant general superintendent of the same
road, with headquarters at Milwaukee,
Wis., vice Mr. D. L. Bush, promoted.
Mr. George R. Webster has been ap-
pointed right-of-way superintendent on
the Canadian Pacific Railway. This is a
new title on the road. Mr. Webster will
deal with the constantly increasing quan-
tity of real estate. He will have to do
with the laying out of new real estate
acquisitions, and will report upon pros-
pective purchases.
Mr. J. N. Barr has been advanced from
the position of general superintendent
of the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul
Railway to that of assistant to the presi-
dent. Mr. Barr will supervise the mo-
tive power and rolling stock department
of the company, and the West Milwau-
kee Shops will be very much enlarged
and put in condition to build all loco-
motives required by the road.
Mr. W. O. Duntley. vice president and
general manager of the Chicago Pneu-
matic Tool Company, has just returned
from a short business trip abroad in the
interests of his company. While on the
Continent Mr. Duntley visited several of
the most prominent shipyards, manu-
facturing establishments. etc.. and
brought back with him a large number
of orders for the various pneumatic appli-
ances manufactured by his company.
Mr. Thomas Tail, the former manager
of transportation on the Canadian Pacific,
was given a complimentary banquet at
the St. James' Club. Montreal, on the
occasion of his departure for Australia,
where he will be chairman of the
Victoria Railroad Commission. Fare-
well speeches were made by Sir Thomas
Shaughnessy and the three vice-presi-
dents. Happy things were said, and
278
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
prosperity and success was predicted for
the guest of the evening.
Mr. C. W. Werst, who has been gen-
eral foreman of the locomotive depart-
ment of the San Bernardino Shops of
the Santa Fe, has resigned his position
to accept the important post of inspector
of work in the erecting department in
the Baldwin Locomotive Works. Mr.
Werst has for fourteen years been con-
nected with the Santa Fe, and is a warm
friend of Railway and Locomotive
Engineering. His many friends wish
him every success in his new position.
Mr. H. P. Knight has been appointed
division master mechanic of the Balti-
more & Ohio Railroad at New Castle
Junction, succeeding Mr. H. B. Brown.
Mr. Knight began railroad work as an
apprentice in the Altoona Shops of the
Pennsylvania, and has held the positions
of assistant foreman of erecting shop
on the Norfolk & Western, general fore-
man of locomotive repairs, on the
Chicago & Alton, and foreman of the
machine department in the Baldwin Lo-
comotive Works.
Mr. J. W. Leonard, formerly general
superintendent of the Central Division
of the Canadian Pacific Railway, has
been appointed assistant general manager
of lines west of Winnipeg, with head-
quarters in that city. Mr. Leonard
joined the service of the Canadian Pa-
cific when that company took over the
Credit Valley, a north Ontario line, in
December, 1880. Previous to that he had
filled various positions on the Credit
Valley. He was made superintendent at
Montreal in 1890, general superintend-
ent at Toronto in 1893. and at Winnipeg
in 1900.
Mr. F. A. Delano, general manager of
the C, B. & Q. Railroad, recently gave
an address before the engineering stu-
dents of Purdue University upon The
Comparative Development of American
and European railways. Mr. Delano
is one of that class of general managers
who came from the ranks of the motive
power department. His accurate and
comprehensive knowledge of railway
matters makes him easily master of such
a subject.
Mr. T. A. Summerskill, superintendent
of motive power of the Central Vermont,
was seriously injured recently as the re-
sult of a peculiar shooting accident at
his home in St. .Mbans, Vt. His
house was visited by a burglar early
one morning. Mr. Summerskill, on
discovering a man on the premises,
called loudly for help, in order to
to prevent the burglar making his escape.
Mr. Harry Hall, a neighbor, armed with
a revolver, ran to render assistance. In
the darkness each supposed the other to
be the burglar, and in the fight which
ensued, Mr. Summerskill was shot. The
burglar, however, escaped.
Robert J. Gross, second vice-presi-
dent of the American Locomotive Com-
pany, and his secretary, Charles M.
Muchnic, mechanical engineer, are in
Japan, meeting officers of the Japanese
railroads, where 258 locomotives of the
American Locomotive Works are now
in service. From Japan Mr. Gross and
Mr. Muchnic will go to Corea, China
and Siam, returning to North China and
to Russia over the Trans-Siberian Rail-
way. From there he will go to Europe
and North Africa. The trip will take a
year. Mr. Gross is looking for busi-
ness, and finds that the prospects for his
company receiving orders for many lo-
comotives from the far east are very
encouraging.
Mr. J. L. Mohun recently severed his
connection with the Pennsylvania Rail-
road to accept a position as mechanical
engineer with the Western Steel Car &
Foundry Co., whose main offices are in
the Old Colony Building, Chicago, with
works at Hegewisch, 111. Mr. Mohun
entered the service of the Pennsylvania
as a special apprentice at their Altoona
Shops on February 6, 1890, was made
inspector on the P. R. R. division in
August, 1897; assistant master mechanic,
Juniata Shops, March, 1899; master me-
chanic at Lambertville Shop, January
1900, and was promoted to the position
of assistant engineer of motive power for
the U. R. R. of N. J. division in August,
1900, which position he held up to the
time he left railway work.
Mr. Frank S. Gannon, formerly third
vice-president and general manager of
the Southern Railway and the Northern
Alabama Railway, and general manager
of the Alabama Great Southern, has
been made vice-president of the Inter-
urban Street Railway Company, with
office in New York. The Interurban is
the company operating the Metropolitan
street railway of New York and other
allied lines. Mr. Gannon entered rail-
way service in 1868, since which time he
has been telegraph operator on the
Erie; clerk in the president's office. New
York, Susquehanna & Western; ter-
minal agent, superintendent's clerk and
train dispatcher on the Long Island
road; train dispatcher, depot master,
train master, master of transportation
and supervisor of trains on the B. & O.:
general superintendent, New Y'ork City
and Northern; general superintendent,
general manager, Staten Island Rapid
Transit; general superintendent of the
New York division of the B. & O., and
president of the Staten Island Railway.
Mr. Gannon brings to his new position
the fruits of a large and varied experi-
ence in practical railway work. He has
been a strong advocate of train men
studying the principles of their business
and has urged them to read railroad
papers. This has brought us hundreds of
subscribers.
Softening Feed Water.
The Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul
Railroad Company have devoted more
intelligent efTort toward mitigating the
bad influences of impure boiler feed
water than any railroad company in the
world. The matter has been long under
the direction of a very efficient depart-
ment of chemistry, under whose direction
feed water has been treated so that the
boilers give less trouble and make more
milage than the locomotive boilers be-
longing to any railroad in the Northwest.
The company appear now to have come
to the conclusion that even their best
efforts can be made better and that those
who make the softening of feed water
their particular business are likely to do
the work more efficiently than the chem-
ists belonging to the road. They have
accordingly given a contract to the
Kennicott Water Softener Co. for the
installment of one plant, and if it proves
as satisfactory as they expect others will
be put in, so that the regions where the
feed water is particularly bad will be
robbed of their terrors for enginemen.
The department of chemistry is a very
useful one when it keeps to the business
of analyzing the quality of material sup-
plied to the company. There is, however,
considerable temptation for the members
of the chemistry department of a railroad
to become manufacturers when they find
out the exact cost of the material their
employers are purchasing. The chemist
frequently sees big profits that do not
realize in practice. When a railroad
chemist succeeds in inducing the railroad
company he serves to become manufac-
turers of oil, paint, soap or other material
which can be bought by competition in
the open market, he is leading his su-
perior officers to engage in an enterprise
likely to be expensive in the end. When
he interests himself financially in start-
ing the manufacture of goods to be sup-
plied to his company, or of appliances
which he can influence his company to
purchase on the pretense that they are
superior to others on the market, he is
using his influence against his employers
for his own personal benefit. The laws
of competition may be depended upon to
provide railroad companies with all kinds
of material and appliances at reasonabi''
rates, so there is no advantage in permit-
ting their employees to become their
manufacturers.
We have on our list at present several
good men looking for positions as gen-
eral foreman or master mechanic. We
do not recommend any but efficient men,
so superintendents of motive power look-
ing for help will find it an advantage to
correspond with us.
There is no royal road to learning, and
what is life but learning. — Our Mutua!
Friend.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
279
Over the Nickel Plate.
(Second Section.)
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
After a remarkably short wait at Buf-
falo, considering that it is the terminus
of one railroad and the beginning of an-
other, we were again speeding west-
ward, this time on the New York,
Chicago & St. Louis Railroad, popularly
known as the Nickel Plate Line. As the
train was working into speed amidst the
labyrinth of tracks, I could not help
going mentally backward to a time when
there were no sleeping cars running
through long distances. Now the pas-
senger jemains in luxurious ease over
numerous junction points where he used
to change cars, often after tedious waits
and the worry of uncertainty of getting
into the proper train. Tt is only those
pares to make himself comfortable.
Takes oflf his boots and rests his feet on
his bag to keep them of? the floor. After
a brief trial finds his legs in the way, and
slides them up to the top of the seat in
front. Body and legs now form an in-
verted N, and he falls asleep. When the
conductor rouses him half an hour later
to ask for his ticket, he imagines that
his neck is broken, but it has only got
the cramps. He decides to try another
plan, so he takes his bag to use a? a
pillow. As he lays his cheek upon it, he
finds that the bag has picked from the
floor an abandoned chew. He says
two or three times, and then
he takes out his knife and scrapes ofT the
tobacco. After that he lies down and
stretches his legs over into the aisle.
"Comfort at last," he grunts, and has
just fallen asleep when a man comes
along to take a drink, and calls upon him
careless passenger as lumbermen bless,
prepares to warm up with a drink, but
finds that his bottle has got broken, and
he remarks again and walks in
the aisle to renew his circulation. By
the time he reaches Buffalo he has made
up his mind to adopt the practice of en-
gaging a sleeper a month ahead or of
staying at home."
But that is not doing justice to our
journey over the Nickel Plate Line. As
we are speeding along by the shining
Lake Erie, through a well-cultivated
country just rolling enough to banish
monotony, the Truthseeker, who is a
member of the party, asks, "Why Nickel
Plate?"
That calls for reference to another
note book which says: "Senator Brice
built the New York, Chicago & St. Louis
Railroad, paralleling the Lake Shore &
Michigan Southern from Buflalo to
TRESTLE ON NICKEL PLATE LINE.
GIRARD, PA., BRIDGE. NICKEL PLATE LINE.
SHOWING METHOD OF ERECTION.
who have traveled before the sleeping-
car era that realize the misery escaped
and discomforts avoided during a pro-
tracted journey.
There are many more people who
travel all night in day coaches than there
are in sleepers, the proportion is about
5 to I : but those who have to loimge
throughout the night on a seat three feet
long or even occupy the half of it, pass
through an ordeal not to be envied.
But go back still further to the ro-
mantic stage-coach days and think of a
night and day journey hemmed inside
of a coach rattling over iniquitous roads.
While on this subject my readers will
perhaps excuse me for giving an extract
from one of my note books about a night
journey in the region I am traveling in.
"At Port Jervis a six-foot-and-a-half
lumberman enters a sleeper, and is dis-
gusted to find all the berths taken.
Finds a seat in the day car, and pre-
to take his legs out of the passage. He
holds them in a perpendicular position
like the draw of the tower bridge until
the man gets through going and return-
ing. Again he goes to sleep, and has
hardly begun to snore, when another
passenger demands the right of way to
the water cooler. By the time that
eleven others have taken their turn, and
the trainmen have claimed the right of
way seven times, he decides that it is bet-
ter to sit up.
After a time he prevails upon a brake-
man to turn the back of the seat next
to his, which was empty. Taking his bag
for a pillow, he curls himself into an ir-
regular U, and occupies both seats. He
is now comfortable, and dreams that he
is visiting Florida; but presently the
scene changes to the .\rctic regions, and
he imagines himself searching for the
North Pole. On awakening with a start,
he finds that the passenger who went out
at Corning had forgotten to close the
door, and a zero wind is blowing in at
fortv miles an hour. He blesses the
Chicago, for the purpose of selling out to
the Vanderbilts, who own a controlling
interest in the Lake Shore. Operating
of the road began in 1882, but the scheme
of selling was slow of fruition. The
principal owner of the road kept up such
an annoying fight by means of rate cut-
ting, that after a struggle of seven years'
duration, and the rejection of repeated
offers, Mr. Vanderbilt yielded. In giv-
ing up he remarked that the price was
outrageous and enough to "nickel plate
the line from Buffalo to Chicago." The
expression got into the papers and the
name first used in derision became popu-
lar, and it will probably stick to the prop-
erty as long as it is a railroad.
Like all things made merely to sell,
the Nikel Plate was originally an inferior
railroad, and for a time the Vander-
bilts did not display any inclination to
improve it, but of late years a different
policy has been adopted and the property
is becoming first class in every particu-
lar.
Since Mr. W. H. Canniff. the present
2So
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
president, was elected in 1898, the road
has been practically rebuilt, being laid
with 65-pound steel rails throughout.
Although the railroad traverses a fairly
level country, it crosses a great many
water and ice excavated ravines that re-
quire expensive bridging and trestling.
That work was originally done as
cheaply as possible, and the company are
now making heavy expenditures on de-
sir.ible improvements. Since Mr. Can-
Most of the scenery is mild compared
to the imposing scenes of the Lacka-
wanna, which we had just passed
through; but there are many rugged
glens and other attractive spots that de-
light the eye of the traveler. Many of
the gorges crossed are grand, and are
the bottom of pretty valleys, while the
creeks and rivers, though comparatively
small, lend variety to the woods, green
pastures, spreading vineyards and wav-
^H
■
^^^^^^^M ^^^M
^ivi mtlgL^I
•*^fe-''
HIp
^1.^
iriPf^?- ¥^-
^7^^^
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^H
^^^^^^^K^'n
^ t '5 S
^^^^^^^^^H
^B^lt^
/,;•■ V ::■ ■
^^^^<^s^^^^^w
w-^
t* -l^ll
- ^ v€^x
■■■■>i.^
^^^1
■li. '^'■'^
v'i'
"^nHn
^^^H
\ ^^^Hwi
bI^"
^■^^^^
,r"^,'T^*"'^
MiS'iU'' -^^^^WV
B^ ■'
mg^K^HHir'''
^^^^^^H
. ^P^
K^t
Bl
u ■. " ^ ■
' '•\'^- ''ii^^
^
,^ ■ ^^vfi
'* '^ \ ^-'i
RVWYtlOtaErtCIWERlNC
^^^^^^^^HR^S
. .V.'
ABUTMENT 111' GIKARl), I'A., IlKIDGE, NICKEt PLATE Ll.N'E.
nifl took hold they have renewed seven-
teen iron bridges, replaced four wooden
trestles with iron, and filled forty-eight
wooden trestles, all of which was charged
to operating expenses. During this time
they have added materialy to the locomo-
tive, passenger and freight-car equip-
ment.
■ " Besides these important betterments,
they paid, in 1900, 5 per cent, on the
first preferred stock, 2 per cent, was paid
on the second preferred stock, being the
first time that was done in the history of
the road. The succeeding two years 5
per cent, was paid on the first, and 3
per cent, on the second, a magnificent
testimony to first-class management.
The illustrations of bridges which I am
able to present, through the courtesy of
Mr. Walter B. Wright, secretary to the
president, give a good idea of the mag-
nitude of that work; but there are many
others quite as large which I am com-
pelled to omit for want of room.
The speed of the trains is not high,
but it is fast enough for comfort, and is
little -.behind the fatest expresses in the
country. The smooth road-bed and easy-
riding cars make the journey of fifteen
hours from Buffalo to Chicago a pleas-
ant holiday outing, which even a feeble
invalid in my own party found enjoy-
able. The dining cars are operated on
the restaurant plan, and deserve to give
universal satisfaction, for a great variety
of well-prepared food is ready to satisfy
nearly every taste.
we are scarcely away from Buffalo when
we enter farms devoted to grape culture,
and they extend with little interruption
for hundreds of miles. Chautauqua
county, once famous for its cheese and
other dairy products, now raises little
else than wine in the lake townships.
There is a curious commentary on hu-
man nature in people turning from dairy-
ing to wine production. This Chautau-
qua county was largely settled by Scotch-
Irish, who are even more conscientious
than the single race they sprung from.
I knew a Scotch-Irish farmer in Iowa
who was in a district noted for raising
barley, but he would sow none, of it for
fear it should be turned into what he
called "Devil's Drink." There must have
been severe racking of consciences in
Chautauqua before the farmers changed
from the cow to the wine press.
In spite of the backsliding of Chau-
tauqua's lake border, the land along
which the Nickel Plate Line runs is still
flowing with .milk and honey, with ad-
ditions of wine and the oil known as pe-
troleum. There are also forests where
oak, black walnut, hickory, pine, hem-
lock and other trees of a marketable size
await the axe. One of the occupations I
have followed, during a somewhat varied
career, was that of a hunter of timber
VERMILLION TRESTLE, NICKEL PLATE LINE.
ing grains, that form the leading features
of the waysides. Lake Erie is in sight
for many miles, and its sparkling waters
convey the restful air which attracts the
weary, the sick and the overworked to
seek rest and health in river and lake re-
sorts.
Most of the journey of 523 miles from
Buffalo to Chicago is through land as
fertile and as intelligently cultivated as
anything to be found in the United
States, and other sources of wealth have
been bestowed abundantly upon the
dwellers in the different regions. The
ordinary traveler usually associates grape
culture with a semi-tropical climate, but
suitable for ties. To this day when I
look at a tree I make a mental estimate
of how many ties could be got out of
it. From personal observation I noted
that there are still many ties in growth
where the Nickel Plate runs. There are
also numerous farms where corn grows
high and fat swine are to be seen turn-
ing it into a higher food. Wheat has
not altogether disappeared, and all the
other small grains I could think of may
be seen in lu.xuriance absorbing the sun's
rays to stimulate the soil element into
producing abundant harvest. All riches
come from the soil, and there is a fine
foundation for wealth in the strip 523
June, 1903.
RAILWA^■ AM; LO( OMOI IVK ICNf;! NKICKING
281
miles long, wliich gives a share of its
products to the Nickel Plate to carry.
Manufacturing towns are not wanting
After leaving i^uffalo with its varied in-
dustries, we get a glimpse of Dunkirk,
which is now the third town in the coun-
try as a locomotive producer. I do not
intend to convert my letter into a guide
book, and so I can merely mention
Cleveland, Fort Wayne and Hammond,
because they are the largest freight pro-
tluccrs on this line. But there are many
small manufacturing places which aggre-
gate big business, as the small brooks
feed great rivers.
When one looks into details, it is not
surprising that the Nickel Plate has be-
come a dividend-paying property.
The Kelso Freight Car Coupler.
Tile Kelso coupler is made by the
McConway & Torley Company, of Pitts-
burgh, Pa,, and ni it are embodied all
the good points of the well-known Jan-
ney coupler. The Kelso has been de-
signed to meet the most severe service
conditions. Tlic knuckle has a Hp at the
back, .nul wlun in position this passes
through the ciiu|iUr wall and so relieves
the knuckle pin of part of the strain.
An additional feature is the "lock-set"
arrangement. I'y means of this, when
llie cuuplmg position until the coupler
has swung through eighty per cent, of
its total outward movement. The lock
cannot be shaken down by a slight move-
ment of the knuckle. It is therefore
positive in its action.
There is another function which is per-
formed by the knuckle-lock lifter, and
that is that when the knuckle is closed,
the former drops down and holds the
knuckle lock so that it cannot move.
In fact this has been called a "lock to the
lock," as it cfifcctually prevents any pos-
sible chance of the knuckle lock work-
A Truly Fast Run.
On May 25 an extraordinarily fast run
was made with the Twentieth Ccntiu'y
Limited train on the Lake Shore &
Michigan Southern. The run was continu-
ous, over two divisions. On one division
a Brooks ten-wheeler, with cylinders 20x
28 inches, driving wheels 80 inches diam-
eter and 2,890 square feet of heating sur-
face was used. On the other division
was a Prairie type engine with cylinders
203.2x28 inches, driving wheels 80 inches
diameter and 3,356 square feet of heal-
ing surface. They hauled a train of four
heavy Pullman cars 307 miles in 292 min-
utes. One stretch of 133 miles was made
in 114 minutes. The average speed for
ROCKY RUN BRIDGE, NICKEL PLATE LINE.
ing up and so allowing the knuckle to
open when in service.
The rush of business on the Illinois
Central in recent months has been so
great that it has been found almost im-
possible for the machinery department
to handle it. As a result of this the
company has leased a number of locomo-
tives to be used on its system during
the rush. Some of them were leased
from the Union Transfer Company, of
Chicago, and from other locomotive
owners, to whom the high rental paid is
a consideration.
ST.\TE LINE TRESTLE, NICKEL PLATE LINE.
the long distance was over 63 miles an
hour, and for the spurt of 133 miles, 70
miles an hour. During this part ot the
run the speed frequently reached 90 miles
an hour, or forty seconds for each mile.
This is no record based on guesses, but
is taken from the train dispatcher's re-
ports.
Work; don't make fine playing
speeches about bread, but earn it. — Rn!pli
Nicklcby.
it is desired to uncouple a car. the op-
erator simply raises the uncoupling lever,
and the knuckle lock is then held out of
the way of the knckle shank and the cars
may be drawn apart, and the opening of
the knuckle brings the locking mechan-
ism into position for coupling by impact.
The uncoupling le\tr does not require
to be held up or locked up. The rais-
ing of this lever places the "lock set."
and the operation is complete, and, fur-
ther than this, the lock will not drop to
The Baltimore & Ohio Company will
order from 100 to 150 new locomotives
for delivery during 1904. These addi-
tions will represent an outlay of from
$1,500,000 to $2,300,000. When it is re-
called that the Baltimore & Ohio has
spent in the past two years, including the
locomotives now under construction,
close on to $5,000,000 for motive power,
the growth of the traffic and the liberal
efforts being made to take care of it
are evident.
The Rand Drill Company report the
removal of their San Francisco office
from 223 First street to the Rialto
Building, additional space being needed
because of the rapidly expanding busi-
ness of this company.
282
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Fast Passenger Engine for the Illinois
Central.
The Rogers Locomotive Company, of
Paterson, N. J., have recently suppHed
the Illinois Central Railroad with some
good examples of the now popular
4-4-2 type of locomotive for passenger
service.
The cylinders are 20x28 in. and the
driving wheels are 79 in. in diameter.
The engine is simple, with ordinary slide
valves, actuated by indirect motion. The
rocker arm is between the driving
wheels, and as the eccentric rods pass
beyond the rocker the transmission bar
works back from link to rocker. The
crosshead is of the allegator type with
top guide recessed so that outer edge of
bar and guide are flush. The weight of
the engine in working order is 188,000
lbs., of which 102,000 lbs. rest on the
drivers. The engine truck carries 45,000
lbs., while the wheels at the rear bear
41,000 lbs.
The boiler is of the extended wagon-
top type and measures 66 in. at the
Tubes, out dia., 2 in.; length, i5 ft,; thickness, 11
in. B. W. G ; number, 331.
Boiler, type, ex. wagon top; dia., outside front, 66
in.; working pressuie, 200 lbs.
Wheels, eng. truck, dia., 36 in., Paige; trail., 48 in.
Tender, cap., 15 tons coal; 7,000 water bot. gals.;
frame, 12 in. steel channels; trucks, Fox;
wheels, dia., 38 in.; kind, Paige.
Meeting of the American Railway
Association.
At the last semi-annual meeting of the
American Railway Association, held in
New York two very interesting reports
were presented. One was by the com-
mittee on standard dimensions of box
cars, and the other was from the com-
mittee on car service.
The first imentioned report called spe-
cial attention to the idea which has got
abroad that the preference in classifica-
tion given to the standard car will make
the large car useless. This opinion is
not well founded, because while the large
car will not have an advantage over
smaller cars as heretofore and will not in
the future be built, vet it can be used eco-
To bring about these desirable ends
there has been increased cost. Railroads
which have done a large portion of their
business in the cars of others have had
to pay accordingly. There has been a
further cost for additional clerical work
and correspondence. Also a number 01
roads have found themselves short of
power when their own cars came home,
and these roads have been unable to
promptly return foreign cars. Both of
these causes have probably tended to re-
duce the average mileage per car per
day. In the last six months of 1901 the
average was 21.6, while in the last six
months of 1902 it was 20.8. Another
cause for this may probably be found in
the fact that there has been an enormous
number of freight cars in service. It is
estimated that there was an increase of
100,000 freight cars on all the railroads in
the country. No modifications in the
rules governing the per diem system have
been recommended as yet, as it was
deemed advisable to wait another six
ROGERS ATLANTIC K.XCINE; for ILLINOIS CENTRAL.
smoke box ring. The pressure carried
is 200 lbs., and flexible or expansion stays
are used in the critical rows in fire-
box side sheets and in throat sheet.
Water is supplied by two injectors
placed on the right side, both delivery
pipes enter the boilers at the same
point, there is close to each injector a
line check valve, and two globe valves
are placed where the top check is usu-
ally located, which can be shut off or
opened as occasion requires. The grate
area is 35 sq. ft., and the total heating
surface is 3,129 sq. ft.
The tender is carried on a steel frame
made of 12-inch channels, Fox steel
trucks are used and Paige wheels. The
tank capacity for water is 7,000 gallons,
and for coal 12 tons.
A few of the leading dimensions are
given below:
Cyl., 20x28 in.; drivers, dia., 79 in.; driving wheel
bse., 7 ft. 3 in.; tot. wheel bse. of eng., 27 ft. gin.
Weight on driv., 102,000 lbs.; on truck, F, 45.000
lbs , B, 41,000 lbs.; total, 188,000.
Heating surface, tubes, 2,954.5 sq. ft.; fire box, 174.7
sq. ft., tot., 3,129.2 sq. ft.; grate area, 35.01 sq. ft.
nomically until worn out. The chairman
of one of the classification committees,
after a careful examination, estimates
that 95 per cent, of all commodities can
be so carried when housing conditions
are favorable. The committee further
urged that all advantages which appear
to arise from discrepancies in classifica-
tion and other regulations which may
interfere with use of the standard box
car, should be considered secondary.
The car service committee dealt fully
with per diem. It appears that for the
last six months of 1902, the percentage
of home cars on roads making returns
was 9.6 per cent, more than the year be-
fore. The per diem plan may be said to
have accomplished the ends for which it
was devised. It has given car owners
better control of their own equipment.
It has increased the revenue derived for
the use of their equipment by others,
and it has enabled railroad companies
to check the car service accounts of
other roads where their own cars are
concerned.
months, when fuller records will be to
hand.
Progress was reported by the commit-
tees on train rules, safety appliances,
statistical inquiry and the standard
cipher code. Mr. A. W. Sullivan, assist-
ant second vice-president of the Illinois
Central Railroad was again elected presi-
dent of the association.
The Vitrified Wheel Company, of
Westfield, Mass., has issued an illus-
trated catalogue descriptive of the corun-
dum wheels made by their vitrified pro-
cess. The company also manufacture
emery and silicate wheels, emery cylin-
ders, wheel dressers, emery bricks and
corundum rubs. There are illustrated
and priced, fifty-three special shaped
wheels, with cipher telegraph word for
ordering. The catalogue also gives the
various grinding machines made by this
concern, with dimensions, weights and
prices. Write to the Vitrified Wheel
Company for the catalogue if you are
interested.
June, 1903.
RAir.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEHRING
283
Hints on Break-Downs.
With the big engines of to-day some
engineers thoughtlessly send for the
shop force in case of break-downs when
repairs should have been made by them.
Often this is a cause of great expense
and reflects no credit to the engineer.
Very often it causes his endless worry
explaining to the officials why he did not
do the work himself.
It is for the young and the old
thoughtless runners that the following
advice is given:
In case of a broken forward cylinder-
head, rocker arm. link, eccentric or strap,
never take down a main rod, for you
still need the rod to help you. You can-
not do any damages to the cylinder. If
pinch-bar, saved yourself time, and the
operation need not consume over five
minutes.
bon't remove the chest cover for a
broken valve yoke. Invariably, if your
engine breaks a yoke, you will, in your
endeavor to locate the side, put the good
side on the dead center.
Don't worry, leave that to your neigh-
bors.
If you cannot find any visible defect in
the running gear and cannot move the
engine, remember, that the good side is
"ahvays" on the dead center, and the
disabled side on the quarter.
In this case disconnect valve rod and
shift valve by hand. Move your engine
od center, then remove relief valve cas-
Placc your engine as near the forward
dead center as you can, let the reverse
lever down into the extreme forward
notch of quadrant. Take an inch chisel
resting one-half on the guide and the
other half on the cross-head and mark
them. Now mark all four eccentrics and
straps in the same way, and on a line
with top edge of eccentric blades, while
the engine is in this position. If the en-
gine has blades with slotted holes, mark
them also at end of strap.
Should you at any time slip an ec-
centric, place the engine in the same
position as when you marked eccentrics,
being careful to note that the marks
on cross-head and guide correspond.
You will find that three of the marked
Photographed by .V. Lazarnick.
PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT TAKING A RIDE IN AN ENGINE.
you stop to consider that with ordinary
engine oil you make 50 or more miles
with one oiling of the eccentrics and
the amount of hard work they perform,
there is no reason why a good oiling
with valve oil should not carry the piston
the same distance without damage to it-
self and cylinder. Taking down a rod
means unnecessary work for you and
extra work for the shop.
Engines of to-day cannot be moved
with one pinch-bar on the road when
it takes four or more to move them in
the shop. Leave up your rod, discon-
nect valve stem, and after covering ports,
clamp it. Should you at any time stop
on the dead center, shift valve on dis-
abled side so as to admit steam to cyl-
inder, move her ofT the dead center,
cover port again, clamp stem and pro-
ceed. You have used your rod as a
ing, cover ports and clamp rod. Insert a
wooden plug of sufficient length into
casing to hold the valve in place and
screw it back into chest. In this and
the previous case disconnect the cylinder
cock rod on the disabled side and block
cocks open. Be sure and do not re-
move the main rod.
Where you are running an engine,
whose eccentrics have no keys, and have
to rely on set screws entirely, it is a good
plan to look out for and be prepared for
such accidents. A few minutes' work
before starting your trip may relieve you
from an embarrassing position, if you
will follow these directions.
Setting valves by the third spoke of
driver, or marking valve stem is very
uncertain of good results. The method
mentioned here is far superior, infallible,
and consumes less time.
eccentrics will correspond to the marks
on straps and the one that is out will
have the mark separated. Shift this ec-
centric around to mark on strap and se-
cure it. You will have your engine as
square as the valve-setter left her for
you, and you need not call upon him.
Follow these instructions and save your-
self grief.
Some parties in St. Paul are experi-
menting with a magnetic appliance by
which the adhesion is increased between
the driving wheels and the rails, ob-
viating entirely the necessity for using
sand. Inventions of this kind have been
tried repeatedly, but it was always found
that they increased the resistance in
proportion as they increased the ad-
hesion.
284
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Roberts' SeU-Adjusting Piston
Packing.
The Roberts' improved self-adjusting
piston packing can be used either with
water or steam air or ammonia, and it can
be appHed to any kind of piston. It con-
sists of seven parts, there is one bull
ring, two packing rings, a proper center
ring, a spring, and two joint pieces. The
two packing rings and the center ring
are fitted into grooves in the bull ring.
The center ring which has a spring un-
derneath it, is intended to carry the
weight of the piston in the cylinder and
to keep it running true. The packing
rings are steam expanded, and as a con-
sequence only one is acting during each
stroke, thereby reducing the friction; the
two steam joints are fitted in the rib of
the bull ring and this prevents either ring
from turning, and effectually removes all
chance of a blow. The steam rings have
a groove into which the steam joints fit
with a tongue and they are dovetailed
so in order to allow the steam rings to
wear down and yet do their work. The
"I do not know whether there are ne-
gotiations on between the other two,"
said Mr. Johnson, "but there is abso-
lutely no truth in the story that we are
in any deal. There have been no over-
tures to us lately, and if there were, we
should not entertain them. Neither in
the question of a combination or prices
is there any agreement or understanding,
nor will there be."
Tlie Time for Betterment of Railroad
Property.
Railroad companies have expended
sums of money during the last two years
in making betterments on their proper-
ties, but there appears to be a lull in this
kind of enterprise at the present time.
Quite a number of railroad presidents
have just realized that material and labor
are now so high that the cost of better-
ments severely depletes the net revenues.
The talk now is to wait until the inevit-
able hard times reduce the cost of
labor and of material.
those of the railroad presidents. No in-
stitution dominated by Wall street in-
fluences, be it devoted to operating rail-
roads or to manufacturing goods for
sale; will ever be able to profit by the
cheapness of hard times. The people
who speculate in stocks provide for no
future. They want the return of profits
immediately and will not wait for the
harvest that comes from judicious sow-
ing and carefully nurtured crops.
The Locomotives of the Great
Northern of England.
We have just received a copy of a
book written by Mr. George F. Bird,
which is the history from 1847 to 1902
of the locomotives of the Great Northern
Railway of England.
A very pleasing portrait of Mr. H. A.
Ivatt. the present locomotive engineer of
the company, forms the frontispiece. With
an introduction, the book deals with
what we may call the administrations of
Archibald Sturrock, Patrick Stirling and
Mr. Ivatt and recounts the work done in
steam joints will also prevent the rings
from falling out in the cylinder. It is
claimed that by the use of this packing
the friction of the "piston' is greatly re-
duced. The Roberts' Company, of South
Fourth street. Philadelphia, will be
happy to forward their pamphlet on the
subject, or supply any information con-
cerning it to those interested enough to
apply to them for it.
No Combination for Baldwin's.
"There is no combination between the
American Locomotive Company and the
Baldwin Locomotive Works, nor will
there be," said .■Mba B. Johnson, answer-
ing a press agent.
His assertion was made in reply to a
rumor printed in a financial news sheet
of a combination affecting the Baldwin
Works, the American Locomotive Com-
pany and the Rogers Locomotive Works.
While it has been suggested that in time
the Rogers plant and the American Com-
pany might come together, it has been
emphatically denied that the Baldwin
Works would entertain any proposition.
At the first glance this would seem to
be sound financial policy, but we are
afraid that it will delay betterments in-
definitely. When a railroad company is
prosperous, and is making lots of money,
the expenditures for improvements are
not felt very heavily, but when hard
times come. Wall street influences de-
mand retrenchments at every point where
expenditure of money is not absolutely
imperative. The consequence is that
when material and labor are cheap noth-
ing is done, and the companies put off
the evil day of spending money until
they cannot put it off any longer. Re-
vival of business eventually makes it ab-
solutely necessary to make large ex-
penditures on equipment, and the better-
ment of the permanent structures, which
is generally done when it costs most.
There have been a good many flush
times, and a good many panics and de-
pressions since the railway era opened,
and the same experience is gone through
every time. We do not see that it will
ever be any different as long as Wall
street influences are more powerful than
the locomotive department under each of
these men. There are numerous line cuts
showing the various types used at dif-
ferent times, and a photogravure of 'the
famous "eight-foot singles" of Mr. Pat-
rick Stirling and also of the more mod-
ern "singles" or 4-2-2 engines designed
by Mr. Ivatt.
The book is published by the Locomo-
tive Publishing Company, Limited, I02.\
Charing Cross Road, London.
A Few Points on Grinding.
Mr. Charles H. Norton, of the Norton
Emery Wheel Company, of Worcester,
Mass., has written a little treatise called
"A Few Points on Grinding," and what
may be called the text upon which Mr.
Norton bases his exceedingly interesting
discourse is that "There are signs that
very much work now done by cutting will
be done by grinding, and those soonest
informed upon the subject will profit
by it." The author tells an amusing
story and a pleasing story of grinding
which reminds us of a story we once
heard of two high-priced workmen in a
JlMU', 1903.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMOI I ViC ENGINEERING
385
JoCDnidlivL' .shop in the days vvlit-n "slicip
appliances" were in tlicir infancy. These
men were working piece work and were
surrounded by pneumatic tools, flexible
shafting and all sorts of "labor savers,"
but they were not using a single one of
them. When asked why they worked
away so hard by hand at everything they
replied, "We simply haven't got time to
monkey with the blamed things. We're
too busy!"
Mr. Norton says that a certain niaini-
facturcr purchased a cylindrical grind-.ni;
machine and received with it a wheel for
soft steel and one for cast iro'.i. An
operator from the grinding works saw
them grinding a Corliss valve with the
wrong wheel, and on speaking to the
manufacturer about it, the grinder-man
was told that it saved time and did the
job splendidly, and that the shop couldn't
afford the time to change wheels for
every different thing because results
were so far superior to old methods. The
operator got permission to do the job
with the right wheel, and throwing in
time of changing wheels, it turned out
that more than three-quarters of the
former time was saved by the use of the
right wheel in the right way on the right
job. Oh yes, gentle reader, it some-
tiflies does pay to "monkey with the
blamed things." Write the Norton Com-
pany to send you their little book and
you won't regret it.
tli.il tin- lading may be discharged cither
in sections or all together.
The drop dof)rs are opened, closed
and locked by rotating geared shafts,
manipulated by a fixed ratchet lever
which, after the doors are closed, is put
into a receiver and is sealed with the
standard car seal in order to i)revent
the shafts turning by accident or other-
wise, until it is necessary to discharge
the l(jad.
As will be seen from our engraving
showing doors open, there are ribbed
malleable iron transoms between each
door, placed below the level of the floor.
In each of these castings there is a slot
which slopes toward the center of the
the weight of the lading on the drop
doors is sufficient to roll the shafts down
the inclines, thus opening the doors to
45 degrees. To raise the doors to the
level of the fixed portion of the floor, the
shafts are turned with the ratchet lever
in the opposite direction and they will
carry the doors, which rest on rollers
secured to the shafts, up in front of ihcm
into place and securely lock them there.
A Kood deal of attention has liecn
given to simplicity of construction of
the Caswell Dump Car. And while it is
not claimed that this car is absolutely
self-cleaning, the load can be removed
in the same average time as from self-
cleaning hopper dump and convertible
>^
CASWELL DUMP CAR-DROP DOORS CLOSED.
CASWELL DUMP CAR-DROP DOORS OPEN.
The Caswell Dump Car.
The Caswell level dumping car was
■designed for the carriage of materials
usually hauled in gondola cars. The
idea being to provide for the dumping
of the load quickly or tor unloading with
shovels if required.
With these objects in view the car is
constructed with a perfectly level floor,
w^ithout inclined surfaces or projections
or parts to manipulate. The floor is as
clear as that of a flat car and most ex-
peditious shoveling can therefore be
done on it, and moreover, the maximum
capacity is thus secured. In order to
dump the load, drop doors are provided
in the floor near the sides of the car.
and these extend from end to end so
car, and the lower face of this slot is a
toothed rack. The rotating shaft passes
through all these slots and out through
similar slots in the body bolsters and the
end sills, and the pinions fastened to this
rotating shaft engage with the racks. The
outer ends of the racks do not slope in
conformity with the long slot, they are
level, so that when the doors are in place
the weight is borne directly on the
pinions with no strain on the teeth, and
there is no effort on the part of the shaft
to turn.
When it is desired to dump the con-
tents the shaft is rotated and the pinion
rolls toward the center of the car. When
the pinion, together with the shaft,
reaches the inclined portion of the racks.
cars. Every part of the Caswell car is
built in accordance with M. C. B. Stand-
ards. It is easy of inspection, replacing
parts and repairing any portion of the
operating mechanism is a simple matter
and is inexpensive.
The offices of the Caswell Car Com-
pany, which controls the sales of these
dump cars, are in the Fisher Building.
Chicago, and the company invites corre-
spondence.
Owing to the scarcity of motive power
on the Pennsylvania Southwest sj'stem,
the Pennsylvania Railroad will give the
Panhandle 20 of the engines ordered for
the Pennsylvania Railroad, and now be-
ing built at the Baldwin Works for im-
mediate delivery.
The Tabor Mfg. Co., of Philadelphia,
have arranged with the Draper Co.. of
Hopedale, Mass., for the manufacture and
sale of the Hand Rammed Molding Ma-
chines, which the latter firm has been
building for its own use. The Draper
Co. have had probably greater experi-
ence in moulding by machine than any
firm in this country: consequently their
machines represent the result of years
of experimenting. At present they have
in operation in the Hopedale plant sev-
eral hundred of these machines, which
are light, and are mounted on wheels,
and do not require power to operate
them. Moreover, they are cheap.
286
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Byrd's Flue Welder.
There is a very efficient tube welder to
be seen in the Winnipeg shops of the
Canadian Pacific Railway. It was in-
vented and patented by Mr. Walter
Byrd, the general foreman. In doing
work with this tool, the scarfing ma-
chine has been dispensed with, the tube
and the safe end are taken just as they
come from the cutter, and the safe end
is expanded in an air machine so that
it goes 3-16 of an inch on the end of
the tube and is ready to weld. When
at a welding heat the tube is pushed on
to the stationary mandrel of the machine
and the rollers are brought down. The
pressure which the rollers put' upon the
hot tube is supplied by compressed air,
which is admitted to a cylinder by a very
ingenious device, which is actuated by
the foot of the operator. Pressure is ap-
plied until the tube and safe end are
shafts, E, E, lie, a movement of the ring,
M, away from the rollers, causes them to
come down on the mandrel, K, while an
opposite motion of the ring forces the
rollers away from the mandrel. The
mandrel is pinned in place and can be
easily removed when required.
The method of attaching the lever to
the ring, M, is very simple. The ring
has a groove turned in it all round, and
in this groove slide two studs, which
latter are secured to the forked ends of
the lever. The attachment resembles the
gimbles, which support the familiar
kerosene lamp, which is such a con-
spicuous feature in torchlight proces-
sions at election times.
A treadle is arranged near where the
operator stands, and the pressure of the
foot upon this treadle opens an air valve
which admits air behind the piston of a
small cylinder, and this moves the lever,
F.ig. 1
Railway ^ l.ocoiiu
Fig. 3
BYRD'S FLUE WELDER.
movement is spreading and it is highly
probable that the other blocks in this
vicinity will adopt the same plan and
that finally the capitol will be encircled
with these celebrated little street lamps.
brought down to the required thickness.
The work is done so neatly that it is
necessary to scrape ofT the scale in order
to discover the weld. Any size of tube
may be welded by simply changing the
mandrel and rollers. For cutting tubes
the rollers are taken ofl and disc cutters
put on instead.
The machine as shown in our illustra-
tion, consists of an upright stand, J,
carrying a pulley, A, and gear necessary
to revolve the four rollers, F, F, around
the mandrel, K. The shafts, E,E, carrying
the rollers, F, are pivoted to a head, D,
which revolves upon a hollow water-
cooled center. These shafts pass at a
slight angle through openings in the
ring, M, which latter can be moved in
or out parallel to the axis of the mandrel
by the action of a lever which is oper-
ated by air. The ring, M, revolves with
the rollers, and turns upon the water-
cooled center of the machine. On ac-
count of the angle at which the roller
Favors American Locomotives.
The rabid engineering Anglomaniacs
who can see no merit about machinery
made outside of Great Britain, and par-
ticularly of locomotives, will be badly
shocked over the report sent in by Sir
George Whitehouse, manager and chief
engineer of the Uganda Railroad of Af-
rica. The report says:
"We have thirty-six American and
thirty-four British main line engines.
The experiment with the American loco-
motives proved entirely satisfactory.
They are 10 per cent, cheaper, and al-
though their finish is not so perfect they
are more suitable for a mountain rail-
way, like the Uganda road, because they
are not so rigid and take the curves
more easily.
"Of the steel viaducts along the line
twenty-six are of American and eight are
of English make. The American via-
ducts are excellent, but the contractors
were greatly behind time, and took a
year instead of seven months to erect
them."
The erecting of first class bridges is
always a difficult matter in the wilder-
ness, but it seems to have been particu-
larly difficult in Africa. Sir George
Whitehouse mentions that the difficulties
of bridge construction were badly in-
creased by the presence of lions along
the route. It is said that these savage
brutes carried ofT no less than twenty-
seven employees. None of them re-
turned.
O. Springs are arranged to produce an
opposite motion in the mechanism as
soon as the pressure to the little cylinder
has been cut off and the air exhausted.
The Canadian Pacific officials speak very
highly of the good work done by this
simple, though ingenious tool.
The streets of the city of Madison,
Wis., are being illuminated with Nernst
lamps. Some of the business men in
one of the blocks on East Main street
put in five of these lamps independent
of the city arc lights at each end of the
block, making that section of the city
a blaze of electric lights. The absence
of flicker in the Nernst lamp, and the
fact that it casts no shadow on the street
make it especially adaptable for outdoor
lighting, and the occupants of the ad-
joining block to the west were not slow
in seeing the benefits of having their
block better illuminated, and also made
arrangements for five of the lights. The
Congress Hall, the very handsome
hotel at Saratoga which has been closed
for several years, will be open for the
Master Car Builders' and Master Me-
chanics' convention in June. The pro-
prietor offers the rate of $3.50 and up-
wards, $4.50, each for rooms with bath.
Congress Hall was the first headquarters
of these conventions in Saratoga. When
the joint committee of the two associa-
tions first decided to go to Saratoga,
they selected the Grand Union Hotel
for headquarters, but when the commit-
tee of arrangements went to make ar-
rangements they were very frigidly re-
ceived by the proprietors and plain in-
timation was given them that the hotel
did not want any conventions of that
kind. The committee then went to Col.
Clement, who was manager of the Con-
gress Hall, and received the very best
kind of treatment.
The Kingston Locomotive Works of
Canada are importing machinists from
Great Britain. There is no contract
labor law in Canada.
June, 1903-
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
a87
New Jerome Packing.
"Circumstances alter cases," is true in
general, but it is particularly true con-
cerning the new Jerome packing which
has .lately been devised by Jerome &
Elliott, of 35 South Canal street, Chi-
cago. The increasing use of piston rods,
with enlarged ends in the crosshead fit,
and the higher boiler pressures carried
nowadays, has made it necessary to get
out a new design for cone and follower,
which can be used with the standard
Jerome rings. The new cone and fol-
lower are each made in two pieces, di-
vided horizontally so that they may pass
over the enlarged end of the piston rod
when being applied. These pieces are
fitted with dowel pins to hold them in
place after they are put on the rod. The
cone marked C in the cut is provided
with a collar, which prevents the retain-
ing ring, D, being driven on hard enough
to burst it. Without this collar the
heavy cylinder pressures used in start-
ing, would force the retaining ring on
so hard that it could not easily be re-
moved in case of repairs, or the cone it-
self might be crushed. The illustration
shows the arrangement of the various
parts, in which A is the piston rod,
showing enlarged crosshead fit. B is
the gland proper, C is the cone made
in halves, D is the cast iron retaining
ring, with ground joint at J. The stand-
ard Jerome metallic packing rings are
shown at E, and the follower, F, also
made in halves, is held in place by
the retaining ring, G. The spring is
marked H in the cut. The new style of
swab holder, which is also made in
halves, is arranged to admit oil through
three openings, two in the sides and one
on top, thus insuring perfect lubrica-
tion to all parts of the rod.
Shaw electric crane, equipped with three
motors. Besides the main traveling
crane there arc numerous hoists and Jib
cranes actuated by compressed air. The
machine tools arc all driven by electric
motors. In the testing department
proper arrangements are made to pro-
vide practical working conditions for the
air compressors. Portable and station-
ary riveters, hoists and cranes, which are
produced in great variety and size.
The boiler and engine house, with fire
wall and metal door between, may be
considered as one building. The boiler
room is well equipped with all necessary
appliances required by modern usage and
has substantial storage capacity for coal.
The engine-room contains a belted au-
tomatic air compressor of the type
largely sold by the company, and two
American imports into Manchuria are
cotton manufactures, oil and flour. The
Russians have imported railroad ma-
terial, rolling stock, machinery and like
articles. In ten years our trade grew
almost 200 per cent-, and it is steadily
increasing. Count Cassini has assured
Secretary Hay that there will be no dis-
crimination against American goods and
American industrial enterprise. Secre-
tary Hay sought to have China open two
more ports in Manchuria, which would
benefit not only American, but interna-
tional trade generally, in this observing
the principle of the "open door." Russia
has based her objection upon the fact
that foreign concessions will be estalv
lished at those ports, which will become
scenes of political intrigue, and she
wants no political intrigues in territory
New Pedrick & Ayer Shop.
The well-known Pedrick & Ayer Co.
is one of the many concerns forced by
the growth of their business to seek
more commodious quarters. For sev-
eral years this company occupied its own
factory in Philadelphia, extending its
rapidly growing line of air tools, while
continuing its older line of special rail-
road tools and appliances for which the
company gained its reputation.
A site for the new modern works was
purchased adjoining the Clinton avenue
station of the Central R. R. of New
Jersey, at Plainfield. N. J. No expense
has been spared in the construction and
equipment of the buildings, which are all
of brick and steel.
The main building contains the offices
of the company, draughting room, tool
room and storage of principal raw ma-
terials and finished parts. The principal
portion, however, is occupied by the ma-
chine shop proper, the fitting, assem-
bling, testing and shipping departments.
The main bay is provided with a 15-ton
JEROME ft ELLIOTT METALLIC PACKING FOR ENLARGED END PISTON RODS.
direct-connected dynamo-engine sets for
supplying power and light to the entire
works. The sets are 150 kilowatts
capacity each, the engines furnished by
the Ames Iron Works and dynamos and
switch-boards by the General Electric
Co. The blacksmith shop and pattern
shop and storage house are equally well
provided with the accessories for good
reliable, up-to-date work. The entire
plant reflects credit upon the enterprise
of the Pedrick & Ayer Company. They
have sufficient capacity to develop im-
provements for which the buying public
is always ready.
which Great Britain and Germany, as
well as other nations, have recognized
as comprising her sphere of influence.
Manchuria as Our American Market.
American manufacturers are directly
interested in the attempt that Russia is
making to take possession of that Chi-
nese province. A correspondent of the
Washington Post says: The principal
The National Malleable Castings Com-
pany, of Cleveland, Ohio, have lately put
upon the market the National Malleable
iron brake-jaw and dead lever guide,
which were illustrated in our April issue.
Both of these devices have been pat-
ented by the company. It will be remem-
bered that the principal feature, common
to both, is the method of attaching the
rod. There is no welding, the jaw is
slipped onto the rod through one of the
two parallel holes in the end of the cast-
ing, then the end of the rod is bent over
a mandrel and is made into the form of
a pot hook, and is then slipped through
the other parallel hole. The end is then
slightly bent over so as to prevent the
jaw slipping back, and the thing is done.
The dead lever guide is similarly fastened.
2S8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
A Modern "High Duty" Shaper.
The "new machine shop practice," in-
cluding tlie modern betterments of thor-
ougli factory organization, the use of the
new "high duty" too! steels, and the
accurate recording of successive similar
operation time expenditures, is said in
a certain instance to have reduced the
per pound finishing labor costs as much
as 30 per cent., although the shop in
which this very large gain was made was
at the start a thoroughly well-equipped
establishment. A considerable propor-
tion of this gain came from the intro-
duction of the new steels for cutting
tools, intelligently used in connection
with improved speed-changing devices
applied to the machine tools themselves,
whereby the workman was enabled to
ing devices. Gould & Eberhardt advo-
cate individual motor application to ma-
chine tool driving, claiming that it has
decided advantages over the grouping
of several machines and driving them
with one motor. As a strong argument
in favor of their advocacy of the single
motor drive, they cite their new shaper,
the arrangement of which permits of
the speed being instantly changed to
suit the metal being worked, which
would not be possible if the machine were
one of a group, where any change in the
speed of one would affect all of the ma-
chines in the group.
The variable speed motor is started by
the knife switch K. and its speed is con-
trolled by the rheostat knob R and by the
back-gear change obtained through the
putting through an order for fourteen
of their new 24-26-inch Extension Base
Shapers, for one of the largest railroad
companies in this country, which will be
used in their repair shops.
l.OI. LD ^ KiitCKHARUT SHAPEK.
very quickly change the cutting speeds,
and so secure the fullest possibilities
. from the great endurance of the high
duty cutting steels.
The shaper has been allowed, by most
builders of machine tools, to remain
in nearly the same general form and
possessed of the same metal-removing
powers, for a long period of time, dur-
ing which some improvements were
made in the way of certainty of measure-
ment in tool setting, but no very great
advance in quickness of handling or
range of cutting speeds. Recently Gould
& Eberhardt, of Newark, N. J., have
made a series of shaper improvements,
involving almost every detail in tools
of this class, and finally resulting in the
perfected electric-motor-driven "double
triple quick" stroke shaper shown in the
accompanying illustration. It has great
flexibility of drive, and a m ost con-
venient series of speed-change produc-
lever C. All of the ram stroke varia-
tions, from 100 strokes per minute single
geared, to five strokes back geared, can
be made inside of 10 seconds, actual
time, thus making it possible to eco-
nomically vary the tool speed, to suit
the best working conditions for perform-
ing short operations, as must be done to
obtain the lowest possible labor costs
of part-finishing with the new tool steels.
The hand wheel G, on the outer end of
the pinion shaft, gives a very convenient
hand movement of the ram, either way,
as may be desired by the workman in
setting the tool. All shafts run in cyl-
indrical bushes held in bored seats in
the frame, and can be cheaply renewed
without change of original alignment.
The pillar is ribbed inside, and the whole
machine has all the metal everywhere
that can be used to advantage for solid-
ity and stiffness.
Messrs. Gould & Eberhardt are just
Water Purifier and Feed Water Heater.
The Centrifugal Feed Water Separator
and Purifier Company, of 21 Quincy
street, Chicago, have recently placed
upon the market a machine which is the
invention of Mr. E. P. Caldwell. It has
for its object the purification and heat-
ing of feed water. It consists of three
cylinders grouped together as closely as
possible so as to take up minimum space.
The feed water is passed into what is
called an "intensifier," where it goes
through a series of steam-surrounded
tubes, down one side of the chamber
and up the other. In this chamber it is
brought to a temperature of between
275 and 300 degrees F. The high tem-
perature precipitates the soluble sub-
stances in the water, and there is a sedi-
ment collector at the bottom of the
chamber. The feed water then enters the
second chamber, where it is mechanically
agitated and allowed to cool somewhat,
more sediment, therefore, falls to the
bottom in this chamber and is collected
and blown off from time to time. The
cool feed water is now introduced into a
second "intensifier" and passes down one
series of tubes and up another, and from
there it is ready to be supplied to the
boiler at a temperature of from 285 to
300 degrees F. A sediment collector is
also placed at the bottom of this vessel
where scale-producing matter, if any
then raiiains. is collected and drawn oflf.
The company also manufacture this ap-
paratus in very compact form, consisting
of one cylinder for use on locomotives.
They will be happy to answer any in-
quiries and to send a copy of their pam-
phlet on the subject to any persons who
are interested enough to apply to them
for it. An analysis of feed water used at
the Ewart Building, Chicago, was made
by R. W. Hunt & Co., and shows very
satisfactory results from the use of this
purifier.
The Manchester Locomotive Works
long ago carried on a lucrative business
in the building of the Amoskeag fire
engine, which was famous for its ef-
ficiency in extinguishing fires. Since
the American Locomotive Company ob-
tained control of the Manchester Loco-
motive Works, the building of fire en-
gines has fallen into disrepute. As all
the accommodation of the works is more
than needed for the construction of lo-
comotives, the owners are disposed to
sell their interests in building fire en-
gines and rumors are current that a sale
has been effected.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE EXGIXEERIXG
289
Sviccessful
Engineer
We are told that an engineer who so
cares for all the parts that go to make up
that magnificent, modern piece of ma-
chinery, the railway locomotive, in such
a manner as to ensure reliable service
with the best possible economy and
safety of operation, is entitled to be
called a successful engineer.
It often happens that one engineer
reaches success more (juickly than
anothe ■, and this is quite as often due to
a feelirg cf confidence that one engineer
has, which is lacking in another.
Confidence is grown on the tree of
experience. The engineer that secures
it never loses his nerve; he is always
master of himself and of his engine.
The engineer whose experience has
taught him the needs of his engine, and
who has profited by that experience,
knows that it is not alone in the superior
construction of the engine on which he
must depend. Every working part of
that mighty steed of steel must move with
the greatest ease and the least friction,
and to do this the lubrication must be far
more perfect than good workmanship
and oil alone can make it.
Engineers have learned through papers
read at conventions by superintendents
of motive power, that fifty-five per cent.
of tram delays, where oil only is used,
are traceable to the engine, and the
successful engineer knows, through his
own experience, that the introduction of
DLXON'S PURE FLAKE GRAPHITE
to engine cylinders and the various
working parts of his engine means a
large reduction of the fifty-five per cent,
mentioned.
The experienced engineer also knows
that when an engine comes from the
shop with new brasses, or with old
brasses rebored, there is no danger of a
hot pin if he puts some of DIXON'S
PURE FLAKE GRAPHITE in his rod
cups. The graphite fills the pores of the
metal and all the irregularities of the
surfaces, making them of marvelous
smoothness. The engineer who has in-
telligently used DIXON'S PURE
FLAKE GRAPHITE has gained a con-
fidence in his engine and in himself that
ensures success.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
JERSEY CITY. N. J.
Hollow Car Axles for Heavy Freight
Service.
Some very successful work has been
dune at the Homestead mills of the Car-
negie Steel Company in the preparation
of hollow steel axles for freight car ser-
vice. The method pursued has recently
been set forth in a paper read by Mr.
Camille Mercader, of Pittsburg, before
the British Iron and Steel Institute.
The work may be briefly described as
follows; A rolled, round steel blank, as
it is cailcil, is uniformly heated and
placed in a t\vu-p;irt die which has its
cavity in the form of a rough-turned
axle. The blank being as nearly as pos-
sible cylindrical is smaller than the
cavity of the die. When in place, this
blank axle is clamped in the center ;in(l
punched simultaneously from each end
by two water-cooled high carbon Besse-
mer steel punches made slightly taper
and pointed with drop forged steel caps
made in the form of a parabola, like the
reflector of a locomotive headlight.
These caps are made slightly larger in
diameter than the body of the punch in
order to reduce friction, when going in,
and the barrel of the punch is coated
with black lead for the same reason.
The punch entering the hot steel
blank squarely in the center, encounters
equal pressures all round and so has no
tendency to deviate, but produce's a deep
perforation which coincides exactly with
the axis of the axle. As the punch goes
into the hot metal of the axle, the latter
is forced out, into the cavity of the die
and so takes a sharp impression and
comes out in the shape of a rough-turned
axle. In order that there may be no
abrupt change from the hollow to the
solid form, toward the center of the axle,
the cap of the punch is left in the axle as
the barrel is withdrawn. It is made, as
already mentioned, in the form of a para-
bolic curve, which is the best form which
can be used to "shade ofT," if one may
so say, from hollow to solid metal.
The advantages which this form of axle
is believed to possess are that it com-
bines minimum weight with ma.ximum
strength. The hollow axle would, how-
ever, have to be slightly larger in diame-
ter at the ends than the solid axle to
give the same strength. The forging of
these axles being carried out externally
and internally, the material is more
homogeneous, and much more dense, and
any danger of segregation is removed.
Being strongly compressed the journals
can be finished with a high degree of pol-
ish, thus tending to reduce friction. The
hollow journal will not heat as readily as a
solid one and the cavity in the center
may become an oil reservoir, and when
appropriately plugged will permit only
the amount of oil to leak out which is
required for perfect lubrication. The
forcing of the axle tightly into the mat-
rix of the die insures a perfectly straight
and true axle which does not have to be
straightened after punching. The ends
do not have to be cut, as the back ends
of the rams, when punching, compress
the axle to the exact length, and upaet
the outer journal collars at the same
time.
Three times the number of axles
can be punched and so made from blanks
into practically rough-turned axles with
a given number of men as the same
number of men could forge under a
hammer, thus producing a corresponding
saving in fuel and steam. The process
of punching develops any hidden defects
in the steel, and by exposing them in the
process of manufacture, most satisfactor-
ily anticipates failure on the road. The
uniform taper toward the center both
ways between the wheel seats produced
by this process of pressing, insures more
uniform fiber stresses throughout the
body of the axle. The fact that the solid
central portion of the axle is not so
dense as the journal and wheel-seat por-
tions, facilitates the transmission and
absorption of shocks and vibrations due
to service. The skin of the steel is
HOLLOW AXLE SHOWING OIL RESERVOIR.
only cut on the journals and wheel seats,
rough turning of the center being un-
necessarj', and the whole of the inter-
nal skin of the cavity remains unbroken.
A saving of :ii per cent, in steel is ex-
pected and the possibility of supplying
perfectly uniform axles of mmimum
sizes and weights, is relied upon to thus
secure less dead weight for the car under
which they are used.
This system opens up the pleasing pros-
pect of re-working old axles, worn below
the limit, and of giving to them a new
lease of useful life, just as the re-rolling
of worn rails does to that kind of track
material. The processes in each case
are like Aladin, of Arabian Nights fame,
who went about offering new lamps lor
old. The Bessemer & Lake Erie rail-
road are experimenting with a number of
these hollow axles, under cars in heavy
freight service.
Nebraska was visited on May 2 with
a snowstorm that was so severe that
passenger trains were blocked in several
places and much suffering resulted
among people and stock.
The dog that snapt the shadow dropt
the bone. — Tennyson.
290
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Change in Meeting Place of Railroad
Mechanical Conventions.
The railroad mechanical conventions
meet this year at Saratoga under diffi-
cult circumstances. When the joint
committee of the two associations met
last December to decide upon a place of
meeting, representatives of hotels from
four or five places were present and
made offers of accommodation that
seemed satisfactory. There was a desire
to meet the wishes of western members
by the selection of a western place of
meeting, and the Grand Hotel Mackinac
was chosen. A Mr. Ritchie, representing
that hotel, was present at the Joint Com-
mittee meeting, and engaged to supply
all the accommodation required for fif-
teen hundred guests, and even went to
the extent of saying that they could
accommodate twenty-five hundred people
if necessary. When the time of meeting
approached near enough for applications
for rooms to be sent in, the proprietors
of the hotel discovered that they did
not have rooms enough to supply more
than half the applicants, so they declined
at the eleventh hour to have anything to
do with the conventions. When this de-
cision was arrived at the Joint Commit-
tee met without loss of time and decided
that the conventions should be held at
Saratoga, where they were certain suffi-
cient accommodations would be provided.
This required that the meetings should
be postponed one week, so they will not
meet until Wednesday, June 24, when
the Railway Master Mechanics' Associa-
tion will begin their sessions. The
Master Car Builders will meet on the
following Monday.
or break the disc. Owing to the peculiar
nature of self-hardening steel, however,
it is not affected in this manner by the
cutting disc, which makes in it, even
when forced hard, a clean, clear-cut in-
cision. The periphery of the disc is
coated with self-hardening steel par-
ticles, and these particles do the cutting.
Its convenience and economy make it
a paying investment in any machine
shop, especially to those which are using
the Armstrong Tool Holders. The ma-
chine is of combination form, the steel
cutting disc being mounted on one end
of the spindle, while the other end of the
spindle carries a 12-inch grinding disc.
The speed at which the macffine is in-
tended to run is such as to give the very
best results for both operations. The
spindle is of tool steel ground true.
Bearings are cast iron and are dust-
proof, with convenient and positive ad-
justment for wear. The swinging table
The Armstrong Cutting-Off Hachine.
In the manufacture of tool holders it
is often necessary to cut off large quan-
tities of self-hardening steel into cutter
lengths. This class of steel gives most
satisfaction when cut off cold. The ordi-
nary shop practice has been to cut the
steel off hot or to break it off on an
anvil. The objection to the latter
method is that the break is liable to be
very irregular, resulting not only in a
loss of steel, but also in increased grind-
ing, with attendant waste of time and
wear of emery wheels. After experi-
menting with various methods of doing
this work, the Armstrong Brothers Tool
Company have developed the machine
here illustrated, which in a slightly dif-
ferent form has been in practical use in
their works for about two years. A
patent has been applied for.
The cutting is done by a disc of special
grade tool steel revolving at high speed.
Any attempt to cut soft steel or ordinary
cast steel with a disc results in a rough
dragging cut, with flaring lips, which
bind the disc to such an extent as to
reduce its speed to a point where it is
ineffective, if it does not actually stop
ARMSTRONG O I I IN. -OFF MACHINE.
is provided with a length gauge, and is
conveniently adjustable for steel of dif-
ferent sizes or depth of cut. The cut-
ting disc is provided with a neat guard,
which can easily be swung back out of
the way when changing the disc.
The grinding disc is made of boiler
plate, and is provided with an adjustable
table, so located that the operator will
not interfere with cutting off long bars
of steel.
Each machine is equipped with coun-
ter shaft, one cutting disc, one grinding
disc, one breaking block, one press for
emery discs, one dozen emery cloth discs
assorted, one pound lubricating grease
and one can special cement for attaching
emery cloth to grinding disc.
to the sawyers of the world. Upon re-
quest this useful little book, which is
fully illustrated, will be sent free of
charge to any sawyer or other person in-
terested, by the J. A. Fay & Egan Co.,
of 44S West Front street, Cincinnati, O.
The J. A. Fay & Egan Co., manu-
facturers of woodworking machinery,
have just issued a neat little pamphlet
entitled. Instruction on the Erection and
Care of Band Saw Mills, Band Bosses,
Hand Saws, etc. The book is dedicated
The Lunkenheimer Company, Cincin-
nati, report that on account of the un-
precedented demand for their superior
line of brass and iron steam specialties,
they have been compelled to increase
their foundry output 50 per cent. Ma-
chine tools of the most improved type
are being installed in various depart-
ments as fast as they can be obtained.
Three hundred employees of the Lima
Locomotive and Machine Company went
on strike last month because the com-
pany sought to put machinists and
moulders on piece-work basis. The
strikers demanded that they be given
straight day work, and that M. Coakley,
of Chicago, the newly installed superin-
tendent, be removed. The dispute was
settled by the company yielding to the
demands of their employees.
There have been a tremendous num-
ber of new locomotives built for rail-
road companies during the past three
years, but the increase in numbers does
not by any means represent the increase
of power. The rule now is with all
roads to increase the engine capacity,
and with many to reduce the number of
engines. As shown by the annual report
of the Union Pacific that road reduced
its number of engines during the fiscal
year ended June 30, 1902, about 5 1-2 per
cent, and at the same time increased its
aggregate motive power by 9 1-2 per
cent.
The Rand Drill Company, through
their pneumatic tool department, report
the recent sales of many large complete
air plants, including their new "Imperial"
Pneumatic Hammers and Piston Air
Drills. Plans are now being drawn for
an extensive enlargment of the Rand
Drill Company works to meet these in-
creased demands.
The White Mountain Paper Com-
pany has recently purchased from
the Westinghouse Electric & Man-
ufacturing Company three l,ooo-kilo-
watt and one 300-kilowatt, three-
phase, engine-type alternators, which
are complete with exciters and are to
be direct connected to Hamilton-Cor-
liss engines installed in its paper mill
at Portsmouth, N. H. The various ma-
chines in this mill will be operated by
Westinghouse, type "C" induction mo-
tors, aggregating 5.500 horse power.
When this apparatus is in operation it
will comprise the largest individual elec-
trical installation in a paper mill in the
world.
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
391
Gilman-Brown
Emergency
Knuckle ^
Fits any M. C. B. Coupler
*^
Can be fitted instantly
^»
Makes a safe and strong
connection
Prevents traffic delay on
the road and loss of
car service
^«
Over 30,000 are in use
^«
Send for Catalog on this and
other Track, Locomotive
and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with the Q. & C. Co.
GENERAL OFFICES
OLD COLONY BlILDING
...CHICAGO...
New York Office, 114 Liberty Street
1
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(37; G. R., Tweed, Ont., asks us to
please explain (i) why a short stack
should interfere with an engine steam-
ing. The engine referred to was a good
steamer, but when going through the
sliop had about a foot taken off top
of stack. A. — In the matter of draft, the
volume of smoke-box gases which are
ejected at each exhaust is important.
Exhaust steam does no useful work when
it has passed out of the stack, the
greater volume of gas it can draw with
it as it goes up the stack, the more
powerful will be the draught. Suppose
we say that each exhaust expels a stack
full of hot gas, it is apparent that the
shorter the stack, the less the amount of
gas which will be thrown out. The
Grand Trunk Railway of Canada use
long stacks of small diameter, and be-
lieves that it enables them to use large
nozzles. (2) Please explain why an en-
gine crowds over to, say, the left side,
and cuts flange on that side. A. — The
engine is probably not quite "square."
(38) W. W. P., Newark, Ohio, asks,
if there is any ready method of finding
how many gallons of water are in tank
for every inch in depth, so that an en-
gineer can readily compute water con-
sumption. A. — There is no ready
method such as you speak of; the cross-
section of very many tanks now used
varies with the height on account of the
sloping of the sheets in the fuel space,
which is done so that the coal as used
will keep working down to the fireman.
If thf tank had a constant cross section
such as the old U-shaped ones with
straight sides, it would be easy to cal-
culate what a layer of water one inch
deep amounted to, but the calculation
would only hold good for that particular
tank and others exactly like it. A gallon
of water, U. S. measure, contains 231
cubic inches.
(39) W. S. M. writes:
If you have a standard tram for your
driving-wheel centers, say for a mogul
engine, and you lay oflf shoes and wedges
from these tram points, put wheels under
engine and she trams all right all
round, and you have solid side rods with
new brasses in all round. You tram
your rods and find one or two % in.
too long and another ^ in. too short.
What would be the proper thing to do,
with solid end rods? A. — The proper
thing to do would be to have the rods
altered to the proper length in each case.
(40) A. B., Newark, N. J., writes:
(l) Will }'0U kindly advise me how a
two-cylinder compound engine should be
counterbalanced? Should the low-pres-
sure side be balanced according to the
weights on that side, and the high-pres-
sure side according to its weights, using
the M. M. rules in both cases? A. —
Each side should be balanced for itself
alone, using M. M. rules. (2) Have you
ever printed an article on the Davis
counterbalance? A. — We illustrated an
engine having the Davis counterbalance
in the December, 1902, issue, page 523.
The engine is used on the Big Four.
(41) J. J. T., Philadelphia, asks in
what way does the air valve to the blow-
off cock work, and suppose that I turned
the valve and opened the blow-off cock
and turned the valve back to shut it off
and found it did not close blow off, and
that I could not turn regular valve wheel.
What could I do? A. — Air enters above
a piston and moves it down, the stem
of the piston unseats the valve. When
you shut off air the valve should close.
When operated by hand the nut should
be screwed upward and partly out of
the valve case, and the action of a spiral
spring inside is supposed to close the
valve. Screwing the nut further out
should draw the valve shut. If it is stuck
open after everything has been done to
close it, as your question suggests, then
the valve probably requires overhauling.
TRACK INSPECTION C.^R.
Railway Motor Car.
The photograph here reproduced
shows a new petrol-driven railway in-
spection car which has just been con-
structed for the London & South- West-
ern Railway Company by Mr. Robert W.
A. Brewer, A.M.I. M.E., etc., of West-
minster. So successful has this car
proved and so satisfied with its perform-
ances is Mr. Grainger (of the London &
South-Western Railway Company) that
the London, Brighton & South Coast
Railway Company have ordered a similar
vehicle. The following description of
the car has been furnished by Mr.
Brewer:
The car is very simple in its construc-
tion. There are no springs, the axles
running in brasses bolted on the front of
the car. The cylinders are outside the
frames; the valves are all vertical and all
mechanically operated. The lever which
throws the electric ignition in gear also
holds open the exhaust valve in its "off"
position, so that when running down a
bank there is no compression, the ig-
nition, of course, being out of gear. The
carbureter is fitted below the petrol feed
tank (which holds 2 gallons), and the
quantity for each charge is regulated by
a needle valve, the lever of which works
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June. 1903..
over a graduated scale on the feed tank.
There is storage provided for extra
petrol, but the car is said to run nearly
one hundred miles on two gallons. The
.engine, of course, is of slow speed— maxi-
mum about 500 revolutions per minute—
the wheel being 20 in. in diameter. The
engraving and description are taken
from The Car. London.
Cleveland Pneumatic Hammers.
Catalogue E. of the Cleveland Pneu-
matic Company, is a very attractive pub-
lication. It has just been issued from
the office of the company at the corner
of Hawthorne and Second avenue,
Cleveland, Ohio. This publication, of 58
pages, shows the tools made by this
company in beautifully clear half-tones,
which are printed on heavy cream paper,
the letter press on the side giving full
information as to size, weight, speed,
etc. -A .sectional line cut numbered and
named affords a convenient reference
page for ordering parts. There are a
number of engravings showing the tools
in use, chipping a steel die. chipping
structural work and chipping gray iron
in the foundry. Beading flues in the
boiler shop, or caulking a seam. The
long stroke riveting hammers are illus-
trated and fully described. A sectional
view for ordering parts is also given.
A series of pictures of the long stroke
hammer show it "going up against"
structural work, tank work and bridge
work. The German Kaiser's yacht
Meteor, having been riveted up with these
hammers, is displayed "under full press
of canvas," and the Twentieth Century
train on the Lake Shore is shown and
quoted as the standard of excellence
which is maintained in the manufacture
of these tools. The catalogue is exceed-
ingly well got up, and is most interest-
ing, as it shows the pneumatic holder-on,
the painting machines and the air hoists,
and gives actual scenes from workshop
and factory, with all these tools in actual
use. Send to the company in Cleveland
and have a look at it yourself.
of kerf that will be readily appreciated
by all users of fine lumber. The strain-
ing device, with knife-edge balance, m-
surcs at all times an even tension on the
saw blade, something very necessary to
prolong its life, and yet so seldom found.
The lower wheel being solid, there is
no vibration, increased momentum, and
no possibility of it overrunning the up-
per. By the single movement of a lever
the machine is converted into a hand feed
rip saw, and where flooring is made in
large quantities, it is fitted with a long
table on which are rolls for quickly re-
turning material. The feed rolls are
placed close together, so that short work
can be done to advantage.
New Band Rip Saw.
If any of our readers haveany ripping
to do, the machine here represented will
without doubt prove of much interest.
Its makers claim it will surpass in quality
and quantity anything in this line they
are now using. For ripping fine lumber
it is far in advance of other models,
and represents an entirely original de-
sign.
It will do either light or heavy work,
and will cut either soft or hard wood,
with no possible danger to the operator.
Its many advantages which enable it to
do good work and prove itself a labor
saver require detailed description, so
cuts should be asked for in order to
thoroughly understand what it can do.
The thin saw blade will shave an amount
NEW BAND RIP SAW.
The builders of this tool, J. A. Fay &
Egan Co., Front street, Cincinnati. Ohio,
can be addressed for further particulars.
Their new complete catalogue of wood
working machinery will be sent free to
those interested who write for it, men-
tioning this paper.
Tlie Book=Worm.
The book-worm is described in the
dictionary as a ptinid beetle, and that
rather odd word comes from a Greek
root, which means to destroy. This little
insect is fond of hiding away among the
leaves of books, and in time destroying
the paper. Now it must be remembered
that this little destroying insect does not
eat its way into a book very fast, so that
books which are constantly in use or are
even kept clean do not suiTer from the
inroads of the beetle. The book-worm's
home is the unused library where old
books, treating of dry, uninteresting sub-
jects lie upon shelves covered with cob-
webs and dust. Modern works upon en-
gineering and scientific subjects are not
likely to become food for the book-
worm for a long time to come by rea-
son of the fact that those people who pos-
sess them, read them, and having read
them, refer to them time after time. If
there is anything a book-worm hates, it is
^
(52
June, I (JO.!.
RAHAVAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
273
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS A1
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, M3
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
lAlLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's .''HiKJ'e'e"- Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
•ol« Representative:. In the United States,
Canada and riexico
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EQlilPMEM
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of service
CARS. TREIGHT. PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Monadnock Bidg., Chicugo HI Broadway, New York
AN QUNCl or Pff£VE-NT/V£ /S BlTTfR THA^f rr>¥ POUNDS OF CURE
loffa"<
INVESTMENT
FROMSgqpuPOR''
PATENT MEDICINES
MISERY-5 FINALLY
THIS -
RIDING ABONE SHAKER
you c/in r/KD our Aci about ir by a postal
fJSTANNARD&WHITEGO.
^ ffAC Ifvc UCT. W/S . , ., ,
trying tn settle ilowii in a book which is
constantly taken from the shelf and put
back again. Cast your eye over the list
of books which follows, and see if any
of them, in your opinion, would like-
ly be left on the sliclf by an owm r
who was in active railway work? Do
you think any of these volumes would
ever become a prey for the book-worm?
The first on the- list is, of course.
Railway and I.oiomotivf. Eniwnf.f.r-
INC, a practical journal of railway motive
power and roliina stock. It costs only
$2.00 a year, and is well worth the money,
and besides the paper is a welcome visi-
tor in every household and its popularity
with children is astonishing.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute mucli
of my success in !'fe to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book, combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particu-
larly useful book to the young mechanic.
It has a stimulating efifect in inducing
him to study his business. Price, 50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers likely to
be hired. It contains in small compass
a large amount of information about
the locomotive. Convenient pocket size.
We cordially recommend this book.
Price, 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book '■ 11 instruct a man so that he
will understand the construction and
operation of a compound locomotive as
well as he now understands a simple
engine. Tells all about running, about
breakdowns and repairs. Convenient
pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant" Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horsepower, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list of its contents. It is in the
question and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. Price, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a forman boilermaker. Also contains
several chapters on oil-burning locomo-
tives, so cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
.'^ny person who gives a little study to
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smolce.
C on tain 6 about 800 pract teal queit Ions and
their antwem on tne .Science of Steam
MaklriK. ByWM. M. BaRH. The necensary
cundltlona for the Economic Firing of a
Looomotlve are explained. 8s lllnstratlont.
}49 pages. Cloth. |i.;o.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM
By KoBKKT H. H|.ACK*L|.. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Air-Brake
equipment, containing over i,cx>o quedtloni
and their answeri on the Westlngbouae
Alr-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endoned and used by Alr-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearly every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
164 pafj^es. Cloth, $1.50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By KoBF.RT Grimshaw. It asks 1.600
questions and gives i,<)oo simple, plain,
Practical answers about the Locomotive,
o mathematics, no theories— >uj/ facll.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 450
pages, over 300 Illustrations, and laTarge
Folding Plates. Bound In Maroon Cloth,
$3.00.
XW~A Special Circular e/ Ikest Botki Sent
on Request.
tST'Any of these Books Prefaid te any
Address in the world on Receipt ot Price.
AGENTS WANTED '."^k?* ^^IV,
sell at sight, and every Engineer.
Fireman and Skopman ttaonld have
them. Wrlta for terms aad particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books Is sent free en application.
Norman A. Henlej d C«., Poblishers I
1 132 Nassau St. NEW !QBK, N.Y. |
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from l to r
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
294
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
June, 1903.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
SIZE,
JEWII.S,
SAPPHIUE PALLETS
BALLS niPBOTED
SAFETT
DOIBLE KOLLEU
Are without question
tlie flneet watches that
American tn lent and
ekilled labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing Buch universal Bat-
istaction that we have
no hesitancy in claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
_ watch on the market.
Tests eevere and uumeronshave proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of « ><;^™"''"y> *°
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
Write us for descriptive matter.
TheWebbC. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
JUST PUBLISHED.
8vo, Cloth, 143 pp., with Illustrations and
Diagrams. Price $2.00.
THE
SLIDE Valve
AND ITS FINCTIONS.
With special Reference to Modern
Practice in the United States.
JULIUS BEGTRUP, M.E.
CONTENTS.
Chapter I.-The Common Slide
Valve.
Chapter II.-Improved Slide Valves.
Chapter Ill.-Four-Valve Systems.
Chapter IV.- Independent Cut-Ott.
Chapter V.-The Slide Valve on
Pumps.
Chapter VI.-Angularity of Con-
necting Rod and Eccentric Rod.
D. Van ^'ostrand Company,
Publishers and Booksellers,
23 Murray and j^gW YORK.
27 Warren Streets,
Copies Sent Prepaid on Receipt ot Price.
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. $1.00.
'■Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can afford to do, without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzhng
for want of a little knowledge. 25 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of com-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily un-
derstood by every intelligent fireman. 50
cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons
trying to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. Cloth, 75 ""ts- Leather,
$1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50-
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehen-
sive treatise on the subject. Ought to
be studied by all trainmen where block
signals are used. $3.00.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating ot all trains on single or double
track. Used by nearly all railroads.
Study of this book would prevent many
collisions. Price. 50 cents.
".Mechanical Engineers' Pocket Book."
Kent. This book contains 1,100 pages
6x3'4 inches of closely-printed minion
type, containing mechanical engineering
matter. It ought to be in the book case
of every engineer who takes an interest
in engineering questions. We use it con-
stantly as a reference for questions sent
to us to be answered. Full of tv.bles and
illustrations. Morocco leather. $5.00.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco-
motive. It will be found particularly
useful to men handling or repairing com-
pound locomotives. It is the real loco-
. motive up to date. $2.50.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
iKG. Bound volumes. $300.
STANDARD_BOOKS
LOCOMOTIVE RUNNING
AND MANAGEMENT
By ANGU;^ SINCLAIR.
Thi^ book tells how to manage a locoinotive in
ruTtn ng different kinds of trains Describes vaWe
oear iniectors, brakes, lubricators, etc. It «as
■writ;enhvapr.icticaln,an. 45'^P='Res. Pnce,f2.oo.
LOCOMOTIVES
By H. C. REGAN.
Simple, Compound, Electiic.
4th Edition. , .
This work illustrates the latest impmvements m
locomoUve practice, includes the latest, types of
ocomotlves'^nd treats "f j^Kor'V'y'nd oil burn-
and boiler construction, liquid fuel and oil burn
ing euijines. 604 pages Price, $?.50.
THE MECHANICAL ENGINEER'S
POCKET BOOK
r.th Kililio".
Bv WILLIAM KENT. A.M.. M E.
This is a reference book of rules, tat'l<=';;. ^ata,
formuhe for the use of engineers and students.
Bound in Morocco, 1 1<« pages. I rice. >,, 00.
PRACTICE AND THEORY
OF THE INJECTOR
Bv STRICKLAND L. KNEASS. C E.
It contains an account of the eaily history of the
;„ ector the development of the invention to its
idem' forms. Notes on the shape and proper-
,.(■ »,.v,p.i; atifl the wear of parts. Gives a re
';°w of thefhe'o"ry oHnjectors. 'and has numerous
tables and tests.
N E XV VO R K :
John Wiley & Sons
London: CHAPHAN & HALL, Limited
The Whitney
Wood Scraping Machine
is not intended to reduce the thick-
iiess of lumber, but to produce a
PF.RFECT SURFACE
Brings out all the beauty of the
grain. Write for circular.
BAXTER D. WHITNEY & SON
Winchendon, flass.
Looking at Things and Not Seeing
Tliem.
Some time ago we advised any of our
friends who wished to test their powers
of observation to do the Sherlock
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGILL BUILDING,
Terms Kr.,on.bV. r.mphlet Sen",
June, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
29s
A. Leschcn & Sons Rope Co.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast LJnIoaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
920-922 NorthFirst St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
( lis IC. I.akc St., Clucayo, 111,
■n \. ,,o:„„, I <)2CentrcSt., New YurkCitv- N- Y.
Branch "ffi«s-| s,Kremomst. Shu Fiaiicisco.Cai.
I 1717-?^ Arajiiihoc St . Denver, Col,
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINQFIELD, VERMONT, U.S.A.
A . B.C. and LUberU Code used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
ion's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph, Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott^nstrasse 112, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
MINNEAPOLIS
AND ST. PAUL
Illinois Central R. R.
New line from Chicago via
Rockford, Freeport, Dobuquf ,
Waterloo and Albert Lea.
Fine service and fast " Lim-
ited" nigtit train, with State-
room and Open-section Sleep-
ing Car, Buffet-Library Car
and Free Reclining Chair Car
through without change. Din-
ing Car Service.
A. H. HANSON
G. P. A., Chicago
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests aod Coasuitatlon,
1137 THE ROOKERY, CtllCAQO.
fi6 Broadway. New York. Park BulWing, Pittsburgh
31 Norfolk House, London, Eng.
Inspection of Steel Rail?. Splice Bars, Railroad Cars,
■Wheels, Axles, etc. Chkmical L.\boratory— .\nalyflii
of Ores, Iron, Steel. Oils, Water, etc. Physical L.^BO-
RATOKY— Test of Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, I>r]iw Bai"s, etc.
ElBoiency Tests of Boilers, Engines and Locomotires.
Holmes act on a certain class of
moving pictures vvhicli are nightly pro-
duced by llic Kalatcchnoscopc at any of
lliu F. I-". Proctor's theaters in New
^ ink, Newark. Albany or Montreal. The
chi.ss of pictures to which we referred are
those where a hansom cab or a lire
engine or any wheeled vehicle is driven
rapidly along a public highway. With
such pictures the curious optical illusion
is sometimes presented of a carriage
bowling along, say in a southward direc-
tion, with the wheels apparently turning
slowly as if the vehicle was moving
iiortli.
In a former issue we gave the reason
for this appearance, and showed that the
inoving picture was in reality a series of
separate and motionless poses photo-
graphed on a celluloid film and drawn
rapidly past an illuminating and obscur-
ing mechanism and flashed ujjon a white
screen.
Not long ago a friend of ours said to
us in great glee, '"I have taken your
advice and I went to Proctor's Piili!
Avenue Theater in New York, and I am
a keen observer and don't you forget
it." lie explained how he had seen a
jiicturc ui llic London fire brigade going
to the scene of a conflagration, and
though the horses were galloping the
wheels of the machine appeared to re-
volve lazily backward. Now, we may
here say that you cannot notice this
kind of thing in the Kalatechnoscope
pictures of a moving train, because the
wheels revolve very fast and on an en-
gine the connecting and side rods show
the direction of motion and the swing
of the counter weights heightens tlie
reality of the scene.
We have sometimes speculated on the
result of running the films of a moving
liicture of a last passenger train, back-
ward, as is so often done to produce
humorous and mirth-provoking situa-
tions with human beings. If a train
photographed going ahead were shown
reversed it is probable that the wheels
and the moving parts would show the
train correctly "backing," but how many
in the audience wi>uld notii'o the marker
flags at the rear of the train fluttering
briskly against the wind, or the smoke
and steam flying back swiftly and very
uaturally over the tops of the cars, but
literally in the "teeth of booming gale,"
and section men on the track with their
hats blown off the wrong way? It would
be interesting to show such a picture
and then poll the audience and announce
the number of real observers. Those
who failed to "catch on" would certainly
be among the class of people who are
constantly "looking at things and not
seeing them."
FOR SALE
rRtlCHT, PASSINCCR AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
«NO
ALL ^ADG 4UICK
SIZES. ^/%^0 DELIVERIES
F.M. HICKS,
»9 DIAKSOKM ST.
CHICAGO, ILL.
P
ETERS'
ATENT
OCKET
Tlie Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool
Company of Twenty-first street and Al-
legheny avenue, Philadelphia, have re-
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. J* Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
(hops in the country.
Union of coune. J^ J^
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEH
EHeiHE AND TENDER.
SORAM FLEXIBLE STEAM JOIHT CO., Inc.
No. 149 Third Strett, LauUville, Ky.
Over One
Thousand
"■•eiSS*"' In I IBS
A DAY
on
"The Colorado Special"
Dinner in Chicago Today
Breakfast in Omaha Tomorrow Morning
Pinner in Denver Tuniorr-iw Evening
SPLENDID TRAIN SERVICE
to DENVER via UNION PACIFIC
FuU information cheerfully
furnished on application to
G. P. and Tkt. Agt..
iniaha. Neb.
1^
2y6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
cently got out a folder which they say is
not simply "hot air." By the way, the
effort of all pneumatic tool people ;i to
use cool air all the time. This folder
shows a man speaking into a telephone
transmitter. The telephone wires which
are here bright red lines are artistically
disposed over the paper, through the
reading matter, and leading to a tele-
phone receiver where another man is
listening. The wires pass round by way
of a workman who is chipping out a
dome space in a ^oiler. The inference is
that he is one of the men who will soon
have a new hammer. The Ironworker
Company are telephoning for a dozen
Keller hammers to be sent to the fac-
tory at once. In fact this firm is so very
rushed that they can hardly take
time to inform the Philadelphia Tool
Co. what they think of the Keller ham-
mer and the other pneumatic appliances
made by this firm, but they appear to
be prepared to pay for what they get
and they think "money talks." The Phil-
adelphia Tool Co. will be happy to give
any information concerning Keller pneu-
matic tools to any one who will apply
to them for it.
The L. S. Starrett Company, of
Athol, Mass., have just issued a new and
comprehensive catalogue of small tools
made by them. The appearance of the
publication is exceedingly good, and it
is well printed and fully illustrated. The
catalogue is No. 17, has 176 pages, and
contains information concerning a num-
ber of entirely new tools, as well as new
sizes and improvenjents in tools for-
merly made. The cuts of many of the
tools are full size. The Starrett Com-
pany have an olBce in New York at 123
Liberty street, and they will be happy to
send a copy of this catalogue to anyone
who is sufficiently interested to apply
to them for it.
terial. for those who want it. Falls Hol-
low Stay-bolt Steel has been specified by
the government to be used in sevei-al con-
tracts they let, among them, the boilers
for the new Light House Tenders "Mag-
nolia" and "Ivy," which contracts were
recently placed with the Baltimore Ship
Building & Dry Dock Co.
The Lunkenheimer Company, of Cin-
cinnati, O., manufacturer of brass and
iron steam specialties, etc., have re-
cently placed with the Nernst Lamp
Company, of Pittsburg, a large addi-
tional order for Nernst Lamps of various
sizes. The Lunkenheimer plant is now
illuminated throughout by this make of
lamp, it having been found superior to
others in its uniform quality of light,
with all sizes of units, a feature that is
impossible with a mixture of arc and in-
candescent lamps.
The Falls Hollow Stay-bolt Co. wish
to announce that trade on the celebrated
Falls Hollow Iron is rapidly increasing
and their stay-bolt material has been spe-
cified in many recent large orders for new
locomotive equipment. They continue to
manufacture solid iron, made of the same
high grade of double refined charcoal ma-
The Standard Paint Company, manu-
facturers of the well-known Rub^roid
Roofing and the P & B products, gave
a "house-warming" not long ago in cele-
bration of the completion of their new
factory at Bound Brook, N. J. From a
social standpoint, the affair was a huge
success. There were present some six
hundred people, including the employees
of the company and their friends and
relatives. They danced until the small
hours, being in the meantime regaled
with refreshments, in an immense room
some three hundred and fifty to three
hundred and seventy-five feet long on
the third floor of the new building.
The Standard Paint Company was or-
ganized in 1886 with Ralph L. Shainwald
as president, Silas S. Packard, since de-
ceased, vice-president, and Felix Jellinik,
secretary and treasurer. Mr. Shainwald
and Mr. Jellinik have continuously held
their offices since. Mr. Max Drey is the
present vice-president. The first factory
was erected at Bound Brook, N. J., on a
part of the site of the present works.
Think and speak and act like an ac-
countable creature. — Martin Chxizzkznt.
CONTENTS.
Air Brake Department 265
Armstrong Cutting-oft Macliim- -'"'
Book Reviews -''-
Byrd's Flue Welder -^li
Center Plates and Side Bearings 261
Conditions on the Air Line 257
General Correspondence 253
Growth ot the Locomotive, by Angus
Sinclair 246
Hints on Breakdowns 2S7
Hollow Axles tor Heavy Freight Service . . 2Sa
Hollow Car Axles 263
Inspection Car R. P. C. & 1 259
Locomotives:
Consolidation for the Rock Island 245
Tandem Compound tor the N. Y. C 251
Fast Passenger 4-4-2 for III. Cent 283
Lecture on Mechanics, A 272
Longest Tunnel In the World 261
Looking at Things and Not Seeing Them 294
Millholland, Jas., by E. J. Ranch 273
Modern High Duty Shaper. A 288
More Men Needed on Locomotives 260
New Jerome Packing 283
Over the Nickel Plate, by Angus Sinclair. . 279
Personals 277
Railway Motor Car 291
Roberts' Self-Adjusting Piston Packing 284
Significance of Block Signals, The 260
Terry Bennett's Address, by Shandy
Maguire 273
To Make Something out ot Nothing 262
Tran.^^continental Railways of the World-.. 245
June. 1503.
0 i
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 _
0 c
m
lb
0
0
0
0
) 0 0 0
IV
0 °
0
0 "
0 0
First Cost
" But Keller tools cost so
mtich more."
True — set it down. Now : —
What does slower speed cost .'
What does a breakdown cost .'
What does a failure to fill a
contract cost .' What does a
reputation for slowness cost .'
Keller
Pneumatic
Tools
give other makes a good start,
in lower cost at first. How
many days do you think it takes
them to earn the difference .'
And afterward, they never
stop earning.
Send for our new catalogue. It
is full of good ideas for using pneu-
matic Chipping and Riveting Ham-
mers, Rotary Drills, Foundry Ram-
mers, Yoke Riveters, etc.
Philadelphia
Pneumatic Tool Co.
2ist St. and Allegheny Ave.
Philadelphia
New York Chicago Pittsburgh
San Francisco Boston
or
Railway ..and
lOcomoiive
Gjpyright by Angus Sinclair Co. — J903L
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
Atlantic Type Engine in Qermany.
In sending us particulars of the Ger-
man compound reproduced here, Mr.
M. Richter says:
The Atlantic, or 4-4-2 type of engine,
was introduced into Germany in i8g8, and
for the same reason that it became popu-
lar here, viz. : the necessary enlargement
of the boiler and the increase of grate
area. In the continental type, however,
the pistons drive the forward axle, and
for that practice it is claimed that the re-
ciprocating parts are less heavy than they
are in America, where the main drivers
are usually the rear pair, and conse-
174 Broadway, New York, July, 1903
rangement of both valves, the cut-off is the
same for all four cylinders, and usually
amounts to 40 per cent, of the stroke. The
carrying wheels have radial axle boxes.
For diminishing resistance, or in order
to tlirow tlie smoke and steam high in
air, the smoke bo.x is fitted with a sharp
conical cover similar to that illustrated on
page 210 of the May issue. The cab front
sheet is composed of two .pieces, running
together at an angle of 90 degrees, thus
forming a kind of prow.
The boiler is straight and contains 279
tubes, IS ft. 9 in. long and 2 in. outside
diameter. The working pressure is 228
No. 7
on an adjacent signal post. The signals
for the next block ahead were clearly
visible from where we stood, and pres-
ently, as the thin wisp of steam from the
engine floated on high, she entered the
next block, and the signals stood in-
stantly at danger, while the home sig-
nal close by, "cleared," leaving the cau-
tion blade still in evidence.
A moment later an engine on the same
track backing a caboose, ran under the
outstretched caution arm and about a
hundred yards down the track the sound
of the exhaust ceased. The engine had
hardly drifted a train leng^th, when the.
--wr
GERMAN FOUR-CYLINDER .ATLANTIC TYPE COMPOl'N'D.
quently the German engine has a longer
wheel base and is better balanced.
These engines were built for the Baden
State railways. They were designed to
haul express trains of 200 tons behind the
tender at a speed of from 75 miles per hour
on the level, and at 62 miles per hour on
grades of i in 300. The cylinders are ar-
ranged with the high pressure inside and
the low outside. The cylinders are 13.2
and 22.4x24.4 ins. The ratio of cylinder
volumes is about 2.9. The cranks on a
side are placed at 180 degrees, but are .it
90 degrees with reference to the corre-
sponding ones on the other side, so thit
the balancing is perfect, and the counter-
weights used are for the rotating parts.
The wheels are 82.7 ins. in diameter.
Each side of the engine has only one
valve gear placed outside the wheels and
that is of the Walshaert type. A rocking
shaft moves both valves, that of the high
pressure, being piston with inside admis-
sion, that of the low, is a balanced side
valve. In consequence of the joint ar-
Ibs. per sq. in. The smoke box is of the
very extended type, being 8 ft. 2 in. long.
The fire box is of the wide type, made of
copper with 42 sq. ft. of grate surface ; the
total heating surface is 2.550 sq. ft. The
safety valves are pops, which is a novelty
for Europe.
The tender is carried on two trucks, and
has a tank capacity of S.300 U. S. gallons,
and it carries from 6 to 11 tons of coal.
.Ml wheels on the engine and tender are
braked and the total weight of the engine
in working order is 74 tons with adhesive
weight of 31.9 tons.
With Brain and Hand.
A very interesting object lesson was
given by an engineer the other day on
the Lackawanna, which we, standing be-
side the track, had the pleasure of wit-
nessing. A fast passenger train had just
roared by and had recorded its passage
by turning the home and the caution
semaphores to the horizontal position
now far-away express entering another
block dropped the home, behind it and
nearby caution signals to "all clear."
With the fall of the semaphore blades
the exhaust beats pulsated again, and you
could hear that little "catch in her
breath" which comes when the reverse
lever latch clicks near the center notch,
and away went caboose and engine over
a guaranteed clear line.
The whole incident was most interest-
ing. There was the automatic mechan-
ism— true of action but without volition,
governed only by the applied laws of
nature; and there was the man playing
the game squarely and with skill. The
signals were observed, obeyed, the throt-
tle closed — steam on again at the very
first moment after Safety said "clear."
The man was working with alert mind,
and quick and steady motion. The pic-
ture might have been painted for the
.Academy and called "With Brain and
Hand."
29S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
July, 1903.
Additional Pacts About James
nillholiand's Work.
BY E. J. RAUCH.
Mr. Millholland built a number of
engines for mountain service at the
mines. The first, the "Mountaineer," had
five pairs of 40-inch wheels connected
with a rigid pony truck in front. Cylin-
ders were 19x20 inches. The small
wheels brought the main pin too close to
the ties to look safe, and the remainder
of those he built for same service had
larger wheels. They did good service,
but soon entailed expense on coal cars.
He also built two engines to help trains
on the grade between Falls of Schuyl-
kill and Richmond. The first was the
Phoenix, five pairs of wheels connected
I9x20-inch cylinders — 46-inch wheels. A
peculiar feature of this engine was that
she had two steam pumps instead of the
regulation pump to supply the boiler,
and fill up while standing in engine house
riachiaist Engineers and Engineer
riachinists.
It is worth notice that the very en-
gineers that kick the hardest and ridi-
cule the most and condemn the "machin-
ist runner" the loudest, are the very men
that think they can file rod brasses, re-
duce eccentric straps and line up guides
better than any machinest alive. "Ma-
chinist runners" do not perform road
work as well as men with road experi-
ence, and are just as poor men for en-
gineers as "engineer machinists" are for
repairs and general shop work. What
both ought to do is to know what the
other needs, but not how to do the
other's work.
If more machinists could recognize the
fact that locomotives ought to be put
up so a^ to stand hard usage at full
capacity for twenty-four hours at a
stretch with the engineers caring for
nothing but to use the engine to make
On each side of the shed on a movable
frame there are arranged brushes which
are made to '.revolve rapidly and beside
these brushes' there are perforated water
pipes which when the apparatus in in ac-
tion, give a copious discharge of water.
The whole is operated by steam power,
and the men -employed in the washing of
cars stand behind glass screens which keep
them from getting wet. By the manipula-
tion of levers, the revolving brushes are
brought against the sides of the coaches.
There are water pipes on each side of the
brushes, so that if by any chance the
brushes should leave streaky patches the
Niagara flow washes it ofT.
The brushes are on shafts driven bv
chain gear and sprocket wheals, so that
water has no effect upon them, and the
track is arranged to drain the water oflf
as rapidly as it falls. Something less than
a thousand coaches are thus given their
'tub" every day with thorough English
liaUway ^ Locimutxvt Engitiearing
GERMAN 4-4-2 COMPOUND LOCOMOTIVE.
— no injectors then. The second engine,
the "Pennsylvania," had six pairs of
drivers connected, 46-inch wheels. Cylin-
ders 20x20 inches were connected to third
pair of wheels from front; second and
fifth pairs of wheels were blank. In a
short time this engine was rebuilt and
number of wheels reduced.
As a number of engines on the road
had cast iron wheels and tire, as soon
as the tire wore out the wheel was done
for. Mr. Millholland conceived the idea
of using cast iron tire on all 46-inch and
smaller wheels. He had the centers
made with six bosses in the fellows,
through which steel pointed 1^4 set
screws passed and engaged in a coun-
tersink in the tire. Centers of tires were
turned and bored to templets. The tire
was slipped onto its place, and the set
screws drew it tight and held it. These
tires seldom broke — not oftener than
wrought iron — and could be changed in
a very short time.
time, and more engineers could be made
to recognize the fact that the joints of
a locomotive should be loose ones, that
the machinists know enough to close up
eccentric straps so as to be loose at the
right place, and that they should be
able to adjust wedges, rods and valve
motion better than any engineer, the
better will it be. Six weeks of firing for
the aspirant of the title of "machinist
runner," and six weeks as helper for the
engineer who knows so much about re-
pairs will cure the most aggravated case.
Wasliing a Moving Train.
A sort of a train-washed-while-you-wait
apparatus is in operation on the Great
Western Railway at the West London
yards. It consists of a small shed buHt
over a single track and through this a
yard engine draws a train at the rate of
about four miles an hourj and it comes
out of the shed as cleajj, as a good rub-
down and cold water can make it.
regularity, and the railway company has
found the washing shed to be a time and
labor saver. The plant is the property of
the Universal Carriage Washing Syndi-
cate of London.
Some curious facts are set forth con-
cerning trees by a writer in Scrihner's.
A single oak of good size is said to lift
123 tons of water during the months it is
in leaf. This moisture is evaporated,
and rises to form rain-clouds. All the
trees are busy doing the same thing, and
the rank ferns and mosses, and deep
mould of the forest depths, acting as
reservoirs for the rain which falls upon
them, in their turn feed the springs and
brooks. From this estimate of the labor
of a single oak we can gain some idea of
the immense force which the forests
exert in equalizing the evaporation and
precipitation and preventing periods of
inundation and drought.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
299
Heavy Consolidation for the Pittsburgh
& Lake Erie.
The Piltsburgh shops of Uic American
Locomotive Company have recently built
some heavy 2-8-0 engines for the Pitts-
burgh & Lake Eric Railroad. These en-
gines are simple, whh cylinders 21x30
in., driving wheels 51 in. in diameter.
These wheels carry a weight of 168,150
lbs. The steam pressure is 200 lbs.
The maximum calculated tractive cfifort
is about 44,100 lbs. The motion of these
engines is indirect, with transmission bar
curved below the second axle. The
three rear driving wheels are equalized
together, while the pony truck equalizes
with the leading drivers. 'J"he two lead-
ing drivers have overhung springs, and
the main driver and the trailer have
springs placed between the frame bars
to economize space. All the wheels are
fl.'inged.
Ilia, of tubcM. 2 in.;lcnKthof tubcsovertubcHhccts,
I.I 11. loin,; length of firebox, inside, 120111..
widtli of fire l)ox. inside. 4*)'^ in.
Boiler pressure, 2fjo lbs.; gralc area, 33.4 sq. ft.
Heating surface in tubes, 2,858,828(1. ft.; in firelx>x,
1H1.7M sq. ft ; total, 3 040.6 St], ft.
Dia. of driving wheels outside of tires, 51 in.;
dia. and lengtli of journals, 9^x12 in.; dia.
of engine truck wheels, 30 in,; dia. and
length of journals, 6x10 in.
Working Up Sentiment to Favor
Railroads.
A sentiment in favor of railroad build-
ing in the United States was cultivated
in various ways by enterprising public
men long before railroad building actu-
ally began. After a long, weary struggle
in 1823 Colonel John Stevens, of Hobo-
ken, succeeded in obtaining from the
Legislature of Pennsylvania a charter
for the building of a railroad from Phila-
delphia to Columbia. That was the first
link in the great Pennsylvania Railroad.
its progress shall in no part rise above
an angle of two degrees with the plane
of the horizon.
"Now let us suppose that a section of
the intended railroad be constructed in
the immediate vicinity of the city, of one
mile in extent, in the progress of which
elevations of two degrees do actually
occur. Should it, however, be practica-
ble, on such section of the intended rail-
road, to cause loaded carriages to move
forward and backward, without encoun-
tering any impediment or difficulty,
would it not be presumable that the ef-
fect would be precisely the same were a
similar road to be extended ever so far?
.Such an experiment, then, would not
fail to produce conviction in the minds
of the most incredulous.
"As a further illustration of the prac-
ticability of the proposed railroad, it
would be barely necessary to notice the
HEAVY CONSOLIDATION FOR THE PITTSBURGH & LAKE ERIE.
The boiler is of the straight-top type,
the smallest ring being 76 in, outside
diameter. The crown sheet is level,
wdiile the roof sheet slopes toward the
back about 6 in. This insures plenty of
steam room. There are 370 tubes, which
give 2,858.82 sq. ft. of heating surface.
The total being 3.040.6 sq. ft.
The tender is of the hopper variety,
and carries 14 tons of coal, the tank con-
tains 7,000 gallons of water. The tender
frames are steel channels, and the whole
is carried on Fo.\ pressed steel trucks.
The tender weighs, with fuel and water,
about 139,700 lbs.
A few of the important dimensions arc
appended for reference:
Total wgt. of enjr. in working order, 189,150 lbs.;
on drivers, 16S.150U5S.; driv'ing wheel base of
engine, 16 ft.; total, 24 ft. 8 in.
Height of stack above rail. 15 ft. 2% in.
Cylinders, diameter and stroke, 21x30 in.
Ilia, at smallest ring, outside. 76 in.; throat, 77S4
in ; backhead, 74^^ in.
Crown sheet supported by radial stays, I'i in. dia.
Staybolts, 1 in. dia., spaced 4x4 in. centers.
In advocating the enterprise Col.
Stevens issued a public address which
makes curious reading to-day. At that
time there was not a yard of railroad
track in the United States and nothing
in Europe except freight tramways op-
erated by horses. Col. Stevens' address
reads:
"It is now generally admitted that a
railroad is not a mere visionary project,
but is actually practicable. .An erroneous
idea has, however, prevailed among its
opponents, that it is only practicable
to short distances, and that the contem-
plated extension of a railroad to a dis-
tance of -3 miles is ridiculous.
".\s the railroad will, throughout its
course, be in its construction exactly
similar, it is only in its deviations from
a horizontal line that any difference in
the progressive motion of carriages'
thereon can take place. The charter con-
tains a provision that the railroad in
rapid progress this important improve-
ment has recentl}' made in the island of
Great Britain. If in the narrow limits
of 21 miles in length and 12 miles in
breadth, in the immediate vicinity of
Newcastle, no less than 450 miles of rail-
road have within a very short period of
time been formed, why should it not be
practicable to erect one extending only
73 miles? The contemplated formation
of a railroad from Manchester to Liver-
pool, between which large towns there
now exists a spacious canal, demon-
strates very forcibly its feasibility and
great utility.
"The expense of the contemplated rail-
road is estimated at about $5,000 per
mile. One thousand shares, then, at five
dollars each, would be sufficient for the
construction of one mile of the road.
"An appeal is now, therefore, made to
the enlightened patriotism and to the en-
terprising spirit of the good citizens of
Philadelphia to step forward, and, by an
300
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
advance of five dollars each, to place the
contemplated improvement beyond all
possibility of doubt or uncertainty.
"That the stock will, from the start,
yield more, than legal interest, there can-
not be a shadow of a doubt. That it will,
ultimately, and at no distant period, yield
12 per cent, per annum, is equally cer-
tain.
"The contemplated railroad will dififer
from turnpike roads in these very im-
portant particulars. The actual expense
of transportation on the railroad will be
reduced to one-quarter of what it now
is on the existing turnpikes. But the
most essential point of difference, as it
regards stockholders, is that the whole
of the emoluments to be derived from
the transportation of commodities, and
from the conveyance of passengers, will
Western lakes. Philadelphia may then
become tiie grand emporium of the West-
ern country.
"Should the subscription for the shrres
be speedily filled the road from Philadel-
phia to Columbia may with ease be fin-
ished before the next winter, and thus
the stockholders will derive an immediate
interest on their stock."
Grand Trunk Front End.
The Grand Trunk people are using a
front end arrangement which combines
simplicity with effectiveness. Our illus-
trations show the netting in the smoke-
box of a crossover compound. The re-
ceiver pipes are not shown, in order that
the netting arrangement may be more
clearly seen.
head well into the upper chamber of the
smokebox, and when in that position he
stands directly in front of the exhaust
pipe, and within reach of all joints, open-
ings, flanges, etc., which he may wish to
get at. A piece of upright netting,
about the shape of a half-moon counter-
balance, though larger, is placed in the
front of the box. This prevents sparks
or cinders from getting around the
arched netting and from entering the
upper chamber without being broken up
in passing through the standard mesh.
The deflector plate is not made so as
to be adjustable. The central portion
is cut in the form of a door, and is
hinged from the top, which aflfords con-
venient ingress to the flue sheet. Our
illustration shows the sides cut to suit
the curves of the receiver pipe, but this
Raiiway ^-LocvmoHvaEnifijutAngj
FRONT END ARRANGEMENT— GRAND TRUNK RAILWAY .SYSTEM.
go to the railroad company, whereas the
turnpike company receives only a toll.
The expense of repairs will bear no pro-
portion to that incurred on turnpike
roads. The railroad, too, will be equally
good at all seasons of the year. This
circumstance gives to a railroad a de-
cided superiority also over a canal, which
continues, for months, during the winter
season, locked up by frost.
But when, in the progress of improve-
ment, the power of steam shall be sub-
stituted for that of horses, transporta-
tion will most assuredly be afforded at
much less than on a canal. However
extraordinary this opinion may appear,
by a recurrence to calculation, it is,
nevertheless, capable of demonstrative
proof. And when this great improve-
ment in transportation shall have been
extended to Pittsburgh, and thence into
the heart of the extensive and fertile
State of Ohio and also to the great
The netting is put in as a rather flat
arch of 8-foot radius, which goes across
the smokebox and springs from the sides
about 6 inches above the center line.
The netting, which is cut to suit the re-
ceiver pipe, is carried back to the de-
flector plate, which is just in front of the
e.xhaust pipe.
The deflector plat-, is carried up a few
inches above the highest point of the
netting arch, and runs straight across
the smokebox. In fact the deflector
plate is placed at the level of the joint
between exhaust pipe and exhaust nozzle.
From the deflector plate to the flue sheet
a solid No. 10, B. W. G. steel plate cuts
ofT the space below the top tubes from
that above, and through this horizontal
plate the steam pipes pass with closely
fitted openings.
In the center of the netting there is a
manhole 18x14 ins., which, when open,
enables a workman to get his arms and
plate is carried solidly across in other
engines, which do not use receiver pipes.
The determination of the position of the
deflector plate is arrived at by test for
a given class of engine, and when its
most satisfactory position has been de-
termined, all the engines of that class
are equipped with non-adjustable deflec-
tor plates and a certain amount of what
is generally called "grief" connected
with front ends is thereby eliminated.
The salient feature, however, about
the whole arrangement, is its lack of
complication and the room and con-
venience it affords to those who are
compelled to work in the smokebox.
Lifting up the hinged door in the de-
flector plate gives immediate access to
the flue sheet, and removing the netting
manhole cover in the netting gives ac-
cess to the upper chamber. The rest of
the smokebox appears to be positively
roomy.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
30
Fast Passenger 4-4-2 F.nglne for the
Pennsylvania Lines West of
Pittsburgh.
The engines which we here illustrate
were recently turned out of the Schenec-
tady shops of the American Locomotive
Company. They are intended to haul
seven to ten-car trains on the Pittsburgh
& Chicago and the Pittsburgh & Cleve-
land divisions of the Pennsylvania Lines.
The first ten engines of this order of
32 are equipped with piston valves, as
shown in our half-tone. The remaining
engines have ordinary Richardson bal-
anced slide valves. The cylinders are
2oM!X26, and the driving wheels are
80 inches in diameter. The weight car-
ried on the drivers is about 109,000 lbs.,
and the calculated tractive eflfort is about
23,800 lbs., while the ratio existing be-
tween tractive power and adhesive weight
is as I is to 4.57.
The valve motion is direct, having a
The boiler is 67 ins. diameter at the
lirst ring, and has a wide fire-box of
the Belpaire type. The two injectors
are placed on the back boiler head and
deliver water to the boiler through one
copper pipe which runs forward over
the crown sheet, and being joined to an
iron pipe just beyond the front end of
this sheet the delivery pipe is then bent
over to the right side, just clearing the
throttle rigging, and delivers water about
30 ins. from the front flue sheet or round
head. The crown sheet itself is perfectly
level, and is stayed in the usual way.
The boiler is liberally provided with
wash-out plugs of ample size, and there
are, in addition, two six-inch hand holes
in the bottom of the barrel, one near the
front and one near the back.
The trailing truck is self-centering;
suspension links are used so that the
action of gravity brings wheels in
position after rounding a curve. The
therefore, about 13,000 lbs. of coal was
saved on the regular coal allowance.
Some of the principal dimensions are
as follows:
OKNERAF, DIMENSIONS.
WciKht in working order, 176,600 Itw.
Weight on (IrivcrR, 109,000 lbs.; weight engine and
tender in working order, 311. 100 lbs.
Wheel base, driving, 7 ft. 5 in.; total, 30 ft. 9J4 in.
Wheel base, total, engine and tender, 60 ft. 2^g in.
Cylinders, 20J4X26 in.
VALVES.
Greatest travel of slide valves. 7 In.; outside lap of
slide valves, t'yi in.; inside clearance of slide
valves, ^ in.; lead of valves in full gear, J, in.
Wheels, dia. of driving wheels outside of lire, 80
in.; tire held by Shrinkage & Gibson fastening.
BOII.KR.
Working pressure, 205 lbs.
rire lx>x. length, iii in.; width, 72 in.;depth, front,
67,'b in.; back, 64^^ in.; plates, thickn., sides, ^^
in ; Ijck., ^''^ in.; crown, }% in.; tube sheet, ^ in.;
water space. 4 in. fnt., 4 in. sides, 3'^ in. back.
Tubes, material and gauge, iron No, 11, B. W. G.;
number, 315; dia., 2 in.; length over tube sheeU,
15 ft. I in.
Heating surface, tubes, 2 474 sq. ft.; fire box, 165.7
SI ft.; total 2 6?9.7 .'q. ft ; grate sur . 55.5 sq. ft.
ATLANTIC TYPE ENGINE FOR THE PENNSYLVANIA LINES WEST OF PITTSBURGH.
slightly curved transmission bar pass-
ing over the leading axle. The valves
are outside admission, with 3V in. lead
in full gear forward and back. The
cross-head is of special form, as are also
the guides. The design has been pat-
ented by Mr. A. Vogt, the mechanical
engineer of the Pennsylvania. The
cross-head is in principle a modified
Laird cross-head, in which the center
line of the piston is considerably below
the top of the cross-head. The sliding
part is really encased in the guide bar.
The guide is designed with broad,
flat surface to take the usual heavy up-
thrust of the cross-head when the engine
is in forward motion, but the guide is
also made to enclose the sides and a
small portion of the underside of the
working portion of the cross-head. The
cross-head is made of steel and the por-
tion covered by the guide is traversed
by two lightening cores, so that the de-
sign probably secures the lightest and
the strongest form of cross-head yet
made for engines of this class.
driving tires are secured to their wheel
centers by shrinkage and by the Gibson
fastening, which consist of a dove-tail
ring on the inside and a lip on the out-
side of the tire, which, when the tire is
in place, is driven hard over on the taper-
ing face of the rim of the wheel center.
The work which is being done by these
engines is very satisfactory, as shown
from the account recently given of a
sister engine, No. 7373- This engine
ran from Crestline, Ind., to Fort Wayne
— a distance of 131 miles on schedule time
with the 5-car Pennsylvania Limited,
without taking water on the trip. She
then doubled back to Crestline, without
addition to the fuel supply, drawing eight
heavy coaches, and again without taking
water on the trip. It was then sent back
to Fort Wayne with fuel still on the
tender and without taking water en
route. The three trips, making a total
of 393 miles, was run on 15,000 lbs. of
coal, though the allowance which engines
of this class are entitled to for these
trains is something over 28.OCO lbs..
Exhaust pipes, single, low; nozzles, with nipples for
blower and fit. with muffler, dia., 5. 5ji, 5H in.
Smokestk., inside dia., 16 and iS^i in; top abv. rail.
14 ft. ilj^ in.
TENDER.
Style, with water bottom; wheel base, 20 ft. 6 in.
Tender frame. 10 in. steel channels.
Water capacity, 7.000 U. S. gals.; coal, 10 tons.
The Canadian Pacific Railway people
are still looking abroad for their sup-
ply of locomotives. In addition to the
engines which they ordered from Glas-
gow, they have recently placed a contract
with a locomotive company at Chemnitz
for twenty locomotives. They will be
built after the drawings and specifica-
tions of the railway company. There is
an impression existing that the importa-
tion of foreign built engines into Canada
will demonstrate how they compare for
economy with the American engines, but
we do not think that anj-thing of the
kind will be shown, because the engines
that come from abroad will be precisely
the same as those built in the United
States by other companies.
302
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
July, 1903-
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
( Coiitin lied from page 24S. )
PIONEER LOCOMOTIVE BUILDING SHOPS.
During the first decade of the railway
era in the United States, that is, from
1830 to 1840. the development of the loco-
motive on native lines vi-as seriously re-
tarded through want of shops where lo-
comotives could be built according to
the ideas of American inventors.
As long as the British Government
ruled the colonies, the short-sighted
policy was pursued of discouraging in-
dustries which converted raw material
into marketable commodities. The rul-
ers wanted the colonists to devote their
energies to the raising of cotton, to-
bacco and other products of the soil,
and to permit the mother country to
perform all the manufacturing processes
on the raw material. Particular objec-
tions were raised against the colonies
engaging in iron and steel industries.
The rich iron ores found in various lo-
calities had tempted the colonists into
converting it into marketable iron and
steel. This excited so much opposition
on the other side of the Atlantic that
Parliament repeatedly enacted laws re-
stricting iron making in the colonies,
and the exportation of machinery and
tools used in metallurgical operations
was forbidden. These restrictions helped
materially to fan the flames of discontent
which culminated in the war of indepen-
dence.
COLONISTS TAKE READILY TO MECHANICAL
PURSUITS.
After independence was won the peo-
ple turned readily to industrial pursuits,
but the art of machine 'making developed
slowly, and it had only about fifty years
to grow when the railroad era began.
The people in the American colonies
were nearly all brought up to the use of
the axe, the blacksmith's hammer and
other tools, and most of them took read-
ily to mechanical pursuits. In fact, by
training and tradition American business
men, farmers and others came to con-
sider themselves as good mechanics as
those trained to the business, a peculiar-
ity which led men to design and build
locomotives without any exact training
in the mechanic arts.
L'p to the time that railroad building
began, the principal mechanical estab-
lishments were forges, wheelwright
shops and millwright shops, the three
sometimes being combined. In the large
cities there wrere "foundries" which did
all sorts of jobbing in metals, and there
were also a few jobbing shops devoted
to repairing machinery, mostly of tugs
and steamboats.
WEST POINT FOUNDRY.
In 1830 the West Point Foundry, New
York, owned by Messrs. Kimball, was
one of the most important machine shops
in the United States, and there naturally
went the pioneer locomotive designers to
have their engines made. The capacity
of the place was, however, limited, loco-
motive building was not regarded as a
promising business, and the concern had
all the steamboat and general work it
could attend to. On this account orders
for the construction of locomotives were
refused after four or five had been built.
JAMES' ENGINE BUILDING SHOP.
As early as 1828 William T. James,
an inventive genius who had a small
machine shop in Eldridge Court, New
York, began to experiment in building
road locomotives. His first production
was a small locomotive with cylinders
2x4 inches, which he ran upon a circu-
lar track pulling a train of miniature
cars. It was an attractive and popular
exhibition, and indicated the interest peo-
ple were taking in steam applied to land
transportation. James afterward built
several steam road carriages which were
fairly successful considering the kind of
roads thev had to travel on. He also
ATLANTIC. FIG. 25.
built two railroad locomotives, one for
the Baltimore & Ohio trials which will
be described in due course.
SMALL MACHINE OWNERS AS LOCOMOTIVE
BUILDERS.
An agitation in favor of railroad build-
ing intensified, various owners of small
machine shops displayed willingness to
engage in building locomotives which
then were no larger than the modern
fire engine. The first practical move in
this direction was made when Col. Ste-
phen Long, of the United States Topo-
graphical Engineers, and Jonathan
Knight, the first chief engineer of the
Baltimore & Ohio, obtained a char-
ter from the State of Pennsylvania for
the American Steam Carriage Company.
The intention was to build steam loco-
motives, but two years elapsed before
they built their first engine, and then
William Norris supervised the work.
DAVIS & GARTNER AS LOCOMOTIVE BUILD-
ERS.
About the time that Long and Knight
were organizing their steam carriage
company in Philadelphia. Phineas Davis,
a watchmaker, of York, Pa., was inter-
esting himself keenly in locomotives,
and studying everything he could find
about their construction and operation.
When the Baltimore & Ohio directors
offered a prize for a locomotive, Davis
formed a partnership with a machinist
named Gartner, and they proceeded to
build a locomotive which was completed
in a few months and was called the
"York," particulars of which have already
been published. The success of the
"York" brought to Davis & Gartner or-
ders for two more engines. The second
engine of their build was called the "At-
lantic," Fig. 25, an engine weighing about
14,500 pounds, then considered a little
beyond the safe weight for locomotives
running on strap rails. The finger marks
of Ross Winans were very prominent on
this engine, which had several important
improvements over the "York," and was
regarded for the time as the standard of
weight and power for a grasshopper en-
gine. The third engine built in the
"York" shops was called the "Traveler."
It had the power at first transmitted di-
rect to a cranked axle, but that breaking,
the engine was changed to conform to
the design of the Atlantic, which trans-
mitted the power through gearing
and a supplementary driving shaft. The
"Traveler" completed the locomotive
building of Davis & Gartner, as the Bal-
timore & Ohio Railroad Company built
shops for themselves which were ready
in 1833, when it was expected that all
locomotives required could be built and
repaired.
WATCHMAKERS AS LOCOMOTIVE BUILDERS.
In connection with the engineering
work of Phineas Davis, it is interesting
to note that he was a watchmaker by
trade, Mtid that two others who built
locomotives for the Baltimore & Ohio
competition were trained to the same
business. Matthias W. Baldwin, who es-
tablished the most successful building
locomotive works in the world, was
trained to the trade of a jeweler. This is
a good illustration of how native genius
will assert itself and defy adverse circum-
stances of early training.
COSTELL ORGANIZES LOCOMOTIVE BUILD-
ING SHOPS.
Another aspirant at establishing a loco-
motive building shoo was Stacey Cos-
tell, a watchmaker, who in 1831 organized
the Pennsylvania Locomotive Works, of
Philadelphia. Under the direction of
Costell a locomotive with double acting
oscillating cylinders was built in the
works for the Baltimore & Ohio compe-
tition which did not prove a success, and
its failure led to the closing up of the
locomotive building shop for good.
There were a few other tentative shops
started where a few locomotives were
built, but most of them failed. Those
which succeeded in keeping at work for
five vears have become historical.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
303
ORIGIN OF Tin; DAI.IJWIN LOCOMOTIVE
WORKS.
The i)ionecr successful locomotive
building shop was started by Matthias W.
Baldwin in 1831. Mr. Baldwin learned
the jeweler trade in Philadelphia, and in
l8ig opened a small shop on his own
account. Si.x years later he entered into
partnership with David Mason, a ma-
chinist, to engage in the manufacture of
book binders' tools and cylinders for
calico printing. The business was so
successful that steam power became
necessary, and. Mr. Baldwin designed
and built an engine which proved par-
ticularly well adapted for the require-
ments of the shop. The success of this
engine led the firm into the business of
engine building, and turned Mr. Bald-
win's attention to steam engineering, and
the way was prepared for his grappling
the difficult problems of locomotive
construction.
some of thcin were crude tramways with
wooden rails, but their existence indi-
cated vigorous activity among railroad
promoters. The coal that was being
mined in increasing quantities had to be
conveyed as cheaply as possible to points
where water carriage would convey it
to a market, and a wooden tramway en-
abled a horse to haul a much heavier
load than could be moved over the exe-
crable roads then the rule.
BALDWIN HUILDS A SMALL LOCOMOTIVE.
In 1830 Franklin Peale, then proprietor
of the Philadelphia Museum, resolved to
gratify public curiosity concerning rail-
roads by introducing into his establish-
ment a small working locomotive and
train of cars. He naturally applied to
Mr. Baldwin to make the engine, for that
gentleman had become the best authority
on engine building in the Quaker City.
The work was duly carried out and the
engine was put into operation on
April IS, 1831, pulling two small passen-
is not exactly correct, for the so-called
Planet class of engine had one pair of
big driving wheels placed in front of the
firebox, and one pair of small carrying
wheels placed under the smoke-box.
The "John Bull" had two pairs of wheels
the same size coupled. The first engine
of that type was built for the Liverpool
& Manchester Railway in 1831, and was
called the "Samson." Nearly all the
locomotives which Robert Stephenson &
Co. sent to the United States were of this
Samson pattern.
"old ironsides" built.
Mr. Baldwin proceeded with the build-
ing of the engine for the Philadelphia.
Germantown & Norristown Railroad,
and it was first tried November 23. 1832.
It was called the "Old Ironsides" (Fig. 27).
It was a four-wheel engine with the driv-
ing wheels in front of the fire-box and
the carrying wheels close behind the
smoke-box. In working order the en-
gine weighed about 11,000 pounds. The
BALDWIN'S FIRST ENGINE. FIG. 26.
"OLD IRONSIDES." FIG. 2r.
BALDWIN BUILDS A ST.VTIONARY ENGINE.
The first stationary engine (Fig. 26)
built by Mr. Baldwin prior to 1830 is still
in good order, preserved in the Baldwin
Locomotive Works. It has successively
supplied the power in six different de-
partrnents as they have been opened,
from time to time, in the growth of the
business.
INTEREST IN MECHANIC ARTS IN PHILA-
DELPHIA.
Philadelphia has always taken the lead
in the development of the mechanic arts
in the United States. It was therefore
natural that public curiosity should be
excited by everything relating to the rail-
roads that were creating much discussion
at home and abroad. Everything relat-
ing to this novel form of land transporta-
tion must have been the town talk of in-
telligent people in Philadelphia in 1830
and 1831, for railroad building schemes
for the neighborhood were very numer-
ous, as may be judged from the fact that
Pennsylvania State reports intimated
that there were sixty-seven railroads in
operation in the State in 1832.
Most of them were small, of course, and
ger cars which seated four passengers,
around a circular track in the museum.
BALDWIN RECEIVES ORDER FOR ROAD
LOCOMOTIVE.
Shortly after the Peale model engine
was put to work the Philadelphia, Ger-
mantown & Norristown Railroad Com-
pany ordered from Mr. Baldwin a loco-
motive to operate their line, si.x miles of
which had just been finished, and was
operated by horses. The Camden &
.•\mboy Railroad had imported their
famous "John Bull" from the works of
Robert Stephenson & Co., a short time
before, and this engine was stored in a
shed at Bordentown. Mr. Baldwin, in
company with his friend, Mr. Peale,
visited Bordentown and carefully exam-
ined the parts of the engine, which were
not yet put together. He took some
sketches and memoranda and with the
aid of these undertook to build a full-
size locomotive.
THE ''.TOHN BULL."
The Englisli engine which Baldwin
used as a pattern has generally been
called of the "Planet" class of engine. That
cylinders were gJ^xiS inches, the driving
wheels were 54 inches, and the front
wheels 45 inches diameter. The boiler
was 30 inches diameter and contained 72
copper flues lYz inches by 7 feet.
The builder experienced considerable
trouble before he got the "Old Iron-
sides" to work satisfactorily, but the dif-
ficulties encountered were as nothing
compared with those the English builders
had to overcome.
The engine was put into regular train
service v,'ith as little delay as possible,
and the railroad company displayed so-
licitude about the care of the engine
which was in striking contrast to later
day practice. They advertised that their
new locomotive engine would haul cars
at certain times if the weather was fair,
but when it rained the cars would be
pulled by horses.
C.RE.\T SPEED ATTAINED BY THE "OLD
IRONSIDES."
According to an article which appeared
in the Railroad Journal for 1833. Dr. Pat-
erson, of the University of Virginia, and
Mr. Peale, rode on the engine and kept
the time when, with its regular train, it
304
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
ran one mile in 58 seconds, and 2V4 miles
in 3 minutes and 22 seconds.
ORGANIZING A SHOP.
The most important work which Mr.
Baldwin performed in connection with
the building of his first locomotive was
the organizing of shops where such work
could be carried on. He was very much
in the position that James Watt was
when building one of his first engines.
After the cylinder was bored he reported
that the work was so well done that he
could not push a half crown between the
piston and the cylinder at any place. Mr.
Baldwin suffered from the want of
skilled mechanics and had to instruct
workmen besides designing and building
many of the tools employed.
THE NORRIS WORKS STARTED. .
Col. Long, whose name has already
been mentioned, was assailed with a
virulent fever of locomotive designing
and building, from which he suffered
for several years. Having met William
Norris, a business man of Baltimore, he
infected that gentleman with the same
fever.
These two enthusiasts formed a part-
nership, and under the name of Long &
Norris became successors of the Ameri-
can Steam Carriage Company. They be-
gan to build locomotives in Philadelphia
about the same time as Mr. Baldwin,
and had a very checkered career for sev-
eral years, but Mr. Norris persevered
and made the business successful. The
Norris Works built one locomotive in
1832, one in 1833, one in 1834, two in
183s. eight in 1836, and so on in increas-
ing scale up to one hundred in 1854. Up-
ward of 1,000 locomotives were built in
the Norris works, and of these 17 were
exported to the Birmingliam & Glouces-
ter Railw.ay, of England, and 153 to the
continent of Europe.
There was a keen rivalry between Bald-
win and Norris in the early days, and the
engines of each had their friends and de-
tractors. The engines of the two builders
were developed on similar lines so far as
power and weight were concerned. Bald-
win placed the drivers of his engines be-
hind the fire-box and Norris put them
in front of the fire-box. The merits of
the relative positions excited no end of-
discussion among the railroad men of
that day.
William Norris afterward established
locomotive building works in Vienna,
and Colburn, author of a well-known his-
tory of the locomotive, says that his
models of locomotives were reproduced
with trifling alterations by M. Meyer,
who still enjoys the credit of originating
a variety of valve gear which was intro-
duced from the United States.
{To be continued.')
Ross Winans.
BY K J. RAUCH.
The name of Ross Winans is certainly
deserving of a place among the names
of the locomotive builders of America.
He was in the business early in the ad-
vent of railroads in this country; and in-
vented and built many locomotives that
were equal to the best, and superior to
many, of those built by others of the
same day.
He early turned his attention to the
construction of locomotive engines to use
bituminous coal as a fuel, and for years
held the "palm" for such engines. Some-
where about 1844 or '45, the Philadelphia
& Reading Railroad began experiment-
ing with anthracite coal as a fuel for
their engines. It was not a success and
Winans was called on to build an engine
for that company. He would not con-
tract for one engine, but agreed to build
four— which he did. The first one of the
RUSS WI.VAXS.
four was named "Baltimore," an 8-wheel
connected engine— horizontal cylinders—
18x20 inches, 4 6-inch solid cast-iron
wheels, weight about 22^ gross tons.
She was fitted with a variable exhaust
controlled by the engineer; and consid-
ering the limited knowledge of the en-
gineers and firemen of those days, was a
grand success.
Right here trouble came in for Mr.
Winans. The Philadelphia & Reading
people had commenced the construction
of a coal-burning engine, and not being
able to get it built before the advent of
the Winans engine, numerous objections
were raised against her, in order to keep
her back until the Philadelphia & Read-
ing engine was in service. First she was
found to be too wide across the cylinders
by an inch. Winans came to Reading
and brought with him a couple of ma-
chinists who took off an inch and a half
of the flanges of cylinders, and so re-
duced the width.
Next objection was that the weight
on back axles was much too great.
Again Mr. Winans came to Reading
brmging his draughtsman, Mr. Whistler,
and took some measurements. In about
two weeks Winans again appeared with
some mechanics, and a lot of appliances
that he placed against the fire-box behind
the axle and under the foot-board that
took, at first, too much weight of! the
hind wheels. A small strong pad was
put on fire-box near the grate line and
just behind the wheels on both sides.
A steam cylinder was attached to each
side of the fire-box, below the foot-board;
a pair of 14-inch wheels was placed on
track close behind the fire-box; a spring,
half elliptic, ran from the pads at one
end, to the axle box on the wheels at
other end. On top of this spring near-
est the back end was a boss with a coun-
tersunk socket. From the piston, in the
steam cylinder, the rod ran down and
rested in this socket. When steam was
on the boiler the same pressure was in
these cylinders, and, of course, lightened
up the rear end of engine. The device
worked nicely until by any chance those
carrier wheels dropped off the track.
Then the spring fell away from the piston
rod, there was no head to lower end of
the cylinder, and no check between the
cylinder and boiler; and, of course, the
water was all blown out.
When James Millholland became mas-
ter mechanic of the Philadelphia &
Reading in 1847, and demonstrated to
that company that their effort to use
anthracite coal with the "Novelty" was
a failure, these carrier wheels were dis-
carded on the "Baltimore" and the three
other engines that meanwhile had been
deli^red. Owing to the construction
nf the rear end of the fire-box of these
engines, the pulling bar was attached by
one end to the ash pan, and other end
to a bolster of front truck of tender,
passing under a pit in front of tender
from which the fireman fed fuel to the
fire-box.
The back end of the fire-box was open
from grate to crown sheet. This space
was filled in with the fire doors. The
lower door was an open grate reaching
across the fire-box. Above this door
were two solid doors for firing through.
The grate bars extended out beyond the
lower fire door, and by means of a lever
could be raked, thus breaking any clinker
that might have formed, and shaking it,
with the ashes, into the ash pan. The
arrangement was a good one; giving
clear access to the fire, also allowing it
to be drawn quickly in an emergency,
by opening the fire doors.
Winans adhered to this plan of grates
and fire doors in nearly, if not quite, all
the engines he subsequently built.
About 1850 or '51, Mr. Winans began
to send some "camel back" locomo-
tives to the Philadelphia & Reading
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
305
Railroad. He seemed to have recog-
nized the necessity for the engineer hav-
ing a better chance to see where he was
going, as the cab on these engines was
on top of tlie boiler and engineers stood
close behind the smokestack. About
1854 or 'S5 Winans built and sent to
the Philadelphia & Reading a unique
passenger locomotive. Boiler was of the
long fire-box, 7 foot grates — "camel
back" type. To show the excellence of
his boiler makers' skill, there was no
jacket or covering of any kind on the
boiler. It was hammer hand riveted,
but not a hammer mark was visible on
the sheets. The engine weighed about
22j/^ tons, was 4-wheel connected, with
a 6-foot spread truck. Driving wheels
five feet diameter — cast with tire entire.
Cylinders 19.X22 inches. The peculiar
feature of this engine was the cab loca-
tion, which was on the platform of front
end.
Being fitted with the Winans' hook and
cam motion valve gear, the reverse lever,
starting bars, hand levers, and gauge
cocks were all in the cab within easy
reach of the engineer.
This engine, "The Celeste," was run
on passenger trains for several months,
but owing to the cast-iron driving wheels
being thought unsafe was changed to
other service. At first there was some
trouble with the spread truck boxes run-
ning hot, but the master mechanic of
the Philadelphia & Reading found a
remedy. After about three years' serv-
ice, one of the driving wheels did break
but did no damage.
The Philadelphia & Reading Company
not being able to build locomotives fast
enough to keep up with the demands of
the fast increasing coal trade, Winans
placed a large number of his engines on
that railroad. They were different from
the original "camel back" in the length
of the fire-box, which sloped, with flat
surface, from line of top of boiler to
about a center line through the same.
On this slope there were two chutes
opening into fire-box, one near flue
sheet and the other about center of fire
box. These chutes had doors top and
bottom, and were filled with coal and
the coal was dumped into fire-box with-
out the admission of cold air. With
poor fuel, these chutes very materially
helped the steaming of the boiler. These
engines all had a "cam motion" cut-off,
which was operated by the same lever
that controlled the hooks of eccentrics.
It was simply thrown one notch ahead
of forward hook motion to put cam in
gear. All the hooks were controlled by
segments of discs on a shaft running
across from frame to frame under them.
If the engine ran over any obstruction
that knocked out this shaft, all the hooks
dropped in gear in the rocker shaft, and
disconnecting of valve motion was com-
plete.
Ross Winans had no belief in a com-
bustion chamber in a locomotive boiler.
His theory, as carried out by him,
was, as much grate and flue surface
as you can get, and as few parts as will
do the work. The side rods of his en-
gines were fitted with bushings for the
pins, and his main rods had only gib and
key to hold on the straps at front and
back ends. The writer was among
Winans' engines and ran many of them
during a term of IS or 16 years, and never
knew of a main rod disconnecting.
On one of the earlier Camelbacks sent
by Winans to the Philadelphia h Read-
ing Railroad was a steam gauge, prob-
ably the first one on any locomotive.
It was a double diaphragm, about 24
inches in diameter, attached to lower
near end of the erecting shop. All the
various parts of the machinery for en-
gines were placed in the erecting shop,
on both sides, and were taken up and
attached in place to the virgin boiler in
the order they were needed, the boiler
being moved along as required until the
finished engine was pushed out the doors
to the street. In a busy season half a
dozen boilers, in all stages of progress,
would be on this line at same time.
The breaking out of the war in 1861
in some way interfered with Mr. Winans'
business, and he dropped out of notice.
New York, May 25, 1903.
Voluntary Advance of Foremen's Pay.
Information has been received that
the mechanical department of the Erie
Railroad has increased the wages of fore-
men in sums ranging from $500 to $25.00
a month. This is a move in the right
direction and we should like to see oth-
GREAT NORTHERN OF ENGLAND-ATI..\NTIC TYPE ENGINE. VESTIBULE CORRIDOR
CAR TRAIN, LONDON-LEEDS SERVICE. PILLMAN VESTIBULES WITH
GOULD AUTOMATIC COUPLERS THROUGHOUT.
part of the boiler, near the front end.
A pipe ran from this diaphragm up to
about the center line of the boiler, to
keep out the mud. From a stud on this
diaphragm across the center a compound
lever ran to near the right-hand frame,
and was there attached to a rod running
up to a guide in cab close to engineer.
The change is pressure caused this rod
to rise or fall through the guide and
thus indicate the boiler pressure. It
worked well.
Another feature of the Winans' loco-
motive was his "variable exhaust." It was
certainly among the best, if not the very
best, appliance of the kind ever in use.
The Winans Shops at Mt. Clare, Mary-
land, were a model of economy and sys-
tem. The erecting shop was one long,
straight track from boiler shop to a con-
necting siding of the Baltimore & Ohio
Railroad. The finished boiler was rolled
on small trucks from boiler shop to the
er railroad companies giving more salary
to the men who perform the important
duties in carrying on the work in dif-
ferent departments. Naturally a foreman
cannot agitate for increase of pay, or,
at least, cannot put any pressure upon
the powers that pay to convince them,
that foremen ought to be better paid than
most of them are, and, therefore, they
are habitually left without any advance
while all the workmen in the establish-
ment receive increase of pay. We often
hear the expression made that men
would be paid just wages without any
agitation to secure the same, but the un-
derpaid foreman is a standing reproach
that justice will not be done unless un-
der threats more or less impressive. The
underpaid foreman is a standing object
lesson to members of labor unions, for
it teaches them that it is only by the
force resulting from combination that
will bring them a fair remuneration.
3o6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
General Correspondence.
Pneumatic Hammer for Shop Work.
Inclosed is a sketch of a pneumatic
hammer that we are using here. It is
one I designed myself and is not patent-
ed. You will note the sketch shows a
SS-pound hammer. I made one with a
22-poimd hammer for driving out flues.
The one shown is the one we use for
breaking out staybolts and shearing
crownbar bolts. It will shear a i-in. bolt
at one or two blows, and can work at
the rate of 50 or 60 blows per minute.
The smaller one will knock out a set of
200 flues in one hour and thirty minutes.
It takes two men to operate either
hammer.
The valve for the large hammer is of
the piston variety; it has two rings on
each head. I'he heads are ij^-in. diame-
ter, 54-'"- thick and coupled on a %-in.
rod 4% in. apart, back end of the stem
being coupled to a lever. The bushing
/Reads 0/8 x 1>^ Iron
manner as the large one. Both ham-
mers use the same bar, which must be a
fair fit in the i%:-in. pipe. The small
hammer is very convenient where a
heavy blow is wanted on a bar, and can
be operated easily and quickly.
R. M. Cole,
Foreman U. P. Shop, Ellis, Kas.
Good Receipt for Hot Box Dope, Lost.
Some years ago there was an engineer
who did not think he knew it all by any
means, and was, on the whole, a "good
sort," but he omitted to tell his fireman
the contents of his orders one beautifully
fine afternoon, and several people were
thereby enabled ta see his finish. He had
taken an engine out of the back shop after
a general overhaul to give it a trial trip,
and he had a machinist along with him, as
well as the fireman.
This happened on the High & Fly Rail-
road, which road believed that the train
i Pipe Jtailwa]/ ^ Li/auiiivtiie Unj/itieeHnff
AIR HAMMER.
is l^ in. on inside, i-^'s in. on outside,
and is lo^-i in. long.
The casing for the bushing is made of
three lJ4-in- gas pipe Ts, with the thread
drilled out to i% in. in diameter, and the
center bored out %-in. large to allow
the air to pass entirely around the bush-
ing. They are held together with a col-
lar on one end and a nut on the other
end of the bushing. The bushing has
twenty-six ^4-in. holes for each port, the
holes are arranged in two rows run-
ning entirely around it, thirteen in
each row. The ends of the T are faced
off to insure an air-tight joint. The
barrel of the hammer is common s-in.
pipe, with heads grooved for pipe to fit
in, and held together with four J^-in.
bolts. The barrel is 24 in. long, with
ports drilled as shown in sketch to allow
pressure to escape and prevent a re-
bound. The hammer is made from an
old crank-pin turned to fit the pipe
loosely, the pipe not being bored. The
smaller hammer has only one row of
holes at the end. It is about 7 in. long.
Each hammer has a steel pin in the end
to strike the bar, which is held by the
gaspipe as shown in sketch. The small
hammer uses i-in. Ts bored in the same
dispatcher was .987 of the whole thing, and
they never found anything like as much
fault with him as they did with the en-
gineers, and as he did most of that kind
of work for the company, it saved a lot
of worry at the top.
The arrangement about the light en-
gine was that if it ran all right it was to
go on to the end of this division, for ser-
vice on the next division, and the ma-
chinist was to go back to headquarters at
the first crossing that was made, if the
engineer was satisfied. This crossing w.is
with a regular passenger train. In start-
ing off there was so much talk about
this and that, that the engineer forgot to
show the fireman his orders, and the fire-
man for some reason or other did not ask
to see them.
When they were out on the road, the
only thing which gave any trouble was a
hot big end, but the engineer thought he
could manage that all right, so the ma-
chinist returned home leaving the engi-
neer and fireman with his very best wishes
and plenty of oil and soap and sulphur and
all the hot-box killers on the calendar.
Now, the train order which the engineer
carried and of which the fireman was ig-
norant, was properly addressed and
dated, and read something like this: "So
and so will run from A to Z, keeping clear
of regular and signal trains, and will hold
for orders at Q." After the regular pas-
senger train which took the machinist
back had been passed at K and other trains
looked out for, there was a clear, good
run to Q, so the engineer "speeded her
up," and as a result arrived at M with the
left big end pretty hot It gave trouble
for awhile, but showed signs of cooling at
Q..
At this station the "hold for orders"
came into operation, but the engineer was
so intent in looking after the hot big end
and his mind was occupied thinking about
a triumphant compounding of a superb
"dope" made out of everything on the
engine, that he forgot all about holding
for orders, and the fireman knew nothing
about it, and the operator at Q knew noth-
ing about it, as he hadn't been told. This
operator had not seen this particular en-
gineer for some time, so he came out and
shook hands and asked how things were
going. They talked about everything but
the hold 'for orders — principally about the
triumphant dope, and the engineer and
fireman climbed into the cab and went on,
after asking the operator to book them in
and out, and the most superior dope on
the whole road was fairly dripping off
the left big end.
Two or three miles out they came upon
a long tangent and found that they were
running against a fast freight. The fast
frcignt saw them and rent the heavens
asunder with a long, shrill scream. The
light engine stopped in lots of time and
the freight did also, so there was no col-
lision de facto, though there certainly was
a bad smash de jure. The light engine
backed up to Q, and the freight came on
with caution.
There was no attempt to hush it up. In
fact, the operator at Q had reported the
deparure of the light engine when it went
on, so all hands made telegraphic explana-
tions, each winding up with most touching
allusions to there being no damage of any
kind to anything and only an exceedingly
minute loss of time to the freight — you
couldn't see it with a microscope!
New orders were issued to the light en-
gine and the fireman read them over five
times aloud and they went on, and the
superior dope simply acted like a charm
and the engine came into Z with every-
thing stone cold, including the feet of the
crew.
Now, after the "carpet" had been trod-
den upon by everybody concerned, there
was a vacancy for an engineer on that di-
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMO'lIVK RNGINKKRIXG
307
vision and the receipt for the triumphant
superior dope was utterly lost to the II.
& F. road, and it was Ai dope, too.
Moral — When it comes to a case of de-
pending upon human memory, two or even
three heads are better than one, and why
shouldn't the fireman have a written copy?
The man issuing orders should tell all
concerned and be careful about it.. Rat-
tling good dope should never be manufac-
tured on a light engine, even by an ex-
pert, and few dispatchers should be con-
sidered more than .922 of tlic whole thing ;
.987 is ratluT higli. A. O. Brooksidh
the line is all curves and turns, the road-
bed is sn perfect that its many reverse
curves are imperceptible to the traveler,
and consequently no one ever suffers
from the sea-sickness so often experi-
enced on mountain roads.
The engineering achievement is so
marvelous and stupendous as to beggar
comparison with anything of its kind.
No expense has been spared by the man-
agement to provide for the comfort and
safety of its patrons. The coaches are
of the latest design and are truly travel-
ing palaces. Each train is provided with
observation cars free to all passengers.
a little farther up the famous Manitou
nestling at the foot of Pike's Peak.
We are now in Bear Creek Canon,
away up among the lofty mountains, and
nearing North Cheyenne Canon. Skirt-
ing around Cheyenne's rim and we are
at Point Sublime, seven miles from our
starting place. Looking down through
beautiful North Cheyenne Canon we get
a magnificent view of Colorado Springs,
1,200 feet below us. Still moving on-
ward and upward, a short distance to
our right we see the Sparkling Cascade
Falls, hundreds of feet above us. Soon
we are at Fairview, the confluence of
A Trip Over the Scenic Short Line.
It was my good fortune on May 2 to
make the trip from Colorado Spr njs to
Cripple Creek on the Colorado Springs
& Cripple Creek District Railway ,as tl.e
guest of Mr. William Lennox, vice-presi-
dent of the line.
I doubt very much if any other road
can lay claim to as perfect a roadbed as
the Scenic Short Line has. Built high
up along the mountain sides, the hnc.
standard gauge, laid with 7S-pound steel
rails and ballasted with disintegrated
granite, is entirely free from dust in
summer or snow in winter. Although
The locomotives are powerful mounta;n
climbers and the best that money can
purchase.
Our day for sight-seeing was clear and
warm — ideal Colorado weather — and
added greatly to the enjoyment of the
enchanting and bewildering scenery en
route.
As we left Colorado Springs on the
regular morning express. Nature began
to unfold her beauties to us at once and
m rapid succession. Scarcely two miles
out and to the right below us lay Colo-
rado City, the first capital of Colorado.
Then came the Garden of the Gcds, and
North and South Cheyenne Canons.
Who has not heard of beautiful South
Cheyenne Canon, forever associated in
memory with Helen Hunt Jackson, the
gifted writer, whose body was laid at
rest there in a lovely spot near Seven
Falls.
We are moving on to new wonders.
Several thousand feet above us is somber
old St. Peter's Dome, a mountain of
granite, one of God's master works,
looming up majestically and defying the
elements for ages.
Our iron steed, throbbing with every
exhaust as though a thing of life, fol-
3o8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903-
lows the serpentine trail up St. Peter's
and brings us to the opposite side of
South Cheyenne. The matchless view
here baffles all description. There is
nothing to be compared with it else-
where.
Following the trail we reach Duffield's,
where we get our last view of Colorado
Springs and the vast expanse of rolling
plains off in Kansas, a hundred miles
away. Three miles from here and twenty
miles from our starting point, we cross
the summit at an altitude of 10,360 feet,
or almost two miles above the sea level.
As we begin to descend we get a fine
have a magnificent view of Pike's Peak
and the Sangre de Cristo (Blood of
Christ) range of mountains.
After a short stay at Cripple Creek we
took the electric line to Victor and in-
spected a gold mine. The whole country
for miles is dotted with dividend-paying
mines, which with their groups of build-
ings look like monster bee-hives.
From Victor we took the steam line
again and began our homeward trip.
The continually changing scenes from
different vantage points on our return
were as fascinating as those we enjoyed
on the upward trip. I know that the
Useful Numbers.
A great many readers of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering failed to ap-
ply the arithmetic they have learned at
school, and we are continually receiving
requests to answer questions that every
school arithmetic solves. Before us is a
question of how many revolutions driv-
ing wheels of a certain diameter make in
a mile. To this we answer: Multiply
the diameter of the wheel by 3.1415926,
which is the ratio of diameter to circum-
ference of a circle. Divide 5,280, the
number of feet in a mile, by the product.
view of Pueblo, forty-five miles away,
with her factories and smelters belching
forth clouds of smoke. Onward we roll,
now over mountain torrents, now
through aspen forests, and in full view
of four tracks below us which we shall
pass over. Soon we are at Clyde and
gazing at the panorama of Cathedral
Park, with its rocks in fantastic shapes,
eroded by the elements thousands of
years ago.
Nearing the end of our journey we see
to the left the famous gold camp, Bull
Hill. At Cameron we take the line that
diverges to Cripple Creek. Here we
members of the Air-Brake Associa:ion,
who, through the kind hospitality of Mr.
F. S. Smith, general superintendent, and
the management of the line, had the good
fortune to make this same trip, will agree
with all I have written here, but I feel
my description is entirely inadequate.
To our eastern friends contemplating
an outing this summer I would suggest
that a trip over the Santa Fe or Rock
Island to Colorado Springs and thence
over the Scenic Short Line will repay
them a thousandfold in present pleasure
and future remembrance.
Jos. A. Baker.
and the quotient will be the number of
revolutions in one mile.
The following are a few numbers that
are frequently used in engineering ar-
ticles:
.7854 = ratio of area of circle to square
of its diameter. 33,000 minute-foot-pounds
= I horse power. 396,000 cubic inches
displacement per minute of engine
wheel would develop I horse power, with
I pound mean effective pressure on the
piston. 55 pounds M. E. P. at 600 feet
piston speed gives i horse power tor each
square inch of piston area.
July, igoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
309
Points Regarding a Monitor Injector.
For the information of those who use
injectors, especially the Monitor injec-
tor, I may say there have been many fail-
ures or so-called failures, where, if the
man in charge of the engine was posted
on the injector, there need not have
been even a detention. If we count the
globe valve on the turrctt as one, tlic
Monitor injector has eight valves. If
the man in charge understands the in-
jector he can take out five of the eiglit
valves and work the injector to a great
degree of success, or so well that it will
not be necessary to dump tlie fire i)r
make any great delay to train.
First, if the check valve in boiler is all
right we can take out the line valve. Then
we can work the injector without the
overflow valve. GilTord never had a
valve at the overflow, so you see we can
do temporarily without it. Then wc
take out the priming valve, put the phrj;
and stem back to its place. We operati-
the priming by shutting o(( globe valve
on the turrett. Every time we work tin
injector, all the loss we are at is tlu
small jet of steam that will flow througli
the priming nozzle, which will be of
small account, the injector will work
O. K. Then we can take the feed water
valve out, and by cutting down the feed
by putting a piece of paper or a smal'
handful of ground stones in the strainer
the injector will work at high or low
pressure, and of course everybody knows
an injector will work with the tank valve
out. So you see we can get aloui;
without the line valve, priming valve.
feed or graduating valve, tank and over-
flow valve, making in all five valves we
can dispense with. A. J. 0'Har.\.
Air-Operated Fire-Door Opener.
The accompanying illustration is of
an automatic device used to open and
close the fire-door. It is the invention
of Mr. F. L. Brewer, engineer on one
of the Rock Island's limited trains and
a pioneer in their service.
A glance at the picture will show the
advantage the contrivance possesses as
an assistant to the fireman and a reducer
of the number of leaky flues. Mr.
Brewer has had it in use on engine 1004, —
the engine in his charge, for the past
twenty months, and up to the present
time no repairs to it have been necessary.
It is very simple in construction.
Whenever the fireman wishes to replen-
ish his fire, he places his foot on the
pedal and thereby opens communication
from the small to the large cylinder by
means of a piston attached to the pedal.
As he turns toward the tank after an-
other shovelful of coal, he removes his
foot from the pedal and the door closes
and latches itself automatically. The
boilerhead shown in the picture slopes
at the top toward the forward end of the
cab, and the door is of a kind hard to
iipcratc and consc'iuently often kept
open until the fireman has given the en-
gine an over-ahundance of coal, also cold
air and leaky flues.
The C. & E. I. are using the device
with excellent results and have reduced
their boiler repair work 50 per cent,
since it has been applied. The C.. M. &
St. P. are also giving it a trial, and have
applied it this week to one of their en-
gines running out of Chicago.
J. A. 15.
Notes of a Trip on the Illinois Cen-
tral.
When Horace Greeley advised young
men to "Go west," he probably meant
"Go southwest." However, the oppor-
tunities of his time can be duplicated to-
Central with crushed rock for its road-
bed, and give employment to hundreds
of men.
My next stop. Champaign, gave me an
opportunity to sec the University of
Illinois, with its score of buildings nes-
tled among a grove of native trees. Here
I also remarked the enormous amount
of traffic passing in almost rhythmic
precision up and down the line, products
from Chicago to the South and Gulf
ports, and New Orleans products for
Chicago and the East and West.
At all of the stopping places mentioned
above I found repair shops with the
latest improved machinery, giving em-
ployment to many men. The power of
the I. C. is in excellent condition, due
to the manner in which it is handled by
AIR-OPER.^TED FIRE DOOR OPENER.
day. Immense tracts of timber and
other lands are still open to purchase by
the man of small means as low as $10
per acre along the lines of the Illinois
Central. When cleared of timber at a
good profit, the soil will produce in
abundance any of our northern or south-
ern fruits or grains.
Having occasion to go as far south as
Memphis, I chose my route over the
Illinois Central, stopping off at Kanka-
kee, Champaign, Mattoon, Centralia,
Carbondale and Cairo on the way down,
and returning by way of Paducah and
Evansville.
Kankakee, fifty-five miles from Chi-
cago, is a pretty place situated on both
sides of the Kankakee River. Among
its chief industries are the immense
stone quarriis of the Sinclair Construc-
tion Company, which supply the Illinois
the mechanical department. Prompt ser-
vice in both freight and passenger de-
partments seems to be the first consid-
eration. To accomplish this their en-
gines are not over-loaded. .\11 freight
seems to be fast freight with them, be it
fruit, garden truck or coal. The eng^ine-
men have "caught on" to the idea and
their proper aim is to "get there" — and
they generally do. Taxed to the utmost
for power, leasing engines wherever they
are to be had, the transportation depart-
ment has succeeded, through its wise
management and the hearty co-opera-
tion of the mechanical department and
its engine men, in averting a congestion
of freight at the division terminals.
Not satisfied with the Ijrge returns
which nature gives them from the soil,
the farmers in this section are claiming
a portion of her secret hoard, and all
310
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
the way from Kankakee to Cairo it was
quite a common siglit to see a fruit or-
chard and grain field on one part o'. a
farm and a coal mine on another.
Entering Cairo the railroad takes a
straight line on the east side of the town,
following the banks of the Ohio. Leav-
ing, it takes a circuitous route along the
west side of the town, forming a huge
letter S in order to reach the two-mile
bridge spanning the Ohio, three miles
north of town and connecting the States
of Illinois and Kentucky. While on this
bridge one gets a fine view of the Ohio
River emptying into the Mississippi.
The two currents can be distinguished
by their different shades of muddiness.
The Mississippi is probably three miles
wide here, and opposite the Ohio's
mouth large islands dot the surface of
the stream. We see three States— Illi-
nois, Kentucky and Missouri— whose ter-
ritories are divided by these mighty
streams.
Going south toward Memphis, we pass
near six different health resorts in Ken-
tucky's famous hills, which can be
reached only by the Illinois Central, and
which offer every convenience and com-
fort to the invalid.
Although the entire system is double
tracked, still the company, looking to
the safety of its patrons, is installing the
Hall Block Safety Signals. An immense
amount of money is also being spent in
cutting down grades between Cairo and
Memphis, and replacing wooden bridges
with concrete and iron structures. The
company has inaugurated a system of
very cheap excursion rates at frequent
intervals, good on their fast trains to
intending investors. The dining-car ser-
vice a la carte is fine, and the lunch
counters rank with the best anywhere.
I was tired of sight-seeing when I
reached Memphis, the half-way station
between Chicago and New Orleans, but
even a weary traveler is roused to inter-
est in this old town with its wide streets,
modern buildings and factories. Since
the war it has become the distributing
point for Arkansas and the far South-
west. Every stranger goes down_ to the
river to see the Mississippi and the for-
ests of Arkansas on the opposite shore.
While I was there one of Uncle Sam's
watch dogs of the navy, the Arkansas.
was anchored in mid-stream. One un-
usual pleasure for a Northerner is to
listen to the darkeys singing negro melo-
dies while transferring freight from the
wharves to the river-packets.
Thoroughly satisfied with the trip, our
party, consisting of myself, suit case and
umbrella, started on our homeward
journey. If you have a little money to
invest, if you want a pleasure trip, or if
you want to get away from the cold
northern winter, take a trip over the
Illinois Central to Memphis or New Or-
leans, and you will be "on time" all the
way and well pleased with your journey.
Speed and promptness, being essential
in Uncle Sam's service, secured for this
line the government contract for carry-
ing the southern fast mail. J. A. B.
Running Railroad with Relatives.
Several years ago a small road, the
P. D. S., concluded that a traveling en-
gineer was a necessity, and engaged the
services of a bright and experienced man
from one of our great trunk lines.
The first thing which the new traveling
engineer encountered, and which acted
as a damper on his enthusiasm, was the
family ties that existed in all the depart-
ments except those of the general super-
intendent and superintendent of motive
power. These relatives seemed to think
that the road was built for their especial
benefit. All of them had their hobbies
and several their pets. Particularly was
this the case with the superintendent and
train-master, who, to make matters
worse, compromised themselves by bor-
rowing money from their subordinates in
sums ranging from $50 to $900- It goes
without saying that these officials were
incompetent and that the rule regarding
employees standing in line of promotion,
if competent, was a dead-letter.
The general superintendent was up to
date and very kind hearted, but, like the
traveling engineer, handicapped by the
general manager, who vetoed every in-
novation as an extravagant and useless
expenditure. However, when the C
M.'s son, who was in the Maintenance
of Way Department, wanted a gasoline
motor car at the company's expen-e, that
seemed p. necessity, and the young man
got it. It was very handy for taking his
friends along the line for an outing, and
every few weeks it was in the shops for
repairs. The stockholders supposed it
was for use in inspecting roadway and
bridges, and the repairs were, of course,
charged up to the locomotive depart-
ment.
The superintendent of motor power,
old in the service of the company, and
very old in years, had had the sermon
on economy preached to him so long
that it had finally made a deep impres-
sion. Every dollar that could be was
gotten out of the poweT with as few re-
pairs as possible, and, if an engine broke
down, the failure was attributed to the
engineman's negligence.
A short time before the traveling en-
gineer's arrival on the line, the P. D. S.
had bought eight new engines, which,
upon trial, were found too heavy for the
weak bridges to carry. The P. D. Q..
which paralleled the P. D. S., saw here
an opportunity to play the good Samar-
itan, and offered to exchange eleven old
and smaller engines for the P. D. S.'s
eight new ones, and the offer was ac-
cepted. These engines were accepted
under steam and never did any good
service. The traveling engineer had a
practical and competent boiler-maker ex-
amine the boxes and stay-bolts. In every
instance the box-sheets were condemned,
and in one case 146 broken stay-bolts
were found. The engines had to be re-
turned to the P. D. Q. for new tire-
boxes.
About the time that the transfer of
engines was made, a similar exchange oi
500 coal cars was made. The tonnage of
the new cars had been increased over
that of the cars formerly in use, and it
was found that the new cars could not
be loaded at the mines without incur-
ring a heavy expense in alterations. So
the good Samaritan exchanged old cars
which had been condemned for the P.
D. S.'s new ones. A coat of black paint
was all that they needed before the line
with an over-stock of relations put the
old cars in service. The result was dis-
astrous. Down on their side-beanngs.
they would not pull easily, and, conse-
quently, the engine rating had to be
cut.
As the two lines were owned by prac-
tically the same stockholders, and the
P. D, Q. was making a favorable show
ing, while the P. D. S. was hardly hold-
ing its own, the two lines were merged
and both put under the P. D. Q. manage-
ment, thus breaking up the family circle
of the P. D. S. A belt line was made
of the two roads, empties were hauled
over the P. D. S. and loads over the
P. D. Q., and the earnings of the latter
were much increased.
This humiliating downfall of the P. D.
S. was directly traceable to the mis-
management and incompetency of rela-
tives who were unable to deliver the
goods. When a foreman gives a black-
gnith a machinist's berth because the
rate of pay is greater, it is a good thing
for the family, but not for the company.
Patents also often eat up dividends. For
instance, the P. D. S.'s superintendent
had a patent nozzle of his own design
put in five engines. Although they
proved a distressing failure on the road,
the performance sheet was doctored to
make them appear a success. They were
of the "freak" order, but, of course, the
superintendent would not believe^ that,
and desired the traveling engineer's en-
dorsement. Under the pretense of mak-
ing a few minor changes in the drafting
of the five engines, the traveling engitieer
removed the patent nozzles and substi-
tuted plain tips, and called upon the
superintendent for a report of the tests
made. That official, believing that he
was boosting his own patent, paid a high
compliment to the traveling engineer
and showed up a remarkably fine record
for the engines. The latter official, feel-
ing that the time for action had arrived,
resigned to accept a better position.
Moral: Protect your own interest
and that of the stockholders first. If
you have any relatives that you wish to
July, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
311
provide for, get them jobs on some other
line, and let them work out their own
salvation. Jrunk Ecrivmn.
nodern Steel Frame.
Througli the cuurtusy oi Mr. S. F.
Prince, Jr., superintendent of motive
power and rolling equipment of the
Philadelphia & Reading, we are able to
place before our readers a good example
of a modern locomotive cast steel frame.
The frame is designed with a view of
reducing the lime required to machine
it, and for this purpose bosses and plan-
ing strips are found only where neces-
sary. The lower bar of the main frame
has two circular bosses to hold the brake
hanger pins; while the upper frame bar
is pierced for the two front and back
driving spring hangers, and has a notch
set, which would have been considered
difficult to make with a forged frame
One side of the rocker-box bracket ami
the flange for fastening the yoke are
cast on the frame front and so require
only the minimum number of bolts and
studs and the minimum amount of ma-
chinery. The main frame bars are: Top,
5j4xs in, ; bottom, 2^x5 in., and the front
is 51/2x4 in.
The buffer beam or bumper is also
made of cast steel cored out for light-
ness, but strong in form and securely
tying the frames together at the head
end. The yoke is also made of cast steel,
bolted to the frame llange close to the
rocker-box. In addition, frame and
yoke are fastened together by a pair of
dovetail strips on each side. In putting
the yoke in place it is lifted above the
frame flange and slides down into place.
for some time and the design has proved
itself thoroughly satisfactory.
Baldwin's Exceed All KecordK.
If they are not disappointed in their
expectation- the Baldwin Locomotive
Works will by July i have turned out the
greatest number of finished engines in
any six months in history. The mark
fixed by the officials of the works as the
production for the six months is 1,000
locomotives, which is equivalent to two-
thirds of the output for 1902, when more
than 1,500 engines were turned out,
breaking all former records.
For May the output was 190 machines,
and the same number were turned out
during April.
Of the 1,000 locomotives the great ma-
jority are on orders placed last year.
j: -,.,:ijj|:^^"
z2
ifdUivay ^ Loewmafw* Bmfi'etri^g
CAST STEEI- LOCOMOTIVE FRAME-PHII..\DELPHI.\ & READINf, R.\ILW.\V.
for the gib of the spring equalizer post.
A hole has also been cored out just
above the frame splice for a stay which
runs from smokebox to a point close by
the lifting shaft bracket. The lower half
of this lifting shaft bracket is cast on the
main frame, thus saving the fitting and
bolting of the brackets, a couple of studs
holding the cap in place.
This form of construction lends itself
readily to the designing of a very solid
and substantial splice, both being flat-
tened to plate fo/m. Main frame and
frame front are both bolted together
with eleven iJ/^-in. bolts, and the plate
portion of the "front" has a lip which
comes against the end of the main frame
and is let into it at the back end so that
the shearing strain is taken off the bolts.
Two keys passing through both, as well
as the bolts help toward the same end.
The frame front also has a curved off-
something like a window sash slides in
its guides. The frame tailpiece is also
of cast steel. It is of I-section, with two
central tapering flanges at the end sec
tions, parallel with the top and bottom
flanges of the section. A rubbing cast-
ing is used with taper wedge and shoe,
so that wear between engine and tender
may be taken up. The shackle-bar pin
passes through the center of the tail-
piece, where the top, bottom and central
flanges are thickened and modified in
position to meet the requirements of the
case. The pin holes are bushed to 2^6
in., so that wear may be allowed for
at all times and standard pins may be
used. The lower flange is also thickened
where the pull of the safety chains
comes.
This steel frame and its attachments
has passed the experimental stage. An
engine with this frame has been running
The number taken this year will keep
the works busy well into 1904.
The passenger department of the
Illinois Central Railroad makes the an-
nouncement that "the daylight special,
wide vestibule fast day train of the Illi-
nois Central Railroad between Chicago
and St. Louis, has become what the lit-
terati would call 'an edition de luxe of a
train.'" They make this and other re-
marks in a very neat little pamphlet
which they have just got out, printed in
colors on tinted paper. The illustrations,
with full description, comprise the buffet-
library smoking car, the parlor car, the
dining car, the reclining chair car and
the day coach, all of which may be found
on the "Daylight Special." Mr. A. H.
Hanson, general passenger agent, Chi-
cago, will send this Httle booklet to tho^e
who apply to him for it.
312
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903-
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
PnbHslied monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, " Loceng," N. x.
Glasgow, " I,ocatito."
Bnslness Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NELLIS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCI/AIR, Editor.
GEO.'S^HODGINS, Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department : .„„—»,
Eastern Representative, S- ^-f^ «?„"
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
■Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
iao4 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd. loza Charing Cross Rd., W.
C., London.
Glasgow Representative:
A. T. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
S^.ooperyi'ar. $1.00 for six moitt Its. postage paid
to the Vnited Slates, Canada and Mex,.o Fo>
other tarts of the world. {2.50. or ten shdUngs.
Single copies 20 cents. Remit by Express Money
6"fer braft. Post Office Order or Registered
^Mailing address can te changed as often "sneces-
saTy-alwavs ^ive old and new address, and i) you
subscribed in a club, state who got it up
Please give prompt notice ivhen your papet fails
to reach you properly .
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., igoj
Pot Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Grades, Profiles and Climbing.
On one occasion a sleeping car, run-
ning over a mountainous road was
notTced, at one of the terminals, to have
a heavy stain on the carpet in the aisle,
just below one of the oil lamps, with
which the car was illuminated. Ihe
lamps were in pairs, each in a hartdsome
double-light brass chandelier which hung
from the clearstory roof, and the oil
used was oi the best non-explosive kind
—but there was the stain.
The porter in charge of the car was a
quick-witted man and when asked for
his explanation of the stain on the car-
pet, promptly replied that a new pair
of wheels had been under one end of the
car at the other terminal, and that the
repair men there had jacked the car up
so hi-h at one end for this purpose
that the oil had spilled out of the tilted
lamp, and had thus most unfortunately
spoiled the carpet.
The master mechanic at whose station
the wheels had been changed, was equally
quick-witted and quite truthful. He
pointed out that when the car was jacked
up, the angle of tilt was the same for all
the lamps, and that therefore all of them
should have overflowed and should have
left a series of stains on the carpet in-
stead of only one. He further called at-
tention to the fact that the car had to
be hauled over a 4 per cent, grade, and
when going up or down this incline the
whole car must be at a greater angle
than it would be when jacked up for
new wheels. A 4 per cent, grade is one
in which there is a vertical rise of four
feet for every horizontal hundred feet
traversed. This car being about 70 feet
long, had one end about 2 ft. pj^ in.
higher than the other in going over this
grade. It is obvious that wheels could
be put in with less end rise than the
grade produced. The porter was there-
fore asked to tliink again.
A railroad chain is 100 feet long and is
composed of 100 links, each one foot
long. When computing the rise of track
on a grade the loo-ft. chain is supposed
to be laid, not along the surface of the
rising track, but to lie along a hori-
zontal line, and the rise at the end of this
railroad chain is the vertical height
measured up from the horizontal. As a
matter of fact the chain cannot be so
laid in actual practice, but the computa-
tion is made as if it was. In fact, there
is here supposed to be a right-angled tri-
angle, in which the base is 100 feet long,
the rise is the perpendicular, and the
track lies along the hypotenuse of the
triangle. The track on such a grade is
therefore slightly longer than 100 feet.
A 2 per cent, grade has a vertical rise
of 2 feet in one hundred horizontal feet.
When a grade is represented on what
is called a profile of the road, it is easy
to see that if drawn strictly to scale, it
would convey little or nothing to the eye.
For example, if a one per cent, grade
was represented with horizontal and ver-
tical dimensions, each drawn to the same
scale, say that of one inch to the mile,
at the end of ten miles the rise, as shown
on the paper, would only be i'b of an
inch.
It is usual, however, when drawing
profiles to purposely distort the diagram.
A scale for the horizontal or road dis-
tance is chosen, suppose it to be one inch
to the mile, and the vertical height is
then drawn to a very much larger scale,
say one inch to 500 feet. This would
make the vertical scale more than ten
times that of the horizontal. This kind
oi distortion shows a rising or falling
grade very distinctly, and is the reason
why a profile of a railroad looks like the
cutting edge of a large saw, with very
irregular teeth.
The horizontal line for a profile is
usually chosen far below the line repre-
senting the track at its deepest sags.
Often the sea level or lake level is taken
if the road is in the neighborhood of a
large body of salt or fresh water. This
hoHzontal is called the Datum line, and
all verticals are measured up from it, and
so figured on the profile. An example of
a railroad profile was given in our June,
1903, issue on page 266. If one point is
marked 200 feet above the datum, and a
second is marked 300 feet, there is, of
course, lOO feet difference in level be-
tween them.
In the matter of climbing a grade, an
engine with a train of cars behind it is
doing work which may conveniently be
resolved into two components. There is
the resistance of the train due to rolling
friction along the level, and there is the
work of lifting the train through a given
vertical distance. The value of the re-
sistance due to rolling friction along a
level road is given by Forney as 6.6 lbs.
resistance per ton (2.000 lbs.) weight of
train, at a speed of 10 miles an hour.
This value remains constant for that
speed, whether the train be moving along
straight level track or going up grade.
This resistance, however, increases with
increased speed.
The resistance due to the grade is
something entirely different. On the 4
per cent, grade, of which we previously
spoke, the total rise at the end of a mile
would be about 211 feet, and each ton
weight in the train would have to be
lifted that distance. In this case the
raising of the train is not done along the
vertical line, like a bucket coming up
out of a well. The pull of the locomo-
tive on a grade is exerted through the
horizontal distance of one mile. If one
ton is lifted 211 feet while being pulled
a mile, the rule which applies in finding
the resistance per ton for the grade is
"multiply the weight of the train in
pounds by the ascent in any given dis-
tance in feet and divide the product by
the horizontal distance in feet." .Apply-
ing this to the case before us we have:
2000 X 211 ,,
= 79.9 lbs.
5280
That is 79.9 lbs. resistance for every
ton weight of train due to the grade.
To this must be added the 6.6 lbs. per
ton due to rolling friction at a speed of
10 miles an hour. The total resistance
per ton which must be overcome to get
a train up a 4 per cent, grade at ten miles
an hour is 86.5 lbs.
In this calculation no account has been
taken of curves or of wind resistance,
or of slewed trucks with cutting wheel
flanges due to poor center plates and
side bearings. We have only considered
a steady pull on straight track in good
condition and in perfectly calm weather.
Observations on Inside Admission
Piston Valves.
There are some advantages and some
disadvantages connected with the piston
valve having inside admission. To be-
gin with the valve is perfectly balanced.
Condensation is reduced because the live
steam passing to the cylinders is con-
fined in the center of the valve, and is
protected by exhaust steam at each end,
and this exhaust steam is warmer than
the covers of the valve chamber, the
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
313
outer surfaces of wliicli arc in contact
with the atmosphere. Such a valve is
easy on valve stem packing, because
the packing is only called upon to stand
the intermittent action of the exhaust
steam which is at a lower pressure and
temperature than the live steam is. An
accident to or a leak from either cover
of the valve chamber would probably
not be as serious as if the valve had
outside admission. These piston valves
are cheaper to make than the balanced
slide valves. There being no steam chest
jointed to the cylinder the chance of
leakage from that source is eliminated.
On the other hand, this valve in com-
mon with all other piston valves, cannot
lift ofif its seat like a slide valve can, and
so relieve pressure of air caused in
drifting, and being incapable of "giving"
in any way it cannot make an emergency
escape, for water if any gets into the cyl-
inder. When water finds its way into
a cylinder whose steam admission is
governed by a piston valve, there is gen-
erally trouble for the round-house stafT
sooner or later. The inside admission
valve has also to sustain a series of
shocks from exhaust steam. As each
exhaust leaves the cylinder and enters
the valve chamber-end, it tries to push
the valve to the other end of the cham-
ber, and the fact that the valve is per-
fectly balanced, allows the full force of
the e.xhaust steam to find out any lost
motion that there may be in the valve
gear, and this lost motion is shut up
by the forward e.xhaust and drawn out
by the back exhaust, with consequent in-
creased wear of parts. The smaller the
exhaust nozzle used the greater the force
of the exhaust shock on the valve, and
when the engine is working hard with
very little expansion, the force of the
shock may be considerable. At any
rate, its cumulative effect is what has to
be reckoned with by the repair stafT.
The " Overlap " and the " Chalk-line "
Stop.
In automatic block signaling the ex-
pression "overlap" is employed to indi-
cate a certain arrangement of track circuit
used in working the signals. In ordinary
practice, a train entering a block im-
mediately causes both the signals at the
entrance of that block, say at A, to go
to "danger." When the train leaves the
first block and enters the second, the
signals at B go to danger and the home
signal at A assumes the all-clear posi-
tion, indicating that no train is in the
first block. Now, with the "overlap" in
use, the train in question would have
to run a certain given distance past sig-
nal B (say 600 feet or more) before the
home signal at A would "clear." That
di.'^tance is called the overlap.
The question as to whether or not it
is advisable to use the "overlap" with
automatic signals was discussed at a re-
cent meeting of the Railway Signaling
Club. The arguments, pro and con,
amount briefly to this: The advocates
of the overlap regard it as an ad-
ditional precaution or safety device,
while those opposed to its use think it
introduces an element of uncertainty
and that it gives incorrect information
to the man on the engine.
Regarding the vise of the overlap a
very pertinent question was put by one
of the speakers in which he practically
asked, would you feel perfectly safe if
you were sitting in the rear end of the
last car of a train which had just passed
out of block A by a few feet and was
halted there with signal B standing at
danger almost over your head? The
train following would, as the limit of
safety, have to make a "chalk-line stop"
at signal B in order not to crash into the
rear of your train. Can the man on the
following train be relied upon under all
circumstances, on good or bad rails, in
clear or foggy weather, with efficient or
indifferent brakes or hampered by the
thousand-and-one variations which may
arise to mar the "chalk-line stop" — can
he be depended upon absolutely every
time?
The advocates of the overlap answer
this question in the negative, and say
that safety demands that your train
should not have "cleared" the home sig-
nal at A until you were well into block
B and far enough past signal B to en-
able the following train to stop at or
near the home signal B. with the chalk-
line element in the stop left out, because
not always possible of realization. They
say the overlap takes care of an oc-
casional or unintentional run-by. They
point to the use of derails on railways as
proving that officials are doubtful con-
cerning ordinary discipline, and the fact
that the derail does claim its victims
shows that the chalk-line stop is not in-
variably made.
On the other side, the argument is
that even if you were just in block B
with the signals almost above your head
showing danger, and the home signal
at A standing at "all clear," thus per-
mitting a fast train to enter the block
you had just left, you would not be in
danger, provided the rules had been
observed. The man on the high-speed
train following knows when he passes
A that the home signal at B is against
him. He knows this because the distant
signal at A works in unison with the
home at B. and when he passed the
post at A he was told as distinctly as
semaphores can say it, "The home sig-
nal at B is against you. prepare to stop
now."
The practice of flagging a follow-
ing train from the back platform of
the last car which was more fashionable
formerly than now. has been found to
be dangerous, simply because the flag-
man had not gone back far enough, but
the home signal at B cannot be accused
of following that method when it has
a flagman in the shape of the distant sig-
nal back the full length of the block, and
showing the caution indication on the
post at A.
The caution signal at A gives a man
one whole block to provide for the thou-
sand-and-one variations which arise and
militate against the chalk-line stop which
he may have to make at B. The overlap
practically gives him one more chance
in case he miscalculates or is somewhat
slow of action.
These are practically the arguments
one way and the other which ■ were
brought out at the meeting of the club.
What we would like to hear now are
the opinions of motive-power men oi all
grades concerning the use of the over-
lap. The columns of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering are open to
those who have something to sav on
this important subject. What do the
men who watch for these signals through
the cab windows think of the overlap?
What have they got to say regarding the
imperative and invariable chalk-line
stop? The motive-power men have the
floor!
Reckless Use of Gasoline.
As gasoline is the liquid from which
the explosive mixture is made that is
used in the driving of gas engines, nearly
everybody understands that it is an ex-
plosive mixture and, therefore, ought to
be treated carefully with lights or heat
that would ignite the gas emanating
from the gasoline. Gasoline is not ex-
plosive until its vapor is mixed with a
certain proportion of air, but when that
is the case it is just as explosive as gun-
powder. Everybody connected with
machinery nowadays ought to be familiar
with these facts; but there still remains
a great amount of ignorance among
those who are supposed to know.
In New York last month there was
an explosion connected with a boiler
which is likely to result in the death of
several persons and we cannot imagine
anything more reckless than the act
which caused the explosion. A steam
boiler used in the basement of a 7-story
apartment house had been getting foul
with lime scale from the feed used, and
the engineer in charge of the boiler with
the help of the porter undertook to clean
out the scale with liquid gasoline. They
pumped a large quantity of gasoline in-
side the boiler and waited a short time
to give it a chance to act on the scale;
then the engineer becoming inquisitive
as to how the gasoline was working on
the scale took a lighted candle and held
it inside with the view of examining
the condition of the boiler. A terrific
explosion followed in which the two men
were very seriously injured.
314
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
Book Reviews.
The American Steel Worker. By E. R.
Markham. Publishers : The Derry-
CoUard Company, New York. 1903.
Price, $2.50.
The author, who has had twenty-five
years' experience in the selection, an-
nealing, working, hardening and tem-
pering of various kinds and grades of
steel, is competent to fulfil the task he
has undertaken. The work, which has
just left the press, is a book of 316 pages,
illustrated by numerous line cuts. It is
not divided into numbered chapters in the
conventional way, but the paragraphs
are headed in bold type and the compre-
hensive index at the back supplies the
student with an admirable reference
table.
Mr. Markham tells how to do things
and why they should be done in a cer-
tain way, and he calls attention to things
to be avoided in the manipulation of
steel. It is a thoroughly practical Work
and demolishes the idea of so-called
"luck" which many hold to regarding the
treatment of metal. The book tells how
to know steel and how to select it, and
what variety of steel is best suited for
some particular use. It explains how 1.0
work steel in the making of small tools,
taps, reamers, drills, milling cutters, also
about the hardening and tempering of
dies large and small ; about pack and
case hardening ; tempering sprmgs ; how
to anneal ; what sort of apparatus to use
and how to make it. The mixtures for
baths are given and all in the book is
written in the plainest way possible.
The Car Builders' Dictionary, 1903 Edition.
New York : Published under the di-
rection of the Master Car Builders' As-
sociation by The Railroad Gazette.
Price, $5.
This dictionary, which has long been a
standard reference book for all those who
are in any way connected with or inter-
ested in the rolling equipment of rail-
roads, has been re-written, re-engraved
and brought up-to-date in every respect.
The new edition contains 525 pages and
4,971 illustrations of cars and parts of
cars, showing practically every standard
type of freight and passenger car, and the
details of their construction. In general
arrangement the lines of the 1895 edition
have been followed, the book being di-
vided into two general parts, the first 151
pages containing definitions, historical
matter and specifications, and the last 374
pages containing the illustrations. In the
illustrated pages are shown, besides the
numerous types of cars and their details,
trucks and truck details, car furnishings,
electric cars and trucks, together with the
electrical machinery placed on them, the
standards and recommended practice of
the Master Car Builders' Association, and
car shop machinery. The subject matter
in each of these divisions has been
grouped together and arranged under
sub-headings in alphabetical order. With
this arrangement the finding of the il-
lustration of any part becomes a simple
matter.
The Baldwin Record of Recent Con-
struction No. 42 has just come to hand.
It is a reprint of the paper read before
the Mechanical Engineering Societies
of Columbia University, New York, and
Lehigh University, South Bethlehem,
by Mr. Lawford H. Fry, of the Baldwin
Locomotive Works. It is a study of the
steam distribution of the Vauclain com-
pound. The subject is fully covered in
Mr. Fry's paper, and is well illustrated.
Half-tones of the cylinders and valves
are shown and a section through cyl-
inders and valve chamber is given. At
the end of the pamphlet there is a valve
diagram constructed on Zeuner's method,
and accompanying this is a series oi
colored sections in which the various
positions of pistons and valves are
graphically represented through an en-
tire cycle with live steam, exhaust steam,
steam expanding or being compressed,
all shown by different colors or intensity
of color. The Zeuner diagram and the
colored sections are printed on a folded
insert which is fastened to the back
cover in such a way that when spread
out they lie before the reader beyond the
printed page, so that they may be seen
without the vexatious arrangement which
usually compels one to turn over several
pages in order to refer to the diagram
or chart about which one is reading.
Don't Abuse the Honkey Wrench.
Among the papers read at the meeting
of the American Society of Mechanical
Engineers, held at Saratoga in June, was
one on "Strains Produced by Excessive
Tightening of Nuts," by A. Bement, a
member of the society. The gist of the
paper is in the first three sentences which
read :
"In the design of machinery, ultimate
strength, elastic limit and deflection of
parts usually receive careful attention; but
with prevailing practice and methods of
erecting machinery in final place, there
is but little assurance that damage may
not be caused by ignorance or careless-
ness on the part of the erecting crew, ow-
ing to excessive tightening of nuts and
screws, which may, and often does, result
in straining bolts and parts beyond their
elastic limit. There appears to be no rule
in general use for the guidance of the men
who perform the work of machinery erec-
tion, and it seems usually to be their de-
sire to make things as tight as possible.
The natural result is that elastic limits are
often exceeded or that breakages may even
occur."
These are facts which the machnie shop
apprentice sometimes learns with humiliat-
ing impressions. There is no rule for
tightening up nuts any more than there is
for pushing a file; but experience teaches
how to do the work right. We believe
there are many members of the American
Society of Mechanical Engineers who
never worked in a machine shop, and the
information imparted by this paper will,
no doubt, prove useful to them, if they
should ever undertake to handle a monkey
wrench.
In some men's hands, the monkey
wrench is a most destructive tool. If its
handle was a yard long, they would exert
the full leverage combined with their own
brute force when screwing up a nut. The
cutting tongue of the foreman sometimes
imparts timely reproof to the man who
wields wrenches without judgment, and
we incline to think that the discipline
thus given is likely to be more salutary
than papers presented to engineering so-
cieties.
If the writer of the paper referred to
had known of the practice, he might have
told that it is a bad thing to twist off the
stud of a cylinder head by exerting the
combination of strength and stupidity ;
and the case is made worse when the
workman sticks the stud in place by bed-
ding it in white lead. There are a great
many bad practices common in some ma-
chine shops which could be ventilated in
a shape that would make interestmg read-
ing. They would also give the writer an
excuse for presenting his name to an en-
gineering society.
Acceleration Tests on the Great Eastern
Railway of England.
In our April issue we illustrated and
described the heavy suburban "decapod"
designed by Mr. James Holden, the lo-
comotive superintendent of the line. It
will be remembered that this is a three-
cylinder simple engine with 18^x24 in.
cylinders and 54-in. driving wheels.
It was designed to attain a speed of
30 miles per hour in 30 seconds after
starting, with a load of about 315 tons
of 2,240 pounds each, behind the tender.
An electric testing apparatus was re-
cently installed on the main line at a
convenient locality, and the up and down
line were each equipped.
The recording mechanism, which was
placed in a cabin beside the track, con-
sists of a ribbon of paper which is
drawn over a roller at a uniform rate
of speed. A battery actuating an electro-
magnet has contact made and broken
by the pendulum of a clock so arranged
that a marker dots the paper at regular
half-minute intervals. A track circuit is
also arranged connected with a marker
which dots the paper tape along a line
parallel with the half-minute dots. In
order to operate this acceleration re-
corder, a series of copper plates are
placed beside the track and over these
passes a contact brush carried by the
engine, which makes or breaks the cir-
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3'S
cuit accorJing as tlic brubh touches or
leaves the copper plates.
The copper plates arc spaced along
the track at the correct though increas-
ing distances apart, which, if the ac-
celeration be just as expected, would
cause the marker to dot the paper every
half minute. If, therefore the series of
time dots and the series of acceleration
dots were exactly equally spaced on the
paper, it would prove that the engine
was gaining in speed as desired.
In the test which was recently made
the weather conditions were not favor-
able, as a high wind was blowing at the
time. The engine had 20 long tons
more than her load, and was drawing
a new train which did not run easily.
In spite of these disadvantages she
showed an acceleration of 1.4 feet per
second. The acceleration necessary to
get up to 30 miles an hour in 30 seconds
is 1.46 feet per second. It was therefore
believed that when conditions are nor-
mal the full acceleration will be
achieved.
The result obtained was in a special
though severe test, but the engine has
yet to undergo the trying and continu-
ous test of daily service with probably
15 stops for passengers in a distance of
ten and a half miles. The engine weighs
about 156,500 pounds, and though she
may develop the acceleration required,
her general appearance would lead one
to fancy that her maintenance charges
will be heavy if she stands up to the
hard work cut out for her.
Another "Balanced Locomotive Com-
pany" has been organized, this time at
Pierre, S. Dak., capital $1,000,000. We do
not suppose the organizers of the Bal-
anced Locomotive Company could pos-
sibly get a specimen of their machine
built in an ordinary contract shop. We
are moved with anticipation to see this
newest balanced locomotive. So many
of them are reposing in the graveyard
of good endeavor or have been used as
good intentions to pave a place which
shall be nameless that we hanker with
great hankering to see a new specimen.
The Watson-Stillman Company's cata-
logue No. 65 has just come to hand. It
is their illustrated index for 1903. The
last issue they made of such an index
was No. 51, several years ago, and it
contained 44 pages. The present issue
has 72 pages, which shows the numerous
additions in all departments which have
been made to the list of tools and ap-
pliances manufactured by this well-
known concern. Jacks, punches, hy-
draulic presses, pumps, riveters, valves,
polishing lathes, etc., etc., are all illus-
trated in endless variety and are named
and numbered. Write to the Watson-
Stillman Company, 204 East Forty-third
street, New York City, if you wish to
obtain a copy.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(42) K. Y. S„ Albany, N. Y., asks:
What repair shop accommodation ought
to be provided for a railroad liaviiig 100
locomotives? In ordinary districts
where the feed water is not particularly
bad provision ought to be made to have
10 per cent, of the engines undergo ng
repairs all the time. About 2 per cent,
may be light repairs which can be dune
in the round houses. About eight repair
shop stalls ought to be provided for one
hundred locomotives.
(43) Inquirer, Cincinnati, asks:
What is meant by the expression
split calking? A. — It consists of driv-
ing a thin calking tool, about 1-16 inch
thick, against tlie edge of a sheet so that
a thin section of the sheet is driven in
between the two sheets to make a tight
joint. The result is that the plates are
separated from the edge of the lap back
to the line of rivets. It is a quick and
bad species of workmanship and is in
vogue principally where piece work is
not subjected to rigid inspection.
(44) Fireman, Cheyenne, Wyo., writes:
Please give me a plain rule for setting
eccentrics on the road in words that it
does not need a college professor to un-
derstand. A. — We certainly think that
the directions given in Thompson, Con-
ger, Sinclair, McBain and otjier books
are simple enough. The instruction
given in any of these hand books ought
to be satisfactory. We also recommend
an article by J. W. Reading on page 253
of our June issue.
(45) R- P- M., Albany, N. Y., writes:
In Mr. Sinclair's article on the
"Growth of the Locomotive," he says on
page 248 of the June number that John
B. Jervis had a locomotive built with a
four-wheeled truck, the first of the kind,
which was called "Brother Jonathan."
I am familiar with the history of early
locomotives, and I have always heard
Jervis' first engine called "The Experi-
ment." Has not Mr. Sinclair made a
mistake? A. — We know that the popular
name for the first Jervis engine was "The
Experiment." but Jervis himself in a
book which he wrote on railroads, which
is before us, said that he called the en-
gine "Brother Jonathan." He ought to
be the best authority on such a question.
(46) R. J., Walkerville, writes:
Will you please explain why engines
equipped with piston valves, pound so
badly while drifting. An engineer on a
neighboring road told me that they had
instructions to drop the lever in the cor-
ner after shutting off. There are a few
Brooks engines here with piston valves
and there are printed instructions in the
cab not to drop the lever more than half
way to corner. A. — With outside admis-
sion valve, when engine is drifting, the
valve is moving as it does when steam is
used and air is being sucked in behind the
piston and is being pushed out before the
piston into the exhaust cavity. When
the valve reverses its motion and travels
forward while the piston is still moving
back, there comes a time when the piston
valve entirely closes the port through
which the air is being pushed into the ex-
haust cavity. It is while the port i»
closed that the air in front i>f
the piston cannot get out because
the piston valve cannot lift od its seat.
1 he sudden stoppage of the flow of air
out of the cylinder, and its consequent
compression takes up all the lost motion
in either the little end, big end or driving
box and develops a pound. Lost motion
in any of these places which would hard-
ly be discernible in an engine with slide
valves, is distinctly noticeable with a pis-
ton-valve engine. The nearer the reverse
lever is to the corner, the closer the pis-
ton will be to the end of its stroke be-
fore the port closes, and when the lever is
in the corner the port closes so late that
there is not much air left to compress in
the cylinder and consequently the pound
will be lighter. Dropping the reverse
lever to the lowest notch does not neces-
sarily remove the pound altogether though
it lessens it. At high speeds if you drop
the lever down to the lowest notch, the
chances are you cannot draw it up again
until speed has slackened and time has
been lost. In any case the sudden altera-
tion from short to long travel is hard on
valve gear, and many roads advise drop-
ping the reverse lever to the corner by
easy stages. Make a card model of cyl-
inder and valve and work it out yourself.
(47) A. N., Chicago, writes:
(i) Will you please give your opinior>
which is the more correct way of compar-
ing horse power? In the usual way, 33,-
000 lbs. one foot high in a minute, or the
European way, in meters and kilograms,
figuring 75 kilograms one meter high
in a second as a horse power. A. — The
horse power in Great Britain and
in the United States is 33.000 Ibs>
raised one foot high in one minute,
or its equivalent. For example, 551
foot-pounds per second is a horse power.
A kilogram is equal to 2.204 lbs., 75
kilograms would therefore equal 165.3
lbs., and that weight raised 39.37 inches
or one meter in a second would be some-
what less than a horse power. It does not
matter how you state horse power, but to
be correct it must be strictly equivalent
to the sum of the three definite factors of
weight, distance and time, or it is not a
horse power.
(2) Would you please give the mp<<
correct way of figuring the resistance
of a train at different rates of speed, on
level and straight track, also on up grades
with straight track and with curves. A.
— Forney answers these questions in the
Catechism of the Locomotive, pjge 585,
3i6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
which see. He says, "It has been found
that it takes from 4 to 6 lbs. per ton of
2,000 lbs. to move a car slowly on level
and straight track after it is started." The
resistance increases with the speed, for 10
miles per hour he gives a resistance per
ton of 6.6 lbs., 15 m. p. h. gives 7.3 lbs.,
20 m. p. h. gives 8.3 lbs.. 25 m. p. h. gives
9.6 lbs. and so on. For resistance 0!i
grades, read the article on Grades, Pro-
files and Climbing in the current issue of
Railw.\y and Loco.motive Engineering
With reference to resistance due to
curves, Kent's rule is 0.5 lbs. per ton of
2,000 lbs. per degree of curve. Many of
these questions involving formulas can be
answered by referring to some standard
Engineers' pocket book.
(48) F. B. H., Philadelphia, asks:
What may go wrong with the air opera-
ted blow-ofT cock and top check which will
prevent it closing? A. — It may be that
some scale gets on the seat of the air
operated valve and holds it open, and if
the opening of this valve be sufficient the
check valve will be held open and steam
jointed close to the main crank-pin, so
that the lowering of the center wheel
in your mogul, causes the two ends of
the side rod to make a very slight angle
with each other. The blue print of a
modern 2-6-0 engine is before us, with
distance between leading and main
drivers given as 7 ft. 2 in. and that be-
tween rear drivers 8 ft. 6 in. Taking these
rod ends as the radii of two circles, it is
easy to sec that any slight lowering of
the main pin such as would be caused by
a track joint, would produce so slight a
difference in length of these lines as to
be practically of no importance. The
rod end, seven or eight feet long,
lies on the hypothenuse of a right-
angled triangle, whose base is the
theoretically horizontal line between
their center lines, and the verti-
cal distance through which the middle
wheel has gone down, may be, perhaps,
J-i of an inch. In such a case the
difference between the length of the base
and of the hypotenuse is so slight that it
may be disregarded. The pins and
signer thinks that the small motor will
save considerable dead weight that ac-
companies the use of a locomotive.
STE.\M p.\ssen(;hk c.\k— i.ondo.n .\nl> sol Tii wkstern railway.
and water will blow through. To remove
the piece of scale, open and shut the air
operated valve several times as quickly and
as widely as possible. A sudden gush of
water may carry it out. If the air opera-
ted valve will not close and appears not
to be held open with scale, it is possible
that the cylinder containing the air piston
may have been subjected to the "soft-
hammer treatment," and a dint or dinge
in the thin brass walls will prevent the
proper movement of piston. If the case
is not very serious the piston may be
made to travel up and close the air opera-
ted valve, by screwing the nut on top out
as far as it will go. If this cannot be done
the v.ilve needs overhauling.
(49) V. D. W., Enbank, Ky., asks:
In building locomotives what provision
is made for the change in the distance
between wheel centers due to the wheels
getting out of line in running over un-
even track? The length of a line drawn
through the centers of the three cran'<
pins of an ordinary mogul is longer
when the middle wheels drop down into
a low place in the track, than when a!l
wheels are standing on a straight rail.
A. — In the first place the side rod is
brasses, and the driving boxes, wedges
and shoes are not so closely fitted as
not to be able to help in the necessary
adjustment. An engine fitted up so
"snug" that it could not "give" in various
ways would run too hot to be of service
on the road.
Motor Coach.
Our illustration shows a motor coach
recently designed and built by Mr. D.
Drummond, locomotive superintendent of
the London and South-Western Railway.
The length of the frames is 56 feet, and
it carries the car, built to seat ten first-
class and 32 third-class passengers, and
a luggage compartment capable of hold-
ing ten tons. The car is carried on two
four-wheel trucks, one of them being the
motor truck. The cylinders of the motor
are 7x10 inches, and it is intended to at-
tain a speed of 30 miles an hour in 50
seconds after the start. We have not re-
ceived any particulars about the actual
tests of the car, but we are inclined to
think that it will come considerably
short of the speed for which it is de-
signed. The intention is to use cars of
this kind on branch railroads. The de-
Convention Men Like to Go Fishing.
Wherever railroad men and those who
supplied things to railroad men met to-
gether during the early part of June,
many congratulations have been heard
about it not being necessary to make a
trip to Mackinac to attend a mechani-
cal convention. Others, however, have
displayed disappointment at being pre-
vented from attending the place where
the waters from the greatest lake in the
world pass through a narrow channel in
their way to the sea. There were visions
of fishing and many of the men who go
to the conventions annually live where
there is very little water in sight, and
consequently they have double desire to
sit on the bank of a pellucid stream.
It is wonderful the amount of patience
which some railroad men and their
friends display when they sit with a fish-
ing rod in their hands. To be sure, it
gives them an opportunity to fabricate
amusing stories which last them the year
round, and no one ought to deny them
this innocent kind of amusement. A
story is told of one of these earnest
tishers who was sitting beside a stream
which ran under the walls of the ground
of a lunatic asylum. He was sitting pa-
tiently in the sun without a murmur and
had been there for several hours when
an inmate from the other side climbed to
the top of the wall and began to question
the fisher. ''What are you doing there?"
says the lunatic. "Fishing," says the
master car builder. "How many have
you caught?" says the lunatic. "None,"
replies the master car builder. "How
long have you sat there?" says the luna-
tic. "Four hours," says the would-be
fisher. "You are in the wrong place,"
remarks the lunatic, "you ought to be at
this side of the wall."
The Roberts Steam Piston Packing
Company, of Philadelphia, have lately re-
ceived some gratifying testimonials from
users of their piston packing. The Youngs
Amusement Company and Youngs Pier
plant at Atlantic City say that they find
the increase of power and the saving in
fuel over the old style packing is 17 per
cent. The Merchant and Miners' Trans-
portation Company, of Baltimore, say
that during the past ten years they have
put in seventeen of the Roberts rings, and
have always found them to be satisfactory.
George F. Sloan & Brother, manufactur-
ers of flooring, Baltimore, say they
have used the packing for years, and are
glad to recommend it. The Standard
Brewery Company, of Baltimore, say they
have used this packing for eight years,
and recommend it to any one using an
engine. The company will be happy to
give any information asked for.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3'7
Air= Brake Department.
CONDUCTBD BV F. M. NELLIS.
Air- Brake Conditions Reported by the
Interstate Commerce Commission.
The report of the Interstate Com-
merce Commission for 1902 gives some
very interesting information in the mat-
ter of air-brake maintenance on railroads.
The ten inspectors employed by the
Commission examined 167,371 cars. Of
this number 1,365 were found to have
defective retaining valve pipes; or, in
other words, 2.48 per cent, of the cars
examined were defective in this respect.
Likewise the cylinders and triple valves
not cleaned in prior twelve months were
7,670 in number, or 13.93 per cent. The
cases of date of cleaning cylinder and
triple valves omitted on examined cars
were 3,428, or 6.21 per cent. From the
total showing, the defects reported each
year before. The number of cars on
which one or more defects were found
was 42,718, a^ compared with 19,462; the
percentage found defective was 26.47, ss
compared with 19.73. This condition is
due, not to worse conditions, but to the
more systematic inspection of air brakes.
Too Frequently Bhinied on the Air Brakes.
— Uncoupling mechanism continues to
be the most unsatisfactory feature of the
coupler situation. A chain too short will
uncouple a car in motion, and this is a
Iirobable cause ot disastrous wrecks.
Should Use All Air Brakes in Train. —
The situation as regards the use of power
brakes on freight trains has improved
during the past year. The percentage of
air-braked cars used in trains is greater
than a year ago. but it still is in a large
teaching of those who are expert in the
management of air brakes.
More Yard-Testing Plants Needed. — The
absence of adequate and suitable inspec-
tion and testing facilities at large freight
yards is still to be remarked on some of
the most important railroads. Bearing
in mind that the air brake is a delicate
apparatus, and that therefore inspection,
cleaning and the maintenance of tight-
jointed pipes are vital elements in safe
and satisfactory service, this lack of yard
plants calls for particular attention.
lax Discipline and Neglected Practice. —
The inspectors' reports show, as they did
a year ago, inefficient practice in the use
of air-brake defect cards; lax discipline,
permitting trains to be pulled apart when
the brake-hose connection has not been
ECHOES OF THE COLORADO SPRINGS CONVENTION OF THE AIR-BRAKE ASSOCIATION. THE LADIES OF THE
CONVENTION FORMING THE NOW FAMOUS "BURRO BRIGADE." BV COURTESY OF MRS. JOHN HU.ME. JR.,
HOUSTON, TEXAS.
month, it appears that the larger num-
ber of defects were reported during the
months of January, February, March and
April. This is doubtless a good indica-
tion that railroads have generally
adopted the practice of placing their air-
brake apparatus in shape as far as pos-
sible during the spring and summer
months, expecting them to last the year
out.
Following are some of the conclusions
drawn by the Commission regarding their
findings in the inspection of air brakes
during the past year:
Results of Systematic Insfcction. — The
report of the chief inspector shows that
the ten inspectors employed by the Com-
mission examined 161,371 cars, as com-
pared with 98,614 examined by the
smaller number of inspectors during the
part of the trains too small, and the use
of hand brakes as the main or only
means of regulating speed on steep de-
scending grades continues on some im-
portant railroads. The letter of the stat-
ute is complied with when the engineman
controls the brakes on enough cars in a
train to control it and to stop it within
a reasonable distance. This may be from
-S to 75 per cent, of the cars, according
to the condition of the brakes, the weight
of the cars, braked and unbraked, and
their lading, and the gradients of the
line. But the statute contemplates — in
spirit at least — the general use of power
brakes on all the cars of every train.
This full use is the prevailing practice on
the railroads in the West, where air
brakes have been longest used on freight
trains, and it is in accordance with the
separated; and very general neglect of
the retaining valve.
Air Brake, if Coupled up. Would Prevent
Destruction. — There is one class of casual-
ties to trainmen, those due to freight
trains breaking in two, in which both the
couplers and the brakes usually figure in
the statement of causes. The parting is
due to some fault in the coupler, but in
compiling this information it appeared
that most of the derailments which result
from this cause are aggravated by the
automatic action of the air brake; and
this automatic action causes damage
chiefly because a part of the cars in each
train have no air brakes, or have air
brakes which are not connected to the
engine and so are not used.
More Strict Legislation Suggested. — To
promote a more general compliance with
3i8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
the spirit of the safety-appliance law in
the use of air brakes, the Commission
recommends the passage of an act for-
bidding the running of trains in which
less than one-half of the cars are
equipped with power brakes in operative
condition and suitably connected to the
engine, and empowering the Commission
to issue a general order or orders re-
quiring the use of power brakes on more
than 50 per cent, of the cars in a train,
as and when it shall find such increased
use to be practicable, the percentage to
be specified in the order or orders.
Leniency Extended in Deserving Cases. —
The belief has been expressed in some
quarters that such an act should also
authorize the Commission, in the case of
any particular road, and after due hear-
ing and investigation, to issue an order
permitting, for a specified limited time,
the running of trains with power brakes
in use on less than 50 per cent, of the
cars therein; and that such orders should
be authorized to prevent any possible
hardship due to unforeseen exigencies.
Important Air-Brake Experiments
Abroad.
Another experiment with the Westing-
house air brake has been made in Eng-
land, says the Electrical Review, for the
purpose of solving the problem of con-
trolling freight trains traveling at high
speeds on steep descending grades. The
North-Eastcrn Railway Company recently
conducted a series of important trials on
its lines, which at one point attains an ele-
vation of 1,800 feet above sea level, and is
one of the steepest sections of railway in
the United Kingdom.
Forty hea^vy coal cars comprised the
train, each car being equipped with West-
inghouse rapid-acting brake apparatus, the
6Z
u
§a^
8^
Sailway ^ LoeumutU'e Enyinttring
AUTOMATIC OILING DEVICE FOR AIR
CYLINDER OF AIR PUMP MOUNTED
ON PUMP.
air pressure being operated from the en-
gine. Despite high speed, unfavorable
climatic conditions and traveling on the
down grade, the train was brought to a
stand in a very short distance, the appli-
cation of power on both front and rear
wheels of the train being practically simul-
taneous.
The trials were conducted under the
supervision of the leading officers of the
North-Eastern Railway and representa-
tives of the Westinghouse Brake Com-
pany, and are said to have been highly
satisfactorv.
ANOTHER ECHO OF THE AIR-BRAKE
CONVENTION. ADMIRAL AND COM-
MODORE OF THE "FLEET." COUR-
TESY OF MRS. JOHN HUME, JR.
Break-in-Twos Due to Burst Hose.
Some years ago when trains breaking
in twos gave a great deal of trouble, the
cause was commonly assigned to the
bursting of air hose. In recent years,
however, the cause has been shifted to
defective uncoupling parts of the auto-
matic coupler, where it undoubtedly more
properly belongs. It has been found in
many cases in every-day service that too
short a chain is frequently placed on the
coupler in making repairs, and when the
train gets in motion and the draft springs
are compressed, the short chain will cause
the coupling pin to be lifted and the
knuckle to become uncoupled. Doubt-
less a great many break-in-twos are
wrongfully placed on the air brake, when
they should be more properly assigned to
short uncoupling chains.
Since the defective parts of the knuckle
coupler have been found to be guilty of
many of the faults commonly placed on
the air brakes in the matter of trains
breaking in two, the question has been
raised as to whether undue importance
was not attached to the bursting of air-
brake hose in years past. A close ob-
server has noted that a rent in a burst
hose usually extends no further than Va
or ^i of an inch in length. He has also
called attention to the fact that in his
opinion this opening, at such a rem.ote
point from triple valve, would not pro-
duce quick action in trains of any con-
siderable length. Indeed, he has gone
so far as to attempt to duplicate these
conditions, by cutting a half-inch slit with
a penknife in the hose, and binding it
with a piece of sheet rubber and twine,
making it temporarily tight. After
charging this hose with pressure, he sud-
denly cut the twine binding, thereby pro-
ducing as close as possible the con-
ditions of bursting hose, but the air
which escaped in the experiment was in-
sufficient in any case to produce quick
action on a train of two cars. It would
seem, therefore, that much of the blame
due to bursting hose has been wrong-
fully placed in years past. It will be
noted also that burst hose is very seldom
nowadays reported as causing break-in-
twos and consequent damage due to the
quick-action application of the brakes.
Defective automatic couplers and their
uncoupling parts are by far much greater
offenders.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Automatic Oiling Device for Air Cylin-
der of Air Pump.
Fig. I is a side elevation of an air
pump with my automatic oiling -device
applied thereto.
Fig. 2 is a central section of so much
of ray oiling device as illustrates my
present improvement.
In the drawings A is the oil cup or
reservoir having port B in the bottom
thereof. C is the ordinary regulating
screw by means of which the flow of oil
D through port B- is controlled. Sur-
rounding port B. is a boss A', which is
exteriorily threaded and screws into the
Itailutaj/ j Loctimotii'a £nj/inetrinj
DETAILS OF AUTOMATIC OILING DEVICE
FOR AIR CYLINDER OF .\IR PUMP.
enlarged top £' of the tube E upon plate
a to hold said plate firmly on its seat
m said tube. This plate has a boss
through which and through the boss is
a port B', which is a continuation of
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3«9
port B. In the Idwct portion of tube E
is the downwardly opening check valve
F, which permits the oil to pass down
in the tube whenever a vacuum or par-
tial vacuum is produced in the upper part
of the air compressor b. It is held
I prefer its use because I prefer to have
the oil dropped in small drops. The
lower portion /" of the feed needle is
also cylindrical. In this portion of the
needle is a groove N which permits the
oil to pass down to the check valve. A
AlltOtHfltlC
X)
Main
Iltstrvoir
Ah-
I'll III jt
Hailwati ^ ^(Kvmufti't LnninMring
FARRAR'S RELEASE VALVE, DIAGRAMMATIC VIEW.
normally closed or seated by spring G.
The opening through tube E is con-
stricted at and just above the check
valve. The lower portion of this con-
stricted portion forms a valve seat H for
the check valve and the upper portion
thereof forms a support for the glass sight
tube /, whose lower end has grooves /'
extending there through so that air may
pass under the sight tube as well as over
the top thereof, as I have found by ex-
perience that if all the air comes over
the top of the sight tube the oil is some-
times blown into a spray instead of
dropping, as it is better for it to do so
that the engineer may be able to see just
how fast the oil is being fed into the
compressor. The external diameter of
this tube is about 3'j of an inch less than
the internal diameter of tube E. Rest-
ing upon the top of the check valve is
feed needle /, having a cylindrical stem
/' at the top adapted to close port B- when
the check valve F is seated so that no
oil will flow out of the reservoir when
the compressor is running.
At the base of stem /' is a circular
groove K having an opening L in the
recess 0 is provided in the side for the
reception of the end of screw P, which
prevents the feed needle from rotating,
thereby enabling the end of wire M to
be seen through sight port R in tube E.
This screw could be placed so that the
end thereof would enter groove AT and
Front Triple
New Release Valve.
I am sending you a blue print of my
automatic release valve, which I think
will fully explain its construction and ac-
tion.
The parts A and R are movable, and
are shown in Fig. i in the position they
occupy when the brake it set, the conical
valve having closed off communication
with the atmosphere. Fig. 2 shows them
in release position, and the arrow lines
indicate the flow of air to and from the
brake cylinders. A pipe is attached to
the exhaust passage and carried into the
cab, and a cut-out cock put on the end,
convenient to the engineer. When this
is closed the valve is cut out and the
air from brake cylinders pass along the
grooves C and through the triple valve
exhaust. The grooves are made equal
to the area of the exhaust port in the
triple valve. The grooves in the blue
print are not correct, and should only
extend as far as the commencement of
the conical seat in the body of the valve.
J. Farrar.
Montreal, Can.
Concerning Oiling of Air Pumps.
Regarding Robert L. Stamp's ques-
tion in May number, I would say
Railmgn i Lieom»bM £mguit*KiMt
FARR.\RS RELEASE VALVE,
BRAKE APPLYING.
the recess omitted. By this improve-
ment, should the compressor stand idle,
the oil is automatically shut off from the
reservoir until it is started up again,
thereby economizing the use of oil. If
desired, the feed needle could be made
integral with the check valve, thereby
that I think the 8-in. and 6-in.
will get the most oil. because a
pumps
greater
volume of steam flows there, and the oil
will go with the current. The 8-in. pump
will get more than the 6-in., as oil always
goes to the top of steam or water.
Hejibert Riddle.
Alamogordo, New Mexico.
/!K^^>iy^;■'y/^■:•7:V.:./.v/,A,w./•v-/,::y\
Fig. 2
Jiailway ^ Loc^mutu^ t:ng\nttrxng
^xltattst
FARRAR'S RELEASE VALVE, BR.\KE RELEASING.
bottom thereof. In this opening L drop forming stem on the face of the check
a small wire M which guides the oil pass- valve which would close the port when
ing through the opening and causes it to the compressor was not running,
drop in smaller drops than if it were not G. W. Thurston.
used. It may be omitted if desired, but Duiismuir, Cat.
Adjustable Device for Loaded and
Empty Cars.
I send you herewith a drawing of an
adjustable braking device adapted to
loaded and empty cars, as the case may
be, patents for which have just been is-
sued to me. It will be noted that I have
slotted the cylinder lever so as to be able
to raise and lower the fulcrum point.
The angularity of the slot avoids an in-
creased piston travel when the fulcrum
is lowered. The changing of the fulcrum
point is done by means of cast iron ec-
centric with a wrought iron strap which
is connected to the fulcrum lever. The
rod passes through the cast iron eccen-
tric with a spring on one end so as to
320
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTRE ENGINEERING
>ily, 1903-
hold it in its proper position. In order
to turn the eccentric, it is necessary first
to compress the spring about J4 in. This
allows the key in the rod to come out
past the key slot in the bracket holding
the eccentric. After making halt a revo-
lution, the spring forces the rod back and
comes into the slot for the lower position.
be seen that it does not take a great while
to make the change.
L. T. C.^NFIELD.
New York City.
This valve demonstrated that the prin-
cfpal was right; that is, if the head end
of a train is held back until the rear
brakes have released, severe shocks, due
ADJUSTABLE DEVICE FOR LOADED AND
EMPTY CARS, SHOWING LEVER SLOT
CONNECTION IN "LIGHT CAR"
POSITION.
It will also be noted that the rod is ex-
tended from one side of the car to the
other, so that it can be operated from
either side.
Some tests were made a short time
ago with this device. The first test was
taking an 80,000 capacity car, loaded to
its marked capacity, setting the fulcrum
in the empty car position. After getting
the car traveling at the rate of 12 miles
per hour, with train line charged to 70
pounds, the car was detached from the
engine and the brake applied. The car
ran 280 feet before making a stop.
The same test was repeated with the
fulcrum pin dropped to the lower end of
the slot, and the result was that the car
ran but 140 feet, or one-half the distance
of the first test. This was repeated with
different speeds up to 30 miles per hour.
The proportional difTerence between the
two positions remained practically the
same.
There are fifty cars equipped with this
device running on the Delaware, Lacka-
wanna & Western R. R., and I am told
that the train and engine men speak very
highly of it. Of course this device must
be operated by hand, and makes another
part of the brake to look after. At the
same time I think everybody realizes
that it is impossible to apply a device of
this kind to work automatically, as the
only opportunity to make it automatic
in its operation is to use the compres-
sion of the springs, and they vary so that
an operation so dependent would not be
at all reliable or accurate.
There are records of changing the ful-
crum position on cars of the Delaware,
Lackawanna & Western R. R. at the rate
of four cars per minute. It will therefore
Retarding Power of Driver Brakes-
Shocks on Long Trains.
Having come to the conclusion that
shocks on long trains, due to releasing
the brakes at low speed, are caused by
the slack being suddenly stopped from
running out, and that high main res-
ervoir pressure, or large volume, will not
entirely eliminate this condition of
things, as was snowTi in my article re-
lating to this matter in the February
number. It appears that the only way to
prevent these shocks is to either not to
release at low speed or provide some
means to prevent the slack from running
out when releasing, until the rear brakes
have released.
I came to the conclusion that it is not
practical, under all conditions of service,
to run trains without releasing at low
speed, and that the only practical way of
overcoming this trouble was to provide
retaining power on the driver brake.
With this idea in view I tried, some ten
years ago, a valve which was fastened
to the under side of the running board,
the stem of which was extended so that
the end was just above the top of the
board in front of the engineer's seat. A
pipe connection was made from this
valve to the exhaust port of the driver
brake triple valve. It was necessary, as
can be plainly seen from the above ex-
planation, for the pressure in the brake
cylinder to pass through this valve in
order to escape and release the brake.
(lie Eni/ineering
ADJUSTABLE DEVICE FOR LOADED AND
EMPTY CARS, SHOWING LEVER SLOT
CONNECTION IN " LOADED
CAR" POSITION,
to releasing at low speed, will not occur.
Trouble was experienced with this
device, however, in holding the small
volume of air left in the cylinders after
the triple was moved to release position,
and I came to the conclusion that any
device for this purpose which did not
positively maintain pressure in the cyl-
inders was worse than not any.
Having come to this conclusion, I tried
an arrangement as follows: A three-
way valve; that is, a valve which had
three openings, was located in the cab
so as to be handy for the engineer to
operate. From one of the openings a
pipe connection was made to the main
reservoir pressure, and from another a
BaUway i Lvcvmuttm Unjiniiering
ADJUSTABLE DEVICE FOR VARYING THE BRAKING POWER ON LOADED
AND EMPTY CARS. SHOWING ARRANGEMENT FOR SHIFTING
THE FULCRUM IN SLOT OF CYLINDER LEVER.
providing all the connections and the
packing leather in the brake cylinders
were tight. In operating, the engineer
closed this valve by placing his foot on
the stem, just before releasing, and when
sufficient time had elapsed for the rear
brakes to release, would permit the driver
brake to release by moving his foot off
the stem of the valve.
pipe connection was made to the exhaust
port of the driver brake triple valve, and
the third opening was left open to the
atmosphere. With the valve in normal
position communication is closed from
the main reservoir, and open from the
exhaust port of the triple to the atmos-
phere. In this position there is no in-
terference with the release. Pressure
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
321
in tlic brake cylinders could be noted by
a gauge which was connected directly
to one of the cylinders.
Directly below the retaining valve,
connected to the pipe connecting it to
the exhaust port of the triple, was a
safety valve adjusted for 50 pounds
pressure. When it was desired to hold
the driver brake applied and release the
train brakes, the handle of the retaining
valve was moved so as to cause the open-
ing to the atmosphere to be closed, and
establish communication between the
main reservoir and tlic exhaust port of
the triple, and when the triple was moved
to release position, main reservoir pres-
sure would be admitted to the brake
cylinders. The flow of air to the cylin-
ders could be regulated by the port
openings in the retaining valve so that
very little air was wasted at the safety
valve.
(Continued in next number.)
Handling the New York Engineers'
Brake Valve.
(Concluded.)
Before closing this article, it will be
useful to remind the reader that it is a
good plan, when it is known beforehand,
that the engine is to be coupled on to a
train that is to be charged up, to make
one or two applications of the brake on
the light engine, just before coupling,
and return the handle to positive lap
position after each application. Hold-
ing down the auxiliary reservoir pres-
sure in this way, and having the handle
on lap, prevents the danger of losing the
main reservoir pressure through care-
lessness on the part of the trainmen in
closing a rear angle cock before turning
on the air from the engine, and will per-
mit of quickly releasing the brakes on
the engine and tender after the hose be-
tween the tender and train have been
coupled, and the angle cocks opened.
In making water-tank stops and other
accurate stops with passenger trains of
ordinary length, avoid overcharging the
train pipe, when releasing the brakes,
after the first application, and to hold-
ing the handle in release position too
long; but instead move the handle
promptly, after the release has been
effected, to lap position.
This method of operating the brake
valve will enable the train pipe and aux-
iliary reservoir pressures to equalize
quickly, and when the second application
is commenced to stop the train on the
mark, your brakes will respond promptly.
T. L. Burns.
New York.
OlESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ON AIR BRAKE SUBJECTS-
(50) C. W. C. Areata. Cal., says:
What defects will cause a blow, either
on the up or down stroke? A. — Any of
the valve motion parts of the pump leak-
ing live steam into the exhaust, will cause
the pump to blow. If the packing rings
of main piston should leak the pump will
blow on the down stroke and also on the
U]) stroke.
(si) H. L. J., Xenia, O., asks:
What is the meaning of shoe-bound?
A. — This term refers to the brake shoes
dragging on the wheels, due to the slack
being taken up too close. Sometimes
brake shoes are driven on to the beams
without letting out the slack, and when
the car is started the shoes drag and rub
on the wheels ; hence the term "shoe-
bound." Sometimes the slack is taken
up too tightly, producing the same trouble.
(52) C. W. C, Areata, Cal., asks:
If air pump runs hot on the road how
would you proceed to cool it ? A. — Put
some heavy-bodied valve oil on the swab
of the piston rod, feed a reasonable quan-
tity into the air cylinder through the oil
cup, and slow down the speed of the
pump, carrying a lower pressure if neces-
sary. Of course, slowing down the pump
will reduce the output of air pressure, but
this is preferable to burning up the pump
and being obliged to shut it down alto-
gether.
(53) B. R. J., Albany, N. ¥., writes:
Will an air pump, without a governor,
pump pressure in main reservoir equal to
that in boiler? A. — Yes, and even higher,
if the air cylinder is sufficiently smaller
than the steam cylinder. The 8-inch
pump, which has 8-in. steam and 7j4-in.
air cylinders, will do it, but the 95^-in.
pump, whose steam and air cylinders are
equal in diameter, will not do it. Some
modified forms of the locomotive pump,
where air cylinder is much less in diame-
ter than the steam, are now being made
for other uses, and deliver a much higher
pressure of air than the steam required to
run the pump.
(54) W. N. P., Newark, O., writes:
We have received a new Pennsylvania
engine here, built by the Baldwin Works,
which has a peculiar auxiliary valve
or cock under the brake valve. There
is a small copper pipe connected with this
cock and the whole arrangement is in the
main reservoir pipe and is about 6 inches
under the brake valve. Would you please
say what this is for. A. — This is doubt-
less the standard double-heading cut-out
cock of the Pennsylvania type. This cock
is placed in the main reservoir pipe and is
so designed that when the engine is second
in a double-head train, and the cock
closed, the engineer can note the train
line pressure as it rises and falls on his
gauge, due to the operation of the brakes
by the head engineer. He can also apply
brakes in service position as well as in
emergency if he desires, without being
obliged in any way to operate the cut-out
cock. This is doubtless the device to
which you refer.
(55) T. H. B., Toronto, Ont., writes:
With the D-8 brake valve was the pres-
sure held in chamber D and equalizing
reservoir when the brake valve handle was
thrown to emergency position? I am told
this, but with the F-6 valve, the black
hand pressure reduces slowly, finally com-
ing down to zero. Please answer and set-
tle the argument. A. — The D-8 valve was
so constructed that it held the air im-
prisoned in chamber D and equalizing
reservoir when an emergency application
of the brake was made. In this event the
black hand of the gauge showed no reduc-
tion, except that caused by leakage of
chamber D pressure past the equalizing
piston ring into the empty train pipe.
With the present form of valve, however,
the equalizing reservoir pressure escapes
by groove P in the under side of the
rotary and groove H in rotary seat, which
.'ire made longer in the F-6 valve than they
were in the D-8 valve. This permits the
pressure to escape and the black gauge
hand to fall.
(56) J. T. T., Philadelphia, Pa..
writes:
We have the latest improved engineers'
brake valve with slide-valve feed valve
attachment on our engine, which ought to
be new, as the engine came from Bald-
win's Locomotive Works in March. Now,
when you make a service application the
brake will stay set, but when you go to
emergency, the brake whistles off
through the triple valve. If you close
cut-out cock in train pipe under brake
valve right away, the brake will stay
set, but when you open cut-out cock the
brake whistles off. A. — We assume that
in making the emergency application you
have returned your brake-valve handle to
lap position, after drawing a certain
amount of pressure quickly from the
train pipe. In this case the train-pipe
pressure has been reduced, but the pres-
sure in the equalizing reservoir remains
undisturbed. When the brake-valve han-
dle is returned to lap, the pressure in the
equalizing reservoir passes by the equal-
izing piston packing ring into the train
pipe, raising the train-line pressure and
forcing the triple valve to release posi-
tion. However, if you leave the brake-
valve handle in emergency position after
making the service application, you will
find that the brake will stay on, as it is
impossible in this case to raise the train-
line pressure above that remaining in
the auxiliary reservoir, therefore the
triple valve cannot move to release posi-
tion and cause the brake to whistle off.
It is reported that the South Side ele-
vated railroads, in Chicago, are discard-
ing the Christensen engineer's brake
valve and are substituting the Westing-
house brake valve for it on all their
cars.
Write us for air-brake books. We
have all the best ones.
322
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July. 1903.
New Canadian Pacific Parlor Cars.
The Canadian Pacific Railway have re-
<ently added two parlor cars to their
passenger rolling stock. The exterior
finish and decorations conform to Cana-
dian Pacific standards and these cars
have all the up-to-date improvements
in car construction which are to be
found anywhere. Especial attention
has been given to strength, and ad-
vantage has been taken to reinforce
parts where experience has shown the
need. The length of the car is 72 ft.
over body sills, the extreme length over
buffer plates being 79 ft. 10^ in. The
exterior finish is Mexican mahogany,
tastefully decorated in gold.' In design-
ing these cars, the C. P. R. authorities
aimed at smooth surfaces, light profiles
and they have eliminated all carving. A
very fine appearance has been obtained
bottom sashes, the inside bottom being
set in a brass-hinged frame; this is to en-
able attendants to easily clean the glass.
Between each window space is a richly
veneered and inlaid pilaster, extending
from the top of the truss plank to the
base of the side cove, while along the
base of the side cove runs a neatly inlaid
moulding.
The bulkheads or end partitions are
in keeping with the side elevation, being
veneered with the same quality mahog-
any, and divided off by pilasters, which
extend from the floor to same elevation
as side pilasters. These bulkheads are
recessed in elliptic lines, which gives the
end views a very novel appearance, ad-
vantage being taken with this to form an
overhead cove of art glass in colors
which match the deck lights. The ceil-
ings are of the Empire style and neatly
ductor in making up the journal or rec-
ord of his train can get the weights in
each case. This permits the passenger
service to be worked out on the ton-
mile basis, the same as freight trains are.
Old-Time Railroad Reminiscences.
BY S. J. KIDDER.
I suppose every division of a railroad
has its meanest man, at least some in-
dividual by his words or actions usu-
ally acquires that reputation among his
fellows, and in the instance I am about
to relate Symson Lovell enjoyed this
distinguishing mark of opprobrium.
Sym. was among the oldest engineers
on the road, both in years and term of
service, and for reasons, by no means
unknown among the rank and file, en-
joyed opportunities by which he could
..f.im»tiiK^'SsiaMfi\ '
CANADIAN PACIFIC PARLOR CAR " RICHKLIEl'."
by the use of rich mahogany veneers
and neat marquetrie borders and lines
decorated in light shades of green.
The chairs are upholstered in pale
green plush and have been designed with
a view to comfort. The smoking room is
supplied with eight chairs of same design
as in the main room, but these latter are
upholstered in maroon-colored leather.
The walls of the smoking room are
divided off, by means of marquetrie lines,
into large panels which extend from
within a few inches of the floor up to
the base line of the monitor deck. The
veneer used in this room is African ma-
hogany. Each car has two ladies' toilets,
a men's toilet and a men's saloon, all
being fitted with the latest improved
flushing closets and nickeline washstand
tops.
The main room or parlor has four
double Acme lamps. On each side of the
parlor are eight large plate-glass win-
dows, the glass being 26x48 in. Each
window is fitted up with double top and
attached to the lower end of each center
lamp is an ornamented brass bell-cord
eye, through which passes the signal
cord. This does away with the objection-
able swinging bell-cord hanger. These
cars represent all that is new and up-to-
date in the way of beauty and luxury.
The chairs, which stand squarely on four
legs, can be moved as desired, and in
their comfort and elegance invite an un-
limited trip, while the eye is never tired
taking in the quiet richness of the in-
terior decorations.
The entire absence of grill work,
carved bosses or mouldings, removes
that dust-harboring form of car decora-
tion which is the bane of cleaners. There
are no hangings or portieres to collect
disease germs, and altogether the scheme
of color and form is like "beauty un-
adorned is adorned the most."
The weight of the car is stencilled in-
side the men's lavatory. This practice is
being followed with passenger equipment
by the Canadian Pacific so that the con-
often shift unpleasant duties, to other
shoulders, thus permitting himself to
recreate in slothful indulgence, while
some one less fortiinate did his work,
he, meantime, drawing full pay.
His fireman, John Nickson, too, either
by nature or association, had developed
many of the traits so prominent in Sym.,
frequently laying off at the same time.
The men were careless in their dress,
general appearance and work, and quite
naturally numerous ear marks about
their engine indicated that wind and
rain were the elements depended on to
remove dust and dirt rather than elbow
grease on the part of John. Even the
scattered coal on the cab deck was per-
mitted to repose there until it interfered
with the swing of the fire-box door be-
fore he used his shovel to sweep it out.
Taking Sym,, his fireman and their en-
gine, the "J. W. Grimes, No. 19," as a
whole, they formed a combination diffi-
cult of duplication.
It was Sym.'s practice to neglect every-
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
323
tiling so long as he could worry along,
but when the inevitable occurred, such
as setting up the wedges or other work
essential to maintain an engine in proper
working condition, then was his time to
lay off a trip, a privilege always accorded
to suit Sym.'s pleasure.
It usually fell to my lot to run the
"Grimes" at such times, to which I did
not seriously object, as pulling varnished
cars was, with me, like other young en-
gineers, an inducement, and I took no
little pleasure in working all day at the
other end of the division fixing up the
engine, but after a time the novelty wore
away and I realized Sym.'s object and the
fact that he was getting decidedly the
better of the bargain, and the conclu-
sion arrived at was that a good freight
engine was preferable to a poor passen-
ger one.
Sam. Seavers, with the "Gen. Sher-
man," had the run opposite Sym., and
one night it fell to my lot to go out on
Seavers' engine. I made the west-bound
trip, and on my return the following
evening, just before starting out, received
a telegram that Seavers was coming with
the "Grimes" and for me to change off
with him when we met, the meeting point
being at Albia, 90 miles away. Upon
receiving the message I realized that
trouble was in store for me, but com-
prehended but slightly what a strenuous
night I was destined to put in before
again reaching Creston. Pulling out we
reached Albia on time (midnight), but
No. I was not there, neither could a
headlight be seen down the two miles
of straight track extending slightly be-
yond Central Crossing. That No. i
was somewhere in the vicinity was evi-
dent from the order received on our
arrival holding No. 2 for No. i, the
operator also imparting the information
that the latter train had left Frederic,
nine miles away, on time, and its non-
appearance was somewhat confusing to
us.
Quite a coterie had gathered on the
station platform and speculation was rife
as to the cause of delay until finally a
headlight was seen rounding the curve
at the end of the tangent, but the delib-
erate speed with which it moved pre-
saged that something had gone wrong
with the train. Slowly the light ap-
proached, first disappearing into one
dip, then the other, the track following
the raises and depressions of the rolling
prairie between the crossing and Albia,
from the latter of which it failed to
emerge, but in its stead a lantern hove
in sight over the hog-back, and as it ap-
proached the platform we saw Seavers
with it afoot and alone.
He had stopped for water at Frederic
and shortly after climbing the heavy
grade west of the town the left hand
tank hose had become detached from
the feed pipe and this had only been dis-
covered when the other pump failed to
work from lack of water supply, the
train meantime being some three miles
from Albia.
Sam. stopped, cut loose and endeav-
ored to reach this station with the en-
gine, but for lack of fluid in the boiler
had been obliged to extinguish his fire.
Under these conditions, however, he had
had no scruples in turning the defunct
"Grimes" over to me, wliicli, in my
stupid innocence, I permitted him to do,
being oblivious at the moment that there
are times when a refusal to obey orders
is justifiable.
that station, where, after procuring the
supply required, she was propelled up
and down the main line until her boiler
had been replenished, after which she
was shoved in on her train, the freight
then departing without ofTcring further
assistance. The next requisite was wood
with which to fire up, and which was
procured by a vigilant search through
the timber and scattered buildings in
the vicinity until a sufficient quantity of
dead limbs, fence rails and boards from
an abandoned lean-to had been gathered
to fill the fire-box, several of the pas-
sengers lending a hand in their anxiety
INTERIOR OF PARLOR CAR "RICHELIEU
The engine of a freight train standing
at the station was procured, to the front
end of which was attached a fiat car, and
we sallied forth for the "Grimes," find-
ing the engine where Sam. had deserted
her, coupled into and hauled up to the
station, following which Seavers pulled
out with No. 2.
Finding, of course, his former train
where he had left it he pushed it back
to Frederic, set it on the side track,
then resumed his homeward journey.
The first thing required by the
"Grimes" was to get her to Frederic and
gel a tank of water, which was accom-
plished by towing her in a freight train to
to facilitate a resumption of their jour-
ney.
The "Grimes" was finally resuscitated,
and four hours behind the schedule time.
No. I was again moving westward.
Albia was soon reached and finding
the coal pile seriously depleted a fresh
supply was taken by pitching on a suffi-
cient quantity of chunks to insure mak-
ing Chariton, the regular coaling station.
At this point the tender was loaded to
its capacity and things seemed to be
coming our way when all at once, while
descending White Breast grade, upon
striking a curve, the headlight gave sev-
eral spasmodic flickers, the blaze then
324
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July. 1903.
vanishing into innocuous desuetude, and
as this indicated an abbreviated vi'ick,
a lantern was suspended from the
bracket in due respect to time card
rules.
The "Grimes" was handling a train
that well ta.xed her capacity on the as-
cending grades, and as we approached
Thayer I began feeling apprehensive,
both on account of the rapid disappear-
ance of the coal pile, which made it
questionable as to our supply being suffi-
cient to take us to Creston, the other
whether we could get the train through
the sharp curves of Thayer hill, it be-
ing about daybreak and an extremely
slippery rail, should we stop there for
fuel.
At this moment a happy thought came
to mind, for when passing Afton, situ-
ated on the summit of a divide ten miles
from Creston, the evening before, I had
casually noticed two flat cars loaded
with wood standing on the house track.
Well, I started the train from the sta-
tion, shutting oflf as we left the yard,
and pitched down the grade ahead, per-
mitting gravity to propel us some two
miles. A light throttle then took us to
the foot of Creston hill, where the final
chapter began. The hill was some four
miles in length, moderate in steepness as
compared with the ruling grades, and
in climbing it fuel economy rather than
speed was the desideratum eagerly
sought.
As we ascended the hill I mounted the
tank and began mining operations by
loosening up the heavy crust of mixed
coal and cinders, sorting out the links
and pins, and shortly before the top of
the grade was reached the last scrapings
of coal, slack and cinders had passed the
fire-box door.
Passing the- summit a medium de-
scending grade a mile or so in length
was before us, then a sharp up-grade less
than half as long into Creston yard. To
niRNI.NG FRJilGHT ENGIXE— TR.\NSC.'\.UCASI.\.\ KAILW.W.
and it occurred to me that as a last re-
sort we could appropriate a sufficient
supply for our needs, and acting on the
impulse I' let the "Grimes" take a flying
run through Thayer which easily dis-
posed of the grade I had been dreading.
The pull up -Afton hill was a long, hard
one, it being the heaviest westbound
grade on the division, but with the lever
in the corner and the throttle wide open
the "Grimes" reached the station.
Stopping at the water tank the next
move was to get our prospective supply
of wood which my optical research failed
to locate, and my consternation may be
imagined when it was learned that the
cars with the much needed fuel had been
picked up by a passing train during the
night. The last prop being gone noth-
ing was left but for us to husband our
resources so far as conditions would
permit, and if it was found impossible
to make Creston, cut loose and run for
coal, though this I did not propose to do
if by hook or crook it could be pre^
vented.
get over that pitch but one thing was
left to be done. The fire would soon be
gone, and why not sacrifice the water?
So just as we struck the down grade I
shut oft' the pump, assuming that the
crown sheet would be in no danger.
Wc made the goal, but when the
"Grimes" stopped at the station an
abundance of red clinkers lined the
grates, water could not be found in the
lower gauge cock and the steam gauge
registered 45 pounds.
It is needless to remark that little
work was done that d-y in rehabilitating,
though the engine had a broken water
glass, the headlight wick required re-
newal, the pump plungers and pistons
were shy of hemp packing, in short there
were few things about the engine that
did not require attention. The piston
on my side and one pump was packed
sufficiently for the return trip; the head-
light reflector placed on the rear of the
tender facing ahead that the falling dew
and sparks from the diamond stack
might possibly bring out some of its
original luster, it being replaced for the
trip by one borrowed from the "Black-
hawk," an engine on a daylight run.
The next morning I was at the Ot-
tumwa round house early to return the
reflectors to their respective places and
remove the packing temporarily placed
in the stuffing boxes the day before, and
had but just got through when Sym.
Lovell walked in.
He climbed into the cab noticing the
undisturbed broken water glass. Next
he took a walk round the engine noting
the position of the piston and pump
glands all hard against the stuffing boxes,
but when he surveyed that headlight re-
flector, the color of which may be im-
agined after a night's ride on the ten-
der, he tumbled. Walking over to a
bench where I was sitting he wanted to
know why I did not put in a water glass,
to which I replied that a Yankee didn't
need it. Then he inquired about the
headlight wick and numerous other
things, to which I replied evasively and
concluded by asking if I had reported
certain shop work, my reply being in the
negative. Straightening up he demanded
to know why I had not reported this
work. Well, Sym., said I, the old 19 is
a horrible example of what a negligent,
incompetent and lazy man can accom-
plish, and I'm through fixing her up for
you, and as for reporting shop work,
the only thing compatable with truth
would be general debility requiring a
jacking up of the whistle and putting a
new engine under it, but knowing she
couldn't be spared from her run to-night
and that you are going out I thought it
best to mark nothing on the slate.
A Curious Cause for a Strike.
A curious cause nearly led to a strike
in the Baldwin Locomotive Works last
month. The men have been accustomed
to wear canvas bag aprons to prevent
their clothing from being saturated with
the oil and grease which they use while
working. A few days ago a fire broke
out and its origin was attributed to spon-
taneous combustion due to the careless
way in which the workers allowed the
oil-soaked garments to lie around. The
fire nearly developed a conflagration and
as a result an order was issued prohibit-
ing the dangerous apron from being
worn as a part of the workers' garment.
The men protested and the superinten-
dent provided them with bags, but they
allege they are of an inferior material
and not the kind they should have to be
free from refuse oil and grease.
A new locomotive manufacturing con-
cern is to be established at Toronto,
Ont., under the name of the British
American Locomotive Works. A char-
ter has been obtained from the Ontario
government, with a capital stock of
$1,000,000.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
325
Ten-Wheel Engines for the Central of
Georgia.
A short time ago the Central of
Georgia received some simple 4-6-0 en-
S;ines from the Rogers Locomotive
Works, of Paterson, N. J. These en-
gines have cyHnders 19x20 in., and
the driving wheels are 69 ins. With
a pressure of 200 lbs. to the square
inch, the calculated tractive force of these
engines is about 23,100 lbs., and as
the weight on drivers is 116,000 lbs.,
it follows that the ratio of adhesive
weight to tractive power is about 5.
The total weight of the machine is
148,000 lbs. The symmetrica! appear-
ance which these engines have is no
doubt in part due to the fact that the
drivers are all equally spaced and the
center line of the boiler is so placed as
to add to the general effect. The drivers
are equalized together on underhung
^springs.
water capacity of the tank is 5,000 gal-
lons.
A few of the leading dimensions are
appended for reference:
Cylinders, rgx26 in.
Urivers, diameter, 69 in.; drivinR journals, yxi2
in.; driving wheel base, 13 ft.; total wheel
base of enKinc, 23 ft. 5 in; weight on drivers,
116.000 lbs.; weight on truck, 32,000 lbs.; total,
148,000 lbs.
Heating surface, tubes, 1,9.55.80 sq. ft.; firebox,
i<J7 57 -sq. ft.; total, 2,123.37 sq- ft.; grate area,
30.59 sq. ft.
Tubes, diameter. 2 in. O.D.; length, 13 ft. 7 in.;
thickness, No. 12 gauge; total number, 275.
Hoilcr, working jiressurc, 200 lbs.; thickness of
barrel, »J in.; thickness of dome course, >> in.;
thickness of crown, ,', in.; thickness of tube,
x"s in.; thickness of side, }% in.
Shooting Round the Corner.
We once saw a man suffering from
delirium tremens who imagined that an
enemy was after him with a gun which
A Miniature Locomotive.
A working jeweler in Meridian, N. Y.,
has devoted three years of his leisure
time to making a toy locomotive. Work-
ing a hobby of this kind is much more
profitable than many others that men
ride to occupy leisure hours, and it de-
velops knowledge as well as skill. Think
of setting the valves of a locomotive that
are only j4-inch wide and adjusting the
eccentrics to suit!
The locomotive is heavily plated with
gold, and the bell, whistle and driving
wheels are solid gold. The trimmings
are of silver. The locomotive is six and
a half inches long and the tender is three
inches long. The boiler is three-fourths
of an inch in diameter, the smokestack
two and one-sixteenth inches high, and
the rest of the parts are in proportion.
Kerosene is used for fuel and steam is
raised in less than two minutes. The
whistle blows, the bell rings and every
part of the locomotive works perfectly.
ROGERS TEN-WHEEL ENGINE FOR THE CENTR.\L OF
The valve motion is indirect connected
and the valves are of the ordinary bal-
anced slide-valve type. The cross-heads
are the two guide-bar style, with the
upper part of the top guide slightly over-
hanging the cross-head, which is lipped
up into the recess, thus avoiding col-
lecting dirt and grit.
The boiler is 62>/a in. in diameter
at the smoke-box end, and is of the e.\-
tension wagon-top type. There are
about 2,123 sq. ft. of heating sur-
face in the boiler and the length of the
tubes is 13 ft. 7 in. The whistle is
placed in a somewhat protected position
behind the dome, and the pop valves are
below the level of the dome casing,
which adds to the general appearance of
the machine. The headlight, as will be
seen in the illustration, is electric, and
the beam of light is thrown from an 18-
inch reflector.
The tender frame is made of lo-inch
steel channels; the trucks are of pressed
steel and the wheels are cast iron centers,
steel tired, with retaining rings. The
the sufferer believed had the peculiarity
of shooting round a corner. We sup-
posed that an attack of jim-jams was
necessary to make people believe any-
thing could be made to shoot round the
corner, but the claim for an equivalent
performance comes to us in a dispatch
from Pueblo, Cal. The disp.itch says:
"Sherman Hobson, a well-known railroad
man of this city, has just perfected an
appliance which, if all proves true that
is claimed for it by its inventor, will
greatly reduce railroad collisions and
save thousands of lives annually. The
new appliance is a sort of looking glass
to be hung on each side of an engine
to enable the engineer and fireman to
see the roadbed for six miles, both in
front and in the rear. The chief value
of the invention is that it does not make
any difference if the road is curved or
straight. The instrument works on the
principle of a mirage, and it has been
named by its inventor as the "mirage-
scope."
GEORGIA.
May not the complaint that common
people are above their station often take
Its rise in the fact of loicommon people
being below theirs ?—.\-icholas NickUby.
Railway Signaling Club Meeting.
The :May meeting of the Railway
Signaling Club discussed Mr. Sperry's
question, which was: "In the preparation
of time-tables what consideration is given
to the block-signal capacity of the line?"
The Pittsburgh & Lake Erie road's ex-
perience did not bear directly on the ques-
tion, as many of their freight trains were
run as "extras" and not set down in the
time table. The block signal system has,
however, been of inestimable value. The
speed of freights had been increased.
Trains running in sections were able to
follow one another closely with safety
under high speed. Rear-end collisions
had been reduced to a very satisfactory
minimum.
On the Lehigh, freight trains were not
on the time table. A great saving in the
326
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
running of slow freights had been ef-
fected by running them ahead of fast
freights where required until ordered by
the dispatcher to take a side track.
On the C, AI. & St. P., the block sig-
nal capacity of the road was not con-
sidered in making a time table. Trains
cannot be run any closer than the distance
apart of the block signals.
The capacity of the Santa Fe had been
increased considerably by the stafY sys-
tem chietly on account of doing away with
train orders and the consequent loss of
time involved in their use. On the moun-
tain with four engines 25 or 30 orders
were often given and it generally took
the crews 40 minutes to read them and get
ready. There was no necessity for a time
table under the staff system.
The question was then re-stated on mo-
tion and put in the form "Does the block
system increase the capacity of the line ?"
One speaker pointed out that here single
track blocking must be distinguished from
double track blocking. On single track,
if the length of blocks is 4 or 5 miles,
it is not possible to run as many trains as
without the block. Some trainmasters
have held that 55 trains a day very closely
approaches the capacity of the track. On
double track roads, it is largely a ques-
tion of how much the company will spend
on signal equipment. Short blocks mean
many signals and increased track capa-
city.
The discussion then turned somewhat to
the matter of giving train orders by tele-
phone, but returning to the question of ca-
pacity another speaker said there was no
question on his line about the increased
capacity of the road. He said, "We had a
heavy freight movement last year and our
freight trains have been run down that
hill under automatic signals, permissive
of course, and we have had no accidents ;
whereas, we had accidents before, on that
same grade."
South African Visitor's Views on
Britisli and American Engines.
We recently had a visit from Mr. Philip
A. Hyde, chief locomotive superintendent
of the Central South African railways,
whose home is in Pretoria. Mr. Hyde
paid the United States a flying visit for
the purpose of buying some engines for
the railways of the Transvaal and Orange
River Colonies. He visited New York,
Philadelphia, Altoona, Pittsburgh, Buf-
falo, Dunkirk, Schenectady and other
cities in which large railway and electrical
interests are centered. During the brief
time at his disposal Mr. Hyde, who has
had an extensive and varied experience
on the government railways of India, has
closely observed American methods and
practice, riding upon engines and making
personal studies of our ways of doing
things.
He spoke of the great difficulties ex-
perienced in the work of organization in
the various railway departments after the
war. The locomotive department, re-
quiring as it does, skilled and intelligent
workers, was at first seriously handi-
capped by the unpromising material which
stepped from the ranks and laid down the
rillc, the bandolier and the bayonet for
the hammer, the throttle and the scoop.
The federation of the former Nether-
lands Railway with that of the Orange
River, has been effected, even before the
political federation of the various states
has been brought about. The earnings
of both roads are pooled and the govern-
ment of each colony is paid on a pre-
arranged basis. The general ofticers, how-
ever, have jurisdiction over both roads
and are entirely removed from political
influence of any kind. They are directly
responsible to Lord Milner, the High
Commissioner.
Speaking of British and American en-
gines in South Africa, Mr. Hyle had kind
words to say for the American machine.
They vifere well liked, and every effort had
been made to give them a perfectly fair
trial. In assigning engines, the existing
premium sheet had been taken and the
best men selected. The first was given an
American engine, the next on the sheet
was given a British engine, the next an
American, and so on. After they had run
for some time and each man had become
familiar with his engine, the performance
was closely watched and coal weighed on
and off, and repairs recorded. The en-
gines were expected to do a certain defi-
nite work. They had to haul so many
tons, so many miles, on a given schedule.
The work was ton-miles per hour, if one
may so say. In this test it was found
that the British engines were 14 per cent,
cheaper on coal for a given ton mileage,
while the American locomotives were 20
per cent, more economical in the matter
of repairs.
One of the reasons why the American
engines were lighter on repairs was that
they had better fires than the English en-
gines. They had much better springs and
their balanced slide valves far outlasted
the plane slide valves of their rivals.
This very satisfactory maintenance fig-
ure was unfortunately reduced by some
very bad tank work. All the tanks had to
be raised off the tender frames and seams
had to be re-rivetted. That, together with
repeated failures of some studs in the
boilers, used for securing back head stays,
reduced the amount otherwise gained by
7 per cent.
In the matter of coal economy, Mr.
Hyde regarded it as a purely engineering
question in which American builders can
secure results quite as satisfactory as those
of British builders, if they would design
their engines to suit existing conditions.
Just here we may be permitted to re-
mark that therein lies the whole secret of
successful competition in foreign fields.
If foreign buyers want engines that save
coal with known loads ; if they do not
care for the reserve power necessary to
lift two or three cars out of an awkward
siding and add them to an already nomi-
nally full train, then it is "up to" Ameri-
can manufacturers to build coal savers.
In the matter of inferior work, there
is absolutely no e.Kcuse for shipping
.'\merican products abroad which have
been worked up in the cheap and nasty
style. Those manufacturers who do it,
especially with railway material, not only
seriously damage their own reputations
and curtail their chances of future busi-
ness, but they wantonly handicap every
other American concern which legiti-
mately attempts to enter and compete in
the foreign markets of the world.
"Far from the Hadding Crowd."
While waiting for the train the June
bride and bridegroom walked slowly up
and down the platform.
"I don't know what this joking and
guying may have been to you," he re-
marked, "but it's death to me. I never
experienced such an ordeal."
"It's perfectly dreadful," she answered.
"I shall be so glad when we get away
from everybody we know."
"They're actually impertinent," he went
on. "Why the very natives "
At this unpropitious moment the
wheezy old station master walked up to
them.
"Be you goin' to take this train?" he
asked.
"It's none of your business," retorted
the bridegroom, indignantly, as he guided
the bride up the platform, where they
condoled with each other over the imper-
tinence of the natives.
Onward came the train, its vapor
curling from afar. It was the last to
their destination that day; an express —
nearer it came at full speed, then in a
moment it whizzed past and was gone.
"Why in thunder didn't that train
stop?" yelled the bridegroom.
" 'Cos yez sed 'twarn't none of my biz-
ness. I has to signal if that train's to
stop."
And as the old stationmaster softly
stroked his beard there was a wicked
twinkle in his eye. — New York Commer-
cial Advertiser.
Not long ago the estate of the late
William C. Baker won a suit in the
Circuit Court for the Northern District
of Illinois, which had been brought by
the heirs to prevent infringement of
rights held under the Baker patents upon
car heating apparatus and fittings. The
case was. however, carried to the United
States Circuit Court of the Seventh Dis-
trict, and a decision has just been ren-
dered affirming the decision of the lower
court.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
327
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. S. Morgan has been appointed fore-
man of the Wheeling & Lake Erie black-
smith shop at Norwalk, Ohio.
Mr. J. M. Gailcy has been appointed
foreman at Brownwood, Texas, on the
Frisco system, vice Mr. E. J. Timlin, re-
signed.
Mr. J. B. Ward has been appointed road
foreman of engines on the Cleveland, ,\k-
von & Columbus, with headquarters at
Akron.
Mr. J. H. Pollard, master mechanic on
the Illinois Central Railroad, at Centralia,
111., has tendered his resignation to the
company.
Mr. J. E. Ley has b.cn appointed mas-
ter mechanic on the Chicago, Rock Island
& Pacific at Valley Junction, la., vice Mr.
D. W. Cunningham, resigned.
Mr. William B. Ott has been appointed
assistant master mechanic of the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad, with office at Harrisburg.
Pa., vice Mr. Lyman, resigned.
Mr. James Lauder has been appointed
master mechanic on the Fort Worth &
Rio Grande Railway, at Fort Worth, Tex.,
vice Mr. Chas. Buck, resigned.
Mr. A. W. Martin has been appointed
assistant general superintendent of the
New York, New Haven & Hartford, with
Central & Hudson Bay Railway, to engage
in private business in Toronto, Ont.
Mr. W. A. George has been appointed
round-house foreman on the Chicago &
Alton, at Bloomington, III. He was f jr-
mcrly with the Colorado & Southern.
Mr. E. J. Timlin, formerly foreman on
the Brownwood shops of the Frisco sys-
tem, has been appointed master mechanic
on the Rock Island, at Chickasha, I. T.
Mr. W. F. Teat has been appointed
master mechanic of the Atlanta, Knox-
ville & Northern, with office at Blue
Ridge, Ga., vice Mr. S. J. .^nderson, de-
ceased.
ENGINES 1H.\T rVLLEU TR.^INS ON E-XTR.\ORDIN.\RY F.\ST RUN OVER L.\KE SHORE & MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DESCRIBED
ON PAGES 2S1, JUNE NUMBER.
Mr. C. E. Fuller has been appointed
assistant mechanical superintendent of the
Erie Railroad and of its operated and con-
trolled lines.
Mr. J. H. Abrams has been appointed
Trainmaster of the Washington division
of the Southern Railway, vice W. S. An-
drews, promoted.
Mr. Ira Southwick has been appointed
master mechanic of the Toledo & Western,
with headquarters at Sylvania, Ohio, vice
Mr. J. Cunningham, resigned.
office at South Terminal Station, Boston,
Mass.
Mr. H. E. Passmore has been appointed
master mechanic of the Western division
of the Toledo & Ohio Central Railway,
vice Mr. J. C. Homer, resigned.
Mr. J. G. Piatt has been appointed en-
gineer of tests on the Erie, with office at
Meadville, Pa., vice Mr. A. G. Trumbull,
appointed mechanical engineer.
Mr. William Apps has resigned his posi-
tion of master car builder of the Algoma
Mr. C. W. Spencer has been appointed
General Superintendent of Transportation
on the Canadian Pacific Railway over all
lines east of Port Arthur, with office at
Montreal.
Mr. \y. C. Hayes has been appointed
assistant mechanical superintendent of the
Erie Railroad, and of its operated and
controlled lines, vice Mr. George Dona-
hue, resigned.
Mr. F. P. Barnes, master mechanic on
the Santa Fe at Albuquerque, Cal., has
328
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
resigned to accept the position of superin-
tendent of motive power on the El Paso &
Northeastern.
Mr. Charles Day, of the firm of Dodge
& Day, modernizing engineers, of Phila-
delphia, recently read a paper on "Ma-
chine Shop Methods," before the S. K. C.
Club, at Pittsfield.
Mr. E. Hacking has been appointed
master car builder of the Algoma Central
& Hudson Bay Railway, with headquar-
ters at Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., vice Mr.
W. Apps, resigned.
Mr. Arthur Piers has been appointed
manager of steamship lines, with charge
of all the steamships owned and operated
by the Canadian Pacific Railway Company.
His office will be at Montreal.
Mr. C. M. Stourbraker, formerly of the
Rock Island route at Colorado Springs,
has been appointed assistant trainmaster
on the Illinois Central Railroad, with
headquarters at Carbondale, 111.
Mr. F. P. Brady, formerly superinten-
dent Canadian Pacific Railway, at Fort
William, has been appointed assistant
general superintendent of the Central
division of the same road, with office at
Winnipeg, Man.
Mr. Robert Streghorn has been ap-
pointed general foreman of the Fort
Worth shops of the Fort Worth & Rio
Grande, vice Mr. H. Ebert, who has re-
signed to accept a position on the Texas
Midland.
Mr. I. C. Hicks, formerly foreman of
the Minneapolis shops, of the Minneapolis
& St. Louis, has been appointed general
foreman of the San Bernardino shops, on
the Santa Fe coast lines, vice Mr. Werst,
resigned.
Mr. Thomas Outhouse, who as foreman
at Cairo, 111., on the Mobile & Ohio, re-
signed to take his run again on the road,
has been appointed general foreman for
the same road, with headquarters at
Meridian, Miss.
Mr. John B. Thayer, Jr., has been ap-
pointed fifth vice-president of the Penn-
sylvania Railroad. He has been on that
road since 1883, and is not only thoroughly
familiar with the whole system, but he is
a trained traflSc officer.
Mr. J. Oborne has been appointed gen-
eral superintendent of the Eastern Divis-
ion of the Canadian Pacific Railway, with
office at Montreal. Mr. Oborne was for-
merly general superintendent of the Atlan-
tic Division of the same road.
Mr. Geo. Spencer, formerly chief train-
dispatcher on the Canadian Pacific Rail-
way, at Toronto, has been appointed Su-
perintendent of the line between Smith's
Falls and Hamilton, vice Mr. J. Manson,
transferred. Office at Toronto.
Mr. J. A. Doarnberger, master boiler-
maker on the Norfolk & Western Rail-
way, at Roanoke, Va., has been elected
president of the International Railway
Master Boiler Makers' Association, at its
last annual meeting, at Columbus, O.
Mr. R. H. Soule, the well-known super-
intendent of motive power, who has been
a long time confined to his home with
sickness, is now entirely recovered and
intends resuming the business of consult-
ing mechanical engineer in New York
City.
Mr. J. E. Mulfeld, heretofore superin-
tendent of motive power of the Baltimore
& Ohio, at Newark, Ohio, has been ap-
pointed general superintendent of nn tive
power for the same company, with head-
quarters in Baltimore, Md., vice Mr. F.
D. Casanave, resigned.
Mr. W. A. Gardner, assistant round-
house foreman at the Altoona shops of
the Pennsylvania, is the inventor of the
patent locomotive sander which we illus-
trated in our June issue, page 252. The
name of Andrews mentioned in connec-
tion with it was introduced by mistake.
Mr. William Burlingham has accepted
an appointment as chief engine designer
with the B. F. Sturtevant Co., of Hyde
Park, Mass., resigning a position in the
United States Inspection Office, with
the Wm. R. Tigg Co., of Richmond,
Va. Mr. Burlingham has previously been
associated with the Bath Iron Works, the
General Electric Co., the Southwark Ma-
chine & Foundry Co., and the Newport
News Ship-Building & Dry-Dock Co. He
has also served on Mr. T. A. Edison's
staff at the East Orange laboratory, and
is a graduate of the Worcester Polytech-
nic Institute.
Mr. Wm. Downie, heretofore superin-
tendent on the Canadian Pacific Railway
at Nelson, B. C, has been appointed gen-
eral superintendent of the Atlantic divis-
ion of the same road, with headquarters
at St. John, N. B., vice Mr. J. Oborne, •
transferred. Mr. Downie is a native of
Rock Currie, Ireland. He entered railway
service in Canada in 1869 and was em-
ployed in the telegraph department of the
Northern Railway of Canada. He held
various positions of importance, and when
the C. P. R. opened their transcontinental
line in 1886 Mr. Downie was appointed
assistant superintendent of the Pacific
division. He subsequently became super-
intendent of the same division, and later
on was appointed superintendent C. P. R.
lines and steamers in the Kootenay dis-
trict, B. C. His many friends wish him
every success in his new and enlarged field
of labor.
Mr. W. Lavery has resigned his position
as assistant superintendent of motive
power on the Erie, to accept the posilion
of general superintendent of the Railway
Steel Springs Company, at Oswego, N. Y.
Mr. Lavery has seen a good deal of active
railroad service, being at various times
master mechanic on the New York, Penn-
sylv.-inia & Ohio, at Gallion, O. : master
mechanic on the New York, Lake Erie &
Western Railway, at Mcadville, Pa., and
also at Susquehanna, Pa. ; later assistant
superintendent of motive power on the
same road. When the Erie took over the
N. Y., L. E. & W. Mr. Lavery went with
the road, and was subsequently assistant
superintendent of motive power for lines
east of Salamanca on the Erie. He has
long enjoyed the reputation of being an
exceptionally good shop 'manager.
Mr. F. D. Casanave has resigned from
the position of general superintendent
of motive power of the Baltimore &
Ohio, to accept the posi.tion of assist-
ant to Mr. Theo. N. Ely, chief of mo-
tive power of the Pennsylvania Rail-
road. He had been connected with the
Pennsylvania Railroad since 1862, at
which time he began as an apprentice in
the Altoona shops of that company.
After holding various responsible posi-
tions and doing special work in the mo-
tive power department, he was, in 1876,
made assistant master mechanic at Al-
toona. In 1881 he took charge of the
Pennsylvania Company's shops at Fort
Wayne, Ind. In 1887 he was promoted
to the position of superintendent of mo-
tive power of the Northwest system of
the Pennsylvania lines west of Pittsburg,
and in 1893 he became general superin-
tendent of the Pennsylvania Railroad.
Subsequently he was appointed to the
position which he has just relinquished.
Mr. Casanave was one of the pioneers in
adapting piece work prices to new and
repair work in railroad shops, and is one
of the ablest motive power men in the
country.
"The Westinghousc Company's pub-
lishing department, Pittsburg, Pa., has
just issued a neat little pamphlet of their
industrial series, "Electricity in Mining."
The first few pages are devoted to the
consideration of the economy which fol-
lows'from the use of electrical power in
the various operations which have to be
performed in the work of mining. Good
half-tones are used to illustrate the nec-
essary power plant, the generators, the
motors, the controller and the Baldwin-
Westinghouse electric mining locomo-
tive. The matter of haulage is next
taken up, explained and illustrated.
Hoisting is touched on and the requisite
machinery and equipment is illustrated.
Pumps and air compressors form tJie
subject of the next section, illustrated
as are the others. Fans and blowers
follow, with paragraphs on drills and
coal cutters, lighting, and machine shop
tools, etc. Some observations on
placer mining and the way in which elec-
trical power may be employed closes the
pamphlet.
The Westinghouse Electric and Manu-
facturing Company, of Pittsburg, Pa.,
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
329
will be very happy to forward this inter-
esting little publication free to anyone
who will drop them a line asking to
have it forwarded. A postal card will do
the business.
The Gold Car Heating and Lighting
Company has brought a suit in the
United States Circuit Court,' Northern
District of Illinois, at Chicago, against
Egbert H. Gold, for infringement of
United States Letters Patent No. 388,772
for car heating apparatus.
European Notes.
It is abundantly clear that limits have
not yet been placed to the provision of
greater locomotive power for express
traffic in Britain. We have witnessed
some startling developments in this di-
rection during the past few years on most
of the British trunk lines, culminating in
Mr. Mcintosh's large locomotive refer-
red to in a previous number. There is
or "Prairie" arrangement, now in com-
mon use in several British colonies. If
such is to be the case, we shall doubt-
less soon witness a further step to the
4-6-2, or "Prairie" with leading bogie,
and, it may be, to 4-6-4, that is, six-
coupled engines with leading and trailing
bogies.
Mr. Churchward has just turned out
his first express engine. This is a 4-6-0
type, different in several respects from
the No. 100 class built last year by Mr.
Churchward's predecessor, Mr. Dean.
TJie cylinders are 18 inches by 30 inches
stroke, placed outside and provided with
piston valves. The boiler barrel is 14
ft. 10 ins. long and is coned or tapered
for nearly half its length. The heating
surface provided measures 2,143 sq. ft.
and the fire grate area 27.22 sq. ft. The
six-coupled wheels are 80}^ ins. and
the bogie wheels 38 ins. in diameter.
An interesting feature is that brake shoes
are supplied to the bogie wheels as well
as to each of the coupled wheels. The
tank engines for that line which are be-
ing built by the Vulcan Foundry Com-
pany, of Newton-Ie-Willows, Lancashier.
The general appearance of these locomo-
tives can be gathered from the photo-
graph. The driving wheels are 67 in.
diameter, cylinders 18 in.x26 in., total
wheel base 29 ft. loj'i in. total heating
.surface 1,143 sq. ft., grate area 19.85 sq.
it., total working weight 142,000 lbs.
Some powerful express engines are be-
ing turned out of the North British Rail-
way shops at Cowlairs, designed to cope
with the constantly increasing loads to
be hauled at high speeds over exception-
ally difficult sections.
It is stated that the de Glehn compound
(4-4-2 type) now being built at Belfort,
by the Societe Alsacienne de Construc-
tions Mecaniques, for the Paris-Orleans
Railway, will weigh at least 164,000 lbs.
in working order exclusive of the ten-
der, or 18,000 lbs. more than the Nord
engines of a similar type.
Excellent work is being done on the
POWERFUL TEN-WHEEL PASSENGER ENGINE ON THE CALEDONIAN RAILWAY.
reason to believe, however, that the Cale-
donian engine will hold record for a very
short time, as rumor has it that the
latest North-Eastern express locomotive
will be of surpassing dimensions. Little
information is forthcoming at present
with regard to the engine, but it has been
stated that it is to be a four cylinder
compound on the du Bousquet-de Glehn
lines, with two is-inch high pressure and
two 2S-inch low pressure cylinders. Such
figures as these are sufficient to indicate
that the provision for steam generation
must be far greater than anything yet
seen in Great Britain. Indeed, it is said
that the boiler will so approximate to the
lines of the loading gauge as to leave no
room for any visible cliimney, steam
dome or safety valves. In view of the
prevailing diversity of practice one point
of interesting speculation is the number,
size and disposition of wheels. There ap-
pears at present a prepossession in
Europe for the 4-4-2 or "Atlantic" type,
but some recent remarks of Mr. G. J.
Churchward, of the Great Western Rail-
way, would seem to point to the possible
adoption in the near future of the 2-6-2
working pressure is 200 lbs. and the
tractive force 21,734. In full order the en-
gine and tender weigh 249.760 lbs., of
which 116,480 lbs. are available for ad-
hesion.
Another interesting type of locomotive
just put into running is a six-coupled,
four-cylinder compound goods engine
with a four-wheeled leading radial truck,
designed by Mr. Webb for fast goods
traffic on the main lines of the London
and North-Western. These engines have
60 in. coupled wheels, two H. P. cylin-
ders 15x24 and two l L. P. 20''<x24. heat-
ing surface 1,753 sq. ft., grate area 20^
sq. ft., total weight in full order with
tender, 205,000 lbs. They are a decided
advance on the 51 in. eight-coupled, iour-
cylinder compound goods engine so ex-
tensively employed on this road, and Mr.
Webb is to be congratulated on what
may prove to be his last great work for
the company.
Mr. J. G. Robinson, the able and en-
terprising Chief Mechanical Engineer,
who has done so much to bring the stock
of the Great Central up to modern re-
quirements, has designed a new class of
Adriatic lines of Italy by the Borsig six-
coupled compound engines which run
with the firebox in front. Loads of 400
(long) tons are hauled with ease at 45
miles per hour upon roads constructed
of light rails, with grades of i in 83 and
a plentiful supply of sharp curves. On
a recent occasion with a net load of 380
(long) tons a speed of 43 miles per hour
was attained in three minutes. The ad-
mission to the cylinders was full in start-
ing and reduced to 15% off after a few
revolutions, which was then maintained
throughout with regulator three-eighths
to half open. A speed of 56 miles per
hour was attained without effort on level
stretches. The facility of starting
possessed by these engines is very re-
markable.
Mr. Borsig (Berlin) has secured an or-
der from the Portuguese State Railways
for some six-coupled, four-cylinder com-
pound locomotives for the 5 ft. 6 ins.
gauge, which are to be in running at the
fall of the year.
In the Spanish portion of the Penin-
sula, the Vasco-Castellana Company is
doubling its line from Bilbao to Burgos,
330
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
125 miles. The line will be continued
from the latter point to Madrid, which
will shorten the journey between Bilbao
and the capital by 90 miles in distance
and eight hours in time. A contract for
eight locomotives has been secured by a
German firm. According to a recently
published report of the British Consul at
Bilbao, the locomotive engineers of two
lines in Northern Spain have pronounced
against American-built engines, stating
that their fuel consumption is greater
and their handling power less than that
of British locomotives. In this connec-
tion it is interesting to note that for what
is probably the first time on record an
American line is purchasing engines from
Europe. The Saxon Locomotive Works,
Chemnitz, Germany, has in hand for the
Canadian Pacific twenty two-cylinder
compounds for passenger service, type
4-6-0, the total working weight of which
locomotives, and the latter for two of
heavier design. Particularly smart work
marked the execution of the orders,
Messrs. Kerr, Stuart and Co. being es-
pecially prominent in this direction.
Their engines weigh 67,500 lbs. each and
exert a tractive force of 18,700 lbs. when
cutting off at }i stroke. The contract
for the steel hopper cars for this line
went to the Pressed Steel Car Co., Pitts-
burg.
With reference to the all-absorbing
topic of electricity versus steam for trac-
tive purposes, the British House of Com-
mons Committee which had under consid-
eration the part-tube-part-surface scheme
of, electric traction in the east of London
known as the City and North East Su-
burban, after a somewhat protracted
hearing, rejected the proposal on finan-
cial grounds, much to the satisfaction of
the Great Eastern Company, whose en-
I^^H 1^ Si
FOUR-CYLINDER COMPOUND — DU
will reach 330,000 lbs., inclusive of tender.
Some very powerful six-coupled tank
locomotives with radial axles fore and aft
have recently been supplied to the Berlin
Metropolitan Railway by the Berlin
Locomotive Works. These are of the
2-6-2 class and have three H. P. cylinders
— two placed outside the frames driving
the second coupled axle and one inside
the frames driving the leading coupled
axle. The coupled wheels are 59 ins.
diameter and the wheel base 29 ft. 6^
ins. To supply live steam to three cylin-
ders I9j4"x24f^", a total heating surface
of 1,667 sq. ft. is provided, which would
seem to be but moderate provision for
the purpose. With about 16,000 lbs. of
water and 5,600 lbs, of coal the engine
weighs 175,000 lbs.
About ten miles south of the Arctic
circle, from the harbor of Moigranen on
the Ranen Fjord, Norway, for 17 miles
up the Dunderland River runs the 4 ft.
8^ in. gauge railway of the Dunderland
Iron Company, now nearing completion.
Orders were placed last year for the
necessary locomotive power for this high
latitude line, the contract being divided
between Messrs. Robert Stephenson and
Co., of Darlington, and Messrs. Kerr,
Stuart and Co., of Stoke-on-Trent, the
former securing an order for two light
BOUSQUET-DE GLEHN TYPE.
ornious ten-coupled experimental tank
engine has on further trials more than
justified anticipations. One result of this
fizzle-out of an electric scheme is cer-
tain to be that the financial considera-
tions will be gone into by the commit-
tees first of all. Meanwhile the almost
hopeless imbroglio of schemes to im-
prove the conditions of London traffic
awaits the findings of the Royal Com-
mission on the subject.
Scarcely one of the British railways
has escaped the "electric flood" which in
many directions threatens destruction of
their short distance traffic. By skilful
amalgamating or co-operating arrange-
ments some of the electric tramways now
in existence, such as those in South
Lancashire, the Potteries, the Newcastle
district and West Yorkshire, have at-
tained to the dignity of inter-urban sys-
tems and there is now no doubt in the
minds of railway officials that the danger
is real. Among the various schemes
for meeting the competition, one which
is daily gaining ground is the provision
of steam "units" in the shape of steam
carriages, a revival of early railway prac-
tice, as will be seen by the photograph.
The London and South Western has late-
ly placed such a car on a section of its
system, and other lines such as the
Great Western, Great Eastern and Lon-
don, Brighton and South Coast have
either already moved in the same direc-
tion or have the matter under considera-
tion. Others, more bold, are using elec-
tricity against electricity. Most interest-
ing and startling developments may with
confidence be expected. As a contribu-
tion to the prevailing fever, some en-
thusiasts are calling on the railways not
only to use road motor vans for the col-
lection and delivery of goods, but to give
passengers the same facilities for reach-
ing and leaving the railway stations.
The severity of electric competition is
also being felt by steam lines in Scotland,
France, Italy, Germany and .\ustria. In
the latter country, Herr Goldsdorf of
the Austrian State Railways has decided
to put into competition with the steam,
electric or petrol motor cars which it
is proposed to introduce on some of the
branch lines, the exceedingly interesting
little locomotive of which we give a
photograph. This is a two-cylinder com-
pound using oil fuel on Holden's patent
system. It weighs 33.600 lbs. and is capa-
ble of hauling two cars, weighing 22
long tons, up a grade of i in 200 at a
speed of 40 miles an hour or a load of
45 long tons, up ,1 in 100 at 16 miles an
hour. The results of working are said
to be very encouraging, and the experi-
ment is being watched with considerable
interest, the use of heavy fuel oil for
steam generation on a service of the kind
being distinctly novel.
Meeting of Safety Car= Heating and
Lighting Co.
A meeting of the board of directors of
the S. C. H. & L. Co. was held at that
company's New York office on June lO
and the following officers were elected for
the ensuing year : Robert Andrews, presi-
dent ; R. M. Dixon, vice-president ; D. W.
Pye, 2d vice-president ; C. H. Wardwell,
secretary and treasurer; I. P. Lawton, as-
sistant secretary and treasurer. At the
same meeting the regular quarterly divi-
dend of 2% and an extra dividend of
1% were declared. This dividend will be
payable July i.
The annual report of the company
showed that the past year had been a
most prosperous one, both in the lighting
and heating departments and the prospect
for the coming year is a particularly
bright one. Further facilities for the sup-
ply of Pintsch gas are being provided for
by the erection of new manufacturing
plants at Philadelphia, Harrisburg, Al-
toona, Columbus, and the capacities of
many existing plants are being increased,
notably Jersey City, Pittsburg, Kansas
City. Washington, Atlanta, So. Louis and
Mott Haven, at the four latter named
points the old works being abandoned and
entirely new works being constructed.
The steam heating business of the
Safety Co. has shown a gratifying in-,
crease.
July, ir)03.
RAIf.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
331
On the Santa Fe Trail.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
It has been my good fortune to ride
over vast stretches of country in differ-
ent parts of the world, and a long jour-
ney gives a striking impression of tlie
eartli's magnitude, but I have never trav-
eled on an unbroken journey which made
such vivid impression of the vastness
of the world we live in, as the ride of
1,570 miles from Buflalo to La Junta,
Colorado. Almost the whole stretch is
through a flat or rolling country, with
no forests, and the traveler seems all the
time to be looking into illimitable space.
I have traveled as far through Germany
and Russia over flat wastes which were
wooded to a great extent. There the
impression given was how much desola-
tion there is on the earth's surface. The
trip to Colorado conveyed no idea of
that kind, for there are always in sight
evidences of man's industry, thrift and
energy in home making, the proofs that .
all over that vast region human labor has
within a few years converted wilder-
nesses into fruitful farms.
The journey from Chicago to the foot-
hills of the Colorado mountains is not one
which a searcher after scenic attractions
is likely to select, but it has its own good
points which are numerous and substan-
tial. To start out with we follow for
about thirty miles the course of the Chi-
cago drainage canal, a huge undertaking.
The canal, a rather unsavory stream
which can be felt without being seen,
diverts a good sized river from flowing
into Lake Michigan, and carries its water
along with the odorous sewage of Chi-
cago through the natural watershed to
the Mississippi slope. The thriving city
of Joliet commands some attention, with
its increasing manufactures and pros-
perous penitentiary, where many Chicago
criminals, high and low, find homes re-
moved from temptation and where many
others ought to be sheltered.
If our people had any regard for
names that would be cherished in other
countries, the doings of Louis Joliet.
after whom the town was named, who
first explored the Mississippi Valley,
would be a household story. The State
of Illinois has honored several of the
early French explorers by naming places
after them, but nothing is done to make
school children familiar with the deeds of
Joilet, Marquette, La Salle and others.
The train spins merrily along through
an ideal farming country that looks as
if it might be the granary of the land,
as Egypt used to be for the ancient
world. This was an ideal region for
railroad building and for railroad oper-
ating. No great excavations needed to
pierce hills and bluffs, no expensive em-
bankments to make level track through
guUeys and earth depressions. Enough
earth scraped up from the deep black
loam to keep the roadbed above water
was generally all tliat was necessary. It
is hard to understand for what purpose
the demand for very heavy locomotives
arose to pull trains in this part of the
country, since a good mogul or ten-wheel
engine could haul all (he cars that could
be comfortably kept together.
The number of thriving towns and vil-
lages passed is surprising for an agricul-
tural country, but beneath some of these
prairies and corn-covered ridges are rich
deposits of bituminous coal, which al-
ways stimulate manufactures by provid
ing cheap power.
Several persons in our car have never
seen the Mississippi River, and long be-
fore we reach its banks we hear repeated
inquiries about when the Father of
Waters will be seen. It is wonderful
how keenly most people are to see for
the first time a great river, and more
especially the Mississippi, and how uni-
formly they are disappointed with the
sight. The only rivers that I have seen
which were not disappointments, were
the Niagara River, between Buffalo and
A considerable part of the passengers
in our car are on their way to California
for the first time, and are out for all
they can see. Acquaintanceship has
spread from seat to seat, and by the time
the Mississippi was reached some of the
women were able to tell something about
everybody in the car, where they came
from and whence they were bound. Be-
fore the journey was over the society of
our little world had differentiated itself
into separate social elements, which rep-
resented the high, the middle and the low
grades of its society. At first our society
was elemental and democratic, with no
one making pretensions over the others.
That lasted throughout the first day and
reminded me of the relations that existed
between Caesar and Luath in Burns'
Twa Dogs, who were
* * * "fain o' ither,
And unco pack and thick thegither."
General interest was manifested in the
coming sight of the Mississippi river, and
I reached the height of my popularity
during the journey by being able to tell
WEBU FOUR-CVUNUER COMPOUND GOODS ENIUNE.
the Falls, and the Danube, at Vienna.
The first time I saw the Mississippi was
at Quincy, in the late fall, when the water
was very low, and I felt not only disap-
pointed, but indignant that it did not ex-
pand a little to meet my expectations.
On this trip the waters were more in
evidence and expressions of delight were
heard as we crossed the fine eight-span
bridge that lands us at Fort Madison, in
Iowa. At this place we get a glimpse of
the northern repair shops of the Santa
Fe, which were a model establishment
seven or eight years ago. They have
been extended considerably since that
time, and I believe are operated no less
efficiently than they were when Mr.
Thomas Paxton was in charge.
The corner of Iowa crossed is a coun-
try with more uplands and more trees
than we found in Illinois, and railroad
builders found something more to do in
forming a fairly straight and level road-
bed. The indications of industry and
thrift, however, continue, and we see no
perceptible difference when we cross the
line into discredited Missouri.
what was coming. My memory was at
fault, however, and I told that we came
suddenly upon the river through an
opening in the bluffs and crossed it on
a high bridge nearly a mile long and 150
feet high. When we ran through the
rough, hill-bound valley at times in sight
of the river for more than an hour be-
fore crossing, my short-lived popularity
died and I could not help feeling that
several of the people regarded me as a
fraud throughout the rest of the journey.
The Missouri River's surroundings are
decidedly picturesque when first intro-
duced to the Santa Fe traveler, although
it still deserves Bob Burdette's descrip-
tion of being "the most dusty stream in
creation."
The party in our car had Christian En-
deavor proclivities, and as we approached
Kansas City they expressed their inten-
tion of going out of the train as soon as
it stopped, to put their feet upon the
sacred soil of what had been Bleeding
Kansas. The ground outside the station
was muddy, but several women stepped
bravely in. They looked resentful when I
332
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July. 1903.
mentioned after we had started that they
had anointed their brogans with Missouri
mud. When travel is left to teach us
geography, the refinements of exact
boundaries are frequently overlooked.
It is a wonder to me that writers of
fiction have failed to make Kansas City
and its surroundings the theater of some
stirring romance. Perhaps a truthful
tale of what happened in this bluff
perched city and the country round
about, makes romance enough without
any help from the imagination.
Leaving the great city, a veritable me-
tropolis of 225,000 inhabitants, with its
stock yards and packing houses and
other vast magazines storing the fruits of
the soil, we steam away through a highly
diversified landscape along the valley of
the Kansas River for many miles. No
wonder that there was hard fighting for
the possession of this country, and no
wonder that the aboriginal inhabitants
clung to it tenaciously and moved back-
wards with hate in their bosoms.
The Santa Fe trail now leads us
through very different scenes from what
were witnesed when courageous men
took their lives in their hands and braved
terrible dangers and endured untold hard-
ships to act as the missionaries of com-
merce. All along the trail have sprung
up prosperous towns and villages stirring
with industrial activities, where a great
and growing population is regeneratmg
human shortcomings by applying the
gospel of labor to their lives. Kansas
air is dancing with hysteria, but its peo-
ple neutralize levity by hard work.
We gaze with interest upon the thriv-
ing city of Lawrence, whose youth suf-
fered and bled, while bearing the brunt
of the conflict which made Kansas a free
State. In passing we get a glimpse of
Lecompton. the first capital of the terri-
tory, where Border RufHans long held
sway and Free Soilers strove for control.
Soon comes the fine city of Topeka. the
capital of the State, and of special inter-
est to railway people as being the me-
chanical headquarters of the Santa Fe
system. Here Mr. George R. Hender-
son, superintendent of motive power ot
the company, holds sway over an indus-
trial community that makes a town in it-
self.
As we advance into the State we recall
the eloquent words of Senator Charles
Sumner uttered during the conflict
against imposing slavery upon the terri-
tory. "Take down your map," he ex-
claimed, "and you will find that the Ter-
ritory of Kansas, more than any other
region, occupies the middle spot of
North .America, equally distant from the
Atlantic on the east, and the Pacific on
the west, from the frozen waters of the
Hudson Bay on the north, and the tepid
Gulf Stream on the south, constituting
the precise territorial center of the whole
vast continent. To such advantages of
situation, on the very highway between
two oceans, are added a soil of unsur-
passed richness, and a fascinating, undu-
lating beauty of surface, with a health-
giving climate calculated to nurture a
powerful and generous people worthy to
be a central pivot of American institu-
tions."
We have been for hours traversing fer-
tile plains that geology tells were once
the bed of an inland sea. Its leavings
are more potent than Byron's "red rain
that made the harvest grow." But the
surfaces of these grcep plains are not the
only source of riches that give energy to
the thriving towns by the wayside. There
are rich coal measures and free yielding
salt mines in various parts, the flourish-
ing town of Hutchinson thriving on salt
industries.
For a long time the trail follows the
Arkansas River, whose bed was well
filled with water. In dry seasons this
stream disappears for many miles, leav-
ing beds of sand and £ravel to disappoint
the thirsty traveler.
Although the general appearance of
the country is level, there are ridges of
considerable height to be surmounted at
times, and in going westward there is a
steady rise toward the Rocky Mountains,
It is not surprising then that the loco-
motive in front of the train is frequently
heard to be toiling hard and the train
moving along quite deliberately.
When I first went through on this line
engines were smaller than they are to-
day, and the trains moved rather slowly
up the grades. There were many cowboys
in the western countries and their free
and easy ways were amusing to the pas-
sengers. They used to ride alongside of
the track and hold a running conversa-
tion with the inmates of the cars. The
story was told of a cowboy named Tom
Hyde who had become notorious for the
freedoms he took with the passengers.
One day Tom rode alongside making
love to the ladies at the windows and
chaffing the men. As they approached
the top of the grade Tom began saying
his adieux, when a gentleman at an open
window asked the cowboy to shake. Tom
was only too willing, and found his hand
grasped as in a vise. Tom wanted to
quit, but the passenger kept his hold,
saying pleasant things about his admira-
tion for cowboys. The top of the grade
was passed and the train soon began
gaining speed. Presently it was too
rapid for the cowboy's broncho and Tom
was dragged from its back and was held
dangling on the side of the car like a
polecat nailed to a barn door. The pas-
senger with the iron grip watched his
chance, and when the train was passing
a muddy water hole the cowboy was
dropped in, amidst the shouts of his
friends, who rode up in time to prevent
him from perishing in the mud.
After a short delay at La Junta, our
part of the train turns south toward the
mountains, and the other part keeps on
toward Denver. The mountains p.re now
moving out of the horizon and our
friends are all on the qui vive to miss
none of the sights.
At the Altoona shops there are 21 vesti-
buled passenger coaches, and nine 60-foot
baggage and express cars being built. In
the Allegheny shops there are eight bag-
gage and express cars under construction.
Fifteen new cars for the northwest sys-
tem are also being built at the Columbus
shops as follows : Four 70-foot combina-
tion coach and baggage, four 60-foot pos-
tal, three horse express cars and four bag-
gage cars. This equipment is additional
to a large order for passenger coaches re-
cently placed with the Pullman company
which will likely be ready for delivery
within a few months. The new equip-
ment will afford the lines west, ample fa-
cilities for handling the gradually-increas-
ing business.
Locomotives propelled by electricity
drawn from the air without cost, and
ocean liners racing over the sea by the
agency of the electric current drawn in-
expensively from the same source, are
promised for the near future by Tesla. It
is to be done on the principle of wireless
telegraphy. Tesla is very much of a
visionary, but he has done great feats,
and if he succeeds in making power out
of nothing, so to speak, the world will
reap the benefit.
The announcement is made that the
Columbus, London & Springfield road
will soon introduce a new feature in
electric railroading. It received an elec-
tric locomotive some time in May, to
be used for all kinds of heavy hauling.
It will probably be placed into service
in assisting the motor cars in handling
heavy trains of excursionists.
Certain independent coal operators in
West Virginia are suing the West Vir-
ginia & Northern for about $90,000
damages on account of the railroad com-
pany not supplying them with the
proper share of cars for the shipment of
coal.
The Kennicott Water Softener Com-
pany have secured the services of Prof.
Bruce, who was formerly connected with
the University of Chicago. He will have
full charge of the laboratories of the
company.
We never know wot's hidden in each
other's hearts ; and if we had glass
winders there, we'd need to keep the
shutters up, some on us, I do assure you.
— Mrs. Gamp.
Human judgment is never infallible.
• — Sketches by Boz.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
333
The Suburban Car Seating Problem,
There is not much likeliliuod of any
change in the seating arrangement of
the ordinary steam railroad coach, but
the future will very probably see con-
siderable alteration not only in the seat-
ing capacity, but also the door arrange-
ment of the suburban car. A typical ex-
ample of the suburban car which wastes
space and is not convenient for passen-
gers may be seen on the Manhattan Ele-
vated Railroad in New York, where seats
are arranged along the sides of the car
with four "square pews" in the center.
These cars have end doors, many of
them swinging, and the car seats 48
persons. The suburban cars on the
Illinois Central have side seats and six
"square pews" in the center of the car,
and hold 56 people. This latter road,
however, is working on plans for the in-
troduction of suburban cars in which
the full floor space will be used for seats
with the exception of that used as a nar-
row aisle. Four plans of seat arrange-
ment have been thought of, and in these
cars side doors will be a prominent fea-
ture.
The first plan has rows of seats ar-
ranged back to back across the floor of
the car with a narrow aisle down one
side, and side doors on the aisle-side of
the car, opposite the passageway between
the seats. Such cars are suitable for
roads with terminal loops and station
platforms outside the tracks. This style
of car would seat 120 persons.
The second plan is similar to the first
and holds as many people, but has side
doors at both sides of the car. This ar-
rangement is suitable to roads without
terminal loops, as passengers can enter
or leave the car from either side.
The third plan provides for the seating
of 115 passengers, and is a modification
of the ideas embodied in each of the
preceding plans. The aisle runs up one
side to the center of the car with side
doors only along the aisle. A cross-over
passage in the middle of the car connects
with the aisle and doors down the other
side. A Joss of five seats is necessary,
owing to the introduction of the -cross-
over passage. This car would be suit-
able for constant traffic of moderate
volume in wrhich people enter and leave
from both sides.
The fourth plan is drawn with two side
aisles and side doors along each side,
seats being arranged across the car floor
as in the other plans; g6 persons can be
accom.modated. This plan is intended
to deal with rush-hour tratiic, which is
very heavy and where a train has fre-
quent stops.
The salient features of all these plans,
any of which is vastly superior to exist-
ing suburban car arrangements, are that
more people can be comfortably accom-
modated—given, except in extreme cases,
what they pay for— seats. The time re-
quired for the filling and emptying of
such cars is Krcally reduced, probably to
ten seconds, by reason of the sliding
side doors, there being one door for
every ten persons. A long car will not
take more time to empty and fill than
a short one will. Persons can enter by
any door and find a seat anywhere in the
car after it has started, by reason of the
aisle arrangement. The liability to ac-
cident is reduced by reason of the fact
that the side doors slide on rollers and
are operated by compressed air, so that
ihey are not opened until the car is fully
stopped and are all shut and latched
before the train starts. There being no
footboards along the sides and no hand-
grabs, there is no means by which a be-
lated traveler can hang on outside.
During rush hours, when standing
room is precious, the proposed cars pre-
sent great advantages. As the move-
on and oflF. The conceptions involved in
modern cars such as we have described,
when put into wood and metal and oper-
ated through the suburbs of the Windy
City will contrast very sharply with the
laissez faire policy which permits new
cars seating 48 to 56 persons to be built
and introduced on modern crowded ur-
ban lines, with all their old fogy, discom-
fort and delay-producing features.
Steam Qauge Service Test Apparatus.
I he Utica Steam Gauge Company, of
New York, have recently placed on the
market a service test apparatus which
is intended to enable a man to test loco-
motive and other steam gauges without
taking them off the boiler. The appara-
tus, however, requires a special connec-
tion of gauge to boiler which only dif-
fers from the standard connection in that
Servicf T?s1 Apparatus
r
n
UTICA STEAM GAUGE C2
. AG Wood.
^€3
.a
^^tl'
GAUGE SERVICE TEST APPARATUS FOR LOCOMOTIVES.
ment of passengers getting on and ofJ
is across the car floor, the space in the
main aisle between seats is available for
standing without blocking the in and out
movement, and even if this movement is
interfered with it can only be impeded
by two or three people who can easily
step temporarily out of the car and so
clear the way. The ends which form the
passage to the vestibules can also ac-
commodate several "standers." The
people who are thus compelled to stand
have the seat backs to grasp, and are
not huddled together in an almost im-
penetrable, swaying mass, holding on to
loose straps.
These plans show an intelligent effort
to grapple with pressing transportation
problems and to increase the safety,
ease and facility of suburban travel, and
at the same time they greatly increase
the legitimate earning power of each car.
They reduce time at stations and put
most of what time there is occupied on
the trip into carrying people, and not in
compelling them to use more time than
they wish to use in fighting their way
it has a threaded flange to which the
testing machine may be attached, and
this flange is covered with a cap nut
under ordinary circumstances.
When it is desired to test a locomo-
tive gauge the procedure is as follows:
Close the cock F, remove the cap
nut D and place the end of the ap-
paratus G on the connection E, fasten-
ing it in place by means of the union
nut H. Open the cock I and the
cock J and push in the plunger K
until an initial pressure is established on
the test gauge L of say 20 pounds or
any desired pressure. This introduces
enough liquid into the test barrel to con-
tinue the work. Then close the cock
J and operate the screw plunger M
as with any ordinary test pump, exerting
any required pressure upon the test
gauge L and the same pressure being
also exerted on the gauge being tested.
When the test has been completed to as
high a pressure as desired, open the
cock J slowly and the pressure which
is then on the apparatus is ex-
erted against the piston N, which pis-
334
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
ton is provided with a small by-pass in
order to form a cushion so that the
plunger K will retract moderately and
not return with a sudden thump. Now
close the cock I and disconnect the
apparatus, replace the cap nut D and
open the cock F slowly, admitting the
boiler pressure to the gauge, and it is
again in service.
When it is desired to make a quick test
for running pressure when time is lim-
ited, attach the apparatus as above de-
scribed, slowly open the cock F and
slowly open the cock I, allowing the
boiler pressure to be exerted carefully
on the entire apparatus. If the gauge
in service agrees with the test gauge
L it is certainly correct for the run-
ning pressure. Close cocks F and I
and disconnect. The apparatus has been
patented by Mr. A. G. Wood.
When Railroad Companiesl Provided
Trainmen with Watches.
Railroad companies have always been
strict about engineers and conductors
carrying good watches, but in early days
of train operating the employers took the
responsibility of supplying good, reliable
watches to the men. In the British Isles
the guard or conductor used to be pro-
vided with a big watch which was secured
in a leather case and strapped around the
holder's neck.
When the Camden & Amboy was first
operated the engineers and conductors
were provided with watches by the com-
pany. If an engine broke down and the
train was taken by another engine, the
engineers exchanged watches. When an
engine was ordered to go out the en-
gineer went to the dispatcher's office and
turned in his watch and received another
set by the standard time clock. But
those days when the companies took the
responsibility of having their trainmen
keep correct time are gone never to re-
turn.
A. Leschen & Sons' Rope Company,
of 920 North First street, St. Louis, Mo.,
have recently issued an illustrated cata-
logue which gives a good deal of in-
formation about wire ropes in general
and shows exactly what the patent flat-
tened strand wire ropes are, which are
a specialty of this company. The flat-
tened strand rope is said to be free from
all tendency to spin or kink, and a sav-
ing in the wear of pulleys and sheaves is
eflfected by the smooth surface of the
rope. The company also make all kinds
of cables, sash cord, galvanized steel
hawsers, rope hooks and couplings, sus-
pension bridge cables, switch ropes for
railways, rope sockets, thimbles, guy
shackles, rope clamps, turnbuckles, chain,
steel or malleable blocks, snatch blocks,
sheaves, wire ferry travelers, tackle
blocks, etc., etc. There is a table of
transmission of power by wire ropes and
some observations on wire rope trans-
mission. Directions for making splices
are given with diagram and the neces-
sary tools are enumerated. Send to the
Leschen Company if you would like a
copy of the catalogue.
A Handy Rig.
A handy rig for assisting the busy car
repairer or round-house man when jack-
ing up an axle box to take out a brass is
here described. It consists of nothing
more than a piece of heavy flat iron, say
J4x4 in., cut to a convenient length and
lipped up at one end so as to rest on the
rim of a wheel as shown in the illustra-
tion. The long flat portion of the iron
bar is laid upon the blocking and sup-
ports the jack.
When pressure is applied to the un-
derside of the axle box by working the
Haitway }■ LuCuumtitt Ensjiiutcnng
HANDY SHOP APPLIANCE).
jack the wheel is practically clamped
down by the jack and the flat iron and
the box has only to be raised far enough
to free the wedge, and the brass may be
easily removed.
In every-day life, where some such
appliance is not used, when the weight
is taken from the journal, the wheel rises
up ofif the rail owing to the weight of the
car resting on the journal at the other
end of the axle and usually the wheel has
to be held down by a helper who often
does a sort of fantastic teeter-tauter act
at the end of a long wooden lever or a
pit plank before the wedge drops below
the lugs in the box roof. Time and
labor may be saved by the use of this
handy little jack attachment, and the
helper can be otherwise employed or at
least can preserve his personal dignity
during the operation, and that may be
worth something at a crowded passenger
station when working against time with
a hot box, amid highly interested on-
lookers.
Within the Suburban Limits.
The Central Railroad of New Jersey
has issued a very interesting pamphlet
called "Within the Suburban Limits,"
made up of about 45 pages. It is beau-
tifully printed and is illustrated with
numerous excellent half-tones. Com-
plete information is given about the
train service together with the regular
single fare, the e.xcursion rate, the family
ticket and the monthly individual or com-
mutation ticket. Among others the
pleasant and picturesque residential
towns which come in for special mention
are Greenville, Bayonne, Elizabeth,
Roselle, Aldene, Cranford, Garwood,
Westfield, with its golf links and its de-
lightful club house. Caldwell in his his-
toric sketch of this section of country
says, "Western towns often begin with
a saloon — Westfield began with a church,
and the history of Westfield is closely al-
lied with the history of her churches."
Fanwood and Scotch Plains are 2154
miles from New York; Plainfield lies a
few miles further on, followed by Dunel-
len, Lincoln and Bound Brook and
Somerville. Diverging from Communi-
paw the Newark branch runs through
Pacific, Arlington, Jackson and West
Side avenues. Each is a residential sub-
urb of Jersey City. Newark lies 8V^
miles from the metropolis.
In order to reach points on the Perth
Amboy branch the main line is left at
Elizabethport, a town I7J4 miles from
New York, where the large locomotive
and car repair shops of the company are
situated. On this branch lie Sewaren,
Maurer, Perth Amboy and South Am-
boy on the Arthur Kill, which separates
Staten Island from the Jersey shore.
Mr. C. M. Burt, general passenger
agent of the Jersey Central, will be
happy to send this pamphlet to anyone
who applies to him for a copy.
The catalogue of the Walworth Manu-
facturing Company, of 132 Federal street,
Boston, shows the various types of Wal-
worth injectors for locomotive use, in
both the lifting and the non-lifting va-
riety. The number of the injector, the
sizes of connections, the capacity in gal-
lons per hour, and the price of each is
given. Sectional cuts show the parts,
which are also numbered and tabulated
below for ordering. The Walworth
check valves are also illustrated and cat-
alogued. The last few pages describe the
Dodge automatic injectors. The Wal-
worth Company also make Stilson pipe
wrenches. Hall's brass pipe wrench, Stan-
wood pipe cutter, the "RufI and TufT"
dies, pipe taps and reamers. Smith fric-
tion drills, "Neverstick" blow-off valves
and cast and malleable fittings and brass
goods for steam, water, gas and oil.
Write them for the catalogue if you are
interested.
July. 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
335
Block Signaling; Applied to Turn
Tables.
A very clever adaptation of the block
signal idea lias recently been put into
effective operation on the turn taljle at
the Jersey City shops of the Central
Railroad of New Jersey, by Mr. Hugh
Montgomery, the general foreman.
The table is an electrically operated
one and the man who attends to the
table has been provided with an appar-
atus by which, when the table is locked
in position opposite any given track, a
dwarf semaphore signal will give the "all
clear" indication. The act of unlocking
the table raises the semaphore arm or
shows the danger light. In order that
there may be no such thing as the table
half unlocked and the warning arm half
down, the rod which works between the
rotating shaft and the semaphore
weight-lever, has a slot in one end, as
shown in our illustration, and this pro-
vides sufficient lost motion to insure
that the bolt be fully three-quarters of
the way home, before the signal will
The sum total of tlii' device and its op-
eration is that day or night when the
signal indicates "clear" an engineer may
be sure that the table is fair for his
track and that it is locked. The service
of one man is all that is necessary to
look after the table, as he now auto-
matically signals, as well as places and
locks the table, and a reduction of turn-
table help has been the result. The turn-
table block signal is a money-saver, it
is prompt and it is sure, and it has a
penalty up its sleeve all the time for dis-
obedience, like unto that of the open
derail.
New Sleepers for Canadian Pacific.
The Canadian Pacific officials seem to
have a fondness for the letter T. They
are building six new sleeping cars which
will be named "Thrums," "Thurso,"
"Trail." "Tyndall," "Trudeau," "Tre-
herne" — names which have a certain sig-
nificance, and which will be appropriate
at once as to geography and human
livered into each engine pit. The heat
so applied will melt off snow or ice from
incoming locomotives when that is re-
quired. From the pits the heated air
rises vertically, so that there is no
trouble from smoke or steam in the in-
habited zone of the building. On ac-
count of the hot, dry air supplied by the
system, all moisture due to the melting
of snow or ice is quickly evaporated,
thus making it possible to work on en-
gines without discomfort within a very
short time. During warm weather the
fan can be operated without steam in the
heater and thus provide very thorough
ventilation for the building. Other ad-
vantages, as compared with the direct
system, are that there is no piping scat-
tered about the building to freeze or
burst in cold weather, there are no joints
to leak, and there is no danger of fire
from the proximity of steam pipes to
inflammable materials. Since the piping
is all concentrated in a steel-plated hous-
ing, where the velocity of the air passing
over it is very high, much less length of
fr
^
» J ■: ■ (o fr P^
Cloned pott t ton
I of Levtr
^
S
Railway f LvCiimutUt Engimmring
TURN TABLE BLOCK SIGNAL ON THE C. R. R. OF N. J.
"clear," and it will also be part way out
of its socket before the signal will begin
to move to "danger."
There can be no "permissive" block-
ing with this table. It is what the boys
call a "dead open and shut" and the dis-
regard of this dwarf signal even after
the time limit has expired, will mean
trouble. Another feature of the device
is that the bolt has what might be called
a turned-up nose, which enables the bolt
to be shot, even when the sag of the
table carries the center line of the bolt
slightly below that of the socket. This
has the peculiarity of restricting some-
what the speed at which the bolt can be
moved, because as the table sags more
or less at the motor end, even when un-
loaded, the slightly uphill movement of
the bolt into its socket produces a cer-
tain amount of friction. The leverage of
the system is purposely not made very
powerful, so that it is an exceedingly
difficult, if not an impossible, task to
shoot the bolt when the table is in mo-
tion.
record. These cars will be of the very
latest designs. They will be largely pat-
terned after six other sleepers which
have just been delivered from Dayton.
Ohio, although the local creations will
have certain features of originality. Each
car will cost about seventeen thousand
dollars. They will have every conven-
ience and comfort, ample light, and a
nice disposition of space which will give
the utmost room.
pipe is needed than would otherwise be
necessary. The equipment above de-
scribed has been designed and installed
by the B. F. Sturtevant Co., of Boston.
Round = tiouse Heating and Ventilation.
The 20-stall round-house of the Nor-
folk & Western Railway, at Portsmouth.
Ohio, has been equipped with the "hot-
blast" system of heating, the apparatus
consisting of a large exhaust fan direct
connected to a horizontal engine and
drawing air through a steam-coil heater
built up of l-in. steam piping on cast-iron
sections. From this apparatus air is dis-
tributed throughout the round-house by
brick' tlues and galvanized iron piping,
so arranged that heated air may be de-
A series of conferences has taken place
between a committee of locomotive fire-
men on the Erie Railroad and the repre-
sentatives of the company, resulting in
an advance of wages for the firemen in
some sections and a general rearrange-
ment of conditions. The conferences
were held in this city with Third Vice-
President Willard, who has immediate
charge of all such matters. Committees
representing other branches of the loco-
motive department have already had con-
ferences with the Erie officials, resulting
in a satisfactory agreement being
reached. The detailed negotiations were
conducted by Mr. W. C. Hayes, assistant
superintendent of motive power. Mr.
Hayes is an old Brotherhood official, and
his skill and experience in settling dis-
putes helped very much in bringing sides
to an amicable agreement.
336
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
Brotherhood Union Meeting.
A very successful union meeting of
railroad brotherhoods was held at Mont-
gomery, Alabama, last month.
On the stage were seated William A.
Love, of Atlanta, Ga., a retired locomo-
tive engineer, who acted as master of
ceremonies; P. M. Arthur, of Cleveland,
Ohio, chief engineer of the Brotherhood
of Locomotive Engineers; Deloss Ever-
ett, of Cleveland. O., third grand engi-
neer; Timothy Shea, of Peoria, III., sec-
ond vice grand master of the Brother-
hood of Locomotive Firemen; L. E.
Shepard, of Camden, N. J., junior con-
ductor; Mrs. W. A. Murdock, of Chi-
cago, 111., grand president of the Grand
International Auxiliary of the Brother-
hood of Locomotive Engineers.
All these brotherhood officials deliv-
ered addresses commending their organi-
zations and the good will of the southern
people. In the course of his address.
Grand Chief Arthur, of the Brotherhood
of Engineers, said he had never ordered a
strike in his life, which seemed to excite
a great deal of interest not only among
his hearers but among newspaper read-
ers all over the country. A number of
local statesmen made speeches welcom-
ing the brotherhoods and commending
the work they are doing.
Nurnberg Gas Engine.
Mr. A. Rieppel, Koeniglicher Baurat,
of Nurnberg, Germany, the managing
director of the Augsburg Nurnberg
Manufacturing Co., well ^known for
many years as one of the largest and
most successful builders of structural
iron work, engines, cars, bridges, etc.,
in Europe, is now visiting this country
for the first time. His works employ
about 16,000 men, and now have over
2,000 at work on the bridges, etc., of the
new railroads being built by Germany
in China.
Their latest success has been with
gas engines, both for gaseous and liquid
fuel. They have long built these en-
gines in smaller units up to 400 H. P.,
and operated with petroleum, but for
the use of waste gas as well as producer
gases and in larger units, they have re-
cently developed an entirely new de-
sign, constituting the result of many
years of extensive experience. The en-
gine which is of the double acting cycle
type, generally in tandem arrangement,
is best adapted for the various purposes
of modern power development up to the
largest units required by municipal cen-
tral stations and iron and steel works.
Mr, Rieppel's visit to this country was
made in order to interest the Allis-Chal-
mers Company in the manufacture of
the products of his concern. A con-
tract was entered into by the two com-
panies giving the Allis-Chalmers people
the exclusive right to manufacture and
sell the Nurnberg gas engine in this
country, and selling rights in many
foreign countries, especially the far east
and in South Africa.
The Augsburg Nurnberg Manufactur-
ing Company, under the direction of Mr.
Rieppel, have had phenomenal success
with this new gas engine, having -within
the past few months received orders for
some 50,000 h. p. throughout Germany
and Spain, chiefly for generating elec-
tric energy and for blast furnace and
spinning mill work. One of these en-
gines now being built is for an impor-
tant spinning mill in northern Germany,
where the engine will be operated by
producer gas.
Mr. Rieppel is now on a tour of in-
spection throughout the United States,
after which he will visit the new and ex-
tensive works of the Allis-Chalmers
Company at West Allis, where these en-
gines will be built.
New Southern Pacific Shops at Los
Angeles.
The Southern Pacific Company are
erecting very fine repair shops at Los
Angeles, Cal., but the work has been
greatly delayed through want of material.
We learn from a correspondent that the
foundations of concrete for the machine
tools, etc., are now well under way. All
the foundation piers for the line and
counter shafting columns are in also for
the lo-ton Niles electric crane over the
driving wheel machine tools. The steel
roof is now going up on the blacksmith
and boiler shops while the one on the
machine and erecting shop is nearly com-
pleted. The 60 ft. turntable for the
roundhouse is being lengthened out to
6s ft. to take the large consolidation
engines with semi-cylindrical tanks
which were shown in our March issue.
The car repair and car paint shops are
now well under way and the office and
storehouse building practically com-
pleted.
The United Engineering and Foundry
Co., of Pittsburg, installed last year a
complete heating and ventilating equip-
ment in the Roll Shop of the Lincoln
Foundry Department. The apparatus,
which was furnished by the B. F. Sturte-
vant Co., consists of a steel-plate ex-
hauster direct-connected to a horizontal
side-crank engine. The exhauster draws
air from out-of-doors through a large
steam heater built up in sections of i-in.
pipe, one of the sections receiving the
exhaust from the fan engine.
Copper sheathed passenger cars are
gaining popularity very rapidly. Five
hundred copper sheathed cars are under
construction for the New York Inter-
urban Railway. The plan of using copper
sheathing introduced by Mr. Wm. P.' Ap-
pleyard, of New Haven, are most popu-
lar.
Buy It Yourself,
If Necessary.
Dixon's Flake Graph-
ite costs but little and is
a wise investment for
the engineer who wants
to get on.
You are judged by re-
sults, and the man who
gets the best work out
of his engine with the
least expense of fuel and
oil, who makes good
time and is not delayed
by hot pins, is the en-
gineer who stands the
best chance of promo-
tion.
The price of Dixon's
Graphite is a small price
to pay for this, and if
your road doesn't fur-
nish it, it will pay you to
buy it yourself.
Says an Engineer :
" Dixon's Pure Flake Graphite is won-
derful. Had a hot driving box. I took
the waste out, put a mixture ot Dixon's
Pure Flake Graphite and engine oil
down through the hole in the top of the
box. and in a distance of i6 miles the box
was ice cold. It has also proved equally
successful for main pins. 1 now use en-
gine oil and Graphite, and pins are ice
cold. Previous it was valve oil and hot
pins. In the future will not be without
It, It IS even better to buy it yourself
and have comfort, than to be without it
and worry,''
LET U.S SEND YOU A SAMPLE FOR
YOUR ENGINE
Joseph Dixon Crucible
Company
JERSEY CITY. N. J.
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
337
Gilman-Brown
Emergency
Knuckle ^
Rts any M. C. B. Coupler
^«
Can be fitted instantly
^*
IMakes a safe and strong
connection
Prevents traffic delay on
the road and loss of
car service
Over 30,000 are in use
Send for Catalog on this and
other Track, Locomotive
and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with the Q. & C. Co.
GENERAL OEFICES
OLD COLOW BUILDING
...CHICAGO...
New York Office, ri4 Liberty Street
I'ittsburgfi Sprlnj^and Steel Company's
Works.
On the banks of the Allegheny River,
in the city of Pittsburgh, in a region
where there are numerous noisy, smoke-
emitting factories devoted to turning the
products of iron ore into merchantable
forms, we find the works of the Pitts-
burgh Spring & Steel Company, which
oflfer to men familiar with engineering
appliances the means of spending an af-
ternoon amid very instructive and enter-
taining surroundings. These works, il-
lustrated in the annexed engraving, are
very large, and are equipped with the
very best machinery made for spring
making, and they contain many machines
and appliances specially made for these
works of designs we had never seen be-
fore and to be found nowhere else.
The shops are in an enclosure of five
each operation until as a finished spring,
carefully tested, it enters the storage and
is ready for shipment.
Facilities are already provided for mak-
ing and finishing a great output of springs
daily and the works can be equipped with
appliances that will make it the largest
spring establishment in the world.
The heating furnaces use natural gas;
but apparatus for making producer gas
is also provided. Reversing valves,
water cooled, are employed, and the blast
is provided by a powerful Sturtevant fan,
which maintains air pressure of 8 ounces
throughout the establishment. Pure air is
provided by a Sturtevant exhaust-fan sys-
tem.
In moving about the works the visitor
is struck the cheerful alacrity with which
all operations are conducted. One visitor
noticed that many of the workmen's faces
PITTSBURGH SPRING AND STEEL WORKS.
acres, which provides ample yard room
outside of the buildings. The principal
mill is II2.\444 feet and another building
is 6PX287 feet.
The facilities for conveying material to
and from the works are exceptionally
good, for on one side there is a line of
railroad tracks which serve all railroads,
and on the other side there is the Alle-
gheny River, which provides water car-
riage.
A notable feature about the works is the
conveniences provided for the handling of
material. There is no double handling
of material of any kind where single hand-
ling could be arranged. All the steel is
brought into the works through the yard
in cars to the unloading department.
Here, after unloading, the steel is cut into
various sizes for use and in due course
it is moved along to the machine or fur-
nace where work is to be done upon it.
It is always kept moving forward after
were familiar. A little stimulating of the
memory and it said you have seen these
men during your numerous visits to the
A. French Springs Works. Then we re-
flect that the president of the Pittsburgh
Spring & Steel Company used to be the
secretary and treasurer of the French
Company. That recalls other memories.
Sixty years ago a young blacksmith in
Ohio became keenly interested in temper-
ing springs for steel traps that he used as
a hunter. He was the kind of youth who
struggles for perfection and he learned to
forge and temper springs as no blacksmith
in the region had succeeded in doing, and
his skill made him a prodigy.
Making springs became this blacksmith's
hobby. Delving for information on the
working of steel was his favorite amuse-
ment. In the course of time he became
foreman of a railroad blacksmith shop and
then put his hobby into practical opera-
tion, to the end of making and tempering
338
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, iqo,-?.
springs that were tight and elastic and
yet did not break. He became celebrated
for the resilience and durability of the
springs made under his direction.
After a few years this blacksmith with
the spring-making affinities, whose name
was Aaron French, became the head of a
spring-making establishment, and he
turned his skill to making springs on a
large scale as they had never been made
before. The art which Aaron French de-
voted to the work of spring making revo-
lutionized the business for railroad rolling
stock and made American cars the
smoothest riding vehicles in the world.
The Aaron French Spring Works main-
tained their high standard of excellence
as long as they were operated.
It looks to us as if the Pittsburgh
Spring & Steel Company had donned the
Aaron French mantle which the trust re-
jected.
with pointer. As the hand car runs along
the track with both rollers touching the
rails, the widening or narrowing of the
track produces a corresponding motion
of the pointer on the dial and thus indi-
cates any variation in track gauge. The
apparatus can run over switches and
through frogs, in fact, anywhere that
w-heel flanges will go this indicator can be
used.
Pneumatic Tools.
The Chicago Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany have issued two special circulars,
Nos. 36 and 37. The first is concerned
with pneumatic hammers, and gives de-
scriptions and sizes of parts, etc., to-
gether with much useful information con-
nected with these hammers. No. 37
deals with pneumatic drills, and is well
illustrated throughout with line cuts and
half-tones. These circulars will be sSnt
to those who are interested enough to
apply. This company is continually on
the lookout for new devices which fit in
with their line of pneumatic appliances
of every description, and have within the
past few months made several additions
which are the most perfect productions
of their kind. Chief among them is a
pneumatic hand rock drill, designated
as the Chicago Rock Drill, and a com-
pression riveter, which is called the
Chicago Compression Riveter. These
machines, although but very recently
placed on the market, have already indi-
cated, by the heavy sales immediately
created, that they are up to the high
standard demanded of all tools manufac-
tured by the Chicago Pneumatic Tool
Company. Both these machines are il-
lustrated and fully described in attractive
circulars which the company is mailing
to the trade.
Metallic 'Packing.
A small pamphlet has recently been got
out by Mr. Charles Longstreath on Metal-
lic Packing and the principles of design
for successful development. The pamph-
let is a reprint from the Journal of the
American Society of Naval Engineers, Vol.
XV., No. 2. In this paper the whole
question of piston-rod packing is consid-
ered, and what is requisite and what is
not desirable are frankly stated.
The packing, for instance, should allow
for vibratory motion. This motion may
be caused by the slight difference in
diameter between piston and cylinder, as
well as by the play between crosshead
and guides. It must provide for this vi-
bration and yet be steam-tight without
producing excessive friction. On the
other hand, packing should not be ex-
pected to act partly as a crosshead guide,
because this function can only be secured
by the sacrifice of the other and essential
requisite, viz., the ability to allow for
vibration.
There is a great deal of information
concerning packing, compressed into the
few pages of Mr. Longstreath's paper.
The United States Metallic Packing Com-
pany, of Philadelphia, will be happy to
forward a copy of this pamphlet to those
interested enough to apply to them for it.
A St. Paul concern has recently de-
vised a very ingenious track gauge indi-
cator which can be applied to the front of
a hand car. It consists of two arms
which hang down at each side, at the
lower ends of which are two rollers which
run upon the gauge side of each rail. They
are held constantly against the rails
by springs and the object of the
apparatus is to indicate any spreading
or narrowing of the track. The upper
ends of the hanging arms are bent over
at right angles and arc attached to a dial
Four Track Series.
The Four Track Series No. 8, issued
by Mr. Geo. H. Daniels, general passen-
ger agent of the New York Central, is
concerned with pleasure tours of from
two to fifteen days. It contains a very
clear colored map of the N. Y. C. lines,
and takes in the territory lying between
the Atlantic seaboard and the Mississippi
river, and from the latitude of Quebec,
Canada, down to that of Richmond, Va.
.\11 sorts of information is given con-
cerning little tours which may last from
Saturday to Monday, or longer if the
traveler has the time; the route is giv-
en, with time of departure from New
York, and the price of the ticket is
stated. There is a great deal of useful
information about the whole country tra-
versed by this great railway system,
which makes pleasant and instructive
reading, even if you "can't get away"
this year as far as you know yet. The
folder will be sent to anyone who applies
to Mr. Daniels for it. Address Grand
Central Station, New York City.
Hi®
oofl
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
339
The Union
S>vitch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal SUtlon.
Broke the Brake.
There was a break in two in Allegheny
last month resulting badly for a street
car. The brakcman in braking broke
the brake, whereupon the car broke
loose after breaking through a safety
gate, breaking the brakeman's head.
The engineer of an advancing train ap-
plied the brakes, but could not brake up
in time to prevent the breaking of the
street car, and it nearly broke the heart
of the brakeman's wife, who had just
prepared breakfast. The whole thing
happened through the brakeman break-
ing the rules of the company.
The Consolidated "Axle Light" equip-
ments of electric car lighting are steadily
coming into general use on the finest
cars constituting the best and fastest
time past, shipped over 120 cars per day
from their McKee's Rocks and Alle-
gheny plants, using in the manufacture
of these cars from 45.000 to 50,000 tons
of steel plates per month. From the
present outlook all previous records
which have been established will prob-
ably be eclipsed. It is estimated that
the output this year will exceed 38,000
finished cars.
A smart hobo was reclining upon a
pile of lumber on a warm day watching
workmen building an addition to the
Schenectady Locomotive Works. Two
Poles came along looking for a job, and
they mistook the hobo for a foreman in
charge of the job. They went up to him
and by signs made manifest that they
were looking for work. By signs the
lAlLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's •' H^KlVd"" Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sol* RepresentativcK In the United States,
Canada and /lexico
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
FITZ-HUCH & CO.
RAILWAY EOIIPMENT
LOCOMOTIVES
Heavy and Light, adapted to all kinds of servlca
CARS, FREIGHT, PASSENGER and BUSINESS
Uonadnock BIdg., Chicago 141 Broadway, New York
We make 20 different styles and sizes of
locomotive cab seats. Send for catalog
and full particulars.
STANNAHD &'WHITE CO., Racine Jet., Wis.
PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT'S TRAIN ON THE SOUTHERN PACIFIC.
trains of leading railway lines, including
the Pullman cars on all these trains.
All private Pullman cars and nearly all
the business cars of railway officials, as
well as private cars of individuals, are
equipped with the Consolidated "Axle
Light" system of electric lights. These
"Axle Light" equipments are also begin-
ning to be used quite extensively on the
railway systems of Great Britain and of
Europe.
Mention has been made concerning
the rapid strides which have been taken
by the Pressed Steel Car Company, of
Pittsburg, in the manufacture of pressed
steel cars. It is with pleasure that we
hear that this company has made and
shipped, up to and including May 29.
1903, 100,467 cars; this figure represents
the actual number of cars which are in
service to-day, manufactured by the
Pressed Steel Car Company. It includes
steel cars as well as wooden cars, for
which steel underframes have been fu"--
nished. The company has, for some
hobo invited them to a remote point
where there was a big heap of sand and
some wheelbarrows. By the same token
he made them understand that by paying
one dollar each they could have a job
wheeling that sand to another spot. The
money was forthcoming and two hours
later a watchman found the Poles ener-
getically moving the sand away from the
spot where it was wanted. The tramp
did not wait to watch developments. He
was evidently a past master of the art of
"graft."
John Lambert, of Chicago, seems to
think that he owns the earth and the
fulness thereof, because he is owner of
enough stock in the Steel Trust to be
called a "steel magnate." Moved by the
fulness of his self-importance, he or-
dered his private car to be coupled to
President Roosevelt's train at Aurora.
111. The steel magnate was astonished
when a switch engine hitched on to it
and pitched it ignominiously into a side
track.
340
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
Western Massachusetts Described by
the Boston & Haine.
Western Massachusetts is a section of
New England which is noted for its pure
air. The country is particularly health-
ful and invigorating by reason of its high
altitude and its delightful situation close
to the beautiful Berkshire Hills and the
impressive Hoosac Mountains. It is a per-
fect haven for the worker who seeks
health and rest. The natural beauties of
this portion of Massachusetts are numer-
ous, and it was here that Hawthorne and
Beecher derived inspiration for some of
their best writings.
The Boston & Maine Railroad Passen-
ger Department at Boston publishes an
interesting booklet of fifty-five pages
which gives a detailed and comprehensive
description of this region, also a mag-
nificent portfolio of views containing
thirty-three perfect photographs of the
most beautiful scenes along the Fitchburg
Division. The title of the descriptive
book is "Hoosac Countrv and Deerfield
Valley," and of the portfolio, "The
Charles River to the Hudson." These
views comprise also some pictures of that
famed historical and scenic country,
eastern New York. This portfolio will
be mailed upon receipt of six cents in
stamps and the descriptive book upon
receipt of two cents in stamps or eight
cents for both.
The Locomotive Magazine, of London,
England, is now a weekly publication.
One of its recent issues contains a de-
scriptive article on some new express
locomotives of the Great Southern and
Western Railway, of Ireland. It also
illustrates the portable pneumatic plant
used by the same road. This consists
of a covered car in which are compactly
placed a steam boiler and air compressor
from which hose pipes convey air to the
various hammers, drills, riveters, etc.,
which are used in bridge work, boiler
and tank repairs at out stations. An
early eight-wheel American locomotive,
the "Daniel Mason," built for the Bos-
ton & Providence Railway in 1858, comes
in for mention. A Lancashire and York-
shire 2-4-0 engine built at Crewe, which
for years has worked the fast Blackpool
expresses to Manchester and to York-
shire, is illustrated and there is an inter-
esting description of a run on a French
compound, a six-coupled bogie locomo-
tive on the Chemin de Fer de I'Ouest. The
subject of brick arches in firebo.xes is
dealt with at some length. Altogether the
magazine is a very interesting publica-
tion, dealing with British and Continen-
tal practice.
The general management of the Chesa-
peake & Ohio announces an increase of
10 per cent, in the wages of trainmen
and all operating employees of the road.
The new order goes into effect at once,
and is a welcome surprise to the men af-
fected. It is the policy of this road to
have the employees participate in the
profits from good business. In the past
twelve months its business has earned a
handsome profit, and the advance in
wages has followed.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works have
recently received an order for ten loco-
motives for Guatemala.
Preparing for an Examination.
We were recently asked to answer a
series of questions taken from an old ex-
amination paper. The questions were not
catchy and not particularly difficult. Go-
ing over an old examination paper is usu-
ally an excellent way of preparing for an
examination, but to work away on old
examination papers only when getting up
a subject is to lean upon, if not a broken,
certainly a very weak reed. The right way
to get a general knowledge of the sub-
ject is to read about it. Your ability to
answer ten or a dozen general questions
at an examination is not much good by
itself, but it is evidence that you possess
the general knowledge which is required
of you. A man possessing this general
knowledge of a subject such as air brake
work, locomotive running, railway signal-
ing, etc., etc., is said by his friends to be
well "posted." One of the best ways to
gain a general knowledge of a subject is
to read what has been written about it
by men of authority. In the various de-
partments of engineering, as in other de-
partments of human learning, books have
been written by experts for the purpose
of taking hold of a man who does not
know anything of a subject and, beginning
at the beginning with him, are able to
bring him gradually and easily along. A
well "posted" man does not need to fear
examinations. Look over the list we
present here, and see if there is not at
least one book which would be of service
to you.
The first on the list is, of course,
Railway and Locomotive Engineering,
a practical journal of railway motive
power and rolling stock. It costs only
$2.00 a year, and is well worth the money,
and besides the paper is a welcome visi-
tor in every household. Let your wife
and boys see it.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book, combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particu-
larly useful book to the young mechanic.
BEST RAILROAD
BOOKS.
COMBUSTION OF COAL
And the Prevention of Smoke.
Con tains about 800 practical quest ions and
their aniwert on the Science of Steam
Maklnr. By Wm. M. Barr. The necessary
conditions for the Economic Firing of a
Locomotive are explained. 85 Illustrations.
349 pages. Cloth, $1.50.
AIR-BRAKE CATECHISM.
By Robert H. BLACKiLL. Fifteenth edi-
tion. A complete study of the Air-Brake
equipment, containing over 1,000 questions
and their answers on the WeBtlnghotts*
Air-Brake, which are strictly up to date.
Endorsed and used by Air-Brake Instruc-
tors and Examiners on nearly every rail-
road In the United States. 1902 Edition.
t64 pages. Cloth, |i. 50.
LOCOMOTIVE CATECHISM.
By Robert Grimshaw. It asks i,(mo
questions and gives 1,600 simple, plain,
Sractlcal answers about the Locemotlve.
'o mathematics, no theories— yw^/ facti.
The standard book on the locomotive.
Twenty-second edition. Containing 43e
pares, over 300 illustrations, and iiTarge
Folding Plates. Bound in Maroon Clotn,
$a.oo.
t^'A Sptcial Circular of tktse Bttki Stnt
on Request,
tST'Any of thest Books Prepaid to any
Address in the world on Receipt of Prico.
AGENTS WANTED i" .V"* V\%-
sell at sight, and •v«rT Engineer,
Fireman and Shopman should have
them. Write for terms and particu-
lars. Our catalogue of practical
books Is oent free on application.
lorman A. Henley & Co., Publishers
132 Nassau St. NEW YORK, H.T.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to X
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
July. 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
341
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
AND 18 SIZE.
17 AM) 21 KUB¥
SArPllIKE rALLETS
BAIJi'S IMPKOVED
SAFKTV
DOritLK ItOIJ'RB
Are without question
the finest wntcht's that
Amorican talent and
Hlcilkd labor can pro-
duct-, and they arc giv-
Infi such universal sat-
isfaction that wo have
no ho8itancy In claim-
ing that they are the
best and flafeet railroad
watch on the market.
Tests eevero and numerous have proven tliis fact to
ihe most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which tlioueiuida of good Itailroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
Write ns for descriptive matter.
TkWebbC. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Whitney Planers
\\hen c(i\iip]H-(l \\ith the
Whitney Sectional Roil
turn out more work, while running
at less speed, than the ordinary' solid
roll planers. This is the ideal con-
dition— increased output and better
grade of work.
Write for Catalog.
Baxter D. Whitney & Son,
. WINCHENDON, MASS. .
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGIU BUILDING, WASHINGTOII. 0. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sent
It has a stimulating elfect in inducing
him to study his business. Price, 50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and travehng
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers Hkely to
be hired. It contains in small compass
a large amount of information about the
locomotive. Convenient pocket size. We
cordially recommend this book. The
price is 75 cents.
"Compound L.ocomotives." Colvin.
This book instructs a man so that he will
understand the construction and opera-
tion of a compound locomotive as well as
he now understands a simple engine.
Tells all about running, about break-
downs and repairs. Convenient pocket
size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horse power, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a par-
tial list of its contents. It is in the
question and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. Price, go cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a foreman boilermaker. Also contains
several chapters on oil-burning locomo-
tives. Price, so cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. Price, $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can afford to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. 50 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of com-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily un-
derstood by ever}' intelligent fireman. The
price is 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons try-
ing to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole. story. We sell it. Cloth, 73
cents. Leather, $1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of prac-
tical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehensive
treatise on the subject. Ought to be
studied by all trainmen where block sig-
nals are used. $3.00.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating of all trains on single or double
track. Used by nearly all railroads. Study
of this book would prevent many collis-
ions. Price, 50 cents.
"Mechanical Engineers' Pocket Book."
Kent. This book contains 1,100 pages
6x3'/], inches of closely-printed minion
type, containing mechanical engineering
matter. It ought to be in the book case
of every engineer who takes an interest
in engineering questions. We use it con-
stantly as a reference for questions sent
to us to be answered. Full of tables and
illustrations. Morocco leather. $5.00.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco-
motive. It will be found particularly use-
ful to men handling or repairing com-
pound locomotives. It is the real loco-
motive up to date. $2.50.
R.-VrL\VAY AND LOCOMOTIVE EnCINEEB-
iNG. Bound volumes. $3.00.
The announcement is made that the Al-
lison Manufacturing Company of Phila-
delphia, will close up their business for
good, directly, and that the firm will go
out of existence. This is a rather ex-
traordinary decision, for the company has
been engaged in the manufacture of cars
and boiler tubes for 70 years, and has al-
ways prospered. The name alone would
be worth a great deal to any concern
wishing to carry on the business, but the
proprietors do not wish to have the name
perpetuated.
The famous old flyer 999 has been
making" some record runs hauling Uncle
Sam's fast mail, on the N. Y. C, but
she's been making pretty fast time out
of our office lately. We have had to
supply this locomotive many times on
shorter notice than generally comes to
a round-house, but we have always sup-
plied the engine, and on time, too. Look
at the reduced reproduction of our chart
It is on page 17, among the advertising
cuts. The chart gives the names of all the
parts of a standard engine and in fact
is an illustrated index.
The J. A. Fay & Egan Company, man-
ufacturers of woodworking machinery,
have notified us that they have a neat
little watch charm which they will send
free to any person who will write
them for one. Their address is 445 West
Front street, Cincinnati. Ohio.
342
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
A Train for Hauling Water.
The Union Pacific Railway has lately
had a train built which is the first of its
kind in the world. It will be used to
convey water to the various water sta-
tions in the West, where the local supply
is strongly impregnated with alkali,
which is very bad for the boilers. The
cars are of pressed steel, covered with
planks, and fitted with the necessary
valves. The experiment has been very
successful.— New York Commercial Adver-
tiser.
A new corporation is the Gould Coup-
ler Company, of Depew, Erie County, to
manufacture and deal in car couplers,
and the business now carried on by the
Gould Coupler Company, of West Vir-
ginia; capital, $5,000,000; directors,
Charles A, Gould and Frederick P.
Huntley, of New York city. The Gould
Storage Battery Company, organized
with a capital of $5,000,000, also filed pa-
pers.
In the Corporation Museum, Leices-
ter, there is a most interesting collection
of railway relics presented by Mr. C. E.
Stretton, the well-known engineer and
writer on railway historical subjects. In
the collection is a pair of wheels from
the Duke of Rutland's Railway at Bel-
voir Castle, which are grooved by wear
nearly half an inch deep. Some of the
rails on which these wheels ran from
1793, over 109 years, are shown. The
rails weigh about 40 pounds to the yard
which was a great weight for the time
the rails were made.
The business of the Pressed Steel Car
Company so far this current fiscal year
shows an increase in gross receipts of
about 26 per cent, over the same period
in 1902. There has of course been an in-
crease in expenses as the result of higher
prices for materials and labor, but the
financial results obtained since January
I, when the company's fiscal year began,
are regarded by the management as
highly satisfactory, j
Among the improvements being made
by the Chicago & Northwestern Rail-
way is the introduction of new turn-
tables, 70 feet long. The modern loco-
motive has outgrown the capacity of the
old turn-tables, and not a few railroad
companies are embarrassed to turn the
locomotives that have lately been
brought into service.
There has been some talk of a strilce
in the Wabash Car Shops at Decatur,
111., because J. M. Lichdenberger, the
head of the Carmen's Union, refused to
go to St. Louis to fill a different posi-
tion. An attempt was made to convert
it into a case of persecution of labor
leaders but it did not succeed very well.
The British Westinghouse Company
has been awarded a contract by the Lon-
don city council that calls for the equip-
ment of 200 electric cars. The contract
amounts to $70,000 and is the largest
contract for equipping such cars that
has ever been let in England. One half
of the cars will be of the single-truck
type and the remaining number will be
double-deck, double-truck tram cars.
A.Leschen&:SonsRopeCo.
Those who usually ride on street cars
would hardly desire to spend the night
upon them, but we notice that in several
parts of Ohio they are placing sleeping
cars on street railways. A sleeping car
service has been introduced between
Cincinnati and Columbus, and we believe
that one will also be established between
Cleveland and Toledo. The speed oi
these cars is not very rapid and they run
over very smooth tracks, so that persons
going frO'm one city to another may
spend the night very comfortably in the
interurban sleeping cars.
The Morton Trust Company, and the
Pressed Steel Car Company have filed
another bill in equity against the Stand-
ard Steel Car Company in the United
States Circuit Court. The new case al-
leges infringement on the part of the de-
fendant company of a patent for a "com-
bined stake and pocket for cars." An in-
junction restraining the defendant from
further manufacture of the device and
damages are asked.
Several years ago the Rome Locomo-
tive Works were purchased by the Com-
pressed Air Co., to be used for building
compressed air motors. That business
did not flourish and lately three credi-
tors filed a suit against the company. The
aggregate of the claims are $3,205, and
they are based on overdue orders, partly
secured by bonding of the locomotive
company. The company's creditors al-
lege that the Compressed Air Company,
although insolvent, preferred certain
creditors by paying them $7,425 interest
on bonds.
Some powerful passenger locomotives
built by the Baldwin Locomotive works,
in Philadelphia, will be added soon to
the equipment of the Long Island Rail-
road. There are eight new ten-wheelers
of the most powerful type, to be used on
the Montauk and main line and the north
side branches, besides new freight and
switch engines.
The gross earnings of the Chicago
Great Western Railway (Maple Leaf
Route) for the month of May, 1903.
show an increase of $76,689.49 over the
corresponding month of last year; being
an increase for the fiscal year of $142,-
908.17.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
HOME OFFICE :
920-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
f 1,15 E. Lake St., Chicago, 111.
i3,„„.-i, r,<Ko«..J 92 Centre St., New York Citv.N.Y.
Branch Offices IsPremont St..San Francisco,Cal.
1 1717-23 Arapahoe St , Denver, Col.
ifefl.^S..
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINGFIELD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
A . B.C. and Luber^s Codt used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen*
ion's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott^nstrasse 112, Dusseldorf.
Germany.
MINNEAPOLIS
AND ST. PAUL
Illinois Central R. R.
New line from Chicago via
Rocfcford, Freeport, Dubuque,
Waterloo and Albert Lea.
Fine service and fast " Lim-
ited " night train, with State-
room and Open-section Sleep-
ing Car, Buffet-Library Car
and Free Reclining Chair Car
through without change. Din-
ing Car Service.
A. H. HANSON
G. P. A., Chicago
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Conaultatlon,
1137 THE ROOKERY, CHICAGO.
66 Broadway, New York. Park Building, PlUsborgh
"31 Norfolk House, Loudon, Eng.
InBpoclion of Steel Ralls, Splice Bars, Railroad Care,
Wheels, Axles, etc. Chemical Laboratory— Analysi*
of Ores, Iron, Steel, Oils, Water, etc. PHYSICAI, Labo-
ratory—Test nf Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Bars, etc.
Efflciencr Tests of Boilers, Engines and LoceniotiTe&
July, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
343
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
ovcrclothes. .»* Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overafls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
■hops in the countr)r.
Union of courie. Jt Jt
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
HORAR FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Ino.
No. U9 Third Street. Louisville, Ky.
PARKER
"Lucky Curve"
FOUNTAIN PEN
A Pen that has the 0, K. running all the way through.
9,000 DEALERS SELL THEM
•'LCCKT CrRVE'*— if s easy to remember. KEPT IN
REPAIR FREE ONE YHAK. We have a catalogue
waiting for you, as well as the name of a dealer you
know who sells them. Both await ynur request.
THE PARKER PEN CO., U Mill St., Janesvllle, Wis.
Great Guide Wheel Railway.
In my younger days I used to read a
great deal in the Illustrated London News
about the Great "Guide Wheel" Rail-
way, that was going to revolutionize rail-
roading in England. I remember there
was a bracket in front of the engine,
that carried a doulile flange wheel iii
contact with a third or middle rail. Who
can tell the readers of Railway and Ix>-
coMOTiVE Engineering all about it?
W. DE Sanno.
San Francisco, Cat.
Tlif ChicaRo Pneumatic Tool Company
have recently issued a couple of special
circulars, Nos. 38 and 39, which illustrate
their various types of pneumatic appli-
ances.
Circular No. 38 shows the method of
cleaning crownsheets, when a locomo-
tive is in the shop for general repairs
To do this work a jam riveter is used
and the method of operation is very
clearly shown in the cut which appears
on the second page of the circular. Tube
expanding is also done with a jam riveter,
and the way this is accomplished is duly
set forth and illustrated. The Boyer
drill, with yoke attachment, which is
shown, makes it possible to drill in any
position and in exact center. The machine
being hung by a bale, enables the operator
to turn it in any desired direction. Sev-
eral other well known specialties made
by this concern are also illustrated.
Circular No. 39 gives illustrations of
the various tools at work. The photo-
graphs from which the half-tones are pre-
pared having been taken from actual
scenes on bridge or building work.
The Chicago Pneumatic Tool Company
will be happy to send these circulars to
any one who writes them for copies.
The Covington, Kentucky, City Coun-
cil have passed an ordinance prohibiting
the use of soft coal by railroad com-
panies while running trains through the
city limits. If hard coal turns out to
be as scarce next winter as it was last
winter compliance with the city ordi-
nance would mean the stopping of the
trains altogether.
The Nernst Lamp Company, of Pitts-
burgh, Penna., has established a Main-
tenance Bureau for the purpose of sup-
plying users of Nernst lamps with new
burners or holders, so it will not be neces-
sary for the customer to visit or call upon
the electric light stations when one of his
lamps gives out.
To meet the demands for additional ac-
commodations on the southwest system of
the Pennsylvania lines. 55 cars, now in
process of building, will be added. They
include coaches, baggage and mail cars.
At the Columbus shops the cars under
construction are : Three "o-foot combina-
tion coach and baggage equipped with
electric lights; five 70-foot baggage, mail
and express cars, one postal and three 60-
foot horse express cars. At the Altoona
shops there are 21 vcstibulcd passenger
coaches and nine 60- foot baggage and ex-
press cars being built. In the Allegheny
shops there are eight baggage and ex-
press cars under construction.
.\merican threshers, reapers, binders
and mowers have a monopoly of this
trade, and are being used more and more
each day in France. As for locomotives
the French railway companies have found
them satisfactory and as economical
when given all the work they can do as
the French engines. They insisted that
American manufacturers should fashion
their products so as to agree with the
requirements of the French law. In
many instances the American locomo-
tives had to be changed and often a re-
distribution of weight on the rails was
necessary. The grates have to be
changed also so as to burn the coal in
use upon that particular railway system.
These changes made after the arrival of
the locomotives, the consul says, could
be obviated by study on the part of the
manufacturer.
Modern express engines are capable
of attaining great speed, but it is doubt-
ful if any advance in speed has been
made since the first decade of the rail-
road era. Seventy miles an hour was
frequently made by British express en-
gines before 1840. A Crampton engine
built by Norris at Schenectady in 1849.
with one pair of seven foot drivers, had
an authenticated record of 76 miles an
hour hauling eight passenger cars. The
difficulty with the early fast locomotives
was that they were short of heating sur-
face and therefore of steam making
capacity. They could not maintain fast
speed.
\\'hen railroad companies first began
to run locomotives without wiping, their
critics said that the engines were gen-
erally run at night because the officials
were ashamed to see the masses of dirt
moving through the country in daylight.
The practice of running engines that are
never wiped is now so common that peo-
ple do not think anything about the ap-
pearance, but we always thought it was
an expensive method of cutting down
expenses.
The small locomotives recently used
on the elevated railroads in New York,
and discarded on account of the adoption
of electricity, are finding their way to
all parts of the world. Many of them
are in use on plantations in Cuba. Porto
Rico and Mexico, and recently two were
shipped to China to be used in construc-
tion work on the railroad between Can-
ton and Hankow.
344
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
July, 1903.
FOR SALE
PREICHT, PASSENGER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
AND
*'-'- ^ADC QUICK
SIZES. W#^nO DELIVERIES
F. AJI LJ|/^|/C 3*S DBAftBORN ST.
■ IYI« niWrVdl CHICAGO, ILL.
TABOR VIBRATOR
MOLDING MACHINES
Have no working parts exposed
to foundry sand.
Patterns by the thousands
are available on TABOR
MACHINES v?ithout change
from their original gating or
sprays ; for that reason a Tabor
Machine can be put immedi-
ately at work as soon as set up
in foundry.
Send for Catalog
THE TABOR MFG. CO.
1742 Hamilton Street
PHILADELPHIA
CONTENTS.
PAGE.
Acceleration Tests on Gt. East. Ry.. 314
A Handy Rig 33^
Air-Brake Department 317
Block Signals Applied to Turn Tables 335
Book Reviews 31^
■ Canadian Pacific Parlor Cars, New. 322
English Motor Coach 316
European Notes 329
Fire Door Opener, Air Operated... 309
General Correspondence 306
■Grades, Profiles and Climbing 312
Grand Trunk Front End 300
< Growth of the Locomotive, by Angus
Sinclair 302
.Locomotives:
Atlantic Type for Germany 297
Fast Pass. 4-4-2 Penna. Lines 301
Heavy Consolidation, P. & L. E.. . 299
Ten-Wheeler for Cent, of Georgia. 325
jMillholland, Jas., Additional Facts,
E. J. Rauch 398
Car Axle Electric Lighting.
The New York Central Railroad has
made successful experiments with the new
system of illuminating cars with electric
light from power generated by the revo-
lutions of the a.xles of the wheels con-
trolled by the Consolidated Railway Elec-
tric Lighting and Equipment Company.
Electric lights have been used on the
limited trains for a long time, the power
being furnished by a dynamo in the bag-
gage car, which required the attention of
a man who did nothing else.
The new system has proved a success,
and it is understood that it will be ex-
tended to the coaches as fast as possible.
In fact, several of them are already
equipped, affordng a good light.
One of these cars is run every night on
the Montreal special. Last evening a still
further innovation was installed in the
form of electric fans, one of which was in
motion at either end of the car.
The General Electric Company are ex-
perimenting with electric motors as a sub-
stitute for the festive mule in hauling the
canal boats that drag their weary way
over the peaceful waters of the Erie Canal.
The politicians of New York State are
giving the electricity project less than
lukewarm support. They are apprehen-
sive that accelerating the movement of
canal boats may restrict the enormous
quarry for stealings that the canal has
been these many years. They don't in-
tend to permit anything to interfere with
the latest huge graft if they can help it.
The Steam Shovel [and the Steam
Navvy.
The American type of shovel differs
from the British navvy, in that it is part
of the standard rolling stock and can be
coupled in a train for transportation,
whereas the British machine is usually
mounted on four rigid wheels. In addi-
tion to convenience for transportation
the double trucks of the American ma-
chine have the advantage of greater
flexibility and distribution of load on
soft or uneven ground and allow it to
work more readily on curves. The
American shovel has powerful indepen-
dent engines for swinging the boom and
feeding the dipper, and its movements
are very fast.
The French and German types of end-
less chain machines are heavier and
more cumbersome; they cannot adapt
themselves to a wide range of conditions,
they require a well laid, straight, level
track of five rails to work on, and they
are adapted to load only small cars that
will go through the tunnel of the ma-
chine. They are inferior to the Ameri-
can type in point of ability to deal with
obstructions such as bowlders and
stumps and to work in rough and irregu- .
lar ground, and the wear and tear of a
chain of buckets and links is very
great. — A. W. Robinson, in the Engineer-
ing Magazine.
CONTENTS.
PAGE.
Modern Cast-Steel Frame 311
Monkey Wrench, Don't Abuse 314
Old Time Remin'ces, S. J. Kidder. . 322
On the Santa Fe Trail, Angus Sin-
clair 331
Personal Items 327
Piston Valves, Inside Admission.... 312
Pittsburgh Spring & Steel Co.'s Wks. 337
Questions Answered 315
Railway Signaling Club, May 325
Reckless Use of Gasoline 313
Ross Winans, by E. J. Rauch 304
South African Visitor's Views 326
Suburban Car Seating Problem, The. 333
The "Overlap" and the "Chalk-Line"
Stop 313
INDEX TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
PAGE.
Acme Machinery Co Front Cover
Ajax Metal Co 4th Cover
Allis-Chalmers Co H
American Balance Slide Valve Co 8
American Brake Shoe Co IS
American Loco. Sander Co 14
American Locomotive Co 21
American Steam Gauge & Valve Mfg. Co.. 4
Armstrong Bros. Tool Co 2d Cover
Armstrong Mfg. Co 22
Ashcrott Mfg. Co —
Baker. Wm. C 15
Baldwin Locomotive Works 19
Harnett, G. & H., Co 2d Cover
Becker-Brainard Milling Mch. Co 7
Big Four Railroad .^.. 13
Books:
Compound Locomotives 13
Firing Locomotives 4th Cover
Handling Locomotives 5
Locomotive Running and Management . . 1
Machine Shop Arithmetic 13
Miscellaneous 12
Oil Burning in Locomotives 2
The American Locomotive 17
Boston & Albany R. R 13
Boston & Maine R. R 344
Brady Brass Co 4
Caswell Car Co 3
Chapman Jack Co 8
Central R. R. of New Jersey 1
Chicago & Alton R. R 13
Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co 16
Cleveland City Forge & Iron Co 4th Cover
Cleveland Pneumatic Tool Co 14
Cleveland Twist Drill Co 4th Cover
Coffin Megeath Supply Co 8
Commonwealth Steel Co 3d Cover
Consolidated Safety Valve Co —
Consolidated Railway Electric Lighting &
Equipment Co 22
Crosby Steam Gage & Valve Co 19
Damascus Bronze Co 16
Dart Mfg. Co 16
Davis, John, Co 14
Day-Kinoaid Stoker Co 4
Derry-Collard Co 8
Detroit Lubricator Co 10
Dixon, Joseph Crucible Co 336
Eynon-Evans Co 4
Falls Hollow Staybolt Co 8
Fay & Egan Co., J. A 21
Fitzhugh & Co 339
Flanders, L. B., Machine Works 5
Franklin Mfg. Co 15
Galena Signal Oil Co 15
General Electric Co 9
Gold Car Heating Co 338
Gould Coupler Co 7
Gould & Eberhardt 4th Cover
Hammett, H. G 1 and 4th Cover
Hancock Inspirator Co —
Harrington & King Perforating Co 2d Cover
Hayden & Derby Mfg. Co —
Hendrick Mfg. Co 14
Henley, N. A., & Co 340
Hicks, F. M 344
Hoffman, Geo. W 14
Hunt. Robert W., & Co 342
Illinois Central R. R 342
Industrial Water Co 8
International Correspondence Schools 23
Jenkins Bros 4tli Cover
Jerome & Elliott 1
Jones, B. M., & Co 339
Jones & Lamson Machine Co 342
Kennicott Water Softener Co 2d Cover
Lake Erie Iron Co 4th Cover
Lake Shore R. R 13
Latrobe Steel Co 15
Lawson Improved Dumping Boat & Car Co. 24
Lescheu & Son's Rope Co 342
Liocomotive Chart 17
Locomotive Publishing Co., Ltd 23
Lunkenheimer Co 5
McConway & Torley Co 10
McCord & Co 40
Railway . .and
lOcomotive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co. — J 903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI. 174 Broadway, New York, August, 1903 No. 8
Baldwin Passenger Oil Burner for tlie
Southern Pacific.
In our issue of last April we were able
to give some details concerning an oil
burning Vauclain compound consolida
tion for the Southern Pacific. We are
now able to reproduce a 4-4-2 Vauclain
compound oil burner for the same road
built at the Baldwin Locomotive Works
at Philadelphia.
This engine is interesting in several
particulars. The cylinders are 15 and 25
ins., and the stroke is 28 ins. The driv-
ing wheels measure 79 ins. outside tires,
and the main driver is forward. The
total weight of the engine is about 200,-
000 lbs., of which about 102,190 lbs. are
borne by the drivers. The pressure car-
Southern Pacific and it is carried on a
steel channel frame. The tank contains
two compartments, the one next the en-
gine holds 3,300 gallons of oil, and the
one at the rear can contain 7.300 gal-
lons of water. There is a running board
and han<I rail along the side of the novel
tank. The tender is standard and is used
with passenger or freight engines with
equal facility.
The engine has a driving wheel base
of 6 ft. 10 ins., and a rigid wheel base of
15 ft. and the wheel base of the whole
engine is 31 ft. 3V3 ins. and the total of
engine and tender amounts to 65 ft. sVi
ins. The weight of the entire machine,
engine and tender — taken together is
about 340,000 lbs. The absence of any
Weight oil driving wheels, 102,190 lbs. ; total engine,
200,030 Ibti.; total engine and tender, about 340,-
000 lbs.
Tank capacity, water, 7,300 gal.; oil. 3,300 gal.
Tender wheels, dia., 38!^ in.; journals, 5I4 x 10 in.
Railroad Equipment.
The following facts and figures were
gleaned from the Interstate Commerce
Commission's recent report:
On June 30, 1902, there were 41,228
locomotives in the service of the rail-
ways, which was 1,644 more than were in
use in 1901. Of the total number of lo-
comotives, 10,318 are classed as passen-
ger locomotives, 23,594 as freight loco-
motives, 6,683 as switching locomotives,
the remainder, 633, not being classified.
— ■-•.^-*
ATI^.'VNTIC TYPE, OIL BURNING COMPOUND FOR THE SOUTHERN PACIFIC.
ried is 200 lbs., and this with other data
gives a calculated tractive effort of about
21,700 lbs. The piston valve gear is
driven by indirect motion in the usual
way. The diameter of the carrying
wheels is 54^4 ins., and they and the
driving wheels are equalized together.
The boiler is of the extended wagon
type and is 66 ins. at the smokebox end.
The dome course is 82 ins., and the cir-
cular back head is 76 ins. The boiler is
supplied with a Vanderbilt Corrugated
firebox arranged for burning oil. There
are 346 tubes, each 16 feet long. The
total heating surface is 3,038 sq. ft. The
furnace is 63 ins. diameter by 117V2 in^.
long, and has an ordinary fire door. Be-
low the fire door is small circular open-
ing for the oil injector.
The tender is of the semi-circular sec-
tion adopted for oil burners by the
grate or ash pan gives this engine a
clearcut appearance at the back and the
general design suggests a "high-stepper."
The cab is made of steel plate and the
window arrangement looks as if the com-
fort for the engineer had been taken into
consideration.
A few of the principal dirriensions are
appended for reference:
Boiler, type, e.x. wagon top ; dia., 66 in.; thick-
ness of sheets. \^ in. and ->i in.; working pres-
sure, 200 lbs.; fuel. oil.
Firebox, Vanderbilt corrugated; thickness of tube
sheet, M in.; tubes, material, steel; wire gauge,
.125 M. M.; No. 346; dia., 2 in.; length, 16 ft.
Heating surface, firebox, 155.0 sq. ft.; tubes, 2.S.S3sq.
ft. ; total, 3,038 sq. ft.
Driving wheels, dia. outside, 70 in.; journals, gx
12 iu.: engine truck wheels (front), dia., 36 '4 in.
Journals. 6 x 10 in.; carr>-iug wheels, dia., 545^ in.
Journals, 85^ x 12 in.; wheel base, dri\-ing. 6 ft. 10
in.; rigid, 15 ft.; total engine, 31 ft. 3W in.;totaI
engine and tendel, 65 ft. j54 in.
The total number of cars of all classes
in the service of the railways on the same
date was 1.640,220, there having been an
increase of 89.387 in rolling stock of this
class. Of the total number of cars. 36,-
991 are assigned to the passenger service.
1,546,132 to the freight service, and 57,-
097 to the direct service of the railways.
The foregoing figures do not include cars
owned by private companies.
The report shows that the railways of
the United States used on an average 206
locomotives and 8,195 ears per 1,000
miles of line, that 62,985 passengers were
carried, and 1,908,310 passenger miles ac-
complished per passenger locomotive,
and that 50,874 tons of freight were car-
ried, and 6,666,499 ton miles accomplished
per freight locomotive. Embracing in
the term "equipment" both locomotives
and cars, it is noted that the total equip-
ment of railways at the end of the vear
346
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
August, 1903.
was 1,681,448. Of this number, 1,306,849
were fitted with train bral<es, the in-
crease in this item being 142,801, and i,-
648,535 were fitted with automatic coup-
lers, the increase being 98,695. Nearly all
locomotives and cars in the passenger ser-
vice were fitted with train brakes, and of
10,318 locomotives assigned to that service
9,462 were fitted with automatic couplers.
Practically all passenger cars were fitted
with automatic couplers. Regarding
freight equipment, it is observed that
nearly all freight locomotives were
equipped with train brakes and 94 per
cent, of them with automatic couplers.
Of 1,546,132 cars in the freight service,
1,204,929 were fitted with train brakes
and 1,520,997 with automatic couplers.
Training an Artist in tlie Forces of
Nature.*
BY E. H. MULLIN.
If we go back in the history of our
language to the first known use of the
present either the jaded palates of a
worn-out race, or the capricious appe-
tites of spoiled children. Instead of the
educational roast and boiled joints of our
forefathers, we toy with highly seasoned
entrees which blunt our appetites for the
time being, but do not give us the
strength for long fasts, the energy for
great work, or the physical repose neces-
sary for deep thought.
We shall find, if we keep the idea of
assimilation as the primary attribute of
all education, that the physical and men-
tal analogies are reasonably close and
hardly, if at all, misleading. Mental
indigestion from over-stuffing, no less
than physical indigestion, produces
cloudiness of the brain. Mental dyspep-
sia may follow a diet of too large a
variety of elective courses, just as physi-
cal dyspepsia may follow over-indulgence
in highly spiced but non-assimilative
foods. In both cases time is an indis-
pensable factor to assimilation; plain
food will be most enduring in results;
and without comprehension, is simply a
machine tool in the hands of a higher
order of intelligence. When Mr. Car-
negie claimed for himself only the power
of acting as a magnet for much abler
men, he either meant much more than
he said, or said much more than he
meant. To utilize ability, to turn it into
its proper channels, to mark the time
and place when and where one kind ot
specialized mind should begin and where
it should stop to allow the next special-
ized mind to take up the running, i^
the function of true greatness. The gen-
eral in command of armies, the states
man responsible for a party, the captain
of industry with success or failure hang-
ing upon his decision, asks no more than
that the subordinate whom he chooses
can convert his ideas into action. "Be
bold, be bold, be not too bold," said the
ancient sage. "Specialize, specialize, but
don't specialize too much," says his mod-
ern analogue.
Capital, modern economists are agreed.
3 Hole with dry /Vpe.
Opening 7"x 19"
BOILER OF SOUTHERN PACIFIC ENGINE WITH VANDERBILT FIREBO.X
Railiea]/ f Iiocvmotim Bnginmi ing
word "education," we find that in 1540
it had as its meaning "the process of
nourishing or rearing a child or young
person." It will be noticed that in this
case, as in so many others, a term which
may now be regarded as meaning some-
thing abstract and psychological is de-
rived by metaphorical extension from an
earlier concrete and physical concept.
Yet if the word "education" has gained
in breadth since its first use four and
a half centuries ago, it has also lost much
in depth — at least as commonly used.
The essence of the word "nourishing"
is assimilation; it conveys the idea of
the food which is most easily converted
into life-giving blood, and thence, with
hardly a pause, into nerves, bones and
muscles, to become an inseparable part
of our bodies. For one reason or an-
other, we seem to have passed beyond
the stage of a simple educational diet
which can be thoroughly assimilated; we
♦ This paper was read at the Convention of the
Institute of Electrical En^neens, held at Niagara
Falls in June. Mr. MuUin is an official of the
Genera! Electric Company.
maximum efficiency will be found in
maximum assimilation and minimum
waste. Fixed habits are perhaps the
most valuable gift we can receive,
whether from home rearing, from college
training, or from that first part of our
lives passed in the world of men. Yet
granted that we have taken a firm hold
of essentials, we may pursue cognate
non-essentials as an enlightening means
of recreation. Every author has his his-
torical background; every science has its
borderland; every art has its path of
development. Knowledge is the result
of profound study; culture is the reward
of diligent exploration. With knowledge
alone we are as flatlanders, realizing our
neighbors only when we touch them; by
the aid of culture we can rise above our
surroundings, and, by viewing the rela-
tion of our neighbors to each other, form
a juster estimate of our relation to them.
For, in our realization of our true
relationship to the whole of the outer
world lies the benefit of our education.
The pure specialist, without sympathy
is the crystallized savings which can be
lent out to reproduce itself in useful
work. It is, in fact, stored energy. In
its baldest form, capital represents the
wheat saved from last year's crop to
enable the laborer to garner next year's
crop without dying of starvation while
next year's crop is growing. In its
broadest sense, education is not capital
but tools. It is not the knowledge of
facts which makes a man educated, but
the possession of method. To teach a
man to learn how to learn is the true
function of education, and to stuff his
mind with facts beyond this point is
merely to encumber him in pursuing his
means of livelihood. It is true that the
method of education adopted may, and
perhaps should, bear some relation to
ultimate ends. The future classical
scholar will save himself much annoy-
ance by a diligent study of Greek irregu-
lar verbs. The future mechanical or
electrical engineer will enjoy an ease,
not otherwise procurable, by a thorough
mastery of elementary mathematics.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
347
But, still, education is not so much in-
tended for the elucidation of old prob-
lems as for the tackling of those that
are new. And, as a knowledge of facts
without the power of ratiocination is
worthless for new ventures, and as every
problem which meets us in life is a new
venture, therefore, method by itself is
everything, and facts by themselves are
nothing.
The faults of technical education of the
present day are that they tend to repro-
duce a microcosm of real life. Every-
one has heard of, or has seen, a typical
specimen of the "tank drama," in which
there is real water, real horses, a real
,fire engine, or what not, lo heighten the
verisimilitude. The technical colleges
■which attempt to make a blacksmith or
a mechanic out of a student, fail, just as
■.the "tank dramas" do, by endeavoring
to make their courses a miniature copy
of future work instead of making them
itypical of crisis and illustrative of prin-
ciples. Let us glance for a moment al
the two great professions where educa-
tion, as commonly understood, utterly
fails to supply a man with the power of
•commanding success. It will be acknowl-
edged that painting is an art which re-
•quires initiation and instruction. Yet,
without genius, without inspiration, even
the most skilful painters have been un-
able to rise above the ranks of medi-
ocrity. The Italians call Andrea del
Sarto "the faultless painter." But, as
Symonds says, he lacked inspiration,
■depth of emotion, energy of thought.
and cannot therefore take rank among
the great Renaissance painters. Or take
again the two typical cases of the Arch-
duke Charles and Major General Halleck.
■for both of whom it may be claimed
they were bright and shining examples
of profound technical education in the
military art. The genius of Napoleon,
not a particularly distinguished student,
overthrew with ease the strategy of the
Archduke Charles, while all that Hal-
leck's technical knowledge seemed to be
able to do for him was to point out every
possibility of defeat without inspiring
him to a single means of victory. More
recently we have seen Sir John French,
the only really successful cavalry general
of the South African War, overthrow in
the field the reputation which the pedants
of Aldershot gave him of not being able
to handle a cavalry brigade.
We may gather from these examples,
and from others which will occur to the
minds of every one, that all that tech-
nical education can do is to give each
man his chance of success or failure.
Genius may be able to dispense alto-
gether with technical education; inherent
stupidity will ultimately sink to its true
level, in spite of the most careful colle-
giate training. In considering educa-
tional matters, therefore, we are con-
cerned not with geniuses or with mud-
dle heads, but with average men. How
the average man may be trained for a
profession for which he feels within him-
self some aptitude is the question which
it behooves us to answer. And the
answer which we should give is to teach
methods, to instill principles, to lay deep
and sure the foundation of elementary
knowledge, and trust the future to take
care of itself. We have, therefore, two
co-related branches of education to con-
sider— education as an art and education
as a science.
Education as an art involves perfect
familiarity with a larger or smaller num-
ber of facts, according to the purpose to
which these are to be devoted. In this
age of universal reading and writing we
are apt somewhat too hastily to assume
that a categorical knowledge of the al-
phabet and the arithmetical tables is
necessary to success in life. Those who
having more pieces than the one pre-
ceding it, and each set of pieces having
more complex moves than the set pre-
ceding it, we shall have a fair analogy
of the gamut of education as an art,
from simple elementary education to the
highest classical or mathematical stand-
ard. Throughout this series there are
things to be known by name — what may
be called primary concepts — and these
mere names have to be clothed with
ideas or attributes or functions, by means
of which we may see how far we can
utilize them. In other words, in educa-
tion as an art we have to exercise the
faculty of memory, and this memory
must be clear and accurate if our minds
are always to have their tools at hand
ready for instant use. But this in turn
implies familiarity and familiarity implies
constant practice for a longer or shorter
time. Here again our average educa-
A SOUTHERN PIpNEER. RECEIVED FROM T. KEPLER JOHN.SON, CONTRACTING
FREIGHT AGENT OF THE ILLINOIS CENTRAL, WHO PHOTOGRAPHED
THE ENGINE AT JACKSONVILLE, FLA.
have lived in countries where a consid-
erable portion of the population is wholly
illiterate must have often been struck
by hearing men who could not read use
language all but grammatically correct,
or by observing intricate accounts made
up by mental arithmetic without the aid
of either multiplication or division. It
must also be remembered that in the
Dark Ages kings and bards were usually
illiterate, though they were none the less
the rulers and inspirers of their times.
Education as an art, therefore, must be
separated from personality on the one
hand and from mere pedantry on the
other. We may compare education as
an art to a knowledge of the names and
functions of the pieces on a chessboard
divorced from any knowledge of the
game of chess itself. If we can then
imagine a series of chessboards, each
tion for the average man comes in. If
we have in mind only the first 25 per
cent, of our pupils^the geniuses and
the hard-reading men — we shall pass
along to the next stage before our 50
per cent, of average men have had time
to become perfectly familiar with the
facts and their connotations which are
being studied. If, on the other hand,
we attempt to wait until the last 25 per
cent, of our pupils — the incorrigibly idle
and muddle-heads — we shall waste the
time of our 50 per cent, of average men.
In every stage of education as an art
we have therefore two things to con-
sider, namely, the accumulation of a suffi-
cient number of names and their con-
notations to give us an ample nomen-
clature or set of tools, and also enough
familiarity with this nomenclature or set
34»
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
of tools to enable us instinctively to select
the right tool and to use it el'ticiently.
Let us now pass to education as a
science. A man might know the dic-
tionary from end to end, and yet not be
able to use more than one thousand
words of it for any particular purpose.
Having obtained our tools through edu-
cation as an art, the problem in educa-
tion as a science is not to use them as
we have been taught but to apply them
to new problems. To go back to our
former illustration we must be able to
play the game of chess after having
learned the names of tlie pieces and their
functions. It took the world 2,000 years
to find out that deductive logic could
state nothing new beyond what was con-
tained in the premises. Science, we are
told, is organized and classified knowl-
edge, and the first thing a truly edu-
cated man will do with a new fact is to
place it under its proper classification —
that is, he will refer it to the principle
which governs facts of a similar kind.
Not only, therefore, is metnory needed
here but imagination. A man's whole
education goes for nothing if in dealing
with a new fact he cannot see resem-
blances in it to other facts where none
outwardly exist, or cannot see profound
differences between a new fact and an
old one where the outward resemblance
is strong. And the highest function of
education as a science is to make a man
of average ability see resemblances and
differences in cases where he would
otherwise be blind. Indeed, genius it-
self, as we see it in the great inventors,
is usually nothing more than the power
of classifying a fact under its proper
generalization and then re-stating it in
terms of some other fact classed under
'the same head.
Rising stage by stage, therefore, ac-
cording to the future for which our edu-
cational requirements are to fit us is
our elementary knowledge plus perfect
familiarity in dealing with and handling
it. Better, far better, that we should
know little but be on terms of perfect
familiarity with that little, than we should
know nnich and have to grope for what
should spring to our minds as quick as
thought itself. The time spent, the labor
involved, in obtaining an absolute mas-
tery over our primary concepts or ele-
mentary knowledge marks the difference
in our future work between having
strange tools to handle and having tools
which so fit into our hands as to become
an inseparable part of ourselves.
Let us turn now to the education "of
an engineer. The definition of an engi-
neer, according to Brunei, is one who
applies the forces of nature to the service
of man. Mr. Mansergh. recently Presi-
dent of the Institution of Civil Engineers,
quoted with approval an American defini-
tion of an engineer as "a man who
could do for one dollar what any fool
could do ior two dollars." Perhaps the
best definition will lie somewhere be-
tween these extremes. If a man does
not know how to apply at least one form
of the forces of nature to the service
of man he is not an engineer; and if
he cannot do this more economically
than an outsider no capitalist with com-
mon sense will employ him. An engi-
neer differs from a physician or a lawyer
in that patients die and cases are lost
without damaging the reputation of a
member of either of these professions,
while, on the other hand, an engineer's
work must speak for itself. The motto
over Sir Christopher Wren's tomb in
St. Paul's might be adopted as that of
the engineering profession as a whole,
"Si monumenium requiris circumspice ."
Posterity camps on the trail of the engi-
neer, and its conclusions, like the judg-
ments of the Lord, are true and righteous
altogether. Whether it be the aque-
duct of Rome or the Brooklyn Bridge,
whether it be a generator at Niagara
Falls or the switchboard of a New
York power station, it will either form
a model from which other genera-
tions of engineers will expand into new
conceptions to meet new needs, or it
will become a beacon post to point out
the way which is to be avoided. Verily,
it is no light thing to train up an artist
in the forces of Nature!
Let us begin with the prime essential.
Without reverence for great works and
for the great men by whose agency they
were brought forth, there will be no
great engineers. Granted that, a sound
knowledge of one's native tongue is the
best substructure. The great engineers
who have been deprived of this aid, have
borne eloquent testimony by their efforts
at self-improvement in later life to what
they considered would have been its use-
fulness at an earlier period of their
careers. An elementary knowledge of
Latin is most indispensable to the clari-
fication and consolidation of the knowl-
edge of nearly every European tongue.
Next to these my vote would go to a
good working knowledge of French be-
cause besides its obvious advantage as
a language to be spoken, it imparts
lucidity and precision to writing— a
thing, by the way, which mathematics
often fails to do. Early practice in me-
chanical drawing should also be given
to every boy who feels within himself
the stirrings to become an engineer, be-
cause familiarity with the pencil is easily
acquired early in life, but is often one of
the greatest stumbling blocks when taken
up too late.
Then as to mathematics. As the pro-
fession of an engineer always involves
constant dealing with quantities and
values, he ought to know mathematics
as he knows the currency of his native
country. In other words, he ought to
be able to make change with ease, quick-
ness and accuracy — not as if one were
in a foreign country in a constant state
of painful reckoning. A thorough
knowledge of ordinary mathematics is
here prescribed, not any vain ascents
with crippled wings into the empyrean.
What is meant by "ordinary mathemat-
ics" may perhaps be more clearly in-
dicated by a remark and an anecdote.
One may make accurate change without
any knowledge of the science of num-
bers. Lord Salisbury, when President
jjf the British Association, told the story
of the old Oxford Professor who said
to him, fiercely, "What I like about
quartenions. Sir, is that they cannot be
used for any base utilitarian purpose."
This makes our substructure complete.
The first part of our superstructure
should consist in learning the principles
of the applied sciences. These should
be studied in books, assisted by oral
teaching, and enforced and re-enforced
by the practice of dozens or hundreds
of examples. If one wants to know
how each principle should be learned,
he should watch a great singing teacher
train a pupil. A false note in a scale
demands a hundred perfect repetitions.
A false note in an aria means back to
the scale for a hundred more repetitions
before attacking the aria a second time.
Why should the future artist in Nature
be less carefully prepared for his work?
Is that work likely to be less important?
or is it merely because his future au-
dience is less likely to detect a false note?
With this, the education, of our engi-
neer ends or rather begins. He may
be fifteen, sixteen or any age. He may
have studied in school, or in college, or
at home. He is, however, a trained en-
gineering soul, according to the measure
of his talents. He is able to learn the
art of engineering, or any other art, for
which he has an aptitude, in months,
where another man of equal ability might
take years and not know it half so thor-
oughly. All he needs to ensure his suc-
cess in life is to find a master who can
utilize his powers.
The Baldwin Record of Recent Con-
struction, No. 43, has just come to hand.
It contains many interesting locomotives,
among which may be mentioned two ten-
wheel engines for the St. Louis & San
Francisco, with wheels counter-balanced
after the Davis method. A Mikado or
2-8-2 engine for the Atchison, Topeka &
Santa Fe. A compound consolidation
with tank for oil and water for the
Southern Pacific. This engine has a
tank which is semi-circular in section, it
was illustrated in our April issue. A
compound ten-wheel engine with Van^
derbilt tender and a compound consoli-
dation with Vanderbilt tender for the
Oregon short line. A simple consolida-
tion for the Ferro Carrill Nacional de
Tehuantepec, and several others.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3-49
Consolidation Engine for tlie Illinois
Central.
The Schenectady shops of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company have recently
supphed the IHinois Central with some
2-8-0 engines which weigh in working
order about 188,000 pounds. The cylin-
ders are simple 20x28 ins. and the driv-
ing wheels are 56^/2 ins. With 200 pounds
steam pressure, the engine can develop
a calculated tractive power of about
26,350 pounds. The adhesive weight is
estimated at 163,000 pounds.
These engines have all the wheels
flanged except the main drivers, and
with long connecting rod the counterbal-
ancing on this pair of wheels is neces-
sarily heavy. The crosshead is made for
two guide bars with the upper bar lipped
so as to cover top of crosshead and keep
bar and cross head side flush. The valve
gear is of the regular indirect connected
type and the valves themselves are the
ordinary D-slide, balanced. The engine
truck and front driver are equalized to-
Cylindcrs — 20 x 28 in.; size of .steam ports, 20X t'A
in.; size of exliaiist ports. 20 x j in.; size of
bridges, 1)4 in.
Valves— Greatest travel of sli<le valves, 6 in.; out-
side lap of slide valves, i in.
Wheels, etc. — Dia of driving wheels outside of
tire, 56 J4 in.; driving box material, cast Btccl.
Holler — Outside dia. of first ring, 6y^^ in.; working
pressure, 203 lbs.
Kirebox— length, 108 in.; width, 72 in.; depth,
front, 72j^ in.; bacU. 62^i in.; plates, thickness,
sides, ^ in.; back, ^^ in.; crown, /„ in.; tube
sheet, yg in.; water space, .1 in. front; 4 in.
side; 4 in, back; crown staying, radial.
Tube.s — material and gauge. No. 11 B. W. G.; num-
ber, 335; dia., 2 in.; length. 14 ft. 7 in.
Heating surface— tubes, 2,539.3 sq. ft.; firetrox,
170 1 sq. ft.; total. 2,709.4 sq, ft.; grate surface,
54.0 sq. ft.
Smokestack — inside dia , r8J^ in.; top above rail,
15 ft. i'A in-
Tender — weight, empty, 56,100 lbs.; wheels, dia.,
38 in.; wheel base. 20 ft. 11 in.; tender trucks,
2-4 whl., Fox pressed steel; water capacity.
7.000 V. S. gals : coal capacity, 15 tons.
flaking Light of a Heavy Train.
An engineer came into the big repair
shop on the Rock Ballast & No Dust
Railway the other day and began boast-
was said the effect was the same at each
station. The baggage was all brought
out and piled on a truck just on the very
spot where the baggage car door would
come, and when the train stopped the
station baggageman called loudly for as-
sistance and tackled the trunks with in-
tention. The station agent perhaps lent
a hand, and before the train was well
stopped the conductor was on the
ground yelling "all aboard!" and the
brakeman had helped passengers off and
others on, and the train mail followed the
last trunk in with a rush and there was a
general air of hum and go about the sta-
tion which contrasted oddly with the de-
liberate actions of the men on the pre-
ceding and following train when they
had occasion to do business there.
"Oh, yes," said the engineer in con-
clusion, "the hidden accelerator in the
G. M.'s car is great, it fairly beats the
band, it can push you through on time
against a heavy head wind and against
conditions where a double header would
nE.\VY CONSOLIDATION ENGINE FOR THE ILLINOIS CENTRAL.
gether, and the three rear drivers are
equalized together. There are also two
main reservoirs for air.
The boiler is an extension wagon-top
one. with smokebox course measuring 66
in. inside diameter. The dome is circular,
but the opening cut through the boiler
course upon which it rests is oval, wjjth
center placed one inch forward of the
dome center. The heating surface
amounts to 2,709.4 sq. ft., of which the
tubes supply 2,539.3 sq. ft. The crown
sheet slopes slightly toward the back, and
the roof sheet slopes 6 inches toward the
back sheet, which is vertical. The grate
area is 54 sq. ft.
The tank is carried on a 12-in. steel
channel frame, and with its water bottom
can contain 7,000 gallons. The coal space
is made with sloping sides and a bulk-
head front, so that 15 tons may be car-
ried. A few of the leading dimensions
are given below:
Wght. eng. and tend, in working order, 332.450 lbs.
Wheel base, driv.. 16 ft.; wheel base. tot.. 24 ft. Sin.
wheel base, tot., eng. and tend , 57 ft. 4J4 in.
ing about the fast time he had made last
week on passenger, pulling an extra
coach. When asked for particulars as
he expected and wished to be, he ex-
plained that the extra coach was the gen-
eral manager's private car. He said he
had not increased the tractive effort of
the locomotive one particle, and that the
ratio of tractive power to adhesive
weight was just as it always had been,
but that the G. M.'s car had a sort of
a mysterious, secret, automatic accelera-
ting apparatus hidden away in it some-
where which always produced "results."
Although hauling that car added perhaps
some 100.000 lbs. to the weight of the
regular train, yet it diminished the delay
at stations, as much as side doors would
on a suburban train.
When the hidden accelerator got in
its fine work, it caught all the telegraph
operators along the line and they, one
after the other, telegraphed ahead some
such expression as the "G. M. on No. 5."
or "I. C. Thruer's car's on 5." or
"Thruer's going through," but whatever
stall, for it's continuous in its action at
each station and awful powerful, and it
never gets out of repair."
Chemistry of Coal.
Prof. S. W. Parr, of the University of
Illinois, has just succeeded in devising a
method for the determination of the
• amount of sulphur occurring in coal. As
the coals of this State contain from one
to five per cent, of sulphur, and that ele-
ment indicates the amount of clinker, this
new process is bound to be extremely
valuable. Prof. Parr has also discovered
a means of arriving at the total amount
of carbon in coal and other combustibles,
a matter of the highest importance to op-
erating engineers, who need to know pre-
cisely how much energy a given fuel
ought to yield.
The calorimeter, which Prof. Parr in-
vented a few years ago, is to-day uni-
versally used in the mines, factories and
technical schools of this country and has
been widely adopted in foreign countries.
— Press Bulletin Unirersity of Illinois.
350
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
( Continued from page SO4. )
COLONEL long's FIRST LOCOMOTIVE.
In 1830 Colonel Long, president of
the .American Steam Carriage Co., built
in Philadelphia a locomotive which had
a boiler with a combustion chamber
in the middle, but otherwise it resembled
the improved English locomotives. In
working order the engine weighed about
8,000 pounds. It was tried very e.xhaus-
tively on the Newcastle & Frenchtown
Railroad, but its performance resem-
bled that of a pioneer Scotch locomo-
tive, which the builders wished to rec-
ommend through the influence of Napier,
a celebrated engineer. Napier had been
invited to witness the test of the loco-
motive which had been designed by an
ambitious amateur. The promoters of
the engine succeeded in bringing Napier
into the presence of capitalists; but when
the attempt was made to have the engi-
neer testify in favor of the engine's per-
formance nothing was forthcoming but
a succession of protesting grunts. Los-
ing patience the inventor exclaimed.
"You must admit that you saw the en-
gine running." "You may call that run-
ning," replied Napier, who stuttered.
"all I saw was you fellows sho-sho-
shovin' her."
The trials of Long's engine were a
succession of failures because the boil-
er would not make the steam required
I believe that was the first engine with
a combustion chamber, the most decep-
tive device ever applied to a locomotive
boiler. A designer could prove by the
most convincing reasoning that a com-
bustion chamber must improve the
steaming properties of a boiler and
eflfect saving of fuel, but experience has
always proved it to have the opposite
effect.
LONG & NORRIS' "bLACK HAWK."
Col. Long was by no means dis-
couraged by the failure of his first lo-
comotive, but entered very cheerfully
with William Norris into what was in-
tended to be a permanent business of
building locomotives. The records now
to be found concerning the early loco-
motives built by Long & Norris are very
meager. Their first engine which they
built was called the "Black Hawk." It
was designed by Col. Long and was an
extraordinary production. The designer
aimed at novelty and succeeded in mak-
ing a locomotive different from anything
built before or since. There was
not then much of a beaten path
in locomotive designing, and what
there was he disdained to follow. He
proposed burning hard coal by natural
draft only, and employed an unusually
high chimney which could be lowered
when passing under bridges. Later on
he made the chimney telescopic and ob-
tained a patent on the invention.
The boiler was peculiar and consisted
of two cylinders, about 20 inches di-
ameter, secured side by side (as was also
done by Horatio Allen) and forming the
roof of a detachable firebox which had
water sides but no crown except that
formed by the bottom of the twin boil-
ers. A notch was cut half way through
these two cylinders on their lower half
diameters, about midway of the length
of the firebox, directly over the fire,
and from these notches flues about two-
inches diameter and about seven feet
long, passed through the water space of
each cylinder portion of the boiler to
the smokebox. The fire gases had an-
other passage besides the flues, for a
channel was provided to let them flow
under the boilers to the smokebox.
The engine was carried on four wheels
and had inside cylinders with crank axle.
A cam cut-off, then greatly in favor on
the engines of river steamers, was used.
The Long & Norris engines were not
much in demand in the first few years
MATTHIAS W, BALDWIN.
of the firm's history. Col. Long retired
in 1834 and William Norris brought en-
gineering skill into the concern that
greatly changed the reputation and
worth of the engines built.
THE JAMES LOCOMOTIVE.
When Philadelphia was stirred up with
•locomotive designing schemes in 1832, a
candidate for honors as a locomotive
designer and builder was busy in New
York. This was William T. James, who
built the sixth peripatetic engine turned
out of his shop, which was a most re-
markable engine in some respects. An
authentic drawing of this engine has
been preserved, and its reproduction is
shown in Fig. 29. As will be seen, the
engine was carried on an oblong wood-
en frame, resting upon four wheels.
The boiler was upright after the Balti-
more & Ohio fashion, for which it was
intended, but it had no flues, the prin-
cipal heating surface being in the fire-
box. The cylinders, 10 x 10 inches in
front, were set at an angle of 30 degrees
and transmitted the power through a
supplementary shaft which engaged with
the driving axle by gears of two sizes
that were intended to increase the power
or the speed as required in the same
way that automobiles are now con-
structed.
The striking feature of the engine was
the reversing gear which was the link
motion, operated by two fi.\ed eccen-
trics, the link being afterward lost sight
of and reinvented ten years subsequent-
ly by William Howe^ a workman in the
works of Robert Stephenson & Co.,
Newcastle. There is no question that
the link was first invented by James and
that he understood its peculiarity of
varying the point of cut-off, an action
which was first discovered when they
were setting the valves. The writer has
frequently talked with Samuel B.
Dougherty, who was foreman in the
James shop and an intelligent helper and
adviser, concerning the construction and
designing of pioneer railroad machinery.
Dougherty lived till about 1890.
DIVERSITY AMONG PIONEER LOCOMOTIVES.
In 1832 it looked as if there would
be as much diversity in the general ap-
pearance of locomotive engines as- there
were in the marine engines up to that
time. No locomotive had appeared in
America to set the fashion as the Rocket
did in Europe. Cooper's Tom Thumb
had vertical engine and boiler, so it was
natural that the type should have imi-
tators, although a vertical engine, more
especially a vertical boiler, was not
adapted to a moving engine.
The first locomotive built for practi-
cal work, the Best Friend, had a verti-
cal boiler, but the second engine built
under the same supervision, the West
Point, had a horizontal boiler, and the
Baltimore & Ohio made their standard
locomotives for years with upright
boilers. The DeWitt Clinton, the
third locomotive built by the West
Point Foundry Company, had a hori-
zontal boiler, but nothing about it
indicated that the designer was not
original in his ideas. There were five
locomotives, built for the purpose of
competing for the reward offered by the
Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Company,
and none of them had any resemblance
to each other, the only common grounds
of all designs being that they had boil-
ers for steam generation and mechanism
through which it was intended that the
steam should produce locomotion, al-
though it did not always accomplish
that.
Baldwin's "miller" established a na-
tional TYPE.
Confusion and uncertainty reigned
among locomotive designers as to the
fittest form such an engine ought to
have, until Baldwin built his second en-
gine in 1834. There were freaks after-
ward brought forth that departed radi-
cally from the design of the "E. L. Mil-
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
351
ler," but they exerted no influence on
the development of the American loco-
motive. The American locomotive of
to-day was developed directly from the
E. L. Miller, just as certainly as a huge
oak tree grows up from the small acorn.
An engraving of the E. L. Miller ap-
pears in our April numher, page 164.
The leading features are a horizontal
boiler with Kury's haystack firebox, one
pair of (IriviiiK vvhoi-ls. located behind
ner, among which may be ■ mentioned
Stephenson's Rocket, the consolidation
safety valve, all modern injectors and
sight-feed lubricators.
Baldwin's driving wheels.
The leading policy which Mr. Bald-
win adhered to, as a locomotive builder,
was to reproduce the same general form
of engine and to effect improvements on
details. The pioneer railroad companies
had experienced much annoyance from
FIG. 28. THK JOHN HUM, OI'' TIIK CAMDKN & AMBOV RAILROAD.
the firebox, a four-wheel swiveling
truck under the smokebox, and outside
wooden frames sheathed with iron
plates. The cylinders, lo x 16 inches,
are secured between the smokebox and
frames, and transmit the power to th':
driving wheels through a half-crank
axle. Fig. 30. This is a decided im-
provement in crank axles, for the wheel
is made to form one side of the axle,
thereby materially strengthening what
had come to be considered a weak mem-
ber of inside-connected locomotives.
The engine weighed in working order
about 16,600 pounds.
BALDWIN'S VALVE GEAR.
The valve motion was given by a sin-
gle fixed eccentric for each cylinder.
Each eccentric strap had two arms at-
tached to it, one above and the other
below, and, as the driving axle was back
of the firebox, these arms were pro-
longed backward under the footboard,
with a hook on the inner side of the end
of each. The rocking shaft had arms
above and below its axis, and the hooks
of the two rods of each eccentric were
moved by hand levers so as to engage
with either arm, thus producing forward
or backward motion. This form of
single eccentric, which was peculiar to
the Baldwin engines, was preferred in
the interest of simplicity in the working
parts and was used for many years.
The E. L. Miller had very little that
was decidedly original, but old forms
were combined in a shape that produced
the best locomotive engine then built.
Many other highly successful inventions
have been worked out in a similar man-
the driving wheels failing. Baldwin in-
vented a wheel. Fig. 31, in which the
hub and spokes were of cast iron, cast
together. The spokes were cast without
a rim, and terminated in segment flanges,
each spoke having a separate flange dis-
connected from the others. By this
means the injurious effects of unequal
expansion and contraction was prevent-
GROUND PIPE JOINTS.
One of the most valuable invention*
which Mr. Baldwin introduced early in
his career, was ground pipe joints. All
other locomotive builders made joints
of canvas and red lead, which were
continually blowing out, causing annoy-
ing delay and materially increasing the
cost of maintenance. The trouble with
the steam joints prevented the English
builders from carrying more than 60 or
70 pounds boiler pressure without danger
to the joints, while the Baldwin engines
were carrying 120 pounds without trou-
ble. The red lead joints gave so much
trouble with three English engines on
the Pennsylvania State Railroad that they
had to be sold because the enginemen
refused to run engines that failed so
often.
OUTSIDE TUBE FERRULES.
Another very important improvement
introduced by Mr. Baldwin was in boil-
er tubes, which consisted in driving a
copper ferrule or thimble on the outside
of the end of the tube and soldering it in
place, instead of driving a thimble in-
side the tube end. The new practice
strengthened the end of the tube and
left the inside unobstructed, so that
cinders passed freely out.
TRACTION INCREASER.
Tn iR^4, Mr. E. L. Miller secured a
FIG. 29. ;AMES' ENGINE, 1832.
ed. The flanges bore against wooden
felloes, made in two thicknesses and
put together so as to break joints.
Around the whole the tire was passed
and secured by bolts. This made a good
wheel which held its own until the mold-
er's art advanced sufficiently to cast a
reliable cast iron wheel center.
patent on a traction increaser, which
transferred part of the weight of the
tender upon the driving wheels. Mr.
Baldwin applied this device to many lo-
comotives, and subsequently purchased
the entire right to use the invention.
Among the tentative improvements in-
troduced on Baldwin's early engines.
352
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
were a set of brass tires wliich he sup-
posed would increase the adhesion, but
tliey wore out so rapidly that they were
abandoned for iron. The tires, made by
S. Vail & Sons, Morristown, N. J., the
only American maker, and those import-
ed from England were very thin, only
about I'/i inch. Baldwin ordered a sup-
ply from England three inches thick,
and had very great difficulty in getting
the order filled.
The making of cylindrical pedestals
was early introduced, pedestals and axle
boxes having been finished on a lathe.
a method which was cheap and ensured
a proper fit. Chilled wheels were intro-
duced as a means of increasing the dur-
ability of the engines.
Good workmanship and attention to
much less -repairs, either to the engine
or the track than any other engine.
(To be continued.)
Drawbar and Buffer Attachments for
Use Between Engine and^Tender.
Mr. Henry Bartlctt, superintendent of
motive power of the Boston & Maine,
presented an individual paper at the re-
cent meeting of the Master Mechanics'
Association on drawbar attachments be-
tween engine and tender. Mr. Bartlett
in his opening remarks quoted Mr. W.
H. Marshall to the effect that "it is
found, out on the road with a skilful
engineer on an engine that the tensile
and buffing stresses seldom exceed 50,-
000 lbs. and 80,000 lbs., respectively; with
FIG. 30. H.\LF CK.\NK.
the engine, and from suggestions made
by numerous motive power officials, it
would seem reasonable to recommend
that the working stress should be 4,000
lbs. per square inch of section for straight
drawbars. When large offsets occur,
concessions in the factor of safety must
be made, and in such cases it would be
rcaonable to set 12,000 lbs. per sq. in.
as the maximum permissible limit.
Using 28.000 lbs. per sq in., as the prob-
able ultimate strength for repeated
stresses of tension, this would indicate
that the strength of the drawbar is from
7 times to 2 J times the tractive power
of the engine.
Considering the bufling feature or the
compressive stresses Mr. Bartlett said
that no form of spring buffer had proved
thoroughly successful. He questioned
the soundness of the principle upon which
this form of design now stands. The
presence of the spring means a space
between engine and tender, and as the
spring is inadequate the space simply be-
comes "slack" or just that much lost mo-
tion. He thought we should bend our en-
ergies toward the production of a design
which would eliminate this lost motion.
One suggestion was to use some form nf
coupler after the fashion of the M. C.
B. vertical plane device, modified to suit
engine and tender.
FIG. .31. BALDWIN'S IMPROVED DRIVING WHEELS.
details made the Baldwin locomotives
unusually popular. Mr. L. A Sykes,
engineer of the New Jersey Transporta-
tion Company, wrote, in 1838, that he
could draw with his engine twenty, four-
wheeled cars with twenty-six passengers
each, at a speed of twenty to twenty-
five miles per hour over grades of twen-
ty-six feet per mile. As to simplicity of
construction, small liability to get out
of order, economy of repairs and ease
to the road, Baldwin's engines stand un-
rivaled. He considered the simplicity
of the engine, the arrangement of the
working parts, and the distribution of
weight, far superior to any engine he
had ever seen, either of American or
English manufacture. Had no hesita-
tion in saying that the Baldwin engine
will do the same amount of work with
a less skilful engineer, however, the
stresses increased to about 70,000 lbs.
and 150,000 lbs., respectively."
The fundamental elements, Mr. Bart-
lett says, of a drawbar attachment be-
tween engine and tender are essentially
three: (i) The drawbar itself, which re-
ceives the tensile stresses. (2) The
buffers or chafing irons, which receive
the stresses of compression or impact.
(3) The safety device which comes into
play only in case of failure of the draw-
bar.
An examination of the designs used
on a good many roads revealed the fact
that uniformity of practice has not been
brought about, nor, in general, has suffi-
cient capacity been provided for modern
requirements. From a table prepared
by the writer, showing relative strength
of the drawbars and tractive power of
Electric riotors for the Baltimore &
Ohio.
After considerable unexpected delay
two electric motors built by the General
Electric Co., at their shops in Schenec-
tady, for the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road have been delivered. They are in-
tended to operate the railroad com-
pany's tunnel at Baltimore and are re-
markably powerful motors. They weigh
75 tons each and develop 1,500 horse-
power when working slowly on a heavy
pull. Their tractive power is sufficient
to pull the drawbar out of any car made.
They are built so that every part is inter-
changeable and can be supplied from
stock kept on hand for the purpose.
It is very fitting that the Baltimore &
Ohio should be the first steam railroad
to employ electric motors for regular
traction purposes, for the first electric
locomotive ever built was run on the
Baltimore & Ohio. That was in 1851.
Dr. Page, of Baltimore, was the inven-
tor. It was a four-wheeled motor and
made several trips successfully, but the
inventor's ideas were ahead of his time
and the project was abandoned for want
of public support.
The Rogers Locomotive Works of Pat-
erson filed a certificate in the Secretary
of State's office last month increasing its
capital stock from $1,600,000 to $2,000,-
000. There are 20.000 shares of stock.
Of these 10.000 shares will be preferred
and 10.000 common.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
353
General Correspondence.
"The Kansas City Flood." what ihc flood did to operating expenses
The views herewith shown of flood for the Kansas City roads!
situation in Kansas City were taken View 4 shows 'Frisco system bridge
June I. after water had subsided some No. i loaded with coal cars. Armour-
four feet, the continued cloudy and dale in the distance, the large buildings,
rainy weather preventing photographers packing houses. This view taken after
FIG. 1. STATE LINE STREET, LOOKING SOUTH
from making photographs when flood
was at its height.
View I shows State Line street look-
ing south from elevated road. When
water was at highest point as shown by
marks on the brick building to right, it
was just level with eaves of box cars,
the current moving at rate of eight miles
per hour causing the accumulation of
debris to left of cars.
Views 2 and 3 show the now famous
''Sante Fe sink hole," which was formed
by counter currents of water meeting
and eddying around several Sante Fe
engines left standing in the yard of
that company. The eddy that formed
this hole, 35 feet deep and covering an
area of about lyi acres circular in shape,
was so vicious as to capsize a skjfif,
drowning one man. The Sante Fe peo-
ple did not know what the hole con-
tained until they pumped it out, finding
five Pullman cars and four engines, one
a switcher, one simple passenger 4-6-0
type, two compound 4-6-2 type, and one
compound consolidation not shown in
views presented.
Behind view 2 can be seen the shops
of the 'Frisco system in which the water
reached a level of 7 ft. I in., leaving
when it receded a mass of refuse, dirt
and slime.
A glance at these pictures will show
water had subsided four feet. \'iew 5
shows the Kaw river pumping sta-
The expanse of water submerging the
Schwarzschild-Sulzberger packing plant
covered the village of Argentine, wreck-
ing thousands of homes, the property
of packing house employees. The flood
from Topeka, supplemented by heavy
and continuous rains, proved too much
for the Kaw river. The mighty Mis-
souri up to and beyond the danger line,
unable to care for this addition, combin-
ing with the lesser Kaw worked havoc
among the many industries that have
gone to make Kansas City what it is.
Among the heavy losers were the Mis-
souri Pacific, Sante Fe, San Francisco,
Rock Island, Burlington and Union
Pacific Companies, and prompt restora-
tion of traffic brought about by stupend-
ous effort on the part of the officials
of the lines centering in Kansas City,
will fill an earnest page in the history
of railroading.
After a flood 7 feet in depth, with a
current ranging from 8 to 14 miles per
hour pouring its avalanche of dirt and
wreckage for days over a yard equipped
with an interlocking plant such as is in
use in Kansas City subsides, there is
work to do and lots of it. The daily
papers spoke of railroad officers who
pumped hand-cars into holes, the water
rising to their breast, searching with
prod poles for bridges that might be
FIG. 2. VIEW OF THE "SANT.^ FE SINK HOLE.'
tion after water had fallen, admitting of
firing boilers. The black smoke was a
welcome sight to a city that had been
for days without w-ater, gas, street cars
or electric lights, in fact in a condition
similar to a city besieged.
gone, one general superintendent walking
into the Union Station for miles ahead
of an engine and train of passengers,
feeling the way foot by foot until the
train stopped in the Union Depot in a
foot of water, the whistles screaming out
354
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
the news that Kansas City was again
part of the great commercial world.
Amusing instances might be recorded,
among which was the unloading of a
car of pineapples by the Superintendent
of Transportation of the Frisco System,
the car submerged to the eaves, the
a few months, but the M. M. had a "pet"
and he set nic back firing. The engineer
(a new man) did not know any more
than I did about setting eccentrics. We
had one get loose and he could not set
it; he tried it twice, but it was no go. I
told him T could set it and not get off the
FIG. 3. THE ".SANT.'i FE SINK HOLE."
I would like to have some one tell me
how I set the eccentric.
Yours truly,
Benj. Garvin.
Here is a venerable old brother en-
gineer, who, in the first days of his rail-
roading, learned something that thou-
sands of engineers since have failed to
acquire.
There are but few locomotive en-
gineers alive to-day who handled the old
"hook motion" engines in the '40s, and
I wish it could be my pleasure to meet
with all the old-time lads and hear the
story of their railroad days. Who of the
readers of Railway and Locomotive
Engineering knows this venerable, aged,
brother, and what brother of his ac-
quaintance can get the history of his early
railroad days and give it to the readers
of your journal? I am not prepared to
voice the sentiment of the thousands of
the readers of the "L. E.," but I am
strongly of the opinion that the biog-
raphy of these old-time brothers would
be intensely interesting to a majority of
the subscribers to one of the best, if not
the best of all railroad periodicals.
J. W. Reading.
freight taken out through holes cut in
the roof and rafted to terra firma; this
gentleman saving the fruit and $500
freight charges. The passing around of
several cars of dressed beef that had
spoiled for want of ice, the railroad
companies compelled to keep it moving
until the packing house people could get
it in their fertilizing tanks.
The first shops to resume operations
were those of the railroads, and in addi-
tion to their own work, the amount of
which was sufificient to appal, they ren-
dered "first aid" to the water company,
the light company and others situated
in the bottoms. Millions of dollars were
lost in this six days' flood that exceeded
even the famous flood of 1844.
Eugene McAuliffe.
foot board, and he said "you can set
hell." The conductor told him to let me
try it, I set it and told him to go under
and tighten set screw, the conductor told
him to set them up and he did it; when
he came out from under engine I moved
her ahead a few rods, then back and
coupled onto train, whistled off brakes
and engine went of? all right.
The engineer was a "Mum" English-
man after that, but I learned to set valves
How Tom Burke Won His Spurs.
BY SHANDY MAGUIRE.
One beautiful moonlit night in August,
a few years ago, Ed Townsend, Tom
Burke and "49" were running down Ar-
cher's grade, with the through freight,
on time. Ed. was using a light throttle,
just enough to keep the links stretched
and the cylinders lubricated. Tom had
a tank of good coal; and he was perched
upon his seat with his back reclining
Setting an Eccentric on a Hook notion
Engine.
I have just received a letter from an
old brother engineer who it seems wrote
me at once after reading my article in
the June number of Railway and Lo-
comotive Engineering on "Slipped Ec-
centrics." Thinking it might interest your
readers I herewith quote the letter in
full.
Fond Du Lac, Wis., June 6, 1903.
J. W. Reading, Dear Sir—
I have just been reading about setting
eccentrics which made me think of old
times. I set a loose eccentric in '47. I
was firing a drop hook "Hinckley," the
first engine with 4 drivers; had a re-
verse lever, 2 valve levers and a cut-off
lever. I had been firing 11 months when
the superintendent set me running. I ran
FIG. 4. FRISCO SYSTEM BRIDGE LOADED WITH COAL CARS.
and eccentrics beginning with that ex-
perience.
I am the oldest living engineer who
ran an engine through New Hampshire
and Vermont, and between Chicago and
Lake Superior on the C. & N. W. I am
80 years old Oct. 2, 1903. I was born in
Chichester, N. H., October, 1823. I ran
the first train over the divide of Green
Mountains in 1848.
against the back-board of the cab, "49"
being a McQueen, and constructed so as
to give the men a little comfort when-
ever they had an opportunity to take
a spell off, the same as on this especial
evening. Tom was looking ahead in a
dreamy sort of a way and singing in a
good voice one of Moore's sweetest
songs, "Believe Me if all those Endear-
ing Young Charms," and Ed. listening.
August, 1903,
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING,
355
"Tom. you're a good singer," said Ed.,
when the song was finished.
"It's kind for me, Ed., I came from
the land of song."
"I suppose all you Irish are Eood
singers?"
"Do you? If some of 'em were to be
obliged to sing for cold hash, they'd
starve to death."
"How are you and Nick Miller getting
on now? I have heard nothing lately."
"First rate. I got onto the whole
racket last pay night, and charged him
with it. He was mild enough. I heard
afterwards that he told Jack Eldridge
he didn't want to lick me on account of
the new train that is going to be put
on. He expects to be set up, he being
the oldest man, and he doesn't want to
do anything to me to lessen his chances."
"Is it true that after you had '49' all
thoroughly cleaned, and the paint work
of the cab washed, that he sneaked into
the round house and smeared her all
over with oil?"
"No, Ed., it is not. He hadn't the
courage to do it. Sneak like that he is;
he gave Jack Langan a half dollar to
do it, and promised the lad he would
boost him into a cab to go firing if
he did it and kept still about it. Now,
Nick never took kindly to me since I
came firing for you. I have tried to
keep my engine clean and suit you,
so as to make our work pleasant, for
Ed., if the two men who are in the cab
do not pull together, and help each other
out, they not only sufTer themselves, but
the service sufifcrs also. It does not hurt
the time they go out of the yard till
they get back, is how handy things are
kept for you, and the dirty devil-may-
care-way in which he does his work.
This got him to hating me worse than
the devil does holy water, and watching
his chance to thump me, when he catches
me out with the gang."
"He can't do it, Tom, from my way of
thinking, although he is cmiiilcd handy
vvilh his dukes."
good luck. Kittie is a peach if ever
there was one. Amongst a whole
orchard full, I'd pluck her first."
"That's what I did. I am glad you
like her, she's as good as they make."
"When is it coming off?"
"Cut her up a notch or two; you're
gettin' so interested, there'll not be a
bit of fire on the grate-bars, and choke
off the pump, or we'll have a deck load
of water in the stack, and I'll tell you:
THE K.\Vl' KIVEK PUMriNG STATION.
"That's the truest thing you ever said
in your life. If I can't make his face
look like a hand-ball alley after a game
with a wet ball, I'll go tamping ties
the rest of my life for punishment."
"Who told you all this?"
MAIN STRHlvT IN I'RONT OF RAILWAY STATION. WATER
CURRENT 14 MILKS PER HOUR.
FEET DEEP.
me to keep the deck clean, the coal wet
down, the brass in here at its natural
color, the boiler head black, and to keep
a nice piece of clean waste stuck be-
tween the head of the reverse lever and
the latch for you to wipe off your hands
after you come up here from oiling
round. You have been singing a song,
Ed., of what a clean chap I am, and all
Nick can hear from Jim Lathrop from
"Ed., you're no squealer, I'll tell you:
Dickey Reilly."
"How came you and Dickey to be so
thick?"
"Can't you guess?"
"No."
"Kittie."
Ed. gave a low monotonous whistle
and said: "That's how the cat jumps,
eh? Well, Tom. I wish you the best of
One week from next Sunday night; and
I want you to 'stand up' with me. Are
you willin'?"
"Indeed, I am, and I'll take the first
kiss from Kittie once she is Mrs. Burke,
or die trying."
"You're welcome to it, Ed. It will be
your first and last, for Kittie knows her
place."
"That's so, Tom. I know her since
she was a little toddler, and I always
admired her growing up to be a comely
lassie. It seems that by your going to
be married on a Sunday night you intend
it to be a private affair?"
"None but the immediate friends of the
family, as they say in the papers. Arrah.
listen!"
(Tom drifted into a rich broad brogue
as natural as a duck sliding down a
mossy bank into water, when he got
interested in a conversation. He had a
flow of good language talking to
strangers, but with familiars, the brogue
suited him best.)
"I went to see Father Tom O'Leary
a few nights ago. 'I'm glad to see you,
Tom.' says he. 'I return the same com-
pliment to you, Father,' says I. 'I sup-
pose you came to give me a ten dollar
bill to help paint the church.' says he.
'The devil a cent. Father,' says I. 'Now,
Tom, you are gettin' big pay on the
railroad, compared with the rest of my
poor people, and you ought not to be
so stingy.' 'If I am I earn it. If you
had to throw coal into "49's" firebox.'
says I. 'with 25 loads behind her, and
356
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
keep her clean for deserts, you'd find it
a_ divilish sight harder work to get dol-
lars out of the job than thrustin' the
collection box under our noses in church.
Faith, it's the good job you have, and
the ould woman missed it when she
didn't prepare me for ■ Holy Orders.'
'Did you come here to abuse me?' says
he. "I did not, Father,' says I. 'It isn't
in me breed to abuse one of your cloth.
I came here to make arrangements to
get married.' 'Who is the girl?' says he.
to be called to the office for, unless Nick
Miller and the gang have worked up
something agin me."
"I didn't hear," said Ed., with a cold
look on his face, not at all reassuring to
Tom.
"Mr. Burke," said Master Mechanic
Dawson to him on the day in question,
"I have watched you very closely, as well
as I have and am watching others in the
employ. You have always attended to
your business faithfully and soberly, and
BLOSSOM HOUSE IN KRONT OF UNION DEPOT. FLOOD PUT TICKET
BROKERS OUT OF BUSINESS.
'Kittie Reilly,' says I. 'One of me own
flock, God bless her. So you want me
to publish the banns?' 'I want you to do
nothin' of the sort,' says I. 'Do you
suppose I am goin' to have a whole
church full of gawkers lookin' at us as
we walk up the aisle to the altar; what
we wear and how we act? Then a lot
of invited guests come to the house, this
one bringin' an ould chair, another a
knife and fork, another a few spoons, and
so on; then, bime by, if we don't happen
to please them, goin' round the town
tellin' this one and that how they helped
us to go housekeepin'? No, Father, I'd
rather use an ould three-legged stool for
our parlor rockin' chair than take any
of their presents. When it comes to
beggin' I'll go from house to house and
be honest about it.'
" 'That's right, Tom,' says he, 'and I
agree with you. I'll get a dispensation
from the bishop and be ready when you
call.'
"Now, Ed., I've tould you all; and one
week from ne.xt Sunday night come and
witness Father Tom tyin' the knot I
never can open with me teeth. Have
Mrs. Townsend at the house, and we'll
have a cup of tea together when it's all
over."
About one month after Tom's marriage
he received a letter from the Master Me-
chanic to be at his office at 10 A. M.
the next day.
"Arrah, what's up, Ed.?" he said on
the trip out the day he got the letter.
"Faith, I don't know of doing anything
I have never known you to resort to any
method of obtaining what is known as
'a puir for your advancement in the ser-
vice other than attention to duty, which
is far and away ahead of everything
ler, the man who should be set up under
our rules of seniority, alU else being
equal, is a continual disturber and agi-
tator, the most pernicious of all grief
hunters. Were he the tenth part as ac-
complished in his work as he is skilled as
a pilot, who can navigate schooners of
booze across a bar, without ever punc-
turing a bubble floating on top, until
it is in Snug Harbor, securely moored,
he would be the peer of the best man
in the employ. I intend to give him a
chance to do better, if he wishes to get
rhead. Instead of dismissing him from
the service I shall disrate him to the
place you occupy, and advance you to
tlic position I take him from. This will
not be doing an injustice to the other
men. To-morrow you will take charge
of the Berwick in the Upper Yard."
Tom commenced twisting his hat
around in his hand, trying to say some-
thing in reply, but at last he only suc-
ceeded in making himself understood
that by being put to the running of the
Berwick he would be doing an injustice
to the other four men between him and
Nick.
Mr. Dawson satisfied him that he
could accept with a good heart, as two
had expressed a wish to remain in road
passenger service firing, in preference to
running a yard engine, and the other
two were too young to be set up.
"So then, Mr. Dawson," faid he, "if
I decline will you give Nick a chance?
He is smart and he may do better when
he gets to be an engineer."
I know of to get a step or two up the
ladder. I have never heard of you
agitating or being in any way connected
with any clique who considers the road
and engines were built for its members
exclusively, instead of trying to earn
money for those who invested capital to
purchase them, and to keep them in
running order. I am not making any
mistake by promoting you. There are
a few who will not be satisfied, but it
is not any concern of yours. Nick Mil-
BUT .\RE "UP IN THE AIR.'
"No, sir. You would have me act as
some girls do who go with drunkards,
they marry them so as to reform them?"
"Well, sir, I thank you. If I fail to
please you it will not be but that I'll
try hard enough."
Tom bowed himself out of the office,
and with the speed of a greyhound he
ran to Townsend's house, where panting
and almost breathless, he managed to
bluster out: "This is all your doin's, Ed."
"What's the excitement, Tom? You
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
357
look as flurried as you did the night you
went out to liand oil the valves and lost
the tallow pot, because you claimed you
saw the ghost of Jim SUinncr, that was
killed on Bailey's hill."
"Arrah, Ed., instead of you kissin' Kit-
tie, I'll have her kiss you the next time
you meet. God bless you, old friend,
and I say it from a heart as sincere
as the priest would if you put a dollar
bill upon the contribution plate, instead
of a cent." With that, he shot out of
Ed.'s presence, saying: "Begor I must
hurry home and tell Kittie she is the
wife of an engineer."
Heavy 4-6-3 Engine for the Northern
Pacific.
The American Locomotive Company
have recently supplied some passenger
4-6-2 engines to the Northern Pacific.
These engines were built at the Schenec-
tady shops. The cylinders, which are
simple, are 22x26 ins. and the drivers are
tender weigh, together, in working
order, about 318,400 lbs. According to
the classification adopted by the North-
ern Pacific, this engine is one of class
Q, but according to the builders' scheme
of classification the engine is referred to
as 462-195. This latter method indicates
the wheel arrangement and the total
weight of the engine. The wheel spac-
ing and the disposition of the vertical
and horizontal lines in its design, gives
to this machine a symmetrical and well
balanced appearance.
The Mosquitoes' Song.
One of the latest scientific discoveries
is, that a certain musical note, raised to
a great number of vibrations per second,
will completely paralyze mosquitoes. It
is an intensified form of the note which
mosquitoes sound so merrily while
searching for victims into which to force
their poisoned dart.
The scientists who are studying the
ferocious breed of mosquitoes have their
abiding place, and the discomforts of
the pest are merely comparative in other
places; so he can write with feeling.
These insects not only cause much
personal discomfort; they interfere with
business. A gentleman who intended
erecting a factory that afterwards em-
ployed hundreds of men, wished to lo-
cate near New York city. He was of-
fered land on the Newark meadows
and thought of locating there; but he
happened to visit the Pennsylvania rail-
road meadow shops, and while there no-
ticed that the workmen spent a serious
part of their time fighting mosquitoes,
so he decided to locate in a place where
that obstacle to production did not exist.
The Erie Railroad Company are pre-
paring to erect large repair shops in the
meadows near Jersey City, the most fer-
tile breeding ground of mosquitoes in
the United States. We advise Presi-
dent LTnderwood to pause before erect-
AMERICAN LOCOMOTIVE COMTANY 4-G-'-' FOR THE NORTHERN PACIFIC.
69 ins. in diameter. The driving wheel
base is 12 ft., while the wheel base of
the whole engine is 33 ft.
The total weight of this machine in
working order is 195,000 lbs., out of
which 132,000 lbs. is carried on the
drivers. The tractive effort is 31,000 lbs.
and the ratio of tractive power to adhe-
sive weight is 4.25. All the wheels on
this engine are flanged. The crosshead
top guide bar is lipped over so that side
of crosshead and side of guide are flush,
thus eliminating a dust and dirt collect-
ing opening from the top of the cross-
head.
The boiler is the straight top type
with wide firebox. The heating surface
is altogether 3,462.42 sq. ft., of which
3,264.3 sq. ft. are in the tubes. There
are 23.02 sq. ft. in a series of water tubes
and the firebox itself contributes 175.1
sq. ft. to the total. The grate area is
47.2 sq. ft. The working steam pressure
is 200 lbs.
The tender, which weighs, loaded,
about 123,400 lbs. is built with the or-
dinary steel frame. The tank capacity
is 6,000 U. S. gallons. The engine and
habits of mosquitoes say that railroad
trains and ships have been the means of
transporting mosquitoes to many regions
where they were formerly unknown and
that they have proved fertile immigrants.
This increases the number of the coun-
try's population, who are interested in the
successful operation of methods proposed
for exterminating mosquitoes. We know
of no .minor evil which so seriously inter-
feres with man's natural heritage to fol-
low the pursuit of happiness, as the in-
cessant biting of mosquitoes. A great
statesman once asserted that the man who
made two blades of grass grow where
only one had grown before was a benefac-
tor of mankind. If the scientific gen-
tlemen who are devising extermination
of mosquitoes succeed in preventing
ninety-nine of the bites of every hundred
that mosquitoes are now inflicting, they
will deserve the gratitude of the people
and the finest monuments that suffering
humanity can erect.
There are few parts of the country
exempt from the mosquito pest and they
are growing fewer. The writer is at
home in New Jersey where the most
ing workshops in such a place unless the
new method of exterminating mos-
quitoes is proved to be practicable. The
people working on the musical note
method say that the mosquitoes are at-
tracted by the sound and fly with light-
ning speed to their place of execution.
Every insect within reach of the sound
goes there and stops not on the order
of their going.
It may be that mosquito exterminat-
ing machines will come to be part of
the equipment of every manufacturing
concern located in mosquito haunted re-
gions. If the buzz-saw could be tuned
up to produce the murderous note, it
would increase the usefulness of that
enterprising tool. Be that as it may,
manufacturers will not grudge the ex-
pense of purchasing a mosquito exter-
minating machine when its tunes will
increase the comfort ot workmen and
at the same time enable them to do
more work. The picturesque Italians
who tamp the ties on some New Jersey
railroads have been kept so busy fighting
mosquitoes that their work on the track
has amounted to nothing.
-3S8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
The Rushton Drifting Throttle.
The accompanying drawing is of a lo-
comotive throttle valve designed and
; patented by Mr. Kenneth Rushtown,
-chief draughtsman of the Baldwin Loco-
motive Works. The object of this device
is, when desired, to permit some steam
to enter the dry pipe, when an engine
is drifting, for the purpose of lubricat-
ing the cylinders.
The throttle case has one external
opening which is at the top, and the in-
ternal opening through which steam en-
ters the dry pipe is a circular port 2V2
ins. deep, which runs all round, and is
• opened only when the throttle valve itself
lifts. Relnw this circular port is what
the steam which does flow through, is
suflicient to keep the cylinders lubricated
while engine is drifting.
When it is desired to open the throttle,
the lever lifts the small valve ^ of an
inch off its seat and the nut which is
on the bottom of the small central stem
engages with the throttle proper, and the
valve is raised. The throttle and its
auxiliary valve can be shut off, and both
will be held firmly in place by the pres-
sure of the steam on top of each.
It will be noticed that this valve has
only one large disk and when tightly shut
off is not balanced as are the valves of
usual form. When, however, it is desired
to open the main valve when starting.
livilutap ^ Liic'imofive Enntnecring
RUSHTON DRIFTING THROTTLE.
may be called a sort of saucer just
I the size of the cylindrical portion of the
> valve.
The throttle valve has in its center a
small valve which, when just off its seat,
• permits steam from the boiler to fill the
spaces between the wings of the main
valve, but as the main valve remains on
lits seat, no steam can pass through the
• circular port into the dry pipe. Pro-
vision is, however, made for the escape
• of some steam to the cylinders through
a small hole drilled through the wall of
■the saucer which is below the main valve.
As this hole is -f^ of an inch in diam-
eter, it is manifest that the amount of
■ steam passing through it will not be as
great as that usually caused by a leaky
•throttle, yet wire drawn., as it must be.
the movement of the regulator first un-
seats the small valve, which from its size
has only a small amount of pressure on
top of it, and as soon as the steam gets
inside, it reduces that pressure under the
large disk, so as to make it about equal
in balance to the ordinary double poppet
valve.
We have received from the secretary
of the American Railway Engineering
and Maintenance of Way Association a
copy of the specifications for material
and workmanship for steel structures
adopted by the association at its 1903
session. Copies may be had from the sec-
retary, 1562 Monadnock Building, Chi-
cago. Price of single copies, postpaid,
ten cents.
Recent Improvements in Boiler Design.
The following is the first part of the
report submitted to the Master Me-
chanics' Convention on the above sub-
ject. The committee was D. Van Al-
styne and O. H. Reynolds.
Progress in boiler design may be said
to be along the lines and in pursuit of
increased efficiency as a steam generator,
rather than in perfection of constructive
details which affect first cost and that
of maintenance.
The most prominent features of design
to attract attention are those of heating
surface and grate area. Professor Goss
pretty nearly exhausted the boiler-power
question when he said: "The mainten-
ance of pressure in the cylinders de-
mands steam from the boiler, and the
limit of cylinder work is reached when
the boiler can no longer meet the de-
mands made upon it." This is all funda-
mental, though recent, but is in strong
contrast with the old order of things
where cylinder dimensions alone signi-
fied a powerful engine.
The boiler of 1903 is designed witli
special reference to well-defined condi-
tions, in which the horse-power involved
is provided for by a heating surface and
grate area, of proportions that are ex-
pected to unfailingly supply the cylinders.
That these expectations are fully met is
attested by the performance of the latest
engines.
The wide firebox which is rapidly be-
coming recognized as a standard form
of construction, is responsible for the ex-
traordinary length ol tubes on engines
which, on the 4-6-2 type, reach a length
of 20 feet in some cases, made necessary
by placing the wide firebox at the rear
of six-coupled 80-inch wheels. Foreign
builders are regarding with favor the
trailing truck design, since they gain a
i;rate area impossible of attainment in
the older form of passenger engines, and
to this is due the appearance abroad of
the 4-4-2, 4-cylinder compounds of the
Baden State Railway, with 42 square
feet of grate, and others. The De Glehn
4-cylinder balanced cotupound is also of
the 4-4-2 type, although it has not the
firebox extending over frames, but the
design of engine lends itself to such con-
struction which will doubtless be seen
on future engines of the De Glehn type.
The foreign engines have a ratio of
firebox to tube surface more nearly in
harmony with the work of the committee
of 1897. The 4-4-2 De Glehn 4-cylinder
balanced compound engine of the North-
ern Railway of France has made a record
for development of a high horse-power
on a very small heating surface, contend-
ing with 0.5 per cent, grades at a speed
of seventy-four miles an hour, with 295
tons of engine and train. More than 1,500
De Glehn engines are now in service.
The o-io-o 3-cyIinder simple engine of
the Great Eastern Railway has boiler
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
359
proportions of the greatest magnitude
of any of the foreign engines, having
been designed for suburban passenger
service in which stops are numerous, and
with a gross load of 414 tons. This work
requires the engine to accelerate quickly,
therefore the small wheels and large
boiler, the latter feature being an inno-
vation in English design.
The London & Southwestern Railway
has more than one hundred of tlie Drum-
mond water-tube boilers in service, and
it is stated that all locomotive boilers of
this road are now being fitted with cross
water tubes. Under this system, the fire-
box heating surface is increased nearly
one hundred per cent, by means of the
water tubes, and equals 30.8 per cent, of
the tiital. This would appear to be a
practical illustration of the ancient pro-
position, that the higher the percentage
of fire-box heating surface to total heat-
ing surface, the greater the evaporative
efficiency of the boiler, a logic that re-
mains to be controverted. A boiler of
this character, but with water tubes in
the fire-box only, has been designed by
Mr. Riegel, of the American Locomotive
Company. This system contemplates
two nests of water tubes extending from
center of crown sheet diagonally down to
side water spaces, by which it is claimed
to be possible to get over 1,800 square
feet of efficient heating surface in the fire-
boxes of the larger types of engines,
making a total heating surface of over
6.000 square feet. There is no doubt of
the necessity of such a design, since fire-
boxes have about reached the limit of
size, both from a clearance standpoint
as well as that of operation. There is no
record of any construction of this idea.
Superheating of steam is attracting
considerable attention abroad, particu-
larly on the Prussian State Railways,
where seventy engines are fitted with the
Schmidt system of superheating. In ad-
dition to these the Schmidt principle
is in use on the Alsace-Lorraine State
Railways, the Belgian State Railways,
the Moscow-Kasau Railway, the South-
ern Railway of Italy, and the Munich
Suburban Railway. In this country
the same superheating device is in use
on the Canadian Pacific, and the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company is now con-
structing another engine similarly
equipped for the same road. It is
understood that there are also five of
these engines under construction by the
Pennsylvania road. Very glowing ac-
counts of the performance of Schmidt
engines, by an American engineer who
has recently returned from Europe,
would imply that there were economics
in superheating of steam for locomo-
tives.
Even with the successful overcoming
of resistance at continuous high speeds
there is a question among some officials
that, while we have ample heating sur-
face, it may not be in the right place, or,
in other words, it is pos.sible that we
have too much heating surface in the
wrong place, that is, are not too
many tubes used, and would not a
boiler furnish an equivalent or a higher
evaporation with a lesser number? There
appears to be good reasons for question-
ing the efficiency of a multitude of tubes,
among which arc the following for re-
ducing the number: A better circulation
due to the wider spacing of centers; a
reduction of liability to leakage, and
longer life to tube sheet due to the
greater section of material between
holes. It is not apparent that there are
any very serious difficulties to surmount
in making tests that will demonstrate to
what extent evaporation and cost of
maintenance is affected by a wider spac-
ing of tubes. Such experiments would
definitely decide whether the practice of
meet the greater demands of the cylin-
ders, it is plain that the question of de-
sign should have direct reference to the
amount of water evaporated by each
square foot of heating surface per hour.
If the heating surface is designed for the
work to be done, that is, on a horse-
power basis, then the problem becomes
one of design for specific conditions. In
that case the facts entering into calcula-
tion are:
(i) Resistance to overcome.
(2) Horse-power required.
(3) Water consumption per horse-
power hour.
(4) Water evaporated per square foot
of heating surface per hour.
(5) Evaporative value of one pound of
coal.
(6) Grate area to accord with calorific
value of fuel.
This process has to do with actual
\ ^1 n I . t- !
I J^l
— ir"
ENGINE HOUSE, MONCLOVA, MEXICO, MEXIC.'\.N INTERN.\TION AL RAILWAY.
GENERAL REPAIR SHOPS TO BE BUILT L-^TER.
encroaching on circulation space with
tubes is conducive to an economical
evaporation, and in addition would no
doubt incidentally furnish some needed
light on the effect of a higher ratio of
fire-box to tube heating surface under
the new conditions. Restricted water
spaces around the firebox are well
known to be inimical to a proper circu-
lation, as well as dangerous to the sheets,
and the same effects are known to oper-
ate at the fire-box ends of tubes. The
wide fire-bo.K has shown a marked ten-
dency to crack at the sides, and as a
remedy it is proposed to make the fire-
box ring 4J4 inches wide on some en-
gines now under construction.
In bracing and staying there is little
to be recorded as new. In joint con-
struction the welt type is said to be im-
proved to an efiicienc}' of 90 per cent, of
the solid plate, and welding of joints is
said to be satisfactorily done, both on
dome sheets and longitudinal joints, the
latter, howe-- continuous but at
ends only.
The reason \crease of heating
surface being boiler power to
values only, eliminating all factors of
doubtful utility.
Your committee is under obligation to
the technical press for courtesies extend-
ed in the way of illustrations, among
which are, the American Engineer, Rail-
road Gazette, Railway and Locomotive
Engineering and London Engineering.
Plans have been completed by the
Pennsylvania Railroad Company for an-
other important addition to the big works
at Altoona. It is announced that the
railroad company proposes to erect a
plant for the manufacture of car wheels,
which will be an innovation at the com-
pany's works. The plans provide for a
building with a capacity for 600 cars a
day. It is understood that the company
proposes to start work on the construc-
tion of the plant at once and will have it
ready for use by fall. The cost is some-
thing like $25,000. During the past year
the Pennsyh-ania has spent over $2,000,-
000 increasing the facilities of the works
at Altoona until they have been made the
most complete railroad shops in the
country.
36o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
August. 1903.
Lo%k^^Ei$ineeriii$
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling: Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York,
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "l/oceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, "I,ocanto."
BnslnesB Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRBD M. NEI<I/IS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NELLIS, j
GEO. S. HODGINS, J Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
AdvertlslnK Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
iao4 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative :
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd. loaa Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, London.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
f 2.00 tfr year. Si. 00 /or six months, fostage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of the imrld. S2.J0, or ten shillnigs.
Sin/rle copies, 20 cents. Kemit by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Jie^stered
Letter. , , . .,
Mailing address can be citanged asolten as neces-
sary—always jirive old and new address, and i/ you
subscribed in a club, state who got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper fails
to reachyou properly.
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.. 1003.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Why Large Engines FaiL
The problem of overcoming the too
frequent failures of the large engines
has been the one absorbing thought of
the builder, designer and superintendent
of motive power. Opinions from these
different sources have been given to the
public through the press of late, and in
the majority of cases the cause of failure
has been attributed either to the ignor-
ance or indifference of the enginemen—
due to the pooling system — or the em-
ployment of new engineers and firemen
made necessary by the increasing traffic.
While this is often the true cause, it is
not by any means the whole reason for
the failure of the big engines. Faulty
design and bad water have contributed
more to these failures than anything
else. When engines break 500 stay-bolts
in five months, or an average of three
and one-third per day, there is certainly
a fault in the design. On many of our
roads where stay-bolts are tested Only
at wash-out periods, which come about
twice a month, an engine breaking three
stay-bolts a day is a slumbering volcano,
liable to create havoc any minute. Nurs-
ing an engine to please the superintend-
ent of motive power is not the trans-
portation department's idea. Their in-
struction to the engineman is, "Never
mind the engine. She belongs to the
company, and we want you to pull cars
and gfet there." With this order, the
"good" or the "indifferent" engineman
has no choice.
Pooling engines has been a blessing to
llic careless and incompetent men and
a curse to the energetic and competent.
Abridging water-space \\\ order to get
more heating surface has been the pro-
lific cause of leaky flues in the bad water
districts of the West.
Pressing "handy men'' into service to
do experienced boiler-maker's work, in
order to save expense, has caused many
an engine failure, and is always an ex-
pensive sort of economy.
The engineman has no voice in the
question of pooling, tonnage-rating or
the employment of repair men, yet much
blame is laid on his shoulders. With
the advent of the large engines came
a change in fire-door design, some of
our "battle-ships" having two doors and
so arranged that it is almost impossible
for the fireman to operate them to ad-
vantage. The result has been that the
fireman, unable to close the door after
each scoopful of coal, and having to coax
the monster with 25 tons or more of coal
over the division, has adopted the oppo-
site plan and left the fire-door open until
five or six scoops at a time have been
shoveled into the fire. This always
means disaster to the firebox. The in-
difference of some of our lines to these
conditions is the cause to-day of so
many of their old firemen leaving their
service. Breaking-in new firemen is ex-
pensive business. So long as railroads
place so little value on the services of
an experienced fireman, ignoring his
needs in order to save a few dollars,
just so long will the stockholders con-
tinue to wonder why the big engines
earn so much less than they were ex-
pected to.
We must disagree with the builder
who tells the public that the waters of
the western states are almost certain
death to those who drink them. We are
familiar with the waters of California,
Colorado, New Mexico and Kansas
through years of experience, and know
people who have been using them for
twenty years without serious inconveni-
ence. We must also disagree with the
statement that 50 to 75 per cent, of cyl-
inders in the old single expansion en-
gines in use ten or fifteen years are
b''.nded or patched, owinjr. of coiirse, to
this same deadly water. Bad water will
convert a steam engine into one of the
hydraulic kind very often, but many of
the fractures mentioned were made by
defective pistons or piston-rods. Fre-
quent inspection would have reduced the
percentage. When those engines were
built, we had no piston valves. Piston
valves are not a success in bad water
districts, because they cannot free them-
selves of water so readily as the old
slide valves. For the sake of argument,
allowing the damage to cylinders on the
engines with slide valves to have been
25 per cent., the damage to the piston
valve class, had there been any such,
would have fooled up 50 per cent.
The lack of facilities for repairs to
the large engines is to be charged against
the railroad compames. The lack of in-
terest on the part of the engineers and
firemen is also directly attributable to
the nearsightedness of officials who
failed to see far enough ahead to es-
tablish a thorough system of instruction
and examination for their enginemen.
Had this course been pursued, the care-
less and incompetent men could easily
have been located and removed without
wasting years in misplaced confidence.
Later, when rush of business compelled
wholesale promotions, some officials shut
their eyes to plain facts and promoted
men who passed a quasi-examination,
but never made any effort to study the
mechanism or management of a locomo-
tive until the coming examination was
announced.
If the large engines are to be a suc-
cess, the needs of the enginemen must
be considered, and they must be assisted
in every way in the performance of their
work. Periodical examination of fire-
men will give good timber to promote
from. Coupled with these examinations
there should be on every road a com-
petent force of traveling engineers and
firemen, masters of their business, thor-
ough instructors and disciplinarians, with
lots of patience to help those who show
a disposition to help themselves. Many
an indifferent engineman, with proper
instruction and kind treatment will de-
velop into a first-class runner and careful
student of mechanics.
Superheaters for Locomotives.
In the admirable paper on Recent Im-
provements in Boiler Design, presented
to the Railway Master Mechanics' Con-
vention we find the following paragraph:
"Superheating of steam is attracting
considerable attention abroad, particu-
larh on the Prussian State Railways,
where seventy engines are fitted with the
Schmidt system of superheating. In ad-
dition to these the Schmidt principle is
in use on the .-Msace-Lorraine State Rail-
ways, the Belgian State Railways, the
Moscow-Kasau Railway, the Southern
Railway of Italy, and the Munich Subur-
ban Railway. In this country the same
superheating device is in use on the Cana-
dian Pacific, and the American Locomo-
tive Company is now constructing an-
other engine similarly equipped for the
same road. It is understood that there
are also five of these engines under con-
struction by the Pennsylvania road. Very
glowing accounts of the performance of
Schmidt engines, by an American en-
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
361
gincer who has recently returned from
Europe, would imply that there were
economy in superheating of steam for lo-
comotives."
We believe that the introduction of an
effective superheater would effect more
economy on many of our locomotives
than any form of improvement that could
be applied; but it would not be equally
efficient on all locomotives. There has
been for several years an urgent demand
for providing locomotives with immense
heating surface, and this demand has too
often been satisfied by sacrificing steam
room. The boiler of a modern locomo-
tive has to evaporate water so rapidly,
that the ebullition inside must throw vol-
umes of spray that under the most favor-
able condition mix with the outgoing
steam; so it is easy to understand that a
boiler with contracted steam space,
passes through the dry pipe much aque-
ous vapor that has not been converted
into steam. That vapor exercises a very
pernicious influence on the real steam
that passes into the steam chest, for it
possesses enormous capacity for the ab-
sorption of heat and robs the steam of
part of the heat of vaporization and chills
the walls of the cylinder in robbing the
metal of its heat. This intensifies the
process of initial cylinder condensation,
and revaporation at the end of the stroke,
causing great loss of heat. Any super-
heatmg device which will convert the
aqueous vapor into saturated steam is
certain to effect economy and if it goes
to the extent of superheating the steam
all the better.
proceed to stuff their mental stomach
with facts, as Frenchmen stuff geese with
food to produce foie gras, an abnormally
fattened liver.
'I'hcre is a genuinely earnest desire
among thousands of people to acquire
knowledge and there are many institu-
tions trying to cater to the demand, but
in the majority of cases the aid is not
wisely given. It is easy to direct a stu-
dent to pump information into his brain.
The real teacher will instruct him how
to assimilate and arrange the facts ac-
quired so that they may be applied to
useful purposes.
The paper appeals strongly to the
writer, who wandered for years seeking
knowledge in the wilderness, sent there
by blind teachers, and kept there through
lack of learning methods.
How to Learn Things.
We direct the attention of our readers
to the article in another part of the paper
on Training an Artist in the Forces of
Nature, by E. H. Mullin, which was read
at the convention of the American In-
stitute of Electrical Engineers. We hear
a great deal nowadays about the ad-
vantage of education, mental training,
culture, etc., but very little concerning
how the mental pabulum should be swal-
lowed and no caution against overeat-
ing. Mr. Mullin favors plain mental
food and comments very sensibly about
turning attainments into proper chan-
nels. What will strike many people as
a paradox are his words: "It is not the
knowledge of facts which makes a man
educated, but the possessibn of method.
To teach a man to learn how to learn
is the true function of education, and
to stuff his mind with facts beyond this
point is merely to encumber him in pur-
suing his means of livlihood." Although
these expressions may sound strange to
the unthinking, they touch a condition
that imposes a woeful burden upon peo-
ple who acquire a thirst for knowledge
years after they have left school. They
have not learned how to learn system-
atically, and too often, under advice, they
Motive Power Department Holds Up
Its Bnd.
In his admirable inaugural address to
the American Railway Master Mechan-
ics' Association President West, re-
ferring to the unparalleled rush of freight
business, said that railroads which a few
years ago employed a corps of freight
solicitors had during the past year re-
fused business through inability to han-
dle it. "The press of the country have
tried to pursuade the public that the
trouble was with the motive power de-
partments, or a lack of motive power or
equipment; as a matter of fact, it was
because nearly, if not quite all, the trunk
lines lacked terminal facilities. It was no
uncommon thing during the past winter
to see miles and miles of trains, with the
engine of the following trains within
coupling distance of the leading train
waiting for orders to move, and instances
have been cited to me of train crews re-
porting for duty immediately on arrival
of train at destination ready for work,
having had the required amount of rest
on the trip while sidetracked or await-
ing orders. All these facts tend to prove
that the freight congestion so much talk-
ed about was not due so much to lack
of power and equipment as to operation
or lack of termmal facilities. These con-
ditions have proven more forcibly than
could any committee of our association,
had it continued its investigation of cost
of running high speed trains, that the
number of factors entering into the prob-
lem make it an unknown quantity, de-
pending entirely on how much other
traffic is delayed in keeping high speed
trains on time, and unless they are kept
on time it is no credit to the system at-
tempting it."
The people who supply information
that becomes press articles do not know
enough about railroad operating to lo-
cate the cause of traffic congestion. They
say what officials in the operative depart-
ment tell them and that generally means
reflection on the mechanical department.
This thing of trying to put upon the
motive power department the blame for
delay in moving traffic is an unfounded
charge of very ancient origin. If a full
supply of locomotives is not always
ready when asked for by the operating
department, complaints have been made
that the power is not forthcoming when
wanted, no matter how many engines are
standing on sidings in the front of trains
or blocked in yards. The operative de-
partment has always had the ear of the
management and it is only human for
these officials to shift blame from their
own shoulders to that of their fellow
officials responsible for keeping the mo-
tive power in train hauling order. It is
beyond the memory of man to recall the
beginning of the perennial complaint
that tlie locomotives arc not moving the
number of cars they ought to do.
When cars were waiting to be moved
and engines were found to be held in the
round-house while necessary repairs
were being done, or while enginemen
were obtaining a few hours' sleep, people
belonging to the operative department
began working up the sentiment that it
was senseless to keep engines waiting
till human brains and bodies should rest.
Locomotives needed no rest. Let an-
other crew take the engine out, was the
demand, and the pooling system was
gradually brought into use.
Then a constantly recurring complaint
was, the engines are not hauling the
number of cars they ought to pull. As
cars increased in capacity and weight
the operative department insisted on
engines pulling the same number of loads
until traffic became blocked with stalled
trains. Then the tonnage rating wa& in-
troduced and it is still with us without
promoting harmony in a striking man-
ner, or facilitating the movement of
trains to a great e-xtent. Tonnage rat-
ing ought to be just and equitable
toward trainmen, toward the mechanical
department and toward the operative de-
partment. Predictions were made that
its general introduction would lead rail-
roads to the starting point of L'topia.
but it seems to have led many of them to
the entrance of the region which genteel
people now call Hades. No doubt there
has always been a tendencj' among the
motive power men toward light loading
of engines, while the operative depart-
ment tended to the opposite extreme.
When an engine was rated to haul a cer-
tain number of cars over a division, the
enginemen were aware of any attempt
at overloading; under the tonnage rating
system they have no means of knowing
that they are overloaded until the dis-
tress of the engine and incidentally of
the fireman tells it. Favoritism is by no
means unknown in railroad business, and
the complaint is common that screened
by tonnage rating certain engines are
habitually run light, while others are
362
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
constantly loaded with more than they
can haul comfortably.
After the tonnage rating was introduc-
ed the next complaint heard was, the
engirtes are not powerful enough. The
fashion for increasing the size of loco-
motives became the rage, and railroad
men are fiends for following a fashion.
They have rushed after that craze until
many locomotives have reached the limit
that tunnels and bridges curtail them to.
and the enormously large engines bid
fair to be the worst elements for demor-
alizing train movement ever introduced.
One influential class of railroad officials
hold that the proper way to move cars
promptly is to load engines with trains
they can handle comfortably and push
them at the highest speed which can
safely be made; another set of officials
believe in loading every engine down
with every car it can haul, no matter
how long the trains may be on the road.
The latter class of men are those who
demand more powerful engines, and their
policy is responsible for the slow move-
ment of trains.
Under the slow movement system the
motive power department do not receive
proper credit for the work done by the
engines. They are credited with ton
mileage, but they ought to have credit
for the hours they are waiting in side
tracks, or delayed on the road. When a
report of performance tells the volume
of work done by an engine it should add
the number of hours it was idle while in
steam on the road, otherwise there is
no record of wasted work which in some
cases amount to more than the useful
work. We propose a new expression to
measure the work done by locomotives —
it is hour-mile-tons.
Honey's Hagnetlc Traction Increaser.
Several technical journals of late have
had favorable comments on the Honey
Magnetic Device and its probable appli-
cation to steam and electric lines.
The device, briefly described, consists
of a soft steel arm wound with copper
wire. One end of the arm is secured to
a band which encompasses the axle. The
other end supports a small idler wheel
which rides the rail when it is desired to
put the device in action. Its object is to
abolish the use of sand, to secure adhe-
sion to the rail and increase the tractive
effort by substituting magnetism. Under
ordinary circumstances the idler wheel is
held in suspense about one inch from the
rr.il. but when, from any cause, the ad-
hesion of the wheels to the rail is de-
ficient, the idler wheel is lowered to the
rail. This causes an electric current to
flow from the arm to the car wheel or
driver, and in its passage through the
rail to the idler wheel, producing a short
magnetic circuit.
It is claimed by the Magnetic Equip-
ment Co. that tests made on an electric
car at Seattle, Wash., developed a 300
per cent, increase in drawing capacity. A
railroad official on one of our large trunk
lines, and a probable stockholder with
the Magnetic Co., ventures an opinion
that it will enable a locomotive to pull
four more cars with this equipment than
without it. How he arrives at the num-
ber of cars or the class of engine he
should use to pull these four extra cars,
neither he nor they venture any enlight-
enment.
These species of claims are made by
people interested in the invention. Ef-
forts to use magnetism to increase the
adhesion of driving wheels to rails have
been made repeatedly, and they have al-
ways failed because it was found that in-
crease of resistance to advance of the en-
gine was always in proportion to the in-
crease of adhesion due to magnetism.
The Honey Magnetic Traction Increaser
people appear to be devoted more to
selling stock than to demonstrating by
practical tests the value of their device.
If they have got anything worthy to re-
ceive financial support they cannot too
soon apply their invention to a full-sized
locomotive and show what the engine
can do hauling a train on a slippery rail.
Meanwhile, we advise our readers to de-
cline investing their hard-earned savings
in the Traction Increaser Company's
stock until they see the invention prop-
erly tried. This caution includes the
employees of the Wabash Railway in and
around Springfield, 111.
Effects of Tonnage Ratings on the
Cost of Transportation.
An individual paper, on the above-
named subject, was read at the recent
meeting of the Master Mechanics' Asso-
ciation by Mr. C. H. Quereau, superin-
tendent of the Albany shops of the New
York Central, he said:
The car was recognized as an unsatis-
factory unit long before the ton was
substituted for it. Even after the theo-
retical correctness of the ton had been
fully admitted there was a quite general
opposition to its adoption on the grounds
that it would not work out in practice.
Soon after its adoption, the discovery
was made that the ratio between train
weight and train resistance is not con-
stant. This discovery lead to a scientific
investigation of the matter with dyna-
mometer cars, etc. These investigations
revealed the fact that the greater gross
weight per car, the less the resistance
per ton and that the heavier the adverse
grade and the slower the speed, the less
this difference is. The next step was
naturally in the direction of adjusted
tonnage ratings, which increase the nom-
inal weight of empty, partly loaded and
low capacity cars in proportion to their
resistance per ton. so that the adjusted
ratings much more nearly approximate
the resistance a train will develop than
if the actual weights had been used.
The effect of this tonnage rating sys-
tem has been to reduce transportation
costs. The ton-mile basis for statistics
logically followed the introduction of
tonnage ratings. While the engine mile
had been the basis of motive power sta-
tistics, the effort oi master mechanics
and engineers was to pull as light trains
as possible, because an engine made more
miles per ton of coal the lighter the
train, and this fact no doubt tended to
neutralize the efforts of the transporta-
tion department to handle heavy trains,
and both departments working at cross
purposes kept up the cost of moving
cars. The advent of the ton-mile basis
for motive power changed all this, and
caused both departments to work to-
gether in harmony because it was found
that, within reasonable limits, the heavier
the train the less the cost of coal, wages
and repair per ton-mile. Actual records
show that the use of tonnage ratings in-
creased the work done by the engines
on a certain division by 24 per cent.
A table submitted by Mr. Quereau,
based on the assumption that it takes
an average of four hours to get an en-
gine from its train to round house, clean
its fire, give it necessary repairs, furnish
supplies to it, and have it on its train
again. Also on the assumption that a
train of forty cars will allow an average
speed of ten miles per hour. On the
further assumption that a reduction of
the train from 40 to 35.2 cars or twelve
per cent., will permit an increase in
average speed to fifteen miles an hour.
This table showed that it was possible
to get an increase of from 16 to 22 per
cent, in the number of cars an engine
will handle per month, due to a decrease
of 12 per cent, in the number of cars
handled per train, and that the longer
I lie division the greater the increase.
Book Review.
Railway Legislation in the United
States, by B. H. Meyer, Ph.D., Professor
of Institutes of Commerce, University
of Wisconsin. Publishers, The Macmil-
lan Company, New York, 1903. Price,
$1.25.
The aim of this book is to present a
condensed analysis of the private and
public laws which govern railways in the
United States, and also to give the im-
portant decisions relating to interstate
commerce. Several of the chapters have
already appeared in the Annals of the
American Academy of Political and So-
cial Science and in the Political Science
Quarterly.
The whole subject treated of here has
been divided into three parts; the first
is an introduction under which are dis-
cussed the significance of railways; char-
acteristics of railway legislation in the
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
363
United States; foreign side lights, and
economic adjustments. Part two, on the
Progress of Railway Legislation, takes
111' early railway charters, later charters
and early general laws, constitutional
provisions and present general railway
legislation. Part three deals with the
past and future of the Interstate Coin-
Micrce Cotrmission, and discusses events
preceding the act to regulate commerce,
leading principles of the decisions of
ihe commission, the Supreme Court and
the Interstate Commerce Commission,
and the Cullom bill. There are four
chapters in the appendi.x, giving an
American railway charter, articles of in-
corporation under general laws, the
Massachusetts commission law, and the
Interstate Commerce law. A supplement
deals with the Elkins law and its inter-
pretation. The book closes with an
index.
Steam Turbines.
On another page will be found an ab-
stract of a paper on A Steam Turbine,
read by Mr. L. R. Pomeroy, at the Rail-
way Master Mechanics' Convention. The
-team turbine is so steadily pushing its
way into favor with power users that
the paper is very seasonable in giving
railroad men information concerning a
species of motive power that they may
soon be called upon to employ. Those
who use electric headlights are already
beginning to have charge of the small
turbine engines employed to drive the
electric motors, and the indications are
that electric machinery in repair shops,
round houses and other places will soon
be driven by steam turbines. We believe
that the New York Central Railroad
Company are arranging to install steam
turbine engines to drive all the machinery
at the West Albany shops, and other rail-
road companies are negotiating for simi-
lar purposes.
The conspicuous advantage possessed
by steam turbine over other forms of
steam engines is its simplicity. The
steam acts in the turbine as water acts
on a water turbine, and not unlike the
way that wind drives some forms of wind
mills with many vanes. Strangely enough
an elementary form of steam turbine was
experimented with during the seven-
teenth century by the philosophers,
whose efforts eventually led to the con-
struction of the piston engine. In 1629
Giovanni Branca, an Italian, published
the description of an engine, in which
motion was produced by a jet of steam
impinging upon the vanes of a horizontal
wheel. The principal defect of that in-
vention was the absence of appliances
for making the' steam follow the vanes
until more of its energy was converted
into useful work. If an ingenious en-
gineer had devoted himself to improving
the Branca invention, we do not believe
that the reciprocating engine would have
been forced into favor, as it was, by
grim necessity.
The leading merits of the steam tur-
bine as compared with the steam engine
are: Small loss from friction of jour-
nals and other workinc parts; few mov-
able pieces to get out of order; the ca-
pacity of being housed in very small
space, and freedom from loss of heat by
cylinder condensation. In a steam en-
gine part of the steam is converted into
work by the expanding steam pushing
a piston; in steam turbines the work is
done partly by the steam at high velocity
propelling the vanes, partly by the ex-
panding force of the steam. The prin-
cipal steam turbines on the market are
the De Laval, the Parsons, the Curtis
and the Rateau. Recent improvements
have made the steain turbine about as
economical in the use of steam as the
best reciprocating engines. The West-
inghouse Electric Company, which make
steam turbines under the Parsons pat-
ents, and the General Electric Company,
which are making the Curtis steam tur-
bine, are both installing many power
plants, and are making serious inroads
into the business formerly done by high
class reciprocating engine builders.
Steam turbines seem to be peculiarly
well adapted as power for steamers,
since they do not occupy but a small
fraction of the space occupied by ordi-
nary marine engines. There are a few
steam turbine steamers in use in Europe
and two in the United States, but the
owners of the large transatlantic steam-
ers are slow about adopting the steam
turbine. They probably are waiting for
developments and to find out what kind
of an old engine a steam turbine proves
to be. Strangely enough we have not
yet heard of the steam turbine being ap-
plied to a locomotive, but patents have
been granted for that type of power to
be applied to automobiles.
The Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific
Railroad Company are building a huge
locomtive repair shop near Moline, 111.
Mr. C. A. Seley, the mechanical en-
gineer of the road, has made the designs
for the works, and it is expected that
they will be as perfect as anything built
for locomotive repair purposes. Reports
have been circulated that the shops were
intended for the construction of new en-
gines, and that the Rock Island system
intended to build all its roljing stock as
soon as the facilities were provided, but
we have the best of reasons for believ-
ing that such reports are not correct.
There will be enough repair work sent
in from the lines in Illinois, Iowa and
Missouri to keep their large works fully
occupied.
There is no playing fast and loose with
the truth, in any game without growing
the worse for it. — Little Dorrit.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(50) R. L. S., Sarnia Tunnel, asks:
Why can more weight be obtained on
Ihc drivers than on the leaders or trail-
ers when the spring gear is connected by
means of cfjualizcrs? A. — The spring
gear is connected by equalizers to two or
more wheels as the case may be, and the
reason one wheel may carry more weight
than another with which it is "equalized"
is that the whole equalizing gear is not
sufficiently sensitive to adjust weights
closely. Many driving springs stand on
the full flat underside of the buckles, and
though the hangers and equalizers are
pivoted they are comparatively rough
and are never lubricated. The whole ar-
rangement, however, does very well be-
cause there is no object in producing so
very close adjustment. If you examine
a track scales you will see the pivot
points and knife edges of hard steel finely
finished and protected from dust and dirt,
and giving practically perfect ajustment.
By making a mental comparison between
track scales and locomotive spring rig-
ging you will get an idea of their rela-
tive value as equalizers.
(so J. R. and Others, Truro, N. S,
write:
(i) Some years ago "Balanced Com-
pound No. I," with four cylinders, cranks
set at 180 degs., with small trailer under
firebox and Mother Hubbard cab, was
tested at Perdue and ran very smoothly,
the wire coming from under the drivers
like a ribbon. We have heard nothing
of it since. A.— The even ribbon-like ap-
pearance of the wire as it came from un-
der the drivers showed that the engine
was well balanced. If the wire had been
very flat in places and only slightly flat
in others, it would have been evidence of
uneven balance. The engine left Perdue
University after the test, and was taken
to Altoona, where for a year or more it
was more or less used for experimental
work on the Pennsylvania Railroad.
{2) Not long ago an engine of similar
type was built at the Baldwin Works for
the Plant System. It was the 20,coo en-
gine built at Baldwin's. Can you tell
something of the performance of this
engine? A. — The engine is now running
on the Wheeling and Lake Erie Rail-
road, where it is doing excellent work in
freight service. (3) We have been told
that the Baldwin's are experimenting
with an apparatus to admit live steam to
the cylinders, but without its escaping
from the exhaust. In other words to
make the cylinder for the time being a
part of the boiler, probably with an inter-
cepting reducing valve. \Miat can you
tell us concerning this? A. — You have
probably heard something 01 the drifting
throttle recently patented by Mr. Ken-
neth Rushton, of the Baldwin Loco-
motive Works. This throttle is designed
364
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
to allow a small amount of steam to enter
the steam pipes when the engine is drift-
ing, in order to convey the lubricant to the
cylinders. We have illustrated this throt-
tle in another column of this issue, headed
"The Rushton Drifting Throttle," page
358.
(52) J. G., Muskegon, Mich., asks :
How many railroads in the United
States have a trench in the track from
which their engines take water without
stopping? A. — We have no statistics be-
fore us on this subject, but we may say
that track tanks are used on the New
York Central, the Lake Shore & Michi-
gan Southern, the Philadelphia & Read-
ing, the Central Railroad of New Jersey,
the Pennsylvania, the Chicago, Milwau-
kee & St. Paul, the New York, New
Haven & Hartford, the Baltimore &
Ohio, and the Michigan Central Railroads.
(53) G. D., Evansville, Ind., writes:
Please explain to me how to lay the
keyways for eccentrics with wooden
straight edge before setting the valves,
and if there is another way to lay oflf
(55) G. W. D., Columbus. O.. writes:
I am firing a lo-vvheel Brooks on a
fast run that is causing me much trou-
ble. Two weeks ago the steam pipes
on this engine were found leaking and
were ground in. On her first trip out
after this work was done she steamed
for twenty-five minutes and quit. Since
then the foreman tells me that if I fired
her right she would steam. I claim she
has leaky steam pipes again, and am
ridiculed for it. What is the trbuble?
A. — From your description, if the draft
plate is in its proper place, you may
have either leaky steam pipes or ex-
haust stand, possibly both. With bot-
tom joint on steam pipes or exhaust
stand joint leaking, there is always ex-
cessive heat at the fire-door. Go out
on the running-board and watch the cyl-
inder saddles when engine is working
steam. No doubt they are working and
shearing the saddle-bolts, and have
loosened the steam pipes again.
(56) C. V. D., Chicago, writes:
(i) Are there any engines in use with
first question should be: Take of? head
on right cylinder and put it on left.
Leave main rod, right side up, to help me
off dead center in case I stopped on dead
center left side. Then disconnect right
valve stem, cover port and clamp stem.
(2) Cover port on right side, leave up
main rod, take down both eccentric
straps on right side and replace the
broken strap with one of them. In both
cases, I would try to bring in part of
a train with the engine.
Heaviest Car in the World.
Our half-tone illustration shows what
is probably the heaviest car of its kind
in the world. It is, of course, a special
car built for a special purpose, like the
steel flat car used in connection with
heavy gun which we illustrated in our
January issue. The Bethlehem car meas-
ures 64 ft. between king pins, it is 9 ft.
9 in. wide and is 10 ft. 2^ in. high. The
length over couplers is 103 ft. loj^ in.
This car itself is practically a bridge
truss, 6 ft. high in the center and 66 ft.
HEAVIEST STEEL CAR IN THE WORLD.
eccentric keyways which may be better
than that with the wooden straight edge?
A. — We do not understand exactly what
you mean, but the usual way to find the
position of the keyways on locomotive
axles is to put the eccentrics on, having
the keyways already cut in them. Secure
the eccentrics to the axle by means of
the set screws, then set the valves, and
mark off the kej'way in the axle from
the keyway in each eccentric.
(S4) I. M. S., Biwabik, Minn., asks :
How to calculate the tractive power of
a compound locomotive? A. — The for-
mula used for a two-cylinder compound
is
C2 X 5 X f /-^
D
= T
The formula for a four-cylinder com-
pound is
C^ ^ S y.\P a X S % P_
D '^ D ~
Where T is the tractive power in
pounds, C is the diameter of the cylinder
and S the stroke, both in inches, P is
the boiler pressure in pounds and D is
the diameter of the driving wheels in
inches.
the eccentrics on the forward axle and
the main rod connected to the second or
main driver? A. — Yes, some of the
western lines have them yet. A modern
example will be found in the Baldwin
engine illustrated in this issue on page
371. (2) If such an engine breaks
the forward side-rod is it safe to run
the engine with the rod on the opposite
side up? A. — Yes. If you should at-
tempt to move the good side with the
rod down there would be danger of
slipping the main drivers, and the result
would be a rupture of cylinders or de-
struction of running gear. An engine
in that condition should never attempt
to bring in a train. See article. Hints
on Break Downs, page 283, June issue.
(S7) F. B. M., Louisville, Ky., writes:
I am a fireman with three years' ex-
perience and in line for promotion. If
the examiner should ask the following
questions how should I answer? (i)
Suppose you broke the left forward cyl-
inder head and the right back-up eccen-
tric, what would you do? and (2) Sup-
pose you broke the right piston rod and
the left go-ahead eccentric strap, what
w'ould you do? A. — Your answer to the
10 ins. long over all. This is carried
upon two trucks, each containing 8 axles.
The capacity of the car is 300,000 pounds,
and when fully loaded this gives an axle
load of 18,750 pounds. The trlicks are
about 38 ft. long. The axle boxes work
in jaws and upon the top of each box
rests a heavy semi-eliptic spring, all the
springs being equalized together. The
light weight of the car is 196,420 pounds.
The car was made by the Bethlehem
Steel Company for their own use, and
has already borne the weight of two iron
castings the combined weight of which
was 277,000 pounds. There are also sev-
eral other castings, made of steel by this
company for the 1,200-ton forging press
for the Carnegie Steel Company, which
are in all likelihood the largest steel-cast-
ings in the world. The amount of metal
necessary to make one of these castings
being about 325,000 pounds. This re-
quires six 40-ton open-hearth furnaces
running full blast to provide the required
metal for each such casting.
"It ain't our station in life
changes us — thoughts is free !"
— Little Dorrit.
that
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
365
Air= Brake Department.
Operating Conditions of High-Speed
Trains.
The advantage gained by the use of
Westinghouse high-speed brake appa-
ratus is, in general, sufficiently empha-
sized by the bare statement of superior
•efficiency; but, to appreciate the reasons
that have led many of the leading rail-
ways of the country to adopt it as the
standard for trains running at high aver-
age rates of speed, it is necessary to
keep in view the special circumstances
under which such trains are operated.
While many local trains frequently run
at very high speeds for comparatively
short distances in convenient places, this
occurs under conditions that involve no
unusual risks. The chief characteristic
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NEI,I<IS.
been established, is accompanied by com-
plications of greater gravity than would
readily be anticipated. The distance in
which a train can be stopped from a
speed of forty miles per hour is nearly
twice as great as that from which it
can be stopped from a speed of thirty
miles per hour. At fifty miles per hour,
the stopping distance is more than three
times as great as that required at thirty
miles per hour, and nearly twice as great
as that required at forty miles per hour.
At sixty miles per hour the distance re-
quired for stopping is about five times
as great as that required for thirty miles
per hour, and more than two and one'
half times as great as that required at
forty miles per hour. In addition, the
requirements of the special conditions,
and in a manner that will enable such
trains to be operated with the same
degree of safety as is now common with
ordinary trains, in so far as the con-
trolling of speed by power brakes is con-
cerned.
The most scientific and efficient way
of stopping trains is by the automatic
regulation of brake-shoe pressure, be-
ginning with comparatively heavy pres-
sure at high speeds, and reducing the
same relatively as the speed slackens.
This is exactly the method employed in
the use of the Westinghouse high-speed
brake.
This brake, which consists of the
Standard Westinghouse Quick-Action
OFFICES AND FACTORY WORKS OF THE WESTINGHOUSE AIR BRAKE COMP.\NY AT ST. PETERSBURG, RUSSIA.
of the special train service here consid-
ered is not so much the maximum speed
attained as its high average rate between
terminals, which required a velocity
through yards and over bridges, switches
and crossings (where ordinary trains are
required to be under full control) not
heretofore demanded and consequently
not provided for.
Signals have already been located at
such distance from danger points as to
provide ample space in which to bring
trains to a stop from customary speeds;
tut they are sufficiently near such points
to avoid interference with the orderly
movement of trains through unneces-
sarily retarding their progress at remote
distances. The distance between block
signals, upon roads subject to heavy
traffic, has been likewise established upon
these principles. The introduction of a
train service in which the speed is con-
siderably greater than that for which the
operating conditions of the road have
frequency of meeting danger signals —
and therefore the frequency with which
applications of the brakes are likely to
occur — increases directly with the speed.
It is therefore important that unusually
frequent applications of the brakes shall
be provided for, without seriously im-
pairing their capacity to stop the train
in the shortest possible distance at any
instant that emergency demands it.
The safe operation of such trains re-
quires either a reorganization of existing
signal systems or more effective means
for controlling speed by the brakes than
have heretofore existed. The objections
to materially increasing the distance be-
tween signals and the points which they
protect, or introducing additional sig-
nals for the special protection of such
fast trains, are many and obvious; and
a satisfactory solution of the problem
seems to be found only in providing
high-speed trains with a brake apparatus
of extraordinary efficiency to meet the
Brake with a pressure-regulating attach-
ment, was originally designed to meet
the exceptional requirements of trains
scheduled at the high average rates of
speed now so common in regular service.
The most gratifying results following
the extended use of this device has been
the demonstration of its absolute relia-
bility, the quality which, above all others,
is requisite in brake apparatus. The
Westinghouse High-Speed Brake will
stop a properly equipped train in about 30
per cent, less distance than that required
for stopping a similar train under the
same conditions with the best braking
appliances in use before the high-speed
brake was introduced.
This superior stopping capacity is ob-
tained in part by increasing the air pres-
sure, from the usual 70 lbs. to about no
lbs. An additional advantage is that an
ordinary quick-action brake may be con-
verted into a high-speed brake without
difficulty and at slight expense.
366
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 190J.
Ingenious Compressed Air Tools.
At the New York. Susquehanna &
Western Railroad shops, at Stroudsburg,
Pa., there are some very handy and effi-
cient appliances operated by compressed
air, several of which are herewith illus-
trated by permission of Mr. W. H. Tay-
lor, M. M., who was assisted by the gen-
eral foreman. Mr. M. N. Diefenderfer,
and Mr. T. Y. Mcllin. in working out the
details of these tools.
pushing the piston and rod upward,
thereby closing the throttle and at the
same time sounding a warning whistle.
A small bleed cock is placed below the
cylinder to allow the throttle to be open-
ed at once if desired.
Fig. 2 is an improvement added to the
ordinary lever handle pump (i) for test-
mg gauges, and consists of an air cylin-
der (2) 3-in. diameter by 6-in. stroke,
and a water cylinder (,?") iV.-in. diameter
THE WESTl.NGllOfSK AlK ISKAKE CuMfA.W S OIIICKS AND WORKS .\T HA.MILTON,
ONTARIO, CANADA.
Fig. I shows an ingenious device at-
tached to the throttle valve of a sta-
tionary engine, for instantly stopping the
engine in case of danger to life or ma-
chinery. A cylinder l54-in. diameter by
i2-in. long is placed below and at one
side of the throttle valve stem. The top
head of this cylinder has a square hole,
through which passes a i-in. square pis-
ton rod, having teeth cut on the side
FIG. 1. THROTTLE VALVK OPER.4TED BY
AIR PRESSURE.
next to the throttle stem. These teeth
engage a 4-in. gear wheel keyed on the
stem, and permits throttle to be opened
nearly one turn. At convenient points
in the different departments a J|-in.
cock is placed, which, when opened, ad-
mits air to the bottom of the cvlinder.
by 6-in. stroke, place above it, the pis-
ton rod from the lower cylinder passing
up and connecting to the plunger in the
water cylinder. Air is admitted by
means of a 3 way cock (4), having a
i-32-in. port, to under side of the lower
piston and forces it upward, thereby
compressing the water above the plunger
in the upper cylinder and creating suffi-
cient pressure to test any gauge in or-
dinary use, a small coil spring is attached
to the piston rod, drawing it back to
normal position when air pressure is
• xleased. This makes a very neat and
onvenient arrangement, is very steady
in its action and does not interfere with
use of lever handle pump when air pres-
sure is down.
Figs. 3 and 4 are views of an air pump
repair stand which is simple in construc-
tion, very rigid and easily handled. Fig
3 shows the table in position to receive
the pump, which is bolted to lugs, and
when the 3 way cock at the base is
opened, the air forces the piston up, and.
.Ts the table rises, a small rod attached
to the floor and the top of the table
pulls the table to a horizontal position
(Fig. 4), where it can be turned in any
position or fastened at the will of the
operator. The skeleton frame of the
table makes any part of the pump easy
of access, and is constructed to hold
both 8-in. and 9^-in. pumps.
Fig. 5 is a boiler test pump, the upper
parts of which consist of a steam cylin-
der, top head and center piece of an 8-in.
air pump. The lower or water cylinder
(2) is made from 3-in. galvanized pipe,
reinforced at the ends by shrinking on
a i^-in. by 2-in. band. The piston rod is
iV4-in. longer than the standard 8-in.
pump rod. and a stop piece l^-in. long
is placed on under side of the top head
of the water cylinder to prevent the
plunger covering the inlet port on the
up stroke. The supply is at 3 and deliv-
ery at 4, the check valves being placed
in front as shown. The pump is mount-
ed on a special truck which makes it
very convenient to handle, and it does
the work in a very satisfactory manner.
Train Pipe Leakage.
The increasing use of air brakes in
freight service is developing certain
difficulties of operation and maintenance
that have required considerable experi-
ence to reveal and which should be reme-
died, as they are greatly reducing the
efficiency of the brake service that is
obtainable if certain conditions can be
controlled. The principal manifestation
of an unsatisfactory state is the large
number of instances in which but few
of the whole number of brakes in a train
are connected. This is a most objection-
able practice and so contrary to the ideas
that led to the application of brakes to
freight trains, that careful inquiry has
been made to ascertain why the practice
is so general. The result of this inves-
tigation shows that several reasons of
more or less importance combine to ac-
count for it, but the chief causes are few
in number and at the head of the list is
train pipe leakage.
If this leakage is of any considerable
degree the pump is overtaxed, with ab-
normal wear and tear, and brakes are
^i^^BBt:^
? um
mmm.
r
1
Yt.LUUI.CM.INlE:illNC ~
t-
' 1
FIG. -i. AIR PRESSURE DEVICE FOR TE.ST-
ING AIR GAUGES.
cut out of service until the pump capacity
is sufficient to keep a working pressure.
It also interferes with graduated brake
application on level track and is almost
fatal to safe working on down grades,
for when communication with the main'
reservoir is cut off, leakage acts in one
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
367
respect as an engineer's valve in tliat
train pipe pressure is reduced and the
brakes are applied, but without manipu-
lation on the part of the engineer. As
the leak is nut of his control, the appli-
FIG. a AIR I'USIl' KKPAIR STAND OPER-
ATED BY AIR PRESSURE.
cation continues until the brakes arc
fully set, even though only a moderate
force is needed or desired. It is there-
fore evident that train pipe leakage not
only limits the number of brakes that
can be used, but also seriously interferes
with the proper and normal actuation
of those that are in service. As intimated
above, it is one of the principal causes
for excessive air pump repairs.
The principal source of leakage is
from defective hose coupling gaskets
that have been injured by the practice of
pulling the couplings apart when cars
are separated, instead of uncoupling
them by hand. While the construction
of the coupling is such that this can be
done without injuring the hose, yet a
continuance of the practice destroys the
gasket. It appears to be conceded that
it is practically impossible to get train-
men to disconnect couplings by hand.
and the remedy seems to be the sub-
stitution of a coupling that can be pulled
apart when cars are uncoupled without
in any way affecting its capability for
making an air-tight joint.
This object is fully attained with the
Westinghouse automatic coupler, which
also facilitated the making up of trains
and insures the use of brakes in many
cases where now there is a disposition
to couple up just enough to meet the
requirements of the situation as meas-
ured by the ideas of the trainmen. A
train partially fitted with air brakes has
elements of danger that are to be avoided
as far as possible, and anything that will
automatically tend to assure the opera-
tion of all the brakes on the train is
in the right direction. There is no other
single modification that would contribute
to the desired result more than the use
of a good automatic hose coupler. When
all the cars in trains are fitted with
operating brakes, the disastrous results
of parted trains will almost entirely dis-
appear, and until this is done one of the
greatest benefits to be derived from their
use will not be realized.
at the smaller, outlying places, and the
carrying of extra stock at those points
for making repairs, which is one of the
greatest expenses attached to a railroad
company. It can be readily seen that the
CORRESPONDENCE.
Rconomical Repairs to 9 1-2 Inch Air
Pumps.
In order to give what we considered
the best practice for repairs to the gVi
inch air pump an accurate account of
both labor and material was kept to as-
certain definitely the most economical
way of doing the work creditably, and
we have found that the following is the
best.
The practice of partially overhauling
pumps on engines should only be in-
dulged in to a very limited and unavoid-
able extent. It has been found a much
more economical and reliable practice to
remove the pump from the engine and
give it a thorough overhauling in the
air-brake repair room, than to attempt
FIG. 5. BOILER TEST PU.MP.
to repair it on the engine in the round
house.
We have adopted the plan of overhaul-
ing air pumps at our general shop. This
eliminates improper repairs being made
^^^^li^^^--
.' j^ " ^^^H
r — —
JSS^^^^
i i: — —iJH^ il
FIG. 4. AIR PU.MP REPAIR STAND IN
HORIZONTAI, POSITIO.V.
repairs to air pumps will be much more
satisfactory and economical when done
at a general, centralized point, and under
the direct supervision of a competent and
thorough air-brake man. There are two
very important factors we must bear in
mind; first, "Workmanship;" second.
"Standards." Only such men who have
proved themselves competent and who
have been thoroughly instructed by the
general air-brake inspector, should be
employed on repairs to air pumps. Stand-
ard sizes and parts should be adhered to
as much as possible.
Air pumps should first be put into a
vat or tank containing a strong solu-
tion of lye, and allowed to soak until all
grease and dirt have been removed.
Steam should not be admitted direct into
the vat. as with this method the solution
is rapidly diluted. A coil with a drain
should be used. The pump should be
removed from the vat and thoroughly
blown out with steam until all ports and
passages are perfectly clear. This work
should be done by a helper. The pump
should then be turned over to the air-
pump repairman, and should be thor-
oughly dismantled.
The practice of scrapping main valve
bush No. 75, and applying a new one in-
stead, is an extravagance, to say the
least. The main valve bush should be
pressed out of the head, put in a lathe,
and bored to 3f\ of an inch, after
which a bushing should be turned to fit
the main valve bush that has been bored,
and should be forced in, bored to stand-
ard size and properly faced, ports to be
drilled through the new bushing. The
bush is now ready to be pressed back
368
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
into the head. This work can be done
for 8s cents, and against $475 for a new
bush is a saving of $3.90.
The left main valve cylinder head
should be placed in a lathe and bored to
2-% of an inch, after which a bushing
should be turned and pressed into the
head, bored and faced to standard size,
and ports properly drilled. This work
• can be done for 40 cents, and against 75
cents for a new head, is a saving of 35
cents.
The large and small main valve piston
■ packing rings, Nos. 78 and 80, should be
• removed and new ones applied and prop-
! erly fitted. Our experience has been that
i home-made rings do not give the proper
I wear and life that rings furnished by the
■ Westinghouse Air-Brake Company do.
The main slide valve and its seat
should be properly faced. When the
main slide valve has ,5^, of an inch play
between shoulders of the main valve
stem, it should be scrapped and a new
valve applied.
Next remove the reversing valve
chamber bush, No. 73. and apply a new
one. Also apply a new reversing valve
No. yz. We have found that when bush
is renewed an old reversing valve should
never applied.
Three sixty-fourths of an inch play be-
tween valve No. 72 and reversing valve
rod, when valve is new, calls for a new
rod; however, templets should be used
to ascertain which part is worn and needs
renewing.
It should also be noted that the re-
versing valve chamber cap is properly
fitted on bush No. T2, and on the head
proper.
Care should be taken that the distance
between the knob on the end of the re-
versing valve rod and shoulder is of the
proper length, the reversing valve plate
should be removed to ascertain the e.xact
condition of the under side. If worn on
either side, apply a new plate.
Steam piston and rod No. 65 should
be examined, and it is quite essential,
that the rod be perfectly true. New pis-
ton packing rings should be applied.
Great care should be taken in the work-
manship in applying rings, otherwise the
pump will blow, and back pressure will
be materially increased.
When a packing ring is cut, that por-
tion of it nearest the ends has a ten-
dency to remain straight. When the ring
is reduced to the size of the cylinder, the
result is a poor fit for almost one-third
of the circumference. To obviate this
trouble and thereby secure better fitting
rings, it is necessary to either file ofT the
outside of the rings nears the ends, or
turn them up in a lathe after the rings
have been cut. Either plan will do, just
so the rings are made to fit the cylinder
properly. The same is applicable to the
air cylinder piston packing rings.
In applying piston No. 66 it is desir-
able that lock nuts should be used on the
end of the piston rod, as furnished by
the Coffin-Megeath Supply Company,
h'ranklin, Pa.
It is the most advisable and most econ-
omical way, when necessary to bore
steam and air cylinders, to bore them to
a standard of Q-j^ of an inch and apply
new pistons and rods.
The centerpiece needs more than pass-
ing notice. If the piston rod has been
turned down in order to true it up, new
glands should be applied, and as close
a fit on piston rod without binding.
Stuffing box nuts should fit neatly, and
the bo.x itself should be carefully ex-
amined to see that it is properly secured
and tightened in the centerpiece. Air
valve seat No. 87 and valve cage No. 88,
when worn, should be removed and new
ones applied; also new air valve No. 86.
Care should be taken that the lift of the
air valves does not exceed /j of an
inch.
It is not advisable nor practicable to
use new air valves with old valve cages
or valve seats unless seats are properly
trued. All copper joints should be an-
nealed.
All repaired pumps should be put on
Main Ittseri'mr
Haiiway i iMOumutive Enginetrxng
DESOE'S RETAINING DEVICE.
a test rack and run a sufficient length of
time to assure their efficiency before be-
ing placed in active service.
By following the above recommended
practice of repairs, the failure of air
pumps on our line of road has been re-
duced to a miniinum. For the year end-
ing June I, '03, there were but three air
pump failures, which were reported as
follows: "Reversing rod broke." "Main
piston rod broke." ''Reversing plate bolt
worked out."
Otto Best, Gen'l Air-Brake Inspr.
N. C. & St. L. Ry.
Nashville, Tenn.
Retarding Power of Driving Brakes.
(Continued.)
The trouble experienced with this ar-
rangement was the unsatisfactory opera-
tion of the safety valve, and not being
able to admit air from the main res-
ervoir to the cylinders before the triple
was moved to release position. The
latter trouble was overcome in a way by
a pipe connection between the pipe con-
necting the gauge to the cylinder, and
the pipe connecting the valve with the
exhaust port of the triple, in which a
globe valve was placed, so that when it
was desired to admit air from the main
reservoir to the cylinders with the triple
in application position, the handle of the
retaining valve was placed in the proper
position and the globe valve opened.
This, however, made the arrangement
complicated, and the safety valve was
very unsatisfactory, so the entire ar-
rangement was discarded.
The next arrangement, which is illus-
trated by the accompanying sketch,
proved to be much better than any tried,
and is in use on a number of engines to-
day. It consists of a three-way valve,
located in the cab. One opening is con-
nected to a train air signal reducing
valve (Pipe "C" in the sketch), which,
being adjusted to 40 pounds pressure, re-
duces the main reservoir pressure ad-
mitted to the brake cylinders to 40
pounds. One of the other openings is
connected to the pipe leading from the
triple to the brake cylinders (Pipe "A"
in the sketch), and the third opening is
connected to the pipe from the brake
cylinders (Pipe "B" in the sketch).
That is, the pipe connecting the triple
with the brake cylinders is extended
up into the cab, where it is cut and the
retaining valve inserted. In one position
of the handle of the retaining valve the
automatic brake can be applied and re-
leased just the same as it can when piped
as ordinarily, for pipes "A" and "B" are
connected through the retaining valve
and pipe "C" is blanked. With the han-
dle of the valve in retaining position,
communication from the triple to the
cylinders is closed, and communication
is established between the reducing valve
and the brake cylinders; that is, pipes
"C" and "B" are connected and pipe
"A" is blanked, therefore, in this posi-
tion 40 pounds pressure is assured in the
cylinders, with any ordinary leakage,
whether the triple is in application or re-
lease position. There is a lap position
to the valve so that any portion of the
40 pounds may be admitted to the cyl-
inders.
A gauge is connected directly to one
of the cylinders, so that the pressure de-
veloped may be known at any time. This
arrangement works very satisfactory,
but some trouble is experienced by the
plug-cock leaking, and I am having made
a valve in which leather seat popet
valves will be used, and I expect to use
with this valve a slide-valve reducing-
valve. I see no reason why the West-
inghouse Air Brake Co.'s "Straight Air
Automatic Brake" would not fill every
requirement of a straight air retaining
valve, which I term the valve described.
E. G. Desoe, Gen'l. A. B. Inspt.
B. & A. R. R.
Springfield, Mass.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3'>9
QIESTIONS A^D ANSWERS
ON THS AIR BRAKE
(57) B. J. S., Frankfort, Ind., asks:
Does the friction of the air passing by
a leaky packing ring in the air end of an
air pump cause the pump to heat? A. —
The greater amount of heating is due to
compression, during which process the
molecules of air are forced against each
fither harder as the pressure increases,
thus causing friction between the mole-
cules and consequent heat. The mere
passing of air by the packing ring from
one end of the cylinder to the other
does produce a certain amount of fric-
tion, doubtless, but not very much, per-
haps about the same amount that would
be produced by air passing through a
pipe in which the pressure does not vary
much.
(58) J. W. E., Pittsburg, Pa., asks:
Why does a cylinder wear larger on
the ends than it does in the middle?
This applies both to air and steam cylin-
ders of the air pump. A. — Because the
• pressure at the end of the stroke is
higher than at the beginning. This pres-
sure gets behind the packing rings and
forces them more tightly against the
walls of the cylinder as the stroke pro-
gresses, the greater pressure being at
the extreme end of the stroke. Thus
the greatest wear is had where the pres-
sure is highest. On the return stroke
this same is true. The steam cylinder
does not wear as much larger at the
ends of the stroke as does the air cylin-
der, but wears irregularly at all points
of the stroke, and has a great tendency
to wear out of round.
(59) B. F. R., Camden, N. J., asks :
Would the friction of the air passing
through a crack in a leaky discharge pipe
cause the pump to heat? A. — The air
passing through the crack would not
heat due to the friction caused between
the air and the edges of the crank
through which the pressure is passing,
as the pressure, in escaping at the crack,
would reduce and cool. The pump, how-
ever, would be required to do more work
to keep up this leakage. The greater
heat, due to greater amount of air com-
pressed, would cause the pump to run
hotter than though the crack did not
exist and did not have to be supplied. In
other words, it is the friction of the air
molecules rubbing together that causes
heat, more than the mere rubbing of the
air against the sides of the piston and
walls of the cylinder.
(60) J. W. E., Pittsburg, Pa., writes:
What would you think was the trouble
if an air cylinder that has been properly
oiled and had packing rings perfectly
fitted, and in fact everything in perfect
working order, if, upon examination, it
is found to have the inside of the cylin-
der cut? A. — If the cylinder walls and
packing rings are always lubricated, and
foreign matter excluded from the cylin-
der, there will be no cutting. However,
the present method of lubricating the air
cylinder gives it a flood ol oil at some
times and a dearth of supply at other
times. This permits the parts to get dry,
and friction of the dry parts causes cut-
ting and scoring of the cylinder walls
and packing rings. On long trains in
Ireight service it is seldom that the air
cylinder is kept constantly and uniformly
lubricated, and this cutting, due to dry
surfaces and entrance of sand, cinders
and other foreign matters into the cylin-
der through the suction, causes cutting
of the parts.
(61) A. M. E., Frankfort, Ind.,
writes:
A number of the truck wheels on our
engines which have steel tired wheels
are troubled with fiat spots. The spots
do not seem to come from the wheels
skidding on the rail, as there are no
brakes on these wheels to skid them.
A. — Doubtless you are experiencing a
trouble similar to that had on some of
the Atlantic type trailing wheels, al-
though these are braked. This trouble
is had from flat spots, at first believed to
be due to too much brake power, but
which is really due to "faults" in the tire
material. A number of these tires have
been found to have "blow holes" or
"faults" in the tire. When this "blow
hole" comes in contact with the rail,
the metal around it closes in to fill up
the "blow hole" or shelled out place,
causing the metal to recede from its
original position, thereby creating a flat
spot. In the event of the "blow hole"
being found in the middle of a flat spot,
it would seem proof conclusive that the
flat spot comes from the "blow hole"
and not from the skidding of the wheel.
(62) C. A. K., Jamaica, Long Island.
N. Y.. writes:
We have a case of a three-car train
sliding wheels with 50 pounds train line
pressure. We find it impossible to carry
70 pounds train line pressure, because of
wheel sliding. A. — Doubtless this trouble
comes from poor brakes on the locomo-
tive and tender. In cutting down the train
line pressure to 50 pounds you would
undoubtedly get away from the sliding of
wheels on the cars, except in extreme
cases of bad rail, etc., but at the same
time one puts himself in a very undesir-
able position in doing this by so weak-
ening the braking power of his train that
he cannot make a quick stop if he should
be required to do so. We should cer-
tainly advise putting the train pipe pres-
sure up to 70 pounds. Put a gauge on
the driver brake cylinders of the loco-
motive and also one on the tender brake
cylinder, then apply the brakes and note
whether the pressure holds in the cylin-
der or whether it leaks off quickly. We
think you will find your trouble from
wheel sliding on the cars due to poor
leather packing in the driver brake cylin-
ders or tender cylinder.
(63) W. J. J., Little Rock, Ark.,
writes:
We have an 8-in. pump here that will
make an up stroke and down stroke
quite regular when the pump first starts
to pump up air, and until it gets up to
about 40 pounds. Then its down strokes
are much quicker than the up strokes.
The higher this pump pumps pressure,
the quicker are the down strokes and the
slower are the up strokes. We have
looked for the trouble everywhere and
find the pump in good condition. A. —
There is doubtless dirt or other foreign
matter under the upper discharge valve
of the air cylinder of the pump which
you have failed to note. Possibly there
is either a flaw in the upper discharge
valve or its seat, causing it to let pres-
sure pass from the main reservoir to the
air cylinder of the pump when the valve
is seated. When the pump is first start-
ed this fault would be little noticed, be-
cause the pressure is not very high; but
as the pressure increases the fault will
become more noticeable, and the down-
ward stroke would be made quicker, due
to the leakage of pressure from the
main reservoir back into the air pump
through the upper discharge valve, due
to the dirt between the valve and the
seat or to the fault in the valve or its
seat.
(64) L. R. M., Trenton. N. J., writes :
On some of our high-speed trains
when the brake is applied in service ap-
plication position, with a three-car train,
and sometimes with a ten-car train, the
brake will go on in quick action when
not wanted. A. — Your trouble on the
short train is probably due to the fact
that the equalizing piston perhaps hangs
back, and when it does rise it rises too
quickly and discharges train pipe air to
the atmosphere too suddenly when the
service application is made. The equal-
izing piston may be dirty, causing it to
move with a tardy or jerky movement,
thus squirting the air out of the train
pipe in jerks, which so affects the triple
valves as to throw them into quick ac-
tion. Possibly the triple valves them-
selves are dirty and need cleaning. In
either event we would examine both the
triple valves and the equalizing piston
of the brake valve. This same trouble
has been experienced on other roads,
and after careful investigation of the
triple valve and brake valve conditions,
it has been decided to put on an equaliz-
ing reservoir 10x14 in., in place of the
present one of 10x12 in. The 10x14 in.
reservoir is now the standard of the
Westinghouse Air Brake Co., and is be-
ing sent out on all orders.
"You'll be switched if you don't keep
to the right," as the flagman said to the
train on the single track.
370
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Sheedy Circulator for Locomotive
Cylinders.
On page 275 of our June number we
illustrated locomotive 2279. a piston valve
engine belonging to the Southern Pacific
Company, which is equipped with the
Sheedy patent circulator for relieving
cylinders of back pressure and vacuum.
Annexed we present some indicator dia-
grams to illustrate the effect of the in-
vention and the conditions that exist in
the cylinders when the circulator is not
in use.
As many of our readers do not under-
stand indicator diagrams the following
e.\planation will be helpful. The hori-
zontal line shown in all the diagrams is
called the atmospheric line, and indicates
the division between pressure and vac-
uum. The lines which the indicator pen-
cil draw above the atmospheric line in-
dicate pressure in the cylinders, the lines
below the atmospheric line indicate
vacuum. A spring of 30 pounds resist-
ance was used in the indicator, so the
pressure or vacuum is calculated by the
height or depth of the diagram from the
atmospheric line.
The cards i and 2 were taken when
the engine was running with the reverse
lever in the 10 cut-off notch with the
circulating pipe cut out. Cards la and
2a were taken in the same notch with
the circulating pipe in operation. We
have put these cards in pairs to show
the great beneficial difference when the
pipe is doing its work. Cards 3 and 3a,
4 and 4a represent the engine running
with the lever in the 22-inch cut-off
notch. The pressure shown in the cylin-
ders, which goes as high as 45 pounds
to the square inch when running at 10-
inch cut-off with the circulating pipe
cut out, acts as compression or back
pressure and resists the movement of the
piston. The vacuum also resists the mo-
tion of the piston and sucks dirt into the
cylinders.
Diagrams show the result of indicator
tests. This engine has been shopped re-
cently for general repairs. An examina-
tion of the piston valves shows them to
be in perfect order with no noticeable in-
dication of wear and outside of the cost
of examination there has been no ex-
pense connected with their use since
they have been put in service.
This circulator is also used on low
pressure cylinder of compound engines.
The device is absolutely automatic in
its operation. Whenever steam is ap-
plied to move the engine, the valves are
bound to close and cut off the communi-
cation between the front and back of the
cylinders. Whenever the steam is shut
off by the closing of the main throttle,
the circulator valves open without fail.
Its application to a single expansion
piston valve engine brings the compres-
sion line just where you want it. In the
case of engine 2279 the circulator takes
liailaa]/ $ hocomotive i^nfftncerinff
3 a
=^
4 a
Bailwan i Locumotivt inpiMMft'ip
SHEEDY CIRCULATOR DIAGRAMS.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
371
off eighty to eiglity-six per cent, at point
of terminal compression, and leaves suf-
ficient to steady the reciprocating parts
when the engine is drifting at high
speed.
The circulation of the air in cylinder
from one end to the other through the
medium of the circulator valves and pipe,
keeps the temperature of the cylinders
normal. The air is neither chilled by
the use of the relief valve opening to the
atmosphere nor is the degree of heat
run up by compression at high speed,
noticeable. As is quite well known, the
force that is responsible for this heat'
is the weight of the train pushing the
engine down hill with throttle closed in
opposition to the retarding power de-
veloped in the cylinders by compression
and partial vacuum. When the piston
valve engine is at the morcy of these two
contending forces, the degree of heat is
so high that cylinder oil is not effective.
This arrangement on either a single
ders on piston valve engines of water
which finds its way to these cylinders
when the engine primes. This question
of water in cylinders of piston valve
engines has given serious trouble where
water is inclined to foam or prime.
It has been responsible for broken cylin-
der heads, forcing piston rod fits of! or
on crossheads (this depending on which
end the water got trapped in), doubling
up main rods and other annoyances of a
similar nature.
Baldwin Simple 2-8-O for the Long
Island Railroad.
The Long Island Railroad has recently
purchased some 2-8-0 engines from the
Baldwin Locomotive Works. The cab
is of the kind generally called "Mother
Hubbard," and it is placed very close
to the smokebox. The sandbox, auxiliary
dome and dome proper and bell are all
behind the cab, the center of which is
just above the rocker arm.
as to leave plenty of steam room above
it. There are 330 tubes 11 ft. 7J4 in.
long, giving 1,993.2 sq. ft. of healing sur-
face, the firebox gives 192 sq. ft., mak-
ing a total of 2,185.2 sq. ft. The grate
area amounts to 70.6 sq. ft.
The tender has steel frame and trucks
having boxes working in jaws with
equalizers. The tank holds 5,000 gallons
of water. The weight of the engine and
tender in working order is about 265,000
lbs. Some few of the principal dimen-
sions are as follows:
Cyltnder— 2t x 2H in.
IJoilcr— Dia., 72 in.; thickness of sheets, ^ in.;
working pressure, 200 Ibfl.; fuel, anthracite or
bituminous; staying, radical.
Firebox— Length. 119I/4 in.; width, 8s!4 in.; depth,
front, 62 in.; back, bo'A in ; thickness of sheets.
sides, }^ in.; back, H in.; crown, *> in ; tube. %
in : water space, front, 4 in.; sides, 3W tn-i
back. ^\-^ in.
Tubes — Material, iron; Kauge, No. ti.
IleatinR surface— Firebox. 192. sq.ft.; tut>e9, 1,993-2
sq. ft.; total. 2. 185.2 sq. ft.
Driving wheels — Dia. .outside. 51 in,; journals, 8x10
X 0 m t
li.\Ll)WIN CONSOLIDATION FOR THE LO.NG XSL.^iNU KAII,KO.\D.
expansion piston valve engine or on the
large cylinder of a compound engine, re-
lieves the engine of the necessity of draw-
ing on exhaust nozzle for relief to neu-
tralize the effect of vacuum resistance
present in the cylinder of the engine
when drifting. This vacuum resistance
not only induces heated gasses and cin-
ders from the firebo.x and front end to
enter the cylinders through the nozzle,
thereby destroying all lubrication on sur-
faces and fouling all movable parts of the
piston packing in the cylinders as well
as the valves, but it is also responsible
for an excessive use of fuel. This fuel
must be applied to protect the tubes.
etc., from injurious drafts when the en-
gine is drifting as the draft on the fire is
very severe because of the induction
through the nozzle to which the fire is
exposed, To protect the firebox the coal
must be applied even though the safety
valve is blowing.
Relief valves appearing in' connection
with the circulator are intended for the
purpose of relieving the large cylinders
of compound engines of the excessive
pressure when reducing valve or other
appliances fail. Also to relieve the cylin-
The engine is simple, with cylinders
21x28 in. The driving wheels measure
51 in. outside tires. The weight of the
whole machine is 165,080 lbs., and it is
capable of. exerting a tractive effort of
41,160 lbs. The ratio of tractive force
to adhesive weight is as i is to ■^.47,
the weight on the drivers being 143,080
lbs. The driving wheel base of this en-
gine is 14 ft. 6 in. and only the front
and rear drivers are flanged. The total
wheel base ot the engine is 22 ft. 9 in.
The pistons drive on the third pair of
wheels and the eccentrics are placed on
the axle of the pair ahead. In order
to make the eccentric rods of sufficient
length, the links are carried beyond the
rocker and a short transmission bar runs
from link block back to rocker. The
valve gear is the usual indirect type and
the valves are the ordinary balanced
slide.
The boiler is of the straight top va-
riety with wide firebox. The outside
diameter of the first course is 72 in.
The back sheet is 84^^ '"• high, and the
hood for the protection of the fireman
is bolted flat down upon the roof sheet.
The height of the crown sheet is such
in.; engine truck wheels, dia., 30 in.; journaLs
5)4 X 10 in.
Wheel base— Total engine and tend., 48 ft. 11 >s in.
Weight — On driving wheels, 143,0^0 lbs.; on truck.
fiont, 22,ooolbs.: total engine, 165,0^0 lbs.
Where Railroad Travelers Were Not
Hurried.
In 1845 the series of small railroads
connecting Albany with Buffalo were
connected so that an unbroken journey
could be made so far as the cars were
concerned. But the people managing
the lines acted as if travelers had no
right to be in a hurry. Trains were not
permitted to run after dark in New York
state. Trains going West stopped at
Syracuse all night. Through trains
from Buffalo east stopped so that the
passengers had supper and breakfast in
Auburn.
In Pennsylvania and Maryland the
railroads did not pay much attention to
the shades of night falling. As early as
1838 sleeping cars were run between Bal-
timore and Philadelphia and various
Pennsylvania lines soon fell into the
habit of providing seats which could be
converted at night into fairly comfort-
able beds.
3-2
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Another Air Valve Setting Hachine.
This very efficient machine shown
herewith for revolving the main wheels
of a locomotive during the operation of
valve setting, has been operated for sev-
eral months at the Chicago, Milwaukee
and St. Paul shops, at Minneapolis, Minn.
The idea has been worked out by Mr.
James M. Brearley, general foreman,
applying an ordinary air motor to the
gear of a cylinder boring bar attached
to single rollers in each pit rail, the
motor being operated by a tradle on ttie
outside of pit. Right and left tram cen-
ters are taken on one wheel. One ma-
chinist and an apprentice boy are all the
labor required for valve setting. Speed
as well accuracy in stopping at tram
centers are also among the fine features
of the machine. Mr. Brearlev has sev-
formance got into the papers lately. He
was on his way to be married and had
to wait at a noisy junction for a belated
train. He fell asleep in the waiting room
that all the trains for the day passed and
did not awake until he was roused, when
it was time to close the waiting room.
He was kept entirely awake for some
time after reaching his destination, after
all the wedding guests had gone.
Steel Cars.
In the topical discussion of sleel cars
Mr. A. L. Humphrey, of the Chicago &
Alton, who spoke first, pointed out that
no one has questioned the advisability of
the steel car from a purely traffic stand-
point. It reduces dead weight and so
permits increased percentage of revenue
load. Repairs to steel cars are phe-
HANDY AIR VALVE-SETTING MACHINE.
eral other devices of value. One being
a ilue rolling attachment to an air motor
which we shall be pleased to give the
readers of your valuable journal in the
near future.
Evan M. Jones,
Minneapolis, Minn. Foreman.
A Sound Sleeper.
Flagmen have repeatedly met death
by sitting on the track and falling asleep
remaining in that condition until struck
by the train they went out to stop. There
is the familiar illustration of the miller
going to sleep beside his wheel and it is
believed that some people sleep peace-
fully in streets traversed by elevated rail-
road trains while others lie undisturbed
when the Pullman car porter crashes up
a neighboring bed into position. These
people may be considered sound sleepers,
but they hardly equal a man whose per-
nonienally low, and when railroads ac-
quire shop equipment capable of handling
repairs caused by wrecks or otherwise,
the work will be as simple as it now is to
wooden cars.
The composite car, that is one with
steel underframe and wooden superstruc-
ture when used in hauling coal, as far as
service is concerned, is equal to the all-
steel car, but the ratio of dead weight
to paying load is higher for the com-
posite car than it is with the all-steel car.
In case of wrecks the composite cars do
not stand as well as the all-steel cars, but
in the matter of ordinary maintenance
there is very little difference in the cost.
The question, however, arises: "What
will be the comparison in ten to twelve
years hence?" The one danger which
besets the future of the steel car is de-
terioration due to corrosion and rust. The
composite car has been thought by some
to be superior in this respect to th; all-
steel car, but the experience of the Al-
ton appeared to be that the composite car
with its wooden floor and sides became
soaked with water and moisture from the
coal, and this keeps the metal parts of the
car damp with water containing sulphur
and other injurious elements, all of which
help on the corroding action, especially
where this contaminated water drips
upon the steel. On one car which was
specifically mentioned it was found neces-
sary to scrape and paint three or four
times a year.
From experience obtained with the
high side steel hopper gondola the
speaker saw no reason why an all-steel
frame box car should not be as success-
ful as the all-steel gondola is. The same
advantage with reference to dead weight
and paying load, would apply to them as
it now does to the gondola. With proper
steel underframing and truck and with
suitable design of draw gear, running re-
pairs to freight equipment can be brought
down to a minimum. The matter of de-
sign, however, is important, as success-
ful design must do away with the possi-
bility of corrosion by preventing water
dripping on the metal. Remove the pos-
sibility of corrosion and the steel car, will
be everlasting. The steel car has come
to stay and some preventative must and
will be found. The outside of the car
can be taken care of now, but the preser-
vation of the inside of the car has not yet
been successfully accomplished, and there
is important work in this direction yet to
be done.
Consolidation Company Raise Rates.
The New York, New Haven & Hart-
ford Railroad Company have shocked
many freight shippers by making a con-
siderable advance in freight rates. The
advance will range from one to two cents
per hundred pounds, and there will also
be a readjustment of coal rates, which
were advanced recently 10 and 20 cents
per ton. The New York, New Haven
& Hartford Railroad Company are in an
unusually good position for raising trans-
portation rates, for the reason that they
have practically no competition, and it is
well known that they own the legisla-
tures of several states. It appears that
the company, in advancing th«ir schedule
of rates, endeavored to spread the in-
crease so that it would touch the whole
community, which proves that the man-
agement are entirely satisfied that they
can defy public sentiment without fear of
retaliation. There have been talks sev-
eral times since the decision in regard to
the Great Northern Railroad merger case
of something being done to test the
legality of the New York, New Haven
& Hartford Railroad Company absorb-
ing and operating competing lines; and
it may be that the new burdens which
they have imposed upon the people may
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
373
induce some public spirited citizen to
bring their case of merger before the
courts. It is a good opportunity for
some village Hampden to make himself
famous by defying aggressive might as
represented by the president of the con-
solidated lines.
American Locomotive Report.
Directors of the American Locomo-
tive Company met on June 24, and the
following statement was given out by
President Callaway:
Earnings of the company for the year
ending June 30, 19031 with the month of
June partly estimated, were $32,863,730,
an increase over the previous fiscal year
of $6,465,337. More than $4,000,000 has
been expended in enlarging the different
plants, and in introducing modern ma-
chinery. The work of improving and en-
larging the plants now outlined and au-
thorized by the directors will be com-
pleted during the next fiscal year. The
expenditures already made have pro-
duced an increase in the output of 40 per
cent. The company has orders for a
large number of engines to be delivered
in 1904. Full detailed reports of the
year's operations will be furnished to
stockholders as soon as the books are
closed, and the inventories can be made.
The regular dividend on the preferred
stock is payable July 21 to stockholders
of record on July 2.
been cITccted and results that have been
secured during the term of the preced-
ing contract.
The Galena-Signal Oil Company main-
lain in the United States and elsewhere in
the world, where they have established
business, a corps of mechanical inspectors,
who are experts in the matter of lubrica-
tion, devoting their entire time and at-
tention to studying the question of apply-
ing the oils so as to give the greatest
satisfaction. If railway officials desire
them, these experts are assigned to their
roads free of charge, to assist the railroads
to secure the greatest mileage with the
least consumption of oil. These experts,
when assigned to roads, have no authority
to issue instructions covering the use of
the oil, but only inspect existing condi-
tions and pr.icticcs and make recommenda-
have a perfect burning oil with an ad-
hesive and constant flame.
The lubricating oils manufactured by
the Galena-Signal Oil Company are:
Perfection Valve Oil. Galena Car Oil.
Galena Coach Oil. Galena Engine Oil,
and Galena Coach-Engine Oil.
The valve oil is composed of the very
best products it is possible to obtain,
compounded with the utmost care, the
testing and laboratory departments tak-
ing precautions to see that all of the
materials are exactly right before the oil
is made; and after it is compounded it is
again tested to make certain that the
mixture has been properly effected and
that the product is uniform with their
standard.
The Galena brands for the lubrication
of journals of cars, coaches and engines,
and the moving parts of engines, are
The Lubrication of Railroad Rolling
Stock.
We recently received a letter from a
locomotive superintendent in Great
Britain asking for particulars of the sys-
tem in vogue by which American rail-
ways obtain lubricants and other oils for
the use of their machinery. After mak-
ing careful inquiries we find that the
Galena-Signal Oil Company are supply-
ing lubricating and other oils to about
97 per cent, of the present railroad mile-
age of the North American Continent,
which with double track, side tracks, etc.,
amounts to about 204,000 miles, operat-
ing about 39.000 locomotives, 40.000 pas-
senger cars and 1,640,000 freight cars.
This business was commenced thirty-
four years ago and has gradually grown
up to its present dimensions. The usual
plan followed by the Galena-Signal Oil
Company is to make a contract with the
railroad company whereby they guaran-
tee that the cost per thousand miles on
the different classes of equipment, name-
ly, locomotives, passenger cars and
freight cars, shall not exceed a certain
maximum figure, which is determined on
the previous performance on the rail-
road entering into a contract with them.
When a contract is renewed after it has
once been made, the guarantee for re-
newal is determined on changes that have
BOMBAY,
WITH OFFICES OF BOMBAY. B.\ROD.\ & CEN"TR.\I, INDI.\
RAII,WAY IN FRONT.
tions to the proper railway official con-
trolling lubrication. If their recommenda-
tions are found to be good, and the rail-
way official approves of the same, he
takes such action as he deems fit. If he
does not see fit to adopt the suggestions
made by the company's expert, it is not
incumbent upon him to do so. It is
found, however, that almost invariably
the railway officials accept and put into
force the suggestions or recommenda-
tions made by the experts.
When trouble arises anywhere with
hot boxes or defective lubrication ot
locomotives special experts are assigned
to investigate and they never fail to
overcome the difficulty.
In addition to their lubricating oils,
they manufacture a Signal Oil, to be
used in hand lanterns, tail lights and
wherever necessary on a railroad to
compounded of whale oil, red lead and
the best crude petroleum obtainable,
namely, Franklin Crude Oil. They are
located right in the center of the only
district in the world producing this qual-
ity of oil. and taking an oil that is the
best natural lubricant known, they add
to, or strengthen it by the addition of
whale oil, which is recognized the world
over as one of the best lubricants obtain-
able, and red lead. Through their process
the red lead becomes a part of the com-
pound and is held in the oil in solution.
It assists lubrication by being conveyed
to the journal, or part to be lubricated,
and fills the interstices which are to be
found in the most highly polished piece
of steel, making the same smoother, and
decreasing friction.
In addition to the domestic business
the Galena-Signal Oil Company com-
374
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
menced several years ago soliciting
foreign trade, and now have substantial
business in Peru. Chili, the Argentine Re-
public. Uruguay and Brazil. They have
started in England, where the business has
grown steadily, though slowly. They have
two very large contracts in France, and
substantial business in Spain, Italy and
Egypt. Theif oils are being used from a
■southern temperate zone through the
tropical, northern temperate, and even
in the northern frigid zones of the world,
and are found to give complete satisfac-
tion everywhere, under all climatic and
geographical conditions.
The Steam Turbine.
The following is an abstract of a paper
read by Mr. L. R. Pomeroy at the Rail-
way Master Mechanics' Convention.
vacuum of 28 inches, will attain a veloc-
ity of about 4,000 feet per second. A jet
striking, a surface will exert a definite
pressure against that surface, the value
of which, in the case of normal impact,
is expressed by half the square of the
velocity per second into the mass of, the
fluid delivered against the surface per
second. Should a surface against which
such a jet impinges, such as that of a
vane attached radically to a shaft, remain
fixed, there will, of course, be no energy
delivered to the shaft; it is also evident
that should the vane have the same veloc-
ity as the impinging jet, no energy will
be delivered, since there is no exchange
of velocity between the jet and the vane.
The maximum amount of energy deliv-
ered will be when the vane has about
one-half the velocity of the jet, for in
tliat case the remaining velocity in the
.4 k: i
VICTORIA STATION, GREAT INDIAN TENINSULAR RAILWAY, liO.MUAY.
More interest has probably been mani-
fested by steam users in turbine develop-
ment than in any single subject of a me-
chanical nature which has come up in
steam circles during the last twenty
years, or since the application of steam
power to electrical generation has been
jn accomplished fact. And by many ex-
perienced steam engineers it is believed
that the turbine will accomplish a revolu-
tion in the methods of generating elec-
tric power for all purposes.
A gasoline fluid, such as steam, in
passing from a receiver at one pressure
into a receiver at another pressure, ac-
quires a definite velocity, due to the dif-
ference in pressure. For example:
Steam at iSO'pounds pressure expanding
into the atmosphere is capable of im-
-parting to itself a velocity of about 2,950
feet per second, and if expanded into a
jet after impact will equal the velocity
of the vane, and therefore be incapable of
imparting further energy. Speaking
broadly, in order that a single wheel
steam turbine may act at maximum effi-
ciency, its vanes should have a velocity
of about 2,000 feet per second working
between the foregoing limits of pressure,
that is, not far from the velocity of a
projectile from a modern piece of ord-
nance. The spouting velocity of water
discharged from a nozzle with a 100-foot
head is 80 feet per second. These fig-
ures illustrate the radical difference or
conditions between water turbines and
steam turbines. On account of the lower
velocity of the water jet, it is possible
to approach the speed of revolution in
the water turbine corresponding with the
theoretical maximum economy. The
elasticity of steam, however, as con-
trasted with the non-elastic condition of
water, compels the compounding of the
steam turbine, as the compounding of
the water turbine would destroy its effi-
ciency, while the momentum of the
steam, though checked by the first series
of buckets, recovers itself instantly by
expansion, and is checked again and
again by successive series of buckets-
until the steam has expended its expan-
sive force. It is thus readily seen that
the problem encountered in the steam
turbine is to extract from the steam the
work due to its velocity without exceed-
ing a moderate rate of revolution of the
shaft carrying the vanes upon which the
steam expands its velocity.
In the Curtis turbine the reduction of
speed is obtained: First, by placing the
vanes upon which the steam impinges
at a relatively great radial distance from
the axis of revolution, since for a given
speed of peripheral velocity, the revolu-
tions will be inversely as the radius,
.'^econd, by a gradual absorption of the
velocity of the steam at the periphery of
a nimiber of vane wheels; and instead of
having. all of these wheels in one cham-
ber, they are divided into two or more
groups of three or more wheels, con-
tained in separate chambers, but secured
to the same shaft. This provides for the
development and partial absorption of
velocity in stages, the work being equally
divided among the several stages.
The De Laval turbine depends almost
entirely on an initial velocity due to
complete expansion of the steam in the
nozzle while with the Parsons, being of
the parallel flow type, the energy im-
parted to the vanes is that due to the ex-
panding steam through the wheel. In
the Curtis, advantage is taken of any
initial velocity due to the amount of e.x-
pansion in the nozzle, availed of, coupled
with the additional velocity as the result
of expansion through the turbine. Ve-
locity is imparted to the steam in the ex-
panding nozzle so designed as to efti-
ciently convert nearly all the expansive
force, between the pressure limits used,
into velocity of the steam itself. After
leaving the nozzle, the steam passes suc-
cessively through two or more lines of
vanes on the moving element, which are
placed alternately with reversed vanes on
the stationary element. In passing suc-
cessively through these moving and sta-
tionary elements, the velocity acquired
in the nozzle is fractionally abstracted,
and largely given up to the moving ele-
ment. Thus the steam is first thrown
against the first set of vanes of the mov-
ing element, and then rebounds alternate-
ly from moving to stationary vanes until
it is brought nearly to rest. By this
means a high steam velocity is made to
efficiently impart motion to a compara-
tively slowly moving element. The noz-
zle is generally made up of many sec-
tions adjacent to each other, so that the
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
375
steam passes to the wheels in a broad
belt when all nozzle sections arc in flow.
In steam consumption, several of the
present commercial forms of steam tur-
bines show economic performances
somewhat less than those of the most
eflicient reciprocating steam engine,
such as is designed for pumping service,
though apparently fully equal to the best
types of reciprocating engine used in
electrical generation and superior to the
ordinary engines employed in that ser-
vice. A specific advantage claimed, how
ever, is that there is very much less fall-
ing ofT in economy at fractional loads as
compared with the best type of recipro-
cating engine, which, it is perhaps un-
necessary to add, is a point of the high-
est importance in electrical generation.
Moreover, there are the undisputed
commercial advantages of considerable
less cost of turbo-generator unit and
less floor space occupied. Moreover,
the possibility of using a very high de-
gree of superheat with the turbine still
further extends its possible economic ad-
vantages over the reciprocating steam
engine. A 600 kw.* unit showed an
economy of 19 pounds of dry steam per
kw. hour full load, and 20 1-2 pounds at
half load; this is the equivalent of 12 !-2
pounds per I horse power hour full load
and 13 1-2 pounds at half load; and with
150 degrees superheat, 16.75 pounds per
kw. full load and 17.8 pounds a half load,
or the equivalent of 11 pounds per i
horse power at full load and 11. 7 pounds
at half load.
A very interesting fact concerning the
development of the steam turbine is that
large and small turbined are nearly
equally efficient.
The steam turbine lends itself directly
to solutions of problems involving the
necessity of concentrating the largest
amount of power in the smallest possible
area consistent with economic operation.
Some of the advantages are:
1. High steam economy — full load
economy being substantially the same as
the overload economy, thus permitting
of a very large overload capacity, and
the fractional load economy being but
little inferior to that of the full load.
2. Extreme mechanical simplicity —
there being no packing except a single
shaft packing on the top of the turbine
which is required to hold only one or
two pounds pressure, the bearings have
no weight and the wear on the parts will
be substantially nothing.
3. Extremely small floor space — in the
larger sizes about .02 sq. ft. per kw. of
rated capacity.
4. Perfect symmetry of form.
5. Uniformity of expansion with no
alignment difficulties.
* Kilowatt written kw. is in the electrical meas-
ure of power and is equal to 44,250 foot povinds per
minnte, a little over one third more than a horse
power. One watt is 44.25 foot pounds per minnte
and represents the energ>' of one ampere urged by
one volt. — Ed.
6. Ideal form and speed of generator.
7. Accessibility of all parts.
To sum up: if then, we can ofTer a
prime mover for the generation of clec-
liicity, that is more simple than the com-
plex piston engine, the cost of mainten
ance of which will be less on account of
this simplicity; that is more economical
of operation and of space occupied, and
v\ithal, that is cheaper, it would seem
that the subject of steam turbines ought
til interest nearly every steam user.
No More Car Sparking.
The New York & Stamford Railroad
Company, which operates a trolley line
in Larchniont, Rye and other towns on
Long Island Sound, has a superinten-
Intent to Deceive.
ilie grand jury of the United States
court, sitting in Scranton, Pa., last
month, found a true bill against Alt. F.
Clark, Conrad Lotz, Louis Conrad and
W. M. Bingham, proprietors of the Cor-
respondence Institute of America, for
using the United States mails to defraud.
One of the witnesses before the grand
jury in the case was George Lines, of
Connecticut, who stated to your cor-
respondent that when he took a schol-
arship in the Correspondence Institute
he thought he was enrolling in the Scran-
ton school, of international reputation.
The Baldwin Locomotive works of
Philadelphia are one of the largest em-
ployers of workmen of all trades in this
.'ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES OF BOIIB.W, B.\RODA & CE.NTRAL RAILWAY. INDIA.
dent of a very courageous nature. He
has discovered that its motormen and
conductors devote too much time to
their young women friends, and has post-
ed an order, which reads:
"The last three seats and rear platform
are reserved for smokers. To be more
specific, do not reserve it for your 'lady
friend.' Let her be seated with the rest
of the crowd. It may have a tendency
to decrease the number of complaints
received at the office lately. The con-
ductor's place is on the rear platform,
unless he is collecting fares, issuing
transfers or assisting passengers on or
off the car."
The company, it is said, employs the
best-looking motormen and conductors
in the State, and many young women
have been in the habit of riding on the
platforms and in the rear seats to talk
with them.
country, or any other, except Krupp's,
possibly. No less than 15,000 men are
now under the roofs of the Baldwin
works, and the pay roll amounts to $190,-
000 weekly. The capacity of the works
is equal to five locomotives daily, but in
April last 197 complete engines were
turned out, with an average weight of
125 tons, and valued at $2,750,000.
That correspondence instruction is fill-
ing a real need is no longer questioned
by thoughtful people. It not only brings
an education within the reach of thou-
sands of people who otherwise could
never have one. but it increases the in-
fluence of the resident technical schools
and colleges by stimulating a wide-
spread interest in education, and by act-
ing as a "feeder" in preparing young
men for the higher institutions of learn-
ing.
376
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING.
August. 1903.
Pratte's Crude Oil Burner.
The accompanying sketch shows an
appliance used on the Colorado & South-
ern Railway for heating tires, bent
fraimes or any other part of an engine,
without removal. The device is the in-
vention of Mr. C. A. Pratte, foreman
at the C. & S. shops at Denver. It con-
sists of an oil reservoir mounted on a
pair of wheels, a burner and combus-
tion chamber. When not in use the
whole apparatus can be wheeled about
the shop like a wheelbarrow, two pipe
handles, not shown, projecting out be-
yond the filling funnel, for that purpose.
When at work the reservoir stands in
the upright position resting on its base.
Fig. I gives a side view of the reser-
voir, with attachments and valves on top
of the reservoir; Fig. 2 shows the burner.
The combustion chamber, not shown in
the illustrations, is mounted on a stand,
which can be raised or lowered at will
by the operator. A Westinghouse re-
ducing valve is used to regulate the
pressure and is set to 5 pounds, that be-
ing amply sufficient and giving the best
results. The device has already proved
its worth, and it is not patented. We
are indebted to Mr. Rathbone, of the
C. & S., for the blue print from which
our illustrations were made.
The Morris Canal and Banking Com-
pany, which owns the Morris Canal in
New Jersey, have filed an application
with the State authorities for permission
to abandon the operation of the canal,
because it has not paid operating ex-
penses since 1876. Yet the politicians of
New York State are working up public
sentiment to permit $101,000,000 to be
spent on enlarging the Erie Canal. The
Erie Canal has been a quarry of graft for
politicians ever since it was built. The
proper thing to do with that ditch is to
close it up for it never will compete with
railroad transportation that can move
freight for J4 cent per ton mile. This is
apparent to everybody but Governor
Odell and other hungry politicians, and
so the agitation is kept up to increase
the Erie Canal boodle reservoir. It is
nothing else any more. There is no use
arguing against the canal enlargement
for no one favors it except those who
think they can obtain for themselves or
their friends part of the immense tax
they are trying to cozen out of the rate
payers.
The Hamilton Machine Tool Com-
pany, of Hamilton, Ohio, have recently
issued a very fully illustrated catalogue,
No. 4. The half-tones and the printing
are excellent, and there is an index at
the back of the book by means of which
the particular description of the various
tools made by this concern can readily
be found. The Hamilton lathe comes in
2 n: 1. 1'iiic
i- —
-r«-
i Pipe Threada
yi Pipe-'
Jtaitwaii \ l.neomaHi^ L'ntfinMring
PRATTS CRUDE OIL BURNER.
Filling Funnel
Q
^ S..!, -r---f III
41--^ 'it—^
X-Pipe'
% Pipe to tdthin
1" of Bottom
■" i/l
liailtnay ^ Lacumutiiv Enginttring
TANK FOR PRATTS CRUDE OIL BURNER.
for special mention, being built in va- illustration with descriptive letter-press
rious sizes and adapted to different accompanying it. The company will be
kinds of work. Other tools and appli- happy to send this catalogue to anyone
ances are mentioned in the catalogue who is interested enough to write to
and each has a line cut or half-tone them for a copy.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
377
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. W. W. Boulincau has been ap-
pointed traveling engineer on the Central
of Georgia Railway, with headquarters
at Columbus, Ga.
Mr. H. Bentlcy has been appointed
road foreman of engines on the Chicago,
Rock Island & Pacific with office at Val-
ley Junction, Iowa.
Mr. Thomas H. Pindell has been ap-
pointed superintendent of the Wyoming
division of the Lehigh Valley, vice Mr.
John T. Keith, transferred.
Mr. W. K. Thompson has been ap-
pointed superintendent of the Twenty-
fourth District, Canadian Pacific Rail-
way, vice Mr. D. R. Bell, transferred.
Mr. A. Tripp has been appointed su-
perintendent of terminals for the South-
ern Railway Company at Jacksonville.
Fla., vice M. E. H. Barnes, resigned.
Mr. Norton A. Mears has been ap-
pointed storekeeper on the Indiana,
Illinois & Iowa Railroad, at Kankakee,
III, vice Mr. C. C. Dibble, promoted.
Mr. J. J. Scully has been appointed
acting superintendent of the Twenty-
third District, Canadian Pacific Railway,
vice F. Dillinger, on leave of absence.
Mr. T. McHattie, master mecl:anic of
the eastern division of the Grand Trunk
Railway system, Montreal, has been en-
joying a vacation in Scotland this sum-
mer.
Mr. John M. Lynch has been appoint-
ed traveling engineer on the Chicago &
Great Western Railway. He will have
charge of the Northwest division of the
road.
Mr. George T. Depue has been ap-
pointed master mechanic on the Erie
Railroad at ITornellsville, vice Mr.
Joseph Hainen, resigned, to accept
service with another company.
Mr. S. R. Richards, master mechanic
on the Southern Railway at Selma, Ala.,
has been transferred to Spencer, N. C,
in a similar position, vice Mr. J. T. Rob-
inson, resigned.
Mr. John T. Keith has been appointed
superintendent of the Buffalo division,
and the Lake lines of the Lehigh Valley
Transportation Company, vice Mr. L. H'
Van Allen, resigned.
Mr. D. A. Robinson has been appoint-
ed road foreman of engines on the Chi-
cago, Rock Island & Pacific on that por-
tion of the line between Rucklin, Kan.,
and Santa Rosa, N. M.
Mr. H. K. Mudd has resigned his posi-
tion as master mechanic of the Chicago.
Ciniinnali & f^ouisville. This road was
until rcccnlly called the Cincinnati Rich-
mond & Muncie Railroad.
Mr. T. W. Turner, road foreman of
engines on the Canadian Pacific, has late-
ly Iiad the territory he supervises ex-
tended to include the whole of the Lake
.Superior division of that road.
Mr. John W. Dalman has been ap-
|)ointed assistant master car builder of
ihe Union Tank Line Company, with
office at No. 26 Broadway, New York,
vice Mr. Willard Kells, resigned.
Mr. A. H. Fetters has been appointed
assistant mechanical engineer of the
Union Pacific, with office at Omaha, Neb.
Mr. Fetters has been chief draughtsman
on the road for a number of years.
Mr. E. L. Gibbs has been appointed
road foreman of equipment on the Red
River and Fort Worth and the Rio
Grande divisions of the Frisco system,
with headquarters at Sherman, Tex.
Mr. D. G. Farragut has been appointed
representative of the Pressed Steel Car
Company in Mexico. His office is at
Calle de Gante 8, Mexico City, where all
the business of that republic will be han-
dled.
Mr. T. J. Lockwood has been appoint-
ed trainmaster, Charleston Division of
the Southern Railway, vice Mr. M. Kelly,
resigned. The office of assistant super-
intendent at Blacksburg, S. C, has been
abolished.
Mr. S. L. Bean has been appointed
master mechanic on the Santa Fe system
at Albuquerque, vice Mr. H. P. Barnes,
resigned. Mr. Bean has been in charge
of the shops of the Northern Pacific at
Brainard, Minn.
Mr. George Smith, formerly master
mechanic at Albuquerque on the Santa
Fe system has been appointed master
mechanic on the Illinois Central, in
charge of the Burnside shops, vice Mr.
F. E. Place, resigned.
Mr. C. L. Acker, heretofore erecting
foreman and inspector on the El Paso-
Northeastern System, at San Bernar-
dino. Cal., has been appointed general
foreman of all shops on the system, with
headquarters at Alamogordo, N. M.
Mr. Edward Haskins. who has for the
past twelve years been foreman of the
Burlington blacksmith shops at St.
Joseph. Mo., has resigned his position
to accept service with the new locomo-
tive building concern in Montreal. Can-
ada.
Mr. George R. Henderson, superin-
tendent of motive power on the Atchi-
son, Topeka & Santa Fe, has handed the
company his resignation, which goes into
effect on August i. Mr. Alfred Lovcll, as-
sistant S. M. P., has been appointed acting
superintendent of motive power.
Mr. T. A. Summcrskill, superintendent
of motive power on the Central Ver-
mont, who was injured not long ago in
an attempt to capture a burglar, has
now recovered and is able to resume his
railroad duties. His many friends are
pleased to know he is at work again.
Mr. Thomas McPherson, for the pa.st
two years foreman of the motive power
department of the Chicago & North-
w-estern at Des Moines, has been pro-
moted to the position of general foreman
of motive power and machinery, with the
same company, at Eagle Grove, Iowa.
Mr. Lacey R. Johnson, assistant super-
intendent of rolling stock of the Cana-
dian Pacific Railway, accompanied by
Mrs. Johnson, sailed a few days ago on
S.S. Bremen for their native land. Mr.
Johnson is enjoying a well-earned vaca-
tion. He will be some time in England,
and intends to visit the continent.
Mr. E. H. Symington, formerly con-
nected with the T. H. Symington Co., of
Baltimore, is now associated with the
Railway Appliances Company, of Chi-
cago and New York, as manager of the
Symington journal box and dust guard,
the Railway Appliances Company being
agents for the Chicago territory.
Mr. R. M. Hoffman has been appointed
assistant superintendent in the operating
department of the Manistee & Grand
Rapids Railroad Company. Mr. Hoff-
man will, in the absence of the superin-
tendent, perform such duties as might be
incumbent upon the superintendent were
he on duty. The office of roadmaster
has been abolished.
Mr. W. D. Hatch, formerly with the
Raihvay Department of the International
Correspondence School, has been ap-
pointed air brake instructor on the Cana-
dian Pacific Raihvay. Mr. Hatch began
railroad work as a fireman on the Cana-
dian Division of the Michigan Central
and was promoted to the position of
engineer on the same road. His experi-
ence includes service on the Weft Shore
and on the Pere Marquette.
Mr. W. H. Lewis, of the Lehigh Val-
ley Railroad, was elected president of
the American Railway Master Mechan-
ics' Association for next year. Messrs.
P. H. Peck, of the Chicago & Western
Indiana; H. F. Ball, of the Lake Shore
378
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
and J. F. Deems, of the Vanderbilt lines,
were elected vice-presidents. Mr. Angus
Sinclair, editor Railw.w and Locomo-
Tivr. Engineerinc, was elected treasurer
of the association, and Mr, John W. Tay-
lor was again elected secretary.
Mr. George H. Gibson has resigned
as manager of the advertising and pub-
lication department of the B. F. Sturle-
vant Co., of Boston, Mass., to accept an
appointment with the International
Steam Pump Co, having offices at 114-
118 Liberty street, New York City. Mr.
Gibson was formerly connected with the
\yestinghouse Companies' Publishing
Department, of Pittsburg, Pa., and was
for two years a member of the editorial
staff of the Engineering News, of New
York city.
Mr. F. VV. Brazier, assistant superin-
tendent of rolling stock on the New York
Central, was elected president of the
Master Car Builders' Association for the
ensuing year. Mr. W. P. Appleyard,
M. C. B., of the New York, New Haven
& Hartford; Mr. Joseph E. Bucher, as-
sistant superintendent of machinery, Illi-
nois Central, and Mr. W. E. Fowler, M.
C. B.. Canadian Pacific, were elected vice-
presidents. Messrs. D. T. Crawford, of
Fort Wayne; J. T. Chimberlain, of Bos-
ton; J. S. Chambers, of Florence, S. C,
and T. S, Lloyd, of Scranton, form the
executive committee of the association
Mr. John Kirby, of Montreal, was elected
treasurer, and Mr. John W. Taylor, of
Chicago, was elected secretary.
Mr. Calvin W. Rice, of the Nernst
Lamp Company, of Pittsburg, Pa., has
announced his resignation from the com-
pany, to the universal regret of his busi-
ness associates, who found in liim that
combination of executive ability and per-
sonal attraction so much to be desired
Since May, 1902, Mr. Rice has held the
position of second vice-president, to
which he later added the duties of sales
manager. To his efforts is due in a large
measure the success of the company and
its present substantial commercial stand-
ing, the past year having been a particu-
larly successful one. Mr. T. H. Bailey
Whipple, who has been associated with
the Sawyer-Man Electric Co. as assistant
to the second vice-president, succeeds
Mr. Rice in the Nernst Lamp Co. Mr.
Whipple, who was formerly connected
with the Janous Electric Company, of
Cleveland. C, is a man of wide experi-
ence and acquaintance in the electric
lighting field, arid eminently fitted for the
position which he assumes.
One of the most persistently abused
and persistently persecuted public offi-
cials in New York is President Vreeland.
of the Interurban Street Railway Com-
pany, and president of the New York
Railroad Club.. Mr. Vreeland went
through an excellent practical railroad
training that seems to have made him
ready for every emergency and he al-
ways comes up smiling in front of his
accusers and tormentors. When they
expect to obtain a victory, they generally
sneak away after a humiliating defeat.
One of the most persistent rumors about
Mr. Vreeland is that he has decided to
resign his position with the Interurbin
Company and go away to the country for
his health, or accept a position under
Yerkes to straighten out the urban trans-
portation problems in London. We have
no doubt but that he would help Lon-
don very materially in straightening out
their congested street railroad traffic. He
has lately been invited to appear before
the Royal Commission which is investi-
gating the question of surface traffic in
London. Fle has gone over there to help
out our English friends and to take a
lioliday. Mr. Vreeland is a great joker
and we expect to hear some amusing
stories of his experience among the
great men of London. We have not yet
heard that he was dining with King Ed-
ward, but we would not be surprised to
learn that he had a special invitation to
go to Windsor.
Grand Chief P. M. Arthur.
While beginning to speak at a banquet
which closed a union meeting of the
Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers
PETER M. .\RTHUR. -
held at Winnipeg, Manitoba, P. i\I.
Arthur, grand chief of the Brotherhood
of Locomotive Engineers, dropped dead.
Mr. Arthur, although sixty-nine years
old, was a remarkably well preserved
man, and was seemingly in excellent
health when he was stricken down.
Peter McArthur was born in Scotland
in 1834, and came to this country with
his parents when he was si.x years old.
He began railroad work as a blacksmith's
helper and shortly afterward obtained a
position as fireman on the Schenectady
& Utica division of the New York Cen-
tral Railroad. Here he rose to be a pas-
senger engineer. He took a very active
part in the Brotherhood of Locomotive
Engineers and was elected chief of his
division. Having written something for
publication about Brotherliood matters
the printer left out the c of Mc and his
name went abroad as P. M. Arthur. That
name suited him and he determined to
abide by it. He was elected grand chief
in 1873 and proved to be an exceedingly
efficient leader. He had the rare pecu-
liarity of always remembering names and
faces. In conventions he would sit in the
chair and name every member who rose
to speak. This in itself was a great
source of popularity. The rules of the
Brotherhood required that he should be
re-elected every three years, and he al-
ways was elected by a big majority, al-
though at different times there was bit-
ter opposition.
P. M. Arthur was Grand Chief En-
gineer not only in the technical sense,
not only as the master of the Grand
Lodge. He was the Grand Chief En-
gineer in even a wider and more exalted
sense, because like all other successful
engineers he guided, not wrecked that
which was entrusted to his care. He
strove, not wantonly to exhibit to man-
, kind the extent of the power of
which he was the master, by disastrous
collision, in the economic world, with
those who temporarily opposed him, but
like the true chief engineer he guided
.Tud controlled the mighty forces within
his grasp, so that the total effort of his
powerful organization was steadily for-
ward along the line of progress and good
will, and behind it safely followed the
material advancement for the hosts of
the brotherhood who so loyally put their
trust in his coolness, his judgment and
liis inviolable honesty of purpose.
P. M. Arthur was the most successful
leader of a united labor the world has
ever seen. A variety of attributes con-
tributed to his success. The first was
1 is natural ability as an organizer. With-
out that his earnestness, honesty and
fairness would have availed little. One
of his favorite expressions was "Let us
reason together." When he found any
section of the Brotherhood in a fierce
mood over grievances that he believed
were not serious, he would collect the
loaders together and say "Let us reason
together." No attempt was ever made
to abuse earnest men, they were quietly
invited to subject all dilTerences to tl".e
test of reason. The same policy was fol-
lowed with railroad officials. When they
were inclined to be unjust the Chief of
the Brotherhood invited them to meet
their aggrieved employees, to reason to-
.gether. Most of them came to agree that
conciliation was better than conflict.
The success of the policy always advo-
cated by Mr. Arthur made him very
much of an autocrat of late years, but it
was the supreme power yielded willingly
to many years of successful management.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
379
His voice and influence were always used
against one man power, and he domi-
nated the mal<ing of a constitution wliich
prevents one man from ordering a stril<e,
or from committing tlie organization to
any violent conflict.
P. M. Arthur did Iiis work wi-11. Few
rulers of men have left behind them a
monument of greatness such as was
achieved by this Giid-fcaring loCDinotive
engineer.
Pulaski Leeds.
The tragic death of Pulaski Leeds,
superintendent of machinery of the Louis-
ville & Nashville, robs that road of a high-
ly capable, and trusted motive power oflfi-
cer, and removes a familiar figure from
the railroad world. Mr. Leeds was a
native of Darien, Conn., and has been in
railroad service since 1861. He was at one
time a locomotive engineer on the N. Y.,
N. H. & H.. and held the position of su-
perintendent of motive power on the Bos-
ton & New York Air Line, and also on
the Indianapolis, Decatur & Springfield,
before going to the L. & N.
The facts concerning his death are,
briefly, an employee, named Warner, in
the electrical branch of the machinery de-
partment had not given satisfaction with
some work at Decatur, and he was re-
called, the intention being to give him em-
ployment elsewhere. This, Warner re-
sented, and demanded a general letter of
reconmiendation. the giving of which
would have been contrary to the com-
pany's rules. Mr. Leeds offered to assist
the man in other ways and signified his
willingness to write an individual letter
to anyone who should inquire about him.
Warner insisted upon the general letter,
and in a moment of unreasoning passion
shot down the man who had thus offered
to befriend him.
The sad death of Mr. Leeds is only
one more terrible proof of the in-
sensate folly committed by men who
habitually carry firearms. If Warner had
not had a loaded revolver in his hip pocket
when talking to the superintendent of ma-
chinery his unreasonable ill-temper would
probably have spent itself in a few hot
words, and what was at best only a trivial
episode in their lives, would never have
deepened into tragedy and crime. No
truer words were ever penned than those
which Sliakespeare puts into the mouth of
King John ; "How- oft the sight of means
to do ill deeds, makes ill deeds done."
Thomas Banister, of Winona, la.,
one of the oldest and best known en-
gineers on the Northwestern system,
died recently at his home in Winona. la.
Thomas Chalmers, father of Mr. W. J.
Chalmers, chairman of the executive
committee of Allis-Chalmers Company,
died July 13 and was buried Thursday,
July t6. Thomas Chalmers was the
founder of the firm of Fraser & Chal-
mers, which firm was recognized as the
world's largest producers of mining ma-
chinery. He was a native of Scotland,
having been born at Dronley, near Dun-
dee, and was just entering his eighty-
eighth year.
T. .\. MacKinnon, first vice-president
and general manager of the Boston &
Maine, died at his residence in Boston a
few days ago. A funeral train carried
the remains to Montreal for burial.
Mr. A. 1.. liuniphrey, superintcndrnl
of motive power of the Chicago & Al-
ton, has resigned to accept a position
with Wcstinghouse Air-Brake Company,
of Pittsburgh, Pa. He will be succeeded
as S. M. P. on the Alton by Mr. W.
J. Hemphill, formerly superintendent of
motive power on the Jacksonville South-
eastern Line.
MR. W. W. SNOW,
The Most Popular Manufacturer of Railroad .\p-
pliances. Had Lived Three-quarters
of a Centurj' on July IT.
Some of Sir William Van Home's
Railroad Experience.
Sir William Van Home, chairman ol
the Canadian Pacific Railroad, was inter-
viewed in New York not long ago by a
young gentleman who insisted on treat-
ing him like a foreigner. The Montreal
capitalist took it as a matter of course
until the interviewer asked, innocently:
"Did you ever have anything to uo
with our American railroads. Sir Will-
iam?"
The good knight's eyes sparkled as he
answered: "Oh, yes. I served on both
Alton and Illinois Central."
"In what offices?" asked the scribe,
with pencil ready.
"I sold books on .Alton and oranges
on Illinois Central," said the chairman
of the Canadian Pacific quietly; "but that
was some little time ago." — A^ V. Times.
A Nickel Steel Engine.
One of two locomotives which are be-
ing built at Baldwin's Locomotive
Works for the Canadian Copper Com-
pany will be a mechanical novelty in its
way, as parts of it will be composed of
nickel steel, making it cost about $4,000
more than the ordinary locomotive.
An important feature of the boiler
from a mechanical standpoint will be
tl-.at every one hundred pounds of steel
in it will contain from three to four
pounds of nickel. The parts which will
be of nickel will be the frames and rods
driving axles, crankpins. piston rods and
other important parts of the machine.
The castings and forgings have been
made by the Bethlehem Steel Company.
The International Nickel Company,
which controls the Canadian Copper
Company, will provide the nickel.
Educational Opportunities.
One scholarship in the Stevens Insti-
tute of Technology, belonging to the
American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association, is open, and candidates,
who must be sons of members or of
deceased members, are advised to apply
to the secretary of the above associa-
tfon at once for a certificate authorizing
them to attend the competitive examina-
tion.
Joseph T. Ryerson & Son, of Chicago,
have donated to the Master Mechanics'
Association, one scholarship in the
Purdue University, on which they agree
to pay $600 a year, to pay expenses of
tuition and living, to the successful can-
didate. He is required to be:
First, a high school graduate.
Second, an employee of a shop com-
ing under the jurisdiction of one of the
members of the association.
The American Steam Gauge and Valve
Manufacturing Company, of Boston, re-
cently gave their annual dinner to their
sales department. This is a feature
which the company brings out every
year. They have their traveling sales-
men, branch house managers, together
with the head office officials go over the
business of the year thoroughly and wind
up with a dinner. We have had the
pleasure of seeing the menu, and when
we find that the Benedictine punch used
on that occasion was said to be the presi-
dent's mixture and the champagne was
designated as the treasurer's delight,
there is little doubt of the generous hos-
pitality of the hosts or of the genuine good
w'ill of the party. About fifteen or
twenty sat down to dinner and thus
pleasantly celebrated the close of a year
of prosperity for the company.
For everything you have missed you
have gained something else: and for
everything you gain you lose something.
— Emerson.
380
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Over the SanU Fe Trail.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
Second Paper.
When the train turned southward at Li
Junta, the passengers at once began to
look for the mountains. It docs not mat-
ter how short a time a person may have
been away from tlie sight of the ocean or
of mountains, he, and especially she, is
certain to search with pleasing anticipation
on approaching either to enjoy the first
sight. It is an interesting study to watch
the way different people enjoy their first
sight of mountains or of any other strik-
ing plienonicnon. Some are struck with
silence and they may be credited as be-
ing full of speechless emotion, or plunged
in the stupidity that is never touched
with anything that cannot be eaten. Our
car load of Endeavorers displayed hys-
terical enthusiasm, not to say gush, and
their admiration was not of the silent
kind.
The enjoyment to be derived from sight-
seeing depends very much upon the spirit
in which the sightseer starts out. I once
knew an old Scotchman whose son had
bound Santa Fe trail excites more ex-
pectation than satisfaction. The hazy out-
lines that can scarcely be distinguished
from low-lying clouds, are said to be
domes belonging to the great Rocky
Mountains ; but the admiration must for
a time be based on faith. We are in
Colorado and nearly in romantic New
Mexico, and I hear objections raised to
the name of the stations we pass.
Thatcher, Tyrone, Earl, repeats our young
ladies in disgust ; but El Moro sounds
better and then we reach Trinidad, u
modern town with furnaces and smoke
and street cars, and a curious mixture of
brick, frame and adobe houses ; but a few
miles out brings touches of the Spanish-
speaking people with adobe huts, women
and children in high colored rags, and
men lounging under sombreros. The
frame section house has given place to
low, oblong adobe houses, and we see
swarthy-faced trackmen who handle a
tamping tool as if it were a spear.
But now we are among the real moun-
tains, whose profusion of towering peaks
can be seen without artificial aid. The
'UNCLE DICK," ONCE THE MOST POWERFUL ENGINE IN THE WORLD.
made a fortune in the L^nited States and
resolved to take his father out to see the
wonders of America. The old man was one
of a type of his countrymen who are always
in opposition; who constitutionally dis-
agree with other people. He was a de-
voted admirer of his own country, and
was very dubious about seeing any-
thing in foreign parts that would
surpass the beauties and wonders of
Scotland. The principal cities were '
visited, but the old man could not see
that any of them was so attractive as
Edinburgh and Aberdeen — maybe a wee
bit bigger was the most he would admit.
Various mountain scenes were passed
through, but the father would not admit
that they were grander than the Grampian
hills and, "man," he would remark, "they
lack the life and color that the bloomin'
heather spreads over our hills." As a last
resource the son took his father to Niag-
ara Falls and watched to see the effect.
The old man looked on a minute almost
in wonder, and remarked, "it's a great
spate (flood), but it would be more
wonderfu' if it fell up instead o' doon."
The first seventy miles of the south-
transparent air vanquishes distance and
the naked eye can distinguish Pike's Peak,
a hundred miles away. Far and near are
scenes of grandeur, mountain piled upon
mountain with chasms and canyons and
valleys opening between and the whole
softened by green trees and shrubs and
other verdure that ranges from deep blue
to yellow. The unanimous decision of the
Endeavorers is, "Isn't it lovely?"
' The railroad is ascending the mountain
to get over through the Raton Pass, and
the locomotives are toiling slowly, for
they rise 185 feet for every mile advanced.
There is no going around, so the grade
must be climbed up through the Devil's
Canyon, winding and twisting under many
a giddy precipice and overlooking awful
gulleys, but always ascending until we
plunge into a black tunnel which takes us
out into sunny New Mexico.
The operating of trains over this Raton
Pass has been a difficult task for the
Santa Fe management and they have al-
ways used the best power available for
doing the work. One of the first move-
ments connected with the building of
enormously powerful locomotives was in-
augurated in connection with the steep
grade over the Raton Pass.
When the line was under construction
in 1879, and while the piercing of the tun-
nel was going on, the road was operated
by a switchback with a grade of 316.8
feet to the mile, and having curves of
359 feet radius. The temporary track was
at first operated by ordinary American
type engines with cylinders 17x24 inches;
but they hauled such light loads that a
special engine was ordered from the
Baldwin Locomotive Works. The engrav-
ing annexed shows the "Uncle Dick," a
consolidation engine with saddle tank,
which had 1,700 gallons capacity. The
cylinders were 20x26 inches, the driving
wheels were 48 inches diameter and the
engine weighed in working order 115.000
pounds. It was then the heaviest and most
powerful locomotive in the world, and
continued to be so for several years.
The Uncle Dick does not, however,
compare very favorably with the power-
ful engines working the same grade to-
day. Its tractive power is about 26,000
pounds; the tractive power of some 2-8-2
Vauclain compound engines built at the
Baldwin Locomotive Works this year for
the company is about 62,000 pounds.'
Uncle Dick is called after Dick
Wooten, a pioneer, who was a very im-
portant personage in these parts at one
time. He became possessed of the land
through which the Santa Fe train passed
over the north side of the pass, and
erected a toll house and collected toU
from all wagons that used the trail. The
moldering ruins of the toll house are still
to be seen near the railroad track.
When the railroad company began con-
structing the line over the pass, Uncle
Dick, as he was familiarly called, objected
to the intrusion upon his rights, privileges
and solitude and gave the surveyors a
great deal of trouble. He would neither
sell nor donate the right of way, and was
inclined to declare war upon the intrud-
ers. When the track was built close to
his domain, certain officials went up there
with a private car which was liberally pro-
vided with the good things of this life.
Uncle Dick was invited to enjoy the hos-
pitality of the visitors and before they left
he had agreed to grant the right of way in
consideration of an annual pass over that
part of the line.
Anyone with the slightest knowledge of
road construction is certain to be im-
pressed with the skill displayed in the lo-
cating of this line which involved unusual
engineering difficulties. The hunters who
acted as guides to the first traders we:c
the real locating engineers, for they knew
every ford over rivers and every defile
through the mountains. For many miles
the train was seldom out of sight of the
Santa Fe Trail. The locating engineers
faithfully followed its route, only cutting
off detours where the natural obstructions
could be cut through or bridged.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
381
Wlicn the trail tiirnrrl away from our
route near Las Vagas, leading the way
to the old city of Santa Fe, other trails
took its place. The railway track is taken
valley green with alfalfa and blooming
with fruit trees and the siglit of the
desert would be postponed ; for the herds
of sheep and cattle rin'l eviilcnci-s of lifu
BUDS AND BI,ObSOMS IN SOUTHERN CALlFORNtA.
most of the infertile plains and valleys
blossom like the rose when touched with
life-giving moisture. The floods that now
devastate Ihc land in the rainy and
thawing seasons will some day be hoarded
up and circulated as it is wanted to make
the thirsty carlh produce food for the na-
tions. The work is well begun in some
places, and proofs are abundantly given
that the carlh will produce fullness if man
only will do his part.
The cities of Las Vegas (the meadows)
and Allnifjuerque are the only places of
importance touched in New Mexico by
the railroad. They are well worthy of
closer inspection than a through traveler
can give. There are numerous pueblos,
small Indian villages with swarthy deni-
zens to be seen, who seem to suffer from
the chronic scarcity of water, for most of
them look as if they did not wash them-
selves once a year. "Lo, the poor Indian!"
is picturesque in the distance, but, like the
bagpipes to untrained ears, distance lends
enchantment to the intercourse.
as a safe guide by pathseekers. and every-
where west of the Missouri river, a trail
is to be see following within sight of every
railway. The drivers of prairie schoon-
ers and other lonely vehicles, are willing
to follow the railroad, knowing that
though long stretches of wilderness may
intervene, they will emerge eventually
into places where men and women have
established homes.
As the train rushes along over its
smooth track, diving through ravines and
winding around mountain sides, through
cedar forests and over grass covered
plains, there is variety of scenes to suit
everytasteand novelties sufficient to excite
frequent cries of admiration. The desert ?
"When are we coming to the Great
.■\merican Desert?" were inquiries I fre-
IX A CALIHORNI.\ V.iLUEY.
"iWj^i
RO.\D WINDING OVER 1 HE MOUNTAINS.
qucntly heard repeated. "This is the desert,
sure," some one would say when an arid,
forbidding stretch of country was struck,
then we would suddenly emerge upon a
and activity had no suggestion about them
of the desert.
There is, notwithstanding, real desert
enough and to spare on the route; but
Notwithstanding its arid plains and
bare, rugged mountains, there are many
things of interest to be found in Xew
Mexico and Arizona. During more lei-
surely visits, I nave enjoyed much pleas-
ure looking up places of physical and his-
torical interest. Santa Fe is one of the
oldest cities ruled under the United States
flag, and possesses antiquities and venera-
ble looks that no other city in the Union
can boast of. Its history is a stirring ro-
mance, but want of space prevents me
from touching on that part of its attrac-
tions. Even more interesting to me are
certain community dwellings built by the
aboriginal inhabitants of the country, each
one being a town in itself, the substantial
stone houses having been built generally
in inaccessible locations for defense
against enemies. They represent the re-
mains of a departed civilization which may
have been contemporaneous with the
glories of ancient Egypt.
3S2
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
When we are in search of ancient re-
mains we find things in this arid region
that no other country possesses. There
are petrified forests which are unique.
Huge trees converted in Nature's labora-
tory into agate and jasper, are objects of
antiquarian interest that tortures the
imagination to conceive the age of their
growth and period of their conversion.
As we approach California a real desert
is at last encountered, a dreary stretch of
nish an equivalent or a higher evapora-
tion with a lesser number.' There ap-
pears to be good reasons for questioning
the efficiency of a multitude of tubes,
among which are the following for re-
ducing the number: A bettor circulation
due to the wider spacing of centers; a
reduction of liability to leakage, and
longer life to tube sheet due to the
greater section of material between holes.
It is not apparent that there are any very
.\ NEW-ME.XICVN PVEDLO.
sand, gravel and alkali with labyrinths of
black rocks and almost entire absence of
things that grow, even the yucca and cac-
tus being stunted.
Out of this world of desolation we de-
scend by a steeply descending grade into
Southern California. The long-looked for
orange groves spread out in regulated
rows and all sorts of semi-tropical plants
testify that we have reached the land of
perennial sunshine.
serious difficulties to surmount in mak-
ing tests that will demonstrate to what
extent evaporation and cost of main-
tenance is affected by a wider spacing of
known to be inimical to a proper circu-
lation, as well as dangerous to the sheets,
and the same eflfects are known to op-
erate at the fire box ends of tubes. The
wide fire box has shown a marked ten-
dency to crack at the sides, and as a
remedy it is proposed to make the fire
box ring 4'/2 inches wide on some en-
gines now under construction."
In the discussion that followed the
presentation of the paper Mr. O. H.
Reynolds of the American Locomotive
Company, a member of the committee,
emphasized the points made in the fore-
going paragraph. He said:
"The matter of flue space and its effect
on circulation was referred to in the re-
port of the committee, and I deem it on'y
proper that it should be brought before
the association for the purpose of em-
phasizing the fact that it is something
we must give some attention to. Ever
since the locomotive has been a factor
in transportation, this question of cir-
culation has been of vital importance.
Fifty years ago the eminent engineer,
the late D. K. Clark, formulated some
values for tube spacing, which appear to
apply as well to present-day conditions as
to those of his time. He selected en-
gines known to give a high evaporation
on a low fuel consumption, and from that
data determined that the distance between
tubes on one-eighth of an inch should
not be less than one-thirtieth of the total
number of tubes. That was for engines
of about the year i860, or in that neigh-
borhood, where the tube numbers were
lower than in the present case. For that
time the number would be about 150 flues,
Flues Are Set Too Close.
It frequently happens in reports and
papers presented to technical associa-
tions, that the most important point in
the discussion of a subject is covered up
in an obscure paragraph and overlooked.
We think that this was the case in the
excellent report on Recent Improvements
in Boiler Design Presented to the last
Master Mechanics' Convention. Design-
ers of locomotive boilers are rather in-
discriminating in their demand for more
heating surface. Our sympathies are
with a paragraph in the report which
reads:
"There is a question among some of-^
ficials that, while we have ample heating
surface, it may not be in the right place,
or, in other words, it is possible that wc
have too much heating surface in the
wrong place, that is, are not too many
tubes used, and would not a boiler fur-
AMONG THE BIG TREES OP SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.
tubes. Such experiments would definite-
ly decide whether the practice of en-
croaching on circulation space with
tubes is conductive to an economical
evaporation, and in addition would no
doubt incidentaly furnish some needed
light on the effect of a higher ratio of
fire box to tube heating surface under
the new conditions. Restricted water
spaces around the fire box are well
and would give a space of about five-
eighths for that number of tubes.
We have engines running to-day with
over 300 tubes where the space is not
more than five-eighths of an inch, and
there is no question in the mind of the
thinker that this fact has a good deal to
do with the lack of circulation in our
boilers. For clearance between tubes and
boiler shell, some recommend one-six-
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
3«J
tceiith of the (liamcter of the shcli for the
the upper rows of tubes. We make a dis-
tance of Yi inches on boilers 72 inches in
diameter. We know we have boilers of
that diameter where the flues approach
a great deal closer to the sheet than that,
and its effect on the circulation is evi-
dent. Herr Von Berries, in recent tests,
placed the limit of rate of evaporation at
14.5 pounds of water per square foot of
heating surface per hour. This figure
comes very close to known records, and
known results recently obtained. He also
places the limit of rale of combustion at
97 pounds of coal per square foot of
grate surface per hour. We can get no
such evaporation at that low rale of com-
bustion. It will amount to pretty nearly
twice that.
I think it is proper and meet, that this
association should take some steps to
demonstrate what effect a reduction ot
the number of lubes in a boiler would
f;6 ins. diameter at the smoke-box end.
The weight carried on the drivers is loi,-
420 lbs., and the total weight of the ma-
chine is 193,760 lbs. The tank capacity
is 8,400 gallons. The cranks and crank
pins are so placed in this machine as to
practically form a self-balanced engine.
Her performance on the road will be
watclu-d with considerable interest.
The netric System In the Railroad
Mechanical Conventions.
In acting upon a paper on the Metric
System presented to tlie American Rail-
way Master Mechanics' and the Master
Car Builders' Associations, by Angus
Sinclair, these organizations put them-
selves squarely on record as being op-
posed to a change in our system of
measurements.
In the paper Mr. Sinclair briefly ad-
verted to the efforts of the advocates of
the metric system to push through Con-
service is beyond computation. To-day
a car built in California loses in Maine
a nut off a bolt, and all the car repairer
has to do is to look in his box for a nut
belonging to that size of bolt and screw
it on. These easy facilities of inter-
change car repairs arc enjoyed over
every railroad on this continent. This
is a very beneficent change from the con-
ditions existing anterior to the adoption
of standard screw threads, when the car
repairer would have had to search
through a scrap pile for a nut to fit or
probably put in a new bolt. The transi-
tion period in changing from' one stand-
ard to another would throw railroad in-
terchange of car repairs back into the old
intolerable conditions.
Screw threads are mentioned merely
as an example of one of the many incon-
veniences that would result from chang-
ing the unit of measurement. The inch
and foot units are in themselves more
BALDWIN FOUR CYLINDER BALANCED COMPOUND.
have; that is to increase the center space
— and that would mean a reduction in the
number of tubes — to show what the re-
sult would be. These tests should be
made both in the laboratory and on the
road; the laboratory tests for refinements
to show exactly what can be dene, and
the road tests to see if actual practice
confirms the expectation adduced by the
laboratory tests.
Baldwin Four-Cylinder Balanced Coni=
pound for the Santa Fe.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works are
building some Atlantic type engines for
the Santa Fe. The engine we illustrate
here is a four-cylinder compound in which
the four pistons drive on the forward
wheels which are mounted en a cranked
axle. The cylinders are 15 and 25x26
inches, the high pressure ones being on
the outside and the valves are of the
balanced piston type. The driving wheels
are TZ '"s. in diameter. The pressure car-
ried is 220 lbs. and the total heating sur-
face is 3,083 sq. ft. The boiler measures
gress a bill to make the metric system
the legal standard of weights and meas-
ures in the United States. The efforts
of the metric system advocates are
toward making the use of the French
system compulsory, and even to proceed
the length of changing the adopted
screw thread standards, to make them
conform to units of metric measure-
ment. The author reminded the mem-
bers of the great work their associations
had done in leading to the general adop-
tion of the United States screw threads,
and dwelt on the conveniences resulting,
not only to railroad companies, but to
every manufacturing concern which uses
bolts and nuts.
The metric system partisans say that
the change in screw thread standards will
be effected gradually, a pretense which
reveals the impractical character of the
men. They do not seem to realize the
persistence of car and other railroad ma-
terial. There are cars in use that were
built fifty years ago. and the life of some
of the million and a half of cars now in
convenient, especially for shop work,
than any metric unit. The bisections of
the inch and foot can be carried as far
as refinement of measurement requires,
and the subdivisions are easily remem-
bered. With the four units of lineal
measure, the inch, foot, yard and mile,
there is always a convenient unit with a
distinctive name, which the memory
readily grasps and divides mentally when
necessary. The attempts to push these
units aside for a system whose additions
and divisions are notoriously difficult to
memorize ought to be opposed by all
practical mechanics and business mer
These and other objections being pre-
sented the following preambles and reso-
lutions were submitted:
"Whereas, A bill for the adoption of
the metric system in the departments of
the Federal Government has been re-
ported favorably to the House of Rep-
resentatives;
"Whereas, We consider that the only
effect of such a law will be the creation
of a government metric system and the
3S4
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
continuation of the existing system in
ordinary commerce and industry;
"Whereas, It is evident that the con-
fusion resulting from such a condition
of things would be intolerable;
"Whereas, We believe a change in the
system of weights and measures used by
the people at large to be impossible,
therefore be it
"Resolved, By the American Railway
Master Mechanics' Association, and by
the Master Car Builders' Association, in
convention assembled, that we condemn
all legislation intended to promote the
adoption of the metric system in this
country.
"Resolved, That we especially condemn
the bill which was reported to the last
House of Representatives as one which
carriage way. From these overhead gir-
ders the car hangs. Its trucks and mo-
tors run along the track over the roof
of the car, so that to a spectator in ths
forward end of the car, the sensation is
exactly as if he was flying over the ci:y,
just below an overhanging steel struc-
ture. Streets are crossed, stations are
passed, a river is "flown" over, curves
are rounded, sights are seen and cars
moving in the opposite direction are
passed as our car glides on. The motion
is easy, steady, continuous and rapid. It
is like the flight of a bird. In the kala-
technoscope pictures the illusion of fly-
ing is perhaps more complete than it
would be in reality, because of the com-
plete absence of noise. The picture is
interesting as well as instructive, and
A very decided drawback to the suc-
cess of the Railroad Mechanical Conven-
tions at Saratoga was the miserable
acoustic properties of the room where
the meetings were held. They were held
in the ball room connected with the
Grand Union Hotel, and we seldom sat
in a hall where speakers labored under
greater difficulties in trying to be heard.
Complaints were made by leading mem-
bers of both associations to the village
authorities of Saratoga of the want of
a suitable hall for holding conventions,
and we understand that the people are
now preparing a hall that will accommo-
date from 300 to 400 persons.
The Gold Car Heating and Lighting
Company, of New York, report that the
ARRANGSMENT OF CYLINDERS AND VALVES, BALDWIN BALANCED COMPDUND.
can do nothing but introduce confusion
where we now have uniformity."
The resolutions were adopted after
very feeble opposition, mostly of an
academic character.
Berlin Brought to New York.
A few nights ago at one of F. F. Proc-
tor's theatres, in New York, one of the
most interesting moving pictures ever
shown was exhibited. It was a continu-
ous view taken from a car on the new
"hanging railway" in Berlin. The scene
w-as exactly what a pa.ssenger would
look at as he apparently flies over the
streets of that city, and the picture was
recorded as seen by the "eye" of the
kinetograph, or photograph-taking ma-
chine.
The Berlin hanging railway is in a
sense an elevated road; two long contin-
uous steel girders supported at intervals
by steel pillars, are carried along the
streets at considerable height above the
would have been absolutely perfect if the
car had been shown at rest before the
trip began, with passengers entering
and leaving, so that its construction and
appearance might have been studied. As
it was, however, it was a novel and most
pleasing sight:
Science may have made the marvelous
appear commonplace to some, though
science to the thoughtful and observant,
never really cheapens worthy achieve-
ment. By her aid we may sit in one of
the Proctor theaters in New York on a
summer evening, with the breeze of an
electric fan cooling the air, and accom-
panied with the soft strains of music
played by an orchestra hidden in the
gloom which always falls just this side
the stage — here we may experience the
sensations and see the sights which a
resident of far away Berlin feels and sees
as he "flies" along on the overliead hang-
ing railway in the capital of the German
Empire.
apparatus sold during the past year is
nearly double that of any former year
since the origin of the business. Orders
have been received from the Canadian
Pacific for 290 equipments, the Brooklyn
Heights Railroad ordered 240, the Mis-
souri Pacific I2S, and the Wabash 105.
Other railway orders come to 1,136
equipments or 1,896 equipments in all.
At the recent stockholders' meeting of
the Rogers Locomotive works the fol-
lowing were elected directors: William
Barbour, J. E. Brone, J. W. Griggs, John
Havron, F. B. Lord, E. H. Norton,
Stephen Peabody, J. D. Probst, Robert
Pruym, James Henry Smith, Sir William
C. Van Horn and Reuben Wells. It is
a strong board, and indicates that these
noted locomotive works are in good
hands.
Let us be among the few who do their
duty. — Mr. Pecksniff.
AiiKiisl, if)03.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
385
One of the strange losses incidental to
the June flood at Kansas City was that
of 38 box cars that burned to the water's
edge, a rushing torrent isolating them
from all other combustible matter. The
cars in question were loaded with un-
slaked lime and when the water rose
above the floor line the lime fired spon-
taneously and the upper part of cars were
entirely destroyed. The blazing cars in
the midst of a sea of water offered a
strange spectacle and suggests the neces-
sity of moving lime cars above the flood
line^ — if you have time!
During the discussion on the metric
system in the Master Mechanics' Con-
vention Professor Hibbard told of liis
difficulty in understanding the British
monitary system, with its pounds,
shillings and pence, which is not divisible
on a rational basis, and used that as an
argument in favor of the meter as a unit
instead of an inch. To us the force of
the argument tended in the other direc-
tion. It offered a good reason why our
mechanics should be permitted to con-
tinue using the plain inch, to which they
are accustomed, instead of a strange
unit of measurement with high falutin
names which are more than foreign to
their ears.
Petitions have been filed with the In-
terstate Commerce Commission by the
Boston & Maine Railroad Company
and the Denver & Rio Grande Rail-
road Company with the provisions of the
safety appliance act. The former com-
pany asks for additional time to equip
its passenger cars and locomotives with
automatic couplers, and the latter for ad-
ditional time to equip its locomotives
with power driving-wheel brakes. The
commission will give a hearing on the
petitions in this city August 5.
The British Westinghouse Company
has secured the contract for the electri-
fication of the Wirral Railway, the same
system to be installed as that now in
successful operation on the Mersey Tun-
nel Railway. The Wirral Railway is
about fifteen miles in length, and con-
nects Liverpool by means of the Mersey
Railway with the residential district of
the Wirral Peninsula in Cheshire, Eng-
land. West Kirby and New Brighton
being the terminal points.
The Standard Coupler Company, of 160
Broadway. New York, are presenting their
friends with a neat little paper-knife or
letter opener. The knife in is the form of
a dagger and is nickel plated both on
handle and blade. The Standard Com-
pany are makers of the Sessions draw gear
and the Standard steel platforms. Write
to the company if you want to have a neat
and useful desk accessory, or if you want
to know anything about Standard railway
material.
The Canadian Pacific Railway has
placed an order with the Canadian Foun-
dry Company of Toronto, Ont., for the
construction of ten compound freight lo-
comotives. The engines are booked for
delivery in September. The cylinders arc
to be 22 and 3S.\26 in. Driving wheels,
diameter 57 in. Weight on drivers, 144,-
800 lbs. Total weight, 164.000 lbs.
Pressure, 200 pounds; total heating sur-
face, 1,876 sq. ft. Diameter of smallest
boiler ring, 6oj4 '"• The tender will
carry 10 tons of coal and the tank will
contain 5,000 Imp. gallons of water.
The Hammond Packing Company
have abandoned their plant at Ham-
mond, Indiana, having spent over a mill-
ion dollars in the construction of a fine
new plant at the Union Stock Yards,
Chicago. The new offices are lighted by
three and si.x-glower Nernst lamps, sold
through the Chicago Sales Office of the
Nernst Lamp Company, and it is stated
that a large additional number of these
disseminators of light will soon be in-
stalled in their extensive packing house.
A large addition is being planned to
the works of the Standard Steel Car
Company, at Butler, Pa. The plans are
now being considered by the officials of
the company, and if approved the ca-
pacity of the works will be increased to
80 steel cars a day. The new addition
will be about 400 feet long and about
100 more hands will be employed.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company
is equipping more of its offices with
Nernst lamps, thereby attesting to the
superiority of the illumination afforded
by this now famous lamp. The Phila-
delphia office of the Nernst Lamp Com-
pany reports that twenty-six six-glower
and five three-glower Nernst lamps have
recently been installed in the freight
department of the Pennsylvania Railroad
at Broad and Washington avenue, Phila-
delphia, this being one of the most im-
portant departments of the company.
A news dispatch of July 19 from
Meadville, Pa., says: A. B. Youngson,
Assistant Grand Chief of the Brother-
hood of Locomotive Engineers, is slowly
improving from an illness which for sev-
eral days. was expected to result fatally.
His physicians say that his chances for
recovery are fair. He has been in the
City Hospital for a month.
The Safety Car Heating & Lighting
Co. has brought suit in the U. S. Circuit
Court for the Northern District of New
York, against the Consolidated Car
Heating Co. for alleged infringement of
its patents in connection with car heat-
ing devices.
The F. M. Hicks Locomotive and Car
Works, Chicago Heights, report that
among a number of orders recently re-
ceived there arc seventeen locomotives
to be rebuilt, fourteen coaches, including
baggage cars, to be overhauled, and two
hundred and fifty-six freight cars of all
kinds to undergo heavy repairs. This
firm does all manner of repair and over-
hauling work to cars and engines.
Below is the kind of newspaper item
wc like to reproduce. Ignorance always
aims at extremes. A speed of ico miles
an hour is a claim easily remembered:
Articles of incorporation were filed yes-
terday in the office of the Clerk of Essex
county, in Newark, N. J., by the New
York-BufTalo Air Car Railway. Thcpapers
were prepared in the offices of James R.
Dill, in New York. The charter gives
the company power to construct an air
line from New York to Buflfalo. The
cars run on steel rails, but the motive
power is compressed air, and it is de-
clared tlfat the trains will attain a sp^ed
of 100 miles an hour.
A new car building company has been
organized by leading business men of
Cincinnati, which expects to do business
on a large scale. Mr. Thomas B. Egan,
of the well-known Fay & Egan Com-
pany, is the leading spirit of the enter-
prise. He is reported to be giving the
car building scheme a great deal of per-
sonal attention.
Among the jetsam found in a Missouri
Pacific round house at Kansas City after
the late floods was a piano. It needed
tuning and heavy repairs before it was in
condition to charm the savage breast.
The New Castle Forge & Bolt Com-
pany, of New Castle, Pa., are installing
in their plant the following electrical ap-
paratus which has been purchased from
the Westinghouse Electric & Manufac-
turing Company: Two engine-type gen-
erators, of 73 and 100 kilowatts capacity
respectively, which will be operated by
engines furnished by the Erie City Iron
Works; seven 30 horse-power, direct-cur-
rent motors, complete with rails and pul-
leys; and a three-panel switchboard with
the usual auxiliary apparatus.
A conference was recently held be-
tween the management of the Boston &
Maine Railroad, and the trainmen em-
ployed in freight service, with the result
that a raise of 25 cents a day has been
given to the latter. Switchmen employed
in the freight yards will also get a simi-
lar increase.
Curiosity is and has been from the cre-
ation of the world, a master-passion.
— Barnaby Rudge.
386
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Roller Bearings In Passenger Service.
Through the courtesy of Mr. W. Mc-
Wood, Superintendent Car Department
for the Grand Trunk System, we are
enabled to present to our readers some
details of the roller bearings which are
being used on several of their passenger
cars, on suburban service.
The axle-box is circular inside, and is
lined with a steel bushing which is dow-
elled into the bottom of the box to
prevent the bushing turning round.
Upon this bushing the rollers move. The
rollers themselves are pieces of hollow
steel tube 2J4 in. diameter outside, with
walls ^ in. thick. The rollers are dis-
posed around the journal in a curious
way. There are three zones covered by
the rollers. The central zone of the
journal has round it eight rollers, each
5,'g in. long. The two end zones have
rollers 2S^ in. long. There are also
grooves cut in the upper part of the
steel bushing, just over the collars of
the steel rods. Two or three men can
push one of these cars along a level
track.
The Grand Trunk ofiicials use this
roller bearing only on a certain number
of suburban cars, which do not get far
away from home at any time. The bear-
ings were applied in 1895 and are still
in service. The bearing makes the car
run very easily and is a great advantage
to suburban trains in that it enables
them to be started much more quickly
than an ordinary bearing would permit.
An objection which has been raised to
their use on heavy, through equipment, is
that in the event of anything going
wrong with a roller it might cause seri-
ous trouble, because all the rollers are
continuously revolving round the jour-
nal, and within the steel bushing. The re-
ways to get instruction is to read for
yourself. Get hold of the literature of
the subject you feel yourself to be de-
ficient in. Look over our list of books
and see if they do not strike you as an
excellent means of "posting" yourself on
all sorts of railw-ay and engineering mat-
ters.
The first on the list is, of course.
Railway and Locomotive Engineering,
a practical journal of railway motive
power and rolling stock. It costs only
$2.00 a year, and is well worth the money,
and besides the paper is a welcome visi-
tor in every household. Let your wife
and boys see it.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
Railway ^ Lucumotive Eti^/inceriiiff
GRAND TRUNK ROLLER BEARING A.XLE BOX.
eight of these and the rollers in the two
outside zones are placed with centers
opposite each other, while those of the
central zone are placed so that their
center lines would pass between the out-
side circumferences of any two adjacent
rollers in the outer zones. This position
of the rollers is maintained by a very
ingenious device. A set of steel rods
about 1/2 in. in diameter, with collars
placed so as to keep in touch with the
ends of the rollers, are placed inside
the rollers. Two rods are in each roller,
and each rod passes through three roll-
ers.
Our illustration shows the arrange-
ment of axle, rollers and rods. The
rollers in one zone are kept from inter-
fering with those in another by the col-
lars on the rods, and any two adjacent
rollers are kept from rubbing against
each other by the size and position of
the rods. The external surface of the
rods rolls on the internal surface -of the
rollers, and the rollers bear upon the
axle and the internal bushing of the box.
Lubrication is arranged for through oil
suits so far which have been achieved
with these bearings on the Grand Trunk,
in suburban service, have been very satis-
factory.
The Meaning of Being Well "Posted."
The word "posted," in the sense of
being well informed is generally used in
what is said to be, the coloquial way.
That is, the word is correct enough in
conversation, but is not generally so used
when writing a book. The way in which
the word has acquired the significance
of zvell informed, is that one of its mean-
ings is an appointment to some public or
official place. A man may become, for
example, an army officer. Such a man
from the nature of the position he holds
is required to instruct those under him,
and when on duty at such work he was,
so to speak, "on post," and the work he
was doing gradually came to be describ-
ed as "posting" his subordinates. The
men so instructed, when they came to be
proficient were said to be well "posted."
The prerequisite to being well posted is
to receive instruction and one of the best
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for ^'2.co.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particu-
larly useful book to the young mechanic.
It has a stimulating effect in inducing
him to study his business. 50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used by
many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers likely to
be hired. It contains in small compass
a large amount of information about the
locomotive. Convenient pocket size. We
cordially recommend this book. The
price is 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book instructs a man so that he will
understand the construction and opera-
tion of a compound locomotive as well as
he now understands a simple engine.
Tells all about running, about break-
downs and repairs. Convenient pocket
size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
387
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horse power, condensers,
feed water heaters, air pumps, engines,
strength of boilers, testing boiler per-
formances, etc., etc. This is only a par-
tial list of its contents. It is in the
question and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. Price, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a foreman boilermaker. Also contains
several chapters on oil-burning locomo-
tives. Price, so cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halscy.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. Price, $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no per-
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals." El-
liott. Tells what signals are, what they
do and how they do it. Comprehensive
treatise on the subject. Ought to be
studied by all trainmen where block sig-
nals are used. $3.00.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating of all trains on single or double
track. Used by nearly all railroads. Study
of this book would prevent many collis-
ions. Price, so cents.
"Mechanical Engineers' Pocket Book."
Kent. This book contains 1,100 pages
6.X3V4 inches of closely-printed minion
type, containing mechanical engineering
matter. It ought to be in the book case
of every engineer who takes an interest
in engineering questions. We use it con-
stantly as a reference for questions sent
to us to be answered. Full of tables and
illustrations. Morocco leather. $S.oo.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
"Do you fire them first and then investi-
gate their family, or do you investigate
first?"
Hays smiled. "I just fire," he said.
And perhaps that's the reason Grand
Trunk is paying more dividends than
ever in its historv. — iV. )'. Times.
Krncaid Stoker iriustrated.
The Kincaid J^ocomotive Stoker Com-
pany, of 1 146 Harrison avenue, Cincin-
nati, Ohio, have issued an illustrated
catalogue showing the stoker in various
positions ready for business, with oper-
ating mechanism exposed, and with feed
apparatus on view. The letter press ex-
plains the method 01 setting the stoker,
its operation and the ease with which it
may be disconnected in case anything
does go wrong with it, but though that is
only a remote contingency, it has been
provided for in correct engineering style.
The Kincaid stoker is a steam operated
device, the hopper of which holds about
three bushels of coal. Coal is thrown
LOJOMOTIVKS BEtONGING TO SOUTH AFRICAN R.\ILWAY.
son engaged in mechanical occupations
can aflord to do without. Enables any
workman to figure out all the shop and
machine problems which are so puzzling
for want of a little knowledge. We sell
it for 50 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of com-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily un-
derstood by every intelligent fireman. The
price is SO cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons try-
ing to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. We sell it. Cloth, 75
cents. Leather, $1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of prac-
tical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco-
motive. It will be found particularly use-
ful to men handling or repairing com-
pound locomotives. It is the real loco-
motive up to date. $2.so.
Railway and Locomotive Engineek-
INC. Bound volumes. $3.00.
Hays Fired Them.
When "Hays of Wabash'' became gen-
era! manager of the Grand Trunk Rail-
way he found himself confronted with a
difficult problem in the shape of younger
sons, nephews, cousins, etc., of certain
English stockholders, who held nice fat
positions on the system. Mr. Hays be-
gan to weed them out. There were much
perturbation and much curiosity. A good
many people expected to see Hays him-
self weeded out before long. Nothing
happened. A friend of Mr. Hays met
him one night and began to talk about
the matter.
"How do you do it, Hays?" he asked.
into the furnace in what may be called
the foreground, the middle distance and
the background of the firebox, so that
an even distribution of coal is secured
all over the grate. There is a small, ver-
tically sliding door in connection with
the stoker, through which the fireman
may at any time examine the condition
of the fire. The Kincaid Stoker Com-
pany will be happy to send a copy of the
catalogue to any one interested enough
to apply to them for it.
The associates of George M. Pullman
were by no means the first to propose
putting a covered vestibule between pas-
senger cars. As early as 1852 a patent
was granted to a man named Atwood,
of Waterbury, Conn., for a closed ves-
tibule between cars and it was applied to
a train on the Naugatuk Railroad of
Massachusetts, and was highly popular.
It did not. however, increase the earnings
of the company and for that reason it
was abandoned.
388
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
Convention Notes.
An improvement was made this year
on the grounds of the hotel where the
convention was held, by the opening up
of some new "streets" of booths, and by
carrying the whole area devoted to ex-
hibits, farther back on the lawn. The
weather was disappointing, but the same
lively interest was manifested this year,
as formerly, in the many and tastefully
arranged exhibits which were to be seen
upon veranda and lawn.
A feature which always adds to the en-
joyment of those present is the services
of that very efficient band which Mr.
Church brought with him from Provi-
dence, R. I. This band earned the
good will of all who heard them.
Their repertory was extensive, and
they played constantly while on duty.
Mr. Church was most obliging in
giving various selections which were
asked for by his auditors. One could not
fail to see the pleased expression which
would light up the face of motive power
and supply men alike, when the stacatto
notes of the "Hiawatha" intermezzo were
heard, or to notice how that pleased ex-
pression settled into one of calm enjoy-
ment as the delicate and persuasively in-
sistent tones of that popular air floated
among the booths where wheels whirled,
steam puffed and pneumatic apparatus
snorted and sneezed in the interest of
good railroading and pure science.
There was what might be called a full
turnout of exhibitors and supplymen, and
among the principal ones may be men-
tioned the following:
The Adams & Westlake Co., of
Chicago, had, as is their custom, one
of the most striking exhibits on the
ground. They showed in their hand-
some pagoda the Adiake acetylene gas
car lighting system. Not only were the
elegant forms of chandeliers and lamp
brackets dispalyed, but gas generators
were shown and their mechanism laid
open for inspection. At night the ex-
hibit was practically self-explanatory, but
in the day time the whole subject of car
lighting was brilliantly illuminated by the
enlightening remarks of Mr. F. E. Jones,
the genial secretary of the company.
The American Balance Valve Co., Jer-
sey Shore, Pa., was represented by Mr.
K. T. Wilson. A model of the Wilson
high pressure valve was shown, also the
American Metallic Piston-rod and Valve-
steam packing. The Nixon safety stay-
bolt sleeve was also in evidence.
The American Brake Shoe and Foun-
dry Co., of New York and Chicago, had
a most interesting and excellent exhibi-
tion of their brake shoes, among which
are the diamond "S," the Streeter, the
Corning, the Sargent "U," the Lappin
and the Cardwell patents. The steelback
brake shoe was among the newest things
shown, the shoe weighs 25 pounds when
applied and is said to give a scrap of only
5 pounds, when worn out.
The American Steam Gauge & Valve
Co., of Boston, Mass., exhibited a num-
ber of steam gauges with black and white
faces and one-corrosive movement, also
locomotive pop valves muffled and plam.
The American Thompson Improved In-
dicator was on view among the other
specialties and in connection with this
indicator, the American ideal reducing
wheel was shown. With this apparatus,
all complicated and troublesome reducing
gears are entirely done away with. Loco-
motive vacuum and relief valves formed
part of the exhibit.
.American Steel Foundries Co., of New
York and St. Louis, had on exhibition
the Davis Wheel center which was made
from open hearth steel. The spokes of
the wheel may be bent or twisted and so
indicate the quality of this special steel
for wheel centers. The company also
had photographs, models and drawings
of the "Keystone," "Player," "Ameri-
can" and "Ajax" trucks, Leed's pilot
coupler, and several kinds of truck and
body bolsters.
The Armstrong Bros. Tool Co., of
Chicago, had a full line of their tool
holders and their improved form of hold-
er for extra large cutters. Their planer
jacks and clamp lathe dogs were on ex-
hibition and also the well known univer-
sal ratchet which, as everybody knows,
is especially adapted to drilling holes in
exceedingly cramped spaces. This firm
generally goes by the name of the "tool
holder people." At the convention, their
excellent exhibit made them the "atten-
tion holder people."
Baltimore Railway Specialty Co., of
Baltimore, were represented by Mr. T.
H. Symington and by Mr. J. E. Nor-
wood, the inventor of the Norwood cen-
ter and side bearings. The claim made
for these ballbearing center plate and
side bearings is that they move with less
friction than any other kind, resulting in
less draw bar pull, less fuel, less flange
wear, and less truck repairs, all round.
The Bethlehem Steel Co., at South
Bethlehem, Pa., had a large display of
nickel steel and carbon steel castings and
forgings for locomotive use. They
showed specimens of high maganese
foundry pig iron and a special quality of
staybolt iron, Taylor-White tool steel,
malleable bronze castings, aluminium
castings, forgings and shafting of all
kinds, and they showed a rapid fire gun
with ammunition. They also exhibited
for the Shelby Steel Tool Co. non-cor-
rosive locomotive tubes made of Bethle-
hem ya% nickel steel.
Brady Brass Co., of Jersey City, N. J.,
had specimens of their Cyprus bronze for
locomotive and car bearings, also sam-
ples of ingots of Cyprus bronze, babbitt
The Scientist and the
Engineer
Dixon's
Flake Graph-
ite for locomo-
tives is where
the scientific
expert and
the practical
locomo t ive
engineer
stand upon
the same
ground.
Prof. R. H.
Thurston has
shown by ac-
tual test' that
under the
same number
of pounds
pressure, and
traveling at
the same rate
of speed,
Dixon's Flake
Graphite did
nearly three
times as much
work as the
best quality
of winter
sperm oil.
He showed
further that
under the
same number
of pounds
pressure, and
traveling at
the same rate
of speed,
when Dixon's
Graphite was
added to lu-
br i c a t i n g
grease, the
bearings ran
nearly six
times longer
than they did
with either
the best sperm
oil or the best
quality of
lubricating
grease.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
lERSEY CITY, N. J.
"During
the month of
Sept embe r.
1S95, an en-
gineer on the
Atchison, To-
p e k a and
SantaFcRail-
road used 16
pints of valve
oilandburned
89 tons of coal
in running
3032 miles
and doing 25
hours' switch-
work. He was
as saving as
possible in the
use of valve
oil and coal,
and his en-
gine made
the best rec-
ord for the
. month on that
division. Dur-
ing the month
of O c t o b e r,
however, with
the aid of less
than two
ounces of
Dixon's Pure
Flake Graph-
ite, he made
about 5 300
miles and
switches 12
hours, using
only 17 pints
of valve oil
and 1234 tons
of coal, saving
about 58 per
cent, of oil and
30 per cent,
of coal, not
c o u n ting
switch-work."
Let us send
you a sample
of D i X o n ' s
Flake Graph-
ite to try on
your engine.
August, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
38';
Gilman-Brown
Emergency
Knuckle ^
Fits any M. C. B. Coupler
Can be fitted instantly
Makes a safe and strong
connection
Prevents traffic delay on
the road and loss of
car service
^•
Over 30,000 are in use
^«
Send for Catalog on this and
other Track, Locomotive
and Car Devices
RAILWAY
APPLIANCES
COMPANY
Consolidated with the Q. & C. Co.
GENERAL OEFrCES
OLD COLONY BlILDING
...CHICAGO...
New rork Office, 114 Liberty Street
iiictals, solder and metals suitable for
making packing, and samples of ma-
chined locomotive castings.
The Buffalo Brake Beam Co., of Buf-
falo, N. Y., were represented hy Mr. S.
A. Crone and others. The company
whose office is at 30 Pin ■ street. New
York, manufactures the Vanderbilt brake
beam. The beam is simply a structural
steel shape of I-section. The heads lit
neatly on the ends of the beam and are
held in place by one rivet each. The
shape of the beam prevents the head
working and the fulcrum grasping the
flange of the beam in the center is se-
curely held in place by one rivet. This
latter is a malleable casting of ingenious
design and neat workmanship.
The Cling Surface Mfg. Co., of Buf-
falo, N. Y., were also on the ground.
The exhibit consisted of a machine hav-
ing two pulleys on one shaft connected
by belts, driving two pulleys a little dis-
tance away, each weighted to give the re-
quired tension. One of these belts was
plain and the other coated with "cling
surface." It was interesting to see the
latter belt following the driving pulley
half way down to the shaft while the
other would give an occasional slip to
show that it had not "caught on." A
number of people were viewing this ex-
hibit and from the sprinkling of politi-
cians among them, it was evident that
they considered the "machine" was giv-
ing an excellent exhibition of pure
"pull."
The Camel Co., of Chicago, 111., were
represented by Messrs. Hopkins & El-
liott. Their exhibit consisted of journal
bearing and hose clamps. They also
showed the Security car door, the Dun-
ham car door, the Q- & C. car door. This
company also handles the N. R. S. hose
bands and the Camel journal bearing.
The last straw has not been laid on the
back of this journal and is not likely to
be. The Camel Co. was formerly the
National Railway Specialty Co.
The Carborundum Co., of Niagara
Falls, N. Y., displayed a full assortment
of their products, carborundum wheels,
carborundum paper, carborundum cloth
and carborundum grains were to be seen
along with other grinding specialties.
The product of the carborundum works
is the nearest artificial approach to the
diamond which has ever been made.
A. M. Castle & Co., of Chicago, had
on exhibition a Cour depressed corru-
gated locomotive firebox side sheet. In
this sheet a vertical depression is made
along each line of staybolts and this
series of corrugations gives sufficient flex-
ibility to provide for the necessary expan-
sion and contraction of the sheet. The
claim is made that steel of lower tensile
strength can be used with the same fac-
tor of safety, if the Cour method is used.
The Chicago Pneumatic Tool Company
of Chicago, displayed a full assortmeni
of their well known tools, and also gave
away as a souvenir a whirling "mind-
changer." This is a very ingenious toy,
consisting of a small piece of wood,
square section, notched along one edge,
with a pin in one end upon which re-
volves a thin flat piece of wood. When
the thumb nail is run over the notches
with the forefinger on one side the
thin flat bit of wood revolves in one
direction, and when the second finger
is pressed on the other side and the
notches rubbed as before the little
piece of flat wood should revolve in
the other direction. The pneumatic peo-
ple humorously assert that to perform
the latter feat it is necessary for the op-
erator to concentrate his mind — if he
has one— upon the matter in hand, and by
changing his mind succeed in altering the
rotation of the little blades. Considerable
merriment was produced when men hold-
mg responsible positions in the railway
and mechanical world apparently proved
that they had no minds. The company,
however, presumed that everybody pres-
ent at the convention had a mind, as they
gave away their souvenir freely. In fact
the pneumatic tool people went on the
principal of the young divinity student,
who when asked at an examination to
name the minor prophets, replied that it
was not for him to make invidious dis-
tinctions.
The Chicago Railway Equipment Com-
pany, of Chicago, displayed the National
Hollow brake beam, also the "Diamond
Special" beam for high speed service.
The Kewanee, the Sterlingworth, the
Monarch and the "Ninety-Six" brake
beams. Automatic frictionless side bear-
ings and the "Creco" brake slack ad-
juster completed the interesting exhibit.
which was presided over by Mr, E. B
Leigh, vice-president and general man-
ager of fhe company.
The Commonwealth Steel Compar.y,
of St. Louis, had on exhibition models of
the Commonwealth truck with rigid
bolsters, and also with the ingenious
swing arrangement by which a certain
amount of lateral motion is permitted to
the bolster and supporting springs. The
Commonwealth Truck bolster and bod>
bolster were represented by models, and
also what is called the Separable body
bolster. This bolster will permit the re-
moval of continuous draw timbers with-
out requiring the removal of their at-
taching bolts. It is made for all capac-
ities and all styles of cars.
The Consolidated Railway Electric
Lighting and Equipment Company, of
New York, often described as the "Axle
Light," had an exhibit which this year
fairly carried away quite a number of the
company's friends and well wishers. The
"carrying away" was, in one sense, done
390
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
in the beautiful private Pullman car
"Elysian," which took a party of rail-
road men and others from New York
to Saratoga. Col. John T. Dickinson
made a most genial host, and his guests
enjoyed themselves thoroughly. This
car, which had been used by President
Roosevelt on his recent Western trip.
was placed upon the D. & H. tracks at
Saratoga and stood there as a practical
demonstration of what the ''Axle Light''
is, and can do.
W. W. Converse & Co.. of Palmer,
Mass., were represented at the conven-
tion by Mr. Converse, who was engaged
in explaning the merits of the Converse
New Headlight Cleaner, a preparation
which is guaranteed free from grit, acid
or any ingredient which would injure the
surface of a reflector. This headlight
cleaner can be used to clean silverware,
or, indeed, any metal surface, but it lays
itself out with special gusto when a head-
light reflector comes within its sphere of
influence.
Tlie Crane Company, of Chicago, were
to the fore with their new crane locomo-
tive muffler pop safety valve. The self-
adjusting feature is considered to be a
decided advantage, and the convenient
outside regulator for operating the gear-
ing for raising or lowering the adjust-
ment ring is a thing which instantly ap-
peals to any practical man. Gun metal
globe and angle valves and blow-ofif
valves for high pressure were also to be
seen. The Crane Company had as a
souvenir a very neat packet steel measur-
ing tape contained in a nickel plated case.
The tape is on one side divided into feei
and inches and on the other into centi-
meters. The metric side of the tape is
one meter long, while the other gives a
distance of 36 inches.
The Crosby Steam Gauge and Valve
Company, of Boston, had on exhibition,
locomotive steam gauges, pop valves,
their ingenious spring seat globe and
angle valves, Johnston blow-ofF cocks,
air brake recorders, counters, duplex air
brake gauges, indicators, chime whistles
and vertical reading gauges, in which
the figures are always "right side up
with care" before the beholder.
The Detroit Lubricator Company, of
Detroit, had an exhibit of their lubrica-
tors in one of the rooms of the Grand
Union Hotel. Locomotive sight feed
lubricators were shown, also the com-
pany's graphite lubricators which feed
flake graphite regularly and in small
quantities.
The J. A. Fay & Egan Company, of
Cincinnati, exhibited photographs of
their wood working machinery, and had
one of their new band saws set up in their
space on the hotel veranda.
The General Manifold Company, of
Franklin. Pa., exhibited their various
manifolding devices, also their requisition
cards, defect cards, replacer cards, etc.
The Gold Car Heating & Lighting
Company, of New York, had on view
their car heating apparatus showing
duplex coil system, and the straight
steam system. These were in working or-
der under steam. The various parts and
details of their equipment were shown
separately.
The Gould Car Coupler Company, of
New York, showed a great variety of
products, among which were their im-
proved maleable draw gear, with spring
buffer blocks for freight cars. The Gould
improved coupler for ioo,ooo-lb. cars.
Improved M. C. B. journal boxes, coup-
ler for back of tender for heavy equip-
ment, passenger steel platform with
friction buffer and draw gear. Friction
draw gear for steel or wooden sills and
improved roller freight car side bearings.
Mr. H. G. Hammett, of Troy, N. Y..
was on the ground as usual, and had
an intersting exhibit of the railroad spe-
cialties which he handles. These include
the Richardson and the Allen-Richard-
son balanced slide valves. The Sansoni
bell ringer, his own ingenious link grind-
ing apparatus, the Pendergast metallic
packing, and some oil cups.
The Handy Car Equipment Company,
of Chicago, had several things which are
as the name implies, "handy." The
Handy box car which was not shown is
practicaly a gondola with box car top.
with capacious doors on the side. The
car can do the work of a box car or that
of a gondola. The snow locomotive and
car replacer and the handy swinging pilot
coupler were on the ground.
Messrs. Herman, Boker & Co., of New-
York, were reprsented at the convention
by Mr. E. Haring, who explained the
properties of Novo steel and exhibited
the steel and Novo steel cutters.
The Homestead Valve Manufacturing
Company, of Pittsburgh, Pa., exhibited
the Homestead locomotive blow-off
cock, which is a very ingeniously de-
signed valve.
The Huff Locomotive Appliances
Company, of Boston, Mass., had an ex-
hibit showing the Huff track sanding de-
vice, automatic steam blower, a variable
exhaust nozzle and the Huff fuel econ-
omizer and smoke preventer.
The Illinois Maleable Iron Company,
of Chicago, exhibited the Pruyn automa-
tic smoke jack for round houses. This
jack lowers on to the top of a locomo-
tive smoke stack, and makes a satisfac-
tory joint.
Jenkins Brothers, of New York, dis-
played a full assortment of their well
known valves and packing. The firm was
represented by Messrs. Williams. Lang-
ston and Martin.
vb:¥
AiiBii^i. lon.^.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
391
A.Leschcn&SonsRopeCo.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
iioMK orincK :
920-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
(135 E. Lake St., Chicago. 111.
q2Centre St., New York City, N. Y.
SsKrcmontSt. San KrancisccCal.
1717-23 Arapahoe St., Denver, Col.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Bulldins, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
lAYLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's .''SKe'e'd"- Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sol* Kepresentatives In the United States,
Canada and Hexlco
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO,
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation,
1137 THE ROOKERY, CHICAGO.
eeBroadwa.v, New York. Park Bullciicg, Pittsburgh
31 Norfolk House, London, Eng.
Inspection of Sttel Ralls, Splice Bars, Railroad Cars,
Wheel.s, Axles, etc. Chemical Laboratokt— Analysis
of Ores, Iron, Steel. Oils, Water, etc. Physical Labo-
KATORT— Test of Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Bars, etc,
ElBciencr Te«t8 of Boilers, Engines and Locomotires,
Tin; lii-111 of Jcruiiic & Elliott, of Chi-
cago, exhibited .specimens of metallic
packing, iMth in the ordinary form and
that used with piston rods, having en-
larged ends. Valve stem packing was
also in evidence. They exhibited the
Mcintosh air-npcratcd blow-off and
check valve.
The Kennicott Water Softener Com-
pany, of Chicago, displayed a water
softening apparatus and idiotographs of
the numerous installations which they
have made on many of our leading rail-
roads.
The Kindl Car Truck Company, of
Chicago, showed the Kindl and the Cloud
irucks. their roller side bearing and the
pedestal lateral motion device, which it is
claimed eliminates broken wheel flanges
and minimizes rail wear.
The Lawson Dumping Boat & Car
Company, of New York, had as an ex-
hibit a very bautifully made working
model of their instantaneous air-operated
dump car. This car has a steel frame and
carries two steel boxes, the full length
of the car. These bo.xes rest on a series
of steel balls and when desired the boxes
arc run out to the edge of the frame and
ti; ped over, by appropriately placed air
cylinders. The air mechanism also re-
turns the boxes to their proper places
where they are automatically locked.
These cars are called and are instantane-
ous unloaders.
The McConway .& Torley Company, of
Pittsburgh, Pa., exhibited tne Janney and
the Kelso couplers for freight car ser-
vice and for the back of tenders. The
couplers were made of malleable iron and
steel.
The McCord Company, of Chicago
and New York, had on view the McCord
Axle box. The McKim gasket. The
McCord spring dampener, and the Tor-
rey anti-friction metal. As a souvenir
this company gave away a neat little
replica of their axle box, about Vs size,
made of malleable iron and lacquered on
the outside. The little axle box is in-
tended for use as an ink well, and is a
useful as well as a " 'cute'' desk orna-
ment.
Manning, Maxwell & Moore. New
York, displayed a number of their spe-
cialties such as the Ashcroft Company's
steam gauges, Hancock inspirators, Edi-
son recording gauges, the Consolidated
Safety Valve Company's safety valves,
the Metropolitan injectors and ejectors,
and numerous other check valves, steam
valves, strainers and pop valves muffled
and plain, for use on locomotives.
Manufacturers' Railway Supply Com-
pany, of Chicago, III., exhibited their in-
terlocking brake-shoes as made for cars
and for driver brakes. They also ex-
hibited the driver brake head made for
the interlocking shoe. The driver brake
head has only lately been put on the
market.
The Mason Regulator Company, of
Boston, Mass., were on the ground with
a very full assortment of their steam spe-
cialties. This company manufactures
steam regulating devices and steam
|)umps, and also a locomotive reducing
valve for use on an engine in connection
with the heating of cars with steam. The
company also manufactures automobile
appliances.
The Metal Plated Car & Lumber Com-
pany, of New York, had a section of a
passenger car plated with sheet copper.
The Interboro Rapid Transit Company,
of New York, are having 500 cars cov-
erd with this material, the N. Y., N. H.
& H. have ordered 126 new metal plated
cars. The Boston & Maine and the Erie
are using this style of car, and it is grow-
ing in favor.
The Moran Flexible Joint Company,
of Louisville, Ky., showed their ball
joints in all its shapes and sizes for use
everywhere where piping is employed. A
striking feature of the exhibit was an
enormous Moran flexible joint for water
mains, beautifully finished.
The National Car Coupler Company,
of Chicago, had examples of the Hinson
draw gear and the Hinson draw bar at-
tachment. The National freight car
coupler and the National steel platform
and buffer for use on passenger cars.
The National Malleable Castings Com-
pany, of Cleveland, Ohio, had an exhibit
which comprised the Tower coupler as
applied to locomotives made of malleable
iron or steel. The National car door
fastener and the National journal box
were also exhibited.
The New Jersey Car Spring and Rub-
ber Company, of Jersey City, N. J. This
company had a full line of railway hose
and packing, for use on a railway line.
Mr. A. O. Norton, of Boston, Mass.,
had a display of his well-known ball bear-
ing jacks. These jacks are of all sizes
and shapes and are used wherever there
is lifting to be done. They are made in
all forms and in all sizes.
The Philadelphia Pneumatic Tool
Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., had a
sample of very nearly all the tools they
manufacture. The Keller pneumatic
hammers were in evidence, and also their
pneumatic holder-on. Rotary drills,
breast drills, yoke riveters, and their
pneumatic rammer were also to be seen.
This latter tool is the one which knows
enough to pound sand. The company
gave away as a souvenir a neat little
shopping list tablet made of aluminum.
They also gave their friends a very ser-
viceable key ring and aluminum chain
with an imitation of Keller hammer as
one of the links of the chain. Thus have
392
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
they sought to chain attention to the
riveter, and to rivet attention to the
hammer on the chain.
The Pittsburg Spring and Steel Com-
pany, of Pittsburgh, had an interesting
exhibit of locomotive and car springs.
E. L. Post & Co., of New York, dis-
played specimens of the Post Zero Bab-
bitt metal for use in journal bearings.
The Pyle-National Electric Headlight
Company, of Chicago, had an exhibit on
the D. & H. tracks, which consisted of
a passenger car lighted with acetylene
gas, also a headlight in operation. The
Commercial Acetylene Company's safety
storage system was also shown.
The Railway Appliances Company, of
Chicago, had quite a display of railway
appliances, among which may be men-
tioned the Symington journal box and
dust guard, the Whall metallic window
casing, the Fewing's car and engine re-
placer. Globe ventilators, Ajax vestibule
diaphragms and the "Sanwood" car step.
This company also handles the Gilman-
Brown emergency knuckle.
The Railway Materials Company, of
Chicago, exhibited Ferguson oil furnaces
for rivet heating, fiue welding and bolt
heating purposes, and the Ferguson
locomotive fire kindler.
The Rand Drill Company, of New
York, displayed a full assortment of the
Rand pneumatic tools; they also ex-
hibited steam, electric and gas-driven air
compressors.
The Republic Railway Appliance Com-
pany, of St. Louis, displayed interlock-
ing brake shoes and driver brake head,
Republic friction draw gear, Symington
journal boxes and dust guards. Falls
Hollow stay bolt iron and other railroad
specialties.
The Safety Car Heating and Lighting
Company, of New York, had an exhibit
of car heating apparatus in one of the
hotel cottages, all the recent improve-
ments in the company's system were
there shown, also an exhibit of car light-
ing apparatus showing bracket lamps and
fancy deck lamps was in the usual corner
of the rotunda. A buoy lantern was also
shown.
The Schoen Steel Wheel Company, of
Pittsburgh, Pa., exhibited some of their
new solid forced and rolled car wheels.
These wheels are made by a very in-
genious process. Messrs. C. T. and A.
E. Schoen, with Mr. M. R. Jackson, were
in charge of the exhibit.
The Standard Coupler Company,^ of
New York, had an exhibit consisting of
the Sessions' Standard friction draw
gear. Standard couplers and Standard
steel platforms.
The Standard Paint Company, of New
York, exhibited models of refrigerator
cars showing methods of insulation, pre-
servative paint for iron and steel, Ruber-
roid roofing and car flooring.
The T. H. Symington Company, oi
Baltimore, Md., had a .very fine exhibit
of the Symington axle box and dust
guard. Mr. T. H. Symington and others
represented the company.
H. B. Underwood & Co., of Philadel-
phia, showed catalogue of special tools,
such as valve seat facers, boring bars, etc.
The U. S. Metal and Manufacturing
Company, of New York, exhibited a
number of railroad specialties, such as
the Cliff and Giubert automatic hose
reels, the Camel journal bearings, the
"Johnson Hopper door" and the "John-
son flush door" for cars, the Dexter and
the Dexter, Jr., brake beams, etc.
The Walworth Manufacturing Com-
pany, of Boston, had a very attractive
display of steam whistles. Smith's rail-
way track ratchet, Stilson wrenches,
stocks and dies, pipe taps, pipe vices,
pipe cutters and nipple holders. Ratchets
of all kinds were in evidence together
with Mack & Dodge injectors and Bes-
tosking packing.
The Washburn Coupler Company, of
Minneapolis, showed some flexible head
passenger couplers and couplers suitable
for switch engines, and a regular line of
freight car couplers.
The Westinghouse Air Brake Com-
pany, of Pittsburgh, Pa., the Westing-
house Electric and Manufacturing Com-
pany, of Pittsburgh, the Westinghouse
Automatic Air and Steam Coupler Com-
pany, of St. Louis, Mo., and the Ameri-
can Brake Company, of St. Louis, were
jointly represented in one booth. Their
exhibit consisted oi models of railway
cars equipped with the air brake for
freight and passenger service, also the
Westinghouse friction draw gear for
freight and passenger, the automatic
steam and air coupling, the automatic
brake slack adjuster and the Westing-
house high speed reducing valve. Each
of these companies had representatives
on the ground.
Julien L. Yale & Co., of Chicago, had
an exhibit of Major couplers, which was
in charge of Mr. H. L. Winslow.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
SIZE.
1; A>D 21 KlBt
JEWKLS,
SAPPinRE PAUiETS
BALL'S IMPBOTED
SAFETY
DOIBLE ROLLEB
Are without question
the finest watches that
American talent and
Bkilkd labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing such universal sat-
iBfactiou that we have
no liceitancy In claim-
ing that they are the
beet and safest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests severe and numerous have proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Railroad and .Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent In nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facta.
Write us for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
The Joint Committee of the Railway
Master Mechanics and of the Master
Car Builders' Associations will meet in
New York on August 3, to decide on
WHITNEY PLANERS
pressure bars hold the work firmly
and knives travel a constant path,
insuring smoothness of planing.
Write for Catalog.
the next place
' conventions.
for holding the
;il
How many among us at this very hour
do forge a life-long trouble for ourselves,
by taking true for false or false for true?
— Tennyson.
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
WINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGILL BUItDING. WSSHINGTOH,
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sen*
D. e.
AuRUst, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
393
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothcs. j» Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Ma.de in one of the best
■hops in the couatry.
Union of course. Jt Jt
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
Raiiway nilea^e of ttie World.
There have been years when railroad
building has been much more active in
the United States than it has been any
year since the present prosperous times
came on, but our railroads arc steadily
extending and the people have no reason
to apologize for the rate of increase.
The New York Sun recently published
a letter from Walter J. Ballard which
gives the railroad mileage of the world
as folows:
At the end of igoi it was 507.515 miles,
and by the end of 1902 it had increased
to 532,500 miles, distributed as follows:
Miles.
United States 202,471
Europe 180,708
Asia 41,814
South America 28,654
North America (except the United
States) 24,032
Australia 15,649
Africa 14,187
By chief countries the figures are:
Miles.
United States 202,471
British Empire 91.485
German Empire 32,75,3
Russian Empire 31.945
The aggregate capital invested in rail-
ways is $36,850,000,000.
The mileage figures show that the
United States has within 2,269 as much
railroad mileage as has all Europe with
the rest of North America thrown in, and
19,501 miles more than twice as much as
the British Empire. We have more than
six times as much as either the German
or Russian Empire.
In 1902 our railways received gross
earnings of $1,726,380,297, an increase
over 1901 of $137,854,230, and paid out
for wages $676,028,592, an increase of
$65,344.89i- The net earnings were $610.-
131,520, an increase of $52,002,753. Rail-
way statistics since 1897 afford dead-sure
testimony of American prosperity.
Recently the Lunkenheimer Company
of Cincinnati, makers of brass and iron
steam specialties, gave their forty-first
annual "outing." Seven hundred em-
ployees and their families participated in
the enjoyable excursion. There were in
all about two thousand people present,
including children. Everything was free
— transportajion, refreshments, music,
etc. — the Lunkenheimer Company acting
as generous hosts to their employees.
Woodsdale Island Park, about thirty-one
miles from Cincinnati, on the C. H. &
D., was chosen as the "objective point"
for the picnic, and the transportation of
the holiday-makers required two trains
of ten coaches each. The programme
included games, with races, etc.. inter-
spersed with humorous features. The
musical programme was excellent, con-
sisting of thirty numbers, in which the
delightful waltz appeared many times.
The Lunkenheimer Company had the sat-
isfaction of bringing home twenty cars of
perhaps tired, but thoroughly liappy peo-
ple, who had had a day of amuscnicnt
and social intercourse whicli will long
be remembered.
The Joseph Dixon Crucible Company,
of Jersey City, have got out a very neat
little folder showing their protective
paint for steel and iron. They give four
samples, olive green, natural, dark red
and black. These samples give a good
idea of the shade of color each repre-
sents. Half-tone reproductions of photo-
graphs of buildings, bridges and chim-
neys which have been painted with these
colors are shown, and the letter press
gives a paint specification for steel and
iron construction work and one for steel
and iron maintenance work. Altogether
the folder is very useful and it is of con-
venient size. The Dixon Company will
be happy to send the folder to any ad-
dress on receipt of a request to do so.
A very artistic catalogue has just come
to us from the Railway Materials Com-
pany of Chicago. On the title page arc
the words "Oil as Fuel — Its advantages
for railroad shops and manufacturing
plants." The various types of the Fergu-
son oil furnace are set forth and de-
scribed in the pages which follow. The
first is the Ferguson flue welding furnace,
then comes the rivet furnace, the bolt
furnace, the four forging furnaces, the
bulldozer furnace, the furnace for taper-
ing, the spring banding furnace, the two-
spring fitting furnaces, the annealing and
flanging furnace, the portable heater for
steel car repairs and the Ferguson port-
able heater and kindler for kindling loco-
motive fires or removing locomotive
tires, straightening frames, etc. The cata-
logue is well printed and the line cuts
and half-tones are good. There is no
doubt but that the Railway Materials
people can "make things hot for you."
but not in an unpleasant way, they do it
in a manner which produces results eco-
nomically and quickly. Write to them —
Old Colony Building. Chicago— for their
catalogue if you wish to know all about
oil furnaces.
The application of electricity as a mo-
tive power for machine shops has been
an evolution rather than a revolution,
and, except in special instances, its use
is steadily superseding that of steam,
compressed air, hydraulic, rope drive, or
combinations of these powers. In the
past ten years the use of electric motors
in shops has risen from a few incom-
plete and scattered cases to the pres-
ent employment of about 600,000 hp.
regularly supplied by electricity. .-Ks
agents in this industrial advance, the
Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing
Company has taken a prominent and im-
portant place.
394
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
August, 1903.
The Allis-Chalmers Company, of Chi-
cago, have recently issued a partial list
of users of the Reynolds Corliss engines.
These machines are built by the Allis-
Chalmers people. The book contains an
index of cities and states, and following
that is the list of electric railway and
lighting concerns which use these engines
and the size of the engine owned by each
is given. The next list is of concerns
using blowing engines and sizes of each
is given. Next follows air compressors,
pumping engines, rolling mills using the
Reynolds engines. Also flour mills, ele-
vators, mines, foundries, and machine
shops, sawmills, woodworking shops,
etc., etc. The AUis-Chalmers Company
will be happy to send this list to anyone
sufficiently interested to write them for it.
Gentleness, which, when it weds with
manhood, makes a man. — Tennyson.
CONTENTS.
PAGE.
Air Brake Department 365
Berlin Brought to New York 384
Book Review 362
Convention Notes 388
Effects of Tonnage Rating on Cost of Trans. 362
Flues are Set too Close 382
General Correspondence 353
Growth of the Locomotive. Angus Sinclair. 350
How Tom Burk Won His Spurs. Shandy
Magutre 354
How to Learn Things 361
Locomotives:
Baldwin Oil Burner for So. Pac 345
Am. Loco. Co. 2-8-0 for 111. Cen 349
Heavy 4-6-2 for No. Pac 357
Baldwin 2-S-O for the Long Island Road.. 371
Baldwin 4-cyllnder Balanced Compound.. 383
Lubrication of Rolling Stock 373
Motive Power Dept. Holds Up Its End 361
Obituary Notice of P. M. Arthur 378
Obituary Notice of Pulaski Leeds 379
On the Sante Fe Trail. Angus Sinclair 380
Personals 377
Questions Answered 363
Railroad Equipment 345
Recent Improvements in Boiler Design 358
Roller Bearings in Passenger Service 386
Rushton Drifting Throttle 358
Steam Turbines 363
Steam Turbine. Tbe 374
Steel Cars 372
Superheaters for Locomotives 360
Training an Artist in the Forces of Nature.
E. H. MuIIin 346
Why Large Engines Fail 360
INDEX TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
PAGE.
Acme Machinery Co Front Cover
Ajax Metal Co 4th Cover
Allis-Chalmers Co 11
American Balance Slide Valve Co 6
American Brake Shoe Co 16
American Loco. Sander Co 6
American Locomotive Co 19
American Steam Gauge & .Valve Mfg. Co. . 5
Armstrong Bros. Tool Co..' 2d Cover
Armstrong Mfg. Co 20
Ashcroft Mfg. Co ^—
Baker. Wm. C 13
Baldwin Locomotive Works 17
Bar»et, G. & H., Co 2d Cover
Becker-Bralnard Milling Mch. Co ' 3
Big Four Railroad 1
Books:
Compound Locomotives 1
Firing Locomotives 4th Cover
Handling Locomotives 4
Locomotive Running and Management.... 6
Miscellaneous 17
Oil Burning in Locomotives 2
Tiie Amerlcap I^ocomotlve .,,,,, ,, JS
Boston & Albany R. R 8
Boston & Maine R. R 1
Brady Brass Co 5
Caswell Car Co 2
Chapman Jack Co 4
Central R. R. of New Jersey 1
Chicago & Alton R. R 5
Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co H
Cleveland City Forge & Iron Co 4th Cover
Cleveland Twist Drill Co 4th Cover
Coffin Megeath Supply Co 5
Commonwealth Steel Cc 3d Cover
Consolidated Safety Valve Co —
Consolidated Railway Electric Lighting &
Equipment Co 20
Crosby Steam Gauge & Valve Co 17
Damacus Bronze Co 14
Dart Mfg. Co 15
Davis, John, Co 6
Day-Klncald Stoker Co 5
Derry-Coilard Co —
Detroit Lubricator Co 10
Dixon, Joseph Crucible Co 388
Eynon-Evans Co 1
Falls Hollow Staybolt Co 6
Fay & Egan Co., J. A 19
Flanders, L. B.. Machine Works 4
Franklin Mfg. Co 13
Galena Signal Oil Co 13
General Electric Co 8
Gold Car Heating Co 390
Gould Coupler Co 3
Gould & Eberhardt 4th Cover
Hammett. H. G 4th Cover
Hancock Inspector Co —
Harrington & King Perforating Co... 2d Cover
Hayden & Derby Mfg. Co —
Hendrick Mfg.- Co 6
Henley. N. A., & Co —
Hicks. F. M 394
Hoffman, Geo. W 6
Hunt, Robert W.. & Co 391
Illinois Central R. R 1
Industrial Water Co 3
International Correspondence Schools 21
Jenkins Bros 4th Cover
Jones, B. M. & Co 391
Jones & Lamson Machine Co 394
Kennicott Water Softener Co 2d Cover
Lake Erie Iron Co 4th Cover
Lake Shore R. R 14
Latrobe Steel & Coupler Co 13
Lawson Improved Dumping Boat & Car Co. 22
Leschen & Son's Rope Co 391
Locomotive Firemen's Magazine 7
Locomotive Chart 17
Locomotive Publishing Co., Ltd 21
Lunkenheimer Co 4
McConway & Torley Co 10
McCord & Co 394
Manning. Maxwell & Moore 17
Moran Flexible Steam Joint Co 394
Nathan Mfg. Co 6
National Car Coupler Co 4th Cover
National Malleable Castings Co 4th Cover
Nicholson, W. H.. & Co 393
Niles-Bement-Pond Co 9
Niles Tool Co —
Norton Grinding Co —
Norwalk Iron Works 20
Otto Gas Engine Works 13
Parker Pen Co 1
Pedrick & Ayer Co 15
Peters, H. S 393
Pond Machine Tool Co.. The —
Porter, H. K.. & Co 17
Pratt & Whitney Co 9
Pressed Steel Car Co ' 20
Prosser, Ttios.. & Son 3
Protectus Co., The 16
Railway Appliances Co 389
Railway Material Co 2d Cover
Ramapo Iron Works 14
Rand Drill Co 8
Roberts' Steam Piston Packing Co 2
Rogers Locomotive Works 17
Ross Valve Co 4th Cover
Rue Mfg. Co 14
Sackman, F. A 4th Cover
Safety Car Heating & Lighting Co 5
Saunders', D.. Sons 20
Seamless Steel Tube Co..; 16
Sellers. Wm.. & Co.. Inc 1
Shaw Electric Crane Co —
Smoothon Mfg. Co 6
Standard Car Truck Co '16
Standard Coupler t^ 4
Standard Steel Works 14
Star Brass Mfg. Co —
Starrett Co.. L. S §
Sturtevant, B. F., Co 21
Tabor Mfg. Co 1
Union Pacific R. R 295
Underwood, H. B.. & Co 4
Union Switch & Signal Co 391
United States Metallic Packing Co 10
Universal Car Bearing Co 13
Utica Steam Gauge Co —
Vitrified Wheel Co 4th Cover
Walworth Mfg. Co 2d Cover
Watson-Stlllman Co 2d and 4th Cover
Webb C. Ball Watch Co 393
Westlnghouse Air-Brake Co 18
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co 19
Whittlesey, Geo. P 392
Whitney & Son, Baxter D 392
Williams Typewriter Co 3
Wood, R, p., & Co , 4
i?LS.--
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINQFIELD, VERMONT. V. S. A.
A . B . C. and Luber^s Code used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephtn-
lon's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlotf'nstrasse 112, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
FOR SALE
FREIGHT, PASSENGER AND LOGGING
LOCOMOTIVES
AND "~
ALL ^ADC QUICK
SIZES. ^A%^0 DELIVERIES
F.-M. HICKS,
aM^ Moran Flexible
■^F' Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECI*LIY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
HORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. 149 Tbird Street, L«ul9ville, Ky.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord ft Company,
CHICAGO. NEW VORK.
L Railway ..and
ocomotive
Q)py right by Angus Sinclair Co.- 1903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, September, 1903
No. 9
rir. Forney as a Newspaper nan.
In a very interesting p;ii)fr wliicli Mr.
M. N. Forney read before the New
York Railway Ckib, in 1902, there are
some notes of his newspaper experience
which we think worthy of reprothicing.
He says:
"In 1870 your lecturer became a news-
paper man antl then commenced editorial
iiM'Ci- and authority and one then feels
more contidence in iheiii. That fascina-
tion every editor can enjoy until he
makes some blunder — and they all do^
and then he finds that he is not as
infallible as he thought he was. This
recalls a little story \*iich perhaps you
have heard from me before, but it is
.good enough to tell twice. A Catholic
doubtless like that of many another, who
if he had been ten times more infallible
would have made fewer mistakes. There
was, though, one experience that was a
little peculiar. Of course, unless a per-
son is an absolute ass, he does not ex-
pect to produce a sensation when he
begins to write for the public. But
even at this remote distance I can re-
W.ATER TROUGH ON THE LONDON .\NU NORTH WESTERN R.iTLWAY.
w>^rk on the Railroad Gazette. Pre-
vious to that he had had neither educa-
tion nor training which would especially
qualify him for that kind of work.
Years of subsequent experience have
taught him that the number of people
who do not like to see themselves in
print is very small. There is a fascina-
tion in seeing our ideas in type. They
then appear to be entirely disassociated
from ourselves. It is said that nearly
all people's opinions are strengthened
when others agree with them. Seeing
one's thoughts presented in print some-
how seems to give them additional
priest was passing through his kitchen
one day and happened to hear his Irish
cook violently berating an Italian. After
tTie Italian or 'dago,' as she called him.
had vanished, the rector felt it his duty
to rebuke the cook and to remind her
that Italians were people to be treated
with respect, if for no other reason on
her part than that the Pope himself was
an Italian. 'And you know, Bridget.'
said he. 'the Pope is infallible." 'Yes,'
said Bridget, 'but he would have been
ten times as infalliable if he had been
an Irishman.' " .
"My beginning of newspaper work was
call the curious question that came over
me on discovering that apparently no
one ever read what I wrote. The word
'apparently' is used advisedly, because
in time the writer who works honestly
and intelligently will find that here and
there someone has read what he has put
in print, and that if he only keeps at
it and does not 'weary in well doing.'
his work will produce some results ac-
cording to his ability, pertinacity and
mental integrity. This was illustrated
in the adoption of standards by the
Master Mechanics' and the Master Car
Builders' Associations. In 1870 hardly
396
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
-anything had been done in that diret
tion. As early as 1864 the inconveni-
ence and confusion resulting from the
diversity in the screw-threads used in
machines and other structures was
brought up tor cunsideration before the
Franklin Institute of Philadelphia. It
may be almost incredible to the younger
members present to be told that at that
time there was no common standard.
The number of threads to an inch^ their
form and the diameter of screws were
all made in accordance with the whims
and fancies of different manufacturers
or master mechanics, with the result
that a 7/j;-inch nut on one car or locomo-
tive would often not screw or stay
screwed on to a bolt of nominally the
same size on another. This was the
cause of endless confusion and loss. It
would take too much time to tell the
story over again of how the Frankhn
Institute first adopted the Sellers Stand-
ard, which was followed successively by
the Navy Department, the Master Me-
chanics' and Master Car Builders' Asso-
ciations. It may all be found in a re-
port of the Master Car Builders' Asso-
ciation Convention of June, i88j. About
that time as much was written on the
subject as would make a book as big
as the New Testament or larger. All
kinds of obstacles and opposition were
arrayed against the adoption of the
standard, and had it not been for the
commanding position occupied by the
railroad companies toward the manu-
facturers, it is doubtful whether the
standard screw-thread would have yet
been generally adopted."
A Strike for Lower Wages.
Theodore Smith & Sons, boiler makers
of Jersey City, have asked for police pro-
tection of non-union employees.
Charles Smith, one of the firm, said the
strike presented a novel feature, the move-
ment being practically an effort to bring
about lower wages. The firm, he said.
Iiad always paid union rates, but they had
also established the plan of paying e.xtra
wages to men who proved to be expert
workmen. The union rate, he said, was
$3 a day, but the firm had several men to
whom they paid $3.75 a day in recognition
of the better work done by them. When
the International Machinists' Union
learned this, the firm were notified that
they must establish a uniform rate of $3
a day or a strike would be ordered. The
firm refused to comply with the demand
and the strike followed. The men who
were getting $3.75 a day went out with
the others, thus protesting against the
higher wages they received. Since then
the firm have employed non-union labor.
— Iron Age.
An Improvad Locomotive Fire -Box
Door Flange.
In the construction of steam boilers,
and particularly those employed in loco-
motives, difficulty has often been ex-
perienced in preventing cracking and
leakage about the door of the fire-box.
The outstanding flange carried by the
inner sheet is disposed substantially at
right angles thereto, and the connection
of the flange w'ith the sheet is in the
form of a sharp bend in the metal. It is
with this portion of the structure that
the difllculty is experienced, as the
cracks occur along the inner bend or
knuckle.
There are several reasons which co-
operate to cause this damage. In tlic
Every man ought to know his own
business best. — ^fr. IVemmick.
EXPANSION KIRE-BOX DOOR.
first place, the inner door sheet and
flange are highly heated by the fire, but
as soon as the door is opened by the fire-
man a great volume of cold air rushes
in through the doorway. As a result the
flange and knuckle are suddenly cooled,
causing unequal and instantaneous con-
traction of the metal, thus setting up
strains which tear the flange away from
the sheet. This unequal expansion and
contraction is furthered by the fastening
of the short flanges together, these
flanges thus being more rigid than the
remainder of the sheets and being of
smaller area they are incapable of as
relatively great movement. Another ob-
jectionable feature lies in the very
limited body of water whicli lias here-
tofore surrounded the doorway. This
space is so contracted by the overlap-
ping flanges and the heads of the rivets
fastening them that very little water can
come into direct contact with the flange
extending outward. Moreover, in this
small space incrustation and deposits of
foreign matter soon collect, thus sepa-
rating the water entirely from the sheet
and permitting the metal to become
overheated, thereby assisting in doin;?
the injury above described.
Information that I lately received from
foreman boiler makers who have charge
of boiler shops in the western and north-
western portions of the country indicates
that they arc having a great deal oi
trouble with the door flanges by crack-
ing, and they describe it as "the mean-
est leak and the hardest to keep tight oi
.iny leak about a fire box."
It is the object of my improvement
to entirely eliminate this objectionable
feature by providing an improved struc-
ture which will freely expand and con-
tract without causing undue strain, and
at the same time obtaining a sulificiently
enlarged water chamber about t-Iie door-
way to prevent to a very great degree
accumulations therein.
The structure by which these objects
are obtained is simple and is not more
expensive that that heretofore employed.
Instead of the usual sharp bend or
knuckle between the flange and the inner
sheet, the portion of the metal connect-
ing the flange and sheet is inwardly
swelled, thus forming a circular and in-
wardly convexed boss about the door
opening. As a result, an enlarged water
chamber is provided which entirely sur-
rounds the opening.
While it will be apparent that thi->
change does not involve any radical de-
parture from the usual construction and
that it can be easily made without addi-
tional expense, the advantages which aru
obtained are very important. In the
first place there is no comparatively
sharp bend in the metal, while additional
area is obtained. As a result, when the
flange is cooled during the inrush of
cold air in the manner above described,
tlie swelled portion can freely contract
without any danger of cracking, as the
pronounced curve in the inner sheet
gives freely to the strain. A number of
benefits are derived from the enlarged
water space. The comparatively large
body of heated water tends to maintain
a more even temperature of the metal,
preventing to a great extent its being
overheated and also tending to preclude
the too rapid cooling of the flanges.
Furthermore it provides more room
about the inner heads of the rivets and
in this enlarged chamber there is not so
much danger of the sediment accumu-
lating and separating the water from the
flanges.
■September, 190J.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
397
Tliis feature is, therefore, of special
•importance in locomotives running in
bad water districts. Actual experience
on a Fremont, Elkliorn & Missouri Val-
ley locomotive has proved that the
structure is entirely practicable and sat-
isfactory.
While the invention as described is
particularly useful in locomotive boilers,
it will be readily understood by those
skilled in the art that it is applicable to
boilers of dififerent types and hence is
not limited to any one class.
In forming the improved door flange
to position I would recommend that in
the large shops where power can be ap-
plied that it be pressed to position by
using male and female blocks, but in the
absence of these facilities it can be easily
made by using the .swelled cast iron
former and wooden mauls. Steel ham-
Fast Baldwin Passenger linglne for
the Norfolk & Western.
The Norfolk & Western Railway
have recently bought some simple 4-4-2
engines from the Baldwin Locomotive
Works of Philadelphia. The cylinders
of these engines are 19x28 ins. and the
driving wheels are 79 ins. diameter. The
total weight of the machine is 168,650
lbs. and there are 85,790 lbs. carried by
the drivers. The valve motion is in-
direct with transmission bar curved be-
low the forward driving axle. The
rocker-arm works the valve rod by
means of a small crosshead arrangement
as the rod passes through a guide in
the yoke. The valve is of the balanced
piston type and placed immediately over
the cylinder whose steam distribution it
governs. The diameter of the carrying
wheels is 50 ins. and they are equalized
with the rear drivers by means of what
jector delivery pipe, through which,
when washing out, the deposit which
necessarily forms in this region may be
easily removed.
The lender has a 6,000 gallon tank
which is carried on a steel channel frame,
the whole carried on two arch bar trucks.
The total weight of engine and tender
is about 289,000 lbs., and the total wheel-
base of both together is 53 ft. q'/z ins.
An electric headlight illuminates the
track at night ahead of this modern high-
speed machine.
A few of the principal dimensions are
as follows:
Cylinders — 19 x 28 in.
Bailer— Uia.. 62 in.; thicknesA of sheets. y^Sc Hin.;
working pressure, 200 lbs.: staying, radial.
I-iiobox — Length, 100 in.; width, 64^ in.; depth,
front, 72^ in.; back, 61H in.; thickness of
sheets, sides, )j in.; back, 'A in ; crown, >» in.:
tutje, % in ; water space, tront, 4 in.; .sides, 3^
in ; back. 4 in.
B.^LDWIN 4.4-
ENGINE FOR THE NORFOLK & WESTERN.
mers or sledges should never be u<ed on
a door sheet flange.
M. O'Connor.
Foreman Boilermaker C. Sf N. IV. R. R.
Shops, Mo. ]' alley, lo'va.
The balanced compound locomotives re-
cently built by the Baldwin Locomotive
Works for the Atchison, Topeka &
Santa Fe Railway system, which
were illustrated in our August issue, have
steel crank axles which were imported
fiom England. The Bethlehem Steel
Company is the only concern in the L^ni-
ted States that have facilities for making
such articles, and they asked such a high
price for them that it was cheaper to pay
the high duty and import the axles from
England. Yet there is no doubt that
.American steel makers can produce their
goods cheaper than any steel making con-
cern in the world, but they are not con-
tented with ordinary profits.
may be called a box equalizer in which a
bemi-elliptic spring is placed, the upper
side of the spring buckle acting as the
fulcrum for the equalizer. With this
arrangement it is possible to readjust
the weight o'n the drivers by temporarily
lifting the engine and moving the spring
forward or back in the "box," within
certain restricted limits. The drivers
are, of course, equalized together. Every
wheel under the engine is braked.
The boiler is of the ordinary wagon
top type with wide firebox. The smallest
ring measures 62 ins. in diameter.
There are 326 tubes, 16 ft. long, which
give a heating surface of 2,716^:4 sq. ft.
when the 162 sq. ft. in the firebox are
added to this, it gives a total of 2.878!^
sq. ft. The roof sheet is level, w'hile the
crown sheet slopes slightly to the back,
and there is ample steam space. There
is a 3'2 in. hand hole in the bottom of
the first barrel cotirse nearly straight
below the point of entrance of the in- ,
Heating surface — Firebox. 162 sq. It.: total. 2.S7^ 75
sq. ft.; grate area, 45.1 sq ft.
Driv. wheels— Dia. outside. 79in.; jour.. SJ4x 10 4in.
Wheel base— Drixnng. 6 ft. loin.; rigid, 14 ft. io in.:
total engine. 26 ft SJ^ in.: total engine and
tender. 53 ft. 95^ in.
Weight— On driving wheels, 85,790 lbs.; on truck.
front, 39,480 lbs.; on carrying wheels, 43.3S0 lbs.
Seeking Russian Harkets for Locomo-
tives.
Vice-President Robert J. Gross, of the
.-American Locomotive Company, is now
in Russia exploiting the advantages of
-\merican locomotives for operation on
Russian railroads. American locomo-
tives have been used in that country for
a good many years, and with general
satisfaction, but at the same time Ger-
man locomotives have been more largely
used because of the nearness of the Ger-
man manufacturers. The American
Locomotive Company, however, has de-
cided to make a thorough study of con-
ditions that exist in Russia, and is de-
398
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIXI-: ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
termined to enter the field, if conditions
will warrant, and this accounts for the
present mission of Vice-President Gross.
Incidentally, it may be stated that the
company has no expectation of doing
business immediately with the Russian
railroads, for the reason tnat they have
about all the orders they can care for
tor many months ahead for the Amer-
ican railroads, but the company is figur-
ing on the future, when home orders
may possibly show a decrease.
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINC'L.MR.
( Continued from page 3^2. )
The first decade of railroad history
was one of the most critical periods the
United States had passed through. It
opened up with the people unusually
prosperous and with money to devote to
internal improvements. In 1833 Presi-
dent Jackson ordered an accumulation
of money stored in the United States
Bank, amouning to forty millions of
dollars, to be distributed among state
banks. These banks loaned the money,
so unexpectedly obtained, on all kinds
of doubtful securities, and a wild season
of speculation arose. The purchase and
sale of lands belonging to the public
domain was the principal object of spec-
ulation and incidentally the construction
of railroads was worked up to a highly
inflated degree.
A R.MLROAD MANIA PUSHES RAILROAD
CONSTRUCTION.
A decided railroad mania prevailed,
which was overtaken by the inevitable
panic the following year, in 1836. In
1830 there were 23 miles of railroad in
the whole of the United States.
The following table shows the mileage
of railroads in operation or under con-
struction in the different states in 1836:
Miles.
Alabama, under construction 62
Delaware, in operation 17
Georgia, in operation u
Kentucky, in operation 85
Louisiana, in operation .S
^laryland, in operation 144
Maryland, under construction 70
Massachusetts, in operation 72
Mississippi, in operation 26
New Jersey, in operation 105
New York, in operation 70
New York, under construction 20a
Pennsylvania, under construction... 234
Pennsylvania, in operation 392
Rhode Island, under construction.. 46
South Carolina, in operation 136
Virginia, in operation 195
Virginia, under construction 86
These figures show that nearly two
thousand miles of railroad had been built
in si.K years, a most extraordinary
achievement for a new country.
RAILROAD MILEAGE EXCEEDS THE NECES-
SARY POWER.
The progress of railroad building in
the United States, as compared with
that of Great Britain, conveys a good
idea of the energy displayed by Ameri-
can public men in pushing improved
methods of land transportation. In
1840 Great Britain, with what was then
unparalleled financial resources, had
3.430 miles of railroads and the United
States had 2,755 miles. P'or this mile-
age, the United States, however, had
only 270 locomotives, the small amount
of motive power being due in some
measure to the high price nf locomotives
and difficulty in obtaining them. A con-
siderable part of the mileage was oper-
ated by horses, which were the first form
of motive , power used, and they were
slowly being pushed aside by the loco-
motive, just as they have of late been
pushed aside in street car service by
electric traction.
JOSEPH HARRIbON.
liRITAIN THE WORKSHOP OF EARLY LOCO-
MOTIVE BUILDING.
As the principal center for the build-
ing of machinery at this time was Great
Britain, American railroad companies
naturally imported from that country the
locomotives which they could not have
built at home, and there was at first an
idea that foreign built locomotives must
necessarily be better than the home-made
article. In Wood's Treatise on Rail-
ways, published in 1838, particulars are
given of sixteen locomotives which had
been built by the Stephensons for Ameri-
can railways, and there were other
makers who found the United States a
profitable market. Edward Bury's first
engine, built in 1831, was sold to the
Petersburg Railroad of Virginia, where
it was long known as the "Spitfire," and
the firm, Bury, Curtis & Kennedy, built
several engines for Southern railroads,
and the first engine owned by the Boston
and Providence Railroad was made in the
Bury shops.
SIIOKTCO.MINGS OF BRITISH BUILT LOCO-
MOTIVES.
British-made locomotives were a very
short time running on American rail-
roads, before the locomotive engineers
began to make unfavorable comparisons
between them and those made in the
United States. The unique privilege
which American locomotive engineers
enjoyed for many years, of criticising the
designs and working of their engines,
soon closed the United States market
for British locomotives and stimulated
native machine shop owners to enter
the field of locomotive construction.
The principal fault found with the Eng-
lish locomotives was that they were in-
convenient to handle and to repair, the
latter being a very serious objection
when the principal part of the repair
work had to be done by the enginemen
themselves. The annual expense of re-
pairing the Stephenson locomotives on
the Liverpool and Manchester Railway
was enormous. In 1833 the cost of keep-
ing thirty engines in repair was about
$140,000, and ten of the engines were
reported to be useless. As the mileage
made by each engine did not exceed
10,000 miles a year the cost of repairs
alone was about 47 cents a mile.
American railroad companies were not
disposed to rival that kind of extrav-
agance.
The British locomotive builders did
not heed suggestions, that changes might
easily be effected which would make their
engines more reliable for continuous
mileage, more convenient to repair and
to handle; so they lost the American
market for locomotives in a very few
years, just as other British manufacturers
lost the American market for axes, be-
cause they would not make the axes of
the shape demanded by the users.
GARRETT S: EASTWICK BEGIN LOCOMOTIVE
BUILDING.
There were soon going to be plenty
of competition in the business of loco-
motive building. In 1835, the year after
Mr. Baldwin entered seriously into the
work of locomotive building, the firm
of Garrett & Eastwick, then making
steam engines and light machinery, in
Philadelphia, obtained an order to build
a locomotive for the Beaver Meadow
Railroad, the first section of what is
now a branch of the Lehigh Valley
Railroad.
THE BEAVER MEADOW RAILROAD.
The Beaver Meadow Railroad winded
about the mountains and forests of the
Mauch Chunk region, and was originally
built for the transportation of coal for
shipment on the Lehigh Canal. The con-
struction of the line was a great enter-
prise as it involved the overcoming of
greater engineering difficulties than any-
thing previously encountered in railroad
building. When finished the road was
Seplcmber, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
399
exceedingly crooked and hilly. It had
one curve 300 feet long of 250 feet radius;
tlicrc were two grades 96 feet to the
mile, three-cjuarters of a mile each, and
one grade 80 feet to the mile, five miles
long, having several curvvs, one of them
being 550 feet radius.
The capitalists who undertook the con-
struction of that railroad were leaders
among the most enterprising gentlemen
in Pennsylvania at that time. They
spared no expense to ni.ike the railroad
men. li is said to have been a very
crude tab, but it was a Ijeginning of
a very desirable improvement, that was
soon acknowledged to be an absolute
necessity for locf)motives operating in
tl>e rigorous climate of the United States.
•niK FIRST Ki<;iir-\viiKi;i. esgisk.
Early in 1836, Henry R. Campbell, a
civil engineer on the Philadelphia and
Gcrmantown Railroad, secured a patent
on .in eight-wdicel engine, Fig. 32, with
FIRST .S-VVHEEL ENGINE.
FIG. 3L>.
and its equipment equal to the best that
could be procured at that period.
E.\STWICK & HARRI.SON's FIRST ENGINE.
The Beaver Meadow locomotive was
called the "Samuel D. Ingham," after
the president of the road. The engine
had the Bury boiler and inside frames
with outside cylinders, a style of con-
struction that had up to that time found
very little favor from locomotive design-
ers. The reversing gear invented by
Andrew M. Eastvvick was entirely orig-
inal, and consisted principally of a slid-
ing block intervening between the valve
seat and the slide valve. Particulars will
be given in my article on locomotive
valve gear.
JOSEPH HARRISON, JR.
.\s Garrett & Eastwick had no experi-
ence in locomotive building, they en-
gaged as foreman. Joseph Harrison, Jr..
a young man who had worked for several
years in the Norris Works, where he
learned a great deal from the failures
and a little from the successes in loco-
motive building. Harrison developed
into an excellent designer of locomotives,
and he invented a variety of improve-
ments which became permanent features
of the locomotive engine.
THE FIRST CAB.
The "Samuel D. Ingham'' compared
favorably with any locomotives then in
use. The engine was noteworthy as
being the first built with the deck cov-
ered to afford protection of the engine-
one pair of driving wheels in front of
the fire bo.\ and the other pair behind.
It was the first of what afterwards be-
came known as the American Locomo-
tive, the pattern of which was copied
more or less by all the railroads of the
world.
builders. The native furnaces could not
produce but a small fraction of the iron
needed for rails, and the import duty
was about $25 a ton. As the building
t)( a railroad provided with substantial
rails was out of the question, the pioneer
builders did their best with the material
at their command.
One engine was built after Campbell's
drawings in a shop in Philadelphia be-
longing to James Brooks & Co., and
it was put to work on the Philadelphia
and Gcrmantown kailroad, but did not
become popular. The principal objec-
tion to it was that it rode hard, due
to the want of means for equalizing the
weight on drivers.
GARRETT & EASTWICK's IlERrULES.
Late in 1836 the firm of Garrett &
Eastwick built an eight-wheeler called
"Hercules" (Fig. a), for the Beaver
Meadow Railroad, in which an attempt
was made to render the engine more
flexible. Mr. Eastwick devised a separate
frame with pedestals, in which the two
pairs of wheels were placed. This frame
vibrated upon the center bearing, and
could move as the truck does, except
that it could not turn. This allowed it
to adjust itself to uneven track, pro-
vided the unevenness was alike on both
sides, otherwise it racked the framing.
This frame was underneath, and separ-
ated from the main frame by side bear-
ing springs. This was l>etter than the
old rigid plan of Campbell's, but not very
much better. This engine "Hercules"
EASTWICK Sl HARRISON'S FIRST ENGINE WITH FLE.XIBLE FRAME. FIG. 33.
In designing his engine, Campbell was
infli'.enced by the desire to produce a
locomotive that would be easy on the
tender track. Strap rails laid on wooden
stringers were still the rule, and the
Beaver Meadow road, recently opened.
was considered particularly substantial
with strap rails 2,'/2X->^ inch.
The tendency towards the building of
light railroads was due more to the pov-
erty of the country than to want of
foresight on the part of our railroad
was the first one to have bolted straps
and half-boxes on the side rods, instead
of a gib and key: the rods had no keys.
The "Hercules" weighed fifteen tons,
and was to run on a very crooked and
hilly road. This engine was so flexible
that it could accomplish more work than
the others in use. and more like it were
ordered. But in the meantime, the firm
took into partnership Joseph Harrison.
Jr.. their young foreman, who set about
simplifying the flexible engine; and the
4<x>
fi-\LLWAi' -iALD J-£
IVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
result was the invention of the modern
equalizer, now universally used in this
country and in most foreign countries.
THE FIRST EQUALIZERS.
Harrison's first equalizers were made
of cast iron, very heavy and clumsy and
were hung above the frame just as they
are now in 8-wheeIers, the ends bearing
on round pins that went down and rested
on the top of the box. Mr. Harrison's
The engine built upon this order was
known as the "Gowan & Marx" (Fig.
34), which became one of the most
famous, locomotives ever built.
The engine was of the eight wheel
type, and in order to properly distribute
the weight, the rear axle was placed under
the firebox, just as it is now placed under
six and eight coupled engines. The
boiler had a Bury dome firebox 5 feet
diameter. Two-inch tubes 9 feet long
nearly filled the cylindrical part of the
boiler.
The cylinders were i2jjxiS inches, and
JtaUui^y ^ Lucumotitt Lnj/tHWrini/
GOWAN & M.^RX. FIG. 34.
patent covered all the combinations of
equalizers now known, and also provided
one for the truck. This device made
it possible to use any number of driving
wheels on the roughest track, and was.
up to that time, the most useful im-
provement made on the locomotive en-
gine.
EQU.\LIZERS DISCREDITED.
The other builders condemned the use
of more than one pair of driving wheels,
and did not, for some time, credit the
equalizer with any merit. Mr. Baldwin
said he could not see how the engine
would curve without slipping some of the
drivers, and he thought it impossible
to maintain all four wheels exactly the
same size and thought them complicated;
but their good points were forced upon
him by their service, and, in 1845, he
bought the patent of Mr. Campbell's
8-wheeler, and that of the equalizer of
Eastwick & Harrison, and at once turned
out his first class "C engine, and after-
wards said she was the best engine he
had then turned out.
THE "gOW.\.^ & M.\RX."
In 1839, Eastwick & Harrison, as the
firm was now called, received an order
from the Philadelphia and Reading Rail-
road for a big locomotive to weigh all
of eleven tons, not less than nine tons
to be on the four drivers, and it was
specified that the engine must burn
anthracite coal in a horizontal boiler.
the driving wheels were 42 inches diam-
eter. A blower for stimulating the fire
was first used on this engine, and it was
the first to be equipped with Harrison's
equalizers.
When put in service the "Gowan &
Marx" developed such extraordinary
train weighed 423 tons, and, including
the weight of engine and tender, equalled
forty times the weight of the engine.
In connection with the great amount
of tractive power developed by the
"Gowan & Mar.x," in proportion to it.s-
weight (forty times its own weight), it
is curious to note that only ten years-
earlier, the Liverpool and Manchester
Railway Company, in offering a prize
of five hundred pounds for a practicable
locomotive, required that it should pull
three times its own weight. The South
Carolina Railroad Company, in ordering
a locomotive from the West Point
Foundry, in 1830, also specified that it
must pull a train three times the weight
of the engine.
The success of the "Gowan & Marx"
promised to promote rapidly the busi-
ness of the builders, but the personal
good fortune brought to the firm de-
prived the United States of gljod loco-
motive manufacturers.
The remarkable performances of the
engine attracted much attention at home
and abroad. The Russian Government,
on account of the work done by this
engine, sent two engineers to the United
States to verify the account and to re-
port on the best machinery and appli-
ances for the St. Petersburg and Moscow
Railway, then under construction.
The report of these engines was so
favorable that Eastwick & Harrison were
requested to visit St. Petersburg, with
the view of making a contract for build-
MERCURY.
tractive power that the whole railroad
would become interested and many in-
dividuals were incredulous. On one of
its first trips in February, 1840, it hauled
from Reading to Philadelphia a train of
104 4-wheel loaded cars, at an average
speed of 9.82 miles per hour. The road
had a descending gradient of nearly 4
feet per mile, 27 miles level, 9 miles of
it in one place, and only one ascending
grade, 26.4 per mile for 2,100 feet. This
ing locomotives and cars. The contract
was made and the Americans established
locomotive building works in Russia and
shortly afterwards closed up their works
in Philadelphia.
Before closing their works for good,
Eastwick & Harrison built two passenger
engines for the Baltimore & Ohio, which
were as notable for fast speed as the
"Gowan & Marx" was for load pulling.
One of these, the "Mercury" (Fig. 35),
September, 1903.
RAir.WAY A.MJ LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
401
in 1844 worked the great aggregate of
37,000 miles, the greatest animal mileage
achieved by one engine up to that time.
Why Steel Cars Are Popular.
The Besseiner & Lake Erie Railroad
were the first to adopt the steel car of
large capacity and that was in 1897. An
cars or cars with steel frames is that
it enables the draw gear to be put on
the center line of pull and not kept
altogether below the center sills, as is
required in wooden cars. That this is
a thoroughly correct and scientific
method of construction has no doubt
been proved conclusively to anyone who
has seen the behavior of a light wooden
Mat car in even a slight collision. The
wooden flat car invariably breaks up-
ward in the center, due to the line of
Schmidt Superheater Performance.
Through the courtesy of Mr. E. A.
Williams, superintendent of rolling stock
of the Canadian Pacific Railway, we
have received a very interesting tabu-
lated comparison of the performance of
locomotives in freight service on the
.Smith's Falls — Outremont section of the
O. & Q. division of the C. P. R,
An engine was fitted with the Schmidt
superheater and her performance was
compared with the average performance
of simple and compound engines on this
section and in the same service. It is
interesting to note how in the contest
the "fortune of war" sometimes favored
one of the contestants and sometimes
another, but the result which the eigh-
teen months' test brought out was that
the Schmidt superheater engine showed
a saving of 33.3 per cent, over the sim-
ple engine and 13.8 per cent, over the
compound. This performance makes the
men on the road speak enthusiastically
about engine 546 whenever the subject
is brought up.
JiaUway ^ LoiMmiitiva Eni/trutring
EIGHT-WHEELER BUILT BY EASTWICK & HARRISON. FOR RUSSIA.
estimate made about the middle of this
year places the number of big tonnage
steel cars now in this country at over
100,000 cars.
There are several reasons why the
popularity of the steel car has increased
and that of the wooden car has dimin-
ished, in the railway world, but perhaps
the most cogent reason for the prefer-
ence given to steel cars is the fact that
considering the total load behind the
tender in any train, the dead weight
hauled will be less if the train be made
up of high capacity steel cars. That
being the case it follows that fewer cars
will be required per 1,000 tons of freight
with a consequent reduction of light
mileage.
These two reasons taken in conjunc-
tion with the fact that steel cars are
more durable than wooden ones, has
brought about a reluctance on the part
of interchanging lines to haul old light
wooden cars in trains of heavy high
capacity steel cars. The large high-side
hopper car also possesses very great
advantages in the matter of handling
rough freight, as the majority of such
cars are loaded by mechanical means
and are dumped quite easily through
their drop-doors. The steel car while
holding a much greater load than the
wooden car, with less dead weight on
the wheels in proportion to load carried,
nevertheless occupies practically the
same track space which its predecessor
required, and the advent and increasing
use of the steel car does not necessitate
longer sidings or more of them to be
introduced on railways.
Another interesting feature about steel
thrust being below the sills and this ten-
dency to break upward is assisted by
the slight camber produced by the ten-
sion of the truss rods.
The steel car, however, is uncertain
in one particular, and this uncertainty
can only be eliminated by the lapse of
A New Metar Called Selium.
A Washington dispatch tells of the dis-
covery in Germany of a new metal called
selium by Edward Mollard, a French-
man, which is reported to the State De-
partment. The discoverer asserts that
selium costs only one-twelfth as much as
aluminum and is lighter and stronger.
It does not rust and is therefore suitable
for shipbuilding, for the manufacture of
pipes and for railroad construction.
It is asserted also that, as it is capable
of taking a fine polish resembling nickel,
it would be desirable for cooking uten-
TD U ZJ ^
FIRST MOGUL EVER BUILT. MADE BY
time. The steel car has not been long
enough "in our midst" to enable owners
and builders to determine what are the
cumulative effects of wear and tear and
of corrosion and rust, but this uncer-
tainty which is bound to be cleared up
sometime in the future does not appear
to have so far handicapped the steel
car in its career of usefulness.
EASTWICK & HARRISON-, FOR RUSSIA
sils. Its hardness is not quite equal to
that of iron, but is greater than that of
lead or zinc. Its power of resistance is
said to be greater than that of iron,
but less than that of steel.
Reports of this kind have to be largely
discounted, but if this one is nearly cor-
rect a very important discovery lias been
made.
402
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
De Glehn Locomotive for Pennsylvania
Railroad.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company
may be depended upon to find out the
merits of any improvements in railroad
machinery, no matter where it is to be
found. The latest news is that they have
ordered a De Glehn locomotive from
France.
Pennsylvania otTiccrs said that there
was no special significance attached to
the order beyond the fact that the Com-
pany wished to try on its tracks a loco-
motive which has the reputation of being
the best made in Europe. The Penn-
sylvania regards the American locomo-
tive as a world beater, but wishes to see
what a foreign exhibit can do over its
rails and roadbed.
The Pennsylvania's first French loco-
motive will reach here early next year.
It will be given a test, and then made
a part of the Pennsylvania's exhibit at
There is no division between the engi-
neer's place and that of the inspection
party. Tlic Hoor, which is practically an
enlarged running board, is about 22 ins.
wide, and extends from the back of the
boiler to the smokebox. Over the steam
chest and cylinder, on each side a wind-
ing stairway with brass hand rails curves
up to the door. The smokestack is
carried up through tlic sloping plat-
form hood, which has the advantage
of giving the engine a long stack as
well as throwing smoke and steam high
in air, even when running shut ofT.
A novel feature which may be seen
in the engraving is the tender, which is
of ordinary construction, entirely hooded
over vviih a sort of turtleback top. The
central portion, however, is made with
hinges and can be opened up when it
is necessary to take coal. The bell is
placed on top of tlie tank near the man-
hole. A lo-inch steel cliannel frame
LAKE SHORK INSPECTION ENGINE.
St. Louis. After the close of the Ex-
position the locomotive will be placed
on the road for regular runs, when it
will be carefully tested to determine the
uniformity of draw bar pull and the
capacity for maintaining immense trac-
tive power at high speed. Tests will
also be made to determine the uniformity
in rail pressure due to the balanced en-
gine, as well as its economy in coal and
water consumption.
carries the tank. There is also the Lake
Shore standard water scoop apparatus,
with pneumatic operating and locking
device for high speed service.
Inspection Engine on the L. S. & n. S.
The Lake Shore and Michigan South-
ern Railway are using a very handy in-
spection engine. We are indebted to Mr.
H. F. Ball, superintendent of motive
power, for the photograph from which
our illustration was made. The machine
consists of an ordinary 8-wheel locomo-
tive w-hich is housed over with a car-
like cab. The cylinders are 17x24 ins.
and the drivers 62 ins. The weight is
about 80,000 lbs., of which 53,000 are
on the drivers. The steam pressure is
150 lbs. The engine belongs to class Q
on the L. S. & M. S.
Defends American Locomotives.
James H. Worman, Consul General
at Munich, refutes statements in the
German press depreciating the American
locomotive in these words:
"The German papers have recently
been circulating the report, and it has
even gained currency in the English
]>res5, that the locomotives which have
been purchased in America by the Ba-
varian state railways within the last three
years had proven unsatisfactory, and
that their durability had been called into
question. In these reports it is also
asserted that experts had declared that
the American locomotives could only
last at best from eight to ten years,
while the locomotives manufactured in
Bavaria had stood service for thirty years,
and that for these reasons, as well as
because of frequent necessary repairs,
the further use of American locomotives
had been abandoned.
"From official sources ihe information
is obtained that these reports are un-
authorized and wholly groundless. The
facts are that the locomotives which had
been bought in order to study the Atuer-
ican system of locomotive building have
proven, because of their simplicity,
tlieir originality of construction, and
their remarkable locomotion for fast
and freight trains, most acceptable,
especially as to durability and efficiency,
and that up to this time nothing has
been discovered to warrant a statement
that, with the same care bestowed upon
them as upon the Bavarian locomotives,
the American locomotives would prove
less durable than those built here. In-
deed, many of the parts of construction
have been found so simple and prac-
ticable that they will be adopted in the
construction of Bavarian locomotives."
A Car With a History.
Lying in the yards of the Lake Erie
& Western Railway at Peru, Ind., dis-
mantled of its trucks, and used as a
paint shop and store house for car in-
spectors, is an old car with a remark-
able history. It is one of the old-fash-
ioned kind, with small, high and narrow
windows, and an upper deck, the sort
of a sleeping car in use forty years ago.
The interior decorations, especially the
painting, is on an elaborate scale with
gaudiness far beyond that generally seen
in those days. Underneath the coats
of paint that have since been put on
can plainly be seen the initials, "B. &
O., No. I." It was the first sleeping
car used in the West and formed a part
of the funeral train of President Lincoln.
The original owners of the car were
the Baltimore & Ohio. From that line
it was purchased by the Pennsylvania
Company, and later it went to the old
Indianapolis, Peru & Chicago, now
merged into the Lake Erie & Western.
It w-as used by the latter road as a pay
car for years. The car is now 42 years
old. It has occupied its present posi-
tion for the last fifteen years, and is
yet in a good state of preservation.
The proper place for this car would
be in the Field Museum, Chicago. Some
corner could surely be found for it.
where people interested in its history
could look upon it.
The bright orange color of the Big
Four trains has long attracted general
attention to them in all the cities they
enter. It has been in use for so many
years that few employees of the com-
pany can recall when it was not the
standard color of the company for Big
Four coaches. But this is going to be
changed. An order has gone forth that
all passenger car equipment must in
future be painted the somber Pullman
color.
Scplcniljcr, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
403
General Correspondence.
PlugKinK Broken Stay Bolts.
It's surprising to note that some of
our railroads in these days of high boiler
pressures will persist in the criminal prac-
tice of plugging up the holes in drilled
stay bolts that have been broken in serv-
ice, rather than make immediate repairs.
This is generally put off until the boiler
is washed out, which may mean several
weeks or a month, according to the water
used. Not only is such work criminal,
but it destroys the object for which the
drilled bolt was adopted. Experience has
taught that it is impossible even with an
expert to locate broken bolts at all times,
and it is due to this that the drilled
bolt has been adopted. At best it is only
a makeshift. The drilling is generally
done by inexperienced labor and a large
percentage of the holes are found away
from the center of the bolt, which natur-
ally weakens it. If it is done by the
piecework system and no ii-spector
around, cases have been found where the
hole did not penetrate the thickness of
the boiler shell. Adopting rules and fur-
nishing special charts for the guidance of
those whose duty it is to watch the
broken bolts, is a waste of time and
money unless the rule is rigidly enforced.
We are not quoting from hearsay, but
are giving facts as we found them. On
one road we counted 36 broken bolts on
a Mogul that had not seen a yea'"'s serv-
ice. Wire nails and file points were
used. The engineer claimed that he re-
ported them and that the boilermaker
had used the file ends in the absence of
wire nails, the nails he had put in him-
self, taking his lesson from the boiler-
maker who made repairs that way. The
M.M. said these engines always came in
at night and got out again before morn-
ing, so that the work could not be done,
as he had no night force to do this
work. With the hollow bolt plugging
is out of the question. If a plug is in-
serted from the outside, to prevent the
annoying escape of steam and water, it
simply drives it into the fire box, which
means death to the fire. We do not be-
lieve that the parties guilty of these prac-
tices do so with any criminal intent, but
it behooves the management to watch
this more closely. Life and property is
at stake, and certainly the crews that
man these engines are due every con-
sideration. This practice of having boiler
insurance companies that make a special-
ty of this sort of risk do this work is a
commendable one.
When the inevitable explosion happens
to boilers whose broken stay bolts have
given due and timely warning that was
disreg.irclL-d, men will holil up their liands
and say that the cause of the accident
was a mystery. Then others interested
in having the owners of the locomotive
escape the penalty of th>; reckless prac-
tice of plugging leaky stay bolts will
look wise and say that the accident was
due to low water, and the engineer who
was in charge having ended his life with
the explosion, no one can for a certainty
defend his professional character, and
so he is blamed for carelessness, and the
company escapes paying heavy damages.
J. A. B.
It would cause me to trespass too much
upon your valuable space to justify by
chapter and verse these generalizations,
but if they excite the interest of some of
your readers, through your courtesy in
giving publicity to this letter, may I also
be permitted to say that I shall be happy
to forward an up-to-date map and sketch
of Peru, to any persons who may furnish
me with their names and addresses.
Eduardo Higcinson,
Consuhdo Del Peru, Consul.
Southampton, England.
Facts About Peru.
Inquiries which reach me, from time to
time, show that many erroneous impress-
ions have existed till recently as to Peru
(at least in Europe), not merely in re-
gard to the political, financial and
economic situation in the Republic, but
also in respect of its physical character-
istics.
Peru is often spoken of as the "Little
Republic." Relatively to the L^nitcd
States of North America that is true ; but
the fact remains that Peru has an area
approximately six times that of the L'nitcd
Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, or
three and a half times that of Germany.
What the Republic needs is more popu-
lation, the density of which is as I to 70
compared with that of Great Britain and
Ireland, and as i to 60 compared with that
of Germany ; more industrial and agricul-
tural activity for which the opportunities
are many and immense, and more capital
employed in developing the natural riches
so plentifully bestowed upon it.
The emigrant who needs to choose his
climate cannot fail to find in Peru a set-
tlement fitting his requirements at any
part of the temperature scale; enterprising
manufacturers may find there facilities for
the employment of their skill unrivalled
in any other State ; the capitalist has mag-
nificent opportunities for the investment
of his wealth, and its profitable employ-
ment.
Peru also offers exceptional opportuni-
ties to scholarly gentlemen, with a little
capital to establish more private colleges
and schools for the study of the English
language.
Politically considered. Peru offers every
security which accompanies stability of
purpose, and a wide franchise ; in mu-
nicipal and taxation matters there is elas-
ticity, and — to suit the needs of young in-
dustries— generosity, while in respect of
personal liberty, there are constitutional
guarantees unsurpassed for their effect-
tiveness and comprehensiveness.
Defects of Cast Iron Wheels and How
to Inspect for Them.
The cast iron wheel, the most common
wheel in use in passenger and freight
cars, as well as engine tenders, is some-
thing that requires close attention by men
of experience.
Cast iron wheels arc often found
cracked in hub, from wheel-fit outward,
and this defect should be carefully
watched for on new cars and on new
wheels, as well as old. for while in fitting,
the wheel may stand the required pres-
sure, it may burst or crack soon after
being put into service. Re-fit or second
hand wheels crack in wheel-fit or hub,
more frequently than do wheels from first
fitting. When wheels crack in hub, the
pressure is relieved to a certain extent
and they are often found loose on axle.
.\s a usual thing, the hub of a wheel will
be found cracked on one side only, but
they are often cracked from wheel-fit out-
ward on opposite sides of wheel, with
cracks extending entirely out to tread,
thus requiring only a slight side pres-
sure on a curve or passing over a frog
to cause them to break. This defect is
more readily discovered by inside inspec-
tion of hub of wheel.
Cracked plate is a defect that is most
commonly detected by outside inspection.
Where the wheel plate is clean, it is eas-
ily detected, when covered with dust and
dirt it is more difficult. Cracks in wheel
plates are more commonly found in out-
side plates only, and are located in or
near the disk of wheel. It is therefore
very necessary to watch closely the out-
side plates of wheels, bearing in mind the
indication in the collection of dust on the
wheel. The inside plates may be cracked
when the outside plates show no indica-
tion, but they are not found as frequent-
ly as the outside plate is.
In the inspection of wheels for this de-
fect, the inspector should watch closely
the wheels on opposite side of car, as he
might detect a defect in a wheel that
404
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, lyoj.
would be overlooked by the other inspec-
tor.
Cracked tread, in nearly all cases, is
caused by wheels being worn through
chill and hollow, and is a very dangerous
defect. As only about two-thirds of the
tread and flange of a wheel can be seen,
while cars are standing, the inspector
should watch and listen closely for worn
wheels while cars are rolling into yards
and in case of wheels being worn hollow,
they should make close inside inspection
to see that tread is not broken through.
In most cases where the tread of a wheel
is cracked, one or more brackets will be
found also, therefore the inspector should
not fail to see all the brackets and closely
inspect for indications of cracked tread.
Wheels are seldom ever found with
he may be sure he has found a dangerous
wheel which should be removed.
There are a great many chill worn
wheels running that are beyond the safe
limit. Wheels are often worn through
chill, yet not worn flat, hollow, nor flange
worn, at the same time they are w'orn en-
tirely through the chill all the way
around and are very easily broken. There
are more or less seams in all cast iron
wheels and although they may not be de-
veloped so as to be detected by inspec-
tion, where the wheel is worn through
chill, they render it more liable to
break. After a wheel has worn through
the chill, it is no more than common
gray cast iron and is absolutely unsafe
for a car wheel. Wheels are often worn
through chill in places for only a few
VICTORIA TERMINUS, BOMBAY, G. I.
cracked brackets, unless the plate or
tread is cracked, but such is sometimes
the case.
A wheel with seams in treads is a most
dangerous defect. It is also one of
the most uncertain; that is, the inspec-
tor is often unable to decide as to the
extent of the defect. It is found in new,
as well as old wheels, but more common-
ly in wheels that have run from one to
three years. It may show on the sur-
face to a very small extent, yet under the
chill it may be of very great extent, and
for this reason it is difficult for the inspec-
tor to pass judgment. Seams in tread are
most dangerous when located in or near
the throat of the flange. In inspection
for this defect, the inspector should
watch all wheels that show any consider-
able extent of flange wear and where it
is seen that the chill in the throat of the
flange is beginning to show fine cracks.
inches, due to soft places in chill, or
wheel having been slid. Such flats or
worn places cause the wheel to pound
and the tread is cracked thereby, thus
making a very dangerous wheel. Wheels
are often found worn hollow and not
worn entirely through chill, and such
wheels are dangerous on account of be-
ing liable to cause the flange or rim to
break.
Worn wheel flanges should have care-
ful attention. When flanges of wheels be-
come worn sharp they are liable to cause
a car to leave the track. Sharp flanges
find defects of the track that are safely
passed by good flanges. The trouble
caused by sharp flanges is greater in
train yards, where track curvature is
usually very short. They are also danger-
ous on account of the liability of "split-
ting switches. All flanges do not wear
evenly; flange on one side of wheel may
be all right, while on the other side it
may be worn to the condemning limit.
Such conditions are caused by one of
three things: First, the axle is liable to be
slightly bent and cause the flange to wear
on one side more than on the other,
or, second, the wheel may be slightly
warped, or third, the wheel may not
have been bored true in fitting. As only
a portion of a wheel flange can be seen
to advantage while cars are still, the man-
ner in which the tread is wearing should
be closely observed. If it is noticed the
wear on tread is near the rim and di-
agonal across tread toward flange, it will
be found that wear on the unseen portion
of flange is great and close inspection
should be made. If axle is bent, caus-
ing this uneven wear, it will be found
that both wheels are wearing in the same
manner, but if only one wheel is wearing
in this manner, it is most likely caused
by wheel being warped or not bored true.
Another way of detecting this defect is
by watching cars as trains are pulling
into yards or while they are being shifted
in yards.
When wheels are found with flange
vertically worn or sharp, but not con-
demning limit, it should be closely ob-
served whether or not the wheel is chill
worn in throat of flange, also whether
or not seams have begun to develop, if
either defect appear the wheel should be
promptly removed.
There are a great many wheels loose on
a.xle and they are often very difficult to
detect. There is more or less danger in
all loose wheels, but more especially
when there is no shoulder to prevent
wheels from working to the center of axle
when they become loose. Where there is
a good shoulder and not cut too far back
on axle, there is not so much danger, for
while the wheels work outward to a cer-
tain extent, as far as journal boxes will
admit they usually work into place when
going around a curve, without causing
car to leave the track. Loose wheels are
known to inspectors as "dry" and "wet"
loose. "Wet" loose wheels are not so dif-
ficult to detect as the "dry" loose are, for
the oil is an indication of loose wheels,
although the wheel may not be loose m
all cases where oil is found on inside of
wheel. Such a case will, however, bear
close inspection. Where oil is on inside
of wheel, there is generally a collection
of dust, and if it is cracked or broken
the wheel is very likely loose. By close-
ly observing this collection, it can be
easily determined whether or not wheel
has been turning on a.xle.
One of the greatest difficulties in the
inspection for loose wheels, is the prac-
tice of many wheel fitters in counter-bor-
ing wheels, in order that axle will enter
the bore of wheel without difficulty. This
practice should be discountenanced as
far as possible, for when counter-bored
the wheel does not touch the axle where
Sfj)! ember, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
40;
visible, and thus destroys all indications
of a loose wheel. The same difficulty
is experienced with wheels where the
"pan-cake" core, as it is called, is used.
This core leaves the inside of' wheels ex-
actly like one that has been counter-
bored, so far as destroying the indica-
tions of loose wheels is concerned.
Chipped rims of wheels are usually
caused by one of two things; hollow rim
or tread worn hollow. This is one of
the easiest defects to find as it is the
outside of wheel and is at once manifest.
This defect renders a wheel unsafe when
it extends beyond the limit as laid down
in M. C. B. rules.
Shelled out spots in wheels as a
defect is becoming more frequent, on ac-
count of modern high break power, and
when once started, the wheel soon
reaches the point beyond safety. When a
wheel starts to shell out, the constant
poimding soon increases the size ot the
spot.
Where shelled out places are near the
a train as it is pulling into the yard, the
chances are slid flat wheels will be over
looked, as in a great many cases the flat
places stand on rail or behind brake
shoes, and unless heard pounding while
rolling into yards, they are not likely to
be seen. W. A. Mitchell.
Nashville, Tciin.
Effect of Leng^thening the Reach Rod.
I have a question I would like to have
answered. I am a macliinist on a rail-
road at Houston.
We have a class of 8-wheel pnssenger
engines liere which have been having
trouble in making time. The engineers
said they just would not make it, and
came in late.
The M.M. came in the shop one day
and gave orders to the foreman to have
the reach rod of one of them lengthened
H inch; understand the rod was the ex-
act length it should have been. The mo-
tion was not changed except that the
European Notes.
NEW ATLANTIC TYPE EXI'RF.SS LOCOMO-
TIVE.S, NORTH EASTERN RAILWAV.
Following the practice of other loco-
motive engineers in adopting locomotives
of the "Atlantic" type for heavy pas-
senger trafific Mr. Wilson Worsdell has
recently constructed at the North East-
ern Railway Gateshead Works several,
claimed to be the most powerful and
largest in England. The accompany-
ing diagram shows clearly the huge pro-
portions of these locomotives which are
built to the limit of the loading gauge
and have 82 in. drivers and 20x28 in.
cylinders. The boiler barrel has a lengtli
of 190.3 ins. The external diameter
being 66 ins. and the height of center
line from rail 107 ins. The fire box is
long for British practice, i. e., 108 ins.,
and provides a grate area of 27 sq. ft.;
the working pressure is 200 lbs. per
sq. in. A large heating surface is ob-
tained from the tubes, i. e.. 2,275.8 sq.
a
'.^n-.'^ ■, ■ i ^ *nJt^n
GLASGOW AND SOUTH-WESTERN ^-C-0.
flange of wheel, the wheel at once be-
comes a dangerous one and should be re-
moved. This delect should be watched
very closely, especially on wheels in pas-
senger trains, as the size of the sore spot
increases much more rapidly on wheels
in passenger service than in freight, on
account of the faster speed and greater
number of applications of the brake be-
ing made. A very small shelled out place
in a passenger wheel will develop into a
large one, in making only a few hundred
miles.
In the inspection of wheels for slid
flats, the inspector should not fail to
closely watch trains as they are pulling
into yards and the cars while being
switched. There is rarely ever any in-
dications of a slid flat on a wheel, except
where it will be noticed the wheels are
slightly spotted from sliding, and this
it not a sure indication of a slid flat.
In a great many cases a wheel will have
quite a number of small flats, but none
sufficiently large to condemn. If the in-
spectors do not get a chance to watch
reach rod was lengthened. The engineer
came in next trip on tmie and said the
engine -would outrun itself and every one
should be worked on and changed.
Can you give any reason why the reach
rod should make the difference, especi-
ally if it was right to start with?
Machinist.
Lengthening the reach rod had the
same effect as advancing the reverse lever
a little. The engine would work strong-
er because the point ot cut off was de-
layed.— Ed.
A contract has been awarded by the
Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company
for additional passenger equipment, in-
volving an expenditure of about $600,-
000. With this new rolling stock the
company will be equipped to handle the
World's Fair business to and from St.
Louis next year. The order covers
forty passenger cars and forty baggage
and postal cars. Deliveries will begin
in December, and be finished by April
1, 1904.
ft. which being augmented by 180 sq.
ft. from the fire box brings the total up
to 2,455.8 sq. ft. The engine weighs,
in working order, 161,280 lbs., of which
87,360 lbs. are on the coupled drivers.
The tender is of the standard pattern,
carries 11,200 lbs. of coal and 4,125 gal-
lons of water, and weighs, in working
order. 97.440 lbs. These locomotives are
being built for working the East Coast
Scotch traffic and their performances
will, no doubt, be watched with interest,
especially when comparison is drawn
with the working of the six coupled
bogie locomotives of the 2001 and 211 1
classes.
NEW SCOTCH LOCOMOTIVES.
In the July issue of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering one of the
new Caledonian fliers was illustrated and
described and in the present number is
shown the new six-coupled bogie pas-
senger locomotives for the Glasgow &
South Western Railway. These engines
have been built for working the Scotch
406
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
-traffic in connection with the Midland
Railway Ironi Londmi and most of the
provincial towns, and .previous to their
introduction the trains have been worked
by two ordinary bogie locomotives hav-
ing 81 in. coupled drivers and 18^x26
in. cylinders. The new type have six
coupled wheels 78 in. diameter, outside
cylinders 20x26 in. balanced valves placed
on top worked by a rocking shaft, a
large boiler and a Belpaire fire bo.x. The
heating surface obtained is 1,852 sq. ft.
and the grate area is 24.5 sq. ft. The
engine weighs 150,080 lbs. in working
order and with the tender, which is of
weight. -^ new design of cab with side
windows has also been provided. The
chief dimensions are: Cylinders, 19x26
ins.: coupled drivers, 90 ins., placed with
their centres 114 ins. apart; total heating
surface, 1,577 sq. ft.; grate area, 22.5
sq. ft.; total weight, including tender, in
working order, 206.080 lbs. The tender ,
has a capacity for 3,525 gallons of water
and 15,680 lbs. of coal. The increased
weight of both the East Coast trains
and also the Midland. Edinboro' and
North trains necessitated more powerful
engines, consequently Mr. Holmes de-
signed the 317 class.
subject of a patent by .Mr. Drunimond,
is the balanced crank axle, the cranks
being built up and heavy projections
forged with and directly opposite the
webs. By this means the strains on
the crank axle are, it is claimed, better
counteracted than when the balance
weights are placed in the wheels.
The distance from London (Waterloo)
to E.xeter is 171 miles, and with one
stop for locomotive purposes at Salis-
bury the trains are timed to cover the
distance in 3^ hours.
A long distance record run on the
L. & N. W. Ry. was made on June 19.
INTERLOCKING PLANT. NEWCASTLE CENTRAL STATION.
a new design running on four-wheeled
bogies and carrying 4,100 gallons of
water, the total weight is 262,080 lbs.
Ten of these fine locomotives have been
delivered by the North British Locomo-
tive Company from their Atlas works,
and are numbered 381-390, inclusive.
Several novel features have been intro-
duced and the steam reversing gear and
steam sanding apparatus have been
fitted.
The North British Railway Company
have built several of their new passenger
locomotives at the Cowlairs works, and
they are an enlargement of their pre-
vious type, "729" class, the most im-
portant augmentations being in the size
of cylinder's, boiler and fire box, and total
NEW MIXED TRAFFIC LOCOMOTIVE, LON-
DON A.MD SOCTH WESTERN RAILWAY.
For working the new accelerated ex-
press trains from London to the west
of England, Mr. Dugald Drummond has
built at the Nine Elms Works a new-
class of mixed traffic locomotive hav-
ing 72 in. coupled drivers, a leading
bogie and a large boiler. As will be
seen by the accompanying illustration
the general features of the designer's
standard practice have been adhered to,
including the cross water tubes in the
fire box. The latest pattern of eight-
wheeled tender running on bogies has
been built with the engine. One feature
in those locomotives and which is the
with a special train conveying delegates
of the International Telegraph Confer-
ence from London to Glasgow. The
journey from Euston to Carlisle was
accomplished without stopping, the dis-
tance being 299 miles. The tram was
composed of nine six-wheeled bogie din-
ing saloons and two four-wheeled bogie
brake vans, representing a weight of
about 420 tons, and was drawn by two
of the latest four-cylinder compound
passenger locomotives. The time taken
over this portion of the journey was
three minutes under six hours. The train
continued its journey over the Caledo-
nian Railway to Glasgow, and on June
22 returned from Edinboro', the distance
from Carlisle to Euston being again
Scptc-mbci'. 190,3.
RAILWAY AXD I.OCOMOII \ I'. KXCilNKKKING
407
accoiiiplislu-d, without a stop, in six
hours.
CALEDONIAN WAC.ON STOCK.
The Caledonian Railway Company is
adding largely to its stock of bogie
wagons, and the illustration shows one
of several recently supplied by the Leeds
Forge Company, having a capacity of
30 tons. In comparison an old existing
four-wheeled mineral wagon is shown
of which the company possess a large
man in tlic motive iiovvcr department of
the (i. G. & W. Ry. invented a nic-
clianic.d flagman. This same sort of
tiling lias been invented before now. and
has proved to be a perfectly feasible pro-
ject as far as mechanical construction and
operation are concerned. The young
man, however, invented it all over again,
and devised a machine which would run
back swiftly over the road, carrying a
red flfig liy day and a red lamp by night.
I.ONDUN AND SOUTH WESTHRN 4-4-0.
number. The dummy liufifer so prev-
alent on British wagon rolling stock has
at last been condemned, and its entire
wilhdrw'al is to be effected liy January
I, 1910.
PRUSSIAN TANK ENGINE.
The Prussian State Railways have re-
cently received from Messrs. Henschel
& Sohn, of CasscI, a heavy multi-cou-
pled tank locomotive built on the
Hagans articulated system for working
the difficult portion of their road on the
Stettin-Jasenitz section, which has many
sharp curves and steep gradients. The
cylinders are 20^x24^4 ins., driving
wdieels 3 ft. 11^ ins., total heating sur-
face 1,488.03 sq. ft., total weight, in
working order, "'.< tons.
It was to be operated by compressed air
stored in a reservoir which it carried,
and the supply of air could be drawn
from the brake line of a stalled train by
simply coupling the air hose at the end
of the train line with a similar hose at-
tached to the reservoir. It is obvious
The young man made a model and it
worked fairly well, and then he asked
Mr. Guilderlhike to look at it and give
his opinion as to its merits. Eli took
a look at it very carefully with his prac-
tised and critical eye, and said, "it's all
right, but it docs not go far enough."
The young man said that it would go
back several miles. Then Eli explained
slowly and ponderously that what he had
intended to convey was that the inven-
tion was ciudc, that it needed improv-
ing, that the whole scope of the thing
was limited, that the young man had not
"overcome obstacles" which were certain
to arise— had not "dealt with known con-
ditions," and in fact had only seen the
idea through the glimmering and misty
moonlight of inexperience, and had failed
to dash into the scorching sunlight of
day and garner the ripe and rich harvest
with a bold and skilful hand. The young
man felt awfully sorry that he had in-
vented anything, but asked as a favor if
the great inventor would design to indi-
cate briefly how even a few of its many
shortcomings might be, in any way. recti-
fied.
Eli told him offhand that the machine
ought to have a small mail-pouch at-
tachment in which a written statement,
signed by conductor and engineer, might
be placed. Said statement to contain a
full description of the hot bo.x or the
burst hose, or whatever it was that had
stalled them, for the information of the
following crew, and Eli suggested a sea*
on the machine, in case they might at the
last moment want to send a man back
The Story of a ilechanical Flagman.
Not long ago, our old friend, Mr. EIi
Guildcrfluke. was appointed general mas-
ter mechanic of the Great Gas & Wool
gathering Railway, with headquarters at
Flapdoodle. As. He was thoroughly
pleased with the appointment, because
he had been "rusting." as he expressed
it, for a long time. His friends had urged
him to take the appointment and had
said confidentially to him, "Guilderfluke,
old man, it's not only your ability to run
the whole road which counts for so
much, as it is your marvelous powers for
revolutionizing everything in sight,
which is going to score — you can leave
them all at the post easily."
A few days after Eli had "taken hold"
and had got "things humming," a young
PRUSSIAN .ARTICULATED T.-VNK ENGINE.
that the stalled train could not possibly
start while this charging-up process was
in progress, because the brakes wouid
be hard on, so any attempt on the part
of the train to play the "flagman"
false would be "nipped in the bud."
The machine, not being human, when
started out, would not be consumed with
a feverish desire to return to its train,
so it was presumed that it would go back
far enough to warn a following train.
a little way to oil it and see that every-
thing was working all right. The j'oung
man thanked Eli profusely, but the great
man said he was always glad to help
bright young men along, and that he
would make a sketch of the invention at
home that evening, giving the whole
thing wider scope and enlarged powers.
Next day. when the two "got to-
gether." Eli explained his sketch to the
voung man. The machine had certainlv
4oS
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September. 1903.
been '■modified," but the young man was
able to recognize some of the salient fea-
tures of his invention. There were the
wheels to be sure, but they were larger
and better — more adapted to the work
they had to perform, you know. There
was the compressed air reservoir — re-de-
signed to stand "modern pressures," you
see. There were the lamp holder and
flag socket — yes. but more firmly secured
to a new and much stronger frame, you
understand. There was the seat for the
attendant, suggested last evening — but
of improved design, automatically col-
lapsible, after three minutes' use, to pre-
vent the attendant riding back too far,
and subsequently claiming mileage.
Guilderfluke explained further that he
would equip this machine with suitable
inch olT the rail, while the collapsible
seat would Hap like anything. He
showed how the whole mechanism, by- a
beautiful and harmoniously worked out
plan, would, under the circumstances, de-
vote its energies to the work of register-
ing an emphatic "kick," which few would
have the hardihood to resist.
If, however, this "warninj^" should be
disregarded, and the whole thing thrown
over the fence. Guilderfluke said he had
arranged that the good work should still
go on. A pair of powerful electric
"magnelicons," as he called them, oper-
ated by a storage battery placed below
the frame, would infallibly bring it back
to the track, at the same time reversing
its motion, so that it might now pursue
the train which had despitcfully used it.
chine have a big grab hook arranged to
rip off the air hose from the pilot of the
"approaching" engine if she tossed the
"flagman," and so stall her right there,
and he also said, sarcastically, that he
would provide a recording phonograph
to take in what the men on the engine
said when they found out what they were
up against. Noyes thought that would
do away with the "magneticons," and the
whole of the back-up paraphernalia and
so save expense, but Guilderfluke showed
at once how crude that idea was.
"By removing the storage battery, the
electric magneticons and the combat-trig-
ger," he said, " you would greatly reduce
the weight of the machine, and so bring
her tractive eflfort away out of line with
her adhesive weight, so that she would
SPECIAL TRAIN FOR DELEGATES, INTERNATIONAL TELEGRAPH CONFERENCE, L. & N. W. RY.
apparatus in the shape of buffers and
springs, a three-way cock and a wide-
open-let-go attachment, so that if the
engineer of an approaching train failed
to observe the mechanical flagman and
should strike it and knock it oflf the
track, then the machine would automati-
cally protest against that sort of un-
friendly treatment by every resource
known to the science of mechanics.
An air whistle had been provided in
the sketch, and this whistle would sound
continuously the moment the machine
was lifted ofT the track by the pilot of the
on-rushing and impudent engine. The
sky-ward motion of the "flagman" would
also appropriately set oflf a battery of
rockets and explode a string of tor-
pedoes, a huge alarm-clock bell, with
double hammer, would "burr" unceas-
ingly the moment the forward wheel of
the "flagman" was raised even half an
As soon as it had overtaken the fugitive
train — as it certainly must, by reason of
its great speed in the back-up direction,
due to the electric magneticons work-
ing in unison with what was left of the
compressed air, then the real serious
work of the "flagman" would begin. A
trigger of peculiar shape on the back of
the "flagman" would engage in mortal
combat with the rear angle-valve handle
on the train and eventually turn it, thus
opening the train line, and so bring the
train to a stop. A train so "warned"
would likely be glad to surrender rather
than keep up the unequal struggle.
At this stage of the proceedings Eli
sent for his master mechanic and gen-
eral foreman and asked them what they
thought of it. The M. M. didn't say
much — he just thought, but Rabid
Noyes, the foreman, who is a most un-
pleasant fellow, wanted to let the ma-
be 'slippery,' non-efiicient and practically
inoperative, don't you know; and further,
the phonograph would only record the
mingled sound of the whistle, the rock-
ets, the detonators, the alarm-clock bell,
and the flapping of the seat, and such a
record would be quite valueless." Rabid
Noyes retired feeling miserable after
being shown up, as he deserved to.
Eli Guilderfluke, kind old fellow, is
preparing patent claims for the young
man, and is not going to take any undue
credit to himself in the matter — he
doesn't need to. He made his reputation
years ago when he got out the perfection
locomotive, which was, as all remember,
published in Locomotive Engineering
in December, 1897.
Be as rich as you honestly can. It's
your duty. If not for yourself, for
others. — Little Dorrit.
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
409
New S. O. Shops at Los Angeles.
In regard to the new shops here lack
III material is still the drawback, al-
though things are coming our way slow-
ly, but surely. There have been a tew
changes made in the details for machine
sliop, and Mr. Campbell says he will
endeavor to send you prints as soon as
motive engineers who believe it to be
true. Now why is this not a good sub-
ject for investigation? There is going
to be a great testing plant installed by
the Pennsylvania Railroad Company at
the St. Louis Exnosition next year, and
it seems to me that they would oe work-
ing in the interests ol all railroad com-
s Jt^nrf t4J^:QJ^i^ixl^
i>i
j. — 6'6' -•!> — t'u"— <+ tV — »j« «V »j" — «•'«=— »t«-»-'iv^^ — oV - >j^- -oT >,
KaUwaii f t<ieumulltv Enffinttrinff
NORTH EASTHRN J-4-2 ENGINE.
jector disorders, was sent to remedy the
defect and make the injector work. He
took the injector down, examined it, and
lound nothing the matter. By the teach-
ing of past experience he then decided
that the trouble was in the feed-pipes,
so he examined the strainer and tender
valve and found nothing there to ob-
struct the flow of water. Then he was
forced to tlie conclusion tliat the check
valve was stuck down, so the engine was
cooled down and the check valve found
in working condition. Then it looked to
be a case out of the ordinary line of dis-
orders. What was the matter?
Woo LEV West.
Chicago.
they are ready. Since writing you last,
it has been decided to put in quite a
number of additional machine tools in
machine shop, necessitating the building
of more concrete foundations. The loca-
tion of same has not as yet been decided.
Quite a number of tools have been set
on their foundations and are now being
cleaned and set up. The floor in ma-
chine shop is laid except for a space
around the 42 and 44 in. engine lathes
.ind 72 in. planer, where jib cranes witli
air hoists, capable of lifting from 4 to
6 tons, are to be put in. Concrete
foundations for tools in blacksmith and
boiler shop are now in, and boiler shop
is to have a 30-ton traveling crane, the
material for which has not yet arrived,
nor the material for the lo-ton crane
over driving wheel machines in machine
shop. The 70 ft. transfc- table is on
the ground, but has not been assembled.
The turntable in round house is to be
lengthened out to 70 ft. instead of 65
ft., as I had in my last letter. Roof is
now on the coach repair shop, and two
65,000 gallons steel water tanks have
been erected cast of round nouse, in
which is now being laid creosoted blocks
run with tar for a floor. Besides the
new shops here, the company is build-
ing a new steel double track bridge over
the river above Elysian Park, and also
practically rebuilding the single track
bridge at the shops with a double track
one. This is all I can let you know
about just now, but will keep you posted
from time to time, and hope you will
get this in time for the September issue.
O. H. V.\N Rensselaer.
A. M. E.
panics if they would thoroughly test the
valve of long and short valve travel,
M. E.
Pittsburgh, Pa.
An Injector Puzzle.
.\ man learning to run a locomotive
ought to practice thinking out the solu-
Keying Eccentrics Before Valves
Were Set.
Forty years ago it was quite a ^omnion
custom in some locomotive shops to key
the eccentrics to the shaft before the
wheels were put under the locomotive.
The position of the eccentric bears a
fixed relation to the position of the crank
pin, and it is much easier to slot the
shaft before the wheels were under, than
later. To what extent is it now
practiced? Some locomotives
have eccentrics forged on the
shaft. To turn them up false
centers were made in the shaft.
or in heads secured to the shaft.
TAoricoNic.
O J-WHEEI, .MINERAL WAGON.
tion of any disorders about the engine
that are likely to happen and I send you
a puzzle for firemen and young engi-
The edition of filackall's Air
Brake Catechism, which we have
been selling at $1.50 per copy,
has been exhausted, and we are
therefore not in a position to
fill the many orders which have
come in for it. A new, re-
vised and enlarged edition of
this valuable book will be out tow^ard
the end of September, ft will contain
310 pages. 100 illustrations and 11 fold-
Long and Short Valve Travel.
I am under the impression that you
have said at dift'erent times that tne rapid
opening of the exhaust in locomotives
with long valve travel tears the fire
CALEDONIAN NEW .■Jll-TON BOGIE W.\GON.
neers to guess about. I enclose the solu- ing plates, including three printed in
tion on another sheet. colors. This is the eighteenth edition.
, , A" engmeer came in and reported that and the price will be $2.00 per copv
more than exhaust rteam escaping more his right hand injector would not work .
..-radually as happeiis when the valve All the explanation given was that it It is in the finishing touches alone that
rave ,s short. That can only be a broke every time he tried to work it. great experience and long studv tell.-
hypothesis. but I know several loco- A machinist, who is an expert on in- Mr. Pecksniff.
410
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903
LS^'i)Wi7^Egneeriii$
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, Ne-w York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, " I,ocengr," N. Y.
Olaseow, " I^ocanto."
Bnslness Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
PRED M. NELLIS, Vice President.
JAMBS R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NEI-I/IS, 1
GEO. S. HODGINS, > Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— J. A. BAKER,
iao4 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111,
British Representative:
THE I,OCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd. loaa Charing Cross Rd., W.
C, London.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
$2.00 per year, $1.00 Jor six montlis, postage paid
to the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of the -world, Ss-SO, or ten shillings.
Single copies, 20 cents. Remit by Express Money
Order, Draft. Post Office O.-der or Registered
Letter.
Mailing address can be chari^ed aso^ten as neces-
sary— always gife old and new address, and i/ you
subscribed in a club, state who got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you properly .
Entered at Post Office, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., 1903.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
No Need to Investigate Locomotive
Front Ends.
The committee of the American RaiUvny
Master Mechanics' Association, which has
been investigating the subject of loco-
motive front ends, in connection with the
American Engineer and Railroad Journaf,
has come to the end of its labors at pres-
ent for want of funds. In a brief report
submitted to last convention the committee
intimated that at least $4,000 is necessary
to go on with the first year's work. As
there are no funds in the Association's
treasury available for use in making tests
the money, of course, will not be forth-
coming.
We do not think that there is any
pressing need for heavy expense being in-
curred to pursue this investigation, for
the subject of locomotive draft appliances
has received more attention from the As-
sociation than any other question, and
very thorough tests have been made by
various committees whose labors furnish
all the information that can reasonablyNbe
looked for and much more than what has
been made use of. Tests of draft appli-
ances made on a stationary plant have
positive limitations that make them little
better than suggestions to guide people
wrestling with road conditions ; and it is
doubtful if experiments made on the Pur-
ihie testing plant will ailil anything to
the information elicited by the extraordi-
narily exhaustive tests made on the Mil-
waukee', Lake Shore & Western testing
lilaiit, designed by Mr. Robert Quayle,
and conducted under his directions in
1894, and also the even more comprehen-
sive tests made on the Chicago & North-
western testing plant in 1896, conducted
under Mr. Quayle's supervision and re-
porled by a committee of which Mr. W.
S. Morris was chairman. It would be hard
to conceive any detail concerning the ac-
tion of locomotive draft appliances that
these committees failed to investigate, or
of the influence of any combinations for
producing draft and relieving back cylin-
der pressure that were not tested. Those
who want more light on the subject of
draft appliances are mostly people who
have never found out what the reports re-
ports referred to demonstrated.
At the second convention of the Ameri-
can Railway Master Mechanics' Associa-
tion, held in Pittsburgh in 1869, a report
on smoke stacks was presented by a com-
mittee of which Mr. Reuben Wells was
chairman, and it discussed all details of
what are now known as "draft applian-
ces." Since that time there have been re-
ports or discussions of draft appliances in
some form at every convention held by the
Association. It has been an easy resort
to investigate smoke stacks, exhaust noz-
zles, grate openings, brick arches, or ex-
tension fronts when live subjects were
lacking; and the introduction of any one
of these subjects seldom failed to excite
discussion in which nearly every member
was ready to join. There has been more
interchange of experience elicited by these
subjects than by all others combined, and
they have always been popular because
many people were given the opportunity
to talk on a subject concerning which they
had decided opinions.
We have frequently heard the complaint
made that many members of the railway
mechanical associations discuss reports at
conventions and seemingly indorse the
recommendations of committees, then go
home and pay no more attention to what
has been agreed upon as better practice
than that which they are following. Men
listen to committees' reports as they listen
to sermons. They have a vague idea that
they would like to follow the precepts in-
culcated, but it is found easier to for-
get than it is to practice what may entail
some self-denial or exertion.
This line of reflection readily in-
trudes itself in connection with the small
influence exerted on locomotive practice
by the two splendid reports on exhaust
pipes and steam passages. The conclu-
sions arrived at by the committee read :
"The work pn the Chicago & North-
v\-estern testing plant relates principally to
the proper design of an exhaust pipe and
nozzles for maximum efficiency, and the
results obtained arc believed to :onfirm
the following conclusions:
"First. — The exhaust pipe should be as
short as possible with a proper arrange-
ment of diaphragm and netting, provid-
ing this does not make it less than ig
inches high, which is the lowest limit
tested.
"Second. — The bridge in this pipe
should not be less than rj inches high.
"Third. — The area of each of the open-
ings of the pipe at the most contracted
part should not be less than the area ot
the nozzle.
"Fourth. — When it is necessary to re-
duce the area of the exhaust opening, it
should be done at the nozzle and not at
the choke.
"Fifth. — The nozzle should be raised
when necessary by lengthening the portion
of the pipe above the top of the bridge,
rather than that below.
"Sixth. — The form of exhaust tip
shown as X in these tests gives better
results than either forms Y or Z. (The
tip X has a cylindrical opening; Y is tap-
ered toward the opening, and Z has an in-
side flange at the opening.)
"Seventh. — The distance from the
choke of the stack to the nozzle for 14-
inch choke, stack 52 inches long should
not exceed 50 inches, nor be less than 40
inches for maximum efficiency.
"Eighth. — The distance from the top of
the smoke arch to the nozzle with 14-
inch straight stack 52 inches long, should
not be greater than 38 inches, nor less than
23 inches.
"Ninth. — The distance from the top of
the smoke arch to the e.xhaust nozzle with
a 16-inch straight stack 52 inches long,
should not be greater than 38 inches nor
less than 28 inches.
"Tenth. — The efficiency of the steam jet
is reduced by spreading it by means of
cross bars in the nozzle.
"Eleventh.: — Cross bars not wider than
% inch placed in the nozzle or above it
nearer than I inch increase the back pres-
sure ; wider cross bars increase the back
pressure when farther removed in propor-
tion to their width.
"Twelfth. — A petticoat pipe with the
single nozzle, when properly arranged,
increases the efficiency of the jet.
"Thirteenth. — Double nozzles, with 14-
inch choke stack and 16-inch straight
stack, 52 inches long, are not as efficient
as single nozzles, the difference being
very slight.
"Fourteenth. — Double nozzles should be
located with reference to the stack the
same as single nozzles.
"Fifteenth. — The maximum height of
stack, measured from the e.xhaust nozzle,
if the diameter of the choke is properly
chosen, need not exceed five times this
diameter. For cylindrical stacks the ratio
of diameter to height is the same.
"Sixteenth. — The vacuum decreases as
the stack is shortened, and more rapidly
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
411
with the cylindrical than willi the conical
stacks.
"Seventeenth. — The decrease in vacuum
due to shortening the stack vi-ithin cer-
tain limits can be nearly overcome by
lowering the nozzles. The amount
which the nozzle should be lowered with
cylindrical stacks is almost equal to the
amount the stack is shortened."
These conclusions embrace the discover-
ies made by the most exhaustive series
of shop tests that had ever been conduct-
ed on locomotives, and they answer ques-
tions that locomotive men are constantly
asking without knowing where to look
for the answers. The committee recom-
mended proportions for a front end which
they had found to produce the best re-
sults in the tests made and it ought to
have been adopted as a standard of the
Association; but it was not, and the mem-
bers have never reaped the benefits of the
valuable work done. Instead of appoint-
ing new committees to make other inves-
tigations of locomotive front ends, one
ought to be appointed to let the members
know what has already been found out.
It is doubtful if ten per cent, of the mem-
bers of the Railway Master Mechanics'
Association remember that exhaustive
tests of front ends were carried out in
1896, and we feel sure that less than one
per cent, of the locomotives on this con-
tinent have been equipped with the front
end recommended.
The "Normal Danger" and the " Nor=
mal Clear" Automatic Block
Signal Systems.
There are in general two systems of
automatic block signals used in this coun-
try. One is called the "Normal Danger"
system and the other is called the "Nor-
mal Clear" system. These expressions
are intended to indicate the position of
every automatic block signal on the road
at the time when they are not influenced
by the presence of a train in the vicinity.
With the first mentioned, or normal
danger system, every block signal on
the line would stand at the danger posi-
tion if all trains were off the main line.
When a train is running on the main
line, the signal immediately in front of
it would remain at danger until the train
reached some point a definite distance
from the signal, say 2,000 feet, then if
the apparatus was in working order, the
signal would "clear" and permit the
train to proceed, and after it had passed,
the signal would again assume the dan-
ger position, and a following tram could
not "clear" this signal until the first train
had passed out of the block ahead.
When the home and distant signals
are on the same post, the following takes
place, and to make a beginning some-
where in a continuous series of actions,
we may put it this way: As train No. I
approaches signal A, both the home
and distant signals, we will assume, are
standing "clear," so that the train may
go on and demonstrate the working of
the system. The entrance of the train
into block A produces three effects.
First, it causes the home signal at C to
"clear" if no train is in that block. The
"clearing" of home at C then acts upon
the distant signal at B and causes it to
"clear" also, and it sets the signals be-
hind it at danger. The home signal at B,
as can now be seen, had been "cleared"
when the train was in the block preced-
ing A. When the train gets to B both
these signals will be found at "clear,"
which indicates that block B is free of
trains and also that block C is clear.
With this system the home signal in-
dicates, when it "clears," that the block
it guards is clear, and the distant indi-
cates that the block beyond is also clear.
By this means the train "feeling its
way" along, as it were, is informed
whether either of the two blocks ahead
are occupied. As the train passes into
each block both signals behind it at
once go to "danger" and the home at B
cannot be made to "clear" again until
the train is in block C. and the distant
at B cannot be "cleared" until the train
has entered block D. The normal danger
system meets a question asked by an on-
coming train, with a definite reply. The
signals stand at danger until "asked" by
the train through the electric connection,
if it may be permitted to proceed. The
answer is definite in each case, and con-
cerns two blocks ahead.
The normal clear system, as its name
implies, lias all its signals at "clear" when
there is nothing on the road. The ap-
proach of train No. i to block A does
not alter the signals which are stand-
ing at "clear" and which permit the train
to rush on. As soon as the train enters
block A, both signals fly to "danger"
and protect the train from the rear. The
train having passed, the home signal on
post A will only "clear" when the train
has passed out of block A and the distant
signal on the same post remains at "cau-
tion" until the train is out of block B
and is in block C. Thus these signals
reveal to following train No. 2 the con-
dition of the road for two blocks ahead
and when the semaphores are in the
"clear" position they guarantee the line
for that distance to an oncoming train.
If the normal clear signals should get
out of order they at once assume the
d.inger position, and so though they may
cause delay, they act on the side of
safety. With the normal danger system
a signal out of order would be indicated
by the inability of an on-coming train
to "clear" it when the block ahead was
actually unobstructed. This also might
occasion delay, but the claims of safety
would have been recognized.
Both these systems, when in good
working order, are equally truthful in
the indications they give concerning the
presence or absence of a train in the
blocks they stand for. In fact the two
systems may be likened to a man pass-
ing through a long suite of rooms con-
nected by doors. With the normal dan-
ger system all the doors would be slui;.
but each would fly open as he approached
it, if he was entitled to entrance to the
room ahead, and would close as he
passed in. The normal clear system
would have all the doors open, but
would close any one against him, in due
time, if the room he desired to enter was
occupied at the time, and a door would
close behind him every time and stay
closed until he was in the room ahead.
The normal danger, says to an on-
coming train, "Ask me at every block
and I will answer; I will tell you when
and how you may proceed." The nor-
mal clear, says, "Go steadily on, witli
an eye for my warning, but stop when I
bid you stay."
Loading Locomotives to Their Full
Capacity.
The Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific
operating department seem to be de-
termined that their freight locomotives
shall pull all the cars within their ca-
pacity. They have introduced a system
of daily reports which shows just what
percentage of the total power of the
locomotive is being used each trip. The
reports are based on a table compiled
from the dynamometer car, which de-
termines the actual tonnage which an
engine can handle on certain grades.
The table was compiled by means of
test trains. The dynamometer car is
coupled direct to the engine and ^the
remainder of the train to it. The draw-
bar is attached to a graduated spring
scale. The engine is loaded with the
full tonnage, and at every grade a record
kept of it which is used as the basis of
the table. Each different class of engine
is tested, so that the table is complete.
The tonnage capacity of the engines
varies at different grades, so that a sepa-
rate list is kept of the capacity between
various stations.
The conductors of all trains now have
to furnish the chief dispatchers a list
of the tonnage of their train at the
various points on the system. From
this the chief dispatcher figures the exact
percentage the engine is doing of the
work it is capable of doing. Usually
this averages about 90 per cent., and
this is considered good. If the percent-
age falls below 90 per cent, then the
engineer, conductor or dispatcher is
called on the carpet and asked to ex-
plain, and usually receives instructions
not to let it occur again.
The reports are made by the con-
ductors at the end of each trip, and the
dispatchers forward a daily report to
the main offices. In some instances the
percentage may run over the 100 per
412
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE . ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
cent, mark, as on through trains the
load is based upon the tonnage the en-
gine is able to haul on the heaviest
grade on the division.
By means of these reports the com-
pany is able 10 compute the exact cost
of handling freight and to keep close
tab on useless expense in running en-
gines over the road without half a load.
There are two well known systems of
train operating, the merits of which
have been exhaustively discussed in
these columns. One system is to load
an engine with a train that she can pull
comfortably and make good running
time, say an average of eighteen miles
an hour, including stops. The other
plan and that adopted by the Rock
Island people is to load the engine with
all the cars she can haul over grades
making an average speed below ten
miles an hour. Superficial inspection
v.ould lead people to believe that the
heavily loaded engine is doing the work
at the smallest possible expense, but
she is not doing anything of the kind.
The moderately loaded engine is doing
the better work for the company, makes
operating of trains more convenient and
is much more comfortable to trainmen
than the slow and heavy movement. It
also serves to prevent the loss of busi-
ness due to shortage of cars.
The Fellow Servant Iniquity.
We have repeatedly commented upon
the working of the Common Law of
England as applied in this country which
prevents railroad companies and other
employers from being held responsible
for damages for accidents due to "the
negligence of fellow servants." That law-
is the worst relic of barbarism that we
know of being applied to modern in-
dustrial conditions; for it came into force
by degrees when every servant was
known intimately by his fellow servants,
who could refuse to work with any one
who was a reckless, careless or dangerous
character. Modern conditions of em-
ployment keep hundreds of persons class-
ed by law as fellow servants who have
no acquaintance whatever with the char-
acter and habits of each other. Equity
and justice demand that laws should be
enacted to take the place of the Medieval
Common Law and that progressive ac-
tion has been taken in many States, but
the State of New York still adheres to
the barbaric law, although many attempts
have been made to pass an equitable
law to take its place. Of course, the old
law is kept in force because large cor-
porations prefer to pay as little com-
pensation as possible for injuries or
death inflicted upon employees by the
reckless or careless acts of fellow em-
ployees.
So far as the railroad side of this mat-
ter is concerned, there is a curious con-
dition of affairs in New York State. The
laws enacted in most States to abolish
the comrnon law power to deal with ac-
cidents to fellow servants, have been pro-
moted by railroad labor organizations
which have taken a prominent part in
working for a change. In New York
State the legislative board of the
Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers
have done all in their power to prevent
any change from being made. Why they
should do this we can only conjecture.
One thing is certain — the ordinary mem-
bers of the Brotherhood of Locomotive
Engineers ought to institute a very
searching inquiry into the cause of their
interests being so grossly misrepresented
by the board appointed to promote their
interests.
.\n Employers' Liability .\ct was pass-
ed by the Legislature of New York last
winter and it originally contained the
clause, "By reason /of the negligence of
any person in the service of the em-
ployer, who has charge or control of any
signal, switch, locomotive engine or train
upon a railroad" which if passed would
have canceled the common law iniquity;
but Governor Odell raised strenuous ob-
jections to the clause, the Legislative
Board of the Brotherhood of Locomo-
tive Engineers appeared against it, and
the clause was left out. Now a great
manv railroad men are naturally asking
why did the representatives of their class
take this stand?
New Self Hardening Tool Steels and
Old Hachines.
In machine operations in railroad or
other shops, they are three factors which
go to make up what may be called the
efficiency of the machine. These are
the cutting speed, or the speed at which
metal is cut off. The feed, which is the
amount of advance which the cutting
tool makes at each stroke of the ma-
chine, or at each revolution of the work.
The cut, which consists of the depth of
metal removed. All these when com-
bined to their highest point give maxi-
mum output.
Not long ago several new self-harden-
ing tool steels were put upon the mar-
ket, which were capable of doing much
more work and lasting much longer
than the tool steels with which shop men
were then familiar. It was at once ap-
parent that high cutting speeds, increased
feeds and greater depths of cut were in
order. The immediate result was the
speeding up of main line shafting. A
large manufacturing establishment which
in order to get maximum efficiency out
of a special grade of tool steel increased
the speed of their line shaft from 90 to
250 revolutions, with the phenomenal
result that a gain of 340 per cent, in
the amount of metal removed per hour
was thereby effected.
The heavy strains thus put upon the
machines themselves have lead to prac-
tically a re-designing of many standard
tools by tool builders. Beds have been
strengthened, gears have been widened
and a general increase of stability and
staying power, if one may be allowed
to say so, has been added in all tools
intended for really heavy work. The ad-
vent of the new tool steel has in many
cases put comparatively new tools out
of business by reason of their not being
able to stand up to the work the new
tool steel could do.
Transportation in New York.
Artemus Ward is reported to have
said on one occasion, that whenever an
emergency arose he just liked to see a
man come along who could cave in the
head of that emergency right there.
That is about the feeling which rises in
the mind of anyone who reads the ad-
mirable paper by Mr. W. W. Wheatly
on "The Transportation Problem of
Greater New York," a brief abstract of
which appears in another column.
There is no one great cure-all for the
overcrowding which takes place during
rush hours, but there are two forms of
the detention "emergency" which con-
stantly arise, and these two heads should
be speedily caved in''W we are to have
comfort, and the thanks of the com-
tiiunity will be gratefully given to the
man who does it. The statistics given by
the author of the paper should carry
great weight as he was formerly Assist-
ant General Superintendent of the
Brooklyn City Railroad and knows
whereof he speaks.
There are on surface lines, daily,
numerous petty detentions to cars, which
in the aggregate, lengthen out the time
occupied on every trip. All sorts of
street obstructions bar the way. Heavy
trucks do not, as a rule, turn out from
the tracks until the car has slowed down
or stopped, and until the noisy and in-
sistant gong has annoyed everybody
within ear shot. The driver of the truck
really gains nothing by his tardiness and
the car with its load of passengers loses
time, uselessly. There is no doubt that
some reform is now in order which will
minimize these petty detentions along
the road. From about 5 to something
after 6 P. M., the whole business of low-
er New York is to get home, and from
the facts and figures brought out at the
club meeting, the complete prohibition
of heavy vehicle traffic along important
street car routes during rush hours does
not appear to be a harsh measure. The
number of those who would suffer by its
enforcement would be quite insignificant
compared with the vast multitude who
would be benefitted. Municipal authority
is of course the only force competent
to act in the premises.
In the case of elevated or steam sub-
urban lines where track is not obstructed,
the cause of detention along the line
Scptcmbor, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND LOCO.MOTIVF. F.XGINERRING
413
must be dealt with by the companies
themselves. One important reason for
delay at stations is the fact that in
handling great masses of people, railroad
companies still continue to use cars with
end doors, and some of the doors at the
present day actually swing on hinges. In
many cases the floor space of the car is
wasted as far as seating accommodation
is concerned. Crowds of people arc
compelled to fight their way on and ofif
the cars, to the great inconvenience of
themselves and the detention of the en-
tire train.
Last month we called attention to the
design of suburban cars proposed by the
officers of the Illinois Central Railroad,
by which uo persons can be provided
with seats, and by which there would be
a side door for every 10 or 12 persons.
The time required to fill and empty one
car, or for that matter the whole train,
would not be greater than that required
for the movement of the occupants of
one compartment, and that can be
brought down to about 10 seconds. The
average time at way stations would prob-
ably be even less than this, owing to the
fact that it is likely only a few persons
would get in or out of any given com-
partment.
Engines or electric motors with high
tractive power and capable of giving
very rapid acceleration are necessary
and useful in their proper place, but the
loss of time along the road, in city and
suburban traffic has not as yet received
that measure of attention which it de-
serves, and which the pressure of a
growing population in all our large cities
and towns is steadily forcing to the
front. The Illinois Central has by its
new designs of suburban cars, made a
determined effort to cave in the head of
one form of this delay "emergency," and
what can be done in the West can be
done elsewhere, and ought to be forth-
with attempted.
Book Reviews.
The .\rt of Pattern Making. By I. Mc-
Kim Chase, M.E. Publishers, John
Wiley & Sons. 1903. Price, $2.50.
This book is a comprehensive treatise
on the subject, in which numerous ex-
amples of all kinds of pattern work are
given for green-sand, dry-sand and loam
molding. Pattern work for marine en-
gines and screw propellers is taken up,
and useful information and rules are
given for the practical use of pattern-
makers and others. The book contains
254 pa.c;cs ;md is illustrated with 215 fig-
ures. It is about 5x7'^ inches in size,
and has been written by a practical man
who can do the kind of work he writes
about.
The subject of the intersection of cyl-
inders of different sizes and at various
angles is elucidated and the appearance
of the line forming the intersection is
shown wlien "developed." The way to
correctly draw this developed line is made
clear by the use of a little paper pattern
which the reader is instructed how to
make. Following this subject comes the
teeth of gear wheel patterns, and belt-
pulleys and flywheels, with numerous
worked-out examples for the proper pro-
portioning of parts, etc. Altogether the
book is useful and clear and, moreover,
it is well printed and neatly bound.
Compound Corliss Engines. By Jas.
Tribe, A.S.M.E. Published by the
.■\uthor. First edition. 1903. Price,
$2.50. For sale by Railway and Lo-
comotive Engineering.
In the Preface the author thus describes
his work: "In its present form this book
is an elementary text-book on the genera-
tion and utilization of heat and the trans-
formation of heat energy into mechanical
energy by means of the multi-cylinder
Corliss steam engine. Although the work
is theoretical in treatment, it, neverthe-
less, aims to be thoroughly practical in
its purpose, all of the examples being
based upon actual up-to-date practice, and
the data from engines which are actually
built and running."
i'hc subjects included in this work of
178 pages, are Steam, Water for Steam,
Heat, Energy, Economy of Expansion,
Theoretical Diagrams, Horsepower, Mul-
tiple Expansion, Steam Jackets, Single-
Cylinder Engines, Double Expansion and
Non-condensing Engines, Double Expan-
sion Condensing Engine, Electric Gen-
erators, Double Expansion Pumping
Engines, Triple Expansion Engines,
Quadruple E.xpansion Engines, Receiv-
ers, Condensing Apparatus and Injec-
tion Water. There are also eighteen
tables containing useful information on
various subjects connected with steam
engineering.
Roof Framing Made Easy. By Owen
B. Maginnis. Publishers, The Indus-
trial Publication Company. 1903.
Price, $1.00.
This work, of over 150 pages, is now in
its second edition and has been revised
and enlarged. The language employed is
that which would be used by a practical
workman and the carpenter or builder who
studies the methods therein described
will gain a knowledge of the constructive
value of every piece of timber which
forms part of a frained roof. He will also
understand how to lay out each piece and
so save himself from the laborious method
of "cut and try." All kinds of roofs are
dealt with and many are illustrated. The
book will be found useful to those who
have this kind of work to do.
correctly be described as a valve motion
demonstrator because the motion of the
valve with reference to the piston may be
studied by its aid. It is made of heavy
Russia iron and is 14x18 ins. and stands
21 ins. high. The valve is full size and
the inches of piston travel arc marked
on the graduated disc. Turning the crank
moves valve and shows the piston
travel as in actual service. With
this demonstrator diflfcrent kinds of
piston and slide valves may be
studied as a number of cards rep-
resenting the various kinds in ordinary
use, go with the apparatus. One may ob-
tain the effect of regular link motion with
increasing lead when reverse lever is
notched up, or the effect of decreasing
lead may be produced, due to what is of-
ten called "crossed" eccentric rods, or
the effect of constant lead may be had
with this mechanism. It is sold for $.30.
delivered, and may be secured through
this office.
The Pratt & Whitney Company have
just issued one of their standard 6x9
booklets, dealing with their Bench Lathe,
lo-inch Tool Makers' Lathe. 13-inch En-
gine Lathe and l4-inch Gibbed Carriage
Engine Lathe. The book contains 67
pages and is fully illustrated with ex-
cellent half-tone plates. The first thirty-
seven pages of the book are taken up
with a description of the 7x32-inch
Bench Lathe. This machine is described
in detail and illustrations are given of
more than thirty of the various attach-
ments which may be furnished with the
lathe, thus giving an adequate idea of
the great diversity of work for which
this machine is adapted. The lo-inch
Tool Makers' Lathe is also fully de-
scribed, and illustrations are given show-
ing the application of the collets and
split step chucks to the spindle. There
are two views of the 14-inch Lathe, one
showing the standard lathe, the other
the lathe with pan bed. A number of
important attachments for this lathe are
also illustrated and described. These
include the relieving attachment for re-
lieving straight, taper and spiral taps
and milling cutters, draw-back collets,
step chucks and closers and expanding
arbors. While these lathes perhaps are
not applicable to rough shop use, any-
one who cares for good machines or
who has to do accurate work will appre-
ciate them. This catalogue will be sent
to anyone who is interested enough to
write to the Pratt & Whitney Company,
of Hartford. Conn.
The Derry-Collard Company, of New
York, have got out an ingenious mechan-
ism which is not exactly a valve motion
model because there are no rods or ec-
centrics connected with it. It mav more
"With a comparatively rough exterior
there was no one whom I knew whose
sympathy for an unfortunate person
would be more easily aroused and whose
interest in assisting one in trouble more
ardent than that good old man," was
said by a well known railroad man writ-
ing about Pulaski Leeds.
414
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
QUESTIONS ANSWERHD.
(58) C. W. C., Leadville, Colo.,
writes :
I have had considerable trouble with
the metallic piston rod packing, the piston
rod rides the packing so hard it cuts the
packing out in a few days. The ma-
chinist raised the cross head end of the
piston, but that did not do much good,
so I went to the round house and took off
the cylinder head myself and found a
solid piston head and the follower plate
dragging on the bottom of the cylinder. I
suggested turning the piston round, but
the foreman said he never heard of such
a thing. I have always understood it was
the general practice with solid heads. If
they are turned over, where are they
turned, on the piston rod or is the piston
rod turned in the cross head? A. — It is
not general practice to turn pistons this
way. If the piston was worn so much on
the bottom as to require turning, it was
about time that another one was substi-
tuted for it. With cross head and piston
correctly in line, rod quite smooth and
sufficient play in the vibrating cup of the
packing, there should not be the excessive
wear you speak of.
(59') \V. C, Dunedin, New Zealand,
writes :
In the twenty-first edition of Angus
Sinclair's book on Locomotive Engine
Running and Management, there is one
question on page 386 which I would like
to have explained. It is question No. 16,
and reads : "Will steam come out of both
cylinder cocks on the same side at the
same time?" A. — ^The answer given in
the book is, "Yes; if steam port is
open." This must be taken in connection
with question No. IS, which deals with
the detection of a blow of steam past the
cylinder packing. If the engine was
standing, for example, so that it would
take steam at the front end, it is obvious
that the front steam port must be open
and the front cylinder cock would then
blow. If the cylinder packing was not
tight, steam would leak past it into the
back end of the cylinder and blow out
of the back cylinder cock. Under
these circumstances the blow out of the
front cylinder cock would be the stronger
of the two, but both would blow at the
same time.
(60) F. J. C, Albuquerque, N. M.,
asks:
How much variation from determined
standards the manufacturing companies
will allow in the size of their injector
cones, the delivery ends of the several
sections, the tapers and the spaces between
the delivery end and the receiving end of
the next one? A. — The manufacturers
will not permit the .slightest variation from
their standards. One of the manufac-
turers recently said, in a letter on a ques-
tion like yours: "Injector nozzles are
very delicate instruments of precision, in
the interior diameters and concentricity,
of which a variation of the one-hun-
dredth part of a millimeter is sufficient
to ruin its functions." Injectors may
be made to give a high lift or a low
lift, they may be made to work with
warm or with very hot water, and for
each of these four cases makers have ex-
perimentally determined the best ad-
justment. Any variation, then, from
the best adjustment for a particular kind
of service, they hold to be a step back-
ward.
(61) R. C. asks:
Why does air heat in compression and
cool in expansion? A.— Air, in common
with other substances, expands when
lieated and contracts when it is cooled.
A gas expands jVs of it^s volume for every
degree of temperature (centigrade)
which it receives, and it contracts th of
its volume for every such degree
taken from it. If air is compressed
there is mechanical work done to
it which manifests itself in a rise
of temperature, just as a chip of
steel heats when being cut off in a ma-
chine. If you were able to reduce the
air, without compression, to the same vol-
ume as it had after it had been com-
pressed, you would have to do it by cool-
ing, or by taking heat from the air. If
you then wished to expand it to its orig-
inal volume you would have to give it the
quantity of heat necessary to bring about
that amount of expansion. A volume of
air might be compressed and so heated,
and, while under compression, cooled to
its original temperature. If it was then
allowed to expand it would take from the
walls of the containing vessel or from
external objects the amount of heat which
it would have lost if it had been reduced
to that volume by cooling.
Traveling Engineers' Convention.
The Traveling Engineers' Association
meet in convention at Chicago on Sep-
tember 8, and there is every indication
that they will have a successful and in-
teresting meeting. We confess having
a weakness for the meetings of this
association, for it is composed mostly
of men who have come to their posi-
tions through a process of searching
selection that few other bodies of men
have gone through. The greater part
of them have been successiul engineers,
and most of them have been promoted
because they were first class engineers
and had the faculty of managmg men
and instructing them in their duties,
if necessary.
The traveling enfineer was a product
of necessity, as recognized by the most
enterprising class of railroad managers.
A great deal of heat was wasted by
engineers working their engines in a
careless way regardless of any idea that
it was his business to make the engine
do its best, and firemen frequently used
coal as if it cost nothing. The most
successful method adopted to close up
the leaks arising from these sources
was in the appointing of live progres-
sive men as traveling engineers, men
who had interested themselves in doing
their work well, and had the capacity
for instructing indifferent engineers and
young firemen. We have repeatedly
heard general managers and superin-
tendents of motive power admit, after
traveling engineers had been perform-
ing their duties for a few months, that
the expense incurred for salaries of
traveling engineers was among the best
investments their companies had ever
incurred.
There have been, however, many
failures in the appointment of traveling
engineers. When the oldest engineer
was appointed, or the loudest talker, or
the man most popular with the other
engineers, without strict consideration
of his fitness, as was often done, the
company reaped little or no benefit from
his services, and he was frequently a
source of discord.
To make a success a traveling engi-
neer must be intelligent enough to be
the master of his business, which will
compel the respect of the men he is
going to influence and control. He
must have clear ideas of how firing
should be done to make the greatest
possible amount of steam per unit of
coal burned. He must know how steam
ought to be used in the cylinders to
convert all the heat possible into the
mechanical work of taking a train over
the road, and he must understand all
the mechanism of the engine and train
so thoroughly that any failure or dis-
order may be at once understood.
These attributes and attainments the
successful traveling engineer possesses;
but to make a success he must have
ample authority that no one has a right
to question. Without this authority the
traveling engineer might as well re-
linquish his position.
There is a movement to change the
name of the Traveling Engineers' As-
sociation to that of Road Foremen of
Engines Association. We do not think
that much gain or loss would be effected
by the change so long as it is the
same band of bright practical men who
compose the organization.
We hate puzzles and riddles and all
those trifling things that require strenu-
ous guessing, but the Joseph Dixon
Crucible Co., of Jersey City, N. J., have
sent out a movable puzzle called "Figure
it Out," which is really amusing. We ad-
vise our fun-loving readers to send for
the "Figure it Out" and figure it out
faithfully without tearing open the slide
to give premature revelations.
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
4«S
Air= Brake Department.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NELLIS.
A Neat Air Driven Machine.
The accompanying cut shows a neat
stand (i) supporting a small air motor
(2) which drives a shaft on which is ar-
ranged a cast iron balance wheel, a small
grindstone (3), a metal circular saw (4)
(1-32 in. by 3 in.) which is used prin-
cipally to split metallic piston rod and
valve stem packing rings as shown, and
on the end of the shaft is a small chuck
which is used to grind valves in angle
cocks as shown at 5; also air valves, etc.
This is a machine in the shops of the
New York, Susequehanna & Western Ry.
at Stroudsburg, Pa., to whose officials
we are indebted for this illustration.
A Pioneer Air Brake JVIan (ione.
"Harry" Frazer died suddenly at his
home in San Francisco, July 21. Mr.
Frazer was apparently in excellent health,
and the news of his death comes sud-
denly and with great shock.
Mr. Frazer was born and reared at
Lancaster, Pa., where he graduated from
the high school, and being of a mechan-
ical turn of mind entered the machine
shops of the Pennsylvania Railroad at
that place to learn the machinist trade.
After serving his apprenticeship he went
to Pittsburg, where, in time, he became
Fifty Per Cent Air-Bralced Freight
Trains.
On September i, 1903, the new amend-
ment to the automatic coupler and power
brake law goes into eflfect. This amend-
ment is broader and covers the ground
more thoroughly than did the law itself.
The law required that railroad companies
should have sufficient air-brakes in each
train in interstate traffic to permit the
engineer to safely handle the train. The
amendment requires that the train shall
not only contain sufficient brakes for the
engineer to safely handle the train, but
goes further and makes it obligatory to
have 50 per cent, of the cars in the
train equipped with air-brakes, coupled up,
and in operation under the engineer's con-
trol. Thus, the object sought, which is
to have freight trains under air-brake con-
trol, is reached in the amendment better
than by the law itself, as the law contain-
ed a loop-hole which permitted but a few
air-brake cars, out of many available ones,
to be coupled up.
Mr. Frazer was one of the first travel-
ing inspectors sent out on the road by
the Wcstinghouse Air Brake Co. He
went to California early in the 8o's to
introduce the automatic brake on freight
trains in mountain service. This work
was of an initiatory and a very important
character, as air brake control of freight
trains had up to that time never been
attempted on any mountain railroad.
Going to the mountainous districts,
where absolute control at all times was
so necessary, Mr. Frazer realized that
upon him personally devolved the im-
Changes in the Wcstinghouse Travel-
Ing Force.
Mr. I. H. Brown, until recently chief
air-brSke instructor of the Westinghouse
Air Brake Co.'s instruction Car No. i,
has been promoted to traveling inspector
of the Cincinnati district. Mr. Hutchins
leaves this district to give his entire at-
tention to triple valve repair work. Mr.
S. H. Down succeeds to the chief in-
structorship of the W. A. B. Co.'s in-
struction Car No. I, and Mr. Harry Or-
chard, for some time past air-brake
instructor and inspector for the Erie
Railroad at Huntingdon, Ind., has ac-
cepted the position of assistant instructor
to Mr. Down.
A VERY NE.^T .\IR MOTOR AND M.\CHINE.
assistant foreman to "Nick" Johnson,
now deceased, in the Pan Handle round
house.
It was while in this capacity that Mr.
Frazer came to the notice of Mr. George
Westinghouse. who was then struggling
to bring the air brake into successful
existence. It was here that Mr. Frazer
did his first air brake work by assisting
Mr. Westinghouse to convert an old
Worthington water pump, with leather
packing, into an air pump. Shortly
afterwards Mr. Frazer regularly entered
the employ of Mr. Westinghouse, who
was then starting a small factory in Pitts-
burg, at Liberty avenue and Twenty-
eighth street.
mense responsibility of laying the ground
work for the success or failure of air
brake freight train control. Slowly he
began to make headway, and railway
people began to realize that the West-
inghouse air brake was not only adapted
to passenger train service, but that it
had an equally great, and even greater,
value in control of the freight trains,
especially on mountain grades, where at
that time four and five brakemen were
required to successfully drop a train
down a heavy grade.
The constant application and faithful
ser^'ices of Mr. Frazer in these early
days did much to place the automatic
air brake where it is to-day, for no trip
4i6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 190J.
was too long or fraught with hardships
for Mr. Frazer to undertake and carry
out. He became the trusted instructor
and air brake manipulator of engincc-s
and trainmen with whom he became so
well known by close association, and also
with the officers of the road, who held
especially to hold trains on long, heavy
grades, and street-car service where stops
are frequent; also for a high-speed brake.
The valve used (Fig. i) is a hollow
casing separated by a diaphragm in two
compartments and controlled by the ex-
haust air. The casing is in two parts and
/,V/V;>/|<-
.1
WestiHuh
}use Reservoir
JIurst
s Improvement
/;
Engineer's Valve
1 Retaining Valve
1'
Union Keservotr
V Equalizlno Reaervot'r
n
"
Train Pipe
,'$ Air Gauge
t:
"
Trijite i'alve
4 Setaining Pipe
r
f,"
"
Auxiliary licservotr
Brake Cylinder
.7 Interposed Valve
it Duplex Coupling
//
Air Gauge
/
Pressure Cock
THE HURST AUTO.MATIC
Hailw
RET.\INER.
him in especial high esteem and confi-
dence. After a successful experience
with air braked freight trains on the
heavy grades in the far West, Mr. Frazer
was called East to participate in the
Master Car Builders' Burlington trials,
in 1886 and 1887, where his advice and
suggestions availed his company much.
In later years Mr. Frazer was privi-
leged to enjoy the fruits of his early
labors on the Pacific Coast, having lived
to see the day when not a car was
allowed to enter any of the Pacific Coast
or Rocky Mountain roads unless it was
equipped with an air brake, and no train
permitted to move on these roads unless
the entire train was so equipped.
Mr. Frazer was the oldest traveling
inspector in the service of the Westing-
house Air Brake Co.'s employ, and was
held in high esteem by both his official
and employee associates. No man was
more popular or better known through-
out the air brake world than he, and the
passing out of no air brake man will be
more generally and sincerely regretted
than that nf "Harry" Frazer.
is screwed together, holding the dia-
phragm between the joint. The dia-
phragm has a stem through its center
which seats on an exhaust port in the
casing. There are two other openings
in the valve casing. They are for the
admission of air, one on each side of
the diaphragm. To connect the retain-
ing valve to the engineer s brake valve,
you must attach the side having one
On the cars the retaining valve is at-
tached to the exhaust port of the triple
valve by the same opening that is screwed
into the train pipe exhaust port of the
brake valve. This side of the valve has
the exhaust port and receives the air
from the brake cylinders. The other side
is attached to the retaining pipe that
comes from the engine and receives the
air from the train pipe exhaust port of
the engineer's brake valve.
The small reservoir used on the en-
gine should be about one-half the size of
the brake valve reservoir, as this reser-
voir gets its air from the brake valve
reservoir when the application is made,
and being one-half the size, we would
get two pounds' pressure for one pound
exhausted. The pressure obtained here
governs the train. Then a seven-pound
reduction would give fourteen pounds'
pressure in the small reservoir and one
side of the valve and guage, and push-
ing the diaphragm and stem and closing
the exhaust port in the other side with
the fourteen pounds' pressure. The air
from the train pipe exhausf port goes in
to the valve on the side of the diaphragm
that has the exhaust port, but the port
being closed with the fourteen pounds'
pressure from the other side, the air
goes to the gauge and retaining pipe
that extends throughout the train, clos-
ing the valves on the cars with the four-
teen pounds' pressure. If the retaining
pipe gets more than the fourteen pounds
it moves the diaphragm, opens the ex-
haust port, and the excess pressure
passes out. All the retaining valves on
the cars are closed with the fourteen
pounds' pressure. This allows the en-
gineer to place the brake valve in the
recharging position and charge up the
auxiliary reservoirs. The brake cylin-
AKoioable-^ f_^^
M. C. B. PROPOSED LOCATION FOR
PIPES AT END OF
12
13' <
STEAM HEAT, fAIR BRAKE AND AIR SIGNAf.
PASSENGER EQUIPMENT CARS.
The Hurst Automatic Retainer.
The Hurst improvement is an auto-
matic retainer designed for the purpose
of holding the brake set while recharg-
ing the auxiliary reservoirs, to equalize
the brake pressure, to make a gradual
release, to make stops on grades, to show
pressure used in brake cylinders and
opening to the exhaust port of the brake
valve reservoir. There is also attached
here a small reservoir and one side of a
duplex gauge. The other side must
be attached to tlic train pipe ex-
haust port of the brake valve. This side
of the retaining valve has the exhaust
port in it and is connected to the cars
by a pipe that extends throughout the
train. It has the other side of the du-
plex gauge attached also.
This is the equipment for the engine.
der, having more than fourteen pounds'
pressure, will move the diaphragm, open
the exhaust port in the retaining valve,
and the excess pressure will pass out.
The engineer's brake valve must have
a port in it for releasing the air from
the retaining valve and small reservoir.
The opening should be very small so
that we can reduce one pound if desired,
for every car will reduce the same as the
engineer reduces the pressure on the
retaining valve in the engine.
September^ lyoj-
KAH.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
4'7
CORRESPONDENCE.
Not Service, but Emergency Only.
In llic July niiiiibtr (Jiicitiuii 54, page
.32T, I note a mistake. It says: "He can
also apply brakes in service position as
well as in emergency if he desires."
FIG. 1. HURST ALITOM.\TIC RETAINER.
Willi Ibe P. R. R. cnt-out cock closed
the train line exhaust is closed and brakes
cannot be applied in service position.
If brakes are to be applied by the second
engineer it must be done by using the
direct application port. The copper pipe
leading from the train line pipe to end of
cut-out cock supplies air to keep rotary
valve seated when cock is closed, as main
Fiij. 6
D Ml
reservoir air has been cut off. The other
small copper pipe coupled to angle fit-
ting at brake valve and to cut-out cock is
for the train line exhaust.
C. L. jMiller,
Harrisburg, Pa. Engr. P. R. R.
[An oversight by us. Our corre-
spondent is correct. — Ed. J
A Recently Patented Four- Way Cock.
I have just been granted a patent
wliich relates to certain new and useful
iniprovcmcnls in four-way cocks adapted
for use ill connection with an air-brake
train line.
In the accompanying drawings I have
illustrated my improved four-way cock
as follows;
Fig. I is a plan view of my four-way
cock. Fig. 2 is a side view. Fig. 3 is a
sectional view on line X X of Fig. I.
Fig. 4 is a sectional view on line 5 5 of
Fig. 2. Fig. 5 is a view showing the ap-
plication of the invention to a train-line,
and Fig. 6 represents diagrams showing
the various service positions.
FUj. .3
Jiaitway J Lt>cvma;tv4 t:n^.nteriii^
In the drawings the numeral I desig-
nates the shell or casing having a tapered
r>])ening 2 therethrough, and air-pass-
ages or ports 3 and 4 communicating with
the said opening and train-line connec-
tions or ends 5, and a similar port 6 com-
municating with said opening and triple
valve end 7.
A tapered plug-valve 8 is fitted into
the tapered opening of the casing and is
held in position by a spring 9 and cap
TO. The plug-valve is provided with a
side or cut-away part 11. straight-away
part 12, and part 13 branching from said
straight-away part, which parts are
y iloiilCl:^ J i<ift.nt«fli'e £nif.n«rfM7
adapted to register with the parts in the
casing and with the dead-air ports 14.
At the upper end of the casing is found
four stop-notches 15, and to the top of
tlie plug is attached a handle 16, which is
provided with a spring catch 17 to en-
gage said stop notches. Said spring and
notches serve to indicate the position and
retain the cock in such position.
In practice the train-line is connected
to the ends 5 and the pipe leading to the
triple valve to the end 7. If it is desired
to let air from the train-line on the left
to the triple valve, the cock is turned
into position shown at Figs, i, 2, 3 or 4
and at B of Fig. 6. To let air from the
train-line into triple valve at right, the
cock is turned one quarter, as at C,
Fig. 6.
From both cars to triple th< cock is
as at D, Fig. 6, and for straight-away
train-line as at A, Fig. 6, the stop-spring
Fia. s
JtMlifaif f Lit^jmtMU^ Lni/imMring
17 and notches 15 holding the cock at
any position to which the same may be
turned.
This device does away with several in-
dependent cocks on the train-line, and
the dead air remaining in the parts es-
capes out of ports 14. By the "expan-
sion dead air" it will be understood is
meant the air which remains in the pipes
under pressure and which it is desired to
release when the air is not required for
Fly. 3
0 ^ rii
service, and which air is released to re-
move the pressure from the parts of the
cock and connected mechanism.
Patrick McDonald.
Pittsburg, Pa.
Fig. 1
is 1
RaUmat f Lteomatitm SitfUttKring
Port Arrangement in Cylinder tjas-
ket for 9 1°2 Inch Air Pump.
The accompanying sketch is submitted
with the idea of trying to overcome the
breaking away of the steam ports in the
upper steam cylinder gasket for the
Westinghouse g'/i in. air pump. The
ports as dotted represent the gasket as
at present in use. and the full line at each
y
4i8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
end of the ports represents the sugges-
tion.
This gasket has always been a source
of considerable annoyance, by breaking
away of that portion between the broken
lines A and B in the steam port (i) and
C and D in the steam port (2), because
of the fact that the corners of the ports
are brought to an acute angle, which
weakens the gasket when it should be de-
signed to withstand a high pressure, as
it does. This portion in the exhaust port
(3) seldom breaks because the pressure
is low and the strain is not so severe on
that part of the gasket.
Over so per cent, of the gaskets re-
moved from our pumps at Burnside are
broken as shown at the broken line in the
sketch, and consequently unfit for fur-
ther service, when if the corners of the
gasket were arranged as shown, the
breaking would be reduced to a very
small per cent.
Will W. Up De Graff.
Chicago, III.
Railway J- Locomotive Engineering
PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS IN TOP
HEAD PUMP GASKET.
1901 riodel New York Pump Qovernor.
A certain fixed limit for train pipe pres-
sure must always be maintained in order
that the proper braking force to suit the
conditions under which the brakes are be-
ing operated, may always be available.
By opening the air pump steam throttle,
steam is admitted to the pump, and the
latter starts to work, but without some
automatic steam regulating device the
pump would continue to pump air into the
main reservoir until the pressure therein
became nearly as high as the steam pres-
sure on the boiler of the locomotive, un-
less the engineman should attend to the
task of regulating by hand the supply of
steam admitted to the pump. To do this
it would be necessary for him to watch
the air gauge very closely, closing down
the steam throttle when the air pressure
reached the required limit, and then,
when the air pressure fell below the re-
quired limit, opening it again.
It can easily be seen that hand regula-
tion of the steam supply to the air pump
would require considerable of the engine-
man's attention, and that, too, sometimes
when his attention should be given else-
where to other more important matters.
Therefore, to relieve him of the neces-
sity of regulating the working of the air
pump, and to insure a uniform air pres-
sure in the main reservoir and the train
pipe at all times, an automatic steam
regulating device, called the pump gov-
ernor, is placed in the steam pipe, be-
tween the pump steam throttle and the
pump, whose duty is to shut off the steam
from the pump when the required air
pressure has been obtained in the main
reservoir and the train pipe, and to admit
the steam to the pump again as soon as
the air pressure falls sliglitly below the
required limit.
The accompanying illustrations, Figs, i
and 2, show the 1901 Model New
York pump governor, with the steam
valve open and with it closed.
It may be well to state here that the
rate of speed at which the pump is to
work must be determined by the engine-
man, and provided for in the amount of
opening he gives the steam throttle; the
pump governor simply determines the
point in the air pressure at which the
steam is to be shut off from the pump,
and again admitted to it.
The operation of the governor is as fol-
lows: steam being turned on, it passes
through the steam valve body, I, on its
way to the air pump, in the manner and
direction indicated by the arrows, and as
It does so, raises, and holds up steam
valve, 5, in the position shown in Fig. i.
As the air pump accumulates air in the
main reservoir and the other parts of the
air brake apparatus, air pressure forms
in diaphragm air chamber. A, on account
of the air flowing into this chamber
through the air imion connection at 17
and 18. as indicated by the small arrows.
It will be observed by reference to Fig.
I, that the regulating spring, 10, holds
diaphragm button, 12, and diaphragm air
valve, 13, firmly to the air valve seat, 14.
preventing communication between cham-
ber A and B.
The tension of the regulating spring.
10, is either increased or diminished by
screwing down or in screwing up the ad-
justing screw, 8, and is always made suffi-
cient to prevent diaphragm air valve 1,3
from being lifted from its seat until the
required air pressure in the main reser-
voir and the train pipe has been obtained.
When the air pressure in chamber A,
pressing upwards against diaphragm air
valve, 13, is sufficient to overcome the
tension, or resistance, of regulating spring,
10, the diaphragm air valve lifts, and air
flows past it down into chamber, B, as
shown in Fig. 2.
Air being admitted to chamber B,
forms a pressure in this chamber which
acts on the governor piston, forcing the
latter together with the steam valve, 5.
upon which it rests, downward until tht
steam valve is seated, as shown in Fig. 2,
and thus the pump governor cuts off the
supply of steam to the pump, causing the
latter to stop momentarily.
When the air pressure in chamber. A,
reduces in pressure sufficiently to allow
the regulating spring, 10, to seat the
ITC. 1,
NEW YORK PUMP GOVERNOR OPEN.
diaphragm air valve, 13, communication
between chambers A and B is cut off, and
the air remaining in chamber B quickly
escapes to the atmosphere through the
small relief port, indicated by the dotted
circle in the passage connecting chamber
A with chamber B, relieving the pressure
in chamber B. When this occurs, the
steam valve, 5, which is being acted upon
by the steam pressure beneath it. and the
governor piston, 4, are raised to the up-
FIG. 2.
NEW YORK PUMP GOVERNOR CLOSED.
per point, or extremity of their travel,
and steam is again admitted to the pump
starting it to work again as shown in
Fig. 1.
Port H relieves all pressure above
diaphragm air valve, 13, that might form
in the spring case, 3, due to leakage from
chamber, A, and thus prevents possibility
of governor, on account of such leakage,
allowing too high air pressure to accumu-
late.
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
419
The small port, I, is provided for the
purpose of supplying a small quantity of
steam to the pump, sufficient to keep the
latter moving, while steam valve s is on
its seat, thus providing a circulation that
prevents condensation of steam in the
steam pipe, and in cold weather prevents
freezing up of the pump.
There are several combinations of the
pump governor to suit particular kinds of
service, such as the single, the duplex,
and the triplex governor. These together
with the defects to which the governors
are occasionally subject, will be treated in
another article. J. P. Kei.i.y.
Walcrtown. N. Y.
QIESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ON THE AIR BRAKE
(65) S. J. B., Trenton, N. J., writes:
I have noted that on one of our high-
speed trains coming to a stop there was
a hissing noise of the triple valve which
finally went into the well-known sound
of the triple valve releasing the brake. I
would ask what makes this peculiar re-
lease with the high-speed brake? A. —
This hissing sound is probably the pres-
sure reducing valve of the high-speed
brake releasing brake cylinder pressure,
due to a full service application, and
while the reducing valve was still blow-
ing the engineer released the brake, thus
stopping the discharge at the reducing
valve and creating a new one at the ex-
liaust port of the triple, the sound with
which we are all quite familiar.
(66) J. C. M.. Packerton, Pa., asks:
How do you tell the difference between
a leak from the auxiliary reservoir into
the brake cylinder and one from the train
line to the auxiliary? A. — Train pipe
pressure leaking into the brake cylinder,
past the rubber seated emergency valve,
the gasket between the lower case of the
triple valve and the main body, or any
other passageway, will be manifested by
a blow at the exhaust port of the triple
valve the instant pressure is turned into
the train line. However, if the leak be
one from the auxiliary reservoir into the
brake cylinder, past a leaky slide valve,
broken gasket between the auxiliary res-
ervoir and brake cylinder, or defective
tube in the auxiliary reservoir, this leak
will be manifested by a very slight leak-
age as pressure is first turned into the
auxiliary, but gradually increasing as the
auxiliary reservoir charges up.
(67) P. S., Frankfort. Ind.. writes:
In the February issue of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering I saw a cut
of an automatic sight feed lubricator for
the air cylinder of the air pump. Do you
think they are a great enough advantage
over the ordinary cup now in use to make
them advisable? A. — The service of the
air pump on long trains of to-day is much
more severe than formerly with shorter
trains. Doubtless the old form of cup
was adequate and suited to that service,
but not so well suited to the heavy serv-
ice of to-day as is the regular feeding
automatic cup. The sight feed feature
doubtless aids the engineering consider-
ably in advising him whether the cup is
feeding, and when it has fed out. Un-
doubtedly, experience to date has proved
that the automatic sight feed cup for the
air cylinder of the air pump is a decided
advantage.
(63) P. E. M., Murray Bridge, So.
Australia, writes:
What is the advantage of placing the
release valve of rolling stock air brake
on the auxiliary reservoir? Some vehi-
cles have this valve on the brake cylin-
der. I fail to see any advantage in the
placing of this valve on the auxiliaries.
By what I can see of it, it seems to me
that the auxiliary attachment is rather
to a disadvantage. A. — With the earlier
forms of air brakes, the release valve
was placed on the brake cylinder, but
on account nf it being left open so fre-
quently after bleeding off the brake,
thereby causing trouble and even expen-
sive accidents, because its open condition
was never known until the brake was
applied, the release valve was removed
and placed in the auxiliary reservoir.
Now, when it is desired to release a
brake with the release valve, the triple
valve is made to move to release posi-
tion, and the brake releases in the natural
way. which is much quicker than if the
release was made with the brake cyl-
inder, where both the brake cylinder air
and the auxiliary reservoir air sometimes
have to be reduced to release the brake.
(69) B. C. G., New York city, writes:
There are some complaints from one
or two of the motormen of the Manhat-
tan Elevated road saying that seme sort
of mufflers had been put in the exhaust
ports of the triple valves, which results
in making the air escape from the brake
cylinder so slowly that it sometimes takes
the control of the train away from the
motorman. A. — The muffler placed in
the exhaust port referred to is an ordi-
nary pipe plug with a hole about 3-16
of an inch in size through it. This plug
not only muffles the sharp whistling
sound of the triple valve, but retards the
discharge of pressure from the brake cyl-
inder. It has been found necessary to
retard and lengthen the exhaust because of
the very short piston travel on these cars,
the travel being between three and four
inches. With this travel the air escapes
so suddenly that it is very difficult to
make a smooth stop. The lengthened
exhaust acts more like a longer piston
travel, and permits the train to be
brought to a standstill with greater ac-
curacy, at the same time avoiding the
disagreeable shock experienced with the
short travel and wide-open exhaust.
(70) J. R. McE., Little Rock, Ark.,
asks:
Why does the slide valve feed valve at-
tachment on some brake valves allow the
pressure to creep up above 70 pounds
what it is set for, and equalizes at 90
what the main reservoir pressure is set
for? A. — The diaphram valve may be
held from its seat by foreign substance
or the slide valve or its seat be cut, thus
permitting main reservoir pressure to
leak into the train pipe. Again, the lead
gasket between the brake valve body and
the feed valve attachment may leak, caus-
ing the same trouble. Sometimes, in tru-
ing up of the slide valve seat, no heed is
taken that the seat be kept parallel with
the floor and roof of the piston's cylin-
der. The slide valve, fitting snugly be-
tween the shoulders of the piston stem,
tends to slightly lift at one end or the
other, thus tipping it and permitting
main reservoir pressure to feed slowly
under it into the train pipe. Sometimes,
in screwing home the cylinder cap, the
spring is twisted, and transmits the twist
to the piston, which slightly tips the side
of the slide valve from its seat, permit-
ting main reservoir pressure to leak un-
der the edge into the train pipe.
(71) P. E. M., Murray Bridge. So.
Australia, writes:
I start the pump and accumulate 80
pounds in the main reservoir, and having
handle of driver's valve in release and
full-charge position, I understand that
both pipes (train and reservoir) contain
an equilibrium of pressure. Now I put
the handle in running position and a de-
crease of 8 to 10 pounds train line pres-
sure is shown by the gauge pointer. Why
is it? Our engines are fitted with the
old-type driver's valve with lo-pound re-
serve valve, and all plain triples. A. —
If the train line pressure drops when
you bring your brake valve handle from
release to running position, there is a
leakage of pressure from the train pipe
at some point. If the main reservoir
pointer goes up, and the train line
pointer stands still, there is no leakage
in the train pipe, and the difference be-
tween the two hands indicates merely a
rise of pressure in the main reservoir.
If, after coupling the engine to the train,
with the handle in full release position,
the black pointer drops and continues to
drop when the handle is brought to run-
ning position, it shows that pressure is
passing into the train pipe in full re-
lease position faster than the feed groove
in the triple valves can take the pressure
from the train line. When the handle
is returned to running position, and the
black pointer falls again, it shows that
the feed grooves at the triple valves are
taking train line pressure faster than it
can be supplied by the running position
of the brake valve.
420
RAILWAY AXD LOCOMOTIVE EXGIXEERING
September, 1903.
Lining of Shoes and Wedges. *
By \V. D. CHAMBERLIN.
The following method of lining up
shoes and wedges is, I t.nnk, safe ana
practical if properly carried out. It has
been used for years in one of our railroad
repair shops, and gives satisfaction, hav-
ing been much used on repair work
where the old center lines and marks
are worn off or cannot be depended
upon, so that new and reliable lines have
to be laid out.
In lining up shoes and wedges the ut-
most care should be observed when lay-
ing off distances or taking measurements,
as the accuracy of the finished work de-
pends, of course, upon the care which
has been taken in doing it. This is true
of most machine shop work, but par-
ticularly so with shoes and wedges, the
face or surface, which bears against the
driving box. This is left rough until
properly laid out.
On- the side of the frames over each
jaw lay off short lines F F, Fig. I, par-
allel to and equally distant from the top
of frames. When this is done', a point
A, Fig. 2, on back of cylinder saddle
equally distant from each frame and
down a convenient distance from the
boiler, must be located as follows: Lay
off a point C, Fig. i, on the inside of
each frame near the cylinder, the dis-
tance from the finished surface D of
the front jaw being the same on both
frames, and the distance down from the
tpp of frame also being the same on both
frames. Mark this point lightly with a
prick punch. Now get a piece of 54-inch
wire and bend it as shown in Fig. 7, the
the frame (right main jaw), the intersec-
tion of £ £ and F F. Take the trams to
the left side of the engine, leaving it set
at this distance, place the pointed end at
A as bfore, and with the movable point
scribe a line on side of frame over left
main jaw, intersecting F F, thus locating
at this point of intersection a point cor-
responding to B of the right side.
Through this point scribe a line at right
angles to the top of frame. This line is
the center line of that jaw and corres-
ponds to £ £ of right side.
In some cases the guide yoke or other
parts interfere so that the movable point
of the trams canpot be set at B. In such
cases continue the center line E E across
top of frame by means of a square set to
£ £, the blade extending across top of
frame. On this line locate a point a cer-
"l^l-g
/••;</. /
1S5
:.v; .-.xijiy
JJ IjJ^I
Stitall Square
Vii/.
CL-l ^ straiaM lUlye
-Jc
ri,j. -i
n.i. :s
I'll/. <!
J''ifh '
•
I ;
jj
1
i|
ji
C
-^
Ij
Ll,
±.
J
1 1
1^ jiftitr pJftmtf
VII our nUIv
1 1
/•'/</. 4
Railu/ay i LecomoUva Ejiginaarvig
LINING UP SHOES AND WEDGES, LINES AND POINTS REQUIRED.
work being simply a matter of taking
and laying off certain measurements.
The main object in view is to place the
axis of the driving wheels and axels at
right angles to the frames and parallel
to each other, the distance from the axis
of one pair of wheels to the axis of the
next pair being the same as the length
of the rod which connects them. There
are other points which must be taken
into consideration, but this is the prin-
cipal one. In the first place, the frames,
cylinders, boiler, etc., are supposed to be
set up and firmly bolted into place.
The pedestal braces should also be bolted
into place. We will suppose the engine
to have six drivers, the shoes and wedges
being ready to set up, having been planed
and fitted to the pedestal jaws, all planer
work on them being finished except the
* Reproduced by request, from Railway and
Locomotive Engineerin(, of Februars-, 1900.
end bent being about I inch long. Cut
the wire off long enough so that it will
reach from the point C to where point A
will come, then sharpen both ends. Place
the point of straight end at C and with
bent end scribe a line on cylinder saddle
about where A will come, then do the
same on the other frame. Where the
two lines cross will be the point A,
midway between the frames. Before lo-
cating A it is best to chip off the rough
casting at that point and make a smooth
surface to work on. Mark the point A
with a prick punch. Now go to the
right main jaw and lay off its center line
E E, intersecting F F at B, Fig. i.
It is best to use the main jaws to work
from, but if they are unhandy to get at,
use the front jaws. Take a long "fish"
tram with one movable point; place the
pointed end at the point A on cylinder
saddle and set the movable point at B on
tain distance from edge of frame, say
midway between edges, and set the tram
point to this point. Take the trams to
the left side of the engine, place the point
at A as before, and with movable point
scribe a line on top of frame. Now lay
off the line N N, shown on plan view of
Fig. I, midway between edges of frame
and intersecting the line scribed with
trams at X. Scribe the line P P through
X, across the top of frame, and continue
it down the outside by means of a square.
This latter line then is the center line of
that jaw (the left main), and corresponds
to £ £ of the right side. Of the two
methods just described for locating this
center line, the first is the best and safest,
and should be used whenever possible.
The "fish" trams mentioned may per-
haps be strange to some machinists. It
consists of a long rod (J^-inch iron pipe
is suitable) about 12 feet long, one end
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMO'IIVJ': I'lNGINEERING
421
beiiiK (lr;iwii out to ;i rather lilunt iioint.
One ordinary tram point is used, it being
provided with the usual set screw so as
to set it at any position on the rod.
To continue with our work: Wc now
have the center lines of the right and left
main jaws. Now take an ordinary dou-
ble-pointed trams and carefully set them
to the length of the side rods which con-
nect the main drivers to the front drivers
(it will be leniembcred that our engine
has three pair of drivers, the middle pair
being the main), place one point at B on
the right main jaw of engine, and with
the other point scribe a line on the side
of frame over the right front jaw, inter-
secting F F. This i)iiint corresponds to
B on the main jaw. Through this point
scribe a line at right angles to the top
of frame. This is the center line of that
jaw. With the trams set at same dis-
tance, go on the other side of engine
and repeat the operation for the left
front jaw. Now set the trams to the
length of the side rods which connect
the main drivers to the third pair of
drivers, and repeat the same operation
for the third pair of jaws. We now have
the center lines £ £ of all the jaws. The
utmost care and caution should be taken
in this work, as a large pair of trams can
very easily play tricks on the man who
handles it. The work should be gone
over with again in order to prove its
accuracy.
The next thing to do is to consider
each driving box, which should by this
time be ready to set up, the machine
work on them being finished. The boxes
are supposed to be bored out central;
i. c, G = H, Fig. 3. They are, how-
ever, not always bored central, owing to
faults of workmanship and other causes,
so it is best to take this into considera-
tion.
Take a box, say the right main one,
get the distance H from the center of
the brass to the front bearing surface,
and lay it off on F F of the right main
jaw, measuring to the front from the
center line E E, thus locating point H^.
Do the same with G, measuring back
from E E and locating C on F F. Take
each box and repeat the operation for
its corresponding jaw. These points H
and G show the exact position which the
box should occupy in its jaw. By doing
this the center line of the box will be
kept at the center line £ £ of its jaw,
no matter if the box is not bored out
central. To get G and H take a piece
of lead or a piece of wood with a tin
strip set in its surface and place it be-
tween the sides of brass bearing, then
take maphrodite calipers and locate the
center of the brass bearing on this lead
or wood piece. A J^-inch plate planed
on one side an,d cut out to the shape
shown at Fig. 4 should now be made.
This can then be set on the bearing
surface of the bo.x, the plate projecting
over the si<le of the box as shown in the
plan view of Fig. 3. The distance // or
G can then be obtained by measuring
from this plate to the center of the brass
previously located on the strip of lead.
The plate should be made so that it can
be used on any ordinary box. It can
then be used on any job of shoes and
wedges.
To return to the frame: We have now
located on each jaw the position which
its box will occupy. Now take each shoe
and set it up in its place on the jaw, the
set bolt being set up tight, thus holding
the shoe firmly in position. The line K
K. passing through H and parallel with
/■■ /;, must now be scribed on the outside
of the shoe. In order to do this, place
two parallel strips across the top of
frame, the ends projecting over the
edge of the frame. Take a large square
and set it on these projecting ends, with
the blade hanging down at the side of
the shoe; then take a small square, place
the engine from frame to frame. Select
two points L L on K K, near the top
and bottom of the shoe. Cut two small
wooden blocks long enough so that when
placed on the pedestal brace (one on
each brace;, with the straight-edge rest-
ing on them, it will come opposite the
lower point L. Two blocks should also
be cut so as to reach the upper
I)oint L in the same manner. With
the straight-edge resting on these smaller
blocks, place it .so that it is the same
distance from L on each shoe. The plan
of Fig. 1 shows one block and the end
of the straight-edge as it rests against
the shoe.
Now take your maphrodiles and set
them to this distance; j. c, from the
straight-edge to L, which is equal on
both sides of engine, then lay that dis-
tance ofT on the inside of the shoe with
the leg of the maphrodites placed against
the straight-edge. Do this on the other
shoe on the other side of the engine,
ROGERS SWITCHER. WITH WIDE FIRE BOX.
Description on page 4^*2.
it on the side of frame with blade at //,
and move the large square until its blade
touches the blade of small square. While
doing this hold the small square tirmly
in place and keep the blade of large
square pressed against the side of shoe,
but be careful and not cramp it so that
it will not rest evenly on the parallel
strips. When the large square is prop-
erly located, take your scriber and scribe
a line along its edge upon the side of
shoe, thus locating line K K. In order
to prevent the parallel strips trom tip-
ping off the frame on account of the
weight of the square, place a piece o!
iron of sufficient weight upon them as
they rest on the frame. Fig. 5 shows
the arrangement of the squares and shoe.
This operation should be repeated on all
the shoes.
The next thing to do is to locate on
the inside of the shoe a line correspond-
ing to K K and at the same distance
from £ £. Take a long straight-edge
and pass it between the jaws and across
then place the straight-edge on the long
blocks in the samfe manner and repeat
the operation for the upper point L.
Scribe a line through these two points
just located on the inside of shoes. This
line then corresponds to K K on the
outside of shoe. Repeat this operation
on all the shoes.
If the distance H is not the same on
the opposite jaws it will be seen that the
above operation is not theoretically cor-
rect, but unless the distance H varies
greatly it is considered close enough
for practice, the error being very small.
After all the shoes are thus laid out,
they are taken down and planed to these
lines. Before taking them to the planer
locate with your dividers a point M, Fig.
6, a certain distance from L on the side
of shoe — ^4 inch is a convenient distance.
It should be laid off from each point L,
and a small circle described about it so
as to make its position plain. After the
shoe is planed, by measuring the distance
from the planed surface to this point, it
422
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
can be seen whether the shoe was planed
to the lines laid out. This is called a
"proof" mark, because it is a means of
proving whether the shoe was planed as
laid out. If this mark is left off the
planer hand can swear that he planed
to the lines, and his word will have to
be taken.
After the shoes are all planed, set them
up in place again; also set the wedges in
place on their respective jaws, the wedges
being set at their lowest position. Now
take a large pair of calipers and caliper
the distance between the bearing surfaces
of the right main driving bo.x, j. e.,
H + G, Fig. 3. A line K K parallel to
the planed surface of the shoe must now
be scribed on the wedge, both inside and
outside.. The handiest and most accurate
way to do this is by means of the tool
shown at Fig. 8. This consists of a
piece R, shaped as shown, the inside
surfaces T and R being at right angles
to each other. In this piece is screwed
a 5-16-inch steel rod, with an offset and
a movable point 5". The side T has a
slot cut in it for convenience in setting
the point 5 to its proper position. Set
the point 5 a distance from the surface
T equal to the distance obtained by
calipering the box.
Place the squared surfaces R and T
against the corner of shoe, the surface T
bearing against the bearing surface of the
shoe, and the surface R bearing against
the outside of shoe as shown. Now
slide the tool down the shoe, holding it
firmly with the point i" against the side
of the wedge. This scribes a line K K
on the side of the wedge parallel to the
planed surface of the shoe and at a dis-
tance from it equal to the distance be-
tween the bearing surface of the box.
Do this on all the wedges both inside
and outside, being careful to set the
point 5" for each box, then take the
wedges down, put on the proof marks
and get them planed.
After the wedges are planed set them
up in place again, then place the long
straight-edge across from frame to frame
as before, first rubbing its edge with
damp lampblack. Place this edge against
opposite shoes or wedges and rub it back
and forth a few times, then notice how
it bears on the surfaces. By this means
it can be seen whether the bearing sur-
faces of opposite shoes or wedges are
parallel to each other or not. To test
the work in another way, caliper the
boxes again and set the inside calipers
and caliper the corresponding shoes and
wedges. As a final test after the wheels
are placed under the engine and wedges
set up in place, the side rods not being
up, go to each wheel and plug up the
center holes made at the lathe, by ham-
mering lead into them, then with di-
viders carefully locate the center of
wheel, a circle for this purpose being
usually cut in the hub of wheel when
it is in the lathe; then lightly prick the
center. Do this on all the wheels. Now
set the large trams to the length of the
side rod as before, place one point in
center of main driving wheel, and try the
center of the next pair of drivers with
the other point.
It can then be seen whether the work
is right or wrong. Try all the wheels
this way with the trams set to the proper
length. If the wort has been carefully
done, the wheels will undoubtedly come
all right.
It will be noticed that the point G, Fig.
I was not used in locating K K on the
wedge. It is not necessary to lay in G,
but it will do no harm to do so, as the
position oi K K on the wedge may be
compared to it as a proof.
This method of lining up shoes and
wedges, of course, cannot be used in all
its details on some makes of locomotives,
owing to their peculiar construction, but
it will be found that it can be used on
ordinary engines. For instance, in get-
ting the line K K on the shoes by means
of the squares and parallel strips, as de-
scribed, it will be found that this cannot
be done on the rear pair of jaws with
those locomotives where the fire box sets
on top of the frame. Instead of getting
K K in the manner described, it may be
located by setting the large trams to the
length of side rods, as before and tram-
ming from K K of the main shoe, then
K K of the wedge can be obtained as
usual.
the track is clear ahead, then the white
light appears on the entering section.
If the section is occupied the red lamp
lights up, the white light going out.
The system is stated to be absolutely
trustworthy, and unaffected by climatic
conditions.
Rogers Switch Engine.
The Rogers Locomotive Works, of
Paterson, N. J., have recently supplied
the New York Glucose Company with
a six-wheel switcher, illustrated on
page 421, which weighs altogether
about 113,000 lbs., and all of this
is of course, adhesive weight. The
cylinders are 18x24 ins. and the
drivers are 44 ins. in diameter. The
pressure carried is 180 lbs., and the cal-
culated tractive effort of this little ma-
chine is, therefore, about 27,000 lbs. and
the ratio of tractive power to adhesive
weight is, on this basis, 4.1.
The boiler is a straight top one, radial
stayed 55 ins. in diameter at smoke box.
It has a total heating surface of 1,134
sq. ft. The grate area is 30 sq. ft., the
fire box being of the wide type set over
the frames, and intended for small
anthracite and bituminous coal. The
saddle tank holds 1,700 gallons.
The total wheel base of the engine is
II feet and the main drivers are not
flanged. The valves are balanced slide
valves, with ordinary indirect motion. Al-
together the engine is a compact, neat
looking and serviceable machine.
Automatic Electric Signals Introduced
In Great Britain.
With a view to facilitating the work-
ing of their main line traffic to and from
South Wales, the Great Western Rail-
way Company are now arranging to in-
stall electrical automatic signaling
through the Severn tunnel, which is 4
miles 600 yards in length. With the
new signaling system the tunnel will be
divided into sections of 1,200 yards
length, thus permitting more than one
train on the same line in the tunnel at
the same time and with perfect safety.
The usual semaphore signals at the
sides of the line will be supplemented
by "repeat" signals indicated in the cab
of each locomotive before the eyes of
the driver. This novel system, which
is controlled by the Union Switch &
Signal Company, can only be used in
connection with electrical track circuit
signaling, is in successful operation in
the Park Avenue tunnel of the New
York Central Railway, and, after a short
initial experimental working on the
Great Central Railway, has recently been
approved by the British Board of Trade.
Each locomotive is equipped with a re-
versing switch battery and two lamps,
the latter being mounted in the cab of
the engine. One of the lamps shows
a white light, and the other a red. If
Lincoln's Car Sold.
The Union Pacific has sold the Lin-
coln car, which has been the property
of the road for the last thirty-seven
years, and it will be placed on exhibi-
tion on The Pike in St. Louis next
year. For years the car has stood on
the tracks near the Union Pacific shops
at Omaha and it has attracted scarcely
passing notice of Omaha people except
when it was on view at the Trans-Mis-
sissippi exhibition. It was also exhib-
ited at Chicago in 1893.
The car was built at the military car
shops at Alexandria, Va., in 1864. It
was ironclad, armor plate being set be-
tween the inner and outer walls to make
it bullet proof. After the car was built
the President used it practically alto-
gether, and his remains were taken to
Springfield for burial in it. In 1866 it
became the property of the Union Pa-
cific, and has only changed hands within
the last month.
The proper place for this car is in the
Smithsonian Institute at Washington.
We hope it will go there when the St.
Louis Exhibition closes.
Industry is the soul of business and the
keystone of prosperity.
— Barnaby Rudge.
September, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND I.DCOMOTIVK ENGINEERING
423
Electric Locomotive for the U. & <).
Tunnel.
Probably tlic most powerful electric
locomolive in the world has just been
built by the General Electric Company
at Schenectady, for the Baltimore &
Ohio Railroad for use in its tunnel un-
derneath the city of Baltimore. This
locomotive marks a very distinct advance
in electric locomotive design. It will
handle all the freight traffic of the B.
& O. which passes through Baltimore,
and will operate over the same section
as the present electric locomotives built
by the General Electric Company and
mean.s of the Spraguc General Electric
Multiple Unit Control.
The section of the road to be operated
runs from Camden Street Station
through the tunnel to the summit of the
grade outside the tunnel a distance of
y/2 miles. Under practical operating
conditions the motors have sufficient ca-
pacity to maintain this service hourly
running loaded up the grade and re-
turning light.
Train Conductor Sold Kish.
A newspaper man recently found the
following item in a New York paper
dated 1858:
his fingers, and reckon over how he had
disposed of the four dozen he had started
with. After a while, "I have it; hold on
a little while and I'll be back,' said he;
and he run the train back seven miles
to a place where he let a woman have
one more than she paid for, got it, came
to Suncook, and let the old v/oman have
the six she wanted, and then the 'smelt'
train went to Concord."
When it was first proposed to make
passenger cars for the Baltimore & Ohio
Railroad with end doors and an aisle
in the middle great opposition to the plan
UOUBi:,E ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVE FOR THE B. S: o.
which have been in successful operation
for the past eight years.
In designing this locomotive the speci-
fications called for an electric locomo-
tive capable of handling a 1,500 ton train,
including the steam locomotive but ex-
cluding the electric locomotive on' a max-
imum grade of ij4 per cent, at ten
miles per hour, with corresponding
higher speed on lighter grades. This
required a locomotive weighing approxi-
mately 160 tons on the drivers lor pur-
poses of adhesion, and the engineers of
the General Electric Company decided
that the most practicable scheme was to
build an articulated locomotive consist-
ing of two complete 80-ton units oper-
ated together as one locomotive by
"It is well known that the Portsmouth
Railroad has to turn everything to ac-
count to pay running expenses, and many
are the jokes they perpetrate upon the
conductors in reference to their shifts to
get a living. It is said that one of them
last year was accustomed to bring fish
from Portsmouth and peddle them out
at the stopping places on the way to
Concord. One day he brought along
smelts, dealing out to customers at every
stations, till he got to Suncook, where
he blew his horn, and an old woman
came out and wanted six, 'just a pattern
— all I've got left, you're in the nick of
time,' said he, and he began to count
them and found only five. "How's this?
I should have six;' and he began to count
was raised in a directors' meeting. The
leader of the opposition declared that
with passengers sitting at each side the
aisle would be converted into a long spit-
toon. When the other directors reflected
enough to realize the prevailing prac-
tices of travelers of that day, they de-
cided that their colleague was right, so
side doors and cross seats were decided
upon.
It is not things, but opinions about
the things that trouble mankind. When
therefore, we are worried or troubled or
grieved, never let us blame any other
than ourselves; that is to say, our opin-
ions.— E{'ictctus.
424
RAILWAV AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
Bex Car with Strong End Construc-
tion, for tlie Central Railroad
of New Jersey.
In Oliver Wendell Holmes' poem,
"The Wonderful One-hoss Shay," it
will be remembered that the Deacon
pointed out that the trouble with shays
in general was that "they always broke
down but never wore out." To avoid
this breaking down he made every part
just as strong as every other part, and
it ran a hundred years, to a day. The
trouble with railroad equipment is that
it more often breaks down before it
wears out, and talking of box cars one
of the weakest portions of its anatomy is
its ends. Many cars with steel under-
posts. The lower ends of ihc end and
corner posts, therefore, are contained
in pockets which are placed I'A ins. down
behind the steel end sill. Each end po'.-^t
is covered on the inside of the car by
a 4-in. channel, S'A lbs. per foot,
w-hich is bolted through. The end
sheeting of the car is carried down to the
top of the steel end sill and is backed
by a ij^xijij-in. angle, which also stands
on the top of the end sill. From this it
will be seen that the end posts have at
their lower ends, with end sill and angle
iron, a depth of backing 3]4 '"• deep with
which to resist breaking out at the bot-
tom.
In addition to the security of the
I
SIDE VrEW OF END
NEW BOX CAR, CENTRAL RAILROAD OF NEW JERSEY.
framing and strong sides, and covered
with good roofs, are notoriously weak as
regards end construction. Through the
courtesy of the motive power department
of the Central Railroad of New Jersey
we are able to place before our readers
some information regarding a 6o,aoo-
pound capacity box car, with steel un-
derframing, and an end construction of
exceptionally strong design.
It will be noticed from our illustra-
tion that the side sills are made of 8-in.
steel channels, the center sills are 12-in.
channels, and the end sills are also 12-
in. steel channels, placed 4 inches higher
than the center sills. Close behind the
end sill a flat 2'/2-in. piece of oak ex-
tends across the car, and upon this
•piece rest the malleable pocket castings
which receive the bottoms of the end
end posts the belt rail is covered
inside the car with 4-in. channel, 5/4
lbs. per foot, which extends across
the car. Just below this is a tie
rod which goes through from side
to side, while just above the belt
rail are two tie rods passing through
the corner posts and carried back co the
first upright side post which stands
above the body bolster. Here this
longitudinal tie rod is fastened with a
strap bolt end. The sheeting inside at
ends of car is Ij4 in. thick, and where
secured to the end posts a strip of
2xJ4 steel ii placed outside, and against
this the heads of the bolts are drawn.
A feature which is noticeable all over
this car is the fact that bolts are used
throughout and the nuts are on the out-
side, where they can be readily seen
by tile car inspector and easily tightened
up when necessary. There are two wide
inside sheeting boards run all round the
car, above the belt rail level, for addi-
tional protection of the outside sheet-
ing against the side play of high loads.
These boards are 71/2 ins. wide and are
spaced 3^ ins. apart. The vertical tie
rods are not set into the edge of the
side posts, the rods stand clear so that
they may be held with a pair of tongs
or pipe wrench, and prevented from turn-
ing when the nuts are being tightened
up. The roof is stiffened by having an
extra course of wood lining which rests
upon the carlines, and above this extra
course is placed the Excelsior improved
inside car roof.
The body bolsters of this car arc built
up as shown in our illustration, and
the needle beams are composed of steel
channels and flat braces. The two cen-
ter sills are covered, for the greater
part of their length, by two flat plates
riveted to the flanges, so that the draw
sills in this case practically become a box
girder braced to the outside sills by
body bolsters and needle beams. The
trucks are of the heavy arch bar type
and are supplied w-ith the Barber oscel-
lating device, which permits side motion
and insures automatic centering. The
wooden portion of the side sills are se-
cured to the 8-in. channel by an angle
iron riveted to the steel sill, which re-
ceives a series of bolts and holds the
timber firmly, to which the side sheeting
is attached at its lower end.
Tower couplers are used, Symington
journal boxes, and the Williamson & Pries
draw gear. The cars are also equipped
with the New York air brake.
These cars, notwithstanding the re-
inforced roof, steel underframe and
stiffened ends, weigh light about .37.500
lbs. They were built by the Ameri-
can Car and Foundry Company at Ber-
wick, Pa., from designs furnished by the
motive power department of the C. R.
R. of N. J., of which Mr. Wm. Mc-
intosh is superintendent of motive
power and Mr. Geo. W. Wildin is me-
chanical engineer. The order is for .1
thousand cars.
Machinists Going to Canada.
A large number of the employees of
the Schenectady branch of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company has left for
Montreal, Canada, where they have se-
cured positions with the Montreal Lo-
comotive Works, which has been opened
in that city to furnish locomotives for
the railroads of the Dominion. Many
of the best machinists of the Schenec-
tady works have been secured by the
Canadian works, and they have been
appointed to positions as foremen at
once, with good financial prospects.
The Canadian works have been insti-
tuted because of the fact that the Amer-
;'l)ti-nil)cr, 1903.
KAII.VVAY ANU LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
425
jcan works, mi whicli the Cau.iiliaii
roads dpcntlod for the supplies of en-
gines, arc ^already rushed with orders
and arc unable to take any new orders.
The books of the American Locomotive
Company, it is announced, arc full for
the next year or more, and the orders
which have been received from Cana-
dian rciads have, in many cases, been
returned unfilled. The Canadian Pacific
Railroad needs 500 new engines in a
hurry. Forty-six have been secured
from the .\mcrican Locomotive Com-
pany, a few in Scotland, several more in
Germany, and half a dozen from France.
The opening of the great transconti-
nental line through Canada is sure to
result in a continued demand for loco-
motives, so that it has been found to
be ncccssarv to start in the manufac-
block between the jaws is drawn up
tight and clamped.
There are a number of Brooks' details
to be seen on this engine, such as the
reach rod, made of extra heavy 2-in.
pipe; the Player ash pan, the spring
hanger jrjints and the spring self-center-
ing device on the carrying wheels at the
rear. The e(|ualizer between rear driv-
er and carrying wheel has three pin
holes, any one of which may be used,
thus giving a chance for a slight re-
distribution of weight when engine is in
the round house. The engine truck is
supplied with the three-pivot link hanger
for the cradle, which produces a rapid
and sure return to center, though allow-
ing considerable side movement.
The boiler is one of the -extension
w-agou-tnp variety, with wide fire box.
Uoilcr— Working pressure, 210 lbs,: UiiclcneftH of
plates in barrelsand outnide of fire box, H. H,
fn-'A. 'A in,; firebox, lent(th. 90 in.; firebox,
widlli, 6H in.; fire Ijox, depth, front, 67 In.;
l)ack,57in.; fire Imx. water space, 4 front; jJi
sides, s% back; tubes, No. 11 B. W. O.; heating
surface, tubes, i.Syo <u\. ft.; fire box, 146 sq. ft.
total. 2,016 s<|. ft ; grate surface. 41 s »<^ ft.;
smoke stack, top above rail. 14 ft. 11 in.
Tender— Weight, empty, 44,c>to ll>s.
First Sleeping Cars.
Many accounts 01 the origin of sleeping
cars have been published, but the earliest
reference to this means of promoting the
comfort of passengers is contained in the
following article which appeared in the
Baltimore Chronicle, of October 31,
1838:
"The cars intended for night traveling
between this city and Philadelphia and
F.\ST PASSENGER 4-4--.' ENGINE FOR THE EVANSVII.LE & TERRE HAVTE
ture of engines on a large scale, in order
to meet the demand.
Evansville & Terra Haute Fast
Passenger Engine.
The American Locomotive Company
have recently turned out of their Dun-
kirk shops some 4-4-2 engines for the
Evansville & Terre Haute Railroad, a
half-tone illustration of which is Iiere
shown.
The engine is simple, with I9x26-in.
cylinders and 73-in. driving wheels. The
total weight of the machine is 150,000
lbs., of which 88,000 lbs. rest upon the
drivers. The valve motion is direct, both
arms of the rocker being above the pivot
point, and the transmission bar passes
with a gentle curve over the forward
driving axle. The valves are balanced
piston. The pedestal binders are made
something in the form of a link with a
screw at one end. This encloses the
base of the pedestals, and with a filling
The total heating surface amounts to
2.016 sq. feet, made up as follows: Fire-
box, 146 sq. ft.; tubes, 1.870 sq. ft. The
grate area is 41Y2 sq. ft. The tubes are
248 in number and are each about 14 ft.
6 in. long. The taper course is the first,
and is 58J4 in. diameter at the smoke-
box end.
The tender has a coal capacity of 10
tons and the tank holds 5,000 gallons.
A few- of the more important dimensions
are appended for reference:
General Dimensions— Weight in working order,
150,000 lbs.; weight on drivers, S8 000 lbs.;
weight engine and tender in working order,
2JS.COO lbs.; wheel base, driving. 6 ft. 8 in.;
wheel base, total, 27 ft. S in ; wheel base, total,
engine and tender, 51 ft. 51^ in.
Cylinders— 19 X 26 in.; size of steam ports, 2U x
24 Ji" in.: size of exhaust ports, 50 sq in.
Valves— Greatest travel, 5^^ in.; outside lap, i in.;
inside lap, o in.; lead in full gear, j'5 in.
Wheels, etc.— Dia. of dri\-ing wheels, 73 in.; dia.
and length of dri\-ing journals. 8t^ x 1 1 in. ; dia.
and length of main crank pin journals. 5>s x 6
in.; dia. and length of side rod crank pin
journals, 6."^s x 4V4 in.
which afYord berths for twenty-four pas-
sengers in each, have been placed on the
road and w'ill be used for the first time
to-night. One of these cars has been
brought to this city and may be inspected
by the public to-day. It is the most com-
plete thing of the kind we have ever seen,
and is of beautiful construction. Night
traveling on a railroad is. by the introduc-
tion of these cars, made as comfortable
as that by day, and is relieved of all irk-
someness. The enterprise which con-
ceived and constructed the railway be-
tween this city and Philadelphia cannot
be too highly extolled, and the anxiet>- of
the officers who now have its control in
watching over the comforts of the passen-
gers, and the great expense incurred for
that object, are worthy of praise, and we
are glad to find, receive the approbation
of the public. A ride to Philadelphia
now, even in the depth of winter, may be
made without inconvenience or suffering
from the weather. You can get into the
cars at the. depot at Pratt street, where
426
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Sep'icmber, 1903.
is a pleasant fire, and in six hours you are
landed at the depot in Philadelphia. If
you travel in the night, you go to rest
in a pleasant berth, sleep as soundly as
in your own bed at home, and on awaken-
ing in the morning, find yourself at the
end of your journey and in time to take
your passage to New York, if you arc
bent there. Nothing now seems to be
wanting to make railway traveling perfect
and complete in every convenience, ex-
cept the introduction of dining cars, and
these we are sure will soon be intro-
duced."
The distance from Baltimore to Phila-
delphia was only about ninety-six miles
and did not afford the length of journey
that demands sleeping car accommoda-
tion. With all the enterprise displayed
01 a cross-bow, with string pulled taut
and locked ready for the discharge of
the arrow, only in the case of the^ brake
beam the arrow is replaced by the ful-
crum, which itself does the locking, in
this form any tendency of the bowed
beams to straighten under service
stresses, tends to tighten the truss rod.
This beam has stood up most satisfac-
torily under severe tests and the Grand
Trunk people have reason to be pleased
with its simplicity of design, its few
parts, its easy construction and its un-
doubted staying powers when out on the
road.
Cochran Pipe Wrench.
The Cochran Pipe Wrench Company, of
De Soto, Mo., have got out a pipe
Hailway ^ turnnmlu't i'nj/inten'itf
GRAND TRUNK HIGH SPEED DRAKE BEAM.
by the company, and the praise to the
scheme accorded by and shown on the
part of the public, they did not, however,
make it a success, and we are sorry to
say that the sleeping cars were so poorly
patronized that they were withdrawn af-
ter three months' trial.
Grand Trunk Brake Beam.
On the Grand Trunk Railway System
a very simple and strong passenger high-
speed brake beam is being used. It is
made out of a bar of wrought iron zVi
xlM in., bent to a twenty-foot radius,
thus giving a camber of ij4 in. at
the center. This bar, which forms the
backbone of the beam, is reinforced by
a truss rod of flat iron aVix^ in., which
is riveted to the main member at each
extremity, and is lipped over the ends.
Between the beam and truss rod is in-
serted a malleable iron fulcrum through
the center of which the brake lever
passes at the proper angle. The brake
heads are riveted to the beam with
5^-in. rivets. Two safety hangers are
secured to the truss rods by clips, which
do not require the boring of holes in
the truss rods, and the outer end of the
fulcrum has an eye to which is fastened
the end of a hanger, which prevents the
beam from sagging, so that there is no
undue wear on the upper portions of the
brake shoes.
The whole beam is really in the form
wrench that has several novel and inter-
esting features. It is made of crucible
and drop forged steel and is therefore
practically indestructible. It will not
mash the pipe upon which it is placed, as
it has a rocker which governs the grip.
The outer or hook jaw is made wide at
the vital point and its shank is threaded
half its length which gives the wrench
the required range. The nut is extra
long and, as more threads engage than
in fact, at the time of the summer solstice,
which is about June 21, the sun does not
set at all, and this circle is the boundary
of the area where for a certain length of
time there is no night.
The railway which penetrates into the
"polar regions" has its southern terminus
at the Swedish town of Lulea, which is
on the Gulf of Bothnia. The northern
terminus is Victoria Haven, on the Ofoten
fiord in Norway. The road was built for
the purpose of marketing the very valua-
ble iron ore which is found in Swedish
Lapland. The railway is substantially
constructed and its equipment thorough-
ly modern. In addition to doing a heavy
ore business every arrangement has been
made to deal with a considerable tourist
traffic. A station has been built at the
exact point where the railroad crosses
the Arctic Circle, and trains will be
stopped there for the purpose of letting
tourists enjoy themselves, if they so de-
sire, by standing for a few moments
with one foot in the temperate zone and
one in the frigid, or in doing little ec-
centric things which people usually do
when they cross the equator.
The ore, which is used extensively in
Great Britain and Germany, was formerly
brought to Lulea, but as the Gulf of
Bothnia is frozen over during about half
of every year, the transportation of the
ore has been very seriously retarded. The
opening of the northern terminus, how-
ever, has changed all that, and as the
Ofoten fiord is deep and is always free
from ice, uninterrupted communication
can be had with the rest of the world.
The road is in many respects similar
to our railways over the Rocky Moun-
tains; tunnels were driven through th>:
mountains which barred the way, and the
line, especially on the Swedish side, has
to be protected by snow sheds. The gov-
ernment of Norway and Sweden supplied
ihe money and built the road, but the iron
ore mining company which operates it, is
THE COCHRAN I'IPK WRENCH.
would, in an ordinary nut, it is strong and
the wear of the threads is consequently
reduced. The price ranges from $2.00 to
$6.00, according to size.
to pay back the cost of the undertaking
and will eventually own the Arctic Rail-
road.
The Arctic Railroad.
The most northerly railroad in the
world is the Arctic railroad, in the Scan-
dinavian Peninsula. Its northern term-
inus is about 130 miles above the boundary
of the north frigid zone. The Arctic
Circle is an imaginary line drawn about
23P2 degrees from the North Pole, and
within this circle during the summer the
days are long and the nights are short ;
The first railway in Germany was be-
tween Prague and Piken. The work of
construction was done mostly by women
who were paid twelve cents a day. The
road was opened in 1837. There were
about two thousand women employed on
excavating and in forming embankments.
It was said to have been the cheapest con-
structed railway in the world up to that
time, and well it might have been with
such cruelly underpaid labor.
Scplcmbi-r, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND l.OCO.MOTI VK ENGINEERING
■42-
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. M. M. Albright lias been appointed
Trainmaster ot the Blueniont Branch of
the Suiithern Ivailuay.
Mr. J. C. Mcehan has been appointed
assistant master mechanic of the Mobile
& Ohio, at Mobile, Ala.
Mr. R. Worrell has l)cen promoted to
the position of road foreman of engines
on the Kansas City Southern Railway.
Mr. R. E. Simpson has been appointed
Trainmaster o( the Murphy Branch of
the Eastern District of the Southern
Railway.
Mr. J. Kirkpatrick has been appointed
master mechanic of the Baltimore &
Ohio, at New Castle Jet., Pa., vice Mr.
H. P. Knight, resigned.
Mr. R. H. L'hommedieu has been
appointed general manager of the Mich-
igan Central. He was formerly general
superintendent of the road.
Mr. C. D. ShalT has been appointed
acting road foreman of engines on the
New York Central Railroad, with head-
quarters at Watertown, N. Y.
Mr. Frank Barr has been appointed
third vice-president and general manager
of. the Boston & Maine Railroad, vice
Mr. T. A. MacKinnon, deceased.
Mr. John W. Winn has been appointed
general foreman at Richmond, Ind., on
the Pennsylvania lines, west of Pitts-
burgh, vice P. M. Dunn, transferred.
Mr. J. H. Tonge has been appointed
chief train despatcher on the Cumber-
land Valley Railroad, at Chambersburg.
Pa., vice Mr. H. A. Logue, promoted.
Mr. J. E. Harlan has been promoted
to the position of road foreman of en-
gines on the Illinois Central Railroad,
with headquarters at McConib City,
Miss.
Mr. L. T. Hutchinson has been ap-
pointed superintendent of the car de-
partment on the Mobile & Ohio, at
Cairo, 111., vice Mr. James Thornton, re-
signed.
Mr. A. Harrity has been appointed
master mechanic on the Atchison, To-
peka & Santa Fe, with headquarters at
Ranton, N. M., vice Mr. D. A. Sullier,
resigned.
Mr. J. E. Irwin, formerly master me-
chanic of the Marietta, Columbus &
Cleveland Railroad, has been appointed
master mechanic of the Little Kanawha
Railroad.
Mr. Geo. M. Whinney has been ap-
pointed master mechanic on the Great
Northern Railroad, with headquarters at
\Villmar, Minn., vice Mr. G. A. Bruce,
transferred.
Mr. II. A. Liigue, formerly train mas-
ter on the Cumberland Valley Railroad,
at Chambersburg, Pa., has been pro-
moted to the position ol train master
on the same road.
Mr. S. H. I lutchinson, assistant gen-
eral superinlendent of the Michigan Cen-
tral, has been made general superintend-
ent of the road, vice Mr. R. II. L'liom-
mcdicu, promoted.
Mr. M. J. Maloncy has been appointed
road foreman and assistant train master
of the Cumberland Valley Railroad, at
Chambersburg, Pa., vice Mr. K. M.
Moore, transferred.
-Mr. W. D. Stratton has been elected
president and general manager of the
-Mobile, Jackson & Kansas City, with
headquarters at Mobile Ala., vice Mr.
F. B. Merill, resigned.
Mr. Harry Swoyer, formerly general
master mechanic of the Louisville &
Nashville, has been promoted to the
position of assistant superintendent of
machinery of the same road.
Mr. W. R. Howden, formerly round
house foreman on the Louisville & Nash-
ville, at Anniston, Ala., has accepted the
position of master mechanic on the Mo-
bile, Jackson & Kansas City Railroad.
Mr. B. Haskell, formerly superintend-
ent of motive power on the Flint &
Pere l^Iarquette, has been appointed
general manager of the Franklin
Rolling Mills & Foundry Company,
Franklin, Pa.
Mr. Henry Giegoldt, formerly master
mechanic of the Atchison, Topeka &
Santa Fe, at La Junta, Colo., has ac-
cepted a similar position with the Colo-
rado & Southern, with headquarters at
Trinidad, Colo.
Mr. W. K. Christie, master mechanic
on the Pere Marquette, at Saginaw,
Mich., has accepted the position of mas-
ter mechanic of the Lake Erie & De-
troit River Railroad, with headquarters
at Walkerville, Ont.
Mr. Theodore H. Curtis, formerly me-
chanical engineer of the Louisville &
Nashville, has been appointed superin-
tendent of machinery of that road, vice
Pulaski Leeds, deceased. The position
of mechanical engineer has been abol-
ished.
Mr. A. G. Elvin, master mechanic on
the Delware, Lackawanna & Western
Railroad at Scranton, Pa., has resigned,
to accept a position with the Coffin-Me-
gealh Supply Company. Mr. Elvin will
be the manager of their mechanical de-
partment, with headquarters at Frank-
lin, Pa.
Mr. C. K. Shelby, until recently as-
sistant master mechanic of the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad, at Altoona, has been ap-
pointed to the position of assistant su-
perintendent of motive power of the
Philadelphia & Erie division of the
Northern Central, vice Mr. J. M. Henry,
promoted.
Mr. W. II. Lewis, superintendent of
motive power of the Norfolk & Western
Railway, was elected president of the
.American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association, at the annual meeting in
Saratoga, this year. Last month we in-
advertently connected Mr. Lewis' name
with the Lehigh Valley.
Mr. E. J. Egan has been appointed
transportation inspector on the New
York, New Haven & Hartford. The
position is newly created and Mr. Egan
is the first incumbent. He will inves-
tigate the cause of all delays to trains
and have general supervision over the
movement of equipment.
Mr. Henry Engels, of 91 Fremont
street, San Francisco, who represents the
Chicago Pneumatic Tool Company on
the coast, has lately secured several
large orders for pneumatic equipment
fro'm a number of western concerns.
The orders include a number of Frank-
lin .\ir Compressors manufactured by the
company.
Major Arthur E. Hodgins, superin-
tendent engineer in the construction de-
partment of the Central South African
Railways, who had been visiting his na-
tive land, Canada, on a three months'
leave of absence, passed through New
York early in August, en route for the
Dark Continent, where he will resume
his railroad duties.
Mr. W. H. Monroe, round house fore-
man at Cedar Rapids, la., on the Chi-
cago, Rock Island & Pacific, has resigned
his position to accept a similar one with
the Chicago Great Western, at Dubuque,
la. The machinists, engineers and fire-
men on the C, R. I. & P. presented
him with a gold watch and chain as a
token of esteem and regard.
Mr. W. H. Dunlap, who has been en-
gine house foreman on the old E. T.
V. & G. and general foreman on the
Southern Railway, has resigned his con-
nection with the road upon which he
has been employed for the past fourteen
j'ears. and has been appointed general
428
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
foreman of the Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, with headquarters at Atlanta, Ga.
- Mr. D. A. Wightnian, so well known
among railroad men when he was gen-
eral manager of the Pittsburgh Locomo-
tive Works, is greatly improved in
health since he retired from active work.
Mr. Wightman was such a strenuous
worker that he drew very rapidly upon
his reservoir of vital force. He is doing
some work for the Baltimore & Ohio
people in connection with shop exten-
sion.
Mr. W. S. Stone, of Eldon, la., has
been elected Grand Chief Engineer of
the Brotherhood, of Locomotive Engi-
neers, to succeed the late lamented P.
M. Arthur and A. B. Youngson. Mr.
Stone has been in railroad service for the
past twenty years, and has been on the
Missouri division of the Chicago, Rock
Island & Pacific. He has been, for sev-
eral years, chairman of the General
Board of Adjustment ot that road. He
will fill the position of Grand Chief for
the une.xpired term of his former chief.
Through depending on infdrniation re-
ceived from a newspaper clipping we
had, it appeared by a notice in last
month's paper, that Mr. W. J. Hemp-
hill had been appointed superintendent
of motive power on the Chicago & Al-
ton Railroad. We have been informed
that the report was entirely unfounded.
JNIr. Hemphill is now general manager
of the Evens & Howard Fire Brick Co.,
of St. Louis, and occupies a more lucra-
tive position than what he would be like-
ly to obtain on a railroad. He has no
desire whatever to return to railroad
work.
Mr. W. O. Duntley, vice-president and
general manager of the Chicago Pneu-
matic Tool Co., left Chicago recently on
a trip to the Pacific coast, in the in-
terest of his concern. His trip will ex-
tend over a period of several weeks, as
he will endeavor to call on as many
as possible of the host of friends and
patrons of his company on the coast.
He states that business in the pneumatic
tool line is in a flourishing condition,
and that while the usual depression in-
cident to this season is, of course, some-
what noticeable, still the various plants
of the company are yet working in-
creased forces in order to take care of
the business already on hand.
Mr. Thomas Plunkett. who has been
connected with the Chicago & Alton
Railroad for the past thirty years, has
resigned from that road to accept the
special agency of the Revere Rubber
Company of Boston and of the Detroit
White Lead Works of Detroit. Mr.
Plunkett began his railroad career in
the Alton's local freight department,
where he remained for five years. He
was then transferred to the stationery
department, and was stationer for a
period of six years. He subsequently
became chief clerk in the purchasing
agent's oflfice, and acted as dining car
superintendent for two years. Alter this
he was given the position of assistant
to the purchasing agent, which position
he held for nineteen years. He resigned
to go into the railway supply business.
Mr. Plunkett makes his headquarters at
168 Lake street, Chicago. His friends,
who are man}', wish him every success.
The Transportation Problem of Greater
New York.
Mr. W. W. Wheatly read a very in-
teresting paper at the last regular meet-
ing of the New York Railroad Club. It
was on the Transportation Problem of
Greater New York. He said that based
story city demands more than a one-
story street.
The interruptions to traftic are very
great in a city like New Y'ork. On the
surface lines there are a daily average
of 24 serious detentions, averaging 18
minutes each. The delays less than 5
minutes are not taken into account, but
there are an average o( "5 of them every
day. On one particular day last winter
when a record was taken, at the triangu-
lar intersection of Fifth avenue, Broad-
way and Twenty-third street, there were
by actual count 1,910 vehicles which went
across the street railway tracks in the
hour from 11 A. M. to 12 noon. So great
in the ag.gregate do these obstructions
become that surface cars with a possible
speed of twenty to twenty-five miles an
hour, are practically reduced to a speed
of six miles per hour. It may in time
1^
••V,/v^-w,.
OLD AND NEW INDUSTRIES MEETING.
on the census returns of 1900 it was es-
timated that the population of New York
city at the beginning of this year was
3.437,202 persons. For the week ending
Dec. 13. 1902, the average number of
persons carried per day on the Manhat-
tan elevated was 749.172 persons and on
all the surface lines 1,519,608 persons,
making a total of 2,269,229 persons car-
ried every day in the Metropolis.
In giving an outline of the problem to
be solved he said, in a recently built 29-
story structure there are 1.125 little boxes
called offices. Nearly 6,000 people do
business in this building. To furnish
Seating accommodation to the occupants
of this one building, to take them- home,
would require twenty solid trains of six
cars each. Notwithstanding the steady
expansion of the city, the street facilities
remain the same. A twenty or a thirty
become necessary to prohibit heavy
trucking on streets like Broadway dur-
ing the rush hours.
The speaker dealt with the probable
increase in the city's population, and re-
duced the "problem" to a series of
definite propositions. He spoke of the
additional facilities already authorized
for providing transportation to and from
Long Island and the Jersey shore. At
present the ferries and the Brooklyn
bridge are the only ways travel can pass
over the East River. The Manhattan
bridge, the Williamsburg bridge, the
Blackwell's Island bridge, the municipal
rapid transit tunnel, and the Pennsyl-
vania and Long Island Railroad tunnel,
will, when completed, have an hourly ca-
pacity of 277,800 passengers. On the Jer-
sey side the Pennsylvania Railroad tun-
nel and the tunnel of the New York &
September^ 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCn.MOTIVE ENGINEERING
429
New Jersey Railroad, together willi llio
municipal rapid transit subway, will have
an hourly passenger capacity of 43,000.
Other plans are also under considera-
tion.
In discussing the paper Mr. M. N.
Forney said the crowding of street cars
was the same in New York many years
ago as it is to-day. It is the same
wherever street car. lines exist. The
transportation facilities are always just
behind the demand. He advocated the
doctrine of "A seat on demand, or half
fare," as much less unfair to the cor-
poration than the present system is to
the passenger,
Mr. Geo. L. Fowler said that years
ago he had occasion in New York to
take measurements of the speeds and ac-
celeration on every type of motor used
in and about the city. He found the best
speed which was made on the Hudson
County electric road was on the line
coming down from Fort Lee on a down
grade was 31 miles an hour, while on the
diseunifurt it rose (rom 18 to 20 seconds.
With cars jammed as are the uptown ex-
presses in the evening rush, the stop
lasted from 25 to 30 seconds.
Mr. W. J. A. Boucher quoted from the
New York Times, and said the elevated
trains in New York now maintain a ser-
vice equal to 165,000 car miles a day,
which is approximately equivalent to 400
cars a day between New York and Pitts-
I)urgh, say 400 miles, which would re-
quire a 5-car train every 9 minutes dur-
ing the entire 24 hours. The magnitude
of the New York "problem" may be ap-
preciated by remembering that this car
mileage was made on no miles of track
and 800,000 were carried daily.
Prof. Wade Hibbard pointed out that
the average New Yorker's idea was to
save time, not to save his strength. On
the surface, elevated and underground
lines, he said, New Yorkers were not
going to save time by sitting down, so
they were content to stand. He advo-
cated side door cars such as were used
177.772 lbs., which leaves 130,856 lbs. on
the engine truck. The tires of the main
driving wheels arc without flanges and
the side rods arc solid-end rods of
I-scction. With 200 lbs. boiler pressure
these engines would be capable of exert-
ing a calculated tractive effort of about
24,200 lbs.
The boiler is of the extended wagon-
lop type, 62 in. outside diameter at the
smoke-box end. The grate area is 33.43
sq, ft., and the total heating surface is
2.460.1 sq. ft., of which 188.1 is in the
fire-box and 2,272.0 is in the tubes. The
height of the center line of the boiler is
8 ft. 10 in. above rail level, while the
top of the smokestack is 15 ft. iJ4 in.
above the rail. The smokestack for this
class of engine measures i6!4 in. outside
diameter, and is 38J4 in. high. It rests
on a flanged steel base, which is Grand
Trunk standard.
The valve gear is indirect and the
valves are of the piston type. Cylinder
and valve chamber are placed close to-
TEN-WHEEL PASSENGER POWER FOR THE CRAND TRUNK SYSTEM.
road coming out of Coney Island on
straight level track across the meadows
near Bath Beach was about 2i miles per
hour. He said 45 miles an hour was the
maximum speed made by express trains
on the Manhattan elevated, on the Ninth
avenue line on the down grade between
Ninety-third and Twenty-third streets,
and the uptown expresses were slower.
In the matter of acceleration he referred
to some experiments made by the Gen-
eral Electric Company at Schenectady,
with one of their cars. The Schenectady
car attained a speed of 36 miles an hour
in 16% seconds. The Royal Blue line
express running from Jersey City to
Philadelphia took 75% seconds to do the
same thing, and the Central Railroad of
New Jersey on local trains between Jer-
sey City and Easton took 80V2 seconds
to get up to a speed of 36 miles an hour.
In the matter of stops, he pointed out
that the size of the crowd had everything
to do with the time involved. On the
Manhattan elevated, with a car two-
thirds full, the average stop was 5 sec-
onds. With car full and a few standing
it lasted 10 seconds. With car filled to
at the Columbian Exhibition at Chicago
in 1893.
Mr. H. H. Vreeland said: If you
take the Interstate Commerce Commis-
sion's report for last year on the steam
railroads of the United States and Can-
ada you will find that they did not
move as many passengers during the
last fiscal year as were moved on the
Island of Manhattan and the Bronx,
and you will get some idea of com-
parison of conditions. In Greater New
York last year, over 700,000,000 were
carried in the Boroughs of Manhattan
and the Bronx, and the whole country
only carried something over a billion.
Grand Trunk Ten=WheeI Passenger
Engine.
A good example of ten-wheel passenger
pnwer built by the Grand Trunk Railway
nf Canada at their Point St. Charles
Shops, Montreal, is here shown. The
engine is simple and has cylinders 20x26
in. The outside diameter of the driv-
ing wheels is yz in., and the weight car-
ried by them is 132.608 lbs. The weight
of the engine itself in working order is
gether and are neatly enclosed in one
casing. The cross-head is of the al-
ligator pattern, and carries an oil cup
on the side in addition to the usual guide
bar cup. All the drivers are braked and
so is the engine truck, the wheels of
which are 38 in. in diameter. The driv-
ing tires are held in position by shrink-
age and a retaining ring is also used on
the inside of each wheel.
The tender frame is made of steel
channels, the outside sills have the
flanges turned inward. The water capac-
ity of the tank is 6,000 U. S. gallons and
20,000 lbs. of coal is carried. The tender
wheels are 42 in. in diameter, and the
weight of the tender is 130,856 lbs. The
total weight of engine and tender in
working order is 308.628 lbs.
We are indebted to the courtesy of
Mr. W. D. Robb, superintendent of mo-
tive power of the Grand Trunk System,
for the photograph and data which we
are able to reproduce for the benefit of
our readers. The engine presents the
neat and trim appearance which is the re-
sult of careful designing and compact
grouping of parts.
430
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 190,5.
A New Style of Draw Gear.
The accompanying illustration shows
in general the construction and action
in service of the Waugh spring draw
gear, which is covered by patents re-
cently issued to J. M. Waugh. Fig. i
shows all parts at rest. Fig. 2 shows
auxiliary groups curved in second action.
hi A;'M"\('M
the main group is a separating block C.
which is made up of two parts, one part
provided with lugs, and the other with
corresponding holes, and between the
parts is a steel plate 1-16 in. thick, the
length and width being the same as those
of the follower plates, but this plate is
intended simply to hold the block C in
Flg.l
B'
U U W VJ M'
^
WAtTGH DRAW GEAR. ALL PARTS NORMAL.
the center. The surface of the block C
in contact with the auxiliary group is an
oval of % in. curvature, while the surface
in contact with the main group is a ,|-
in. curvature, and are the curvatures
taken by the au.xiliary and main groups
In service the gear has three distinct
grades of cushion. The first is when the
coil spring has been compressed 54 in.;
the backward movement of the auxiliary
group .A. will slide the abutment blocks
D until they come in contact with the
auxiliary group Al, and in this travel,
about 7,000 lbs. of the capacity of the
coil spring has been untilized. The sec-
ond action is shown in Fig. 2. The coil
spring has been compressed iJ4 in. more
and in this second action each auxiliary
group has been curved -^ in., but in
opposite directions, by the abutment-
block D and 83.000 lbs. of the blow has
been absorbed on a total travel of i^ in.
It will be seen in Figs. I and 2 that the
bearing shoulders of the pocket for the
main followers are not at right angles
to the wall of the pocket, but diverge at
an angle which will allow the followers
Bl to be curved 54 in. out of a straight
line before taking the angle of the
shoulder and in the third action as
shown in Fig. 3 the thimbles in the
springs are in contact and the pressure
is directed along a center line through
the thimbles F separating blocks C :o
the center of the rear followers Bi, and
when curved to the angle of the shoul-
ders f^ in., making a total travel of 2 in.,
a compression test showed 183,600 lbs.
When the coil spring has been com-
pressed until the abutment-blocks are
brought in contact with each auxiliary
group A and Al from that point to the
limit of travel of the coupler, the force
of the blow is resisted by front and back
followers alike and in opposite direc-
Flg. 2
Fig. 3 shows all spring plates curved
when coupler has traveled 2 in. and
buffer of coupler is in contact with the
headblock.
The construction consists of pocket
castings which are of malleable iron or
steel. They are recessed in the timbers
I in. and have flanged projections ex-
tending along the inner face of the draw
sill and bolted through the timber to
prevent the timber from splitting. Oii
the inner face of the pocket casting are
two lugs on which slide abutment-blocks
D, these are provided with oblong slots
corresponding to the lugs to allow the
abutment-blocks D to change their posi-
tion, as the followers travel in either
direction. Surmounting the lugs are
caps E which hold the abutment-blocks
D in position, and also keep the coil
spring on the center line. The coil
spring used is the standard 8x6j4 in-
double coil spring. The plates which
compose the followers are all of spring
steel I in. thick, 6 in. wide and 12 in.
long.
Groups A and Ai are au.xiliary fol-
lowers and in the combination and dia-
gram shown, are each composed of 6
straight plates of above dimensions.
Group B and Bi are the main followers
and are each composed of 8 plates of of plates when coupler has traveled 2% tions through the abutment-block D, and
the same dimensions. F and F are in. in either direction. In Fig. i the so long as the coupler travels there is a
thimbles inserted in either end of the ends of the abutment-blocks D are not resiliency in the spring plates and the
coil spring, the inner ends of the thim- in contact with the auxiliary groups A draw gear or timbers do not receive a
bles come in contact li in. before the and Ai and the opening admits of the solid shock, and with 2]/$ in. travel of the
coil spring is closed, thus preventing the coil spring being compressed H in. be- coupler only 1-3 to 2-3 of the elastic limit
coil spring from being driven solid, fore pressure is exerted on the auxiliary of the plates has been used. The ad-
Separating each auxiliary group from groups through the abutment-blocks D. hesion of the smooth surfaces of the
COIL SPRING COMPRESSED
Sfptcnibor, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
43'
steel plates in each group by pressure
tlirough the abutment-block to curve
them together with the check olTered by
the abutment-block to their return to a
straight position until the coil spring is
released prevents the recoil. What has
been shown of the action in buffing
shocks is true under tensile strains.
Tests made with different combinations
of the plates show 03,000 lbs., 125,000,
166.000, 183,600 and 218,000 in 2 in. travel.
The device is being used by several
railroad and car companies, on high ca-
pacity cars, and is giving entire satisfac-
tion. The 125,000 lbs. capacity draw
gear has been adopted by some railroads
on their passenger equipment. The de-
vice is manufactured and sold by the
Waugh Draft Gear Co., 1525 Monad-
nock Block, Chicago.
Rise of nr. A. C. Bird.
We frequently hoar the complaint
made that the chances for advancement
in the railroad service are almost
blocked by the presence of men favored
by influence, and that merit and hard
work no longer count. That is not true.
The chances of promotion by hard-
working merit are as good as they ever
were, and they never will be beaten
where honest work has to be done.
The ambitious railroad man will find
a new beacon in the success of Mr. A.
C. Bird, who has just been created traffic
manager of the Gould Railway System.
After returning from the war in 1865
he began railroad work as a night
watchman on the old St. Louis, Alton
and Terre Haute Railroad. Then he be-
came a bill clerk in the freight depart-
ment with work to do which brought
his opportunity. He proceeded to
master every detail of the business, and
the same policy pursued in every posi-
tion vi^hich he reached, kept him moving
upwards. He succeeded because he de-
served success, as others with similar
attributes will do as long as railway
business lasts.
Cost of Steel Ralls.
We have repeatedly, said that railway
companies are charged by the Steel
Trust an exorbitant price for steel rails.
We suppose from our knowledge of
steel making that the steel makers were
obtaining a profit of about 100 per cent.,
but a letter from Mr. Schwab to Mr.
Frick, which has been published by the
Kcw York Herald, indicates that the
profit ranges from 130 to 150 per cent.
The letter reads:
"As to the future, even on low prices,
I am most sanguine. I know positively
that England cannot produce pig iron
at the actual cost for less than $11.50
per ton. even allowing no profit on raw
material, and cannot put pig iron into
a rail with their most efficient works for
less than $7.50 a ton. This would make
rails at net cost to them at $19. We
can sell at this price and ship abroad
so as to net us $16 at works for foreign
business, nearly as good as home busi-
ness has been. What is true of rails
is equally true of other steel products.
As a result of this we are going to con-
trol the steel business of the world.
"You know we can make rails for less
than $12 per ton, leaving a nice margin
on foreign business. Besides this, for-
eign costs are going to increase year by
year, because they have not the raw ma-
terial, while ours is going to decrease.
The result of all this is that we will be
able to sell our surplus abroad, run our
works full all the time, and get the best
practise and costs in this way."
Yet an import duty of $8 a ton is
imposed to protect these steel makers
from the ruinous competition of cheap
r.urdpean labor.
you of our anxiety to give you any in-
formation you may desire, we beg to
remain," etc.
ft may be that the contrivance for in-
creasing adhesion by magnetic attrac-
tion may ultiinalcly be made a success,
as many other inventions have been de-
veloped over the wrecks of repeated
failures; but meanwhile, we entreat our
readers not to put any of their hard-
earned savings into the stock of this
company. A new concern which so-
licits stock subscriptions before thor-
ough practical trials have demonstrated
the value of their property, ought to be
avoided on general principles. — Ed.
Ubituary.
The engineering world has suffered a
severe loss in the recent death of Dr.
John Elfreth Watkins, who for many
years was curator of mechanical tech-
POSITION WITH COri'LER AGAINST HE.^D", BLOCK.
Magnetic Equipment.
We have received from Thomas .Allen
Box. general manager of the Magnetic
Equipment Company, Chicago, the fol-
lowing letter:
"We have noticed your editorial on
our device, in your .\ugust number, and
appreciate very much your kindness in
mentioning same; however, we believe
there are some facts in connection with
our device you are not fully informed
upon; if this is the case, it would afford
us great pleasure to give your repre-
sentatives any information in our pos-
session. We herewith enclose copy of
letters from engineer and fireman who
have been running our locomotive.
"We do not compare an investment
in our company with a Government
bond, yet we feel the earning possibil-
ities of our stock is as great as any
ever offered on the market.
"Thanking you in advance for cour-
tesies shown our company, and assuring
nology in the United States National
Museum. He began life as a mining
engineer in the service of the Dela-
ware & Hudson Canal Company, after
which he became connected with the
Pennsylvania Railroad as assistant en-
gineer of construction. He filled vari-
ous important positions on that road,
meanwhile pursuing investigations into
the early history of transportation in
the United States. In 1884 he became
honorary curator of transportation in
the National Museum in Washington,
and at once began to develop that part
of the museum's collections which are
now so valuable. He subsequently sev-
ered his connection with the Pennsyl-
vania and became curator permanently.
He was called upon to assume the di-
rectorship of the Department of Indus-
trial Arts in the Field Columbian Mu-
seum in Chicago, when that institution
was opened, but returned again to the
National Museum after a vear. He
432
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
published numerous papers on the liis-
tory of transportation, among which
niay be mentioned, the "Beginnings oi
Engineering," in 1888; "The Develop-
ment of the American Rail and Track,"
in 1889; "The Log of the Savannah," in
1890; "Transportation and Lifting oi
Heavy Bodies by the Ancients," in 1898,
and also the "History of the Pennsyl-
vania from 1845 to 1896."
A. B. Youngson, assistant grand chief
engineer of the Brotherhood of Loco-
motive Engineers, who, upon the death
of the late P. M. Arthur, became grand
chief of the order, died suddenly at
Meadville, Pa., July 29.
Rumors of N. \ . Central Discharging
Engineers.
The discharge, within the last month,
of over twenty locomotive engineers be-
longing to the New York Central most
of them advanced in years, has led to
rumors that the company was system-
atically dropping its old men.
A Press-Knickcrbocker-Ex[>rcss reporter
talked with a number of Central engi-
neers regarding the reports in circula-
tion. "I am aware that a number of
engineers have been discharged of late,"
said one, "but that is likely to occur at
any time. The fact is the company is
becoming stricter every day, especially
as regards the indulging of their engin-
eers in intoxicating drinks."
It is said that the engineers are con-
stantly being shadowed by spotters in
the shape of unpretentious young men
who would be taken for the sons of
farmers rather than city bred youths.
On duty or oft duty the engineer is
under surveillance, and when he visits
a saloon he is immediately reported to
headquarters, with the result that he is
shown no mercy.
Track Train Stopper.
An item has been sent out from Wash-
ington as a notice contributed by the
United States Consul at Leipsic, that
the invention of putting appliances in
the track to stop locomotives when
danger is ahead has been patented in
the United States probably fifty times.
It seems, however, to be new to Ger-
many.
"A meeting of the commission com-
posed of representatives of the Imperial,
Prussian, Bavarian, Saxon and Baden
State railroads was held at Karlsruhe on
July 9 in order to test a new brake, which
is known as the Steiner distance brake.
"This new invention may be said to
be an improvement upon the air brakes
now in use. It is so connected with the
air brakes of a train that when the front
wheels of a locomotive pass over a
danger or halt signal placed upon the
tracks it will automatically put on the
brakes at the same time opening the
whistle valve.
"The apparatus worked satisfactorily
even at the great speed of 83.75 miles an
hour, but because of the extraordinary
strain to which it was subjected an im-
portant part thereof was broken.
"The commission has recommended
that an extended trial be given to the
Steiner brakes upon the regular train
service."
Blacklisting Not Unlawful.
We have always understood that the
"blacklisting" of discharged employees
was a crime before the law, and one of
the meanest actions that an employer
of labor could be guilty of; but the
United States Circuit Court has just
rendered a decision that the miserable
practice is lawful. The man who "begs
a brother of the earth to give him
leave to toil" may legally have his plaint
denied because some other brother has
secretly put a knife into his character.
The Commercial Telegraphers' Union
applied to the Circuit Court of the
United States for an injunction prevent-
ing the Western Union Company from
discharging employees because they
belonged to the union and from main-
taining what is known as a blacklist of
such discharged employees.
The complaint alleged, first, that men
had been dismissed without notice from
the company's employ because they were
members of the union, and, secondly,
that the Western Union, its officers and
its agents had entered into a conspiracy
to destroy the union.
The appUcation for an injunction was
denied, and Judge Rogers in the decision
held that in the absence of contract re-
lations the employer has the same right
to discharge any employee, with or with-
out notice, as the employee has, under
the same conditions, to quit the service
of the company.
In regard to the charge of conspiracy
to destroy the union by discharging
members thereof, the Federal Judge's
opinion was that the dismissals were
lawful and that there could be no con-
spiracy in doing a lawful thing.
N. & W. Building 500 Cars.
To meet the constantly increasing
growth of its coal traffic, the Nor-
folk and Western Railwa> has an-
nounced that it will build 500 new cars
at its own shops, for fall delivery. The
cars will have a carrying capacity of 100,-
000 pounds and will have under frames
of steel. Double I-beams, bolsters and
truck frames of the barber type will .be
used, with cast steel center places. The
bottom will be constructed of copper.
The additional rolling stock will repre-
sent an outlay of about $500,000.
Norfolk is one of the greatest coal
distributing ports on the Atlantic coast,
and the trade is rapidly increasing in
volume every year. The Norfolk and
Western has announced that it will con-
tinue to haul cars as the conditions jus-
tify. The 500 new cars will be ready for
service when the fall activity in shipping
begins.
Tests of speed with the new Mail Train
No. 43 on the Lake Shore & Michigan
Southern were made between Toledo and
Cleveland the other day. Engine 651, with
Engineer Charles Parish, covered 108
miles in no minutes. Eleven minutes
were consumed on the first six miles due
to an arbitrary grade. The 102 miles fol-
lowing were covered in 99 minutes. This
included five slow-downs and a loss of
5 minutes at Sandusky, which brings the
actual time_ consumed for the 102 miles,
with 5 mail cars, down to 94 minutes.
n. C. B. Report on Cast Iron Wheels.
The M. C. B. committee on cast iron
wheels made some interesting observa-
tions in their report to the Association
on the design, weight and material for
cast iron wheels for cars of 60,000, 80,000
and 100,000 pounds. In answer to a cir-
cular which was sent out by the commit-
tee to all members of the Association
and to prominent wheel makers, there
were submitted to the committee some
twenty different designs of wheels for
the three capacities of cars, given above,
which designs were giving satisfactory
results in actual service.
The committee had each of these
wheel drawings made full size on card-
board and cut out. The committee then
made a composite wheel draving by
grouping all those designs where tlie
contours of the plates were fairly alike
were placed one over the other, and a
composite drawing was made, these com-
posite drawings were again plotted and a
final composite drawing was made for
three wheels, suitable each to the three
capacities of 60,000, 80,000 and 100,000
pounds. The committee regards these
"evolved" designs as giving a very hand-
some wheel and thinks that though they
may not be any better than any of the
designs from which they were made,
yet the committee were of opinion that
the designs of these representative wheels
which they thus worked out, would be
at least equal to the best design now
in use, and one safe to be followed in
making new patterns. This original
method of producing one wheel from
many designs reminds us of the defini-
tion sometimes given of a proverb. A
proverb is said to be "the wisdom of
many and the wit of one." These wheel
designs are the result of experience on
many roads and the composite design is
due to the skill of one committee.
A form of wheel design was submitted
by one manufacturing concern which is
intended for wheels of ioo,ooo-lb. cars.
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
433
It is a double plate wheel, but the out-
side and inside plates run separately
from hub to rim, and so include a large
core space. Sixteen ribs on the inside
plate are introduced into the core space,
and both plates are curved slightly out-
ward on lines which are at once easy and
graceful. The committee, while submit-
ting this design to the Association along
with the other composite ones, makes no
comment on the maker's design on ac-
count of having no data concerning its
behavior in service.
Baltimore & Ohio Articulated Loco-
motive.
The huge locomotive here illustrated
is under construction for the Baltimore
& Ohio Railroad, and will be consider-
ably heavier than any other locomotive
ever built. This engine will be built as
an experiment and will be used as a
helping engine on mountain grades to
demonstrate its usefulness. If found sat-
isfactory it wnll be sent to the St. Louis
Exhibition.
point at C. The boiler slides on sup-
ports at A and B, and a joint has to be
made in the steam pipe.
The leading dimensions of this tre-
mendous engine are:
Weiplit til workiiiR order. 28,";. 000 ]t>s.; riRid wheel
ba.se, 10 ft.; total, .^o.s ft.
Cylinders. j,i and 20 x 32 in,; wheels, 56 in, dia.
lialaiiced slide valves,
Boiler, waKoii top, 76 ins. dia.; firebox, 105 ins.
lonp, 77 ins, wide; tubes. 376, 7'% ins. dia.
Heating svirlace of tubes, 4,135 R(l. ft,; heating sur-
face of firebox, 190 sq. ft. ; grate sur., 56. i sq. ft.
Ratio— Heating surface to grate surface, 77.1;
heating surface to cylinder volume, ,0068;
tractive power, 63,800 pounds; heating surface
to tractive power, 15.43; tractive power to
weight on drivers, 4.46.
Saving from High Pressure Steam.
riic tendency of locomotive designing
keeps toward increasing the boiler pres-
sure, and it is difficult to tell when a
limit will be reached. I was giving a
talk a short time ago on the progress
of locomotive engineering to a meeting
of railroad men and after the meeting
was over several of them expressed the
= 0.1886
tions. Experiments have located this
point at 460° Fah. below zero, so to re-
duce to absolute temperature, add this
figure to the readings of a common ther-
mometer.
The temperature of steam at 200
pounds is 388° and at 140 pounds boiler
pressure 361° and at S pounds 2j8°. Re-
ducing to absolute temperatures and
substituting in the above »ormula we
have for engines using steam at 200
pounds
848—688
^ "~84r
For engines using steam at 140 pounds
821—688
E 3^^ =0,1620
DifTerence in favor of 200 pounds, .0266
or 2j^ per cent.
That is not a great saving for people
who are always looking for at least 25
per cent, saving for any improvement,
but it counts up on an engine when the
whole of the monthly fuel bill is con-
sidered.
Albert Conveth.
New Haven, Conn.
The engine is of the Mallet articulated
type, which has been used very success-
fully in France and Switzerland for many
years. Small specimens of the Mallet
type of compound locomotives were used
in the grounds of the last two Paris
expositions, and they were reported to
be highly efficient. We think the type
is particularly well adapted to mountain
service in any country and we have been
surprised that it was not introduced into
this country before. The Baltimore &
Ohio was the first railroad company in
the world to introduce the use of freight
locomotives weighing more than twenty
tons, and it is quite fitting that they
should take the lead in introducing a
practical freight engine weighing over
one hundred tons.
This locomotive really consists of two
engines with power transmitting mechan-
ism for each. They are compound; the
forward cylinders being H. P. and the
back pair L. P. The front cylinders
with their saddle and the wheels can
move radially under the boiler with radial
A. IVIOIMS-rER l-OC:OIVIOTI\/E.
belief, very freely that locomotives car-
rying steatn of 140 pounds gauge pres-
sure did their work just as economically
as engines do that are now carrying 200
pounds gauge pressure. I find that this
opinion is held by many practical rail-
road men. As it is difficult to show
by experiment the saving effected by the
higher pressure owing to the difficulty
of getting people to undertake exhaus-
tive shop tests I shall show by calcula-
tion that there is economy in using high
pressure steam.
The mechanical theory of heat is ad-
mitted to be correct and its teaching has
brought about very great improvements
in the steam engine. Authorities on the
mechanical theorv of heat gives the effi-
T — T
ciency of a perfect engine as E = — 7^ —
where T represents the absolute tem-
perature of the steam before doing work
and T, after it is ready to pass through
the exhaust. Absolute temperature
means reckoning from the point where
there are supposed to be no heat vibra-
Kerosene Leakage.
While it is true that kerosene is of a
penetrating nature, and that it will leak
through a very narrow crack, it is also
the case that water is nearly, if not
quite, as penetrating. One reason why
a leakage of water through a narrow
crack is not so apparent as that of kero-
sene is that it evaporates and leaves lit-
tle or no trace of the leak. Again, if
there is any sediment or suspended min-
eral matter carried by the water, the
evaporation soon leaves a deposit that
effectually seals the crack and prevents
further leakage. In the case of kerosene
the leakage does not evaporate, or does
so very slowly, and spreads over the out-
side of the vessel, making its presence
very apparent, whereas the total leakage
may be quite small. With the oil there
is no tendency for a leak to seal itself,
but, on the contrary, kerosene is of a
highly solvent nature, and tends to re-
move all deposits clogging the crack. —
National Oil Reporter.
4?4
RAILWAY AXU l.OCOMOllVE EXGIXRii RING
September, 1903.
Railway Matters in India.
British India appears to be suffering
from evils connected with its railway
system, which have been paralleled in
the United States in the construction
of canals. The work has fallen into the
hands of people who do not require to
make the enterprises pay, and the tax-
payers who have to provide the capital
sometimes receive less remuneration in
utility and convenience than justice and
fair dealing demands. There are about
30,000 miles of railway in India which
is not very great for a territory of 1,458,-
000 square miles, with about three
hundred million inhabitants; but the
conditions of life are so peculiar there that
one of the most influential newspapers
in Bombay recently made the assertion
that it is a highly problematical ques-
tion whether India would not actually
have been better off without a railway
than she is to-day with a system which
has no parallel outside of Europe. The
writer of that remark holds, that those
who glory in the lengthening railway
mileage mistake exhaustion for progress,
and sacrifice profit-producing irrigation
to the profitless railway development.
Judging from the tone of the railway
press of India, to which we devote con-
siderable attention, we conclude that
Indian railways are suffering from
a species of, "not how to do it" bu-
reaucracy. They are too much domi-
nated by officials whose principal ability
lies in the line of drawing large salaries.
Too great a percentage of the earnings
of Indian railways has been devoted to
paying ornamental officials, while the
men who perform the real work are un-
derpaid.
The discontentment which has long
prevailed about the unsatisfactory man-
agement of the railways of India for
many years, moved the Government of
India to appoint Mr. Thomas Robertson,
C. V. O., whatever that may mean, a
special commissioner to inquire into the
working of the Indian railway systein,
and his report was published a few
months ago. The commissioner appears
to have done the work thoroughly, and
his recommendations would no doubt
effect desirable remedies if they were
only carried out.
The commissioner is very positive in
his condemnation of the administrative
machinery in existence, and the practical
effect of his finding is that railway ad-
ministration is antiquated, ineffective,
wasteful, cramped, wanting in expert
knowledge and generally confused. His
chief recommendation for remedy is
drastic, but on the face of it apparently
sound. He says the existing system, so
far as general revision by Government
is concerned, should be swept away, and
that in its place should be appointed
a board of experts with home training.
The last point is insisted upon, not be-
cause suitable men are not available
in India, but because in the initial stage,
and while the department is being put
into proper working order, they should
be free from local prejudices and tradi-
tions. The operations of this board, to
be successful, should be excluded from
the general administration of Govern-
ment, and, unless they are so excluded
and the board is allowed to manage the
railways entirely on commercial lines,
the success they should achieve cannot
possibly be secured. Subject to the con-
trol of the Governor-General in Council,
the board should otherwise be left en-
tirely free to administer the railways,
and they should be judged by results.
"It is very desirable," he says, "that
the principal officer, that is, the agent
or manager, on each railway should have
had special training in the working of
traffic. It is difficult otherwise for him
to deal efficiently with the many ques-
tions which must come before him in
connection with the chief business of the
railway. At present this appears to be
the last qualification required of an
agent or manager. Senior officers on
every railway should be sent home at
the expense of their employers at reg-
ular intervals to study improvements
made since their last visit, so as to keep
themselves abreast of the times in their
railway knowledge."
We certainly think that the fundamental
principle of good railway management
is, that the principal officer should know
his business, although that does not seem
to have always been a requirement in
India; but we doubt the value of having
thein drawn exclusively from Britain or
that they should keep abreast of the
times of railway knowledge as it is found
in Great Britain. British railway man-
agement of Canadian railways inclines us
to think that Indian railway officials
woidd profit more by keeping in touch
with railroad operating in the United
States, for the conditions are much more
in unison. If the railway officials in
India make a systematic study of the
.Vmerican railroad press they will not
miss the introduction of many improve-
ments that would be helpful in their
business.
The following criticisms and recom-
mendations of the commissioner sound
like what a good American railroad man-
ager would make:
"The average speed of trains is not
as high as might be expected in a coun-
try which has had the benefit of railway
communication for nearly fifty years.
The speed of the fastest trains ranges
from 22 to 30 miles an hour, and that
of slow passenger trains from 7 tO' 17
miles an hour. This cannot be justified
by the poverty of the traffic, because
the average number of passengers per
train is greater in India than in any
other country in the world. It is partly
due to the actual working speed and part-
ly to dilatory arrangements for watering
engines and for performing station duties
at stoppage places. A very material ac-
celeration of speed is necessary for the
purpose of cultivation of traffic, and the
existing staff is qui'Q capable of working
the trains at a much higher speed with
safety.
"On the principal main lines there
should be not less than tw'o fast through
passenger trains each way per day, and
on every other line not less than two
ordinary trains. Dining cars should be
provided on all fast through services to
economize lime.
"Railw-ays in India are insufficiently
appreciative of the value of their third
class passengers traffic. The less paying
first and second class traffic appears to
receive all the attention, whereas the
traffic which really needs to be fostered
is that represented by the third class
passengers, who are the backbone of the
passenger business of every railway in
India. Overcrowding should oe avoided.
The system of conveying pilgrirfis in cat-
tle trucks also points to the same ab-
sence of proper facilities. Generally
speaking the amount of stock provided
on trains for third class passengers is
inadequate; moreover, third class pas-
sengers are subjected to gross incivility,
annoyance, abuse, extortion, and even
personal violence by the subordinate sta-
tion staff, and by the police. This is
a matter which calls for very special
attention.
"Electric lighting and electric fans
should be introduced and made compul-
sory within a fi.xed number of years,
say, five.
"Goods traffic should be greatly quick-
ened. The present speed ranges from
three to seven miles an hour. This in-
tolerable state of things is due largely
to want of a proper system of running
goods traffic, and the whole arrange-
ments need complete revision, on drastic
lines indicated in the report.
"Fares and rates are too high. Judged
from the standpoint of actual money
payment made they are considerably
lower than in England, but taking the
cost of construction and working of rail-
ways in the two countries the fares and
rates in India should be only about one-
sixth those charged in England, whereas
this rate is greatly exceeded. The re-
duction should be made for passengers
by. 18 to 40 per cent., for merchandise
by 30 to 60 per cent., and for coal by
40 to 60 per cent. These large reduc-
tions could not be made straight away,
but considerable reductions are immedi-
ately possible."
People accustomed from infancy to lie
on down feathers, have no idea how hard
a paving stone is without trying it.
— Hard Times.
September, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE F.NGINEERLN'G
435
Fifty Miles
More per Pint.
One thing" the en-
gineer should not forget,
and that is that when he
uses Dixon's Graphite
he uses less oil, and that
the Graphite doesn't
cost as much as the oil,
and that very little
Graphite is required.
Some engineers draw
their full allowance of
oil and then do not have
enough. This puts you
in a bad light with the
master mechanic.
A little Dixon's Graph-
ite will enable you to
run farther with less oil
and keep your engine in
better condition.
Says a sensible en-
gineer :
" I tind we are making fifty per
cent, more miles per pint cylinder
oil and using only one ounce of
Graphite per cylinder for 2S5 miles
run."
If this engineer can do
that, wliat can you not
do with your engine ?
Let us send you a sample
to try on your engine.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
JERSEY CITY. N. J.
High Smoke Box Temperature.
A mechanical engineer of a western
railroad is reported to have made the
following statement to a reporter:
"We find that our 19x24 inch lo-whcel
engines with 1,700 square feet of heat-
ing surface and 30 square feet of grate
area are very limited in the capacity to
get freight up a long, heavy grade. Thry
are not lacking in cylinder power, but In
the ability to make steam. The incapacity
of the boiler is further indicated by the
fact that the gases escape from the smoke
box at a temperature of 1,200 degrees and
over, while our recent engines discharge
their smoke box gases at only (100 de-
grees."
If the interview was a real one, the
mechanical engineer must have been bad-
ly oflf concerning smoke box temperatures.
A temperature of 1,200 degrees would
keep the smoke box red hot and is
higlier than the temperature of fire
bo.xcs when the engine is working hard.
Tuition to rtcclwt
(Ac wAMta
Tt be »»curely holtnl to boarS*
between the tracks
Jtii. f Loro. Eng.
HAXDY RIG FOR TURNING WHEELS.
Handy Wheel Press Jack.
A handy jack for turning mounted car
wheels is to be seen in the Ottawa shops
of the Canada Atlantic Railway. It con-
sists, as may be seen in the illustration,
of a short upright casting or piller which
has a wide V-shaped top into which the
axle to be turned, fits. The upright cast-
ing is made to rock on an intermediate
one. but it is provided with a lip so that
the rocking can only take place in one
direction. This intermediate casting is
pivoted into a circular base so that it can
be turned about in any horizontal direc-
tion.
When the jack is ready for use it
stands leaning over at a slight angle,
supported by the strut which hangs from
the small eye-piece which is bolted to
one of the central ribs, and as the pair of
wheels come along the track the center
of the axle just passes over the side of
the inclined V, and strikes the other. The
momentum of the rolling wheels carries
the jack to the upright position, and at
the same time it lifts the wheels from the
rails. The operator is then able to swing
them wherever required and with a slight
push, tilt the jack, which discharges its
load with sufficient momentum to bring
them up to the wheel press, or run them
down the shop track for storage or use.
Something; lor Their noney.
Some years ago a railway was being
made in the neighborhood of Galashiels,
and it was arranged that each of the nu-
merous navvies employed should pay one
penny per week to a medical practitioner,
so that they might have his services in
the event of accident or medicine in the
case of illness.
During the summer and autumn neither
illness nor accident occurred.
But when a severe winter followed, all
at once the "navigators" began to call
on the doctor for castor oil.
Each brought his bottle, into which
an ounce was poured, until the oil was
exhausted, and the doctor was forced to
send to Edinburgh for a further supply.
When that, too, was getting done, the
doctor one day quietly asked a decent-
looking fellow what was wrong with the
men that they required so much castor
oil.
"Nothing wrong at all, doctor," he re-
plied, "but we grease our boots with it."
The Car Shortage.
Despite the fact that the Pennsylvania
Railroad now has 213,000 freight cars,
31,000 more than in 1901, there is a car
shortage on the road and its branches.
The situation is so threatening that Gen-
eral Manager W. W. Atterbury has is-
sued an appeal to consignees asking
their co-operation to 'prevent such a
catastrophe. From a ready movement
of freight on all divisions of the Penn-
sylvania Railroad it is evident that the
shortage i» not due to tratftc but solely
to delay in relieving cars at destination
points. Grain is often held in the West
to await more favorable market condi-
tions. Suddenly this bulk is rushed to
the eastern ports in such manner as to
make it impossible to unload the cars,
thus tying them up in loaded trains.
This condition is affecting all the larger
lines. The same is true of other com-
modities, especially coal at the lake ports.
The Ear Racking Flat Wheels.
The flat car wheel is greatly in evi-
dence on street cars. That its ear rack-
ing noise has been endured so long with-
out murmurs that would rival the noise
made by the wheels is adequate testi-
mony for the patient long suffering of the
American citizen. Brooklyn, N. Y., ap-
pears to have been the first community
to lose patience. A petition signed by
fift)'-nine petitioners, residents of Pros-
pect Park West, has been received at
the Health Department, complaining
that the flat wheel cars which are now
operated on that street make sleep al-
most impossible, and that invalids and
others are seriously affected bj* the con-
stant thumping of cars, and ask that the
Department of Health take action in the
matter.
436
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 190J-
Tlie Board of Health has declared ttie
running of flat wheel cars a public nui-
sance, and the matter is now in the hands
of the Corporation Counsel. An arrest
has been made and the matter is now
before the Court of Special Sessions.
The Mexican Great Eastern Railway,
now under construction, will, when com-
pleted, connect the city of Mexico with
its port, the town of Coatzacoa, on the
Gulf of Mexico. The road will be about
400 miles long and lies amid moun-
tainous country. Mr. Walter G. Seaver,
vice-president and general manager of
the road, was recently in New York and
has placed orders with the American Lo-
comotive Company for ten passenger
engines, twenty freight, and four switch
engines. The passenger engines are of
the 4-6-2 type, simple, with 21x26 in.
cylinders, 62 in. drivers and a total
weight of about 180,000 lbs. The freight
engines are 2-8-0, simple, with cylinders
22x26 ins., 56 in. drivers and weight in
all about 200,000 lbs. The special equip-
ment consists of Armspear classification
signal lamps, Snow rerailing device and
the Handy Coupler on pilots.
eases that have developed on people rid-
ing automobiles at high speed, indicat-
ing that a pace out of the ordinary gait
is dangerous to health. We do not think
this is proved in the case of locomotive
engineers who are jarred very consider-
ably more than automobile riders, and
are among the healthiest class of the
community. Among our newspaper
clippings received in one day we find an
account of one locomotive engineer still
in good health who had run a locomotive
for 51 years, another in a similar con-
dition who had run 53 years, and one
veteran who had begun running four
years after the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road was opened, is still living in a green
old age. The name of the latter veteran
is Mr. Christian Smith, now living at
Harper's Ferry.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company
are building at Altoona a steel passenger
coach to be used in the tunnels 01 New
York. The experience in building the
car has suggested quite a number of im-
provements, wlrich will be carried out
in the other cars to be built. It is 50
feet long, vestibuled, and has no steps,
they being unnecessary, owing to the
depressed tracks. The car is equipped
with Westinghouse air brakes, and is
heated with steam and lighted by elec-
tric generators. The seats are of rattan.
The car is an experimental one, and
is made on plans that will allow its use
in interchangeable traffic with the inter-
borough lines of Greater New York.
Joseph T. Ryerson & Son, of Chicago,
makers of steel structural shapes, etc.,
have just got out a desk inkstand of
unique design, which they are sending
to their friends. The inkwell itself rep-
resents a pile of circular stamped shapes,
such as cylinder covers, with half a
chain link on top, and tnis inkwell stands
upon a number of steel boiler plates and
a couple of piles of steel and galvanized
iron plates, and between these piles a
number of Ts, angles, I-beams, Z-bars,
channels, square and round iron, are
placed, and on top are two kegs of nails,
which in the model are arranged one as
a pen wiper and the other as a small pin
cushion. A pile of tubes and a pair of
miniature forgings make a very inge-
nious pen rack. This is a very useful as
well as a striking desk ornament.
It is wonderful the vitality of some
false statements. An item has been go-
ing the rounds of the press for six
months that there are 500,000 locomo-
tives in this country, and almost every
day we receive the item dished up in
a new form, frequently with comments
on the aggregate power of such an army
of locomotives. One cipher too much
is used and 50,000 is about the correct
number.
The Associated Press Reporter of Bal-
timore appears to have got hold of a
story about an immense locomotive
about to be built for the Baltimore &
Ohio Railroad to weigh over 150 tons,
and the story is going all over the
country. We understand that that com-
pany contemplate having some unusually
heavy locomotives built, but the story of
the Reporter is an extreme exaggeration.
The Wabash Railroad are experiment-
ing with a locomotive having what is
known as the Haberkorn valve motion.
We learn from one of the master me-
chanics that the engine is doing very
good work, but they are not prepared
to say anything definite about it at
present.
We have received a neatly bound vol-
ume of the Official Proceedings of the
Western Railway Club for the club year
1902-1903. The book is, of course, stand-
ard size, bound in cloth, with an alpha-
betical index at the back. It contains
a number of useful and instructive
papers on live topics.
Owing to labor troubles among their
workmen at Springfield, Mass., the Bos-
ton & Albany people have decided to re-
move the mechanical headquarters of the
road to Worcester.
We frequently notice articles in auto-
mobile papers telling about certain dis-
We have just finished our new Book
of Books. Every man likely to buy a
book for self help ought to keep a copy
handy for reference.
s
s
^l
a
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
437
Q and C Priest
Snow Flanger
Can be uperated with perfect safety
on all trains.
Gives clean rails for all wheels and
prevents derailments.
Adopted as standard by many of
the leading roads.
Order now ; don't wait.
.M.'iiri for rntaloL', lur^'i- dniwiiii:
of fiiLritic ;iiiii 'lniu'nt*ii>n f^lirrls.
Railway Appliances
Company
GENERAL OEEICES
Old Colony BIdg., Chicago
New York Store, 107 Liberty St.
MORAS FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
N«. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. NEW YORK.
The Trans-Siberian Railway.
Traveling on the new Trans-Siberian
Railway, from all accounts does not
appear to be by any means the
uncomfortable journey which many
persons thought it would be. Every
Monday, Wednesday and Saturday the
Tri-Weekly Trans-Siberian Express is
run by the Compagnie Internationale, on
other days the Russian State Railway
runs its trains. The express train con-
sists of one first-class coach, which holds
eighteen persons, and in addition there
are seven small compartments, each
holding two persons, and one compart-
ment for four persons, thus giving ac-
commodation for thirty-six in all. Two
second-class coaches holding in the body,
twenty-si.K persons, three compartments
in each car, hold two people, with five
compartments for four people, making
the total second-class accommodation
sufficient for fifty-two in each coach.
There is also a restaurant car with smok-
ing saloon, and also a car called a
"fourgon," virhich has a bathroom.
to the car attendant and the otiier in
communication with the restaurant.
"Each night the attendant would noake
up a comfortable bed, soft and clean, and
the regulation is that the linen be
changed three times in the eight days.
A touch of the bell in the early morning,
and a boy brought a cup of tea. Ten
minutes later there was a rap at the
door, and the attendant entering, put
down your boots he had polished and
told you the bath was ready.
"As the rails are wide, the coaches
heavy, and the speed something under
thirty miles an hour, there was none of
that side-jerking which is so incon-
venient on an English line. The train
ran smoothly, with only a low dull thud
to remind you that you were traveling.
So steady was the going that I shaved
every morning without a disaster.
"Returning to my coupe, I found the
bed removed, the place swept and aired,
and the attendant spraying the corridor
with perfume."
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
CHISA
MAP OK THE TRANS-SIBERIAN RAII.\V.\V— MOSCOW TO PORT ARTHIR.
Reproduced from The Car.
lavatories, provision compartment and
an installation of electric light machin-
ery.
At the present time part of the main
line round the southern end of Lake
Baikal, near Irkutsk, is under construc-
tion, and the traveler is now compelled
to cross the lake, train and all, on a huge
ice-breaking ferry. The time occupied
in crossing is usually about four hours.
Mr. John Foster Eraser has recently
published his impressions of a trip from
Moscow to Vladivostock and back, in
book form. He has called his work "The
Real Siberia." Speaking of the journey,
among other things, he says:
"The train was luxuriously fitted, and
first-class passengers (there not being
many) had each a couple of seats to
themselves, double-windowed to keep out
the cold, hot-air pipes in plenty, and a
thermometer on the wall so that they
might see the temperature; a writing
table, a chair, a movable electric lamp
with green shade, two electric bells, one
Study and Profit.
In Charles Dickens' instructive and in-
teresting story called LiMe Dorrit, there
occurs these words, which might almost
make a text for a sermon: "Study, and
profit by all that lies beyond it, like a
practical man." We have no intention
of writing a sermon, but we may here
remark that the quotation given above
contains an excellent piece of advice.
Study; that is an essential, if any man
or boy would succeed in his life's work.
Studying is really drinking in the con-
centrated experience of others. At the
present time the reading of books is the
most usual way of getting hold of the
thoughts of those who have worked bi-
fore us, but there is another matter
besides mere study to which Dickens
draws attention, it is to profit by all
that lies beyond study. Now the thing
which lies beyond study is the assimi-
lating of what has been taken in. It is
like digesting the food which has been
eaten. To profit by that which lies be-
yond study, one must call into play the
43S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
faculty of reflection. It is no great use
to merely know the answer to a ques-
tion on locomotive firing or running or
some such subject and at the same time
not to know why the answer is right,
or how to apply the knowledge to cir-
cumstances slightly different from those
under which the answer was learned.
Study, the taking in of facts, is the first
process. Reflection, or the understand-
ing of the facts, the examining of the
facts, the turning of them over and over,
talking about them, this is the second
process and this is being able to profit
by all that lies beyond study. The great
writer and portrayer of human lives,
says to do this "like a pra;tical man."
In order to assist in study and in the
enjoyment and profit of that which lies
beyond it we invite you to cast your eye
over a few of the books which we re-
commend to our friends:
The first on the list is, of course.
Railway and Loco.motive Engineer-
ing, a practical journal of railway mo-
tive power and rolling stock. It costs
only $2.00 a year, and is well worth the
money, and besides the paper is a wel-
come visitor in every household. Let
your wife and boys see it.
"Locomotive Engine Runnmg and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
01 railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of ray success in life to the inspiration
of that book. It was my pocket com-
panion for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book combining in-
struction with amusement. It is a par-
ticularly useful book to the young me-
chanic. It has a stimulating effect in in-
ducing him to study his business. Price,
50 cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used
by many master mechanics and travel-
ing engineers in the examination of fire-
men for promotion and of engineers
likely to be hired. It contains m small
compass a large amount of information
about the locomotive. Convenient pocket
size. We cordially recommend this
book. The price is 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book instructs a man so that he
will understand the construction and
operation of a compound locomotive as
well as he now understands a simple
engine. Tells all about running, about
breakdowns and repairs. Convenient
pocket size, bound in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant.'
Hemenway. Contains information that
will enable a man to take out a license
to run a stationary engine. Tells about
boilers, heating surface, horse power,
condensers, feed water heaters, air
pumps, engines, strength of boilers, test-
ing boiler performances, etc., etc. This
is only a partial list of its contents. It
is in the question and answer style. IJ8
pages. Pocket size. Price, 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a foreman boilermaker. Also con-
tains several chapters on oil-burning
locomotives. Price, 50 cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. Price, $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no
person engaged in mechanical occupa-
tions can afford to do without. Enables
any workman to figure out all the shop
and machine problems which are so
puzzling for want of a little knowledge.
We sell it for 50 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of coan-
bustion. While treating on the chemis-
try of heat and combustion is easily
understood by every intelligent fireman.
The price is 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger.
Nothing better can be found for persons
trying to learn all about air brakes.
Tells the whole story. We sell it. Cloth,
75 cents. Leather, $1.00.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those
who have not read these stories have
missed a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Block and Interlocking Signals."
Elliott. Tells what signals are, what
they do and how they do it. Compre-
hensive treatise on the subject. Ought
to be studied by all trainmen where
block signals are used. $3.00.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating of all trains on single or dou-
ble track. Used by nearly all railroads.
Study of this book would prevent many
collisions. Price, 5° cents.
"Mechanical Engineers' Pocket
Book." Kent. This book contains
1,100 pages 6x3j4 inches of closely-
printed minion type, containing mechan-
ical engineering matter. It ought to be
in the book case of every engineer who
takes an interest in engineering ques-
tions. We use it constantly as a refer-
ence for questions sent to us to be
answered. Full of tables and illustra-
tions. Morocco leather. $5.00.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
A.Leschen& Sons Rope Co.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
HOME OFFICE:
920-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
( 137 K. Lake St., ChicaRo. 111.
Branch Offices \ 92 Centre St., New York City. N^Y,
j Rialto Bldg , San Francisco, Cal.
( 1717-23 Arapahoe St., Denver, Col.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Buildlag;, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
lAYLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's :;S,Ss;':e"-' Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE QOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sol* Representative!. In the United States,
Canada and Hexlco
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tasts and Consultation,
1137 THE ROOKERV, CHICAOO.
seBroadway, N«w York. Park BulldiDg, PlttGbarfh
31 Norfolk House, Loudon, Eog.
Inrpection of Stesl Ralls, Splice Bars, Eallroad Care,
Wbeels, AxJes, etc. Chemical Laboratory— Analyiis
of Ores, Iron, Steel, Oils, Water, etc. Physical Labo-
ratory—Test of Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lara, Draw Bars, etc.
ElBciencr Tests of Boilers, Engines and liOcomotlrea.
September, 1903.
RAH.WAY AND I OCfJ.VUrnVE ENGINERKING
43V
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
16 AND
SIZE,
17 A>n 21 «i n»
JKWKI.S,
SAI'PIIIIIK PALLETS
BAM/S IMI'KOVED
SAKKTV
DOrni.K KOLLKB
Are without qiicatlon
the fliicBt wntclu'H that
Anu-rictin talent and
Bkilli'il labor can pro-
ilucu, anil they are giv-
ing Buch universal sat-
isfaction that vpe have
no hcpltaticy In claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests severe and numerous have proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorlEed agent In nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
Writfi us for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch IVlanufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco-
motive. It will be found particularly
useful to men handling or repairing
compound locomotives. It is the real
locomotive up to date. $2.50.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
iNi;. Bound volumes. $3.00.
WHITNEY PLANERS
Fitted with Sectional Feed Rolls
will simultaneously take thick
and thin pieces and plane
them to an even thickness.
Write for Our Catalog
Business Dull at the nanchester
Locomotive Shops.
Most of the locomotive building shops
are so busy that it is strange to read
of workmen being laid off, but this has
happened at the Manchester shops of the
-American Locomotive Company, where
157 men were laid off. Those affected
were mostly planers and drillers, the
new hands and the night force suffering
greatest.
The boiler and blacksmith shops had
only half the regular force at work, due
to lack of stock, but those are not in-
cluded in the number laid off.
At present, the working force of the
company, both night and day crews, con-
sists of only about 300 men, the general
force being about 600 hands.
The Peterborough Hydraulic Power
Company, of which Senator Geo. A. Cox
is president, is building a new power
plant on the Otonabee River in the Town
of Peterborough, Ontario, Canada, which
will be equipped with the following ap-
paratus, recently purchased from the
Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing
Company: A 1,500 kilowatt, 2,240 volt
generator, having 7,200 alternations and
running at 150 revolutions per minute, to
lie direct connected to water wheels ; also
two 125 volt, D. C, direct coupled ex-
citers of 7S kilowatts capacity each ; to-
gether with switchboard consisting of a
large generator panel and two exciter
panels. This power house, when com-
pleted, will be an unusually fine one and
is to furnish power to the Peterborough
Mill of the .American Cereal Company,
owned by the Quaker Oats Company;
power will be supplied to several other
manufacturing plants in the town, and
also to the Peterborough Light & Power
Company, which does the electric light-
ing and small power business in Peter-
borough.
fire by accident and the electric mechan-
ism. The terrible accident which liap-
pencd in Paris last month where some
sixty people lost their lives, seems to
be looked upon as a dreadful warning.
We feel assured, however, that the
cars under construction for the under-
ground railways in New York will be
absolutely fire proof, even when the
worst kinds of accidents happen. They
are built mostly of steel, and floors and
doors will be coated with fire proof
material.
Baxter D. Whitney & Son
WINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
CEO. P. WHITTLESET,
HcGltL BUILDIKG, WMHIIIGTO«. 0. C.
Term! Reasonable. P«mphlet Sen*
The Heffcrnan Engine Works filed ar-
ticles of incorporation in the county
auditor's office, at Seattle, last month.
J. T. Heffernan and Nellie Gertrude
Heffernan are the incorporators. The
capital stock of the company is placed
at $50,000. Mr. J. T. Heffernan was a
regular contributor to Locomotive En-
gineering a few years ago.
For the last year we have found a
great many newspaper articles about the
Standard Motive Power Co., a $10,000,-
000 concern, which was building immense
shops at Canaldover, O., for the con-
struction of what is known as the Dodge
locomotive. The locomotive is a freak
of the worst kmd, and now the company
that was trying to float it against na-
ture's laws have fallen into the mire
themselves. A receiver was lately ap-
pointed for the company.
The Compensating \'alve Co., Wil-
mington, N. C, are making a throttle
valve that is worthy of general applica-
tion. The ordinary throttle valve is a
triumph of bad designing. To say that
it is balanced is distorting facts; it is
secured in the dome as if it would never
have to be looked at, with the result that
grinding the joint is a job to dread.
The company's new valve designed by
Mr. J. S. Chambers is quite the reverse.
It is a finely balanced valve and the
stand is designed so that a man can get
inside the dome. It is a great comfort to
engineers, who ought to insist that their
engines be equipped with this valve.
Mr. Charles T. Chapin, president and
superintendent of the Rochester Car
Wheel Works, who is very well known
to railroad men, has been engineering
a trust to absorb all the car wheel
makers of the countn,-. His scheme
worked very smoothly until he struck
the Massachusetts car wheel makers,
who would have nothing to do with the
deal. It looks as if Mr. Chapin's trust
plan was not thriving so well as he
e.xpected it would do.
The Chicago, Burlington & Quincy
Railroad Company are extending the prac-
tice of subjecting wooden ties to pre-
serving processes before they are put into
the track, and it is said to be one of the
best investments the company has ever un-
dertaken. To pickle a tie costs from lO
to 12 cents and the process doubles its life
which is a good investment considering
that ties cost over 70 cents each.
There has been considerable talk about
the dangers that will be incurred riding
in the Interurban Rapid Transit tunnels
in New York, due to cars being set on
The first railway was opened in
Canada in 1836. It extended from La
Prairie to St. Johns.
440
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September. 1903.
A Breakdown Question.
Should or could a compound engine,
being towed under the following con-
ditions, form enough compression to
knock a cylinder head out? She was
towed in with rods up and valve con-
nected and traveling at very near full
stroke. I claim it is impossible for en-
gine to form any more compression then
than she does in drifting every trip on her
train.
Enquirer.
An engine being towed under these
conditions blew out, or, I should say,
knocked out a high pressure head. How-
ever, the big nuts on back pistons were
both loose, and I claim that this running
at a pretty high rate of speed did the
damage, and that it was not due to any
compression.
M. H. Blount.
We agree with our correspondent's
opinion. — Ed.
The Joseph Dixon Crucible Company,
of Jersey City, N. J., have just issued
a little book called Dixon's Index for
Pencil Users. Now, as civilized man-
kind are pencil users, the catalogue — for
such it is — should reach a very large
audience. The Dixon Company manu-
facture so many varieties of pencils for
"all sorts and conditions of men" that
this index is intended to make easy the
selection of a pencil suitable for a par-
ticular use. Stenographers, office men,
station agents, telegraphers, trainmen,
everyobdy in fact, are included in the
index. For instance, if you are a car
inspector you look up your vocation in
index and then on turning to page 11,
you will find that No. 303 is the pencil
for you, as it meets the requirements
of M. C. B. Association for making out
defect cards, etc. Thus you are lead to
the pencil which you should have. If
you happen to be a draughtsman the
page for your calling will explain the
kind of pencils which are suitable for
your work. This enables you to know
what you want— which is a great thing—
and you can ask for it, and if you like
you can "take no other," as some old
advertisements of food used to advise.
We think we are justified in saying that
this index "fills a long felt want." Write
the Dixon Company for the index.
in front, followed by a pair of carrying
wheels set in front of the huge drivers.
The tender is carried on two 4-wheel
trucks.- The cab is on the front plat-
form and behind the engineer's seat is
one for a "cleaner." The fireman's place
is behind the fire box, which is very
short.
We are not impressed with Mr. Rey-
nolds' ideas as a locomotive designer.
His engine is decidedly inferior to one
designed by the Erie locomotive engi-
neers and exhibited at the Chicago
World's Fair. Locomotive engineers
so far have been more successful in run-
ning than in designing locomotives.
There is a wise Latin saying, Sittor nc
supra orepidam judkaret.
A Celebrated Engine Driver Turns
Designer.
A curious form of express locomotive
has been designed by Mr. Michael Rey-
nolds, the well-known English writer
on locomotive operating subjects. En-
gine and tender are enclosed in a house
which makes it look like a long pas-
senger car. only that a single pair of
driving wheels, lo-feet diameter, and a
pair of diminutive smokestacks indicate
the engine. There is a 4-wheel truck
The Chicago, Burlington & Quincy
shops at Aurora, 111., are working on
an order for a thousand box cars. The
shops are turning out thirty-six cars a
week. There was a movement at one
time to close up these shops and get
all the cars built in contract shops, and
the change, which would have been a
serious blow to Aurora, was averted by
Mr. G. W. Rhodes, who was then Su-
perintendent of Motive Power. He made
a careful investigation of the capacity of
the shops and found that they could
build cars cheaper than the company
could buy them, and they have been
doing the work ever since.
The people of Cleveland seem deter-
mined to secure the convention of the
Fireman's Brotherhood, which had ar-
ranged to meet at Buffalo next year,
and they have offered to spend $20,000
for the entertainment of the delegates.
They think the money will be well spent,
as they expect that during a few weeks
of the session the firemen will spend at
least $200,000. The business men of
Buffalo do not appear to realize what
they are going to miss and the appear-
ance is that the convention will go to
Cleveland.
Someone has been kind enough to
send us a small pamphlet with the cap-
tion "Her First Run." It tells about
a Chicago girl running alone a locomo-
tive for a wager over the Alton Railroad.
The work done by this society Amazon
was to hold her hand on the throttle
while the engineer sat beside her and
did the work. We have no patience
with sensational fads of this character.
The Chicago Car and Locomotive
Works has been incorporated with $100.-
000 authorized capital stock, has acquired
the plant of the Pease Car and Locomo-
tive Works at Hegewisch, 111., and placed
the works in full operation. The ca-
pacity of the plant is being increased.
L. H. Baldwin is president and treas-
urer, and E. Gaidzik secretary.
COLD DRAWN
SEAHLESS STEEL
Locomotive
Boiler
Tubes
AND
Safe Ends
BOILER, TANK AND
STRUCTURAL RIVETS,
WIRE ROPE, SWITCH-
INQ AND WRECKING
ROPES
Miller, Thornburg:h&: Co.
13S = '37 Broadway
New York, U. 5. A.
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINQFIELD, VERMONT, V. 5. A.
A. B.C. and LUbtr*s Code used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
son's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott<>nstrasfte it 2, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
September, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
441
P
ETERS^
ATENT
OCKET
is only to be had in
Brotherhood
overclothcs. ^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made in one of the best
shops in the country.
Union of course. Jt jt
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
Committees for ConductinK the Work
of the American l^ailway flaster
Mechanic's Association for the
Year 1903-1904.
I. — Ton-Mile Statistics:
To confer with the American Railway
Association regarding the mileage allow-
ance for switching engines, and make
positive recommendation to the Conven-
tion of 1904.
C. H. Quereau, Chairman,
G. R. Henderson,
G. L. Fowler.
z. — Coal Consumption on Locomotives:
As affected by enginemen, size of boil-
ers and grates, loss of time on side
tracks, ash pits, terminals, etc.
H. T. Herr, Chairman,
S. K. Dickerson,
R. L. Ettinger.
3. — Locomotive Front Ends:
To assist in tests being conducted at
Purdue University, La Fayette, Indiana,
by the American Engineer and Railroad
Journal, and carry on the tests outlined in
its report at the 1903 Convention.
H. H. Vaughan, Chairman,
F. H. Clark,
Robt. Quayle,
A. W. Gibbs,
W. F. M. Goss.
4. — Locomotive Driving and Truck
Axles and Locomotive Forgings:
To follow up the proposed specifica-
tions as submitted, and make final report
after the meeting of the International
Railway Congress in 1905.
F. H. Clark, Chairman,
E. B. Thompson,
F. W. Lane.
5. — Boiler Design:
To investigate (i) the proper location
of water glasses and gauge cocks in re-
lation to the crown sheet and center line
of boiler; (2) the proper slope of crown
sheet expressed in inches per foot of
length; (3) is the automatic low water
detector a desirable attachment for gen-
eral use on locomotives; (4) the de-
struction of side sheets in wide fire boxes,
and the reasons therefor; (5) the best
form of radial stays; (6) boiler tubes,
with especial reference to length, ar-
rangement and spacing to improve cir-
culation and reduce the trouble from
leaky flues.
D. Van Alstine, Chairman,
C. E. Fuller,
O. H. Reynolds,
H. T. Bentley,
Prof. W. F. M. Goss.
6. — Revision of Standards:
To revise the present standards on (l)
shrinkage allowances, to provide for the
necessary difference between cast iron
and cast steel centers, providing for the
larger diameter tires, 70-90 inches; (2)
to revise boiler and fire box steel speci-
fications; (3) to revise specifications and
tests for boiler tubes, providing for both
steel and iron tubes; (4) to revise speci-
fications and tests for cast iron wheels
for engine trucks and tenders.
T. A. Lawcs, Chairman,
Wm. Forsyth,
\Vm. Garstang.
7— Air-Brake and Signal Instructions:
To revise the present Air-Brake and
Signal Instructions. To confer with com-
mittees of the Master Car Builders' As-
sociation and Air-Brake Men's Associa-
tion.
A. J. Cota, Chairman,
T. R. Browne,
G. W. Wildin.
8. — Piston Valves:
To conduct tests as outlined by report
of committee at Convention of 1903.
Wm. Mcintosh, Chairman,
J. A. Pilcher,
H. F. Ball,
G. R. Henderson,
C. B. Young.
9.— Electrical Equipment of Shops and
Shop Power Houses:
To investigate (l) what do the manu-
facturers need to consider in order to
more fully and satisfactorily meet the
special requirements of railroads as to
electrical machinery; (2) motor driving
for shops; what are essential principles
of successful systems? What are the
possibilities and limitations of variable
speeds in railroad shop practice; (3) all
things considered, what is the most sat-
isfactory system for railroad shops as
developed in actual practice?
C. A. Seley, Chairman,
L. R. Pomeroy,
R. V. Wright,
R. .\tkinson,
E. D. Bronner.
10. — Automatic Stokers:
Has past experience led to the belief
that they may be satisfactory for gen-
eral use on locomotives?
J. F. Walsh, Chairman.
H. T. Herr,
J. G. Neuffer.
II. — Locomotive Frames:
To consider (l) the question of large
locomotives with reference to a study of
the causes of breakage; (2) how shall
distortions, both vertical and horizontal,
be provided for, and which deflection is
most necessary to provide for or pre-
vent? (3) which is the better material,
cast steel or wrought iron?
S. M. Vauclain, Chairman.
J. E. Sague,
Reuben Wells,
S. Higgins,
Alfred Lovell.
12. — Cost of Locomotive Repair Shops:
The following sub-headings are sug-
gested:
442
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
September, 1903.
1. Power Plant. Cost per horse pow-
.er, separating boilers, engines, gener-
ators, buildings, coal and ash handling
facilities, piping, switchboard, etc.
2. Locomotive Shops. Cost per cubic
foot, and cost of machinery on basis of
horse power of tools and tool list.
3. Countershafting. Relative cost of
direct drive as compared with counter-
shafting.
4. Piping. Cost of air, water and
steam.
R. H. Soule, Chairman,
L. R. Pomeroj',
T. H. Curtis,
5. F. Prince, Jr.,
A. E. Manchester.
13. — Safety Appliances for Locomotive
Front Ends:
J. F. Deems, Chairman,
W. S. Morris,
J. Milliken.
14. — Subjects:
H. Bartlett, Chairman.
J. F. Deems,
A. W. Gibbs.
The gross earnings of the Chicago
Great Western Railway (Maple Leaf
Route) for the second week of June,
1903, show an increase of $13^602.63 over
the corresponding week of last year;
being an increase for the fiscal year of
$121,178.36.
THE:
McVICAR
OIL CAN
Jim Skeevers said of it :
"No mechanic who has
used an oil can can help
seeing its advantages."
Made of Rolled Steel.
Cannot be Dented— Will
not Rust.
No Leaking— Oil can't
even ooze out.
every Oper-
Positive in
ation.
Can be held in any posi-
tion without loss of oil.
Flow governed absolutely
by valve.
COFFIN =
HEGEATH
SUPPLY
COMPANY
FRANKLIN, PA..
U. S. A.
Law Concerning (jrab Irons.
We have received a nuticc from .\lr.
Edward A. Moseley, Secretary of the
Interstate Commerce Commission, to the
effect that the law concerning Grab
Irons on locomotives will not be en-
forced until October 15 of this year. In
connection with this notice Mr. Moseley
writes:
Herewith enclosed please find copy of
an order issued by the Commission "In
the Matter of Grab Irons on Locomo-
tives," temporarily extending until Octo-
ber 15, 1903, the time of carriers to com-
ply with the Safety Appliance Law in
regard to grab irons on the front ends
or sides near the front ends of locomo-
tives.
This order was issued upon the appli-
cation of the Atchison, Topeka & Santa
Fe Railway Company. At the hearing
held here on August 5 and 6, which was
attended by representatives of a number
of railway companies and also by repre-
sentatives of railway employees' asso-
ciations, it appeared that the proper loca-
tion of grab irons or hand holds on the
front ends or sides near the front ends
of locomotives was a matter that had
not yet been determined by the Me-
chanical Departments of the railroads,
and that the subject is one which has
been under discussion by the American
Railway Master Mechanics' Association.
This temporary extension of time within
which to comply with the law was
granted to carriers by the Commission
to enable them to come to a satisfactory
determination as to the proper location
of these grab irons on the front ends
or sides near the front ends of locomo-
tives, and not with any view of authoriz-
ing the carriers to dispense with that
requirement of the statute.
It was suggested at the hearing by
railway employees' representatives, and
generally acceded to by the railway rep-
resentatives, that the employees as repre-
sented by their associations should be
consulted with reference to the proper
location of grab irons on the fronts and
sides near the fronts of locomotives;
and also, while the law does not specifi-
cally require it, that the use of a hand
hold on that part of a locomotive would
be greatly facilitated by the addition of
a step. At some convenient date prior
to October 15, 1903, the matter will come
up for further hearing as to the time
necessary to enable proper compliance
with the statute in this respect, and of
that hearing due notice will be given
through the public press or otherwise as
the Commission may determine.
Edw. a. Moseley,
Secretary.
The hardest and best-borne trials are
those which are never chronicled in any
earthly record and are suffered every
day. — Old Curiosity Shop.
DRAUGHTSMAN
Electric Tramway Car Draughtsman re-
quired ; permanent and improving position
to right man. Only these who have had
actual experience in drawing office of
Tramway Car or Railway Carriage or
Wagon Works need apply to No. 999,
Locomotive Engineering office.
FOR SALE
FREIGHT, PASSENGER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
AND
*'-'- ^ADQ QUICK
SIZES. ^^^^O DELIVERIES
F. lUI LJir>UC "5 DEARBORN ST.
. m. niv^i\d) cHicAoo, ILL.
CONTENTS,
PAGE.
Air Brake Department 415
Arctic Railroad 426
Automatic Electric Signals Introduced in
Great Britain 422
Booli Review 413
Box Car for C. of N. J v>. 424
Cochran Pipe Wrench 4"I6
European Notes 405
Fellow Servant Iniquity. The 412
First Sleeping Cars, The 425
General Correspondence 4i)3
Grand Trunk Brake Beam 426
Growth of the Locomotive. By Angus
Sinclair 398
Improved Locomotive Fire Box Door
Flange, An 396
Lining of Shoes and Wedges 420
Loading Locomotives to Their Full Capa-
city 411
Locomotives:
B. & O. Tunnel Electric Locomotive 423
De Glehn for the Pennsylvania 402
Fast Baldwin for N. & W 397
Fast Passenger for E. & T. H 425
L. S. & M. S. Inspection Engine 402
Monster Locomotive for B. & 0 433
Ten-Wheeler for Grand Trunk 429
Mr. Forney as a Newspaper Man 395
New Self-Hardening Tool Steels, etc 412
No Need to Investigate Locomotive Front
Ends 410
"Normal Danger" and the "Normal Clear"
Automatic Block Signal Systems, The 411
Personals 427
Questions Answered 414
Transportation in New York 412
Trans-Siberian Railway 437
Traveling Engineers" Convention 414
Waugh Draw Gear 430
Why Steel Cars Are Popular 4IJ1
INDEX TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
PAOK.
Acme Machinery Co Front Cover
Ajax Metal Co 4th CoTer
Allis-Chalmers Co 14
American Balance Slide Valve Co 3
American Brake Shoe Co 16
American Loco. Sander Co ". 3
American Locomotive Co 19
American Steam Gauge & Valve Mfg. Co.. 7
Armstrong Bros. Tool Co ■ 2d Cover
Armstrong Mfg. Co 21
Asbcroft Mfg. Co —
Baker. Wm. C 8
Baldwin Ljocomotive Works 20
Barnet, G. & H., Co 2d Cover
Becker-Brainard Milling Mch. Co 9
Big Four Railroad 6
Books:
Computers 7
Compound Locomotives 6
Firing Locomotives 4th Cover
Handling Locomotives —
Locomotive Running and Management. . 7
Miscellaneous 10
Oil Burning in Locomotives —
The American Locomotive 17
•a
TO
m
<n
C
o
c
2
o
0)
o
in
O
Si
C
o
O
in
o
cn
in
©>
o
tn
S
t^
CD
0
w
10
0
01
o
o
O
tn
Oi
to
O
S
w
O
Ui
:« % 5=:-
<" ^ ^ •:r'i o ™
3303
0< 0^
5 5- CD
». O 6> q =
5 3 C ^ _
«> •* a. •
0.0
C r~
r> a-
I
i
KEY
M.
n
c
o
c
z
a
t/i
O
o
H
O
03
m
:X3
o
00
o
o 0_
o
>
° CD
o
03
o ^
c
A CD
CO
CO
Q_
0
1—
0
^
0
0
<0
3
0
0
p— t-
in
<
CD
0
0
m
0
13
CPq
-
3
0
0
CD
Ul
-^
13
iG
(rq
0
M
CO
1/1
m
33
Ul
0
m
(/)
1>1
"1
z
0
0
UJ
CO C '^ «i
5^°
0 S
^ - ,- M
'?^£
<« ft "^ s^
■ i » 5 -
1^3 «0
> '
55;
35.0;
p W = < »
0- ^ K *
V( p 1; -t
' -1
3£>i
is; 5^
=; s P
On.
L#
- s K
o &. en
3 c k;
S-S tn
og.cn
S3"-? Taq(0|-E,0)5
9 5 B, J O »■ 1-^03 -
3 5 ° =
S * i-
05 Oi
5S-o>
o 0.0
3 c 1 —
ISfflfiPO
nS
!a:i O
-I Q.
^ o S T =
= 3 ■= _
3 J-S^"
!N
-lo
o ao
3 c.—
o
o
H
o
03
o
o 0_
o
ro
-^
01
TT
CD
vx
0
^-
0
11)
Ifl
0
C/)
c
Jk
CD
*n
Q.
(it
0
o-
•~<
Oi
m
XI
ff^
Q)
5-
Q]
■<:
,.
0
03
-I
a,
CL
s
r-
0
R
0
0
•0
3
0
0
>0
<
CD
0
0
m
0
01
3
OP
-
3
0
CD
CD
in
~^
:3
^i
oq
0
tt
«tX PREJJURE.
TRAIN LINE
PREJJURE.
BRAKE VALVE
REJ. PREJJURt
AUXILIARY
REJ PRESSURE
BRAKE CYL
PRE»JJURE
Designed by e, g. DESOE, Genl Air Brake Inspector,
8. & A. R. R., Sprinqfielo, Mass.
Railway ..and
lOcomotive
&>pyright by Angus SincIairiCo.— J903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, October, 1903
No. 10
Power From Great Hountain Streams.
Those who are familiar with the im-
mense power for manufacturing purposes
taken from mountain streams in Switzer-
land and other countries are surprised
that so little use has been made of run-
ning waters so abundant in the United
States. Niagara Falls has, of course, been
touched, but that case merely emphasizes
this hemisphere, from which rivers of ice
water of abundant volume and rapid de-
scent constantly flow. According to the
Mail and Express, it is proposed to im-
pound a part of this melted snow and ice,,
and use the water power to develop elec-
tric currents, which can be transmitted to
the place of their use, for trolley railways
or for factories.
wheels to be installed will produce the
estimated equivalent of the power of
20,000 horses. Other tubes and wheels
can be added when there is a demand for
more power. It is calculated that from
this glacial source can be derived power
sufficient for all the industries of the
Puget Sound region.
The Swiss, who are utilizing water
the absence of efforts to utilize other great
opportunities.
This apathy toward opportunity is about
to be broken by certain enterprising peo-
ple in Washington State. Moimt Tacoma.
a huge peak, thirty miles from Puget
Sound, whose altitude is 14.444 feet, a
solitary cone, rising out of a level plain,
has a cap of ice said to be the largest in
UNION PACIFIC EXPRESS TR.\IX.
For this purpose the first dam is build-
ing at a point 1,900 feet above the sea
and thirty-five miles from Tacoma. From
this dam, just below the junction of the
Mowich and Puyallup rivers, the water
will flow eleven miles through a chan-
nel to a reservoir. Thence the water will
fall 1.700 feet, through steel tubes, upon
turbine wheels. The first four of these
power in a similar fashion, have named
their glaciers "the white coal of the
Alps." This compact description will
apply with equal fitness to the eternal
ice cap of Mount Tacoma. Its power is
one of perennial renewal. The atmos-
pheric moisture, the frost and the sun are
the agents of this mighty alchemy of na-
ture, that puny man thus turns to his
444
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
use. Utility cannot here interfere with
beauty, as is threatened through the har-
nessing of Niagara or other majestic
waterfalls.
The sublimity of the mountain glacier
remains undisturbed, its grandeur unim-
paired. The toll upon the generous, in-
cessant flow from that impassive, ma-
jestic mass is imperceptible, even though
it add to the forces of the industrial
world the muscular power of armies.
Ever the brilliant, shining peak freezes
and melts, so long as wind blows and sun
shines amid its lofty solitudes. Man
grasps unnoticed at the hem of its mantle
a bit of the largesse of nature.
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
(Continued from page 401.)
One of the pioneer locomotives still
preserved is the ''Mississippi," shown in
Fig. 36. Tliis engine belonged to the
Company a locomotive which was spoken
of as being the most thoroughly Ameri-
can locomotive ever built, so it is highly
probable that the Missir.-ippi was of a
similar pattern.
There is in the Astor Library, New
York, the drawing of a cow catcher made
by Dunham, of the exact pattern useil
by Isaac Dripps on the Camden & Amboy
John Bull, which Dunham recommended
for locomotives. It had an arrangement
for transmitting part of the weight from
the forward drivers to the wheels sup-
porting the cow catcher. The probabili-
ties are that the Mississippi had the cow
catcher originally and a single pair of
leading wheels.
The latest record we have of the en-
gine is, that in 1868 it was removed from
Natchez to Vicksburg. It was used there
switching for a time and was then
put in a remote siding, where it became
buried in sand, until 1878 when it was
cxinimed and put to work on the con-
Natchez & Hamburg Railroad, now a
part of the Illinois Central system. The
meager history preserved of the engme
says that it was imported from England
about 1836, but I am inclined to doubt
the correctness of this statement. It
has none of the characteristics of any
English builder of that period. It is on
record that Samuel B. Dougharty, for
some years assistant to W. T. James,
had gone to work for H. R. Dunham &
Co., of New York, who had engaged in
the business of assembling locomotives,
and that in 1836 he took several loco-
motives from New York to the Natchez
& Hamburg Railroad. The likelihood is
that the "Mississippi," now to be seen in
the Field Museum of Chicago, was ofie
of these. H. R. Dunham & Co. bought
parts mostly in England, and put them
together, making the minor fittings in
their own shops, and contracting in New
York for the boilers. In 1835 they built
for the Engineering Transportation
struction oi the Meredian, Brookhaven
& Natchez Railroad. When that short
line was finished the Mississippi was em-
ployed pulling trains until 1891. The en-
gine weighed 14,000 pounds, had cylinders
gVa^i6 inches and driving wheels 43
inches diameter.
About the year 1845 Dr. Dionysius
Lardner, a celebrated English writer on
transportation problems, visited the
United States for the purpose of investi-
gating the progress of railroad construc-
tion. During his tour he traveled in
Mississippi, probably behind the engine
"Mississippi," and he thus describes part
of the journey: "To the traveler in
these wilds, the aspect of such artificial
lines of transport (railroad) in the midst
of a country a great portion of which is
still in the state of native forests, is most
remarkable and strongly characteristic of
the irrepressible spirit of enterprise of its
population. Traveling in the back woods
of Mississippi, through native forests
where, till within a few years, human
loot never trod, through solitudes the
stillness of which was never broken even
by the red man, I have been filled with
wonder to find myself drawn on a rail-
way by an engine driven by an artisan
from Liverpool, and whirled at the rate
of twenty miles an hour by the highest
refinements of the art of locomotion.
It is not easy to describe the impression
produced as one sees the frightened deer
start from its lair at the snorting of the
ponderous machine, and the appearance
of the snake-like train which follows it,
.ind when one reflects on all that man
has accomplished within half a century
in this region."
Dr. Lardner was a most bigoted Eng-
lishman, and he would not have failed to
mention it if the locom.otive had been of
English manufacture.
PROGRESS IN LOCOMOTIVE DESIGNING AND
BUILDING.
The year 1836 was celebrated for the
successes achieved by Philadelphia loco-
motive builders. Baldwin built 40 lo-
comotives, Campbell had designed a new
type, Garrett & Eastwick had introduced
a decided improvement in the equalizing
levers, and William Norris, who had la-
bored persistently against adversity, made
a hit with one ol his engines which
brought him fame and fortune.
This was the "Washington," which
inade a wonderful record on the first
section of what is now the Pennsylvania
Railroad.
COL. JOHN Stevens' enterprise.
I have already referred to the per-
sistent efforts made by Colonel John
Stevens to have railroads constructed in-
stead of canals. As early as 1823 he ob-
tained by an act of the Legislature of
Pennsylvania authority to build a rail-
road from Philadelphia to Columbia.
Mr. Stevens' spirit of enterprise greatly
e-xceeded his financial resources, for he
failed to begin the work within a speci-
fied time and the State Legislature three
years later repealed the Stevens Act and
passed another which intended to saddle
the State with the burden of building the
road. This came to naught, but two
years later, in 1828, the Canal Commis-
sioners of the State of Pennsylvania were
ordered by the Legislature to put under
contract the construction of a railroad
from Philadelphia to Columbia via Lan-
caster. A liberal appropriation of money
was made for the purpose and work on
the enterprise was commenced with little
delay.
PHILADELPHIA .\ND COLUMBIA RAILROAD.
The Philadelphia & Columbia Rail-
road, usually spoken of as the "State
Road," was 82 miles long and the work
of construction was done under Major
John Wilson, who worked out the lo-
cating with decided ability the maximum
grades having been only 30 feet to the
October, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
445
mile. At each end of the line there was
an inclined plane, that at tlic Philadel-
phia terminus having been 2,805 feet long
with a rise of 352 feet to the mile. The
inclined plane at the Columbia end was
1,800 feet long, rising at the rate of 264
feet to the mile.
The purpose of the Philadelphia &
Columbia Railroad was to make a
through route from Philadelphia to the
West as a rival to the Baltimore &
Ohio, which was expected to draw West-
ern products to Baltimore, and to hold
for Philadelphia some of the business
that the Erie Canal was taking to New
York. A through route to Pittsburgh
was established by means of canals and a
portage railroad formedi by a series of
inclined planes.
The original scheme of operation for
the Philadelphia & Columbia Railroad
was to make it a public highway, on
which any citizen of the State could
operate cars on payment of a fixed toll.
Horse power was used exclusively at
first, except on the inclined planes, which
were worked by stationary engines and
rope traction.
OPER.^TINO A U.MLRO.\D AS A PRIVATE
HIGHWAY.
Operating a railroad like a private
highway worked very badly. Writing
on the subject Soloman W. Roberts, a
state official, says:
"The experiment of working the road
as a public highway was very unsatis-
factory. Individuals and firms employed
their own drivers, with their own horses
and cars. The cars were small, had
four wheels and each would carry about
seven thousand pounds of freight. Usu-
ally four cars made a train, and that
number could be taken up and as many
let down an inclined plane at one time,
and from six to ten such trips could be
made in an hour. The drivers were a
rough set of fellows and sometimes very
stubborn and unmanageable. It was not
practicable to make them work by a
time-table, and the officers of the road
had no power to discharge them.
"When the road had but a single
track between the turnouts, a large post
called a center post was set up half-way
between two turnouts, and the rule was
made that when two drivers met on the
single track, with their cars, the one that
had gone beyond the center post had
the right to go on and the other that
had not reached it had to go back to
the turnout which he had left. The road
was, in many places, very crooked, and
a man could not see far ahead. The
way the rule worked was this: when a
man left a turnout he would drive very
slowly, fearing he might have to turn
back, and, as he approached the center
post, he would drive faster and faster,
to try to get beyond it, and thus drive
back any cars that he might meet, and
in this wav cars have been driven to-
gether, and a man killed by bemg crush-
ed between them."
He also states that when a bill was
pending in the State Legislature, to au-
thorize the purchase of locomotives, he
was journeying in a horse car toward
llarrisburg and says:
"Two gentlemen were sitting opposite
to me who were members of the Legis-
lature from Chester county, one being a
senator. The car stopped and a man
spoke to my traveling companions, say-
ing that he hoped they would oppose the
bill to authorize the purchase of loco-
motives for the road. The senator said
that it should never be done with his
consent. Thereupon, as the car drove
on, I proceeded to argue the matter, but
with poor success; the reply being that
the people were taxed to make the rail-
road, and that the farmers along the
line should have the right to drive their
own horses and cars on the railroad, as
they did their wagons on the Lancaster
turnpike, and that if they were not per-
mitted to do it, the railroad would be
a nuisance to the people of Lancaster
concourse of people gathered similar to
the crowd which witnessed the first of-
ficial trip made by the "De Witt Clin-
ton," at Albany, N. Y., two years be-
fore.
Excitement was intense and the move-
ments of the engineer were watched by
thousands of eager eyes. He mounted
to the deck, manipulated the starting
levers, then pulled open the throttle
valve, but the engine would not move.
After the engineer had exhausted him-
self in vain to start the engine, the
people, like most American crowds, were
good natured, rushed in and pushed en-
gine and train into motion. Good nature
could not, however, deny that as a starter
the English engine was a failure. It
maintained its first reputation and its
further history is lost in oblivion."
Baldwin's "Lancaster."
Shortly afterward Mr. Baldwin in
1834 built the "Lancaster" (Fig. 37) for
the Columbia line. That engine was
similar to the E. L. Miller, and worked
satisfactorily. The following year two
more Baldwin engines were placed on
the line. Several other English locomo-
tives were imported and they perform-
ed better than the first one, but the
BALDWIN'S LANCASTER. FIG. 37.
and Chester counties. It required time
to overcome this feeling."
LEGISLATURE CONSENTS TO THE PURCHASE
OF LOCOMOTIVES.
In spite of their tender mercies for the
interests of the farmer and of other
horse owners, the Legislature of Penn-
sylvania were eventually compelled to
consent to the use of locomotives on the
State Railroad. When this decision was
reached, a locomotive was imported
from England for use on the Philadel-
phia & Columbia line. Great expecta-
tions were aroused about the wonderful
performance this engine would display.
As the line was not yet completed at the
Philadelphia end, the locomotive was
hauled over the turnpike road to Lan-
caster, where rail connection was reach-
ed.
A BALKY LOCOMOTIVE.
The starting of the locomotive was an
event which attracted crowds from far
and near, and a holiday was declared for
the occasion. Governor Wolf and the
leading State officials participated in the
ceremonies, and the day being fine a
American engines were much more popu-
lar than those imported.
RIVALRY AMONG LOCOMOTIVE BUILDERS.
There was some rivalry among loco-
motive builders to display what their en-
gines could do on the Columbia Rail-
road. William Norris concluded that he
could build a locomotive that would work
not only the level section but the in-
clined planes as well. The engine built
for this purpose was called the "Wash-
ington," shown in Fig. 38. The en-
gine was of his ordinary six-wheel
type, a four-wheel truck in front under
the smoke box and a single pair of
drivers in front of the fire box. The
cylinders, 10x18 inches, were outside the
smoke box, the driving wheels were 48
inches diameter. The boiler was of the
Bury pattern and carried 90 pounds
steam pressure. The total weight of the
engine was 14.400 pounds, the greater
part of that resting on the driving
wheels. In addition to that the tender
coupling was so arranged that part of
the tender's weight was thrown upon the
driving wheels when the engine was pull-
ing.
446
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
TRIUMPH OF THE "WASHINGTON."
- When put to a test the Washington
hauled a load of 19.200 pounds at a speed
of fifteen miles an hour up the inclined
plane at the Philadelphia end of the Col-
umbia Railroad, which was 2,800 feet
long, rising at a rate of yjy feet to the
mile.
Some controversy arose concerning
the correctness of this performance,
some engineers insisting that it was an
impossibility. When subjected to the
testimony of figures it is found that the
load was quite within the tractive power
of the engine so long as no slipping oc-
curred. The tractive power was about
3,000 pounds and the resistance of the
train due to gravity was 1,181 pounds.
The frictional resistance would not ex-
ceed 100 pounds.
Whatever may have been the merits of
the performance of the George Wash-
ington, it brought fame upon its builders
and was the means of launching the
works upon a prosperous career. There
was no longer any sneering at the
Baltimore & Ohio for one engine which
was the first with a horizontal boiler
used on that road, also the first with
six wheels. The engine was delivered
in 1837 and was called "La Fayette."
It was of what had become the usual
Norris form, outside cylinders, single
pair of drivers in front of a haystack
fire box, a four-wheel swiveling truck
under the smoke box, and inside bar
frames. The La Fayette was more
squatty in appearance than the Wash-
ington, but the power was about tlie
same.
THE COLUMBIA RAILROAD AS A TRAINING
SCHOOL.
The Columbia Railroad early became
a sort of training line for railroad men,
just as the developed system of the
Pennsylvania Railroad became a train-
NORRI.S' WASHINGTON.
"Billy" Norris engines being inferior to
the best. The fame of the Norris en-
gines for high tractive power brought a
few years later the first order given by
an English railway company for an
American locomotive.
THE BAR FRAME.
The bar frame was first applied to loco-
motives in the United States by Coleman
Sellers & Son, who built locomotives in
Philadelphia for a few years, but the in-
vention became popular principally
through its use on the Norris engines.
There is no doubt that the bar frame
was imitated from the Bury engine of
the Petersburg Railroad. It made a
simple form of carriage which ordinary
blacksmiths could forge, and, that with
its convenience for attaching mechanism
which could be conveniently reached,^
made the bar frame popular with Ameri-
can locomotive designers and users and
it came rapidly into favor.
THE LA FAYETTE.
The success of the Washington
brought an order to Norris from the
ing school for railroad business on a
larger scale, and it held the reputation
until it became a hotbed of politics.
Men who had worked on the Colum-
bia Railroad claimed to be competent
to act as leaders and supervisors on
any other railroad in the country, and
their claims were generally admitted
as being well founded. In 1840 they
had locomotives built by all Ameri-
can locomotive builders of the day,
Baldwin, Norris, Coleman Sellers &
Son, Eastwick and Harrison, of Philadel-
phia; Dotterer & Son, of Reading; John
Brandt, of Lancaster; Ross Winans, oi
Baltimore, and others. Enginemen
could experiment with so many different
kinds of locomotives that they were con-
sidered capable of handling any engine
that ran on wheels.
STATE RAILROAD REPAIR SHOPS.
Shops were established for the rail-
road at Parkesburg. 44 miles west of
Philadelphia. Great difficulty was at first
experienced in effecting repairs in these
shops from the fact that the nuts and
bolts on the locomotives procured from-
a number of different locomotive estab-
lishments were all of different sizes and
patterns, every bolt having its own cor-
responding nut. One of the first ef-
fective reforms made in this shop was-
the establishing of standard sizes of nuts
and bolts, an action which was highly
creditable to the men in charge, for stand-
ard sizes were little thought of in tliose
days.
All general repairs of engines were
done at the Parkesburg shops, and the
running repairs were done at either end
of the line by blacksmiths and helpers,
whose duty it was to do the work un-
der the direction of the engineers.
The payroll of the Parkesburg shops
for September, 1843, gives the number
of employees as thirty-one, including one
manager, one foreman, thirteen machin-
ists, three blacksmiths, one coppersmith,
two file makers, one pattern maker
three carpenters, one stationary engi-
neer, four assistants and one watchman.
The aggregate amount of the pay-roll
for these thirty-one men for one month
was $1,087.88, a little over $35.00 for
each person.
The pay-roll of locomotive engineers
and firemen employed on the Columbia
Railroad during the month of August,
1843, shows that their number was forty
— twenty engineers and twenty firemen.
The standard rate of wages at that time
and for some years previous to and
subsequent to that period was $2.00 per
day for engineers and $1.25 per day for
firemen, the time piaid for being that irh
which actual service was performed, and
all accounts being verified by affidavits.
The total payments for that month were
$990.00 for engineers and $674.36 for fire-
men, being $40.50 for engineers and $33.21
for firemen. Of the twenty engineers,
two were employed on a night line, two
on a fast line, and sixteen in running
"burden" or freight trains.
GROWTH OF COLUMBIA RAILROAD BUSINESS.
After locomotives were introduced the
business of the Columbia Railroad in-
creased very rapidly for a report made
in 1836 by Mr. A. Mehaffey, superintend-
ent of motive power, gives a table of the
names of twenty-seven locomotives
which he had at work and the mileage
they had made. Of these eleven had
been built by Baldwin, one by Long &
Norris, four by William Norris, two by
Coleman Sellers & Son, five by the
Stephensons, three by Young, and one
by McClurg & Co., Pittsburg.
In connection with this report Mr.
Mehaffey said: "Owing to the infancy
of the business of engine building and
the deficiency of motive power last
spring, some were necessarily purchased
which have been a constant source of
vexation, delay and expense. The run-
ning of these must ever be an actual
loss to the State. Hereafter none will
October, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
447
ibe kept on the road except such as can do
full work; all others will be disposed oi
as soon as possible consistent with the
interests of the State. . . . Two of
the engines of British make have recent-
ly been sold, and it would have been a
saving to the Commonwealth had they
been given away for nothing the first
day they were placed upon the track."
They had a happy-go-lucky way of
operating trains on the State road in
those days. Tl'.e stations were nearly all
located at taverns, and it was the prac-
tice to stop long enough to permit the
passengers and train hands to partake of
liquid refreshments.
Ihe rules for the running of trains
were conspicuous by their absence. As
late as 1840 trains were started only
whenever those in charge of the motive
■power were assured that there was suffi-
cient traffic along the line to warrant
the use of locomotives. Belated trains
were searched for by crews that were
kept in waiting orders for the purpose.
An e.xtra engine with six or eight men
equipment only those couplers which
had a lock-set in the head, and which do
not depend entirely upon the uncoupling
lever to hold up the lock. Dependence
upon the lift rigging to keep the lock up
presupposes that this part of the device
shall always be in exact adjustment,
which is not invariably the case in every
day service. They further recommend-
ed that as cases often arise where, with
cars coupled together, one knuckle can
be opened more easily than another, that
the uncoupling lever should be placed
on both sides of every car, thereby giv-
ing a man two chances instead of one to
cut or uncouple cars as the case may be.
A circular was sent out asking for an
expression of opinion as to whether link
slot and link-pin hole in the knuckle
niiglit not now be abandoned with ad-
vantage. Twenty-one roads replied. In
this number there were nineteen which
had been for some time using the solid
knuckle and they were very much in
favor of making it standard. One road
reported no experience with the solid
tour had been designed for lighter ser-
vice than exists to-day, and they believed
that manufacturers were now making
stronger couplers than formerly and that
the limit of strength with present con-
tours had practically been reached. An
altered contour was suggested which
would make the knuckle somewhat more
hook-shaped and would gain 3-32 of an
inch across the contour at the pivot pin-
hole. The recommendation is to still
use the i5^-in. pivot pin in a coupler
II or 12 inches deep with a solid knucklt
having a 9 or 10 inch face, and with the
improved contour, which would, of
course, couple with existing equipment.
This compromise plan makes possible
further evolution along similar lines, as
the future may render present condition*
more strenuous or may even impose
other limitations upon the ikill of the
designer or of the manufacturer.
The railroad companies leading to St.
Louis are making special efforts to meet
the rush traffic expected for the exhibition.
LAC1-:.\W.\NNA FREIGHT MCXUl
was sent out whenever the occasion war-
ranted, curves being "run," that is, a
flagman sent out ahead until the delayed
train was found.
The operating of this railroad by the
Stale of Pennsylvania was far from
being a success. It was managed in the
interest of politicians, with the usual re-
sult that having interest with the politi-
cal wire pullers was much more power-
ful in advancing employees than knowl-
edge of their business or faithful service.
The inertia of corruption kept the poli-
ticians in control for many years, but
their authority was greatly curtailed be-
•fore the final coup which turned over the
whole of the property to the Pennsyl-
vania Railroad Company in 1857.
(To be continued.)
M. C. B. Coupler Tests.
The standing M. C. B. Committee on
Coupler Tests, in making their report
■practically expressed the opinion that in
the multiplicity of couplers now on the
-market a judicious weeding out process
■might be applied by specifying for new
knuckle and one road was in favor of
doing away with the link slot, but de-
sired the link-pin hole to be kept in the
knuckle. The committee said that the
only objection to taking action definitely
in this matter was the difficulty experi-
enced in handling cars around sharp
curves, and on and off floats at tide
water. The committee had, however, ex-
perimented with an auxiliary device
which seemed to meet the requirements
of the case, and which they brought offi-
cially before the association, through the
medium of their annual report.
The committee pointed out that the
elimination of link slot and link-pin hole
in the knuckle would transfer almost the
entire breakage of knuckles to the pivot
p:n hole in the knuckle and to the coupler
lugs, and that in order to give these
parts the necessary additional strength,
an increase in section rather than in
depth would be desirable. They argued
that "metal around a deep hole will tear
at the point of greatest shear as readily
as it will around a hole of less depth of
the same section." The committee
further indicated that 'the present con-
Mogul for the Lackawanna.
The Scheneciady Shops of the .Ameri-
can Locomotive Company have recently
supplied the Delaware, Lackawanna &
Western with fast freight power in the
shape of some 2-6-0 engines. They
weigh each, about 140,000 lbs., and are
classified by the builders as 260-140 type.
The cylinders are 20^x26 and the
diameter of the driving wheels amounts
to 63 ins. -All wheels are flanged. The
pony truck and the leading driver are
equalized together and .the two rear driv-
ers are also equalized together. The cal-
culated tractive effort of this engine with
200 lbs. steam pressure in the boiler is
about 29,500 lbs. The engine is simple,
with .\llan-Richardson balanced valves,
actuated by indirect motion. The cross-
head is of the two-guide bar type and has
a lip cut on each side of the upper guide,
so that outside of guide and crosshead
side are flush. The-piston rod is not se-
cured to the crosshead by key, but has a
shoulder on the rod drawn up tightly
with a couple of nuts.
The boiler is of the straight top variety,
with wide fire bo.x. The diameter of the
448
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, igo,^
first ring is 665^4 ins. The fire box has
a grate area of 53.43 sq. ft. The heating
surface is 2,342.2 sq. ft. in all, the fire
box giving 166.2 sq. ft. The tubes which
are 310 in number, are 13 ft. 6 ins. long
and contain 2,176 sq. ft. of heating sur-
face. The crown and roof sheets are level
and the back sheet is perpendicular, and
the staying is radial. The fire door has
curved and flat lines in its contour. The
sides are made each with 6 ins. radius
and the bottom upon which the scoop
rests when delivering coal, is flat, while
the upper edge of the door is arched,
with a 2254 in. radius.
The tender has an ordinary U-shaped
tank, which holds 6.000 U. S. gallons ot
water. The tender weighs empty 49,400
lbs., and is carried on two diamond arch
bar trucks. There are two main reser-
voirs for air. Ten tons of coal is carried.
A few of the principal dimensions are
here given for reference:
Tender— Weight, empty, 49,400 lbs. : wheel base, 16
ft. 95^ ins.; tender frame, lo ins. steel channels;
water cap., 6,000 U. S. gals.; coal cap., lo tons.
Improvements on the Pittsburgh & Lake
Erie at McKees Rocl^s, Pa.
The Pittsburgh & Lake Erie Railroad
are making some very extensive im-
provements at their Pinsburgh Shops,
situated at McKees Rocks, Pa. A new
shop building has just been put up which
is 170 feet wide by 525 feet long. The
twenty-four pits in the erecting shop
bay are served by a lo-ton and by a
120-ton electric crane. The pits run
parallel with the end walls of the build-
ing. The heavy machine bay is covered
with a lo-ton crane and the light ma-
chine bay is served by air hoists, light
travelers, etc. The shop is very similar
in general layout to that of the L. S.
& M. S. shops at Collinwood, a descrip-
tion of which we gave last November.
.\ ii>i,i iK \ij( . i;onj:R i;.\i'i,ijMijN. i-..\r, i.\i.;i.;r .v.vu j_iii<u.m.\.n iKii.i^iii).
General Dimensions— Weight in working order,
161.000 lbs.; weight on drivers, 140,000 lbs.;
weight engine and tender in working order,
28o,4co lbs.; wheel base, driving. 15 ft.; wheel
base, total, 23 ft. 10 ins.; wheel base, total, en-
gine and tender, 52 ft. 54 ins.
Cylinders — 20^ x 26 ins.; size of steam ports, 18 x
I >i ins. ; size of exhaust ports, 18 x 3 ins. ; size of
bridges, 1^ ins.
Valves— Allen Richardson ; greatest travel, 55^ ins. ;
outside lap, 1 in. ; inide clearance, -^ in. ; lead of
valves in full gear, j^ in.; lead J4 in. at 6 in. cut off.
Wheels— Dia. of driving wheels outside of tire,
63 ins.; engine truck wheels, steel tired spoke,
tire 2^ ins.
Boiler— Thickness of plates in barrel and outside
of fire box. r>i. H, %, }J '"s.; fire box, length.
102^ ins.; firebox, width, 75I4 ins.; fire box,
depth, front. 63^.^ ins.; back, 56;. ins.; fire box
plates, thickness, sides, >i in.; back, % in.;
crown, }i in.; tube sheet, -^n in.; fire box, water
space, 4 ins. front; 3 14 ins. sides;3Hin» back;fire
box, crown staying, radial; tubes, gauge. No.
12 B.W.G.; tubes, number, 310; tubes, dia., 2ins.
heating surface, tubes, 2,176.00 sq. ft.; heating
surface, fire box, 166.2 sq. ft ; heating surface,
total, 2,342. 2sq ft.; grate surface, 53.43 sq. ft.
The machines are not yet fully in
place in the P. & L. E. shop, but when
completed every machine will have an
individual electric drive with the sole ex-
ception of half a dozen bolt cutters
which will be driven in a group with one
piece of shafting. Thus there will be
no belts or shafts anywhere, except at
this one point. The roof arrangement
of this shop is interesting. The erecting
bay is covered with a roof of somewhat
flat pitch, sloping both ways from the
center. For the heavy and the light ma-
chine bays the saw-tooth form of roof
is used with the upright portion of the
wall^ corresponding to the vertical edge
of the saw-tooth, made of glass. This
gives two large areas of glass placed so
as to be affected very little by snow or
ice, and with the additional advantage
that condensation of vapor and the drip
of moisture is taken ofT through gutter
pipes placed at regular intervals. A
striking feature of the saw-tooth roof,
here, is that a spectator standing a few
feet away from the line of the erecting
shop posts and looking away from that
shop, sees two enormous unbroken
areas of clear glass, which, assisted by
the wall windows, throw a flood of light
into and upon the floor of the erecting
shop, as well as lighting the other two.
In the paint shop this effect is even
more marked, as there are more "saw-
teeth" to shed light and the vertical light
of the glass area is greater in propor-
tion. The shops throughout are heated
by the Sturtevant system. In the wood-
working department the shafting for all
the machines are below the floor and this
has the effect of apparently giving more
room and of certainly giving more light
to the workmen.
There are also two roundhouses of
modern design, having together si.xty-
eight stalls. In each roundhouse there
are two tracks fitted up with drop pits
for driving wheel work, and two other
pits in each shop are arranged for drop-
ping tender wheels at one end, and for
dropping engine truck wheels at the
other end of the same shop pits. The ordi-
nary pits for each stall are made of con-
crete and are sloped up in the center.
Steel roller doors are used in both round-
houses, and Mr. D. J. Redding, the
master mechanic in charge, speaks very
highly of their efficiency in keeping warm
air in and cold air out during the winter
months.
In the matter of lighting and ventila-
tion these roundhouses are well con-
structed. No. I roundhouse is of the
usual form, the back or turn-table end
having the lower wall; but from the top
Lif higher wall, toward which the engines
face, rises a Mansard roof, which is
pierced with windows, which, together
with those in the higher wall, supply
more light than usually finds its way into
an engine house. No. 2 house has in
addition to the Mansard roof, a hip roof,
or rather a box of square section with
slatted vertical sides, which being placed
in the highest point of the roof, acts as
a very effective ventilating and smoke
removing medium. The smoke jacks
used are of unique design, the illustra-
tion of which we have reserved for a
future issue. Altogether, shops, round-
houses, power plant, etc., present an ex-
ample of a thoroughly well-designed and
modern railroad repair plant, and when
in full operation will greatly augment
the facilities of the Pittsburgh & Lake
Erie to cope with their ever increasing
business.
The latest title given to J. Pierpont
Morgan is "King of Wall Street." The
title is not in derision either, for there
is no doubt that Mr. Morgan is the real'
monarch of all he surveys in the atmos-
phere of that street.
October, if)03.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
449
Schmidt 5teain Superheater.
Varied attempts have been made at dif-
ferent times to estal)lish the use of su-
perheated steam on locomotives, says the
Locomotive Magazine, from which we re-
produce illustrations and description, but
hitherto the majority of the eflforts have
resulted in failure due to the difficulties
of construction and trouble of the super-
heating devices. The Prussian State Rail-
way Administration, however, claims to
have secured a more favorable arrange-
ment of apparatus, and has applied it to
some 60 or 70 locomotives. The device
is known as the Schmidt superheater,
and we give a drawing of the apparatus
as installed in the smokebox of a loco-
motive. Applied originally to stationary
pounds per sq. in. will give as economi-
cal results as an ordinary "saturated"
steam engine will at 170 pounds per sq.
in., and witli steam at a temperature of
572 degrees F. it is possible to run with-
out any cylinder condensation with pres-
sures as low as 70 pounds per sq. in.
The Prussian State Railways have four
different types of superheated steam lo-
comotives, which are intended to deal
with all classes of traffic, thus reducing
the variety in engines, as it is claimed for
superheating tliat the power of individual
engines can be considerably increased.
missed should have gone the day before,
and was really twenty-three hours and
fifty-five minutes late. — Indianapolis News.
Train Nearly a Day Late.
The sale of tlie Indiana and Illinois
Railroad to the Illinois Central last
At the Traveling Engineers' Associa-
tion meeting held in Chicago on 8th and
three following days of September, a
resolution of sympathy with the wife and
children of the late P. M. Arthur was
unanimously passed. In referring to the
departed Grand Chief the association ex-
pressed itself as mourning the loss of an
honored and respected member, and
joined with the Brotherhood of Locomo-
tive Engineers in sorrowing over the loss
to them of a wise and efficient leader,
and united with every association of
RIGHT HALF
FRONT VIEW
4-. 1. i
SCH.MIDT STEAM SUPERHK.^TER
engines, considerable doubt existed for
a time among German locomotive en-
gineers as to the advisability of adopting
it on locomotives, but apparently in ser-
vice it has convinced critics of its econ-
omy.
Superheated steam must possess cer-
tain advantages, and among them are the
increase in the boiler efficiency (25 per
cent, is claimed), and the absence of con-
densation in the cylinders, a serious ele-
ment of loss on ordinary locomotives.
As this superheater is placed in the
smokebox it necessitates the latter being
made much larger both in diameter and
length, but the additional expense in con-
struction is not excessive, the extra cost
being comparatively slight.
It is stated that a locomotive using su-
perheated steam at a pressure of 85
week recalls an amusing story. When
the Switz City division of the Illinois
Central was built it was known as the
Indiana and Illinois Southern. It was a
narrow-gauge road, the roadbed was bad,
the engines and cars were built on a
miniature scale, and while there was a
schedule, had a train been on time the
fact would have been regarded as a
miracle. The road was known as the
"Try-Weakly."
About twenty years ago Josiah Mc-
Connell desired to go to Switz City from
Sullivan, but missed the train by a minute
or two. The clock at the station showed
that the train had left Sullivan five min-
utes ahead of time, and McConnell sued
the railroad company for $S,ooo damages.
On a trial of the case, it was proved be-
vond a doubt that the train McConneH
labor worthy of the name in lamenting
the death of a counsellor, guide and true
friend. The death of P. M. Arthur— the
resolution concludes — has left a gap in
ranks of the successful conservative labor
leaders, which all alike realize will be
difficult to fill.
We are always ready to excuse the
printer and reporter for the mistakes they
make, but when they use the word mon-
grel instead of mogul and repeat the mis-
nomer three times in the course of one
column, we cannot suppress a suspicion
that it was a case of malice aforethought.
Nothing can be won without anxiety
and care. — Old Curiosity Shop.
450
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
Oerman Freight Cars.
Mr. B. H. Warner, Jr.. United States
consul at Leipzig, Germany, writes to the
Department of Commerce as follows :
"The carrying capacity of the average
German freight car is from 10 to 15 metric
tons. Recently the Vereinigte Konigs unci
Laurahutte Akliengesellschaft fur Berg-
bau und Huttenbetrieb. one of the great-
est manufacturing and industrial estab-
lishments of the empire, received an order
from the Prussian State Railways for 200
freight cars, each of 20 metric tons capa-
city. The railroad authorities are now dis-
cussing whether it will be wise to still
further increase the car capacity. While
they are busy investigating the subject
and gathering statistics relating thereto,
it has been decided to have a few cars,
each of 30 tons carrying capacity, ■ con-
structed, in order to make a practical
test as well"
A metric ton weighs 2,204.6 pounds.
pistons so annoying and wasteful on our
large engines.
Water Softening in Relation to Wash=
ing Out, on Railways.
The mechanical department of the
Pittsburgh & Lake Erie Railroad, which
is presided over by Mr. L. H. Turner, as
superintendent of motive power, is mak-
ing an extensive instalment of Kenni-
cott water softening plants at various
points along the line. The plant, which
is situated at the McKees Rocks shops, at
Pillsburgh, will handle the company's
daily consumption of water at that point,
which now ranges between 750,000 to
1.500,000 gallons of water during twenty-
four hours. At this station it is ex-
pected that water drawn from a well on
the bank of the Ohio river, containing
35 grains of solid matter per gallon, will
have the solid matter reduced to about 5
MADDOX PATENT PISTON PACKING.
riaddox Piston Packing.
Annexed is a drawing of a metallic
packing, the invention of Mr. S. J. Mad-
dox, an employee of the Illinois Central
Railway. It has been put to the severest
test on suburban engine No. 141 1, of the
I. C. Ry. for twenty-one months, and
the piston rod has shown only ,Ji; inch
wear in that time.
The packing has also been tested with
equally good results at the Burnside shops
of the same company on a Buckeye high
speed engine making over 300 revolutions
per minute.
There are two features of the invention
that recommend themselves. The drawing
shows two grooves which collect the con-
densation and which are intended to keep
the piston rod moist and act as anti-fric-
tion agents in addition to the oil packing.
There is also a steel spring band which
keeps the packing in place.
Mr. Maddox guarantees the packing to
outlast the life of a pump, and to prevent
the escape of steam on valve-stems and
grains per gallon after treatment by the
Kennicott process.
There will be in all, eighteen of these
Kennicott water purifying plants installed
along the road, and though the treatment
of the water at each purifying plant will
necessarily vary with the composition of
the water used at each station, the result
will be to deliver to the engines all over
the road practically a uniform quality of
water. The entire road, which is some-
thing under 200 miles long and which has
the distinction of being one of the few
with an engine for every mile of road,
uses about three-and-a-half million gal-
lons every twenty-four hours, and bear-
ing this in mind, it is easy to understand
the great value a uniform quality of water
must be to a road so situated. The P.
& L. E. people are fully alive to the pos-
sibilities of the situation and intend to
profit by the achievements of modern
chemical science.
It is said that hard scale ^5 inch
thick formed upon a flue by the use of
raw or untreated water, will disappear in
probably a month after the treated water
has been continuously introduced into the
boiler. There is, however, a soft sludge
which forms in all boilers using treated
water, most of which sinks to the bot-
tom and which, though it does not hard-
en, will cause foaming if allowed to ac-
cumulate, while in any case flues, crown
sheet, water legs and barrel will be free
from scale or hard deposit. The sludge
is not entirely removed in any case, as
it would not be safe to take it all out, for
an absolutely pure water would tend to
pit the boiler. The washing out of boil-
ers using treated water thus resolves itself
into the much more simple process usual-
ly known in round houses as "changing
the water."
To meet this state of affairs, a plant
will be put in operation at McKees Rocks,
after the water softening plants have been
installed and are in full operation. In
order to blow out very nearly all of this
"sludge" the water in the boiler must be
run off before fresh water is introduced,
and the method to be employed for this
purpose may be summarized something as
follows:
An engine under about 125 lbs. steam
pressure will be blown off into a hot well,
the heat of which will be utilized to
warm fresh water presently to be intro-
duced into the boiler. When the boiler
is quite empty the outlet will be shut off
and hot water will be pumped in through
the second connection of the Y-pipe, at-
tached to the blow-off cock and against
whatever pressure of steam may remain
after the "sludge" water has been blown
out. When the boiler has been filled with
fresh hot water a total steam pressure of
about 70 lbs. will be present in the boiler,
and with a banked fire drawn over the
grate and fresh coal applied, the blower
may be used at once, and the effects due
to the alteration of temperature on sheets
be thus reduced to a minimum. The total
time for "washing out" by this method
will be about 45 minutes, which is a great
improvement over the most expeditious
methods now in vogue.
The Pittsburgh Shops of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company have a way 01
providing for the boring out and bushing
of cylinders, when such becomes neces-
sary, without requiring the making of
other changes. When it is desired to
be able to do this work, they make the
counter bore of the cylinders ^ ins. on
a side, and both cylinder covers when de-
signed to suit this counter bore, do not
need to be altered after a new bushing
has been put in. The slight extra clear-
ance involved in this method is thought
to be fully offset by the advantage thus
gained.
A thousand things are hidden still.
And not a hundred known.
— Tennyson.
Oclnbcr. li)C3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
451
General Correspondence.
Davis H. Uotterer.
Uavis H. l^otlcrer was a builder of fur-
nace and rolling mill machinery, and also
of locomotives, away back between 1833
and 1850, when the number of establish-
ments engaged in such work in this coun-
try could have nearly been counted on
a man's fingers; that entitles his name to
a place on the roll of the early Ameri-
can mechanics.
Mr. Dotlcrcr was the senior partner of
the firm of Dotterer & Darling, whose
shops were in Reading, Pa., between
183s and 1840. The firm built several en-
gines for the Philadelphia & Columbia
Railroad. Mr. Dotterer was the mechan-
ical head of the firm, and designed these
■engines. A feature, and peculiarity of
one or two of them, was "water grate
bars" ; not put in to protect the bars, but
as a heater for the feed water between the
ipump and boiler. They were put in in form
of a square coil, but did not prove a suc-
cess, as iron piping in those days was of
a crude character. Neither did the>
amount to much as heaters. To quote
Mr. D., "the fresh air through and over
them kept the grates nice and cool." Not-
withstanding the failure of the device, it
was, no doubt, the first attempt to use
water grates on a locomotive in this coun-
try, if not anywhere.
Later on the firm built some locomotives
•for the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad
Co., weight about 15 tons, 15x20 in cyl-
inders, wheels 4 ft. 6 in., 4 wheels con-
■nected and 4 wheel truck. They were
very efficient engines and well built. One
■of these engines, the Monocacy, was con-
■nected with endless chains on inside driv-
ers instead of side rods. Lost motion
soon caused a change from the chain con-
tiection to side rods.
The firm built the engines and machin-
ery for the Scranton Coal & Iron Com-
■pany's rolling mill and furnace.
When the "Leggets Gap" Railroad was
rehabilitated and called the Lackawanna
& Western Railroad, running from Scran
ton to the Great Bend in New York State,
Mr. Dotterer was called to the superin-
tendency and master mechanicship of the
company. He bought a small English en-
gine, the "Spitfire," from the Philadelphia
& Reading Co. to haul the iron and ma-
terial to build the road. The writer, with
his brother, took the engine via Pennsyl-
vania Canal to Pittston, and thence to
Scranton via the Pennsylvania Coal Co. s
road to Scranton in the early spring ol
1851.
One day the writer was sitting in the
rolling mill with Mr. Dotterer waiting for
the loading of rails, when he called my at-
tention to the hard exhaust of the 90
horse stationary engine that drove the rail
train of rolls, and said, "Ranch, there is a
great loss in the high pressure engine. I
don't see anything to prevent the exhaust
steam from being passed into another cyl-
inder of twice, or more, the size of the
liigh pressure, and to get 180 horse power
from the steam that now yields only 90."
He took out his memorandum book and
made a rough sketch of a tandem com-
pound engine.
Later on when the new engines began
to arrive, they had enormous whistles
that were deafening. Mr. D. showed me
a sketch of a whistle bowl somewhat sim-
ilar to the present siren.
Thus, in 1851, Mr. Dotterer had the
idea of compound engines and musical
whistle, which other men in later years
perfected and brought into use.
New York, .August, 1903.
E. J. Rauch.
great system to which the line is now
very closely allied.
The engine and tender are contained
on one continuous frame.
A peculiar form of steam chest is used,
in which the cover is on the side.
The main rods, and in fact all of the
parts, are very light.
Principal sizes of this engine are as
follows: Cylinders, 9x14 ins.; drivers,
54 ins. diameter; weight of engine, 26,-
000 lbs.
Another engine very similar to the
Pioneer in size and shape of parts, but
having a car rigidly attached to it, stands
on the same track with the Pioneer. On
this engine a badge-plate on the smoke
arch names the Cumberland Valley
Railroad shops as builder. The similar-
ity of appearance to the Pioneer would
indicate that this latter engine is also
a Wilmarth, remodeled in the Cumber-
land Valley Railroad shops.
ig^ ' ^"^^ ^ 8^ ^^ 6^1
ONE OF SETH WILM..^RTHS SHANGHAIS.
An Old Seth Wilmarth Locomotive.
The accompanying drawing shows a
locomotive still in running order, which
was built in 1851 by Seth Wilmarth at
South Boston, J\Iass., for the Cumber-
land Valley Railroad Co.
The Pioneer was used for a number of
years in the passenger service of that
company, and according to Mr. J. L.
Lawrence, the general foreman of the
Motive Power Department, has never
been changed or remodeled.
On October 22, 1901, Mr. Lawrence
took it under steam from Chambers-
burgh to Carlisle, on the occasion of a
centennial gathering at the latter place,
but did not keep it under steam during
the ceremonies on accoimt of a leak-
ing flue.
The engine, it will be observed, is fitted
with link motion, thus showing this
form of valve gear to have been used
by the Cumberland Valley Railroad five
years previous to its introduction on the
It would be well if this engine,
"Pioneer," could be preserved in some
museum or public building, as it is un-
doubtedly the only Wilmarth engine in
existence.
Little seems to be known now of the
locomotive works of Seth Wilmarth ex-
cept that they were located at South
Boston, Mass., and that many of his
engines were closely on lines of those
built by Hinckley.
The Boston & Albany Railroad, or
one of the roads later combined in that
system, owned one named "Fury," built
in 1849, of which a photograph is still,
or was, at least in 1897, in existence.
Three were built for the Pennsylvania
Railroad in 1852-3. and continued in serv-
ice until 1870. All these had hook mo-
tion and variable cut-oflf. Others were
built for the C. V. R. R. beside the
Pioneer, but correct information as to
these cannot be obtained.
It might be interesting if those yet
45=
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
living who were familiar with Scth Wil-
marth and his shops and their engines
could place such knowledge on record
through the columns of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering. The latest
date to which the writer can trace work
from these shops is 1853.
C. H. Caruthers.
Yea don. Pa.
We should be very glad indeed if old
railroad men would tell what they know
about very old locomotives that have
escaped the scrap heap. There is a good
deal of valuable historical data among
old men who ought to impart it before
they pass away. — Ed.
Circus Trains.
Just as I write there comes news of
a serious disaster on one of the western
roads, due to the collision of two sec-
tions of a circus train. At this time I
do not have the information whether the
accident was caused by the neglect of
the engineer to apply his brakes, poor
condition of the brakes, or failure to
properly flag. The report states, how-
ever, that the accident was caused by
"failure of the air brakes to operate,"
an excuse exceedingly antiquated and
flimsy.
Circus trains are usually the most val-
uable trains in the freight class which a
railroad company is called upon to trans-
port. The movement of such trains is
hazardous, needs unusual care and atten-
tion, and pays the railroad company none
too well for its transport. The large
collection of valuable wild animals makes
a collision or serious accident of great
consequence and expense.
The circus people own their own cars,
and very seldom take the same interest
in the condition of the equipment as
do railroad companies in theirs. The
result is that the equipment is very
seldom up to the M. C. B. standards
and requirements, and are not always in
first class condition. Usually consider-
able difiiculty is experienced in obtain-
ing permission for the railroad company
to make the necessary repairs on circus
cars, and to get their pay for the same.
Again, nearly every circus train passing
over a railroad to-day is accompanied
by a corps of railroad officials to insure
the success of the transport of the train,
those accompanying the train usually
being the train master, the general air
brake inspector, a car repairer or two,
and frequently a railroad detective, and
the superintendent of the division.
Circus cars are, as a rule, notorious
for the bad condition of their air brakes.
Recently a general air brake inspector
on one of the large systems in this vi-
cinity was ordered to receive a circus
train of thirty-five cars at certain con-
necting point on the system, and to have
the brakes put in a condition equal to
those on the system's own cars. The
result was that the train liad to be held
at the starting point an unusually long
time to accomplish all of the necessary
work. It was found necessary to clean
and oil all of the triple valves on the
thirty-five cars. The foundation brake
gear was so badly patched up that it was
found necessary to replace a score of
rods and levers. One-half dozen anti-
quated, wooden brake beams and four
poor metal brake beams were replaced.
Eight triple valves which had been cut
out on account of being defective or in-
operative were placed in good working
condition. Ten new packing leathers
were required in as many brake cylin-
ders, and the leathers remaining in other
cylinders were removed and softened up,
being found in a dry and poor holding
condition.
This specific case is cited to call at-
tention to the fact that circus trains are
sometimes permitted to pass in poor con-
dition over roads. Possibly the number
of brakes in working condition are sufti-
cient to handle the train in ordinary
movement, but sadly deficient if the train
is called upon to make an emergency
stop in close quarters. The circus people
are as a rule reluctant to permit repairs
to be made on their cars or on car
apparatus; and even when such work
is performed a great deal of difficulty
is experienced in collecting the money
due the railroad company for this work
done. The result is that railroads some-
times run the risk of moving a poorly
conditioned train, and the circus people
reason that if one road can do it that
all can afford to do it equally well.
Railroads cannot be too strict in torc-
ing the circus people to either place their
own cars in as good condition upon en-
tering a system as a system itself re-
quires its own cars to be.
Amos Judd.
Boston, Mass.
Early Reminiscences of Lucius and a
riule.
As I pen these lines my thoughts go
back to the good old days when I was
a fireman on the Central Pacific Rail-
way in California, in the early 8o's.
As I have not the engineer's permis-
sion to use his name in connection with
this story I am going to tell, it will
suffice when I say that it was not Bill
Kretley, nicknamed Stuttering Bill by
the railroad boys, who was the hero in
this case of mine. As Stuttering Bill
worked on the South Pacific coast for
a few months only, many of the old
timers on the Central Pacific, where the
accident occurred, never knew of Bill,
but they had good reason to remember
Lucius G., as I am going to call him.
Lucius, like Bill, had an impediment
in his speech and stammered badly when
there was anything to arouse his temper.
He was considered one of our crack
throttle pullers and hauled the fast ex-
press. Thirty miles an hour was the
limit of speed allowed and considered
fast time. Lucius, for some reason, had
been delayed on one of his trips and
was attempting to regain some of the
lost time, so as to make connection with
the Ferry. When within a short dis-
tance of his terminus he espied an old
decrepid mule contently browsing on
the track ahead of him. The company
having been assessed heavy damages a
number of times for the killing of stock,
specified, in one of its rules, that every
effort was to be made to prevent the
killing of stock, and with this Lucius
complied. He whistled, applied the air
brake and came to a stop. His mule-
ship left the track, only to return each
time that Lucius got his train in motion
again, and disputed the right of way
with him.
Thoroughly exasperated at the turn
of affairs Lucius gave vent to his pent
up anger and remarked: "Da — da — damn
yer, ye have ch — ch — changed yer mind
have ye, wu — wu — wull so have I." Put-
ting on a full head of steam and lever
at full stroke he sent the mule to the
happy hunting grounds.
Now, the company's stock report
asked a multitude of questions, which
Lucius could not truthfully answer, and
he lost his breath when the story leaked
out. But Lucius was of a thrifty nature
and went to fruit raising in the mterior.
Fortune smiled on him and the ranch-
ers in his vicinity built a line to connect
with the Central Pacffic, so as to better
market their crops. Lucius was put in
charge of the engine. During the day
his time was spent on the farm and in
the evening he would run in his train
to connect with the Central Pacific Over-
land express. The little line was finally
absorbed and the Central Pacific once
more had Lucius in its employ.
Lucius was sent on another division
and I fired for him one week on wheat
specials. While coaling un the engine
with the train crew one day, one of the
brakemen volunteered to tell the story
of Lucius and the mule. Lucius was a
patient listener, boiling over with rage,
and I, anxious to see the outcome, did
not put the brakeman onto his quiet
listener. But I hadn't long to wait.
Mr. Brakeman was making a bee line up
the track with Lucius after him, and
the brakeman, now dead, never forgave
me for not telling him that the hero was
listening to his own exoerience. Lucius
through the kind offices ot the engi-
neers' brotherhood, was shortly rein-
stated to his former position, and when I
last saw him, several years ago, he was
still a throttle puller on the flyer and
making sixty miles an hour. He must
have ch — changed his mind, for he was
keeping out of trouble and proving him-
self a very successful engineer.
J. A. B.
October, igo.i.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVK KNOrNKliRING
453
Broken Staybolts.
Your article is timely, I have observed
as many broken staybolts, as you say,
taken from locomotives.
Yes, drilled holes are not always in the
center, they weaken the bolt, and fill up
with grease and dirt, preventing warn-
ing, and often breaking where the drill-
ing stops.
Plugging the hole is reckless of conse-
quences. Life and property is at stake,
and those who hide defects by plugging
the holes should be held responsible, for
those who do such things know that they
are inflicting risks of disaster on the un-
suspicious.
Broken staybolts, like a disease which
has become epidemic, are very prevalent
now, more so than usual, if one may
judge from the discussion of the Master
Boiler Makers' Association, at their re-
cent convention, where they diagnosed,
and imagined many causes, but proposed
no definite cures, their diagnosing and
prescribing were indeterminate, with
tendency to empirical theories.
Yes, "when the inevitable explosion
happens, men will hold up their hands
and say that the cause of the accident
was a mystery." Just like a coroner's
inquest, when a train runs down a pre-
cipice. Why? Experts are called before
the jury to tell why? The experts de-
cide, as they have often done, that it was
because of "spreading of the rails." Why
.should the rails spread?
The experts may answer: Because they
find the iron in the spikes or bolts crys-
tallized and the momentum of the train
would break them.
What would cause the iron to crystal-
lize? The experts might answer: That
it might have been crystallized in the
manufacture of the iron before it was
made into bolts or spikes; or that it
might have been caused by vibration; and
in the case of staybolts, they might say
it might have been caused by burning;
or by unequal expansion and contrac-
tion.
True, "with hollow bolts, plugging
would be out of the question," and with
hollow bolts, the expansion and con-
traction would be reduced to the mini-
mum, for with air flowing through them
their maximum temperature would not
be much, if any more than the tempera-
ture of the water or steam in the water
space, they could not be burned, nor
could their molecular structure be af-
fected by the expansion or contraction of
the sheet against them, for the air in
the center of the bolts relieves the pres-
sure on the walls of the hollow bolts.
Air and water are eflfective protectors
of the bolt from burning, the hollow
staybolts enjoy both, the solid has only
the water, and where it passes through
the inside sheet, the solid staybolt and
the sheet are least protected, cracking and
burning are probable, whereas, the hol-
low bolt is protected throughout its en-
tire length; the hollow bolt receives the
expansion of the sheet without the resist-
ance at expansion to the sheet, which the
solid bolts present, with risk of crystalliz-
ing by pressure on the molecular struc-
ture, the hollow bolt has its relief inward
on the elastic air passing through it, and
the elasticity is most where it is most
needed, at the inner end of the bolt, the
air expanding to about a three-fold vol-
ume between the outer and the inner
end of the bolt, with heat.
What may be asked is the effect of
burning? The answer may be given spe-
cifically from a technical journal with re-
spect to tests?
A plate of steel showed when tested,
results as follows:
Tensile strength 50.350 lbs.
Elongation 31. 5%
After service in the fire box, a strip of
hollow staybolt, nor can expansion and
contraction, in the same degree as with
solid staybolts, tend by vibrations from
such action, to crystalizc the hollow
staybolts.
That is not mere theory, it is founded
on demonstration in various ways, and
in a report from a railway upon a boiler
in which the hollow staybolts were con-
tinuously in service for over six years,
there is nothing said about burning, nor
about crystalization.
With the quality what it always should
be, in hollow staybolts, they will endure
more, and outlast any solid staybolt on
the market. John Livingstone.
Monlrcat, Can.
Treatment of Train flen in Mexico.
From time to time items have ap-
peared in your paper commenting on an
C, HUM AN CHIP.
the same plate was cut out and tested,
with results as follows:
Tensile strength 30,720 lbs.
Elongation . . . . 5%
It was found to be burnt, and the frac-
ture showed crystallization.
Much of the staybolt trouble of to-day,
a writer in Motive Power says, "can be
traced to the fire, as those who are
familiar with the fatal blue heat are
aware of the fact that when one of the
ends of the staybolts is heated the
fatal blue heat must appear somewhere
in the total lengths of the bolts, hence'
very little expansion is necessary to
break such a bolt."
That alleged cause of breakage which
may be charged to solid staybolts has no
place in the service of the hollow stay-
bolts, because the air passing through
them, and the temperature of the water
or steam in the water spaces are abso-
lute preventatives to the burning of the
alleged state of affairs in Mexico than
which Americans working on the rail-
roads there are frequently subjected to
unjust and even brutal treatment by the
authorities in case they (the employes)
chance to be connected with an accident,
and giving the impression that even
when they are in no wise directly re-
sponsible for the trouble they are liable
to be thrown into prison and left there
indefinitely without recourse.
I was in Mexico a few weeks ago. One
afternoon a freight ahead was derailed
and during the wait that resulted I had
a little talk with our engineer on this
subject. I began it by remarking that
I supposed some poor fellow country-
men of ours would either have to prompt-
ly take to the woods or lanquish for this
spill, judging from what I had seen in
our papers, and he laughed at me. He
said, in effect, that most of that sort of
thing is tommy-rot, as every railroad
454
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
man in Mexico knows. That a conscien- allow sufficient margin in working beiore
tious trainman there has no more to fear having to transfer tablets from one end
than in the United States, and that the of the section to the other should this be-
tales to the contrary originate mostly come necessary on account of a greater
with sore-heads who, either because of number of trains running in one direc-
incapacity or for some other good rea- tion than the other. Suppose the sta-
son, have found the country too warm tions to be named A B C D and so on,
for 'them and who then endeavor to jus- and the signalman at A wishes ^^to de-
tify their leaving by relating fanciful spatch a train he would g;ve the "Is line
stories of persecution. As I remember it, clear?" Signal to B. If the line is clear
he said that when a trainman appears to to B the signalman there will acknowl-
have been grossly negligent, especially edge this signal and give permission to
in cases involving casualties, then he
must answer in the courts, and not other-
wise, and no one can well take exception
to that.
Not being especially interested I did
not investigate further, but this engineer
was a big, bluff, jovial man, having ap-
parently no axe to grind, and h;s asser-
tions convinced me, at least, that Mexico
has been slandered more or less.
Ralph B. Bowm.\n.
The Steff System of Train Control.
In looking over some of your back
numbers for some information I was in
want of, my attention was arrested in the
issue of April, 1902, by an article bearing
the signalman at A to remove a tablet
from his instrument. The signalman at
A knows when he has received this per-
mission by seeing a magnetic needle on
the front of his instrument deflected to
zero and he then turns a commutator
to the left, draws out a slide containing
the tablet and gives one beat on a bell
to B which causes the indicators on both
instruments to indicate "tablet out" for
up or down trains as the case may be.
He then pulls off his semaphore signals
and hands the tablet to the engine driver.
When the train has entered the Sec-
tion A sends the 'Train entered Sec-
tion" signal to B, on receipt of which
B will go to his instrumentfor the oppo-
site section and send the "Is line clear?"
This apparatus consists of a cast iron
pillar erected in a suitable position on
the left hand side of the line near the
signal cabin. A sliding lever is placed on
the top of the pillar, and affixed to the
lever is a cross arm with a spring catcher
at one end and a delivery spring at the
othgr. A corresponding apparatus is
fixed on the left side of the engine, but
the position of the spring catcher and de-
livery spring is reversed. When tablets
are to be exchanged they are enclosed in
leather pouches. The signalman places
the one to be picked up in the delivery
spring of the ground apparatus, and the
driver places the one to be left in the de-
livery spring of the apparatus on the en-
gine. The sliding levers are then pushed
nut as far as they will go and firmly held
in that position until the exchange has
been effected.
I have not been able to make this
quite so clear as I should like to have
done, but from the enclosed sketches
and other descriptive matter you will
perhaps be able to follow it.
William Leith.
Aberdeen, Scotland.
the above heading, and it struck me that ^j^^^, ^^ ^^ ^^^ ^^ ^^
the system of train control you there » ^j^^ switches for sidings situated be-
refer to as being in use upon a certain ^^^^^ ^^^ j^^^j^^ stations are locked for
portion of the Cincinnati, New Orleans ^^^ ^^-^^ y^^^ ^^^ j,^g f3^,gt f^r the sec-
& Texas Pacific Railroad must be very ^j^^^ j^ ^,.^1^,^ ^j^^y ^^^ located forms the
much like a system which has been in ^^^ j^^. ^^^^^ ^^ ^^^^^ ^j^^y cannot be
use upon all the single track of the
Great North of Scotland Railroad for
twelve or. fourteen years, and known as
Tyers Electric Tablet System. The only
point of difference which I can see is
that under the system which you describe
a train can be put into a siding between
two stations and the staff instruments at
both ends unlocked so as to permit of
another train going through the sec-
tion; whereas with the tablet system
I am not aware of any provision being
made for this. There is no doubt this
is a decided advantage where the block
sections are long, but where, as with us,
they are not more than five or six miles
in length it is hardly worth while making
provision for.
The object of the tablet system is to
moved unless the engine driver who is
in possession of the section at the time
gives up the tablet for that purpose. The
locking frames for these sidings have
two levers and in order to get the
switches shifted the tablet is placed in a
recess in the frame, which allows the
lever for locking the switches to be
pulled over, but when this is done the
tablet is locked in and cannot be with-
drawn until the switches are set for the
main line and the locking lever put back
to secure them, so that there is no pos-
sibility of taking away the tablet and
leaving the switches set except for the
main line.
When this system of train control gets
interrupted in any way such as the in-
struments being damaged by a severe
provide a quick means of dealing with ^^^^^^^ ^^^^^ ^^ ^^^ ^.^^^ ^^.^^ ^^„^^„
we resort to what is known as Red Cap
pilot working, but as it is practically the
same as the staff and ticket system which
you mention in your article I will not
deal with it here.
In conjunction with the tablet system
trains and at the same time prevent more
than one being between two tablet sta-
tions at one time, and, when no train is
in the section, to admit of one being
started from either end as occasion re-
quires. In order to accomplish this each
division is broken up into sections, the
ends of which are electrically connected we use an apparatus for exchang.ng tab-
and provided with loop lines where two lets- Th>s apparatus was an invention
trains can meet and pass one another.
of the late Mr. McWilliam McKay, who
Each terminal tablet station is provided was for many years shop foreman with
with one, and each intermediate tablet the G. N. S. Railway at Kutybrewster,
station with two tablet instruments. Each and I am sure you will agree that it does
pair of instruments are supplied with its work very well when by its use we can
thirty tablets, and each instrument can exchange tablets with trains runnmg
hold all the thirty, but this is simply to over 60 miles per hour.
A Scientific Liar.
BY SHANDY MAGUIRE.
Jim Kelly and Jack Stanley were the
engineer and fireman of engine "63" on
the P. E. & W. road. As their names
indicate, they were offsprings of the
Ould Sod, Kelly being a Corkonian ana
Stanley from Kerry, two adjoining coun-
ties. They were what Roadmaster Dee-
gan called "Two strappin' fine fellows,"
because when he had them on work
train they attended to business. They
never could hitch between themselves
within the confines of the cab. They were
continually on the chew, Kelly standing
on the time-honored prerogatives of an
engineer, and Stanley also thinking he
had something to say. To their credit
be it said that there were no tales told
out of school; what took place on each
trip being kept as secret as if each life
was depending on secrecy.
Running on time one evening on the
"pick up" a sudden jar and a deafening
rattling caused Kelly to apply the emer-
gency. A first glance underneath woula
convince a skeptic that "63" was some-
what dilapidated,
"She's there, but not the whole of
her," said Stanley.
"I see she is, what's left," said Kelly
with a scowl.
By this time several passengers had
picked themselves up from between the
seats and very considerately had arrived
at the engine to offer suggestions on
what to do. The conductor, watch in
hand, said to Kelly: "How long is it
goin' to take you to get out of here?"
"About half an hour it everything
works all right."
In an aside, away from Kelly, but in
October, igo3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
455
the hearing of a bunch of passengers,
said he: "Nothin' works all right with
you. I'll have you stopped from haulin
me."
The passengers smiled, and one ol
them, a yokel from Tarburg, on his way
to Cluxton for a couple of yearlings,
looked with concentrated admiration at
his mighty ribs. Kelly found a hell's-
hurrah underneath. The two eccentric
blades and one lifter bent on one side;
the driver-!)rake rigging, the ash pan,
one sand pipe, one brake cylinder and a
cross brace all tangled up together, what
was left of them.
"Hand me the hammer, chisel and
monkey wrench, Jack," said Kelly from
underneath.
"There's no Stanley here," said a pas-
senger.
About this time Jack showed up and
the spectators were expecting a set-to
between Cork and Kerry. "Where was
you and Stanley at such a time as this
when you was needed so badly by me?"
"Oh, just eatin' a sandwich, and top-
pin' oflf with a swig of Adam's ale."
The look on Kelly's face indicated
struggling of a severe mental order.
Kelly knew that his best plan was to
conciliate Jack, in view of the investiga-
tion to take place so as to locate the
cause of the engine failure, and he only
said: "Come here and give me a hand.'
"I'll have to give you two, Jim, and
you'll need two heads to tell to the old
man's satisfaction how it happened,
when you are called up for trial."
In about 25 minutes the engine was
ready to go home on one side. There
was a terribly glum look upon Kelly's
face all the way in, and Stanley did not
help to smooth his ruffled feelings in the
least. "Say, Jim, if the little widow with
the coaxin' eyes and tawny locks could
get a glimpse ol you now she'd not be
quite so conscious that you were the
handsomest man that ever sat in a cab,
as she said to Jack McCabe's wife after
you left her last pay night.
"Jim, I'm in no humor to listen to any
of your ould guff to-night. Give me a
rest."
"Be gob, me bucko, it you only medi-
tated quarter as much on tossing up the
rascalities of your heart, to pour them
into Father O'Leary's ear in a penitential
mood, when at his knee, as you are now
thinking what you'll tell Dawson caused
the failure, the church would soon hear
from the college of cardinals that an-
other saint, by the name of Jim Kelly.
was added to its calendar."
"Say, Jack, let up on me to-night; 1
am in no humor for your fun."
"If you had looked her over as she
ought to have been, may be you'd have
found a cotter or a pin gone out of the
forward brake head by the looks of
things, which let them down. You trust
too much to a perfunctory inspection by
a man getting one fifty a day, who
doesn't care a tinker's dam if school
keeps or not.
■'I'll tell that I inspected her good, con-
sidering the time I had to turn around
in."
"Of course you will, and you'll flounder
around from lie to lie until you'll get
lost in a fog of blunderin' blather. You
don't know how to 'lie truthfully,' Jim,
as your townies, the Corkonians, would
say, so you'd better tell Dawson as little
as you po.ssibly can, because he doesn't
take much stock in your guff anyway,
ever since the time you told him the lie
of going to see your sick mother, when
he let you lay off, and learned that you
went to the hop fields with old Peg
Thorpe and her chums instead."
away from the vacations you take be-
tween runs, and attend to your dutie*
closer than you do."
"Well, if the old man does not get on
to me this time, I'll promise you that
I'll take your advice."
"You do?"
"Yes."
"Gimme ycr hand upon it."
They shook hands warmly, Stanley
saying: "This reminds me of the loyalty
of our daddies. When the fight would'
be going against the Corkics, and they'd
turn tail, when the Kerry boys would be-
found, coming to the rescue, the cry
was 'Come back Cork, Kerry is comingT
I'll get you out of this scrape, or die
trying. When we are up for investiga-
tion, all you have to say is when yoi»
^
LEHIGH VALLEY EXPRESS TRAIX AT 60 MILES AN
Photographed by Lynn Merrill, LTtica, N. Y.
"Jack, I know he is after me, and only
waitin' for a chance to let me out."
"And when you know it why don't you
look out for your job? You have one
of the best runs in the country. You
leave your home every morning at 7.30,
you are back at 7 in the evening, and
have 4 hours and 37 minutes of a lay
over in Cardiff, and if you cared anything
about the splendid position you'd take
six dollars and eighty-seven cents a day
out of every day in the month, and only
from home for one meal, you'd attend
more to looking after the engine you
make it on than you db."
"What good does it do you to be so
gifted with gab as you are to-night?"
"I'm sick of the way you've been
carrying sail for some time. For the
sake of your decent wife and your noble
old mother and the county where your
father tirst drew the breath of life, break
were rounding Rupert Curve you saw
something on the track, between the
rails, but you being on the outside, you
could not tell what it was or check speed
until you ran over it. I'll do the rest."
Next morning the train master, repre-
senting the transportion department, the
master mechanic and a stenographer were
seated in the shop office. There was ab-
solute silence for a few moments after
Kelly and Stanley entered and took seats,
until Stanley broke it by saying: "Be-
gob, I often heard tell of a Quaker
meetin'. but never was at one before."
"It will not long remain one where
you are. Mr. Stanley," said the train
master, who had no love for him. "Mr.
Forsyth," was Jack's reply, "you are
noted for doin' a lot of talkin' with your
mouth yourself."
The stenographer being ready, the
456
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
talking was turned into another channel
by M. M. Dawson.
"Mr. Kelly," said he, "you are re-
ported on yesterday's work sheet 37 min-
utes late, owing to a breakdown caused
by poor inspection. Please give us your
explanation." The sarcastic force laid on
the please was all Kelly required to
stiffen his backbone; besides, he had
faith in Stanley, so he spoke up saying
he was rounding the sharp curve, he be-
ing on the outside, and saw something
ahead, but was over it before he could
do anythii^. "What the result was is
e.xplaincd on my report, which I see you
have in your hand."
A supercilious sneer was on the face
of the M. M., who again led, looking for
an opening.
"Are you sure you saw an obstruction
in front of you?"
"Yes, sir, just as sure as I see you" — ■
without the quiver of a muscle.
"Did you go back to find out what it
been through a fusilade, saying 'there's
yer damned packin' block for ye, the
tlirack is all right.' "
While Jack was talking Kelly watched
him with the same anxiety of vision a
culprit watches the foreman of a jury
after his return to court to ascertain it
he was a dead man or not, his face
brightening as Jack talked, the crests ol
the M. M. and the T. M. dropping notice-
ably as the talk went on, for both of them
were after Jim, and very anxious to erase
his name from the pay rolls. The inves-
tigation was continued but a few mo-
ments longer, as the witness for the de-
fence could not be shaken, so the two
executioners lost their victim.
When Kelly and Stanley were well out
of hearing Kelly's exultation showed it-
self almost to the point of hugging Jack,
but he warmly said, "Jack, I feel like
kissin' you." "You'd better get over
your appetite for kissin'," he replied,
"particularly the tawny-haired widow, or
ynu miy sup sorrow without a spoon
could produce it in court at the proper
time. That is where I was, instead of
eatin' the sandwich."
"Suppose they make a search for the
car that lost the spring?"
"They might as well look for a needle
in a bundle of straw. The last train of
95 cars left the division at the junction
for the P. & D. an hour before. They'll
not follow it up.''
"Well, Jack, I thank you. All I can
say is that you are a scientific liar, and a
first class preacher. You gave me a
thoroughly moral lecturing all the way- in
last night, and this morning exemplified
to my astonishment how you can make
black appear white."
"Yes, I did, but the end justified the
means. If I saved you from the divorce
court and kept a happy home for you,
besides your job, by hurting nobody, I
am willing to stand up for punishment
when the sheep and goats will be gath-
ered together, and I will not get it very
bad for what I said to-day. You look
1 ., Mi
1
rft- A" ,',--^^ J
g^ I &
1 1
P--X
HP
>
m
^■|P^^^^^ ,4f!aMi
\- >.^-j-..
iM \i
1
Iwww - 5^_.
Ss\rf
i
h : T
■^^^""^ .■■.v^||^^_^^^^g^g;^i
^^^^ ^ -^^
_*" ^ . .Jft--^ Afejg^.fe. ,_^.._ v^^Ii '\ T^.«j
im«:&.LOCO.CNGINEERrN&
r '- - THihT 1 iTMmT ItW^ Ti^ fir
J. R Slack,
Supt. Motive Power.
"No, sir, I was in too much of a hurry
to get out of the way of the limited, and
get in with my passengers."
"You did not make very good time tak-
ing down your engine."
"You haven't a man could do it quick-
er, considerin' the kit of tools you fur-
nish."
That was a solar plexus thump from
Jim and he was dropped. Stanley was
now taken in hand.
"Mr. Stanley, what do you know about
this?"
"I know that I saw something right
ahead of us, but not soon enough to
notify Kelly, as I was attendin' to my
fire. I helped him to take down the en-
gine after I notified Tom McCarthy that
he'd better go back to the curve and
pick up one of his brace blocks, which
are spiked on the outside of the rails to
keep them from spreading. Before we
got started he went back, but I d d not
see him again until I was coming up
here. He gave me this — Stanley went
outside of the door and fetched in an
8-inch coil spring, looking as if it had
4-6-0 FOR DEL.'VVVARE & HUDSON.
iie.xt time ould Dawson gets a grip on
you."
"Well, yer a trump anyway. I never
heard so accomplished a liar. How did
you do it? And where did the spring
come from?"
"I'll tell you, but don't forget your
promise. Be square and manly with your
family and the company, and as far as 1
am concerned, mum's the word. Here
is the way I saved you: Some time ago
I asked Joe Wheeler, the car foreman,
for an 8-inch coil spring to make us a
handy push bar. I was waitin' my
chance to get the blacksmith at it. While
the royal Poo Bah of a ticket puncher
and the passengers were comin' up on
one side of the train to see what was the
matter, I was scootin' out the other side
to place the spring where it would do the
most good. I would have gone back to
pick it up, so as that no one would run
over it, but I met Section Boss McCarthy
and told him it was a cast iron brace
block that binds the outside of the curve,
knowing he'd go back to save his neck,
and fetch it in. I left it handy, so as 1
American Locomotive Co ,
Builders.
out for your promise. If there is any
more monkeying between you and the
widow you'll hear from me again."
Teii=Wheeler for the D. & H.
The Schenectady Works of the Ameri-
can Locomotive Company have recently
supplied the Delaware & Hudson with
some culm burning engines of the ten-
wheel type. These engines are simple,
with 21x26 ins. cylinders and 72 ins. driv-
ing wheels. All the wheels are flanged.
The cab is placed over the .center of the
boiler and this makes the engine a
"Mother Hubard" in railroad parlance.
The valve gear is indirect, the eccentrics
being on the main driving axle and an
extension bar curved slightly over the
forward axle reaches the rocker in the
usual way. The pedestal braces are bolts
with thimbles between the jaws with
cross-brace joining frames forward of the
leading axle, and with cross-frame braces
behind the main and trailing wheels.
The valves are American balance slide
valves, and are used on all the engines of
October, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
457
this order except two, upon which the
Ricliardson Balance valves are tried.
The boiler is a straight top one, with
a Wooten fire box. It is 63 ins. in diam-
eter at the smoke box end. The total
heating surface 2,663.72 sq. ft., of which
the 308 fifteen-foot tubes contribute
2405.5 sq. fl. The grate area is 84.85 sq.
ft. The fire box has one wide door, and
the staying between the crown and roof
sheets is radial. There is a cab roof over-
hanging the deck of the tender, which
protects the fireman when at work, and
the grate slopes lightly forward.
The total weight of this engine is about
175,000 lbs., of which 1,31.500 lbs. rest
upon the drivers. The tender is carried
on a steel channel frame, and the tank
has a water bottom. It has a water ca-
pacity of 6,500 U. S. gallons, and is de-
signed to carry 8 tons ot coal. The en-
gine is an example of good serviceable
medium passenger power in which ex-
cessive weight has not been desired. A
few of the leading dimensions are ap-
pended for reference:
General Dimensions— Fuel, fine anthracite coal;
weight in working order, 175,000 lbs.; weight
on drivers, 131,500 lbs. wgt. eng and ttnd. in
working order. 292,350 lbs ; wheel base, driv-
ing, 16 ft.; wheel base, total. 26 ft, 4 ins.; wheel
base, total, engine and tender, 53 ft. ";% ins.
Cylinders -Dia . 21 x 26 ins.; size of steam ports,
18 X 1'*^ ins ; size of exhaust ports, 18 x 3 ins. ;
size of bridge^, ih ins.
Valves — Greatest trav. of slide valves, $)4 ins.; out-
side lap of slide valves, l in ; inside lap of slide
valves, o in ; lead of vf.lves in full gear, ^^ in.
Wheels — Dia. of driving wheels outside of tires, 72
ins.; dia of engine truck wheels, 33 in.
Boiler — Style, VVootin type; working pressure, 200
lbs. ; thickness of plates in barrel and outside of
fire box. ^>y. ^J, K', 7i "*■• fire box, Igt, llgT's ins.;
fire box. width, 102 ins.; fire box, depth, front,
64 ins.; back, 42 ins ; fire box plates, thickness,
sides, ^ in ; back, >s in.; crown, ^sin.; tube
sheet, l^ in.; fire bos, water space, 3^ ins front;
3 in. sides; 3',4 in. back; firebox, crown staying,
radial; tubes, num., 308; heating sur., tubes.
2,405.5 sq. ft.; heating sur., water tubes, 78.54
sq. ft.; heating sur., fire box, 179 6S sq ft.;
heating sur., total, 2,663 72 sq. ft.; grate sur.,
84.85 sq. ft. grate, style, water grate.
Tender -Weight, empty, 47,100 lbs, ; wheel base, 18
ft. 5 ins.; tender frame, 10 ins, steel channels.
tested in the Missouri Pacific shops. The
method here adopted, does away with the
strut which usually stands between out-
side of stack and eye for block and
tackle hook. The use of heavy cast iron
stacks makes this form of crane quite sat-
isfactory and it has been known to work
all right £vcn with the "foot" broken off,
under such circumstances. With the
lighter form of stack the "foot" is bow-
ever very necessary in order to distribute
the thrust of lower end of the inside bar
over a certain area, but in either case it
makes a very useful, simple and easily-
made shop device.
Simple Shop Crane.
Probably the simplest style of shop
crane for use on the front end of loco-
motives is to be found in the St. Louis
shops of the Missouri Pacific Railroad.
The crane is one of those handy shop ap-
pliances which makes use of the smoke
stack as its excuse for being. The crane,
as our illustration shows, is simply a
heavy bar of round iron, perhaps ij4 or 2
ins. in diameter, with an eye at one end
to take the hook of a small block ana
tackle, and the other end is flattened out
and riveted to a "foot" which lies up
snugly against the curved inside of the
stack while the "crane" end of the device
bangs over the stack at what may be de-
scribed as the "appropriate anglr," This
bandy and simple crane has been in use
for some time and its merits are well at-
Changes In M. C. B. Interchange Rules.
Among the changes made in the code
of car interchange rules at the last M. C.
B. convention the principal are : Rules
Nos. 35 to 39 — Side doors lost are now
considered as owners' defect. Rule No.
64 — No wheels arc to be applied to for-
eign cars if they have been cast over
six years. Rule No. 69 — Air brake hose
applied to foreign cars must be new.
Rule No. 73 — Whenever cars are chained
together and delivered to any other
company, the receiving road shall deliver
to the delivering line, an equal number
of chains or issue defect card covering
same. Rule No. 87 — Labor charge cov-
ering the application of wheels has been
Ryerson Scholarships.
The Executive Committee of the
American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association has awarded the Joseph T.
Ryerson & Son Scholarship in Purdue
H.\NDY .SMOKE STACK CRANE.
University to Arthur B. Marsh, of Bos-
ton, Mass. The committee, consisting
of W. H. Lewis, of Roanoke, Va., presi-
dent of the association, Peter H. Peck,
of Chicago, vice-president, and Joseph
W. Taylor, also of Chicago, secretary,
held a meeting at Purdue and reviewed
the results of the examination of all
candidates as presented by the university
authority. It was found that seventeen
candidates had submitted to the prescrib-
ed examination. Mr. Marsh was certi-
fied to by the university authority as
having obtained the best results in his
examination.
The percentage of merit displayed by
the competitors in this examination was
remarkably high. It is a great pity that
no scholarships are open for the unsuc-
cessful candidates.
changed. Rule No. 104 — Several changes
have been made in charge for labor.
Rule No. 109 — No additional labor is to
be charged when replacing or renewing
a coupler when one or both of the draft
timbers at the same end of the car have
been replaced or renewed. Rule No.
Ill — Prices or bodies and trucks of cars
have been changed.
Some high-speed tests were made on
the Jersey & Seashore Division of the
Pennsylvania Railroad under very careful-
ly conducted arrangements. It was ex-
pected that one of the heavy high-speed
engines would attain a speed of 100 miles
an hour with eight coaches, but 90 miles
an hour was the highest speed attained.
If ordinary reporters had been keeping
the record any speed required wou'.d have
been made.
45S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
lo^ati^iEgneerint
▲ Practical Jonmal of Railway Motive
Power and Rollings Stock.
Published monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, " ioceng," N. T.
Glasgow, " Locanto."
Btislness Department ;
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NELLIS, Vice President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Secretary.
Editorial Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NEWS, )
GEO. S. HODGINS, Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department ;
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Snmmer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative— C. J. LUCK,
iao4 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative:
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd., Amen Comer, Paternoster
Row, E. C, London.
Olasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
fa.oo per year, $1.00 for six months, postage paid
/# the United States, Canada and Mexico. For
tiktr parts of the world, is.jo. or tin shillings.
Single copies, so cents. Kemtt by Express Money
Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Registered
Letttr.
Mailing address can bechatigedasoften as neces-
sary— always give old and new address, and i/ you
subscribed in a club, state who got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper fails
to reach you property .
Entered al Post OfEce, New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Anffus Sinclair Co . 1903.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Counterbalancing Locomotive Driving
Wheels.
We received recently from a technical
contemporary, little given to discussing
railroad matters, a letter from a super-
intendent of motive power of a prom-
inent railroad, asking for information
concerning the counterbalancing of lo-
comotives. We were su prised that a
man with the experience and standing of
the official who wrote the letter, should
be ignorant of the well established rules
for the counterbalancing of locomotive
driving wheels. On making some in-
quiry, however, we find that there is
still considerable diversity of opinion
about the proportion of conterbalance
weights, which may be used to the best
advantage, which moves us to outline
the rules generally accepted.
There are two phases of counter-
balancing that must be taken into con-
sideration. One is having too light
counterbalance weight to produce a
smooth running engine, the other is,
having the weights too heavy, with the
result that they hammer the track so
badly that the rails are frequently bent
by the recurring blows. These are two
extremes which it is the duty of the
designer or master mechanic to avoid.
When Thomas Rogers tirst applied
counterbalance weight to the driving
wheels of his engines, other lo-
comotive builders considered it an un-
necessary expense, and tried to make
out that the practice was worthless; but
experience with the engines soon demon-
strated that the invention ,vas a valuable
one, and its detractors all fell gradually
into line. But for a long time there
was great diversity of opinion about
what proportion of counterweight was
necessary to produce the best results,
and fashions in counterbalancing arose
which were as diverse as the fashions
in smoke stacks or in ladies' bonnets.
Every locomotive builder and nearly
every master mechanic had his rule for
counterbalancing, and great confusion
arose as to what was sound engineer-
ing practice. The famous engineering
writer, D. K. Claik, had given some
rules for counterbalancing as early as
1851, but they were largjly empirical
and were little known except among
the most progressive locomotive build-
ers. In 1878 a report on Counterbal-
ancing Driving Wheels was submitted
to the Railway Master Mechanics' As-
sociation, and the replies to a circular
indicated, in an amusing manner, the
progress made in the art. Among the
replies were:
1. Figure a little then guess at it.
2. Counterbalance revolving and re-
ciprocating parts, placing the weights as
far from the distance as possible, and
allow for distance accordingly.
3. Counterbalance by filling hollow
wheels with lead. We fill five spokes
and the rims between them. In small
wheels we have to balance between the
spokes in addition to the lead.
4. I find that in counterbalancing it
becomes necessary not only to counter-
balance the weight of the rods and other
attachments to the rods and axles, but
that there is a cushion in the cylinder
and the momentum of the rods to over-
come; consequently I balance weight of
rods perfectly, and then add 30 per cent,
of the weight counterbalanced; this
gives me a perfect and steady engine.
5. Ascertain the weight of metal in
arm of crank projecting beyond the
diameter of hub; add to this half the
weight of the connecting rod; counter-
balance this by cast iron plates fitted to
spokes and rim of wheel and held
together by bolts, the difference of lever-
age and weights being taken into con-
sideration.
6. Have experimented and found that
the following plan gives a perfect bal-
ance:
Weigh the piston, cross head, main
rod and side rod of one side, then
put two-thirds of the whole weight
balance in forward drivers, and one-third
in back drivers.
7. I usually calculate the amount of
counterbalance required to balance the
revolving parts, such as the lower end
of main rod, parallel rods, crank pins,
and hubs of each wheel and assign the
proper weight to each wheel. I also-
divide the reciprocating weights — cross-
head, piston, plunger and upper end o£
main rod, equally between the two
wheels, giving rather more to the front
wheels if any difference is made, and
always giving rather less than mo "e
counterbalance weight tlian the parts
to be balanced. I then calculate the
center of gravity of the counterbalance,
making due allowance for its distance
from the center as compared with that
of the crank pin. I prefer balancing
the moving parts by pouring lead into
the spokes and rim, if the wheels are
so made; and if not to cast the balance
in between the spokes. After the wheels
are down on the axles I generally raise
them off the ground and allow the
journals to rest on parallel strips. I
then hang the proper weights on the
crank pins and correct the balance to
suit, if they are much out of the way.
I prefer to have an excess ii. the front
pair of wheels, and a deficiency in the
back pair. I do not like the practice
some builders have of making the same
pattern of wheels for front and back
axles and same amount of counter-
balance.
These answers constituted the report
and the committee did not make any
recommendations. The only comment
on the report was made by Mr. William
Hudson, of the Rogers Locomotive
Works, who said that it was a very
important consideration in the arrange-
ment of counterbalance, to know ex-
actly what kind of work the engine was
to perform.
While slow train speeds under forty
miles an hour was the rule, the prin-
cipal requirement for counterbalancing
was to make the engine ride smoothly
without oscillation, and every master
mechanic engaged to adjust the weights
in the driving wheels to bring about
this result. If he did not. he would
soon hear from the engineers. As the
weight and power of locomotives kept
increasing, new complications arose
which proved that making an engine
ride smoothly did not meet all require-
ments. Heavy engines with small driv-
ing wheels turning very fast were found
to transmit destructive vertical shocks
to track and bridges and means were
necessary to soften what became known
as "the hammer blow." Investigators
found that the counter weights applied
were in many cases too heavy. By
degrees a practice became common ta
add weights to counterbalance the dis-
turbing action of the one sided revolv-
ing parts, and as little as possible of
the reciprocating parts. A majority
of railroads fell into the habit of bal-
October, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
459
ancing all ihc rcciprucauiig and two-
thirds of the reciprocating parts divided
equally among all the drivers.
Complaints having continued to be
made by the engineering departments
about the destructive effects of badly
balanced driving wheels, a committee
was appointed by the Railway Master
Mechanics' Association to investigate
the subject, and it was thoroughly done.
This committee, of which Mr. E. M.
Herr was chairman, worked for two
years and made reports to the conven-
tions in 1896 and in 1897. The rules
for counterbalancing driving wheels
which they recommended were:
"First. — Divide the total weight of
the engine by 400; subtract the quotient
from the weight of the reciprocating
parts on one side, including the front
end of the main rod.
"Second. — Distribute the remainder
equally among all driving wheels on one
side, adding to it the weight of the re-
volving parts for each wheel on that
side. The sum for each wheel, if placed
at a distance from the driving wheel
center equal to the length of the crank.
or a proportionately less weight at a
greater distance, will be the counter-
balance required."
Block Signaling on a Single Track
Road.
On a double track road the object of
block signals is primarily to preserve the
required space-interval between trains
moving in the same direction, or to put
it in plain English, obeying the signal
indications will prevent rear collisions.
The function of block signals on a
single track road is to prevent collisions
front and rear and for this purpose the
signals have not only to remain at dan-
ger behind a moving train in a block
but they have to show beforehand that
a train is approaching.
The Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas
Pacific is a carefully operated single
track road which is protected by auto-
matic block signals and is perhaps the
best example of its kind to be found in
the country. Distant signals are being
introduced on this line, but at present to
consider the simplest form of these sig-
nals may be the more satisfactory way
for the reader.
The signals for south-bound trains
are placed at the right, and those for
north-bound trains on the other side of
the track. The beginning of a block is
indicated by a small post placed about
150 feet from the signal, the object of
which will be apparent later on. When
we speak of the signals for a south-bound
train we mean the signals which the en-
gineer of a south-bound train would look
for, in order to be informed of the condi-
tion of block ahead. On a single track
road, however, the north-bound signals
are also operated by a south-bound train
in the vicinity, but they are then for the
information of any possible north-bound
engineer.
The operation of the system is briefly,
a train moving south enters block C
and the following signal indications give
visual indication of the fact. The en-
trance to block C is marked by a post
called the "signal station," which is 150
feet from the home signal for that block.
The engineer as he approaches block C
observes that the signal is "clear," if
the track ahead is unoccupied, when he
reaches the small post or signal station,
the signal just ahead of him goes to
"danger" as he passes on. The object
of this as explained by the officers of the
C. N. O. & T. P. is to give the engineer
the opportunity to actually witness the
movement of the semaphore blade, and
so feel satisfied that the apparatus is in
efficient working order, and also to give
him that feeling of security which comes
from the knowledge that the signal im-
mediately behind his train is protecting
it by showing the "danger" indication.
At the same time the home signal at B
is lowered, showing that the train has
passed out of block B. These indications
are given by what we may call the
"south-bound" signals, but the entrance
of this train into block C operated two
signals on the "north-bound" side. It
first raised the semaphore blade at E and
lowered the "north-bound" one at C,
which latter had already performed its
duty.
The train therefore on entering block
C protected itself from a following train
and at the same time caused a stop sig-
nal to be instantly displayed two blocks
ahead, which being a "north-bound" sig-
nal, would be looked for by an engineer
of a north-bound train, if one was then
on the line. This protection from "com-
ing events" on a single track line is most
important, because it pre-empts the line
ahead for two blocks and says to all and
sundry who are moving in the opposite
direction, "Your written orders may be
right or wrong, but a south-bound train
is now in block C." The same kind of
information is also given to the engineer
of the train in block C concerning the
one moving against him.
There is an interesting feature with re-
gard to the operation of this system,
and it is the fact that no sooner has a
train put up the danger indication ahead
of it, than by its own onward motion it
tends to reduce the distance ahead at
which it is protected. If on entering
block C it is at once protected at E, the
distance of the train from E, constantly
diminishes until at a certain point, gov-
erned by circumstances, the moving train
throws up another signal ahead and so
maintains an advance guard all the time.
The varying distance ahead at which a
train is protected, owing to its own mo-
tion, is arranged so that, taking track
and grade conditions into consideration,
the minimum distance will at all times
be adequate. "Forewarned is forearm-
ed," and a mistake in, or a misunder-
standing of, train orders would at once
become apparent to the engineers of the
opposing trains when they were on the
road and practically beyond the reach of
direct human aid, in that short but bless-
ed interval of time, before it is just too
late.
Electrically-Driven Shops.
The report of the Committee on Elec-
trically-Driven Shops, which was pre-
sented to the Master Mechanics' Associa-
tion, pointed out that the general subject
of electric transmission of power was
first treated in the association by a com-
mittee report in 1900. A charged wire is
a more convenient agent for the trans-
mission of power than shafting and belt-
ing. Electrically-driven tools permit the
shop designer to study the movement of
material in the shop and to lay out the
position of each machine in the most con-
venient and satisfactory manner.
The most important factor in the eco-
nomical movement of material is the
overhead electric traveling crane and
auxiliary hoists for doing rapid work
with light weights. Most of the tools
which have heavy material carried to
them by the crane, require a good deal
of power. These tools are wheel lathes,
planers, boring mills, slotters, rolls,
punches, shears and heavy engine lathes.
The motors required for these machines
are usually large enough to give a good
electrical efficiency and a low cost per
horse power, as compared with motors
for the smaller class of machine tool.
Sufficient belt power is often difficult to
obtain, to work modern tools to the
capacity of some of the existing tool
steels. Closely related to the question
of power is that of lighting, and fre-
quently in modern plants power and
light are taken from the same genera-
tors.
The problem which the shop designer
has before him to-day is to decide which
system of electrical power shall be used,
the alternating or direct current. Where
it is necessary to convey current to out-
lying portions of the company's prop-
erty, such as passenger stations, freight
sheds, etc. The alternating current
is the one to use. as the cost of the
copper for direct low voltage current
would be practically prohibitive. On the
other hand, if no long-distance transmis-
sion question enters into the calculation
the power plant may be entirely used for
distributing energ>' to a group of shop
buildings situated close together, so as
to make low voltage reasonably economi-
cal. If electrical speed control is desired
direct current must be used for driving
those tools which require speed control,
but it certainly entails extra expense, and
460
RAILWAY AXD LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
it is necessary to demonstrate that the
advantages of having it outweigh the ad-
ditional cost.
With beh-driven machines, if a speed
for a certain piece of work is too low.
the next higher may be too high, say an
increase of 40 per cent. There is always
a certain ammmt of time and trouble
required in shifting belts on cone pul-
leys. With electrical control, the simple
movement of a convenient lever produces
an increase of from 10 to 20 per cent. An-
other advantage of speed control is the
chance it gives for making a practical sys-
tem for setting cutting speeds. For exam-
ple, by adopting a uniform roughing feed,
and two uniform feeds, one for heavy and
one for light work, the most importani
variable in the case is eliminated, and tlio
speed problem becomes comparatively
easy. The report says: "In general it
may be stated that while close electrical
speed regulation may not be theoretically
necessary, it presents a practical method
of increasing the output from shop ma-
chinery that can not be approached by
the old belt and cone pulley, and that
this increase in output should largely out-
weigh the slight additional cost, and in
any shop where this small increase in
outlay can be made in order to effect a
substantial economy in operation, in
other words in any shop that is laid out
on reasonable business principles, some
form of speed control should be applied."'
The report also discusses the various
systems of wiring and of speed control.
Increased Speed with a Traction
Reducer.
When the traction increasers were ap-
plied to the large 4-4-2 engines on the
New York Central, the non-technical press
of the country were deeply interested and
regarded a traction increaser as a mys-
terious agency which resided somewhere
in the boiler and which gave the engineer
an opportunity to suddenly develop any
amount of power when nobody was look-
ing. Such an ordinary matter as the
transfer of weight was entirely too simp'e
to waste space on, so that columns of
"mystery" was the order of the day.
The non-technical press are now busy
with a new idea which has been worked
out by Prof. A. C. Albertson. an electrical
engineer, late of Copenhagen University
in Denmark. His idea, according to the
descriptions which have appeared in the
public prints, includes a train of cars, elec-
trically driven, which shall run on an ele-
vated structure, at the modest rate of 300
miles an hour. That is, a speed of 440
feet per second will be attained. How far
Prof. Albertson's scheme is correctly re-
ported we cannot just now tell, but it is
said that a one horse-power engine,
operating at one-sixth the cost of an
ordinary railway, will pull wheelless cars
at the speed quoted above.
The way all this is done is simple
enough on paper. The cars are mounted
on two trucks having very small wheels,
but these trucks and wheels are not used in
running, but are for the cars to sit down
on after a stop has been made. From the
body of the car at each end, attached to
the car sides supports pass down each
side of the girder of the elevated way and
on the ends of these supports arc power-
ful electro-magnets so placed as to slide
along the bottom face of the girder.
When current is turned on. mignetic at-
iniction carries the electro-magnets close
up to or nearly touching the bottom face
of the girder, this lifts the car up, small
trucks and all, and severs all connection
lietwcen the underside of the car and the
lop of the girder.
The weight of the car, acting down-
ward, and the upward effort of the mag-
nets are said to so nearly balance each
other that the car becomes as light as a
feather, so to speak, and therefore can be
moved along with the exp niditure of ver_\
little power. If, for example, a car
weighs 20 tons, magnetic force capable <<i
producing an upward effort of 21 tons
could be turned into the coils, and the car
would "weigh" one ton as far as the en-
gine was concerned, and the friction
would then be equ:il to a weight of <ine
ton being drawn along the track. Just
how far this is true, and if true how the
application of the principle will be worked
out for a train of full sized cars, we will
not attempt to say. A working model is
said to be on exhibition, which demon-
strates the truth of the theory.
We are further told that current neces-
sary to supply 1. 000 electric lights of or-
dinary power would suspend a weight of
120 tons or six cars each weighing 20
tons. The locomotive to be used would,
of course, be electrical, with large drivers
and supplied with the "weight reducing"
apparatus as is used on the cars and ap-
parently as tractive effort will be a mat-
ter of no importance to this engine, it be-
comes easily master of the situation.
One of the objections which may be
urged against the whole scheme, is that if
the magnets actually touched the under-
side of the girder, they would develop
considerable friction even at moderate
speeds, and the parts would certainly re-
quire lubrication, and constant adjustment
for wear. If the magnets were not al-
lowed to touch the girder, their lifting
power would be lessened, and wheels
would have to be introduced, and when
that is done we are at once face to
face with the old hot box problem,
which it is so joyfully stated will dis-
appear from the wheelless car on the
5-mile-a-minutc train. When it comes to
the very high speeds talked about in con-
nection with this railway, we may say
that at the present time, mankind does
not know anything about wind resist-
ance to cars, or the effects of weather
conditions or storms at these velocities
for tlie simple reason that so far nobody
has traveled continuously 300 miles an
hour. The railway requires to be built
and the whole thing done exactly as the-
oretically outlined, before it is worth any-
thing to the public, and the building and
the doing are the two things we are not
likely to see much of.
The Traveling Engineers on Locomo-
tive Front Ends.
The committee's report on Locomotive
Front Ends with the very long discussion
which took place at the Traveling En-
gineers' Convention last month, to which
we devote liberal space in this issue, are
well worthy of careful study. .\n attempt
was made to find a front end or design
one that the Traveling Engineers' As-
sociation could recommend to railroad
companies as a standard: but instead of
advancing those interested towards uni-
formity, the report and the discussion re-
vealed an amazing diversity of practice
and great conflict of opinion about the
utility of the appliances most commonly
used. We had supposed that the dimen-
sions and appliances which produced the
most satisfactory results, in the investi-
gations and tests made by the committee
of the Master Mechanics' Association in
1896, of which Mr. Robert Quayle was
chairman, would have been used as a
basis for designing front ends and their
attachments, but the remarks of the
various speakers indicated that very little
attention has been given to conclusions
reached by the Master Mechanics' Coin-
mittee. That may have been due in some
measure to the fact that the Master
Mechanics' Association made no specific
recommendations of particular forms or
dimensions, merely stating what pro-
duced the best results in creating draft.
But the discussion revealed the tendency
of different railroad companies and in-
dividuals to go on experimenting for
themselves regardless of what had been
found out by others better equipped to
make accurate experiments.
Great allowances must be made for
individual tastes and prejudices, full at-
tention must be given to varied con-
ditions of fuel and service: but when one
man throws away and utterly rejects as
worthless things which the majority of
motive power people have found to be
so valuable that they are indispensable in
making an engine steam freely, there is
scmiething wrong, something demanding
further investigation. Jumping at con-
elusions on insufificient information is a
very dangerous practice when it leads
to a radical change on such important
devices as draft appliances, yet one listen-
ing to the discussion at the Traveling
Engineers' Convention could not help
feeling that very little judgment was dis-
played in the actions described by some
of the ooeakers or in the conclusions
October, I'jo^.
KM I. WAY AND LOCOMCJTIVE ENGINEERING
4') I
they arrived at. To do tilings diffcrciuly
from otliers may bo impressive, 1)iit it is
dangerous.
Tlic most bopefiil thing connected witli
the discussion liappened at tlic conclu-
sion, when Mr. W. G. Wallace got the
following resolution carried:
Resolved, That we, the Traveling ICn-
ginccrs' .Association, recommend no
special or delinite front end arrange-
ment at this time, but do recommend
that the facts developed by the Master
Meclianics' Association and by Professor
■Goss, ot I'urdue University, be made inn-
basis for future work and research; and,
further, we believe the greater part of
the dilliculties experienced in service are
due, more to lack of .system in keeping
the appliances adjusted, so as to give
the best results, than to the mechanism
itself.
The Unresilient Driving Wlieel.
Tlie sur))risingly high speed attained
by automobiles using pneumatic tires
has moved inventors tc scheme on the
production of some elastic medium in-
tended to soften the blow of tires on the
track and incidentally to reduce the noise.
There is certainly urgent need for an in-
vention of this character, but it is very
doubtful if anything practicable can be
produced. Springs were first applied to
railway vehicles because the engineers
of permanent way discovered that the
unresilient weight inflicted severe in-
jury on the rails, and it was found that
the intervention of springs between the
load and the rails materially lessened the
damage of the rolling blows.
The early locomotive builders were
quite alert to the necessity for making
the wheels of their engines as easy as
possible on the track, and it was a com-
mon practice to insert a lining of wood
between the wheel center and the tire.
Mr. M. W. Baldwin obtained a patent on
a wheel ni this knid which was illustrated
on page 352 of our August number.
George S. Griggs, master mechanic of
the Boston & Providence Railroad, pat-
ented a resilient wheel and had great
success in using it. On an inferior track
his wheels fitted with Lowmoor tires
made as much as 140,000 miles to the
inch of wear. Some difficulty was ex-
perienced keeping the tires tight on the
soft lining, but the invention was not
abandoned on that account. The practice
originated and progressed of shrinking
iron or steel tires upon cast iron centers.
It was an easy way of securing the tire,
and the ordinary railroad mechanic never
paid so much attention to a little ex-
pense as he did to convenience, so the
resilient tire gradually went out of
fashion. It never was conclusively
demonstrated that elastic wheels were
less destructive on the track than wheels
with s<ilid centers, and nobody displayed
nuich anxiety to find out. The use of
wooden lining between wheel centers and
tires was sufficiently prolonged to prove
its efficiency, for in"a report on tires sub-
mitted to the American Railway Master
Mechanics' Association in i86g, five rail-
road companies were reported as using
wooden blocks between wheel center and
tire. That practice would not have been
adhered to so long, if it had not pos-
sessed merit which appealed to the mas-
ter mechanic keenly interested in secur-
ing all the wear possible out of tires.
With the light engines going out of use
thirty years ago and the introduction of
steel rails, there was probably little dif-
ference what kind of wheel center was
used, but we think that modern con-
ditions demand that something be done
if possible to soften the blows of the
heavy driving wheels, now pounding over
the rails at double the velocity common
wiien engineers first demanded the gen-
eral introduction of sprmgs.
The whole weight of the pioneer loco-
motives built in the days when the neces-
sity for the use of resilient driving
wheels was first acknowledged, was fre-
quently little more than the driving
wheels of a modern locomotive with
their attachments. Baldwin's second en-
gine weighed about seven tons and the
driving wheels of a modern passenger
engine weigh nearly as much. The fol-
lowing may be accepted as an approxi-
mate weight of one pair of driving
wheels 72 inches diameter with their un-
cushioned attachments:
Weiglit of wheel centers 6 300 lbs.
Weight two tires 3 x 55^ inches. 2,6co lbs.
Weight one 9 x 12 ins. driv. axle 700 lbs.
Weigtit four eccentrics 600 lbs.
Weight four eccentric straps 500 lbs.
Weight two crank pins 250 lbs.
Weight two steel driving boxes. 800 lbs.
Weight main and side rods 500 lbs.
12 250 lbs.
VV'e have heard a great deal about the
destructive effects of the "hammer blow"
imparted by the unbalanced forces in a
revolving driving wheel, but we think
that the impact of the great unresilient
weight is sufficient to commit serious
damage to rail joints and frogs, without
the addition of other disturbing forces
being taken into account.
We recently heard objections made by
a number o' railroad officials to the use
of brick arches in locomotive fire boxes
on the ground that a boiler could not be
w-ashed out immediately on arrival oflf a
trip, because the brick arch held the
heat so long that the fire box sheets
were liable to receive damage from over-
heating. That confesses a reckless want
of care of the boiler wdiich ought to have
time to cool before washing out is com-
menced. But it represents the prevail-
ing tendency to rush the engine back
into work regardless of fair usage. It
has no doubt been the same spirit of
rushing the motive power which led the
practice of putting a, cushion Ijetwecn
the wheel center and the tire to be aban-
doned. Applying that lining was a tedi-
ous operation which required careful
work that could not be rushed, it would
probably hold an engine in the shop a
few hours nuirc than would be neces-
sary to shrink a tire upon an iron center,
and so the practice was discontinued in
submission to tlje strenuous conditions
of locomotive operating that have devel-
oped of late years.
In the early days of railroad operating
the chief engineer exercised much great-
er power than he does to-day; and he
always opposed practices calculated to in-
jure the track. We believe that had the
chief engineer of to-day been as influ-
ential as he was forty years ago, a vigor-
ous fight would have been waged against
the solid driving wheels and all their un-
cushioned attachments.
Mr. George Richards, the veteran re-
tired master mechanic who was asso-
ciated with Mr. George S. Griggs, writes
to us:
Mr. Griggs took out a patent on the
wood block wheel and used it with good
results on the B. & P. R. It was also
used on several other roads. After his
death his heirs sold the patent to par-
ties who did not push it. There is need
of some one with a push with moot in-
ventions. It was used most with iron
tyres and increased their life very much,
and I never heard of a broken tyre which
was set on the wood blocks.
The edition of Blackall's Air Brake
Catechism, which we have been selling
at $1.50 per copy, has been exhausted,
and we are therefore not in a position
to fill the many orders which have .come
in for it. A new, revised and enlarged
edition of this valuable book will be
out toward the end of September. It
will contain 310 pages, 100 illustrations
and II folding plates, including three
printed in colors. This is the eighteenth
edition, and the price will be $2.00 per
copy.
A curious feature of the discussion on
Locomotive Front Ends at the Traveling
Engineers' Convention was the play on
the expression, "a delusion and a snare."
Mr. Roesch applied it to the double lift
pipe in the smoke box, then during the
protracted discussion that ensued nearly
every speaker used the expression.
Some of the magazines have been
publishing notices of rich men and call-
ing them captains of industry. In sev-
erSl cases sharks of industry would have
been a very appropriate title, for the
"captains" never did an honest day's
work in their lives.
462
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE -ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED
(62) Apprentice asks:
What is the difference between stress
and strain, when used in a mechanical
sense?— A. Stress is distributed force
and tends to change the shape of a body;
strain is the amount of change of the
shape of the body caused by the applica-
tion of stress.
(63) A correspondent or subscriber
in Australia writes:
"Why is the throttle valve on our
very big engines (10 wheelers) so very
difficult to open in full gear, and by
winding up the gear near center the
throttle is quite easy to open? This ques-
tion particularly applies to the engine
from a locomotive firm in Manchester."
[f our correspondent had given some more
particulars about the kind of throttle used
and where it is located, we might be able
to answer the question. (We, however,
refer the matter to our readers; perhaps
some of them can suggest what it is.)
(64) L. A. M. writes;
I am one of the men who listened to
the discussions at the Traveling En-
gineers' Convention last week, and I am
convinced that little progress has been
made by railroad companies to abate the
joint nuisance of locomotives throwing
sparks, dirt and smoke. When the nuis-
ance cannot be stopped it ought to be
shorn of its annoyance to passengers, and
I am working on a scheme to lead the
fire gases back to the end of the train.
Could you help me to induce some rail-
road company to give the invention a
fair trial? If you will pay the expenses
of the patent I am willing to give you
a quarter interest. A.— At the conven-
tion referred to the editor of Railway
AND Locomotive Engineering said that
people investigating the efficiency of rail-
way appliances ought to read up on
what had previously been done in the
line under investigation. If our corre-
spondent had done this he would have
found an arrangement for carrying the
gas and cinders of the locomotive to the
back end of the train had been patented
as long ago as 1840. Practically the same
thing has been invented periodically ever
since.
(6s) W. B. says:
We have two water tanks and a dis-
pute has arisen about the pressure to be
obtained from them. They are about
twelve feet high, but one of them is
about 20 feet diameter and the other is
about 10 feet diameter. I say that a
greater pressure of water can be got
from the big tank than from the small
one, but I do not know how to figure
it and some of the men say I am wrong.
We decided to refer the question to you.
A.— The pressure depends upon the
height of the water, and the diameter of
the tank has nothing to do with it.
The pressure per foot of height is about
.433 pound, or nearly half a pound. Thus
the pressure at 10 feet head is 4.33
pounds, at 20 iect, 8.66 pounds, and so
on.
(66) T. C. S., Durand, Mich., asks:
I. In making report of defective pack-
ing in a cylinder which would be proper
to say, examine cylinder packing or ex-
amine piston packing? Should you de-
sire to report metallic packing for pis-
ton rod would you make this report:
"Examine piston rod packing?" A. —
"Cylinder packing" is all right, but
there seems to us to be no ambiguity in
saying piston packing when you mean
the packing rings of the piston, or in say-
ing piston-rod packing when you mean
the metallic packing rings which sur-
round the rod. The blow of steam whicli
the rings are intended to prevent is past
the piston in one case, and past the rod
in the other, and it is logical to use words
indicating those parts. 2. You are dis-
connecting an American type standard
engine; you disconnect valve rod and
cover the ports, disconnect back end of
main rod, shove crosshead ahead in the
guides, block it there and let main rod
hang in the guide yoke; would this be
considered better practice than to take
down both ends of this light main rod,
putting it away, blocking crosshead back
in the guides, no haste being required in
the case? A.— The better practice is to
take down the main rod and get it out of
the way. One can never be quite cer-
tain of the behavior of a disabled engine
on the road, and strange things some-
times happen. If the crosshead was bad-
ly blocked you might have serious
trouble. In any case it is advisable to
block the valve on the center when-
ever you can. 3.. You have an en-
gine with front cylinder head gone;
no damage to cylinder, piston, packing
or follower head; you have a passenger
train and are within five or ten miles of
a terminal, favorable piece of road part
down hill, engine being a free steamer,
would you think it advisable and possible
to start this train and maintain steam
pressure enough to handle the train this
distance, avoiding delay disconnecting;
also in this connection in starting the
train would the jar be greater or less with
the engine in this connection or working
only one side? A.— We have known it to
be successfully done where conditions
are favorable as you describe, but it is
not good practice. It requires the tak-
ing of chances of running out of steam at
a critical point, in any case it wastes
steam profusely, and would, especially
on the right side, tend to dangerously
obscure the engineer's view of track and
signals. If the engine be carefully han-
dled the jar would not be so very heavy,
because high speed could not be made
under steam.
Your other questions will be answered
next month.
(67) J. W., Toccoa, Ga., writes:
In running an eight-wheel passenger
engine, weight about 72,000 lbs., rear
axle on front truck broke in center of
journal. Everything was running per-
fectly cool and in good shape. Can you
give any reason for this breakage? A.—
There are several possible causes for this.
The axle may have been defective from
tlie beginning, service simply developing
an inherent flaw or defect. The journal
may have been very hot at some previous
time and have been improperly treated.
The material may not have been thor-
oughly fibrous in structure and may have
crystalized in service and so become brit-
tle, or for some reason the journal may
have been worn or have been carrying
an excessive load.
How Expense of Front=End Tests
May Be Met.
The chairman of the committee of the
American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association appointed to help in the in-
vestigation of locomotive front ends un-
dertaken by the American Engineer and
Railroad Journ<il has made application to
the executive committee to provide
money to defray the expenses of the
tests. As the association does not have
any money available for such an expen-
diture, there is danger that the tests may
not be carried out. As the work was
originated by the Ameriean Engineer and
Railroad Journal an impression is abro id
that the enterprising proprietor of t.iat
publication will say to the committee,
"Proceed with the work, gentlemen, I
liave got valuable advertising from the
work of this committee, and I am ready
to pay all the expenses necessary for
finishing the tests."
The thirty-fourth annual convention
of the Master Car and Locomotive Pamt-
ers' Association was held in Chicago in
the second week in September. Among
the reports of committees may be men-
tioned the paper on the Proper Method
of Painting and Maintaining a Locomo-
tive Engine, and the paper on Best Meth-
od and Material for Painting and Main-
taining Steel Cars. There were several
essays read at the meeting, one by Mr.
J. A. Cohen, of the Big Four, was on
the copper-sheathed cars; Mr. J. H.
Pitard. of the Mobile & Ohio, discussed
the question. Is the authority and re-
sponsibility of the Master Painter co-
equal? And Mr. C. Clark, of the Nickel
Plate, took up the matter of Harmony
in Color in finishing and furnishing the
modern railway passenger car.
The New York sales offices of the
Nernst Lamp Company have recently
been removed from the Equitable Build-
ing and transferred to the new Hanover
Bank Building, No. 11 Pine street. New
York.
October, icjoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
463
Baldwin Engines for the Wabash.
The Wabash Railroad liavc recently
ordered 32 fast freight moguls of the
two-cylinder or cross compound type
from the Baldwin Locomotive Works of
Philadelphia. The cylinders are 20J/2 in.
and 32>4x28 ins. and the driving wheels
are 63 ins. in diameter. The pressure
carried is 200 pounds, and the calculated
tractive effort is about 24,900 pounds.
The main driving wheels are the only
ones not flanged.
The weight of the engine in working
order is 148,880 pounds, of which 139,660
pounds rest on the drivers, while the total
weight of engine and tender are about
269,000 pounds. The crosshead is of the
two guide bar type, and the piston rod is
secured to it by nut and shoulder.
The motion is of the usual indirect
kind, and the valves are balanced slide"
valves. The yoke or what may be called
the spectacle plate is secured across the
frames in the usual way, but as it does
not entirely surround the guide bar
ing dimensions of these engines are as
follows:
Cylinder -20^ ins. and 32^4 x 2H ins.
Iloiler - thickness of sheets, ;"ix)Jin,; working
pressure, jcolbs.; fuel, soft coal; slaying, radial.
I'ire box— length, 114 ins.; width, 42 ins,; depth,
front, 77},^ ins., back, 63^ ins ; thickness of
sheets, sides, A in.; back, ,•, in.; crown. }•/. in.;
lube, li: in.: wat. space, front, 4 ins.; sides,
3% ins.; l)ack, 4 ins.
Tubes— material, iron; wire, gauge 12; number,
290; dia , 2 ins.; length, 11 ft. 4% ins.
Heating surface- fire box, 169 sq. ft.; tubes, 1,712.7
sq. ft.; tot., 1,881.7 sq.ft.; grate area, 33.2:; sq. ft.
I)riv. wheels— dia., outside, 63 in.; jour., 9x11 ins.
lingine truck wheels— dia., 36 ins. ; jour.. 6x 10 ins.
Wheel bast-driving, 14 ft, o ins. ; total engine, 22
ft. 7 ins. ; L<jt:il engine and tender, 51 ft. 2'/j ins.
Weight— on driving wheels, 129,600 lbs.; on truck,
front, 19,220 lbs.; total engine, 14K H80 lbs.;
total engine and tender, about 269,000 lbs.
Tank — capacity, 6,000 gals.
The Missouri Pacific people at the St.
Louis shops often have occasion to finish
their piston packing rings on a boring
mill in order to save the use of some of
their busy lathes. When the outside of
motive concerns have not been able to
turn out without much delay all the lo-
comotives needed by the western roads,
and now these roads have taken steps to
m^kc themselves independent of the
eastern builders. The practical result
of this fine scheme will be that Wall
street influences will order all the lo-
comotive building shops closed, as soon
as trade depression arrives. Then skilled
labor will be scattered to all parts of
the country where employment can be
obtained and the railroads will have to
order their power from eastern shops
as soon as prosperity returns. That is
the way history repeats itself.
Spoiled the Banquet.
Some years ago the Lodge of Loco-
motive Firemen bought a valve model
for educational purposes and they had a
little difficulty with it. They met in the
lodge of the Order of Elks and the
Master of the Firemen's Lodge asked the
ii.\i.i)\viN' i-;m,im'.
\\,\r.-\sll K.MI.ROAD.
blocks, it is supported from a bracket on
the boiler by means of a bar with piN
connections top and bottom. The lead-
ing drivers and the pony truck wheels
are equalized together and the main and
rear drivers are also equalized together.
The boiler is an extension wagon top,
the gussett sheet sloping to the smoke-
box. The smallest diameter of the boiler
is 6354 i"s. and the largest diameter is
7i}4 ins. The roof sheet slopes 3% ins.
toward the back sheet and the crown
sheet has also the same slope toward the
back.
The tender has arched bar trucks and
the tank, which holds 6,000 gallons, is
supported on a steel channel frame. The
tender axle boxes are provided with rub-
ber hose tubes so that cold water may
be used in the event of a hot bo.x show-
ing itself.
The whole machine presents a neat ap-
pearance and reflects credit upon de-
signer and builder alike. The engineer
has been provided with a very ample win-
dow and has all the light which can be
obtained in that way. A few of the lead-
the drum has been faced oiT and the in-
side bored out to the required size, a gang
tool, specially made for the purpose, is
put in, and four rings are cut off at each
operation. This saves a great deal of
time, as the adjustment for the top ring
is made with a spacer and all the others
are evenly divided by the gang tool. This
operation is somewhat more than four
times as fast as if each ring were cut
off by itself by reason of the facility of ad-
justment, and at the same time it is a
quarantee of absolute uniformity.
Railroads to Build Their Own Motive
Power.
Before many years, say a series of
press dispatches, most of the western
roads will be in a position to build their
own locomotives. Until recently few lo-
comotives were built in the West, and
the railroads had to depend entirely upon
the big eastern locomotive works for
a!l of their motive power. Owing to
the great demand for locomotives dur-
incj the last few vears. the eastern loco-
old he-Elk where they could put it. He
told them to put it into the banquet-
room, but to get a case made for it so
that it would not be injured. The car-
penter employed made a bo.x to go over
it that would take up the least room,
and when it was done and stained it
looked just like a coffin set up on legs.
.\ few days after it was in place, the old
he-Elk sent for the secretary of the
lodge and asked him what in the name
of the everlasting gee-whiz they had in
that casket. Said he : "We tried to have a
little banquet after initiation last night,
but the boys couldn't enthuse with that
thing there, and the whole thing was
solemn as a church, so the lodge voted
that I tell you to please remove the re-
mains or get a new hall — we don't keep
a vault."
The Chicago & Eastern Illinois have
been using the Brewer fire door, which
was illustrated in our July number, and
are highly satisfied with it. They have
recently given an order for the door to
be applied to ten more engines.
464
RAILWAY AXD LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
(X-tobcr, 1903.
Air=Brake Department.
CONDUCTED BY F. M. NELLIS.
Air Signal on Air-Brake Train Pipe.
A corrospondeiU asks it any one has
ever devised a scheme to operate the
air signal on the train pipe of the air-
brake. For his information and that of
others we would say that as fir back
as 1876 Mr. Westinghouse patented an
air signal to operate on the train line of
the brake system. This scheme is illns-
rifj. 3
trated in accompanying cuts in this de-
partment.
To give the signals with this arrange-
ment, a modification of the three-way
cock, the brake valve then in use, was
neces.sary. The construction ot tliis
valve is shown in Figs, i and 2. The
connection from the main reservoir is
made to the union ./, the brake pipe is
connected to the union B; and the
branch C forms a discharge port. The
modification consists of the introduc-
tion, in the reservoir connection, of a
piston valve for limiting the diameter
of the opening to the brake pipe to one-
eighth of an inch at all times, except
when the brakes are to be released, when
this valve, by moving the handle of the
three-way cock to the position shown in
Fig, 2, is raised from its seat, leaving
the passage unobstructed. The slightest
return of the handle toward its central
position reseats this valve, leaving the
opening one-eighth inch as before.
A further modification is the small
whistle and valve screwed into the top
of the plu.g and connected by the union
I,', with the port f, of tiie diaphragm
\alvc. The piece D, by opening a side
port, enables the engineer ^o prevent the
blowing of the whistle while operating
the brakes. This, of course, throws the
signaling device out of commission,
meanwhile.
The diaphragm valve. Fig. 3, has a
port. a. connected to tlie brake pipe,
thriiugh which air passes to the signal
reservoir, located at some convenient
point under the cab or running board,
which latter is connected to the port b.
cliar,?ing it with the same pressure. A
slight reduction of pressure in the train
pipe causes the excess of pressure in the
reservoir, acting upon the diaphragm in-
terposed between the ports a and b. to
open a valve which permits the air to
pass from the reservoir to the port c, to
the pipe connection d. on the three-way
cnck and valves to the whistle, sounding
it until the equilibrium is restored on the
two sides of the diaphragm.
Fig. 4 shows the car-brake valve for
application of the brakes and the giving
of signals. The connection from the
main brake pipe is made to the port f,
leading into the chamber F. A second
cliamber. G, has a connection, g. leading
to the atmosphere. The chambers F and
G communicate through a port closed by
a valve having a rubber face, which is
held in its seat by a small spiral spring
assisted by the air pressure. The cord
extending through the car is attached to
the lever H, and, when pulled, opens the
port between the chambers F and G,
discharging the air through the port G
and into a small pipe leading through
the bottom of the car. As will be seen,
the signal valve is really the beginning
of the present conductors' valve which is
now used to apply brakes only.
In addition to this patent held by the
Westinghouse Co., a number oT similar
patents have been gotten out by railroad
and air-brake men from time to time.
Our readers will recognize the weakness
of the scheme in the fact that signals
cannot be given at the moment that
brakes are either being applied or re-
leased, and can only be made effective
at such times as the pressure in the
train pipe is in equilibrium and is not
flowing in or out.
Octol)lT, H)0,'\.
RAILWAY A\n I.DrOMOI IVF. KN'Cil N'F.ERING
465
Oil Cup for the Air Cylinder.
'I'lic acciiiiipanyiiig cuts of an oil cup
for the air cylinder of tlic pumi) has
been invented by Mr. Frank JJickcl. of
the New York Air Brake Co., and is in
quite .siiccesstnl and extensive u.se on the
Central Railroad of New Jersey.
Fig. I is a sectional view of the cup
; StTcic into fti'arf of air
! _ci/liitiler uf air pump
FIG. 1,
body. Figs. 2 and 3 are dimension cms
of the cup l)ody and cap nut respectively.
Fig. 4 in a dimension and illustrative
cut of the "choke" or piece containing
the restricted feed port. The operation
of the cup is as follows:
The air pressure comes up from the
air cylinder through the passage i, port
g, chamber f. and down throxigh port e
into chamber D. As the pump runs, the
oil in chamber D is supposed to vaporize
and pass from chamber D up through
passage e. and down through restricted
port g and passageway i into the air
if ; 1 '4I J
I - — l\t. KThds. — ^L-4-
ii 36 Threads
going to ch.imber I) in the oil cup, be-
comes luliricatcd from contact with the
oil, and carries a certain amount of oil
in vaporized form with it back into the
air cylinder.
cylinder. Drops of oil do not rise from
the quantity in chamber D and pass to
the air cylinder as might be supposed,
but is carried along with the air in a
vaporized form. In other words, the air
.\
Air Pump Tests.
)rrespondcnt writes interestingly in
this department of the air pump tests dis-
cussed at the last .'Mr Brake Convention.
These tests were four m number, and
were bricHy and substantially as follows:
The first test consisted of a drilled
diaphragm placed either in some con-
venient point near the brake valve or at
the rear of the tender, and the pump run
at about 100 or 140 strokes per minute,
being rc(iuired to keep up a pressure
against a 3-16 in. opening in the dia-
pliragm.
Test No. 2 consisted of a similar ar-
rangement described in No. I, except
that the speed of the pump was about 60
or ;o strokes per minute, and was re-
ciuircd to keep up a pressure against an
escape port 3-32 in. in diameter.
Test No. 3 consisted of a gauge screw-
ed into the bottom head of the air ryl-
der of the pump, and at a slow speed,
pressure passing by the packing rings
would pile up in pounds in the suction
end of the cylinder and show on the
gauge.
Test No. 4 was called the "oil cup
test" and was made by opening the oil
cup on the top end of the air cylinder,
and running the pump at a slow speed.
If air blew out of the oil cup on the down
stroke, it meant a leakage of pressure
past the packing rings. This degree of
leakage either passed or condemned the
pump.
malic reducing valve of the WcstinRhouse
Air-Brake Co. We appenfl herewith
tables No. i and No. 2, showing the
results of these tests, which we believe
will be interesting and instructive to
our readers.
It should be noted that in all New York
tests a final brake cylinder pressure of
Hot Boxes.
A correspondent asks if a hot journal
or "hot box" will have any tendency
toward wheel sliding. As our engineer
and firemen readers have observed on
trains, a "hot box" will cause a train to
pull much harder. In fact, when an en-
gineer discovers his train to be pulling
hard he invariably looks about to find
whether there is not a "hot box" or two
on the train. On the other hand the
cooling of a "hot box" or replacement
of the old brass with new one. has
ofttimes been done and train been found
to pull easier.
Some Competitive High-Speed Brake
Tests.
Durin.^ the months of May and June.
1903. some interesting high-speed brake
tests were held by the Central Railroad
of New Jersey, being placed under the
direct supervision of Mr. T. L. Burton.
General .Air-Brake Inspector of that sys-
tem. The apparatus used was that of the
New York Air-Brake Co., which consisted
of a pop or safety valve, and the auto-
> •?
Mtf. t Un. £mi.
-Mi 1< Thit.
FIG. .3.
70 lbs. was retained by the use of their
safety valve. This 70 lb. final brake cyl-
inder pressure resulted in a terminal brak-
ing power of about 115 per cent. There
was no wheel sliding from the use of these
valves because of the favorable weather
conditions that prevailed. In competition
with these special safety valves and unu-
sual conditions, the Westinghouse special
high-speed reducing valves were used.
These valves were set to close at 60 lbs.
final brake cylinder pressure: but they
were so adjusted that the blow down of
pressure from the highest to the final 60
lbs. required a longer time than does the
standard type of reducing valve, thus put-
ting the apparatus of both companies on
substantially the same basis. The results
of these tests are shown in Table No. I.
Upon the completion of the tests with
-J ^-ii
h—^XDrOl
36 r«r«lds-X
/'<Hi*/# fill orer
£,.«£.ai.bf.
FIG. 4.
this special apparatus, it was decided by
the railroad representatives that the use
of so high a final brake cylinder pressure
as 70 lbs. was not adapted to general ser-
vice, and especially to poor rail condi-
tions. Therefore, a second series of tests
466
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
TABLE No. 1, COMPARATIVE TESTS OF HIGH-SPEED BRAKE
On the Central Railroad of New Jersey, Near Atsion, New Jersey, May and June, 1903, Between the
Westinghouse Air Brake Company and the New York Air Brake Company.
No. of
Test.
Kind of Brake.
No. of
Cars.
Actual
Speed.
M. P. H.
Actual
Brake-Pipe
Pressure,
Pounds.
Actual Length
of Stop.
Feet.
Speed for
Calculated
Stop,
M. P. H.
Brake- Pipe
Pressure
for
Calculated
Stop.
Pounds.
Length of
Calculated
Stop,
Feet.
Average
Length of
Calculated
Stop.
Feet.
Amount
Shorter Stop
by
Westinghouse
Brake,
Feet.
9
10
11
17
18
19
Weslingliouse,
Westingliouse,
Westinghouse,
New York,
New York,
New York ,
3
3
3
3
3
3
78.60
79.64
77.92
77.58
78.60
80.35
110.3
110.5
109.7
1095
109.6
109.5
2053.00
2108.00
1929.75
215225
2255 10
2340.75
80
80
80
80
80
80
110
110
no
110
no
no
2133.44
2137.0!)
2029.37
2270 96
2334.92
2318.71
2099.96
2308.19
208.23
22
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
3
3
70.03
70.86
109.2
109.6
1595.58
1572.75
70
70
no
no
1579.23
1629 99
1554.61
"9 07
29
32
00
New York,
New York,
New York,
3
3
3
69.23
68,70
69.23
109 3
109 5
109.3
1540 58
1537.08
1548.00
70
70
70
no
no
no
1573.19
1594.23
1580.63
1682.68
C3
64
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
6
6
09.23
70.86
109.6
109.3
1262.91
1424.58
70
70
no
no
1286 31
13S106
1333.68
237 C6 '
43
44
45
New York,
New York,
New York,
6
6
6
70.31
70.03
70.03
110.0
109.5
109.6
1566.16
1600.33
1666 50
70
70
70
no
no
no
1552 38
1597 60
1564.06
1571.34
27
38
39
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
6
6
6
59.80
60.20
5S.82
109.4
109.4
109 4
974.75
995.00
954 83
60
60
60
no
no
no
976.16
982.82
987 92
982.30
32 77
34
35
36
New York,
New York,
New York,
6
6
6
59.60
59.21
58.82
109.1
109.3
109.0
1014.66
908 41
98925
60
60
60
no
no
no
1026.19
992.57
1026 45
1015 07
40
41
42
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
6
6
6
51.28
61.13
50.84
109.0
109.1
109.1
656 75
613.25
031.83
50
50
50
no
no
no
618.60
5S2.03
005.95
602.16
68.79
46
47
48
New York,
New York,
New York,
6
6
6
50.56
49.18
50.42
109.3
1094
110.0
706.08
650.08
664.00
50
50
60
no
no
no
688.98
670.90
652 98
670.95
4
S
2
3
Westinghouse,
Westiiigliouse,
Westinghouse,
Westinghouse,
3
3
3
3
79.30
78.26
70.87
69 50
70.16
71.16
71.10
69.70
2804.66
2660.41
2061.16
2066.00
80
80
70
70
70
70
70
70
2,S.->9.76
2817.97
2036.90
2078.63
2838 86
2057.71
of a more service condition character valve, set at 60 lbs. pressure, over the biy appreciated by reference to Table No.
was run in which were used only
the standard Westinghouse high-
speed reducing valves, thousands of
which, similarly adjusted, are in suc-
cessful use to-day throughout the
ordinary pop or safety valve, set to hold
a final brake cylinder pressure of 70 'bs.
Perhaps one of the most valuable bits
of information derived from these tests
was the greatly improved showing of the
2. It will be observed that the length of
stop made by the use of the high-speed
brake is about 30 per cent, shorter than
that made with the ordinary 70 lbs. train
line brake.
BaUicayi Aoevmofii'* EnffinMringf
SHELTON BEAMLESS BRAKE AS APPLIED TO DENVER & RIO GRANDE COACH No. ^03.
country under the many and varied con-
ditions of general air-brake service. The
tests demonstrated forcibly the superior-
ity of the high-speed automatic reducing
high-speed brake stops, with no lbs. train
line pressure over the stops made with
the ordinary brake operated by 70 lbs.
train line pressure, as will be more forci-
The proceedings of the Colorado
Springs convention of the Air Brake
Association is just from the press and
contains much valuable information.
October, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOIIVE ENGINEERING
467
TABLE No. 2. TUSTS OF HlflH-SPEED BRAKE
On the Central Railroad of New Jersey, Near Atsion, New Jersey, May and June, 1903; Train beinj:
Equipped with the Westinghouse Air Brake Company's Standard Valves.
No. of
Tc-l.
No. of
Cars.
Actual Speed,
M. P H.
Actual Brake-
Pipe Pressure,
Pounds.
Actual Length
of Stop,
I-cct.
Speed for
Calculated Stop,
M. P. H.
Brake-Pipe
Pressure for
Calculate^! Slop,
Pounds.
Leni;th o(
Calculated Stop.
l-cel.
Average Length
of
Calculated Slop,
Feel
101
102
117
6
6
6
70 03
69.51)
70.31
109.75
109.80
111. SO
1527.25
1533.06
1 456.08
70
70
70
110
no
110
1.52288
1541.75
1464.04
1509.55
104
loy
110
6
6
6
61.13
58 44
59.00
109.66
110.25
110 50
1029.50
935.75
973.92
60
60
60
no
no
no
970.44
98S.34
990.95
986.24
111
111'
<>
6
51.42
49.58
110.25
110 30
670.41
622.00
50
50
no
no
635.15
034.08
634.61
120
3
76.27
100.3
Iil45.o0
80
no
lit74.37
103
ICS
ion
6
6
G
70.03
70.58
70.31
70.08
70.00
70.00
1972 58
1893,50
1879.58
70
70
70
70
70
70 1
1972 73
1862.50
1863.04
1899.42
CORRESPONDENCE.
Pump Repairs and Tests.
Regarding the proper test of air pumps
for shop repair rooms, I would say that
at the Colorado Springs Convention of
the Air Brake Association last April the
subject of test for air pumps was pretty
thoroughly discussed, and resolved itself
into four principal tests, which I will de-
scribe as follows:
Test No. I. This test was with a dia-
would' appear to many that this was tlie
better test of the two.
Test No. 3 consisted of a gauge
screwed into the bottom head of the air
cylinder of the pump, and a speed of
about 40 strokes per minute obtained. In
this test the gauge would show the pres-
sure leakage past the packing rings into
the suction end of the cylinder, showing
up in pounds on the gauge. In this test
the gauge would show also the leakage
past the discharge valve in the main res-
ervoir, allowing the pressure to come
OlESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ON AIR BRAKE SUBJECTS.
(72) A. L. B., Birmingham, Ala.,
H rites:
I find a lot of trouble in trying to
*tudy 'the air brake from the instruction
book gotten out by the air brake manu-
facturer. Is there any plainer book on
this subject that I could get to help me
study the brake and get a good under-
standing of it? A. — We do not know
of any simpler book than the one gotten
SHELTON BEAMLESS BRAKE AS APPLIED TO DENVER & RIO GRANDE R. R- COACH No. 703.
phragm connection placed at the engin-
eer's brake valve, or in the hose coupling
at the rear of the tender. The test of the
diaphragm at the brake valve was a com-
paratively reliable test, inasmuch that it
showed the capacity of the pump, pump-
ing against the leak in the diaphragm.
The diaphragm placed in the hose at the
rear of the tender, showed leaks in the
main reservoir connections, the train pipe
and the auxiliary reservoir, and did not
show reliably the condition of the air cyl-
inder of the pump.
Test No. 2. was a similar test to No. i,
except that the speed of the pump was
much slower. In the first test the pump
was run at a speed of about 130 strokes
per minute against a 3-16 in. opening in
the diaphragm. In test No. 2 the pump
was run at about 60 to 70 strokes per
minute against an opening of 3-32 in. It
back into the cylinder, thereby confusing
the test, unless the discharge valves had
been previously tested.
Test No. 4 consisted of opening the oil
cup on the top end of the air cylinder,
the pump run at a slow speed, and on the
down stroke, if pressure passed by the
packing rings, it should blow out of the
cup. This test is good and simple but
does not tell the degree of leakage past
the rings, e.xcept to practiced and skilled
repairmen; but then, only practiced and'
skilled repairmen should work on air
pumps.
These four tests combine some very
good features, and I think all air brake
men should be able to select from a
combination of these a good test for
themselves.
J. S. Kr.\nbean.
Flushing. L. /., .Vric York.
out by the manufacturer of the air brake.
You can greatly reduce your difficulty if
you get some one to study with you. In
this way one can follow the designation
figures and parts on the charts while the
other reads aloud the explanations. We
have known this to be tried in several
cases with very good results.
(73) G. E. L., Council Bluflfs, Iowa,
asks:
Which is the best engineer for moun-
tain work, the one who holds his train
a long time between releases and re-
charges, or the one who recharges fre-
quently? A. — Without question the man
who makes moderately light applications
and frequent recharges is the better man
from an air brake point of view, and
possibly all others. The man who re-
charges infrequently is obliged to draw
46S
RAILWAY AXD LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Oclobcr, 1903.
down his train pipe auxiliary reservoir
pressures dangerously low, thereby re-
quiring considerable time to get it up
again to where it becomes efficient. In
the meantime, it emergency should arise
requiring the train to be stopped, suffi-
cient braking power would not be avail-
able and could not be obtained in time
to do it. On the other hand, the en-
gineer who recharges fre(|uently and
makes short holds, always has a higher
train line and auxiliary reservoir pres-
sure, is ready for emergencies, and al-
ways has his train under control.
(74) J- M. E.. Cleveland, O.. asks:
What causes air whistle to sound on an
engine every few minutes when engine is
moved slowly, but when engine is
coupled to train a)ul running either fast
or slow, the whistle never sounds except
when signal valve is operated in the
coacli. Applying brakes or releasing
them does not affect the whistle. It sim-
ply sounds of its own accord. The re-
ducing valve, release valve and all
pipes and connections are a iparently in
good order. A. — The stem of the signal-
ing valve probably fits too snugly in its
bushing, or is gummed with thick or
burned oil. This, in connection with
very small, imperceptible leaks in the
signal line on the engine and tender, will
cause the whistle to sound from no ap-
parent cause. When this engine is
coupled to a train the volume of signal
line pressure is increased, and the small
leaks thereby loose their influence over
the signaling vahe.
(75) E. R. L., Buffalo, N. Y.. writes:
On some of the Pullman cars the triple
valve will blow for a long time after the
train has come to a standstill. Also on
some of the coaches I have observed that
the brakes release so slowly that the
exhaust will blow half way to the next
station. A. — This is undoubtedly due to
an excessive length of piston travel,
which permits the cylinder to take a large
volume of air at each application; and,
in releasing this large volume, the pres-
sure must necessarily take a long time
in passing out at the exhaust port of the
triple valve. Generally, but not always.
a long piston travel can be discovered
by the length of the exhaust of the triple
valve; however, this is not true in cases
where the exhaust port of the triple valve
has become clogged and its opening re-
duced by accumulation of dirt and oil.
(76) J. M. E., Cleveland, O., asks:
Can an engineer with His brake valve
release 3 or 4 cars on a front end car,
on the rear end, or in the middle, as he
sees fit? One engineer here says he can
do this on any cars in train that he likes.
A. — No. It is impossible. This is an old
bit of foolish bragging. However, on a
train of 7 or 8 cars, or thereabouts, the
piston travel may be so adjusted that a
quick shot of air from the main reservoir
into the train pipe with the engineer's
brake valve, will cause the long travel
brake to release first, wlienever it may
be in the train. This is especially true
if the brakes are about fully applied. By
manipulatin,g the piston travel m a train
of this kind, the long travel car may be
placed anywhere in the train and made
to go off first. As to releasing any cer-
tain brake he is called upon to do. he
can't do it. The engineer who makes
the claim is making a very preposterous
one. and can be shown his mistake by
requiring him to release a certain speci-
fied brake.
(77) .M. R. II. .Montreal, Canada,
w rites:
My brake valve on my engine acts very
<iueerly. When I go to apply my air in
service position, the black pointer hand
of my air gauge will drop down very
quickly, and 1 get an emergency appli-
cation of brakes on my train. 1 have
cleane<l the valve and it has also been
cleaned and inspected by the air man. _
but tlie trouble does not disappear,
riease tell me where I can look for the
trouble and how to remedy it. .A. — The
small equalizing reservoir under the foot-
board is probably partly filled with
water, thus reducing the capacity of this
reservoir and the chamber D above the
equalizing piston. In this event each
time the service application is made the
air in chamber D and the equalizing
reservoir will quickly reduce and the
black pointer suddenly drop. -Again, the
gasket in the union which connects the
reservoir pipe to the brake valve may be
crushed into the opening, thus reducing
the opening through the union, in some
instances almost cutting the equalizing
reservoir off.
(78) G. E. L.. Council Bluffs. Iowa,
writes:
Will a hot journal, or hiit box. cause
a wheel to slide under a car. or will it
have any eft'ect in the direction of caus-
ing the wheel to slide? A. — Anything
which occurs to hinder or retard the roll-
ing action of the wheel, whether it he
from brake shoe friction applied to the
rim of the wheel, or to friction applied to
the axle, will operate against the rolling
action of the wheel and tend to produce
sliding. If the friction between the
journal brass and the journal is exces-
sive, as is frequently the case with a hot
box, that friction will tend toward wheel-
sliding to the same degree in which the
friction is applied. With the brake shoe
applied to the rim of the wlieel with
braking power adjusted so that the
brake will hold all it possildy can with-
out sliding, the wheel, it any further
friction is applied on the wheel by the
shoe, or on the iinirnal l)y the brass,
sliding will doiiliiless result. Hence the
hot box will have a tendency toward
wheel sliding.
(79) G. F. .A„ Wilmington, Del.,
writes:
1 liave seen the wheels under some
.\dams Express cars sliding on a bad
rail. Would it not be best to reduce the
brake power on these cars until wheel
sliding will disappear, even on a bad
rail? A. — If we were to so reduce the
leverage to insure no sliding of wheels-
whatever, even on a slippery and greasy
rail, we would deprive the car of suffi-
cient breaking force to permit it to make
a reasonable stop in ordinary service;
that is, if the braking power was so low
as to insure absolute freedom from sl.d-
ing of wheels on a bad rail, the car would
not hold its share in making ordinary
service stops; and, with a train of such
cars, not a half way respectable stop
could be made. Such sliding, as on a
greasy rail, does very little damage to-
wheels, and it may be expected on bad
rails. It will be noticed on such bad
rails that the driver wheels of the loco-
motive will generally spin freely when
starting the train out of a station. On
such a rail, wheel-sliding does not spot
wheels but wry little.
(80) G. E. L., Council Bluffs, Iowa,
asks:
Why will not the water brake do as-
good work and answer all purposes oix
a mountain engine as the combined
straight air and automatic brake will
do? -A, — The water brake, which was
advocated by air brake men until recent-
ly, and which has been in quite extensive
service on mountain grades in the West,
perforins about the same work as does
the combined straight air and automatic
brake on the engine when the train is-
running. The particular advantage of the
combined straight air brake is not only
that it can be used to steady the engine
and tender while the train is being re-
charged and held in check, but that it
can also be used to hold the engine and
prevent it from moving after it has been
brought to a standstill. Frequently at
water spouts, coal pockets and such
places, it is necessary to hold the engine
after it has been brought to a standstill
until taking water or coal has been fin-
ished. Likewise it is necessary to hold
the engine while the fireman may be
cleaning the ash pan or the engineer oil-
ing around, between the spokes of the
wheels, etc. The straight air brake al-
lows pressure to be pumped directly into-
the driver brake cylinders, thus holding
the engine and tender, even though the
packing might be poor and permit the
brake to leak off. .^gain. the water
brake is objectionable inasmuch that it
will hold the engine only, and not the
tender, and tends to rack the machinery
to a certain extent. The straight air
brake brakes on wheels of the locomo-
ti\e and the tender both, and permits the
engine machinery to drift free in running
down grades.
OcldlllT, HKM.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMOTI VK ENGINKERING
4'"j
Proceedings of Traveling Kngineers'
Convention.
I IIH IlKK'K Al<( II.
'I'lie cuiiiniiUce of the 'J'ravflinK En-
gineers' Associalion presented its report,
through Mr. W. G. Wrillru-c, nf tlie
Chicago & Nortliwesterii, on ilu- l)ricU
arch, at tin- meeting recently luM in
Chicago. 'I'Ue report was licailnl "How
do you consider the u.sc of tlie brick
arcli in engines ])urning bituminous coal
in deep, sliallnw .nid wide fire boxes?"
A series of nineteen ipiestions were sent
out by the committee.
The replies received from members on
lines where bituminous coal is used indi-
cate that they consider the use of the
arch as a powerful adjunct in steam mak-
ing and economy. With an engine prop-
erly drafted less coal is required by rea-
son of the gases being retained longer in
Ihe fire box and uniting the carbon with
the oxygen in better proportion at the
igniting temperature, which gives more
perfect conilnistion.
The committee, however, say that it is
not claimed that an engine can be draft-
ed to give a more economical perform-
ance without an arch than with one, and
opinions differ as to wlu-ther or not the
fire will burn whiter with or without the
arch, but the important assertion is made
that all unite in claiming that the pres-
ence of the brick arch will assist in re-
ducing black smoke.
No data was presented in the report
to show the amount of coal used per
train or per ton mile, but the committee
favors the use of the arch in engines
where the conditions are favorable. This
appears to mean that in good water lo-
calities and where sufficient time is al-
lowed at terminals to clean off grates,
bore out and caulk flues and do necessary
fire box work, the arch can be used witli
advantage.
The disadvantages urged against the
use of the arch under conditions differ-
ent to those just stated are that in poor
or bad water localities and where tlie
time at terminals is limited, the flues be-
come stopped up and the flue sheets
honeycomb behind the arch. The flue
and fire box cleaners cannot bore out
flues or clean the sheet and grates in the
time given them with a hot arch, and
the work of properly caulking leaky
flues under the circumstances is well nigh
impossible.
In the matter of engine failures the
arch is one more cause which may pro-
duce a failure either by falling down it-
self or by the leaking of the supporting
tubes or circulation pipes upon which the
arch rests. An inexperienced fireman w'ill
probably find greater difficulty in plac-
ing coal on the grates wdiere an arch is
used than where the fire box is clear, and
may therefore produce what may be
called a steam failure.
The committee, however, believe that
l.iki-n from the standpoint of economy
ill doll.ns ,ind cents, on shallow and wide
lire box engines, the arch is not a benefit
except as above stated, where work can
be done properly and coiicblions war-
rant its use.
The discussion which followed showed
Ihe keen interest taken in this subject by
the members of the association, and it
served to emphasize the fact that to be
of use the brick arch and tlie engine
using it must receive fair play.
The first speaker, Mr. J. J. Gill, stated
that upon his road, the New York Cen-
tral, a test had been made with six cn-
brick in them, Nos. 2421 tandem com-
pound, 2.387 cross compound and 1753
simple engine, during that test — it was
from the i8th day of .May until the loth
day of August — those three engines n'lt
using the brick arch, were dumped eigh-
teen times, something like every two
weeks. On the other hand, the engines
with the brick arch, Nos. 2419 tandem,
2350 cross and 1779 simple, were dumped
twenty-five times, seven limes oftener
than the engines without the arch. Dur-
ing that test we kept track of the engine
failures of those six engines used in this
test with and without arch. The engines
DRIDCE COLLAPSED WITH ENGINE TRYING TO 6T.\RT TR.^^IN.
gines, three using the arch and three with-
out. He said: "The first two engines were
very large tandem compounds, w-eighing
187 tons. They had a grate area of 58 sq.
ft., a hauling capacity of 4.200 tons. The
next two were cross compound, weighing
about 150 tons, with 53 ft. 32 ins. area,
hauling a tonnage of 3.333 tons, and the
next two were two simple engines in fast
freight service. I would like to state
here that the engine in fast freight ser-
vice gave a little better satisfaction with
the grate, on account of being a little
sharper on the fire without the brick.
"The first three engines that had no
that had not the brick in them had no
failures whatever during this ninety days
for steam or leaky flues. The engine with
the brick arch, one of those engines. 2350
a cross compound, had two failures, one
on the 1st of July, due to flues leaking,
and one on the 12th. due to too low steam
and flues leaking. Two failures against
the arch. Engines with a brick arch
would save one ton of coal per trip of
140 miles. .\t that rate fifty engines on
the Mohawk Division, making fourteen
round trips or twenty-eight singles, at
two dollars a trip saving in fuel, would
save about $2,800. This test was all in
470
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
the freight service. We use in the freight
service Beech Creek brick. These brick
cost about so cents apiece. Ten brick
to a set cost $S, labor 50 cents, engine
dumped twice a month vi'ould be $11.
You save about four brick, $2, leaving a
balance of $9 to keep up the brick arch.
Average number of trips per month on
engine will make fourteen runs, or about
4,000 miles. Average to set of brick
about 2,000 miles. Fifty engines at $9
per month for the brick would cost $450.
Four hundred and fifty dollars deducted
from $2,800 leaves a balance of $2,350
saving by the brick arch in fuel.
"On the other hand, take fifty engines
without brick arch. Those engines we
found by actual test could be got ready
anywhere from three to four hours quick-
er without the brick arcn. Now those
engines that got ready four hours quick-
er dumped twice a month would be about
eight hours to an engine or about 400
hours. Four hundred hours divided by
twelve would equal 33 1-3 trains of
eighty-five cars each, or 2,805 cars moved
over a division 141 miles long in thirty
days. That is in favor of the engine
without the brick arch. Now if any gen-
tleman can give us the figures what the
company would realize in moving a car
over the division, multiplied by 2,805 we
can find just what the saving will be and
put that against the saving of fuel on the
brick arch.
"I sent the following letter on the
subject to the master mechanic. 'In re-
gard to brick arch test on 'Mohawk di-
vision I watched the performap^te of the
engines very closely and find 'that the
engines without the brick arch steamed
just as freely as engines with -the brick
arch in freight service. We did .not have
occasion to change draft of any .engine
after arch was removed. ' E^iiveS without
the aiioh burned a h'ttle-lnore 'coai and
threw 'more black sraokei £93! \vas not
weighed, consequently I'catmot give- ex-
act amount consumed, tut would estimate
it at about 8 or 10 per cetit. Without the
brick afch we have the advantage of keep-
ing the fines cleaned out and when engines
are dumped for repairs they can be used
from three to four hours quicker than if
brick had to be cooled off, taken out and
replaced. Engines using brick arch
when flues become stopped up cannot be
cleaned with advantage and the flues be-
hind the brick arch which are plugged,
commence to leak. Another feature,
without the brick arch we have no deten-
tion from brick falling down and causing
low steam and time lost getting brick
out of fire box on road. On the G2 and
G4 class of engines the brick arch is
supported by the water bars and the
weight of the brick and jar of engine
causes them to leak, also miking engine
failures. Taking everything into consid-
eration, I think in freight service if the
arch was removed and the flues thor-
oughly cleaned at terminals the company
could use their engines quicker and to
greater advantage, especially in winter,
when power was being turned at each
end of the division."
The next speaker, Mr. Crandall, also
on the New York Central, said that on
the Western division they had also been
making a test and had found that more
flues plugged up with the arch than with-
out it, and without the arch flues can be
cleaned more easily and quickly at ter-
minals and they can be cleaned out if
necessary on the road. With the arch,
when the flues begin to leak they be-
come honeycombed, and it is a hard mat-
ter to get the honeycomb off the lower
flues, and an inexperienced fireman will
get along better without an arch than
with one. There is much less heat in the
cab without the arch than where the
arch is used.
Mr. Jas. E. Donnelley, International
Cor. Schools, read his answers to
the questions proposed by the com-
mittee and spoke in favor of the hol-
lo vv or double brick arch, a model of
which was on exhibition at the meeting.
The representative of the Santa Fe,
Mr. Beardsley, said: We think we save
one ton of coal in seven by the use of
the brick arch, and the arch costs from
$5.30 to $7.50 each. The average life of
the arch is from seven to ten thousand
miles, or about from five to eight weeks.
It is used in all engines on all divisions
with which he is connected.
Mr. E. R. Webb, of the Michigan
Central, said they used the arch in pas-
senger engines with short deep fire boxes
making about six or seven thousand miles
a month. He had not found a boiler-
' maker who cared for the arch. The heat
in the bo.x is more intense with the arch
than without it, and combustion better,
but side sheets crack more quickly with
, it than without, as the flame at the sides
'follows the line of the arch, s'
The discussion was clo'setl by Mr. Gil-
lett, of the Norfolk S-Westefi^'.^Who re-
ported that his Company had entirely
given up the use of the brick arch, and
that on a test a saving of twelve pounds
per mile was made by the engines with-
out the arch.
DISCUSSION ON FRONT ENDS.
The committee of the Traveling En-
gineers' Association appointed to inves-
tigate the subject of Front Ends for Lo-
comotives started' out with the idea of
finding a front end that they could claim
originated with the association. In their
search for originality of design they were
no more successful than Diogenes was in
finding an honest man. The nearest ap-
proach to perfection they found was a
modification of the front end recom-
mended for standard of the Master Me-
chanics' Association, by Mr. Robert
Quayle, after the experiments he carried
out with locomotive front ends in 1896.
Front ends of this design were tried by
the Michigan Central Railroad, but did
not give such good results as a front end
previously used.
The master mechanics' front end was
applied to a new 4-4-2 engine built for
the Michigan Central, and it did not give
satisfaction. Various changes were tried,
and those in charge finally settled on the
arrangement shown in the annexed en-
graving, the results having been most
gratifying.
The committee discovered that the old
idea, that the steam jet from the exhaust
nozzle should fill the stack is a fallacy.
They expressed the belief that little im-
provement can be made on designs al-
ready in successful use. They urge lib-
erality on the part of members to try
without prejudice some of the things
known to be good, and to quit following
empty theories. The best designed front
end will not prove satisfactory unless
surrounded by proper conditions, such as
freedom from steam leaks in front end,
air leaks in smoke-box, and improper
alignment of nozzle petticoat pipe and
smoke stack.
After the reading of the report Mr. J.
A. Taltz, D., L. & W., said they had
received forty Consolidation engines
equipped with the Michigan Central
front end, which did fairly well, but
after running fifty or sixty miles the fire
box would be full of dirt and clinkers.
They tried a change. Instead of bring-
ing the plate around the nozzle stand,
they ran the plate back of the nozzle
stand at the same angle as the deflecting
plates. In addition to this, they put in a
single draft pipe and reinoved the double
one. After that change the engines
would run over the division without hav-
ing their fires cleaned. They also gave
less trouble from leaky tubes.
Mr. Bentley, C, R. I. & P., directed
attention to the value of the petticoat
pipe in regulating draft, and objected to
men putting the pipe wherever they
pleased. He was not satisfied that the
theory of the jet shooting through the
stack without touching the sides was
right.
Mr. Donald R. McBain, Michigan
Central, took the ground that the steam
jet passes through the center of the
stack and that the fuel gases pass out in
the annular space surrounding the col-
umn of exhaust steam. His experience
went to prove that an engine with a
short stack could steam as freely as one
with a long stack.
Mr. E. W. Brown, D., L. & W., be-
lieved that the jet seen passing through
the stack was due to steam condensation,
and that expansion would cause the
steam to fill part of the stack.
Mr. Taltz mentioned that the steam
jet passing through the smokestack is
( Continued on ptige ^yj. )
October, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
471
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. J. A. Lynch has been appointed
traveling engineer on the Chicago, Great
Western witli headquarters at St. Joseph,
Mo.
Mr. J. H. McGonigal has been appoint-
ed traveling engineer on the Northern
Pacific Railroad, vice Mr. J. H. Sally,
promoted.
Mr. J. W. Shrader has been appointed
locomotive foreman at Luther, Mo., on
the Wabash Railroad, vice Mr. II. L.
Needham, resigned.
Mr. Joseph L. Bartlett has been ap-
pointed general foreman of the Walker-
ville, Ont., shops of the Lake Erie and
Detroit River Railway.
Mr. John P. McSteen has been ap-
pointed traveling engineer on the Chi-
cago, Rock Island & Pacific, with head-
quarters at Cedar Rapids, la.
Mr. A. S. Wilson has been appointed
acting master mechanic at Creston, la.,
on the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy,
vice Mr. F. A. Torry, promoted.
Mr. J. J. Shaw has been appointed
master mechanic on the Denver, Enid &
Gulf Railroad, with headquarters at Enid,
Okla., vice Mr. W. H. Whitaker, re-
signed.
Mr. M. K. Jones, heretofore yard mas-
ter on the Choctaw, Oklahoma & Gulf,
has been appointed trainmaster on the
same road, with headquarters at Shaw-
nee, Okla.
Mr. Mark J. Maloney has been ap-
pointed road foreman and assistant train-
master on the Cumberland Valley Rail-
road, with headquarters at Chambers-
burg, Pa.
Mr. Lloyd Grimes, heretofore travel-
ing engineer, has been appointed train
master on the Illinois Central in charge
of the Paducah district, vice Mr. J. F.
Sheridan, resigned.
Mr. John H. Dacey has been appointed
master mechanic of the Kansas City, St.
Joseph & Council Bluflfs, with head-
quarters at St. Joseph. Mo., vice Mr. C.
E. Lamb, resigned.
Mr. F. A. Torry, formerly master me-
chanic on the Chicago, Burlington &
Quincy, has been transferred to Chicago
as assistant superintendent of motive
power on that road.
Mr. Robert H. Rogers has been ap-
pointed general foreman of the shops of
the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, which
are situated at Cumberland, Md., vice W.
S. Galloway, resigned.
Mr. J. 11. Sally, heretofore traveling
engineer on the Northern Pacific, has
been appointed master mechanic, with
office at Livingstone, Mont., vice Mr.
W. S. Clarkson, promoted.
Mr. George H. Gilnian, formerly su-
perintendent of the Tacoma shops of the
Northern Pacific, has been appointed
master car builder of the same road,
with headquarters at St. Paul.
Mr. J. Q. Mathews has been appointed
assistant superintendent Of the second
district, Rio Grande Western Railway,
headquarters. Grand Junction, Colo., vice
Mr. George Geiger, transferred.
Mr. E. G. Potter has been appointed
trainmaster on the Chicago Great West-
ern. He will have charge of the Des
Moines-Kansas City section, which was
formerly in charge of Mr. W. G. Whalen.
Mr. John Vass has been promoted
to the position of road foreman of en-
gines, with jurisdiction over the twenty-
sixth district on the Grand Trunk West-
ern, with headquarters at Battle Creek.
Mich.
Mr. M. D. Strout, for twelve years
superintendent of the Engineering La-
boratory of Purdue University, has re-
signed that position to enjoy in his de-
clining years a well-merited release from
routine duties.
Mr. W. S. Clarkson, heretofore mas-
ter mechanic on the Northern Pacific at
Livingstone, Mont., has been appointed
shop superintendent and is in charge of
the shops and motive power of the Mon-
tana division.
Mr. W. A. D. Short, heretofore signal
engineer on the Cincinnati, New Orleans
& Texas Pacific Railway, has been given
the title of superintendent of signals on
the same road. His headquarters are at
Lexington, Ky.
Mr. J. T. Foster has been appointed
assistant trainmaster on the Northern
Pacific, with office at Tacoma, Wash. He
has special jurisdiction over the new
work which is being done between
Tacoma and Seattle.
Mr. A. L. Moler has been appointed
superintendent of motive power of the
Chicago, Cincinnati & Louisville, with
office at Richmond, Ind. Mr. Moler was
formerly master mechanic on the Vicks-
burg, Shreveport & Pacific.
Mr. C. H. Prescott, master mechanic
of the Spokane Falls & Northern Rail-
way, at Spokane. Wash., has had his
jurisdiction extended as division master
mechanic over the Spokane division of
the Great Northern Railway.
Mr. Otto E. Walters, who was a short
time ago appointed assistant foreman in
the boiler shop of the Brooks Works of
the American Locomotive Company, has
been given the position of foreman of
the shop, vice Mr. W. Burns, promoted.
Mr. S. Austin, formerly master me-
chanic of the Lake Eric & Detroit River
Railway, at Walkerville, Ont., has been
assigned to other duties. He has been
succeeded by Mr. W. K. Christie, who
was formerly with the Pere Marquette.
Mr. J. J. Krauss has been appointed
master mechanic by the Ouchita &
Northwestern Railroad and Louisiana
Central Lumber Company, with head-
quarters at Clarks, La. The mill is
one of the largest and most modern
plants of its kind in the South.
Mr. L. B. Ferguson, formerly chief
draughtsman of the New Orleans &
Northeastern, at Meridan, Pa., has been
appointed master mechanic of the Vicks-
burg, Shreveport & Pacific, with head-
quarters at Monroe, La., vice Mr. A. L.
Moler, resigned.
Mr. W. H. Conry, who was recently
in charge of the tool room of the To-
peka shops of the Atchison, Topeka &
Santa Fe, has been appointed superin-
tendent of the engineering laboratory at
Purdue University at Lafayette. Ind..
vice Mr. M. D. Strout, resigned.
Mr. K. Kiyita, a young Japanese gen-
tleman, who has been making a practical
study of American methods at the Bald-
win Locomotive Works, in accordance
with the policy inaugurated by the Em-
peror of Japan, was, while at work, seri-
ously injured a few days ago. by being
.struck by a heavy iron bar.
Mr. R. D. Davis was elected president
of the Traveling Engineers' Association
at the last annual meeting held in Chi-
cago. Mr. G. W. Wildin was elected
first vice president, Mr. J. D. Benjamin
was elected second vice-president. Mr.
James McDonough, of Galveston, was
elected as treasurer of the association.
Mr. Robert J. Gross, second vice-presi-
dent of the American Locomotive Com-
pany, and Charles M. Muchnic, his secre-
tary, arrived in Dunkirk last month from
a trip around the world. Mrs. Gross. Miis
Gross and Miss Wheeler, who had joined
Mr. Gross at Paris, returned with him.
As the party passed the First Presby-
terian Church the chimes rang out
Home. Sweet Home. The chimes were
472
RAILWAY AND LUCiJ.Mi) ri\T-. F.XGINEERIXG
Oclobcr, 1903.
prc-seiitcd l;ist year by Mr. and .\[rs.
Gross.
Mr. Albert Ladd Colby, for tbc past
ten years metallurgical engineer of the
Bethlehem Steel Company, has accepted
the position of assistant to the president
of the Orford Copper Company, 74
Broadway, New York, which is one of
the constituent companies of the Inter-
national Nickel Company, who cuiitrnl
the nickel output in the United Slates.
Mr. Colby's duties will be chiefly in con-
nection with the manufacture and appli-
cations of nickel steel.
Mr. W. II. Elliott, formerly signal en-
gineer on the Chicago, Milwaukee & St.
Paul,, has been appointed signal engineer
on the New York Central & Hudson
River Railroad, vice Mr. P. G. Ten Eyck,
transferred. His headquarters will be in
New York. Mr. Elliott is well known
to readers of R.mi.w^vy .\nd Locomotive
ENt;iNF.ERi.NG. He is the author of the
book on signaling called "Block and In-
terlocking Signals."
Mr. Henry Marquette Lane, mechani-
cal engineer, of Scranton, Pa., has joined
the staflf of the Railroad Herald as me-
chanical editor. Mr. Lane is a graduate
of Perdue University. He has been
superintendent of machinery for the
Santa Fe coal properties in New Mexico,
consulting engineer at Lafayette, Ind.,
consulting engineer in Michigan, pro-
fessor in the College of Montana, and
professor in the Washington Agricultural
College and School of Sciences.
Mr. C. A. Cook; master painter of the
Philadelphia, Wilmington & Baltimore.
Wilmington, Del., was elected president
of the Master Car and Locomotive
Painters' Association at its recent meet-
ing in Chicago. Mr. J. F. Lanfersiek, of
the Nickel Plate, Columbus, O., was
elected first vice-president, Mr. H. M.
Butts, of the New Y'ork Central, Albany,
N. Y., was elected second vice-president,
and Mr. Robert McKeon, of Kent, Ohio,
was elected secretary of the association.
Mr. George Lindsay, of the Evansville
& Terre Haute, was elected president of
the National Railroad Blacksmiths' As-
sociation at its recent annual meeting at
BufTalo, N. Y. Mr. T. F. Keane. of the
Ramapo Iron Works, was elected first
vice president. Mr. J. W. Riley, of the
Pullman Company, was elected second
vice-president. Mr. J. W. Riley, of the
of the C. H. & D., was elected secretary
and treasurer, and Mr. G. H. Williams,
of the B. M. Jones Co., of Boston, was
elected chemist of the association.
Mr. D. F. Crawford has been appoint-
ed general superintendent of motive
power of the Pennsylvania lines west of
Pittsburgh, with office at Pittsburgh. He
has been succeeded as superintendent of
motive power of the Northwest system
by Mr..T. W. Demarest, with lieadquar-
ters at Fort Wayne, Ind. Mr. M. Dunn
takes the place of Mr. Demarest as su-
perintendent of motive power of the
Southwest .system, at Columbus, O. Mr.
S. W. Miller succeeds Mr. Dunn as mas-
ter mechanic of the shops at Columbus,
and Mr. G. C. Bishop takes Mr. Miller's
place as master mechanic at Logansport,
Ind.
Mr. Charles S. Mellen, who is about to
be elected president of the New York,
New Haven & Hartford Railroad, will
have an opportunity to distinguish him-
self as a manager which few men have
enjoyed. The railroail he takes charge ol
is the only artery of travel between Bos-
ton and New York; it is the channel over
which travel between New England and
all States south of the Hudson River has
to pass, a route of travel with illimitable
possibilities. The property has been man-
aged in a ridiculous fashion, the conveni-
ence of the public being the last thing
considered. The trains are slow and run
at long intervals, while the eating accom-
modation is twenty-five years behind the
times. The business has been deliberately
managed to force passengers to travel by
the water lines belonging to the com-
pany. Mr. Morgan and Mr. Rockefeller
have combined their forces to push out
President Hall and invite President Mel-
len in. If the latter will reform the N. Y..
N. H. & H. to provide comforts and con-
veniences similar to those given by the
Pennsylvania or the New York Central,
the increase in business will vindicate the
change of management.
Mr. Augustus C. Home retired to-day
from the post of assistant master me-
chanic of the Louisville & Nashville Rail-
road and master mechanic of the Cum-
berland Valley division, and began his
duties as general manager of the Louis-
ville & Atlantic Railroad, with headquar-
ters in Versailles, Ky. Mr. Hone was
graduated from the Rensselaer Poly-
technic Institute of Troy, N. Y., in 1890.
He first entered the railroad business in
1898, when he went with the Evansville
& Terre Haute Railroad as civil engineer.
Mr. Hone forged ahead quickly, and in
August, 1899, became superintendent of
motive power for the road. He was ap-
pointed general manager of the road in
January, 1901. One year later he entered
the service of the Louisville & Nashville
as assistant master mechanic of the local
.shops. He attracted the attention of
the higher officials, and soon was made
master mechanic of the Cumberland Val-
ley division. Mr. Hone filled both posi-
tions acceptably. This is another of the
many cases now on record in which me-
chanical department officers are ad-
vanced to responsible positions in the
operating department.
Rumors have been current that Pres-
ident Duntley, of the Chicago Pneu-
matic Tool Company, is about to resign
and that Mr. C. M. Schwab would take
his place. Mr. Schwab has invest-^J
largely in Chicago Pneumatic Tool Com-
pany stock, but we are authorized to say
that ther-v is no truth in the rumor of the
likelihood of his becoming president.
Obituary.
Nathan Washburn, the inventor of the
Washburn car wheel, died recently in
Stafford Springs, Conn. He was eighty-
tive years old, Mr. Washburn invented
a process for puddling steel whereby he
made a gun iron superior to the English
manufacture. In 1876 he began the
manufacture of steel locomotives at his
Worcester plant, and he was the first man
to pill an enduring steel tire (ni a loco-
nioti\ c.
Union Switch and Signal Company's
Installation.
Two recent and important contracts by
the Union Switch & Signal Company are
tho.se for the Interborough Rapid Tran-
sit Company (Subway), of New York,
and the North Shore Railway of Cali-
fornia.
The Westinghouse Electro-Piiouniatic
system is to be installed on the first named,
but a new feature is to be introduced,
that of using alternating current. It is
obvious that the use of track circuits on
third-rail roads, where the rails are used
for the return circuit, and at the same
time for the signaling circuit, introduces
what may be serious complications. In
order to avoid these difficulties, the signals
will be controlled by alternating current,
through relays that are sensitive to alter-
nating current only, and which will not be
afifected by the direct current used for
train service in the subway.
On the North Shore Railway, which
runs about thirty miles north from Sau-
salito, Cal., across the bay from San Fran-
cisco, the electric semaphore system of
automatic block signals is to be used with
a track circuit. This being a high tension
third-rail electric road, alternating cur-
rent will be used for the signal system.
The .gross earning.s of the Chicago
Great Western Railway (Maple Leaf
route) for the fourth week of August,
1903, shows an increase of $26,923.79 over
the corresponding week of last year.
Total increase from the beginning of the
fiscal year, $198,040,00.
The voice of Time cries to man, Ad-
vance ! — The Cliiiiics.
A scries of exhaustive tests were made
recently with a three-furnace oil-burning
locomotive on the California Southern
divisions of the Santa Fe. The perform-
ance of the engine was found to be about
as good as that of fire box engines, but
no better.
October, igo.?.
KM I. WAV A.N'I) l.()Cf).\KJTIVE ENGINEERING
473
The Proper Lubrication of Piston
Valves and Cylinders.
The nialter of mlinn inslmi \alves is
practically a new r>iu'. hut a very import-
ant one, and as tlie piston valve has
tome to stay for a time at least, I be-
lieve some method other than the meth-
od of oiling the slide valve is necessary.
With this fad in view, I have made a
test on this matter and am well pleased
with the resnlls obtained, Beyond any
doubt a piston valve needs less oil than
a slide valve, owing to the fact thtil it is
a perfectly balanced valve or nearly so.
I have discovered that a piston valve
may be receiving a sufficient amount of
oil while the cylinders are not receiving
a snl'hcient amount, and that when the
cylinders are getting oil enough the
valves are usinK mnre oil than is neces-
sary. On .\pril I, 1903, engine 290, a
class R-i, with 21x26 in. cylinders, was
being reported at every terminal that
left cylinder was groaning badly. On
examination we found that the cylinder
was not receiving oil enough as it showed
cutting very seriously. It was necessary
to hold the engine in for some light
work, and I had a ^ in. copper pipe
connected direct from the top and cen-
ter of the cylinder to the bottom of
elbow of oil pipe, where it connects to
steam channel and cylinder saddle. The
elbow having a ball valve in the oil pas-
sageway, which was seated by steam
pressure when engine was working steam,
thus closing the passage of oil to valve
and allowing oil to How direct to cylin-
der; but when engine was not working
steam, the ball valve would be unseated
and the oil flow direct to the valve. Thus
the cylinder would get oil direct from
the lubricator while working steam and
the valve would get oil from the exhaust
while the engine was working steam and
from lubricator when engine was not
working steam. After putting this device
on we had no further complaint of cylin-
der groaning, and after one week's time
we applied the device to the right cylin-
der of this engine. Soon after this en-
gine left the Iowa division and a letter
from the master mechanic of the divis-
ion on which the engine is now running,
shows the cylinders and valves chamber
heads have not been off up to August I.
We also had a class D. high speed pas-
senger engine with cylinders 21 by 26
equipped in like manner April i, on ac-
count of the engine continually groaning
and laboring hard. The cylinders of this
engine at the time of application showed
a dark dull lead color and were badly
scratched, but after the device had been
in use during the time the engine made
12,000 miles, we took the cylinder heads
off and found cylinders as bright as a
mirror and valves showed that they had
not suffered for want of lubrication. This
engine has now made over 50.000 miles
since the device was put on without her
cylinder^ grotming and without a renew-
ing rjf cylinrler packing,
K(J.\D FoKliM.V.N III- lvsi.l.Ni;s.
Omaha Rxpress Engine.
.'\nniNc(i i-, a photograph of the big
twelve-wheel new engines, now being put
in service to pull the North-VVestern
Limited lo Chicago. These engines have
drivers 75 inches in diameter with cyl-
inders 21 inches in diameter by 28 inch
stroke. Weight of engine is 192,000
pounds, of which 130,000 pounds are on
the drivers, 32,000 on trailers and .30,000
pounds on trucks. Boiler is 64 inches in
diameter, and has 275 flues, each flue is
21,4 inches in diameter and 20 feet long.
Fire box is 90 inches long by 75 inches
wide, with a total heating surface of
3,425 square feet. Wheel base of engine
is 32 feet 4 inches; of engine and tender.
59 feet 6 inches, and total length of en-
j inc :'.nd tviuLr is 72 feet. The teniljr
chilled cast iron with (lat rubbing sur-
faces. Several sizes of this form of plate
were made with rubbing surfaces rang-
ing from 100.14 sq. in. down to 46.793
sq. in. There was not much to choose
from in the various sizes but the Hat
plate with an area of 86.738 sq. in. and
with no lubrication, gave the best gen-
eral results, and a flat plate of that
description was therefore recommended
by the committee as the standard form
of center plate for the M. C. B. Asso-
ciation to adopt.
Ball bearing center plates were also
made the subject of experiment and the
results obtained were such as to estab-
lish the conclusion that flange friction
would be much reduced by their use.
The committee suggested that a number
of cars on various roads should be
eijuipped with ball bearing center plates
in order to test the durability of the
latter.
Some unexpected results of lubricai-ng
0.\I.\H.\ 4-11 ■.■ KXl'KKSS I{Xr,INK.
carries twelve tons of coal and 6,200 gal-
lons of water. Total weight of engine and
tender is 242.000 pounds, and. including
coal and water, 318,000 pounds.
These engines are of the new Pacific
or 4-6-2 type, and are capable of main-
taining an unusually high rate of speed,
and especially designed for getting up
speed quickly in leaving stations.
The total weight of the North-Western
Limited Chicago Train pulled by these
engines, not including engine, is about
410 tons.
Center Plates and Side Bearings.
Some interesting results of experi-
ments were brought out by the Master
Car Builders' committee on Side Bear-
ings and Center Plates, which were pre-
sented to the Association at its recent
meeting at Saratoga.
The least flange resistance was sectired
by the use of center plates made of
center plates appeared during the tests.
They were, as the committee say.
"startling exceptions" to the genera! rule
that lubrication reduces friction. A
Kloh's plate, smooth and fitted, gave.
when lubricated, a higher flange pres-
sure than the dry plate. Another feature
was the rapid, and at times, the complete
disappearance of the lubricant from the
points of contact under comparatively
low pressures.
.\ number of side bearings were tiied.
but were not tested completely, as the
apparatus used with the center plates
would have had to undergo some modi-
fications which the time at disposal of
the committee would not permit.
In busy places, where each man has
an object of his own. and feels assured
that every man has his, his character
and purpose are written broadly in his
face. — Old Curiosity Slwl>.
474
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, T903.
New Plainer Type Milling Machine.
This machine is built from new de-
signs and new patterns and is of very
heavy construction. It is designed for
strength, rigidity and power, with special
provisions for ease of operation and the
demands of modern milling machine
practice. It is built by the Beckcr-Brain-
ard Milling Machine Company, of Hyde
Park, Mass. The machine is 32x26 ins.
by 10 ft., and is of the plainer type of
milling machine.
The spindle is made of hammered cru-
cible steel, s ins. in diameter, has a
threaded nose and runs in self-centering
bronze boxes with a nut and check nut to
compensate for wear. The spindle car-
rier is heavy and is held firmly to the
upright by long gibs. It is elevated by a
screw with adjustable dials graduated to
thousandths of an inch and has a coun-
terbalance for ease of operation. There
are 20 changes of speed tor the cutter
spindle obtained by gearing in the main
driving cone, operated by clutch ami
lever, so that all changes can be mai
instantly.
The table is very heavy and is regularly
built with five T slots lengthwise, and an
oil channel the full length and at each
the arbor in order to change their posi-
tion in relation to the work.
The bed is extra deep, extending to
the floor and making a solid foundation.
It is securely bracej by heavy cross gir-
ders which are evenly spaced throughout
the entire length. The bed can be made
any length desired.
The specifications are as follows:
Working surface of platen, 120 ins. by 26
ins.; length of bed size of platen inside oil
pockets, 120 ins. by 26 ins.; longitudinal
feed, automatic in both directions, 120
ins.; greatest distance from center of spin-
blows delivered by iron bars or other hard
substances which dent the surface. The
objet of this rough usage is no doubt to
loosen frozen coal or ore, but the effect
upon the paint is disastrous. Another
way in which the paint is removed in
large quantities is by loading hot iron
cinders and ashes. This has the efTect
of melting the pigment, and the unload-
ing process carries it off. A good way
10 minimize this evil would be to set
apart certain cars for this particular serv-
ice and not load hot material promiscu-
ously into steel cars.
BECKER-BRAINARD PLAINER TYPE MILLING MACHINE.
end. It travels on flat ways securely
gibbed and has a quick return operated
by power from a separate countershaft.
It can also be moved by the usual hanJ
wheel.
The feed of the table is directly oper-
ated through gearing from the spindle
at ratios of 13H and 27 to i by 5 in. belt
on a 5-step cone, the diameter of which
is 23 ins. on the largest step and 13 ins.
on the smallest, giving a range of feed
through eight changes from 3-64 to J^ in.
These changes of feed can be made in-
stantly by means of a lever, without stop-
ping the machine.
The head may be adjusted in either
from either side of the machine, so that
it is not necessary to take the cutters off
die to table. 28 ins.; least distance from
center of spindle to table, 2 ins.; greatest
distance from end of spindle to center
of table, i6>^ ins.; least distance from end
of spindle to center of table, 6J4 ins.;
greatest distance from end of spindle to
tail stock pin, 37 ins.; least distance from
end of spindle to tail of stock pin, 17 ins.;
net weight. 25.000 pounds.
A good point was brought out at the
meeting of the Master Car and Locomo-
tive Painters' Association, recently held
in Chicago. In two of the papers read it
was pointed out that the paint on steel
cars is often destroyed by what the M. C.
B. rules would probably call "unfair us-
age." One way in which the protective
covering of the cars is knocked off is by
"Tie Preserving Cylinders for the
Alamosa-Colorado plant of the Denver
& Rio Grande Railroad have just been
shipped from the Fraser & Chalmers
Works of the Allis-Chalmers Company,
making thirty-one cylinders which have
been shipped by this company for that
purpose during recent years. The three
cylinders for the above named company
are of the average size, 6 feet diameter,
by no feet long. The plant was designed
by Mr. Samuel M. Rowe, member A. S.
C. E., Chicago, III, and is intended for
treatment of ties by means of the Well-
house process."
A man never knows what he can do till
he tries. — Pickivick Papers.
October, 190,3.
RAILWAY AND I.OCOMOTI VI-: KNGINEERING
475
Proceedings of TravelinK Hngineers'
Convention.
(Continued JroDi Page 470.)
not perccptiliU- when duiihlc nozzles arc
used.
Mr. J. B. Johnson, C, M. & St. P.,
said they use the baffle plate set back
of the nozzle stand, and they have
trouble with the smoke boxes filling up
with cinders.
Mr. W. K. Widgeon, T. II. & I., said
that the extension front end was origi-
nally intended as a receptacle for cinders.
When the diaphragm is extended in front
of the nozzle stand the front end is self
cleaning.
Mr. Stevens, on the Union Pacific,
we have five or six different styles of
front ends. We have no trouble in keep-
ing the front ends clean with the dellect-
ing plate back of the nozzle. Our super-
intendent of motive power sent out a
question asking if maintaining cinder
chutes was necessary? We are now re-
moving the cinder hoppers as fast as the
engines pass through the shops.
Mr. G. H. Horton, Soo Line, said they
had changed the diaphragm of some pas-
senger engines from the back to the
front of the nozzle for the purpose of
making them clean the front end, and
it worked all right. They were not so
successful in changing a compound en-
gine which deposited cinders on the bed
plate to an alarming extent. They had
taken out the petticoat pipe witliout im-
proving matters.
Mr. Johnson, C, M. & St. P., said
that when first they adopted the exten-
sion front, they used a bed plate up to the
exhaust pipe. They afterwards put net-
ting in place of the bed plate and got
better results in steaming. He wanted
to know if those using self-cleaning front
ends were troubled with sparks and dirt
thrown upon the train.
Mr. Johnson answered that he recent-
ly drafted two new engines for the M.
& O. that have a straight draft pipe,
single nozzle with a draft plate extend-
ing in front of the exhaust pipe, which
is adjusted at a height of 17 inches. The
distance between petticoat pipe and base
of stack is 3,'i inches. These front ends
clean themselves almost entirely. The
sparks seem to be pulverized before they
are thrown out and there is little fire
in them. He did not believe that a
vacuum could be created in the smoke
box unless the exhaust steam filled the
.stack.
Mr. McBain said that if the steam
filled the stack, he could not see how
the gases could get through. Some one
having- suggested that the action was the
same as that of the injector, Mr. Mc-
Bain replied that the cases were differ-
ent, as two permanent gases had to pass
through the stack.
Mr. George W. Wildin, Central Rail-
road of New Jersey, asked if he under-
stood Mr. McBain to say that the length
of stack did not affect the steaming ol
an engine
Mr. McBain answered that he- had nni
found it made any difference.
Mr. Angus Sinclair, Railway a.nd
LocoMOTivii Enuineering, referred to
the discoveries about draft appliances
made by Mr. Rcjbcrt Quayle, and a com-
mittee of which he was chairman for
the Master Mechanics' Association in
1896. These demonstrated beyond ques-
tion that the plunger theory of the ex-
haust jet is a fallacy. The Master Me-
chanics' Association have devoted great
attention to the investigation of draft
appliances, and their discoveries ought
to guide those working in the same field.
He directed attention to the fact that
people are undertaking every year the
investigation of -subjects that have been
thoroughly investigated by others, and
that the new investigators are frequently
ignorant of anything having been done
in the same line before. He made a plea
for the study of engineering literature by
would-be inventors and investigators.
fleeting plate is, that it is set too close to
the flues at the lop, with the result that
draft through the upper flues is restricted.
Owing to obstruction caused by the dia-
pliragtn, nozzles have frequently to be
reduced to create velocity of draft. Be-
lieved the Master Mechanics' front end
is all right as a general design and that
it can be adapted to our needs. Had no
faith in adopting what might be called a
Traveling Engineers' front end. Thought
a double lift pipe a delusion and a snare.
They cannot be kept in line. Cited case
where new engines came with double
lift pipe and they never steamed until a
single pipe was substituted.
Mr. Robinson agreed with Mr. Roesch
concerning the little influence the posi-
tion of the draft pipe exercised on the
fire.
Mr. Roddy, Santa Fe, believed that
the draft plate exerted influence on tiie
fire of deep fire-box engine. With cer-
tain big engines he found that steaming
was improved by removing altogether
the deflector plate. They have all kinds
of petticoat pipes, single and double and
MASTER MECHANICS- FRONT END ON THE MICHIGAN CENTRAL.
He strongly commended the annual re-
ports of the Master Mechanics' Associa-
tion for the valuable information they
contain.
Mr. Wildin claimed that the draft on
the fire was created by the action of in-
duced currents.
Mr. Johnson insisted that the induced
currents were due to the piston-like ac-
tion of the exhaust steam in the stack.
Mr. F. Roesch, Chicago & Alton, be-
lieved that a successful front end must
be designed to suit the conditions of fuel
and service. One man may want his
diaphragm ahead of the nozzle, and an-
other behind it, and both get good re-
sults. He had been on a road where
they changed the S. M. P. with every
moon. Each S. M. P. had his own front
end and they all steamed. Believed that
the quality of the coal has more to do
with steam than the design of front end.
Did not believe that the deflecting plate
has any great effect on the action of draft
on the fire. Principal trouble with de-
simple and compound, and he expressed
the opinion that the petticoat pipe was a
delusion and a snare from beginning
to end. He called it the result of a pipe
dream. It the steam jet does not fill the
stack, what do we want a petticoat pipe
for? To prevent the gases from escaping
out of the stack? He related numerous
facts of experience that reflected against
the petticoat pipe, and made the asser-
tion that the most useful place for that
appliance was at the back of the round
house." I have got fifty of these pipes
lined up back of the round house and
the engines are steaming well.
jNIr. Frank O. Miller, C. H. & D.,
defended the diaphragm and the petti-
coat pipe. He had converted a poor
steamer into a good steaming engine by
applying a petticoat pipe. With a shal-
low fire-box engine he was able to ad-
just the diaphragm plate to draw every
bit of fuel to the front of the fire box
or vice versa. Had been taught that the
lifting pipe and the diaphragm plate
476
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
could be adjusted to make an engine do
its best in steam generating, and he had
found that to be true.
Mr. E. R. Webb, Michigan Central,
said they were not troubled with report
of engines not steaming, and they use
the lift pipe. He believed that instead
of throwing away the deflector pipe Mr.
Rocsch ought to have changed the fire-
man.
Mr. Stewart, Union Pacific, said: "On
our road we have got a class of engines
with a very short stack; I think they are
about 20 inches. They used them for a
little while, but the engineers did not
think they steamed as well as they ought
to because the stack was too short, and
one or two of them got a sleeve and put
on the top and raised the top about 15
inches, and it made an improvement, m
their mind. They would be going along
up an eighty-foot grade, the e.xhaust
would be pretty heavy and out would go
the sleeve. They wouldn't know it for
two or three trips, but as soon as they
found it out, they had to have a new
pipe, is a pipe dream in a good many in-
stances."
Mr. McBain protested strongly against
the lift pipe being called a delusion and
a snare. A man from one corner of the
country comes and applies that expres-
sion to a device in popular use. It seems
to cast a reflection on all the superintend-
ents of motive power in the country.
Mr. Roddy said that the mechanical
men of this country are going wrong, for
to-day they are building engines with
3,700 feet of heating surface to supply
17-inch cylinders.
Mr. Brown mentioned that the D., L.
& W. had adopted an 18-inch stack and
all engines were being equipped with
tliat size.
Mr. Benjamin. Chicai;,(. & Northwest-
ern, mentioned that they had tried on an
engine a downward ^-xtension of the
smoke stack. That did fairly well, but
it soon wore out and was reitioved. After
that they applied an ordinary lift pipe
and the engine steamed better.
Mr. Buckbee drew attention to the fact
MODIFIED MASTER MECHANICS
sleeve because the engine did not steam
well.
"As Mr. Roesch said awhile ago, we
changed coal on the Union Pacific, and
1 was sent down there to assist in ad-
justing the engine to the new coal. The
Denver & Rio Grande were using the
same coal and they had a bushing in their
stack. The first thing the firemen be-
gan to complain of was that they had no
bushing in that stack like the Rio Grande
engines, with that they would steam all
right. I asked them what they wanted
it for, and they said to make the stack
longer. I asked them why they could
not have it in the front and extend it
down instead of up. That wouldn't do.
They wanted it on top.
"At that time we had some trouble, a
strike on the road, and a good deal to^
contend with, and I put a bushing in
one or two stacks and ran the engines
myself. I could not see that it made any
difference. I took the bushing out, and
I think the length of the stack, as my
friend Roddy says about the petticoat
that great changes have been made on
locomotives since the Master Mechanics'
experiments of 1896 were carried out.
The changes call for modifications of the
proportions found best by the Master
Mechanics' Committee. He thought' that
Mr. Roddy was probably right in throw-
ing out the lift pipes, thereby removing
obstructions to the escaping gases.
Mr. Buckbee believed that enlarging
of stack diameter was made necessary by
the increase of grate area.
Mr. Conger raised the question, does
an engine with a large grate area gener-
ate more fuel gases than one with a
smaller grate area?
Mr. Bentley thought they were making
a mistake who were trying to get rid of
the unconsumed gases. They put in the
petticoat pipe to retain these gases.
Mr. Roesch wanted to retain the un-
consumed gases in the fire box as long
as possible, but he favored letting them
escape freely when they reached the
smoke stack.
Mr. McBain: After some consolida-
tion engines we received had fairly
demonstrated to every person concerned
that they would not boil water satisfac-
torily, something had to' be done to get
them to do, that. The first move that
was made was to apply a vacuum gauge,
one in front and one behind the dia-
phragm plate, and a trip was made over
the road. The reading of that test show-
ed a 2^-inch vacuum behind the plate
and a 4-inch vacuum in front of the
plate. Those engines had a diaphragm
plate coming down the usual slant, then
over horizontally six inches in front of
the nozzle, then down perpendicularly
until about 14 or 16 inches of the bottom
of the arch. We proceeded to experi-
ment to produce better results. The first
was to take out all the diaphragm ar-
rangement except that extending down
behind the nozzle. In place of the plate
a netting was put in from the front end
back. The result was that the vacuum
was practically equalized from the front
to behind the plate and diminished slight-
ly in both places. The engine had a
14-lnch choke stack on. On the return
trip by keeping the blower on full the en-
gine was kept fairly hot and did good
work. The engines came with a 14-inch
choke stack extended 15 inches into the
smoke arch on the single section petti-
coat pipe, fitting tightly into the bottom
of that so that all the outlet for gases
there was, was right under the bottom of
the pipe, directly over the exhaust tip.
The next change made, after changing
the diaphragm plate, was that the smoke
stack was taken ofT and an ordinary
straight stack 18 inches in diameter and
26 inches long was put on in place of it,
and a two-section draft pipe, having sec-
tions twelve and fourteen inches in diam-
eter, respectively. Then we went out on
the road and had a free steamer. But,
to the consternation of the Mechanical
Engineer, who was riding on the engine
at the time, and myself, the vacuum was
lower than ever. At any time when the
engine was working along, drawing full
tonnage, at little better than half cut ofi,
probably at a speed of 25 or 30 miles per
hour, the vacuum would not exceed ij4
inches. Yet the engine steamed splendid-
ly all the time. Instead of increasing the
draft and hurrying the unconsumed gases
out of the engine, is it not evident that
the opposite was the effect? The com-
bustion was slowed up and the disin-
tegration of the coal was lessened and
the gases were liberated more slowly and
more thoroughly. It is a fact that the
vacuum is only about 1^4 inches now on
those engines when they are working full
capacity.
Mr. Hurley: I might say that we re-
ceived a number of those engines wun a
14-inch stack and we increased them to
18 inches with good results. They were
lighter on fuel and better steamers. We
went a little further. We went to 23
October, 1903.
RAH. WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
477
inches, and I am iiuIiiKil in iliiiik wc
exceeded tlie limit. The engine is not
doing as well. We have got one 23 for
experiment. She does very well with a
heavy train and fast run, but when she
has a light train and slow time she doesn't
make steam.
Mr. Wallace, Chicago & Northwestern,
I would just like to say a word to the
remarks that Mr. Sinclair made, where
he spoke about changing llie front end
to meet the conditions you find in serv-
ice. If he had said "Let it alone when
you get it there," he would have iinisli-
ed it. That is the troidde. When the
engine is properly drafted to give the
best results, the first thing we know
some one reports hci"* not steaming, and
a change is made.
Mr. Gillett, Norfolk & Western, was
struck with the conflict of opinion about
the front end. He favored progress.
They had abandoned the lift pipe and
got on well without it. He directed atten-
tion to the fire claims that railroad com-
panies have to pay, and considered it the
duty of the Association to provide the
best front end they coidd find, and he
recommended one designed by a medical
doctor which he considered nearly per-
fect.
After some desultory discussion, Mr.
Wallace proposed the following.
Resolved, That we, the Traveling En-
gineers' Association, recommend no
special or definite front end arrangement
at this time, but do recommend that the
facts developed by the Master Mechan-
ics' Association and by Professor Goss,
of Purdue University, be made our basis
for future work and research; and, fur-
ther, we believe the greater part of the
difficulties experienced in service are due
more to lack of system in keeping the
appliances adjusted so as to give the best
results than to the mechanism itself.
Mr. Conger: I move the adoption of
that resolution just read.
Carried, and discussion closed.
DISCUSSION OF MR. BE.\RDSLEV S P.\PER ON
THE CARE .\ND H.VNDLING OF THE
COMPOUND LOCOMOTIVE.
At the conclusion of his paper Mr.
Berrdsley requested President Meadows
to call upon Mr. McCarroU, of the Bald-
win Locomotive W'orks, to say some-
thing on the four Vauclain balanced
compounds now on the Santa Fe. Mr.
McCarroll responded by reading a paper
as follows:
Four compound locomotives of the
four-cylinder balanced type have been
recently built for the Atchison, Topeka
& Santa Fe Railroad, and are in very
successful operation on their line in the
heavy fast passenger service of that sys-
tem.
The following advantages are claimed
for this type of locomotive over the or-
dinary type of locomotives: I. Practi-
c.illy a perfect balanced locomotive. 2.
Lightness of reciprocating parts. 3.
Smoothness in running. 4. Quickness
in starting and handling trains. 5. Re-
duction of injury to track and permanent
way structures. 6. The usual advantages
claimed for compound locomotives
(economy in fuel and water;.
In consideration of these advantages
of the locomotives, a knowledge of the
general design is necessary. The most
striking feature, of course, is the employ-
ment of crank axles with inside connec-
tion to low pressure cylinders. The cyl-
inders are set in direct opposition to
their respective low pressure cylinders,
which are located outside the frames and
connected to the driving wheels by crank
pins in the usual manner, or, in other
words, a high pressure cylinder is con-
nected to its low pressure cylinder with
a connection at 180°, but the high pres-
sure cylinder on one side of the engine is
coupled to the high pressure cylinder on
the other side with its connection at 90°
or quartered in the usual manner. Simi-
larly, the low pressure cylinders on op-
posite sides of the engine are quartered
with each other. This arrangement dis-
tributes the power at four quarters of
the driving mechanism instead of at two
quarters, which is the usual method em-
ployed on ordinary locomotives.
With this short explanation we may
proceed to the individual advantages:
I. Practically a perfect wheel balance
is obtained by opposing a high pressure
cylinder to a low pressure cylinder at
180°. The individual weights of the parts
composing the driving mechanism are
thus made to balance each other. They
are so designed that the weight effect of
the interior parts exactly counterbalances
the like effect of the exterior parts. The
revolving weights on the coupled wheels
are balanced by counter-weights in the
usual manner so that their vertical efforts
are eliminated. The reciprocating parts
by moving in opposite directions at the
same time effectively balance each other.
Tl;e only discrepancy being the difference
in weight between the inside and outside
reciprocating parts which is usually too
slight to require any serious considera-
tion In this matter of unbalanced re-
ciprocating parts it is well to note that
the common practice of counterbalancing
ordinary locomotives is to consider only
two-thirds of their weight and to add
this proportion to a revolving balance,
which at the best is only an approximate
method of absorbing their effects. The
reciprocating motion can never be cor-
rectly balanced by the revolving motion.
as their effects are different at all points
in their travel. In the balanced com-
pound locomotives the reciprocating
parts are always balanced by other re-
ciprocating parts and never by their re-
volving parts. The slight error in bal-
ance due to the difference between the
internal and external weights is never so
far from a theoretical balance as is the
ordinary method of balancing a propor-
tion of reciprocating parts by counter-
weight having an entirely different mo-
tion and effect.
2. The balanced compound locomotive
offers splendid opportunity for lightness
of reciprocating parts, as the distribution
of power is on four different quarters of
the driving mechanism Instead of on
two points only, as is usual on locomo-
tives of all other types. This reasoning
is obvious and is simply a matter of
mental arithmetic for rough explanation
by the way of i divided by 2 equals V2,
and I divided by 4 equals 14. The unit,
of course, representing the total power
developed by the cylinders for distribu-
tion to the driving mechanism.
3. Smoothness of running is of course
the result of equal distribution of power
(at four quAters as just explained) as
well as in the perfection of balance pre-
viously mentioned. This feature will
make itself apparent to engine men very
early in their experience on running such
a locomotive.
4. Quickness in starting and hauling
trains can also be attributed to the equal
power distribution, and the consequent
fact that at least two cylinders are al-
ways effective for starting instead of but
one, which latter condition is often the
case in locomotives of ordinary types.
5. A reduction of injury to track and
permanent way structures by the perfect
balancing and power distribution with
consequent ease of running should be no
mean factor in the success of this type
of locomotive. Much has been written
on the injurious effect of the "hammer
blow," and to those familiar with this
feature of practical railroading, the ad-
vantages of a machine which practically
eliminates all vertical blows on the rail
will be quite apparent.
6. We may safely pass over the usual
advantages claimed for all types of com-
pound locomotives. The saving of fuel
and water has been so universally ac-
knowledged that no attention need be
given to this question. With the advan-
tages of this system of balancing in ad-
dition to those ordinarily obtained by
compounding, we may safely assert that
the Vauclain Balanced Compound Loco-
motive is the coming engine for develop-
ing high speeds and power and minimiz-
ing risk of injury to permenent way
structures.
I have a photograph here of the effect
of the hammer blow on the rail. I would
like you gentlemen to look at it. I do
not believe any of you ever saw the ef-
fect of it as developed here. I do not
want to lose this, but I will gladly pass
it around.
Mr. Stewart, of the Union Pacific,
speaking of the Vauclain Compound,
said that road had about 140 or 150 of
478
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
them, and if given a choice, a good com-
pound and an average simple engine, the
U. P. engineers would take the compound
every time. He said his experience had
been that if the round house does not
keep up its end, the compound is not
much good very long. He also pointed
out that it was possible to get home with
a compound with something gone wrong
a good deal better than with a simple en-
gine in the same condition. He did not
think that the U. P. compounds are any
lighter on water than the simple engines
when cutting oflf at say 7 or 8 ins., but
they are lighter on fuel and the fire box
lasts longer, and they are easier on flues.
With heavy consolidation compounds
the weight of the reciprocating parts
causes the imperceptible slip when the
crank pin is on the bottom quarter to
wear the wheels out of round before the
engine is ready for the shop. In that
case new tires are applied and the en-
gine kept in service. The system of
monthly inspection of piston packing is
in vogue with beneficial results. The
wear of the heads are recorded when the
piston packing is examined. The men
are not allowed to pull cars over the road
with the starting valve open. He did
not see much use in cylinder cocks in the
high pressure cylinders, but he had rec-
ommended that they put in test plugs on
the left side, same as the right, to aid the
engineer in locating his troubles and to
assist the round house people in doing
their work quickly.
Mr. Roesch, of the C. & A., said th.it
he saw no necessity of splitting hairs on
this subject. He did not see why an
ordinary engineer or an average engineer
should be asked to designate what par-
ticular ring in 16 valve rings was broken,
and he believed that this hair-splitting
business and making fun of a man that
cannot detect exactly what ring is broken
had as much to do with getting the com-
pound into disrepute as anything else.
If an engineer comes in and reports
"valve ring broken on left side," that
ought to be sui^cient, he ought not to
be required to say ring No. I or ring
No. 8. With rings I or 8 broken we
will have three equal exhausts and one
unequal one. If we, as traveling engin-
eers or road foremen of engines, would
try to instruct our men a little bit better
in locating the principal defects on com-
pound engines, and not try to make fun
of them about it, we would get along
much better and the compound engine
would get more credit than it is getting
to-day.
Mr. Beardsley said in answer to a
question from Mr. Buckbee as to what
defects in design have been most noticed
in the Vauclain compound and the tan-
dem on his system: "While this paper
is not intended to take in the design of
a locomotive, and I am not a locomo-
tive designer, I do not suppose there are
very many of us here that have not found
there are a few defects, anyway. I might
mention a few. The first is that a lew
years ago we had a compound locomo-
tive, turned out with a isJj in. high pres-
sure cylinder and a 12 in. valve. Then
we had a 15 in. cylinder with an li><
in. valve. Then we had a 17 in. Tins
is the high pressure cylinder 1 am
speaking of. Then we had a 17 in.
cylinder with a 15 in. valve, and now we
have got a 15 in. high pressure cylinder
with a 15 in. valve, that is, I mean, the
diameter of the valve. The balanced or
twentieth century engines that have now
come to us have a 15 in. high pressure
cylinder and a 15 in. valve, which I claim
is one step in the right direction so far
as the design is concerned. That is
one of them, and I don't know but the
most important one, according to my
ideas. Of course with this same engine
we have got a lighter engine or an en-
gine designed to handle the train. These
engines should and are handling ten,
twelve and even fourteen cars at a speed
of 60 miles an hour, across what we call
level country, where before that we had
on the same runs a 17 in. cylinder on an
engine weighing a great deal more. I
cannot give you the exact figures.
"Those two points in the design are
foremost in my mind right now. One
is the size of the valve; the other is. if
you please, the size of the engine, being
designed for the train that you want her
to pull. There are a great many others.
There was just one thought came to my
mind. ' In fact, Mr. Quayle mentioned
it, that I should have included in answer-
ing your question. That is, the inside
and outside admission valve. I think
they have made another improvement,
which is an inside admission valve."
Mr. Buckbee said: "I have seen dif-
ferent sections of the country, defects in
the general design of the engines often
charged to the compound feature, such
as light frames, limited heating surface
and grate area, etc. Other times where
engines were too light for the service. I
asked this question for the purpose of
asking whether Mr. Beardsley had no-
ticed such things as that with the engines
he has on his system."
Mr. Beardsley replied: "Certainly we
have. We have got engines that have
got too much cylinder for the size of
the wheel. They have not got too much
cylinder for the size of their boiler, but
they have too much for the size of the
wheel. The consequence is we have a
very slippery engine, an engine that
wears the tires very fast. I have also
noticed, as you say, the broken frame.
I have found no reason so far to charge
a broken frame to the compound feature
of the engine, because we always had
broken frames; probably always will
have, but locomotive designers as well
as builders are getting more familiar
every day — 1 can see it — with these
things, and the consequence is they are
improving them; at least I think so."
Speaking of the compound, Mr. Webb,
of the Michigan Central, said: "You can-
not operate the engine, kick it out into
service as you would a wheelbarrow, and
in the end, at thirty days or ninety days
or a year have as good an engine as you
would a wheelbarrow. You are getting
greater service from the engine; you
must give it greater care. The fact that
many of the roads operating compo>ind
engines are not having the success which
they expected need not be laid entirely
to the door of the locomotive engineer.
If he is not doing as well as he should
do, in a great measure the failure rests
upon the traveling engineer, the road
foreman of engines and the master me-
chanic as well. The engineer if he is to
do good service must be educated."
Mr. Crandall, of the New York Cen-
tral, Western division, said there were
about 70 cross compounds on the sys-
tem, and 30 tandems. They handle 70 to
85. possibly as high as 90 loaded cars.
The train is 3,000 tons. He said: "We
find the wear on the knuckle pins and
the side rods is greater on the compound
than on our simple engines. We have
a good many leaks around the front end,
more than on the simple engines, in view
of the fact that there are more places to
leak." The tandem compound, in his
opinion, was not as good an engine as
the cross compound. Some he referred
to were rated at 3.300 tons, but they did
not handle 3.3OQ tons nearly as well as
the cross compounds.
Mr. Conger, of the International Cor-
respondence School, said; "I would like
just to ask one question. On the Colo-
rado Midland or Colorado & Southern
compound I saw that the exhaust from
the air pump goes to the by-pass valve at
the cylinders, so that the exhaust steam
from the pump when the engine is shut
ofT goes in there and helps them about
drifting. I should like some member to
explain a little about that. Probably Mr.
Roesch can tell us about that, whether it
is satisfactory or not?"
Mr. Roesch, in replying, said: "At
the time I was connected with the Colo-
rado & Southern we did not have the air
pump exhaust into the compound en-
gines. We had at that time some tan-
dem compounds, but these tandem com-
pounds were equipped with an auxiliary
throttle which was opened when the en-
gine was drifting. We. however, used
the air pump exhaust in the simple en-
gine. The results were fairly satisfac-
tory."
Mr. Corbett said: "We have about 28
of the cross compounds on the Michigan
Central. They are rated for 2,oco tons
on a grade of about 20 feet to the mile.
They make a trip of 150 miles with about
eight or nine tons of coal. No trouble
OclnlllT, KJO.I.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
479
CHOICE
The measure of the en-
gineer is the work he gets
out of his engine with the
least amount of wear, fuel
and oil.
Dixon's Graphite costs
but little and adds greatly
to your reputation as a
first-class engineer.
To give you some idea
of what can be done with
Make Graphite, read this
bona fide letter from an
engineer :
"If our master mechanic were
to ask me to accept my choice of
pulling two cars less than a full
train with valve oil only, or two
cars more than a full train usmg
valve oil and Graphite, I would
certainly take the two cars over."
Such would bethechoice
of every engineer who has
had e.xperience with Flake
Graphite.
Let us send you a sam-
ple to try on your engine.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
.JERSEY CITY, N, T
willi tlic cylinder packing breaking. Oc-
casionally we find the rings in the pis-
Ion valve broken. Wc very frequently
make the run of 103 miles without slop-
ping, scoop water twice. We arc troubled
Init very little with running warm and
all in all I think the cross compound are
a success on llic Michij;an Central."
Mr. Richardson (U. & O.; spoke
lirielly as fcillows: "We have a few ol
all kinds, but I think the engine that wc
are looking (or is the one that will earn
the company the most money for the
least repairs, goes in and out without
much trcndjlc. I have listened to these
uontlemen telling about the big trains
ihcy pull with the compound engine.
Won't the simple engine with the same
tractive povvcr do just as well? Come in
and go out again and do it finely and do
it with less work? We have compound
engines that we have made simple. While
they were compounds they went in twice
f(ir machinery repairs and for one set ol
llues. Now they go in twice for flues for
one set of machinery repairs. We have
some cross compounds that are doing
good service, but we don't know but what
a simple of the same tractive power
would do as well."
Mr. Webb, when asked for the oil
record of the compound engines making
in the neighborhood of 4.500 miles a
month, said 75 miles is allowed for
valve oil, and 24 for engine oil, and the
work w'as done on this allowance.
The discussion closed by Mr. Beards-
Icy extending an invitation to the mem-
bers of the association to visit the Eigh-
teenth street round house of the Santa
Fe Railway in Chicago, and see some
compounds which were lately received
on that road.
r.\RE .\ND H.\NDLING OF THE COMPOUND
LOCOMOTIVE.
The Traveling Engineers' Association
at their recent annual meeting in Chi-
cago, listened to a paper read by Mr. A.
L. Beardsley. of the A. T. & S. F. on
Care and Handling of the Compound
Locomotive. The speaker laid down the
principle at the outset that before the
men whose duty it is to care for and
handle the machine can get good results
they must first have an engine designed
and built for the service expected. He
nut in a plea for the proper use of the
starting valve. He said "the fact that this
device adds to the tractive force of the
locomotive is often taken advantage of
and the engine is overloaded, causing the
starting valve to be used and the engine
to be run 'simple,' which is very hard on
any compound." There is no question
but that the economical point at which
to \york a compound locomotive is in
one-half stroke, or a little more, but we
often find times in the service when
this is not practicable.
In llie matter of detecting blows, Mr.
HcardslcyxSaid, when on the road:
"Two heavy exhausts on one side gen-
erally come from high-pressure packing
blowing, caused by the rings being
broken. This, however, may be caused
by a leaky valve, a loose bushing, crack-
ed bridges, a leaky starling valve, or any
defect that will increase the pressure in
the low-pressure cylinder, cavity of valve
or low-pressure steam-chest. Two light
exhausts on one side may be caused by
low-pressure packing blowing, which is
very hard to detect while running, be-
cause the steam is admitted to the low-
pressure cylinder at a greatly reduced
pressure. The same result may be caused
by packing rings in the valve being
broken, which will allow part of the
steam to escape to the atmosphere while
it is passing through or around the valve
to the low-pressure cylinder, or by loose
bushing, cracked bridges, etc.
One loud exhaust with the Vauclain
engine may be caused by either rings
No. I. 2. 3, 6. 7 or 8 being broken. Rings
No. I or 8 broken gives us more port
opening at the end of the high pressure
cylinder that ring is broken on, and, of
course, more volume of steam in the
high-pressure cylinder. This goes to the
opposite end of the low-pressure cylinder
and gives us one heavy exhaust. If rings
No. 3 or No. 6 are broken the volume of
steam adtnitted to the low-pressure cylin-
der is increased and the effect is practi-
cally the same. Rings No. 2 or No. 7 be-
ing broken will give one loud exhaust
on that side of the engine for the reason
that steam will blow by the ring from the
live steam-way directly into the hollow of
the valve when the steam-port at the op-
posite end of the valve is open.
If you have one heavy exhaust from
the front end on the right side, it may
be caused by ring No. 8 in the valve be-
ing broken, or perhaps ring No. 2 is
broken. In either case the volume of
steam, or the pressure, is increased in
the low-pressure cylinder and you have
one heavy exhaust. This point must be
considered when testing for a high-pres-
sure packing blow on the Vauclain en-
gine, as explained later.
The Tandem compound may have one
heavy exhaust from rings No. 5 or No. 8
being broken, which will increase the
port opening to the low-pressure cylin-
der. Rings No. 2 or No. 3 broken in a
Tandem merely increases the volume of
steam in high-pressure cylinder and low-
pressure steam-chest, and gives two loud
exhausts. If rings No. i and 2 or No. 3
and 4 are broken it increases the pressure
in the low-pressure steam chest, and
anything that increases the pressure or
volume of steam in the high-pressure
cylinder or low-pressure steam-chest
gives two heavy exhausts on that side of
the engine.
48o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
If rings No. 5 and 6 or No. 7 and 8 are
broken we have two light exhausts, be-
cause part of the steam from the low-
pressure steam-chest or receiver is blow-
ing by them to the atmosphere. Assum-
ing that we have found which side the
blow is on. and that the starting valve is
in good order, wc should make a stand-
ing test to locate the trouble, as follows:
STANDING TEST FOR BLOWS — V.\UCL.\IN
COMPOUND.
Place the engine on the bottom quar-
ter on side to be tested. lilock drivers
or set brakes and remove both indicator
plugs on the high-pressure cylinder. If
the engine is not equipped with these
plugs, remove pops or water relief valves
on the cylinder heads. Give the engine
the back motion and make same test.
If it is the high-pressure packing that is
blowing it will show: while if it is ring
No. 7 it will not show.
To test for low-pressure packing, put
the reverse lever in forward motion with
all the indicator plugs in except the one
in back end of low-pressure cylinder.
Open the starting valve, which will ad-
mit steam to back end of high-pressure
cylinder, hollow of valve and front end
of low-pressure cylinder. If the low-
pressure packing blows you will note it
at the back indicator plug. In this same
position if rings No. 3 and 4 or No. 5
and 6 are broken, steam will blow
through the stack. The blow in either
case, however, will be very light, as the
0:¥
VAUCLAIN COMPOUND CYLINDERS AND VALVE.
steam and in doing this be sure that you
open the throttle enough to set the pack-
ing rings out against the bushing. These
packing rings will leak a little, but if you
fan cover ports it shows that rings No.
I and 8 are in good order. In testing
for high-pressure packing blow put the
reverse lever in forward motion, which
opens front port to tht high-pressure
cylinder. See that the starting valve is
closed and indicator plug or pop is out
at the back end of the high-pressure
cylinder. Give engine steam, and if it
blows out of the indicator plug the high-
pressure packing may be blowing on ring
No. 7 in the valve may be broken.
To determine which this is, replace the
indicator plug in back end and remove
the front one. Put the reverse lever in
steam, you must remember, had to pass
through the starting valve.
STANDING TEST FOR BLOWS — TANDEM COM-
POUND.
Place the engine on the bottom quar-
ter, on side to be tested, block the wheels
or set the brake and cover ports. Re-
move the indicator plugs on high-pres-
sure cylinder. Give the engine steam,
using the .same precaution to set out the
packing rings. If you can cover the
ports, it merely shows that rings No. 2
and 3 are tight. To test low-pressure
valve, leave the engine in the same posi-
tion and open the starting valve. Re-
place indicator plug in high-pressure
cylinder and remove those in the low-
pressure cylinder, also remove by-pass
2^
Oi' toiler, lyo.i.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
481
Q and C Priest
Snow Flanger
C in be operated with perfect safety
on all trains.
Gives clean rails for all wheels and
prevents derailments.
Adopted as standard by many of
the leading roads.
Order now ; don't wait.
Semi for CatJilo::. large drawini;
of t-nfrine and dimensum shet'ts.
Railway Appliances
Company
GENERAL OFFICES
Old Colony BIdg., Chicago
New York Store, 107 Liberty St.
valve and screw the cap-nut down. If
rings No. 5 and 8 are l)lowing it will
blow throiiKh the stack and out of tlie
plug. Test high and low-pressure cylin-
ilrr packing llie same as you would with
the Vauclain engine. We have one blow,
however, on the Tandem that wc do not
have on the Vauclain engine; this is the
sleeve or bushing between the high and
low-pressure cylinders, and is tested
by adniittiug steam to back end of high-
pressure cylinder with starting valve
shut. If this sleeve blows it will show
through front cylinder cock or indicator
plug in the low-pressure cylinder and
blow through the stack. Some authori-
ties advise to place the engine on lower
forward eighth in testing for blows. With
the compound engine we find the largest
part of the cylinder in the extreme end
,111(1 there is nothing gained by placing
ihc engine nn the eighth.
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEH
ENGINE AND TENDER.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. U9 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
The MIcCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. HEW YORK.
much easier to remove cylinder heads,
and I find from experience that it is not
necessary to take down main rods. The
engineer, being on the ground, should,
however, use good judgment in handling
his engine, and must be held responsible
for its condition. If the engineer is care-
ful in watching the engine work while
pulling a train over the road, and makes
a standing test on completing the trip,
he will generally find what is wrong; but
there are so many different blows that
have the same cfTcct that we often hear
the engineer criticised for not reporting
the \Vork right, when he is not at fault.
The machinist who does the work should
look for loose bushings, etc. This can
generally be detected by tapping the
bushings over the bridges with a light
hammer. He should also look for crack-
ed bridges and cylinders.
In concluding Mr, Beardsley summar-
=0
TANDEM COMPOUND CYLINDERS AND VALVES.
In testing for blows we find it very
unsatisfactory to go by the cylinder
cocks, and for that reason I recommend
removing the indicator plugs on the side
of cylinders, or the water relief valves
on cylinder heads. Some roads are put-
ting indicator plugs in all cylinders. This
is. you will find, an improvement, not
only as a help in locating blows, but to
assist in lubricating when it is necessary
to tow the engine in. If for any reason
the locomotive is disabled and has to be
towed in. there will be no bad effects if
you remove all the indicator plugs and
the plugs over the valves and lubricate
valves and cylinders well. This is quite
an advantage, as it would be a hard mat-
ter to take down the main rods on the
large engines.
In fact, some roads now instruct their
enginemen not to take down the main
rods in cases of this kind. It would be
ized his own observations and those of
some locomotive designers, builders and
iuperintendents of motive power in a
series of Don'ts.
"In conclusion." he said. "I wish to add
a few "don'ts." Don't carry too much water.
Don't work too much throttle. Don't fail
to keep guides tight. Don't fail to keep
guides closed. Don't let engine slip.
Don't fail to open the starting valve
when you close the throttle. Don't fail
to close it shortly after starting. Don't
fail to have the reverse lever in full
stroke before starting. Don't fail to
open cylinder cocks. Don't set out
packing rings with the peen of a ham-
mer. Don't fail to examine valves, bush-
ings, cylinders, etc. Don't fail to keep
pistons in line when closing guides.
Don't jump at conclusions about a blow
or the engine going lame. Don't bush
the nozzle everv time the engine is re-
4f2
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
ported not steaming. Perhaps the en-
gineer or fireman is at fault. Don't
blame everything that happens to the
compound. The large engine and the
compound feature are coming together
and if the compound is properly treated
it will show a saving in fuel as before
stated."
American Correspondence School.
The American School of Correspond-
ence, Chicago, send us some particulars
about their educationMl course, from
which we select the following para-
graphs:
We invite your attention to the copy
of our catalogue which we are sending
you under another cover. We believe
that it contains much information of in-
terest to you personally on a subject of
growing interest to all thoughtful peo-
ple— Correspondence Instruction.
We want to interest the editors of the
representative periodicals more actively
in this phase of popular education, a
phase in which more progress will in all
probability be made in the next five years
than along all other lines of educational
effort combined. That the people want
this form of instruction is shown by the
thousands who apply for help to Chau-
tauqua and the various correspondence
schools. It is a form of education that
has come to stay because it meets a real
want, and the position that our repre-
sentative periodicals take toward this
new educational force will do much to
hasten or retard its good influence.
Many colleges, such as the University of
Chicago and Armour Institute of Tech-
nology, have adopted it as a regular fea-
ture of their work, and others have il
under serious consideration.
We should like to call your attention
to the following distinctive features of
the .\nierican School of Correspondence,
at .Armour Institute of Technology:
The instruction is under the direction
of members of the faculty of Armour
Institute of Technology, and Dr. Gun-
saulus, president of that institute, has
given the work his enthusiastic support
and personal supervision. Due credit will
be given for the work covered by corre-
spondence should the student later pur-
sue his studies at the Institute.
The instruction papers are prepared
especially for home study, and are used
as text-books by the Government in the
School of Submarine Defense at Fort
Totten. N. Y., by the Westinghouse
Electric & Manufacturing Company, of
Pittsburg, which is using over seven hun-
dred of the papers in the "Shop School'
maintained for its employees. The paper
on "Storage Batteries" is used as a text-
book for the Senior Class ^in Electrical
Engineering at Columbia University.
We invite your attention particularly
to the list of instructors, text-book writ-
ers, and to the .Vdvisory Board. We
have students within a few miles of the
Arctic Circle — in the Fiji Islands — and
in the Falkland Islands, ofif of Cape
Horn. We have over three hundred stu-
dents in New Zealand alone. Wherever
knowledge of American enterprise has
penetrated, there will be found corre-
spondence school students.
The catalogue referred to will be sent
free to any person expecting to become
a student.
Adhesive.
Army and Navy I^iquid Glue is the
name of the new and very adhesive
cement which the Wachter Manufactur-
ing Company, nf Baltimore, Md., has
placed upon the market. The glue is
put up in cans, kegs, barrels and bottles
as required, but no matter from what
kind of a receptacle it may be taken it
stays right where it is put, and by the
way, the substances it unites stay there
also. It is the glue that glues and it glues
anything, and as the manufacturers say,
it is "the glue for you," They mean
this latter phrase to be taken literally,
because at the back of the pamphlet
which they have issued telling "what it
is, how it is and what it is good for,"
they say of this pure hide and sinew glue
(which is in liquid form and does not
need to be prepared in any way), that
though they will be glad to have a rep-
resentative talk the matter over with
you, and show you actual tests and
proofs of all their claims, yet in the
meantime samples and prices are yours
for the asking. It is put up conveniently
in cans of all sizes, in small mucilage
bottles, ready for ofiice use, and in tubes,
so that whether you are in shop or office
they can give you what you want and
you can make things adhere. Write the
firm for their little booklet telling the
story of its invention or discovery by
Mr. J. W. Wachter, late of the U. S.
Navy Department, and also ask for a
sample and try the liquid glue, or let your
wife try it on the cup and saucer you
broke not long ago, or you try it in the
shop on wood or iron and see for your-
eslf. You will notice that in offering to
give away a sample to those who write
for one, the firm is not running a "gum"
game, nor are they trying to "stick" you
in any way; they simply desire to cement
a legitimate business friendship, and the
Army and Navy Liquid Glue will do it.
Write Wachter Mfg. Co., Baltimore, and
say R.MLWAV .and Locomotive Engin-
eering gave you the clue to the glue.
.\ number of German, Belgian and
Austrian mine owners are tising benzine
locomotives for hauling cars in the
mines. They are a dwarf form of gaso-
line motor and operated very much in
the same way.
JIST
PIBLISHED
Air Brake Catechism
By ROBT. H. BLACKALL
JUST ISSUED
Eighteenth Edition Revised and Enlarged.
Tlii> 1 k ih liKlit up til (l:i,i' iiiul ie a i(iiii|il<lc
study of tlic .\ir Brake Ei|nipnK-iit, ini-liuhnj,'
the latest devices and iuveiitioiiw used. .Ml ii;iits
nf the Air linilie. their liciililei- and iieeuliarilks.
and a practie 1 \^ay In tiiid and remedy tliein.are
i-xplained. It contBins o\er 1500 questions
with their answers. Fnll> iUuf-Irated, iiieliid-
in^' Two Large Westinghouse Air Brake
Educational Charts iirinted in ten different
lilMlile for study or framing. 300 Pages.
iind, IHlli edition revised and enlarged.
olli lie
Price, $2.00
Locomotive Breakdowns,
Emergencies and their
Remedies
By GEO. L. FOWLER
An L'p-To.Date Caterhism on Railroad
Brcalidowns, or What To Do in Case o<
Accidents. This work treats in full all kinds
of a( eidinis that arc likely to happen to loco-
motive engines while on the road. The various
liarts nf the locoinntive are discussed ami every
aecidetit that can jwssibly happen with the
remetiy to lie applied is given. Every railroad
man sliould have this book, so that he will know
what to do when the time comes. 250 Pag» s
SCO (Juesticms and Answers. I'ully Illustrated
Price, $1.50
Locomotive Catechism
By ROBERT ORIHSHAW
Tins work asks IlKKI l^iiestions and gives ItiOO
Siiuple, Plain. Praciieal Answers about the
Locomotive. No mathematics, no theories — just
facts. The standard book on the locomotive.
'I'weuly-sccond edition. 450 pages. Over 300
ilhistralinns and 1'2 large foldiuL' plates.
Price, $2.00.
Don't put oK until Examination Day conies,
but send for these books at once, as they
ask and answer many questions as given
by the examiner on your road.
i' #" -4 Special Circular of these Books Sent
on liff/uisf,
<l':lr' Any of these Books Prepaid to any
Address in the Wortd on Beceipt of' Pricf.
AGENTS WANTED'?;*" ft '"m
They ecll at sight,
jiml fvi'iy Engineer, Fireman and Slmp-
niau sliuuld have them. Write for terms
and particulars. Our catalogue of prac-
tical books ie sent free on application.
Norman A. Henley & Co., Pnblishers,
132 Nassau St. New York, N. Y.
October, iQo.v
KM I. WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
483
A.Lesckn&: Sons Rope Co.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
The management of the Baltimore &
(Jhio have undertaken the work of sup-
plying wcll-etiiiipped buildings at all im-
portant division points for the use of
locomolivc engineers, firemen and other
trainmen when they arc away from '
home. TIu- first building will be erected
at Glenvvood, and will be fitted with
smoking and reading rooms on the first
and on the second will be tubs, baths and
sleeping rooms.
IIOMIC Ol' l-U'IC
920-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS. MO.
( 1J7 E. I^ake St.. ChicnKo. 111.
Branch Offices ] 92.CentreSt., New YorkCitv.N Y.
^ Rmlto BldR , San Francisco, Cal.
( 1717-23 Arapahoe St , Denver, Col.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
^ew York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis: Terminal Station.
lAlLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's iiH^K'.Vd"'' Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Col* Representatives In the United States,
Canada and Hexico
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation.
11.17 THE ROCKER V, CMICAOO.
fifiBroadway, New York. Park BuUdisg, i'lusbargb
31 Norfolk House, London, Eng.
Inspection of Steel Ralls, Splice Bars, Railroad Cais^
Wheels, Axles etc. Chemical Laboratory— Analj>li
of Oris, Iron, steel. Oils, Water, etc. Physical Labo-
EAToiiY— lest of Metals, Drop and PulllngTest of Coup-
lers, Draw Bars, etc.
Cfflrlency Tests of Boilers, Engines and LocomotiTei.
Motor Car Speed Exceeds 1 1 4 Hiles an
Hour.
For several years the electricians con-
nected with Zossen military railway of
Germany have been trying to run electric
motors at a speed exceeding one hun-
dred miles an hour. Last year and the
year before a speed close to 100 miles an
hour was attained, but the track dis-
A NEW SINXLAIR COMP.^NY.
played signs of collapsing at the high
speed and the trials were abandoned.
They have now built an extraordinarily
strong track with lOO-pound rails laid on
substantial wooden foundations, and on
trials made on it. the motor attained a
speed over 114 miles air hour, and no
weakness of track or motor developed.
They expect to attain speed of 125 miles
an hour and over. The test is more for
scientific than for commercial purposes.
Son of Mark Twain's Jack Rabbit.
A jack rabbit that Mark Twain tells a
story about has a son which is torment-
ing the life of a 'Frisco engineer. That
engineer lias made a request to be al-
lowed to run faster than 85 miles an
hour, because a jack rabbit has been
making fun of him on his run. A jack
rabbit is noted for its speed, and this
particular jack, it seems, has been in the
habit of coining out of his burrow, just
south of Olathe, Kansas, when he hears
the flyer coming in the morning, looking
up and winking at the engineer, and
then, throwing back his ears, racing
alongside the track. He seems to know
that the engineer may not run ahead of
his schedule, so he keeps up only a fair
speed, but at that he often gets on the
track in front of the locomotive, and put-
ting up one foot to his face, spreads out
liis toes and makes a sign perfectly fa-
miliar to all small boys, which is expres-
sive of the highest scorn and derision.
This is a true story and vouched for by
a Kansas paper.
The coal handling machinery installed
by the C. W. Hunt Company, West New
I'.righton, N. Y., at the Lincoln Wharf
Power Station of the Boston Elevated
Railroad Company recently lowered the
world's record for rapid unloading. The
coal was raised 90 feet above tide water
and delivered to the storage pockets at
the rate of 320 tons per hour. The in-
stallation follows in general design the
standard Hunt steeple tower rig, the
moving gear ar.d coal cracker being elec-
irically driven, and the hoisting engine
'lirect connected. The overhang of the
I'lding boom is 40 feet, and the capacity
"f the shovel two tons.
I'he New York offices of the sales or-
ganization of the Westinghouse Electric
Oi Manufacturing Company, consisting
of the New York sales department, the
export department and the general
agent's office, have been removed to the
new Hanover Bank Building, corner ot
Xassau. and Pine streets. The new of-
fices occupy the entire seventeenth floor
of this building, where the arrangements
and facilities will be of the best, both
for the representatives of the company
and the public with whom they do busi-
ness. The mail address of the several
departments of the Sales Organization
in New York will be No. II Pine street.
The telephone number, 6131 Cortlandt.
remains unchanged. The executive, finan-
cial and stock transfer offices will remain
on the fourth floor of the Equitable
Building.
Extraordinary ratings were made by
tlie candidates for the scholarships which
Jos. T. Ryerson & Son gave to the Mas-
ter Mechanics' .Association. Seventeen
candidates were examined, and the high-
est grade (gi 2-3) was obtained by Mr.
.\. B. Marsh, of Boston, who was exam-
ined under the supervision of the author-
ities of the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology. The second is Mr. A. A.
Kellogg, with a grade of 91 1-3. The
third is Mr. H. L. Richardson, with a
grade of 91 1-6. It is a great pity that
more scholarships of this character are
not available.
484
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
She Had the Right to the Seat.
A man wlio had been dining walked
into a Christopher Street Ferry boat
one night last month and took the only
vacant seat in sight. Seeing an acquaint-
ance on the opposite side he walked
over to say how are you, old friend, leav-
ing his hat to keep his seat. Just as he
began to pay his respects to the ac-
quaintance he noticed a big negro
woman approaching his seat.
"That's my seat," he exclaimed, but
the woman had plumped down before he
could stop her.
"No suh," she replied, "dis is de side
for ladies, an' drunken loafers am not
allowed here."
"You get up." he shouted, "there's
something under you."
"Yes," she replied, "the seat is under
me, and it will be dar till I get to Ho-
boken."
When she arose the man's plug hat
looked like a concertina and he had to
fit it upon his leg before it would go on
his head.
Smith's Exhaust Arrangement.
Several very ingenious locomotive ex-
haust pipes were invented by Mr. John
Y. Smith, the inventor of the vacuum
brake. Mr. Smith had made a great study
of induced currents and was remarkably
well informed about locomotive draft ap-
pliances. His last arrangement was put
upon an engine belonging to the Pitts-
burgh & Lake Erie Railroad several years
ago. Wondering what had been the fate
of the invention, we recently wrote to
Mr. J. H. Tijrner, superintendent of mo-
tive power of the railroad mentioned,
and we have the following letter about
the invention:
It is true that we experimented witli
the above mentioned device on three dif-
ferent classes of engines in order to dem-
onstrate beyond all question as to its
merits. Not knowing as to whether or
not you are familiar with the device, will
say that it was composed of an exhaust
pipe, surmounted with a perforated cap.
When first placed in service, the area of
the perforations was sufficient to relieve
the engine, but each day the holes became
a little smaller, due to the oil from the
cylinders mixing with the smoke from the
fire box. which resulted in increased com-
pression, stopping up of boiler tubes and
various other ills, which rendered the de-
vice entirely impracticable. The same de-
vice was tried on a number of other roads,
but has never been adopted anywhere.
The Nernst Lamp Company, of Pitts-
burg, has recently established an agency
for the sale of Nernst lamps and supplies
with the W. G. Nagel Company, Toledo.
Ohio, this company having for several
years acted as selling agents for the
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co.
New Cut-Off Saw and Gainer.
This cut represents a new and improved
machine especially built for car shops.
Special attention is invited to some of its
features. It will carry a saw 40 inches in
diameter, cut-off material 13 inches
square, or 26 inches wide by one inch
thick, and when proper gaining head is
used, will cut a gain 6 inches wide and
1V2 inches deep. The head expands from
3 to 6 inches. The column is securely
bolted and lias a large base, decreasing
vibration.
The feed raising the arbor consists of
frictions operating on two large screws
resting on ball bearings, nuts being fit-
ted to take up all wear. The arbor is
easily adjusted, controlled by treadle con-
CUT-OFF SAW AND GAINER.
venient to operator, and th; travel regu
lated by adjustable stops. The table is
mounted on a stand, adjustable to and
from the arbor, and can be swung to an
angle of 30 degrees. It has friction rolls
on each side, and provision is made for
securely holding the work. The machine
can be belted either overhead or from
below, the swinging idler being rever-
sible to bring the weight into action for
either position.
Further particulars, cuts fully describ-
ing it and terms, will be willingly sent by
the makers, J. A. Fay & Egan Co., of
No. 445 West Front street, Cincinnati,
Ohio, who will also send free their new
catalogue showing their machines, to
those interested who will write, mention-
ing this paper.
Some engines on the Burlington &
Missouri River Railroad in Nebraska have
recently been equipped with the Ed-
wards electric headlight. Some of these
engines run in the open stock country and
the light has been found very advantage-
ous by engineers from the fact that its
powerful illumination of the track ahead
enables them readily to see stock on the
COLD DRAWN
SEAHLESS STEEL
Locomotive
Boiler
Tubes
AND
Safe Ends
BOILER, TANK AND
STRUCTURAL RIVETS,
WIRE ROPE, SWITCH-
ING AND WRECKING
ROPES
Miller, Thornburgh&: Co.
I35 = '37 Broadway
New York, U. S. A.
JONES & LAA\SON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works:
SPRINQFieLD, VERMONT, U.S.A.
A. B.C. and LUbtr^ s Codt used.
English Office : Room 6, Exchange Building, Stephen-
ion's Place, Birmingham. France and Spain: Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlott^nstrasse 112, Dusscldorf,
Germany.
October, igo,i.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
485
P
ETERS'
ATENT
OCKET
is only to he had in
Brotherhood
overclothes. ^ Insures your
watch from falling out no mat-
ter what you do. Whether
you're in the shop or on the
road the
Brotherhood
overalls are best. Easy to wear
— always fit and give satisfac-
tion.
Made (n one of the best
shops in the country.
Union of course. <^ j(
H. S. Peters
DOVER, N. J.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wllkesbarre, Pa.
track. 1 lie animals often seek the open
line of the right of way in order to be
free from the annoyance of flics, etc., and
for coolness in the summer nights. Even
if the animal found on the track by thi-;
"railroad searchlight" be too small to be
deemed dangerous to the train, the fact
ihat it can be seen in time and in every
instance driven off. has a very decided
tendency to reduce chances of claim
against the company, together with the
likelihood of troublesome litigation to fol-
low.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
The City Council of Richmond, Iiul.
a small one-horse hamlet, at its last meet-
ing took action on two or three things
of more than ordinary interest. It was
decided to make the effort to stop the
whistling done by locomotives while
within the city limits, and the police were
nntilicd to serve notice on the railroad
cumpanies that the practice must stop.
SIZE
1; ANt> 21 RIBV
JKHKI.S,
HAri'lllltK TALLETS
BAI.I.'S I.1IPB0TKD
SAKKTV
IXX'BI.K I10I.I.KB
The roller bearings for cars is getting
another trial. The hrst invention of that
character was patented by Ross Winans.
about 1830. It was as good as any of
its numerous progeny. The latest roller
bearing car was exhibited at Detroit last
month and met with much favor among
the operating officials who attended the
national convention there. It is claimed
that just half the power will carry this
car that is required for the car with the
ordinary bearing, claimed, of course.
Are wlthont qtlcstioD
tlic flni«t watchca ttiat
Ameriran talent and
»^ki]tf-d labor can ptt>-
durc, and they arc giv-
ing Bucb nnlveraa] aat-
Utactinn that we have
no hesitancy In claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the market.
Testa Beverc and numcrouBhave proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the coantry, to
which thousands of pood Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for Information and facta.
■Write ns for descriptive matter.
TheWebbC. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
Americans and Europeans have been
for years mystified about the value plac-
ed by Chinamen on the roots of a plant
called ginseng. It appeared to have no
medicinal property and chemists long
declared that its constituents were noth-
ing better than those of common weeds;
but an analytical chemist who has lately
been making very exhaustive tests of
ginseng roots declares that they contain
an element new to chemistry. Mean-
while the market value of the root is on
the rise.
The Master Steam Boiler Makers' A:
sociation will hold its second annual con-
vention in the Palmer House, Chicago.
October 7, 8, 9 and 10, at which time
it is expected that the_largest number of
superintendents, foremen, assistants and
layers-out of boiler shops ever congre-
gated together will be present.
A WHITNEY
PLANER
equipped with a sectional feed roll will
feed narrow stuff through in quantities
doubling, often trebling, output, at the
same time retaining a medium lineal
feed-
BAXTER D. WHITNEY & SON
WINCHENDON. MASS.
It is announced on apparently relia-
ble authority that the Pennsylvania Rail-
road contemplates the erection of two
additional steel car plants at Altoona.
after the completion of the one now
being built. They will cost together.
$1,000,000. Changes' and improvements
in the present style of cars will likely
be made.
Patents.
CEO. P. WHITTLESET.
NcGlll. BUItDIMe, WtSHINGTOI, D. C.
Term* Reasonable. Pamphlet Seii»
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
October, 1903.
^U
?
Do
You
Boil
Glvie
7
ARMY & NAVY
LIQIID GLIE
does away with this work. A pure
hide and sinew glue in liquid form.
No smell, clean and convenient. Will
reduce your shop expense for this line
of work twenty-five per cent.
T/ie Glue of the Twentieth Century
Put up in cans, kegs and barrels.
NOT A FISH GLUE
Samples for testing and prices are
yours for the asking.
Wachter Mfg. Co.
BALTIMORE
MARYLAND
Railway ..and
locomoiive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co.- 1903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI. 174 Broadway, New York, November, 1903 No. II
THE CROMER EXPRESS— GREAT EASTERN RAILWAY. THIS IS THE SHOW TRAIN ON THE " POOR MAN'S LINE'— l-il MILE
RUN IN 2 HOURS 38 MINUTES. AVERAGE SI'HED, 49.T MILES PER HOUR WITH HE.-VVY TRAIN. PHOTOGRAPH
TAKEN WHEN ASCENDING BRENTWOOD BANK. A GRADE OF 1 IN 100.
The Age of Specialists.
He used to be the mechanical oracle of
every community, great and small. H".
could patch up a machine that the ma-
chinist swore wasn't worth the rivets re-
quired in the patch. He could mal<e a
condemned boiler carry more steam than
ever without a simmer. He could repair
a watch, grind skates, put rivets into
bladeless knives, make humming tops "and
botch up good work with a caution. He
was attached to the machine shop and
roundhouse about the same as a liveried
fool was to the court of foolish kings.
His work is over and his days numbered.
This is not the stone age. or the iron age.
or the age of steel, nor yet the age of
progress — it is the age of specialties. A
few years ago and a printer must be a
writer, proofreader, pressman and com-
positor, and know all the details of the
business from blank paper to the gilt-
edged book — even to living on store or-
ders. A machinist must be everything,
from a watchmaker to a foundryman. A
locomotive engineer must know how to
build his engine, repair it, clean it, wash
boiler, teach firemen, know the rules of
the road and laws of the State concern-
ing the same — and we had mighty poor
engineers until locomotive engine running
was recognized as an exclusive mechanical
specialty, and men trained for that spe-
cialty. A few years ago, if a breakdown
occurred in the shop all hands sat down
and waited for the Jack-of-all-trades to
come to the rescue. Now they have men
specially trained to look out for the break-
downs. In all well-managed shops they
have a man wlio has charge of the belting,
and if a belt needs lacing he does it in
his own room — for he keeps a duplicate of
every belt in the place in reserve. If the
main belt breaks there is not a hundred
men idle while half a dozen repair the
belt, the "extra" takes its place and the
other is repaired and itself goes on re-
lief duty.
The writer was in a railroad repair shop
recently when the division superintendent
brought in a typewriter to be fixed — said
it was out of kilter. The foreman looked
at it. struck a key or two. and remarked :
'T don't know much about these things."
4S3
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
■'Why," exclaimed the superintendent,
"you have the reputation of being the
best mechanic on the road; I thought you
were j ust the man." The foreman turned
to the speaker and said: "I am a locomo-
tive repair machinist, and have carefully
studied it for fifteen years; if you will
bring me any job on a locomotive that I
cannot do that any other mechanic can, I
will resign ; life is too short for a man to
spread himself out so thin as to attempt
to be familiar with all classes of machin-
ery. There are men who make a spe-
cialty of typewriters, as I do of locomo-
tives. They can repair that machine in
half the lime, for half the money, and
twice as well as I can. I would be as
foolish to attempt to put new letters on
that machine as the maker of typewriters
would be to put a new tire on a locomo-
tive."
Let every mechanic have a specialty and
stick to it.
light from central stations he spends
$3.20 for transportation in electrically
propelled street cars.
In the face of these facts any request
of the companies for additional terminal
iacililies or higher speeds are usually
regarded as attempts to better them-
selves at the expense of the city and
the rights of the man in the car are
overlooked. On the principle of the
"greatest good for the greatest number,"
common sense would seem to dictate
that a crowded street car from the pre-
ponderance of the number of persons
it contains should have a superior right
of passage to a vehicle with only one
or two persons in it, or to a van or
dray containing merchandise. Mr. Vree-
land's logic in this matter is irrefutable.
It is for just such a reason that fast
passenger trains on a steam railroad
are given right of way over mixed
and freight trains, and nobody regards
the operation of that rule as a hardship.
Locomotive Life.
Statistics have been completed recently
which state that the average life of an
English express locomotive is twenty-
five years, of a local passenger engine
twenty-five years, of a freight locomotive
twenty-six years and of a switch
engine twenty-seven years. The total
mileage of an express passenger engine
was fixed at from seven hundred thou-
sand to one million miles, and for each
of the other classes of engines a mileage
of five hundred thousand to eight hun-
dred thousand.
In the United States the average life of
an express locomotive is eighteen years,
of a local passenger engine nineteen
years, of a freight engine sixteen years
and of a switch engine twenty-two years.
Whereas the mileage of an English ex-
press locomotive was only at the out-
side 1,000,000 miles in twenty-five years,
or forty thousand a year, in the United
States it is often as high as 2,000,000
miles, or 110,000 miles a year.
Tiie Right of Passage.
Mr. H. H. Vreeland, president of the
Interurban Street Railway Company, in
a paper recently read before the Ameri-
can Street Railway Association, put forth
a plea for the superior right of passage
of a street car along the street. He
showed that the street railways of the
country serve a larger number of per-
sons than does any other public elec-
trically operated utility. The average
number of times each person in this
country uses the telegraph is twice in
the year, and he uses a telephone on
the average between forty to fifty times a
year, but the average man will ride about
sixty-three times on a street car in the
same time. Putting it in another way,
Mr. Vreeland said that where the in-
dividual spends one dollar on electric
New York Railroad Club Heeting.
The first meeting for this season of
the New York Railroad Club v^as held
at Carnegie Hall, New York, on l8th of
September, Mr. H. H. Vreeland, presi-
dent, was in the chair. There were two
papers presented. The first was by Mr.
Lawford H. Fry, of the Baldwin Loco-
motive Works, on the Proportions of
Modern Locomotive. The paper was
the result of a great deal of special work
and was in substance the collection and
arranging of data concerning a group of
each type of locomotive recently built.
The paper will be a valuable one for ref-
erence.
The second paper was read by Mr. Ira
C. Hubbell, of St. Louis. His subject
was the Effect of Cylinder Clearance
upon the Quantity of Steam consumed
in doing Specific Work, with special ref-
erence to Locomotive Practice. He said
that in ordinary locomotive practice the
clearance generally amounts to about 8
per cent, of the cubic contents of the
cylinder or what is called the piston dis-
placement, but with a valve movement
so timed and arranged as to not only de-
lay opening and closing of the exhaust
ports at the early parts of cut ofT. but at
all points of cut off so that these events
do not occur until the piston is within
about 3 ins. from the end of its travel,
regardless of the point of cut oflf, the cyl-
inder clearance, by which was meant the
space in the ports and the striking dis-
tance of the piston, may and should be
reduced to zVo. per cent, or less in a 20x26
in. cylinder. The discussion which fol-
lowed was animated, and several interest-
ing points were brought out.
Men Who Helped >ew Jersey.
"New Jersey," says William B. Wilson,
in his History of the Pennsylvania Rail-
road, "is deeply indebted to the early pro-
motion of its internal improvements for its
great prosperity and rapid growth. They
were more than ordinary men. Prominent
among them were John Stevens, engineer,
architect, patriot; Robert L. and Edwin
A. Stevens, naval constructors, inventors
in steam appliances, railroad material,
armored ships, bombs, organizers, con-
structors and managers of railroads ; John
S. Darcy, eminent as a physician and pub-
licist, generous, genial and infatigable;
John P. Jackson, lawyer, statesman, giv-
ing up public life to serve his State in
promoting and managing the New Jersey
Railroad, energetic, efficient, faithful and
liberal, religious and charitable, and Rob-
ert Field Stockton, who wrote his name
on the waters of the globe, the great com-
modore, the conqueror of California,
statesman, patriot. These were the lead-
ing men that brought prosperity to the
State through the mediumship of lines of
transportation conducted on business and
equitable principles." _
Old Fashioned Rate Cutting.
We have been under the impression
that ruinous public rate cutting was a
thing of the past among railroad com-
panies, but the Monthly Review, publish-
ed by the National Civic Federation tells
a different tale. We quote from a recent
issue of that publication the following
item :
"Houston, Tex., Aug. 17.— Five hun-
dred tickets were sold to Chicago yester-
day at startling prices as the result of a
war of ticket brokers, the outgrowth of
the fight of the Missouri, Kansas & Texas,
the International & Great Northern, the
Cotton Belt and the Santa Fe for North-
ern passenger business.
"The lowest rate before yesterday was
$18 for the round trip. One broker cut
it to $8. Another broker at once cut it to
$4. Yet another announced Houston to
Chicago, 30 cents J Houston to St. Louis,
20 cents ; Houston to Kansas City, 10
cents.
"Another met ihc cut and offered a $S
bo.x of cigars with each ticket."
Duty on earth, restitution on earth, ac-
tion on earth ; these are the first steps
upward. — Liltle Dorril.
When Oliver Evans applied to the
Legislature of Maryland for a patent or
protection for the invention of a road
wagon to be propelled by steam the ap-
plication was vigorously opposed by
Benjamin H. Latrobe, who denounced
the inventor as a visionary. Latrobe pro-
duced figures which seemed to prove that
all the power which the engine could pro-
duce would be used up in moving the
wagon. Light seemed to come to that
family later, for Latrobe's son became
a famous civil engineer and was chief
engineer of the Baltimore & Ohio Rail-
road.
November, 1903.
RAH. WAY AND LOCOMOTIVK ENGINEERING
489
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
( Continued from paj^e 447.)
THE SELLERS LOCOMOTIVES.
Those familiar with ihe history of early
locomotives in the United States are
aware that the Philadelphia & Columbia
Railroad had two locomotives built by
Coleman Sellers & Sons, but very little is
popularly known about the engines, al-
though they possessed features of design
which ought to have made tlu-m famous.
Coleman Sellers was the ilcscciulant of
a family that had come from Derbyshire,
England, with a party brought out by
William Penn. They were a race of skil-
ful mechanics.
COLEMAN SELLERS & SONS.
Coleman Sellers had four sons, of
whom the two elder, Charles and George
Escol. with him constituted the firm.
In 1834 the senior died and the brothers
continued to carry on the business at
Cardington, close to Philadelphia. In a
series of engineering reminiscences con-
tributed by George Escol Sellers to the
American Machinist in 1885 he gives the
following particulars about the building
of their locomotives.
BIG PIONEER MACHINE TOOLS.
"In the year 1834 the foundry and ma-
chine shop then carried on by my brother
HI the United States, one at West
Point, N. Y., shops and the other at Dr.
Nott's Novelty Works. This primitive
machine had a capacity for 8 ft. length
by 4 ft. wide and 3 ft. high. . . .
"In the latter part of the summer of
CHARLES SELLERS.
and myself were mostly engaged on work
for iron furnaces, rolling mills, flour mills
and machinery for paper making. To turn
the drying cylinders for the latter we con-
structed what at that time was considered
a mammoth engine lathe that would turn
g ft. in length and 4 ft. 10 ins. diameter.
Also for finishing the housings for paper-
press rolls and calenders, we had built and
put in operation the first iron planing ma-
chine in the State of Pennsylvania. If I
recollect right there were only two others
% ^^1
^^^^^^H?r^
^^^^^p J
1^1
COLEMAN .SELLERS. ;.-
1834 James Cameron, brother of the Hon.
Simon Cameron, at that time chairman
of the Board of Canal Commissioners,
called on us and said that he had been
informed by John Brandt that we had the
above described lathe and planer, both well
adapted for locomotive work and asked if
we would undertake the building of some
locomotives for the State railroad. As
the paper machinery and other work was
slack, we took the subject under consid-
eration and a few days later I accompan-
ied Mr. Cameron to the Parkesburg shops
to see and consult with their engi-
neer and with Mr. Brandt, foreman of the
shops. . . .
UNDERTAKE TO BUILD LOCOMOTIVES.
"The result of the trip was that we un-
dertook to build some engines for the
State road, the commissioners stipulating
that the boilers should be dome boilers,
one pair of drivers back of the fire box
and cylinders outside of the smoke box,
drawings to be made and submitted to their
approval. Brandt was very pressing that
we should undertake to build these en-
gines. He proposed while making the
drawings to give me the advantage of
what experience he had with the English
locomotives with the Baldwin engine and
with one of Norris' that was having some
changes made on it.
"Before commencing the drawings I
had several discussions with Brandt and
while making them he several times came
down to the city and remained over night
witli me. It soon became evident that re-
quiring the driving wheels to be placed
back of the fire box was more due to Mr.
Brandt's opposition to full cranks in front
of the tire box with the cj'linders, valves
and their connections under the smoke
box, than that urged by the commissioners
of unequal distribution of weight and its
injurious effect on the rails.
AGAINST FULL CRANKS.
"It was also evident that full cranks
could not be placed back of the fire box
and the cylinders outside of the smoke
box without reducing the diameter of the
boiler and narrowing the fire box to an
extent that was not admissible.
"I proposed outside connections, but
that would not be listened to. The Bald-
win half crank must be adopted, but this
we refused without written consent from
Mr. Baldwin, which Mr. Cameron under-
took to secure, saying he would pay a rea-
sonable consideration for its use. Mr.
Cameron returned saying that Mr. Bald-
win had applied for a patent on the half
crank ; that he had made the invention for
his own protection and it was not for sale
on any terms.
OUTSIDE CYLINDERS PROPOSED.
"In this dilemma I again unsuccessfully
urged outside connections. I proposed to
equalize the weight by another pair of
drivers back of the fire box (afterward
done by Campbell) connected by outside
GEORGE ESCOL SELLERS.
cranks in the manner of the English four-
wheel engines, the front pair of drivers
having full crank axie. I made a sketch
of this which met with Mr. Cameron's ap-
proval, but Mr. Brandt would not give
way in his objection to the cylinders with
steam connections under the smoke box,
he had so much trouble with English en-
gines. He finally joined me in advocating
outside connections. Mr. Cameron said
the commissioners were not willing to risk
experiments. I urged that outside con-
490
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Ncveiiiber, 1903.
nections was no experiment, that Stephen-
son's Rocket, Hackworth's Sanspareil, in
fact, most of the early English locomotives
were outside connected. . . .
"We offered to build either as I had
suggested with full cranks and two pairs
of drivers or outside connections and one
pair of drivers back of the fire Dox, but
it was not until we guaranteed against in-
jurious oscillation that the latter plan was
accepted. . . .
"I made the drawings and submitted
them thinking everj'thing would be satis-
factory, but I was mistaken. My draw-
ings called for iron frames instead of
wood, that up to that time was the only
frame in use. It was objected to on the
ground of its having too much rigidity.
After considerable argument and delay the
iron frame was approved of."
ORIGINALITY IN DESIGN OF THE ENGINES.
After a great many trifling objections
had been raised and overcome the engines
were eventually built. They had outside
cylinders with a single pair of drivers be-
hind the fire box and a four-wheel truck
with a center bearing. The frames were
iron and the driving wheels had counter-
balance weights bolted opposite' the crank.
rated by special charter in February,
1830; and the company was authorized to
survey, lay out and construct a railroad
from' the Delaware River to Raritan Bay,
with as many tracks as might be deemed
necessary, provided the width of road-
way did not exceed 100 feet. A lateral
road from the main line to Bordentown
was also authorized. The road was to
be commenced within two years and
completed within nine years, otherwise
the charter would be null and void.
Considerable opposition to this rail-
road w-as made at first by the canal in-
terests; but they finally formed a com-
bination and the construction of the rail-
road proceeded without interruption. A
portion of the road near Bordentown was
opened late in 1831 with becoming cere-
monies, this having been the first rail-
road opened in New Jersey. Among the
guests of the railroad company on this
occasion, was Madame Murat, wife of
Prince Murat, a nephew of the first Na-
poleon. The members of the legislature
came in a body from Trenton in stage-
coaches, and thousands of people from
far and near assembled to see the "John
Bull" pull its first passenger train.
ping point for New York. Thy railroad,
which the people of Bordentown did
much to promote, was eventually the ruin
of the town, for it was left a way sta-
tion on a branch line. It was originally
a quaker settlement, yet one of the most
cherished glories of the place was that
it was for years the residence of Joseph
Bonaparte, brother of Napoleon.
CAMDEN & AMBOV'S CELEBRATED
PIONEERS.
The Camden & Amboy Railroad Com-
pany exercised a powerful influence on
the development of the locomotive en-
gine; but the work was due principally
to the ability of two men, Robert L.
Stevens and Isaac Dripps. Mr. Sievens
was president of the company and Mr.
Dripps was a young machinist and ma-
rine engineer whom Mr. Stevens en-
gaged to take charge of the machinery
of the railroad.
Robert L. Stevens was a son of John
Stevens, whose wonderful foresight into
the future of land transportation by
means of the steam engine has been re-
^m-^m^ t2> i:ij-i^
THE "JOHN BULL" AND ITS FIRST TRAIN.
Mr. Rogers, of Paterson, visited the shop
when the engines were under construction
and expressed approval of the counterbal-
ance weights, but thought they ought to
have been cast in the wheel center.
The engines gave much satisfaction in
service, and the four novelties of design,
the outside cylinders, the iron frames, the
counterbalanced driving wheels and the
center bearing truck, were all gradually
adopted by American locomotive builders,
but I am not aware of the credit of these
improvements ever having been given to
those who originated them. They pos-
sessed all the elements of what after-
wards became the representative "Ameri-
can locomotive" except the second pair
of drivers, and that arrangement the
builders had proposed.
The Pennsylvania Railroad Company
was a direct development of the Phila-
delphia & Columbia Railroad, but it af-
terwards absorbed a line which was
earlier in operation and one of the first
railroads in the United States to begin
operating. This was the Camden & .^m-
boy Railroad.
THE CAMDF.N & AMBOY RAILROAD.
The Camden & Amboy Railroad and
Transportation Company was incorpo-
NEW JERSEY HAD FIRST RAILROAD
CHARTER EVER GRANTED.
The Camden & Amboy Railroad was
not the first project of the kind agitated
in New Jersey. As early as 1815, the
legislature of that State passed an act
creating a company "to erect a railroad
from the Delaware River near Trenton
to the river Raritan near New Bruns-
wick." Commissioners were appointed
to raise money by subscription to execute
the work; but the enterprise died for
want of financial support. Its promoters
were ten years in advance of the railroad
building sentiment.
The movement is of historical inter-
est because it was the first company in
the world formed to build a railroad for
general transportation purposes.
QUAKER AND ARISTOCRATIC BORDENTOWN.
The old town of Bordentown, 28 miles
from Philadelphia, was well worthy of
being the starting point for the first rail-
road train to run in New Jersey. Situ-
ated on a bend of the Delaware River
which formed the nearest point to water
communication with New York, the
people of the place had long been noted
for their enterprise, in maintaining stage
coach lines to South Amboy, the ship-
peatedly referred to. The son was as
progressive and enterprising as the
father, and was besides an engineering
genius. He effected celebrated improve-
ments on steamships, invented along with
his nephew the famous Stevens cut-off,
first applied anthracite as fuel to steam-
ers, invented the T-rail for railroads, and
did many other wonderful things.
About the time that Robert L. Stevens
became president of the Camden & Am-
boy Railroad, he found Isaac Dripps,
while still an apprentice machinist, in
charge of the erection of the machinery
of one of the largest steamboats that had
ever been built, and doing other impor-
tant marine engineering work. Mr. .
Stevens recognized in the young engi-
neer the material from which leaders of
men and managers of great enterprises
are made, and engaged him as master
mechanic of the Camden & Amboy Rail-
road.
ERECTION OF THE JOHN BULL.
The first work which Mr. Dripps did
was to put the locomotive, which was
originally called the Stevens and which
they had christened the "John Bull," into
working order. The engine had been
ordered from Robert Stephenson & Co.
No\embcr, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
49'
and was received at Philadelphia in i8ji.
Mr. Uripps transported it in a sloop up
the Delaware River to Bordentown,
where he put the parts together. He had
never seen a locomotive engine before,
but he studied the mechanism carefully
and succeeded in erecting it without
making a mistake.
OVERCOMING DIFFICUr.TtES.
The engine was not provided with a
tender, but this did not embarrass Mr.
Dripps much. He found a small four-
wheel car that could carry enough wood
the John Bull, as shown in our August
number. This was made to carry
some weight off the front driving wheels,
and performed in an inferior way the
functions of the Jervis swiveling truck.
Cow catchers were peculiar to Ameri-
can railways, and were made necessary
through the unprotected condition of the
track, which was rarely fenced. In other
countries the owners of domestic animals
were held responsible for keeping them
ofT the property of a railway company,
just as they were held responsible for
Mr. Dripps at Hobokcn were taken by
him to South Amboy, where they were
used to haul material and to perform the
part of schools to instruct men in the
art of locomotive engine running. The
school of experience was the principal
institute of instruction afterwards, but
in 1832 a special school was necessary.
NEW JERSEY AS A BARRIER BETWEEN
POPULOUS REGIONS.
Before railroads were opened the State
of New Jersey seemed to act as a barrier
-ORIGINAL MONSTER.
SECTION THROUGH
REAR AXr.E.
SECTION THROUGH
FIRE BOX.
to last a short trip, and for water tank
he purchased a whisky cask from a
neighboring grocery. For a hose to con-
nect the tank and engine feed pipe, he
called in the services of a shoemaker,
who made a leather pipe that answered
the purpose. Thus equipped the engine
was ready for the service of hauling the
spectacle passenger train.
The company had ordered several new
engines from England, but Mr. Stevens
did not propose to be dependent on for-
eign makers for the motive power of the
railroad. He opened shops in Hoboken
the trespass of their animals upon any
other property; but a different policy was
inaugurated with railroad construction in
the United States. It became the recog-
nized practice to hold the railroad's re-
sponsible for any damage done by tres-
pass of animals upon their right of way,
and the cow catcher was introduced to
prevent the neighbors horse, or his ox,
or his ass, or his hog, from throwing
trains off the track.
The first cow catcher was a heavy
cross-bar secured in front of the leading
pair of wheels. -A. master mechanic in
between the two great centers of popu-
lation. New York with its drainage of
business from the whole of New Eng-
land and Philadelphia, which was the en-
trepot of commerce from a vast region
to the South and West.
Although the distance between New
York and Philadelphia is only about
ninety miles, the journey was a remark-
ably tedious one in the beginning of last
century. The most expeditious journey
was to take a boat from New York to
South Amboy, then a thirty-five mile
stage ride to Bordentown, thence a8
IWI
1 '^
FIG. 40.— ORIGINAL BOILER OF MONSTER.
FIG. 41.— REBUILT BOILER OF MONSTER.
for the construction of locomotives, and
Mr. Dripps had general charge of the
work.
THE COW CATCHER.
In the first few locomotives he built
Mr. Dripps imitated the John Bull in
wheel arrangement and in running gear,
but the boilers were made without the
hemispherical dome. The necessity for
a pilot to push obstructions oflf the track
early became apparent, and Mr. Dripps
designed and applied to the engines the
two-wheel pilot or cow catcher, now on
Philadelphia & Reading used double
bars and fortified them with long
spikes like elongated harrow teeth.
A stray bull was impaled on this
weapon shortly after it was intro-
duced, and the use of a switching rope
was necessary to detach the animal.
That form of bull catcher was at once
ruled out of use, and the germ of the
modern pilot soon appeared. The sleigh-
like contrivance put on the "John Bull"
did not attain any popularity.
The first three locomotives built by
miles by the Delaware River to Phila-
delphia. The trip which is now done
in two hours was generally performed
in two days and that was considered
wonderfully fast traveling.
The opening of the Camden & Amboy
Railroad greatly stimulated the traffic be-
tween New York and Philadelphia, and
the railroad company had more than
enough to do in trying to provide power
and rolling stock to move the growing
business. The railroad had not been in
operation more than two years, when
492
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Xi)vi'nil)cr, 1903.
ROBERT L. STEVENS.
President Stevens and Superintendent of
Machinery Dripps began consulting
about the desirability of building more
powerful locomotives
than anything that had
previously been thought
of.
THE MONSTER.
The result of consul-
tations was the design-
ing of a class of loco-
motives known as the
"Monsters." The first
of these engines was
partly built in Hoboken
^the boiler in New
York and the parts were
assembled in the com-
pany's shops at Borden-
town in 1836. The origi-
nal design of the engine
copied from shop draw-
ings is illustrated in Fig.
39-
In 1885 Isaac Dripps
sent some tracings of drawings to the
American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association; and in a letter concerning
them he says: "Plate No. i (Fig. 40)
shows a boiler for burning anthracite
coal for 18x30 inch cylinder freight en-
gine, built in New York in 1835 for the
Camden & Amboy Railroad Company.
The furnace of this boiler, at its front
end and some distance back from the
tube sheet, had a bridge wall, or water
space extending upwards to within 13
inches of the crown sheet. Between the
bridge wall and tube sheet was a com-
bustion chamber.
"The boiler as originally constructed
was very deficient in steam making, and
after being in use some time she blew off
the dome, breaking through the cast iron
throttle valve at the bottom of the dome.
CONVERTING A COMBUSTION CHAMBER
INTO A FIKE BOX.
"In rebuilding the boiler, I altered the
combustion chamber into a small fire
box, by cutting away the bottom of the
boiler between the tube sheet and the
bridge wall, placing the grate bars low
down and putting a fire door on the side.
The bridge wall, or water space, being
so high, that is near the crown sheet,
gave me sufficient room to raise the
grate bars of the main or back fire box.
"These alterations of the boiler with
the use of the exhaust jet box inside of
smoke box, and tapered smoke pipe, in-
creased the steaming qualities of the boil-
er very satisfactorily. This was the first
time that the exhaust jet box was ever
used." (Changes shown in Fig. 41.)
In the bridge that separates the fur-
nace from the combustion chamber is a
flanged pipe extending through the
crown sheet for the purpose of promot-
ing circulation. The crown sheets of fire
box and combustion chamber were sup-
ported by crow-foot stays, which were
found to be perfectly satisfactory.
FIG. 42.— THE REBUII,T MONSTER.
DESIGN OF ENGINE.
The engine part of the Monster was
very peculiar, the design having no doubt
been influenced by Mr. Stevens' and Mr.
Dripps' connection with marine engines,
which in those days included many curi-
osities. It was an eight-wheel connected
engine, each set of four wheels being free
to move in a plane slightly different from
the other set, which gave it some flexi-
bility in passing curves, the idea of which
was afterwards developed by Fairlie,
Mason, Mallet and others.
The cylinders, which were 18x30
inches, were set on the side of the boiler
at an angle of about 30 degrees, with the
piston working towards the front. The
cross-head connected with a vibrating
beam which the men called the "horse
neck," that moved like a pendulum. A
main rod was connected to the pendu-
lum and transmitted power to the third
pair of wheels, which were the driving
wheels. Between the second and third
pair 01 wheels was a supplementary shaft
carrying a gear wheel, which engaged
with gears on the second and third axles
by that means transmitting the power to
the forward wheels. Each set of four
wheels was provided with connecting
rods the crank pins on the forward set
being located on the opposite side of the
wheel from the hind set.
The valve motion was driven from a
return crank on the main pin, as shown
in the rear section. It will be noticed
that this return crank carried an eccen-
tric as well as a pin. The eccentric
moved one of the drop hooks, the pin the
other, being the first time this arrange-
ment was used. There was a riding cut-
off valve like other cut-off arrangements
common in those days, and it was driven
by connection with the pendulum lever.
Large copper exhaust pipes were used,
and each had a feed pipe traversing the
inside for the purpose of heating the
water.
There was no frame used, all the at-
tachments having been secured to the
boiler. The axle box .pedestals were
riveted to the boiler. The four back
driving boxes had
wedges, but" the forward
boxes had none, the
loose fitting box in the
pedestal being designed
to give some flexibility
in rounding curves.
The engraving, Fig.
42, shows the Monster
rebuilt into a ten-wheel-
er and numbered 635 of
the Pennsylvania Rail-
road's list. The en-
graving was made from
an old tintype found by
Mr. John A. Hill in 1890
when he was editor of
the Locomotive Engineer.
Some details of the pic-
ture were very obscure,
but people who were acquainted with
ISAAC DKIPPS.
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
493
the engine say that the liUeiiess is faith-
fully brought out. The engine was in
use as hite as 1875.
The Monster was not a success as a
locomotive, but its work was sufficiently
satisfactory to bring an order for three
others, whicli were built at the Trenton
Locomotive Works.
{To be continued.)
Railways of the Ancients.
Railways, composed entirely of massive
blocks of smooth stone and adapted to the
passage of wheeled carriages, arc still in
existence in the vicinity of the quarries
whence the stupendous stones were ex-
tracted which were used in the construc-
tion of the Pyramids. These roads have
been incidentally mentioned hy the
French and Italian savants who have
visited that cradle of the arts ; but none of
them have hitherto imagined that they
were, in fact, railways. Their preserva-
tion for three thousand years, notwith-
standing their exposure to the assaults of
time, the havoc of war and the ravages of
barbarians, is remarkable, while every
vestige of the numerous canals which were
constructed by the Ptolemies, or the
Caliphs in Egypt, has long since been ob-
literated from the face of the earth. In
Palmyra and Balbec, similar railways
still exist ; and in Cyrene, in Africa, long
lines of such railways, composed of stone
blocks, may yet be traced for many
leagues, connecting the ruins of the once
splendid cities which the modern desert
contains.
Efficient Smol<e Jack in P. & L. E.
Round Houses.
A very satisfactory smoke jack is in use
in the MeKees Rocks Roundhouse of the
Pittsburgh & Lake Erie Railroad. It con-
sists of the usual smoke pipe passing
through the roof, but the lower or flared
end has a long trough-like opening, which
is 3 ft. 8 ins. wide and 14 ft. long. The
advantages of this form of jack are that
smoke is conducted out of the round-
house, no matter where the engine may be
placed as long as the smoke stack of the
engine comes under some portion of the
overhanging funnel.
The engine is usually placed with stack
just below the 30-in. smoke pipe, but if,
as is often the case in roundhouse work,
the engine has to be moved a few feet
back or forward to facilitate repairs, the
smoke still finds its way out of the shed,
and when not exactly under the center of
the jack, if lighting up be done, the whole
shop is not made to suffer as is so often
the case where jacks with small bell
mouths are used.
On the roof there is a sleeve surround-
ing the smoke pipe and this sleeve has
openings at the bottom which allow warm
air to pass up. Thus the outside of the
central smoke pipe is kept dry and so
greatly reduces rust, with increased life
for the pipe. These openings through
which soiTie Warm air constantly rising,
also necessarily prevents down-draughts
of cold air from entering the shop.
The drip pans or troughs are made of
light angle iron which hang below the
side edges of the flared bottom, the drip
from the end edges is provided for by
a small stiffening angle acting as
a gutter and sloping to the sides.
Ihc jack has given excellent re-
sults in service and is very much liked
by those who have to work under it.
stay bolt passes through a little more than
will receive the riveting at the end of the
stay bolt. This places the iron in such a
shape in the sheet as to allow it to spring
when the expansion of the sheet and the
stay bolt takes place. The experiment
clearly shows an advantage from the in-
dentation, as the opposite sheet in the
same fire box is cracked and leaks, while
the stay bolts in this are as perfect as
the day they were put in, never having
leaked at all after having been run 22,388
miles."
ROUND HOUSE SMOKE JACK, V. ft I.. E.
Our illustration was made through the
courtesy of Mr. D. J. Redding, the mas-
ter mechanic at McKees Rocks.
This was what in late years has been
known as the cupped side sheet. It is
passing strange that such a simple im-
provement has been abandoned.
Origin of the Cupped Side Sheet.
It is curious how inventions are re-
peated with no suggestion of separate
origin. At various times plans have been
tried to save stay bolt heads in fire box
sheets from receiving direct impingement
of the flame, but no decided improvement
has resulted. As long ago as 1859 James
Millholland. writing to the president of
the Philadelphii & Reading Railroad, said :
"I think, from an experiment with an iron
sheet in a fire bo.x with vertical sides, that
I have hit upon a plan that will prevent
the radiating cracks around the stay bolts.
It is to indent the sheet at the hole the
In 1870 there were about 10,000 locomo-
tives in use in the United States with
41,800 wheels and 3.900 of them had cast
iron tires ; g.620 had wrought iron tires
and 28.280 or nearly 68 per cent, of the
whole had steel tires. The rapid advance
into favor of steel for tires may be in-
ferred from the fact that it was only ten
years previously that steel tires were first
introduced.
The Great Western Railway of Eng-
land, have introduced gasoline motor cars
for feeders to the passenger carrying
business in country districts.
494
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Novcnil)er. igo.^
Braking, Breaking or Broken.
A good story of old-time braking was
told the other day of an engineer run-
ning on the Ampersand & Polysyllabic
Railway. The story-teller deposed as fol-
lows:
"Some years ago when air-brakes were
first being adopted the A. & P. had an
engineer nicknamed Modoc. Now, Mo-
doc was supposed to be up on air-brake
matters and the M. M. went out on the
engine with him one fine day. Modoc
rushed into the first station at high speed
and brought the handle of the brake
valve to emergency position. 'There's
the way I do it,' said Modoc, 'everybody
is at the door ready to get out; no de-
lay.' When he got a signal to go he start-
ed the engine with a jerk — 'and here is
where I get my fine work in again : every-
The engine is simple, with cylinders
21x26 ins. and the driving wheels arc 75
ins. in diameter.
Weight of the engine is 192,000
pounds, of which 130,000 pounds are on
the drivers, 32,000 on carrying wheels, and
30,000 on truck. The boiler is 64 ins.
in diameter and has 275 flues, each flue is
2V4 ins. in diameter and 20 feet long. The
fire box is 90 ins. long by 75 ins. wide and
has a total heating surface of 3.425 square
feet. The wheel base of this engine is 32
feet 4 ins., of engine and tender, 59 feet 6
inches, the total length of engine and
tender ^2 feet. The tender carries
thirteen tons of coal and 6,200 gal-
lons of water. Total weight of en-
gine and tender is 242,000 pounds,
and including coal and water 320,-
000 pounds. These engines are of the new
cases it is passed through a screen or
strainer before falling into the water; in
others it falls on to a stream of water,
which is forced through a nozzle ; but
as there is no material advantage either
way, the direct pouring is conmionly em-
ployed.
On falling into the water the metal is
split up into little globules, which sink
to the bottom. Then the tank is emptied
and the solder, before it is ready for use,
gets a thorough good washing to free it
from oxide.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works'
Record of Recent Construction, No. 44,
has just been issued. It contains some
modern examples of the Atlantic, or
4-4-2 type of fast passenger power,
both simple and compound. An
CHICAGO, .ST. PAUL. MINNEAPOLIS & OMAHA i-i-'l EXPRESS ENGINE.
body is seated before they realize it ; that's
where I cut out delays.'
"It goes without saying Modoc was
requested to change his ways or change
his job."
He is to-day one of the best men on
handling air, on a road where the average
performance is first class.
4-6-2 type and are capable of maintaining
a high rate of speed. They were especially
designed for getting up speed quickly in
leaving stations. The total weight of the
North-Western Limited Chicago train,
pulled by these engines, not including en-
gine is 410 tons.
Fast Passenger 4-6-2 for the C, St.
P., M. & O.
The Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis &
Omaha Railway, of which Mr. J. J. Ellis
is superintendent of motive power, has
recently received from the Schenectady
shops of the American Locomotive Com-
pany some 4-6-2 passenger engines. Our
illustration shows No. 372 as she stands,
with steam up, ready to take out her train.
The photograph which is here repro-
duced was obtained through the courtesy
of Mr. T. W. Teasdale, the general pas-
senger agent of the road.
To Make Brazing Solder.
There are two methods in general use
for making brazing solder. By the first,
rods or blocks of the desired alloy are
pulverized and graded — coarse, medium,
fine — and as we have quite got beyond
the age of "mortar and pestel," special
plant and machinery are required to ac-
complish this. The second method is
simpler : the molten alloy is poured in a
thin stream direct from the crucible into
a tank or barrel of water placed in po-
sition to receive the dropping metal, about
10 ft. or 12 ft. below. Of course, there
are other styles of casting solder; in some
"American" type for the Wheeling
& Lake Erie is illustrated, and a
number of Consolidation engines of the
simple and compound variety, are shown.
Several switching engines, four and six
wheel, are catalogued, and inspection lo-
comotives built for the Rochester & Pitts-
burgh Coal & Iron Co., and the Central
Railroad of New Jersey, and a "double-
ender," with a diamond smoke stack for
the California Northwestern Railway. The
half-tones are excellent, and are printed
upon paper which is tinted inside the
border line. The opposite page in each
case gives dimensions, etc., in English and
French.
The Kern River Power Company, of
Los Angeles, Cal., has recently purchased
from the Westinghouse Electric & Mfg.
Co. two Type C, compound-wound, 150-
kilowatt generators to be installed in its
power house.
\ovenil)cr, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
495
General Correspondence.
James H. Boon on RIastic Wheel
Centers.
Knowing that Mr. James M. Boon,
the old-time superintendent of motive
power, was one of the most progressive
men of his time and always well in-
formed on railroad mechanical matters,
we wrote asking him why elastic wheel
centers were abandoned and have receiv-
ed the following interesting letter:
Referring to your letter of September
4, relative to elastic substance between
wheel center and tire of locomotive driv-
ing wheels, would advise that my ex-
perience in this matter was with wooden
blocks in the center of drivers and on
these blocks the tire rested. This ar-
rangement was patented by Mr. George
5. Griggs, who was M. M. of the Boston
& Providence road. I think N. E. Chap-
man, of the Cleveland & Pittsburg, had
some on his road. Samuel Cummings.
who was M. M. of Eastern Division of
P., H. W. & C, equipped a lot of en-
gines, and Mr. I. Dripps, of Ft. Wayne,
equipped others. I was general fore-
man for Mr. Dripps, and had charge of
the work, which consisted of the wheel
centers being cast with unusually heavy
rims. This rim had recesses cored into
it about eight inches long and one and
one-quarter inches deep. The bottom
angled one-quarter of an inch, and the
end slightly dove-tailed, so as to hold
the blocks in place, they being driven in
from the inside of the center, when the
tire was in place; the block wedging it-
self and being held in position by wheel
center.
The process of fitting up these wheels
was to put the centers in the shaft and
turning them so that the tire would slip
in easily when cold. The wheel centers
had set screws which were put in to hold
the tire in position, and in case of a
tire breaking to hold the pieces of brok-
en tire from flying off. The blocks were
driven in from the inside of wheel, and
the outside turned and finished flush with
wheel center. When the tire was in posi-
tion in the wheel center, the openmg
for the block was wedge shaped. There
were as many blocks put in as would go
around the wheel center, with about one
and one-half inches between the blocks.
The center was not permitted to touch
the tire at any point. When the tire was
in position on the wheel it was turned
up and blocks driven in from inside.
These blocks were second growth sea-
soned hickory. The tires were put in
position and the wheels stood up in one
side, and the blocks driven home with
sledges as heavy as one man could swing.
The wheels were then put in lathe and
tires turned for service.
The process was somewhat expensive,
but when completed the job was a good
one. The tires used in those days were
generally iron two and one-half inches
thick, and we knew that the blocks re-
lieved the tire from the severe pound-
ing to which it would have been sub-
jected had the blocks not been there to
relieve it. We frequently run this tire
until one inch thick. As the tire was
with heavier centers and tires, and
heavier rails and tracks, the blocks would
not be necessary. This was never
demonstrated, and the problem remains
an unsolved one to this day. It has been
my opinion for some time that we are
overdoing the weight question, and that
the gain from increased weight is very
much over estimated, as I doubt whether
the increased weight of rails and super-
structures has been accounted for and
charged up for in this increase of motive
AMIDST THE UT.\H MOUNT.\IXS.
PhotogtBpbed by-
Miss M. J. Wilson.
reduced in thickness it would stretch and
get loose. This necessitated the shim-
ming up of the blocks with light sheet
iron and re-driving them. We never
had a tire break that was running on
these blocks, and though the job was
expensive, we felt the results justified it.
Other plans of engines were gradually
adopted and heavier wheel centers and
tires were used, and the wooden blocks
were abandoned. It was considered that
power of weight. I am of the opinion
that lighter engines, moved at a higher
rate of speed and kept moving, would
at the end of the year show more money
to the stockholders and less expense of
maintenance of roadbed and equipment.
J.\MEs M. Boon.
Chicago, September 15, 1903.
Better leave undone than do by
halves. — Tennyson.
496
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November. 1903.
Did Not Reflect on Locomotive
Designers.
In looking over the proceedings of the
Traveling Engineers' Convention, in the
October number of Railway and Lo-
comotive Engineering, I find that on
page 476, second column, third para-
graph, I am quoted as saying that "the
mechanical men of this country are
going wrong, for to-day they are building
engines with 3.700 feet of heating surface
to supply 17-inch cylinders."
These remarks were made as a re-
joinder to a statement made by Mr. Mc-
Bain, that an engine with a ipJ^xaS in.
cylinder, and 1,915 feet of heating sur-
face was well proportioned^ and it should
so appear in the report. I have too
much respect and admiration for the
mechanical men of this country, to make
a statement that would in any way re-
flect on their ability, and it would be
very presumptuous on my part to do so.
Will you kindly correct the error through
the columns of your journal, and oblige,
J. F. Roddy,
Road Foreman of Engines,
A., T. & S. F. Ry. Co.
Boiler Washing and Firing.
In order to get good results in run-
ning a locomotive: First, you want the
inside of the boiler clean and kept as
clean as possible. Scales on the flues
retard the heat going through and the
flues fom heating the water. Now they
are using soda ash by putting it in the
tank to break the water. That is all
right to put in enough to break the
water, but sometimes they overdo the
thing and put in too much, it goes
through the injector into the boiler and
makes a very hard scale. If the boiler
washers neglect their business, which
they sometimes do, the scale gets thicker
and thicker on the flues until there is
no space between them, then it takes lots
of fuel to make steam. I have found
by using kerosene oil in the boiler it
will soften the scale and it will come off
and can be washed out. After washing
out boiler put in about 8 pints of kero-
sene oil after putting in hand hole plates
before filling the boiler, as the water
rises. The kerosene oil staying on top
of the water will oil the sheets, stay
bolts and flues and prevent scale from
sticking to them. I have used kerosene
to good advantage. Sometimes the
boiler washer forgets to put the oil in
until he has filled the boiler, then the
oil is all on top of the water. The
sheets, stay bolts and flues will take up
about 8 pints of oil, keeping the boiler
clean makes it possible to make a good
coal record. Then the fire wants to be
kept clean in the fire box, the corners
and sides want to be kept well filled
so there will be no holes next to sheet
for cold air to follow sheet up and
strike flues until it is well heated.
You cannot get good combustion with
cold air coming up the sides of sheets;
the fire wants to be light enough so it
will burn free; it all helps to save coal
for the company, and that is a big item.
Now in regard to valve oil there is no
valve oil but has more or less gummy
substance in it, so all of the valve oil
I use I cut with kerosene oil, about i
pint of kerosene to 8 pints of valve
oil, that keeps the cylinder packing clean
and helps to save fuel. I have run
cylinder packing over two years with-
out having it looked at and when it
was looked at it was perfectly clean and
not one-half worn out, and did not blow
only a very little when being worked
around so the two openings came oppo-
site each other. It is a good plan to
give engine a light inspection whenever
there is no resetting, as the set screws
under the corners hold it up in place
and the four spurs hold it down on the
set screws.
Then again, if a shoe or wedge has to
be skimmed off again on account of en-
gine not tramming, the operator places
two parallels between or outside of each
holder, then turns shoe or wedge up-side-
down on parallels and skims flanges, then
turns over and takes ofT the required
amount. This last operation with the
parallels saves the time of setting again
to pop marks.
This holder can also be used to hold
guides while being planed. The two
pieces of holder are separated to any
required distance and by placing parallels
under guide (as in skimming ofif shoe)
we then hold the guide in place with the
four spurs.
i,_.
DStted Lines Itepresent
Shoe in 2'ltice
-7t Holts-
-c:
""I "s St. Screw
-■'j St.sli ITmlrr
Cottntay SunK ill \f^
Una
I SL
T"
■'idi-
[1 i
Itailway ^ LoeoiTtotiva EnginMring
PERCY'S SHOE AND WEDGE HOLDER.
you get an opportunity; it is a saving of
expense to the company. The old adage,
"a stitch in time saves nine," is applic-
able to a piece of machinery as well as
to a garment. William Shackley.
Omaha, Neb.
1 hope this will find space in your
valuable paper and be of some value to
some of your readers.
John W. Percy.
So. Tacoma, Wash.
Percy's Shoe and Wedge Holder.
Enclosed you will please find a draw-
ing of a shoe and wedge holder. It
is one of my latest designs and I have
used it for three or four months now
and it is the best I have ever used. I
have used various kinds of shoe and
wedge holders but this one meets more
of the requirements of a holder than any
other I have seen or used, inasmuch as
it does away with the small wedges used
to raise and lower the corners. Then,
beside, when the wedges are used a heavy
cut will disturb them and a second set-
ting is necessary before taking finish-
ing cut, but when shoe or wedge is set
up and fastened in place in this holder
The Nickle Plate.
I attach a clipping from an article from
your pen which I found in a recent num-
ber of the Railway and Locomotive
Engineering, in which I was much mler-
ested, but wish to make a statement with
regard to the name "Nickle Plate." Dur-
the winter of 1882 I was operator on one
of the Pennsylvania lines about 40 miles
from Cleveland, to which point the road
in question had just been built, or at least
not very long before. The first time I
heard of it it was called the "Nickle
Plate," and I remember distinctly of ask-
ing my informant why it was so named,
and he replied that the character of the
road and the elegance of equipment were
to be such that it was to be worthy of
November, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
497
that name. Your account in the article
to which I refer would place the origin of
the name about 1889.
Of course this is not a vital matter, but
in the interest of truth may we not look
for another source for the name which has
become so popular? H. A. Dalby.
A Floating Test Plant.
The subject has been broiiRht up as to
a testing plant for merchandise cars load-
ed in New York City and placed in a
train at Jersey City and sent by fast
freight to some western point. When
the car arrives in Jersey City it is usu-
ally hurriedly placed in a fast train which
has been held for it, and very little, if
any time is had to repair and test the
brakes. In this case a car going into a
high-speed train is obliged to do so with
less preparation than a car traveling in
a slow freight train, which is absurd and
out of reason.
Quite some time ago some of the rail-
road floats plying between New York City
and the Jersey City roads were supplied
with a hand pump, and a man was sent
over from the Jersey City yards to the
float in New York City to pump up the
cars on the float with a hand pump and
test them while they were being loaded
at the dock in New York City. This was
an extremely laborious and primitive
procedure, and what little testing the
brake got was at a comparative low pres-
sure, as the hand pump required too
much elbow grease to get up to the or-
dinary 70 pound train line pressure. Hav-
ing in mind this primitive practice, and
the medium results acquired, and the
possibility of a much better system along
similar lines, it has been suggested that
some arrangement be made whereby air
pipes can be run along the docks and
connected by rubber hose to the cars on
the float, thereby giving pressure with
which the brakes can be tested on the
float.
After the cars have left the float in
Jersey City they can be placed in a train
at once without any further test, and be
relied upon to reach their destination
without further repairs except such trif-
ling ones as may develop en route. 1
have thought that some plan like this
could be arranged, and if so would it not
contribute largely to the maintenance of
brakes in fast freight service?
P. J. Elkerson.
Middleiown, N. Y.
A common expression among railroad
men about certain classes of locomotives
is, that they are over-cylindered. A more
correct description would be that they are
under-boilered. The practice of putting
on heavy cast iron decks to increase the
weight was amazingly bad engineering
when increasing the size of the boiler
w6uld have given increased weight and
steam making capacity.
The Reality of a "Practical" Opinion.
liY A. O. BROOKSIDE.
A gentleman with an eye to originality,
by name Mr. Lendcn Ear, was recently
given the position of fifth vice-president
and general purchasing agent on the
Once Burnt & Twice Shy Railway, with
headquarters at Buytown. Mr. Ear suc-
ceeded a man who in this position had
been exceedingly conservative and who
had believed in investigating the merits
of any new device before committing
himself to its extensive purchase, and
who had always been open to hear what
those who had to use material on the
road had to say about it as to quality or
effectiveness as the case might be.
The new 5th vice thought that this
conservative policy had been carried too
far, and he believed in having an opinion
of his own and not going by what was
told him all the time. He thought that
"the men" on the road had altogether
loo much to say about what they wanted
or about what they liked, so he in-
augurated the "use-what-I-buy" policy.
When Harding Steel, the general fore-
man, got his M.M. to recommend the
A-i company's upsetting machine, and
the "old man" had put his signature to
the requisition, Lenden Ear bought a
machine from the Just-as-Good Company
and complacently said, "They can't run
me."
By and bye a salesman from the Em-
bryo Supply Company came to see Mr.
Ear and showed him the model of a
new car jack which would do the work
of two ordinary ones. Lenden Ear was
quite delighted because the supply man
showed him how well the model work-
ed, lifting a couple of books on the of-
fice desk, and appealed to him as a
"practical" railroad man and "one who
could judge for himself." The jack was a
hydraulic one, large and very good of its
kind, with a very broad base and a kind
of bar or a T-shaped top which was sup-
posed to engage with the end sill of a car
on each side of the coupler, and so raise
one end in order to put in wheels or do
other work. It was just as if you took
an ordinary jack and put a heavy bar of
iron on top, and allowed it to rock slight-
ly so as to adjust itself to any slant of
the end sill. Of course the jack in ques-
tion had this bar made of steel, of pe-
culiarly strong section, with both ex-
tremities roughened so as to avoid slip.
This was, however, the fundamental idea
w'hich the "inventor" had in view when
he "designed" the jack. Perhaps you
may wonder why such a thing could be
seriously brought out, and that sensible
men would bother with it, but it had been
invented by some friend of the Embryo
company with more cash than gray mat-
ter, and besides, gentle reader, let me
tell you what perhaps you already know,
that several railways much better than
the O. B. & T. S. have had foolish
schemes forced along by officials until
the schemes fell down as they were
bound to, at last.
Well, as for the jacks, when you
wanted to put in a pair of wheels all you
had to do was to use one of the Embryo
car lifters (they were not styled jacks)
placed so that the T-shaped top took the
end sill each side of the coupler, give a
few strokes of the lever and up goes the
car. The old way required two jacks, so
there you are.
The supply man begged Lenden Ear
to go out into the yard and actually see
one operate, and then he would know
as much and more than "the men" could
tell him. Lenden Ear and the supply
man went out and tackled an empty flat
car. The Embryo man put the jack
squarely under the center of the end sill,
which by the way was made of wood, and
jacked up the car easily. He stood smil-
ing on Lenden, one hand in his pocket,
and the toe of his right foot touching
the ground beside the instep of his left,
just as if he was a sailor being photo-
graphed for the first time, and he said,
"You have had a practical demonstration
and you can appreciate it." Lenden Ear
went back to the office and placed an or-
der for twelve Embryo jacks, and in due
time they arrived, painted a beautiful
shade of bottle green, and Lenden E^r
had them issued for use.
When half a dozen found their way
to Harding Steel's shop, he turned them
over to the car foreman, remarking at
the time that they were no good. The
car foreman said he shared that opinion
but would give them a whirl. He there-
fore put Billy Boyd, a good square fel-
low and a good car man, to jack up a
loaded car and see how it worked. Billy
read the directions which were tied to
the T-shaped top, and placed the jack
squarely under the coupler with the T
arms set for the end sill. He then be-
gan to pump and the car went all over
to one side. "Hello," said the foreman,
"just as I thought — move the jack to the
right." Billy did so, and on jacking
up again the car went over the other way.
"Too far, Billy, come in again!" Billy
"came in" but it would not balance until
he "came in" some more and then the
car began to go up, but the jack was
not under the center by any means.
"Eight minutes setting it for a load," said
the car foreman to Harding Steel that
evening, and Steel told him to put them
on one side until further orders.
About a month or six weeks after this,
Lenden Ear came down to the shop and
dropped into the office of the "old man."
They talked about the weather for the
thirty-second part of a minute and then
Lenden asked him how much saving he
had effected by the use of the new jacks.
He did not ask if any saving had been
effected, he asked "how much." He was
told no saving had at any time been
498
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERINC,
November, 1903.
within a thousand miles of the jacks as
' they now stood. When asked for par-
ticulars the "old man" said, "I have a
report which though it passed through
the proper cliannel all the way up, start-
ed with Billy Boyd and the car fore-
man." They said that with an unevenly
loaded car it took too long to place the
jack, and it wasn't safe anyway, because
you never could tell how near it was to
"balancing off again," that was probably
Billy Boyd's expression, but although it
did not read well in a letter, Billy had
eternal truth on his side, when he manu-
factured it. The "old man" also said
that he had a letter from the M. M. at
the other end of the line who had re-
ceived the other six Embryo jacks say-
ing, "One of our car men tried to jack
up a loaded steel hopper with one 'Em-
bryo' and had only succeeded in slightly
bending the lower flange of a very
light steel end sill before we caught him,
and I have had the jacks set on one side
awaiting further orders."
Lenden Ear at first said "prejudice,"
and thought "the men" were very stupid
and very pig-headed and had clubbed to-
niight order things the men who used
them daily could make or mar his repu-
tation as a buyer. He thereafter became
a useful and considerate oflicial, and in
time he came to respect the judgment of
Billy Boyd, on anything which Billy had
to work with day in and day out and to
keep in repair to make his living with,
because, as Billy once explained to him,
he wanted a thing to be "handy and good
and safe because he wasn't railroading
much for his health."
Moral: Two or three drops squeezed
out of the opinion of some honest, capa-
ble men who have gone up against it
good and hard, in all weathers, outside,
and who don't know what a railroad
looks like over the top of a mahogany desk
in a steam-heated office, should now and
then be poured on a requisition form, and
if the ink does not fade out, it's likely
all right.
Only Trying;.
A traveler mustered up courage to ask
when his train was due.
"Nine fifteen," said the agent.
OI.D BELGL-^N ENGINE. WIDE FIRE BOX. FROToTYFE OF
MODERN CLASS.
A POPULAR
gether to "down" the jack. The "old
man" tried to cheer Lenden up a bit by
saying that "the men" had not been
clubbing together because the jacks had
not given satisfaction in the service
which they would have to be put to
by the practical men who had to use
them, and live with them, and make them
work, and "take chances" with them —
men like Billy Boyd and the car fore-
man. The "old man" said, however, that
Harding Steel that morning had asked
him through the M.M. to let the shop
have those jacks as they were no good
outside arid he would put on an ordinary
top and make the valves work a little
better, and they would be all right, and
the old man said he had given his per-
mission as the G. M. might be "along"
some day and ask questions if he saw a
row of new jacks "on the side track."
Lenden Ear began to see that the
"old man" and "the men" were not the
headstrong, prejudiced, self-d^inionated
lot he had taken them for, and as the
"old man" expounded unto him the law
and the prophets he began to see day-
light, and to understand that though he
He waited a half hour and then went
back to the window.
"Train ain't here yet, and it's 9.30."
"What are you going to do about it?"
asked the ticket man.
"You've got it marked 'on time' on
the board."
"Bet you $1 I ain't."
"Then I'd like to know what 'O. T.'
stands for."
" 'Only trying.' It's a mixed train, and
they're trying like Sam Hill to get over
a grade fifty miles from here with twenty
cars of stock. But don't you worry;
they'll get here some time to-day. They'll
keep trying till they get over the hill."
The note taker had been making the
rounds of the veterans listening to their
reminiscences of early railroading. At
the conclusion of a long series of inter-
views he complained that most of the
pioneers were afflicted with inventive
memories.
Things cannot turn up of themselves.
We must in a measure assist them to
turn up. — Mrs. Micawber.
Old Time Railroad Reminiscences.
BY S. J. KIDDER.
I am sometimes inclined to believe
that new appliances or inovations,
when introduced on railroads, are not
properly appreciated by the employees
who more or less generally seem fo
think that the employment of devices
differing from those with which they
have become familiar are of needless or
doubtful utility, when to their way of
thinking the older ones have worked
all right and are good enough. With
such thoughts it is little wonder that
the engineer who indulges them is in-
clined to overlook the fact that progres-
sion and perfection are the levers which
impel the business of the world and
safety as well whether it be in the form
of a railroad train, safety appliance or
any form of contrivance intended for
profit or the comfort or safety of the
man who handles the novelty or those
dependent on him for their well being.
It is very fair to assume, and observa-
tion and experience has very generally
proven, that when a railroad company
has adopted something new arid the
adoption of which must necessarily be
attended with more or less expense, that
its merits over existing appliances have
been carefully considered before making
the change, hence instead of taking the
position to "let well enough alone" the
better way would seem to be to become
familiar with the device, when its forth-
coming is a settled fact, with a view
of promoting its valuable features. We
can all recall how universally engineers
protested against injectors in lieu of
pumps, automatic lubricators and other
devices, and in too many instances con-
tributed to their apparent unreliability
and uselessness by neglected effort to
become familiar with and how to operate
them, but in time were forced to admit
that their merits were superior to the
apparatus supplanted and after all had
been opposing the natural fruits of evo-
lution which later they were compelled
to concede were steps in the way of im-
provement and most desirable.
It was always my way of thinking that
when aything new was in sight that those
sure to come in contact with it sooner
or later should leave no stone unturned
to familiarize themselves with it before
it came under their immediate control
and thereby save perhaps lots of vexa-
tion and possibly dire results. I am
led to these thoughts by an experience
with automatic brakes where knowledge
I possessed at the time of the incident
prevented an accident, but before recit-
ing it will refer to experiences connected
to and leading up to it.
For years we had been using the
straight air brake on the C. B. & Q.
oh all passenger trains, and during that
period I had never experienced a brake
failure at a critical moment, though had
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
499
several times when approaching a stoij-
ping place or descending grade, in Icst-
ing tlie brakes found the hose coupHngs
disconnected somewhere in the train,,
but by this practice at such times had
ample room to stop and avoid, in two
instances, head end collisions where the
opposing train happened to be occupy-
ing the main track unexpectedly at a
station, by the vigorous application of
hand brakes. Hence when it became
noised about, as such things do, that
our passenger equipment was to be pro-
vided with automatic brakes which could
not fail, I was only too glad and anxious
to see the work completed. This, I
think, was in 1882, and my engine was
among the first in the division to re-
ceive the new equipment. Having the
smallest passenger engine. I was fre-
quently sent out on specials, composed
of officers' cars, they also being among
Had also observed that a 20 to 25-
pound reduction of train *pipe pressure
appeared to apply the brakes to their
full efficiency and ensured a prompt rc-
leatffk These and other features were
apparent, and while imperfectly under-
stood were found to promote desirable
results and prevent troubles generally
believed to be inherent defects of the
brake.
With these experiences I had been
able 10 become fairly familiar with au-
tomatic brakes, and when a bulletin was
posted in the round houses to the efifect
that on a certain day and hour all trains
would leave terminals with brakes work-
ing automatically I felt a certain degree
of security that I would be able to get
along all right with them. This was
before the days of pump governors and
to prevent carrying an excessive pres-
sure a safety valve, set at 70 pounds,
EVOLUTION OF THE AIR PUMP VALVH.
the first of the coaches to be changed
to the new brake, and on these trips
it was my practice to cut the engine
and cars into automatic and use that
brake while on these trips. With this
experience and a book containing a
general description of the apparatus,
literature on the subject at that time
being extremely limited and no air brake
instructor to appeal to, I was able to
gather considerable knowledge of the
' brake's operation, while at the same
time I understood little of the philosophy
which contributed to the results I found
myself able to obtain by proper brake
valve manipulation. For instance, by
lapping the brake valve when approach-
ing a stopping point the brakes released
more freely than otherwise, the three-
way cock of that period not being ar-
ranged for obtaining excess pressure.
was attached to the main reservoir of
engines on our division.
The time for our initial trip was ap-
liroaching, and pretty soon Jim Brown
rame rolling into Burlington with the
I7.T carrying 100 pounds train line pres-
sure, and when the 245 was coupled to
the train of course all train brakes set
with a bang, and while the passengers
were at supper I took advantage of the
time in bleeding the auxiliary reservoirs
to a point which would permit control
of the brakes with my more modest
pressure.
We soon pulled out with our six-car
train, and afer two or three stops, two
cars being the most I had previously
handled, I had properly gauged the ex-
haust from the brake valve and the
brakes worked quite to my satisfaction.
Thirty-one miles up the road was
Kctchum's Siding, a flag station, and
four miles beyond, down a heavy grade.
Rome, the regular meting point for an
opposing passenger train which, by the
way, had the right of road. At the
Ketchum whistle post I sounded the
station signal, and receiving no response
from the cab bell, indicating a stop
there, I let the 243 sail along, and as
we passed the switch the brakes sud-
denly applied and before I recovered
from my astonishment the train came
to a stop with a terrific jerk, the main
reservoir and train pipe pressures mean-
time vanishing.
Too late to save the reservoir pres-
sure I recovered my senses, and when
"Goldy," the conductor, came up to as-
certain why I did not respond to his
go-ahead signal, I learned he had pulled
the conductor's valve cord to see how
the thing worked, and abundant success
had certainly crowned his efforts. The
delay incident to restoring the pressure
with a 6-inch pump resulted in a lay
out and our waiting at Ketchum for No.
4. Following this everything worked
very smoothly for the following two
days, when the incident happened that
proved my knowledge of automatic
I)rakes was the one thing which pre-
vented what, .without question, would
otherwise have been a most deplorable
accident.
It was a beautiful August night, about
10 o'clock, with a full moon, and we
were going east on No. 4 and had
reached West Burlington, where a slight
delay had been encountered, necessitat-
ing a quick run down the S2-foot grade,
to reach our destination on time, the
grade extending from our stopping point
to Burlington.
As we pulled through the yard I no-
ticed a heavily loaded freight train
waiting to follow us down the hill. We
hid gone some three miles, and just
as I reached for the brake valve to slow
up the train before passing several street
crossings the brakes suddenly applied,
and hearing air escape under the tender
deck I knew from former experience that
the hose between the engine and tender
which, by the way was simply clamped
to the air pipes, had pulled off. My
first thought was that no one on the
train knew anything about releasing
brakes under such conditions; the next
that in a few moments that freight train,
dependent on hand brakes alone, would
come thundering down the grade at a
high rate of speed, such as is usually
considered safe when following a pas-
senger train, and with no time on our
part to get back a flag, owing to the
long Sunny Side curve obscured from
view not far in our rear. These thoughts
passed my mind in an instant and,
jumping from my seat I crossed the
cab deck, descended to the tender step
and waited for the train to slow up
suf^eiently to permit my alighting with-
out being compelled to perform any
acrobatic contortion. When the train
had slowed down to a speed of perhaps
15 miles an hour I jumped, and after
faking a number of strides that would
have resembled those of an ostrich in
rapid movement. I finally got stopped
and headed west then sprinting to the
best of my ability, was opposite the
fourth car when the train came to a
standstill. I immediately dove under the
car, throwing the 4-\vay cock to straight
air, it was in the days of plain triple
valves, then out again for the next car,
until the Pullman was reached at the
rear of the train.
Then turning towards the front of the
train, running from one car to another at
my best sprint, manipulating each triple
as I passed it, I soon reached the en-
50O
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
_gine. During this time the conductor
and brakeman were standing on the plat-
forms inquiring as I passed what was
the matter, but too much hinged on the
facihty of my movements to satisfy
curiosity. Jumping aboard I pulled out
wildly, and just as I did so heard sev-
eral frantic whistles for brakes and saw
the headlight of the old 256 rapidly clos-
ing up on my tail end.
As we approached Mt. Pleasant cross-
ing, my train at this time covering a
curve, I looked back, and as I did so
saw the headlight pass out of sight be-
hind the Pullman, we at this time
moving, perhaps, 30 miles per hour.
Bracing my shoulder against the back
board and grasping the reverse lever I
prepared for the shock, but not receiv-
ing it looked again and saw that the
headlight was in sight and receding from
our rear.
The relief experienced at that moment
can hardly be described, and when as-
than ever of the importance of men han-
dling trains familiarizing themselves with
new devices they are to come into con-
tact with, as such may result in pro-
tecting themselves, as well as the lives
and property under their charge from
accidents which, when they occur, are so
apt to be attibuted to hard luck.
Did I say no insignia followed my
efforts to protect the company's inter-
ests and property? Well, I hardly meant
it that way, for shortly after I did re-
ceive one in the form of a telegram, over
the signature of the general manager,
summarily "firing" me from the service
of the company, the details of which will
be given in a future number of Railway
AND LoCOMOTtVE ENGINEERING.
A Suburban P. &. R.
The accompanying illustration is of a
simple, wide fire box, slide valve subur-
ban locomotive recently built by the
above. This arrangement compensates
for the backward motion of the reach-
rod in this case and lowers the links
so that, when the reverse lever is thrown
forward, the engine moves ahead in con-
formity with usual practice. When the
reverse lever is thrown back the links
are raised and the valve gear is operated
by the back-up eccentrics.
The main drivers are the only wheels
not flanged. The springs are on top
of the boxes and the pony truck and
leading driver are equalized together, and
the main and trailing drivers are also
equalized together.
The boiler is 66 ins. diameter at the
smoke box end and is of the wagon
top type. There are in it altogether
1,981.8 sq. ft. of heating surface, of which
the tubes give 1,825.5 sq. ft. The grate
area is 68.5 sq. ft. and the fuel is anthra-
cite buckwheat There are 447 tubes 9
ft. long, diameter 1% ins. The auxiliary
dome carrying the pop safety valves is
PHII..\DEI.PHIA ^: READING 2 - « - 4 FOR SUBURBAN TRAFFIC.
sured, a lew moments later, that the
freight was under control and the dis-
tance between us rapidly increasing, I
shut ofT, whistled for brakes and not long
after was brought up safely by the hand
brakes at Union station.
Now, some of mj' readers no doubt
will attribute this narrow escape to a
streak of good luck, but I do not tliink
so, for had it not been for the knowl-
edge I had gathered regarding the au-
tomatic apparatus we would have been
struck by that freight train, moving at
a speed of at least 40 miles an hour, and
it can only be conjectured what would
liave been the result to the 127 passen-
gers at the time aboard the train, and
v.'ho little realized the narrow escape
they had had from disaster. My efforts
to avert an accident were never rewarded
by a medal or other insignia of grati-
tude on the part of the railroad com-
pany, but it impressed me more firmly
Baldwin Locomotive Works for the
Philadelphia & Reading Railway, of
which road Mr. S. F. Prince, Jr., is the
superintendent of motive power and roll-
ing equipment.
The engine has 20x24 ins. cylinders and
the driving wheels measure 61% ins.
outside tires. The tank and coal box
is carried on a rear projection of the
main frame and the wheel arrangement
therefore makes it a 2-6-4 type- The re-
verse lever, unlike those in general use,
is one which in text books on elementary
mechanics would be called a lever of the
first class. That is, the fulcrum is situ-
ated at some point between where the
power is applied and where the resist-
ance acts. This gives a backward mo-
tion to the reach-rod when the lever
is thrown forward. The reach-rod how-
ever passes beneath the level of the
lower frame-bar and operates a tumb-
ling-shaft arm which hangs down from
so placed as to require the whistle, which
has a long top, to be set at an angle
in order not to stand above the level
of the top of the smoke stack.
The tank has a capacity of 3,000 U. S.
gallons and the fuel space will hold
7.500 lbs. of the kind of coal used. The
total weight of the machine is 201,700
lbs., the drivers carrying 120,860 lbs.
There are 19,120 lbs. on the pony truck
in front and 61,720 lbs. on the rear
truck. The steam pressure carried is 200
lbs., and the calculated tractive effort is
about 26.500 lbs.
A few of the principal dimensions are
appended for reference:
Cylinder— 20 x 24 ins.
Boiler — Dia., 66 ins.; thickness of sheets, } J in. and
3/^ in.; working pressure. 200 lbs.
Firebox — Length, 94 ins.; width. 105 ins ; depth,
front, ,^9*4 ins.; back, 46^ ins.; thickness of
sheets, sides, '-s in.; back, :>a in.; crown, }^ in.;
tube, ^2 in.; water space, front, 5}.^ ins. ; sides,
34 ins.; back, t,'A ins.
November, igoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
501
Tubes— Material, iron; wire Rauge, No. 10; num-
ber, 447; dia , vi., ins.; length, q ft, o in,
HeatinK sur - Kirc box, 156 .^sq. ft; tnbes, 1,825,5
sq. (t.; total, 1,981.8 sq. ft.; grate area, 68,5sq ft.
DrivinK wheels— Dia. out.side, 61H '"s.; journals,
main, 8^4 x 12 ins.; others, Hii x 12 ins.
Engine truck wheels, front- Dia., .loins.; journals,
6x12 ins,; back, dia , .isins.; journals, 6x 12MIS.
Wheel Iin^c Ri^id, 12 ft, 6 ins ;tot, tng., 30 ft, gins.
Weiglit -On driving whfels, 120,860 lbs.; on tciick,
front, 19.120 lbs; ontitiok, back, 61,720 lbs.;
total engine, 201,700 lbs.
Engine of a Trans-Mississippi 5hop.
The small switching locoinolive here
illustrated was built by tlie Davenport
Locomotive Works, of Davenport, Iowa.
That company seems to have crept very
quickly into a fair business in building
small locomotives, for they have turned
out 52 engines since last November and
have done some repairs for railroad com-
panies. This is the first company that
we know of that has established a busi-
ness of building locomotives west of the
Mississippi River. The officials of the
'■"T!m
beware of platitudinous ponderosity. Let
your conversational communication pos-
sess a clarified conciseness, a compacted
comprehensibleness, a coalescent con-
sistency, and a concatenated cogency.
Eschew all conglomeration of flatulent
garrulity, jejune babblement, and asinine
affectation. Let your extemporaneous
descantings and unpremeditated cxpatia-
tion have intelligibility and veracious vi-
vacity without rhodomontade or thra-
sonical bombast. Sedulously avoid all
polysyllablic profundity, pompous pro-
lixity, psittaceous vacuity, ventriloquial
verbosity and vaniloquant vapidity. Shun
double entendre, prurient jocosity and pes-
tiferous profanity, obscurant or apparent.
In other words, talk plainly, briefly,
naturally, sensibly, purely and truthfully.
Don't put on airs; say what you mean;
mean what you say; and don't use big
words."
No letter was ever sent out afterward
by the young railroader which contained
words of more than two syllables.
ENGINE BUILT WEST OF THE MIS.SISSII'II KI\EK.
company are : E. S. Johnson, president ;
J. Flick, vice-president; Alfred Hagen-
boeck, secretary; C. L. Grimes, general
manager. George Strahle, who learned
the machine trade in the Burlington,
Cedar Rapids & Northern Railroad
Shops at Cedar Rapids, Iowa, is general
foreman.
Cured by a Letter.
A few months ago the son of a rail-
way director was, through his father's
influence, given a position of some im-
portance on a large railway. He was
fresh from Cambridge, and in the orders
which he from time to time issued to the
men under him always made use of the
longest, most unusual words. This habit
led to some rather expensive blunders,
and the matter coming before the gen-
eral manager, he wrote the young offi-
cial the following letter:
"In promulgating your esoteric cogi-
tations and in articulating your super-
ficial sentimentalities and amicable phil-
osophical or psychological observations.
Water Softening on the Pennsylvania
Lines.
Among the many improvements re-
cently inaugurated on the Pennsylvania
systems, not the least interesting is in the
matter of water softening for locomotive
use. A typical installation for this pur-
pose on the lines west of Pittsburgh,
northwest system, is located at Middle-
point, Ohio, where a machine of capacity
to soften 10,000 gallons of water per hour
has been in use for some time. The
water to be treated is particularly bad,
yet the softening and purification are
practically accomplished.
The chemicals used in the softening
are fresh lime and soda ash, and this
particular water requires for treatment
approximately 4.75 pounds of lime and
4.5 pounds of soda per thousand U. S.
gallons. Running at full capacity, 1.744
pounds of incrusting calcium and mag-
nesium salts are removed per day by
the machine employed.
In its slow upward progress in the
tank the water dissolves a sufficiency of
calcium hydroxide and becomes satur-
ated lime water. Owing to the absence
of agitators in the upper portion of the
tank, the liquid there is comparatively
quiet, and by the time the exit is reached
all the heavy particles of milk of lime
have been left behind by the lime water,
which issues clear and of constant
strength. Flowing through the chute it
meets the main body of raw water from
the gate as well as the proper propor-
tion of soda ash solution which has pre-
viously been prepared in the box. The
soda solution is fed by means of a valve
which is so constructed and automatically
operated that the flow of solution is al-
ways proportional to the amount of
water to be treated. The water and the
reagents then pass downward through
the reaction pipe into the reaction tank.
This tank is of such a size as to per-
mit the water to remain in it for a period
of half an hour, during which time it
is very thoroughly agitated by means
of stirrer bars on three vertical shafts.
The precipitate subsides to the bottom of
the settling tank; the treated water rises
slowly and passes through a wood fiber
filter, where the very small quantity of
matter which is carried in suspension, is
deposited. The water then flows clear and
soft from the outlet to the storage tank.
The builders of this plant. Industrial
Water Company, of 126 Liberty street,
New York, have also installed another
plant of a like capacity and treating
water of the same general character at
Washington, Hardin County, Ohio, about
forty miles farther east on the same
railroad.
It is gratifying to note of late the
peaceable manner in which the railways
and brotherhoods are adjusting their
grievances. This has been made possible
by the Brotherhoods, in their wise selec-
tion of conservative committeemen, who
have been able to demonstrate to the
officials of railways the fairness of their
requests. On the Great Northern, after
a conference lasting several weeks, the
engineers and firemen got a raise of pay
?nd a reduction in working hours for
the men on the switchers. On the
main line the firemen got a raise of pay,
ranging from 5 to 15 cents per hundred
miles, according to the class of service.
In a time book for engineers on the
South Carolina Railroad dated 1833,
there are a few rules about the pay of
engineers. Among them is one which
provides that when an engine broke
down and returned without finishing the
trip, the engineer would not be entitled
to any pay.
The Northern Pacific are receiving
seventy-five engines this year. There are
sixty-five road engines and ten switch-
ing engines in this "batch" of new mo-
tive power equipment.
502
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
lo%w;^Egneeriii$
A Practical Journal of Railway .Motive
^. j^-^^ Power and Rolling Stock.
Published Monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, Ne'w York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, "Loceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, ** ItfOcauto.*'
Business Department:
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NEI<1,IS, Vice-President.
JAMBS R. PA lERSON, Sec'y and Treas.
Bdltorial Department :
ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor.
F. M. NELLIS, /
GEO. S. HODGINS, ^Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, )
Advertising Department:
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative, C. J. LUCK,
1204 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative :
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO-, Ltd., Amen Corner, Paternoster
Row, E. C., London.
Glasgow Representative :
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
S2.(XI ji^y ij'ar, ^l.iiU for nix nionthg^ jiontagf paid
to tlie Uiiittil Ulad'g, Canada a/id Mexico. Fo^'
olfier fiarU of the woiid, s^.5U or ten shillings.
Single eopien^' 20 centn. Jietnit by Express Money
Order. Unifl. Post (Jffiee Order or JiegiKlered Letter.
MaUiiHj liildrizss can tie changed a^ often «/•■ nece*:-
ttary — lUcays gie, old and new addre^n^ and if you
sulJiKcritied in a club, state who got it up.
Please giie prompt notice when your paper failtf to
reach you projferly.
Entered at Post Office. New York, as Second-
class mail iiijtter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co., 1903-
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Attempts to Improve Locomotive
Valve Motion.
We once read a statement made by a
celebrated engineer that cylinder clearance
is always a source of loss, a statement
which appears to be thoroughly endorsed
by Mr. Ira C. Hubbell, who read a paper
at the September meeting of the New
York Railroad Club on "Effects of Cyl-
inder Clearance Upon the Quantity of
Steam Consumed in Doing Specific Work,
With Special Reference to Locomotive
Practice;" With the shifting link motion
arranged to increase the lead as the cut-
off is shortened, there must necessarily be
considerable clearance space provided to
hold the compressed steam, and Mr. Hub-
bell contends that the work of compres-
sion is wasted effort which could be
avoided by employing a valve motion that
would keep the exhaust port open till
near the end of the stroke and thereby
leave a small amount of steam to be com-
pressed. He submitted indicator dia-
grams taken with the AUfree Valve Gear,
and they certainly exhibit almost ideal
steam distribution. Link motion engines
cannot be operated smoothly with less
than eight per cent, piston clearance, which
makes a large hole to be filled at the be-
ginning of each stroke. A material re-
duction of this space ought to result in
steam saving sufficient to effect a marked
economy on the operation of a locomo-
tive.
The , indicator diagrams illustrating
Mr. Hubbell's paper would lead us to be-
lieve that the claim for the valve motion
producing them has the merit claimed for
it. The valve movement is so timed and
arranged as (o not only delay opening and
closure of the exhaust ports at the early
points of cut-off, but at all points of cut-
off, so that these events ao not occur un-
til the piston is within about three inches
from the end of its travel, regardless 01
the point of cut-off. With such action the
clearance, including the space clear ot
striking and that beneath the valve faces,
is reduced to about 2j4 per cent, without
disturbance to the moving mechanism.
The author of the paper cited calcula-
tions to show the saving that would be
effected, with an engine having cylinders
20x26 inches, and theoretically he proves
a good case. We have enjoyed considera-
ble experience in making and watching
tests of locomotives with valve motion de-
signed to improve on the link motion.
That experience makes us skeptical
about the real steam saving that will
result from a valve motion producing
ideal diagrams; but the diagram ought
to point the -way toward real progress,
and act as a guide to improvement.
The link motion attained popularity ow-
ing to its durability and simplicity, two
features that are of the highest importance
in locomotive mechanism ; but it is possi-
ble to over-estimate their value. As a
mechanism for steam distribution, the link
motion is very defective and it is possi-
ble that its shortcomings overbalance its
merits. The ordinary link motion when
tested by the indicator, always displays
excessive compression at short points of
cut-off, at the points where most locomo-
tives are worked the greater part of the
time. When fault is found with this pt-
culiarity, the admirers of the link motion
explain that the high compression is neces-
sary to .produce smooth running at high
speeds and that the action fills the clear-
ance spaces and thereby saves steam from
being drawn from the boiler to produce
high initial pressure at the beginning of
the stroke. Most of them also believe that
the act of compressing the steam costs
nothing, which is contrary to all nature's
laws, and to the principle of the conserva-
tion of energy. They say it costs noth-
ing to arrest the swing of the moving
parts, which would otherwise expend their
blows upon the frames and pedestals ; but
the absorption of the blows cuts off the
heel of the indicator diagram, and there-
by wastes part of the power, or, rather,
reduces the cylinder capacity. When the
heel of the diagram is materially increased
by reduction of compression a propor-
tionate increase is given to the power of
the engine.
It seems to us that the ideal valve mo-
tion, is one that makes a low percentage
of cylinder clearance possible and provides
for only sufficient compression to raise
the compression to steam chest pressure
at the beginning of the stroke. This, of
course, would call for something belter
than the link motion.
It may be that the valve motion advo-
cated by Mr. Hubbell fulfils these condi-
tions. The fact, however, that it produces
an ideal indicator diagram, will not sig-
nify conclusively that it is destined to
displace the link motion.
Valve motions with independent cut-off
were used very largely before the link mo-
tion forced its way into popularity; and
some of them produced remarkably good
steam distribution. George H. Corliss ap-
plied his famous valve motion to a locomo-
tive, but it proved the worst kind of a
failure. David Clark, of the Lehigh Val-
ley, designed a valve motion which pro-
duced indicator diagrams very like those
taken from Mr. Hubbell's motion, but the
engines did not use less coal than those
having the link motion. All railroad men
are familiar with the repeated struggles
engaged in by George S. Strong to pro-
duce a valve motion that would be super-
ior to the link, but he failed. Ihen there
was the Stevens' valve motion used on
the Southern Pacific, which seemed ideal
in every respect, so far as making indi-
cator diagrams were concerned ; but the
influence of its inventor who was superin-
tendent of motive power of a great rail-
road system, could not make it displace the
the link.
In i88g William Wilson, superintendent
of machinery of the Chicago & Alton Rail-
road, made exhaustive trials of a radial
valve motion of his own design, which
had separate exhaust valves which could
be adjusted to open and close at the points
best calculated to effect saving of steam.
It was a splendidly designed valve motion
and thoroughly practicable as a valve op-
erating mechanism. The engine worked
admirably but those with the link motion
did the work more economically, a fact
which was reluctantly admitted by the
clever inventor of the motion.
People who have watched with sym-
pathy the attempts to improve the valve
motion of the locomotive are rather mys-
tified by the failures that have overtaken
all attempts to produce a motion which
would correct the admitted faults of the
link motion, and do the work on a smaller
volume of steam. As the cylinders of lo-
comotives are peculiarly susceptible to
chilling influences, with resulting exces-
sive cylinder condensation, it may be that
.the high compression may perform useful
functions in heating up the cylinde4" there-
by preventing loss of heat. As the loco-
motive is abnormally over-cylindered to
give it great starting power, it may be that
the excessive compression acts to auto-
matically reduce the cylinder capacity at
a time when a smaller cylinder is sufficient
November, lyoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
503
for the work to be done. In that case,
cutting off the heel of the indicator dia-
gram is gain instead of loss. It might
be argued that an earlier cut-off would re-
duce the capacity of the cylinder, but that
again would increase the evil of condensa-
tion, which is no imaginary source of heat
waste.
The history of attempts to improve the
link motion out of use, docs not inspire us
with hopes that the vanquisher is yet in
sight. It may be, however, and Mr. Hub-
bell has worked so intelligently and per-
sistently that his motion deserves to come
out the victor. Other successes have been
attained after years of failure and this
may be another case where intelligent per-
severance will be ultimately rewarded.
Stock Investing by Employes.
In these days when the diverse interests
of capital and labor threaten to prostrate
many industries the fact becomes accen-
tuated that some form of co-operation in
which the workers would be directly inter-
ested in keeping the wheels of industry
movingwouldconfer untold benefits upon
all concerned. The tendency being for all
productive operations to be carried out on
a stupendous scale, there is no opportunity
left for small capital to engage m manu-
facture unless it be done by co-operation
or by the purchase of stock in companies.
Co-operation is the proper manner for
workmen to secure interests in produc-
tion business, but there seems to be very
little tendency, more's the pity, toward
that form of self-help among the people
who take the lead in organizing the na-
tion's workmen. So far the work of these
leaders has been principally to cultivate
antagonism between capital and labor
with disastrous results to both sides.
A certain class of social economists are
constantly prating about the interest of
capital and labor being identical. The
only identical interest is that the one can-
not produce without the other, but in
other respects it is to the interest of each
to get all he can out of the other. That is
the way the case works in practical life.
If anything could be done to curtail this
grasping spirit it would greatly enhance
the comfort of millions of people.
Several attempts have been made of late
by capitalists to invite labor to sail in
the same boat as their employers, but no
great success has been achieved. One of
the most ambitious of these schemes was
made about a year ago by the United
States Steel Corporation inviting its em-
ployees to become stockholders in the
company and offering them inducements
which seemed highly advantageous. Spe-
cial incentives were offered to those who
"are charged with the responsibility of
managing and operating these vast com-
panies." The stock was offered at $82.50
a share, when during the same week the
offer was made it sold in the market as
high as $87 a share. Quite a number of
the employees of the company availed
ihemsclvcs of this offer and purchased the
water laden stock which shortly after-
ward displayed a decided tendency to drop
toward its natural level and it went down
to about $60 a share.
United States Steel Stock became badly
discredited and it looked as if the enter-
prising employees who bought of the stock
were likely to lose a large share of their
investment. At this juncture the finance
connnittee of the corporation stepped in
and guaranteed the value of the stock to
their employee purchasers. This was a
wise and sagacious action. "All's well
that ends well," may remark those stock-
holders, but to us it carries the lesson
for workmen of all kinds, "don't invest
in your employer's stock or in any
other."
There are some railroad companies that
have urged their employees to invest their
savings in the stock of the company, but
it is unwise policy. Very few railroad
presidents or the president of any other
corporation have assurance that the stock
they represent will not soon fall into other
hands or even into the hands of Wall
street gamblers, who may manipulate it
with as little consideration for small hold-
ers as if it were merely poker chips. If a
railroad magnate wishes to have the em-
ployees financially interested in the prop-
erty he ought to make some arrangement
by which they could purchase bonds even
if it were done by instalments. Bonds
are as safe as mortgages and their value
is little influenced by market gambling.
Those Who are holders of stock would be
very wise to convert their shares into
bonds as soon as convenient. The indi-
cations are that railroad stocks will fol-
low the industrials in the near future
and be worth less money than they are
to-day.
Inevitable and Preventable Heat
Losses.
One of the first discoveries usually
made by students of steam engin-
eering, is the fact that in transforming
the latent energy of coal into mechanical
work, the steam engine is an extremely
wasteful machine. Scientists have found
that a pound of good coal represents about
eleven millions of foot pounds of energy.
Very few steam engines develop one mil-
lion foot pounds of work for each pound
of coal used in the furnace, and engines
utilizing 10 per cent, of the coal energy
are considered thoroughly first class. This
percentage of waste appears enormous and
the novice readily concludes that mis-
management must be responsible for a
great portion of the wasted power. But
increase of knowledge brings a realizing
sense of the tremendous difficulties that
obstruct the way of radically increasing
the efficiency of the steam engine.
There have been a great many prime
motors invented for the purpose of con-
vertnig liie latent energy .if carbon into
mechanical work and several of them have
been capable of utilizing a greater pro-
portion than the steam engine of the heat
energy employed; but with the exception
ot the high class of gas engines none have
been so reliable for everyday work, and,
with all its shortcomings and defects, the
steam engine continues to be popular with
the greater part of power users who find
it important that their machinery be kept
running day by day without interruption.
In popular addresses we are continually
hearing the prediction reiterated that
science will yet lead the way in effecting
radical improvements upon the steam en-
gine. The past achievements of science
in this direction have been exceedingly
slender, and do not make the promises of
future deeds very encouraging. The prac-
tical men, on the other hand, have done
most toward developing and perfecting
the steam engine, and those whose opin-
ions regarding future progress are en-
titled to the highest consideration, be-
lieve that its limit of possible economy has
been practically reached.
Although a steam engine that converts
10 per cent, of the potentLI energy of
fuel into mechanical work may be re-
garded as a wasteful machine, it is not
wasteful when compared with the great
mass of engines running on railroad trains
and our mills, for very few of these uti-
lize more than 5 per cent, of the energy
stored in the coal used. The opportunity
for railroad engine improvers at the pres-
ent day appears to be in carrying out
methods which will bring up the perfor-
mance of the common five per cent, engine
toward the high-class engine that takes
ten per cent, dividend out of the coaL
The men who busy themselves with this
problem may safely leave to others the
work of improving what is now regarded
as the high-class engine. The great ave-
nue of waste with all steam engines is
the exhaust steam, and there is little prob-
ability that the loss of heat passing out
of this channel will ever be radically de-
creased while steam is employed as a
mode of tnotion.
There are, however, lines of economy
that may be worked on to advantage by
the users and designers of locomotives.
Numerous minor channels of waste could
be closed up by intelligent management,
and the result in saving would materially
increase the economy of the engine. Even
the most defective locomotive boilers in
use are more efficient in giving back
equivalents for the heat received, than
the best proportioned and best protected
cylinders ; but it is easier effecting im-
provements on the boiler than on the cyl-
inders. A good locomotive boiler accounts
for over 50 per cent, of the heat liberated
from the coal ; few cylinders cover 10
per cent of the steam entering them into
mechanical work. Still, with all of its
relative efficiency, there is much prerenta-
504
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November. 1903.
ble waste going on in boilers owing to
faults of design and to unskillful and
careless management. There is loss from
bad proportion of grate area and flue sur-
face, from the gases of combustion being
improperly mixed, from defective means
of admitting and restraining air supply,
from the gases being pa.sscd over the heat-
ing surfaces loo rapidly, from bad boiler
circulation, from water ■ being passed
through the dry pipe along with the steam
and from radiation of beat due to defec-
tive covering. The preventable losses in
the cylinders are due to too limited ex-
pansion caused in various ways, to back
frtrsure caused by faults of design and
lestricted exhaust opening, to attenuated
steam line at short cut-off, and excessive
compression resulting also from faulty de-
sign of the valve motion, and to conden-
salion caused by entrained wet steam and
imperfect covering. In spite of the high
steam pressure now so common, very wet
steam finds its way into most cylinders,
cuu.^ing most wasteful condensation that
could be greatly reduced by a steam super-
heater. It seems to us that some of the
super-heaters now on trial would effect
greater economy in the use of steam than
any improvement recently tried.
Pointing out errors of design and
causes of waste is, we admit, much easier
than the work of effecting remedies.
Wasteful practices and carelessness about
details are apt to creep into the best con-
ducted departments unless persistently
checked by supervising officials. The vig-
ilance and labor that produce the checks
must be ever awake, ever active, and
when this is the case their effects are
very apparent on the operating expenses.
Books Reviewed.
How to Measure Up Woodwork for
Buildings, by Owen B. Magnus. Pub-
lishers, the Industrial Publication Com-
pany, New York, 1903. Price, 50 cents.
This book of 79 pages, 5x7 ins., with
161 illustrations, is intended to aid the
estim.itor or mechanic in the measuring
up of woodwork for buildings from plans
or in the building itself. It gives full
and explicit directions for doing this
work, either where the building is en-
tirely composed of wood, or where the
measuring of the trim alone has to be
done, as in brick or stone buildings.
The concluding chapter gives some mis-
cellaneous information such as the
weight of moulding, weight of lumber,
weight of windows, weight of doors,
amount of nails required in carpenter
work, etc., etc.
The Hardwood Finisher. Compiled
and edited by F. T. Hodgson. Second
edition. Publishers, The Industrial Pub-
lication Company, New York, 1903.
Price, $1.00.
This book has 109 pages which are
about 7x5 ins. It contains directions
for finishing in natural colors and in
antique, mahogany, cherry, oak, syca-
more, birch, walnut, redwood, ash, pine
and other domestic woods. It gives
rules for filling, staining, varnishing,
polishing, dyeing, gilding and bronzmg.
In this, the second edition, there has
been added an illustrated treatise on
the preparation of wood work by the
joiner or cabinet maker for the finisher.
The book is divided into four chapters:
Hardwood finishing, preparing wood
work for the finisher, wood fillers and
wood filling; staining, finishing, var-
nishing and polishing. The chapters
are also divided into paragraphs with
opening words giving the subject of the
paragraph printed in large type, and
these paragraphs are all indexed at the
end of the book.
The Mechanical Engineer's Pocket Book,
by the late D. Kinnear Clark. Revised
by Mr. H. H. P. Powels. Publishers,
D. Van Nostrand Company, New York.
1903. Price, $3.00.
The fifth edition of this valuable me-
chanical engineer's pocketbook comes
from the press revised throughout and en-
larged. The book is too well known in
engineering circles to require an extensive
review. The copy before us, however,
contains, with the index, 692 pages. It is
neatly bound in red morocco and the
pages are about 6x3^ ins. and just about
I in. thick. The edges of the pages are
gilt and have rounded corners. It is a
handy book of reference for daily use in
engineering practice and contains all man-
ner of tables, formulas, rules and general
engineering data.
There is something curious about the
way that the people who regulate the
spelling of words make decisions. Ac-
cording to common sense the words
kerosene and gasolene ought to have
the last syllable spelled with i instead of
e, or with two e's instead of one. We
wonder if the pronunciation will change
to agree with the spelling, or if the spell-
ing will be adjusted to suit the pro-
nunciation. We notice that our British
friends spell the words as they are pro-
nounced.
Before the articles on "The Growth
of the Locomotive," by Angus Sinclair,
are published in book form the author
wishes to obtain representative locomo-
tives built during the decades 1850, i860
and 1870. Those of 1850 and i860 are
scarce. If any reader will favor us with
the loan of the picture of a locomotive
built during these d-ecades the favor will
be appreciated.
The edition of Blackall's Air-Brake
Catechism, which we have been selling
for $1.50, is exhausted and the new and
enlarged edition now for sale costs $2.00.
Please remember this.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED.
(68) F. B. II., Philadelphia, writes:
What would be the result if, by mistake,
the main driving wheels of an engine
should be turned end for end and the
eccentrics being keyed could not be sliift-
ed? I think tlie engine would move, but
B. says not. A. — You are right, but with
the lever in forward motion the engine
would run backward, if it was an in-
direct motion engine, which, we pre-
sume, is what you had in mind.
(69) A. D. P., Toronto, asks:
Can an engine with both eccentrics
broken on left side and the back up on
right side be put into condition to help
herself to terminal, light, without assist-
ance? A. — Yes; you have the same con-
dition here that exists in stationary en-
gines with one eccentric whose motion is
in one direction. Your lever would have
to remain in the corner of quadrant to
avoid damage to link and valve gear, and
your engine would be a poor steamer.
(70) R. O. H., Mason City, la,,
writes :
I was assisting an old valve setter while
running over the valves of an old engine
which had a lot of lost motion. When
the valve stem was traveling forward he
took hold of it and kept shoving it in the
same direction to take out the lost motion.
I think he should have shoved it the other
way, for, in doing as he did, a considerable
amount of lead was obtained, which he
claims an old engine will get, while I say
an old engine will lose lead. Which is
right? A. — An old engine will lose lead,
as lost motion develops ; you are right in
that; but the valve setter was right in the
way he took the lost motion out. He
placed the valve as nearly as possible
where it stood before the lost motion de-
veloped, and if he took all the lost mo-
tion out of the valve gear he would give
back the lost lead. If he did not intend
to take the lost motion out, he would
have to move the eccentric to regain the
lost lead.
(71) T. C. S., Durand, Mich., writes:
(l) Suppose you have a Standard type
engine, overhung springs, with a broken
equalizer post, on passenger train; what
is the quickest way to handle this break-
down, and what is a fair estimate of time
required for same? A. — About the only
thing you can do if the post itself is broken
is to block the boxes, which you can do
easily by running the wheels up on wood-
en wedges placed on the track. It is im-
possible to give you a close estimate of
the time required, because no two men
take exactly the same time to do a given
piece of work, and, besides, the operation
involved may be complicated by other
things.. If the breakage of the equaliz-
ing post occurred on the right side, the
reach rod might become jambed, in which
case you would have to disconnect the
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
505
roach rod from llie tumbling shaft arm,
before you could move up on the wooden
wedge.
(.2) Willi a Detroit, No. 3 C. hibricalor,
also Michigan lubricator choke plugs at
steam chest plug, with lubricator in op-
eration and engine working steam, is the
oil pipe from steam chest to lubricator at
this time filled with steam or is it
filled with water, and in either case
what influence would a bend or
pocket in the oil pipe have? A. — The
pipe from steam chest to lubricator
will be filled with steam and oil, some
condensation will take place in pipe be-
tween where it leaves the boiler jacket
and reaches the steam chest, a bend or
pocket in the pipe will have little or no
effect as the current in the pipe is flowing
toward the steam chest.
(72) C. P. C, St. Louis, writes:
I was greatly interested in your answer
to Question 61, of the September issue,
•on the expansion and contraction of air
under compression. Kindly answer the
following: We pump up a reservoir of
eight cubic feet to 75 lbs. gauge pressure.
The temperature of the air in the reser-
voir at the time the pump is stopped is
110° Fahrenheit. The temperature of the
reservoir and contained air is permitted
to fall to the surrounding atmospheric
temperature of 60° F. What loss in gauge
pressure have we suffered ; there being
absolutely no leakage? A. — You would
probably, in sucli a case, lose between 6
and 7 lbs. gauge pressure. In answering
this question we have assumed that the
temperatures you give are correct, though
we think air at 60° F. compressed to 75
lbs. gauge pressure would be hotter
than 110°. This kind of an experiment
is very difficult to perform, because it is
practically impossible to retain all the heat
due to compression, in the air during the
operation, and it is equally impossible to
abstract all the extra heat as the pressure
rises. The outside of the containing ves-
sel might be cooled to the required tem-
perature while the air near the center of
the drum remained hot. Good air com-
pressor practice gives a sort of happy
mean between the theoretical curves due
to what is called adiabatic and to isother-
mal compression. The first of these
words indicates that the heat of com-
pression does not pass away, and the
second indicates that it does pass
away as the compression proceeds.
Air heated expands 1/273 of its vol-
ume for every degree of temperature
(Centigrade) which it receives. The
equivalent of this fraction for the Fahren-
heit thermometer is 1/490. If you care to
follow up the subject further the book on
compressed air by Frank Richards is use-
iul.
We lose money and comfort, and even
temper sometimes, by not learning to be
■more careful. — David CoppcrHcld.
Break-Downs.
liV JOSKl'Il A. I).\KKK.
The object of this chapter is to give
the easiest and quickest way of making
temporary repairs to a disabled locomo-
tive with the few tools supplied and at
the engineman's command.
Some of the instructions given a de-
cade ago arc fast becoming obsolete,
as the frequent and fast trains on our
trunk lines of to-day demand the clear-
ing of the main line with as little delay
as possible to prevent a blockade. With
this object in view the writer who until
a few years ago was in the harness
himself for 20-odd years, will endeavor
to present the subject of break-downs as
plainly as possible, so as to make it
possible for the man of ordinary educa-
tion to understand.
In order not to confuse, let it be
understood that a locomotive consists
of two complete and independent en-
gines, so that in case of disablement of
one the other can still perform its work.
Much valuable time can be saved in
knowing how and just what parts to
disconnect in certain break-downs, and
this is where the up-to-date engineman
shows his value to his employer. A
good engineman will carefully inspect
his engine before starting on a trip,
whether pooled or regularly assigned,
to avoid accidents of this nature. With
the heavy power of to-day some of the
temporary repairs insisted upon in for-
mer years are abandoned to-day, and
many of the tools furnished engines for-
merly are removed from them now.
I. DISCONNECTING ONE SIDE.
Aim to do as little and as quickly
consistent with safety. Never remove
a main rod unless absolutely necessary.
Pinch-bars are of very little use to move
the large engines of to-day and a main
rod left up will, with a little thought,
.■iupplant the pinch-bar and do it more
effectively. In removing the forward
section of side rods on some makes of
ten-wheel, mogul or consolidations, care
must be exercised where blocking of
cross-head back is necessary. Very
often the crank pin will interfere with
the piston rod key in cross-head. When
this is the case cut off the key flush
with the cross-head or block the cross-
head forward.
2. BROKEN MAIN ROD.
Remove the broken parts, block cross-
head back to within one-half inch of
clearance to keep the cylinder packing
out of the counterbore. disconnect cyl-
inder cock rod on disabled side and
block cocks open. Shift valve in the
same direction as piston if a slide valve
or outside admission piston valve, and
in the opposite direction if an inside ad-
mission piston valve. An easy way to
remember and distinguish a direct from
an indirect motion is in the position of
the rocker arm. With the indirect, one
arm is above and the other below the
rocker box, with the direct both arms
are cither above ■ or below the rocker
box. In moving valve give it just enough
opening to show steam at the cylinder
cock which will take the prcsssurc off
of the blocking.
3. BROKEN SIDE ROD.
Remove the broken rod and the same
section opposite. If the break is on the
forward section of a ten-wheel or mogul
and the knuckle-pin on the rear section,
lake down all side rods. If the break is
on the knuckle-pin section, take down
only those sections. U the intermediate
section on a consolidation, take down
all sections, if on a forward or back sec-
tion take down only those sections.
4. BROKEN VALVE YOKE.
This is not so hard to locate as one
imagines. Generally the engineer in at-
tempting to locate the heavy blow
places the engine on the good side on
the dead center unintentionally, and is
then unable to move her either forward
or back. First inspect your eccentrics
and blades, and if found intact go to
the side on the quarter. A little thought
will tell you that if this side were not
disabled it would move the engine off
the center on the other side. If your
chest has a release valve, don't take up
the cover. Disconnect the valve stem
and take out release valve. You can
then shift the valve to cover steam ports
and also help your good side off the
dead center. When covering ports, in-
sert a plug in the release valve of suffi-
cient length to hold the valve central
from one end and with the valve-rod
from the other. Don't take down main
rod, you may want it to help you off
the center again. Block cylinder cocks
open on that side and with a very little
admission of steam through valve the
cylinder will get sufficient oi> to prevent
damage. The Vandalia Railway has a
record of a passenger engine making 86
miles this way and no damage to cyl-
inder.
5. BROKEN PISTON ROD.
If the broken rod has taken cylinder
head along with it, disconnect valve-rod
only and cover ports. Take in as much
of a train as you can.
C. BROKEN PISTON OR VALVE GL.\ND.
If this break happens near the stud,
place a large washer on either side of
the lug over the stud and tighten nuts
against them. With a broken valve
gland, use the clamp generally provided
to hold a disconnected valve central, and
bend the beak out of the way to clear
the valve-rod key. Where stud has
pulled out. changing end for end some-
times will answer. You can generally
find a nut around your engine that will
answer for this purpose. Sometimes a
5o6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
little canvas wrapped around the gland
and forced into the stuffing box will
hold.
7. BROKEN CYLINDER HEAD.
In most instances there is a heavy
leakage of steam around the head to
give warning, and if it is a forward head
it may be saved from total destruction.
The writer on several occasions of this
kind placed heavy blocking against the
head and with a screw jack placed
against the pilot timber, brought in his
train a distance of 100 miles without
any further mishap. With the back head
broken in such a manner as not to inter-
fere with the guide block it is generally
safe to run with the main rod up, but
if there is any liability to damage, take
down rod and cover steam ports.
8. BROKEN STEAM CHEST OR COVER.
When the break is not a bad one,
wedging between the chest and bolts is
sometimes successful, but where the
break is a bad one, remove the cover,
block the supply ports, which on mod-
ern engines are at each end of cylinder,
with blocking of sufificient thickness to
be held down by cover, disconnect valve
stem only, block the cylinder cocks open,
and proceed on one side. The same
method applies to a broken cover.
9. BROKEN RELEASE VALVE.
This does not imply that the valve is
entirely useless. Remove release valve
casing from chest and insert a wooden
plug in casing and screw back in. Bet-
ter still, if you have a spare washout plug
on your engine, remove the casing and
screw the plug in instead. A modern
engine should be supplied with such
emergency appliances and a modern en-
gineer will provide himself with such
appliances.
ID. BROKEN CRANK-PIN.
With a broken main crank-pin,
any class of engine, take down all side
rods and be sure that the crank-pin
on the forward wheel does not interfere
with the cross-head in blocking the lat-
ter. With the back crank-pin on a con-
solidation or a ten-wheel engine, pro-
ceed as with a broken side rod, see chap-
ter on side-rods, but if the crank-pin
of an intermediate, otherwise known as
driver No. 2, take- down all side-rods
and run in light with main rods up.
Remember that taking down one section
and not the other on the opposite side
is dangerous; there is nothing to pull
the wheel on the good side off the dead
center. In only one case is this per-
missible when the eccentrics are on the
first or leading, and the main rod on
the second or main drivers. In this
instance if the forward section with a
solid end breaks, the other side is left
up so as to control the valve motion on
the good side, but the valve gear on
the crippled side must be disconnected.
II. BROKEN CROSS-HEAD.
If the break is with a 4-bar guide or
a Laird guide with yoke, block ahead
and let niain rod rest in yoke; but the
butt end brass and strap must come
down, otherwise the rod would interfere
with main pin. If the cross-head is of
the alligator type and yoke secured near
middle of guide, block back and take
down main rod. It is always a good plan
to allow enough port opening in block-
ing valves central, to admit a little steam
against the piston in the direction you
are blocking. Remember also that an
outside admission valve is pushed in the
same direction as the piston and an in-
side admission in the opposite direction.
12. BROKEN ECCENTRICS, STRAPS AND
BLADES.
With a broken go-ahead eccentric or
blade take down the back-up also. If
the back-up is not disturbed the link
lifter must be taken down. With a
broken back-up eccentric, strap or
blade, the go-ahead need not come
down, but the engine must be run
with a full cut-ofT and no attempt
made to bring the lever back to
center of quadrant. The above sug-
gestions are only to be used where the
distance to a siding is short and you
want to clear the main line. At any
other time if you break one, take down
the other also and cover steam ports.
Don't take down main rod.
13. BROKEN GUIDE YOKE.
If a bad break, take, down main rod,
disconnect valve-stem and cover ports.
14. BROKEN ROCKER-BOX OR ARM.
With the bottom rocker arm broken
there is more or less danger of catching
the link or blade on the rocker-box
if the link motion is considerably worn.
Take no chances but take down both
eccentric straps and blades and cover
ports. If the top arm is broken, re-
move broken part and cover ports.
With a direct motion valve gear
remove transmitting bar and broken arm
and cover ports. By transmitting bar
is meant the rod that conveys the mo-
tion from the link to the rocker arm.
For a broken rocker-box or sheared
bolts, if no repairs are possible or no
bolts at hand of nearly the same diameter
as the old ones, take do.wn both eccentric
straps and secure the link to link lifter
and remove rocker-box if bolts are
sheared.
15. BROKEN^ LINK LIFTER.
Place the lever in quadrant at a point
where you can comfortably start your
train. Cut a block of wood to fit be-
tween the top of link block and link, also
one to fit between bottom of link block
and link. Fasten them securely. Block-
ing for the forward motion, never drop
the lever below the point of cut-oflf
selected, as the lifting arm on tumbling
shaft may interfere with link. You can
cut the lever back toward the cente,"
without danger and work steam ex-
pansively on the good side, but this will
give you two light and two heavy ex-
hausts. Don't attempt to reverse your
engine without first removing the block-
ing from below the link block and plac-
ing it on the top of the link block.
Gifts to Cornell University.
The president of Cornell University
announced recently that the Department
of Railway Engineering of Sibley Col-
lege had received two substantial gifts of
money for the erection of a laboratory
for that department. Mr. H. H. Vree-
land, president of the Interurban Street
Railway Company of New York, starts
the fund with $1,000, and Mr. M. N.
Forney, of New York, the well-known
consulting railway engineer, has also
promised a large gift. He expressed a
desire to equal Mr. Vreeland's contribu-
tion.
The plans drawn for a new hall of
experimental engineering, to be built in
the rear of Sibley College, provide for 1
locomotive laboratory adjoining the
present blacksmith's shop. The building
will cost between $10,000 and $15,000.
The Baldwin Locomotive Works has
already presented a complete locomo-
tive especially made for experimental
work and valued at $20,000, to be avail-
able as soon as the laboratory is built.
Contributions from several other rnen
of means are assured.
"The Canadian Pacific carries off the
honors for strange names among its
officials. Mr. Ham is the road's adver-
tising manager, with headquarters at
Montreal, and the city ticket office there
is in charge of Mr. Egg. Because of
their strange names, the two men be-
came fast friends, and if they chance to
be out of town, as they sometimes do,
they both report to Mr. Bacon, whose
chief clerk is Brown. A few days ago
Ham called on Egg at the latter's office.
While talking, the telephone rang. He
was asked if that was the Canadian Pa-
cific office. Before he answered as to
that, he said, 'Who do you want. Ham
or Egg?' 'Neither,' was the reply. 'I
want the Canadian Pacific ticket office.
I don't want any of your old ham or
eggs. Central, get that cheap restaurant
off this wire.' Both Ham and Egg are
now looking for that man." — Railway
and Slnffi"g World.
The editions of Conger's Air Brake
Cathechism that were sold for 75 cents
are all exhausted and an enlarged book
will be offered in place of the old one.
The new catechism will cost one dollar.
The new edition is so much of an im-
provement over the old one that the
small rise of price will cause no com-
plaint.
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
507
Air= Brake Department.
Air Pump Repairs.
It has been observed that considerable
trouble is now being had with air pumps
on trains going into high-speed brake
service. The trouble seems to be that
sufficient care has not been given to
properly repairing the air pump and put-
ting the air cylinder in proper condition.
When only the 70 pounds train line
pressure and 90 pound's main reservoir
■pressure were required, the pumps were
amply able to reach these figures, but
when the pressures have been raised to
1 10 pounds train line and 130 pounds
main reservoir line, the pump is unable
to reach the higher pressures. The lower
pressures the air pump can easily reach
with the piston packing of the air cylin-
<ier in fair condition, but when a consid-
erably higher pressure is demanded, this
condition of air cylinder packing, which
■ is sufficient for the low pressure, is not
sufficient for the high pressures, and
therefore fails. Most any pump can com-
press air to 50, 60 or 70 pounds pressure,
but each succeeding 10 pounds up to 150
is proportionately more difficult to com-
press. The whole matter summed up is
that the test of the air pump after ap-
parently good repairs have been made,
lias been sufficiently good to pass pumps
for low pressures, but it is not sufficiently
good for higher pressures.
A new test for higher pressures will
necessarily have to be made, after the
pump has been repaired, and that means
that better repairs will have to be made.
The old repairs were good enough for
the low pressures, but better repairs will
have to be made for the high pressures
■of to-day. This means that not only
must the packing rings in the piston be
renewed, but the cylinder must be re-
bored, too. Also, the rings must be
fitted new into the piston head grooves.
Air pressure will leak past the sides of
a ring that is poorly fitted to the sides
■of the groove as badly as it will past the
outside diameter of the ring and the
cylinder wall. A new ring fitted to an
•old cylinder only fits at mid-stroke posi-
tion, and is loose at the ends of the
stroke, where the greatest leakage past
the piston occurs and where more air
pressure is lost.
The repairs on the air end of the pump
must be better made for high speed brake
service than is now being done for 70
pounds train line pressure. This means
that packing rings must be renewed of-
tener and cylinders rebored more fre-
quently.
CONUUCTED BY I'. M. NliHIS.
The Air Brake Inspector.
As modern railroading progresses, and
longer trains arc being hauled by more
powerful locomotives, the position of gen-
eral air brake inspector on railroads be-
comes more important and of greater
consideration.
The main object sought in appointing
a general air brake inspector is to
achieve the highest possible efficiency in
air brake service. This efficiency will de-
pend very largely on the methods em-
ployed by the inspector and the directions
in which his energies are exerted to ac-
complish the desired results. It has been
the prevailing custom to use a car. or local
school plant, to instruct the men in the
various devices, the belief being that the
more a man knew about the structural
parts of the apparatus, the better would be
his road service. Later, it has been the be-
lief that the instruction should be confined
alone to school rooms, but should be ex-
tended to cover actual operative service
on the road as well. In accordance with
this belief a number of roads have made
secondary the inspector's work in the in-
struction car and placed him on the road,
installing air brake testing plants in the
various terminal yards, and riding with
the men. The instructor's efforts, there-
fore, have been directed more to the main-
tenance of the brakes and to their opera-
tion on the road. Results prove quite
conclusively that this course is a good
one ; for no crew can handle a long train
smoothly if the train pipes leak badly
and "kickers" get into the train. The
most skilled workman does not perform
a creditable job if he be supplied with
poor tools.
A prominent inspector recently made
remark that the preliminary training of a
man in air brake practice should be had
in the car, but that such training should
be dropped in due season and advance in-
struction be given him in actual practice
on the road, keeping in mind, meanwhile,
the important fact that to do good work
the air brakes must be creditably main-
tained.
Qraduated Release and Retaining Triple
Valves.
It seems that any one who nowadays
wishes to invent a new triple valve turns
his attention to either the graduated
release triple valve or a triple valve
containing a feature which retains the
brake cylinder pressure without the as-
sistance of a retaining valve. In the
first place, it is open to question whether
such a modified triple valve is necessary,
or even desirable for general service. It
has been very properly argued that a
triple valve which would graduate its re-
lease in the same manner that it grad-
uates its applications, would be a de-
sirable triple valve for an electric rail-
way service, and similar service of this
character. Upon second thought, how-
ever, it would seem doubtful whether
this is true.
Attention has been called to the fact
that some kind of triple valve that would
closely approach either the straight air
brake or vacuum brake in its operation-
would be better for electric railroad ser-
vice than the standard quick-action triple
valve, inasmuch that the braking power
could be .quickly varied by slightly in-
creasing or simply diminishing the brake
cylinder pressure as the requirements of
the stop and the engineer's judgment
would dictate. This is further argued
to doubtful advantage when it is said
that smoother stops can be obuined with
such a device than with a standard quick-
action automatic brake. While it is true
that some very smooth stops are possi-
ble with either the straight air brake or
the vacuum brake, still it is possible to
so abuse their operation that equally
rough stops may be had with them as
with the standard automatic brake im-
properly handled. The straight air brake
and vacuum brake are seldom, if ever,
operated ideally, so that the brake power
is greatest at the beginning of the stop
and eased off as the stop approaches its
finish. This is noticeably true when we
remember that with the vacuum brake
several light applications are made to
each stop. The first application is mam-
fested by an escape of steam at the ejec-
tor exhaust, and then shut off. Several
similar discharges of steam can be no-
ticed, and indicates that the brake is
being applied harder and harder. Ob-
servation of the engineer's action in the
cab will show that he very seldom, if
ever, releases a part of the brake power
obtained. He will begin with a light
application at the start, continuing with
additional applications to the finish, the
braking power growing heavier as the
speed of the train reduces. This same
applies to the straight air brake. It
can also be truthfully said that this
method of braking is entirely wrong, and
diametrically opposite to the proper
method.
The correct and most advantageous
way is to apply the brake fully at the
beginning of the stop, when the speed
5o8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 190J'.
of the train is highest, and have the
braking power reduce as the speed of
the train reduces. This is an ideal way
of braking, and is embraced in an emer-
gency application of the Westinghouse
high-speed brake. It would seem that
the nearest approach to this kind of an
ideal application could be had by the
ordinary quick-action automatic triple
valve, so modified that the full emer-
gency application at the start of the
stop could be released, and the exhaust
port of the triple valve so reduced or
modilied as to permit pressure to escape
slowly as the speed of the train came
down. If it became necessary to shut
off the exhaust and hold the braking
power a little longer, it could be done
by making a light reapplication of the
b"ake.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Release Cock in Auxiliary Reservoir or
Brake Cylinder.
I am much interested in a few remarks,
which in your September issue of Rail-
way AND Locomotive Engineering,
you make to a correspondent, P. E. M.,
Murray Bridge, So. Australia. Like
him I have heard many, in this country
at any rate, who would prefer the re-
lease valves in their old position, viz.,
on the brake cylinder, for the reason
that in their present position these cocks,
unless they are carefully worked, are apt
to cause delay.
Suppose, for instance, a train arrives
and stops at a station on a slightly fall-
ing gradient, with the brakes applied,
and say three vehicles have to be run
off it into a siding. The engine is un-
coupled and moves away from the train
and the shunter proceeds to release the
brakes on the three vehicles. Number
one brake is easily bled ofif. He next
goes to number two, and after giving
it a good sniff, proceeds to the third
vehicle, which he in turn releases only
to find that unless he has been careful
in reducing the pressure in the auxiliary
reservoirs, that the brakes on numbers
one and two are again set. In busy
stations where there is much hurry and
noise from engines, etc., it is difficult
at times to tell when the triples reverse
themselves, and so to stop pulling the
release cock. Thus I have heard many
say that they would rather have the old
arrangement as being more certain, if,
perhaps, a little longer in its action.
A case came under my notice the other
day. I failed to release the brakes on
two vehicles by opening the release cocks
on the auxiliary reservoirs, and the only
reason I can think of to account for it
is that the pressure in the train pip# had
all or nearly all gone. The triples were
new, and of the quick action pattern,
but working as ordinary triples by means
of the cock usual on British railways.
In this instance had the release cocks
been on the brake cylinders I would
have experienced no difficulty.
Hknry VV.m.kkr.
Barrow-in-Erighnd.
[In the instance cited, the better prac-
tice would have been to hold the three
cars with hand brakes after the stop had
been made and brakes released. If, how-
ever, that method is seriously incon-
venient, cautious handling of the re-
lease cock must be resorted to, care be-
ing taken to make short, sharp dis-
charges of pressure at the release cock
until the exhaust is hard at the triple
valve, or the brake cylinder piston is
seen to move inward. In the last case,
all air, of course, would have to be bled
from the auxiliary reservoir.' — Ed.]
Undue Release of Brakes.
In answer to the question No. 46 in
your isue of June regarding brakes com-
ing off after a 2 pounds reduction,
though the 7 pounds reduction held the
place in the train pipe by the auxiliaries.
recharging.
It makes an cnginenian look foolish
when working a heavy train, to come up
with a rusli after making an applica-
tion, and the blame to be put on him.
when it is not his fault, but tlie fault
of some of the triples going into re-
lease position when they ought not to
have done so, J. Hopkins.
Wellington Station, Neiv Zealand.
[We assume that the equalizing dis-
charge form of brake valve has been
used, and that the reductions have been
made in service position. In this event,
the answer given to question 46 is ap-
plicable. If, however, the service posi-
tion has been passed and emergency
position used, even slightly, and air
drawn direct from the train pipe instead
of through the medium of the equaliz-
ing piston, the current of air rushing
forward, set up in the train pipe by us-
ing the emergency position even slight-
ly, will tend to release brakes, favoring
these on the forward end of the train.
A service application, with the equaliz-
rt
1 1
/
"
N
■«■
^^^
>!
/
■7
\2
^
)
'^^■^>
-v->'\
1(
V
^
A
^
^
(
r-iei-
/ f '
<iple
^-S'a
*
^
H
J
sl
\_
1
■^
^
^
>^
'7
S ^
\
I-,
~\
i-\)
\
r
).
)
^■^ siK-'
y
(
)
H
M.
rt
\
^
^
feg
%»•
4>
^4^_)
r^
\
,-=^
^^
D
Li
'1.1
--J
■J
7^
&
0
i
V
j5
1
f^
s^
0
1
i'l
r 1
t' 1
Im
1^1
o\
8"
7'
0*
5-
4- 3
2'
i'
1
■ 2'
3- I
• 5
■ 0
■ ^
' 8
■ 9
", 1
O' 1
1' 1
. . I L.
2 13 ir 15 1
li'i
ri8- 1
Railway ^ Locomotiv* Engxntarmg
position of the steam heat, air-brake and signal pipe connections
AS indicated by replies to a letter sent out by the
M.C.B. ASS'N ASKING RAILROADS FOR THESE LOCATION.S.
brakes set on tlie first application, and
rotary valve on lap. I ask .any of the
enginemen on your side of the world
to give it a trial, as it is not any one
engine you get the results from over
here, but any engine you like to try.
If what I say is true, your answer to
the question can't be right, as all equali-
zation pistons can't be dirty, or have
foreign matter causing the piston to
close the port, or rotary valves leaking.
And if you make another 2 pounds
reduction, after the first 2 pounds, more
brakes will come off and others that
were off will go on. If brakes come
off with these light reductions on fairly
long trains when standing, what must
it be when braking into a station and
a nasty jar is felt through the train?
Sometimes the train parts couplings,
caused no doubt by triple valves going
into release position, charging up those
auxiliaries that have released their
brakes, and setting the other brakes
harder by the reduction that has taken
ing piston working so stiffly as to sud-
denly close the train pipe e.xhaust at the
brake valve, sets up a similar surge for-
ward with the same tendency to release
forward brakes. After observing and
possibly correcting the above referred
to irregularities, the condition of the
triple valves should be looked into.
Possibly insufficient attention is given to
cleaning and oiling. Triples working
stiffly, or having dirt between the grad-
uating valve and seat and slide valve seat
in poor condition would allow triples
to whistle off on a light reduction. — Ed.]
Mr. Thomas Renaud has been appoint-
er air-brake instructor for the Wiggin.5
Ferry Co.. which company embraces the
East St. Louis Connecting Railway and
St. Louis Transfer Railway, headquarters
being at St. Louis, Mo.
The 1903 Air Brake proceedings tell of
frozen train pipes. Send to us for a copy.
November, iyo3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
509
A Clever Design of (lauee.
These gauges, wliicli I claim to have
originated, and are illustrated herewith,
are two in number, and are used in cor-
recting the air valve lift in gVi in. and
II in. Westinghousc air pumps. In tlie
11 in. pump it may be necessary to
change the dimensions of the gauge
somewhat, but so long as the staff, B. of
the gauge is the required lift of air valve
longer than the width of the gauge, A.
this does not matter.
The smaller gauge is used in regulat-
ing the lift of the upper receiving or
discharge valves, and the same principle
is involv(,-d in this gauge as in the other,
TOP VIEW OP OAXIGES.
The gauge can be made in a variety
of ways. I have illustrated the form
which seemed to be the most simple to
make. As indicated by the drawings, the
gauge is made of two plates of steel. A,
riveted together so as to bring a pres-
sure on the staff, B, and prevent it from
being moved by accident.
gauge for some time past, and have had
excellent results.
M. H. Siikparh,
Foreman Air Pump Rcprv,
N. V. C. & H. K. R.
Ilcsl .Itbaiiy, \. V.
Jty. d i"Cu. f:«ff.
GAUGE REVERSED, GETTING LIFT OF
VALVE.
and it is used in a similar manner. The
chamber cap is removed, the gauge
placed on the cap, as shown in the draw-
ing, pressing the staff firmly down on
the valve stop. The gauge is then re-
moved, placed on the cylinder as shown
in the drawing, filing away the valve
until the head just touches the staff of
ADJUSTING THE GAUGE IN THE CAGE
CAVITY.
The larger of the two gauges is used
in regulating the lift of lower receiving
or discharge valve, and is described as
follows: The air valve cage, D, is re-
moved from the cylinder of the pump.
he gauge is inserted in the cavity from
which the cage was removed, as shown
in the drawing, and the staff of the
gauge pressed firmly against the valve
stop, bringing the body of the gauge
at the same time against the bottom
face of the cylinder. The gauge is then
removed and placed on the air valve
cage with the valve in position, the valve
filed off until the points of the gauge
resting on the flange of cage will per-
mit the head of the valve to just touch
the staff of the gauge, as shown in the
drawing. It will be found that the valve
has the required lift, 3-32 of an inch.
Thus it will be seen that the use of this
gauge does away with all measuring in
adjusting the lift of the air- valves.
ADJUSTING LIFT OF VALVE.
the gauge while the gauge is held firmly
against the face of the cylinder. Care
should be taken that the gauge is not
shifted after adjusting to chamber cap.
The small projection which is usually
found worn out on the valve stop should
be removed. The interference of this
ADJUSTING THE GAUGE.
projection is overcome in adjusting the
gauge, however, by having the end of
the staff hollowed out as shown.
This gauge does away with rule or
scale measuring and the possible errors
of such method. We have used the
A Queer Acting V 1-2 Inch Air Pump.
I have had an odd experience whh a
queer acting gVs inch air pump, which
I give herewith for the benefit of some-
one else who may possibly be caught as
I was.
A short time ago it was decided by our
officials to instal a battery of three 9'A
inch air pumps to supjily air for testing
repaired air-brake apparatus in the shop
and for testing air brakes on freight cars
on the repair track. These O'A 'nc*!
pumps were taken from the storeroom
and erected in the boiler room, all three
pumps being placed side by side, and
QUEER .\CTING
INCH PU.MP.
taking live steam from a 3 inch main
steam pipe.
The exhausts of the three pumps were
connected with a 4-inch exhaust pipe.
A throttle cock was placed in the steam
pipe of each pump, and stop cocks were
placed in discharge pipe leading from
each pump. When the steam was turned
on. No. I and No. 2 pumps started off
in a business like manner, but pump No.
3 made an up-stroke and finished as
though wedging against something and
could not be induced to make any fur-
ther movement. The steam was turned
off by closing the throttle cock and the
steam pipe disconnected at the pump,
but the stop cock in the exhaust pipe
was left open. Pump No. 3 then made
a complete stroke, very much to our
surprise, and continued to run very slow-
ly, but regularly.
Cutting a long story short, pump No.
3 was a left-hand side pump, and we
had it connected up wrong and was run-
ning with exhaust steam. By referring
to the opposite cut you well understand
our trouble. The exhaust pipe was con-
nected at A and live steam pipe at B,
the plugs C and D being left in. We
exchanged the plugs and connections.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
putting connection B where plug C is
shown and connection A where plug D
is shown, thus converting our left hand
9J4 inch pump to a right hand pump.
Amos Judd.
Boston, Mass.
Testing Air Cylinders of the New York
Duplex Pump.
There is now hardly any time or place
on a large road where air pumps are not
required to do about all they are capable
of doing to supply air at ordinary pres-
sure for the long trains hauled on levels,
and at much higher pressure for the
shorter ones handled on heavy grades,
and, in addition to supply air for the
numerous compressed air attachments to
be found upon the locomotive, and on
passenger cars, in the form of bell
ringers, air sanders, water raising sys-
tems, etc., as well as to supply the all
too numerous leaks to be found in the
train pipe and its connections.
For this reason the condition of an air
pump, especially the air end, should be
Iool<!'ed after carefully, and this end
should be frequently tested to ascertain
its condition, and if any parts are found
defective, to have necessary repairs
made.
For those who use the duplex air
pump, the following information will be
found helpful in locating defective air
valves, packing rings, etc.
Referring to the cut of the duplex
pump, valves 9 and 10 are the air inlet
valves for the low pressure, or larger,
air cylinder 4. If these valves leak, they
will allow the air that is being com-
pressed ahead of piston 32 to blow back
to th'' atmosphere. Hence, whenever
piston ^2 is moving toward either of
these valves and air is felt escaping to
the atmosphere from the one toward
which the piston is moving, it is an indi-
cation that that valve is leaking, and that
it should receive attention. It may be
noticed, too, that the piston will make a
quicker stroke toward the leaky air inlet
valve than toward the other that is tight.
It is possible for leakage to exist
around the upper receiving air valve seat
41, and also the lower receiving air valve
chamber 39, if these are loose; and this
should be borne in mind when testing
for leaky air receiving valves. In fact
it is always a good plan before com-
mencing the test of the air end of the
pump, to try all caps and pipe connec-
tions with a wrench to know that they
are tight, which, if they are, there will
be little likelihood of leakage around
and through them.
Air valves 9 and 10 being tight, or
made so, we should next test for back
leakage from the high pressure air cylin-
der 3, into cylinder 4. To do this satis-
factorily, the main reservoir should have
a pressure of at least 90 pounds in it,
because under working conditions the
air in the high pressure air cylinder must
be compressed to a pressure a little high-
er than the main reservoir pressure be-
fore any air will be driven past the d.s-
charging valves 13 and 14, and, there-
fore, it is at this pressure, if any back
leakage exists, that we can obtain a cor-
rect idea of its size and importance.
With the high pressure piston 31 mak-
ing its stroke, should there be any back
leakage through the intermediate air
valves ir or 12, their seats 40 or 42, or
around the threads on the upper end of
the valve chamber 39 around the upper
intermediate valve chamber 43, the air
thus leaking would accumulate in the
hausts, coupled with the failure of the
receiving valves to lift promptly as the
low pressure piston moves away from
them.
If there is any leakage through the
top and the bottom air cylinder gaskets
48 and 49. at the point where they form
a joint between the high and the low
pressure air cylinders, it will have the
same effect as back leakage through the
intermediate valves. However, when
these gaskets, properly annealed, are
applied and the heads firmly bolted down
upon them, there , will be no leakage
throu.gh them from one air cylinder to
the other.
t5B3;er«i<=^ERHOR>
NOTE.
Wlieft making repairs, please
note tbat lift of Air Valves 9,
'JO. 11. J3. 18 ana 14, aliomd b«
^1 of an Inob.
THE NEW YORK DUPLEX AIR PUMI'.
low pres5ure air cylinder, under or over
piston 32, as the case might be, depending
on whether the high pressure piston was
making the up or the down stroke, and
form a pressure there that would cause
piston 32 to start rapidly the moment
steam was admitted to its steam cylinder
2, and would cause the receiving valves
9 or 10 ncit to lift promptly.
Hence, the indication of back leakage
from the high pressure to the low pres-
sure cylinder is had in a quicker stroke
of the low pressure piston away from the
end in which the leakage exists, and it
may be eanily detected by noting the un-
even spacing between the pump ex-
The final discharge valves are 13 and
14. Should these valves leak, main res-
ervoir air would flow back into the high
pressure cylinder and would produce two
effects simultaneously, namely, piston 31
would make a comparatively quick stroke
away from the leaky final discharge valve
and the air inlet and intermediate valves
will not lift promptly, and if the back
leakage be considerable, not at all, to
admit air from the atmosphere to the
high pressure cylinder, when the high
pressure piston is making its stroke.
Another effect of back leakage from
the main reservoir to the high pressure
air cylinder will be noticed in the pound-
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
5"
ing of tlic low pressure piston as it ap-
proaches close to the end of its stroke,
which is toward the end that has the
leaky final discharge valve. An interme-
diate air valve that has too little lift will
also cause the low pressure piston to
pound as it approaches it.
Back leakage into the upper end of the
high pressure air cylinder may be easny
detected by opening the oil cups and
listening for the blow.
A little practice and careful observa-
tion will enable an engineman to detect
leaky valves, to locate them properly,
and hence, to report necessary repairs in-
telligently.
The lift of all air valves in the duplex
air cylinders should be 1-16 in., and it is
very important that the lift of the air
valves does not vary from this.
Sometimes the receiving valves 9 and
10 stick on their seats, and do not lift
when the air pistons commence their
stroke away from them.
When this happens it will be noticel
that the low pressure piston will make
a slow stroke away from the stuck valve
and a much quicker one toward it.
The condition of the packing rings in
the air pistons is a very important mat-
ter, and these rings should never be over-
looked when we are testing the air cylin-
ders.
If packing rings leak, much of the
air that is being compressed ahead of the
air pistons will leak past them to the
other side of the piston, ai:d will help to
fill that end of the cylinder from which
the piston is receding, thus preventing it
from drawing in as much free air as it
would if the rings were tight.
To test for leaky packing rings, it
should first be known that the air valves
do not leak and that they have the proper
lift, then with full main reservoir pres-
sure to pump against, run the pump at
a moderate rate of speed, say 30 double
strokes per minute, and notice whether
the suction at the air inlet valves is
good during the greater portion of the
stroke.
If the suction is weak and ceases alto-
gether after the air piston has moved but
a short distance on its stroke, it is pretty
■good evidence that the packing rings are
leaking considerably more than they
should.
LeaKy packing rings, air valves and
pump gaskets cause the pump to make
irregular strokes and to heat up rapidly,
and these defects will tend to cut down
its efficiency considerably.
In running the pump, the speed of the
piston is an important matter for con-
sideration. If the speed is very slow,
slight leakage past the packing rings
•counts for more on account of the
longer time the air has to blow by them,
while if the speed is very fast, the air
is compressed in the cylinder to a higher
pressure than it would be if the piston
speed was such that the air passages
could carry away the air as fast as the
piston compressed it. Between 30 and
60 strokes per minute, depending on
conditions, will be found a satisfactory
speed.
With too slow a piston speed, there is
loss, due to leakage past the packing
rings, and with too fast piston speed,
there is loss due to inability of the air
passages to deliver the air as fast as the
piston compresses it, and consequently
the pump heats, and loses in efficiency.
With well-fitting packing rings, smooth
air cylinders properly lubricated, air
valves having proper lift and rod packing
in good condition, and all joints and
pipe connections tight, the efficiency of
the pump will be kept at its highest;
and when this is done, there will not be
much cause for compla'nt from lack of
suflicient 'air to do the work required
satisfactorily, provided, of course, that
the air is used economically after the
pump once compresses it, and not wasted
through leakage and improper manipu-
lation of the brakes. J. P. Kelly.
Water town, N. Y.
ihc key to remain inert. The trouble
was ijrobably due to the first cause.
(82; W. B. E., Cincinnati, O., writes:
I noticed in the questions on air
brakes, where in number 66 J. C. M.
asks how to designate a leak on the
train line side or the reservoir side of
a triple valve I do not think you have
answered this question quite right. Now,
as you have answered it, if our man
had to operate the brakes and locate
defects, he could not get off of the
engine quick enough to tell the differ-
ence. As I test such leaks, I charge
the train up, and if I find a triple blow-
ing I usually tap the triple lightly. If
that will not stop the blow, I cut out
the car or engine, whichever it may
be, at the cutout cock on the branch
pipe, and if the brakes apply on this
car or engine, it is evident that we have
a leak on the train line side of the fiple.
If the brakes do not set, and all of the
air leaks out of the reservoir, we have
a leak on the slide valve side of the
triple. A. — This is also a good method,
and, under the circumstances cited, is
as efficient as the one prescribed.
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ON AIR-BRAKB SUBJECTS
(81) C. p. C, Harrisburg, Pa., writes:
Upon taking his engine at the round-
house, an engineer applied and released
his brake several times O. K., but sev-
eral minutes later he was amazed to
find that he could not apply his brakes
in either service or emergency positions
of the brake valve, and the gauge showed
full pressures, which were no lbs. train-
line and 130 lbs. main reservoir. In
fact, he could not get any air out of the
train pipe with the brake valve. This
question may sound ridiculous and seems
impossible, but the above statement is
absolutely true. Please explain what
the trouble was. A. — Inasmuch that he
was unable to get any air out of the
train line in either service or emergency
position of the brake valve, and the
gauge pointers showed no reduction, it
is evident that the rotary valve did not
move from some cause or other. Pos-
sibly the rotary valve and seat had been
worn away either through hard service
or excessive grinding, and the washer
on the top of the rotary key had be-
come so thin that the key did not fit
in the keyway in the top of the rotary
valve, thus permitting the key projection
to slip out at its groove, and allow the
valve handle and key to turn, without
turning the rotary valve. Again, it
might be possible that the key projec-
tion, or the slot into which it fits in the
top of the rotary valve had been broken
off, and prevented the turning of the ro-
tary valve. Still again, it might have
been that the stem of the key had
broken, thus permitting the handle to
turn, but allowing the rotary valve and
Latest Air Brake Book.
The eighteenth edition of the "Up-to-
date Air Brake Catechism," by Robert
H. Blackall, comes to us fresh from the
press in revised and enlarged form, con-
taining 300 pages of reading matter an^l
an unusally large number of illustrations.
The book is really up-to-date, having
been purged of obsolete matter, and re-
taining only sufficient on out-of-date de-
vices to make the history of the air
brake art complete. The various devices
are so carefully treated, their possible
disorders so clearly explained, and the
latest practices and tests recorded,
that a student assimilating the infor-
mation proffered, and combining it with
his every-day practical work will have
the satisfaction of knowing that he is
well up on air-brake work.
Accompanying this revised work are
two colored educational charts. The
first is on the modern high speed brake
and signal equipment used on passenger
engines, passenger tenders and passen-
ger cars. The other shows the standard
equipment for freight engines, tenders
and cars. These charts are especially
handsome, being over four feet in length
and printed in bright colors on a sub-
stantial linen paper. The book is cloth
bound, and the price is $2.00, including
the colored charts. The two charts may
be had alone for $1.00. Both on sale at
this office.
The 1903 proceedings of the Air Brake
Association treats fully on frozen train
pipes, their causes and methods of correc-
tion, containing report and discussion.
The books are bound in leather and
paper. 75 and 50 cents, respectively.
512
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
No\ ember, iyo,5.
Steam Turbines for Factory Driving.
The Eaton Cole & Burnham Company,
of Bridgeport, Conn., arc preparing plans
for a turbine plant which will furnish
power to their works located at Bridge-
port, Conn. Large extensions to the
present works are now under way, and
the entire plant will then be operated by
polyphase motors from the new power
station. A 400-kilowatt VVestinghouie
turbine luiit will be immediately installed
to provide additional power during the
construction work. It will temporarily be
installed in the present power house and
will operate under 200 pounds steam pres-
sure and 28 ins. vacuum without super-
heat. The unit will furnish three-phase
current at 440 volts. The installation is
in charge of Mr. Geo. Hooper, enginear.
No. II Broadway, New York.
Hallway S( Lueomutn-a Eitginetrin
.SANTA FE 3 10-2 RELIEF VALVE FOR
DRIFTING.
Tired Locomotives.
When a piece of superstition gets into
some people's minds, no force on the
earth or in the air above will drive them
back to common sense. The following
ancient gag is taken from a Milwaukee
paper and displays the ancient super-
stition that comes up periodically to
worry people who are naturally inter-
ested in locomotive matters even when
they express silliness:
"During the past few mornings the
Pioneer Limited on the Milwaukee road
from the West has been arriving in Mil-
waukee from forty minutes to an hour
late. These delays are said by railroad
men to be the result of the heavy trains
now being drawn, and also from the fact
that the company's locomotives have
nearly all been overworked during the
past summer and this fall. Unless a lo-
comotive has its regular lime to rest and
recuperate, it becomes unsteady and un-
certain, much like an overworked hor.sc
or man. The business on the road has
been so heavy in the past si.\ months
that more work has been recjuired of
locomotives than they are intended to do
or can stand and the result is trouble.
A number of newly built locomotiv-'s
for the road are expected to be received
within a week or two, when some of the
hard worked ones will be given more
vacations than they have had in months."
The first number of the seventh vol-
ume of the Book of the Royal Blue, that
for October, has just come to hand. The
first article is on the Louisiana Purchase
Exposition, and is devoted to the con-
sideration of Power. It is beautifully
illustrated with half-tone engraving.:.
The New Union Station at Washington,
D. C. is ilhHtratcd and described. Mr.
A petition in involuntary bankruptcy
against the New York Car Wheel Works,
of Buffalo, was filed in the United States
District Court, one day last month, the
petitioners being the Rochester Car Wheel
Works, of Rochester ; the Keystone Car
Wheel Company, of Pittsburg, and Tim-
othy J. Murphy, of New Jersey. The pe-
tition shows that the claims of the three
petitioners aggregate about $30,000. It is-
also set forth in the petition that the ag-
gregate amount of the liabilities of the
.Vew York Car Wheel Works is about
$800,000. Assets are said to be about $250,-
000. A movement was made recently to-
combine all these wheel makers in a trust,,
but it docs not seem to have exercised
much saving grace.
An increase in wages to 8.000 employee*
of the twenty car and locomotive repair
shops of the Chicago & Northwestern
Railway has been granted. The increasc-
SANTA KE ;-I0-2 SELF-ADJUSTING PISTDN-ROD PACKING
Riiitwiiy ^ Lueoiitoliv
BETWEEN CYLINDERS.
IL H. Bryne contributes an article on
Berkeley Springs, the Fountain of Youth.
The proposed B. & O. articulated freight
locomotive weighing with tender ni
working order, 415,000 lbs., is shown
in a line cut with specification and di-
mensions. Two historical articles con-
clude the intellectual menu. One is on
the town of Frederick, Md., the home of
Francis Scott Key, the writer of the
"Star Spangled Banner," which has re-
cently, by government order, become the
national anthem of the United States.
The other article, by R. M. Cheshire, is
on the Story of Bladensburg and the
Sacking of W^ashington. Any one desir-
ing to know how Key came to write the
words of our national anthem while war
was going on should send to the man-
ager of passenger traffic, B. & O., Cen-
tral Building, Baltimore, Md., and ask
for a copy of the October issue.
means an additional expense to the road
of $300,000 a year. The agreement recog-
nizes the union and grants an advance in
wages of from i to 2^ cents per hour.
The men are members of the Inter-
national Association of Car Workers of
.America.
The Rand Drill Company, of i.;8
Broadway, New York, have issued a
folder dealing with their "Imperial"
pneumatic tools. It explains, by half-
tones and by letter press the merits of
the various tools made. The "Imperial"
motor running at 3,000 revolutions per
minute; the "Imperial" piston air drill;
the "Imperial" air motor hoist; the "Im-
perial" breast and screw feed drill; "Im-
perial" air hammers, and the "Imperial"
air compressors. The folder contains
twelve pages and gives in compact form a
lot of information on air tools.
Nov'.Miibcr, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
5"3
Baldwin 2-10-2 for the Santa Fe.
The Atchison, Topcka & Santa Fc has
recently been buying very heavy freight
power from the Baldwin Locomotive
Works of Philadelphia in tlie shape of
some tandem compound 2-10-2 engines,
each of which weighs 287,240 lbs. Tlio
cylinders are 19 and 32x32 ins., and the
driving wheels, of which there are five
pair, measure 57 ins. With 225 lbs.
steam pressure, the calculated tractive
force which can be exerted on the level,
at slow speed, is about 62,730 lbs.
In this engine the main drivers arc the
only wheels without flanges. In the mat-
ter of equalizing, the main drivers, the
back intermediate, ancl the trailer arc,
with the rear carrying wheel, all equal-
ized together, and the forward inter-
mediate, the leader and the pony truck
are equalized together. The springs are
all overhung. The valves are actuated by
indirect motion in the usual way.
liild in place without internal bolts. This
is accomplished by means of a casing or
packing box in which the segmental sec-
tions of the packing arc held and kept
in contact with the piston rod by means
of suitable springs. The whole packing
box has a steam-tight bearing in the re-
cess between the two cylinder heads, but
is free to move on this bearing without
breaking the joint, thus accommodating
itself to any slight variation in the posi-
tion of the rod. A piston valve is used
and so arranged as to avoid all necessity
of crossed ports.
The steam pipe joint between the
steam chest and the cylinder saddle is
made with a stuffing box and gland in
order to give a certain amount of flexi-
bility and by its use a tight joint is se-
cured after tlie cylinder has been bolted
permanently to the saddle.
There is a relief valve inserted in
till' dry pipe, tlie stem of which .valve
The tender has a steel frame and the
tank, with its deep water bottom, cai>
contain 8,50a gallons, with correspond-
ing coal capacity. The total weight of
engine and tender is about 450,000 lbs.,
and the total wheel base of both taken
together is 66 ft.
A few of the principal dimensions arc
as follows:
CylindcTH-iyanfl 32 x .^2 ins.
Boiler— Type, waRoii top; di,T., 7**^ ins.; thickncHF^
of Khcetti, ^ and \i inn.; work'g preHf* , 225 lbs,
Fire box— Lenglli, i;>8in8; width, 78 in».; depth,
front, 8014 ins.: back. 781^ inn.: thick ofaherts,
sides, H in.; back, H in.; crown, >»in.; tube, /»
in.; water space, front. 4^ ins. ; sides, 5 ins. r
back, 4 ins.
Heating surface— Fire box. 210 fl<| ft. ; tubes. 4,586-
stj. ft.; tola], 4.7'y6 sc]. ft.; {(fate area 58.5 sq. ft.
Driving wheels— Dia., outside, 57 ins.; journals,
main, 11 x 12 ins.; others. 10 x 12 ins.
Wheel base— rigid, 19 ft. 9 ins.; total engine, 3.S ft.
1 1 ins. ; tctal enRine and tender, 66 ft.
Weight— on driving wheels, 234.580 lbs. ; on truck,
front, 23,420 lbs.; on truck, back, 29,240 lbs.:
total engine, 287,240 lbs.; total engine and
tender, about 4.SO.000 lbs.
VAUCLAIN TANDEM CO.MPOUND 2-10 1!, FOR THE SANTA FE.
A noticeable feature is the small
permanent crane placed on the smoke
box on each side. It is intended for use
in reinoving the forward or high pres-
sure cylinder. There is a tapped hole
in the cylinder which is so placed that
wdien the threaded eye-bolt of the crane
is screwed into it, the cylinder w-ill bal-
ance when swung by the crane.
The arrangement of the cylinder heads
and the connection between the high and
low pressure cylinders are such that they
are securely held in position without the
use of interior bolts. By removing the
external bolts, which hold the cylinders
together, the high pressure cylinder and
the front head of the low pressure cyl-
inder can be easily taken down, givin.?
free access to the piston and interior of
the low pressure cylinder, without re-
moving the guides, breaking the joints of
the back head, or interfering with the
steam chest valve.
A piston rod packing between the two
cylinders is so arranged that the parts
are confined between the two heads and
comes out through the top of the
smoke box about midway between tlie
sand box and the smoke stack. This
valve is for the purpose of admit-
ting air into the steam pipes in the smoKc
box, when the engine is drifting. The
boiler is of the wagon top type, and
measures 78^ ins. at the smoke box end.
There are 391 tubes 254 ins. diameter 20
ft. long, and these give a heating sur-
face of 4.586 sq. ft. When the amount
in the fire box is added to this it brings
the total heating surface up to 4,796 sq. .
ft. An idea of this area may be had by
saying that if the width of the regular
right of way of a single track railroad
between fences is 66 ft., then it would
require a strip of that width 72^^ ft.
long to equal the heating surface which
is stowed away in this boiler. The whis-
tle, as will be seen in the illustration, is
placed in a horizontal position, where
it is attached to the auxiliary dome,
otherwise it would be higher than stack
or headlight.
.\ new type of locomotive lubricator
has lately been put upon the market by
the Detroit Lubricator Company, of De-
troit, Mich. Considerable interest has
been manifested in it by railroad ofh-
cials and enginemen. The sight feed
feature of this new lubricator will prob-
ably help to make it popular with
those who have to use it in locomotive
service, as it consists of glass disks about
I in. thick, so that the danger of break-
age is practically removed. It has very
few joints, and thus the chances of leak-
age are considerably reduced, and it has,
perhaps, only a little more than half as
many parts as the regular type of lu-
bricators have. The manufacturers will
be pleased to send descriptive matter
concerning this lubricator to any one
who will write them for it.
It is reported that the Rogers Loco
motive Company have purchased con-
siderable property in Paterson, N. J.,
for the purpose of extending the works.
514
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
European Railway Doings.
The summer traffic on the British rail-
ways invariably stimulates the different
departments to do their best with com-
petitive traffic, and this year has proved
no exception, new engines for fast
service having been introduced on
most of the trunk roads leading out of
London. The keen running between the
Meliopolis and Scotland has been re-
sumed and both East and West Coast
routes are making best efforts by cutting
cut intermediate stops and offering quick
and luxurious equipment to their patrons.
The fast run to the West on the Great
We.=tern Railway in June with the 10.40
A. M. express from Paddington Terminus
with the Prince of Wales on board, open-
ed the ball so far as the holiday traffic
m that part of the country was concerned.
The train was hauled from London to
Plymouth by a four-coupled locomotive,
No. 3433, "City of Bath," having drivers
7oV4 ins. diam. and cylinders 18 ins. by 26
north shore of the River Thames, had,
until recently, but one type of four
coupled tank engine (4-4-2) for passenger
and freight service, but owing to the con-
siderable insrease in the latter, a new type
of locomotive has been introduced of
which a photograph is appended. Six are
at work and have cylinders inside the
frames and six coupled drivers (0-6-2).
The headquarters of the locomotive de-
partment of this road are at Plaistow, an
eastern suburb of London and the next
photograph shows the running shed at
that place.
A fast run was made on July 26 from
London to Brighton with the Pullman
Limited Express. This train is composed
entirely of Pullman cars and is timed to
run between the two cities in one hour.
On the occasion named it performed the
journey in 48^^ (forty-eight and a half)
minutes. The locomotive was No. 70,
"Holyrood," which has drivers 81 ins.
diam. and cylinders 19 ins. by 26 ins.
Western Company also provided some cars
built in Dublin.
In Russia the railways of the South
have been completely stopped by strikes
among the employees, the chief centers of
disturbance have been Kieff and Baku,
the oil producing city. The views are from
the camera of a gentleman who has visited
those parts. At Kharkoff, the headquart-
ers of the Kursk and Sebastopol systeiJ
of the State Railways are located. The
miserable lot of the Russian worker is no
doubt answerable for the troubles, at the
same time the amount actually earned by
the individual is but a fraction of that se-
cured by his British or American breth-
ren. It takes six men in Russia to do
one man's work calculated from the Eng-
lish standpoint, and as for holidays.
Saints' days, and "Don't-do-any-work
days," the loss of time is deplorable.
The terrible accident on the Metropol-
itan Railway in Paris has struck conster-
nation among the "tube" makers. The
PASSENGER 4-6-0 ENGINE ON THE GLASGOW Jt SOUTH WESTERN.
ins. The photograph reproduced shows
the "flyer" ready for the road. The 24314
miles from Paddington (London, W.) to
North Road (Plymouth) were covered in
.233^^ minutes, jfiVi minutes ahead of
schedule. The engine ilustrated is one
of a very numerous class which is being
■continually added to, but the latest sent
out from the Swindon shops has a much
larger boiler, 66ys in. diam.; the railway
people having fallen in line with others
and admitted that a large boiler is essen-
tial for fast running.
The opening of a new direct line cuts
the distance by the G. W. R. between Lon-
-don and Bristol to 117 miles and the fast-
est trains are timed to cover this in 128
minutes. The rival road to the West, the
London & South Western Railway, has
put on some larger engines and quickened
up some of the best trains. The photo-
graph of 395 has water tubes across the
fire box, arranged on the patented plan of
•the chief of motive power, Mr. D. Drum-
mond.
The London, Tilbury & Southend Rail-
way, a road running parallel with the
In Scotland the Glasgow & South
Western Railway has put into service
some ten wheelers (4-6-0), of which the
following are the chief dimensions:
Cylinders, 20x26 ins.; H. S. of boiler,
1,852 sq. ft.; grate area, 24^ sq. ft.;
drivers, diam., 78 ins.; working pressure,
180 lbs. per sq. in.
These engines haul the Midland Scotch
trains between Carlisle and Glasgow.
The rush to the North sets in at the be-
ginning of August, and the distributing
centers of Edinboro', Glasgow, Perth and
Aberdeen are besieged with tourists. The
Waverley Station at Edinboro' is one of
the largest in Europe and has lately been
completed by the construction of a very
fine hotel fronting on Princess street at
.\berdcen, the Granite City, the final cut-
ting up of the trains with passengers for
the Highlands takes place here.
The visit of the King and Queen to Ire-
land required the provision of a handsome
special train which was built by the Irish
Great Northern Company at their Dun-
dalk shops, and which is shown in the
photograph herewith. The Midland Great
section on which the mishap occurred is
the last opened and newest. It appears
clear that if the motorman of the first de-
fective motor had obeyed his , printed in-
structions, no collision would have hap-
pened, and no catastrophe would have re-
sulted. The uncontrollable excitement of
the French people seems to have added
the greater number of victims.
The Commonwealth Steel Company
The Works of the Commonwealth Steel
Company are situated at Granite City,
III., close to the city of St. Louis, Mo.
There are at present on the pay rolls
about 1,200 men, and the output of the
plant is 3,000 tons of steel castings a
month. These are almost exclusively
railroad castings, and include some small
locomotive steel frame castings for the
Davenport Machine Works, of Daven-
port, la. The Commonwealth now makes
practically all the steel castings used by
the Santa Fe Railroad.
Among its products regularly turned
out may be mentioned the Commonwealth
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
S>5
Truck, which combines the M. C. B.
standard arch bars with improved bolster
and column steel castings. Their swing
truck is composed of the ordinary dia-
mond side frame, combined with the
Commonwealth bolster end casting and
swinging spring scat. The Conimonwealtti
Chicago Great Western for 700 cars ; St.
Joe & Grand Island for 250 cars ; Inter-
borough Rapid Transit for 350 cars ; Law-
son D. C, S cars. Standard truck and
body bolsters: C, B. & Q. for 2,250 cars;
Mexican Central for 1,100 cars; Atlantic
Coast Line. 400 cars; Mexican National
KOVAI, TR.\1N ON GRKAT NOKTIIICKN KAII.W.W.
Steel truck bolster has the metal distribu-
ted so as to withstand all the shocks in-
cident to severe service. In it the tension
and compression members are made as
for 500 cars ; Bellington & Beaver Creek
for 300 cars ; Union Pacific for 100 cars ;
Coal Blast for 100 cars; Cudahy Packing
Co. for 100 cars; Stewart-Peck Sand Co.
LONDON AND SOUTH COAST EXPRESS ENGINE WITH DRUMMOND BOILER.
nearly flat as moulding will permit and
are reinforced by vertical ribs to provide
against shear loads and buckling. Their
body bolster has its top member bifurcat-
ed to increase its bearing surface and
transverse stability without increase of
weight. The bottom or compression
member is of inverted T-section which
provides for both compression and shear
loads. The separable body bolster is de-
signed to T3ermit of the removal of con-
tinuous draw timbers, without the neces-
sity of removing their attaching bolts. By
removing the center plate and the nuts
from the draw timber bolts, the draw
timbers may be removed and replaced
while car is under load.
For the past year the following orders
have been booked : Separable body
bolsters, Missouri Pacific for S.300 cars ;
by D. & R, G. for 750 cars; Wabash for
1.500 cars; by Mexican National for 500
cars; by New i'ork Central for 500 cars;
by Santa Fe for 1,200 cars; for National
Coal Dump Co. for 5 cars. Special
trucks on the following lines as follows :
for 10 cars; K. C. Refrig. Car Co. for 20
cars; New York Central for 250 cars;
Grand Trunk for 25 cars; Jacob Dold P.
Co.. 5 cars; M., K. & T., 1,100 cars; C.
Hconomy of the Qas Engine.
Ill a paper on Internal Combustion En-
gine in Railway Service, Mr. R. P. C.
Sanderson, S.M.P., Seaboard Air Line,
says :
"Had the internal combustion engine
been invented before the steam engine, it
IS reasonably certain now that the latter
would never have been developed and
assumed the important standing in the in-
dustrial accomplishment that it has to-
day, but the internal combustion engine
would be in its place, doing its work and
very much more efficient than it is to-
day.
" I'he mechanical genius of this country
and Europe has for years been striving
with really wonderful results to improve
the efficiency of the steam engine, and
when we compare the high pressure,
quadruple expansion steam engines with
surface condensers of to-day with the
long stroke, low pressure single expan-
sion engines of fifty years ago, the co-
efficient of efficiency tells the story of
the progress made during that interval
of time in perfecting the steam engine
and boiler,
"But, apart from the perfection of work-
manship and design of the boiler and the
skill in making the engine develop the
greatest amount of power with the least
amount of steam, there are inherent losses
in the process of converting the energy
of coal or oil into power at the crank,
which can never be eliminated in the
>team engine and boiler. No boiler can be
made which will absorb all the heat which
can be given by the coal. There is a loss
in the boiler due to the evaporation of
water into steam and other losses with
which we are all familiar. The process
itself is an extravagant and wasteful one.
"To illustrate this, if we take an en-
gine of reasonable efficiency in ordinary
service (I do not now refer to the high-
est type of multiple expansion or condens-
ing engines), with a reasonably good
boiler, we cannot expect to get a brake
LONDON, BRIGHTON .4ND SOUTH COAST
R. I. & P., 10 tenders; C, N. O. & T. P.
for 2 tenders; E. & T. H., 137 cars; Coal
& Coke Co., 400 cars ; Lehigh Coal &
Coke Co., 20 cars. This is considered a
splendid record for the first year's busi-
ness of a new company, and it is all the
more gratifying as the shops are now
working full time.
EXPRESS ENGINE.
horse power for much less than five or
six pounds of coal per horse power per
hour.
"In the present imperfect condition of
the internal combustion engine there is no
difficulty in getting a brake horse power
for one pound of coal per hour from pro-
ducer gas, where nothing is wasted but
5i6
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
the ashes, and, of course, some heat in
the producer itself necessarily, due to the
change of the carbon from its fixed form
into that of fuel gas."
One Way of Measuring Horse Power.
In the CDursc of a speech made at a
social meeting of the Northwestern Rail-
way Club Professor Flather said :
"To succeed in railway work one must
learn the value of thoroughness and hard
work. It has no shifts. It has been said
by-product put inside of the boiler. A
young man standing on the bank had
watched these proceedings very interest-
edly,, and when he finally saw this manure
going inside of the boilers he said: 'Well.
I never understood before how it was
ihey measured the horse power of a
boiler, but now I know.' "
All automatic bell ringer on an engine
is a good thing for several reasons.
With it in working order the bell is
have good lasting qualities and can be
replaced in a few minutes by either of
the engine crew. The valve gear is ar-
ranged so as to prevent any jumping of
the piston while the bell is making its
stroke. It is a good reliable ringer and
when it is doing its work continuously
you can go into court, if necessary, and
testify surely that the bell was ringing.
C. M. Hammett, Troy, N. Y., is the man
to write to if you arc interested in bell
ringers.
The American Railway Engineering
and Maintenance of Way Association has
issued a pamphlet which contains
specifications for Portland and Natural
Cements adopted 1903. The pamphlet
also contains the specifications for con-
crete, submitted by the Committee on
Masonry. Price, 10 cents. 1562 Monad-
nock Building, Chicago.
J... j.:B*<Al!; St,U5C0.HS 01 N E ER I N 0
LONDON, TILBURY AND SOUTHEND SUBURBAN ENGINE.
that success is made up of about 30 per
cent, of knowledge, personal experience,
skill and education and 70 per cent, of
hard work. And so it is in the railway
service, it isn't the shifts that make. suc-
cess, but it is the hard work that every
one who attains to the higher positions
must accomplish. To-day we have great
opportunities given to the engineering
student. Our colleges, our technical
schools, our laboratories, our mental train-
ing schools are so numerous throughout
this great country in which we live, thai
almost every boy is familiar with the gen-
eral principles of mechanics, and knows
what horse power is and knows, fre-
quently, the general principles of the dy-
namo and of the steam engine. It was
not so formerly. Not a great many years
ago the matter of horse power was a very
intricate subject. I recall a story in which
it is related how the early steamboat boil-
ers had to be filled with some extran-
eous material in order to allow them to
carry steam properly. Sometimes to-day
we find engineers putting bran in boilers
in order to close the seams, and in early
days this was also appreciated ; it was
necessary to put in some extraneous ma-
terial for the same purpose. One time a
steamboat had been built on the Hudson,
had been finished and equipped with its
machinery and the boilers were ready to
fire. At the last moment a two-horse
team drove up with a by-product of a
livery stable and dumped it on board the
boat : the man-hole was removed and the
rung continuously, so that when between
stations there is no road crossing but
hears the bell. The fireman's attention
is not distracted looking after the bell
The fourth index of the technical press
has corne to hand. It is four times the
size of the first issue. The relerences are
in English, French and German. The
principal articles which are of general in-
terest, taken from the technical journals
of the world, are catalogued under appro-
priate heads. The book is published by
the Association de la Presse Technique,
20 Rue de la Chancellerie, Brussels, Bel-
gium.
The Lincoln & Williams Co., Taunton,
Mass., successors to the Lincoln &
Wood Co., have purchased the large
GREAT WESTERN HEAVY EXPRESS ENGINE.
and the engineer need not worry, the
ringer just takes the responsibility off
their shoulders. An exceedingly good
ringer which knows how to keep the
bell busy is the Sansom bell ringer. It
is operated by compressed air and it
has its valve motion outside the cylinder,
with a plug valve held in place by a
spring and the stroke of the bell can
be adjusted by nuts on the valve rod.
The piston has a leather packing ring
and a leather cup on the bottom, which
factory building formerly occupied by
the Atlas Tack Corporation, and will
continue in it the manufacture of twist
drills. The new concern has available
more than 30,000 feet of floor space, and
will make extensive improvements in
their property. The plant will be newly
equipped with up-to-date appliances.
We must trust and hope, and neither
doubt ourselves, nor doubt the good in
one another. — Chimes.
Novfinber, lyo.i
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVF. ENGINEERING
517
Signals and Signaling.
IIY GEUlUil: a. IIDUGINS.
Historical Retrospect.
Wlicn thai lacitiini yet kindly old man,
■whom Dickens humorously called Bar-
box Brothers, took a walk for the pur-
po.se of seeing Mugby Junction by day-
light, he naturally turned to the railways
— "But there were so many lines. Gat-
ing down upon them from a bridge at
the JuiK-tion, it was as if the concentrat-
ing Companies formed a great Industrial
Exhibition of the works of extraordinary
ground spiders that spun iron. And then
so many of the lines went such wonder-
ful ways, so crossing and curving among
one another, that the eye lost them.
.\nd then some of them appeared to
start with the fixed intention of going
live hundred miles, and all of a sudden
gave it up at an insignificent barrier, or
turned off into a workshop, * * *
there was no beginning, middle, or end.
to the bewilderment."
The picture here given and in what
ANCIENT SEMAPHORES.
follows, of the intricacy of an interlock-
ing plant such as Rugby Junction, must
have appeared to a layman, even in the
■days of Charles Dickens, is not over-
drawn in the least. It is only when the
■whole wonderful system of block signal-
ing and interlocking, complete as we
know it to-day, is analyzed, that it is
found to be not the work of one man
■or of one time, but to be the result of a
slow growth or evolution from very small
beginnings indeed.
The art of signaling and the use of
semaphores vis.s known and practised
long before railroads had any existence.
The word semaphore, from the Greek
scma, a sign, and phero, I bear, means
simply "sign bearer," and as early as
1749 the French made and used them
for military purposes. In 1750 they were
introduced into England and were used
by the Board of .Admiralty in London
to communicate with seaport towns.
These semaphores were mounted on tow-
•ers, built at intervals of from five to ten
miles on commanding sites. The earlier
forms had six shutters arranged in two
frames on top of each tower and by the
■operating of these flat movable pieces of
■wood, in various combinations, sixty-
three definite signals could be given. In
1816 a mast with two arms was substi-
tuted, and this was practically the fore-
runner, in form at least, of the now well-
known railway semaphore signal. The
l;ist message which passed over this
crude semaphore system between Lon-'
don and Portsmouth was sent on 31st
December, 1847, after which the electric
telegraph made its appearance and took
the field.
The seni;i|)liore, thus displaced liy tho
more rapid and more certain means ot
comnuniication. was nevertheless destined
to appear again and to take an accepted
place in what may be called its own
legitimate sphere — that is the giving of
a certain definite piece of information in
a most unmistakable way. The semaphore
appe-jrs to have been one of those con-
trivances, which Nature, as it were, sug-
gested to man. What is more natural
than the erect body and the arms ou:-
stretched across the path, when it is de-
sired to stop any living object which is
approaching? The semaphore is but a
man of wood or iron with the sole abil-
ity to raise or lower his arms, and actu-
ated by sonie outside intelligence, as-
sumes the "stop" position with out-
stretched arm, as naturally as if the imi-
tative action had been handed down frbm
father to son. In fact whatever may be
said as to what ought to be the position
of a signal showing "danger," the sema-
phore has come by its attitude, honestly
and antidates all other forms or posi-
tions.
In 18,^0. when the Liverpool and Man-
chester Railway was opened, the signal-
ing of trains was carried out by means of
a flag held in the hand of the pointsman
in day time, or a lamp in his hand at
night. The general instructions of the
Great Western Railway issued in 1865
shows the "police switchman" of that
day clad in the regulation swallow-tail
coat of the period and the tall hat which
was the ancient form of our modern
"stove pipe."
Four years later, stout posts were set
up at convenient points, on which flags
or lamps were placed by the pointsm.en
to indicate the position of the rails at
switches, and this innovation marks the
first step in the direction of establishing
fi.xed signals on a railroad.
In 1837, the opening of the Grand
Junction Railway, saw the introduction
of station signals. These were practi-
cally an early form of the now familiar
switch target and light, but were then
used to indicate whether an approaching
train must stop at the station or go on.
The edge of the disc or a white light
indicating "go on," and the face of the
disc displayed or a red light, indicating
"stop." A very ingenious form of disc
signal, invented about 1840. was used on
the London and South- Western, practi-
cally as a distant signal as it stood out-
side the yard. .A disc, rotated about its
center, was made with one-half only being
solid: the other half being open, with a
bar across the clear space. The disc ■was
turned by a cord, passing in a groove
around its circumference. When the
solid or blocked portion was turned to
the right, it indicated that the line of
rails branching to the right was blocked,
and the left-hand line was clear and vice
versa. When the disc was placed so that
the blocked portion of the disc was on
top. the indication given was that both
main track and siding were blocked.
About 1842 the familiar semaphore sig-
nal made its appearance in railway work,
Caution
TO GO SLOWLY
is shown by
holding the
RIGHT ARM
above the
head, thus —
or by a
GREEN FLAG.
— » —
Pa.je :il,
" General InstruclioDS
(lass).
)'OLICE-S^VITCHMAX, G. W R.
Keprodiiced from T/iir Railway Magazinf.
introduced by Mr. C. H. Gregory. Three
positions of the arms being possible; the
horizontal — danger; the vertical — go on;
and the angle of 45° — slow speed; the
semaphore easily displaced the two-posi-
tion disc. Four years later, the idea of
working a signal at a distance, dawned
on a pointsman who had two semaphores
placed some distance apart. He rigged
up two levers near his cabin, and at-
taching wires to the lever of the signals,
and improvising suitable counterweights,
he succeeded in performing his duty
without having constantly to walk to and
fro.
The year 1843 saw what may be called
the birth of the interlocking idea. The
contrivance was, of course, very crude,
and its scope of operation limited, but it
embodied the principle which makes in-
terlocking signals trustworthy, and this
is, that with it conflicting indications can-
518
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
not be given at the same time. The
mechanism for operating was so ar-
ranged at a junction that it was impossi-
ble for a signahnan to lower the sema-
phore governing the branch line while
the main line signal stood at "clear," and
when the branch was "clear" the main
line had to show "stop."
In 1846 the practice of grouping the
levers in one or more cabins, for work-
ing adjacent signals, was adopted on sev-
eral roads, though at this time there was
no attempt made to lock the rails by the
signal mechanism, and the idea of pro-
viding that no false indication could be
given, had not yet been conceived. Ten
years later Mr. John Saxby made the
first apparatus in which the concentra-
tion of all the signal levers at a station,
into one tower and their interlocking
was successfully carried out. This was
done at a junction in London called the
time interval, but are always separated
by a certain distance or space, and that is
the block system in essence.
In 1839 Cooke and Wheatstone in-
duced the Great Western to use their
newly invented electric needle instru-
ment, to telegraph the arrival and de-
parture of trains between Padington,
Dayton and Hanwell. The block sys-
tem idea was here carried out as under
this arrangement, for unless "arrived"
was telegraphed concerning any train on
the line, from one of the stations, the fol-
lowing train was held. The first practical
application of the block system was in
1844, when the Great Eastern Railway
divided its line between Norwich and
Yarmouth into five sections. The elec-
tric instrument here employed to trans-
mit signals was one having five dials,
each bearing the name of one of the five
stations along the line. Each dial had a
PKOB.'V.BLE EVOLfTION OF THE .SEMAPHORE.
Bricklayers' Arms, but in 1859 Mr. Austii
Chambers installed the first interlocking
plant worthy of the namcf on the Lon-
don and North-Western Railway.
While the interlocking principle as ap-
plied to railway signals was being gradu-
ally worked out, the block signal idea
was, by the introduction of electricity,
also made a factor in railway opera-
tion. In 1842 a pamphlet was issued by
Sir William Cook, in which he advo-
cated the regulation of traffic on a single
track by dividing the line into sections or
blocks. The rule laid down was that
when a train entered a block no other
train should be permitted to enter that
block until the first train had passed out
of it, and until that section of the line
had been signaled "clear" to the point
of entrance of the block. By this method
trains are kept apart, not by an uncertain
needle which could be deflected to the
right or left, and so made to indicate by
pomting to the designating words, the
presence of an "up" or a "down" train
in any given block. Thus all the stations
were informed of the movement of
trains, though each operator manipulated
only the needle belonging to the block
for which he was responsible at the time.
Mr. C. V. Walker, the telegraph en-
gineer of the South-Eastern Railway, in-
troduced in 1851 a system of block sig-
naling in which a bell struck by a ham-
mer gave an audible signal. This system
worked exceedingly well, though it wa.s
faulty in a very important point. Nearly
all the other forms and methods of early
electric block signal instruments employ-
ed a bell as an adjunct to the visible
signal, the bell being designed simply
to attract the operator's attention. The
Walker system depended entirely upon
the strokes on the bell, and of course any
signal so given was not permanent.
About 1854 Mr. Edwin Clark devised
a system which was far less costly to
operate than the five-dial instruments of
the Great Eastern Railway. The ap-
paratus used by Clark was the "double
needle," which also had an alarm bell
with which to attract the operator's at-
tention. The London and North-Western
used this system. Each block had its
own dial, so that each station was
equipped with an instrument with two
dials, one for the block north and one
for the block south. When the handle
was moved to the right the needle point-
ed to "train on line," and when moved
to the left, it pointed to "line clear."
The handle could be pegged in either
position, so that the indication remained
fixed until altered by the operator. The
lower end of the needle, indicated, by its
vertical position, when the current was
interrupted, "Line Blocked" or "Instru-
ment out of order." A small wire form-
ing part of the circuit was carried down
every alternate post in the form of a loop,
so that the guard of a disabled train
could produce the "Line Blocked" indi-
cation by cutting the loop wire on the
nearest telegraph post. The Great
Northern adopted the block system in this
year, 1854, but the instrument used on
that line did not permit the handles to
be pegged over to right or left as in
Clark's device.
During 1852 the first attempt at auto-
matic block signaling was made. Mr.
Tyer induced the Brighton and South-
Eastern lines to try it. The instrument
installed was provided with indicators,
and these were actuated by the move-
ment of a treadle, placed close to the
rail, and which was depressed by th^
wheels of a passing train. The train it-
self thus automatically sent an indication
to the station next ahead, but in 1854
the automatic feature was abandoned, and
the work of transmitting the signal was
again placed in the hands of an operator.
In all the instruments described, it
must be remembered that operators re-
ceived and sent the signals. On receiv-
ing an indication, from a distant station,
it was the duty of the operator to raise
or lower the semaphore arm, and so con-
vey the desired intelligence to the men
on the engine. There was no safeguard
against the operator's failure to display
the corresponding signal to the indica-
tion he had received, and in abandoning
the crude automatic system the Brighton
and South-Eastern clung to the "fallible
human element," unchecked by any me-
chanical device in the important busi-
ness of signaling in train operation.
The year 1862 saw the London and
South-Western Railway open their line
between Exeter Queen street and St.
( Continued on page 5^7. )
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
519
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. Robert Rennic, mecbanical en-
gineer of the St. Louis & San Francisco,
has been made shop superintendent, vvitli
headquarters at Springfield, Mo.
Mr. J. Francis Lee has been appointed
second vice-president and general man-
ager of the Valdez, Copper River &
Tanana Railway Company.
Mr. LesHe G. Roblin has been ap-
pointed locomotive foreman at London,
Ont., on the Canadian Pacific Railvv.iy,
vice Mr. J. Wilkinson, resigned.
Mr, J. A. Carroll has been appointed
to the position of road foreman of en-
gines of the Albuquerque Division of
tlie Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe.
Mr. S. Rothwell has been appointed
mechanical superintendent of the Brock-
ville, Westport and Sault Ste. Marie Rail-
way, vice Mr. H. Wilkinson, resigned.
Mr. Robert Preston has been ap-
pointed master mechanic on the Ontario
Division of the Canadian Pacific Railway,
with headquarters Toronto Junction,
Ont.
Mr. James R. Bunce has been pro-
moted to be road foreman of engines,
with jurisdiction over the 25th, 271h, 28th
and 29th districts of the Grand Trunk,
Western Railway.
Mr. H. S. Williams has been appointed
superintendent of motive power and
works of the lines of the Cuba Company
west of Alto Cedro, vice Mr. E. D.
Stegall, resigned.
Mr. J. C. Howard has been appointed
superintendent of the Dakota Division
of the Great Northern Railway, with
headquarters at Larimore, N. D., vice
Mr. L. B. Allen, resigned.
Mr. Lacey R. Johnson, assistant super-
intendent of rolling stock, Canadian Pa-
cific Railway, and Mrs. Johnson, returned
to Canada last month after a short but
enjoyable trip in England and Scotland.
Mr. Christopher Kyle has been ap-
pointed master mechanic of the Lake
Superior Division of the Canadian Pa-
cific Railway with headquarters at North
Bay. Onr., vice Mr. Robert Preston,
transferred.
Mr. W. L. Pierce has been promoted
to the position of trainmaster of the
branch lines of the Danviile Division of
the Southern Railway (except the Rockv
Mount Branch), with office at Greens-
boro, N. C.
Mr. G. V. Peyton has been promoted
to the position of assistant superintendent
of the branch lines of the Danville Di-
vision of the Southern Railway (except
the Rocky Mount Branch), with office at
Greensboro, N. C.
Mr. H. A. White, formerly mechanical
accountant on the Grand Trunk Railway
at the Point St. Charles Shops, has been
appointed chief clerk to the superintend-
ent of car department, vice Mr. W. H.
Rosevear, Jr., resigned.
Mr. G. C. Scarlette has been promoted
to the position of trainmaster of the main
line of the Washington Division of the
Southern Railway from Alexandria to
]\Ionroe, and of the Warrenton Branch,
with office at Alexandria, Va.
Mr. Hobart B. Ayers, formerly sup-
erintendent of the Manchester Works of
the American Locomotive Company, has
been appointed general superintendent of
the Pittsburgh Works of the same com-
pany, vice Mr. J. H. McConnell, resigned.
Mr. H. K. Gilbert has resigned as
president of the Railway Appliances
Company, of Chicago, and Mr. C. F.
Quincy has been elected president. Mr.
Geo. H. Sargent was elected vice-presi-
dent, and Mr. Percival Manchester, sec-
retary and treasurer.
Mr. J. W. Fogg, master mechanic of
the Chicago Terminal Transfer Com-
pany, met with a painful accident a short
time ago. He had his right leg broken
above the knee by a tire falling on him.
He is at the Mercy Hospital in Chicago
and is reported to be making good pro-
gress toward recovery.
Mr. John Smith, who for the past ten
years has held the positions of master
mechanic and superintendent of car re-
pairs at Du Bois, Pa., for the Buffalo.
Rochester & Pittsburgh Railway, has re-
signed his position. He was popular on
the road and his retirement is regretted.
His present address is 416 South Main
street, Du Bois, Pa.
Mr. C. E. Gossett has been appointed
traveling engineer on the Chicago, Rock
Island & Pacific, with headquarters at
Chickasha, I. T. He entered the service
of the company in 1898 as an engineer
and has had an excellent record. His se-
lection for the responsible position of
traveling engineer is a promotion for
which he may feel justly proud.
Mr. A. J. Fries, formerly general fore-
man of the New York Central Shops at
West Albany, has been appointed division
superintendent of the Boston & Albany
Railroad Shops, with headquarters at
Allslon, Mass. His promotion was made
the occasion of a presentation, by the
entire shop force, of a handsome ring.
The hearty good wishes of his many
friends follow him.
Mr. A. W. Greenwood, superintend-
ent and master mechanic of the East
liroad Top Railroad, has resigned hi«
position, after more than twenty years'
service with the company. He has been
an active railroad man for about forty-
two years, having been on the Pennsyl-
vania for twenty-one years, holding suc-
cessively the positions of gang foreman,
foreman, and assistant master mechanic
at the Altoona Shops. He is at present
at his former headquarters, Rockhill
Furnace, Huntington county. Pa.
Mr. F. D. Cassanave, who is to have
charge of the Pennsylvania Railroad's ex-
hibit at the St. Louis Exposition, is mak-
ing an extensive tour of Europe on busi-
ness connected with the company's ex-
hibit. He will visit the De Glehn Loco-
motive Works in France, where the
Pennsylvania is having built a high class
passenger locomotive. The locomotive
is expected to arrive in this country about
the first of the coming year. It will be
thoroughly tested on the company's lines
East and West and then placed on exhi
bition at St. Louis.
Mr. Alexander Robertson has resigned
as division superintendent of the Wabash
at Decatur, 111., to become manager of
the West Virginia Central and the West-
ern Maryland roads, with headquarters
at Baltimore, Md. It was on the Fitchburg
railroad that he first took to railroad
service in 1885 as passenger brakeman.
He served in various capacities on that
line till 1897, when he moved west and
took service with the Wabash as general
yardmaster. The following year he w^s
made trainmaster, and in September,
1899, he was appointed division superin-
tendent of the Wabash to succeed Mr.
Garrett.
Mr. A. M. White, formerly superin-
tendent of the New York Locomotive
Works, in Rome, and vfho has for the
past 17 years been connected with the
Schenectady Works of the American
Locomotive Company, occupying various
positions of superintendency, has gone
to Manchester, X. H., where he takes
charge of the Manchester Works of the
-American Locomotive Company. Before
he left Schenectady a deputation called
on him and on behalf of the officials
and the entire working force of the local
plant presented to him a magnificent sil-
520
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
ver service, a diamond and emerald ring
and a pair of stereo-binocular field glasses.
Mr. Howard Elliott has been elected
president of the Northern Pacific Rail-
way. He has up to the present time been
second vice-president of the Chicago,
Burlington and Quincy Railroad. He
leaves this road to take the position ro-
cemly vacated by Mr. C. H. Melhn,
who has become president of the New
York, New Haven & Hartford. Mr. El-
liott entered railroad service in 1880, his
first work being in the engineer corps of
the C, B. & Q. He subsequently became
clerk in the office of the president of the
St. Louis, Keokuk & Northwestern.
From 1882 to 1897 he was auditor and
assistant treasurer "of the Chicago, Bur-
lington & Kansas City, and of the St.
Louis, Keokuk & Northwestern. Later
he became general freight and passenger
agent of the same roads. In 1891 he
was made general freight agent and in
1896 he became general manager.
Mr. Charles L. Allen, secretary and
general manager of the Norton Emery
Wheel Company, of Worcester, Mass.,
was the central figure in a very enjoy-
able evening entertainment given by the
officers and men in the company's em-
ploy. The festivities were in honor of
Mr. Allen's return from a trip abroad,
and it is safe to say that few general
managers have received any more cordial
welcome home than he did, when
greeted by the 400 employees of the
company. The shops were decorated by
the men with autumn leaves and flags,
and shortly after eight o'clock in the
evening a general reception was held m
the oflices. Following this, the general
manager was escorted through the works
accompanied by a band. In the grinding
machine department a heavy silver cup
mounted on ebony, with three buckhorn
. handles, was presented to the man whom
they all "delighted to honor." Appro-
priate speeches were made and after a
series of stereoptican views had been en-
joyed the pleasant evening came to a
close The Norton people make emery
wheels, it is true, but there is not a parti-
cle of friction existing in the way the
works are run under Mr. Allen's man-
agement.
Grand Chief Engineer Stone.
Through the courtesy of Mr. C. H.
Salmons, editor and manager of the
Locomotive Engineers' Journal, we received
a photograph of Mr. Warren S. Stone,
the new Grand Chief of the Brotherhood
of Locomotive Engineers, and are now
able to present his picture to our read-
ers. Mr. Stone was born in Iowa 43
years ago and was introduced on his
father's farm to the wholesome toil that
so often lays the foundation to a lite of
successful industry. He enjoyed the
privilege of attending college for a short
time, then he obtained employment as a
fireman on the Chicago, Rock Island &
Pacific Railway, where he rose to be a
highly respected engineer. From hi?
first connection with railroad work Mr.
Stone has been an ardent brotherhood
by Mr. II. H. Westinghouse, vice-presi-
dent of the Westinghouse Air Brake Co.,
of Pittsburgh, Pa.; Mr. John Caldwell,
treasurer of the same company; Mr.
Frank H. Taylor, vice-president of the
Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing
Co., and Mr. George C. Smith, president
of the Security Investment Company, ail
of the same city. They were met by Mr.
Paul J. Myler, of Hamilton, who has been
manager and secretary of the Westing-
house Manufacturing Company, Limited,
which the new organization succeeds.
The new company, to be known as the
Canadian Westinghouse Company, Lim-
ited is a consolidation of all the West-
inghouse interests in Canada, which here-
tofore have been conducted individually.
It will take over all the property, pat-
ents and other interests of the succeeded
companies, including the sales organiza-
tion and business of Ahearn & Soper, of
Ottawa.
We have several names of men capable
of filling the positions of master me-
chanic or master car builder, which we
would be happy to give to any railroad
official who is on the lookout for such
men. We also have an inquiry from a
leading road for a first-class boiler fore-
man. A man of good education is
wanted.
Of the Greatest Intrinsic Value.
Vt the October meeting of the Pacific
Coast Railway Club, our correspondent,
Mr. D. P. Kellogg, read a pape " on,
•Of the Greatest Intrinsic Value to the
Railway World." He described the
dreams of a visionary who was cogitat-
ing on the introduction of all kinds of
perfected appliances into railway ser-
vice, these being the dreamer's ideal.
Of the Greatest Intrinsic Value. The
writer of the paper relinquishes the
schemes of the dreamer, and takes up
good practical education as furnishing
the Greatest Intrinsic Value to railroad
companies. He concludes that educa-
tion, universal education, is the crying
want of the age. We will devote more
space to Mr. Kellogg's paper in a future
issue.
WARREN S. STONE.
man. Latterly he became the salaried
chairman of the Board of Adjustment of
the Rock Island System, where he dis-
played so much ability as to present a
commanding personality for election to
Grand Chief of the Brotherhood of Lo-
comotive Engineers. We believe that
the brotherhood as well as railroad com-
panies have reason to congratulate them-
selves on the selection the engineers have
made.
Cheerfulness and content are great
beautifiers, and are famous preservers of
good looks !--R(rn!o&.v Rndge.
Canadian Westinghouse Company,
Limited, Organized.
At a meeting held at Hamilton, Ont.,
last month, presided over by Mr. George
Westinghouse, the Canadian Westing-
house Company, Limited, was organized
with a capital of $2,500,000,
Mr. George Westinghouse, the found-
er and head of the great industries which
bear his name, arrived in the city in hn
private car at 10. 15 A- M., accompanied
Catalogue No. 36, of the Newton Ma-
chine Tool Works (Incorporated), of
Philadelphia, has just come to hand
The catalogue is a book of 236 pages. An
idea of the contents may be had by a
glance at the alphabetical index which in-
cludes among others, eight sizes of bor-
ing machines, twenty-nine cold saw cut-
ting-off machines, ten duplex milhng ma-
chines, forty-seven dilTerent kinds of
milling machines, twelve plain millmg ma-
chine?, eleven planing machines, eleven
rotary planing machines. thirteen
slotting machines, and others "too
numerous to mention," as the saying is
The catalogue is neatly printed and the
illustrations of the tools are clear and
well defined. Each page is devoted to
some tool and contains a cut and descrip-
tive matter which gives sizes and other
data and where necessary mentions the
kind of work which can be done on the
machine. Write for the catalogue if you
want a bird's-eye view of up-to-date shop
equipment.
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
521
nechanical Work Active on the
Pennsylvania Systems.
Tlicrc appears to be a lull generally
in Ihc demand for railroad rolling stocU.
but the Pennsylvania Railroad Company
does not display any indication of reduc-
ing the output of their shops during the
coming year.
We understand that Superintendent of
Motive Power R. M. Durborow, in
charge of the worlds at Altoona, will re-
ceive within a few days the list of en-
gines and cars that are to be manufac-
tured at that place. An e.xceptionaliy
large order will be made on the Juniata
shops, the capacity of which will be in-
creased about 25 per cent, by reason of
the additions that have been made dur-
ing the past year. The most of the new
worlv will be given to the Juniata shops
on account of the need of the Altoona
plants for repair work. It is said that
only the standard types of engines arc
to be built ne.xt year. No more new
work will be done at the Altoona shops
this year on account of the present
crowded conditions of the plants. The
repair work has completely swamped
the works.
The car shops will get their schedule
of new work within a week. This will in-
clude steel cars almost entirely, although
some wooden ones of a favorite type
are to be built. The Pennsylvania is
building comparatively few wooden cars,
but the short " gondola ' style is still
in favor among the officials, and from
300 to 1,000 of them will be included in
the order, along with box cars. .All
wooden equipinent will be built on steel
frames. After the summer lapse comes
flush times for the men employed in the
various shops of the Pennsylvania sys-
tem. Every department is working full
time and many of them have been
obliged to work overtime to get out the
orders on hand. The motive power de-
partment will be one of the busiest on
the system during the coming year.
MOTiVii Engineering are made up and
enough mater standing in type to nearly
lill anotluT paper.
nr. Lucius E. Johnson.
Mr. Lucius E. Johnson, general man-
ager of the Norfolk & Western, has
been elected president of the road, vice
F. J. Kimball, deceased. Mr. Johnson
will continue to act as general manager.
lie began his railroad career as a fire-
man on the C, B. & Q. Mr. Johnson
is another example of a man reaching
the highest rank in railroad life through
the mechanical department. In 1866 he
entered the railway service as a fireman
at Aurora, on the Chicago, Burlington
»& Quincy Railroad. He rose to be en-
gineer, then master mechanic, in which
position he displayed so much ability
that he was advanced to be superin-
Knows How to Train and Treat
Employees.
While on a visit to the Pacific Coast
we made the acquaintance of Mr. E. N.
Cutting, assistant signal engineer, who
was kind enough to explain the working
of a school he has established for the
instruction and training of the men em-
ployed in the signal departitient. From
our talk with Mr. Cutting we recognize
him in "Sam Weller,'' who read a paper
at the Pacific Coast Railway Club on
"Selecting. Treatinent and Training of
Employees." Some system of training
IS well worthy of general imitation, and
the method of treatment deserves the
greatest praise. We will give oyr read-
ers more particulars when we are not
so short of space as we are this month,
when two forms of R.mlway and Loco-
MR. L. E. JOHNSON.
tendent. After filling that position for
several years he was in 1890 appointed
superintendent of the Montana Central
and three years later left there to take
a similar position on the Lake Shore
& Michigan Southern. In 1899 he was
appointed general superintendent of the
New York and Western, where he rose
to be general manager, and now presi-
dent. He has earned all the good for-
tune that has come to him.
The Third Han.
No doubt this "third man" on a loco-
motive question has been pretty well
threshed out; at the same time I ask
your indulgence for a few practical ques-
tions on the subject. One phase of the
third man proposition is newspaper rot,
which is on a par with the age limit,
and color blindness rot of railroad com-
panies. This third man "behind the
gun," will, I suppose, ride on the left
side of the engine, and he will no doubt
be entitled to a copy oi the "orders."
Suppose the train is running a system
of block or other signals, or runs up
against a red light out on the desert, or
is following the tail lights of another
train, how does this overseer know ih.it
the eagle eye of the man on the right
side is not taking in the situation, an<l
will act at the proper time? If the third
man is nervous, he will be watching tha
air gauge to notice any reduction at
places where he thinks there is danger,
and just when the engineer knows every-
thing is all right. By making sugges-
tions and giving advice, he would rattle
a good engineer and make him go wrong
unintentionally. The writer will wager a
year's subscription to Locomotive En-
GiNEERiNG that the first trip over a busy
'livision, and with the third man on the
ngine, the train will come in late. One
"1 your correspondents some time ago m
-peaking of that Jersey Central wreck,
^aid, that no doubt inventors would be
iqual to the occasion and devise some
means to prevent these things. Now I
wish to say right here that there is some-
thing in use now that will prevent such
things. You will find it in your book
f rules, and on the back of your time
ird. The substance of it is never run
list a danger signal.
I don't care whether it is a semaphore,
led light, flag, or anything waved vio-
lently across the track. In nine hundred
;ind ninety-nine cases out of a thousand
that railroad man who gets into a hole
is the one who takes things for granted.
The one crew knowing that the other
fellows are late, takes it for granted that
they can get out on the main line and
do a little switching, and before that
^witching is ever finished there is a call
tor the wreck rtain. Why? Well, we
did not dream of No. i making up so
much time, and we thought we would get
through with our switching before she
came. But what about the widow and
children? No. i is late, she has a me^rt
up in the canyon, and her engineer takes
it for granted that No. 2 will be in to
clear. No. 2 is a little late, also, and
they take it for granted that No. i will
slow down, but she don't, and the unex-
pected happens. When engineers will
stop the dangerous practice of running
past a flag, without stopping, picking it
up, apd then proceed with care to the
point of obstruction, there will be fewer
rear end collisions, and the chances of
the third man on the engine being out
oi a job will be good. Do we want
the third man on an engine? Y'es. He
is wanted on the deck of some of the big
mountain climbing coal burners; he is
wanted to shovel coal. Now comes the
S. P., according to newspaper talk, giv-
ing orders for their conductors to spend
a part of the trip on the engine; another
522
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE .ENGINEERING
November, :903.
phase of the third man proposition. If
there is anything an engineer detests, it
is to have the "con." riding on the en-
gine; and if the "con." had at one time
been a plug puller, it makes matters
worse. The proper place for a passenger
conductor is in the coaches, taking care
of his people. The proper place for a
freight conductor when his train is un-
der way is in the caboose, where he
can cuss the man with the eagle eye if
the train is not making time, from too
much tonnage or too little steam, or, if
everything is lovely, he might pound his
ear, and dream of a nice story to tell in
the ofiice, of the fine run I made last
night. W. DE San NO.
Sail Francisco.
practice, but it is followed on many
roads, morc's the pity. \Vc often wonder
if any other kind of machine is so thor-
oughly abused as the locomotive in the
efifort to keep it working. The men
in charge are not to blame, for irresist-
ible pressure is kept upon them to fol-
low revolting practices that a few hours'
extra work per month may be forced out
of locomotives.
The Names of the States.
Nebraska takes its name from the In-
dian name of the Platte river, which
means "sallow water." Michigan is
called from the Indian name of a great
lake called Michi-gan. Kansas got its
name from Dakota, which means "the
south-wind people." The Indian origin
of Kentucky means "hunting land," and
the Indians called it Kenta-kee. Colo-
rado gets its name from Spanish origin
on account of the redness of the rocks
of that State. New Mexico is a daugh-
ter of Old Mexico, whose early name
was Mexitl, a war god. Pennsylvania
takes its name from William Penn. New
Hampshire is called from Hampshire.
England. Montana is of Spanish origin
and means mountainous. Missouri
takes its name from the Missouri river,
which in Indian language means "great
muddy." Connecticut derived its name
from the Indian word meaning long
river, which the Indians called the Con-
necticut river. Iowa takes its name
from the term which the Indians applied
to the country beyond the Mississippi,
which signifies across. California is of
Spanish origin, and was supposed to be
a land near the terrestrial paradise. Ari-
zona means arid zone. Massachusetts
is an old English word, Massa-wachuset,
which means a great hill, and was first
applied to a tribe of Indians living near
Milton. New Jersey takes its name from
the little island of Jersey in the English
channel. New York takes her name
from James, Duke of York, brother of
King Charles I. It was originally called
New Netherland. — Blacksmith and Wheel-
wright.
From Master Mechanic's Office to
Third Vice-President.
Mr. Benjamin L. Winchell has been
elected third vice-president of the Chi-
cago, Rock Island and Pacific system,
and he takes the position of genern^
manager, with headquarters in Chicago,
with charge of the whole operation de-
partment. Mr. C. H. Warren, first vice-
president, will remove to New York. Mr.
Winchell did his first railway work in the
office of Mr. L. N. Towne, master me-
chanic of the Hannibal and St. Joseph
Railroad, from whence he went into the
A floating newspaper paragraph tells
us that in the Philadelphia and Reading
round houses it is a common practice
for the boiler makers to enter the fire
boxes of locomotives and caulk flues
or do other repairs while fire is on the
grates. The practice is to smother the
top of the fire with fresh coal and put
some boards on the top for the work-
man to rest upon. It is a melancholy
He is said to be highly discrimating :n
his judgment of men and makes no pre-
tense at knowing the details of work
assigned to his subordinates so long as
results are satisfactory.
MR. BENJAMIN I,. WI^■CHELL.
auditor's ofiice. Close attention to bus-
iness raised him in two years to be
chief clerk of the passenger and freight
department. He rose rapidly through
the passenger department until, in i88t,
twelve years after he entered railway
service, he became assistant general pas-
senger agent of the Kansas City, Fort
Scott and Memphis system,, where he re-
mained thirteen years. General Nettle-
ton, president of the Kansas City, Fort
Scott and Memphis developed a high re-
gard for Mr. Winchell, and this influence
led to the latter being elected president
when General Nettleton died. When the
St. Louis and San Francisco absorbed
the K. C, F. S. and M., Mr. Winchell
was elected vice-president and leaves
there to take charge of t'.e operating of
the Rock Island system.
Mr. Winchell has been unusually pop-
ular in all the positions he has held; hU
strong points being clear headed energy
and fair dealing between man and man.
We learn from Mr. Henry F. Colvin,
of the Rue Manufacturing Company,
Philadelphia, who is remarkably well in-
formed concerning the history of the
locomotive, that Seth Wilmarth's loco-
motives were popularly called "Shang-
hais," owing to their unusual height,
which made them the roosters of the
railroad barnyard.
We understand that orders have been
issued for reduction of the working
force in the various repair shops belong-
ing to the Vanderbilt system of rail-
roads. A ipovement of that kind gener-
ally takes place about this season of the
year, but transportation business has been
so very active during the last summer
that we supposed the cutting down of em-
ployees would be omitted.
Young men trying to lift themselves
upwards in railway service might profit
by the advice lightly given to a son by
his mother: He was trying to make a
high leap with a bar, but merely ac-
complished a series of failures. "John,"
she cried at last, "put your heart in the
bar and you will go over."
We spend considerable time obtaining
information for correspondents, and in
searching for books and articles which
they want; but there is a limit to our
accommodating spirit. When a corre-
spondent writes asking us to send him
a matrimonial paper not named, which
contained a certain advertisement we
must ask to be excused.
We understand that the historic lo-
comotive "Washington," illustrated in
our October number, was run on its
famous trial by Fred de Sanno, grand-
father of W. de Sanno, who is a fre-
quent correspondent of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering. Do any
other interested readers have relations
who were associated in any way with
the building or operating of pioneer
locomotives?
The Canadian Northern Railway are
building a new round house at Winnipeg,
Man. Fifteen stalls will be completed
this year, and twenty-six stalls will be
added early in 1904. The engine house,
cH fire-proof construction, will be 80
feet in the clear and will have three en-
trance tracks. A 70-foot turn table, op-
erated by compressed air, will be put in.
This road has received fourteen engines
out of'an order of twenty-five from the
Canadian Locomotive Works in Kings-
ton, Ont. The engines are of the 4-6-0
type.
November, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
523
New Klondyke Railroad.
The Sun reported the other day that
the first standard gauge railroad in
Alaska is now being built. It will extend
inland fifty miles, affording transporta-
tion when completed to the rich mining
camps in the southern part of the Seward
Peninsula. The road is to be known as
the Council City and Solomon Railroad.
It is only the beginning of a system
which is to be extended with branches
through the Seward Peninsula, making
all the great mining centers easily ac-
cessible from the sea.
Work on this railroad was begun on
June 15, and a force of 500 mpn is work-
ing in day and night shifts. More than
ten miles have already been graded and
it is expected that two-thirds of the line
will be completed this season.
The Seward Peninsula is as yet the
operation from Nome beach to the head
of Anvil Creek, a few miles in the in-
terior. Good wagon roads have also
been built from this railroad to adjacent
creeks, so that it is now possible to han-
dle heavy machinery for the region
tributary to Nome; and the fact that the
railroad now rapidly pushing forward is
expected to solve the problem for the
more isolated camps gives the enterprise
its great significance.
The first districts to benefit by the new
railroad will be the Solomon River
region and the camps on Ophir Creek
north of the southeast coast of the penin-
sula. The railroad will push right
through these regions. It will start from
Council City in the southeast and extend
to the northwest and north. How im-
portant the road will be for these great
mining camps will be appreciated when
Our illustration shows the small high
stack supported on the pressed steel base
which is standard on the Grand Trunk.
Weather-Proof Windows.
We have received from Mr. R. E.
Allison, a locomotive engineer on the
Grand Trunk Railway, a copy of a cir-
cular he has issued in connection with
the Allison weather-proof window. This
window is, among other things, for
use in locomotive cabs and is de-
signed to prevent the formation of
frost on the pane and also to pre-
vent the lodgment of snow. This is
accomplished by providing two panes set
in a suitable frame, with an air space
between them. Below this frame in a
casing is a series of steam heating pipes.
The air which is heated by these pipes
rises between the panes and prevents
_t . J .* . - ^
COMPOUND MOGUL — GRAND TRUNK RAILWAY SYSTEM.
great center of gold-mining operations
in Alaska. About eleven-twelfths of all
the placer gold yielded by Alaskan min-
mg operations last year, or $5,500,000 in
all, was obtained from this region, a wide
tract of land jutting out into Behring
Sea, north of St. Michael's. Nome, at
the southwest corner of the peninsula, is
still the greatest producer, but mining is
in progress on many of the streams and
gulches in the interior and last year the
other districts contributed a large amount
of gold dust to the total output.
The most serious problem has been to
transport machinery and supplies into
the gold-producing regions, away from
the coast. The difficulties of transpor-
tation have impeded the development of
this wonderful region although great
things have been done in spite of this
impediment. After heavy machinery has
been landed on Nome beach it has been
found in a number of cases simply im-
possible to transport it from the coast
to the mines.
The difficulty has been solved, as far
as the Anvil Creek region is concerned,
for a narrow gauge railroad is now in
the fact is mentioned that in spite of the
present difficulties of transportation, the
output of Ophir Creek last year was
more than $1,000,000 of gold dust.
Cross Compound flogul.
Through the courtesy of Mr. W. D.
Robb, superintendent of motive power of
the Grand Trunk Railway, we are enabled
to present to our readers a very good ex-
ample of freight power which has been
built in the Point St. Charles shops of
the Grand Trunk system.
The engine is a mogul, or 2-6-0 engine,
as will be seen from the illustration, and is
a cross compound of the "Richmond"
type. The cylinders are 22^ and 35x36
ins. and the driving wheels are 63 ins. in
diameter. The valves are piston on some
of this class and slide on others, and the
usual indirect motion is used. The springs
are all underhung and the main driver is
is the only pair of wheels without flanges.
The adhesive weight is about 140.744 lbs.,
while the total weight of the machine is
163.704 lbs. The weight of the tender is
about 130,856 lbs., thus giving a total
weight in working order of 294,560 lbs.
the formation of frost and melts any
snow that may be driven against the
outer pane. Tubes are provided on each
side of the air space whereby the air
which as become slightly cooled by con-
tact with the glass, is conducted down
into a space below the heating chamber.
Suitable inlet and outlet valves for air
and steam are provided, and when once
warmed up, the hot pipes keep up a cir-
culation of warm air between the panes.
Mr. Allison's address is Lindsay, in
the Province of Ontario, Canada. He
is prepared to grant licenses for the
use of his window.
Our facetious friend, Mr. H. H. Vree-
land, president of the Metropolitan Rail-
way System, visited Europe last summer
and he gives some funny descriptions of
what he saw abroad. He says as to speed
of trains in Europe, it is about the same
as ours here, although he said he had
traveled 700 miles on the "Oriental Ex-
press" at the rate of eighty miles an
hour — fifty miles straight away, twenty
miles up and down, and ten miles side-
ways."
5=4
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November. 190J.
Steel- Frame, Side- Door, Passenger Car
on the Illinois Central.
In the July issue of Railway and Lo-
comotive Engineering (page 333) we
gave a brief account of the steel-frame,
side-door passenger car, built by the
Over the body bolsters and over the
needle beams, 6 by i2'/i ins. 1-beanis
in short sections are placed between the
longitudinal sills as stiffening members
and riveted with angles to the webs of the
sills.
thick is placed on the plate floor, and on
the asbestos a maple floor is laid.
The underframe is carried upon four
body bolsters made of 7 by i in. steel
bars in the upper and lower members. The
bolsters are arranged in pairs, 4V2 ft. cen-
1>L.-VN NO.
PLAN NO.
_ _ - _
_ _- _T*_ _ _
- -
~ ■ ~
n
3 ffl m m E
5 m ffl' m ffl E
i
PLAN NO.
DOORS BOTH SIDES.
PLAN NO 4. DOORS ONE SIDE.
Illinois Central Railroad for suburban Upon the metal sills, a steel floor of
service. " J4 in. plates, 60 inches in width, is laid
This new type of car is the result of with butt joints formed by the planed
careful study based upon long experience edges of the plates and extending entirely
NEW SIDE-DOOR, STEEL-FRAME SUBURBAN C.\R, I. C. R.
in the handling of a large suburban traf-
fic on the part of Mr. A. W. Sulivan, as-
sistant second vice-president, and of Mr.
William Renshaw, superintendent of ma-
chinery of the Illinois Central.
The underframe of the car consists of
four 9 ins. by 21 lbs. steel I-beams, 64
ft. in length, spaced nearly equal distance^;
apart and of a total width over the flanges
of 10 ft. 4 ins. The end sills are g ins.
by 2$ lbs. steel channels, set with backs
to the squared ends of the longitudinal
sills and riveted to them with double an-
gle plates reinforced by gussets. Four
truss rods passing over the inner body
bolsters and anchored to the outer body
bolsters, are used to support the middle
of the car. These rods are solid, that
'p, without the usual swivel connection
in the middle; their adjustments being ob-
tained by eight vertical screw queen-
posts resting with their lower ends upon
the rods and their upper ends support-
ing two steel needle beams of 7 ins. by
IS lbs. I-beams extending entirely across
the car under the sills, with their upper
flanges riveted to the lower flanges of the
sills, thus bracing as well as supporting the
under-frame.
across the underframe. This floor is
riveted to the upper flanges of the sills
with double rows of % in. rivets. There
is thus obtained a continuous metal sur-
fers, and bolted to the lower flanges of the
sills. Heavy truss connections extend be-
tween the bolsters, to which are bolted the
center plates.
The corner posts consist of two 4 by
S, V4-in. channels set transversely on the
side sills and spaced 11 ins. apart. On
the outside and inside of these posts four
triangular gussets of V^, in. by 15 Vg-in.
steel plate are riveted to the flanges, ty-
ing them firmly together ; the corner posts
are riveted securely to the side sills and
to the upper plates with angle connec-
tions. The space between the corner posts
and the adjoining side-door posts is
braced with a double set of diagonal
bracing, formed of I '4-in. angles in three
vertical panels and riveted to the gusset
connections. This arrangement of corner
bracing gives stability to the upper frame
and forms a collision bulkhead of great
resistance.
The utilization of floor space for seat-
ing accommodation has been referred to
in a previous issue. There are
four plans, any one of which is
vastly superior to the one former-
ly used. The old I. C. R. suburban car
SIDE-DOOR TRAIN— METROPOLITAN DISTRICT RAILWAY, LONDON.
face extending the entire length and width
of the car, insuring perfect rigidity of the
underframe and giving complete protec-
tion from fire underneath the car. In ad-
dition to this, a layer of asbestos % in.
seated 56 people, plan No. I seats 96;
plan No. 2 seats 115, and plan Nos. 3 and
4 seats 120 people. The time required to
fill or empty the car, or for that mat-
ter, the entire train, is no longer than that
Novciiiher, kjo^.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
525
"PULLED
THREE
CARS
LIGHTER"
The best demonstra-
tion of the value of
Dixon's Flake Graph-
ite about an engine is
in the actual experi-
ence of the engineers.
Results are things
that can be measured.
For instance, the fol-
lowing is quoted from
a letter of an experi-
enced engineer:
*' Dixon's Pure Flake Graphite
mixed with oil and applied to all
■working: parts of the engine makes
it again as easy to handle. Admitted
to valves and "cylinders before start-
ing up a grade the train seems to
pull two or three cars lighter."
This is sound evi-
dence from an experi-
enced man.
Let us send you a
sample to try upon
your engine.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
JERSEY CITY, N. J.
fur any one pair of cross scats to be va-
cated and re-occtipicd. With the use of
side-door cars of this description people
do not, stand together in groups on the
platform, and the crowding and surging
incident to tlic c-nd door car is thus avoid-
c.l.
VVc arc indebted to Mr. Sulivan for the
information here presented.
"Words, Words, Words."
When that obsequious old court func-
tionary Polonius approached Hamlet
with the question, "What do you read,
my lord?" he was met with the senten-
tious reply, "Words, words, words." This
rejoinder was almost in strict accord with
the scriptural injunction to "answer a
fool according to his folly." It was, how-
ever, not only intended to perplex Polo-
raisers to point out that very advantage
to prospective subscribers of our maga-
zine, and it is true not only of our own
readers, but it is true of the readers of
good, reliable books on technical sub-
jects—they get hold of other people's
ideas, which is the important thing now-
a-days.
Look over the list we give here and sec
if some of the books will interest you.
You will get the "words" which Hamlet
humorously spoke of, but you will also
find them backed up by good ideas and
thoughts.
The first on the list is, of course,
Rau,way and Locomotive Engineer-
ing, a practical journal of railway mo-
tive power and rolling stock. It costs
only $2.00 a year, and is well worth the
money, and besides the paper is a wel-
INTERIOR OF ILLINOIS CENTRAL SUBURBAN CAR.
nius, but was intended to strengthen the
prevalent opinion concerning the young
prince of Denmark, viz: that he was
mad.
Now, it is quite true that if Hamlet
was reading the book he had in his hand
when Polonius addressed him, he certain-
ly read words, words, words, and many
of them, too. That was, however, mere-
ly a somewhat witty reply which Shakes-
peare permitted him to make to the
tedious old man. The real meaning of
reading is not simply to con over the
words used, but to get hold of the sub-
ject matter presented, to understand it
and to grasp the author's meaning. In
other phrase, the reading of a book or
a magazine is beneficial if it enables
one to get hold of other people's
ideas. We have often urged our club
Let
come visitor in every household.
your wife and children see it.
"Locomotive Engine Running, and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately. "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years. '' We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book, combining instruc-
tion with amusement. It is a particular-
ly useful book to the young mechanic. It
has a stimulating effect in inducing him
to study his business. The price is 50
cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used
by many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
526
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
for promotion and of engineers likely to
be hired. It contains in small compass
a large amount of information about the
locomotive. Convenient pocket size. We
cordially recommend this book. The
price is 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book instructs a man so that he will
understand the construction and opera-
tion of a compound locomotive as well
as he now understands a simple engine.
Tells all about running, breakdowns and
repairs. Convenient pocket size, bound
in leather. $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horse power, conden-
sers, feed water heaters, air pumps, en-
gine's, strength of boilers, testing boiler
performances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list of its contents. It is. in the
question and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a foreman boilermaker. Also con-
tains several chapters on oil-burning
locomotives. Price, 50 cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. Price, $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no
person engaged in mechanical occupa-
tions can aflford to do without. Enables
any workman to figure out all the shop
and machine problems which are so puz-
zling for want of a little knowledge. We
sell it for 50 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of combus-
tion. While treating on the chemistry
of heat and combustion it is easily under-
stood by every intelligent fireman. The
price is 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons try-
ing to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. We sell it. Cloth, 75
cents. Leather, $i.oo'.
"Skeevers' Object Lessons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating of all trains on single or double
track. Used by nearly all railroads.
Study of this book would prevent many
collisions. Price, 50 cents.
"Mechanical Engineers' Pocket Book."
Kent. This book contains 1,100 pages
6x3^ inches of closely-printed minion
type, containing mechanical engineering
matter. It ought to be in the bookcase
of every engineer who takes an interest
in engineering questions. We use it con-
stantly as a reference for questions sent
to us to be answered. Full of tables and
illustrations. Morocco leather, $500.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco
motive. It will be found particularly use-
ful to men handling or repairing com-
pound locomotives. It is the real loco-
motive up to date. $2.50.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
The latest catalogue of the Tabor
Manufacturing Company, of Philadel-
phia, has been received. It is artistically
printed and sets forth the merits of the
Tabor Vibrator Molding Machines. The
pamphlet opens with an introduction
which deals with machine moulding.
Vibrator moulding is explained and the
materials used are mentioned. Matches,
paraffined wood plates and sprue cut-
ters are then taken up. Aluminum as
a pattern material is discussed, and the
advantages of its use are explained.
Split pattern vibrator machines, and
their operation, are well illustrated by
half-tone and letter press. Vibrator
frame machines are also described and
the action of vibrators is set forth, also
that of automatic stripping-plate ma-
chines. A list of stock sizes of power
ramming split pattern machines with
vibrators is given, also those of vibrator
frame machines, and power ramming
single or duplex automatic stripping-
plate machines. The concluding pages
contain half-tone illustrations of parts,
numbered and named, to facilitate order-
ing. The Tabor Company will be happy
to send a copy of the catalogue to any-
one interested enough to write for one.
The report of the proceedings of the
thirty-sixth annual convention of the
American Railway Master Mechanics'
Association has just come from the press.
It is bound in half leather and is there-
fore uniform with those of the printed
records of former years. This volume,
which covers the Saratoga convention
held on June 24, 25 and 26, 1903, con-
tains 457 pages of reading matter as well
as numerous tables, illustrations and
data belonging to the reports; and in
the recommended practice of the asso-
ciation. The book, price $1.50, makes
a valuable volume, and may be obtained
from the secretary, Mr. Joseph W. Tay-
lor, the Rookery Building, Chicago.
e
DGfl
November, 190.3.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
527
Keep
Yo\ar
Mind
On.
It
CftANDAU'S
Littoniolivc Air Pump
Thu bo» conUin* on«
».,,n..H.»>. WK HKT
CRANDALL'S HEIIOS
AIR PlIVIP and
THROTTLE VALVE
PACKING
Put Ip in Sets
Exact Lit to Rod and Box
Send Trial Order
The Crandall Pkg. Co.
123 Liberty Street
N. Y. CITY
Chicago Office. 30 La Salle St.
Over One
Thousand
'•^i^iss^-* Miles
A DAY
"The Colorado Special"
Dinner in t'hioaj^n Today
Breakfast lii Onialm Toniorrow'siornlng
Dinner in Denver Tomorrow Evening
SPLENDID TRAIN SERVICE
to DENVER via UNION PACIFIC
KuU Infornmttoii i-liferfiilty
furnished on iippliration to
G. P. and Tkt. Agt.,
Omaha, Neb.
Signals and Signaling;.
(Conlinutd from page jrS'.j
David's station, with a steep grade be-
tween the two places. Mr. W. H. Preecc
invented a new form of instrument which
(lid much to popularize block signaling.
Realizing that the difficulty of teaching
operators the method of working sig-
nal instruments had delayed the gen-
eral adoption of the block system, Mr.
I'rcece produced an instrument in which
.1 small lever was used to actuate a minia-
liire semaphore, so that the work of
transmitting a signal to the next station
ahead was similar in form at least to the
work performed when the large sema-
phore out of doors was being operated.
With the electric signal on the operator's
table, simply a repetition on a small scale,
of the full-sized line signal, the appar-
ent complication of the signal instru-
ment disappeared, and the whole matter
PKEECE'S INSTRUMENT.
was rendered perfectly intelligible to
pointsmen, signalmen and operators
alike. A further improvement was also
noticeable in this instrument. Hereto-
fore the man sending the signal could
not tell whether or not the instrument at
the receiving station showed the correct
indication. In other words, an instru-
ment out of order at the distant station
would be difficult of detection. Mr
Preece's device was so arranged that the
operator at A sending a "Line Clear"
indication to B, would not only see his
own miniature semaphore arm drop, but
would hear a bell ring on his instrument
if the arm on the miniature semaphore
at B had been lowered at the same time
as his own. In 1866 Mr. Preece intro-
duced his single wire system. It was
further improved in 1872, and in order
to obviate disturbances produced on a
single wire system by lightning or by
the crossing of wires, he arranged his in-
strument so that the "all clear" signal
could only be produced by the concur-
rent action of operators at both ends cf
the section.
The first use made of the block signal
principle in this country was made on
the Camden & Amboy Railroad in i86.i.
The signal then used was practically a
square box with clear glass on two faces,
and a lamp in the center. Red, green
and white flannel banners or screens
were drawn into the field of view as oc-
casion required, and at night the light
shone through these screens and gave the
appropriate indication. In 1873, after this
road had become part of the Pennsyl-
vania, this signal was modified, as it was
found that the reflection of the sun from
the glass sometimes obscured the screen.
It was therefore arranged that when
the red color was shown in the case,
an arm would be extended from the box
bearing a red disc, and when the green
color was displayed in the case, a green
clover leaf at the end of an arm was ex-
tended from the box. The first signal
flICHT HAND ROIO SLOCKED 80TM RO&DS BLOCKU
I
LCrT HANDR04}8LOCKeo BCTH n(
ADS CLCAft
REVOLVING DISC SIGNAL.
depended upon color alone to give the"
correct indication. The improved sig-
nal not only had a color indication, but
one depending upon position as well. In
1883 the semaphore block signal was in-
troduced as the one which was still more
reliable, in that it depended upon posi-
tion alone. In 1886 the semaphore for
switch signals was installed. The Penn-
sylvania Railroad was thus the pioneer
road in the United States to introduce
block and interlocking signals.
In America the first automatic signal
system was the original Hall, which was
used in the States of Massachusetts and
Connecticut about 1871; it was then op-
erated by wires carried on telegraph
poles. In 1879 the track circuit, which
dispenses with wires and poles, was in-
troduced by the Union Signal Company
and used on the Fitchburg. The Penn-
sylvania installed an interlocking plant,
made by the English firm of Saxby &
Farmer in 1875. They used the Toucey
and Buchanan signal in 1877, the sema-
phore flag station signal in 1885, the
pneumatic interlocking in 1891, and in
5«8
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
1892 the automatic pneumatic block sig-
'nal.
Signals and signaling on a railway an:
simply precautionary devices and meth-
ods for securing safety in train opera-
tion. The principal aims to which all
railway signaling and interlocking should
be directed are, that the right road for
a given train should be prepared, that i«,
all switches and derails on the line
should be closed so as to make the rails
continuous for that train. That having
properly "made" the road it should be
secured by operating suitable locking de-
vices. That only after the road has been
made and locked, the correct signal be
given. That the correct signal be the only
one that can be given. After the road
has been made, locked and signaled, that
a certain amount of time must be re-
quired to elapse before any alteration is
possible in signals or road. Lastly in
blocking, that the required space inter-
val be preserved faithfully and any fail-
ure of the apparatus shall indicate "dan-
ger," and though it causes a delay, it
shall never permit disaster.
Mr. Dorsey, an American engineer,
when writing some years ago on "Eng-
lish and American Railroads Compared,"
said of the block signal system, which
has been compulsory on all railroads in
Great Britain since 1889: "It is aston-
ishing to see the blind faith the English
engine driver places in his block signals.
In dense fogs, when he cannot see 100
feet ahead, or dark nights, when his
vision is also very limited; for his head-
light in only an ordinary lantern, useless
for illuminating the track, and only used
as a signal; or, frequently when he has
dark night and dense fog tp run through,
yet he runs at full speed, and generally
on schedule time, feeling sure that he is
perfectly safe, because his block signals
have told him so, and they cannot make
a mistake or lie."
(To be Continued.)
The J. A. Fay & Egan Company of
Cincinnati.
We recently had the pleasure of visit-
ing the manufacturing establishment of
the J. A. Fay & Egan Co., of Cincinnati,
Ohio. The shops are located in a busy
portion of the "Queen City," and com-
prise in all fifteen acres of floor space,
over which are spread 1,200 employees.
The output of this large concern is 8,000
machines per year, and it is made up of
every known kind of wood-working ma-
chine.
An old-time vaudeville joke was for
the entertainer to announce that a gen-
ius had been discovered in the West, who
was able to cut wood without using a saw
or an ax — he did it with a hatchet ! A
glance through this establishment would
show that the modern way is to use a
Fay & Egan machine and cut it quickly
and accurately. This firm makes wood
cutting appliances for everybody who uses
machinery to cut wood from the smallest
pattern' shop up to the large railway and
the government navy yard. It is not
only within the borders of the United .
States that the Fay & Egan machines may
be found, fully half their business is an
export one, and their wares are to be
found in all the manufacturing countries
of the world.
They have recently got out an exten-
sive line of wood-working machinery es-
pecially adapted to use in railroad shops,
besides the general run of tools for mis-
cellaneous wood using shops. In fact, an
entire factory could be equipped by this
firm, and a tool or tools supplied for every
wood-working operation which the factory
might need. This is something which it
would probably be impossible to parallel
anywhere in the United States. They
are very busy at present but are fully
equal to cope with this or a larger de-
mand for first-class wood-working ma-
chinery.
This well known company is yz years
old and has had a continuous growth since
it started in 1830 at Keene, N. H. The
consolidation of the J. A. Fay & Egan
Co. took place in 1893, and it has felt the
beneficial effects of the amalgamation ever
since. The J. A. Fay Co. and the Egan Co.
were healthy rival concerns in the begin-
ning and gave each other a great deal of
trouble in the matter of law suits, etc.,
over patents, until the "merger" put an
end to their disputes. The new company
showed much business sagacity in retain-
ing in its service brainy men from each of
the original companies and in selecting the
best machine niade by either firm as the
standard one in its particular line to man-
ufacture for sale, and to improve upon as
time went on.
The J. A. Fay & Egan Co. have been
uniformly successful in securing recog-
nition wherever their machines have been
exhibited. Beginning with the first inter-
national exhibition, the famous Crystal
Palace Exhibition in London, in 1851,
down to the present time, they have taken
medals at all "World's Fairs." They have
been awarded the Grand Prix in Paris in
1878, 1889 and 1900. Two decorations of
the Legion of Honor have been conferred
by the French government upon members
of the company, one upon a former presi-
dent and one upon Mr. Thomas B. Egan,
the present president.
Robert H. Thurston, the celebrated
mechanical engineer, dean of Sibley Col-
lege of Engineering in Cornell Univer-
sity, died suddenly on October 25 on his
64th birthday. Professor Thurston was
long connected with the Stevens Insti-
tute of Technology and was a volumi-
nous writer on engineering subjects, his
History of the Growth of the Steam
Engine being the most popular of his
works. He served as an engineer in the
United States Navy during the civil war
and made an enviable record.
Photographs
of Locomotives from railways all over the
globe. The Largest colleclioii on earth. Over
lo.duo varieties ol Locomotives, cars and trains
from Anit-rican. British. French. German, Ital-
ian, etc., etc., railways. Samples 6x'^ inches, 25
cents ; s X 10 inches, ,^6 cents, postage paid.
ILLLISTRATED PRICE LIST TRHE
THE LOCOMOTIVE MAGAZINE
Fnll of railway i>ictures and information.
6 cents a copy, postage paid.
SEND rJlI^ICT TO
Locomotive Publishing Co., Ltd.
The World's Railway Photographer
3 Amen Corner, Paternoster Row, London, E. C.
New York Agents, The Derry-Collard Co., 256 B'way
London Agent, Railway and Locumotiva Enginaering
MINNEAPOLIS
AND ST. PAUL
Illinois Central R. R.
New line from Chicago via
Rocktord, Freeport, Dubuque,
Waterloo and Albert Lea.
Fine service and fast "Lim-
ited " night train, with State-
room and Open-section Sleep-
ing Car, Buffet-Library Car
and Free Reclioin Chair Car
through without change. Din-
ing Car Service.
A. H. HANSON
G. P. A., Chicago
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIALLY APPLICABLE BETWEEN
ENGINE AND TENDER.
HORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Inc.
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
The McCORD BOX
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICAGO. HEW YORK.
NrivcnilnT, HjO,^.
RAir.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
529
A.Leschen& Sons Rope Co.
MANUFACTURERS
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Pittings and Supplies
IIOMK Oinaci? :
910-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
( H7 !•;. I.akc St., CliicaKo, 111.
Rnnrh Offices 1 92 C-ntre St., New York City, N Y.
Braiicli omces . J^j.^^^ ^^j, ^a„ prancisco, Cal.
( 1717-23 Arapahoe St., Denver, Col.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Building, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Building.
St. Louis : Terminal Station.
TAYLOR YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by the Leading Railroads
R. Mushet's .'.'SSs;;"' Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
I'he B. F. Sturtevant Company's New
Foundry and l^attern Department
at H>de Park, Hass.
The new plant erected by the 13. F.
Sturtevant Company^ of Hyde Park,
Ma.si., comprises a commodious four-
story office building 45x125 ft., a three-
story building 80x500 ft., devoted to the
niannfaclure of blowers, heaters and gal-
vanized iron work; a building 80x250 ft.
used for testing engines and for electrical
ii|uipment. The general machine shop
MH-asures 120x500 ft., with 40 ft. side
galleries, devoted principally to the
building of engines, a forge shop 40x100
fl., a two-story building of the same floor
,irca set apart entirely for lockers, wash-
ing and sanitary facilities for the em-
ployees, a pattern storage building 80x150
It., a foundry 170x350 ft., and a power
house 80 ft. square. The aggregate floor
area of these buildings exceeds nine
acres. The arrangement of the buildings
is the result of the most careful study
and endeavor to simplify the matter of
inter-transportation.
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
Sol* Representative:, in the United States.
Canada and Hextco
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. H3 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation.
il37 THE ROOKERY, CtllCAUO.
66 Broadwa.v, New York. Park BuUding, Flttsbnrsh
"31 Norfolk House, London, Eng.
Inspection of Steel Rails, Splice Bars, Railroad Cars,
Wheels, Axles, etc. Chemical Laeou-itoky— .^ralysis
of Ores, Iron, Steel. Oils, Water, etc. Phvsicai Labo-
BAToKY— Test of Metals, Drop and Pulling Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Ears, etc.
EBlciency Tests of Boilers, Engines and LocomotWeb
the cross aisles, which provides for ll:e
distribution to all parts of the building of
metal, etc.
An ingenious system of charging has
been devised, by which the charging cars
pass at floor level in front of the bins.
They arc there loaded, weighed and
passed to the elevator for the charging
floor. As each car is unloaded it is
pushed forward and started down an in-
cline on which it runs, but in an opposite
direction to that taken when coming up.
A novel apparatus gradually stops the
car, and releases it so that it may roll on
to the elevator, which is automatically
tripped and descends to the ground floor.
The two cupolas are 56 and 72 ins. in
diameter respectively. The eminent
adaptability of the Sturtevant pressure
blower is here exhibited in a marked
manner. Two blowers, Nos. 8 and JO,
driven by a 30 and a 40 h.p. Sturtevant
belted motor, are supported on the
charging platform through which they
discharge directly downward and thence
to the cupolas.
WORKS OF THE B. F. STURTEVANT COMPANY, HYDE P.\RK, M.^SS.
The flask-shop. 6o.x8o ft., is equipped
with band, crosscut and splitting saws,
boring machine and lathe, all driven by
a 10 h.p. Sturtevant motor suspended
from the ceiling. Imtnediately above is
the pattern shop, abundantly lighted upon
three sides and equipped with a full com-
pliment of tools. In the pattern stor-
age, around the pipe columns which sup-
port the floors, are clamped the pattern
shelving brackets, which are adjustable
to any height. The first floor is concrete
and is designed for the keeping of heavy
cast iron patterns. The foundry consists
ess.entially of two long cranevfays each
35 ft. in width, with center bent of, the
same width and side floors 30 ft. wide.
The craneways are designed for 20-ton
electric traveling cranes. Brick division
walls 3' j ft. high, running lengthwise of
the foundry, separate the floors on the
lines of the columns. Lighting is secured
through monitors in both of the crane-
ways and through ample side windows.
In the center line the craneway, and in
the bent between them runs an industrial
railway with turn tables connecting with
The entire transportation equipment
of the plant, including tracks, cars,
trucks, etc., was designed and built by
the Sturtevant Company. The cars are
provided with a special type of ball bear-
ings having chilled wearing surfaces.
The brass foundry, located in a cor-
ner of the main building, is provided with
crucible furnaces, and a special form of
reverberatory furnace designed prin
cipally for melting babbitt and similar
soft metals. In the middle of the end
of the foundry is the core room. Jthe
ovens are six in number, three being'.^ ft.
diameter of the reel type, and three
being respectively 4, 5 and 7 ft. in width
by 8 ft. 10 ins. long, provided with car.s.
At the other end of the foundry is the
cleaning room, adjacent to this is the
pickel room, both floors laid with con-
crete. Provision has been made for sani-
tary arrangements all through, but this
equipment is most generous in case of
the foundry, which has a large locker and
wash room.
Naturally the entire plant is heated and
ventilated by the Sturtevant system. Dis-
530
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
tribution of air is made through a sys-
tem of overhead galvanized iron piping
discharging downward to the floor. A
complete underground tunnel system is
provided for the distribution of steam,
electricity, compressed air, etc., and re-
turn of condensation.
and piston valve and the pj^ in. pump.
His instructions, which are free to B.
& M. enginemen, are much appreciated.
Frank Brackett's Models.
Mr. Frank Brackett, round house fore-
man of the B. & M., at Nashua, N. H.,
Mr. George F. Tinkham, for a num-
ber of years the engineer of the Upson
Nut Company, has, through native skill
and knowledge gained by correspondence
study, invented and patented a Hydro-
Carbon device for increasing the effi-
ciency of a brick furnace. It was de-
cided to determine by test the merits of
1
FIG. 1. MODEL ENGINE OPER.^TED BV AIR.
and a thorough mechanic as well, has
favored us with several photos of work-
ing models of which the above are re-
productions. These models are used by
his invention. Two of the seven boilers
of the plant were fitted with this device
and the others used mechanical stokers.
Mr. Tinkham wrote to the Americafl
FIG. 2. SECTIONAL MODEL OF SLIDE AND PISTON VALVES.
him in illustrating the valve morion of
slide and piston valves, their diseases
and remedies. They are of his own de-
sign and construction and he has spent
a great deal of time and money on them.
He uses air taken from the train line
of an engine as the motive power. Fig.
I is a complete engine for this purpose,
and Fig. 2 a sectional view of the slide
School of Correspondence, who suggest-
ed Mr. Carl S. Dow, chief of the Depart-
ment of Mechanical Engineering, as a
man best fitted to give an impartial
judgment in the matter. Upon this re-
quest Mr. Dow made the test. By
means of this device steam is taken
from the boiler and conducted through
the fire-brick setting to the furnace. It
COLD DRAWN
SEAHLESS STEEL
Locomotive
Boiler
Tubes
AND
Safe Ends
BOILER. TANK AND
STRUCTURAL RIVETS,
WIRE ROPE, SWITCH-
ING AND WRECKING
ROPES
Miller, Thornburgh& Co.
135-137 Broadway
New York, U. S. A.
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works :
SPRINGFIELD, VERMONT. U.S.A.
A^ B, Cand Liebe?-*8 Codevsed.
English Office: Room 6, Exchant,'e Building, Stephen-
son's Place. Biimingham. France and Sjiain : Ph. Bon-
villain, 6, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris, France. Germany,
Belgium, Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyeniann, Charlottenstrasse 112, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
Movembcr, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
531
f H.6.PETER5' ^
VCovXi \x\\.t.<«, Ovt«U\« OkC* v^o^xx o.<\«k.
CO.* <.5»»^"^>j \o»V«,aL it)Ci,< ■, V^«, o^v^ v<;a.>^
ifSvaXT 5>xyii!.-c\.ox'\X'>j tSktvAjt
».» aibio\iv.t«\.v» igu^'co.xv-
fttl. TK«. PA'CttXca
kA a,X\v) oXVvtv- XWClkV*
I'll stnl sa-w^V*
fo AXXUl V5Ve^c.«. VIA Wo.
x«.Ca,\\ a.^«.o.tV|-,
UNION ^v^De.
%xx s-H.5PETeRS-B.ue.i7i
Dover. , new dER*e^Y , ^- S. ^•
is claimcfl by (lie- iiivcnlor tli:it the ste.-im
is superheated and tlien broken up into
its elements, liydroKen and oxygen. This
supcrlieating is accomplished by the in-
tense heat of the incandescent firebrick
and by flowing from a ^-\n. pipe
through small holes j's in. in diameter.
According to his own statement, Mr.
Tinkham owes nearly all his knowledge
of the theory of engineering to his course
with the American School of Corres-
pondence, his boyhood schooling ending
when he was eleven years old, having no
other training but practical experience
until he took up correspondence work
.it the age of forty-five.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre, Pa.
The publication called Graphite is is-
sued by the Joseph Dixon Crucible Com-
pany, of Jersey City, N. J., in the in-
terest of their productions. The October
number is a very interesting issue, larger
than usual, as it contains somethinji
unique. The president pf the company
having photographs of nearly all of the
staflf of superintendents and salesmen
in his employ, sent them to the well
known phrenologists. Fowler and Wells,
of New York, with a request for a "read-
ing" of character of each. The names
of the men were not given to
the "bump readers," each photo-
graph having a number only. The
"readings" thus obtained were so
highly gratifying to President E. F. C.
Young that he had both photographs
and readings reproduced in the October
Graphite. Twenty-three names appear,
including that of Joseph Dixon, who
founded the company in 1827. This is-
sue of the Dixon paper will form a very
interesting study for persons who desire
to acquire the faculty of judging their
fellow men by their faces, or who would
like to do a little amateur "observing"
of the Sherlock Holmes order. Write
to the Dixon company; the paper can
he had for the asking.
An Hngllsh Spark Arrester.
One of the fortunate conditions of lo-
comotive operating enjoyed by locomotive
officials in the British Isles, has been that
they were not required to wrestle with
spark arresters. American locomotive
people had good reason to envy their for-
eign friends of exemption from one of the
most troublesome tasks in caring for lo-
comotives.
It appears that this exemption is to be
no longer enjoyed. Mr. Dugald Drum-
mond, the able chief mechanical engineer,
of the London and South-Western Rail-
way, has invented a spark arrester,
shown in the annexed engraving, and
has applied it to all the engines belong-
ing to the South-Western system. It
has also been applied to the express en-
gines of the Highland Railway, and will,
no doubt, force its way upon all British
The Pratt & Whitney Company, of
Hartford, Conn., have issued a catalogue
of small tools made by them. The sub-
title of the catalogue is "standards and
gauges." In the opening pages are illus-
trations, formulas and dimensions of
screw threads — the LT. S. Standard,
the metric system, the sharp V-
tliread, the Acme standard. the
Whitworth, and the British Asso-
ciation standard threads. The various
taps, hobs, adjustable and plain dies.
chasers, hollow mills, dies, milling cut-
ters, reamers, counter bores, drills,
straight edges, punches, gauges, etc., are
all catalogued and arranged with illustra-
tion, description and price. An index at
the end of the book enables the reader to
quickly find what he may be looking for
The catalogue is about 7x4'^ and 'S a
good specimen of the printer's art.
railways through the legal requirement
that railways, to escape fire claims,
must employ the best practicable means
for preventing spark throwing by loco-
motives.
The Drummond spark arrester consists
of a divided diaphragm plate secured to
the top of the exhaust pipe and extending
from above the upper row of tubes two-
thirds of the way towards the bottom of
the smoke box. No netting is employed
and the diaphragm appears to act as a
cleaner of the smoke box from cinders.
A representative of the Locomotive
Magazine, from which we copy the illus-
tration, investigated the action of the
spark arrester, and concluded that it im-
proved the steaming of the engine. This
would be due to the draft through all
row-s of tubes being equalized by the
diaphragm plate.
The engines have Mr. Drummond's ar-
rangement of water tubes in the fire box
which act as a partial spark arrester
themselves.
532
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
November, 1903.
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
AND
SIZE.
17 AND 21 BUBT
JEWKLS,
SAPPHIBE PAXLET8
BALL'S IMPROVED
SAFKTY
DOVBLE BOLLEB
Are without question
the finest watches that
Amt-rican talent and
ekilltd labor can pro-
duce, and they are giv-
ing Buch nniversal Bat-
Ififaction that we have
no hesitancy in claim-
ing that they are the
best and Bafest railroad
watch on the market.
Tests severe and numerous have proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Railroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for Information and facts.
■Write ns for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
The Ingcrsoll-Sergeant Drill Com-
pany, of New York, has ordered six
gondola cars, of 100,000 pounds capacity,
from the Pressed Steel Car Company,
Pittsburgh, Pa. These cars are to be
40 ft. over end sills and 9 ft. 10 ins. over
side stakes, and will be equipped with
Kelso steel couplers 5x7 ins,, wooden
drop ends, Westinghouse draft rigging,
pressed steel brake beams, arch bar
truck.s, gray iron journal boxes, M. C.
B. journal bearings and wedges, 700
pound wheels and pressed steel bolsters.
A WHITNEY
PLANER
with its eight feed rolls, pressure bars
to hold the work firmly, small diameter
of cut, and its freedom trom vibration
iiisur<fs the smoothest of planing.
BAXTER D. WHITNEY & SON
WINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
McGIlL BUILDING, WASHINGTON. 0. C.
Terms Reasonable. Pamphlet Sen*
Section 3 of the Catalogue of Interlock-
ing and Signaling devices, got out by the
Union Switch and Signal Company, of
Swissvale, Pa., has just been issued. This
number is devoted to mechanical locking
and operating devices, and with an index
it covers 132 pages. The book is uniform
with the other catalogues of this company,
and it is needless to say that it is fully
up to the high standard of excellence
which has always been maintained. The
line cuts are very clearly drawn and
plainly numbered, with name of part and
price on the opposite page. The half-
tones are equally good, and all being
printed on heavy white paper makes a
very satisfactory showing. It is, of
course, intended primarily for use in or-
dering parts, but a good idea of the lock-
ing and operating devices may be obtained
by a glance through its pages.
Mr. A. O. Norton, of 286 Congress
street, Boston, Mass., and Coaticoke,
Que., Canada, has issued a little folder
in which he reminds his friends that the
making of jacks is his only business,
and he therefore claims to know a good
deal about jacks. Years of experience,
labor-saving machinery, and first-class
material go to make up the "Norton"
jack.
Those using the Imperial Pneumatic
Hammers, made by the Rand Drill Conir
pany, 128 Broadway, New York, speak in
the highest terms of the convenience and
durability of the tools. They are con-
sidered particularly good tools for boiler
work, and are popular with the men using
them, which is a very good sign. Fore-
men boiler makers, general foremen and
others directly interested in having .good
working tools should send for the illus-
trated catalogue of these pneumatic tools.
H. K. Porter & Co., of Pittsburgh, Pa.,
has been awarded the contract for a six-
teen-ton locomotive to be used by the
government in the construction work at
the south pier of Superior entry. This
will be the second locomotive furnished
by the Pittsburgh concern, and it will
cost $2,750.
XMASisCOMING
A Book is an Acceptable
Present to give or receive
WE CAN GET YOU ANY
BOOK PUBLISHED
Look at Our List of Rail-
road and Engineering Books
ANGIS SINCLAIR CO.
174 Broadway, New York
CONTENTS.
PAGE.
A Floating Test Plant, P. J. Elkerson 497
Age o£ Specialists, The 487
Air Brake Department 507
Attempts to Improve Locomotive Valve
Motion 502
Boiler Washing and Firing. J. F. Roddy... 496
Books Reviewed 504
Boon, J. M., on Elastic Wheel Centers.... 495
Brackett's (Frank) Models 530
Break-Downs, by Jos. A. Baker 505
Canadian Westinghouse Company, Ltd.,
Organized 520
Commonwealth Steel Company 514
Economy of the Gas Engine 515
Efficient Round House Smoke Jack, P. &
L. E 493'
English Spark Arrester, A 631
European Railway Doings 514
General Correspondence 495
Gifts to Cornell University 506
Grand Chief Engineer Stone 520
Growth of the Locomotive, by Angus Sin-
clair 489
Inevitable and Preventable Heat Losses 503
J. A. Fay & Egan Co., Cincinnati 528
Johnson, Lucius E 521
Knows How to Treat Employees 521
Locomotives:
Fast Passenger, 4-6-2, for C. S., P. M.
& 0 494
A Suburban P. & R 600
Engine of a Trans-Mississippi Shop 501
Baldwin 2-10-3 for the Santa Fe 613
Cross Compound Mogul. Grand Trunk 523
Mechanical Work Active on the Pennsyl-
vania System 521
Names of the States 622
New Klondyke Railroad 523
N. Y. Railroad Club, September Meeting.. 488
Obituary, R. H. Thurston 628
Old-Tlme Railroad Reminiscences, S. J.
Kidder 498
One Way of Measuring Horse Power 516
Origin of the Cupped Side Sheet 493
Percy's Shoe and Wedge Holder 496
Personals 519
Questions Answered 504
Reality of a Practical Opinion. A. O. Brook-
side 497
Signals and Signalling, by Geo. S. Hodgins. 517
Steam Turbines tor Factory Driving 512
Steel-Frame. Side-Door Cars, I. C. R 524
Stock Investing by Employees 503
Sturtevant, B. F., Co., Foundry and Pat-
tern Department 529
The Third Man 521
Tired Locomotives 512
To Make Brazing Snider 494
Water Softening on the Pennsylvania Lines. 501
Weather-Proof Windows 523
Winchell, Benjamin L 522
Words, Words, Words 625
Railway ..and
lOcomotive
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co. — 1903
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock
Vol. XVI.
174 Broadway, New York, December, 1903
No. 12
Scenes in Alaska.
Tlie recent decision of the controversy
between the United States and Canada
concerning boundaries in Alaska, has
excited unusual interest in the region
which bears that name. We therefore
consider it seasonable to publish some
pictures of Alaska which have been wait-
ing in this office for months. The views
of Skagway and the neighborhood pos-
Sam made a poor bargain, until guM
was discovered in the territory about
ten years ago, which changed conditions
amazingly and moved Canada to stretch
forth a searching hand for territory that
nobody had previously displayed any in-
terest in.
This part of the American coast was
"discovered" in 1741 by a Russian expe-
dition under Admiral Bering, who gave
lied forth to take possession, but was
kicked out by the constable.
Bering was no more modest. Like the
spoils politician he claimed everything
in sight and much beyond the vision of
his crew, even along to the coast of
Mexico. Bering's enterprise gave Russia
the excuse for sending some officials to
rule Alaska, but it did nothing to develop
the country, for in 1880 there were less
ROTARY SNOW SHOVEL .AT WORK IX .\I..\SK.\
sess unusual interest, since that is terri-
tory which Canada claimed and which
the Alaskan Boundary Commission de-
cided belonged to the United States. The
railway scenes shown indicate that
Alaska is a hard road for railroads to
find location.
Alaska was purchased from Russia by
the United States in 1867 for $7,200,000.
People generally considered that Uncle
his name to the straits between America
and Asia. The discovery was like that
of a Scots toper who wandered in his
cups to the top of a hill and went to
sleep. In the morning he awoke and
saw his peaceful native village reposing
in the valley. After looking at the place
for a few minutes without recognizing
it he exclaimed: "I've found a toon
that naebody kens aboot." Then he sal-
than 500 white men in the territory. The
gold fever, however, soon swelled that
type of population, and it is estimated
that there are now about 60,000 whites
in Alaska.
The following article taken from the
.Vfti' York Tribune gives a good picture
of the existing conditions in Alaska:
Any one who. has visited the part of
Alaska that has been in dispute has soon
534
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
discovered that it was characteristically
American. Here he found only another
form of the same Americanism which
penetrated the wilderness of the prairie
of the United States a half century ago
and built cities where the buffalo
roamed.
there would be a fight. A squad of
mounted Canadian police moved their
headquarters to White Pass, within the
disputed territory, and raised the British
fiag. As soon as the news reached Skag-
way a crowd of men gathered as rapidly
as they do in Kentucky when the law is
SNOWBOUND IN ALASK.\,
In Skagway, at the head of the Lynn
Canal, and now the metropolis of this
district, there are even tokens of the
civilization of far away New York. There
is another Broadway, and although not
walled up with skyscraping office build-
ings nor perforated with a subway, yet
in Skagway, as in Manhattan. Broadway
is Broadway.
When the thick gold streaks of the At-
lin district were discovered, just over
the border line, the wideawake citizens
of Skagway were the first to pounce
down on them. They hustled across
White Pass and staked out the best
claims. After a time came the Canadian
officials, with the demand that the Ameri-
can miners should become Canadian citi-
zens. There was hardly a man who did
not refuse.
"The flag is better than gold," was a
saying which was heard on every hand.
So most of the miners went back to
Skagway and sought to make their for-
tunes in various lines of trade and man-
ufacture. But soon there was another
bit of news which frightened the more
timorous.
"Canada is After Skagway," was the
headline of one weekly newspaper's ar-
ticle, and it went on to say that the Do-
minion had revived its old claim to this
territory. The sister town of Dyea also
took alarm, for it, too, was within the
disputed territory. A few emigrated to
where the Stars and Stripes floated with-
out danger of being supplanted by the
Union Jack. But the majority simply
waited for "something to turn up."
For a time, indeed, things looked
ominous. The rougher element said
"too slow," and as soon as their horses
could reach White Pass the British flag
was torn down and the Stars and Stripes
floated in its place. Then the police
hoisted another British flag, and again
of empire lloated there all summer un-
disturbed.
Another evidence that the disputed
land must always be American, although
the point was not brought out before
the arbitration tribunal, is the rough
and ready humor which characterizes its
inhabitants. It has the same ring as the
jokes of the Texas cattleman or the
Montana miner. A Canadian would not
think of such an advertisement, for ex-
ample, as that of the "South Dough
Hotel." Among some of the induce-
ments to patrons of this hostelry are
the following:
"Crap, chuck luck, stud poker and
black jack games run by the manage-
ment." "Special rates for ministers and
the gambling perfesh." "Every known
fluid, water excepted, sold here." "Dogs
bought and sold." "Insect powder for
sale at the bar." "Indians and niggers
charged double." "Board, $2 a square
foot. Meals extra." "Spiked boots'
must be removed at night." "Any one
troubled with nightmare will find a hal-
ter hitched to the bed post." "If the
room gets too warm just open the win-
dow and let the fire escape." "All ballists
desiring practice will find a pitcher on
the stand." "The hotel is convenient to
ail cemeteries." "If the lamp goes Oiit
take a feather from the pillow and that
will be light enough." "If you are fond
of athletics lift up the mattress and
watch the bed spring."
ROUNDING RllCKV I'DINT, .'il.ArtKA. ^.•7,.i' ;:SL3
a posse of Skagway citizens started out
to pull it down. There might have been
blood spilled had not prominent Ameri-
cans interfered. At last the Skagwayans
went to a higher peak and unfurled a still
larger American flag The two emblems
Another hostelry built up a large and
flourishing business by issuing circulars
which bore this legend: "The moun-
tameers' saloon; finest, largest and quick-
est line of liquors in the American pos-
sessions. It's where the jolly good fel-
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
535
lows hang out. Come here if you want
to meet the boys."
A steam laundry which was estab-
lished while the city was still roofed
with canvas put out a sign which read:
"All kinds of washing done while you
wait. Clothes guaranteed to fit after
washing. Don't conic if you want to kill
anything."
Although there is a block on the east
side which pos.sessed a city full of peo-
ple, but never a bathtub, the towns with-
in the disputed Alaskan territory have
long been used to such luxurious inven-
tions. There was a plumber of Dyea in
its palmiest days who made a small for-
tune in the plumbing business and whose
cards read:
"Will fix you out with a porcelain-
lined tub for the most reasonable rates.
A bath in one of my tubs is better than
a whole winter without one."
A Blistered Crown Sheet.
BY SHANDY MAGUIRE.
George Morgan is a locomotive en-
gineer, employed by the D. R. & F.
Railroad, and as good a man as the com-
pany has upon its pay rolls. His habits
are excellent, he being an absolute tee-
totaler, reticent in speech, very attentive
to his duties, and one who treats every
one with respect. He has a good pas-
senger run, being entitled to it by right
of seniority, and giving good satisfac-
tion. He has a wife and two children, of
whom he is justly proud, and always at
home with them when off duty.
There was considerable jealousy on
the part of three or four men manifested
toward him on account of an engine as-
signed to his trains, for which he was in
no way responsible. The engine was a
four-wheel connected, and about 185^x24
in. cylinders. The engine that George
had being only 18 ins. diameter, with
nothing to spare in power, the M. M.
put the iSyi in. on the runs, which he
knew would fill the bill. When "631" —
the 18}^ in. — was shopped, she was in
charge of Dick Jones, on through
freight, and was taken in for a generaf
overhauling, including a new fire bo.x
Jones calculated on getting "631" back
when she came out of the shop, but
rumors were flying about that George
Morgan would be the lucky one.
Dick Jones was as fine a worker as
there was on the whole system — -with his
mouth. He was not only an agitator in
the roundhouse, and out on the sidings,
but also a perpetual talker in the lodge
room of his order. He was steadily
around with the dark-lantern of corpora-
tion hatred, looking for grievances
against the company. He would occupy
more time in the meetings discussing
them than all the other members com-
bined. When he gave case after case to
the committee to redress, and when its
members paid no attention to them, he
denounced the organization, although it
succeeded twice in getting him rein-
stated, once for drunkenness and once
for carelessness. AH the friends he had
were soreheads of his own stripe, very
few in number, the curse of the road;
but endured because they managed to
keep barely within the border Hue mark-
ing duly from devil-may-care, and the
cameraderic existing between men of the
one occupation, who abhorred tell-tales
or informers.
Jones satisfied himself that "631," thi-n
in the boiler shop, was to be given to
Morgan, and his hatred of him was in-
tensified. When he was restored to duty.
and the scowl deepened upon his face as
he said to his fireman: "Morgan played
his cards good with the M. M. to get
'631,' but may be she'll be his colTin."
The engine had been on the run about
five months, giving the very best satis-
faction to all concerned, and looking as
slick as when she left the shop, owing
to the feeling of mutual fellowship, and
exertions to please each other, existing
between George and Tom Crosby, his
fireman. One morning thereabouts
Morgan was not called, but from habit
he awoke and got ready to go on duty,
as usual, supposing something had hap-
pened to the caller.
SK.\G\V.\Y, .\LASKA.
after being expelled for drunkenness, the
lodge assigned George Morgan, on ac-
count of him being a teetotaler, to ad-
minister a severe rebuke, which he did.
in chaste language, but which had no
more effect on him than to make him a
deadly enemy of Morgan's.
In due time engine "631," in all the
splendor of regulation color, came out
of the shop, and while being broken in
Morgan was permitted to remain with
her, putting on the finishing touches
here and there that only an engineer
knows, ere taking the run. One day, on
a siding, a few miles out, doctoring a
hot journal, Dick Tones passed them.
"I wonder what is the matter, George,
that the caller did not come after you
this morning?" said his wife, as he was
preparing to take a brief leave of her-
self and his seven-year-old boy, who was
always up to give him "a big hug" be-
fore parting.
"I don't know, Mary; it is some trivial
reason. Good bye, dear. Good bye,
Georgie; be sure you come to meet me
to-night to carry home my pail," and
he was gone.
He saw Engine 528 where 631 ought
to have been when he got to the yard.
'What's up. Jim?" he asked, as he got
alongside Jim Eggleston, oiling round.
536
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1003.
"There is something the matter in
'631's' fire box. They could not send
her out and they called me."
"What is it, Jim?"
"I didn't hear. She had to be
dumped."
George went to the engine house. He
did not feel altogether at ease, yet he
knew of nothing the matter when he left
the night before.
When he got there he asked Jack"
Daley, the night hostler, why had 631 to
be dumped.
"She was leaking in her crown-sheet
in one or two places. Tim Reilly sent
for Jack McGraw and he ordered her
dumped."
"How did it happen. Jack?"
"I don't know. George. They say
you brought her in so."
run than yesterday. The engine steame'l
remarkably free. I never had less than
a glass two-thirds full of water, and it
was water that had direct connection
with the boiler, for I blowed out the
glass and kept the cock open sufficiently
long to clean it thoroughly; so long, that
Tom asked me if I found a new blow-off
cock. On account of my wife's ailing, I
got ofT the last few nights in the upper
yard, and let Tom run her down, but
the last thing I did every night as well
as the first in the morning, was to try
my gauge cocks, and I left her full al-
ways before getting off, so that water
would not be required before I'd come
back in the morning. Jack or Tom can
tell you so."
"Did you look in the fire box before
getting off last night?"
GATEWAY TO THE YUKON, .4I.ASKA.
"What?" said Morgan, with a sharp
sound as if of astonishment. Jack made
no reply, and the roundhouse foreman
coming in sight, he went directly to him
to get some information.
"Mr. Cool, please tell me what is the'
matter with 631," he said, when they
met.
"That is information I would like to
get from you, George. A few minutes
after you left her on the pit last night
the hostler found a sharp stream run-
ning from a bulge in her crown sheet.
He called back your fireman and showed
it to him and then reported it to me. I
sent for Jack McGraw, who pronounced
it a blister, and ordered her dumped.
What do you know?"
"Mr. Cool. I never had a smoother
"No, sir. I have an understanding
with my fireman; when he gets around
ahead of me, he is to look critically
everywhere around the fire box, and to
do the same before leaving at night. I
am always the last oflf nights, except re-
cently, for the reason I told you."
"Well, George, I am very sorry for
j'OU, as well as for the loss of the en-
gine. I would not charge you witli
neglecting your water or by being fooled
by a shut-off water glass. A man daily
running the one engine cannot be easily
fooled that way, but the fact remains
that the engine is blistered in four places
in the crown sheet, leaking badly out of
one of them, and all requiring to be
horsed back and screw-patched."
"Mv God! Mr. Cool, this is terrible!"
"Yes, George, it is. Mr. Wilson wants
you at his office at 10 o'clock, and also
your fireman."
Morgan and Crosby were in the
M. M.'s office at the appointed time, and
to give in detail what was said would
be but a repetition of the foregoing.
Wilson was a friend of Morgan. He
prized him for his manly habits, his up-
right life, and attention to duty. He
made a rigorous search for evidence,
internally wishing to find some clue to
the matter other than to charge the en-
gineer with it, but no use, as the prompt
discovery of it by the hostler, and his
report of the same to Tim Reilly, the
night boss, gave no show. He knew the
rules regarding the slightest trouble
with an engine on account of shortage
of water was a discharge out and out,
;ind no reopening of the question. When-
he submitted his report to Mr. James
Brown, the superintendent of motive
power, the order came back to dis-
charge George Morgan. Poor fellow!
he felt his position keenly. He walked"
homeward in a dazed sort of a way, and*"
when approaching his house little
Georgie spied him and ran to carry
home his pail.
"What is de matter, papa; you looks
sick?"
"Oh, nothing, Georgie. How is
mamma?"
"She is sick, too, papa."
George knew it but too well, and
when he entered the house she raised
herself on her elbow from the couch,
took a sharp glance at him and said:
"Oh, George! Something terrible has
happened."
His reply was a big gulping sob, and
when he saw the beautiful, guileless face
of his boyhood's devotion pinched, pale-
and wrinkled with sickness, he broke
completely down, for if she showed no
improvement he had intended to have
her moved to a more salubrious clime-
for the winter, but with the loss of his
job, the thing was impossible.
He broke the news to her as gently
as he possibly could, but he could not
disguise his breaking heart from her
loving eyes. She became the consoler,
pouring out words of hope and resigna-
tion with the fluency of a gifted being,
and proving to the desponding fellow
that on God's footstool there is not a.
nobler mortal than a good, pure and af-
fectionate wife.
The lodge took it up for discussion
Much sympathy was e.xpressed for
George, who was a listener, but the mat-
ter was cut short by Dick Jones calling
for the enforcement of the law. This
was a brutal thrust. It brought several
members to their feet, who roundly be-
rated him for his brutality in the pres-
ence of poor Morgan. The law was ex-
pulsion for the burning of an engine.,
and in due time was enforced.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
537
The M. M., in reporting the matter
to the M. of M. P., later on, influenced
him so in Morgan's favor that he offered
him a position as assistant road foreman
of engines. George thankfully refused,
knowing but too well that a man with his
record never could fill the position in a
satisfactory way.
Whether it was from the exercise of
will over ailment or not, Mary Morgan
began to show signs of convalescence.
George got a helper's job in the boiler
shop. He knew there was no use any
more in him thinking he could get a
locomotive to run. so he devoted him-
self to his new duties, hoping to get
higher at the business so as to get more
pay, for his family's sake. He made the
acquaintance of Jim McNeill, a helper
like himself. Jim took a liking to him
and did everything he could to show
George how to take advantage of hand-
ling the tools, so as to make the work
light. Jim was a good-hearted
fellow, only too good every pay
night — for with a few boon
companions he let the wages
he got fly. George did all he
could to get Jim to quit drink-
ing, but didn't make much
progress.
In the course of a few days
after "631" was shopped she
was out again, with two screw-
patches on her crown sheet and
two blisters horsed back. Jim
Eggleston had her on Morgan'.s
old run, but to his credit, be it
said, he would rather see Mor-
gan back, if it were possible.
About three months after
Morgan went to work in the
boiler shop Jim McNeill got
arrested for drunkenness and ^,
fighting. George heard of it. IW
and made every effort he could
to get him out for the night,
and to appear in the morning,
and was successful. George passed his
word of honor to the magistrate he
would produce Jim at 9 next morning,
to answer to the charge, so he did
not go to work, but accompanied him
to court, sitting by him in the dock.
The charge was assault and battery upon
the person of one Richard Jones, ano
through the non-appearance of the com-
plainant Jim was discharged. On their
way home George took up the old sub-
ject of reformation with Jim. and had
an attentive listener. George, noticing
him in deep thought, contrary to his
laughing, devil-may-care way, supposed
he was making an impression, and work-
ed the harder.
Jim stopped abruptly when George
ended his appeal to him to quit drink-
ing, and looked him squarely in the face,
saying: "George, I love you. You can
work as a helper in a boiler shop and
still be a gentleman. You are a friend
to everyljody. It was for thumping
Jones for accusing you behind your back
when he was full of Mother Hurley's
tangle-foot that I got pulled. I knew he
wouldn't appear against me this morn-
ing. He knows better. Patsey Miles,
the little rivet heater, who was killed,
told me a story of Jones getting him to
go into the dome, when 631 was in ior
the new fire box, and lay three pieces of
iron, which he gave him. on the crown
sheet, between the crown bars. He told
Patsey that it would make her carry
water better. He did it, supposing Jones
was to have the engine again, but later
on, when Jones got left, he told me
about it, and Jones knows 1 know it.
You know how water scales, and you
know how quick blisters will form when
anything is on the crown sheet. I'd
have told you long ago, but I did not
know how good a fellow you were."
tivc engineer he knew the enormity of,
he wired his M. M. to have the engine
cool by 2 the next P. M. for inspection,
and invited Morgan to accompany him
back, as he was going out to inspect the
system. George was elated. Next day
the upright pipe was taken out and four
flat pieces of iron, scale covered, about
I4x4xf^ ins., were found just over the
screw-patches by the man who went into
the dome. When Mr. Brown saw them
he said to the M. M.: "Mr. Williams,
restore George Morgan to his old run.
Pay him the wages he lost by this damn-
able rascality. Discharge Jones, and if
you can find witnesses to convict, have
him arrested on the charge of destroy-
ing company's property. George, I
congratulate you. Such men as you can-
not be very well dispensed with on our
railroads."
"I thank you, Mr. Brown; that't all
I can say. but your kind heart can tell
^W.
.\:,u LuCu.MuTiM-; Toil on mui nt.\in gr.\de.
"For God's sake, Jim, are you telling
me the truth?"
"My words can be proven. Have the
crown-sheet examined."
Morgan saw a ray of hope. He ran
home to his wife, who, with the eyes of
love, read good news in his face.
He had no committee at his back now
to take the matter up, on newly discov-
ered evidence, so he advised with the
M. M., who counseled him to go direct
to Lansing, and lay the matter before
the master of motive power, furnishing
him with a pass.
"God speed you, George," said his
wife, as herself, little Georgie and curley-
headed little three-year-old Carrie bade
him good by at the door.
Mr. Brown heard the request that en-
gine 631 be examined on the crown
sheet, and he himself, graduating from
the cab, knowing the charge Morgan
was let out on. one which as a locomo-
how mine feels. I made the mistake of
not examining the crown sheet night
and morning. Had I done so I'd have
got on to the blisters when they were
first making, but Poor Mary" — and
he broke away to get to where his heart
was tabernacled, with the good news.
There are some things concerning the
action of steam in engine cylinders that
are really rather mysterious, there are
cases in which the immutable laws of
nature seem to be violated. When steani
goes into a vessel having as high tem-
perature as itself natural reasoning would
say there can be no condensation. Yet
enormous condensation takes place in the
carefully steam jacketed high pressure
cylinder of a triple-expansion engine.
There is no dispute about this being the
case, but both science and experiments
t.iil to account for it.
518
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December. 1903.
A Water-Tube Locomotive Boiler.
-The annoyance and trouble experi-
enced on railroads from the stayed sur-
faces of the fire-box has led Mr. J. M.
McClellon, of Everett, Mass., to design a
water-tube locomotive boiler shown in the
accompanying figures. He states that one
of his objects is to provide a boil-
er having a greater heating surface and
larger flue area than locomotives of the
ordinary construction have, and also
one having a fire-box entirely free from
stay-bolts or stayed surfaces.
The boiler shell is substantially rec-
tangular. The opposite spaces of this
tube between the shells which must act
as a stay. The tubes are expanded into
the shell in the ordinary manner, and
may, if desired, be provided with cor-
rugations near one end to provide for
unequal expansion. The ends of the
tubes are closed by caps. While the flat
surfaces of these shells are stayed, the
method of staying them is an advance
over the use of stay-bolts, and in addi-
tion, the surfaces of these shells are
never brought into direct contact with
the intense heat found in a fire-box.
The distance between the two shells on
the two upper sides is greater than on
bottom, which is perforated to allow the
free passage of steam from the boiler
into the drum. The water line is carried'
a little below the upper angle of the in-
ner drum. In this way sufficient heat is
transmitted to the steam above the
water-line to partly superheat it. The
throttle valve is placed in the forward'
end of the drum, to gain steam space by
reducing the length of the dry pipe. The
outer shell is prolonged to form a
smoke-box. At the very bottom of the
smoke passage through the boiler, a
small opening is left between the tubes,
through which a steam jet blower may
3 [
sliCTION OF McCLE:I<LON WATER-TUBE BOILER.
shell are connected by water-tubes, al-
ternate courses of which cross one an-
other at right angles. As the rectangular
boiler is set with its diagonal in a verti-
cal line, the tubes all stand at an angle
of 45°, which contributes to rapid circu-
lation and free steaming.
To avoid the necessity of carrying a
large stock of various sized tubes, the
inventor has made all his tubes of the
same length. The tubes are 3 inches
outside diameter, No. 12 gauge, and are
upset to 3-16 ins. where they pass
through the shell plates. This facilitates
their insertion, and also gives them suf-
ficient strength in that portion of the
the two lower sides, in order to allow
the steam and water to separate and the
water to circulate downward, while the
steam passes upward to the steam drum.
The inner shell is welded so that no
difficulty w'ill be experienced from a
leakage of steam in an inaccessible part
of the boiler. The outer shell is made
of four plates, with a lap joint at each
\)f the three corners. These may be
readily riveted or caulked in case of
leakage. At the top the outer plates are
flared outward and riveted to the steam
drum, which runs the entire length of
the boiler. This drum is held in place
by a flat stay-plate, riveted across its
be inserted the entire length of the
boiler, if necessary to blow out any soot
which may collect in this chamber.
The sides of the fire-box are made of
straight seamless drawn tubes, 3 ins.
in diameter inside, and 4 ins. square
outside. The tubes, when placed side by
side, present a substantially smooth sur-
face next the fire. Tubes are secured to
one another by steel dove-tailed keys,
driven into corresponding grooves cut
in the tubes. A thin copper caulking
strip or sheet is inserted between the
tubes. A portion of the caulking strips
may be left out to admit air between
the tubes over the fire, as is sometimes
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
539
desired. Tlie shell extends back over
the fire-box the full length of the grate,
but is cut away and riveted to the ends
of these vertical tubes. Both the for-
ward and back ends of the fire-box are
built up in the same manner as the
sides. The lower ends of these vertical
tubes are fastened by thimbles to hori-
zontal headers made of the same kind of
tubing. This gives sufficient metal in
the horizontal tubes to withstand burst-
ing pressure.
By taking out plugs opposite each end
of any of these headers, the headers may
be easily cleaned and inspected. Over
the fire-box are headers of the same
kind of tubing with square outside, intD
which arc expanded short tubes lead-
ing from the header to the shell, where
they are fastened in the manner already
described. Sufficient space is allowed
between each header and the adjacent
tubes for the gases to rise and heat the
water-tubes in this part of the boiler. A
fire brick arch is used.
In the construction under considera-
tion, by reason of the continuity of
metal around the tubes, if a film of
steam forms next the fire, the heat will
still be transmitted around the tubes to
the water on all sides, thus preventing
the overheating of the metal of the
tubes.
By setting the rectangular boiler, as
shown in the drawings, it is possible to
mount it over go-in. driving wheels, and
yet have its over-all dimensions within
the limits ordinarily prescribed. By
using a fire-box 74 ins. wide and making
the boiler 3 ft. longer, the heating sur-
face may be easily increased to about
7,500 sq. ft. The-boile> does not neces-
sitate any radical change in the construc-
tion of the locomotive frame, except
that the saddle must be V-shaped on the
top, instead of circular. The lower
headers of the fire-box will rest directly
upon the main frame.
The "boiler was patented October 13.
1903, by Mr. James M. McClennon,
Everett, Mass., and his claims have been
allowed on the fire-hox construction.
Swindling Would>Be Railroad Men.
A dispatch from Washington reads:
"Postmaster-General Payne to-day is-
sued an order denying the use of the
mails to the National Railroad School
of St. Louis, H. L. Mebegar manager,
for operating a scheme to defraud. Me-
begar advertised in newspapers through-
out the country for railroad engineers,
firemen, brakemen and conductors, "no
experience required, positions secured,
free transportation to place of business."
To those who remitted the necessary
$S for a complete two weeks' course at
the National Railroad School, Mebegar
sent a pamphlet of fifteen pages and a
circular saying that if the prospective
railroad man applied himself diligently,
he could become proficient in the two
weeks mentioned.
An investigation by the Post Office
Department disclosed the fact that the
president, secretary, business manager.
BACK SHEET
AND SECTION
WAIST.
THROUGH
correspondence division, circulation di-
vision, thirty expert teachers and twenty-
seven assistants were all embodied in the
SECTION THROI^GH FIRE BOX.
person of Mebegar. It is not known
just how much Mebegar took in during
the time the scheme was operated, but
he is now considered wealthy, while a
few months ago he was poor.
It seems passing strange to us that
there was no public prosecutor in St.
Louis ready to perform the duty of
prosecuting Mebegar for swindlmg. He
ought to be doing the lockstcp along
with other rogues.
A Speaking Example.
Mr. M. E. Ingalls, president of the
"Big Four" Railway Company, and ont
of the prominent men of the West, tells
the following amusing story, says the
Saturday Evening Post, in connection with
his experiences as a school teacher years
ago in Zanesville, Ohio.
"It was then the custom, of a Friday
afternoon, to have some man of quality
address the pupils — such 'talks' from men
of affairs being deemed of great im-
portance to the children. Often the
speaker sought to point a moral, as was
the case in the instance I relate.
"One afternoon the pupils were held
for over an hour by the long, prosy talk
of an eminent gentleman from Xenia.
In the course of this gentleman's re-
marks he drew an awful picture of a
youth drifting to ruin. Said he: 'I knew
a boy once that disobeyed his parents;
played truant from school, went fishing
on Sundays, learned to smoke, to swear
and' (with a most impressive tone) 'to
play cards! Later, this vicious lad actu-
ally ran away from his comfortable
home. Falling into the hands of most
depraved companions he went from
bad to worse. And now, children,
concluded the speaker, in a most sepul-
chral voice, 'where do you suppose that
boy is now?'
"Whereupon the children, who, I re-
gret to say, had paid but scant attention
to the great man's remarks, shouted with
one voice the usual answer in response
to the question they heard every Friday
afternoon:
"'He stands before us!'"
A Volcanic Railway.
There are a great many people in the
world who enjoy doing what they or
others regard as dangerous, and a rail-
way has been built up the side of Mount
Vesuvius, for the purpose of giving these
people an opportunity to enjoy themselves
and incidentally to put money into the
pockets of the people who operate the rail-
way.
This road runs from the end of a car-
riage road at the foot of the mountain
and the upper terminus is about 1.000 feet
from the crater. The road is of the mono-
rail type, the car wheels run on a central
rail and the body of the car is balanced
on it, half being on either side. The car
is taken up and down by means of a
cable which is moved by steam power, and
the "grip" is adjusted by the movement
of a wheel, like the steering gear of a
ship.
540
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
The road is built over masses of lava,
and sometimes the upper end of the line
is so hot that the rails cannot be touched
by the naked hand. The rails are often
thrown out of adjustment by cracks open-
ing in the side of the mountain. Once
or twice streams of lava have destroyed
portions of the line. Showers of cinders
constantly fall upon the observatory, and
the power house, which would most cer-
tainly be burned up if they were not made
of fire-proof materials. Smoke from the
crater is often so dense and so heavily
charged with sulphur that employees
and passengers have to cover their faces
while passing through it. Fortunately for
travelers on the mountain side, the wind
shifts constantly and the "smoke periods"
are not of long duration.
Great care is taken in operating the
road. The railway office at thebase is con-
Consolidation for the Inverness
Railway and Coal Company.
The Canadian Locomotive Company,
of Kingston, Ont., has recently turned
out some simple consolidation engines
for the Inverness RaiK^ay & Coal Com-
pany, a road which operates on Cape
Breton Island. The cylinders are 19x24
ins. and the driving wheels are 50 ins.
in diameter. The pistons drive on the
third pair, the second or intermediate
wheels are not flanged. With 180 lbs.
boiler pressure the calculated tractive
eflort is about 26,500 lbs. The weight
on the drivers is 124.000 lbs., so that the
ratio of tractive power to adhesive weight
is as I is to 4.67. The valves are of the
ordinary I>-slide type and the motion is
indirect.
The boiler is of the Belpaire type and
height, 14 ft. S'A ins.; healing surface, fire bcx,
140 24 sq. ft ; tubes, 1.691 sq. ft.: total, 1,831,24
sq. It.; working pressure of boiler, iSo lbs.;
number of tubes, 2,0 lbs. ; diam. of tubes, 2 ins.;
length of tubes, 13 ft. o in.
Tender— Weight of tender, loaded. 96.000 lbs.; cap.
of tank in imp. gals., 4.000 lbs, : coal cnp..S tons.
To Solder Aluminum
A patent has been granted by the
United States on a solder for aluminum
which consists of aluminum 5 parts, an-
timony 5 parts and zinc 90 parts. To
make it harder a little more antimony
and a little less zinc is used. The alumi-
num is first melted, the zinc is then
added and when this is melted the anti-
mony is added. Salammoniac is used
as a flux. When the surface is quite
clear and white, it should be poured into
sticks ready for use, the cinder being
first removed.
CONS0LID.\TION FOR THE INVERNESS RAILW.W AND COAL COMPANY.
nected by telegraph and telephone wires
with the observatory where instruments
are placed which indicate any possibile
disturbance, and when the outlook is un-
favorable notice is sent down and traffic
is suspended. All the upper region above
vegetation is considered to be the danger
zone, and it is honey-combed with holes
of all sizes from which pour steam and
gas, and from which at any moment
molten lava may boil forth.
The railway was built by a British
tourist firm, but it is said to be largely
patronized by Americans.
There are quiet victories and strug-
gles, great sacrifices of self, and noble
acts of heroism done every day in nooks
and corners, and in little households, and
in men's and women's hearts. — Battle of
Life.
is 6oJ4 ins. at the smoke box end. The
total heating surface is 1,831.24 sq. ft.; ol
this the tubes contain 1,691 sq. ft., are
each 13 ft. long and there are 250 of
them.
The tender has the ordinary U-shaped
tank with a capacity of 4,000 Imperial
gallons. This is equal to 4.366 U. S.
gallons. The weight of the tender loaded
is 96,000 lbs. The total weight of engine
and tender is about 140,500 lbs. The
whole machine is well proportioned and
presents a neat and trim appearance.
We are indebted to Mr. H. Tandy, su-
perintendent of the locomotive works,
for the photograph from which our illus-
tration is made. A few of the principal
dimensions are apended:
Weight in working order, drivers, 124,000 lbs ;
total, 140.500 lbs.; wheel base of engine, rigid.
14 ft. 10 J^ ins ; total, 22 ft. 6'A ins. : and tender,
.SO ft. l,% ins.; length over all, engine and ten-
der, about 59 ft. 5 ins.; width, 10 ft. o in.;
Travelers who prefer land transit to
that of rolling on the briny deep may
now make the journey from Peking to
Paris by raih The trip gives people
plenty of time to see the country, for in
China the highest train speed is about
twenty miles an hour, and the trains do
not move at night. Passing through
Russia the speed is accelerated to about
twenty-five miles an hour, and the trains
are run at night. We should like to look
upon the strange civilization that is set-
tled on the banks of the Yellow Sea; we
should like to travel through Siberia in
summer, the grave of so many ambitions,
and we might endure the dreary steppes
traversed in Russia by the Siberian rail-
way, but we think on the whole when we
are making the grand tour of the globe
that we will take a steamer from Hong
Kong through the Suez Canal to Lon-
don.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
S4i
General Correspondence.
Wllmarth Hngines.
At page 451 of your last issue is men-
tioned Seth Wilmarlh engines, also re-
quest is made for more information re-
garding them. In the early fifties a
number of Seth Wihnarth engines were
put in service on Delaware Division of
Erie R. R. These engines were of
American type, inside connected, had big
brass pumps and branch pipes, and heavy
brass dome covers. They were mam-
fire box, which is supported by an out-
side frame surrounding the driving
wheels, which, however, have only inside
bearings. The trailing axle is entirely
free geared, and having no pin nor
radial axle boxes it is controlled only by
the spring pressure. This engine is the
first "air cutter" of Germany, with coni-
cal smoke box cover and prow-shaped
front sheet of cab.
No. 2 has already been shown in thii
The cylinders arc inside and much in-
clined, high pressure with flat valve, low
pressure yith piston valve. The boiler
is wagon-top with broad fire box and
very long smoke box. M. Riciiter.
Bingen, Germany.
FIRST ATLANTIC-TYPE E.NC.INE IN GERMANY.
moths by the side of the old engines. In journal, on page 421, October, 1900, but
1858 one of these engines was made into in quite another shape. It had been
a coal burner and run on the Susque- built by Krauss, Munich, for the Paris
hanna Division by Capt. Lork. During Exposition, 1900, and received there the
the scarcity of engines in winter of 1863 "Grand Prix" for its novel features,
and 1864, one of these Wilmarth engines,
the 168, at different times, with the un-
dersigned at the throttle, hauled every
regular time card train and many extras
on the Susquehanna Division, without
breaking more than an occasional
spring or spring hanger. They were
good engines in every respect. There
must be men, at Susquehanna or Port
Jervis, that can give more correct infor-
mation about the said engines.
C. M. She..\fe.
Montreal.
An Answer to Ouestion No. 63.
In answer to Question 63 in October
issue by a correspondent from Australia,
his trouble lies in a poorly balanced
throttle valve. When the throttle is
closed the boiler pressure has a very de-
cided tendency to hold it closed, but
when lever is pulled back to short cut-
off and throttle is opened wide enough
to get boiler pressure in dry pipe, it has
a very decided tendency to come open
quick enough to throw you back into ihi
tank if you are holding on to it. The
reason it does not do this when engine
is working full stroke is because the en-
gine is using the steam as fast as it
comes into steam pipe and does not run
up to boiler pressure. I am using one
of the same breed of cats and know how
to sympathize with ydur correspondent.
Locomotive Runner.
Calesburg, III.
Community of Interest.
The origin of all community of inter-
est is to be found in a common posses-
sion of the inherent principles of human
Atlantic Type Locomotives in Germany.
The two photos reproduced here show
Atlantic type express engines, running
both on the Palatinate Railways and
having each a number of interesting fea-
tures.
No. I is the first Atlantic (4-4-2) en-
gine which has been introduced in Ger-
many; it was built in 1898 by Krauss.
Munich. There are now about twelve
of this kind on the railway. It has inside
simple cylinders, driving the first pair of
wheels; the valve gear is a combination
of Foy's and Walschaert's. The boiler
is of the wagon-tnp type, with broad
COMPOUND INSIDE CYLINDER 4-4-S ENGINE.
But as these were only good in theory
and bad in practice, the opinion of this
journal has been proved correct, as you
said: "The remedy is worse than the
disease." The engine turned out to be
a complete failure, for it never left the
shops after it had been bought by the
Palatinate Railways and made several
trials. Finally it was rebuilt. It is now
an ordinary compound inside cyhnder
Atlantic type engine.
nature. It has been truly said that: "The
great region of inquiry and interest is
not the world of nature, but human na-
ture." The broadening and unifying in-
fluence of material progress has but fer-
tilized the soil of human nature, whose
first product of progress must be a recog-
nition of the principles of moral equity.
Moses, the great law-giver, who was
but the spokesman of the Almighty, first
enunciated the principle that the rela-
542
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
tions ol mankind should be settled upon
lofty moral grounds, and it has been
aptly said that: "He thus gave the first
recorded impulse to civilization and link-
ed his name with the progress of the
human race." The world's history since
then demonstrates that such an elevated
morality, defining the distinction between
right and wrong, must be the foundation
of all advancement, whether individual
or national. As Charles Sumner has
beautifully expressed it: "Moral excel-
lence is the bright consummate flower of
all progress. B. D. C.\ldwell.
At N. y. Railroad Club.
British Ideas of U. S. A.
We often hear of the strange ideas that
Britishers have of things over here, but
I think that the attached clipping from
a London weekly fairly caps everything
I have heard lately.
I suppose the British editor (?)
thought that working "on the roof of the
goods trains" meant sorting and check-
ing freight!!!
Imagine, if you can. a modern
"brakie" handling freight on top of a
fast freight train running down a curv-
ing mountain grade!!!
Arthur W. Line.
The picture which Mr. Line sent rep-
resented a train ^passing under guard
lines that are set up to indicate to brake-
men that a low bridge is near. In ex-
plaining their use, the British editor
says: "The appliances suspended from
the wire across the railway track are in
use on the great American lines to pre-
vent accidents to the freightmen who
work on the roof of the goods trains
during their journeys. They are placed
at the mouths of tunnels and give the
men warning by tapping them on the
head. The roofs of American freight
cars are systematically used for the con-
veyance of goods."
Compound vs. Simple Engines; or, An
Engineer's Plaint.
Mr. Stewart, at the Traveling En-
gineers' Convention in Chicago this year,
put the problem in a nutshell when he
said that if the roundhouse does not
keep up its end the compound's good
work is soon destroyed. You can't get
something for nothing. The compounds
are not safe to go through yards, due to
the vexatious steam leaks around the
cylinders, and they do not ride well
down grade. The poor engineer has but
two hands; one is in constant use hold-
ing the throttle open, and the other on
the brake valve, while the third man on
the engine — the brakeman — has to read
the orders, watch the time card and other
minor matters, just because the machine
designed to revolutionize the motive
power department is not what it should
be. Fault is found with the engineer if
he sliould liappen to report the wrong
packing ring or have the wrong head
taken oflf. It's not so long ago— and I
am not certain but that the practice slill
exists — that cylinder packing on many
good roads is still examined on the good
old simple engines at least once each
month, whether reported or not. F. P.
Roesch was the only one at the T. E.
convention who seemed to have any fair
consideration for the engineer. Great is
the "fin de siecle" foremen and the up-
to-date (?) M. M. You thought that
with the assistance of your mechanical
expert (?) you would find something
new to worry the ignorant engineer, but
the worry is not all his, for you sowed a
wind and are reaping a whirlwind. Who
would not prefer a good compound to a
poor simple engine, but no engineer on
the U. P. or anywhere else prefers a
■good compound to a good simple engine
They are like the "Indian" — only good
when dead. How many of you, traveling
engineers included, know anything about
the compound from a knowledge gained
by actual service running one? If you
have this knowledge why not impart
some of it to us? We are ready and
ever willing to learn. All we want is
facts and a little prompting.
F.\iR Play.
Pueblo. Colo.
There is good wholesome advice in
"Fair Play's" remarks that can be taken
home. Every new device requires an
experienced instructor for successful
operation. The poor showing made by
compounds is largely due to neglect on
the part of some railways in having'
competent instructors to properly edu-
cate the engineman. — Editor.
Castor Oil Prevents Foaming.
Some years ago I read an article in
your paper, written by a correspondent
in Australia, in regard to the use of cas-
tor oil in locomotive boilers, to stop
foaming and kill the efifects of bad water.
We are using water impregnated with
salt water and other refuse from 5 or 6
oil wells, and engines foam so bad it is
almost impossible to do anything with
them.
If castor oil is fed into boiler through
overflow openings in injector, foaming
will stop the instant the castor oil strikes
boiler. Moreover, as much water can
then be carried as boiler will stand with
the best of water, and engine can be
worked just as hard. Two ounces of oil
administered in teaspoonful doses will
last an I 7 engine 26 miles on the hill.
How many miles can be made on this
amount fed by a good needle-feed cup
or water pipe, I am unable to say.
You can imagine the condition of
water from the fact that "icicles" of salt
form in boiler and around leaks at seams,
etc.
1 think castor oil will kill most any
bad water from what I have seen of its
action with this worst of all waters.
I am informed that sulphate of copper
will not aff'ect this salt water in the
least. Do you know of any one using
castor oil for this purpose in alkali re-
gions in the West? It seems to me that
it would be cheaper than washing out
boilers frequently not to mention crown-
sheets that are scorched or dropped.
This is the only thing (castor oil) that
I ever saw used that would stop the
water right in the engine's throat and
never ease the throttle off, apparently
taking effect as soon as it gets into the
boiler. There are only a few of us who
have used castor oil, as we had to buy it
ourselves.
Will you write this up for your paper,
so that your other readers may profit by
it? Would it be asking too great a favor
of you to find out if it is any good with
alkali water?
I think Mr. Nellis has had experience
with just such water on the Pan Handle,
from a tank near Pittsburgh.
This is once Railway and Locomo-
tive Engineering has paid 500 per cent,
on the investment, and not the only or
last time I hope, for me.
Jno. W. Graybill.
Bridgeport, Ohio.
Lubrication of Piston^Valves and
Cylinders.
In the October issue, under head of
"Proper Lubrication of Piston Valves
and Cylinders," the road foreman of
engines has been looking up some
trouble that locomotive runners have
had to contend with for years, but I am
afraid that he has not figured from cause
to efifect, but I will give him credit for
getting after the trouble even if he did
start in wrong end first. Now, to begin
with, I have to take issue with him on the
question of the piston valve not needing
as much oil to keep it lubricated as the
flat valve. I contend that it is only a
question of it standing more punishment
than the fiat valve before it kicks. Now
from observations I have made I have
come to this conclusion about the trouble
that he speaks of: If his right cylinder
was getting sufficient oil, that is, presum-
ing that both were given the same
amount, there must be a cause for the
left cylinder not getting a sufficient
amount, which did not exist on the right
side, which could not be attributed to
the piston valve as they were bathed
the same.
Now, we are getting down to actual
conditions, which is one of the follow-
ing: Not enough oil feed to that
side, or if there was it was blown out
through the valve packing rings without
going to the cylinder, or held up in the
tallow pipe and not getting to either
valve or cylinder until the engine is
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
543
shut oflf. Now, if the latter cause exist-
ed, he has obtained one way to remedy
it even if it is the wrong way; now the
probability is that this engine that he
speal<s of, is in service where it is not
worlced at more than an average cut-of!
of 10 inclies, so tliat by connecting his
tallow pipe to the center of the cylinder
the average pressure at that point was
considerably below boiler pressure
while he has boiler pressure turned on
his tallow pipe, at the lubricator, and the
effect is a strong circutation through
tallow pipe which would have the ef-
fect of carrying the oil to the cylinder
as fast as it is fed from the lubricator,
and, of course, the valves would get the
benefit of this oil from the exhaust on
the exhaust side of valve only. Now.
how much better it would have been if
this oil had been put through the valve
in going to the cylinder so that the valve
could have been oiled on both sides, or.
in other words, caught it both coming
and going, as it is without a doubt true
that we do not get the benefit of all the
oil that is put through the valves, it is
only that which strikes the rubbing sur-
faces that is used.
Now the question is, How are we going
to get the oil to the cylinder by way of
the valve with any assurance of regular-
ity? And well might the question be asked,
for my experience has been with all lubri-
cators that I have worked, they have
failed to do it and I have had some ex-
perience with most all of them. Oh! Wait
a minute. I think I hear a noise. Yes,
and it is getting louder. Now I begin to
hear what it is. It is the lubricator men
wanting to be heard, and this is what they
all have to say: "Our lubricator will put
every drop of oil to the steam chest as
fast as it is fed from the lubricator." Now
that claim is very easy to make, but I
think I hear the man who is using those
same lubricators say, "Prove it." Now,
each of them comes forward with his
lubricator, sets it on the M. M.'s desk,
fills the bowl full of oil and the condensor
full of water, opens up the feeds and
proceeds to oil the M. M.'s valves with
hot air. But hold on, I think I hear the
runners cry out, "He is no locomotive;
come along with us on one of our high
pressure engines while we take a run
at a hill with the full rating behind us.
and then come and land the hard part
of the hill to find your valves dry with
one exhaust saying 'I guess I will,' and
the next one 'I guess I won't,' not much
time then to shove in the throttle to
get a circulation through our tallow
pipe, or come along with us on one of
our heavy fast passenger runs while we
make a run of from 50 to 80 miles with-
out shutting off, with the throttle laid
back and lever pulled back as close as
possible to save making an extra stop
for water, which would make a delay
that would cause us to use one-half ton
of coal more or less to make up and
explain to us what the lever has to say
about your test in the M. M.'s office.
The lubricator man's test is all right il
the lubricator was to be put on a sta-
tionary engine and connected to the
boiler side of the throttle. I know that
it is superfluous when I say that on a
locomotive the conditions are different
and what we want is a lubricator that
will overcome that difference and will
make the conditions the same. Now 1
think I hear the lubricator men who
handle the automatic steam heat plugs
say, "We have done this," but again I
am compelled to say, "Prove it," and if
you are not able to do it, get your heads
together and give us an instrument
which will, for if you don't somebody
else will, which will not only relieve the
roundhouse force, the fireman and the
runner of much unnecessary work, but
will make a saving in repairs; also in
fuel and oil, which ought to interest all
concerned.
Locomotive Runner.
Galesburg, III.
manufactory near Philadelphia for mak-
ing paper, wire and carding machinery.
This industry was afterward conducted
by his sons and his grandsons, who ex-
tended into other lines, the latter having
engaged for a time in locomotive build-
ing.
Progress of the Last Century.
A mere surface view of the future
might justify the query whether the
world will ever again experience an age
of such wonderful advancement as that
of the last century; and while perhaps
its greatest advancement was in the dis-
covery and utilization in the interest of
mankind, of material forces, such dis-
coveries have been so great and wonder-
ful that the new century may be forced
to be content to develop and improve
rather than to create. In man, himself,
however, we find justification for the dec-
laration that progress is still to be the
distinguishing feature of this century.
Not only in control of the material
world, but in the intellectual and moral
sphere, man is higher in the scale to-day
than ever in the world's history and be-
fore him. beckoning him onward, the
flaming torch of progress shines with
greater illumination than ever before.
B. D. Caldwell.
Pioneer riachine IHakers.
The Sellers of Philadelphia have the
right to be considered the greatest aris-
tocrats of American mechanical en-
gineering. During the revolutionary
war Nathan Sellers, known as an aci.om-
plished mechanic, was serving in the
patriot army. He was honorably dis-
charged by a special act of Congress in
order that he might make moulds for
paper making. He was sent under mili-
tary escort to York, Pa., where, under
guard, he made the first pair of paper
molds made on this continent, and on
which the paper for Congressional use
and for printing the continental cur-
rency was made.
Mr. Sellers established a prosperous
Restored the By-Pass.
The Frisco tried the plan of taking the
"Rabbit," otherwise known as "by-pass,"
off some of their four-cylinder Vauclain
compound wide fire box ten-wheelers.
Said they burned too much coal when
used simple. After fifteen or twenty days
they were replaced. They needed them
to get over their grades.
Walter G. Phelps.
The Canadian Pacific Railway people
in Montreal have a good way of
finding flaws in iron or steel. Mr.
H. A. Williams, superintendent of
rolling stock, has introduced a new
method of procedure. It is simply
this: Whenever a pair of wheels
is sent to the lathe for tire turning, the
axle is first carefully cleaned with
naphtha; this removes all the grease;
then a thin coat of white paint, in which
only turpentine is used, is applied, and the
mixture allowed to dry. As soon as the
wheels are put into the lathe, the stress
in the axle, due to the process of turn-
ing, develops any flaw or crack if there is
one, and it shows at once, as the grease in
the crack comes to the surface. Piston
rods and side rods undergo similar treat-
ment, and the result has been that many
dangerous defects have been found that
would have escaped even a careful exami-
nation by the eye alone. Mr. H. Osborne
is the master mechanic in charge of the
Montreal shop.
The new side-door suburban cars on
the Illinois Central Railroad, at Chicago,
designed by Mr. A. W. Sullivan, assistant
second vice-president of the company, and
Mr. W. Renshaw, superintendent of ma-
chinery, have turned out to be, as every-
body expected, a great success. Passen-
gers have become used to the cars and
have learned to distribute themselves
along the platforms, and do not stand in
solid bunches like football players mak-
ing ready for a scrimmage. W'hen one of
these trains draws up, there is a door in
front of every two or three people, and
they get aboard in minimum time, and.
what is more, they nearly all get seats.
These cars have been subjected to a two-
months' test and are "just what the doctor
ordered." The railway people like them
because they save time and ser\'e large
crowds easily. The traveling public likes
them because they are many-doored and
provide the accommodation paid for. With
everybody looking pleasant, it would now
be appropriate for the camera fiend to do
his worst.
544
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
Growth of the Locomotive.
BY ANGUS SINCLAIR.
( Continued from page ^gj. )
THE CAMDEN & AMBOY CRAMPTONS.
In 184s President Stevens visited Eu-
rope, and saw some Crampton locomo-
tives, which excited his admiration. On
returning to the United States he ad-
vised Mr. Dripps to design an engine of
the same general type with a single pair
of driving wheels, 8-feet diameter. The
drawings were made and the engine was
built by Richard Norris & Sons, of
Philadelphia. The engine is illustrated
in Fig. 43.
wise were stayed to outer sheet by bolts,
spaced 10 inches apart. The dome was
very large, and had a flanged joint near
thecenter of its height; the throttle was
of the old slide pattern, encased in a box
that was located on top of an arch pipe
that went out each side of dome to the
chests; there was a dry pipe above the
throttle.
The fire door was below and behind
the axle, and the fireman stood in a pit,
the bottom of which was on a level with
bottom of ash pan, the tank deck being
about breast high. In the smoke box
there was a deflecting plate over the tube
THE STEVENS CRAMPTON LOCOMOTIVE.— FIG. 43.
The order entered in the Norris books
for the engine reads:
'"One passenger locomotive for Cam-
den & Aniboy Ry. Gauge, 4 ft. g'yi ins.
Boiler 38 inches diameter, made with
spiral seams, to burn anthracite coal, the
steam dome to be put on cylinder part
of boiler, with steam pipes leading to
steam chests.
Cylinders 13x34 inches horizontal.
Cut-off. Worked from an, eccentric
outside of shackle pin.
Guides. Of steel with block and heads.
Cross-heads. Of wrought iron witli
cylindrical journals.
Wheels. Two driving wheels 8 feet
diameter.
Axles. Axles 6^^; truck wheels with
tires 36 inches diameter. Axles 4 inches
diameter.
Tubes. 98, of iron 2 in. diameter; 12
in. long.
Name, John Stevens; No. 28; tried
April 17, 1849.
The engine weighed about 50,000
pounds. Both the driving and truck
wheels were made of wrought iron, and
the spaces between the spokes filled with
wood.
The boiler shown in Fig. 44 was very
small — 38in. diameter — with but 98 flues.
In the longitudinal section (Fig. 44) can
be seen the plan of staying, the long
rods among the flues being then
deemed a necessity. The fire box
was 5 feet long, no width given,
but it could not have been over 48
inches; the crown bars running length-
plate, being the first case of a diaphragm
being used for spark arresting.
On top of the dome was a safety valve
whose lever extended to a spring scale.
This was the only means of knowing the
recalls tlie experiments made with dif-
ferent kinds of smokestacks, one of
which terminated in an elbow at the top,
with a loose joint provided with handles,
with which to turn it out of the wind.
The one shown had a place to clean it
out, and the. lower e.xtension of smoke
box also had a cinder slide.
The exhaust pipes were carried from
the chests along each side of the boiler
between the frames, and entered the side
of the smoke box about half-way up.
This engine and its mate had a stroke of
34 in., but the rest of the series had 38-in.
stroke.
The steam ports were only 8 inches
long by I 3-16 in. wide, the exhaust ports
8 in. by 2 in. The cylinder cocks were of
the old, independent kind — fireman had
to run around the engine and close them
up after the engine was in motion.
The 6-wheeled truck was pivoted to
the boiler so far back that it carried
most of the weight, making the engine
very deficient in adhesion and prone to
get off the track. The center pair of
wheels were without flanges. The pe-
culiar plan of arranging the truck springs
is shown in Fig. 46, and seems to have
some advantages over modern devices.
To the younger generation, the valve
motion (Fig. 45) will seem com-
plicated; the two wheel eccentrics
were located inside the wheel and
operated the large hooks, shown
with the curved lifting rod. These
worked the main rocker arm and the
=B ED m
SECTION OF THE
pressure carried — as steam gauges were
not then in use. Near the stack is shown
a safety valve that was encased to pre-
vent the men from meddling with it.
J. W. Sanford. M.M. of the Pennsyl-
vania shops at the Meadows, Jersey City,
fired and ran this engine and others of
its class. He says they used to pull six
of the old, light cars, but even this train
was more than they could handle well.
They were not provided with sand boxes,
and were slippery and very slow to get a
train under way, but, once in motion,
with a light train, they would run as
fast as men cared to ride. Mr. Sanford
STEVENS.— FIG. 44.
main valve, and the reversing was done
by changing from one hook to the other
by handling one of the levers in the
cab. The independent cut-off was a small
valve, riding on top of the main valve,
and operated by the return crank ec-
centric on the main pin. This motion
was transmitted to the valve through the
back rocker.
In starting, the cut-off lever was moved
so as to engage the lower hook. This
made the cut-off valve come to the cen-
ter of the main valve, and, as that always
ran full stroke, it would cut its own
steam off, the cut-off motion merely
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
545
sliding the block on the uppL-r rod back
and forth, and doing no work.
As suon as the engine was under way
the engineer "threw on the cut-off,"
which disengaged the lower hook from
the main valve stem, and engaged the
upper one with the cut-ofT valve, which
traveled on top of the main valve, cut-
ting the steam off short, much as a link
does when hooked up, except that, as
the main valve controlled the exhaust,
the latter was carried well to the end
of the stroke
These engines ran from 1849-50 to
1861-2, and one as late as 1865; two of
them were cut up and the others were
also cut up, with the exception of the
cylinders and guides, these being used
on some 8-wheeled engines with 6-foot
wheels, that were built at that time.
Neither the Monster nor the Cramp-
ton class of engine became the originator
of a type in American locomotive prac-
tice; but both of them possessed details
most extensive of their kind. The bo-
tanical department of the university has
also contributed original knowledge on
the microscopic structure ai woods. .
The selection of Purdue laboratory is,
no doubt, due to the reputation which
Purdue has already established. The fact
that some years ago the engineering lab-
oratory of Purdue University was made
the official laboratory of the Master Car
Builders' Association and has received
from that association more than $10,000
worth of equipment speaks well for the
character of the work it is doing. The
immediate work of the Bureau of For-
estry at the Purdue station will be a
study of the red gum, a wood that is of
very widespread growth and possesses
valuable properties.
Cast Iron Thimbles for Tubes.
At a meeting of tlic Master Mechanics'
Association, held long ago, the familiar
V.^LVE MOTION. FIG -W
of mechanism that were adopted by sub-
sequent locomotive builders. They mark-
ed a decided line of progress.
{To be continued.)
A Testing Station of the Bureau of
Forestry at Purdue University.
The Bureau of Forestry, United States
Department of Agriculture, has inaugu-
rated an investigation of the mechanical
properties of the commercial timbers of
the United States, and has established a
Timber Testing Station at Purdue Uni-
versity, La Fayette, Ind.. to form the
nucleus of the work in the Mississippi
Valley region. Various physical and me-
chanical tests will be made according to
uniform methods at this and the other
government stations, by experts of the
Bureau of Forestry. Additional ma-
chines of a special character, belonging
to the bureau, will be installed in the
laboratory. The work of this station will
be under the direction of Dr. W. K.
Hatt, who has recently been appointed to
have supervisory charge of the work of
all the Timber Testing Stations of the
Bureau of Forestry.
The university has for many years
given a large amount of attention to the
investigation of materials of construc-
tion. The results of the tests on cements
and steel concrete are used by engineers
at home and abroad, and the experiments
on iron and steel under impact are the
ARRANGEMENT OF TRUCK SPRINGS.
FIG. 46.
subject of leaky tubes was under con-
sideration and W: S. Hudson, who was
then superintendent of the Rogers Loco-
motive Works, gave some notes of ex-
perience that might be useful to modern
master mechanics. He was master me-
chanic of a railroad in Western New
York where the feed water was bad and
they had trouble with leaky tubes. It
was usual to use wrought iron ferrules
in the back end of the tubes and it strucR
him that cast iron might be better. He
took some wrought iron ferrules and re-
peatedly heated and cooled them and on
measuring them carefully he found that
they became smaller. He tried the same
operation on cast iron ferrules and found
that they expanded. This led him to
adopt the use of cast iron ferrules and it
stopped the trouble from leaky tubes.
The report of the proceedings of the
thirty-seventh annual convention of
Master Car Builders' Association, has
just been issued from the press. The
convention was held in Saratoga on June
30, 31, and July i, 1903. The proceedings
makes a good sized volume of 620 pages.
and contains as illustrations all the draw-
ings which accompanied the reports of
committees. There are twenty-three
plates at the back of the book, showing
M. C. B. standards, there are twelve
plates showing the recommended prac-
tice of the association and a table giving*
the details of letter ballot for the year.
Volume 37 may be had on application
to Mr. Joseph W. Taylor, secretary ol
the association. His office is at 667.
Rookery Building, Chicago, 111.
An amusing story of Sir William Van
Home is told by. Mr. W. R. Stewart in
a recent issue of the Cosmopolitan. It
illustrates the minute knowledge of rail-
road men and things possessed by the
Chairman of the Canadian Pacific Board,
and it also evidences his very keen sense
of humor and love of a joke. When
division superintendent on the Chicago
& Alton he overheard a message from a
conductor telling a night operator how
the crew on a certain night run were
in the habit of taking cushions out of
the passenger cars, with which to make
themselves comfortable in the baggage
car. A night or so after he wired the
conductor of the train a message which
was delivered at a small and lonely way
station in the dead of night. The message
contained only these solemn words: '"Put
back those cushions," but it filled the
hearts of the crew with dire consterna-
tion.
The Augusta (Me.) lournal is the au-
thority for the following: "It is a fact
not generally known that the use of
pilots on locomotives is not required by
statute law. The evolution of the pilot
was brought about for the purpose of
sweeping cattle from the track during
the early days of railroading, until to-
day it is looked upon as a safeguard for
the general public, although it is of no
special benefit in case of accident."
A president of a prominent railroad
made some critical remarks to the writer
lately about a paper which had been sub-
mitted to a railroad club and asked, Are
there not any restrictions upon the free
advertising by raiload clubs? We could
not answer the question, but we think
it is worthy of consideration by the
various executive committees. The
Master Car Builders' and Master Me-
chanics' Associations have been con-
stantly worked by people wanting free
advertising, but they steadfastly refused
to take the bait. Their example is worth
imitation by the railway clubs.
At the end of July of the present year
the membership of the Brotherhood of
Locomotive Firemen was 48.568. and the
number of lodges 642. In the last year
forty-three new lodges have been estab-
lished.
546
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
The New Caledonian Engines.
The Caledonian ten-wheelers, illustrat-
ed in the June number of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering, have demon-
strated the wisdom of their designer, Mr.
John Mcintosh, in repeated successful
performances with heavy fast trains. The
time of 2 hours and 15 minutes for the
trip of 102.5 miles, gives an average
speed of 45.5 miles an hour. This speed
is remarkable only when considered in
connection with the work done by these
engines on continuous grades averaging
48 ft. per mile. If their performance is
examined on the basis of the resistance
encountered for speeds on American
roads, we will have 10.75 lbs. per ton
due to speed, and this with 19.6 lbs. per
ton due to grade, makes 30 lbs. per ton.
No data is at hand for curves, and the
total resistance will be taken as above,
on the grade of I in 102, or 0.98 per cent.,
where the speed at this point was 35
miles an hour and could not be influ-
enced by kinetic energy, being a dead
pull for a distance of about 15 miles. The
work done is exciting more than passing
comment, since the weight of engine and
tender in working order is 144 tons, and
that of the train load, estimated from re-
liable data, about 436 tons, or a total load
our description of this engine in June
last, the total heating surface was given
at 2,400 square feet; the evaporation per
hour per unit of heating surface was in
this case, therefore, ''^'^^'* =15.5 lbs. of
2,400
TRAN.SVERSE
SECTION OF
BOILER.
MCINTOSH
water. Such an evaporation would not
be expected from so small a heating sur-
face in this country, as is evidenced by
and being directly comparable with the
Caledonian engines, the latter stand out
in strong contrast in the matter of heat-
ing surface, to an extent as to be con-
vincing that our design of boilers is not
conducive to the highest evaporative
efliciency. The conviction is forced that
a remedy is to be found only in an im-
proved circulation, and to attain tliat
desirable end, it would appear that am-
ple water spaces around flues must be
provided not only between flues, but also
between boiler shell and flues at sides
and bottom.
Mr. Mcintosh has demonstrated that
his new engines will steam economically
on a lower heating surface than our
engines, for the same work and of the
same caliber. The Pennsylvania class
E 3 engine approaches the nearest to
the Caledonian in having a low heating
surface, with its 2,640 square feet, and is
properly regarded as one of the most
advanced creations in this respect in this
country at present.
Comparisons of the work done by
foreign and American engines cannot be
made with the degree of accuracy that
gives a reliable tone, since there are two
factors always open to doubt. These
disturbers are resistance and steam con-
Bailwiiy ^ Luco.nutiuu Knyiiiaeriitg
BOILER OF Mcintosh ten-wheEL express engines.
of 144+436=580 tons, of 2,000 lbs. The
drawbar pull necessary to overcome the
resistance named would therefore be
17,400 lbs., and the horse power de-
17.4C0X35
veloped
375
=1.624.
With these values before us, the evap-
oration, based also on American practice
of 26 lbs. of water per horse power hour,
is 1,624X26=42,224 lbs. per hour. In
the tendency to fill up boilers with flues.
Mr. Mcintosh pinned his faith to a
lower heating surface, preferring one
that was smaller, but more effective,
which has always been the policy of the
foreign designer. Recent American
engines of practically similar dimensions
to the Caledonian, lo-wheeler, and also
designed for similar service, have no less
than 3,500 square feet of heating surface.
sumption per horse power hOjUr. Con-
cerning the first of these, the conditions
of permanent way. train and er.:gine are
so nearly alike that they cannot seriously
vitiate results, but the fact remjiins that
there is a wide difference in the .steaming
capacity of boilers, no matter what the
relative cylinder efficiencies may^ be, and
it is time that some rigid invest igations
were being conducted that wc'uld ex-
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
547
plain why similar machines doing like
work should have a difference of nearly
SO per cent, in heating surfaces.
Annexed we show some line cuts illus-
trating the boiler of these engines. The
most striking thing about the boilers is
the arrangement of the tubes, the lowci
part having tubes 2'A inches in diameter,
the principal body being filled with 2-in.
tubes. Mr. Mcintosh explains that this
was done to remedy the trouble caused
by the lower tubes getting slopped with
cinders. The spacing of tlie tubes is also
worthy of study by our locomotive de-
signers. It has been the practice in the
designing of American locomotives of
late years to space the tubes so that a
passage is left clear for the rise of the
steam. The Caledonian engines have the
tube set so that the steam has to wind
among the tubes to reach the surface of
the water. This practice used to be very
Fast Passenger 4--4-2 for the Big I'our.
The Dunkirk shops of the American
Locomotive Company have recently sup-
plied the Peoria & Eastern, which is
now part of the Big Four system, with
some fast passenger power of the 4-4-2
type. The engine is simple, with cylin-
ders 205^x26 ins., and driving wheels 78
ins. in diameter. The weight resting on
the drivers is about 100,000 lbs., and the
total weight in working order is 184,000
lbs. There is therefore 84,000 lbs. borne
by the engine truck and by the carrying
wheels at the rear. The weight of the
engine and tender is 213,000 lbs.
The valves are of the piston type and
the valve gear is direct acting, having
transmission bar passing, with an easy
curve, over the axle of the leading
driver. The rocker has both arms of
equal length hanging down from the
rocker-box. The eccentrics are placed.
hold 6,coo U. S. gallons, and the 12 tons
of fuel can be carried. A few of the
principal dimensions are appended for
reference:
ficiieral I>iincnhiofiH— Wlicci l>a^c, riK'^l, 7 fl- ^' '"•*•■.
wlicci baHc, total. 2H ft. 5 ins.: wheel base, tvjtut,
engine and fender, ^ ft.
CylhKlerH— 2rj^x26 inH.
ValvcB — r.reatcst travel of valves, sVi ins.: ouuirle
la]) of valves, 1% ins.: icad of valves in fiiM
Kcar, ,<„ in.
Wheels, etc.— I>ia. and lenjcih of driving journals,
(}^/i ins. din. x 12 ins.; dia. and lcnf(th of main
crank pin journals, 6^ ins. dia. x 7 ins.; diam,
.'ind length of side rofl crank pin journals.
7 ins. dia. x 4\i ins.
Boiler — WorkiuK pressure, 200 lbs.; thickness of
plates in barrel and outside of fire t>ox, \i,}i,
H' Vbt %, A 'OS.; fire Ijox. length, 97 ins.; fire
\k)X, width, 6fi ins.; fire l)Ox. depth, front. Ho
ins.; back, 71 ins.; fire l>ox plates, thick., sides,
H in.; back, H in.; crown, Hin.; tube sheet,
^^in.; water space, front. 4 ins.; sides. 354 ins.;
back. $li ins ; smoke stack, inside dia. 15x19
ins.; smoke stack, top aliove rail, 14 ft. 9 ins.
Tender— Wheels, dia., jfi ins.; journals, dia. and
R'WAY. 6 LOCO. CINGINEERUSO
FAST 4.4-S ENGINE WITH DAVIS COUNTERBALANCE FOR THE BIG FOUR.
common with our designers, but it has
been abandoned of late years and it is
a question if the change has been an im-
provement. The tubes are set with an
average space of % in., while between
the shell and the tubes there is a space of
5 ins. front and at the back SMj ins. There
is ample space for free circulation of the
water, which no doubt has a good effect
in producing good evaporation, conduc-
ing to the efficiency of the heating sur-
face.
Some years ago. Railway and Loco-
motive Engineering pointed out dur-
ing the time that coal saving was the
rage all over the country, that frequent
and carefully performed washing out of
engines was introduced on some roads
as a means of saving coal. The saving
was effected by the constant removal of
scale and heat resisting incrustation on
the water side of the fire box sheets.
as is necessary with direct motion, so
that the belly of each of them is on the
side of the vertical center line of the
axle, remote from that of the crank-pin.
The springs are overhung with cast steel
equalizers between drivers, and between
main drivers and carrying wheels.
The boiler is an extension wagon-top
one, and is 68j^ ins. at the smoke-box
end. The staying of the crown sheet is
radial and the dome is well forward on
the third barrel course, with its center
about 60 ins. away from the fine sheet.
The heating surface is 3.196 sq. ft. in all.
about 3.015 sq. ft. being in the flues,
which are 362 in number and 16 ft. long.
The grate area is 44.8 sq. ft.
The running board is raised in its
central section to accommodate the main
reservoir, and a cast iron step at the
front end of it enables a man to pass on
to the foot rest over the cylinders.
The tank has a water bottom and will
length. 5 in«. dia. X9 ins.; wheel base, 17 ft.;
water capacity, 6,000 U. S. gallons; coal capac-
ity, 12 tons.
The locomotive engineers of the Bal-
timore & Ohio Railroad have organ-
ized a brass band. There are twenty-
eight pieces in the organization.
On October 31 a terrible accident hap-
pened to a special train on the Big Four
in the yards of Indianapolis, whereby
sixteen people were killed and many
others injured. The accident was caused
by freight cars being pushed into the side
of one of the passenger cars. Efforts
were made to place the blame upon the
engineer of the special for not having his
train under proper control in the yard,
but the coroner's jury held the train dis-
patcher responsible for not having ad-
vised the yard master that the special
train was on its way to Indianapolis.
548
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
LSati^^En^ineerins
A Practical Journal of Railway Motive
Power and Rolling Stock.
Published Monthly by
ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,
174 Broadway, New York.
Telephone, 984 Cortlandt.
Cable Address, " Loceng," N. Y.
Glasgow, "I,ocauto."
Business Department :
ANGUS SINCLAIR, President.
FRED M. NEI<I,IS, Vice-President.
JAMES R. PATERSON, Sec'y andTreas.
Editorial Department :
ANGUS SINCI,AIR, Editor.
F. M. NELLIS, /
GEO. S. HODGINS, > Associate Editors.
JOS. A. BAKER, S
Advertising Department :
Eastern Representative, S. I. CARPEN-
TER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.
Western Representative, C. J. I,UCK,
iao4 Monadnock Block, Chicago, 111.
British Representative :
THE LOCOMOTIVE PUBLISHING
CO., Ltd., Amen Corner, Paternoster
Row, E. C, London.
Glasgow Representative:
A. F. SINCLAIR, 7 Walmer Terrace,
Ibrox, Glasgow.
SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.
$2.00 jier year, Sl.OO fur six months, jmalage paid
to the United Slates, Canada and Mexico. For
other parts of ttie world, $a.50 or ten ehillingii-
Sinqte. co/nes, SO eents. Remit by Express Momy
Order. Drajt, Post Office Order or Jteginlered Letter.
Maiiiiiri address can Af c/ianged as often as nec.es-
sai'ij — aiicafjs t/ire old and tiew address, and if you
svbscritjed in a club, state u'/to got it up.
Please give prompt notice when your paper /ails to
reach yon jn^operly.
Entered at Post Office. New York, as Second-
class mail matter.
Copyright by Angus Sinclair Co , 1903.
For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.
Leaky Fire Boxes and Tubes.
We do not know of any subject which
has received so much investigation and
discussion, from railway associations and
clubs, as leaky fire boxes and tubes, and
we are safe in assuming that no explana-
tion for delay of trains is so frequently
given as "leaky flues." Leaky tubes have
been an annoying cause of trouble ever
since railway motive power began to be
used, but it seems to us that the evil is
more aggravating to-day than it ha.s ever
been in the past. The amount of work
a locomotive has to perform in a given
time has been very much increased of
late years, and this has in proportion in-
creased the causes of leaky tubes. The
increase in the length of the tubes has
entailed greater expansion and contrac-
tion, while the increase of boiler pressure
has raised the temperature somewhat, all
tending to put greater stresses upon flues
and fire box sheets.
In the numerous public discussions
which we have heard and read concern-
ing leaky tubes, bad feed water was
blamed for the greater part of t1ie
trouble, but there are delays and annoy-
ance with leaky sheets and tubes in re-
gions where no complaint is made
against mineral infected feed water. In
a recent issue we mentioned a case where
ihe engine-house people were in the
habit of covering fires over with planks,
to enable boiler makers to enter the fire
box to do work without drawing the
fire. That particular action would not
do any harm to the boiler, but it repre-
sents a strenuous condition of locomo-
tive operating which is responsible for
the greater part of the annoyance from
leaky sheets and tubes. The railroad is
e.xceptional when locomotives, and es-
pecially their boilers, receive fair treat-
ment.
When the best possible treatment is
accorded to it, a locomotive boiler is
constantly subjected to destructive
strains and stresses that struggle to
disrupt its elements, but they adhere
wonderfully together, and it is only un-
der shameful treatment that they display
premature signs of distress. The heat,
to which a locomotive boiler is errati-
cally subjected, demands that the water
side of the heating surface be maintaintd
as free as possible from non-conducting
substances that prevent the heat of the
fire gases from being readily conveyed
to the water; but it seems the rule, rather
than the exception, to permit masses of
mud and scale to cover the heating sur-
faces without proper care being taken to
remove the heat-arresting material.
When anything obstructs the passage of
the heat to the water, the sheets have to
endure the punishment of being spas-
modically overheated. With the vast
extremes of temperature between over-
heating and sudden cooling, the sudden
ranges of expansion and contraction put
irresistible stresses upon fire box sheets,
that manifest themselves in cracking or
breaking of stay bolts, and the tubes are
expanded and contracted so incessantfy
that the ends become loose and leak.
An unusually intelligent boiler shop
foreman, who has charge of the boilers
of a large railroad system, told the
writer that he was convinced that more
than half the trouble from cracked side
sheets and leaky tubes was due to hur-
ried and defective washing of the boilers.
Here is a common experience of a
locomotive boiler. It comes from the
makers in the first-class condition that
the best of material and good workman-
ship can produce. It is put into service.
At one time it is being forced at its ut-
most capacity to produce the steam
necessary for pulling a train up a long
and very heavy grade. The water has
fallen low during the ascent and at
the summit both injectors begin forc-
ing water into the boiler while the
fire is permitted to burn low. Toward
the foot of the grade the blower is
set going fiercely, then the fire box is
loaded and another spurt of hard work
performed. Suddenly the train is run
into a siding and frequently waits for
hours before the order to proceed is
given. Meanwhile the fire has become
low, and when the order to proceed is
given the screaming blower beats up
the boiler as fast as it can be done.
When the engine reaches the end of the
trip the fire cleaner forces the live coal
and clinker through a dump grate lo-
cated under the tube sheet and keeps
the blower drawing cold air directly into
the hot tubes. Then the engine is run
into the house with dampers open and
permitted to cool as rapidly as the cold
blast of probably a winter wind will per-
form the operation. But worse even than
the cold blasts of air is the action of the
injector, which is nearly always kept pour-
ing water into the boiler after the fire has
been drawn, and there is no heat to
counteract upon the hot sheets and flues
the chilling effects of the cold water.
Perhaps the boiler needs washing out
and the transportation officials are de-
manding that the engine be returned
immediately to take out another train.
The steam is blown off, cold water
forced through the feed pipes, the wash-
out plugs are removed and the washing
out done before the sheets not touched
by the water get time to cool. On some
roads the cooling process is carried out
even more expeditiously. The blow-off
cock is opened outside the engine house
and the water blown out until steam be-
gins to flow, indicating that the water has
all run out. Then the steam is used to
move the engine into the house, the
steam is then blown off and the washing
out hose applied. When the washing
out process is finished the boiler is filled
with water and a blower operated by
steam from the round house boiler is
put into action, and the fire stimulated
with all the energy that a strong arti-
ficial blast can produce. We have heard
mechanical officials boast that they orig-
inated or perfected the method of apply-
ing a blower to a cold engine so that
steam might be raised in a hurry. They
did not realize that they aided in bringing
into use a practice that is criminally de-
structive to boilers. In marine service
care is always taken to heat boilers grad-
ually and to give them time in cooling,
so that destructive strains may be pre-
vented; but in railway service the rule /
is to heat and cool with as little consid-
eration for expansion and contraction
as if such a thing did not exist.
We suppose that railroad organiza-
tions will keep on discussing the cause
of leaky fire boxes and tubes, but no
new light is needed on the subject.
Hard feed water will deposit scale which
causes leakage, but it can be remedied
in a great measure by using a water-
softening plant and washing out the
boilers properly and giving the boilers
time to cool a little before cold water is
forced into them. If railway officials
think it pays their company to hurry
boilers to destruction by destructive-
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
549
usage such as we have described and is
going on every hour, they cannot com-
plain tliat their policy brings its logical
results.
Asking Something for Nothing.
Men who would not expect for a
moment to ask advice of a lawyer or a
physician without paying for it, seem
to forget that the same law should hold
good in mechanical affairs.
Inventors, and men who are about to
invest money in inventions, will walk
into the office or the home of some
mechanical expert and ask questions, get
plans and drawings examined, or seek
advice, that none '^ut an educated me-
chanical engineer would be competent to
give, without thinking of paying for the
service rendered.
A man who graduates from any of our
great technical schools spends more
money and more time to get his educa-
tion than a lawyer or a doctor does.
" If a competent mechanical engineer
was consulted before any machine or
device was placed on the market, there
would be fewer failures and disappoint-
ments, and it would be a good invest-
ment to pay well for their services in
any case. Men who want to use the
brains and training of these mechanics,
without pay, would resent an impeach-
ment of "sponging" on anybody; yet to
the expert making his bread and butter
by using his brains and training they
are very despicable dead-beats.
There is another class of men, or a
few of the same class, who seem to think
that a mechanical newspaper exists for
no other purpose than to do their ex-
pert designing for them. They will ask
questions in mathematics that any fair
scholar in their own place could work
out in a few minutes. They want you
to design engines for certain work, valve
gear for certain engines, and boilers for
a dozen different purposes, each stating
many local peculiarities that materially
affect the case, and where the sound
judgment of a first-class mechanic is
necessary to insure success.
One of this class wrote us not long
ago, asking for the required horse
power, sized boiler, sized screw, pitch
of screws, etc, necessary to drive
a boat 22 feet long eight miles per
hour. Now we do know barely
enough about locomotives to get
along, but what we know about boats
is limited — something like our corre-
spondent's information on the same sub-
ject. We wrote him that if we were in
his place we should employ a com-
petent man to work out the problem,
and offered to recommend a mechanical
engineer, if he knew of none. We re-
ceived a postal card reply as follows:
"The reeson you don't answer wright
is becoss you don't no, you editors aint
so smart as you pretend."
The information conveyed in the last
sentence of the rebuke came as a great
shock to us; but, after calmly thinking
it over, we decided not to commit sui-
cide, but to struggle along, as we had
before, without knowing everything.
This is the age of the specialist. Each
man can learn to be an expert at one
thing — if it's only opening clams — and
by exchanging products we can all get
expert service in everything that goes
to make up our lives. An expert me-
chanic will verify your plans or point
out their weak points in a few minutes,
and perhaps save you thousands of dol-
lars; but don't expect his services for
nothing, nor that he will charge by the
hour. He has got to have something for
the time spent in educating himself.
The Hngineman's Plaint.
On another page we reproduce a letter
from one of our many readers showing
the unwise policy followed by some
lines. We frequently have letters of this
nature asking our advice and good offices
to improve their conditions. Often too
little heed is paid by superiors to sug-
gestions made by the engineman that
might improve conditions on the road.
If he has to use water in the locomo-
tive heavily impregnated at certain sea-
sons with sulphates or carbonates of soda
and magnesia, which cause excessive
foaming, and has the temerity to ask the
trainmaster to set out cars enough to
handle the train, he is met with a rebuff.
Generally the rebuff comes from some
overzealous clerk to whom a locomotive
merely represents a certain number,
classified, and rated at so many tons.
Not satisfied with the original delay re-
port several weeks of useless correspond-
ence are kept up on this same delay. The
engineer has long since discovered that
the Brown System of Discipline is a farce
on his line. He receives no credits for
meritorious work, but the demerits, like
the sword suspended by a hair over
Damocles' head, are continually threaten-
ing him. He quietly buys bran to stop
a leaky boiler. Somebody has told him
that bluestone will stop water in a boiler
from foaming, so he buys bluestone, re-
gardless of the effects on the boiler, so
long as he can stop the foaming and
steer clear of those delay reports.
Our correspondent writes: "We have
tried bluestone in our boilers without
result. Our water comes from the mines
and is full of salts of some kind. We
have tried castor oil as you recommend-
ed in one of your issues several years
ago, with excellent results. You have
helped us in this matter and hope you
will give us other good receipts. While
the castor oil prevents foaming, still
there are only a few of us who use it, as
we have to "buy" it ourselves.
Bluestone will stop certain waters from
foaming, but it is an unsafe remedy, as
it seeks out all the weak spots, starts
Hues and scams leaking, corrodes
the steel sheets and leaves a resid-
uum on the outer scams similar to
syrup. In alkali districts, such as can
be found on the wctern transcontinental
lines, the best and most effective remedy
is unslaked lime and a good surface blow-
off cock. This remedy acts equally well
on sulphates and carbonates, reduces
scale and leaves no bad after effects.
The proper method of treating water
is at water stations, before it enters the
engine tender. We know the difficulties
the engineman encounters and his horror
of meaningless correspondence, but we
feel like censuring him for being so fool-
ish in spending his money for something
that is not appreciated. If practical dem-
onstrations of castor oil or anything else
of merit will not convince the compa-.y
that it is a good investment, let the com-
pany take the other alternative and set
out cars until you can handle your train,
without the risk of dropping a crown-
sheet, and your suffering a dismissal.
A Waste of Wood.
The varieties of hard wood in general
use among manufacturers of staves, fur-
niture, wagons, implements, etc., have
largely disappeared from the extensive
forest areas of the Western .States. In
respect of black walnut, this is conspicu-
ously true, for that timber is now confined
to a comparatively limited area in isolated
localities. And yet it was once abundant
in the West ; its presence in Michigan gave
rise to the extensive furniture industry of
Grand Rapids, as did its presence in In-
diana to the manufacture of machine
tables and cabinets at South Bend, Ind.,
by one of the greatest sewing machine
companies in the world. But these and
other concerns established in the black
walnut districts have practically stripped
the country of this timber from the lakes
to Eastern Kansas. In Arkansas and the
Indian Territory the woodsman's ax is
completing the work of destruction west
of the Mississippi. Even the walnut
stumps, left in the earth when the trees
were felled, have for several years had a
market of their ow-n, and are bought at
fancy prices because of the irregularity of
the grain.
White oak is another failing wood. It
has practically disappeared from Ohio and
Indiana ; but in Southern Missouri a good
deal still remains, and in Arkansas there
is an immense body not as yet accessible
in the main. The great area of white oak
timber now left standing is. however, to
be found on the slopes of the Southern
.Mleghany mountain region, in Southern
Virginia, Eastern Kentucky and Tennes-
see. Western. North and South Carolina,
Northern Georgia, and to some extent in
Northern Alabama and Mississippi.
Unfortunatel}'. perhaps, the railroads
are among the heaviest consumers of white
5 so
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December. 1903.
oak. For cross ties their demands are
particularly destructive, since the younger
timber is sought out by the tie contrac-
tors and cutters. In the South the inroads
in white oak for railroad uses has been so
severe as to prompt a special forestry re-
port from the Department of Agricultuie,
wherein it is shown that chestnut oak
is preferable to white oak, when the bark
is peeled from the former, for tanners'
requirements, as a wood for cross ties.
Most roads, however, and especially those
in the South, call for white oak in their
specifications.
The report which the department fur-
nishes on this branch of the subject
shows that millions of feet of tan bark or
chestnut oak are rotting in the forests,
after being .stripped of their bark, because
their value for cross ties is not known or
is underestimated in many regions. And
the eflfect of this does not stop at the
waste of the wood itself, for their is
waste of the bark also, as without de-
mand for the wood it does not pay to
peel the larger limbs. On the line of the
Louisville & Nashville Railroad alone,
south of the Tennessee river, between 5,-
000 and 7,000 cords of bark are shipped
annually, involving the felling ot lO.OOO to
13,000 trees. This timber is consigned to
useless destruction, although capable of
yielding not less than 100.000 first-class
railroad ties.
Books Reviewed.
Locomotive Breakdowns, Emergencies
and Their Remedies, by Geo. L. Fow-
ler, M.E. Publishers: The Norman"
W. Henley Publishing Company, New
York. 1903. Price, $1.50.
This book contains 244 pages and is
a catechism on breakdowns and acci-
dents to locomotives on the road and
gives directions how to repair them with
appliances such as are usually carried on
the engine itself, or which can be readily
procured. The simple and compound
engine are both taken up and emergency
repairs described. The book is divided
into an introduction and seventeen chap-
ters, and is clearly illustrated throughout
with line cuts showing how repairs are
to be made. It contains a comprehen-
sive index and the last three chapters
deal, first with shop tools and appliances
for making engine repairs, air brake
troubles, and first aid to the injured. The
book ought to be useful on the road and
in the shop.
Elements of Steam Engineering, by H.
W. Spangler, Arthur M. Green, Jr.,
and S. M. Marshall. Publishers: John
Wiley & Sons, New York. 1993.
Price, $3.00.
This book is intended for the beginner,
and brings before him examples of the
various forms of steam apparatus used
in modern steam power plants, and ex-
plains the construction, use and rea-
sons for using the parts, or the machines
described. The first three chapters deal
with boilers, their details and accessories
and boiler-room auxiliaries. The next
lour discuss the slide valve, engine de-
tails, valve motions and indicating, and
the two concluding chapters are devoted
to governors and valves, and condensers
and multiple-expansion engines. With
index, the book contains 275 pages, and
is profusely illustrated throughout with
line cuts and half-tones. In make-up it
is covenient for the reader, as each
paragraph contains in large type, the
subjects with which it deals, and these
sub-heads arc enumerated in the index.
The printing and paper are of good qual-
ity.
The Gas Engine, by F. R. Hutton, pro-
fessor of mechanical engineering in
Columbia University. Publisher: John
Wiley & Sons, New York. 1903.
Price, $5.00.
This work is a treatise on the internal-
combustion engine, using gas, gasoline,
kerosene or other hydrocarbons, as a
source of energy. There are 83 pages of
printed matter, and 243 figures, and it
contains an alphabetical index to sub-
jects. It is well printed, and the cuts
stand out clearly.
The opening chapters deal with com-
bustion, mechanical energy from expan-
sion and the heat engine cycle. There
then follows a description of eight types
of engines burning gas, six using kero-
sene, several using gasoline, and alcohol
engines. Then comes chapters on mix-
tures, carburetors, ignition, governing,
cooling of the cylinder, combustion
chamber and exhaust, and one on man-
ipulation of gas engines which gives
practical instruction, among other things
in stopping, starting lubrication and
causes of failure to operate. The per-
formance of gas engines by test follows,
and this is succeeded by a long chapter
on the theoretical analysis of the gas
engine, which involves much higher
mathematics, and may even be open to
the charge of allowing the ostentation of
scholarship to become temporarily too
prominent. Inter-combustion engines,
and experiments on explosive mixtures,
with a short concluding chapter, finish
a work which is perhaps the first im-
portant American contribution to the
subject of which it treats.
Switch Lights, by Edward E. Sheas-
green. Illustrated by P. J. Carter.
Publishers: Iron Trail Publishing
Company, Minneapolis, Minn.
This book contains a collection of
eighty-seven poems of railroad life and
work and tragedy. They are grave or
gay as the thought and fancy of the
author prompts him, in dealing with the
various scenes and experiences of the
ordinary railroad man.
Requesting Information by Circular.
The cliairuiau ot a coumiitlcc of a
railway club that was trying to collect
information by sending a list of ques-
tions to be answered by railway officials,
makes the following melancholy com-
ment: "The encouragement given to
club committees by railway officials in
giving out information, in the opinion
of the committee, should be referred to
a Society for the Prevention of Cruelty
to Animals." There is no mention on
whose behalf the society should bear the
brunt of cruelty, but we think it ought
to lighten the woes of the poor overbur-
dened official, who is bothered beyond
endurance by requests for information
on all sorts of subjects that he has given
little attention to.
That worn out practice of sending out
a list of questions for railway officials to
answer is not fair, and people preparing
papers for railway clubs should be dis-
couraged from using it. The practice
was begun in the Master Car Builders'
Association many years ago, and caused
so much complaint that it is seldom re-
sorted to nowadays. It became grad-
ually recognized in both the Master Car
Builders' and Master Mechanics' Asso-
ciations that the chairman of a com-
mittee who used circulars of inquiry to
obtain the information he wanted was
not a competent collector of facts.
The Engineer's Influence on Train
Loads.
Speaking about the working of "ton-
nage rating," a railroad official who is
in close touch with transportation mat-
ters in the North-West, said: "I think
it is a good idea for the train dispatcher
using his own discretion as to what ton-
nage should be handled by trains, pro-
vided the superintendent will give him
authority to use his judgment in that
line. I find that an engineer is in a posi-
tion to tell more about the capacity of
his engine than the dispatcher; yet at the
same time, if you will let him use his
own judgment, he will frequently reduce
a greater amount of tonnage than is
actually necessary, and I believe he can
generally haul more than what he says
he can.
"I was on a freight train last week,
and the conductor told me that he must
reduce his train at next station, because
he had 60 tons more than his rating. I
told the conductor to say notliing about
it to the engineer, as I was confident he
could pull the train over the hill. My
advice was followed and the train was
taken over all right, but the engineer
seemed to feel that the tonnage was
greater than usual, for he sent the head
brakeman back to see if there was not a
brake stuck somewhere. Yet he had 60
tons more than his rating and handled it
without difficulty. For such reasons I
think that it is necessary sometimes for
December, igoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
551
the (lispatclicr to nuiUc ;iii .nbilr.iry nil
ing and tell the engineers lo take so
much tonnage, whether in their opinion
Ihcy can handle it or not. 1 have al-
ways found a similar result wlien the
engineer was allowed to use his judg-
ment about coal. Sometimes we would
get a message from an engineer asking
to be permitted to reduce his train on ac-
count of being short of coal. When thi.'
permission was refused, nine times out
of ten the full train would be taken
through to the coaling station williout
nmning for coal."
The Modern "Jolly Hiller."
Ancient song and tradition have given
the "jolly miller" a character for honesty
and fair dealing that raised his dealings
away above the petty tricks of trade. The
modern representative of the grinder of
corn does not appear to be well main-
taining the old honor of his craft. A dis-
cussion at the North-Western Railway
Club on "tonnage rating of trains," con-
veys serious reflections on the milling
fraternity of the Northwest.
An official of the Chicago, Great West-
ern Railway said: "I ride freight trains
considerably, and I find there is a vast
difiference in the hauling of trains re-
ported to have the same weight. En-
gineers complain that some trains haul
harder than others from causes hard to
explain. The greatest difificulfy we have
in handling our tonnage is in cars
that are known as special flour cars,
or trains loaded by the millers of Minne-
apolis, and they are supposed to give us
the actual tonnage. We find, however,
that this is not the case, and cars will
run from three to five tons in excess of
the tonnage as given by the millers. That
is a constant source of trouble, causing
our trains to stall and double, and not
only delaying themselves, but other
trains by reason of the tonnage being in
excess of the rating,"
The modern representation of the
"Jolly Miller" is far removed from the
•dusty workmen who used to regulate the
clatter of the mill stones and give fair
weight for grain received. He is a silk-
stockinged individual, often a politician
of high degree. We wonder if the social
elevation is accompanied by moral de-
gradation? Cheating railroad companies
by underbilling of weight is a mean
species of dishonesty.
Horace Greeley was noted for the way
he could swear without using oaths. He
said that of all horned cattle in a newspa-
per office, the college graduate was the
most useless. We heard the chief drafts-
man of a big office paraphrase Greeley's
remark, but he used plain cuss words.
The modern college graduate must be
an improvement over the old stock, for
he is a welcome help in most offices.
QUI-STIONS ANSWERED.
(73) J. S., Hamilton, Australia, writes:
In starting out on a trip I often find
the sight feed lubricator "Detroit" not
feeding and by simply shutting off steam
from the boiler (and leaving the bot-
tom valves of sight feed glasses open)
the oil immediately starts to pass up
the glasses, then turning the steam on
again from boiler, they continue to
work. This little "dodge" proves suc-
cessful nine times out of ten. Kindly
give cause? A.— There is in the oil a
certain amount of sedirtient, which can-
not be taken out by straining, and this
sediment which is really made up of
minute particles of solid matter in the
oil does occasionally clog the small hole
through which the oil feeds. When you
shut off the steam it relieves the pres-
sure in the lubricator, and the conden-
sation of the steam left in the lubricator
when you shut off, causes a slight re-
verse How. The water in the sight
glasses passes down through 'the oil
feed to help fill the central chamber,
and in doing so the obstruction in the
oil feed nozzle is removed.
(74) B. -M. H-, Cape Town, writes:
In the March, 1903, issue of Railway
AND LoCO.MOTtVE ENGINEERING there IS
an article on "Simple vs. Compound
Lubrication," page 116, in which it is
stated that the standard rate of lubrica-
tion for locomotive cylinders and valve
faces in America is 5 drops per minute.
Would you kindly inform me if this
applies to a sight feed lubricator with
one glass, the drop being divided be-
tween the two cylinders, or to a sight
feed lubricator with two glasses and an
independent feed to each cylinder? A. —
The statement that "the standard rate
of lubrication for locomotive cylinders
and valve faces in America is 5 drops
per minute" is a very broad one, and
would be more nearly correct and more
conservative if it had stated that the
average of the standard rate of lubrica-
tion for locomotive cylinders and valve
faces in America is 5 drops per minute.
The rate of lubrication depends very
much on conditions under which the
engine is working, the kind of service
in which it may be, and it varies all the
way from 3 drops to 10 drops per minute
per cylinder. In the article referred to
the reference was intended to mean 5
drops per minute per cylinder.
(75) H. I. M. asks:
What is the meaning of the word
"angularity" as applied to the main and
side rods of a locomotive? A. — The side
rods do not have any angularity ; they are
always parallel to the line of motion of
the piston and cross-head. What is called
the angularity of the connecting rod af-
fects the motion of the piston in a curious
way. When the crank pin is on the for-
ward quarter, the piston is at the end of
its stroke and is close to the front cylin-
der cover. When the pin reaches the bot-
tom quarter, the piston has moved some-
thing more than half its stroke, but when
the pin reaches the back center, the pis-
ton is at the end of its stroke and is close
to the back cylinder cover. When the pin
comes to the top quarter the piston has
not traveled quite half way back in the
cylinder, but when the pin again reaches
the forward quarter, the piston is at the
end of its stroke close lo the front cyl-
inder cover. Thus it is apparent that in
a full revolution of the crank pin, the pis-
ton will have traveled less while the pin
was making the half revolution farthest
from the piston, and it will have traveled
more while the pin was making the half
nearest the piston. In the case we have
been considering the pin described some-
thing more than half a revolution while
the piston was going from exact mid-po-
sition to back cylinder cover and return-
ing to exact mid-position. The pin also
describes something less than half a revo-
lution while the piston moves from exact
mid-position up to front cylinder cover
and back to mid-position again. This can
be easily understood by mentally pictur-
ing the connecting rod as attached to the
cross-head in the usual way, but having
the center of its big end placed exactly
opposite the center of the driving axle, the
cross-head then being in its exact mid-
position. Clamp the cross-head there, and
using the connecting rod as a radius,
lower the big end down to the crank pin
circle and the position which the crank
pin must assume under the circumstances
will be at a point slightly inside or on
the cross-head side of the vertical line
passing through the center of the driving
axle. Similarly if the big end be raised
up to meet the crank pin circle above the
axle, the position of the pin will again be
inside or on the cross-head side of the
vertical center line of the driving wheel.
(76) T. S. M., New York, writes:
I have had a discussion with a friend
about turning off an eccentric without
changing the throw. My friend says if
you turn off say, a half inch, you de-
crease the throw of the eccentric, he
says it is the same as moving the crank
pin nearer the center of the wheel. I
contend that turning off the outside of
an eccentric does not alter the throw.
Who is right? A.— You are right.
Turning off the outside of an eccentric
does not alter the throw. The distance
from center of the axle to the center
of the eccentric is the throw. Turning
off tlie outside does not affect this dis-
tance. The crank example is mislead-
ing. Turning off the outside of the
eccentric would be equivalent to reduc-
ing the diameter of the crank-pin, not
altering the position of its center. The
difference between the short side and
the long side of an eccentric is always
552
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
equal to its throw, the diameter may be
anything.
{77) B. McC, Louisville, Ky., writes:
Will you please answer in your ques-
tion column what percentage of strength
coal loses by lying on a bin exposed to the
weather? A. — There is a slow chemical
action going on all the time with coal
from the moment it is taken from the
mine. The oxygen of the air attacks the
carbon of the coal and forms carbonic acid
gas, also the oxygen combines with what
is called the disposable hydrogen in the
coal and this forms water. Heat is
evolved by both these actions. If this heat
is allowed to accumulate, spontaneous
combustion is the result, a free circulation
of air prevents the danger of fire, but the
chemical action cannot be checked. It is
analogous to the process known as rotting
in the case of wood. It is impossible to
give the percentage of loss, as it varies
with the length of the time the coal has
been exposed, and it varies according as
the atmosphere is generally dry or damp
and it varies with the quality of the coal
itself.
(78) J. A. B., Pueblo. Col., writes:
1. With a loo-ton Vauclain com-
pound, 50 miles from end of division,
valve stem key gone and end of stem
battered so it will not enter the head.
How would you proceed? Engine has
no clamp for valve stem and the bolts
in back end main rod cannot be driven
out. Bulletin says engine cannot be
run over 25 miles with main rod up.
A. — Place valve in center of travel to
cover ports, take out water relief valves
in end of cylinders and run at reduced
speed.
2. With the high pressure piston head
gone, but cylinder head in place, could
the engine be run 50 miles in hard ser-
vice without doing damage to the cross-
head or guides? A. — Can be done, but
would not be advisable.
3. In case this engine should be run
on one side with the back end of
main rod disconnected and the crosshead
ahead and blocked behind, valve pushed
clear ahead and both front cylinder heads
off, would she be entirely safe? A. — Yes.
Valve should be blocked in center cover-
ing both ports and main rod discon-
nected.
4. Men here claim this engine cannot
be blocked securely with wood. How is
it? A. — It can, same as single expan-
sion engine.
5. If a Vauclain can pull her train next
to center notch, is that not the place to
work her? If not, why put the notches
there? A. — Should not cut ofT more
than half stroke. If notches are in
quadrant between center notch and the
notch for half stroke cut-off they should
not be used.
(79) J. A. B., Pueblo, writes:
I. How can it be that one engine uses
less fuel and no less water than another
in the same class of service? Mr. Stew-
art, of the U. P., at the traveling engi-
neefs' convention, in Chicago, stated
that a Vauclain compound cutting off at
7 or 8 ins. is no lighter on water but
lighter on fuel and that the flues last
longer. A. — As Mr. Stewart did not'
produce statistics to prove his assertions,
we assume that it was merely his per-
sonal opinion. The heating surfaces of
the Vauclain compounds may possibly
be greater and better proportioned than
the simple engines he refers to, which
would give them a greater evaporative
efficiency for the same quantity of coal
consumed. Piston clearance, leaks about
the boiler, carrying a high water level
and working wet steam are all factors
to be considered. With the softer ex-
haust of the compound the life of the
flue should be prolonged. Conditions
must govern both cases.
2. Is there any truth in the statement
often made by engineers that an engine
once blown up or burned will be hard
on coal and water? A. — None whatever,
if there is enough left after the explosion
to put her in her former condition.
AUTOMOBII^E INSPECTION CAR.
(80) W. S. B., Quebec, writes:
The Quebec & Lake St. John Railway
some years ago bought two consolidation
engines at Kingston. Two pairs of driv-
ers were under the fire box and gave con-
siderable trouble. Later the M. M. re-
moved the rear driver. A says that the
engines lost some of their tractive power,
while B says there is no change. Who
is right? A. — If in removing the rear
drivers the weight was equally trans-
ferred from the rear drivers to the re-
maining drivers, the tractive effort re-
mains the same, and the engine should
do better work when once under way,
as there is less resistance from friction
due to the removal of one pair of rods
and wheels. The fewer driving wheels
an engine has the better for free work-
ing. If there is weight sufficient to keep
them from slipping, one pair of drivers
is most desirable.
tor Works, of Detroit, Mich., whose well-
known runabout, the Oldsmobile, has for
the past three seasons proven by far the
most popular machine of its weight and
type made.
While the Oldsmobile is light in
weight, its motor is unmatched for power
and strength, and it is this feature of the
machine that brought it successfully
through the recent ordeal of its journey
from San Francisco to New York, with-
out an accident of any kind.
The regular 4% h.p. motor of the
Oldsmobile has been used in making
a new Railway Inspection Car. The mo-
tor has been mounted on a suitable frame
and equipped with four 20 in. pressed
steel car wheels of very light construc-
tion. The axles and underframe are of
cold-rolled steel, with outer casings of
number 11 gauge steel tubing. The mo-
tor, which is the standard runabout en-
gine of 41/2 ins. bore by 6 ins. stroke, is
fitted with the regular two-speed-ahead-
and-one-reverse transmission. It will
carry four people comfortably, and will
ascend any grade, up to the point where
traction fails.
This machine is sure to prove very
valuable in railroad service. It will travel
from 80 to 100 miles with one filling of
the water and gasoline tanks, and wilf
reach a speed on ordinary levels of 35'
miles an hour.
Some improvements have been made
on the Olds motor that promises to give
it still greater efTectiveness. It has been
lightened by reducing the water jacket
to about one-half the length of the cylin-
der. Heat radiating flanges are now cast
on the lower half of the cylinder in place
of the water jacket, which covers only
the combustion chambers and the travel
of the piston head. The changes are not
radical, and in all other respects the mo-
tor is the same one that has carried the
Oldsmobile to its present high standing
in public favor.
Another successful application of the
Oldsmobile motor to the world of com-
merce is in the production of the new
Oldsmobile Light Delivery Wagon which
has just recently made its appearance on
the market.
Its general construction is that of the
famous runabout which has preceded it.
It has a longer body, and carries a box
measuring one cubic yard inside. It
measures, over all, 8 ft. 2 ins., is s ft. 2 ins.
wide, and is 6 ft. 8 ins. in height. The
wheel base measures 6 ft., and its tread
is 4 ft. 7 ins. The wheels are of the ar-
tillery type, and are equipped with 28x3
in. detachable tires.
Automobile Inspection Car.
A very interesting example of the ap-
plication of the automobile motor to
commercial and industrial uses, is seen in
some new productions of the Olds Mo-
I hold every man a debtor to his pro-
fession; from the which as men of course
seek to receive countenance and profit,
so ought they of duty to endeavor them-
selves by way of amends to be a help
and ornament thereunto. — Bacon.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
553
Air= Brake Department.
The Engine Truck Brake As a Hin-
drance to Curvinj;.
In the past few months considerable
discussion has been had regarding the
air brake on the engine truck hinder-
ing the curving of the locomotive. As
one or two instances have occurred in
fast train service where the engine has
failed to keep the rail, and gone ofif the
track on a curve while going at high
speed, considerable adverse comment
has been made on the truck brake, the
charge being made that when the truck
brake is applied the truck is held rigid
and not given the proper freedom which
it should have to properly follow the
curve of the track. A little deliberation
and logical examination will prove that
these objections are unfounded, and that
the truck brake is entirely innocent of
any of these charges made against it.
The truck brake is wholly self-con-
tained; that is, the brake cylinder, all of
the rods and levers, etc., with the ex-
ception of the flexible hose connection,
have no outside attachment whatever to
the engine frame or elsewhere, and are
contained wholly within the truck frame
itself. If the pull on the levers were
from some point back of the truck and
outside of it, there might, possibly, be
debatable grounds for accusing the
brake of hindering the engine truck in
adapting itself to curves in the track.
However, actual service has proven
even this to be untrue.
To illustrate the self-contained prin-
ciple of the truck brake, we might com-
pare it with a man lying on his back on
the floor with his knees under his chin,
feet extended, and tugging at his boot-
straps. In this position, if a person
were to attempt to whirl around in a
circle the doubled-up man while pushing
his feet into his boots, they would find
that it could be as easily done as though
the man were to release the tension on
his boot-straps. This is an example of
a self-contained pull from the inside,
and none coming from the outtside.
Coming nearer to the actual case, we
might place a locomotive upon its back,
wedge the truck brake shoes tightly
against the wheels and then spin the
truck and its frame on its center bear-
ing around on the center casting. Then
we might remove the wedges, allowing
the brake's shoes to be free from the
wheels, and again rotate the truck
around the center casting, and it would,
of course, be found that the ease with
which this rotation was made was the
same in both cases. Hence, it will be
CONDUCTKU BY F. M. NRH,I.S.
seen that where the brake pull conies
from within the truck itself, there is no
hindrance whatever to the truck wheels
adjusting ttheniselvcs to suit the curv-
ing of the engine, and the truck will
faithfully lead the engine around the
curve.
The hindrance of the air brake to the
leading wheels of a vehicle in curving
is disproved in the electric car, which
goes easily around very sharp curves.
The truck has the same connection
through its center casting to the car
body that the engine truck has through
its center casting to the engine frame.
However, if the locomotive or car is
running at a very high rate of speed,
and the curve is not properly elevated
on the outside rail, the natural tendency
of the wheel is to mount the rail and
H. C. FRAZER, A PIONEER AIR BRAKE-
MAN, RECENTLY DECE.A.SED.
jump the track; and improper elevation
of outer rail may be sufficient to permit
it to do so, especially if the flanges of
the wheels are in a worn and sharp
condition. But,- with wheel flanges in
good condition, proper curve elevation
and the center bearing of the truck suf-
ficiently free to permit the truck to
easily turn, there should be no trouble
from this source.
In looking back to the days before
truck brakes were applied to engines
we find certain instances of where a
center casting fitting too snugly in the
center bearing of the truck frame caused
engines to climb the rail and wreck
themselves. Hence, it would seem a
very logical conclusion that the objec-
tions above referred to are whollj' with-
out fact or foundation.
HocklnK Valley k. k. Instruction Car.
In keeping with the spirit of progress,
the Hocking Valley Railroad has re-
cently built at their shops in Columbus,
C, from designs made by Mr. S. S. Stif-
fcy, superintendent of motive power, an
elaborate, up-to-date instruction car,
which contains all the apparatus neces-
sary to demonstrate thoroughly the
workings of the air brakes, steam
heat, injectors, lubricators and other
attachments usually found in mod-
irn railway service, and it is to
be used for the purpose of instruct-
ing the employes of this system in the
correct method of caring for, operating
and maintaining these devices.
In the accompanying illustrations of
the car, view No. i shows the exterior.
View No. 2 shows the interior, looking
toward the office and reception room.
The brakes are operated by the engi-
neer's brake valves, either Westing-
house or New York, as desired, both of
these types of brakes being used on this
system, and they are shown located in the
end of the car, mounted on the main
reservoir. The freight brakes, 18 in all,
consisting of 9 Westinghouse and 9 New
York equipments, are located on one
side of the car, while the passenger
brakes, consisting of engine, tender and
passenger coach equipment, are located
on the other, thus leaving a large space
between the equipments in the center of
the car for the accommodation of the
classes.
The brake valves are so piped that the
apparatus may be operated by either
the Westinghouse or the New York, by
simply cutting out one or the other. To
each engineer's valve there is a sectional
valve of the same type, connected in
tandem, so that the student can see just
what each valve is doing in each posi-
tion of the handle. The triple valves
also have sectional models working in
tandem with them, so that their opera-
tion may be easily seen and understood.
Sectional parts of all air brake valves,
steam valves and lubricators used on
the system, are conveniently located in
different parts of the car, where they
may be examined and their construction
studied.
Five large charts of the New York
quick action triple valve, showing its
different positions while in action, adorn
the sides of the car, and are hung just
above the passenger equipment. The
train air signal piping is attached to the
roof, where it may be conveniently op-
erated and yet not be in the way.
554
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
View No. 3 shows the interior of the
car, looking toward the other end, in
which the Fairbanks and Morse air
compressor, which furnishes the com-
pressed air to operate the brakes, is lo-
cated. A gasoline engine operates' the
compressor, so that there is no neces-
sity for a boiler or a coal and water
storage. View No 4 shows the office and
instructor's room, with upper and lower
CORRESPONDENCE.
Don't Push the Cork In.
Considerable trouble is being had
from the high-speed reducing valve,
which arrives at the shops here with a
small cork in the vent hole in the ad-
justing screw cap. Very often the cork
is pushed in until the Hat head is flush
I claim for this device as follows: Ab-
solute safety, as it is impossible to loose
control of the train. Great economy, as
it saves air and pump wear. Increased
braking power, as there is always full
pressure in the main drum and auxiliary.
Besides this, the brakes are free when-
ever so wanted. There is no delay in
cutting out retainers at stations or level
places, and no risking the lives of brake-
men climbing over icy cars on dark win-
ter nights, turning up or down retainers
as now. V. Bergenheim,
Oakland, Cal. Sou. Pac. Ry.
NO 1 —EXTERIOR VIEW OF THE HOC
TION
berths for the accommodation of those
in charge.
The piping for the brakes is the same
in length as that found on an ordinary
train of 18 cars, and is so arranged that
all angle cocks and cut-out cocks may
be conveniently manipulated in the same
manner that it is done in actual service
on the road, and the whole or any de-
sired part of the brakes operated at will.
By this means all the peculiar opera-
tions of the brakes, due to cutting in
cars with defective triples, or cutting
them out, as well as the effect produced
at the brake valve on the train pipe ex-
haust by different lengths of train pipe
may be shown. The whole interior ar-
rangement of the apparatus is conven-
ient and compact, utilizing all available
space in such manner as best to serve
the purpose for which the car is in-
tended, which reflects much credit on
the ability of the designer.
The car is in charge of Mr. L. C. Eng-
ler, general road foreman of engines,
who is assisted by Mr. H. H. Hill, as-
sistant road foreman of engines, and Mr.
W. H. Wiley, traveling fireman. The
car will be kept in operation all the time
over the 1,100 miles of road owned and
operated by the Hocking Valley Com-
pany, and will on those lines, as similar
cars have done on other lines, prove a
great benefit to the employees, and -a
paying investment to the company.
RlNi, \A1,1.1-;V .\IR-BRAKE INSTRUC-
CAR.
with the metal, and is very hard to dig
out. The man putting up the valve will
take a stick and poke the cork through
the hole, inside of the cap. The cork
will ofttimes fall back into the hole,
stopping it as completely as if it had
been driven in. This allows the brake
cylinder pressure leaking past the pis-
ton to store up in the spring case and
assist the spring in pushing the valve
upward. Cases have been found where
the brake would release much quicker
than it should, and have been found tn
be due to the cork stopping up the vent
hole in the cap. Amos Judd.
Boston, Mass.
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ON AIR-BRAKE SUBJECTS
(83) R. J. L., Philadelphia, Pa..
;isks:
Which will hold the best, a brake shoe
six inches from the rail or one twelve
inches? I mean that many inches from
the top of the rail to the middle of the
shoe. Also, the .same pull on each
slioe. A.— If there is no difference in
conditions except in the height of the
shoe from the rail, the one ten inches
above the rail will have a greater hold-
ing effect. The shoe pulling nearest to
the center of the wheel is the best hold-
ing shoe. The lower hung shoe pulls
farther from the center of the wheel,
and will therefore produce less retard-
ing effect.
To the young this is a world of action,
not for moping and droning in. — David
Cofperfield.
An Automatic Retaining Valve.
This automatic retainer is composed
of (i) a diaphragm, (2) a winged check
valve, and (3) an adjustable spring set
to balance the auxihary pressure as ex
erted on the diaphragm.
Its operation is as follows: Set tb.
spring to balance one or two pounds
over trainline pressure. Charge up the
brake cylinders to whatever pressure is
needed to control the train on a down
grade, recharge trainline by placing the
valve in running position, and the re-
tainer will hold all the pressure that is
in the cylinders. Now, brakes charged,
auxiliaries recharged, pump resting roll-
ing down grade, what more is wanted?
To release, throw some excess pressure
into trainline and raise auxiliary pres-
sures the one or two pounds needed to
overcome the spring and brakes will
come right off.
NO. 2.— AN INTl-.KKlK'. VIKW OF THE
HOCKING VALLEY)' AIR-BRAKE
INSTRUCTION CAR.
(84) A. B. L., Lexington, Ky., asks:
Why don't they put a collar on the
lower end of the piston rod of the air
pump, thus giving a broader shoulder
or bearing surface for the piston head?
The bearing is so narrow that when the
head works loose on the rod, the pound-
ing of the head against the narrow
Dcoembcr, igo.'i.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
555
shoulder will wear a big liulc in the
head and let the rod slip through. A. —
The trouble is not in the narrow
shoulder, which is wide enough if lost
motion is Ucpt out. but is due to the
as in the other A. — As a general rule
the longer the blow at the angle fitting
the longer the train, providing the blows
in both cases sound about alike; but if
one discharge is rather weaker than the
tut a larger thread on it? It would be
stronger then, and would not break as
easy as it docs now. There are a lot
of engines that break the nut off the
rod right where the thread stops. A. —
If the nut is screwed up lightly and se-
curely locked so there is absolutely no
lost motion between the nut and the
piston, the piston rod will be found to
be large and strong enough. The usual
cause of the breakage of the rod at the
point described is the screwing up of the
nut with a chisel when the piston is in
the cylinder. This damage is frequently
done in the round house by the run-
ning repair man, who resorts to a ham-
mer and chisel after finding the whole
piston turns when a wrench is used on
the nut.
R. M.
Buffalo, X. Y..
3.— INTKRIOR VIEW OK THK HOCKING VAI.I^HV AIR-BRAKE
IN.STRUCTION CAR. LOOKING DOWN THE AISLE W.W
TOWARD THE COMPRESSOR.
nuts not being screwed up tightly and
securely, and the head is not held tight-
ly against the shoulder. A little lost
motion will be left which grows and in-
creases until the haad is slipping back
and forth on the rod, finally wearing
through if not properly attended to.
(85) B. McC, Louisville, Ky._, asks:
If a retainer holds 15 pounds in the
brake cylinder, and you recharge to 70
pounds, arid you apply the brake in
emergency, will the retarding force be
greater than the force against the rail of
a freight car? A. — The final brake cylin-
der pressure, after 15 pounds has been
held in the cylinder by the retaining
valve, the auxiliary reservoir re-charged
and brakes reapplied, would be but a
few pounds higher than if the brake
cylinder were empty, and a similar ap-
plication of the brakes had been made.
The pressure of the brake shoes against
the wheels would not be sufficient to
cause them to slide, and would be but a
slight increase over the application
made with the retaining valve turned
down.
(86) E. J. H., Wilkesbarre, Pa.,
asks:
Does the length of the sound of the
train pipe exhaust at the brake valve al-
ways tell the number of cars in your
train? In other words, if the blow at
the valve is longer at one time than an-
other, does it always follow that there
are more cars in the train, even though
the blow mav not be as loud in one case
other, and the length of time of dis-
charge the same, it would indicate that
there is ice or other furci.^jn substance
(88)
writes:
There is a general belief among some
of the engineers and firemen that the
engine truck brake hinders the engine
in tracking or curving, and that several
instances, where the engine has left the
track, that the truck brake has been re-
sponsible for the engine climbing the
rail on the curve. What is you opinion
of this? A. — As it is a fact that the
truck brake is self-contained, and has no
connection to the engine frame, it can-
not, therefore, have any influence on the
engine curving. However, if the truck
brake shoes received their pull from
some backward point on the engine
frame, it might be possible that such ar-
NO 4.
-THE OFFICE AND SLEEPING ROOM OF THE HOCKING VALLEY
AIR-BRAKE INSTRUCTION CAR.
forming an obstruction in the hose or
the train pipe somewhere.
(87) A. B. L., Lexington, Ky.,
writes:
Why wouldn't it be better to make
the air end of the piston rod larger and
rangement would, in a degree, hinder
the truck somewhat in curving: but as
all connections are centered in the
truck itself, there can be no real cause
for accusing the truck brake of causing
the engine to climb the rails.
556
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
(89) R. J. L., Philadelphia, Pa.,
asks:
Which is the best brake, one that is
hung outside of the wheels, or one that
is hung between the two wheels? Why?
A. — Generally speaking, the inside hung
form is more advantageous. A better
length of hanger can be used without
causing the brake shoes to be lowered
close to the rail. Thus the shoe can-
not climb up the wheel and the short
hanger allow a wedging action which
will tend to slide the wheel. The in-
side form does not permit to the same
extent the tilting of the truck and the
consequent jolt to the train in stopping,
as does the outside hung. The inside
hung form is sometimes more trouble-
some to fit with new brake shoes, due
to the interference of some of the out-
side parts of the truck frame. Again,
the inside hung form does not require
the stiff release springs which too fre-
quently find their way on the out-
side form.
(90) C. E. H., Philadelphia, Pa.,
asks:
If an engine is equipped with two air
pumps, should two governors be used,
or would one operate both pumps? A. —
Where two air pumps are installed on
an engine, two air pump governors and
two lubricators should be supplied sep-
arately for these pumps, if a complete
duplication of pumps is desired. If one
pump should become inoperative, from
any cause, there would be another en-
tirely separate machine, and its attach-
ments to carry on the work. If this du-
plication of parts is not complete there
will not be two separate machines, and
in the event of the breaking down of the
governor, the purpose of supplying a
second pump will be defeated. On the
other hand, if it is desired to have both
pumps running all the time, dividing up
the work evenly, the arrangement of one
governor, or one set of tops and two
bodies, would answer the purpose bet-
ter. There are engines equipped both
ways, and doing the work satisfactorily
in the way intended.
(91) H. H., Victoria, British Colum-
bia, writes:
I would like to know what the gauge
is like which is attached to the engi-
neer's brake valve for recording emer-
gency applications. A. — The gauge part
is about three inches in diameter, and is
graded, or divided, into parts like a
steam or air gauge; but instead of
pounds pressure, the gradations mean
the number of emergency applications
made. The gauge is operated by a de-
vice which consists of a piston, having
on the end of its rod an attachment
which notches up in the same manner
that the mileage is recorded on a bicycle
recorder. The whole attachment is
fastened to the back of the brake valve.
where the air comes from the train pipe
when an emergency application is made.
On each emergency application the air
strikes this piston, and drives it inward,
causing the recorder to register up one
notch at a time. Each of these emer-
gency applications is thus shown on the
gauge, and goes against the man oper-
ating the brake valve.
■To Cut uut Cock
Ketainer
Pop Valve
NEW DESIGN OF AN AUTOMATIC RE-
TAINING VALVE, THE VALVE
ATTACHED TO THE
CYLINDER.
(92) R. O. F., Philadelphia, Pa.,
writes:
We have an engine here that is piped
with double topped governor. The low-
pressure head was set in the shop for
90 pounds, and the high pressure head
for no pounds. The connection to the
high-pressure head is tapped into the
main reservoir pressure at the brake
valve, and the low-pressure top is con-
nected to the under side of the brake
valve. It does not matter in which po-
sition the brake handle is placed, the
pump will not stop until no pounds
pressure has been pumped up, when the
high pressure governor head operates.
We have taken off the low-pressure head
connection, and find no air coming
From AuJC. Bes.
Diaphra\
DETAILED PARTS OF A NEW AUTO-
M.^TIC RETAINING VALVE.
through at all. Please say what is the
trouble. A. — Doubtless there is some
obstruction between the feed port in
the brake valve into which the low-
pressure head is tapped and the govern-
or connection, else air would flow from
the pipe when disconnected at the gov-
ernor. Possibly the gasket in the lower
part of the brake valve has not been cut
away,' thereby blanking the port which
should supply air to the low-pressure
head. Possibly, again, there is a stop-
page in the pipe itself.
(93) J- McT., Chicago, 111., writes:
We had a passenger train leaving Chi-
cago on our road on which the brakes
would set and release alternately. In
one case the train was brought to a
standstill before the brakes could be re-
leased, and then a bad leak was found
in the hose coupling between the tender
and first car. The track at which point
this occurred was very uneven and
rough, being a portion of track that was
being elevated, and was lying on a loose,
sandy foundation, making numerous dips
and rises. Could this rough track have
anything to do with the brakes going
on? A. — Yes Doubtless your trouble
was occasioned by undue stretching of
the draft gear and air hose couplings be-
tween the engine and tender, and per-
haps between the cars also, caused by
the track being so rough as to allow the
train to be pretty badly twisted and
thrown out of line, and as soon as the
bad point was passed, the draft gear and
hose couplings would resume their nor-
mal position, stopping the outflow of air
from the couplings, and permitting the
brakes to release. Inasmuch that this
trouble did not appear on any other
track than the very rough track men-
tioned, this explanation would seem a
logical one.
(94) S. H. W., Meadville, Pa., asks:
What is the small -plug for that is on
the under side of the brake valve near
the main reservoir connection? Where
does the port lead to that this plug taps
into, and what is the object of the plug?
Is it a gauge connection or what? A. —
This plug fills a hole which is tapped
into the port which conveys main reser-
voir pressure from the rotary valve seat
to the feed valve attachment. The ob-
ject of this plug is to furnish a connec-
tion to the top of the low pressure,
double topped governor in freight ser-
vice. This low-pressure governor top is
set for go pounds. When the valve
handle is in either full release or run-
ning position, there is main reservoir
pressure in this port, and the governor
will shut steam off the pump when 90
pounds pressure has been reached in the
main reservoir. When the valve handle
is on either lap position or application
positions, this port is not in communi-
cation with the main reservoir, and the
low-pressure governor is, therefore, cut
out. Thus, a main reservoir pressure of
no pounds main reservoir pressure may
be accumulated during brake applica-
tion to insure release of brakes on a long
train, and yet the pump is not obliged to
continually work against a higher pres-
sure than the normal pressure of 90
pounds at other times.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
557
(95) C. C. B., Cape Cliailes, Va.,
writes:
What should I do to maUc a 9>^-inch
Wcstinghouse air pimip have more
speed? Our pumps, after overhauling
them the first time, usually run about
one-third slower, while charging up the
main reservoir, when first starting, and,
in fact, all the time. Our new pumps
will charge up in two minutes, while it
takes the repaired pumps three minutes.
Please tell me how to overcome the
trouble. A. — There are three principal
things that will cause a pump to run
slow, viz., restricted steam passage-
ways, whereby the steam pressure goes
too slowly to the air piston; choked ex-
haust, causing exhaust steam to escape
slowly, and too small lift of air valves
or suction inlets, which prevents air
from getting into (he air cylinder as
quickly as it should. Possibly some of
the ports in the pumps are partially
closed by gaskets lapping over the steam
ports. Again, possibly the lift of your air
valves is insufficient, or the passageways
in the pump are clogged up with burned
oil, due to lubricating the pump through
the air valves. A lye-bath of the air
cylinder and ports would remedy the
latter. Possibly the pump will make as
many strokes per minute after it is re-
paired as before, but will not pump up
the pressure with the same number of
strokes. If this is the case, the trouble
is probably due to the fitting of new
packing rings in a cylinder without re-
boring the cylinder, thus permitting the
rings to fit only at mid-stroke, and be
loose at both ends of the stroke, where
the cylinder is worn larger.
(96) R. M. E., Buflfalo, N. Y.,
writes:
A number of our Atlantic type pass-
enger engines have a truck brake on
the forward double truck, on the driving
wheels, and on the trailing wheels be-
hind. That is, all wheels on the engine
are braked. I note that when the en-
gine comes to a stop at the station with
a train, the trailing wheels pick up and
slide. This looks as though the engine
truck brake pulls the forward end of the
engine down, and allows the rear end to
raise up behind, causing less weight to
rest on the trailing wheels and results
in sliding. Would it not be advisable
to reduce the braking power of the
truck brake for this reason? A. — Inas-
much that the truck brake is self-con-
tained; that is, the cylinder and all the
truck brake parts are on the truck frame,
and not on the engine frame, and have no
connection whatever with any other
part of the engine excepting the rubber
connecting hose, it would be impossible
for the truck brake to pull the forward
end of the engine down. It might be
possible, however, that the engine, hav-
ing very high wheels, and standing very
high in the air, is top-heavy, and has a
tendency to do a summersault when
coming to a stop, thereby lowering the
front end of the engine and raising it
behind. This would cause the rear
trailing wheels to slide. If this be true,
the better plan would be to reduce the
braking power on the trailing wheels to
prevent them from sliding, rather than
reduce the braking power at the engine
truck brake.
(97) G. W. K., Washington, D. C.,
writes:
A class of engines here are piped in a
way that the train signal reducing valve
feeds into the signal pipe back of the
signal valve, or between where the sig-
nal valve is connected and the cut-out
cock on the tender. If the reducing
valve is in good condition, it is impos-
sible to get a long blast of the whistle,
and it requires a neat fit of diaphragm
stem in the bushing in order to get a
blast of the whistle on six or seven cars.
Is this method of piping right? A. —
The method of piping described is not
the best obtainable, and a better method
would be to have the pipe to the signal
valve tee off the main pipe at a certain
point, then of? this branch pipe to the
signal valve have another branch pipe
tee off to the reducing valve, which
should be located a foot or two at least
from the pipe leading to the signal valve.
Then to the opposite side of the reduc-
ing valve have the supply pipe connec-
tion made to the main reservoir. With
this method of piping the signal will re-
spond equally well whether the engine
be going ahead pulling a train, or back-
ing up pulling the train. The diaphragm
stem should be an easy, though neat, fit
in the bushing at all times in order to
insure a good signal at the whistle. If
this stem becomes too loose, it will sup-
ply signal pipe leakage better, but will
not be near so sensitive when respond-
ing to a blast made at the discharge
valve in the car. It might be well to ob-
serve that the discharge valves in the
cars of the train are perfectly free and
open, and a strong, sharp exhaust is
had each time the cord is pulled.
(98) J. E. L., Savannah, Ga., writes-
What kind of oil, and how much of it
should be put in the air cylinder of the
air pump? Some instructors say to put
no oil in the air cylinder until the piston
begins to groan, but to let the swab on
the piston rod do the lubricating. A. —
A good, substantial bodied oil, such as
high-grade valve or cylinder oil, should
be used in the air cylinder, and put in
through the oil cup. W^hile an oiled swab
should be kept on the piston rod, addi-
tional lubricant will be needed as de-
scribed, especially now when the pump
is required to do greater work on longer
trains than formerly on short trains.
The condition of the pump and the ser-
vice it is in must determine the amount
of oil used, good judgment being exer-
cised to discriminate between flooding
and stinting in the supply of the air
cylinder lubricant.
(99) M. R. R., Rutland, Vt., writes:
On an engine equipped with the G-6
brake valve, the train line gauge hand
will show 90 pounds the same as the
main reservoir gauge hand, when the en-
gine is not coupled to a train and the
brake valve handle is in running posi-
tion, where they ought to be 70 and 90.
But when the engine is coupled to a
train of 30 or 40 air-braked cars, and
the handle is put in running position,
the train line and main reservoir hands
will stand at 70 and 90 all right What
makes this difference? A. — Either the
rotary valve, or the supply valve in the
feed valve attachment, or both of these
parts, may leak sufficiently to allow
main reservoir pressure to escape into
the train line and equalize, and show on
the gauge. On the lone engine the leak-
age is sufficiently great, in comparison
with the short length of train pipe, to
bring about this equalization rather
easily. On a train of considerable
length, however, the train pipe volume is
very much greater, and the leakage past
the defective parts described being the
same in amount, will be lost in the
larger train pipe volume.
(100) M. R. R., Rutland, Vt., writes:
When a reduction is made at the brake
valve on a lone engine, and the brake
valve handle is put to full release to let
brakes off, there will be a flash and a
long blow of air at the train pipe ex-
haust. It only acts this way on the en-
gine alone, and will not do it when the
engine is coupled to a train. The piston
seems to raise up and cause the blow,
but why don't it do it on a train, too?
A. — With the light engine the brake
valve in release position will, on account
of the larger port, admit pressure from
the main reservoir into the train pipe
on the under side of the equalizing pis-
ton more rapidly than on the top of the
piston, where a smaller port leads.
Therefore, the piston will rise and flash.
However, when the engine is coupled
to a train, the greater volume of train
pipe will absorb the pressure coming
from the main reservoir to the train
pipe. This prevents the backing up of
pressure under the piston, and the con-
sequent flash at the brake valve.
We would again urge our correspond-
ents to send their letters and contribu-
tions to us as early in the month as
they can, as the air-brake department
goes to press earlier than some other
parts of the paper. Each month we are
obliged to hold over matter coming to
us too late for the current issue. Cor-
respondents should also send full name
and address for our private use.
55S
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December. 1903.
Apparatus for Drilling Stay Bolts.
The accompanying illustration shows
a handy apparatus for drilling the small
tell-tale holes in the ends of stay bolts,
which many railroads require to be done
when buying new equipment. It is used
in the Pittsburgh shops of the American
Locomitive Company.
The apparatus consists of an upright
plank 114 ins. thick, hinged at the bot-
tom upon a il4-'m. round iron rod which
•lies just above the floor level, and upon
this rod the plank can slide so as to
stand opposite any portion of the fire
box sides or end. The long upright
plank is held at the top by a cord lead-
ing to a small weight. The cord passes
over a pulley which revolves upon a
shaft held at each end by temporary
Pulley slides on
aha/t the full Icngtli
of Firebox
is practically balanced, very little exertion
on the part of the workman is required
to hold it as he may require it. The
whole rig is very simple and very in-
genious, and is a time and labor saver
in the shop.
in for his share of condemnation and was
accused of trying to down the S. M. P.'s
pet engines.
What Came of Trying to Save the
Expense of Washing Out Boilers.
About four years ago a Supt. M. P.,
on a transcontinental line, issued an order
for a bad-water district, that the boilers
were now equipped with a sufficient num-
ber of blow-off cocks, and that the fre-
quent washing out, which had previously
been resorted to, must be discontinued.
Conditions were such that boilers had
to be washed every other trip in order to
make successful trips. At each end of
APPARATUS FOR DRILLING STAYBOLTS.
brackets. The pulley also slides along
this shaft as the board is moved along
the side of the fire box. The board for
drilling stays in the end of the fire box
has a counter weight pulley which can
swing on a pin that fits the socket
of a dome stud. The plank also car-
ries a smaller one, made out of i-in. .
stuff and perforated so as to hold the
end of a small drill. The drill is also
similarly counterbalanced with cord and
pulley so that the workman is not
fatigued by constantly supporting the
weight of his machine, and is thus en-
abled to devote his entire attention to the
accurate performance of the work in
hand. The plank can be drawn back, or
pushed toward the fire box at the top so
that the required angle for the drill is
easily got, and as the weight of the board
the line the hostler filled up ihe boiler
and blew down two gauges. After a
month's trial, during which period the
boilers had received two washouts, it was
found that it required a constant water
pressure of 125 lbs. and of four hours' du-
ration to dislodge the scale and mud that
had accumulated at the throat-sheet before
any water got to the leg of the boiler.
Nor was this all the trouble. Trains
were delayed by engines foaming, flues
began to leak, and engines died on the
main line, blocking traffic. The manu-
facturer was unjustly condemned and ac-
cused of furnishing inferior flues, and the
engines, having seen only 60 days' ser-
vice, had to have their flues removed,
while, with the old method of washing
out, the flues generally gave from S to 7
months' good service. The engineer came
For many years engineers cared noth-
ing about the theory of the steam en-
gine. They went on improving and de-
veloping it without any assistance from
men of pure science. The most import-
ant improvements carried out on the
engine have originated from the unaided
good sense of the practical m.en. There
are certain things which science ought
to have predicated, such as the economy
of compounding, which were left to prac-
tical men to carry out. But as sonn as
the advantages were demonstrated sci-
ence theorists rushed forward to make
explanations. If scientists would fall
into the way of giving help before the
practical man had surmounted the gra-
dients opposing success in carrying out
improvements it would profit the indus-
trial world more.
A short time ago the oceam tramp
steamship Arara sailed from New York
with one million dollars of new silver
money for the Philippine Islands. There
was a special guard with this shipment
and the vessel carried two rapid-fire 3-in.
guns and some smaller ones. In her
cargo were twenty-five old locomotives
from the Manhattan Elevated Railway.
They have been refitted and are in good"
shape. They have been painted a bright
j'ellow, with large Chinese characters on
their sides, which indicate the name of
the foreign railway which now owns
them. New Yorkers who have been
familiar with the soberly colored little
puffers on the "L" road would hardly
know them now, dressed each in the
coveted "yellow jacket," which is a mark
of high distinction in the Celestial Em-
pire.
A correspondent on the Illinois Cen-
tral Railroad, at Champaign, III., writes
us: "We have a lot of new engines
which are giving some trouble with
broken steam chests, engineers having
been disciplined by the master mechanic,
who claims fractures were caused by
working water. We think that the trouble
is too little oil. We are allowed 1%
pints of valve oil to keep a 20-in. con-
solidation engine going over a division
of 125 miles. We would like to have
the opinion of your readers as to the
cause of the trouble."
The city of Dunkirk, N. Y.. is enthus-
iastic over a proposal to erect a monu-
ment in honor of the late Horatio G.
Brooks, founder of the Brooks Locomo-
tive Works. It will, when completed,
be placed in Washington Park.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
559
Signals and Signalin);.
BY GEORGE S. IIODGINS.
{Continued from Page 328.)
TIIK ni-OCK SYSTEM.
The block system in itself is not a
piece of mechanism, and though it re-
quires the use of more or less carefully
adjusted apparatus, it is on railroads
nothing more than~ a thoroughly safe
TlIU DISTANCE OR SAFETY I.IGHT ON
A TOBOGGAN SLIDE. '"W
method of train movement. In Canada,
where one of the popular outdoor winter
sports is tobogganing, it is an invariable
custom on a properly managed "slide" to
have a small pine tree branch stuck in
the snow at one side of the track and
about half way down the incline. At
night a lantern or torch indicates the
spot selected. This torch is called the
"distance light," and the rule which
every one is expected to obey, is that
no toboggan shall leave the top of the
slide until the preceding toboggan has
passed beyond the distance light. The
observance of this rule places a certain
definite space interval between each to-
boggan-load of pleasure seekers as they
glide down the hill, and this is, in prin-
ciple, nothing more or less than the
block system.
STATION TELEGRAPH BLOCK SIGNAL.
The methods of applying this principle
to railroad operation are various, but
the end and object of them all is to se-
cure a space interval between trains mov-
ing in the same direction. The time in-
terval between trains has been found to
be so utterly unreliable and so many
serious accidents have happened under
time spacing that it is being displaced
yearly on an increasing number of roads
by the block system.
The simplest form of the block system
on a single track road has already been
alluded to. It consists of constituting
the distance between any two stations,
a block, and placing the operators along
the line, in telegraphic communication
with each other. The method of pro-
cedure may be outlined by a definite ex-
ample. Suppose a train moving down
the alphabet line, arrives at station C.
The operator at that point notifies the
operator at D that a down train is ready
to proceed from C. The operator at D
signifies to C his understanding of the
message, and displays his stop signal.
C likewise displays his stop signal and
the down train moves on, protected at
front and rear by the block signals at
D and C. When the train reaches D
the information is telegraphed back to
C, and the operator there can lower his
stop signal as the block between C and
D is then clear. On a double track road
the down line would be blocked by C a^
soon as the train had passed that sta-
tion, and the signal behind the train
would be kept at "danger" until D had
telegraphed to C the news of the passing
of the train at D. This method briefly
outlined here is called the telegraph
block system.
The telegraph system, which is safe
as far as it goes, when nobody for-
gets, has, nevertheless, several obvious
drawbacks. The spacing of the sta-
tions may be such that blocks will
be of unequal length. A long block
separating two shorter ones, would,
when traffic became heavy, cause serioii-
loss of time, and perhaps lead to con
gestion at points least able to cope witli
it. Even if some particular block wa^
all that could be desired in the matter
of length: grades and curves in it might
so consume the time of trains as to nnke
it practically as objectionable in opera-
lion as an exceedingly long block would
be. A station operator in charge of block
signals would probably have other duties
thrust upon him which would increase
his responsibility and at the same time
tend to distract his attention from the
work of signal operation.
The natural remedy for these defects
would seem to be, to increase the num-
ber of signal stations, so that blocks
more nearly equal in length might be
secured, sections where grades, curves
or other physical features tended tii
lengthen the time required by trains to
pass through them, could be divided up in-
to shorter blocks, thus preserving safety of
operation while naturally increasing
the capacity of the track. The appear-
ance of signal towers along the line with
men in charge whose sole duty related
to the telegraphing of information and
the operation of signals, would mark a
further development of the telegraph
block signal system. The need for some
such arrangement as this would foster
the introduction of automatic block sig-
nals, which have now Ijccn brought to
a high degree of excellence.
THE SIGNALS AND WHAT THEV INDICATE.
From the original telegraph block sys-
tem, by due process of evolution, which
it is not necessary to trace in detail, we
come to the modern automatic system,
and just here it may be advantageous to
glance at the signals themselves and see
what indications they may be made to
give and how they give them. The or-
dinary form of block signal is that of a
semaphore having two arms on one post.
One is placed at the top and the other
is about six feet lower down, the post
being about twenty-eight feet high. The
arms usually hang from the post in such
a position that when raised they
stretch toward the right and away
from the track which they govern. The
SEMAPHORE ARM %VITII POINTED END.
upper one is called the "home" signal,
and it governs the block at the entrance
of which it stands, and which we may
call the block adjacent to the signal.
The lower arm is called the "distant"
signal, and it relates to the block next
ahead, and when once raised, cannot be
lowered while the block next ahead is
occupied. At the entrance of block A
the "home" signal governs block A,
while the "distant" signal on the post
at A indicates the condition of block B.
The "home" signal is usually painted
red, with a white band across it near
the blunt or sometimes pointed end.
farthest from the post. When hanging
at an angle of 60° from horizontal it in-
dicates "all clear." and at night shows a
white light in this position. If the new
color scheme is used it shows a green
56o
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
light for "all clear." When at "danger,"
the arm is extended horizontally from the
-post, and a red light is displayed at night.
The "distant" or lower signal is simi-
lar in shape except that it has what is
called a "fish-tail," which is really an
acute angled notch cut out of its end.
The arm is usually painted green, though
yellow is sometimes used, with yellow
GR£EN Y£LLOW RED
SIGNALS AT "ALL CLEAR ' WITH NEW
COLOR SCHEME FOR NIGHT.
light at night, according to the new color
scheme. It has usually a white band
near the end conforming in outline
to the fish-tail notch. This V-shaped
band resembles the chevron or sleeve
badge worn on the arm of a ser-
geant in the army. On the sema-
phore blade, as well as on the soldier's
arm, it in a measure indicates official
rank and authority. As the sergeant has
not as much authority as the officer over
him has, so the "distant" signal, wearing
the sergeant's badge on its arm, has not
the same absolute authority as the sig-
nal above it has. It acts simply as a
warning concerning the block next
ahead, while the topmost or "home" sig-
nal at "danger" blocks the line where it
stands and must not be disobeyed. These
signals may almost be said to have,
above, the commissioned rank of captain
and below the non-commissioned rank
of sergeant. The backs of both arms
are usually painted white, with a black
band corresponding to the white band
on the "home," and a black V-shaped
band corresponding to the white V-
shaped chevron on the other side of the
"distant" signal. The shape and color-
ing here described may and does vary
on many roads, but these forms and
colors give excellent signals and their
use may be described as exceedingly
good practice.
There is another form of fixed signal
called the three-position or 90° sema-
phore. When its arm is in the hori-
zontal position and a red light displayed
at night, it indicates "danger," as does
the two-position signal described above.
When the arm is placed at an angle of
45°, accompanied with a green light after
dark, it gives the "caution" indication.
Yellow would be shown if the new color
scheme be used. The absolutely vertical
position, parallel to the post, with the dis-
play of a white light, or preferably a green
light, indicates "all clear." The sema-
phore signals are fitted with "spec-
tacles" for holding the colored glasses,
and these spectacles are so spaced
for the two-position semaphores that the
"danger" or the "caution" light is contin-
uously displayed until the arm is within
10° of the "all clear" position, and 15°
for the three-position signals. This ar-
rangement prevents confusion by the
disappearance and reappearance of the
light as the semaphore arm moves. It
also prevents any possible sagging of
the blade due to lost motion in the me-
chanism, giving a premature or incorrect
"all clear" indication.
A yellow light for the "caution" in-
dication and a green for the "all clear"
are used on a number of important roads,
and the practice is growing in favor. This
arrangement is advocated by many, for
the reason that when white is the "all
clear" or safety color, it is liable to be
confused with other white lights, not
connected with railway operation. The
increasing use of electric lights through-
out the country makes such confusion
more and more probable. Again, it is
urged that the breaking of a red or
green spectacle glass would permit the
wrongful display of a white lig'ht, but
that under such circumstances, if yellow
be one of the distinctive signal colors,
the appearance of the white light would
at once give warning that something
had gone wrong with the signal lights.
In this connection it may be mentioned
that modern semaphores are made with
heavy iron spectacle frames, which under
the action of gravity will carry the arm
to "danger" or to "caution," as the case
may be. This provision is made so
that should anything go wrong with the
track or sigrtal circuits, or should a
switch be opened in the block or a rail
broken, the arms would assume the hori-
zontal position, and though delay might
occur to a train stopped by a defective-
signal, the safe course in train operation
would have been followed. The counter-
weighting of the semaphore arm is intend-
ed to overcome the possibility of a
signal sticking or freezing in the "all
clear" position. If the arms did become
frozen in the "danger" or "caution" posi-
tions, delay and not disaster would be
the only consequence which could fol-
low.
THREE-POSITION SIGNAL AT "CAUTION."
There is another form of fixed signal
used on railways which is called the Hall
automatic disk signal. It consists of a
flat case or box somewhat resembling
in outline an inverted pear, and showing
in the center on one side a large sized
circular transparent glass. The interior
of the case opposite this glass, all but a
smaller circle of plain glass, is painted
a strong white color, so that to the en-
ginemen of an approaching train the "all
clear" indication appears as a white cir-
cle framed in the somber color of the
outside case. The "danger" indication
is produced by the electric operation
within the case of a disk of red fabric
stretched on a circular wire frame,
which, when swung into the field of view,
completely obscures the white back-
ground and interposes its red color be-
hind the transparent glass. The "cau-
tion" indication is given by the lower
signal displaying a green disk, or yellow if
the new color scheme be used. The
night signals are given by the light from
a lamp placed at the top and at the back
of the case, and shining through two ap-
propriate openings in either wall. When
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
50 1
it is desired to give the "all clear" indi-
cation, a beam of liglit is made to pass
through the lens of the lamp and un-
ohstructcdly through two transparent
glasses in the case just above the large
circle, used for the day indications.
When the red disk occupies the large
circle, a red spectacle glass is swung up
inside the case which projects a red
light toward an oncoming train, thus
displaying the "danger" signal. In the
back of the case a smaller hole in the
center makes it possible for an inspec-
tor to see from behind what indication
the signal is giving. A small blue glass
in the back of the lamp shows, when
viewed in the rear, whether or not the
lamp is burning. The "caution" indi-
cation is similarly given by interposing a
green glass in front of the lamp, or yellow
if the new color scheme be in vogue.
The mechanism of these disk signals is
so constructed that if the electric circuit
becomes deranged, or if a switch in the
main line is opened or if a rail is broken,
these signals, which are usually arranged
for "normal danger," will maintain the
"danger" and the "caution" position un-
til everything has been made right. The
chances of the disk freezing in any one
position is obviated by the presence of
the weather-proof case which complete-
ly encloses the working parts. It is
necessary to point out that the disk sig-
nal, here described, depends upon the ob-
servance of difTerence of color, both for
the day and the night indications.
METHOD OF OPERATION OF THE SIGN.^LS.
Without at present troubling the read-
er with an account of the various me-
chanical devices for electric, gas or
pneumatic working of block signals, we
will consider briefly the method, or the
rules under which the signals are oper-
ated. As we have seen in the two-posi-
tion signals, the upper arm on the post
is the "home" signal. It governs ab-
solutely the right to proceed into the
block at the entrance of which it stands.
The "all clear" position guarantees the
safe forward movement of a train, while
the "danger" position imperatively de-
mands a stop. As there is no ambiguity
in either indication, so there must be no
faltering in the obedience rendered. The
lower arm is the "distant" signal, and its
position has reference to the block next
ahead, as it has no jurisdiction over the
block adjacent, which the "home" gov-
erns. Its indication is cautionary, or as
some would say, advisory. On approach-
ing an automatic block signal, informa-
tion concerning the condition of two
blocks ahead is given to the men on the
engine. If the "home" and "distant"
stand at "all clear," the two blocks
ahead are unoccupied. If the "home" is
at "all clear," and the distant at "cau-
tion," the block adjacent is empty, but
the block next ahead is occupied. If
both arms stand respectively at "dan-
ger" and "caution," a dead stop must be
made. The "home" signal deals, as it
were, with the present, and the "distant"
with the future, and with both against
a train, it is necessary to halt. It is not
possible, with properly working ap-
paratus, to have the "home" stand at
"danger" and the distant at "all clear,"
on the same post, and the reason for
this will shortly appear.
If both "home" and "distant" show "all
clear" at block A, the train proceeds, and
as soon as it enters block A the signals go
to "danger" and "caution" behind it. The
"home" remains at "danger" so long as
the block A, which it guards, is occu-
pied. When the "distant" has once gone
to "caution," as it must, upon the pass-
ing of a train, it loses its free will, so
HA1,L AUTOMATIC DISK SIGNAL.
to speak, and can only assume the "all
clear" position again when the 'liome"
signal at B, the block next ahead, has
"cleared." In thus going to "caution"
when the block adjacent is entered, and
being "cleared" only when the block
next ahead is empty, the "distant" sig-
nal is enabled to give an indication of
the utmost value. In assuming the "cau-
tion" position it moves with the "home"
on the same post, but in "clearing" it
acts in unison with the "home" on the
post of the block next ahead. It thus
indicates the position of the "home" sig-
nal at B. In addition to this, the "dis-
tant" signal is so constructed that it
never can be "cleared" until the "home"
signal above it on the same post is in the
"all clear" position. It is evident from
this whole arrangement that when a
train enters the block adjacent to the
signals which shows the "home" at "all
clear" and the "distant" at "caution,"
the advisory signal, with the fish-tail
blade, says to the men on the engine,
"The liome signal on the block next
ahead is against you, prepare to stop
now.'
The three-position semaphore has only
one arm on the post, except in cases
where diverging line has to be signaled.
With this signal, the vertical is the "all
clear" position. As soon as a train en-
ters the block adjacent to the signal, the
"danger" position is assumed, and when
the train enters the block next ahead the
arm drops to the "caution" position, and
finally "clears" when the block next
ahead has been vacated by the train.
With the use of automatic signals, the
practice called "permissive blocking" has
been generally adopted because if the
absolute block was maintained, a de-
ranged signal might cause a prolonged
delay of trains and possibly introduce
dangerous conditions. In both absolute
or permissive block systems, the dead
stop is insisted upon, when a danger sig-
nal is displayed. There is absolutely
no right of deviation from this rule. The
danger signal is King and must be un-
questioningly obeyed. The permissive
system recognizing the fact that the dan-
ger indication may be caused by a signal
out of order, sanctions the forward
movement of the train against that sig-
nal, but only after a definite time interval
has elapsed, during which the train has
stood still. This time limit is usually
one minute, after which the train may
proceed under control. The men
on the engine are also expected to
look out for obstruction on or derange-
ment of the line. If the block be found
unobstructed and apparently normal,
and if the block beyond is "clear," the
train may proceed at its usual speed, and
a report of the condition of signal and
block must be sent from the first tele-
graph station reached.
The absolute block is maintained at
all interlocking plants, as it is obvious
that no amount of careful flagging or
cautious train movement could in any
way alter the positions of switch points
open, or derails closed, nor could it have
any effect upon a swing bridge standing
at right angles to the track. On some
roads all the absolute block signal arms
are painted red without being relieved by
the small band of white or black usually
found on the arms of the automatic elec-
tric block signal semaphores. Permis-
sive blocking may, if desired, be indi-
cated by a semaphore arm having a
pointed end.
(To be continued.)
This world is not an utterly miserable
one, with all its faults. — Barnaby Rudge.
562
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
Break-Downs.
BY JOSEPH A. BAKER.
16. BURST FLUE.
Generally in a case of this kind the
■engine is dead in a very few minutes.
Draw the fire and in freezing weather
open blow-off cocks, let out all of the
water, take down hose connections be-
tween engine and tender and be prepared
to be towed in. Do no disconnecting and
oil cylinders in freezing weather with
light oil. With the extension front end
of to-day it's next to impossible to
reach a flue without removal of draft
plates, and the time consumed would
not justify repairs on the road.
With leaky flues the conditions are
different. Most injectors of to-day have
the heater cocks so arranged that they
can easily be removed. If bran or saw-
dust can be had, start the injector first,
then take out the heater cock and put a
small quantity of the bran through this
opening while the injector is working.
The current will carry it to the boiler
without any difficulty. Too much bran
will cause the engine to foam. By this
method you can bring in a full train with-
out any further trouble. Gauge and water
glass cocks must be opened often, how-
ever, to keep from clogging.
17. BROKEN EQUALIZER OR STAND.
If an equalizer post or equalizer breaks
run the back wheels up on a frog and
block between the main driving box and
frame. Next put the frog at the main
driver and run main driver up on the
frog and block between box and frame
on rear driver. Take down all loose
parts that are liable to give trouble and
run slowly as the drivers will heat very
fast otherwise.
iS. SPRUNG LINK.
On certain classes of engines with a
.4-wheel truck and the lever in the ex-
treme forward notch the links are in
such close proximity to the truck that
invariably from any cause of derailment
the links are generally badly damaged or
sprung. With the solid link you have
no other alternative but to disconnect
the valve gear. With the sectional link
unless too badly damaged, slack off the
nuts on top and bottom of link bolts,
partly withdraw the bolts and insert a
washer of sufficient thickness to allow
the free movement of link-block in the
link when reversing the lever. Tighten
bolts again and you are free to go on
with your train without disconnecting.
19. DISCONNECTED OR BROKEN THROTTLE
ROD.
This depends entirely upon the nature
of the break. With a throttle valve open
reduce the steam pressure down to a
point where you can handle part of your
train without slipping your engine. It
is always safer to have some cars in
your train to get the benefits of the
brakes than to run in with just an empty
engine. Sometimes what is considered
as a disconnected throttle valve proves
to be a cocked valve. If the rod con-
nections are badly worn and a full
throttle opening given, a cocked valve
often results, and is mistaken for a dis-
connected throttle. Tapping the throttle
rod will bring it back, with a closed
throttle valve, conditions on your line
must govern your actions. On a line
burdened with frequent trains arrange to
be lowed in without disconnecting any
part of the engine. If your line requires
you to make repairs, blow off the steam,
remove dome cap and make repairs. Gen-
erally you will find it a bolt that has
worked out. Your oil pipes will not
supply sufficient steam to bring in the
engine of to-day.
20. BROKEN WHISTLE STAND.
A broken whistle stand means a dead
engine. Remove the broken part from
the dome. A handy thing to have around
an engine is a washout plug and several
sizes of reducers. In the absence of a
washout plug use the reducer in the
dome cap, then take the nipple and angle
cock off of an air-braked car and insert
into the reducer. This takes but very
little time and I have seen an engine un-
der steam again in thirty minutes. You
can't rely on wooden plugs.
21. BROKEN DRAW BAR BETWEEN ENGINE
AND TENDER.
Do not attempt to pull a train with the
safety couplings, unless the grade is in
your favor. If a chain can be used, in-
sert the linlt in the deck bolt pocket for
draw bar and secure the other end to
body bolster of the tender, taking out
all of the slack between engine and ten-
der.
22. BROKEN REACH ROD OR LEVER.
Block over one link only with a point
of cut-off that will enable you to start
your train and maintain a slow speed.
With some classes of engines you can
use a bar under the lifting arms of the
tumbling shaft by placing the bar across
both frames, and not block the link.
23. BROKEN TUMBLING SHAFT LIFTING
ARM.
Use same manner of temporary repairs
as for broken link lifter.
24. BROKEN LINK SADDLE PIN.
Use same method as for broken link
lifter.
25. BROKEN LINK BLOCK PIN.
Disconnect valve stem and cover
steam ports. Don't disturb main rod.
26. BROKEN VALVE SEAT.
Place the engine on the quarter on the
side you think it is on, set your brakes
and give her steam with lever in for-
ward and back motion so as to admit
steam to each end of cylinder alternately.
If the blow is at one end only it indi-
cates a broken valve seat or section
broken out of valve. Disconnect the
valve stem and move it central if it is
a broken bridge between the steam and
exhaust cavities. If it is the section be-
tween the supply and steam port move
the valve in the opposite direction, with
the cross-head and piston in the same
direction of the valve. This closes the
exhaust and admits the steam under full
port pressure against the piston. Dis-
connect main rod. With a valve badly
broken, remove the valve and block on
the top of steam ports with sheet iron
and wood at your command. With a
balance valve where the space between
the valve and valve table is from ^ in.
to yi in., use sheet iron on the face
of valve and blocking at either end. Take
out cylinder cock valves and leave main
rod up. For a broken piston valve ii
the break is not a bad one shift valve
enough to stop the blow and clamp valve
stem at one end and extension rod at the
other end. Where there is no extension
rod. block between valve and forward
head.
27. BROKEN CENTER CASTING.
If the truck is a standard 4-wheer
truck a short rail put across the top of
the truck equalizer and under the center
casting will bring you in safely, or in
the absence of rails, block with hard
wood blocking over truck frame and
under cylinder saddles. Run slow and
carefully.
28. BROKEN DRIVING AXLE.
This occurs usually close to the wheel
and outside of the driving box. If a
broken main driving axle, all rods on the
disabled side and all side-rods on the
good side must come down. With any
other driving axle only such rods should
come down as would give trouble to
the rest of the rods. See chapters on
broken crank pins and rods. To block
up the axle on the broken side remove
the cellar and put a wooden block be-
tween the axle and the binder brace.
If an hydraulic or screw jack is handy
raise the axle and driving box, if it has
an overhung spring and block under
spring saddle above the frame to take
the weight off of driving bo.x. Use
sponging on the sides of blocking under
axle or better still your hot main pin
grease.
2g. BROKEN FRAME.
For a broken frame ahead of main
driver disconnect the valve stem on dis-
abled side, cover ports and leave up
main rod. Bring your engine in light
with the good side. If the break is be-
hind the main driver take down side-rods
on rear section only if a consolidation.
With a mogul type and the knuckle pin
on forward section of side-rod, take
down all side rods.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
563
30. KEY OUT OF FRAME SIM.ICE OR CYLIN-
IJliR SADDLE.
Unless tlic key lias been lost, try ami
put it back with the use of liners to se-
cure it snugly. The cylinder saddle key
is a taper affair, while the frame key is
a square one, and with the latter a rod
key driven in and watched occasionally
will bring in the engine without shear-
ing frame bolts. With nothing to replace
saddle key, disconnect valve stem and
cover port on that side.
3:. liROKEN DRIVING DRASS.
Run the wheel upon a frog or wedge
and block up between the frame ana
spring saddle to take weight as much as
possible off of box.
With an engine having underhung
springs there is no saddle to block under
and in a case of this kind place a jack un-
der equalizers nearest to broken brass,
the front end of the engine to take the
weight off the truck. Take out the cellar
and block with a V-shaped block of
wood between the axle and pedestal
brace. Jack up the truck frame high
enough to allow broken wheel to clear
the rail and secure the truck to the en-
gine frame with a chain.
Baldwin 2-8-0 for the Internaclonal
Mexicano.
The Mexican International has recently
received some simple consolidation en-
gines from the Baldwin Locomotive
Works, at Philadelphia. The cylinders
are 22x28 ins., the valves are balanced
slide, and the diameter of the driving
wheels is 57 ins.
The boiler is a straight top one and is
74 ins. at the smoke box end. The pres-
sure carried is 200 lbs. The tubes are ,365
mill having two spindles. In the case
which came under our observation a
lire was being bored out, and one tool
on one side of the mill was cutting the
lower half of the lire and on the other,
the second tool was boring out the upper
portion, so that the tire in question
would only occupy half the usual time
required for this operation, after which
it would give place to another tire.
The numerous readers of Railway and
Locomotive Engineering who are ac-
quainted with Mr. R. H. Soulc will re-
joice to learn that he has recovered suffi-
ciently from his protracted illness to re-
sume business. Mr. Soule is carrying on
the business of mechanical engineer m of-
fices at 20 West 34th street. New York,
where he makes a specially of consult-
ing and designing. To our readers who
BALUWl.N. - S-
luK IHE INTERNACION.^L MlvX
then block the other end between frame
and equalizer and remove the spring un-
der broken brass if possible.
32. BROKEN equalizer BETWEEN FOR-
WARD DRIVER AND ENGINE TRUCK ON
MOGUL OR CONSOLIDATION.
If the break is at the forward end get
a jack and raise that end as high as pos-
sible, lay a rail across the frame and se-
cure the equalizer with the chain to the
rail. If the rear end, or the hanger con-
necting the equalizer to the cross-equal-
izer is broken, raise the equalizer the
same as in the other case and secure it
with a chain to a rail placed on the frame
behind the cylinders. Bring tlie cross-
equalizer down from the boiler and block
between the boiler and cross-equalizer
also.
33. BROKEN ENGINE TRUCK WHEEL OR
AXLE.
This is an aggravated case and re-
r|uires considerable judgment. If it is
a broken tire or a broken wheel, jack up
in number, and are 15 ft. 1 in. long. The
heating surface is made up as follows:
fire-box 163 sq. ft., tubes 2,864.5 sq. ft.,
fire-brick tubes 25.3 sq. ft., making a total
of 3.052.8 sq. ft. The grate area is 54.3
sq. ft.
The weight on the drivers is 169,500
lbs., the weight of the engine is 185,750
lbs., that of the engine and tender is
about 336,000 lbs. The tender is of the
Vanderbilt type and the cylindrical tank
holds 8.000 gallons. The calculated trac-
tive effort of this machine is about
40,400 lbs., and the ratio of tractive ef-
fort to adhesive weight is as i is to 4.19.
are likely to need the assistance of a well-
trained mechanical engineer, we would say
make a note of Mr. Soule's address.
A very good example of the laudable
desire for increased shop output was
shown the other day in one of our im-
portant locomotive building establish-
ments. Steel tires for engine truck
wheels, passenger tender wheels and
carrying wheels for locomotives are
when required bored out on a boring
\'ery few people imagine the amount
of water required to fill a 6.000 gallon
capacity tank of one of the new Wabash
locomotives. If a man were to attempt
to fill one by emptying a five-gallon
bucket full every minute without stop-
ping for rest, meals or anything else
whatever, it would take him exactly
twenty-four hours. If a man were work-
ing by the day, taking his time to it, and
stopping for meals, rest, etc., and had a
supply of water handy, so convenient
that he could empty a bucket full every
minute, if necessary, he would find that
four days in which to perform the work
would be a hard job. — Logansport (Ind.)
Reporter.
Be diligent, work for a steady inde-
pendence, and be happy. — Dombey and
Son.
564
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
Phoebe on the Stage.
A very interesting moving picture was
recently shown at one of Mr. F. F. Proc-
tor's four New York theaters. The pro-
jecting apparatus used in these popu-
lar playhouses is Paley's Kalatech-
noscope. The picture was none other
than the railway marriage of Miss
Phoebe Snow, of Buffalo, on the
road of anthracite, otherwise the D., L.
& \V., more commonly known as the
Lackawanna. Phoebe, who is always
dressed in pure white and wears a beau-
tiful white pompadour hat, travels
through the famous Delaware Water
Gap in the Blue Ridge Mountains, while
an engaging young man points out to
her the beauties of the scenery We call
this young man "engaging," because he
subsequently marries Phoebe over the
rear coupler of the last car. The pres-
ence of a coupler at the ceremony, you
will admit, is highly appropriate.
The scenes are all well taken and arc
full of interest, the one where the lovers
chat on the back platform of the obser-
vation car while flying along is particular-
ly realistic, and reflects credit on the in-
genuity of the Edison Manufacturing
Company, who supplied the films. Just
before the train stops the porter of the
Pullman appears, whisk-broom in hand,
prepared to do the customary "brushing"
for a consideration, but is waved away,
as there is no dust to brush off. When
the train stops, pretty Phoebe alights,
and her white gown and graceful figure
easily make her the cynosure of all
eyes.
The good natured humor of the whole
thing is heightened by two tramps who
have stolen a ride on the trucks, sud-
denly coming out from under the cars at-
tired in full evening dress and crush hats,
which latter were probably useful
in the confined space under the
car. These tramps indignantly refuse
the services of a bootblack, who has run
up to dust them off. There being no dust
on the Lackawanna, the "brushing" busi-
ness has completely fallen down.
The films for these moving pictures are
ribbons of celluloid, and contain a series
of separate instantaneous photographs
taken at the rate of from 20 to 40 per sec-
ond, according to the rapidity of motion of
the object photographed. The pictures are
three-quarters of an inch high by one
inch wide. The film for this particular
picture is 275 feet long, and Miss Phoebe
may have the satisfaction of knowing
that in order to entertain the audience at
Proctor's for a few minutes, she has
been photographed 4,400 times. ^
McElvaney'8 Ballast Spreading Scraper
The annexed engravings illustrate the
appearance and the work done by a very
successful ballast scraper invented and
patented by Mr. C.T.McElvaney, master
mechanic of the Missouri, Kansas &
Texas Railway, at Denison, Tex.
The object of the invention is to pro-
vide a scraper for putting ballast be-
tween the rails that has been unloadect
from the side of flat or side dump cars.
With this appliance no special designed
ballast car is required. This is one of
the many reasons that should recom-
mend its use, as many roads do not
care to invest in special ballast cars to
out they extend four feet beyond the
body of the car and can be adjusted to
any height from 6 inches above the rail
to 10 inches below the botton of the
ties. Two men can either open or close
the scrapers in five minutes.
A crane is used to raise or lower the
scrapers. In order to open or close
them, an air cylinder is provided which
is placed length ways of the car and the
piston connection to a hinge joint in the
center of the eye beam that extends
McRLVANEY S BALLAST SPREADING .SCRAPER.
stand idle when not in service on
work train, and even on larger systems,
flat cars can be used to good advan-
tage and many times in connection with
other especially designed ballast cars,
crosswise of the car, and supports the
open ends of the scrapers. As the piston
is pushed out of the cylinder it acts on
the hinge of the eye beam, forming a
toggle joint drawing the scraper under-
BEFORE SPREADING.
providing there was some means where-
by the material could be placed where
wanted without having to shovel it in by
hand.
By referring to the engravings our
readers will see that an ordinary flat car
has been fitted up with scrapers on each
side, in such a manner that they can be
opened or closed, raised or lowered, as
occasion may demand. When closed,
they are drawn under the car body and
six inches above the rail; when spread
AFTER SPREADING.
neath the car. The discharge ends of
the scraper are hinged in such a manner
as to give a clear opening four feet wide.
If wishes were horses beggars would
ride, is an old saying. Some men spend
their lives supinely wishing that some-
thing would turn up for their benefit.
Then they say it was good luck which
helped their neighbor, who had will and
energy to make everything turn up to
his advantage.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVK ENGINEKKl XG
?65
Of Personal Interest.
Mr. H. R. Stevens has been appointed
master mechanic on the Atlantic Coast
Line at Sanford, Fla.
Mr. A. C. Hone has resigned tlic po-
sition of master nieclianic on the Louis-
ville & Nashville, at Louisville, Ky.
Mr. C. V. Mary has been appointed
foreman of the Caklor, Kan., shops of
the Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific.
Mr. George Hocfne has been appoint-
ed foreman blacksmith of the Kno.xville.
Tenn,, shops of the Southern Railway.
Mr. J. R. Crowley has been appoint-
ed foreman of the air brake department
of the Illinois Central at Waterloo, la.
Mr. H. S. Jones has been appointed
master mechanic on the Durham &
Charl(5tte Railroad, with headquarters
at Gulf, N. C.
Mr. VV. J. Camp has been appointed
electrical engineer of the Canadian Pa-
cific. Railway, with headquarters at
Montreal, Que.
Mr. H. P. Timmerman has resigned
his position as general superintendent
of the Ontario division of the Canadian
Pacific Railway.
Mr. D. A. Hatheway has been ap-
pointed master meclianic on the Chi-
cago, Rock Island & Pacific, with office
at Fairbury, Neb.
Mr. W. A. Fort has been proinoted
to the position of resident engineer on
the Southern Railway, vice Mr. O. D.
Killebrew, promoted.
Mr. W. E. Anderson has resigned as
master mechanic of the Colerado divi-
sion at Goodland, Kan., on the Chicago,
Rock Island & Pacific.
Mr. O. D. Killebrew has been pro-
moted to the position of assistant sup-
erintendent on the Southern Railway,
with office at Columbia, ,S. C.
Mr. F. Coe has been appointed round-
house foreman at Riverside. Ohio, on
the Big Four, vice Mr. J. Keegan. who
retired on account of ill health.
Mr. H. A. Sadler has been appointed
general car foreman on the Atchison.
Topeka & Santa Fe, at Needles, Cal.,
vice Mr. M. Whitefleet, resigned.
Mr J. J. Shaw has been appointed
master mechanic of the Denver, Enid
&Gulf Railroad, with office at Enid, O.T.,
vice Mr. W. H. Whitaker, resigned.
Mr. L. Huber has been appointed gen-
eral foreman of the Springfield, Ohio,
shops, of the Detroit Southern Rail-
road, vice Mr. F. Distelrath, resigned.
Mr. J. J. Flynn has been appointed
master mechanic of the Louisville & At-
lantic Railroad, with headquarters at
Richmond, Ky., vice Mr. L. Wellisch,
resigned.
Mr. John R. Mcintosh has been ap-
pointed boiler inspector on the Grand
Trunk Railway system, with head-
quarters at Montreal, vice Mr. J. Black,
resigned.
Mr. W. L. Williamson has been pro-
moted to the position of superintendent
of terminals of the Southern Railway,
at Jacksonville, Fla., vice Mr. A. Tripp,
resigned.
Mr. A. J. F'ries has been appointed
division master mechanic on the Boston
& Albany Railroad, with headquarters
at Allston, Mass., succeeding Mr. Will-
iam H. Taft.
Mr. George Oliver has resigned as
master mechanic on the M. K. & T., to
accept the position of master mechanic
of the Mexican Central, with office at
Mexico City, Mex.
Mr. E, P. Reynolds, Jr., has been ap-
pointed consulting engineer of the
Grand Trunk system. He has charge
of the location and construction of the
Grand Trunk Pacific.
Mr. N. E. Brooks has been ap-
pointed division engineer. Western Di-
vision, Canadian Pacific Railway, with
headquarters at Calgary. Alta., vice Mr.
A. S. Dawson, resigned.
Mr. W. G. Wallace has been appoint-
ed master mechanic of the Duluth, Miss-
abe & Northern Railway, with full
charge of the locomotive department,
with office at Proctor, Minn.
Mr. C. E. Cartwright has been appoint-
ed acting division engineer. Pacific Di-
vision, Canadian Pacific Railway, with
headquarters at Vancouver, B. C. vice
Mr. F. F. Busteed. transferred.
Mr. C. P. King has been promoted to
the position of trainmaster. Charlotte to
Jacksonville including Columbia Termi-
nals, on the Southern Railway, vice Mr.
W. L. Williamson, promoted.
Mr. A. L. Robinson has been appoint-
ed master mechanic of the St. Louis-
Louisville lines of the Southern Rail-
way, with headquarters at Princeton,
Ind.. vice Mr. D. Brown, resigned.
Mr. L. R. Clausen has been appoint-
ed signal engineer on the Chicago,
Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway, with of-
fice at Milwaukee, Wis. vice Mr W. H.
Elliot resigned.
Mr. P. H. McGuire has been appoint-
ed master mechanic on the Great North-
ern. He will have charge of the Su-
perior and Mesabi divisions, with office
at Superior, Wis., vice Mr. G. A. Bruce,
promoted.
Mr. G. S. Pfiaster, formerly super-
visor of signals on the Chicago & East-
ern Illinois, has been appointed signal
inspector on the Nashville, Chattta-
nooga & St. Louis, with office at Nash-
ville, Tenn.
Mr. T. M. Ramsdell, formerly chief
car inspector of the Atchison, Topeka
& Santa Fe at Topeka, Kan., has been
appointed master car builder on the
Chesapeake & Ohio, with headquarters
at Huntington, W. Va.
Mr. James R. Nelson, who has here-
tofore been chief clerk to Sir Thomas
Shaughnessy, president of the Canadian
Pacific, has been appointed division
superintendent on that road, with head-
quarters at North Bay, Ont.
Mr. W. D. Watkins, traveling engi-
neer on the Illinois Central at Jackson,
Tenn., has been promoted to the posi-
tion of master mechanic on the same
road, with otSce at Water Valley, Miss.,
vice Mr. J. F. Price, resigned.
Mr. R. O. Cumbach, who has been for
several years general inspector of locomo-
tives of the Central Railroad of New
Jersey, has resigned to take the position
of superintendent of the Pedrick & Aver
Company's plant at Plainfield, N. J.
Mr. J. W. Doyle, formerly train
master at Clinton, la., on the Chicago
& Northwestern, was appointed assist-
ant superintendent at Boone, to suc-
ceed Mr. G. W. Dailey, promoted to
acting superintendent of telegraphs at
Chicago.
Mr. F. H. Hammill. train master at
Boone, has been transferred to Clinton,
la., on the Chicago & Northwestern, to
succeed Mr. Doyle, and Mr. C. F.
Milett. agent at Des Moines, has been
promoted to the position of train
master of the West Iowa Division at
Boone.
Mr. Thomas Roope has been appoint-
ed to the position of assistant superin-
tendent of motive power on the Chi-
cago. Rock Island & Pacific, with head-
quarters at Topeka, Kan. This office
has just been created. He was formerly
general master mechanic on the Great
Northern.
Mr A. McCormick has resigned from
the position of master mechanic at Fair-
bury,' Neb., on the Chicago. Rock Isl-
and & Pacific, and has accepted the po-
sition of master mechanic on the Colo-
rado Springs & Cripple Creek District
566
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
Railway, with office at Colorado
Spprings, Col.
Mr. Irving H. Reynolds will shortly
retire from the AUis-Chalmers Com-
pany, and the duties of chief engineer
will be assumed by the engineers in
charge of the various departments, these
engineers availing themselves of the ad-
vice of Mr. Edwin Reynolds, consult-
ing engineer of the company.
Mr. C. A. Goodnow has been ap-
pointed general manager of the Chicago
& Alton Railway Company, in charge
of the operation and maintenance of the
property. Mr. J. H. Barrett, general
superintendent, having resigned, the
duties oi his office will, until further
notice, be performed by the general
manager.
Mr. David H. Beecher. president of
the Union National Bank, of Grand
Forks, N. D., is also president of a new
railroad soon to be built from Man-
kato, Minn., to St. Cloud, Minn. The
road will be called the Minnesota Cen-
tral. Mr. Beecher is also president of
the Lawson Boat and Car Company, of
New York.
Mr. Charles Murphy has been ap-
pointed superintendent of District No.
2, Canadian Pacific Railway, with office
at Toronto, vice Mr. James Manson,
transferred. District No. 2 has been
extended over the Toronto and Ham- '
ilton Terminals, of which Mr. F. G.
.\Iartyn has been appointed assistant
superintendent, Toronto, vice Mr. D.
R. Bell, transferred.
-Mr. Joseph M. Whalen. who formerly
held the position of general foreman of
ilie St. Louis Division shops on the
Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St.
Louis, at Mattoon, 111., has been pro-
moted to the position of general fore-
man of the locomotive and car depart-
ment at Indianapolis, Ind. He has been
succeeded at the Mattoon shops by his
brother, Mr. James F. Whalen.
Mr. George D. Brooke, superintend-
ent of machinery and equipment on the
Iowa Central, has resigned his position.
On his leaving the service of the com-
pany Mr. Brooke was presented with a
chest of solid silverware, consisting of
129 pieces. Mr. Joseph Mohr, of the
machine shop stati, made the presenta-
tion. The committee representing the
entire system was composed of Messrs.
J. -M. Speer, of the locomotive depart-
ment; J. C. Crellin, machinist, and
George Patton, of the car department.
A reception was held at the close of
the presentation. The cordial feeling
manifested was evidence of Mr. Brooke's
popularity all over the road.
Mr. Robert P. Allison, heretofore
foreman of the wheel and cylinder shop
of the Richmond (Va.) works of the
American Locomotive Company, has ac-
cepted a position with the Locomotive
and Machine Company, Ltd., of Mon-
treal, Canada. His retirement from the
works was the occasion of a presenta-
tion to him, by the shopmen of a very
handsome Knight Templar watch
charm, and also an equally beautiful
Shriner's jewel. Mr. Jonathan Bryan,
son of the former president of the
works, made the presentation, and most
fittingly expressed the hearty good will
and high estteem felt for Mr. Allison by
all ranks in the Richmond works. He
goes to the Northern Zone followed by
the best wishes of his many friends and
associates in the Sunny Snuth.
The Author of the Ready Reference.
Mr. S. A. Alexander is one of the old
stock of railroad men who has succeeded
in imparting to the rulers of the cab a
l^^iv.
:1
S. A. ALE.X.iNDEK.
large amount of information which he ac-
quired by observation and an experience
of fifty-two years in railroad service. He
was born in Philadelphia on the 31st
day of August, 1829. After a few years'
attendance at public schools in that city,
at the age of thirteen he left school and
friends unexpectedly, and went to sea as
a cabin boy on a merchant vessel trad-
ing between New York and Vera Cruz,
Mexico. After leaving that service he en-
tered the United States Navy as an ap-
prentice, cruising in the Gulf of Mexico,
the west coast of Africa and the Mediter-
ranean. Returning to the United States
in 1848, at the solicition of his friends, he
left the ocean and entered the employ of
of the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad
Co. at Palo Alto. As he had a good supply
of sailor rigging and little cash, he con-
tinued to wear his sailor toggs until they
were beyond repair, this circumstance
causing him to be known by all the Read-
ing's railroaders as Wootten's sailor. Af-
ter serving his time with the Reading Co.
at Palo Alto, Reading and at Richmond
(Reading's Philadelphia terminal), he
went to Altoona in the employ of the
Pennsylvania R. R. Co., in the mor.th of
May, 1855, and remained in that employ
until on January i, 1900, he retired on ac-
count of having reached his seventy-first
year.
Mr. Alexander claims that he wrote his
book for the express purpose of being of
benefit to the engineers and firemen in
the employ of his own company, not ex-
pecting any pecuniary benefit, only for the
advertisements contained in the last pages
of the first issue of the work. Newly-em-
ployed engineers and old firemen and one
on one division of the P. R. R. were sent
to him for examination as to fitness for
the positions. He found some old run-
ners whom he knew to be capable men,
but had never given a thought of what
should be done in some cases of disable-
ment. His sympathies went out to»these
men, so he had a few of such instruc-
tions put in print and gave them away;
but he had so many applicants for the
[lamphlet that he had a thousand printed,
and it was not long before he needed
live thousand more, and these were still
behind the demand. Although the work
had not been advertised until after the
first five hundred had been issued, orders
came faster than they could be supplied.
-Some of the old runners were opposed to
the work because, as they said, it was
giving away all the tricks of the trade.
Such remarks only reminded him of his
experience while serving his time with the
Reading Co. Machinists and other me-
clianics were chary of imparting informa-
tion respecting their occupations, and
many times he had been snubbed by the
remark, "Go and find out as I did."
Mr. Alexander says that he was
always nosey, having a very lim-
ited education and an inqdiring mind,
so he put himself down to hard
study to know everything about the
business in which he was engaged. He
was the only boy out of about fifty on his
ship while he was in the navy who at-
tempted to acquire a knowledge of navi-
gation; and now whatever knowledge
he has he is always glad to impart to
those who wish to have it. He has been
a busy man, for, while working at his
calling, he succeeded in bringing up a
family of seven children, four of whom
are boys, three of these are first-class
locomotive runners and his baby boy is
an officer in the United States Navy; all
except the baby are married and have
families, and all are doing well.
He says that "The Ready Reference"
has found large sales in Canada, Mex-
ico, Australia, New Zealand and Great
Britain, as well as in Boston, from which
point all knowledge is suppose to origi-
nate.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
i<n
Artificial Niagara at St. Louis.
All iiniiiiMisc artificial cascade lias
been deterniined upon by the authorities
of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition
as the centerpiece of the semi-circular
lay-out of the principal buildings. The
cascade itself will be divided into three
parts; a large middle cascade with a
smaller one at each side, the water flow-
ing directly into the head of the Grand
Basin. In all, about 90,000 gallons of
water per minute will be supplied at a
head of 159 feet, forming the greatest
arificial water effect ever attempted. The
water will be taken from the Grand
Basin itself, and will be raised to the
top of the fall by pumps placed under
Festival Hall. The pumping machinery
will consist of tliree 36-inch single-
stage, turbine centrifugal pumps pur-
Six-Wheei Switcher for the Oreat
Northern.
The Rogers Locomotive Works, of
Paterson, N. J., have recently supplied
the Great Northern Railway Line, ot
which Mr. G. H. Emerson is superin-
tendent of motive power, with ten switch
engines of the six-wheel type. The
cylinders are 19x26 ins. and the drivers
arc 49 ins. in diameter. '1 he entire
weight of the engine, of course, rests
upon the driving wheels, and this
amounts to 138,000 lbs., making the axle
load 46,000 lbs. The journals are 9x12
ins. The pistons drive on the middle
wheels. The crosshead is one of the
Laird type and the main valves are the
regular D-sIide.
The boiler is a straight top one, with
Belpaire fire box. It is 671/2 ins. at the
happened in Glasgow as long ago as July
27. A passenger train belonging to the
North British Railway, entering St. Enoch
Station, was not properly under control
of the engine driver, and it struck the
buffer stop with such violence that two
c.'irri?gcs were telescoped with the result
that seventeen passengers were killed and
64 were injured.
The principal blame is put upon the en-
gine driver, for not having the train under
proper control; but the railway company
is severely censured for using antiquated
brakes. A curious thing about Col. York's
report is that he considered it necessary
to discuss recommendations made by vari-
ous persons, that empty carriages or vans
should be placed between tl'.e engine and
passenger coaches to receive the destruc-
tive shocks experienced when a collision
Kt- * i«rp. C-g.
ROGERS SIX-WHEKt SWITCHER FOR THE GRE.\T NORTHERN.
chased from Henry R. Worthington, of
New York City, each driven by a 2,000
horse-power Westinghouse alternating
current motor. The total horse-power
utilized will thus be 6,000, making this
the largest electric pumping station in
the vvorld. The pumps and other pieces
of machinery for this plant are now be-
ing installed at St. Louis.
Club agents would earn blessings
from the young ladies of our mailing de-
partment by sending in their list early
in the month.
A Long- Felt Want.
Casey — Oi see there's bin another
railroad wreck due to an open switch.
Cassidy — Ay, 'tis a pity some wan
don't invint a switch thot'll stay shut
whin it's open. — Philadelphia Press.
front end. The fire box, with grate area
of 27.2 sq. ft., has also a heating surface
of 164 sq. ft., and that of the tubes be-
ing 1,708, brings the total heating surface
up to 1,872 sq. ft. The working pressure
is 200 lbs. per sq. in.
The tender has a water capacity of
400 gallons, and the tank is carried upon
lo-in. steel channels in the usual way.
Diamond arch bar trucks are used.
The calculated tractive force is about
32.500 lbs., and the ratio of tractive
power to cdhesive weight is as i is to
4.24. The total wheel base is 10 ft. 9 ins.
Fatal Collision in a Scotch Station.
The deliberate manner in which the
government officials having supervision
over British railways do their work, is
well illustrated by a report recently pub-
lished from Col. York, inspector for the
Board of Trade, on an accident which
happens. This was entirely in line with
a practice introduced by the South Caro-
lina Railroad about 1833, of putting a car
loaded -vith bales of cotton between the
locomotive and the passenger cars to pro-
tect the people from injury when the boiler
exploded. .Another recommendation which
will appear strange to American railway
men is, that trainmen must be ready to
apply hand brakes when entering terminal
stations. The real cause of the collision
was the use of brakes that were deficient
in stopping power. About them Col.
York says:
"I would make the suggestion that
the time has come for a reconsidera-
tion of the brake question m this country.
I do not now refer to the dual system
which, unfortunately, exists, some com-
panies having the vacuum and some thf.
Westinghouse, though this is all-import-
ant, and will have to be faced if freight
50.-
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, lyoj.
trains are to be fitted with continuous
brakes. But I refer to the fact that the
brakes employed on the passenger roUing
stock in the United Kingdom, whether
they belong to the vacuum class or the
Westinghouse class, are not of the most
modem description. Since automatic con-
tinuous brakes were first adopted in this
country, improvements have been made in
them whereby their rapidity of action has
been largely increased, and the distance or
time within which a train can be stopped
has been proportionately reduced. Both
the Vacuum Brake Company and the
Westinghouse Brake Company have for
some years past been able to supply quick-
acting brakes, the advantage of which in
times of emergency cannot be gainsaid.
These improvements, though adopted,
seem to have been ignored in the United
Kingdom, where, so far as I know, only
one railway company has done anything,
even experimentally, towards fitting its
passenger stock with a quick-acting pat-
tern of brake. The speed and weight of
trains are ever on the increase, and the
rapidity with which brakes can be
brought into operation becomes daily of
more importance. It is, therefore, sur-
prising to find that the modern improve-
ments in brakes have not been adopted
in the United Kingdom, and that Eng-
lish rolling stock is still being fitted with
the same patterns of brakes as were in-
troduced twenty-five years ago.
The Nature of a Patent Right.
BY PAUL SYNNESTVEDT.*
It is the writer's observation that of all
the common mistakes chargeable to those
not posted in patent matters, the mistake
which is most frequently encountered by
the patent practitioner is the supposition
that seems to be held, on the part of many,
that the grant of a patent to an inventor
conveys in some manner the right to the
use of his invention. The fact of the
matter is that no right of this kind is
conveyed by U. S. Letters Patent, but
only the right to exclude others from us-
ing the invention which forms the sub-
ject matter of the patent; in other words,
the right of exclusion for a limited time,
whereby a monopoly may be created which
may bring to the patentee some return
for the labor involved in the development
of his invention.
The patent system, as we know it now in
this country, is altogether on these lines:
The Government, in the grant of a patent,
undertakes to protect the patentee for a
period of 17 years in the right to exclude
every one else from making, using and
selling his invention, save only on consent
of the patentee. Before the grant of any
patent, every inventor has the right to
make, use and sell his invention, assum-
ing that such manufacture, use or sale does
not infringe any other pre-existing right,
♦Abstracts of paper read at Pittsburgh Railway
ub.
but until a patent is granted every one else
has a like right, and hence what the
patentee actually gets is the right to take
away from every one else the liberty of
following in the patentee's footsteps with
respect to such manufacture, use or sale
of the invention.
It is a peculiar incident to this grant,
that unless the public at large is given the
benefit of the invention by commercial in-
troduction of the same, no benefit, finan-
cially, accrues to the owner of the patent.
This is obvious from the fact that the
only recompense in a financial way which
a patent owner gets comes, ultimately,
either from royalties or from profits
arising out of the manufacture, use or sale
of the patented improvement, and, as in-
timated, unless some commercial opera-
tion is carried out, of course, no royal-
ties arc collectible, nor are any profits
made.
In considering the nature of a patent
right, it is next to be noted that the grant
of a patent is not made, as is often as-
sumed to be the case, for the sake of the in-
ventor, but from the standpoint of public
policy, for the sake of the public good, in
order "to encourage the progress of
science and the useful arts." as it is stat-
ed in that clause of the Federal Consti-
tution which forms the basis for all our
patent statutes. And the wisdom of the
framers of our Constitution, in making a
provision of this kind, has been fully prov-
en by the experience of over 100 years,
during which some patent system has been
in force in this country. Whenever in-
ventors have been encouraged in this man-
ner, industry and progress have prosper-
ed, and wherever they have not, as for ex-
ample in certain districts through an un-
favorable attitude assumed by some of our
courts, industry and progress have been
correspondingly discouraged.
That all patentees who hold valid
patents have benefited the community is
obvious, from the fact that in order to
sustain the validity of any patent it must,
among other tests, stand the test of
novelty and utility ; that is, it must be
established that the invention is new, and
adds something in the nature of improve-
ment of a useful character to the arts as
the state of the same existed before the
creation of the invention. If a patent
grant took from the public the right in
any thing of .a determinative or definite
character, or a right in any property for-
merly possessed by the public, it would
be inconsistent with the spirit of our age
and obnoxious to people of all classes, as
was, in fact, the case with some of the
older statutes and special privileges which
existed for several centuries past in Eng-
land at different times.
In the words of Bentham, in his Ra-
tionale of Reward, a patent "is an instance
of a reward peculiarly adapted to the
nature of the service, and adapts itself
with the utmost nicety to those rules of
proportion to which it is most difficult for
reward, artificially instituted by the legis-
lature, to confer. If confined, as it ought
to be, to the precise point in which the
originality of the invention consists, it is
conferred with the least possible waste
of expense. It causes a service to be ren-
dered, which without it, a man would not
have a motive for rendering ; and that
only by forbidding others from doing
that which, were it not for that service, it
would not have been possible for them to
have done. Even with regard to such in-
ventions, for such there will be, where
others besides him who possesses the re-
ward have scent of the invention, it is
still of use by stimulating all parties and
setting them to strive which shall first
bring the discovery to bear. With all
this it unites every property that can be
wished for in a reward. It is variable,
equable, commensurable, characteristic,
exemplary, frugal, promotive of perse-
verance, subservient to compensation,
popular and reasonable,"
That the patent system is distinguished
by having an origin of reasonable antiquity
is evident from the tact that we find that
in the reign of Edward III, on represen-
tation to him of the feasibility of mak-
ing a "philosopher's stone," that monarch
issued a commission of two friars and
two aldermen to inquire into the matter,
and, on their reporting in its favor, grant-
ed to them and their assigns the sole
privilege of making the "philosopher's
stone."
Nearly all of the earliest forms of such
grants in England, dating several centuries
back, were of similar characteristics to
those of our present patent grant, but the
special privileges of those early days were
by degrees perverted from their primary
purpose, and, under the pretense of a bet-
ter government of trade, the prerogative
of the Crown was employed in return for
pecuniary considerations in sanctioning
certain individuals and corporations in the
practice of various oppressive monopolies.
The evil of this grew until in the reign of
Elizabeth, large numbers of the necessaries
of life were controlled by such monopol-
istic patentees.
Thus, at one time, there were included
in such oppressive special grants the ex-
clusive rights of trade in salt, iron, pow-
der, vinegar, paper, starch, tin, sulphur
and a multitude of others.
When a list of them was read in the
House of Commons a great disturbance
was raised, one member crying : "Is not
bread in the number? If affairs go on at
this rate we shall have bread reduced to
a monopoly before next Parliament."
The monopolists were so exorbitant in
their demands that they raised the price
of salt from i6 pence a bushel to 14 or 15
shillings. Such high profits naturally be-
gan to attract intruders upon their com-
merce, so that in order to secure them-
selves against encroachment the patentees
Dcci-iiiber, 1903.
RAII.WAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEEF^ING
i(")
were armed with high and arbitrary pow-
ers by the councils, by which they were
able to oppress the people at pleasure, and
10 exact money from such as they thought
proper to accuse of interfering with their
patent.
Thus the patentees of saltpetre were
granted the power of entering every house
"and of committing what havoc they
pleased, in stables, cellars, or whereso-
ever they suspected saltpetre might be
gathered, and they commonly extorted
money from those who desired to free
tl;cmselvcs from this damage or trouble;
and while all domestic intercourse was
thus restrained, lest any scope should re-
main for industry, almost every species 01
foreign commerce was confined to ex-
clusive coinpanies, who bought and sold
at any price they themselves thought
proper to offer or exact."
"Even Elizabeth's House of Commons
rang with angry complaints. On the 20th
November, 1601, a great debate upon the
subject took place, on an attempt by
Lawrence Hyde to introduce 'A Bill for
the Explanation of the Common Law in
Certain Cases of Letters Patent.' After
much discussion as to whether the pro-
ceedings should be by bill or by petition
to Her Majesty, but before anything was
concluded upon the Queen sent a message
to the House importing tliat the monop-
olies should be revoked."
In excusing the objectionable grants, the
Queen, in a message to the Conitnons.
said: "Since I was Queen, yet never did I
put my pen to any grant but upon pre-
tense and semblance made unto me that It
was both good and beneficial to the sub-
jects in general, though a private profit
to some of my ancient servants who have
deserved well, but the conirary being found
by experience, I am exceedingly beholden
to such subjects as would move the same
at first. That my grants should be griev-
ous to my people, and oppressions to be
privileged under color of our patents, our
kingly dignity shall not suffer it ; yea,
when I heard it I could give no rest to
my thoughts till I had reformed it."
While subsequently to the events just
narrated special grants in restraint of
common trade were gradually reduced in
number to practically nothing, exclusive
privileges in reward of invention have re-
mained, and there is reason to believe that
the practice of making grants of the sole
use of inventions originated in England,
and that the English system of rewarding
inventors has since been copied more or
less closely by almost every European
power. Our own system is based upon it
in many respects, although differing great-
ly in organization and detail, and the char-
acteristics or nature of the grant remain
to this day, after centuries of time, sub-
stantially the same — the securing to an in-
ventor, for a limited time, the right to
exclude others from practicing his inven-
tion save on license secured from him,
whercfrom he secures his pecuniary re-
ward.
Railway Matters in Australia.
I'Vom a letter received from a sub-
scriber in Australia, we cull the following
notes concerning railway matters in the
Colony of Victoria :
Mr. Thomas Tait is Chief Commissioner
of Railways now, being Chairman of the
Commissioners. These number three,
namely, Mr. Thomas Tait, Chairman;
Mr. Fitzpalrick and Mr. Hudson. The
two latter gentlemen have had good ex-
perience in Australasian railway manage-
ment. It was thought that under the rule
of these three gentlemen the Victorian
Railways would soon begin to pay their
way. But many people believe that they
where the root of the evil lies. There are
four ways of attempting to make the rail-
ways solvent, namely :
I. Closing all non-paying lines; z.
raising freights ; 3. raising fares ; 4- Re-
ducing working expenses.
The general public have no doubt but
that the last named was the best manner
of curing the railway overdraft disease, if
one might call it so. This meant an in-
direct reduction in wages and thus it led
to the great railway strike of 1903, which
resulted in the total defeat of the strik»
ers.
Under-Loading of Cars.
Ihc following circular sent to station
agents by the manager of the Southern
Pacific lines in Texas, might be judicious-
DUND.^S LIGHT RAILW'.W Ml)NTE/.lM.\ TRESTLE.
will never pay because of the great amount
of political jobbery that is done in con-
nection with the railways.
This interference was manifested recent-
ly. The Commissioners decided to close
up a line which had been run at a loss
ever since the construction of it. Imme-
diately a great concourse of people af-
fected by the closure, accompanied by
numberless members of Parliament, inter-
viewed the Commissioners with the re-
sult that the line was at once reopened.
This example will suffice to show w-hat
eno'-mous political influence the new Com-
missioners will have to contend against in
their efforts to place the railway finances
on a sound basis.
The reason the railways will not pay, is
because during the land boom period rail-
ways were built anywhere and everywhere
at the bidding of the Jocal members of
Parliament. Now, fully fifty per cent, of
these lines will not pay. so anyone can see
ly sent to station agents of nearly all rail-
roads :
"Ten years ago the average capacity of
these companies' freight cars was 21
tons; to-day, the average capacity is 29
tons. Ten years ago the average loading
was 13 tons ; to-day, it is ig tons. From
which it will be seen that the loading has
not kept pace with the increased capacity.
The demand for cars is very great. If
we can increase our loading 2 tons per car,
it will have the practical effect of adding
not less than 1,500 cars to our equipment
In order that we maj' be in a position
to furnish cars to take care of all busi-
ness offering, and at the same time utilize
our equipment to the best possible ad-
vantage, it is necessan- that the question
of loading be given close attention, and
from date of this circular to June 30,
1904, to 10 agents making the best show-
ing in car loading, premiums based on one-
third of one month's salary will be given.
570
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, lyuj
Of the 10 premiums, one will be awarded
to agents on the El Paso division, four
on the Houston division, two on the Vic-
toria division and three on the Texas and
New Orleans and Galveston, Houston and
Northern. By keeping careful track of the
loading of cars and calling shippers' at-
tention to their interest in the matter, it
is confidently expected that great im-
provements can be made, and the hearty
co-operation of all employees toward that
end is earnestly desired."
Distilled Feed Water.
At a meeting of the Western Railway
Club, where the purification of feed wa-
ter was under discussion, some attention
was given to distilling feed water as a
means of removing impurities. That is
an extreme method, but it is, no doubt,
effectual, as it removes all impurities
from water so treated. Distillation would
part of the loss sustained. We believe that
some of the methods of purifying water
without going the length of distillation are
good enough for all practical purposes,
but there is no question about the purity
of distilled water.
At the meeting where Mr. Hender-
son's paper was read the agent of a boiler
compound concern tried to discredit the
use of distilled water by saying that its
use induced corrosion of the boiler sheets.
That is a very feeble objection, based on
a distortion of facts. In marine ser-
vice while the jet condenser was in use
and pure sea water was boiled in the
boilers, a constant source of trouble was
the sulphate of lime present in the water
forming thick scale over the evaporating
surfaces. In the surface condenser the
exhaust steam is passed through tubes
where it is condensed by the circulation of
cold water and the condensed water is
te^fe^.
HAGAN'S PATENT 40-TON -.'Mhi
be an ideal way of preparing feed water
in districts where mineral salts abound in
the water, but it is so expensive as to be
prohibitive, unless where coal or other fuel
is extraordinarily cheap. Mr. G. R. Hen-
derson made the statement that with coal
at one dollar a ton. water could be dis-
tilled for 13 cents per thousand gallons.
That is an exceedingly low expense, and
indicates that great improvements have
been effected recently on distilling ap-
paratus, yet it represents a heavy increase
on the operating expenses of a locomotive,
but the quality of feed water may be such
that adding one or two cents extra for
eliminating .scale and all of its works
may effect a decided saving. In regions
where the feed water is so, bad that flues
have to be changed for every 10,000 miles
of service, it is likely that distilling the
water would pay for the expense of chang-
ing the flues would represent only a small
r ,,\r<,l I'.NulNJv AND TRAIN.
pumped back into the boilers. This cycle
of operations goes on constantly and
where there is very little leakage about
boilers or engines very little replenishing
of water is necessary during a long voy-
age. Of course, feed water produced in
this rhanner is entirely free from mineral
impurities although there is more or less
annoyance due to the lubricants that have
been used in the cylinders passing into
the boiler.
Whc-n the surface condensers were first
introduced it was discovered that cor-
rosion of the boiler plates were much more
common than it was when water contain-
ing lime salts was used. The worst cases
were found to be where boilers and engine
glands were particularly free from leak-
age, thereby obviating the use of sea wa-
ter. The matter was thoroughly investi-
gated by experts and it was discovered
that water absolutely free from mineral
Hoi Pins.
The crank ;iik1 main pins
become hot. Hot main pins
and hot crank pins cause you
to lose time, which must he
made up or counted against
\(>U. ,
A hut journal, if it is not
watched, begins to cut, or the
babbitt starts to melt.
These things are an en-
gineer's every-day troubles,
yet hundreds of engineers
have written us letters to tell
us that by using Di.wn's Fbke
Graphite on their engmes
they have not been troubled
with hot pins in the course of
a long run.
Says an engineoi' :
"I can recommend Uixons
Pure Flake Graphite very highly
for use on hot pins, as wc are
bothered here a great deal with
them, as the division of the
L. V. R. I. run is up a long, heavy
grade. For 57 miles it averages
1634 feet to the mile. Tmie is
fast, and heavy trains. The tirst
use I put it to was a consolidated
engine. The pin was hot enough
to fry meat. I simply took the
cup out of the strap and poured
the Graphite in the strap hole,
put the cup back and tilled the
cup with engine oil and Graphite,
and for 30 miles up hill with stock
train pounded engine as hard as
she would stand, and at the top of
the hill found the pin cool."
Let US send you a sample
to try on your engine.
Joseph Dixon Crucible Co.
JERSEY CITY, N. J.
December, iqo.v
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
571
>
u V!©
<cx^
impurities and mixed with oil had a corro-
sive effect upon iron and steel. An effect-
ual remedy was found in using sufficient
sea water to deposit a small quantity of
lime inside the. boilers. The lime accu-
mulated in locomotive boilers from other
sources may be depended upon to neu-
tralize any corrosive tendencies of a few
condensing stations.
'Ihat experience gave rise to the say-
ing frequently heard among engineers that
absolutely pure water has a corrosive ef-
iec-t upon boiler sheets. We doubt the
correctness of this theory. In many re-
gions of the world where igneous rocks
cover the entire surface, all the water
found is free from mineral impurities.
When this water is used for boiler pur-
poses it causes no corrosion ; and loco-
motive boilers that have used it for de-
cades will show sheets as free from pit-
ting and grooving as they were the day
they were put in. If the water was mixed
with a little animal or vegetable oil, as
those in marine boilers are, a compound
might be formed which would cause cor-
rosion of metal. Vegetable acids that are
drawn from swamp water are said to have
given a corrosive tendency to soft water ;
but it would be robbed of its venom by
the lime deposits which are perniciously
abundant in locomotive boilers.
To Club Raisers.
Many of our club raisers believe that
it is the best way to wait until near the
beginning of the year before sending in
their list of subscribers. That is a mis-
take. The lists ought to be in not later
than Dec. 15 to insure the names being
put on our regular list, and by that
means be promptly mailed.
Obituary.
Stephen D. Winner, probably the old-
est locomotive engineer in active service
in the United States, died recently at his
home in Newark, N. J., aged eighty-one
years. He began his career as an en-
gineer on the old Germantown and Nor-
ristown Railroad in 1852. He had the
first engine, the "David P. Baldwin,"
that was made at the Baldwin Locomo-
tive Works. For more than forty years
he was connected with the Central Rail-
road of New Jersey, and for the last
twelve years had run a switching engine
in the yards of that company in New-
ark.
An unfortunate accident, resulting in
the death of D. W. Jackson, general fore-
man of the Elmira shops, of the Dela-
ware, Lackawanna & Western, has de-
prived that road of a competent officer.
and one whose loss is universally mourn-
ed by all who knew him. Mr. Jackson
was injured by being struck by an engine
on October 3, while superintending some
work on a locomotive which was stand-
ing near the shop. He had only
been ni charge of the shop for
about one year, but in that short
time he endeared himself to all those with
whom he came in official contact. As a
loving tribute to his memory the Lack.i-
wanna employees sent a guard of honor
with his remains to the home of his sor-
row-stricken parents. A set of engrosscl
resolutions was also sent to his mourning
friends.
L. S. Heald & Son, formerly of
Barre, Mass., arc now located at
Worcester, under the name of the Heald
Machine Co. They make a line of
special machine tools, twist drill grind-
ers, etc.
Mr. J. M. Martin has resigned his
position as district sales agent at the
Philadelphia office of the Nernst Lamp
Company, and Mr. A. E. Baker has been
appointed as his successor.
Recorded Experience.
In those wonderfully interesting series
of chapters called "Extracts from Chor-
dal's Letters," the writer tells, in one
of them, about an experiment in friction
conducted with a load of bricks and some
buckshot on the shop floor. He says:
"Let us suppose that you were the party
who did the experimenting with the
bearing under the pile of bricks; that
you spent six months' time, five hundred
dollars in money, and used up lots of
good judgment and patience; that all
this happened one hundred years ago,
and that you wrote it all down in your
little book." Our author goes on to
say: "Let your name be Moran, and
assume that in the course of years your
little book gets printed and accepted
as an authority on such subjects." Then
he tells us of a man who had been work-
ing thirty years at the machinists" trade,
and as owner of a shop, and he says this
man at last "begins to wonder if. after
all, this thing he has misnamed 'theory'
is simply a knowledge of the successful
experience of other men."
We think that puts the case very neat-
ly; the "book learning" which some men
deride is just the recorded experience
of those who have gone before. It does
not require that the experience be lOO
years old; some practical person's ex-
perience just a month old might be in-
valuable to you if you could get it. The
way experience is recorded nowadays is
in book form. Nobody supposes, how-
ever, that a book by itself, no matter
how good, would make a dry goods
clerk into a skilful locomotive engineer,
or into a first class fireman, just as soon
as he had read it over. That is because
the kind of experience recorded in the
book is not that which touches the dry
goods clerk in his daily work, but it
would help the engineer or fireman or
57*
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
practical railroad man, because it is right
in their line and can be understood and
appreciated by them. Look at the list
of books which follows — the recorded
experience of others, that is what they
really are, and judge for yourself if the
probabilities are not in favor of some
one or two of them helping you?
The first on the list is, of course,
Kailway and Locomotive Engine£R-
ING, a practical journal of railway mo-
tive power and rolling stock. It costs
only $2.00 a year, and is well worth the
money, and besides the paper is a wel-
come visitor in every household. Let
your wife and children see it.
"Locomotive Engine Running and
Management," by Angus Sinclair, is an
old and universal favorite. A well-known
general manager remarked in a meeting
of railroad men lately, "I attribute much
of my success in life to the inspiration of
that book. It was my pocket companion
for years." We sell it for $2.00.
"Practical Shop Talks." Colvin. This
is a very helpful book, combining instruc-
tion with. amusement. It is a particular-
ly useful book to the young mechanic. It
has a stimulating effect in inducing him
to study his business. The price is 50
cents.
"Examination Questions for Promo-
tion." Thompson. This book is used
by many master mechanics and traveling
engineers in the examination of firemen
for promotion and of engineers likely to
be hired. It contains in small compass
a large amount of information about the
locomotive. Convenient pocket size. We
cordially recommend this book. The
price is 75 cents.
"Compound Locomotives." Colvin.
This book instructs a man so that he will
understand the construction and opera-
tion of a compound locomotive as well
as he now understands a simple engine.
Tells all about running, breakdowns and
repairs. Convenient pocket size, bound
in leather, $1.00.
"Catechism of the Steam Plant." Hem-
enway. Contains information that will
enable a man to take out a license to run
a stationary engine. Tells about boilers,
heating surface, horse power, conden-
sers, feed water heaters, air pumps, en-
gines, strength of boilers, testing boiler
performances, etc., etc. This is only a
partial list of its contents. It is in the
question and answer style. 128 pages.
Pocket size. 50 cents.
"Care and Management of Locomotive
Boilers." Raps. This is a book that
ought to be in the hands of every person
who is in any way interested in keeping
boilers in safe working order. Written
by a foreman boilermaker. Also con-
tains several chapters on oil-burning
locomotives. Price, 50 cents.
"Locomotive Link Motion." Halsey.
Any person who gives a little study to
this book ceases to find link motion a
puzzle. Explains about valves and valve
motion in plain language, easily under-
stood. Price, $1.00.
"Machine Shop Arithmetic." Colvin
and Cheney. This is a book that no
person engaged in mechanical occupa-
tions can afford to do without. Enables
any workman to figure out all the shop
and machine problems which are so puz-
zling for want of a little knowledge. We
sell it for 50 cents.
"Firing Locomotives." Sinclair. Treats
in an easy way the principles of combus-
tion. While treating on the chemistry
of heat and combustion it is easily under-
stood by every intelligent fireman. The
price is 50 cents.
"Air-Brake Catechism." Conger. Noth-
ing better can be found for persons try-
ing to learn all about air brakes. Tells
the whole story. New edition contain-
ing added matter relating to the New
York Air Brake. Cloth, $1.00.
"Skeevers' Object L,essons." Hill. A
collection of the famous object lesson
stories which appeared in this paper sev-
eral years ago. They are interesting,
laughable and best of all they are of
practical value to-day. $1.00.
"Stories of the Railroad." Hill. Best
railroad stories ever written. Those who
have not read these stories have missed
a great literary treat. $1.50.
"Standard Train Rules." This is the
code of Train Rules prepared by the
American Railway Association, for the
operating of all trains on single or double
track. Used by nearly all railroads.
Study of this book would prevent many
collisions. Price, 50 cents.
"Mechanical Engineers' Pocket Book."
Kent. This book contains 1,100 pages
6x3^ inches of closely-printed minion
type, containing mechanical engineering
matter. It ought to be in the bookcase
of every engineer who takes an interest
in engineering questions. We use it con-
stantly as a reference for questions sent
to us to be answered. Full of tables and
illustrations. Morocco leather, $5.00.
"Locomotives, Simple, Compound and
Electric." Reagan. An excellent book
for people interested in any kind of loco-
motive. It will be found particularly use-
ful to men handling or repairing com-
pound locomotives. It is the real loco-
motive up to date. $2.50.
Railway and Locomotive Engineer-
ing. Bound volumes. $3.00.
What is it to be educated? It is to
learn to apply the natural conceptions to
each thing severally according to nature;
and further, to discern that, of things
that exist, some are in our own power
:ind the rest are not in our own power.
And things that are in our own power are
the will and all the works of the will.
Cheap Books for
Raifro ad Me n
To meet the coming demand for
Cbrigtmag presents
we have di'termiiied to cut the prices
■ if our most popular books and offer a
Whole Library for Five Dollars
The list comprises
JIM SKEEVER'S OBJECT
LKS.-^UNS $1.00
STORl ES OF THE RAILROAD 1.50
SHOP TALKS 50
CATECH ISM OF THE STEAM
PI-ANT 50
COMPOUND LonOMOTIVES 1.00
LOI'OMOTIVR LINK MOTION 1.00
FIRINt; LOCOMOTIVES . . .50
CARK OF BOILERS ... .50
MACHINE SHOP ARITH-
METIC 50
$7.00
All Good Books
Five DollaLrs Buys Them All
SEND TO
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
174 Broadway, New York
WANT E D.
Travelling Salesman for Locomotive
specialities for a well-known manufac-
turer. Territory : Middle Atlantic and
Southern States, including New York.
Address H, care of Railway and Loco-
motive Engineering, 1 Maiden Lane,
New York.
Twentieth Century
Locomotives
By ANGUS SINCLAIR. COMPANY
This bonk contains val lable facts about
principles of Steam Engireering, Il-
lustrated particulars and descriptions
showing
How Locomotive Repairing
is Properly Done ^ Ng >^ v?
Has Good Articles Illustrating
Pistorv Valves
Valve Setting
How to la.y out a.nd repair Boilers
How to dea.1 with Break-downs
Is a 0 imp'cte hand book of
ALL LOCOMOTIVE MECHANISM.
Nil foreman, engineer or ambitious
mechanic can afford to be without
tins book.
Illustrated descripti ins of a great
variety of modern locomotives.
Will be ready in January
Price $5.00
Railway and Locomotive Engineering
I 74 Broadway, New York.
)-)cccnibcr, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
573
Ball's Official R. R.
Standard Watches
6 AND 18 SIZE,
17 AND 21 KUBY
.IKWKLS,
SArrillUK PALLETS
BAM/S IJIPBOYED
SAKKTY
DOrULK KOLLFB
At*: without question
tin* fluL'st watches that
Amoricnn talent and
Hlvillcd Iiibor can pro-
(lufo, and tht-y are giv-
hi;^ Huch universal Bat-
lefaction that we have
no lu'Pitancy In claim-
ing that they are the
best and safest railroad
watch on the raarl^et.
Teste eevcrc and numerous have proven this fact to
the most critical users in all sections of the country, to
which thousands of good Ilailroad and Brotherhood
men are ready to certify.
We have an authorized agent in nearly every rail-
road center. Call on him for information and facts.
"Write OS for descriptive matter.
The Webb C. Ball Watch Co.
Watch Manufacturers
Ball Building:, Cle/eland, Ohio» U.S.A.
WHITNEY
PLANERS
long ago pissed the experimental and
durability test. They have demonstrated
their adaptability fur either work re-
quirinsT very nice planing or where
quantity is desired.
BAXTER D. WHITNEY & SON
WINCHENDON, MASS.
Patents.
GEO. P. WHITTLESEY,
BcGlLL BUILDING, WASHINGTON. 0. C.
Terms Reasonable. P.mphlet Sen*
Misogyny and Mechanisms.
lie was a misogynist and a mechani-
cian, and very, very young.. Unlike his
companions, he disliked going to chil-
dren's parties, and was remonstrated with
Ijy his mother.
"Why don't you want to go to the
parly?" said the latter. "You surely
don't prefer running your locomotives to
dancing with little girls."
"Oh, but I do," answered the hope of
the family. "Why?" ,
"Well," quoth the philosopher, "I un-
derstand girls."
Wooden Smoke Jack on the Chicago
& Northwestern Railway.
The members of the convention of
Superintendents of Bridges and Build-
ings, had, at their meeting in Boone, la..
tend installing the Walden jack in their
roundhouses at Boone, Belle Plaine,
and other points on the system as soon
as the jacks can be built. Mr. Walden,
the designer of the jack, is assistant
superintendent of bridges and buildings
of the Iowa division of the Chicago and
Northwestern Railway, and has applied
for a patent on his invention.
The New York Central & Hudson
Kivcr Railroad have placed an order
with the General Electric Company for
eight Turbo-generators, of a capacity of
7,500 horsepower each. The turbines
are of the 4 stage vertical Curtis type.
The generators are 25 cycle, 3 phase,
generating current at a pressure of il,oo*
volts. This is by far the largest order
for steam turbines ever placed in this
country or abroad. The New York
ROUNDHOUSE SMOKE
an opportunity to inspect a wooden
smoke jack, designed by Mr. H. A.
Walden, which was in use in the round
liouse of the Chicago & Northwestern
Railway.
The jack, as will be seen from our
illustration, is simply a taper conduit,
measuring 4 ft. x 2 ft. at the base, and 2
ft. X iS ins. at the top. This jack is the
outcome of months of experimenting
with wooden jacks. The lightness of
the structure makes it easy to carry on
an ordinary shop roof, and the roraf re-
pair account is correspondingly kept
down. The inventor also claims cheap-
ness as one of the advantages gained in
the use of the jack. He says these
jacks can be built and installed for $10.00
each, and their simplicity and durability
make the maintenance charge small. It
is painted inside and out with a fireproof
paint.
The motive power department of the
Chicago and Northwestern Railway are
installing 10 of this style of jack in
their Council Bluffs roundhouse and in-
4-0'
JACK MADE OK WOOD.
Central Company has also placed with
the General Electric Company, in co-
operation with the Schenectady works of
the American Locomotive Company, an
order for 30 electric locomotives. These
locomotives are of an entirely new de-
sign, will weigh 85 tons each, with an
adhesive weight on the drivers of 67
tons. Each locomotive will have a ca-
pacity of 2,200 horsepower, and will be
capable of hauling a train of 500 tons
at a speed of 60 miles an hour. This is,
without doubt, the largest order for
electric locomotives ever placed in any
country.
At a meeting of the Joint Executive
Committee of the Master Mechanics' and
Master Car Builders' .\ssociations it was
decided to hold the 1904 conventions at
Saratoga Springs. N. Y. Atlantic City
and Manhattan Beach were considered,
but the former meeting place was again
selected. The M. C. B. convention will
begin June 22. That of the M. M. will
follow.
574
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903
Dotting Drawing Pen,';|ft<,,7^
One of the newest and neatest things in
the way of drawing instruments is a uni-
versal dotting pen for draughtsmen which
has just been put on the market by E. G.
Ruehle & Company, makers of mathe-
matical instruments. The dotting pen en-
ables one to draw a dotted line as fast
as an ordinary straight one can be ruled
by a draughtsman, and when drawn, all
the dots or dashes are all of equal sizi;
and are equally spaced. A fine dotted
line can be drawn, a line with short
dashes or one with longer dashes, suit-
able for cross hatching or one with a
long dash and two short ones can be
drawn, as occasion demands. This lat-
ter can be used as a center line and looks
well. The mechanism is simply a draw-
ing pen which has a small toothed wheel
beside it operating four other small
wheels, each of which in revolving pro-
duces the desired line. The inking point
is constantly raised and lowered from
the paper as the pen is drawn steadily
along. The width of the line can be
varied as with the ordinary drawing pen.
This should be a uclcome instrument in
the drawing office, and with students
learning to draw, as it is a time saver and
does most accurate work. The E. G.
Ruehle Co. do business at 41 West 24th
street. New York City.
electric lamps in a room to be removed
in order to connect wires, and in offices
where electricity is not available this
self-running fan will be a welcome
novelty. It ought to be available in rail-
road service for cars not lighted by elec-
tricity, and thus do much to solve the
vexed question of railway coach ventila-
tion.
When contributors permit their hand-
writing to degenerate so that the char-
acters look like the record on dyna-
motor car traction roll, they can-
not justly blame us when the ideas
they mean to convey get slightly
twisted. We have lost a subscriber
lately because he sent in some
notes about a "powerful mogul" and the
words were converted into "howling
mongrel." Accidents will happen, as we
say, but that is hardly so bad as the poet
was treated who sent in a poem on Sur-
cease of Sorrow and found the words
converted into Smearcase to-morrow.
The politicians of New York State sub-
mitted to the people a proposition to vote
to spend $101,000,000 on the enlarging of
the Erie Canal, which, as an active ele-
ment in transportation, has been dead for
twenty-five years;. The psople of New
York City and of Buffalo, the two cities
likely to receive any benefit from increas-
ing the capacity of the long ditch, voted
so numerously in favor of the scheme that
it was carried. It will be a great thing
for the politicians for the next decade or
two, since the opportunities for stealings
will be almost beyond parallel ; but we are
afraid that it will do nothing to reduce
the cost of food products coming from
the West to feed the people of the hungry
seaboard. If half the sum were devoted
to making roads, the people in every part
of the State would receive substantial ben-
efits.
The National Battery Fan Company,
St. Paul Building, New York, was in-
corporated for the purpose of manufac-
turing a portable battery fan for office
or house use. The portable fan has a
dry battery which unites the principles
of the primary and secondary batteries
in such a way as to retain the advantages
of the primary battery while providing
for periodic recharging. The battery is
capable of running the fan for a week
and the cost to the user is 50 cents per
week. This (an should be popular, as
having its own motive power, stored in
its stand, it will not require one of the
A new and very up-to-date pay car has
lately been turned out of the Columbus
shops of the P. C. C. & St. L. The en-
tire car is bullet proof, floor, roof, sides
and ends being covered with steel plates.
The occupants of the car carry arms,
and a heavy safe is used to hold the
money. In addition to these precautions
no large sums of money are ever car-
ried; only enough is taken on board to
pay employees from one large city to
another. One end of the car is used as
the paying office and the other is fitted
with berths very similar to those of an
ordinary Pullman car. and are for the
use of the paymaster and his assistants.
President Smith is constitutionally op-
posed to giving passes and knows the en-
tire literature of excuses for asking these
favors. A stranger of classical appearance
called at his office the other day and asked
for a pass. "On what grounds?" de-
manded President Smith. "Merely be-
cause I don't want to pay my way," re-
plied the stranger. "Come right in and
sit down," said the president very cor-
dially. "You can have the pass, for you
are the only man I remember who was
not a liar as well as a beggar."
The Lehigh Valley Railroad has just
finished widening the gauge of the
Montrose Branch from narrow to the
standard gauge. This road was built
some years ago as a narrow gauge road
and runs from Tunkhannock to Mont-
rose, Pa. a distance of twenty-eight
miles. The Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company has been in possession of the
property for several years, and some
months ago began the improvements re-
ferred to. From now on all trains op-
erated on the Montrose Branch will be
of standard gauge.
\Ko^\\ \\\\t.%^ Ov<tt«.l\« ixc« vi.o>c<\ a^n^
BEST. Evv.ft^ p<>vx\X o^ n,\^X<i.«\.a.\ ,
i)iJK\>.xv<l.i. E-/«.«w ^AtrntnC
f l»«.c(i-\\.-<\4ai, jOi^dtt)
Yfof llr\ 0~ irtVolt SxxvV
I'll 5«ni s<lx<\^\«
S-uW ya.xt\.cw\aL\:s 30^
UNION IAKD&
oSy COURSE —
a.L.t; s-K.SPETERS-Bkue.tTi
0»vER. , Ncw OER*eY , o. S. ^.
The Twentieth
Century
Master Mechanic
Won't use solid Mandrels.
Cost too much, take up too
much room and don't give
satisfaction.
Nicholson
Expanding Mandrels
Take everything from 1 to 7
inch holes. Take up little
room — always ready and
you can buy four sets for
the cost of one of the solid
kind.
Are You Using Them ?
Catalogue tells you
more about them.
W. H. Nicholson & Co.
Wilkesbarre. Pa.
December, 1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
mmm tubes
BOIL[R TUBES
WIRE RAPE
RIVETS
TIE PLATES
MECHANICAL TUBES
Cold Drawn Seamless
BOILER TUBES
Cold Drawn Seamless
Lapweld Charcoal Iron
WIRE ROPE
Bright and Galvanized
Switching and Wrecking
Ropes
RIVETS
Boiler, Tank and Struc-
tural Rivets of Mild Open
Hearth Steel
TIE PLATES
The Hart Tie Plate
CAN'T WE INTEREST YOU 7
Miller, Thornburgh & Co.
135 Broadway. New York, N. V.
Electrically Operated Train on Fire
After Collision.
When a railway collision happens on
a steam line and people lose their lives
through the cars taking fire, vvc always
hear talk about the safety that would be
insured by electric operating. An acci-
dent that happened to two electrically
operated trains on the Brooklyn (N. Y.)
elevated railway last month indicates
that electric operating possesses poten-
tial horrors that discount anything pro-
ceeding from the fire-b«aring car heater.
On the Brooklyn Elevated Railroad
there was a rear end collsion between
two electrically operated trains, and the
shock was sufficient to kill two persons,
besides injuring many others. The cars
were derailed, and the current from the
third rail (the electric conductor) was
short circuited in various places, and
the current put into operation fires that
acted like a number of electric welding
apparatus. The cars viere quickly a
mass of flames. Had it not been that
the fire department of the city of Brook-
lyn responded promptly to extinguish
the burnmg cars, the accident might
have resulted in frightful loss of life.
After the terrible accident which
happened in the Park avenue tunnel in
1901 some of the advocates of electric
operating insisted that there would have
been little loss' of life had the tunnel
been electrically operated. At the time
Mr. George Westinghouse publicly ex-
pressed the opinion that electricity
might prove more disastrous than steam,
operating under circumstances that
would short circuit into wrecked cars
the powerful electric current employed.
This appears to have happened in the
Brooklyn accident. If we remember
correctly several inventions have been
tried which prevented the electric con-
ductors for railroads from being com-
plete until breaks were closed by the
contact shoe. The introduction of such
an arrangement might be a very desir-
able safeguard against destructive acci-
dents.
Our club agents would help us and
a.ssure the prompt delivery of the Janu-
ary number if they would send their list
of names to this office by December 15.
The last few weeks of the year bring
such a rush of orders that our office
force is overworked. Help them by
.sending in your list in good season.
JONES & LAMSON MACHINE CO.
Main Office and Works :
SPRINGFIELD, VERMONT, U. S. A.
A, B, C and Lubtr's Cade ugtd.
Knglish office: Room 6, Exclmnge Building, Steplieu-
son's Place, Biriniupham. France and Spain : Ph. Bon-
villain, G, Rue Blanche, 6, Paris. France. Germany,
Belgium. Holland, Switzerland and Austria-Hungary,
M. Koyemann, Charlotteustr.asse 112, Dusseldorf,
Germany.
liappens occasionally to nearly all pub-
lishers. To one correspondent who
writes, "Why don't you print another
edition?" we answer that it would cost
about $!,Soo.
On another page we publish a paper by
Paul Synncslvedt on the Nature of a
Patent Right, which deserves the careful
study of all persons in any way interest-
ed in patents. A widespread impression
prevails that when the Government grants
a patent to an inventor it is in some way
bound to take the initiative in
protecting the patentee's rights and
that the granting of the patent is a guar-
antee that the invention is original and
valuable. Mr. Synnestvedt's paper makes
plain what the inventor obtains by secur-
ing a patent and the Government's duties
toward him. Care is taken to grant pat-
ents only on new and valuable inventions,
but the Patent Office authorities some-
times make mistakes about that and then
it lies with the courts to decide on the
rights of the inventor.
October Number Exhausted.
Owing to an extraordinary demand
for our October number the supply is
exhausted, and it cannot be sent to sub-
scribers or others. We regret that quite
a number of applications for that num-
ber have had to be refused. We printed
the usual number of copies, but for
some unexplained reason there was a
great run on that paper, a thing that
The Circuit Court for Wayne County,
State of Michigan, issued an injunction
on November 17 in favor of the Detroit
Lubricator Co., and against the Michi-
gan Lubricator Co., restraining them
from using the words "Detroit Lubri-
cators," "Improved Standard Lubri-
cators," "Detroit Improved Standard
Lubricators,'' in connection with their
lubricators or advertising matter, also
restraining them from using boxes or
packages for their lubricators bearing
the words "Detroit," or "Detroit.
Mich.," unless their firm name be also
given. .
The J. A. Fay & Egan Company, Cin-
cinnati, Ohio, have issued a little pamph-
let, giving a list of second-hand machines-
in stock, and which come to them by way
of exchange and which they sell at re-
duced prices. If you send for the cata-
logue or for a new or an old machine
this company will be able to supply you
on short notice.
The Falls Hollow Staybolt Company,
of Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, have recently
increased the capacity of their works for
the manufacture of double refined char-
coal iron, hollow and solid staybolt ma-
terial for use in locomotive, marine and
stationary boilers. They have also built
an addition 50x200 feet, which increases
their storage capacity for raw material
and for finished product.
"When your engine groans, it need?
Dixon's Graphite. Give it a spoonfu'
and see how much better it feels and
works. A single dose may cure." Ask
for booklet 69 C from the Joseph Dixo^
Crucible Company, Jersey City, N. T
576
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Dcconiber, 1903.
Tests of Hollow Stays.
The testing laboratories of McGill
University of Montreal, Canada, have
made some tensile tests of iron for the
Falls Hollow Staybolt Company, of
Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio.
There were three samples submitted
to tensile test. Each i in. in diameter.
The hollow stay yielded at 27,250 lbs. per
sq. in., with ultimate strength 48.420 lbs.,
having 32.5% of elongation in 8 ins. and
5.37^ reduction of area. The solid sam-
ples yielded at 33,790 lbs. per sq. in.;
broke at 50,150 lbs. per sq. in., and gave
an elongation in 8 ins. of 29.25?) with
I eduction of area of 56.44%.
There were two samples of this com-
pany's product submitted to a vibration
test made by the Grand Trunk Railway.
Each specimen was i in. diameter. The
Falls Hollow charcoal iron sample broke
on 5,024 vibrations, which occupied 157
minutes. The other specimen. Falls
solid charcoal iron, broke on 4,192 vibra-
tions and lasted 131 minutes. Five sam-
ples of iron made by other manufactur-
ers were tested, the best of them failed
in 120 minutes with 3,840 vibrations.
The testing strains were more severe
than those encountered by staybolts in
boilers and were purposely made so in
order to ascertain relative merits.
Among the recent orders received by
the Hicks Locomotive & Car Works, of
Chicago, are the following: One 55-ton
engine for the Butte City Railroad, a
4-wheel switching locomotive for the
Hecla Belt Line, one 4-wheel switching
engine for the International Harvester
Company, and a 50-ton locomotive for
General Construction Company, Daven-
port, Iowa. The firm has orders for
passenger equipment, including: One
coach for the West Virginia & South-
ern Railroad, a 57 ft. combination coach
for the Green Bay & Western; also a
private car for the Santa Fe Central,
three passenger coaches for the Duluth,
Missabe & Northern, one passenger
coach and one combination car for the
Duluth & Iron Range Railroad, and
three coaches for the Louisiana North-
western Railroad. The orders for
freight car equipment include: Thirty
gondolas for the Newton & North-
western; fifteen tank cars for the Santa
Fe Central, twelve flats for the Muncie,
Hartford & Fort Wayne, and fourteen
cars for the Ohio River & Columbus
Railway.
The American Steam Gauge & Valve
Manufacturing Company have again
been compelled to seek new quarters,
owing to the increase of their business,
and are at present removing their entire
plant and offices from Bismark street,
Roxbury district, to the large brick
buildings, 208-220 Camden street, Boston,
Mass. The buildings have floor space of
85.000 square feet. The Mowry & Phil-
lips foundry department will also be re-
moved from South Boston, and every
branch of the business will be consoli-
dated at the Camden street factory. The
new plant will afford them more than
double the present capacity, and will be
employed in producing their valves,
gauges and indicators; also special
metals and foundry work in the Mowry
& Phillips department.
The American Locomotive Sander
Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., have re-
cently issued an illustrated catalogue,
which tells all about locomotive sanders.
'J he catalogue contains some remarkably
clear half-tones which show the sander
in section and in elevation and adapted
for single drivers, double, treble and
quadruple, as the case may be. The
various parts are shown in detail, and
the action of the apparatus is set forth
in the letterpress. This company are
the owners and sole manufactu'-ers of
the "She," sanders, the Leach, the Sher-
burne, the Houston, the Dean, the Curtis
and the Austin sanders. Write for a
catalogue to Thirteenth and Willow
streets, Philadelphia, if you are interest-
ed in sanders.
A.Leschen & Sons Rope Co.
MANUFACTURERS
The Smooth-On Company, of Jersey
City, have recently received a testimonial
from Mr. George E. David, engineer and
machinist for the Bureau of Fisheries, at
Wood's Hole, Mass. Mr. Davis writes
that he repaired a leaky boiler of the
Scotch type by the use of the Smooth-
On compound, which he had purchased
from the Walworth Manufacturing Com-
pany, of Boston. The leaks which he
stopped were around the ends of the
furnaces. In applying the compound"
he cleaned the surface of the iron inside
and washed it thoroughly with gasoline,
then painted on a coat of Smooth-On,
and let it stand twelve hours. He then
mixed a thick putty of the compound
and pressed it well into the joint, and
let it stand twenty-four hours. The
boiler has been tight ever since. The
compound is also used for making pipe
joints. Write the Smooth-On Company,
572 Communipaw avenue, Jersey City, it
you desire further particulars.
We understand that the Southern Pa-
cific people are largely reducing the force
in their different repair shops. This
seems to be rather curious, for from all
accounts the business of the Southern
Pacific system has been very active dur-
ing the past year and business cannot
be conducted without rolling stock being
worn out.
The bound volumes of Railway' and
Locomotive Engineering for the year
1903 will be ready about Dec. 10. As
only a limited number will be for sale it
is necessary that intending purchasers
place their orders with us as soon as
possible. The volumes are $3.00 each.
WIRE ROPE
Ballast Unloaders, Switch
Ropes, Wrecking Ropes
MANILA ROPE
Fittings and Supplies
HOMU OI-KICE:
920-922 North First St., ST. LOUIS, MO.
( 137 E. Lake St., Chicago, 111.
Rranch Offices ' 9^ Centre St., New York City, N Y.
Branch omces ^ ^^^^^^ ^^^^ ^^^^ Francisco, Cal.
( 1717-23 Arapahoe St., Denver, Col.
The Union
Switch &
Signal Co.
OF PITTSBURGH, PA.
GENERAL OFFICES AND WORKS AT
SWISSVALE, PA.
DISTRICT OFFICES:
New York: Central Bulldlag, 143
Liberty Street.
Chicago: 1536 Monadnock Bulldlii(.
St. Louis : Terminal Station.
lAlLUK YORKSHIRE
STAY-BOLT IRON
PISTON RODS and AXLES
Used by tlie Leading Railroads
R.Mushers-gSeed" Steels
Doing More Work than
any other Known Steels
THESE GOODS ARE THE STAND-
ARD OF EXCELLENCE
5ole Representatives in the United States,
Canada and Mexico.
B. M. JONES & CO.
No. 159 Devonshire Street, BOSTON
No. 143 Liberty Street, NEW YORK
THE ROBERT W. HUNT & CO.
Bureau of Inspection, Tests and Consultation,
1 137 THE ROOKERY, CHICAGO.
i>ij Broadway, New York. Park Building, Pittsburgh
31 Norfolk House, Luulon, Eng.
Inspection of Steel Rails, Splite Bars, Railroad Cars,
Wlieels, Axle.s. etc. Chemical Lahokatory Analysis
of Dies, Iron, Steel, Oils, Water, etc. Physical Labo-
ratory—Test of Metals, Drop and I'liUiug Test of Coup-
lers, Draw Bars, etc.
KflicieiK'V Ti-stK nf ItnilerK. Kii^iiics and I.oeoDiotivei.
Or.
1903.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
Keep
Yo\ar
Mind
On.
It
CRANDALL'S HEIIOS
AIR PLMP and
THROTTLE VALVE
PACKING
Put Lp in Sets
Exact Fit to Rod and Box
Send Trial Order
The Crandall Pkg. Co.
123 Liberty Street
N. Y. CITY
Chicagfo Office, 30 La Salle St.
A Kubber-Tired Car Wheel.
Anything that will abate the horrible
noise made by the wheels of elevated
railroad cars will be a blessing and a
comfort to the myriads of persons whose
nerves are racked by the overhead tumult
constantly assailing their ears from the
overhead structures. We have frequently
reflected about the evil and tried mentally
to devise a remedy, but nothing seemed
practicable as long as steel tires were
permitted to roll upon steel rails. We
now believe that an inventor has per-
fected a wheel which will prove an ef-
fective remedy and enable elevated trains
to be operated without objectionable
noise.
Major R. P. Tomassek, a military and
civil engineer of mature experience in
the construction and operating of street
car tires, has been for years devoting
himself to the inventing of a noiseless
car wheel, and we believe that he has
now succeeded in improving a wheel
which will meet all the requirements of
train or street car service. Vulcanized
solid rubber tires have seemed practi-
cable for car wheels since their durability
was demonstrated under heavy trucks,
but no satisfactory means of fastenin.?
them was devised until Major Tomassek
undertook to work out the problem. He
has now produced a fastening which
promises to meet all the requirements of
keeping the elastic material in place and
in shape.
This is done by means of an annular
T-shaped rim supplied with rows of open-
ings which are embedded in the elastic
composition and the tire is forced into
the bed between the rim and the wheel
flange under enormous hydraulic pres-
sure. The tire and fastenings are held
in position by bolts passing through the
rim and the wheel center. The tire used
in the wheels we examined has 354 inches
face and is 4 inches deep, which, with
the strong fastenings, forms a mass that
will readily resist all the shocks likely to
be put upon it by hard train service. It
presents a generous tread that will put as
wide a bearing on the rail as the ordi-
nary steel tired wheel does.
The wheel is known as the "Sampers
Wheel." and is the invention of Isidore
H. Sampers, of New York City. It is in-
geniously constructed to bring the center
of the elastic tire to the center of the
rail-head and to provide for an equal dis-
tribution of the cushion property of the
tire. It is also supplied with a twenty-
inch drum cast on the spokes and in-
tended to receive a steel band for break-
ing purposes.
Completed the wheel weighs nearly
three hundred pounds, about the same
weight as the present cast-iron wheel
now in use.
We believe the wheel is destined to
have a great future. The prevention of
noise is what will recommend this form
of wheel to the public, but users will
find it a valuable preventative of the
shocks which wear out rolling stock
prematurely and grind steel rails into
dust in a few years. Steel springs pro-
vide cars with comfortable resilience, but
when they are carried on rubber tires
they ought to roll as smoothly as a ship
glides through the water.
It may require pressure to induce rail-
road companies to adopt this wheel, but
we feel certain that once they adopt the
improvement they will find it the best in-
vestment they have ever made.
The Walworth Manufacturing Com-
pany, of Boston, Mass., have just issued
an illustrated catalogue of the new Wal-
worth locomotive injector which they
have just put on the market. The Wal-
worth people recently purchased the
right to manufacture what has hitherto
been called the "Mack Injector," buf
which will henceforth be known as the
Improved Walworth injector. The types
made for locomotives are the "Na-
tional," the "NT," "A" and "E." This
latter is a very compact upright non-
lifting injector, the others are horizon-
tally placed "lifters." Each kind is
catalogued and illustrated, with sizes,
capacity and price. The company also^
list to a Walworth stationary non-lift-
ing and a Walworth stationary lifting in-^
jector. The Dodge automatic injector
is also made by this firm. The com-
pany, whose general offices are at 132
Federal street, Boston, Mass., will be
happy to forward a copy of their loco-
motive injector catalogue to any person
who is interested enough to apply to
them for one.
The second edition of Catalogue No.
IIS, the condensed general catalogue of
the B. F. Sturtevant Co., Jamaica Plain.
Mass.. has gone to press and will very
soon be ready for distribution. A few-
pages in this revised edition have been
devoted to Factory and Industrial Rail-
way Equipments, a new departure of this
enterprising concern.. The outgrowth of
the success attained in equipping their
new plant at Hyde Park. Mass., was the
mnnufacture of this new line of prod-
ucts.
The most common measure of work is
the foot-pound which means the raising
of one pound one foot high. Where the
metric system of weights and measures
are in use the unit of work is raising one
kilogram one meter. That is equal about
to 7.24 foot pounds.
Grinding off brake shoe metal through
brake rigging being geared up too tight
is an expensive operation. When a train
pulls unusually hard it is a good thin?
to note how many brakes are only haif
released.
578
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December, 1903.
Do You
Boil Glue?
LIQi GLUE
does away with this work. A
pure hide and sinew glue in
liquid form. No smell, clean
and convenient. Will reduce
your shop expense for this line
of work twenty-five per cent.
The Qlue of the Twentieth
Century. Put up in cans,
kegs and barrels.
Not a
Fish Glue
Samples for testing and prices
are yours for the asking.
lACHTER MFG. CO.
BALTIMORE, M&RYLAND
Locomotive Works Her Passage on
the Uhio.
The story is told of the firm of Smith
& Porter, which later became the well
known H. K. Porter Company. The
original firm in 1868 built a locomotive
for a small railroad rimning out ot
Greenup, Ky. This town is 333 miles
below Pittsburgh. Pa., on the Ohio
River, and at about the time the delivery
was to be made none of the towboat-;
appear to have been available, the river
being very low owing to a long drought,
and other transportation facilities were
not to be had. It was, however, decided
liy Smith & Porter that the engine should
be delivered at the specified time. Mr.
Smith obtained a suitable flat boat, and
placed the machine aboard, and with the
help of several men the locomotive was
arranged to propel the boat.
The main driving wheels were at the
rear, and the side-rod extended forward,
as in many of our modern 4-4-2 engines.
The front ends of the side-rods were un-
coupled and the rods thrown back so
that they extended out behind the en-
gine as far as the leading wheels were
ahead of the main drivers. The project-
ing ends of the side-rods were coupled
to a temporary crank shaft, arranged for
the purpose, and on the ends of this
shaft were two paddle-wheels. The main
drviers were jacked clear of the rail and
the boiler was fired up.
When steam was turned on by En-
gineer James M. Schooley. the locomo-
tive presented a strange appearance,
standing on the deck of ja. scow, its lead-
ing drivers hanging motionless, its main
driver slowly turning and its reversed
side-rods working a crank shaft which
made a pair of dripping paddles revolve,
while the engine solemnly puffed its way
down stream. We do not know if any
conversation was permitted with the man
at the wheel, but this novel locomotive-
steamboat made the voyage successfully,
and furnishes a good example of what
men of enterprise could do to overcome
difficulties thirty-five years ago.
SLIGO IRON
The Standard for Ei§:hty Years
for
Locomotive Staybolts,
Piston Rods,
Crank and Wrist Pins,
and other purposes.
Blows in Two=Cylinder Compound
Locomotives. Sciienectady and
Rliode Island Systems.
Blows in two cylinder compound en-
gines are developed through wear of
packing rings in intercepting valve and
separate exhaust valve, and in rings o'.
piston valve and cylinder packing. Ti>
determine if intercepting valve is blow
ing, place right hand crank on upper
quarter, and reverse lever in center of
sector, bringing main valve central over
its ports. Intercepting valve to be
closed and separate exhaust valve open,
as when starting simple; if intercepting
valve blows, steam will pass through
separate exhaust valve and appear at
exhaust nozzle. See Fig. 3, Schenectady
SLIGO IRON AND STEEL CO.
(Successor to Phillips, Nimick & Co.)
Pittsburgh, Pa.
Photographs
of Locomotives from railways all over the
globe. The Largest collection on earth. Over
10,000 varieties ot Locomotives, cars and trains
from American, British. French, r.erman, Ital-
ian etc.. etc , railways. Samples bxSiuches, 25,
cents ; s x 10 inches, 7,6 cents, postage paid.
ILLUSTRATED PRICE LIST FREE
THE LOCOMOTIVE MAliAZINE
Full of railway pictures and infcruiation.
6 cents a copy, postage paid.
SEND DIRKCT TO
Locomotive Publishing Co., Ltd.
The World's Railway Photosrrepher
3 Amen Corner, Paternt^ster Row, London, E. C.
New York Agents, The Derry Collard Co., 256 B'way
London Agent, Railway and Locomotive Engineering
Moran Flexible
Steam-Heating
Connection, All Metal. .
ESPECIAllY APPLICABLE BETWEEH
ENGINE AND TENOEk.
MORAN FLEXIBLE STEAM JOINT CO., Ine.
No. 149 Third Street, Louisville, Ky.
ThelScCiOROiM
KEEPS OUT THE DUST.
SEE HOW THE LID FITS.
McCord & Company,
CHICXCO NEW YORK.
December, igoj.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
57<>
UNIV
DOTTI
! i
ERSAL
NQ PEN
I Ik universal
I>OTTIN(i PEN IS
utiiivalled in opera-
tion and beauty
of workmanship.
Every part is made
of the linest Ger-
man Silver except
the pen, which is of
tempered steel. No
interchange of
wheels is necessary
to obtain different
dotted lines. When
another seltin;? is
required, merely
give thumb screw
one revolution and
the instrument is
ready for the new
dot.
The pen is hinged
so that it may be
swung clear, as
shown by dotted
lines in cut. for fill-
ing and cleaning.
A few of the princi-
pal features are:
■ St. It is supplied
with ink Bame as
any ruling pen.
2nd. It never
blots.
.^d. Impossible
for dotting wheels
to be lust.
4th. Dots may
he made any desired
thickness.
Price
$6.50
E,G,fiy[iiLE&i;o.
-: Ni 4HIILSI HiH ST.
ii[w nn
FOR SALE
FRIICHT, PASSENGER AND LOCCINC
LOCOMOTIVES
ALL /^ADC wick
SIZES. W^%nO DEUVERIES
F. Ui LJI/^l/e »•' OI»RBORN ST.
• iVIa niV^I\0| CHICAGO, ti.U.
BARRETT
Car and Wrecking
JACKS
Are Quick-Acting,
Powerful and
Easily Handled
For spteti. IMiabil-
ity 311(1 Erticiency tlu-y
are miiV(.TS:ilIy re< os:-
nizeti as vastly Hiiperior
to Hydraulic or Screw
Jacks.
Used by al] leading
railroads for Car Work
in the Shop or on the rmid as pan of the Wrrokinii
Kquipnunr.
Sond for the " Yellow Book." made exclusively by
THE DUFF MFC. CO.
Works: Allegheny, Pa PITTSBURG, PA.
FAIRBANKS, MORSE S CO., Chicago
Au" Ml.~ fur Kiuln.iul Di'i.i
compound pamphlet. There is no way
to visibly detect a blow in the Rhode
Island intercepting valve. If such a blow
exists the steam passes to the low pres-
sure steam chest, whether working sim-
ple or compound.
To test piston valve, place crank on
upper quarter on side tested, and reverse
lever in center of sector. The valve be-
ing on center of its seat and covering
both steam ports, will show steam at one
or both cylinder cocks if rings arc blow-
ing. This test applies to valves of either
outside or inside admission. To test
cylinder packing rings, leave crank on
upper quarter, and place reverse lever
in full forward or back gear, opening
cither steam port full. If packing ring~
blow, steam will appear at cylinder cocks.
If piston valve packing blows on high
pressure side, the effect is to let steam
through the exhaust port into the re-
ceiver, and also to the opposite side of
piston. If cylinder packing of high pres-
sure piston blows, the effect is to let
steam pass to the opposite side of pis-
ton and out -through exhaust port into
receiver. Blows in piston valve rings
or cylinder packing rings have no effect
on the operation of by-pass valves for
the reason that steam chest pressure is
always greater than the wire drawn pres-
sure due to blows.
The separate exhaust valve remains
stationary when running, except as actu-
ated by pressure on its piston to open,
or tension on its spring to close. If
spring in separate exhaust valve is weak,
the result will be closed by receiver pres-
sure. This action applies to the Schenec-
tady compound. The separate exhaust
valve of the Rhode Island compound, in
case the spring is too weak to close the
separate exhaust port, will be forced
open by the receiver pressure when
working compound, diverting the ex-
haust from low pressure steam chest to
exhaust pipe and engine will work sim-
ple.
A drummer who recently returned from
a trip through Texas remarked that the
trains on some roads were so late that
the railroad men sometimes forgot they
had started.
In a scientific magazine published as
long ago as 18S5 we find a description of
a dirigible balloon which was said to
move against a light wind. Balloon mak-
ers have not made conspicuous progress
since that time.
We believe in the maxim that, for all
right judgment of any man or thing it
is essential to see his good qualities be-
fore pronouncing on his bad ones.
CONTENTS.
rxoB.
Air Brake Department U(
Corr^Hpondeoce 664
QueHtloni and Aniwera on Air Urake
Subject 6M
Apparatus for Drllliog StaybolU 5S8
Aninclul Niagara at St. Louis 6<T
Author of HuiiAy Rcf^Tcnce GM
Automobile Inspection Car 652
Blows Id Two-Cylinder Compound Locomo-
tives— Scbnectady and Rbode Island Sys-
tems 57S
Book Reviews 660
Break-Downs, by Joseph A. Baker 642
Cast-iron Thimbles for Tubes 646
Crown Sheet. A Blistered, by Shandy Ma-
gulro 636
Distilled Feed Water D70
Dotting Drawing Pen 574
Editorial:
Asking Something for Nothing 644
Engineer's Influence on Train Loads, The 660
Knglneman'g Plaint, The 649
Leaky Fireboxes and Tubes 648
Modern "Jolly Miller,' The 661
Reque-ting Information by Circular 660
Waste of Wood. A 54>
Elecirlcally Operated Train on Fire After
Collision 675
Fatal Collision in Scotch Station 687
General Correspondence:
Atlantic Type Locos, in Germany 541
British Ideas of U. S. A 642
Community of Interest 641
Compound vs. Simple Engines 642
Lubrication of Piston Valves and Cyl-
inders 542
Pioneer Machine Makers 543
Progress of Last Century 543
Res'ored the By-Pass 543
Wilmarth Engines 541
Growth of the Locomotive, by Angius Sin-
clair 545
Locomotiye Works Her Passage on the Ohio 578
Locomotives:
Baldwin. 2-8-0, for the Mexican Inter-
national 5t3
Consolidation tor Inv. Ry. & Coal Co 540
Fast Pass.. 4-4-2. for the Big Four 647
New Caledonian Engines 54C
Six-Wheel Switcher for the Gt. Nor 507
Nature of a Patent Right, by Paul Synncst-
vedt 688
Personals 6<6
Phoebe on the Stage 5<4
Questions Answered 551
Railway Matters in Australia 569
Recorded Experience 571
Rubber-Tired Car Wheel 577
Scenes in Alaska 533
Signals and Signaling, by George S. Hod-
gins 56S
Testing Station. Bureau of Forestry at
Purdue 546
Tests of Hollow Stays 57«
To Solder Aluminum 540
Under-Loading Cars 569
Volcanic Railway, A 539
Water-Tube Locomotive Boiler, A 53S
What Came of Trying to Save the Expense
of Washing Out Boilers 558
Wooden Smoke Jack. C. & N. W. Ry 573
In France there are 15,319 women em-
ployed as gatekeepers at the railway
crossings. They get very small pay. but
are provided with houses, fuel and light.
Reading maketh a full man, conference
a ready man, and writing an exact man. —
Bacon.
It is true that the world owes every-
body a living, but she must be reim-
bursed by hustling. The sweat of your
brow or brain is the current coin that
must be paid.
RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING
December. igo,«
WATCH THIS space for single and
double Rapid Lathes for Rapid Work
CARPENTER'S \C/ON
Trade
^!jmJ!£US£Sm££££S^
TAPS AND DIES IS A GUAR ^ ANTEE OF HIGH QUALITY. Send for Catalogue
The J. M. CARPENTER TAP & DIE CO., Pawtucket, R. I., U. S. A.
INDEX TO ADVERTISEMENTS.
PAQB.
Acme Machinery Co Front Cover
Ajax iMetal Co 4th Cover
Allis-Chalmers Co 16
American Balance Valve Co 20
Ameiican Brake Shoe Co 18
American Loco. Sander Co 25
American Locomotive Co 23
American Schooi of Correspondence 10
American S eam Gauge & Valvo Mfg. Co 5
Armstrong Bros. Tool Co 2d Cover
Armstrong Mfg. Co 25
Ashcroft Mfg. Co —
Baker, Wm. C 20
Baldwin Locomotive Works 24
Barnet. G. & H., Co 2d Cover
Ball. Webb C. Watch Co 573
Beeker-Bralnard Milling Mch. Co 9
Big Four Railroad 17
Books:
Compound Locomotives —
Computers —
Firing Locomotives 4tb Cover
Handling Locomotives 6
Locomotive Running and Management . . 17
Miscellaneous 7
Oil Burning in Locomotives —
The American Locomotive 19
Boston & Albany R. R 6
Boson & Maine R. R B32
Brady Brass Co 20
Campbell, A. S 20
Carpenter, The J. M. Tap & Die Co 2
Caswell Car Co 3
Central R. R. of New Jersey 17
Chapman Jack Co 9
Chicago & Alton R. R 9
Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co —
Cleveland City Forge & Iron Co 4th Cover
Cleveland Twist Drill Co 4th Cover
Cofflii-.Megeath Supply Co 6
Commonwealth Steel Co 3d Cover
Consolidated Railway Electric Lighting &
Equipment Co.- 25
Consolidated Safety Valve Co —
Crandali Packing Co 597
Crosby Steam Gauge &. Valve Co 24
Damascus Bronze Co 15
Dart Mfg. Co 20
Davis, John, Co 6
Day-Kincald Stoker Co 25
Derry-Collard Co 10
Detroit Lubricator Co 15
Dl.\on. Joseph, Crucible Co 570
Duff Mfg. Co 579
Eynon-Evans Co 17
Falls Hollow Stayboit Co 5
Fay & Egan Co., J. A 23
Flanders. L. B., Machine Works 9
Franklin Mfg. Co 20
Galena Signal Oil Co 20
General IDlectric Co 21
Gold Car Heating Co 571
Gould Coupler Co 8
Gould & Eberhardt 4th Cover
Hammett, H. G 4th Cover
Hancock Inspector Co —
Harrington & King Perforating Co 2d Cover
Hayden & Derby Mfg. Co —
Hendrick Mfg. Co 5
Henley, N. A. & Co 4
Hicks, F. M 579
Hoffman, Geo. W 5
Hunt, Robert W. & Co 576
Illinois Central R. R 5
Industrial Water Co 10
Internation Corre-pondence Schcols 21
International Library of Technology 13
Jenkins Bros -Ith Cover
Jones, B. M. & Co 576
Jones & L,amson Machine Co 575
Kennicott Water Softener Co 2d Cover
Lake Shore R. R 17
Latrobe Steel & Coupler Co 25
Lawson Boat & Car Co 26
Leschen & Son's Rope Co 676
Locomotive Chart 19
Locomotive Firemen's Magazine 12
Locomotive Publish. ng Co., Ltd 678
Lodge & Shipley Machine Tool Co 2
McConway & Torley Co 15
McCord & Co 578
Manning. Maxwell & Moore 17
Middletown Car Works 18
Mil er, Thornbureh & Co 676
Moran Flexible Steam Joint Co 678
Nathan Mfg. Co 6
National Car Coupler Co 4th Cover
National Malleable Castings Co 4th Cover
Nicholson, W. H., & Co 574
Niles-Bement-Pond Co 14
Niles Tool Co —
Norton Grindins Co —
Norwalk Iron Works 5-
Pedrick & Ayer Co 19
Peters. H. S 674
Piit^burgh Crushed Steel Co 4th Cover
Pond Machine Tool Co., The —
Porter. H. K.. & Co 24
Pratt & Whitney Co 14
Pressed Steel Car Co 25
Pros.-er. Thos.. & Son »
Protectus Co., The 18
Railway Appliances Co —
Railway Material Co 2d Cover
Ramapo Iron Works 17
Rand Drill Co 11
Revere Rubber Co 3
Roberts' Steam Piston Packing Co 6-
Rogers Locomotive Works 24
Ross Valve Co 4th Cover
Rue Mfg. Co 17
Ruehle, E. G. & Co 579'
Saqkman, F. A 4th Cover
Safety Car Heating & Lighting Co G
Saunders' D., Sons 5
Sellers, Wm., & Co., luc 8
Shaw Electric Crane Co —
Sligo Iron & Steel Co 678
Smoothon Mfg. Co 25
Standaid Car Truck Co 18
Standard Coupler Co 9
Standard Steel Works 17
Star Brass Mfg. Co 10
Starrett Co., L. S 21
Sturtevant, B. F., Co 8^
Tabor Mfg. Co 10
Underwood. H. B., & Co 9
Union Pacific R. R B7T
Union Switch & Signal Co 676
United States Metallic Packing Co 16
Universal Car Bearing Co 10'
Utica Steam Gauge Co —
Vitrified Wheel Co 4th Cover
Wachter Mfg. Co 678-
Walworth Mfg. Co 2d Cover
Watson-Stlllman Co 4th Cover
Westingbouse Air-Brake Co 22
Westingbouse Electric & Mfg. Co 23
Whitney & Son. Baxter D 673
Whittlesey. Geo. P 673
Williams 'Typewriter Co. 8-
Wood. R. D., & Co.'s »
^?
-v^^l
V Ktr:
^.^}^.
"^^ ^
1^
iH^^Co''-i
.V,*.?(
S;-;
V'^X'
^,..;>^f .
*.■
1
^
• y^ 1
^
1
•-•1*3
%'^»<i'r#